001e e e good morning everyone thank you for good evening good evening thank you for coming to our October board meeting um we will stand for the Pledge of Allegiance thank you I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for you'll notice one empty seat will be filled in about a half an hour but miss Chang is representing the board of education at the New York State School boards Association business meeting and that's why she is not here at present before we begin I would like to introduce legislator Joshua lavasan who is here to say a few words to the board [Applause] thank you very much uh good evening everyone a number of familiar faces but
002for those of you who are meeting for the first time uh my name is Josh lafazan I have the distinct privilege of serving as Nassau County legislator representing district 18 uh and I'm here because it is School Board recognition week uh I learned about this week sitting on this day when I was a member of this school board uh and the late Judy Jacobs who I idolized as as we all did uh gave me a proclamation for serving on a school board and it got me thinking about the importance of this week and it's actually my honor to recognize all of you on 51 million is the number I thought about driving over here 51 million is the number of public school students who attend schools in the United States and if you think of
003about 51 million kids with their own unique stories and experiences and daily trials and tribulations and of that 51 million the 6,000 plus who go to soset schools are the luckiest kids in the country and it's really in part because of all of you and your service and your dedication and your commitment to making sure that our kids want for nothing to make making sure that during a once in a generation pandemic our kids had everything they needed to be safe and to learn and to thrive uh this is an excellent School Board I serve with many of you and I'm grateful to call you my colleagues and my friends uh so on behalf of Nassau County's 1.3 million residents uh I do hereby recognize in honor this board of education uh for school board
004recognition week continue to do what you do for our kids we're so lucky to have you in our Corner uh so I'll announce you one by one we have President Tracy Frankle vice president Thomas Rolo trustee Shany Park where hey how are you nice to see you up here trustee Anna Levitan trustee Brian Greco truste Susan falkov trustee Lisa kosia [Applause] trustee Carol Chang and he's gotten so many for me that I have to give yours in a in in a wooden plaque uh so trustey Rob Gerson yours is coming I thank you for your years of service thank you do you want to do a picture up there yeah all right thank you so much thanks very much for having thank you so much e e we have also been honored to receive from
005um Tom swazi a certificate of special congrat professional recognition presented to the saset board of education on the occasion of school board recognition week it says on behalf of the constituents of the third congressional district of New York thank you to the scasa board of education for your Devotion to our students the value and importance of learning impacts and strengthens our community best wishes for continued success and improving education for our future Generations so thank you to Tom swazy and we will be proud to put this in our boardroom this is what it looks like [Applause] everybody okay just a reminder to everyone that Universal masking is required for all individuals inside preschool through 12th grade schools so regardless of vaccination status by entering our board meeting you will uh agree to wear a mask
006at all time so thank you so much for your compliance uh approval of the minutes meeting September 13th 2021 may I have a motion Please Mr Greco seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extenstions okay Dr rufa the treasures report please as indicated in the treasures report the cash on hand for the month end August 31st 2021 was 83,1 6796 it shows that bank balances for all cash accounts were reconciled to the book balances and were collateralized in accordance with the district's banking agreements and investment policy thank you um I believe there's another voice that would like to add to the recognition of the board in this uh School Board recognition week and that is the president of our sosic Council of ptas Miss D dapas every year the
007New York State Board Association sponsors School Board recognition week the week honors board members commitment to public education as the association States school board members take on one of the most important citizen responsibilities overseeing the education of the community's youth what may be often forgotten is that the school board members are volunteers the gift of your time expertise and commitment is critical to the success of our district you balance your role as Schoolboard members with work family and other volunteering positions all of us in the PTA understand the challenges and the opportunities that volunteerism can bring we know you share our belief that working to promote the welfare of every child makes it all worth it we are happy to recognize your efforts on this special week but please know we appreciate your work all
008year long on behalf of all the PTs in saset we present a small to token of our appreciation along with a certificate from the New York State Board Association signed by Dr Rogers the theme of school board recognition week is school boards lead so students can achieve we thank you for your leadership and tireless support of our students and our community thank you SRA please extend our thanks to the PTA for always supporting uh the board for being such great partners with us and uh for continuing this really open relationship that we all have and thank you so much for thinking of us with these um these gifts as well we really appreciate it school districts are required annually to prepare audited financial statements uh the school district uses the firm of Colin and danowski
009to prepare our financial statements uh annually The Firm reports to the board on the findings of those statements and from The Firm we have Bill erson good evening uh as said as we uh said I'm Bill oison I'm the director of audit services at Colin danowski uh we are the district's external auditor uh our job as the external auditor to is to express an opinion on the district's financial statements uh we conduct our audit in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards as set forth by the aicpa and government auditing standards as set forth by The Controller General of the United States those standards require that we plan and perform the audit to obtain reasonable Assurance about whether the financial statements are free of material misstatement at the conclusion of our audit uh we issued our
010opinion on the financial statements and that opinion uh was an unqualified opinion uh which is the highest level of opinion for all funds with the exception of the extra classroom activity fund uh where we issued a qualified opinion which relates to the accounting of the accounting records of receipts at the individual club levels uh we also issued a report on internal controls noting no material weaknesses in internal controls of the district and we issued a report on compliance with laws and regulations noting no instances of non-compliance um uh we also issued an individual financial statement of the of the extra classroom activity fund uh which included uh an un qualified opinion again relating to the cash receipts and we issued a management letter uh this year uh the management letter only included updates of previous
011year's comments there were no additional comments as a result of the current Year's work any questions from anyone thank you so much all right thank you thank you Mr erson um our district business business official is uh Dr Patricia rufo uh every year uh this time of year as school tax bills arrive we have gotten into the habit of trying to do some explanatory work uh sometimes people will call the office and we'll help explain their bills to them directly but it's uh we've found that it is useful to go through the process of explaining what is within the district's control and what happens at the county level uh it has been um it's particularly challenging this year because the county is doing so much with local property taxes that is new uh primarily the
012county is in the process now of doing a countywide re-evaluation and reassessment of properties what that means is the properties that they uh determine were undervalued are going up in value and therefore going up in taxes and the properties that they determined were overvalued are going down and therefore paying less in taxes so that of course obscures what the school district does and it certainly moves around a lot more uh it is much more volatile than what the school district has done from a budgeting and tax perspective so to try to help make uh sense of this our presentation this year is a little more complicated than it has been in the past because the county is uh doing uh so much more than it has done in the past but I think Dr rufa
013will help us make sense of that so please okay thank you so as Dr Rogers said tonight we'd like to try to bring some clarity um to the roles that the school district and Nassau County plays in this process and we want to explain some of the factors um that impact taxes as well as show how the assessment system is playing out by using some examples of actual properties in the district so starting out with explaining um those factors that impact tax taxes we come to this slide and at the top you can see the box that shows the things that are controlled by the school district I want to emphasize that the one and the only factor that is controlled by the school district is the tax levy the green box that's below are
014the items that are controlled by Nassau County including the assessments the reassessments changes in based proportions the tax rate and assessment challenges and I'll go through those um later in the pre presentation so let's start with what the district controls and that's the school district tax levy which is the total amount of money that the district needs to fund its operations for the school year and that's after all other Revenue sources have been applied and deducted so the district starts out with the budget and then we take out other funding sources such as state aid grants or other Revenue sources such as pilots and things like reserves all of those come out and then what's remaining is the tax levy and the levy is presented to the county in August and it represents the same
015Levy um that we we talk about during the budget and then we present that Levy to the county in August so I think it will be useful to just take a look at the history of the levy over the last 10 years or so since the Inception of the tax cap and both of the charts both on the top left and the bottom right show the the same Trend the First Column up on the left top left shows the tax cap calculation and that is the allow maximum allowable tax uh cap that the district or tax levy that amount and you can see by comparing it to the column on the right which the actual ual tax levy that each year since 2013 the district has been under the tax cap and that's the same
016Trend that's shown in the bar chart to the right and in fact over the 10 years since the tax cap has been implemented the district has been under the cap to the tune of $10.2 million this chart again shows the similar trend of the school district being under the allowable tax cap the blue line is the allowable tax cap and the red line is the actual tax cap that we levied and the green line is the Consumer Price Index the CPI and you can see over the course of time and particularly over the last six years the district has been right at the CPI now if I were doing this presentation exclusively on the district's role in this process this would be the end and I would stop however um as a result of the
017changes that are going on in Nassau County with the re assessments Dr Rogers asked me to spend a little bit of time explaining the role of the County's assessment system and the impact on the taxes specifically this year so once the tax levy is set the method for Distributing the taxes is a function of the county and those factors that are in the right in that green box are the mechanism by which this allocation happens so let's start with the first one which is the determination of Assessments now this definition this is is the Nassau County Department of assessment website and this definition um comes right from their website and the assessed value determines the share of taxes homeowners will pay if we think of the tax levy as a pie the value of the
018assessment determines how big or small each homeowner's piece of that tax levy P will be we also know that property improvements impact value and challenges to the assessment also impact value again all of these factors are controlled by the county additionally what's important to remember in the equation is that the change in an individual homeowner's value will be impacted relative to how the entire District overall assessed values are moving and I have some examples that will describe that um relationship a little bit better now a complicated factor in trying to explain to Residents what's happening to school taxes is the phase in of the countywide reassessment that was first implemented for school districts in the 2021 school year last year so Nassau County's reassessment plan changed several factors in how homeowners taxes are calculated including
019the value of homes and the level of assessment from a quarter of a percent to 0.1 the county provided um information to homeowners on their new system and including the the phase in over 5 years of the assessed the higher assessed values or lower in some cases values um prior to the reassessment values had been frozen for over 10 years and the reassessment was done with the goal of producing assessments that were based on Market values and so it's also important to remember while NASA County's assessment resulted in significant increases for some homeowners in their property it's important to to be aware that the school district only receives the amount of the tax levy no more and no less another important factor in determining taxes that is controlled by Nassau County is the adjusted base
020proportions there are four property classes in Nasa County the class one is homeowners class two is co-ops and condos utilities is three and commercial property is four the county annually shifts the amount of the levy that is paid by each of these four property classes so as you can see in the pie chart in the current school year home owners or class one property owners pay 79.7 eight% of the school tax levy and Commercial properties pay the next highest proportion of 17.32% I thought it would be useful to look at some real life examples to show how taxes are derived and how the assessment system is impacting them I have here neighboring properties on the same street one with a school tax decrease and one with a school tax increase and this information was taken
021directly from the nasau count Department of assessment website where this is all publicly available so if you look at um two those two charts with property 1 and two you can see that first of all there was a significant increase from the 1920 to the 2021 school year essentially going from half a million in change to over a million dollars for both of these property and that's the result of the reassessment process and I also pointed out that how how a property's value moves relative to the rest of the district also impacts what happens to an individual's piece of the pie so let's just look at property one in 2122 if you go third row from the bottom of that chart you're looking at taxable value so the taxable value of property 1 increased from
022612 to 633 and that resulted in a 3.43% change in the value of that that property because overall the scosa district assessed values went up by 12% this one up less they wound up with a smaller piece of the tax levy pi and saw a decrease in their taxes of 6.5% the property property two on the right they also had an increase in their taxable value of 16 point over 16% so that's above the assessed the average assessed value and they saw an increase in their taxes of 4.9% I think it's interesting to notice that while in 2021 they have similar Market values of slightly over a million if you look at the amount of taxes that they pay you can see that they're considerably different property one is paying almost 18,000 in school taxes
023versus 14,000 for property 2 so in this comparison the property paying the higher amount of taxes is having a decrease and the one paying the lower amount is having an increase so in 2021 that difference was $4,000 between these two properties and this year the difference shrank to about $2,200 you have one more example this is a different street but neighboring properties one saw a school tax decrease of almost 1,800 while the others saw an increase of almost 1,700 and again um a a similar Trend you can see the taxable value declined for property one and so they saw a fairly substantial decrease in their taxes again Property 2 had a more significant increase in their taxable value and therefore saw a significant increase in their taxes and they also moved closer together over the
024two years in last year the difference in their taxes was about 2700 this year the difference narrowed to within 850 and again this is not driven the differences um that you're seeing are not driven by the school district we're responsible for the 1.9% increase in the tax levy and how that amount gets distributed to become a 14.3% decrease in one property and a 16.8% increase in another is solely the result of the Nassau County system of assessment and the reassessment that is being phased in so I would just want to recap that the school district only controls the tax levy which is the amount of money that it needs to fund its operations while the county may increase values for homeowners the district does not get any any additional funding as a result we only
025get the levy amount if residents have questions about their assessments and their property values there's a lot of information on the department of educa I'm sorry the Department of Assessments website does anyone have any questions for Dr Ruf on us all right thank you so much for that explanation uh one of the wonderful things that we get to do here is recognize some of the successes of our students in uh pre-co times we would invite them to come to a board meeting so we could congratulate them in person uh but uh in these times we have to recognize them in absentia but uh it's my privilege uh to recognize a number of Our National Merit Scholarship program semi-finalists and commended students and I I do believe will at least be able to show you their
026uh faces as I read their names so they are Sabrina Chen Ethan Chu Rohan chhatra Alex hay Caroline suu Vivian Wang and uni [Applause] Kim and there are several slides uh Christine Lang David louu uh shanji salhotra David Wang Wesley zuu and Caroline [Applause] XU Pria Aurora Joshua burrow Ethan Chen Faith Chen Isabella Chen Eric shisen Chen and Edward Johan [Applause] Tiffany Gaal Emily Goldman Nathan Han Iris ho Elena Hong and Amanda [Applause] hang Eric Wang Ashley Young uh Su yanyong Jim k Mark kimoto Joyce KU and Owen Kyler wank aam Lani Michael Lan Alexandra langman Alex lson Jonathan Lee and Julian Lee Vivian Lynn Frank Lou Michael mishan Sebastian gatri R Krishnan Michael Schneider Lauren Schwarz [Applause] Rishi Shaw Noah Silverman Christina Singh Shan song Jonathan sun and Andor [Applause] shakerz Claire Tong Harish
027Vera Daran Sophie Wang James Wong jinny Yang Andrew Jang and Matthew Jang congratulations to all of them and now to report on uh the high school uh program I believe we have one of those students Caroline XU who is the student government representative hi my name is Caroline zoo and I am the Senate President at sosid high school student government this year and I'm here today to highlight some of our high school's events from the last month starting off with student government we've been having meetings monthly with Dr Dante and administration as well as Senate officer meetings every every Monday morning to discuss the questions and concerns that our student body has as well as planning and organizing school events which include first in early September we had our student uh election process for student
028government's ninth grade officers we also had our spirit week on September 20th to the 24th where students dressed up in different themes every day to show their school spirit on September 21st the entire cused high school student body also participated in the wathon to support the Desi strong Foundation where we raised over $2,000 we also had our annual blood drive on October 6th and our health fair on October 14th where over 20 clubs and departments set up stands on topics ranging in everything from mental health to weightlifting to Stress Management to the importance of sunscreen our pep rally is coming up on Friday October 22nd as well as our Carnival from October 22nd to October 24th we've distributed admission tickets to all 10 schools in scos hung up Flyers around town and in the high
029school alone over 35 clubs and Counting are planning to fundraise at the carnival this year in other news we have also added a couple of new clubs to uh soset High School's repertoire clubs including first the Hydroponics Group which is a group dedicated to helping students learn about hydroponic hydroponic farming which is a sustainable way of growing plants without soil we've also had a student create uh We've also approved the HOSA club which stands for health occupations students of America which is a competition club for those interested in pursuing medicine in the future we also have students planning to host economics and finance workshops with the business departments and in terms of what our other clubs have been doing everybody is happy to be back and meeting in person again we have competition clubs like
030Deca model Congress model un mock trial forensics OVA that are planning and already having in-person tournaments this year our community service clubs have a myriad of fundraisers coming up everything from Chipotle fundraisers to a dance Marathon held by interact to clothing drives held by women in business to even a thrift shop which is going to be held by act and of course we can't forget our annual Halloween candy drive we also have all of our community groups and career clubs meeting in person inviting guest speakers groups like nature of Americans finally being able to get together outside um and overall our over 100 clubs and groups in the high school are finally meeting in person again and students can find all of these groups and their meeting times on the school website that's all for
031now thank you so much and I know that uh the students not just at the high school but everywhere have been really excited to resume a lot of the normal activities that uh they have uh really come to appreciate and that we've all learned to appreciate a lot more in their absence this last year and uh the energy of having all the students back in the high school is definitely palpable and it's been really exciting to see uh as we're getting set up for the next presentation I just want to uhw draw the board and the Public's attention to one of the items on our agenda uh as we've been talking about uh with some frequency one of the major challenges this year uh as a consequence of the pandemic has been the difficulty in
032securing uh adequate bus drivers for our Fleet not just here in saset but this is an industrywide problem so one of the things we've tried to do as a school district is to control as much of uh our own destiny as we possibly can and we're going to uh hopefully with the board's approval work on a plan that will allow us to take some of our staff who already have commercial driers licenses give them the additional training that they need in order to drive buses and uh rent a few buses so that in the event that our bus company is unable to service us with a route or two uh we'll be able to swing into action to make sure that uh no child is left uh without a way to get to school so
033uh as we go into the winter months and uh we all know that uh disease is more prevalent in the winter months uh that certainly means that our bus drivers will probably have some more uh sick days and we want to make sure that uh between us and our bus company uh we're prepared to cover that uh they are certainly a aggressively recruiting drivers and obviously our first choice is to have them do the transportation for the school district uh but we think we've Hit Upon a costeffective way of making sure that we have a backup plan B in the event that we need one so uh I know that the board has asked a number of questions over the last several years about the work that we do to try and protect the school
034districts uh digital assets um certainly we read in the newspapers with some frequency about uh the attacks that occur on uh all kinds of entities ransomware and other kinds of threats that come from the internet obviously we take those concerns very seriously and we periodically report to the board of the efforts that we put into place to try and keep our students safe online keep our staff safe online and protect the assets of the school district so uh without further Ado I'd like to introduce uh Miss Christine Payne who is our director of Information Technology services and Miss Kelly fanos who is a staff developer here with our uh staff and uh library and media technology specialist so please good evening as coordinator of instructional and administrative technology and as a data Protection Officer I'm
035pleased to present Our Song and Scio secure learning environment that includes protection for student data privacy and network security also presenting tonight is our secondary staff developer Kelly fanos who works closely with me our staff and our students why is student data privacy important in 1974 before the internet Senator William Buckley of New York thought it was very important and sponsored the family educational rights and Privacy Act known as furpa furpa limits access to student educational records without prior parental consent it protects student academic and personally identifiable information more protections were added in 1978 with the protection of pupil rights amendment this amendment protects students from participating in surveys or evaluations that might reveal personal data without parental consent and then the internet happened personally identifiable information also known as pii moves from paper to
036digital and becomes available everywhere Congress passes the children's online protection act or Copa in April of 2000 Copa addresses the rapid growth of online marketing and gaming sites that collect data on children under the age of 13 without parental knowledge or consent websites are now required to post a privacy po any policy anywhere data is collected in 2014 New York State education department enacted education law 2D that includes enhanced protections of pii held by schools and school districts this includes Student Records teacher of evaluations and administrative documents the law includes standards for securing data and Computing networks with all these laws how do we in scosa protect student data education law 2D provides the framework the framework includes the protection of pii and school data through network security and best practices the framework includes a
037parent of Rights policies reporting procedures action plans and annual staff training as the data Protection Officer I work with Administration to ensure that contractual and compliance requirements are identified and addressed the scasa board of education has adopted key policies that address the federal and New York state laws these include policies on Internet safety student privacy acceptable use of the Computing Network and data and management of Student Records a plain Language summary and links to the district's work within this framework can be found on the district website in the student privacy section of the parent menu so what is pii personally identifiable information which we refer to as Pi II or Pi is information that can be used to identify contact or locate a single person this can include contact information and demographic information such as
038your name age race ethnicity and gender and medical records family members and household relationships are identified and recorded we also store educational records which include transcripts attendance grades and educational plans these are all the things we need to understand the whole child why is pii and network security so important keeping our staff and student pii and our Network secure can help protect against identity theft ransomware attacks and any disruption or denial of service that would disrupt our school day our goals with the security measures we have in place lead to a safe active and productive learning environment for our educational community in cases of identity theft attackers are trying to steal student identity which students may not realize until much later in their life ransomware attacks are mitigated because we have a secure network and
039backups in place if our network is disrupted it could slow our ability to use the internet to perform any school and work rated tasks during the school day in a few instances our Network could come to a stop so how do we protect against these threats even before education law 2D we've been working to create a secure Computing environment in our schools over the past two years we've implemented security upgrades that include leading Enterprise and Industry standards individual firewalls around each computer each building and the entire District allow us to isolate a problem and immediately protect the rest of the district copies of our data stored in multiple secure Cloud locations protected by their own firewalls allowed us to recover data quickly separate backup schedules provide access to data copied at different time periods offline
040backups provide data that cannot be touched by network communication and allow for threat free recovery tight email security using Advanced threat protection quarantines potentially dangerous emails or emails using trickery to obtain access to Network accounts or pii with the saset learning environment in the cloud how do teachers learn uh how do students and teachers learn and teach online safely with class link we provide our students and staff a secure single sign on to our district approved apps and programs you can think of this like a saset app store or or our Walled Garden of apps students sign into their District provided Chromebook and are brought directly to class link to access their resources students can click on an app icon and are signed in quickly and securely to the program they need class link provides
041ease of access to our appr approved tools from a secure platform so what are the tools that work within this safe environment our staff and students use District provided devices such as Chromebooks laptop tops and desktops our sosic class link platform is updated to reflect the latest access to our secure and approved apps a few programs for our Advanced courses are accessible through virtual desktops and Our IT department pushes updates out to our secure network to ensure that we have the latest Securities staff are continually educated on our district policies and procedures annually teachers and staff teachers and staff support students in their practice of digital citizenship and safe Computing in our soset Learning Community we train support and communicate annual training takes place to review the federal and state data privacy laws at new
042teacher orientation we go deeply into the security and educational technology tools that are approved for our district use we review secure email practices such as encrypting emails that contain personal identifiable information when sending emails to recipients outside of our domain we promote reviewing emails from external senders and previewing attachments before downloading opening or forwarding building support for our staff and students is available through each library media center Communications are frequent from team members and are shared out to the district we create multimedia and video tutorials to support staff and students and provide training in a variety of in-person and virtual formats our goal is to train support and communicate these security practices to our entire educational Community we'd like to thank the Board of Education Dr Rogers and our outstanding staff for supporting the work
043of creating a safe and secure learning environment for our students that enhances their learning and prepares each student for the challenges of an everchanging world thank you does the board have any questions about the presentation okay great uh we are going to start audience to the sorry so I would just like to comment on the presentation a little bit uh this is um one of the challenges one of the new challenges that all school districts are facing obviously uh we want to make sure that we have um a strong and secure environment here but that means that we're constantly making adjustments one of the challenges it's said in this um in the world of Internet services that if the service is free you are the product and so while there are a lot of attractive
044Services uh online that may not have a cost uh the worry is that the cost of those Services is leaking of some kind of personally identifiable information so what we do is we make sure that those uh apps that are in our uh soset App Store are all with companies that we have contracts with those contracts are specifically designed to be compliant with Ed law 2D what that means is that the companies verify to us the procedures that they have in place to make sure that our student data our staff data is not aggregated and resold to anyone else is not available on the internet it is encrypted in in motion and at rest what that means is as it's going back and forth on the internet it needs to be encrypted and if it's
045stored anywhere where it needs to be encrypted and unless one of these companies will agree to all of the provisions that makes that uh app compliant with that law 2D we don't have a relationship with them so I I know that occasionally that can be frustrating because there are some fun exciting tools out there and familiar tools but we want to make sure that uh we have only approved tools here and I really appreciate the patience of our teachers as we go through and make sure that we have the safest possible network uh here so I did want to just comment on that thank you okay we'll begin audience to the public just a few rules to start uh for those of you who have never uh been to audience to the public before there's
046a Podium that we'll ask you to come up and speak at but before you speak we'd like you to introduce yourselves uh To Us by name and there is a ledger at the podium where you'll write your name and address and the reason why we do that is twofold number one you have to be a resident in order to speak at audience to the public and number two if we can't answer your question or comment we need a way to get back to you um you will have an initial 4 minutes to to make a comment or ask a question at the end of your four minutes you'll please be seated after everyone has had a chance to speak for the initial 4 minutes we will uh then take the opportunity to answer questions if
047there are any um or response or comments if at that time someone wants a second chance uh and there is time you can have another four minutes uh to make a comment or a question and we'll Endeavor to answer that as well uh we don't talk about specific teachers or staff or students because of privacy rules and education rules we won't entertain we won't entertain that discussion at all so with that please feel free to come up hi Tanya gats um Pine Road saset and um I have a daughter who's graduated from the high school it's a class of 2021 and a son in the Middle School um so I'm here to um ask a question about recent news that um from earlier this year and just a little note from the Harvard Crimson um
048from earlier this year um the college board will permanently eliminate the SAT subject test or the and the SAT optional essay to better adapt to the pandemic era admissions process the company announced last Tuesday so the subject tests have been eliminated by the SAT I'm going to further quote from um the executive director of the Princeton Review Foundation um who described the use of the SAT subject test and the SAT essay and college admissions and steadily decreasing the tests of both the essay and subject tests are several years overdue Rosner wrote Harvard will eventually see the light and jettison the SAT but maybe not without a fight so for this year Harvard has however made the SAT again optional and that's not the subject test now that's the regular sat College admissions are changing dramatically
049and we'll continue continue to change my issue here though is not to talk about how that impacts the college um admissions for juniors and seniors but to talk about how the retirement of the SAT subject tests affects soset freshmen I first went up to the podium to speak at a soset board meeting when my daughter was a freshman as I was so concerned about the transition process that was going on um Four Freshmen from 8th to 9th grade particularly for those in the honors cohort which my daughter was a part of and um I felt the transition was um didn't allow enough of a ramp between middle school and high school um it was an overwhelming workload of homework and I thought it coed health challenges for the Freshman I think that was born out
050later in the year when we had a freshman who didn't graduate with the rest of the class of 2021 so um I think what I wanted to bring up was that the SAT subject test was used for the curriculum for honors bio in saset that was what the curriculum was geared for the honors curriculum included a lot of curriculum that is highlevel biology some of the curriculum is on the M was on the mcads that my husband took and ited a lot of chemistry chemistry that the students hadn't yet had because they hadn't had chemistry and so it was a lot of wrote memorization without the scaffolding to understand the conceptual concepts of chemistry so my question in short is how is the district going to adapt the honors bio class to perhaps lighten the
051load on the student freshmen who are only 17 and are already accelerated because they're taking honors bio and bio is typically in New York State a 10th grade course a lot of New Yorkers take earth science so what is being done about that I did have a brief conversation with Dr uh with um our science coordinator Mr levero about this earlier this week but I wanted to at least bring it to the attention of the board that I've asked the question and I'd also like to see it addressed in the science uh presentation that's coming up to the PTSA thanks is there anyone else who would like to come up for audience to the public okay hello everyone my name is kareim mazala I've got uh three kids in the school system one in high
052school and two in middle school and I'm here to speak in favor of the installation of the lights uh on the field on the per field I'm not sure I see it as an item on the agenda I'm not sure if it's going to be voted on today or not or if it's just going to be discussed but I I think that there this doesn't really require too much uh discussion it's I think it's an absolutely necessary item we've got a brand new turf field over here um my two sons they play football but this this field is also can be used for soccer for lacrosse for many other sports and having the lights really uh makes it a lot more easier and better uh most of the football games are played across the country
053in high school on Friday nights and I think this is a great time for us to also have games uh many of the other high schools here on the island that have brand new Fields they have lights as well um I was just at a game a few weeks ago at Freeport High School for one of my son's game there had to be maybe a few hundred people at the game I mean the excitement the the level of interest from all different kids that weren't just playing football with cheerleaders kick line I mean it it was just a great atmosphere I had brought my older daughter who's in medical school with me and she said dad this feels like better than an NFL game so I mean um it brings the whole Community together when
054we have these kind of uh games done at night and uh as you all know Sports is an essential part of the students life so I just wanted to bring that as a point um and I don't know if it's going to be voted on today or not thank you so much much for your time do we have to write something or we don't need to write anything if you could please just write your name and address name and address okay thank you hello my name is uh Anthony Alexander um I have two uh two sons uh one just graduated 2021 uh proud member of scas community um moved on to Providence and uh I have a fourth grader so I have a nice big gap um I have volunteered in this community for about
05516 years um even though I'm not formally an educator I consider myself an educator because I've been coaching a lot of kids too many kids but I love it you know I love the sport I love kids I love teaching them and um the reason why I bring this all up is because when we talk about these lights it's not just about the sports you know I've seen really talented kids kids really really challenged kids um you know just being a part of something is a huge deal the more opportunity we can give people to to be a part of something so even if they're taking a football game or lacrosse game the fact that all these clubs could have something to do with it photography club video Club you know band I mean why
056you know marching I mean when I was you know Friday Night Lights were huge when I was growing up I mean the whole Community came out and the word community that you said it's just so big with me you know I don't volunteer my time just simply for lacrosse um if I told you my whole life story you I don't know if you'd laugh or cry but the bottom line is lacrosse gave me an Avenue but the community is what I learned from it right that whole journey was about people say in the you know just kind of doing the same thing being supportive of each other I don't think there's a lot of it right now you know I've had the the benefit of having an older son and a younger son and I'm
057going to tell you there's two two distinct paths that they're both on one one was completely about you know everybody on board doing everything together supporting each other and one is all about me it's like a me world right now and it's upsetting so as a coach I just you know from a team aspect and any team that I've ever coached it's always been about the team I view this as a community or an opportunity to add these lights so that more people have that opportunity right not just the sports but everything that surrounds the sports right when's the last time you had a pep rally with like the whole Community came like that's what I grew up with like why can't these kids feel a sense of Pride even if they have nothing to
058do with football across whatever it is going to the game on a Friday night not only is a productive way to use their Friday night instead of playing Xbox or doing whatever the hell they do you know right but I'm sorry I'm it just it bothers me because I I know all these kids very very well right the trouble they get in with phones the trouble they could get in just because they're not doing something productive Friday night after school they get a chance to go see they get to be a part of you know their Community they feel sense of Pride belonging to something bigger than themselves the lights are going to add to this they're not going to detract from it in any way right so I hope you you know I don't
059know if you're voting on it or I just want to add those two cents I volunteer my time like you do I want to see the community get better not not retract I think this is a a good positive thing for us so thank [Applause] you uh good evening my name is Joe Coley uh I never was a sports guy I was a computer geek I'd be hacking into the systems that they protecting when I was younger uh and I didn't have a whole lot of value for sports even when I was an instructor at PA University downtown it's only after I came here and I had children I realized the tremendous value of sports uh everyone talks about negative pressure no one talks about positive peer pressure I've seen the groups I've seen it
060with my kids I've seen it with other kids I've seen how they kidu struggling and help them go the right path they keep them out of trouble with drugs and a million other things and for that reason alone I can't speak highly enough to the instruction that my children got here with the sports program and again I cannot name 10 sports guys to save my life but from an education from keeping children on the right path point of view how it builds team it teaches them how to work together how to function Society builds their confidence and pushes them head in so many ways I can begin to articulate I'm in favor of the lights so thank you very much for your time have a great day [Applause] hello board my name is Adam waxer
06151 Warner Lane I have two children in the district uh I have a junior and I have a current eighth grade boy I'm currently the president of the scas at youth lacrosse program as well uh and like some of my other people who said some things that I I'll don't want to reiterate it but I just wanted to do some things that maybe fact just read off some other school districts that are kind of like our size that we consider ourselves Section 8 big schools freep Port Oceanside mipa Farmingdale herck Port Washington Plain View Cold Spring Harbor with two Beth Page with two other school districts uh also big and small Roosevelt MacArthur division Southside Glen Cove Seaford Island Trees Malin Wheatley Westberry Manhasset also too unale and Baldwin both have approved bonds for lights
062now go to the other side of the Ledger Hemstead Hicksville East Meadow saset we're on the minority side of having facilities that do not have lights so I find that to be appalling for the community that we live in that we do not have facilities compared to many of other towns in our district um people talk about Athletics yes between all our programs our Varsity junior varsities middle school programs how great it would be that they can use this unbelievable facility we've also had in the past sometimes we bust our kids over to the town of OA Bay uh saasa Woodbury Park and due to some busing issues we haven't been able to do that this year so again in the words uh Dr Rogers you know control what we can control you're correct we
063could not control the busing situation we never knew about that this is something we can control by having these lights here to allow our kids to be able to use these facilities but the word a lot of people have been talking about it I wanted to talk about the word Community because again I don't want this to be just about Athletics we have a beautiful track and I know a lot of these arguments we had discussions about when we talked about stillwall Park okay stillwall Park would have been a place potentially you know for safety issues to allow residents of this town to utilize some Services we have an unbelievable track that many of our many people including my neighbor who says he's never has the opportunity to use the track during the fall why
064during school days he's not allow allowed to use it because of safety issues no no resident is allowed to come up to school premises after school can't do it as well because of all the athletic programs that are there and then the evening time comes and it becomes dark and nobody can use it so this would be something that many of our community members who wanted and approved the track and other uh other parts of the facilities would be able to utilize it interesting story again over the summer time we were at MacArthur High School uh lights were on summertime beautiful day while there was a summer league lacrosse program going on in just around the area many kids were just riding up on their bicycles spikeball whiffle ball just a sense of community kids
065were there 20 30 40 50 kids all in a safe environment to be able to hang out during the summer our children don't have that environment we have no place for our CH children to go to safely congregate uh in in a safe environment so I would love for you guys to take that into consideration as well not so much about Athletics um two a couple of questions I guess I would like for you guys to perhaps discuss nobody understands the process would be to explain to us the process uh voting not voting uh how that would go through State approvals budgets reserves how that all that works um one other thing I guess a question was back in 2019 when we did have the uh bond in the turf approval I just wanted to
066ask a question I did see something about a resolution that talked about conduits and Turf and lighting conduits already being approved and also uh close to $900,000 in approval so just want to understand the process and the conduits is if that could be explained as well thank you very [Applause] much so where do I sign they've got it oh okay uh good evening board and residents of saset uh we've talked a lot about the benefits for I'm sorry what's your name I'm sorry my name is Barry brogy thank you we I live in Marlene Drive in saset I got two kids in saset high school one's a senior one's a freshman um we've talked about a lot of pos positive about having a lighting Lighting in the field and uh having games Friday night and
067having kids out there for different events um but there's one thing we haven't really discussed we the fact is we uh we put a lot of pride in our academic achievements in soset and a lot of these achievements are based on colleges our kids get into and all this testing takes part on Saturday and right now with the current situation uh the kids are taking a three 4our test on Saturday morning and then going out to the field Saturday afternoon and really putting more undue stress on the kids than is necessary if we could have the ability to play games on a Friday night it would clear to mind give more opportunities to relax Saturday morning do what you need to do in the testing front and move forward so that's all I want to
068add thank you hi uh Peter barov 143 berus Lane inet I'll be honest I didn't prepare anything to say tonight but after everyone spoke before me I feel like I have to come up here and say something on behalf of the whs as well um scos at alumni myself I played soccer on the field there um I have three boys in Barry Hill um kindergarten third grade fifth grade I you know I can tell you that um from the point of view of just pride in the school um you know right now we don't have really a whole lot of it right you know games happen on Saturdays for football soccer games throughout the week lacrosse games you know maybe down the week and uh on a weekend occasionally but no one really goes right
069so you know I can tell you that just having everyone come down to the games uh pride in the school you know we talk about academic achievement we're up here talking about taxes you know and all those things that uh that happen in soset but if we had more pride in our school through Athletics you know maybe the community comes down watches some games maybe they can understand where all the tax dollars are going they have more pride in the community they can rally around everybody I know everyone else talked about coming down on Friday nights and giving the kids a place to go you know I have three boys obviously this would you know personally benefit my boys coming through playing lacrosse uh with with Tony and you know waxers teams um which they
070do now but you know coming through the school and having a place to go and having a lot of Pride having colleges come down and recruit it just increases the exposure of the school and makes everybody in the community happier you know come to come down and and watch the games I think it's just really important I think that like Adam said not having lights on a on on a field is you know you get to use it for what a couple hours in the winter time it get starts to get you know it starts to get dark early in the fall we get we get this beautiful field you can't even use it so um I think it's just really important so I just wanted to say a couple things uh thank you for
071your [Applause] time is there anyone else Patrick Dylan 18 winrop Avenue saset good evening everybody the board fellow residents I just like to state that um I have a daughter in the 11th grade and my son is in the 10th grade and my son does play football here in saset and I am in favor me and my family and quite a few of the residents that live on my block they may be listening in this evening um I think it gives the kids great opportunity on a Friday night to come out and you know also for the other programs track and the soccer and maybe you can clarify what your thinking is you know think about it there's going to be lights at the carnival coming up that creates you know a lot of positive
072energy another great thing is even for the pep rally I grew up in went to Holy Trinity High School and I believe we had lights too over in Hicksville and um you know we had the pep rally and one important thing you may want to consider is is the pep rally you know I think that's a great idea tying that in with the Fri nights get a parade the community the neighborhood that's what it's all about representing you know I know everybody has a busy life but it's I mean I never went to a lot of football games in high school but this is positive energy and these kids are really polite hey nice hat there buddy hey how you doing I mean these kids are polite especially for all the pressure and stuff that's
073going on so I just wanted to voice in my opinion me and my family we are in favor of Friday Night Lights thank [Applause] you is there anyone else who wants to speak to audience of the public hello Deborah conanan slia uh one in a son in senior grade and a daughter as a sophomore and as I listen to everybody's points uh they're wonderful strong positive points uh that the lights can bring to the field and um one thing I have to say as a previous coach for p uh lacrosse I've coached for volleyball also but going back to Lacrosse um using that as an example the girls have well they have commented to me that it is a beautiful field but they're proud of it but they can't share it with everyone else that
074they compete with my son who was on track we traveled everywhere for all the track events but it never happened back in saset so the kids want to show off this new field I I hear it from them and and uh they don't want to just show it off in the daytime they want to show it off in the night time too with the benefit of the lights bringing it home that's where they wanted on a Friday night for all the reasons that they said because what better place to be on a Friday night but at home showing it off to um everyone else I hope you get my point Thank [Applause] you so I'm speaking for the kids yeah leave it here leave it here thank you is there anyone who hasn't spoken yet
075who'd like to come up go ahead hi my name is Jim uh Jim kunon I have uh two daughters uh the older one uh Katie she's in the ninth grade and the young one Grace she's in the uh seventh grade in ID middle school so I was actually watching and listening the uh the meeting from home uh on the video and I I realized that I don't have have a chance to ask any questions uh from home so that's why I actually I took the car I drove here I wish there's a way you know for parents that was attending remotely uh those Boe meetings from home they can submit uh questions or questionaries uh online you know that'll be they'll be very convenient for the parents who are not here but again this just
076uh you know one of my ideas so anyway I I I took myself here uh I wanted to so I actually listened the early part of the uh um against the the agenda that talks about um uh privacy uh protection cyber security on the kids uh use of of devices the computers uh for school so my question is uh what they when they took their their Chromebook home what kind of a uh security measures that is actually installed on the Chromebook that can maintain the same security measure the postures when they are no longer on campus I don't know if the uh you know the IT staff are still here I I was just curious like how they maintain that level of security and Prov uh privacy protections on the device that they bring from
077school to home home that that's the only question I have thank you is there anyone else who has not yet come up for audience to the public okay great so um obviously I'll group these things together uh the first Miz gets your question about uh how the bio curriculum will change over time uh it's my understanding that some changes to the biology curriculum have occurred already uh I'll confess that I have not immersed myself in those changes and as you mentioned the uh announcement about the SAT is only a week old at this point so uh it is something that I promise I will Circle back to and I'll get some more information about the how about how the biology curriculum is changing and uh as a biochemistry major myself it's a topic I'm particularly
078interested in so uh it'll be fun for me to learn how the um may be changing and to think about how much it's changed since um well we won't talk about how long ago it was uh when I was in uh undergrad uh but thank you for that comment and uh your point uh the board is going to have a discussion later in the meeting and I suspect that a number of the questions that were posed about uh the process for uh lights and uh the conduit that was installed will probably be uh part of the board's questioning of me so rather than repeat myself I'll wait for that uh if uh any of those questions are not addressed by the board's questioning of me I will make sure to return to them and address
079them and then uh lastly the question about the uh use of the uh devices when students are at home uh all of the devices have uh a filtering uh mechanism on them and they also have a product called goguardian and what goguardian does is it uh restricts the sites that students can visit it also uh will alert us if a student searches for something that is inappropriate or something that is flagged for self harm so uh we will get those alerts because of the use of go Guardian so even though those devices are not on the district's Network that we are responsible for making sure that those devices are protected so um that's actually one of the reasons why we prefer for students to use the district's device because that provides us with an additional
080layer of control over those devices um obviously it's uh something we we take very seriously and we put a lot of energy and time into and if you have uh further questions you you'd like to follow up with any one of us uh call my office and I'll put you in touch with somebody who can give you even more detail and i' just also like to add sir that um there is a way to submit a question uh to be asked at the board during audience of the public uh if you go on the school website uh and you go to board of education you can submit your question uh to all board members uh there's a button to click you can click that obviously you would have to do that ahead of the board
081meeting for us to see it in time uh but you can do that and we will certainly address it whether you're here or not thank you the short drive me anyway okay is there anyone that uh wants to come up a second time for four minutes yep Tanya okay um couple things I'm going to try to fit him in um with regard to the um the lighting situation I am a proud graduate of 87 in '87 from Yukon and when I covered Yukon Sports um as a Conneticut D daily campus reporter um Calhoun was just being recruited and there was a big debate on whether they should pay his salary and the argument Pro was that it'll transform the university it will give Yukon much more school spirit etc etc I have to say having
082um seen the results of that it was absolutely true yukon's sports program transformed the campus in a in so many ways I can't even say and so I do think Sports create community and I think the lights are a very uh compelling idea to make use of our existing Fields okay so um now I'm going to go to another issue that I've I've asked on more than one occasion but one of the things I really um so admired the administration and the board for in the pandemic was the following of CDC guidelines with how it handled um the opening of the schools even during the pandemic mask requirements 6 feet um it was all done with thought and a great deal of care and we really thank the board and the administration for how it
083handled um the health of our students but there's another issue that's so important and it predates the pandemic and that's adolescence getting enough sleep and I'm going to read from the CDC Center for Disease Control schools start too early um according to the 2014 school health policies and practices study 93% of high schools 83% of middle schools in the US started before 8:30 this although the American um Academy of Pediatrics has recommended that middle and high school start at 8:30 a.m. or later to give students the opportunity to get the amount of sleep they need um so um they further go on to note that everyone can play an important role there's that Community aspect again and they suggest what parents can do and one of them is to contact Local School official officials about
084later start times that's what I'm here doing tonight so um I did write Dr Rogers for the summer and um I took a look at our local um High School times of comparable schools when you look at Roslin Jericho Great Neck they all start later than eight um and um yeah we're one of the earlier start times on Long Island um and I think in in our in the peer group of saset that saset has and I think we really have to consider whether that is a good thing to be doing especially as we accelerate our students so much and they enter the school and they're taking a lot of APs um at the same time especially the Juniors and seniors many of them and the freshmen come in and they are not yet fully
085through their maturation process and yet they enter and they have a a a sleep deprivation with the homework load and then you have canvas being used and deadlines for homework being set by teachers at 12: midnight and this is the deadline now one would say well that's because maybe you know well why can't a student go to sleep if the class is at 1 p.m. the next day and then work on it in the morning having slept you know so this is something that we really need to address as a district I think and we already did a survey on it but then the pandemic preempted any followup [Applause] thanks I would say I would love to find a magic wand I'll take one step back this morning I was invited to Barry Hill Elementary
086School to be their uh pick a reading partner secret reader this morning and I went in a robe and a wizard hat and I read Harry Potter to the kids and I wish I had a magic wand uh like I had this morning that would find a way to accomplish a later High School start time uh for all the reasons that you State uh the district prior to the pandemic about two years before the pandemic uh even went so far as to hire a consultant to help us try to think through some of the busing challenges that are involved in uh moving the high school start time because with our current configuration the only way we would be able to do a later High School start time is to do a significantly Later Elementary start
087time and my sense is that that's just not feasible for parents who are working to have their children start in elementary school 20 minutes later so that we can push the high school back 20 minutes so um we use at our Peak about 140 buses a day and right now we're struggling to staff uh even those 140 buses with drivers and really at the time the conclusion that I shared with the board the disappointing conclusion I shared with the board was our two choices were uh either to um completely rearrange start times and start much later for everyone which as I said I don't think is feasible or spend a lot more money to duplicate busing uh because there would be even greater peak times if we had two different sets of Schools starting simultaneously
088uh before the limitation on that was money now the liation on that is drivers even if the money were available to be spent um that doesn't mean that I've lost and or that the board has lost sight of that as a goal so I I do think that it's uh it's important it is a really daunting logistical challenge um it is one that we did put on the back burner during the pandemic uh but it is one that I hope to return to as we emerge from the pandemic because I agree with you um that all of the research suggests that um late adolescence circadian rhythms lead them to more optimal sleep patterns if they can sleep later in the morning so uh that is something that we're going to continue to work on I
089don't have an update for you but I will say as an orientation I agree and the support from the board in continuing that project is is there uh we were disappointed in the results of the um consultant not because they didn't do a good job but because the options available to us just weren't uh weren't feasible so uh more to come hopefully on that so that concludes audience to the public thank you all for making your statements and taking the time we'll begin our discussion item and we've got one and that's the installation of the field lighting at the turf field and I I put this on the agenda because I wanted to see whether there was board interest in beginning the process of installing lights on the turf field when we built the turf
090field we laid the conduit into the turf because we anticipated that there might be a future lighting project and we wanted to make sure that we put it in at that point so that we didn't destroy all the beautiful work that we did uh when we began talking with our teams um when creating the stillw uh plans it became a abundantly clear how lights were not just a want for full sports but was a necessity for full Sports because as the season precedes it becomes dark so soon that practices and games can't fully take place without them at that time the board recognized how critical lights were to the proper functioning of fall Sports and altered the project to include lights prior to the pandemic our District's full teams compensated for the lack of lights
091and the single turf field that we have by busing students to Alternative locations so that their practices could take place on fields of the kind that they would eventually play games on however what this year has shown and specifically as a result of the bus driver shortage and extreme busing issues students are uh and teams are not able to function the way we need them to function and they're not functioning the way we intended them to function the other day I was sitting in front of uh a crowd from another school was a another team's parents it was a girls JB soccer game and I heard them talking about the fact that they came to our Fields with their team a few days back and in the last 10 minutes of the game they were
092playing in utter Darkness I've seen our kids play games and have had to uh call those games early due to lighting after all of that effort uh I've seen them play in the dark the busing has caused delays uh for teams to arrive on our fields and the gamees become too dark to play because of the busing delays we can't transport our students to the other fields as we had pre pandemic and having lights would have allowed us to stagger that field time so that they could all play on the field at one time or another uh in addition to staggering practices having later games we could also have some outdoor events I know one neighboring District who had a lovely PTA event on their lit fields and it brought the community together we have
093no reason to believe that busing will change next year maybe it will maybe it won't there's no way to tell whether the capacity for uh the company we use will return to pre pandemic um capacity but even if it did I think we've heard enough from Ball Sports coaches teams players about how necessary it is to have these lights for proper functioning of their teams um tonight we can talk about the funding sources the realistic timeline for a project like this but I just wanted to start off a conversation by saying that in my my opinion we can do this and we should do this Rob Tracy you could have said it any better um I fully support the installation of Lights uh at the turfield um we thought about this ahead of time obviously
094with uh with respect to the conduits uh but you know obviously there were budgetary considerations and we weren't sure how things would turn out but I have seen firsthand uh that it is getting dark uh in the Autumn and into this winter uh at an earlier hour and uh we definitely need the lights we have a beautiful turf field uh question obviously is where we will where we will get the funding for this um but um I hope that we can figure it out thank you Miss Chang okay I'm also in for support of the project um sayas Community SAS school has been voted the the best community for music education for years and I I do believe that we do have the potential you know if there is one for sports to be voted
095the best community for sports we have very talented kids very devoted parents and we beautiful fields and there's no reason not to have the lighting so I'm in full support of it thank you Lisa kosia sorry thank you um I just wanted to say also that I am in full support of Lights being put on the field I have um an eighth grader who plays soccer as well as my son who graduated in 2020 who played um for school soccer and we have this beautiful field that we waited for years to be built and it would be nice to see um our school like many other schools for these kids to have the same opportunity as the kids from these other schools that they have as well so I am in full support of it
096I think it's not only important for our children but for also for our community in general um I agree with the outpouring of emails that we've had from our community as well as all of um our community members that are sitting in the audience that have spoken and I just wanted to say that I am in full support I only have one question um besides I'm sure Dr Rogers is going to go over how the timeline of events and and funding and whatnot but I had a question about security um as far as if the lights are going to be on in the evenings um what type of security would be there for our children if they wanted to use the field after hours um if a game is not being played um and also
097for our community members if they wanted to use the track and whatnot so I guess my question would be um you know would there be a timeline for lights to be on or usage time for our community to use the field as well and um and the security so that's all I wanted to say I am also in full support and going I agree with everybody and uh continuing with Lisa's question um I know one of the concerns was the security aspect of it um in the outdoor night events um is it possible we have so many fathers here who are ready to be there um work in working together is it possible to have like a um community members to form like a neighborhood watch so that there are enough security enough people watching
098and making sure the uh crowd is cleared after like a Friday night event Miss FAL um so everybody's very well spoken and I fully support the lights I think from a logistical standpoint it's not fair to our kids with all the busing and and all the I mean they roll with it because they're flexible and they're resilient but all the busing that they have to do and having their games called early and not being able to do things and not being able to have the home field advantage and not being able to have their Community around them and also I think the point that a lot of the community members made about the joy and the community and the the togetherness that this Sports bring and to have a Friday night game and have everybody
099there to cheer whether you're playing or part of it or just watching and just a place for the kids to go to be together is really important to the community and especially after you know the last year and a half where people couldn't be together I think it's really important that we try to bring that back and try to bring back as much joy and you know pride and enthusiasm that we you know that we weren't able to have before or wasn't able to do because we didn't have the facilities and that now we can so if we could provide a place to bring everyone together to be kinder and and feel more included that would be fantastic I do have um one question for Dr Rogers I'm sure this is on your agenda of
100things to speak of but I think if you could just for the so people understand um the process of how this would get moving and when it triggers a community Vote or whether it doesn't where the money comes from how we vote on it all the logistical aspects of the process because I think not that many people in the community know exactly how the process would be and I think it'd be really helpful for people to know how it moves forward so thank you so we obviously there's a lot of advantages uh to this and I mean I'll throw one in here I was a high school athlete I'm not sure I was a very good one but playing Under The Lights is one of the greatest experiences I had in high school I don't
101remember much from high school but that was a feeling I'll never forget uh I I hate the idea of denying children that uh especially at home uh I would like to hear uh you know we've talked about security and obviously cost if there's any other disadvantages Dr Rogers that you see in doing this because I think we all know there's a lot of advantages thank you Anna I cannot agree more as everyone said here that parents coaching um it's a lot more than Sports it's Community it's spirit and it's a no-brainer to me to me I view it as not as a project but rather a continuation of a project that we started let's finish what we started I'm sure it's a process um there's a time and there's a cost right so but I'm
102confident we could find a way and uh we're in good hands with Dr Rogers so uh we'll make it happen for our kids I I have faith in that I trust we could do it Tom thank you Tracy um I agree with all of the board members and also with all the the uh residents who came to speak um I played High School sports um we didn't have turf we didn't have lights um we played on the baseball field um and when I came to saset and saw the turf field and the facilities and how safe the schools were to me it was like paradise here um I think the community aspect is really important um when I went to high school our no one came out for the team we had 20 kids on
103the high school team um but we did go in defeated and that brought the whole Community together um it gave us a sense of pride um to me it I was small um it gave me a lot of confidence that if I can excel at football then maybe I can incel in college maybe I can Excel and be a CPA and maybe eventually I can get onto the school board so I think all of those lessons no but it's true because all of those lessons that you learned from Sports carried on to help you persevere um not just through college to any difficult thing that you encountered um so to me um Sports took me to a better place and I'm grateful to my coaches and to my teachers and honestly and my community because
104they all stood behind me um and one quick story when I went to play in college um I was Tiny and I was just getting beat up every day so I remember that there was an older student who went to West Point and at Thanksgiving he was back home and he was supposed to be playing football and I remember I went up to him and I said what are you doing here he said well I don't want to talk about it I'm going to hoser now so I remember he embarrassed himself the school his family the community so every time I thought of quitting I thought I can't be that kid I can't go back to my community to my friends to my family and tell them I quit so I think the lessons learned
105and sports are carry with you through the rest of your life um my other points were we had considered the lights for still well um and we had also considered the walking path for the community I think that's another very important thing that the community gets to use the assets that they paid for um the track is safe it's level um it's good for all ages to to come and walk on um I also with the busing situation there's also the gender equity um piece of it because the boys get to play on the tur field but the girls don't get to play on the turfield because there's not enough time and honestly that's not fair um my questions Dr Rogers and I'm sure you do a very thorough job is can you please go
106through the funding um with the reserves can you please speak about the light pollution from from the um lights um and that said obviously I'm for this [Applause] um uh thanks U to the members of the board for sharing your thoughts I'll try to uh summarize and answer some of your questions so uh maybe some nuts and bolts first uh how would something like this get paid for what would it cost uh as Miss Frankle mentioned uh we as part of the turf installation project we ran under the turf field uh conduit these are tubes that you would later pull electrical wire through uh because it's it would be enormously disruptive to to try and rip up the turf field surface to lay down conduit so we put that in in advance in order to
107preserve the option should the board choose to pursue it at some point the future uh to be able to do lighting without disturbing the existing tur field surface um that puts us in a position now as the board is considering uh whether and how to do that uh the construction of the lights uh our estimate is in the neighborhood of $650,000 or so and uh that would be for the construction of four light towers uh these towers would be approximately 80 ft High and um the uh the the lights the current lights trying to decide what order to do this in in order to make it easy to follow the current light technology is using LED lights uh the advantages they have two uh pretty significant advantages the first is they use less energy than
108the incandescent lights or the hallogen lights that they replace and they also have uh the ability to be much more focused than those in incandescent lights so uh we call that scatter and the lighting technology has much much reduced scatter so uh if you see uh pictures of fields that are using this technology you see a dramatic drop off in light right Beyond the Edge of the track so there's a little bit of Illumination in the the stands if there is uh but not a lot of Illumination beyond that and that's because the lighting technology allows it to be much more focused uh than some of the lighting technologies in the past uh that said um what would it take uh to construct such a project so this building project would require State education department
109approval because it will require a building permit schools are different from uh other entities in that our building permits come not from local municipalities but from Albany from the state education department the State education department does not issue a building permit to a school district for anything that requires a building permit uh without having it go through either an architectural or engineering review depending on uh what type of project it is the state has had difficulty their own version of a bus driver shortage they have an engineering shortage so projects that require engineering review have often had uh in the neighborhood of 40 weeks of lead time in order to get State education department approval it's my understanding that this project would not have quite such a long lead time for State Education Department approval
110and I'd hate to throw out a really ambitious number and then have the state not hit it but we're talking in the neighborhood of um maybe more like a dozen weeks or 10 weeks uh rather than 40 weeks or something like that so uh that's encouraging once the State education department gives us an approval and if we have a funding source I'll come back to the funding source then what we would do at the district level is we would take that project the specifications that are approved by the state designed by Architects and we would then do a public bid and uh it'll take some time for that bid to remain uh open and on the market so that multiple biders have a chance to bid on it they will download it what's called bid
111package they will look through the specs they will decide how much it they think it will cost them to build it and ultimately all the biders turn in their bids simultaneously the district opens the bid simultaneously and obviously we're looking for best value among those bids so uh that process also takes uh a couple of weeks so that the biders have ample opportunity to review the project then uh once a bidder is selected then we go through a process of finalizing a contract that often takes a couple of weeks because it's not just uh signing a contract but we have to ensure that they have uh bonds and insurances so and and this is true of all of these construction projects that we've been doing um every contractor has to have performance Bonds in other
112words we get paid if they don't finish the job they have to have insurances that protect their workers protect the school district if they break something that the insurance has to pay for it they have to be adequately insured in case someone gets hurt obviously there can be huge settlements when there's a property I'm sorry a personal injury so we need to make sure that their insurance is adequate that it's with a company that we believe is uh that not us it's actually our insurance carrier verifies that their company is adequately insured and adequately reserved uh we don't want them to have a flimsy company behind them all of that takes um surprising amount of time and energy once all of that is settled they will and we've awarded the contract you have awarded the
113contracted board meeting then uh they will immediately start ordering materials and it's my understanding that this type of lighting technology has about an 8 to 12 week lead time so um hopefully lead times will improve over the course of the year but I think we're all hearing about difficulties in getting cars difficulties in getting computers uh because of the lead times and the number of container ships that are not able to be offloaded this also ends up fitting into that category of long lead time items as well and then ultimately there's time needed to construct the project and that looks like it's probably in the 8we uh time frame as well so all of that said there's a lot that leads up to actually getting it done in terms of all of these processes that
114have to be followed um I think an ambitious time frame uh might be to think about having a project like this done about this time next year um that would require a lot of things to go right uh but it's not out of the realm of possibility where would the funding come from uh school districts for um the funding has to be approved by the voters no matter what it's just a question of which mechanism it goes through so the district has a uh capital reserve and uh the funds in the capital reserve may be used for capital projects and uh we have certainly taken advantage of that funding mechanism for a lot of the projects that we have done in Phase One and phase two and by us using the monies that are in
115the capital reserve we avoid taking on new debt and then incurring interest costs so it's always wise to use the capital reserve because uh you you don't waste money on interest if it's unnecessary so uh money exists in the capital reserve there has to be a separate vote of the public in order to take money out of the capital reserve so you can either do that as part of your budget vote in May or you can set another date at a different time in the year uh but either way you have to have a vote of the public to take money of the capital reserve another way to fund capital projects is to include them in the school district's budget which will be voted on in May and uh what we have done uh over
116the course of the last several years particularly with our Roofing projects we have included those Roofing projects as part of the budget the budget is approved by voters the roofing projects get done uh as a a matter of course as part of the ordinary uh uh implementation of the school district's budget so that uh goes through the funding sources the different mechanisms my sense of the timeline my sense of the cost um Brian's question about are there any other disadvantages in the past I would say that the the scatter of the light was a disadvantage I think that's been greatly reduced not obviously reduced to zero but greatly reduced um Mr Rolo's uh you know comment on gender Equity that I believe that uh the athletics department has worked very hard to try and make
117sure that there is equal access to the field for boys and girls versions of uh the sports but because it's getting dark early you can only have one sport used the field on any given night if you had lights you would be able to have boys early and girls late or vice versa on the same night so uh that's that is an option that would be improved through the use of lighting um and I I do think that I addressed your question about funding with reserves and light pollution and I'm just going through ah security so the there is no question that night events are harder to manage from a security perspective there's there's no getting around that more misbehavior happens at night a security guard can see 150 yards in broad daylight it might
118be able to see uh 30 40 ft uh at night so you need to have a much larger security presence in order to cover the same amount of territory uh you'd want to have more people in the parking lots uh typically a lot of the misbehavior happens in parking lots at evening events it's not impossible to manage these things though and obviously lots of school districts do it uh but there there is a presence that is needed that presence needs to be uh you need to be a little bit thicker with security when you're running evening events and obviously you need to be um even more Vigilant about um let's call it Red Solo Cup problems uh in order to prevent things from going uh sideways so uh but those are all things that can
119be managed uh how would we manage uh Community use of facilities after dark I'd want to talk with some other school districts that uh provide I'd want to talk to the neighbors and find out how they manage it before making any final determinations but I certainly agree with the point that uh if there's an if there's a way that we can make this an asset to the community by all means let's do so and let's figure out how to do it safely so I do think that we would want have a security presence we do have kids that um use the field during the day and on the weekends they just do pickup games of flag football or touch football I guess um and there's a way that that can be done at night in
120the same way we just have to make sure that we have enough security there uh to keep it safe and to make sure that we know who's there on the property and um so you know that I would I'd want to come back to you with a security plan but I do think that this is something that we can manage I'm sorry I I did address that yeah ear so I'm going to turn to Dr rufo because I'll pick a number out of um the recesses of my memory and I'd rather have your memory be wrong than my memory be wrong I think the 40 I'm not sure if the 40,000 number that was referenced was pre um the new voting machines so I think it was a bit less than that but I'd really
121have to check in terms of um the amount of the additional vote but I will address the question on timeline obviously with tight timelines the more time we have the the the better chance we are of being able to deliver before it gets late enough in the year that the darkness is becoming an issue for us so with any of these construction problems I will always welcome more time but I I don't think that it would be impossible to do uh from May e okay sorry about that good okay uh and the other reason is because we allow the community um to hear what we have to say and then uh and then we uh make a motion at another time so my plan is to um make a motion to um commence this project
122at the earliest meeting that we have and whether that's in November or we have a meeting before that that's when I'm going to be making a motion Lisa I just have a a quick question because I'm not sure if I understand if a community vote is necessary is it's not going to matter whether or not the community vote is done before the may vote it's not it will that not affect the timeline of events of how quickly we would be able to get this project done did I understand that correctly it it won't matter uh if if you got that it won't matter then I didn't phrase it clearly enough um if it is approved in May then it will be a challenge to get it done by this time next year not impossible looking
123closely at the time frame but a challenge if it is approved by the public earlier we'll get started sooner and obviously that just puts more time into the timeline makes it easier for us to manage uh the project and get it done sooner so it is you know I guess in in large part a question of whether the cost of running an earlier vote um the or rather the cost of running the earlier vote buys you a little bit more of a guarantee that you would have the lights in place for The Fall season next year Dr Park does it make sense at this time to also consider lights over the tennis courts would it save uh District money if we do all that project together I don't know that we would necessarily save money
124um I'm guessing that uh those two projects would probably have to be bid separately they would probably get they would be different building projects from the state education Department's perspective so we would probably bid them individually so for example uh with the ventilation projects that we did in the secondary schools even though they're all the same direct outdoor air system uh we have three different vendors in three different schools so um I I don't know that would get like a volume discount or something by doing both sets of Lights at the same time it might it might go through the approval process a little more quickly uh if we were uh specifying the same lighting package in both places but I I actually don't think that the lighting over the tennis courts would be the
125same because I don't think you need uh 80ft Towers there uh the requirements for for football end up kind of dictating that because the ball can go so high in the air and hopefully the tennis ball isn't going that high in in the air uh if it's being played properly so um I I don't know that there would be any necessary advantage to doing that Lisa is there anything that we can do let's say temporarily um that would some of temporary lighting that would allow for students who are playing the sports throughout the 2122 school year to be able to utilize the the turf for night games so we have been using uh portable diesel powered light towers uh at the field and I would say that they are not ideal but they are better
126than nothing and what they have done is they have taken the games uh Miss Franco was describing the dusk games and making the dusk games a little bit more playable um but I think if it was pitch dark outside we would not say that those lights were adequate to make the field a comfortable place to play soccer okay that concludes discussion items there's no one finished business now for new business A1 is the approval of staff changes may I have a motion Please Mr aolo second by Miss Lan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions A2 is the approval of 2021 22 stiens and hourly raid activities make uh may have a motion please miss kosia seconded by Miss Chang are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions A3 is
127the appointment of extracurricular assignments m motion please miss Falco seconded by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions A4 is the approval of coaching recommendations for 2021-22 May I have a motion please miss kosia seconded by Miss changen are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B1 is the approval of Committee of special education recommendations may I have a motion Please Mr Greco second by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B2 is the approval of committee on preschool special education recommendations may I have a motion please miss kosia seconded by Rob gersan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B3 is the authorization for contracts for federal Part B funds may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded
128by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions before is the approval of student Club Charters may have a motion please miss C seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B5 is the approval of the appointment of an internal auditing firm for 2122 may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C1 is the authorization for service contracts may have a motion please miss kashia second of I miss Chang are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C2 is the authorization for special education and nursing contracts may have a motion please miss Levitan seconded by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions C4 is
129the authoriz did I do C4 C3 is the authorization for acceptance of audit report and corrective action plans may have a motion please miss Kia seconded by Miss changen are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C4 is the authorization for a memorandum of agreement with naso bosis regarding renting buses may I have a motion Please Mr Greco seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C5 is the acceptance of the donation of 30 bags of mulch may I have a motion please miss kosia seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions and lastly C6 is the authorization of the disposal of broken Surplus and our obsolete equipment in our books may have a motion Please Mr Greco second am my
130Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor oppose any extenstions motion to adjourn thank you everybody appreciate it