CorpusRecord 136505

Board of Education Meeting - December 14, 2020

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Syosset Central School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,350 words · about 108 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001and justice for all I don't know if you can all notice but we have some beautiful festive decorations here so thank you for doing that for for us and for our viewers and in that vein obviously we are in the throws of uh holiday time time and uh we're all celebrating a little bit differently um but hopefully we're all finding new ways to connect with one another and to lean on our friends and our family not physically but uh via phone um to share and celebrate and remember what means most to us and I know that what means most to us here is all of our Collective safety and so uh my wish is that during these holiday celebrations you all uh find ways to uh connect but to be safe for uh for everyone

002else as much as yourselves so uh with that we will begin on the approval of the minutes for the November 16th 2020 meeting May I have a motion please rob gishan seconded by Andy Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay Dr rufo please provide us with the treasurers report good evening as indicated in the treasures report the cash on hand for the month end October 31st 2020 was $92,200 94 the treasures report also shows that bank balances for all cash accounts were reconciled to book balances and were collateralized in accordance with the district's banking agreement and investment policy thank you Dr rufo may I have a motion to accept the treasurer's report Mr defilippo seconded by Miss Chang are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay Dr

003Rogers you have the floor thank you very much and I will add my holiday greetings to miss frankl's holiday greetings and wish everyone uh safe and healthy break and a happy New Year um and of course uh even though we are celebrating uh this season differently than we've done in the past I hope that we will all discover that there are new ways uh just as we discovered with graduation and some other things this year uh that we can still enjoy familiar uh rights of Passage and uh enjoy one another's company uh but do it in a way that is consistent with obviously the challenges of the times uh we have a packed superintendent report this evening so I'll get right to it uh this is uh the meeting where we get a report from

004the Southwoods uh Middle School student council and so I'm pleased to have them uh queued up and this report good evening Dr Rogers administrative members of the Board of Education and scos Community tonight the Southwood student council will be providing you with the Student Activities update we would love you to be there live with all of you but we are recording this video at our weekly student council meeting which takes place every Tuesday night via Google even during these trying times Southwood students have been enjoying a wide variety of clubs and activities we are going to do our best to give you the highlights of the year so far the annual Halloween wathon was a great success this year sasa's students and families were able to raise a total of $1,184 for rock koll and

005get out for the classroom for a socially distanced exercise in this in addition to the money raised the peer leaders also helped organize a food dve the F Club has also had a very successful Halloween candy drive for operation Sweet Tooth and is currently working with AAA Club to run a December coach ride the south of business club members are learning about businesses ownership and sales while participating in a cookie fundraiser they're also creating Designs For an upcoming clothing sale the art Club has been working on a quiling project repurposing papers such as newspapers magazines and wrapping paper once the students Quil the paper into r 3D objects they transformed the pieces into a decor design the miror club is painting the walls of Southwoods middle school with beautiful signs and Landscapes the Southwoods Multicultural

006Club is busy learning about the cultural significance of holidays around the world the podcast Club is learning all the in and outs of creating a podcast like writing script or recording interviews the Southwoods performing groups have also been very busy like the drama club has trying to record a virtual play and the ukulele Club is someing some much needed holiday cheer ukulele style even clubs like outdoor education and sports and recreation are adapting to our current environment the outdoor education Club has taken students on virtual tours of national parks like the Grand Canyon and Glacier National Park the girls who code are busy learning coding techniques from beginning beginnner to more advanced while the girl talk Club has been discussing activism and leadership they plan to work with the HBC version of their Club in

007order to make a PSA about the wage Gap and as for us the student council is currently holding a toy drive we are collecting new toys for the John th and Children's Foundation for local distribution in neighboring communities thank you for the opportunity to share all the great things that are happening at Southwoods Middle School happy holidays and stay #s strong happy Holidays happy thank you all right I was going to try and read all of their names but they were in the credits so you got a chance uh to hear from all of our students I'll read their names all the same uh thank you Sally biond Isa bhani Hayden fesel ashkara gavali Bui jatra Eileen Lang J Su Julie Julia emirali Shane oiss Haley Chi and Jacob Goldstein and uh from the high

008school uh this is also the annual meeting at which uh we celebrate uh some of the sounds of the season and again this will look a little different from our traditional uh experience some of the selections are the same but the presentation is different and uh because of that uh there's a little special opportunity so we're going to introduce uh Mr Michael salsman our director of fine and Performing Arts who will introduce these two performances good evening Dr Rogers and members of the Board of Education it is our tradition to bring you good wishes from the music department at this time of year and that is a tradition that we are so glad not to have allowed this pandemic to interrupt before I introduce two spectacular performances I just want to congratulate and thank all

009of the District's music teachers the challenges of teaching music with social distancing limits on class sizes and the combination of in-person and remote Learners have seemed almost insurmountable at times yet our teachers across the district have reinvented themselves and their courses reset goals and priorities and have been doing an incredible job of keeping music alive in our classrooms and in the lives of our students and I just wanted to take a moment to to thank them and congratulate them virtual performances like the ones you are about to see are not the same as a live performance because the musicians miss out on the opportunity of collaborating with each other in real time but they do give us an opportunity to share the joys of Music my congratulations and thanks to Mrs Kristen Howell for creating

010these two videos they not only show off the high level of Music performance and education that is continuing in our classes but they also represent a tremendous number of post- production hours on har part and we are extremely appreciative of her efforts you are about to hear a performance of Jingle Bells by the current members of our male AC capella group Coral pride and then a wonderful rendition of White Christmas performed by close to 100 alumni and current members of the adelettes on behalf of the music department and all of our teachers and students we wish you all the very best this holiday season [Music] dreaming of the white Christmas just like the ones I used to know where the tree to list and [Music] children to he bells in the snow in the dreaming

011of a chrristmas with every Christmas C I may your days be Mar and bright so bright and may all your Christmas be one [Music] may your days be mer and bright bright and may all your Christmas [Music] be may your Christmas say [Music] be all your Christmas be one may your days be Mary and bright so bright and all your Christmas be may your Christmas be [Music] jingle jingle jingle jingle jingle all the way dashing through the snow in a one open SL the fields we go laughing all the way bells on bobtail rain making spirits bright what fun it is to ride and sing a slaying song tonight jingle bells jingle bells jingle all the way oh what fun it is to ride in a one horse open sleigh oh jingle bells jingle bells

012jingle all the way oh what fun it is to ride in a onor open sleigh a day or to a go I thought i' take a ride soon miss F Bri was seated by my side the horse was lean and L Misfortune seemed his L he got into a drifting bank and we we got ofing jingle jingle bellsing jingle bells jingle all the way oh what fun it is to ride in a one open SL oh jingle bells jingle bells jingle all the way oh what fun it is to ride in a oneor open Sligh a oneor jingle jingle jingle jingle all the way hey what ride in a open SL oh jingle bells jingle bells jingle all the way oh what fun it is ride in a on open that wasn't just fun it

013was really remarkable and I'm just so proud of the music program so grateful to miss Howell for making it possible for our students to still uh have these wonderful experiences not withstanding the challenges uh that we're facing uh the art and music programs here are obviously part of our wonderful academic offerings uh we're featuring every month uh a presentation to the board from a different area of our uh Academic Program uh this month we're last month we heard about science this month we're going to hear about English language arts and to lead that conversation have Miss Amanda Barney who is the uh coordinator of English language arts K12 in saset she's going to be joined by Miss Sarah waser who is a um library media specialist at the high school and virtually by Miss Kim

014Costa who is a teacher here at Southwoods middle school so miss Barney thank you thank you good evening Dr Rogers members of the Board of Education thank you for the opportunity to share an overview of the amazing aming work in reading and writing instruction that's happening across our district for our kindergarten through our 12th grade students our job as Ela Educators is to prepare our children to become great thinkers who can read and write well take agency or control over their own Destinies and make the world a better more inclusive place tonight we highlight how our Ela program provides the Bedrock upon which our students academic success is built built by supporting inquiry excitement and excellence in the language arts the English program at scasd is the foundation of our cohesive K through2 Learning Community

015I'm proud of the alignment in curriculum K through 5 in reading and writing across all seven of our elementary schools and even more proud of the way our elementary teachers have pivoted instruction given the constraints of our current circumstances dances tonight Miss Kim Costa will explain how the middle schools Usher our Learners across the middle school bridge to high school I'll share how our high school program supports individual excellence and Miss Sarah waser our high school library media specialist and students will shine a light on Book Day a signature program of the high school across our seven elementary schools teachers use a shared reading and writing Workshop curriculum that supports a love of reading a student centered writing process and Independence we've selected the teachers College reading and writing workshop units of study because we

016know the workshop model is powerful research tells us that when students discuss what they read in small groups when students do more of the writing work with greater Independence and when teachers provide more of the feedback achievement is Amplified the workshop model is most potent because it's the highest leverage way for students to spend their time doing the work themselves and in meaningful Partnerships with classmates the Hallmarks of the workshop involve supporting social and interactive aspects of literacy in book clubs students have conversations with classmates about characters in the writing process students support each other's revision work in small groups and in one-on-one conferences teachers provide on the spot feedback and students choose books that boost their reading volume and comprehension the workshop model at first glance does not look like it translates in the

017pandemic this pictures from the before time but we pivoted we can get a lot of learning out of the workshop even with the constraints of masks polycarbonate Shields and social distance we have figured it out and that's something to celebrate we can't do Turnin talks of reading Partners sitting together on the carpet but we can do small groups differently technology and ongoing professional development support instruction in this time when health and safety protocols keep us six feet apart our teachers are learning from Teachers College and in-house staff developers these experts show us technologies that support the meaningful interaction we know boosts reading levels and supports growth in writing vetted apps like flip grid provide our students with the opportunity to collaborate by talking and taking video so that they can be connected even when we

018can't be physically close Chromebooks and the Google apps Suite of resources provide a collaborative environment where students work with one another and receive feedback from their teachers small group instruction is happening in Google meets even when all students are in the same classroom digital libraries like Mayan include books from a variety of reading levels and genres and have been purchased for each grade level to support independent and individualized reading for every Elementary student in the district these Technologies do not replace the authenticity of personal interaction our teachers have transformed that turn and talk into phone a friend here we see a kindergartner holding a make pretend phone talking all about how a character's feelings have changed over time in a story the purpose of students turning and talking to a partner is multifaceted it's social

019talking about reading also supports comprehension and student conversation gives teachers important information about students thinking critically this girl's teacher can listen in on that call to to assess her understanding of the story pivots like this are happening in all grade levels and across all schools excellent reading and writing instruction is Guided by this shared approach Ela digital resources shared online across the district create a virtual Bridge one that connects and supports all teachers and students at every grade whether they are learning in school or from home these resources in the hands of our excellent teachers provide cohesion across each year and connect one grade to the next this ramp builds to sixth grade where our students continue their literacy journey across another Bridge Middle School I'm happy that Mrs Kim Costa seventh grade Southwood English

020teacher will take us over that bridge good evening Dr Rogers and members of the board it is an honor to talk with you about how the Middle School literacy program program has evolved over the years especially with the recent integration of the teachers College writing units of study this is my 24th year teaching English language arts at Southwoods Middle School I share this with you to underscore my understanding of the evolution of the ELA program at the middle level I teach seventh grade literally the middle of the middle this slide illustrates the idea that middle level education is the bridge connecting the foundations built on the elementary level to the Futures built on the high school level what holds this bridge up the success of the workshop model in the elementary schools this proven success

021is why we built on that foundation and continued this model on the middle level we adopted the teachers College writing framework on the middle level in 2017 this slide shows a graphic of the Continuum of curriculum spiraling and building with three types of writing emphasized across the grades when we infused these writing units with our existing reading curriculum we took an already rigorous curriculum and created an even more robust program that allows students to take even more agency over their literary lives what we want most for our young readers is for them to take even more independent choices in their reading to see themselves in the literature and to see beyond themselves in the world in which they live the reading curriculum at the middle schools is determined by the teachers based on the New

022York State nextg Standards we are committed to providing a varied reading experience for students classic to contemporary the realistic to the Fantastical and culturally diverse stories that take students across the world and encourage a lifelong love of reading technology and the apps and websites the district has invested in has proven invaluable especially in light of our current reality technology has allowed us to Pivot from shoulder Tosh shoulder to digital collaboration this slide shows some of the apps and websites that teachers and students have come to rely on most seesaw is a digital interactive class journal and what I love most about it is that students sharing goes beyond the classroom if students didn't get a chance to read a friend's story in class they can later students have told me how great it feels to

023get a like on their story on a Saturday morning or a positive comment on a Sunday afternoon another highlight of the middle level literacy program are visits by author Rachel Vale an author of a story all seventh graders read this year marks her second visit to our students virtually of course this year Rachel Val's visits help students see themselves as real writers in the real world and they really love it the kids had so many great take ways from her visit one of my favorites is from Gabby H she said it takes a lot of revising to make a good story I was inspired to ask Rachel veale to the middle schools after I was invited to participate in book day at the high school a few years back here to tell you more about

024this amazing program is Sarah waser High School library media specialist book day is a Confluence of identity belonging and narrative originating through our high school library learning Commons this annual event started 5 years ago it has been carefully and deliberately perfected into a yearslong collaboration between English teachers and students book day is a profound and important collaboration that allows us to grow our reading culture and our reading of culture the texts and authors we ultimately select first go through a rigorous screening process by our library team each year we select a pool of roughly 10 texts and we work with English teachers and a student committee to thoroughly research analyze and debate the merits of each one one of the central goals of selecting the text each year is to strive to elevate underrepresented voices

025and each participant reads each text and each review and then ultimately votes for just one collectively the authors we have chosen have won a total of 36 awards for their novels including a national book award multiple moris Awards for Best debut novel a Lambda literary award and a Keta Scott King award every book under consideration is Thoroughly reviewed by national Publications and organizations book day is a wonderful occasion where our school Community teachers and students come together to engage deeply with an author students develop and revise questions with their English classes in conversation with the author and share their original projects these pieces allow students a personal foothold in their learning and through the exploration of identity and experience have created a lasting impact I'd like to introduce Matthew feffer who is in 10th Grade

026and Isabella Su Susa who is a senior to tell us more about their experience last year when my n9th grade English teacher requested for volunteers to help choose the next book they book for the incoming students I eagerly raised my hand hoping she would choose me luckily I got selected I along with several other students and faculty have chosen this year's book for the nth graders Monday's not coming by Tiffany D Jackson while deciding this year's book I considered the diverse student body at saset High School in what kind of story my classmates and I would like to read we know the book choice is successful when the students are talking about it outside the classroom and in classroom discussion I love talking about books and seeing if my fellow students would like them I

027definitely plan on staying in the book day selection committee thank you hi everyone my name is Isabelle sza and I'm a senior here at the high school and I'm also a four-year member of the bookday committee so I've been involved with bookday in various capacities I've served as the introduction speaker over the last four years and I also served on the uh selection committee itself for two years so I've really gotten uh both ends of the experience in the actual conduction of the event but also the behind the scenes of what goes on in selecting the book and I would say that in in all of those experiences I've felt really really fortunate I've gotten to meet authors one-on-one I had lunch with Nick Stone who later went on to promote my book which I

028published this past year and I've also gotten to meet teachers and other faculty in the building that I would never have interacted with absent book day and so it's just been so fulfilling in that respect that I I get to see my peers actually enjoying uh the books that they read because they know that it's been hand selected for them and I think that's such a unique experience to not just be surrounded by the literature but to have the opportunity to be surrounded by the authors themselves I had never expected that I would have that experience walking to the high school but I'm so grateful that I did thank you thank you Sarah book day and the program is one way we've used culturally responsive and sustaining practices to inform text selection and curriculum design

029and instruction in the high school English Department what does it mean to be culturally responsive the New York State culturally responsive sustaining education framework gives us some guidance about this topic adopted in 2018 the framework emphasizes academic Excellence professional learning a welcoming and affirming environment and a culturally inclusive curriculum we are a culturally diverse School community and part of being culturally diverse involves responding to our many cultures in an inclusive curriculum we tailor this framework to our saset community because to prepare our students for the future requires us to prepare them for an increasingly diverse future in summer of 2020 we Revisited our high school English Department's curriculum through the lens of the New York State culturally responsive sustaining education framework a teacher team created our own culturally responsive curriculum framework in the high school

030we are proud of our long history of supporting individual excellence in English language arts as Dr Dante says there's something for everyone nearly half of the graduating class experiences college credit bearing coursework among our saset student students excuse me our national award-winning writers and as we learned from Bella published authors she's not alone in our high school English classes our casset students initiate and participate in a range of collaborative discussions with diverse Partners on complex topics texts and issues our teachers expect our students to express ideas clearly and persuasively and teach our students to build their own ideas and build upon the ideas of others in discussion of texts our students respond thoughtfully to diverse perspectives they synthesize comments claims and evidence made on all sides of an issue in Google breakout rooms students have

031small structured conversation connecting students to each other one-on-one conferences over meet connect students to their teachers and in Socratic seminar teachers broadcast the students who are home onto the Smartboard so that they can participate fully in concert with their classmates in the schoolhouse importantly all of our teachers K through 12 create a welcoming and affirming environment in which they teach an increasingly inclusive curriculum upholding our saset standards of academic excellence in English language arts our teachers K through 12 have created the ultimate Bridge one that connects all cohorts of children closing the distance between students through the study of texts connecting them to one another every day fostering the affirming environment in which from home from school online or in person each child is seen each person's ideas and identities are valued and all students

032written work catches them in the act of great thinking thank you thank you so much for uh the presentation and all of your hard work you know we've had academic excellence in this school district for as long as I can remember but what is amazing and what is evident with this presentation is that we don't rest on our Laurels we're continuing to evolve and to strive for uh greatness in everything we do and uh so I know that this board truly appreciates that work uh I saw in this presentation uh the the board's vision of alignment being reflected I saw um PTA comments about easier transitions uh between uh schools being reflected in the work that you've done and I'm especially so uh proud that uh the board had invested in technology at the time

033that we did because that really positioned us to uh to do well as well as can be expected in a uh in pandemic learning so uh thank you and your team for uh the presentation but above all the the effort that you've made and um in still improving on excellent uh the excellent work that we've already done so I'm next going to ask Miss Nora brew and Miss K anond to approach the podium uh as the board knows and I think the public is well aware uh there is a project uh proposed for what is known as the former Sero wire site that is uh proposed to be uh used and developed as a warehouse for a Last Mile distribution center for the Amazon Corporation so uh that site has a complicated environmental history and

034therefore development on that site has to proceed through something known as the New York State brownfields development program uh this is a highly technical uh subject matter and so we have enlisted an environmental consultant to assist us with our uh evaluation of the project the uh this is an evaluation of the remediation efforts what we're going to talk about with you tonight board members is an evaluation of the remediation efforts that are proposed for this site in advance of developing it so we're going to confine our comments and our attention to what's known as a remedial action work plan and that is part of the brownfields uh program and uh I'm just going to ask Mr Escobar if you wouldn't mind could you slide a couple seats in so that Miss tondo can sit uh

035nearer to um Miss Brew thank you so much and uh nor I believe we have your slides uh queued up and ready to go so uh we'll turn it over to you and the Miss Brew will be familiar to the board because she presented to us two years ago when a different plan was being proposed for the same uh location and I gave the board uh feedback that ultimately was in uh incorporated into comments that the school district made on regarding that project so thank you Nora thank you Dr Rogers um thank you board for having me here this evening um I'm Nora Brew I'm a senior in U project manager with Walen environmental engineering in Oyster Bay um and we've reviewed the remedial action work plan that the the New York State DEC released

036just before Thanksgiving they um reviewed this remedial action work plan and have released it now we're in the middle of the the public comment period um so this evening I'm going to present a summary of the contents of the remedial action work plan and describe the remedy that has been selected as the preferred remedy which the dec is now accepting public comment on and once the public comment period is over they will um render a you know a a go ahead for the project um so we reviewed uh in the last few months two reports have been issued for um the saset park site or the former Sero site um in May of 2020 um a report was issued summarizing the remedial investigation work that had been done at the site and in June that

037was released for public comment and now um the remedial election work plan which takes into account the Ral investigation results is out for public comment um the investigation report is over 10,000 pages of um information and data a lot of lab reports and the remal action work plan is 550 Pages um I'm just going to give you a little background on the the dec's Brownfield cleanup program uh which the SOS site is part of that program um the goal of the brownfields cleanup program is to encourage um development of Brownfield sites which are just sort of languishing vacant sites that have are contaminated and need to be cleaned up to be brought back to you know good use and promote the economy and that sort of thing um so the owner of the site they

038apply for acceptance into the brownfields program and once the site is accepted there's a formal agreement executed between the state and the applicant where the applicant commits to undertaking theal activities with the dec's oversight um um and all of the environmental investigation work and cleanup activity at these sites are um done in accordance with work plans and oversight that is provided by the dec um once the site is accepted into the BCP there um are a series of reports and plans that are submitted to the state to um help the pro the the pro program move forward so there's an remedial investigation work plan describing the investigation to be conducted then the remedial investigation report summarizes the the investigation results and then based on that a remedial action work plan is is um issued um

039which Compares various alternatives to each other and and they come out with a a recommendation for the how to proceed um remedial investig remedial election is based on the nature and extent of contamination at the site and it considers exposure risks um so that second bullet there now um is the step we're at right now so the dec has considered the remedial action work plan that um the applicant or the owner of scasa Park is um has recommended and the dec is in you know General currence they've accepted they haven't accepted that's the wrong terminology but they they've commented on the the remal action work plan and now they're soliciting public comment so once they um you know assemble all the comments and review them from the public they will issue a final decision document

040um taking into account the public comments and at that point the um generally the applicant is then uh um has the ability then to move forward with the cleanup action which is overseen by DEC and the the New York State Health Department and then once everything is taken care of and cleaned up in accordance with with the plans um a final engineering report is submitted um documenting that everything was done as as it was planned to be um and then once the cleanup is done a site management plan is is put into place which um ensures that the remedy is is um monitored and inspected and then you know the state stays on top of of what's done there and then once that's all done this the the dec issues a certificate of completion at

041which point you know it the site is just in the management phase the all the remedial cleanup work is done um in the BCP there um there's citizen participation Milestones there's a citizen participation plan that's in in effect and at various stages in the process um public comment is solicited or the state you know will issue a fact sheet so um the first point is when the BCP application is deemed complete that was sometime in the summer of 2016 um so uh there was a 30-day pull comment period then um then when the remedial investigation work plan was issued back in um March or April of 2017 there was another public comment period then um the next one is when the proposed remal investigation report is issued that was back in June and for the

042REM El action work plan that's where we are right now now and the state is so we're in there's a 45-day public comment period for the remedial action work plan and in some instances the dec um holds a public meeting during this public comment period but the state has decided not to have a public meeting at for this project and then there will be a fact sheet issued before construction begins and then at other other points in the process going forward but this is the the the last time that public comment is being solicited by the state for this project so now just a a little general um information on the site um it's shown there outlined in yellow everybody knows where the SOS site is it's it's uh 950 ft or so away from

043South Grove Elementary School um the saset landfill site lies between them um the site's been vacant for many years and obviously has been you know a um of interest to the community for for quite some time as to what the ultimate development will turn out to be so just a g a short timeline of uh the site in the 19 1950s Saro began U manufacturing steel conduits copper rods and steel strips which were used in construction um that process generated waste water which was um managed on site uh that generated um a sludge material that was dewatered and it generated a lot of waste water that needed to be taken care of um it was stored on site and as you know time moved on um different things happened at the site so until the

044site was connected to the the county sewers in 1982 all the wa Wastewater was handled on site and discharged to to recharge basins and um you know resulted in the the issues that that Saro faced in terms of site contamination so in 1982 the sewers were connected and on-site discharge of Wastewater um came to an end um a series of Investigations were done and in 1983 the state the site was added to dec's um State super fund registry the registry of inactive hazardous waste disposal sites um then in 1984 the Saros site was sold and S continued to operate on a limited basis until 1986 the end of 1986 they terminated operations and began to decommission the site um with oversight from the dec and the health department um so in 1986 quite a bit

045of um waste materials and and um contaminated you know liquids were removed from the site and disposed of off site there's a a tally of of them there which is taken from the the remedial action work plan so there's um there was a fair amount of cleanup that was done back in 1986 um then we have some more uh just a summary from the remedial action work plan summarizing historically the types of site investigations that were done um between 1987 after the decommissioning had been completed until um so the earliest phases there were uh soil investigations and groundwater investigations and the original soil investigations identified uh copper Cyanide and zinc as the constituents of concern in the soils um and they were directly related to the the manufacturing that was done at Sero um um

046groundwater investigations didn't find any um groundwater contamination attributable to the site operations um in 1992 soils were excavated um and you know as as the site cleanup continued um there was a report a delisting petition was submitted to the State DEC um itemizing the work that had been done and the contaminant levels that were at the site at that time and the the state um delisted the site so it was no longer on the state super fund registry um and then later in the 90s there was a property transfer transactions going on so there was due diligence investigations involving more in um site investigation work um and they found copper and semivolatile organic compounds um those are the semi volatiles are mainly related to petroleum compounds and uh asphalt pavement um So based on that

047there was some more soil removal done in 2004 and as well as removing underground storage tanks at that time so then between two 2005 in 2015 there wasn't a lot of anything done um until Sasa Park development purchased the site and in in their efforts um to move towards Redevelopment they they retained Ru Associates which is an environmental engineering and consulting firm out in Z County um and they sort of took like a fresh look at the site at that time because you know over 10 years had elapsed since the they had last um looked at the the site conditions so in 2015 there were um 59 soil boring so a boring is you drill down at at a location and you collect soil samples at depth so they did 59 soil borings between 2

048and 35 ft below below ground and they collected a bunch of samples and analyzed them for you know various um classes of contaminants um and the 2015 investigation found that copper and semi volatile organic concentrations exceeded New York State's soil cleanup objectives um for Comm commercial use sites um cyanide was detected at one location and um uh what else so then in 2016 they did some groundwater sampling at five locations and that sampling um was consistent with the old the former sampling that had been done where they did not identify any impacts from site operations on the groundwater and then in 2017 um as part of the BCP program and um in accordance with the approved remedial investigation work plan they did soil Vapor sampling around the dear around the perimeter of the site at

04910 locations and they didn't find that there were any soil Vapor impacts and methane migration was not um was not found to be occurring as either um and then uh last year in 2019 they sampled for monitoring Wells at the site and found no no evidence of uh soil um of groundwater contamination um so now the proposed site Redevelopment plan uh is for warehouse use uh over 200,000 squ foot Warehouse building um so 84% of the of the site would be covered with Warehouse building or parking lot it would be impervious so you know no water going through and the remaining 16% around the perimeter of the site would be landscaped areas um under the BCP there are four different cleanup tracks for for BCP sites depending on um the ultimate use of the property

050and and it ranges from uh track one which would have no restrictions on use so basically you could it would be cleaned up to the point where you could um use the site for for any sort of use and then it steps down to track four um track four is restricted use with site specific soil cleanup objectives uh where the sh the shallowest soils would have to meet the New York state soil cleanup objectives for the intended use of the of the site which in the case of the the former Saros site the its commercial use is the appropriate soil cleanup objectives um so just a a brief discussion of soil cleanup objectives they're used by the state um they're set forth in uh part 375 of the dec regulations and their guidelines to evalu

051Val contaminant concentrations and they guide the type of remedial measures you take at the site and they're developed based on um use of the site ranging from unrestricted use through residential restricted residential commercial and Industrial use um which is that um with the arrows there in the bottom half of the slide and um so obviously the most restrictive or the most stringent cleanup objectives are for unrestricted use and then it you know it get it relaxes As you move towards res IND industrial use and um the soil clean of objectives they also establish them for um groundwater protection and for protection of ecological resources and those vary from compound to compound based on how you know the different chemical characteristics of the compounds and soil conditions so for example here I we just um have

052them listed here for copper um benzo ayene which is a an example of one of the semivolatile organic compounds that is been uh detected at the site and cyanide so as you go across from unrestricted use just say for copper unrestricted uses 50 migrs per kilogram is what the cleanup objective is U milligrams per kilogram equates to parts per million and then for residential use restricted residential and Commercial it the sort cleanic objective is 270 and then for industrial use it jumps all the way up to 10,000 parts per million and for copper the objective based on groundwater protection is 1,720 so that's indicative of Copper's characteristic that uh copper and soils has a a great tendency to stay absorbed to the soils and not to to leech out to groundwater um and it just

053presents the information for the other compounds as well um so now this table summarizes the soil investigation results from 2015 that R the investigation that Rue did so for copper they collected um 161 samples were analyzed by the laboratory for copper and we broke it down into the ranges so of those 161 samples 80 of those samples had copper concentrations that were below the unrestricted use soil cleanup objective um 40 of them had between 50 and 270 so that that's 129 out of 161 samples had copper concentrations that were below the commercial use soil cleanup objective and then um 32 out of 161 were greater than the commercial use and only two of those samples were had copper concentrations that were above the groundwater protection standard or objective and we did a similar um tally

054for benzo Pyne the the semi volatile so of those results um only six of them were above this commercial use objective and for Cyanide um two out of 164 samples were above the 27 part per million soil claim objective um this is just a slide um DEC in the brownfields program they issue a decision document as sort of that'll be the step after they um evaluate the public comments they receive now and they identify contaminants of concern and the definition that or the the statement that they include in their decision documents set says a contaminant to concern is a contaminant that is sufficiently present in frequency and concentration in the environment to require evaluation for IM medial action not all contaminants identified on the property are contaminants of concern so it's just establishing that there

055are they consider the frequency of occurrence and concentration um when determining contaminants of concern and that next bracket um de10 which is the the dec's guidance for site remediation site investigation and Remediation states that um that the the de which is the dec's division of environmental remediation they they consider the magnitude um of which the concentration exceeds the the S the St the state's standards criteria and guidance so as a result of this the dec's November 2020 fact sheet identifies copper and semi volle organic compounds as the primary constituents of concern at the site so the remedial action work plan then evaluates three alternatives to address the contamination at remaining at the Sero site the first alternative is for an unrestricted use cleanup which essentially would involve excavation and off-site disposal of all soils that

056exceed the unrestricted use soil cleanup objectives so that's over six estimated over 636,000 cubic yards of material um and that would take approximately four four and a qu years and cost $137 million alternative two is the track for commercial cleanup considering the um proposed commercial use of the site as a warehouse um so that the gist of that alternative is that a cover system would be placed over the site to um prevent exposure to the soils so the so the soils would be covered by building foundations and slabs um asphalt pavement um parking lot sidewalks or in areas that are not covered with pavement or concrete it would be covered with um the top one foot of soil would be soil that meets the the commercial soil cleanup objectives and then there would be other

057controls institutional controls that would Place deed restrictions on the site um to ensure that the cover system is maintained and inspected and that site use is restricted and groundwater is restricted um the time frame for that alternative to is 10 months and the estimated cost is about $6.7 million upfront plus $117,000 a year in um site inspection and and monitoring costs and then alternative three is just the the Baseline for um comparison of the Alternatives no further action they wouldn't nothing further would would be done the site would remain in its current state and um they wouldn't put any additional controls um I think that $150,000 cost is to abandon the monitoring Wells that are currently on the site so the remedial Alternatives in the remal action work plan are evaluated based on the criteria

058that are listed there um in accordance with the state's rules um they look at how how how the Alternatives compare in terms of protecting human health and the environment complying with um applicable standards short-term Effectiveness and impacts that's related to construction impacts long-term Effectiveness and permanence um and you can read you can read the rest there um So based on the evaluation of the Alternatives the meal action work plan identifies alternative to the track four commercial clean up with with the cover system as the preferred remedy for the site um this slide summarizes uh the how the state boiled down the remedy in their November 2020 fact sheet um so cover would be placed over the site um any there would be a shoot there would be um a a b a a layer they

059call it a demarcation layer but so there' be something placed over the soils that remain in place before they placed anything on above them so that in the future they can always know where the um when they hit the the the remaining soils that that are in place um they would bring in clean material that meets the commercial soil cleanup objectives as C cover material um they would Implement a health and safety plan and a community air monitoring plan and um as I discussed before the site management plan for long-term maintenance and uh environmental EAS easements um this slide just kind of puts us in the direction that we are the reason why we're here is what are these Alternatives and what is the impact po potential that they could have on soset school sites

060um so the unrestricted use where you know 600 plus th000 cubic yards of contaminated or soils with residual contamination would be removed from the site that would involve over 50,000 truckloads of soil being removed from the site and um the truck traffic and heavy equipment that would generate exhaust dust noise traffic and other disturbance over uh a remedial time frame exceeding 4 years alternative two which is the preferred alternative that has been identified by the by the rawp um has the the cover system would prevent direct contact with the soils and reduce contaminant Mobility on-site reuse of the soils would reduce the the volume of soil that was hauled off site so their um the plan that they as described in the remedial election work plan is that the soils would be um dug up

061on site but it would be used in other areas of the site to grade the site and establish the cover system so you wouldn't have you would have soils being trucked into the site rather than being trucked off site and the time frame for alternative 2 is 10 months as compared to over four years for alternative 1 and therefore it would just you know the reduced construction time frame would have result in less disruption to the school sites and the potential impacts are the same as for alternative one except it's just o over a shorter time frame and then the no further action alternative there would be no construction activity no no nothing everything would remain the same um so there would be no disruption to schools associated with construction um and site development would

062be prohibited under this action okay so um for the preferred remedy discussed in the remedial action work plan alternative to um the main types of impacts that would be associated with construction are related to um fugitive dust emissions air quality and odors storm water runoff erosion and siment control on-site soil disturbance um so just anything involving moving around the soils on site bringing in fill material back fill into the site TR traffic control and truck um impacts construction scheduling and potential disruption to school activities associated with construction activities um and noise so this is a rather dense slide but the um the remedial action work plan describes a number of plans that would be implemented during construction and these plans are um the intent of them is to ensure that construction practices are carried out

063in such a way that they're not you know causing undue impacts and that potential impacts can be mitigated and and reduced so complete um plans are included in the remedial action work plan for um health and safety uh health and safety plan dictates um measures that are employed directly related to worker health and safety so it's it's intended to govern work practices at the site so that onsite workers are are protected and it's it's a federal OSHA requirements that are in play there and the health and safety plan includes the community air monitoring plan which um the health and safety plan based on my read of it it's fairly standard it it you know it's um it meets industry standards for health and safety issues um but the community air monitoring plan which is included

064in the health and safety plan is not it's not sufficient um so I'll get into that in a in a slide or two the community air monitoring plan or Camp um describes the air monitoring that will be used during construction to evaluate um ambient air quality um the New York State Health Department publishes a generic Community air monitoring plan which is used as the basis for a lot of the community air monitoring plans that are are implemented but in in this case it doesn't have have the detail needed to provide the adequate protection during this project um the quality assurance project plan that deals with lab analysis so it's it's standard it it's it's nothing special it does the trick um and the citizen participation plan that is in the remedial action work plan is

065dated back in October 17 um so it it doesn't reflect the the current proposed use of the site but it it it outlines you know citizen participation and notifications and things of that nature um a number of plans are not comprehensive or not included in the remedial action work plan and these are plans that um definitely need to be um looked at very carefully when they are put together um because they they impact um the the effects of of construction so storm water pollution prevention plan is noted in the REM action work plan and it says that it will be submitted under separate cover um so storm water pollution prevention plan it outlines how storm water is managed on the site during construction um and and the intent is to avoid having um storm water

066running off the site and you know transporting siment into um surface water bodies or or it's intended to make sure a storm war is handled properly the erosion and sediment control plan is not included in the rawp and it should be um the erosion and sediment control plan it outlines measures and inspections that are to be done to prevent erosion and sediment impacts the soil materials management plan is um it's outlined in in the rawp uh the rwp calls it that it's calls it the plan but in my opinion it's it's not sufficient to have something that takes up you know two or three pages in a um this remedial action work plan to to dictate um the the methods to be used it needs to be better thought out better um similarly dust control

067is mentioned in in the plan but a comprehensive Standalone plan is not was not included Ed and traffic control is also mentioned and there are some measures discussed but it's it's not a not a detailed plan by any means so um see so the major concerns related to the project and the potential impacts construction could have on the district's schools um dust generation this is simp similar to what what we talked about back in 2018 when the scasd park uh draft environmental impact statement was was reviewed and the district commented there um so soils at the site do contain um levels of uh concentrations of contaminants that are above the commercial soil cleanup objectives um so we want to avoid dust being generated and traveling um off site so the community air monitoring plan is

068what we discussed a little just a little while ago um Community air monitoring plan outlines air monitoring that is done during construction and they set up um monitoring monitoring stations upwind and downwind of the construction area um and there are there uh the camp establishes action levels so that if if the say the dust level is approaching the Action level it's an opportunity for the con cons contractor and the oversight Personnel to take action to um kind of suppress the dust so at a lot of construction sites that's sufficient but here we have South GR school you know 950 ft away from the construction area so um the camp should provide for immediate notification to the district if there's any air monitoring exceedences of the action levels so that the district can take action um

069the camp should include a comprehensive plan to have an independent inspect ctor on site who's not affiliated with the contractor or the owner somebody to um independently make sure that things are done in accordance with the camp um the camp should address implementation of more aggressive controls such as like having a continuous misting system as opposed to just you know spraying down um the excavation area if if dust begins to be um generated um and the camp should in include plans to evaluate dust concentrations at um that the standard frequency is every 15 minutes you take a reading and that the the monitoring equipment is set to to log the data that way but you can set it for a shorter time interval so that you can catch um you just be that much more

070ahead of um if a problem was um beginning to to occur that you could take action immediately um excavation and soil handling um so as there's residual soil contamination throughout the site so the soils must be handled properly in accordance with the regulations um the soil management plan that is in the remedial action work plan is not Standalone it doesn't provide adequate detail on the proposed procedures and it it's it's a necessary construction plan in my opinion um similarly a standalone dust control plan is not included in the remedial action work plan and one is is required to provide adequate detail on the methods to reduce dust generation and rut off um for storm water runoff um we don't want the situation to occur where um rain falls on the site you know trucks pick

071up the the the mud on their tires or you know mud runs off the site and then once that dries up it becomes dust and has can become airborne and you know it it all plays into dust and and ensuring that we have adequate protection um theeni action work plan does not um include the required storm water pollution prevention plan and erosion and sediment control plan that would address runoff and erosion um by by um putting the cover system on the site which would have 84% impervious or nonporous surfaces the you won't have the ability for the storm water to just seep into the ground so the the remedial action work plan describes the proposed on-site storm water management system um and it would consist of recharge basins which are fairly standard as well as

072um subsurface Drainage Systems which would be just sort of like big underground systems that would um collect the the storm water and then the storm water would seep into the ground from there but the there's no details in term in the remedial action work plan in terms of how the capacity of those systems um compares to the volume of storm water that the nassa County Department of Public Works requires um on-site storm Water Management Systems to have so that's just another detail that is missing that um is important to know and traffic control obviously with construction workers and truck traffic that that there will be an increase in traffic control um and a comprehensive control plan is is required just to to avoid impacts um similarly noise and vibration the remedial action work plan does

073not acknowledge um that schools are s more sensitive receptors for noise and they they operate at a different standard um in terms of what constitutes an acceptable level of noise and there's no noise and vibration mitigation plan provided in the Ral action work plan in addition uh the plan does not provide a detailed construction schedule they mention that the remedial time frame is 10 months but there's no breakdown as to you know what you know what happens first there's no construction phasing that is is mentioned and monitoring inspection uh in 2018 we made this similar recommendation that like an independent third- party inspectors that are not associated with the owner or the contractor um should be on site to during construction to document that all these plans have been are being properly imp implemented and

074so that appropriate corrective actions can be taken as needed um so that that concludes my summary um as I said so January 11th 2021 is the the date through which the dec is accepting comments thank you Nora I know I have a few questions and uh perhaps my fellow board members do as well can you just explain briefly why different levels of contaminants are permitted to remain depending on the usage of the property um the dec looks at so the the soil cleanup OB objectives are based on risk levels and risk it's the it's risk considers concentration and exposure so um and then there's you know toxicity factors that are associated with the you know different compounds so all those go into they do an analysis and they come up with you know so so

075a residential use would have have a different type of exposure scenario as opposed to commercial use you know residential you could have you know children digging or you're planting gardens in your backyard or something like that so it it factors in that way okay and have uh cover the cover system have they been used successfully in areas outside of saset and by successful I'm mean without leakage or contaminations into the community yes I I can't point to any specific examples but capping for when soils are contaminated with um metals and semivolatile Organics which are typically less they you know they prefer to stay absorbed to the soils so capping is is a a rather common re remedy that is implemented at at these types of sites okay and lastly for me um in just in

076terms of the order of events if uh if capping is going to be done but digging is necessary for construction how does that work my understanding from reading the remedial action work plan is that the remedy is the remedy and the construction are basically intertwined so so they're going to they're going to grade the site they're going to dig out for these um storm water underground subsurface storage systems for storm water so they're going to dig out and they're going to use that soil to to grade and then they'll install their storm water management structures and you know they'll PVE the parking lot and put up the building and so it's you know it the remedy is the construction pretty you know it's it's a just a go intertwined thank you does anyone else have

077any questions do anyone else Christa filippa uh thank you uh thank you for that presentation uh very comprehensive a lot of moving Parts there certainly um I'm just going to uh go over a bunch of things things and then see if you know you have any uh reaction to that okay uh one is um and I'm not going to ask you to answer each one right now you know at the end so what I'm not understanding is uh Siro W made the sale okay and I don't know if you can answer it or any uh but they should be held liable back to you you know having it they they're the ones that caused all this uh the history is is that they started in the 50s 1950s mhm so this has been going on

07870 years okay so you know someone thought that well you know let's sell out the future and we'll wait it out and this toxic Cyanide and all the other chemicals will just go away and it hasn't it hasn't to this day okay we're talking 70 years plus right now and it's not going away so what I'm concerned about is with these different Alternatives is why wasn't this done many years ago when they realized they had the problems and they should have done it you know 50 years ago so I mean 50,000 truckloads of soil is is unimaginable I mean must create like a cater and someone would have to fill that back in I would think but to me my personal opinion and I'm not an engineer but a side cover is like a Band-Aid

079okay covering up the toxics for 70 years we're going to we're going to cover it up another 70 years it no it ain't going to make sense to me and uh I I I'd like to know how this will be decided upon I mean you know the school district will respond other people in the community will respond okay but who who makes the decision on this do we know the the the dec will make the decision New York State DEC because they have the you know the the dec has the authority over the the brownfields cleanup program which this site is part of so that's that's how it's the program is set up and I you know I can't speak to why things weren't done you know way back when um but this is this

080is where we're at now and and the dec is you know it's going through the process and soliciting public comments and and they'll consider the comments and you know you know who's to say what they'll decide but but uh there is no survivorship with this because uh I I thought the you know even though you sell title to the land if if you have an issue like this where it wasn't remediated which you never was then H how does cro W walk away from this it would depend on um like the indemnification agreements that were part of the property sales Chris that's a legal question and nor nor is our environmental consultant so that might be better directed somewhere else yeah are there any other questions Tom hello thank you nor for that presentation so

081in their plan two where they're going to now unearth for these B since obviously if you're building a warehouse you need to dig foundations now they're going to unearth all this stuff how is it really capped it's they're going to have all the soil that's now on Earth chemicals are in the air how is that a remedy well a warehouse do you have to dig foundations Just Trucks and stuff's going all over the place right how is that like containing it I don't understand that aren't you spreading everything around by now you have to dig a deep foundation for for the basins for the building Foundation yeah I don't know where does all that excess dirt go they can't just spread it all around I I it sounds like my understanding is that with the

082the the main the the deepest um excavations are expected to be I believe about 20 ft and these are those are for the um the subsurface storm water uh collection systems that they will have and the the soil that's excavated to create those would be um it would be used to grade the site so I I don't know the the plans or how how large those are but there're that volume of soil would be taken from a you know a smaller piece of the 39 Acre Site and would be would be spread out but I I I don't have the details in terms of how large those are how much soil would be removed right because these basins have to go down pretty far now and then I think the recharge basins would be I

083think they said 8 ft deep um but I just I'm just speculating now I don't have the details so my house foundation is 20 ft how how could they be building a warehouse and they only go down 20 ft how how could that be I I don't have the details as to how they're constructing it there's so the and are they going to do additional borings to see there's more contaminants the remedial action work plants discussed um that they had done earlier this year they had taken soil samples at seven locations that coincided with the where they would be putting the the storm water management so the recharge basins and the the subsurface storm water holding or they're not holding tank the subsurface storm water bleaching systems and the remal action work plan the data

084showed that the metals and semi volatiles concentrations in those locations were they did not exceed the commercial soil cleanup objectives so that's I'm just that's what was in the remal action work plan so they've done some preliminary testing of those areas and I I don't know um if they have plans to do more sampling thank you okay Susan falkov hi um you spoke of the necessity of a independent contractor to monitor the air and the water quality that you know included and I wanted to know obviously that's super important making sure that the air and the water are as safe as possible and that's a huge concern to everyone in the community um is that is an independent person to oversee that included in their plan and if so who would hire that person and

085who would oversee that person to make sure that they are doing their job and making sure that the air and the water quality are are being maintained in the standards that we needed today um I ultimately the the state New York State de New York State DEC I can't hear you guys oh there you are oh um New York State DEC and the health department have um ultimate authority over um the activities going on at the site and um that they're being done in accordance with the plans um in terms of who would hire the independent third party and who makes that determination as to um that they have no conflict of interest with either the site owner or any of the other stakeholders um I I can't I can't speak to that I I

086don't know how that would work how can we find out because making sure that a person overseeing it is doing their job is would be really important so how can we find out who would who would be hiring them and who would be overseeing those people I would say that would be a discussion with um I really don't do you have an idea keran because I I I don't know good evening it's my understanding as Miss Bru just stated that the third party independent Reviewer is not included in the rawp and that if the board were so to direct um comments to be submitted before that January 11th date that would be one of the recommendations Miss Brew is recommending how they go about that once it's recommended would be for further discussion however the

087first step would be to include those sort of comments if that was a concern of the board to be addressed to the dec during the public comment period okay thank you Chris El hi thank you for all the details um just to be clear the three options you went to the the second option is that more akin to what we have at DPW now with the cap where there's is it just um removal of the top soil and a cap or is the the paving and the foundation sort of filling that role a bit you know protecting the soil from the runoff um so that we don't have more seepage down right so the primary um remedial action objective is to prevent uh contact with the soils um and also to prevent um you know

088storm water rainwater from leeching through the soils and potentially mobilizing the contaminants and you know carrying them down to groundwater so the cap by it prevents anybody from touching the soil or ingesting it and it also would you know uh prevent water from from leeching through those areas so it it's it's kind of like a landfill cap except it's not the landfill cap is constructed of impermeable materials right so it's it's not a cap but if if the warehouse is a slab and most of the field is paved with the storm drains on the runoff that serves to protect most of the soil and controls the flow of water so we're not pushing down further towards the water table correct yeah and you have you know it's the groundwater's over 100 ft deep there too

089too so that's good oops are there any other questions for Nora okay thank you Nora so much thank you very much all right um I know the board has a discussion about this a little bit later in the meeting so I'll ask U Miss brew and Miss tondo to stick around if you don't mind uh just to round out my superintendent report and I promise to end on good news so um I wanted to just talk a little bit about um some of the challenges uh that I anticipate ahead uh as we enter into winter months and uh you know as we certainly watch uh closely the data that the state is using to monitor uh the rate of infection with covid-19 and its ression throughout various communities in the state and the mitigation steps

090that the state is putting into place to try and deal with that so U this impacts the school district obviously uh in a number of different ways so um the first is that uh obviously we're uh watching closely a potential weather event that's going to occur later this week that could uh bring with it a potentially substantial amount of snow and uh we've been thinking for uh several weeks now about uh how we would want to handle snow days uh over the course of this year and how and especially we'll handle the upcoming event so there um I'll just frame out the approach uh that we intend to take so our bias is going to be towards let me take one step back sorry this year for the first time the state has created what

091they're calling a pilot program which allows school districts to pivot to Virtual instruction on a day that would have otherwise been a closure day for inclement weather so obviously we've done an awful lot of virtual instruction in the past nine months and uh the state is now saying that that would uh count for state aid purposes towards the number of days that we're required to accumulate for a year my bias would be towards taking advantage of this uh not because I don't uh relish myself the joy of snow days and uh playing in the snow and the kinds of activities uh that uh I recall from my youth and I've even enjoyed as an adult but rather because there are so many unknowns later in the year and uh trying to protect as many days

092of instruction as possible while the unknowns are still familiar so I do anticipate that as the year goes on and uh all indications are that the prevalence of Co will be even even greater in January and February than it is right now uh that brings with it the possibility that there may be days where we're unable to do instruction either in person or virtually because uh we have uh an insufficiency of staff so there's the potential that we'll lose days uh as you no doubt know this morning uh Google uh experienced a 2hour outage worldwide and uh we were minutes away from press in send on a message to the community that would have changed our approach to instruction today because so much of our platform is dependent upon Google services but it could be

093Google or it could be another platform that goes down in our calendar is built around the idea of a typical weather year and accommodating closures for typical weather what it's not built to do is accommodate a typical weather year and the need for Google services to be up and running on every school day as well and so if there's the potential we had a near Miss today of losing a day of instruction because of a Google outage if that happens two or three more times this year and there are four adverse weather days uh we'll very quickly go through what little flexibility we have in the calendar so to the extent that we can uh preserve as many days of instruction in the front half of the year as possible I think that's wise the

094third thing is you know a hopeful note which is uh is my hope at least uh one person's opinion that by the time we get further into spring there will be a lot more vaccine in circulation and it may be possible that by the time we're at the uh Memorial Day break or maybe even earlier in this spring that those breaks will be more meaningful because the level of risk and Community transmission of covid has decreased significantly and so uh part of my job is to think about 6 months from now what will we wish we had done 6 months ago and I think if that opportunity did present itself around Memorial Day we will be grateful that we got as many days of instruction in earlier as we did so uh this is not

095uh the state saying for all time that snow days will be virtual and it's certainly not me saying that this is a decision that we would want to live with uh even if things were back to normal this is an unusual year and this would be an unusual step having said all of that and returning to where I started that my bias would be towards a day of virtual instruction um it is clear to me that there are going to be adverse weather events that do not lend themselves even to Virtual instruction and so if the storm predicted for later this week is lives up to the hype then we will have an awful lot of wet heavy snow driven by high winds that is a recipe for massive power outages across Long Island and

096I don't think uh one would be able to assume that there is enough connectivity either in kids homes or in teachers homes to be able to lead virtual instruction under those circumstances so obviously we're watching this storm uh on a daily basis as we get closer it'll be on an hourly basis and if it doesn't look like it's going to be conducive uh to a virtual day we'll call the traditional snow day the other thing that I've observed in uh my almost 11 years on Long Island is that snow removal efforts here um are not as um rapid as I was familiar with uh when I lived in Buffalo so uh there have been times when we've had particularly impactful storms that have taken multiple days to clean up so it may occur that if

097this is a really impactful storm on Thursday that we're still not ready to have uh instruction in classrooms on Friday but power outages may be restored so it's possible that we might have a traditional snow day on Thursday and then have a day of virtual instruction on Friday it's just an unknown and it'll be dictated by the conditions of this particular storm and that really kind of sums it up for how it's going to be for every storm uh that comes this year I hope there are few and far between but they're each going to have to be addressed on a case-by casee basis because they will each present uh with their own challenges uh so I'll finish where I started my bias will be towards trying to get as much instruction in as we

098can uh while things are still somewhat predictable um following on that uh we have been doing uh certainly the board and Community have noticed an uptick in the number of cases of covid among individuals that are parts of our Learning Community whether they are students or staff um that has been predicted uh to occur for some time and now we're seeing the impact of that it's certainly not limited to scos it's uh consistent uh in all of the school districts in New York State uh obviously some are dealing with even higher rates of incidents than we are and they've been designated as being in yellow zones uh but the uptic is palpable and it is uh certainly islandwide uh we've been uh and I have to commend the contact tracing team uh Dr Curry who

099is one of the assistant superintendent here Mr cardillo uh the deputy superintendent Joan Gonzalez our head nurse Julie naftel another one of our nurses uh who are working literally day and night uh because often the uh calls from parents come in uh late in the evening which is understandable there are long lines at testing centers and so people are getting information about uh positive cases very late in the day we obviously want to be able to react quickly to that information and so uh the that contact tracing team has been staying up as late as it takes to get the job done uh it involves the building principles they in turn involve building staff so that we can interview staff about uh procedures in classrooms uh sometimes it involves surveillance uh video on buses it's

100an extensive process a lot of people are hands- on when that occurs but even with all of that Workforce dedicated to the contact tracing effort it still takes time and what happens in that process is we will identify people who are likely to be close contacts of the case we learn about and then we contact those families and we let them know that there is a youngster that we believe needs to be in quarantine for the next 14 days because they were potentially exposed to someone who has covid and so it would be better for them not to uh expose anyone further because they might develop the disease over the course of the next 14 days so uh obviously uh people comply with that uh decision and it's something that we do in conjunction with

101the health department we support each other in the decision making we do have uh good access to the health department uh in this process but it still takes time and the notification might occur a day or two after exposure because we might not learn of the case for a day or two after the potential exposure where am I going with all of this we're going to Pivot to Virtual instruction on the last 3 days of this calendar year so that would be December 21st 22nd and 23rd the Monday Tuesday and Wednesday prior to Christmas Eve Christmas Day the last week partial week of school in this school year what's the rationale if someone notifies us on Christmas Eve or Christmas Day that they're positive I have no doubt that the contact tracing team will work

102on Christmas day that's not the issue the issue is we will try to do contact tracing for Wednesday the last day that uh children were physically in school we may even be able to get ah hold of all the people that we need to get a hold of on Christmas day but what I won't be able to do is notify someone in time before they've traveled to a relative's house so the the worry is that a student who is a close contact and should be in quarantine we won't notify until halfway through the day on Christmas Day and by the time we notify the family that the child really should be in quarantine because they may be a risk to others uh they may have already visited relatives they may have already visited elderly relatives

103uh who are in a higher risk group so in order to make sure that we're able to make those notifications in plenty of time time for families to make good decisions safe decisions uh by being in Virtual instruction on the 21st 22nd and 23rd we will be in a position to know that the last date of potential exposure at school will have been the Friday of the week before and we assume that we will be able to clear all notifications by Tuesday Wednesday Thursday at the latest but we should be able to notify anyone who needs to know that their child might have been potentially exposed so that they don't inadvertently go to some sort of a family event or even just have an elderly relative over uh for dinner and then unfortunately expose that

104elderly relative to uh the potential risk so uh we're making this announcement tonight obviously to give uh teachers a week to plan uh because this will be a shift for many uh not for all some of our teachers are always virtual and obviously parents will need to uh anticipate child care so working backwards to my conversation about snow days if the storm on Thursday lives up to the hype and it is not possible on Friday to get back into school because the roads still aren't clear it could be that uh Wednesday of this week is the last day of inperson instruction not my preferred scenario but one that everyone should prepare for or by making sure that if you're a staff person you take with you what you need on Wednesday and if you're a

105youngster same thing applies to you uh we'll continue to obviously watch the storm closely personally I'm praying for rain but uh we'll see what happens and we'll try to make the best decision possible beyond calendar I want to talk a little bit about yellow zones and testing so the state has implemented something that they're calling the microcluster strategy they implemented it in the middle of October they did a major revision to it in the middle of November they did an additional revision to it last week and earlier today I was on a uh Zoom call with uh a number of other superintendant and officials from the Department the New York State Department of Health what the state has done is they've created a series of metrics and uh these are measurements of the rate of

106prevalence of covid in a community and measurements of the amount of Hospital capacity that is being consumed or is no longer available in other words how close are the hospitals to being overwhelmed based on those two metrics they identify areas of the state that are determined to be hotspots and they create increasingly restrictive uh controls over those areas so they call them progressively yellow zones orange zones and uh The Hot Spot the hottest of the hot spots are red zones and at each of those levels there are different requirements for about things like whether uh churches can operate and what kinds of businesses can be open Etc but what we're concerned about of course is schools so in a yellow zone and that is one of the triggers for a yellow zone is a 2

1071 12% positivity rate on a 7-Day rolling average for 10 days straight and uh we are uh coming close to the 10th day I believe we're on the 9th day now uh of being at either 2 and a half% or beyond the a yellow zone is triggered so there are a series of other metrics that we don't have access to including the hospital fill rate for a localized area so it may be that we're not designated a yellow zone anytime soon there are currently two y two yellow zones in Nassau one in masipa park the other in Great Neck there are two in suffk one in Hampton Bays the other in Riverhead so if a yellow zone is designated and a school falls into the yellow zone and it is done on a school by

108school basis not a district byd district basis but a school by school basis then in that individual school if the school wishes to remain open for in-person instruction a surveillance testing regime has to be put into place in that school building so if the surveillance testing isn't done the school can pivot to Virtual instruction and remain virtual but the only way for the school to remain open for in-person instruction is to do surveillance testing what is that surveillance testing look like for a yellow zone School 20% of the school population must be tested over a 2E period and at the end of that twoe period the positivity rate of that 20% is compared to the positivity rate of the surrounding area and if the school has a lower positivity rate than the surrounding area and

109we would think that this is likely to occur because we don't believe that schools are a place where there's a lot of transmission then the school would be allowed to remain open and would not need to test again that's yellow in an orange Zone it is also 20% but it is 20% every month and it must continue for as long as the school is in the orange Zone if it wishes to remain open and they don't want the testing to be front loaded all in one week if it's going to be 20% it should be uh 10% in the first two weeks 10% in the last two weeks of the month and like that continuing for as long as the school remains open for a Red Zone it's the same as orange except the percentage

110goes from 20% to 30% initially the state had said that schools in orange and red zones must close they said that those schools after they close must stay closed for 4 days and then can only reopen if 100% of the population is tested so the change that the state made was to back off significantly from that more stringent approach and just say it's 20% in Orange 30% in red you can stay open as long as you get the testing done in the prescribed time frame So 20% of the entire soset School District would be in the neighborhood of 1,700 or more tests because we're not just talking about students we're talking about staff as well and it's only of the student population or staff population that is on site not the students or staff that

111that are learning virtually so uh we have talked with uh the superintendents of the of three of the four uh places on Long Island that have been designated as yellow zones and have gone through uh testing programs and I've talked with two colleagues who are in two Upstate school districts that have gone through uh yellow zone testing programs and uh we've learned a lot from their experience they've been Trailblazers and uh we're trying to put into place some of the best practices to prepare ourself uh in the event that this happens here my hope is that it doesn't uh but uh we're trying to put in place the pieces that are necessary so I see really a plan A and A Plan B the plan A would be to do uh what the Great Neck

112School District did which is to Outsource the testing to a independent third party that we would contract with uh I proposed that for for the board to consider tonight as part of the board's agenda uh this independent third party would conduct the testing it would be done in a school building during the school day Andor at the end of the day uh and obviously would require parental permission this is different from the con the testing center that is here on the joint campus the middle school high school campus that's a satellite operation of Mount Si South Nassau Children's Hospital it is uh I'm sorry Community Hospital it is uh independent from the school district and it doesn't have anywhere near the capacity to do this volume of testing uh this would have to be done

113by an entity that uh has enough capacity to do the testing that's plan a um and I think it makes sense it doesn't have a lot of cost to the school district uh the testing company would Bill uh the insurance of the persons being tested and the school distri would only experience a cost if there was a Youngster who did not have insurance and then uh the school district would pay for the cost of that test in that case the plan B is in the event that a number of school districts are designated as yellow zones simultaneously and suddenly there is a tremendous amount of demand for these testing companies it is possible that they may be overwhelmed and have insufficient capacity if we needed to add to capacity it is possible to do that

114by training our own staff and by administering the tests ourselves in fact the state makes the training available for free and they make the testing kits available for free and several of the schools uh that are in yellow zones have taken advantage of this approach as well and have also had success with it um it obviously will put an additional burden on our staff and some logistical uh efforts to be undertaken in order to accomplish it uh that's Plan B nevertheless I think we should put into place the ingredients for Plan B so that we control our own destiny and uh but still pursue plan a as the preferred way of uh taking care of the testing why pursue testing at all um the one thing that uh I've heard uh in my many conversations

115with parents over the course of the last 9 months and certainly it's been a priority of this board and the board has invested deeply in getting uh kids back into in-person education uh we don't want to uh lose the value of that investment in in-person education by having to close and so uh it's possible for us to continue in-person uh learning by going through this process um I'm I'll report that my colleagues that have gone through this already have um said that it's gone surprisingly well and it has been surprisingly less bumpy than they anticipated that it might be and so I'm hoping that uh if it happens here that we will analogize to that so um that sort of outlines uh the two approaches that we have again U I feel like my job

116is to have a plan and a backup plan and so we're trying to put both of those into place and I promised I would end on a lighter note and uh this is my Shameless PL PL for our association of creative thespians fall show one stoplight town now you might wonder how the fall play is going to take place in a pandemic year and my answer to that is you should tune in and find out because it is going to be extraordinary it is a pandemic approach to putting on good theater and in fact our coordinator of Theater Arts Mr Jean Connor uh I believe is an EMT and he served as an on-site medic and Co compliance officer for a number of films and commercials this summer and so he applied that knowledge to

117our filming so that we could maximize uh the approach to this one stoplight town so it will be live streamed on Friday December 18th that's this coming Friday at 700 p.m. it's a one-time only performance the short comedy is a look at how change affects us all boy could that be more relevant this year uh as we trace the progression of time and a small town beginning with the day the first stoplight was installed so um I know it's going to be amazing uh because the ACT always does incredible Productions and I know it's going to be groundbreaking because this is a year like no other so I will be tuning in and I hope you will be too thank you thank you so much Dr Rogers uh can you make sure that with respect

118to the changing calendar from the 21st to the 23rd that we use all available methods of communicating that to the community uh rooc call and uh website and all of our uh methods and also if you could please uh promote the play as much as possible uh to the community that would be uh a really great way uh for us to all connect with our um theater group and I know they've missed doing uh live performances so I hope they get a good turnout are there any questions for Dr Dr Rogers with respect to his superintendent report before we move on okay Dr rufo do you have a report on the citizens advisory committee for finance uh yes I do um the advis the citizens advisory committee for finance um met on November 19th where

119the administration and committee members discussed the reports of the external auditor and that included the financi statements for the year and June 30th 2020 as well as the extra classroom activity reports we went over the highlights of both of those reports and then discuss the implementation of gby 84 regarding fiduciary activities and how that may change things um potentially with student activities for next year we also updated the committee on the status of the RFP for external auditor and let them know that we will be um starting our rfps for claims and internal Auditors following that and the next meeting is scheduled for February 9th um 2021 where we expect to go over the internal auditor report and also have a um discussion uh preliminary discussion for the 2021 20 2122 budget thank you Dr

120rufo there's no correspondence or legislative items today so we will begin audience to the public uh for those of you who wish to speak to audience to the public you must first come to the podium you'll be recognized by the chair and you will please leave your um name and address both in The Ledger uh The Ledger at the podium and also uh speak that to us since you must be a resident in order to uh speak an audience to the public you'll have your first uh four minutes to address the board and and uh then the next person can come to the podium and when everyone in the audience has had the opportunity to share their first four minutes of comments we will do our best to respond to them um if at that

121point there is anyone who wants uh to follow-up comment or ask follow-up questions then please feel free to come up at that point and then we'll do our best to respond to your follow-up questions there's no polling of the board there's no talking about specific teachers or students obviously for uh privacy reasons and to comply with our legal obligations so with that please feel free to come up to the podium good evening everybody my name is Penny abolos um I live on 28 Colony Lane I have a first grader that is attending South Grove Elementary School and an eighth grader that is attending hbt my questions are related to if we start the uh 20% random testing and I have a couple um would it be uh how do we select the 20% of students

122that will be tested is there a percentage per grade is there a percentage per entire School between the the children um when Dr Rogers mentioned that it will be either in school or after school with uh parental consent will that also include parental or custodial supervision thank you are there any you have four minutes so are those your only questions that's my only question okay great if you could take your seat and allow the next person to come up we'll do our best to respond to your questions as soon as that's finished is there anyone else for audience to the public today going once twice okay thank you for your questions um I can uh describe what some of the other school districts have done and I think there's some Merit in the approaches that

123they've taken but I'll I'll start first with what the rules are um you asked a couple of good questions does it have to be by grade or by school so the Zone designations are by school so it may be and this is the case in both great neck and mapua some of the schools in the district are in the zone some of the schools in the district are not in the zone it is only the schools that are in the zone that must test does the testing have to be sampled 20% of first grade 20% of second grade 20% of third grade no it just has to be 20% of the entire population of people that are live in the building so that let let say it's our High School uh as an example there

124are students who are there every other day both would count as the number their staff who are there every day they would count as well so all of those people the adaa students the bday students and all the staff would be added up and that's the total number of people of which you need to get 20% so if it turned out to be 22% of staff and I'm making this up 18 % of students that would still be okay as long as the overall number was 20% and it wouldn't matter if it was 19% of freshmen and 21% of sophomores that wouldn't matter either it's just 20% of that school census and all lives All Souls in the school are considered equal it's uh just 20% of that and and the rules s seem perplexing

125because it's by school if Walt if it was just the very eastern part of the district and Walt Whitman was in the zone even though kids from Walt Whitman might have older siblings who go to hbt if hbt was not in the zone the older siblings would not have to be tested just the younger siblings because they attend the school that is in the zone so you might say well if that area is a Zone it should be about the families but that's just not the way the program is structured I don't make it up I just report it so uh the what school districts have done to identify the population is uh they have done random uh some sort of random way of generating a list of people from the names uh of all

126the kids that are there in person and just notify the parents and typically what they've done is put out a larger number than would be necessary in order to achieve the 20% and it's not necessary to use the schools plan a or Plan B mechanism uh were allowed uh it's entirely okay to accept testing results from any other testing opportunity so if that's you're going to uh energent Care Center your own personal pediatrician uh you have a test from a hospital the only thing that matters is that it has to be a recent test off the top of my head I don't remember how many days but let's just call it four days it has to be a test that you got sometime in the last four days but if you don't want to do

127this through the school district you get asked to provide a test you go and get it somewhere at your own pediatrician and furnish us with it that works um so uh it you know you parents will have a lot of choice in how they comply with this and again um I wouldn't choose to do any of this uh if uh it wasn't necessary but we do really want to try and preserve in-person learning if at all possible and this is the path to do that Dr Ros I believe also a part of that question was how do we select them I'm sorry I thought I answered that we would do that at random we would uh oh yeah so um Miss Frankle is reminding me a number of school districts that are not in yellow

128zones yet have uh already sent permission slips home to parents so they can start to accumulate uh a body of people that have already got permission slips on file uh that obviously makes sense to me as well and so we'll pursue that process as well uh but the um the sampling will be done initially by random sampling obviously if a lot of those people have permission slips on file already that makes things simpler and then we follow up with the ones who don't have permission slips on file in order to get to the sample that we need sure um Miss Frankle asked me to talk a little bit about um parental uh supervision so the the way the program has worked in these other school districts that have done the testing in schools is that

129uh the testing operation is on site for let's say a full instructional day and uh during the course of the day students are brought down the they have their noses swabbed and they return to class it doesn't you don't have to isolate them while you're waiting for the test because this is not a for cause test they're not exhibiting symptoms this is what's called surveillance testing so uh it's you know very brief and they don't have to wait around for the results uh because uh that's not what we're looking for the uh the districts that have set this testing up have experienced that um most parents are okay with their students just going down and getting tested during the school day but some have wanted to be present for the testing and so uh what

130I think is of the the various methods I've heard to do this the one that I think uh probably is the easiest is at the end of the day uh having additional time at the end of the day so that the parent can go to the school and accompany their child from the test while they're picking the child up at the end of the day and then leaving so it's a trip that the parent is likely to have made to the school anyway they can accompany the child but then we're not having visitors on site in the building during the school day which is something that we've tried to avoid so um that was something my colleague came up with it seems to make sense to me we'd have to work to operationalize it but

131it's a way of if a parent did want to accompany their child they could okay is there anyone who would like any followup time uh if there is you can come up to the podium for four minutes are these rapid tests that that we're conducting that's my first question and if they are rapid tests and there is an asymptomatic child that tests positive how is that handled then at that point you you still have four minutes are is there anything else no that's okay great please take your seat thank you for your questions another terrific question so the plan a test that would be administered by the independent company is a PCR test so those uh results would not be available immediately um they would be available probably 3 days or 4 days after the

132fact obviously if there's a positive in there uh we would end up isolating the child and following our covid protocols if we go to plan B the test that the state is making available is by abbit labs and it's called binax BX now n and the binax now test is a rapid test and the results are available in 15 minutes if there were to be a positive case there uh we would follow the same protocol that we would use if in the middle of the day a student said I have a headache or started to show signs of fever or you know threw up or something like that we'd bring them down to the nurse we' put them in the isolation room we'd call their parents uh and we would you know wait someone would

133wait with them while we wait for the parents to come up but yes if we in Plan B it's the surveillance testing is using a rapid test so we would execute we would execute our plan based on the what we learned plan a is a PCR test so again these are designed as surveillance tests not as um uh for cause tests okay thank you for your questions and Dr Rogers thank you for uh answering them uh we will move on that closes audience of the public and we'll now move on to discussion items we have a discussion item on the yellow zone andoss covid testing and um we've now gone gone through it is there any board member who has any comments with respect to the testing okay the next item for discussion is the

134proposed Amazon warehouse project and really uh what we're looking for is uh a convers ation one about the uh Brownfield cleanup uh report and uh the recommendations that we've been given by Nora Brew today uh and then in addition I'm looking for a discussion as to whether the board would like to direct our Administration to um make comments during the public comment period to the dec so that's a uh distinguished from any potential uh uh uh future comments with respect to uh the town or any other aspect of the project today we really focused on the Brownfield cleanup and uh the methods that are being uh discussed by Amazon uh they're recommended uh their uh request to do a cover system uh the one the uh another option is to do nothing and then another

135option is for a full uh excavation of the entire site so with that um does any board member want to begin the discussion I'm happy to do it okay go ahead uh thank you Tracy uh okay so I would thought I would ask that we uh conduct a uh traffic study of the environment of the area so the impact to the uh the buses and the children and the parents uh that there's not over congestion that would include what areas uh Amazon plans to uh uh drive to uh assuming it's beyond saset and uh Woodberry uh the other thing uh was I would uh shoot High uh so to speak and uh go with uh uh the approach for alternative one track one unrestricted uh use for the cleanup uh and uh put that into

136the that's the statement the comments that we would uh submit right okay um and uh yeah that's that's that's what I uh have down here thank you uh you're welcome uh from my perspective it sounds like the alternative one which is the full cleanup for uh unrestricted use poses more of um a risk to our school nearby School environments because it's uh digging and excavation work for a prolonged period of time I believe uh it was 4.25 years that that would take place and over 600 was it yards of I don't remember the measurement um of of soil as opposed to the cover system which is accepted in the environmental community and as um being successful at containing uh the C contaminants from uh exposure to um human life and surrounding uh the surrounding area

137so uh for me uh the cover system is um okay but I would like to make comments to um the dec Nora had mentioned a number of plans that she found either to be insufficient or absent um and certainly I think for decisions to be made by the dec um they should hear the concerns that the school districts have uh with respect to the work that's being proposed um uh especially the cleanup work Norah had mentioned dust mitigation and runoff and air quality plans and all of those are are critical um the board had written over 100 pages of comments at the last uh proposed development um and those comments many of them uh indicated concern concerns that uh still exist today even though uh the development is very different we do care about traffic

138and we will be undergoing a traffic study we do care about air quality we do care about runoff we do care about noise uh pollution we do care about how our students are going to be able to play outside during the course of uh uh construction and of course we do care about um all of these same things when it comes to the remediation plan um that Amazon has um has developed and so um I am definitely in favor of um of preserving our interest and protecting our community by uh by sharing the areas of concern that we have and impressing upon uh the de see that they should have um all of the information um that they need in order to make a safe and the safest uh decision um in order to protect

139our our students and our staff and our surrounding Community Andy yeah I I think we should go with the recommendation of Walden the option number two um and I think we should definitely incorporate uh statements from the report in a letter and I agree with Tracy that you know obviously with sport has expressed uh extensively in the past of the concern for the safety and well-being of our students and our residents so I definitely think that's uh what you do thanks M Frankle if I may uh I just want to distinguish that uh the remedy number two is not Walden's recommendation it is that recommendation of the property owner and their recommendation of their preferred remedy to the dec uh we commented on their preferred recommendation but it's not Walden's recommendation okay Rob Gerson yes

140uh I agree um with uh Tracy and Andy um I also think that uh the traffic study uh idea is something we should pursue particularly concerning uh the uh trucks that would be going up and down Robin's Lane uh but uh I'm okay with alternate number two the cap system and I do think we should also send comments to New York State DEC uh yes is that Susan or Anna which one Susan hold on one second we're having trouble hearing you Susan can you start again I apologize but you were uh difficult to hear in place and that um there's definitely some kind of independent oversight to make sure that whatever the most stringent Protocols are in place are adhere to and that the community and the kids that are so close to there um

141will be protected and I'm also in favor of the traffic um investigation to see you know what what's going to happen with the congestion and the noise and and the trucks and everything in that regard also thanks Susan did you if can you hear me oh wait yes sorry can you hear me yes did you did you say I heard I heard that you were in favor of um comments with respect to independ Monitor and also um traffic did you say anything before then because you you were qu you were uh too soft for us to hear that oh I'm sorry I was just I I was just expressing concern for the children and the community that are so close to the construction site and that um you know it's really important that we give

142comments because we need to make sure that the most stringent Protocols are in place to make sure the kids in the community are protected and that I feel very strongly about an independent overseer to make sure that um whatever the most stringent protocols that are put in place will be adhered to um because keeping I know we all feel this way keeping the kids and the community safe is absolutely the most important thing and we have to make sure that um you know that we do whatever we can to make sure the most stringent protections are are put in place and I'm also in favor you know doing the traffic survey and figuring that out as well okay thank you if I may um we did release an RFP uh late last week uh to

143do to secure a traffic consultant and the role the traffic consultant would play and I I don't mean to split hairs I just want to be careful uh not to do a traffic study but there is a traffic study included with the um uh proposed site plan and development and so we would review the study that was already done with our own traffic engineer uh because that study contains the information about how many Vans there would be what directions the Vans would go in how many would go in X Direction how many would go in y direction so we don't uh we wouldn't create an independent study we would evaluate the study that exists okay thank you for that clarification is there anyone else who wishes to comment Carol okay um thank you since the

144uh construction site is very very close to two schools and then especially South Grove um I will like the uh the board to uh send comments um to the dec and uh to uh uh about the uh um the pollutions and also the noise and um and the trucks and uh all of that uh to DEC thank you is there anyone else who would like to offer a comments with respect to the uh the proposed plan for remediation yes Chris yeah I I actually think none of the alternatives are suitable but the reason I I'm choosing alternative one is because it's 140 $3 million and they're not going to build anything okay they're going to walk away from it I don't think anything should ever be built there personally on alternative to you're going to

145have the water you know there's floors and all these options but the the alternative to you're going to have the water rain off and it's going to go into a recharge Basin you're going to further have that water go down into the soil further polluting the the uh bringing down those chemicals and eventually it's going to it's hitting the the water supply it may be hundreds of feet down it's going to gravity is going to pull that down there none of us are scientists and uh you know the these toxins and chemicals have been there for years for seven over 70 years so uh you know that's that's my rationale for this okay thank you with no one else um having comments it sounds like um the board is directing comments uh and the comments

146would be with respect to uh the areas of concern for um uh for the project uh with respect to dust and and all the recommendations that Nora had uh indicated so just so I'll I'll clarify what I believe I understand our direction to be uh we will comment on the r awp as it is currently written they have expressed they the developer have expressed their preferred remedy we are going to comment on the preferred remedy that they have expressed by critiquing that remedy and offering our uh observations on what we believe are uh inadequacies in what is proposed because there are missing plans I did not hear a consensus on a critique of the remedy of um the cover system what I heard from the board not enough people indicated that only one did so

147uh the critiques that I heard from the board um were with respect to the deficiencies and what was submitted in terms of mitigating um noise and air pollution and dust and uh and traffic and the areas of concern that we have um mentioned uh back when saset Park was uh being developed but I didn't I didn't hear from enough people today yes critiquing I was that was my that's two so that's two people but well I heard two I heard you and Chris did you critique the the cover system so that's three it's it's still not enough I have Andy and me one second Chris I have Andy and me and Rob um who indicated that they'd be okay with the cover cover system then and well I didn't hear Susan say anything with respect

148to the cover system um and then uh Chris and Chris and uh Tom with respect to um critiquing the cover system um and that's three and three and I've heard from no one else with respect to that issue so if there's any other person from the board that wants to discuss that that would be helpful did we lose sound Susan did you have something to say oh um I yes I um can you hear me yes um so I'm not sure if they gave us an opinion on what they felt was the safest of Choice One or Choice two whether to clean up the the dangers that are posed by cleaning up the whole Land by carting everything away and the dust and what might be turned over by doing that or um the capping

149of it and if that which one um they felt was safer for the community and the kids did they did they give an opinion they did pros and cons um for us so uh not an opinion choose one uh they had mentioned the uh 4 and 1/2 years it would take for the full excavation for number one and uh the amount of materials that would have to be excavated for that with the cover system um they indicate but on the in on the flip side all of the material would go away um and then with respect to the cover system they talked about um the fact that would only take 10 months and that it's an acceptable um uh contamination containment uh system uh in the community that has been successful over time so I

150guess uh Dr Rogers has clarified that the plan that they've proposed is for number two and each one of us who has spoken has critiqued the plan in one way or another regardless of whether the critique was due to um their wanting number number one over number two um we are critiquing the plan um itself so um in that regard I think we can uh safely say we're directing um we're directing our Consultants to put together a um a a comment document that we can send to the dec with respect to that plan and it would be um it would be a critique of the the plan and its entirety with respect to the issues of concern that we have okay um is there anyone on the board that has questions for Nora and and

151um kianne do they need clarification on anything okay no all right yes that's all right uh so Dr Rogers I if I understand you correctly which I said earlier all all the options are flawed so if we were to critique the uh the Contra the vendor for Amazon that wants to they're proposing number two and we we we comment on the floors or the issues and concerns we have with that is that what you're saying so they have proposed a remedial action work plan and perhaps K Anne and Nora can get closer to the microphone so you can support me if needed they Pro there is a proposed remedial action work plan it has been accepted by the dec as complete it is now out for public comment before it will reach whatever its final

152form is and at some point in that process they will be given permission to execute the remedial action work plan uh we can certainly offer any comments we want we can say we we would like a different approach better but the only plan that is there that is uh complete enough to be critiqued is the preferred plan that they're proposing so there there isn't a option one plan to critique so if we're going to say option two the plan you're trying to implement lacks a really good Community air monitoring program it lacks a really good storm water protection plan it lacks the following things option one doesn't even discuss any of those because it's not even explored so it there's there is no option one to critique there's just the plan that they've proposed and

153that is the plan that is out for public comment right now um if so what I was trying to suggest and maybe did in artfully was we have this r rwp the time has come to make comments on the rawp we have the words of the rwp in front of us to comment on we think that it has some inadequacies in terms of the comprehensiveness of the the mitigation controls that are included and our comments would start with if this is the remedy that the dec is about to approve then here are the things that it is lacking and that we think need to be improved and so when I said critique there's there is only one plan they don't explore option three which is do nothing and build nothing Nora explored option three a

154little bit but that's not really explored in the rwp and they don't explore option one either so I the the one question and Miss Frankle alluded to it is which would be and actually miss Falco did as well which would be more impactful to the school district because of its proximity of the three plans probably the least impactful would be to disturb nothing Plan Three but that doesn't sound like it's on offer at this point and then you know it it is a question for Nora as a scientist what would be least impactful to our adjacent properties and again my direction on your behalf to Nora and Kenne I've asked them just to call balls and Strikes we have two properties nearby what is most impactful to those two properties so that we can make

155comments that are comments that are most protective of the students and staff that we have on those sites yes so um in terms of construction impacts is which is what's going to the school district will feel the the brunt of um I think option two which has um considerably shorter remediation time of 10 months is the estimate as opposed to over four years um it it's just in terms of impacts on the school I would say that opt alternative to which is the preferred remedy in the remedial action work plan would create less impact back to the district and the rationale for that is time frame um and the amount of um Trucking of um soils offsite um dust generation you're going to be digging up over 600,000 cubic yards of soil containing um residual

156levels of contamination um so that would it's just opportun Unity for more dust generation more truck traffic more truck exhaust noise um storm water potential impacts Ian the the plans that are developed would um they would apply to either alternative one or alternative two it's just in terms of time frame and quantity of material that's being um dug up and Disturbed and moved around it would be significantly less under um alternative two but to Mr Rolo's question there still has to be material that is moved around uh with the um the capping option in order to put the cap into place and this further question was around the excavation that will be necessary for any construction of a uh a building on the site the when you made your comments you said the the remedy

157is the cap so it is one construction project the construction of the cap and the warehouse and the parking lots is all one 10-month construction job as opposed to two construction jobs one a remediation job followed by uh a site construction is that accurate correct yes yes okay those are the shortterm risks correct so what's the long-term risk to the district after the construction is done because the that chemicals are still there right we're just talking about yet for the next 10 months or however long it's going to take understood but then what happens after like what's our risk the schools are right there mhm well the the soils would be covered by the cap um they're they're not um but we're opening a whole new can of worms right they're going to start doing

158the it's not like this stuff just stays it's Dynamic once they start digging it up you don't know what's going to happen you don't know how much more stuff is going to be Dig Dug up it's like when they started trenching the Huns and for all the toxins that were in there they actually then stopped because they were dredging up so many things that they actually just left it alone mhm correct right I mean that's what we always say you know just leave there's always unknown just leave it I wouldn't necessarily say that I mean there are you know Alternatives that are sound Alternatives like like capping right so is there a longterm effect I would say there is not um the copper and the semi volatile contaminants they're not there they tend to stay

159absorbed to the soil particles so they're not going to to leech out it's not as if you have a pool of gasoline or um a solvent that is has um they volatilize underground and they can cause you know they have a much greater tendency to um move you change phase they so if they did come into contact with water that you know those kind of compounds have a tendency to get flushed out and kind of transfer into the the liquid phase and would travel with with water but um the contaminants of concern being copper and the semi volatiles that's not how they behave um and there were um the concentrations are when you compare them to the commercial use soil cleanup objectives there there are exceedances certainly um but had they done nothing you know

160all along I mean there's been a considerable amount of contamination that had been removed from the site over the years you know beginning back in the early early 90s um so just I'm just speaking from experience in terms of other site remedies that I've reviewed and been involved in and you look at the risks and the contamination levels and um you know if if there was certainly if there was an a concentrated area where you had elevated concentrations and you could go attack that you know you call that a hot spot where you know you dig it out and and you get rid of it that's that's certainly um you know a a a good component of a remedy if if the site conditions are cond Ive to that but if you have widespread um

161you know relatively lower level contamination um sometimes the construction impacts outweigh the benefit of you know just digging it up and getting every Speck of contamination off the site so it's you know it's a balancing act and there's no one siiz fits-all remedy that applies across the board but capping and cover systems when you have soil contamination contaminated with these residual levels of such compounds that are not those which you know would readily flush into to groundwater um capping and cover systems are appropriate remedies excuse me with the uh capping okay you're still going to have the water run off okay so where is that how are they going to handle that water we have to talk about that remediation about water okay and are you talking not you can't tell you can't you don't

162know for sure how many chemicals Sero wire has in that ground cuz they have certain things that they State okay cakes and stored underground and this that's only what they told us this thing that we don't know okay and the cap isn't it isn't the cap a membrane no it would just be um uh concrete well they plan to esal the whole property right the majority where is that water going to go it's going to be I I'm not precisely sure of the exact site plans okay so they have to we they have to get back to us to let us know what they're going to do with that water right cuz there going to be a lot of water so I mean the the parking lots would have you know uh catch basins or

163some sort of drainage structures that would collect and what go on the sewer or go down in the ground it would go um into recharge basins or these underground um storm water collection systemns or I'm not sure exactly what chambers that then it the the water would would seep into the ground yeah thanks does anyone else have any questions or comments on this topic nobody okay there's I just want to give uh Nora and K and the balance of their night back so thank you very much for your help and um we'll see you soon good night okay moving on to uh a items A1 is the approval of staff changes for certified staff may have a motion please Carol Chang seconded by Rob gersan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions

164A2 is the approval of stiens and hourly raid activities may have a motion please rob gersan seconded by Andy Felman are there any questions all in favor yes okay are we on 1382 yes we are yeah okay all right so it starts off where related service provided some are revised it talks about special ed to receive homebound related Services it mentions a psychologist and a doctor and another person here but then I is the coaching recommendations part of the same motion I'm seeing that there's a misprint in the agenda I apologize this is um the caption for this uh should have read about the appointment of stip and hourly raid activities for certified staff the paragraph that's below it um relates just to the first two um under summer C CP those are the related

165service providers everything else is the other stiens and hourly rate activities for certified staff and that's the coaching recommendations beyond that and then there's two more captions appointment of extracurricular assignments hbt and S at high school so the the first caption that says approval of stien and hourly rate activities should have come probably uh well actually they're they're all certified staff it's just the first paragraph applies to the first table the second coaching recommendations applies to the second table the third paragraph applies to the third table and so on okay so so my other question is we got different sports here and I this is recurring because we approv different other stiens and other meetings but here we we got basketball we got um uh sports that we we're not we don't really have these

166sports do we we're not doing these sports are we so right now the status of sports is that uh the state Section 8 has uh determined that there will be three seasons of sports but that all three seasons will run after the first of the year so the winter sports will go first followed by the Fall Sports followed by the spring Sports they will be slightly abbreviated Seasons that operate during the new year there's certainly an open question as to whether any of the high-risk Sports will operate and there you know no decisions have been made the governor two weeks ago had said that he was going to give guidance on the high-risk sports but then in a press conference said that given the escalating rates of covid he was going to delay giving us

167that guidance but there is right now on the books a plan to have sports and what I also know is that these uh coaches have uh been providing their uh players with activities uh drills guidance for them to try and stay sharp for these uh Seasons when they do occur okay uh but Dr Rogers I uh I I don't know if we're going to do the three seasons I don't know if you're getting the value we would have had if we didn't have this pandemic I don't think so uh but you know this alone I added it up it's over $200,000 um so uh I'm I'm just concerned that are we really getting value for the money here you know if they're doing you know some type of things other than the actual sport itself

168like we used to I think all of our coaches have tried to make the best of a bad situation and I know a lot of them consider themselves to be year round coaches they may have a season but they're in touch with their athletes all year uh particularly last spring they went out of their way to try and put together uh training plans for the athletes these were the spring coaches in particular whose athletes uh lost their season I know those spring athletes are really hoping that they'll be able to get their season back this year having missed a year and I also know that their uh coaches have been doing these uh after school and weekend activities to try and keep the kids as sharp as they can and one other activity that our

169coaches do uh is they work with uh we just had our commitment day I believe two and a half weeks ago and the coaches work with college uh coaches to try and encourage those college coaches to take a look at our athletes for potential scholarship programs and that is also a yearr round activity that they conduct so yes we see our coaches on the sidelines and at practice uh that's not the whole sum of what they do obviously we'd like to get kids out there um competing as much as possible we've tried to salvage as much of this fall as we can and I think they've actually done a remarkable job of providing kids with opportunities to to do things safely it hasn't you know tennis has been some games in matches but you know

170others have just been uh drills and training socially distanced with masks but you have kids still working on their shooting uh for basketball I see the volleyball players working on what are called hitting lines and they're they're getting a little bit out of it they're doing what they can yeah just to piggy back off of that I I know for sure that if you if you ask most if not all of these coaches um how they thought of their role they wouldn't really consider it just a you know a game time um a game time position but they are coaching these kids uh you know in life and attitude uh and they're doing that now even though they're not playing games they're keeping their kids on their team together because they know that uh teamwork

171on the field uh means that they have to be a team off the field and off the field is unfortunately where they are right now so uh they're doing a a lot of work to try and keep their kids uh motivated and looking forward to the season and making sure they're working out and doing the after school fitness center and um so I know I certainly appreciate all the work they're putting in right now even though they're not playing games and all they want is to be uh to be on that field so um just my two cents so with A2 are there any other questions Tom Rolo uh Dr Rogers since it's an abbreviated season are these abbreviated stiens uh no these are the regular stiens and again we've viewed this as the coach's

172role is not just the days that they're on the sidelines or at a match but a lot of them see their role as being yearr and the season is just sort of an encapsulation of the time that they put into students but as Miss Frankle said they're working with these youngsters all year round pay the stip so the decisions about whether some sports would be canceled altogether haven't been made uh we did pay the stipend in the spring uh because the coaches provided them with alternative opportunities when the spring season was canceled um I would end up looking to the coaches to provide me as they did last spring with uh an outline of how they intended to make sure that uh they were still helping their athletes compete at their sport even if they're

173not able to have inter school competition so I'm you know wrestling is certainly a high-risk uh sport but it may be that we put together weight training opportunities for them so that they can become stronger compete better there may be film that they can watch with the coaches to uh learn new moves understand what the right counter move is for something an opponent may do it may not be that they get the chance to sit on the side of the mat and watch their youngsters compete but they may be able to do things things to help them still get better as wrestlers and uh what we did last spring was I met with all of the coaches and I asked them to uh furnish me with ideas that and my criteria for them was it

174has to be robust enough that I can put it in front of the Board of Education and I would have the same you know lens for this it's okay it isn't going to be what it used to be there's a lot of things this year that aren't what they used to be doesn't mean it it can't still be good but and I I don't know what the right thing is for the wrestling but the wrestling coach has better ideas than me and you know same thing for football he'll have better ideas than I do but I'll expect them to come to me with how are they going to use this time with these youngsters to keep them sharp any other questions with respect to A2 okay well in favor opposed any extensions A3 is the

175appointment of a perdm substitute principal revised uh Monica Corona for Robin Lan may I have a motion please Carol Chang seconded by Andy Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions A4 is the ratification of the stipulation of agreement with the soset principles Association may I have a motion please Christa Filippo seconded by Rob Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any any extensions B1 is the approval of recommendations for the committee of special education may have a motion please Tomar too seconded by Chris elich are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B2 is the approval of recommendations from the committee of preschool special education may have a motion please Andy Feldman seconded by Rob Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions be

176three is the approval of the 2021 2022 school calendar May I have a motion please Christa philippo seconded by Carol Chang are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay the calendar will be available on the district website before before is the second reading and Adoption of policies School District records parent and family engagement board members School District officers and employee Cote of Ethics student attendance student wellness and Student Records may have a motion please Andy Feldman seconded by Rob Gerson there are any questions all in favor oppos any extensions C1 is the authorization for service contracts may have a motion please christe Filippo seconded by Rob Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C2 is the authorization for special education and or nursing contracts may have a motion

177please Chris ol seconded by Tom Rolo are there any questions all in favor opposed any exensions C3 is the authorization for contracts for federal Park B funds may I have a motion please Andy Felman seconded by Rob Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C4 is the authorization for Peggy backing may I have a motion please Tom Rolo seconded by Chris ol are there any questions all in favor oh Chris sorry yes uh so uh is this just like a uh a contingency because it it relates to uh environmental Consulting and testing and uh because we already have vendors uh that you're using in the district is this just someone else you want to want to have on the list uh this is the Environmental consultant that we use and this

178is how we contract with them by piggybacking on the hulet woodmar contract but this is JC broadrick they're the ones that do um the environmental Consulting for when there's a remediation that needs to take place somewhere and they've done uh indoor air sampling for us they do the radon testing in the buildings uh that's the function that they provide and if there's like an asbest remediation that needs to take place they do the air monitoring after the work is done to make sure that the place is safe to re-enter so uh we we've been using them for years this is just the Contracting Arrangement that we use to get a good um to get the best value in terms of their consulting fee all right and sorry it's also for huet wood to become part

179of it is that it it's contract um this is a hulet Woodmere contract they ran the bidding process the law allows us instead of running our own bidding process to take advantage of the one that they already ran so it's hulet Wood's bid but it's just our contract with JC bradrick taking advantage of the pricing that they were able to get are there any other questions on C4 all in favor opposed any extensions C5 is the authorization to participate in a Cooperative bid through Omnia may I have a motion please Andy found and seconded by Rob Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C6 is the award of bids may I have a motion please Carol Chang seconded by Christa Filippo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions

180C7 is the award of bid to Palace electrical contractors for electrical construction Southwoods Middle School may have a motion please rob Gerson seconded by Andy Feldman are there any questions all in favor oppos any extensions C8 is the award of bids to Palace electrical contractors for electrical construction at HB Thompson Middle School may I have a motion please Carol Chang seconded by Christa Filippo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C9 is the authorization for change orders may I have a motion please rob Gerson second of by Andy Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed and any extensions C10 is the authorization for deduct change orders may I have a motion please Andy Felman seconded by Rob Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C11 is

181the acceptance of donations of Nikon camera and Flash and three bags of golf clubs May I have a motion please rob Gerson seconded by Andy Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C12 is the acceptance to dispose of broken Surplus and or obsolete equipment and books may have a motion please Chris Filippo seconded by Carol Chang are there any questions Chris Al R yeah Dr Rogers I noticed in this particular one um it was a massive inventory of electronics 4 or 500 tablets 100 Network switches is a lot of equipment where does that go are we liquidating it to a surplus company are we recycling are we going to a landfill what what's happening with this Dr rufo can you talk a little bit about what happens to the Surplus electronic

182equipment please we have in the past had contracts with organizations I'm not sure if they're through bosis or not where they come and they dispose of them properly because obviously you have to be care care ful of anything that's stored in them so um I I don't know what's in place now but that in the past we had had different contracts with organizations that do that I mean and the disposals are typically um because the materials have become um obsolete are incompatible and it does a lot of work to make sure that anything that is um could be used is used and and moves it around to other buildings so these are things that really are not working anymore but do we know where it goes because if we're concerned about the data we have

183to make sure it's wiped and if the equipment is still working there are s Surplus buyers who will actually buy it take it and refurbish it we have looked into those we also have um uh in in the past done auctions of typically not all it depends on the type of Technology but before you have to to do that there's also that data cleansing that needs to happen so we can find out specifically what's in place for these items that are on okay are there any other questions on C12 all in favor opposed any extensions C13 is the authorization for insurance policies may have a motion please Andy Feldman seconded by Rob gersan are there any questions Tom Rolo we usually all our contracts July 1 why why we why is again again I'll turn

184this one over to Dr rufo who manages all things Insurance um yes you make a good point we do usually renew contracts um July one just because of the timing of insurance we got into this um doing it on count calend year when we did our RFP and when it be uh got in place but this is actually on here to move us to a July one these are actually just for the the six months of coverage that will take us to July 1st so this year or well in July next year you're going to see these on again these are extensions to get us six more months so that we can get on a school year calendar with our insurance are there any other questions on C 13 all in favor opposed any extensions

185okay motion to adjourn

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.