001we're here to listen but we can't do it if we're getting yelled at uh and we need to have control of the meeting so you can speak your mind we can speak ours but what we'd really like to do is have these kids present their accomplishments because they're extraordinary and if we can agree to do that together we can move on with the meeting and you can be heard so with that in mind we're going to put a pin in the uh budget discussion so that these wonderful kids can present their amazing accomplishments [Applause] projects so with that said I'll skip ahead in the uh agenda to the part of the superintendent report where I get to introduce our K12 science coordinator Mr Ray levero he is going to be able to tell us a
002little bit about the process that led to a wonderful recognition of having four regeneron semi-finalists and finalists from our school district uh we're so very proud of them we know that this is not just the work that they did this year but this is the culmination of work that literally starts in middle school and tremendous amount of effort hundreds and thousands of hours of work that uh allows them to win this incredibly prestigious competition so Mr levero thank you thank you uh good evening Dr Rogers members of the Board of Education and our Administration so um Albert Einstein has said that imagination is more important than knowledge knowledge is limited but imagination encircles the world and the students we're honoring tonight have earned their accolade by hard work yes they've learned a lot over the
003past four years however they also had the audacity to imagine ways in which that knowledge might be useful to the world I've worked in three different school districts and I've never seen the level of dedication and support we have in saset semi-finalists for regeneron student Talent search are very rare not only do we have two semi-finalists we have two finalists our high school is so proud of these students and I know you are as well um the journey from ninth grade research to 12th grade regeneron scholar is really really difficult and our students are Guided by their teachers every step of the way and they are guided with the help of our research facilitator as well miss Veronica Aid and I'm very happy and honored to bring Miss Aid up to introduce to you our
004regeneron Scholars good evening um I I could stand here and tell you what I usually say which is this is the Nobel Prize of high school research and I still firmly believe that but I wanted to take a minute and just tell you that the perseverance of these students over the past four years has blown my mind more so than any other senior class just because of what they've had to go through and the fact that not only these four students that you'll hear tonight but the 17 seniors that have made it from ninth grade research and have continued on and found ways to continue their research from home um some students were not even in the building at all last year which you know they were able to continue find mentors correspond with them
005and then three of our students here actually were able to persevere and go into a lab this past summer and get some res search completed it blows my mind every day to talk to the phenomenal young students in our program but like I said more so than ever this year they stand out so I'd like to introduce to you two of our 300 Nationwide Scholars Sabrina Chen and Eric [Music] Wang and then our two finalists and there are 40 in the entire nation these students are Ethan Chu and Rohan Goa good evening um my name is Sabrina Chen and my project was titled negative charges at t168 s169 Andor s170 of Gene ecm1 promotes wild type myotic progression and synapsis in myotic sacy sisia complicated yes but I'll try to make it sound as simple
006as possible you so meiosis is one of the most important steps of any organism's reproduction and it accounts for a lot of the genetic diversity and the diversity that we see in organisms around the entire world unfortunately myotic aneuploidy or the deviation from the nor normal number of chromosomes constitutes over 50% of miscarriages that we see in the first trimester of pregnancy thus because of this statistic I was inspired to investigate meiosis as well as genetics in sacr serisier more commonly referred to as Baker East recombination is the first step in in meiosis in a lot of organisms and it occurs between homologous group chromosomes in order to form calent linkages and allow for more genetic diversity it first forms through crossover formation initiated by the creation of doubl stranded brakes and eventually leads to
007these calent linkages that allow our homologues to exchange genetic material however one of the intermediate one of the intermediate structures in this process um is called the synaptonemal complex or SC which is formed by first the condensation of sister chromatids in each chromosome into the axial elements as shown in red in the figure and eventually the connection of these axial Elements by the central element as shown in green the synaptonemal complex is one of the most important structures that allows for the Cove valent linkages however the protein of interest in this project was ecm1 which is a critical components of the SC by forming the central region um as shown by when there lacks ecm1 there lacks any of the green coloring or the central elements that link the homologues in my study specifically I
008investigated the phosphorilation or the addition of two negative charges and how this may affect myotic progression as well as SC formation and the results I found were that well when the E cells were mutated to have no negative charges or display an alanine amino acid the ye cells displayed a delayed myotic progression as well as crossover formation and SC formation versus when these genes were mutated to have one negative charge it displayed a more wild type or standard formation thus considering that sacy serier is a model organism or an organism with similar genetic characteristics to humans investigating this Gene as well as meiosis and overall myotic uh myotic recombination is quite imperative to understanding sexual reproduction and overall helping us better understand genetic disorders whether that be in developing more effective treatments such as gene
009therapy or genetic modification mechanisms or overall just forming a better understanding of how we can approach these diseases in the long run we need further studies Beyond just studying yeast but in more human studies as well thank you for listening [Applause] oh hello my name is Eric Wang and my research project was on the comp compant and aerodynamic characteristics of a 3D printed variable camber aircraft Wing So how do airplanes generate lift as air flows above above and below the wing a pressure differential a pressure differential is created generating lift there are several ways to increase lift while keeping the air speed constant increasing the angle of attack adding flaps to the wing and increasing the camber of the wng you can see those animations here uh so what is camber it's forly defined as
010the convexity of the air foil or in other words how much the air foil occurs for a wing with no camber that will produce low lift and low drag while with a wing with high camber that will produce high lift and high drag so for a traditional flap design as the flap angle increases the lift and drag will increase you can also see that as the flap is deployed or the center lifp shifts backwards which can cause a a a pitching moment which can increasing which can increase the chance of stalling and crashing so let's compare this with a variable camber Wing design similarly as the wing camber increases the lift and drag will increase in addition or hypothetically the lift or the center of lift will not shift as the camber changes uh this
011leads to this leads to my hypothesis the main objective was to determine whether or not I can actually design a wing that can alter its camber and Achieve different levels of lift and drag and additionally my second objective was to uh see if the center of lift will shift as previously mentioned uh if these goals can be achieved then I can potentially create a wing that is more efficient than the traditional aircraft flap design as you can see although for flap design you can see that there's a lot of drag produced since the flap is segmented and not continuous while for the variable camber Wing you can see that it's more streamlines reducing wastage drag so there were several main procedures throughout the project first was designing the wing followed by computational software which included
012finite element analysis or FAA and computational fluid dynamics or cftd FAA pertains to stress simulations while cfd refers to simulating air flow over the wing so for the wing design you can see that the wing is very thin or the wing skin is very thin which allows for the wing to be very flexible and Camber and it was found that as more force was applied to the wing the camber increases as expected for the airflow simulation results uh as the wing camber increased the lift and drag increased while the efficiency which was calculated by dividing lift and drag decreased uh in summary I was able to design a wing that can camber and Achieve different levels of lift and although one of my initial hypotheses about the shift and center of lift was incorrect a
013future research can be done to further validate my results thank you good evening my project is on developing a self form ectodermal autonomous multizone orade model using human stem cells to examine the effect of doxy cycling treatment on UV melanoma specifically to give a brief synopsis and an introduction to my research while Vol teering at Nasa University Medical Center a community hospital within Nasa County there was a woman who couldn't afford treatments for her son's cancer and that really shocked me so what I sought to do was develop a more economical treatment to cancer through an antibiotic called doxy cycling and when I was at the library browsing some articles some medical journals on abdominal pain I found that someone ripped out the appendix but that wasn't the most notable thing the most notable thing
014was a specific article that talked about how doxy cyclan had previous ly been used to treat breast cancer and it was really effective and economical in doing so so specifically within my project Uval melanoma is the specific cancer that I sought to investigate the effects of doxcycline on and it currently has a 80% mortality rate within 6 months so it's extremely deadly for those who do have it and specifically oxidated phosphorization which is essentially mitochondrial function is required for tumor growth and metastasis and notably what was previously found in the journal article was that doxy cycling was able to inhibit these oxidated phosphorization processes in breast cancer so what I sought to do was to Port that over to use in Uval melanoma and additionally what I found was that doxy cycline could specifically inhibit
015the cancer stem cell growth as for how I did that specifically because doxycycl is such a rare cancer I sought to create a model of it where I could essentially knock down some of the tumor suppressor genes within a human organoid model you created using stem cells and by knocking down the specific p-53 and bapm cancer genes I was able to specifically induce cancer within that model and create a generalizable and replicable model of uvom melanoma within the human eye and then after treating that toxy cycline after treating that UV melanoma model with oxycline I was able to look at some of these computational models that were created by inserting those specific genes through a gene processing machine so then they could be ported into computational software and essentially what is shown here is the
016different Gene markers that are within the specific model so then I could later group them together which is shown here and here is like the different labeled areas of the human based on the specific genes that were expressed within each regions and specifically if you look at a that's of the normal human eye and b c and d are of different classes of uvom Moma and in this picture I show where the specific genes are expressed so using this computational analysis I was able to identify where specificly the most cancer-causing genes were expressed within the different eye regions and notably here we can see that they're mostly expressed in areas such as the neural crest and retina so after that I was able to do amuno fluoresence analysis and essentially through this I was able
017to label where specifically these genes were expressed within the IM model so then I could evaluate whether they were increased like the tumor suppressor genes were increased or whether they didn't have really or whether doxy cycling didn't really have an effect on any of these tumor suppressor genes and what I I found was after doxy cycling treatment as shown here a lot of the specific like tumor suppressor genes like Bap one and sock 10 were able to increase in their presence which meant that doxy cycling is potentially a candidate for increasing tumor suppressor Gene so then it'll be really hard for cancer to start developing because there are these check imbalances that prevent a cancer from developing within the eye and within this model I was able to use a qpcr machine which is commonly
018used for things such as covid tests in order to identify the different levels of the genes that are impacted in UV melanoma and specifically I was able to see that the oxidative phosphorization genes which are often within the mitochondria were actually really decreased after treatment with Doxycycline which essentially means that it'll be really hard for these cancer cells to continue proliferating continue dividing because they're so little energy available for them to do so as for some future implications the most notable ones include a future investigation about doxy's impacts on liver cancer because again because uvio melanoma has a 80% mortality rate it often spreads throughout the human body and it often specifically goes to the liver and causes liver cancer as well so doxy cycl is a potential treatment to prevent that from happening within
019the deliver and there are other potential therapies that can take place as such as combined oxy cycling and radiation therapy because radiation therapy alone was seen to be uneffective in treating UV melanoma here's a list of my references thank you for listening hi my name is Rohan gotra and my project is titled uncovering Motif interactions from convolutional attention networks for regulatory genomics genetic disorders like Parkinson's disease Alzheimer and cancer are caused by defects in the DNA that we call mutations we know that these mutations cause problems by impacting the DNA's ability to bind to proteins but our understanding of this process is still very limited and so developing computer models that can understand this mechanism and predict how proteins will bind to the DNA is very important one such model is the convolutional attention neural
020network which is a form of artificial intelligence this model has demonstrated very high performance in genome analysis tasks but the problem is its success is predicated on framing The Challenge in a way that actually hides most of the information it's learned and what I mean by that is we give the model a DNA sequence and it will tell us if a protein will bind to DNA or not and that's great but that's not really what we're interested in what we care more about is how it came to that decision what features is it looking at in the DNA to predict if a protein will bind and this is where a concept called interpretability comes into play we need to be able to look at these models and pull out information that tells us how the
021proteins are binding if they're looking for specific sequences along the DNA if they're dependent on The Binding of other transcription factors and so in my study I sought to develop a technique that allows us to pull this types of this type of information from artificial intelligence models or more specifically the convolutional attention Network there was one study that also attempted to do this and it called its technique sator and so I first s out to investigate how effective this technique was and the first step to doing that was developing a data set so I generated my own data set consisting of randomly generated DNA sequences and IA several different models to see how sator fared and I found that in general the performance of this technique was actually remarkably poor It produced many false positives
022and wasn't very accurate and so to address this I designed my own technique that I call GAC which stands for Global interactions via filter activity correlation and I showed in my study that my technique is much more effective at pulling out information from these convolutional attention neural networks and the reason it does this is because my technique is more globalized meaning it looks at multiple sequences instead of only one sequence when understanding how the DNA works and so in summary in my study I showed that my technique called GAC is much more effective at interpreting convolutional attention neural networks which again is a form of artificial intelligence and this is important because it allows us to further understand the DNA's regulatory mechanisms meaning how proteins will interact with it and this is really the first
023step to treating genetic disorders because we know that mutations impact the the Assembly of the transcription initiation complex which is critical to gene expression and so if we can figure out how these proteins interact with the DNA we can understand how mutations can affect gene expression which again is necessary to understand for treating disorders like Parkinson's Alzheimer or cancer or just any disorder that has origins in the DNA thank you these are my references [Music] I want to thank the four of you for coming to the board meeting tonight and presenting to us uh aside from the fact that your presentations showed so much effort so much Ingenuity um it's really hard to get up here and talk in front of a lot of people and that was really very impressive so um thank you
024so much for sharing with us congratulations and thank you to our science department for uh helping these spectacular students reach their potential thank you okay with that if you would like to take an easy exit you may we're going to begin our uh budget presentation if you'd like to stay for the meeting please do [Applause] Dr ruo I can't see her no I'm good okay we left off at security overall you can see the security code increased about by about 771 th000 or 23% it reflects increased presence of both in-house and contracted security um increased hours during the school day and for after school activities and event you mo may notice an increase in the FTE on the bottom right hand corner that does not reflect a decrease in security at it's just a transfering
025security supervision from in-house staff to contracted uh firm with law enforcement experience transfer to Capital the law allows school districts several mechanisms to complete Capital work and we've been successful over the past several years on putting um capital projects into the transfer to Capital project project line item and have them completed that way so um for the proposed budget for 2223 we have several projects in there that are listed in the blue box um essentially the library renovation lighting for the turf field tennis courts some BCS projects including some plumbing and Roofing work and then Paving of the high school lot which is the um beat up lot on the right in that photograph now as we again as we go through the the budget process the mix of projects may change the other way
026that the state allows districts to complete capital projects is through the issuance of debt and so our debt service line is up at the top and it shows a decrease of about 1.4 million as we discussed all during our Capital presentations our goal was to ultimately have level Debt Service so as we had older debt rolling off which is what what you're seeing in that blue in the blue bar the other debt comes on to replace it and in the out years having essentially getting back to where we were the debt that's rolling off is was actually started in the early 2000s so we move to the administration section of the budget the chart on the right the Box on the right shows all the components that are included in there and it represents just
027about 10% a little under 10% of the district's operating budget overall all the administrative codes increased by about 3.5% or 650,000 compared to the current year Staffing changes made in the current school year as well as contractual salary adjustments and other contracted expenses are responsible for the rest of the increase so let's just look at a couple of the codes that have variances they begin with district meeting that contains all the expenses for the district election and that increase slightly just due to the uh expenditure Trend if you look at 2021 it's slightly more than we have budgeted for 2122 so that's just an adjustment the auditing code 1320 contains all the expenses for the different Auditors that the district is required to have and we did an RFP for our internal auditor and we
028had expens expenses that were below our forecast so that's what's responsible for the decrease in that code purchasing and Personnel reflect essentially contractual salary increases of the staff that are in those areas the box at the bottom has uh essentially the district's risk management program another word for it insurance and I have a place holder in there 5% while we work with our insurance experts on quotes for the the following year we were a little bit over budget this year which why it reflects a 7.8% increase with the 5% escalation Central Printing and mailing and data processing again contractual salary increases um and then there's an increase in Bose's cost for copy leases the next two codes culum development and supervision account for the largest codes in the administrative section essentially half of the expenses
029so curriculum development increased by about 235,000 or 8% and that reflects the increase of 1 FTE staff that was added in the current year to provide support for the elementary principles for evaluations and supervision contractual salary adjustments in that code account for the remainder and supervision which is the second code there which contains all of the salaries of the building principles and their staff that increased for um next year 242,000 and that's related to shifts in the current school year including the increase of 05 FTE in in the middle schools for APS and one clerical increase in the High School attendance office to assist with reporting and monitoring of attendance data the last topic we're going to go over tonight is revenue typically we look at Revenue next month but I wanted to just share
030some information on state aid if you look at the bottom line State a we are showing a 5.5 million increase primarily in Foundation Aid and we had a hint last year that we might be getting an increase in Aid and this is the executive budget we'll get the final budget um later in uh March hopefully and while we're very pleased to have this additional Revenue it'll help against the other costs that are coming up um it does reflect just in terms of scale about 8% of the district's operating Revenue in the beginning we talked about the pressure um on TRS rates and the upwards pressure that's putting on the budget the employer contribution rate went up to 10.29 uh% and that reflects an $850,000 increase in the budget fortunately we had created the um the
031TRS Reserve so we can look to that and we've been saving a little bit each year since we established that reserve and so we could consider tapping into that Reserve to offset the variance in that code and we'll talk more about that next month but I just wanted to give you a preview of some of the items that we were thinking about on the revenue side and the March meeting we'll go through the program and instructional budget which accounts for about 80% of our operating budget another look at Revenue reserves and we'll up any updates that we make to these codes and updates to the tax cap thank you Dr rufo if we are adopting the budget in the April meeting and the budget vote is in May how soon after we vote do we
032and can we get the uh budget report card out to uh voters by mail and by other means um after we have the budget hearing that's when the postcard goes out we can send out the postcard until after the budget hearing but the materials like the uh property tax report card and all of the budget materials will be um before the hearing so so a very soon after the April adoption we put all those papers together okay thank you and approximately how uh long before the vote would voters expect to get that in the mail the budget brochure I usually Falls in I want to say two weeks before is my is my recollection okay thank you at least two weeks yes thank you are there any other questions from the board to Dr rufo
033on her budget report Carol okay thank you Dr uh Dr ruer for the uh budget uh presentation uh just two quick questions um I know you are going to talk about the program instructional budget next month uh but in the beginning of today's presentation you did mention that all the programs will be preserved under the current uh budget um I am curious to see if project beond will be be brought back next year because I know that we don't have it and we I know that uh we brought back the uh the n period in middle school but Pro beond still isn't here yet so um so that was one and the second question is that the uh for um the uh the capital codes um there's one the maintenance of plant 1621 um you
034said you mentioned that there's going to be anticipated increases in overtime costs um would you be able to uh elaborate a little more on that overtime overtime cost is and how much would that be and the over times in relations to what projects right um as you as you know the district has been taking on different projects from transfer to capital projects and projects we've um uh borrowed for we also do projects smaller projects as part of the uh the operating budget that 1621 budget and often times those are required to be done after ours and if they're done by our staff then that's where you see the overtime cost sometimes when we have contractors additionally in the buildings we have our staff stay here just to make sure that things are done properly there's
035proper cleanup if things need to be systems need to be turned on and off we want our people who are familiar with our buildings there for those for those cases and in speaking with Greg we are looking at overtime costs very closely and we're expecting as projects sort of slow down as the pace is slowing down we're wrapping up a lot of our projects that those costs will will come down I'm sorry Brian and then uh shie I'll be quick you mentioned Dr rufo and thank you for the presentation um in security you mentioned that the change in FTE is shown but there's also just the overall increase of about 23% yes in security could you could you explain that yes um so security um this year I think we're a little light in security
036we based our our numbers at last year we had the high school was in um hybrid so we had not as many kids in it at one time we have more activities going on this year and have security presence so we're seeing an uptick in our security cost um and our security presence and our hours and additionally we hired although it looks like there's an FTE flat in terms of our part-time security we did hire additional Security in the current year so that we did not we had budgeted nine and we actually hired more as we moved more towards so it's sort of a um cascading effect of uh more hours and more security presence thank thank you Dr Ruf um first question is when you're calculating the tax cap for 2022 2023 um it
037goes the first thing you calculate is the tax Lev for 2021 to 22 22 is that calculation the um what is um allowed or at the actual Levy it's the starting point is the actual Levy okay um and the second one is that in central Printing and mailing our budget is a little bit over half a million are we do we have any plan on going a little bit away from Printing and going paperless and by doing so reducing the uh the expense on printing yes and we have over the years um certainly moved moved less towards um paper um and as you know our students use a lot of electronic resources um we do do a lot of we do mailings um we do budget brochures and so I I don't know that we'll
038ever completely move away from um paper but we certainly have um made a lot of a lot of our um notices to schools or electronic and have moved in that direction any other board member have a question about budget okay thank you Dr rifo okay next we have the approval for the uh minutes of meeting dated January 10th 2022 may have a motion please miss falkov uh seconded by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions Dr rifo you're back for the treasurers report as indicated in the treasures report the cash on hand for the month end December 31st 2021 is 112,500 9841 it shows that bank balances for all accounts were reconciled to book balances and were collateralized in accordance with the district's banking agreements and investment policy thank it
039got a little quieter but all right good evening um first of all I just want to uh add my congratulations to the young people who uh did so well obviously they've left the room now but it really is a credit to all of the people who work so hard for them and I just want to thank the audience here I know how hard it is for me to speak uh when there's a little crackle in the air I can only imagine how hard it must have been for the young people and and so you were very gracious and very welcoming to them and I'm sure it put them at ease and so I want to thank you for that kindness um that said uh part of the conversation tonight part of what I'm going to
040try and do is set a little bit of context so um obviously no one's been through a pandemic before and we're all trying to figure out the best way to move through this pandemic and to get to the other side certainly um I would say that for my part and for Conan you can put my present ation up whenever you're ready um the last 23 months for me have been about trying to do everything in our power to keep students and staff safe and since the beginning of this pandemic I've had three goals uh three goals that I've discussed with the board three goals that the board has emphasized goal one keep everybody safe goal two get everybody back in person as soon as possible goal three return as much of our activ activities to
041prepandemic normal as possible but we've been doing that slowly methodically and what we've tried to do is every time we add something back find some way to compensate for whatever additional risk is added so in looking at this um I'm a science person by training and background myself and so I see my world through data I'm going to share with the board with you the data that I find informative in terms of trying to understand the moment that we're at right now and also data that I think helps us see around the corner for where we're going to be soon and obviously the better we can see around the corner the better we can plan for the future the better we can uh work on those three goals of keeping everybody safe keeping everybody in
042person and returning as much as we can to prepandemic normal so with that said at last month's meeting it was only a month ago we were at the very top of the peak and it looked like it had just started to Crest but obviously without knowing if that was true or not it was still a guess at that point but obviously it has crested and it has fallen sharply this is extraordinarily good news um there are lots of data sites online that let you compare how we've fared through this Omron surge to a lot of other countries South Africa Britain and no one has had as steep an up and as steep a down as we've experienced here these are NASA and suff County data and then uh some more localized data but what strikes
043me from this map from this chart is the large peak in January of uh 2021 which we're calling the ancestral Peak versus this peak which was four times as high so even though we have fallen a tremendous amount from where we were at the beginning of January when the Omron peaked we that was four times where we were when what we thought was the worst Peak we were ever going to see last January it really is a stunning event so the variants in circulation have changed so obviously in the fall the Delta variant was what we were experiencing our understanding of the Delta variant was that it was more transmissible than the variants that had come before Alpha and the ancestral variant and not only more transmissible but slightly more virulent meaning more likely to
044cause more serious disease that Delta variant has been displaced entirely by Omron and if you go on to the state site from which this data is derived it right now the state is showing zero Delta left in in circulation in New York all Omron that's good news um not good news that there's Omron circulating but by any stretch of the imag imagination but it is better news that it is Omron than it is Delta and here's why actually let me come back to that slide so Omron seems to have fewer severe outcomes than Delta these are two research studies that compare experiences for populations of students uh one student's five another one students's a little bit older and what are the likelihood of severe outcomes from Co for students during a period of time when
045mostly Delta was in circulation and a period in time where mostly Omron was in circulation and you can see that the severe outcomes were roughly three times more likely when Delta was in circulation than Omron so it is reassuring that there is apparently no Delta in circulation anymore because this is clearly the nastier of the two variants and you can see this also in the rate of hospitalization this is NASA County data so there's two Act here one axis the green axis corresponds to the green line that's the number of cases and then the other axis corresponds to the orange line that's the number of hospitalizations so the two axes are shifted so that you can see the first Peak as though they were identical so if there was as much hospitalization from Omron as
046there was from the ancestral variant then the second orange Peak would be just as as high as the second Green Peak but it's not it's considerably lower so what does that mean it means that hospitalizations during the Omron Peak went up 50% even though there was a 400% increase in the number of cases so that's good because it means that Omron does not result in hospitalization as frequently as Delta did but it's still more hospitalizations than there were just because of the raw sheer number of cases so one thing that's also a feature of Omron and new is reinfection so for most of the pandemic there were people who were getting sick with covid more than once but they were very very few it wasn't until Omron came along that we were seeing larger numbers
047of people becoming reinfected and that is because Omron is somewhat different from Delta different enough that the immunity conferred by either vaccination or by natural infection was not as powerful as it was when it was uh the Delta variant which was more similar to earlier variants so the question is now are there other variants as we try to look around the corner what is on the horizon so in the united this is a family tree uh if you'll use that as a metaphor for all all of the covid variants that have been found and had their genomes sequenced so there are literally thousands of variants the group of teal colored variants on the top are all the variants in the Delta family the blue uh just below it is um another strain of Delta the
048Orange is the Omron and the further right these lines go the more it is present day so you can see at the bottom there's a purple variant that died out there's another green variant that died out and the Delta variant for the most part is no longer in circulation it's just the Omron variant that is circulating and this is just us uh data if you did this same plot for the world as a whole you'd see that there are a lot of other variants that are still circulating the only question in terms of whether those variants will come here is if like Omron they're much more transmissible than the variants currently in circulation in other words they'd have to be even more transmissible than Omron which has been the most transmissible we've seen so far
049so it is possible that uh there will be other variants but right now none are circulating at least not in large numbers here so just some context for where we are now um even though we have fallen a lot the actual raw number of cases in circulation right now is still higher than where we work at the Delta Peak so th if these numbers keep falling at this rate they're going to fall through that floor soon but in terms of raw numbers we are at where we were in September and October when Delta was at its highest the good news is cases have fallen from 450 per 100,000 that's a daily new cases to 34 that's great but to give you a sense of just how many cases there are in the last 2 weeks
050there have been 8,700 cases in Nassau County versus 6,900 cases in the entire month of October which is when uh we were experiencing the Delta Peak so we're definitely going in the right direction but we are not quite out of the woods yet but I do think we're in a better place than we were uh spring a year ago and spring a year ago was actually good we saw case numbers get very low and we saw a lot of activities get restored and versus last year we now have the advantage of vaccination better Therapeutics and a much less virulent variant in circulation in Omron so for all of those reasons uh this spring to me looks like uh we're in better shape than we were last spring so the dotted line on here just illustrates
051visually where we are right now in our falling Peak and where the top of the Delta Peak was so we're going to fall through that floor for sure and hopefully keep falling to where we were last summer that's the lowest dip on uh the chart but we're not there yet and because we're not there yet obviously we've been working to try and keep everyone safe so I compiled this list I realized the the letters are small and too hard to read but these are all the things that we have been adding back over the last 23 months to try and get ourselves back to normal and when I think of how we started last year we didn't let kids share objects on the playground because we didn't know if that was safe we didn't let
052them do science labs and share microscopes or uh test tubes or uh share books in classrooms share art supplies in classrooms all of that is in the past plexiglass is obviously in the past and we've made some uh pretty chunky decisions about moving all kids in at the high school moving desks to 3 ft apart we've restored all uh Community use of facilities uh we're students are back to 9 period day in the middle school they're using lockers again uh we have been restoring as many activities as we can and we have plans to continue to restore more as we fall through that floor and our case counts go below where we were uh at the Delta Peak so what are those future considerations that I'm also looking at uh obviously uh the February break
053is going to result in travel we saw tremendous uh increase in cases after the January break and so that to me looks like the next point that uh we're going to have to keep our eye on in terms of what it's going to mean for us and um the there's clearly a difference in the level of vaccination among Elementary age students and secondary age students so just two more slides again trying to look around the corner so we have been planning uh with the elementary principles ideas for activities that we can do to start bringing families back onto the campus uh we believe and uh we know that there is a lot of value in having our families together with one another it builds our sense of community uh we also know that there are
054parents uh who have not had the opportunity new parents new kindergarten parents or new parents of first graders who didn't get a chance for a kindergarten orientation last year we'd love to get them into the building and introduce them to the building um we know how important this year is for our fifth graders we have a bunch of special things planned at each of the buildings for recognizing them and just a convenience for parents we're restarting the drop off of things that students forget and leave at home so uh that will help and in addition we'll be uh permitting uh folks to uh identify a second person who could be someone who could carpool pick the student up at the end of the day we think we can manage that safely so we're prepared to
055add that back again all of this is chipping away at the pile of things that uh we want to do to get back to where we were the secondary level particularly the high school uh we've done some work with the contractor who put in the new air conditioning system and we've determined that the fan system can be run without air conditioning in other words run it in a fan mode it has a Merv 13 filter in it so we although it wasn't designed for this purpose we can use it as a very large scale air filter and we believe that that is a a a way of mitigating the risk of having more people in the gym so we'd like to have more people in the gym we'll run that fan we're able to do
056that without overcooling the space uh and we've identified some places where we can have additional uh room in the bleachers so Mr Cronin and Mr cardillo have been working on that and I know the board wants to talk a little bit about uh graduation uh later in the meeting uh last year the state gave us guidance and rules for how to conduct graduation those rules showed up in April so we're anticipating that we're going to be given some guidance again this year I haven't been told that we won't get it haven't been told that we will uh but until we have some of what the state is going to require what we've been trying to do is uh maintain as much agility and flexibility as possible uh so that we can react to that and
057then just lastly to the point about the February break uh the state has been supplying us uh from what used to be very scarce rapid tests now we have ample rapid tests and so if for any reason you want or need uh rapid tests if you're planning on traveling you want to test yourself test your whole family uh we have ample tests to make that possible for you you just have to let uh your building know the building nurse will be able to furnish you uh with the test kits that you need and again this is just a way for us to all uh monitor ourselves so that we keep our neighbors as safe as possible so that concludes my report and thank you the mic is working can anyone hear me out there okay
058great appreciate that that's so much better um are there board members that have questions uh about the superintendent report Brian Dr Rogers you mentioned in your report that we're working towards I think you said in-person activities for elementary families when the weather improves and you obviously acknowledge it's been a long time now that kindergarten parents and a lot of first grade parents have even been in the building many have never been in the building and I'm wondering can we give them that opportunity like sooner than later like not wait until the weather gets better if you didn't clap I would have offered to do the tours of the buildings um I know it's difficult to plan this it just jumps out at me I have elementary kids as as something we should probably do just
059whether it's an orientation a tour um just let them you know a lot of us on this board were spoiled we served lunch for many years we spent a lot of time in those buildings and these families haven't done it yet at all thank [Applause] you yeah that planning is already well underway and um they're we're planning on some uh late afternoon SL evening activities that will make that possible and uh that won't need need to wait for better weather necessarily to do so um that's something those announcements will come from the building level uh as opposed to uh from me but uh the buildings will be reaching out to their P to their families and their parents anyone else on the board have questions Miss Lan Dr Rogers could you elaborate a little bit
060um on uh what's coming um from our governor in light of today's news from our neighboring state um are we expecting any sort of Matrix that um her pred predecessor um used to uh um write out in detail um and perhaps also about the timeline um of what's going on with the mask mandate and the um the news that we're all very familiar with um just what's to come what do what to expect the next two weeks three weeks um is there anything um being communicated to the superintendents to the districts as to you know whether or not the governor is going to follow um New Jersey and sure so uh I don't have have any inside information I get my news from the newspaper as well although I try hard to keep myself informed
061obviously so um I'll tell you what I I think I heard this week and then are you asking for an update on the legal status of the Mask mandate that's uh being adjudicated right now anything you know that we don't I won't presume sorry I won't presume to know something that you don't but I'll tell you what I do know so I saw the announcement today that the governor announced uh yesterday Governor Murphy in New Jersey announced that they're going to be ending the mask mandate sometime in mid-march uh the governor in New York said that she's going to make an announcement I believe on Wednesday about the indoor mask mandate for uh businesses Arenas um places commercial places but not for schools uh and I believe she said something about the it would be
062premature sure to do something for schools at this time so that's what I read in the newspaper so if I'm misquoting the newspaper uh that that's my mistake but that's what I recall reading that said what's the status of the Mask mandate so the The Mask mandate is a regulation it's 10 nycrr 2.60 it was adopted originally in August it had a 90-day life it was adopted again as an emergency regulation in November it has another 90-day life uh it's adopted under something called the state administrative procedures act which is the rules for how the state can issue regulations in addition to laws so the state administrative procedures act says that if you adopt a rule on an emergency basis it either has to be renewed after 90 days or it must expire after 90
063days so the expiration of that particular rule will take place on February 21st now the question will be whether the state renews it again uh as they did the last time if the state renews it again this Sapa the state administrative procedures act says it can be renewed for another 60 days if it's renewed again so I don't have any insight as to whether the state will or will not renew it so what's the status of the court case oh and I should just parenthetically say one other thing the that particular regulation the New York State mask mandate that applies to schools applies to the indoor school facilities it is not the Mandate that is controlling buses the Mandate that controls masks on buses is a federal rule that is ProMag by the CDC so
064no irrespective of what happens with the mask mandate in New York until the CDC removes that rule their rule for buses will still stand so two different authorities with two different um Lanes if you'll pardon the pun so now where is the lawsuit so that particular regulation has gone to court twice it was upheld in an Albany state supreme court and it was struck in a Nassau state supreme court Ironically in New York the Supreme Court is the lowest level not the highest level so the next level above the Supreme Court is the appell Vision above that is the court of appeals the court of appeals is the highest court in the state so the finding in the Nassau case was that the state violated the state administrative procedures act in how it enacted this
065rule in so much as the judge ruled that the agency which adopted the rule exceeded its Authority and that a rule this expansive should have been adopted by a law that was passed by the legislature that's narrow question of law at stake so it's being appealed and the appell at division granted a stay obviously the rule remains in place because of the appell at division stay until they rule on the case and there are four attorneys on the board who know far more about how the appell division works than I do but my understanding is that the state is required to file its brief with the court by March second then the plaintiffs the ones who were successful in Nassau County Supreme Court will have the opportunity to respond to the state's briefs and that
066will take they have up to 30 days to respond so if the state files its briefs on March 2nd and the plaintiffs respond within 30 days that takes you to April 2nd then the state gets to respond back to them that's another 30 days that takes us into May before presumably the appell division would rule so two things are on Parallel tracks here one is how fast will this process move through the appet division it appears to me that the appell division will not be in a position to issue an order until May early May and then will or won't the state renew the Mandate on February 21st when it expires so that's the current state of affairs now one of the things I know we've talked about uh two immediate neighboring states but I'd
067like to just bring up a third so one of the things that Massachusetts has done is they have put together um criteria for what they would see as an environment that is safe enough to Res remove more of the pandemic restrictions so New York has not done that yet and the State Association of superintendent for example has asked the health department the governor to put together something similar to what the Massachusetts has done which is to kind of illustrate what are the data points that they're looking at and what are the places where the state would feel that it is safe to remove some of the uh the layered mitigation strategies masks and other things that we have in place so New York has not done that in the way that massachusett has done that
068so it's hard to know what criteria they're using to make their decision and I would want as an administrator I would want to know not just what the offramp is but what if there's something as bad as Omron out there that comes upon us as suddenly as Omron we would want to know what the on-ramp was too in case some new danger appeared and I'm not hoping for a new danger believe me been two long years but we would want to know how we would protect ourselves and what we would how we would evaluate whether something scary was on the horizon and we needed to protect ourselves so I think the state has I agree with the position of the association of school superintendant that the state needs to be more articulate about what they
069see as the criteria that they would use to make that decision so so my question is we wait um for all of that to resolve I mean obviously the three tracks two tracks you mentioned already as a district what could be done today way to at least start planning for the transition out of this new normal into the old normal I mean are we even talking about it do we um you know I mean obviously we can't regroup in a day so what can we do today to prepare when the day comes we're ready we're ready to go and you know um everyone is understanding there is no uh bullying shouting in the classroom there is no fighting you know between kids teacher kids any combination you know how do we assure that when the
070day comes it's going to be a civil and respectful transition into back to the hopefully all normal yeah it's a sorry it's a great question obviously what happen happened on that Tuesday was a bit of an ambush and um I I think scet handled it well I think some other districts experienced more bumps but it wasn't perfect either so uh one of the things that we did was uh we huddled as an administrative team the entire administrative team of the district we had a meeting and uh the number one agenda item on that meeting was for us to start to go through and plan for uh if this were to happen again either because the courts uh decided uh to remove the mask mandate or because the time came that it was time for us
071to remove the mask mandate what are all the things that we needed to know and to be able to do and to have pre-planned and in place so uh we created for ourselves uh a bunch of internal uh documents about how we would structure things and then we also created an FAQ document that we would release to the community so there are obviously a lot of unknowns because who knows what this State's going to do exactly but we started to think through what some of the challenges would be we have answers for a lot of the challenges we have questions into our attorney for a couple of the challenges I think there are a couple of things that we're wrestling with and just to be very candid about it the level of Tolerance of risk
072is on a Continuum it isn't everybody on one side everybody on another there are there are people along a Continuum with their level of comfort and you we can't accommodate the extreme of either end because it leaves leaves no room to maneuver in the middle so my point is that we will probably have people who are on who will want to send their kids to school with masks but we also want to have some distance from between themselves and unmasked kids and and and that's why it's a difficult challenge so I I'm like [Music] I first so at this point in the meeting I would just remind everyone all your questions can definitely be asked but in a few minutes as soon as as soon as Dr Rogers is finished with the superintendent from for
073answers the questions of the board you will have an opportunity to come up here and ask your questions and make comments even and to the extent that uh we have answers to your questions those can be answered today but we have a ledger on the podium that has uh room for your name and address and so to the extent that we have to do research in order to answer your question um we can follow up with you and we'll have a means to do that so if you can just uh be patient for a few more minutes while Dr Rogers answers the board's questions you'll have an opportunity to ask them as well thank you I I have one other question um and Dr Rogers I read the letter uh that you referred to I
074believe it was the Council of school superintendent it it was a great letter and maybe I'm thinking outside the box here but I think we did something like this when we wrote Tom swasi a letter about about the salt deduction um you know why aren't aren't we sending that kind of letter now to the governor and and and asking for Clarity on these things I mean we're at the mercy right now of the state so we should be asking them for like metric-based formulas I I I don't remember Dr Roger's analogy about getting on and off the parkway but he's right and like we should do that we should send them that kind of letter put some pressure on them you know we we try to be leaders and this is not a bad opportunity
075to do it um I know we're just one District but other people are doing this and if the Dr Rogers you can tell me who the Council of superintendent organization is but I read that letter it's wonderful uh they' they're asking for exactly what I think we should be asking for I don't want to plagiarize it but it it should be something like that I mean it's this is more of a question I guess for the board and not necessarily the superintendent but I guess uh I'm wondering what the process would be if we wanted to send that kind of letter sure so uh first obviously a discussion with the board um uh normally we would put it on a as a discussion item um and we would talk about what kinds of things we
076would want in the letter so with uh the super attendance letter that you referring to that's the type of letter where you're asking for clarity as to expectations on how they're going to decide whether or not to uh remove the mask mandate um what kind of scientific metrics are they looking at um to make those determinations really about setting expectations you also mentioned um letters like other districts are sending other districts haven't sent that letter so what what I'm reading are letters of districts that have taken a position one way or another and asking for a determination to be made as to um the removal of masks um and those are two very different letters so I guess uh when you do you know put this on for discussion it's just about um being clear
077uh on what kind of letter you're looking for and then the board can have a discussion on that and obviously look at some examples would be helpful so I am referring to the the Council of school superintendent letter I'm asking for the state you know as they bicker amongst themselves with these you know three uh you know branches of government I want them to give us a date I want them to give us metrics I mean they're going to do it right other states are doing it and they're going to do it and let's put some pressure on them to do it uh but if it if it's got to be a discussion item I mean you know time is short here um and it would be nice if we could do something quickly and
078get it out if we have board support to do so but yeah I mean l the reason why the reason why the process is typically discussion items is because I'm sorry I'm going to use this [Music] one the reason why we uh put things on as discussion items is so that board members have had a chance to contemplate um so that they don't have to make a you know spur of the moment decision on uh something like advocacy so um just in terms of board operations to help guide a discussion that's more intelligent it's helpful to um it's helpful to do that are there any other questions for Dr Rogers Lisa um just to continue with the letter I don't think it's so much um putting our opinion into the letter as just asking the
079governor for information we're just asking questions I think that's what Brian was alluding to correct just asking the governor questions as far as getting some dates or information as to what she's looking at as being the criteria for when the next step is not necessarily putting our opinion into the letter anyone else shie um it's not a question just wanted to make a comment and I didn't want to lose this chance to appreciate what we are doing here um there are so many people here voicing um challenging what the government has um implemented to us and in many of the world this would not be so free what we are doing here is privilege the right that you have to enjoy and we take it for granted like air like sunshine we take it for
080granted but there are so many people in the world who will have to risk their lives their families livelihood to do exactly what we do here but however I do see I'm I'm surprised at this simple dualistic mindset we have because you know I believe I'm right therefore you have to be wrong you know I am doing this for the children I'm doing this for the children and it has alteristic motive therefore you have evil motive I don't think that's the mindset that we should be going in okay I'm sorry excuse me but just for a moment shie I'm so sorry but listen we are going to need to take a beat if we can't be respectful of the people that are speaking at the time that they're speaking right now it is the board's
081opportunity to ask Dr Rogers questions and to make comments but soon it's going to be your opportunity to do that and I really hope that for the rest of the meeting we can uh take our turns um and not jump on uh each other for their views everyone has a right to their opinion for sure shie so what I'm asking is let's let's give each other a little bit of trust we are in the same team right we all want what is best for our children so trust us to make the decision for our [Applause] listen one more thing I would ask you let's let's do this let's we are so sure that we are right let's give ourselves a little bit of room let's let's give ourselves a little bit of leeway to be
082wrong I'm sorry we're going to just take a five minute [Applause] break I think we can do this I can oh okay all I'm asking is that we do this with a little bit of respect yes a little bit of respect shie we're taking a 5 minute break to do with our own children that's all we're asking you have the right to do what you want with children [Music] what are you doing taking five minute break just sitting discussion it that's after the audience to public shie do you want to continue you're done okay are there any other questions okay thank you we're going to be begin audience to the public just a few rules uh General behavior of respect so we have a lot of people here that have their opportunity to speak we
083have four minutes at the end of four minutes I'm going to ask you politely to please take your seat to give your other neighbors a chance to speak when your neighbor speaks if they should say something that you don't approve of please just hear them out and do not yell from your seat if you yell from your seat we're going to have to stop the meeting uh we don't PLL board members we don't uh we don't allow it we don't talk about specific teachers we don't talk about specific students because of privacy laws we cannot so please make your questions or comments uh General and not about our uh staff or students uh at the end of uh this round of audience to the public we will um ask you to take your seats and
084we will do our very best to answer your questions uh if we can't like I said before we will uh Endeavor to get you the answers that you're looking for if that's something that we can uh do research on so with that uh please come state your name and residence because you have to be a saset resident to speak here okay hi my name is Jennifer rogano I'm the mother of two students at BOS Elementary um today I'd like to follow up on a topic that I brought up last month that we've been also discussing tonight regarding parent and family attendance at school events so what has changed like Dr Rogers noted last month there was about a 20% infection rate now we're about uh 4% but most importantly between last month and today I
085created an online petition titled address ing family attendance at school events and extracurricular activities in saset I have a copy of the petition here for you I can hand to you guys and I can email you the files with the signatures and all the comments after the meeting but 558 parents sign the petition stating that they are ready to get back into the schools for indoor and outdoor events in light of this support and the school district email that I received on Friday I have the following questions first the email states that we're waiting for our numbers to go down below the Delta surge of September to plan outdoor events for parents can you please help me understand how you arrived at this parameter if we're trying to reach numbers that we were at after
086a September surge what prevented us from having any fall events at the school this past year second I received the flyer regarding the High School Musical it stated that 24 400 people would be able to be in the audience that's wonderful news but again I'm looking for some clarification how can it be possible to plan an indoor event of that magnitude one month out but we're waiting for lower case numbers to plan an outdoor event at the elementary [Applause] [Music] schools in addition if we know that in one month 2400 people can gather what's stopping you from lifting current restrictions for example I think it would be very reasonable to assume that we could have more than one parent attend our children's basketball games as soon as next weekend yeah this reminds me of a
087similar instance last fall the entire District was invited to the high school carnival the weekend before Halloween it was a great event I was there however the schools did not allow parents on the properties for even a Halloween parade last I'd like to understand why you're not yet considering inside events rep parents like Mr Greer had brought up people are living their lives they're going in and out of buildings daily with appropriate safety protocols there's no reason that the same camp be done in schools or that they should be viewed as a place of contagion overall we all know there's many layers of the mitigation strategies that are in place in the schools and we all have varying opinions about them all the one point that we could all agree on is that parent involvement
088in school activities is a very important aspect of our children's school aid years keeping parents out of the schools has affected all of us and our children one can even argue that pre- pandemic the district wasn't offering enough parent involvement and this this petition shows that saset is ready to make a change and move forward it's time we all want to be a part of our children's accomplishments at school so Dr Rogers each week I receive your emails about what's happening in the schools and at the end you always include a bright spot how great would it be for your next emails bright spot to state that we're holding in-person events with our parents and our families again and we're lifting stator limits the district is ready and addressing this would go such a long
089way for many thank you for your time would you would you like me to hand out a copy of the petition or should it send it an email sure if you can actually put that on the front desk we'll be able to get them when we're finished thank [Applause] you good evening my name is Michelle monf I am the mother of of twins Who currently attend kindergarten at bis I'd like to address parental involvement in school activities functions and events the past two years have been extremely challenging for everyone especially for school age children and their families it is evident from current data we are no longer in a time of Crisis and it is time to begin getting back to a place where activities and events can be shared as it is the healthiest
090option for our children as a new parent to our district I've witnessed an overwhelming difference in how our district is handling school events as compared to other Long Island districts it is difficult to understand why there is such a vast difference in these experiences for our children I was disappointed when my twins were not invited to Bist for an in-person kindergarten orientation so I also decide to check this box by offering a virtual orientation three months before the start of school in August I saw photos on social media of kindergarten orientation being held in person and mostly with parents in several school districts across Long Island I believe the virtual orientation was not in the best interest of our children I've gathered several photos from districts all over Nassau County showing parental involvement in school
091concerts and performances holiday activities and classroom parties Thanksgiving feasts parents as guest readers Halloween parades sports events parent teacher conferences and career day as you can see soset is handling parent participation very differently and in my opinion to the detriment of our children [Music] our children thrive on praise and acknowledgement for their hard work and success studies show that children have the greatest success academically when parents are involved and partner with their school there should be no reason under the current covid stats why we can't join in the rest of Long Island and put our children's needs first our our children's education will shape their entire lives and parental involvement is one of the most important parts of this equation recent studies confirm our worst fears this pandemic is going to have a lasting impact
092on our children's mental health the international Journal of Environmental Research and public health reports that physical restrictions and social distancing measures have affected every domain of our children's lives study after study show that this pandemic has caused stress worry helplessness and risky behavioral problems among children and adolescents these feelings are resulting in increased amounts of sub substance abuse suicide and academic issues although the number of children significantly affected by this disease is minute the containment measures have negatively impacted their mental health and well-being thankfully we are beginning to see a decline in the severity of covid I am grateful that throughout the entirety of this pandemic children seem to be affected the least by this virus right now the current mortality rate in children 18 and under is less than 0.01% however it frightens me
093to know that substance abuses On The Rise and suicide attempts in adolescent girls has increased over 50% during this pandemic while our children are not getting physically sick from this virus they are suffering nonetheless and the full impact will be felt for years to come science appears to support the fact that covid-19 is here to stay the likelihood of having 0% cases is not realistic however we can clearly see the virus is getting weaker with all the mental health issues our children are facing due to this virus we should be doing everything in our power to to help lift them up make them feel proud of their work and celebrate their talents it's time for parents to be involved in their children's education and school Community more than ever before our parents want to be
094back in the building that is clear from the petition put together by one of our own soset moms it is crystal clear our neighboring districts have found a way to put the children first and bring parents back into the school buildings as this is truly in the best interest of students this is time that we cannot get back with our children and time is fleeting thank you and I also made um I made some I sorry I made some packets of what other districts are doing pictures that I compiled from other parents in nasso county and their um the school websites thank you thank you [Music] okay I've been in the siasa school district for 25 years could you introduce yourself I'm sorry I'm Michelle weiner thank you um I have four kids um and
095I've have been happy for the most part and yes I am against masking my children for over eight hours a day in all other mandates and yes my family's health and well-being has always been my top priority last five years I've been studying the human body and systems and Network biology and I've learned a lot about true Health masks are not about true Health teaching healthy children they are sick and dangerous is sick and dangerous and we will pay the [Music] price for teaching that to our children for the past two years despite the fog of contradictory claims and changing government guidelines dozens of scientific journals have published consistent data that establish these facts 97% of all people recover from covid-19 and children especially 0 to 19 as stated by the CDC have a 99.997%
096survival rate so why are we covering our children's faces for 8 hours a day covid-19 is mainly spread by microscopic aerosols generated by breathing talking sneezing coughing the vast bulk of these infectious aerosols easily penetrate common masks because 90% of the aerosols are less than 17th the size of the pores in the finest surgical mass and less than 180th the size of pores in the finest cloth masks aerosols are light enough to stay airborne for minutes or hours and hence they also travel freely through the gaps and the edges of these cloth and surgical masks government enacted these mask mandates based on false assumptions that covid-19 is mainly transmitted by large droplets generated by coughing seasoning and spitt these droplets are bigger than the pore size of most masks and only remain Airborne for a
097few seconds after they are emitted I could keep going but I'm going to move on why do many associations still promote masks there are many answers to that and one being that many doctors have openly admitted to losing their licenses if they go against the mask mandates and vaccine narrative and yet today there are plenty of mainstream doctors and experts like Dr Dr Scott gotle from the FDA and Dr Monica gansi Dr Lucy McBride who have said it's time to stop forcing these restrictions on our kids but I'm here to tell you that masks have been harming our children for the past two years they obstruct our children's breathing and respiratory systems they are communication barriers as stated by the American Academy of Pediatrics and the wh masks hinder language and socioemotional development seeing faces
098is extremely an extreme important part of Child Development prolonged use of masks can cause asthma anxiety headaches confusion fatigue increased heart rate facial microclimate and bacterial growth dental problems irritation of the mouth and skin and dangerous carbon dioxide levels masks were not intended nor created for children to wear 8 hours a day you have been hurting our babies and you must stop fores if there is a risk there must be a choice like these possible covid vaccine mandates that you're going to possibly enforce on our children they do not prevent transmission nor infection and do not have any longterm safety data they carry risks they carry risk of Adverse Events especially in young men and many children have been infected and have natural immunity so there's no need to force experimental treatments on our children
099you've done enough I'd like to end with the fact that states with mask mandates for states with non-ask mandates it's basically the non-mandated states are doing better than the mask mandated States and children are at the lowest risk for covid but at the highest risk for missing developmental Milestones why are they the last to unmask is it cruelty is it indifference is it stupidity history will not look kindly on our evidence free decision to mask to make our kids suffer the most the last egg SARS K2 virus is a new virus in town it's not going in anywhere just like the flu pneumonia stomach virus and all the billions of other virus we have lived with since the beginning of time nobody likes to be sick so take all this mask energy and teach children
100how to live healthier Lifestyles and be empowered with the knowledge like wholesome food good sleep fresh air exercise vitamin D C dig and maybe a little bit of fun and then we will all be in a much better situation for the next novel virus that comes our way thank you Miss Wier oh I can't read without my glasses don't TI hold the clock hold the clock the hold the clock okay so my name is Kelly brocky I've spoken to you guys before at the beginning of the school year talking about exactly what that woman talked about thank you so much and about toy so what I decided to talk about was uh just data just we are we just had all those wonderful kids who all did all those science experiments they were using data
101data that that meant something so let's talk about the data that that got us into this math problem um we've been told over and over to follow the science we were told that mass would bring the infection rates under control the CDC told state and local governments that would be one of the most important variables in the battle against covid as a result the school district and the school boards across the country have been masking our kids for almost two years now did you know that the CDC pre planning documents and communication did not even support their own Mass recommendations on February 26 2020 experts from the CDC began to make recommendations on policy implementation at individual and Community levels their documents covered 200 Journal articles written between 1990 and 2016 and was specifically tailored
102to a non-pharmaceutical intervention for an influenza type pandemic like pandemic like covid-19 the CDC planned years in advance for just this scenario they specifically trained for a pandemic influenza where there was no vaccine and no proven medical treatment available during all the training and pandemic role playing games that they were doing before the covid outbreak the CDC never once mentioned mask in any of their pandemic planning uh masks were not even considered a marginal benefit mitigation and there were no claims that masks even had the slightest potential to protect people or potentially impact widespread transmission so the CDC took their carefully prepared thoroughly detailed practice documents written by their best public health experts the organization had to offer and essentially just tore them up no new research was ever cited by the CDC to support
103the effectiveness of mas or to look at the different levels of efficiency between the cloth mask the surgical mask and the n95 mask in in March of 2020 Dr FY told the American people that there is no reason to be walking around with masks he said masks were scientifically ineffective and evenly potentially harmful to wear he even mentioned unintended consequences from wearing a mask which what we are all saying is happening with our children these unintended consequences however a month later fousy joined the CDC and told the public to wear a cloth mask in an email dated February 4 2020 fousy told a colleague um that the type of mass you buy at a drugstore is not effective in keeping out a virus which is small enough but pass through material he even stated that
104he does not recommend this colleague to wear a mask he said the mask will not will will maybe stop big droplets from a cough or sneeze but it will not stop the spread of the virus like the CDC F's opinion dramatically flipped without any significant evidence based research there's none FY knew that the evidence on mask had not changed because one of his top employees confirmed to him via an email March 31st 2020 that there was no positive impact from masking based on the gold standard of scientific randomized controlled trials the who also stated that there was a lack of evidence for the effectiveness of face mask in the community setting during an influenza type pandemic so overall the science was wrong from the very beginning so for two years guess what oh wait sorry
105so I can't read this so guess what the CDC actually has returned back to actual cus and stated that CL cloth masks don't work y'all just heard that right the CD said cloth masks don't work the only thing that actually works are the K are the n95s not even the K n95s just the n95s so the CDC just came out with that and said everyone who's wearing a cloth mask in this room does not work anyone who's wearing a surgical mask it doesn't work if you're wearing a k9 k95 mask which this man might be wearing it might work if it's fitted correctly and the way you fit it correctly is actually a very intense process you just don't stick it on your M your face and think that you're good because that's not how
106a c an n95 mask works so miss Bry so now the C Miss braie sorry can you just uh finish up this four minutes allow your neighbors to speak and then if there's time so the CDC says well any mask is better than no mask at what cost to our children is any mask better than no mask um I can do a little bit more let me just talk to you about let's just remember I've got a son who's a junior in high school and the last time he had a normal school year was in eighth grade do people realize that it's been that long I've got more to say but I will give up the podium I'm hopefully I can talk later hi good evening my name is Jean Claude Santini I'm a parent
107of two children in the school district and former saset uh high school elementary middle school student as well um which is something I want to talk about briefly um you know I had prepared a lot to write speak to you about just like many other parents here and kind of re re reiterate exactly what you're hearing them say um but I wanted to uh you know start off just by kind of commenting you know the purpose for me coming here was to you know this evening was to kind of discuss and I'm I feel like I'm under duress to be here actually was uh was to present my arguments and listen to the different topics That was supposed to be presented on the agenda and I have to to tell you to be honest I
108I was not my intention to undermine your process at all and I apologize profusely because I think that that was something I was compelled to do because it really doesn't feel very free I'd like to agree that for what you were saying that this is a an area what I'm so used to having an area to have uh space to communicate and speak and I feel all of you are here behind us kind of like a wedge you know in a football game for for the running backs back there to score and you're in front of us trying to protect and and and guide us and you know in all of what we're hearing about with the pandemic I know there's what I know what I know this what I know what I don't know
109and what I don't know what I don't know and I know a lot of you are so much more aware of those Realms and the the the finite details whether it be legalities and stuff that you were mentioning specifically but I didn't feel very free when I came in here I had what felt like a wedge of men coming up to me right as I went to sit down and for my activity so I felt it was appropo to interrupt the activity when it was discussing perhaps those gentleman's security budget position because you know I wanted you to get an an experience of what it's like to have your activity stopped and and and stifled as a result of somebody else just deciding that they want to do that and it's it feels a little
110bit abusive and it's not something that I felt like I wanted to do to be abusive but I felt I was compelled because I was fooling myself that I couldn't listen to her I couldn't even focus on the conversation I was so preoccupied with the fact that I had a wedge come at me and I was a high school captain of the varsity football team and I was the wedge breaker for all four years a as well as when I was in Middle School so I break wedges you know I'm not here to break this wedge I'm not here to break that wedge all right I'm here to have uh my words spoken and and get you guys to understand that the feelings of everything we're talking about has to be listen to and and
111maybe can be adhered to because of the facts and the legalities that you have to follow through with but um with that said I'm going to continue to what I wanted to talk about okay so um and if it if it ends up stopping uh the the the ultimate goal and the broad scope of my communication this evening is to demand that this board immediately take opposite ition to amendment of section 2.60 of the title 10 nycrr and repeal of subpart 66-3 of title 10 nycrr phase covering for covid-19 prevention and allow for all soset students to mask optionally I would also like to know who bonds the Board of Ed members during the September 13th Board of Ed meeting [Applause] and I know I've seen a lot of this stuff glamorized recently I'll tell
112you to be honest I'll go on a tangent because you know as a parent I haven't really done a lot for my kid going to board meetings you might have seen my face twice so I'm guilty for not contributing and being present the way I should in all facets of what they have to deal with you know so it's interesting when you're cornered like this how all of a sudden it activates you to recognize that you have power and that you have to do something to help and that you should have been doing that before so you know um you know as as I'm standing here I I just you know it's not my interest to to be like a lot of the Glamorous visuals online of of boards and parents fighting that's not something
113that I'm interested in okay maybe people are it seems sometimes interesting and funny but you know that's not funny you know um so uh so again during the 13th uh Board of Ed meeting um that you guys had in 2021 that every student to succeed act part A funds and federal and state coron virus funds were addressed as Essa is a federal educ law that outlines and specifies how States and schools can use Federal grant money to support School District programs and students in need Essa emphasizes equity and education for all students and expands measures for school accountability and Student Success to my best assertion this District ascertain the following amount and relief funds and I may be wrong related to covid $222,100 the cares act sr1 and gear funds um 66398 under the C
114R RSA Corona uh Corona virus um response and relief supplemental appropriation act 2021 and 1,491 213 under the American Rescue plan act 2021 ARP act it is in this interest of this community that these funds be further reviewed in an audit to make transparent to the parents what these funds were used for and I don't assert that you are not going to do what exactly is best for our kids that's not what I'm asserting in anything that you do okay because I do believe in what you are all here for is to advocate for our children's success because their success reflects on your success sanini I will suck thanks [Applause] hello I'm Gina luchano and I'm an alumni as well to the scas Central School District a little bit about what's going on tonight first
115of all I did not have a chance to revise things that were already said so you might be hearing some repetitive information here the past two years have been trying on all of us but the importance to be recognized is that we are not where we were in the beginning of this pandemic I would like to applaud the district and the faculty the staff and the parents on an amazing job in keeping our children safe by following the protocols that were presented to us at the time needed we are not in that same position anymore first our numbers in the state have gone down significantly and with that is it a victory within itself as of today's statistics Dr Rogers I'm not going to challenge your numbers my numbers came up a little bit different
116but the roundabout of new cases was 396 in Nasser County when we have a residency of 1.3 million that's a super low number and again I'm looking that as a positive and another Victory so what we have noticed and learned by staying involved in understanding the virus is that the science and the data it has become a seasonal and has found its way into more flu like symptoms with this new Omicron I do understand that there are immune compromised children so there will always be a reason for concern I like to share light to those parents please understand that this has formed itself like I just said into a flu like illness and we have been able to nurse our children back to health by doing those home remedies the soup the hydration you know
117we know how to nurse these children back if masking your children is what you feel you want to do going forward that is your decision I will not pass judgment I am ready for the mass to come off my children me personally I think it's for the betterment of them and also I do want to touch on upcoming talk of vaccine mandates okay we know the survival rate for the children is 99.998% and right now we have a vaccine that covers variants that have been eradicated so I'm not willing to vaccinate my child to something that's not going to protect [Applause] them so the good news is as least we are past that deadly variant that we started with this is no longer foreign to our body bodies some of us went out we got
118vaxed by the way I'm not an antivaxer but we went out we got vaxed and we even got Omicron so if you were looking for a booster there it is speaking back on the children again I would like to quote Dr Robert Malone the creator of the MRN and and DNA vaccine technology his quote goes as follows in my opinion our public policies advantaging this has had particularly strong adverse effect on our children vaccine mandates for our children are completely unjustified for our children end quote at this point I'm sure most of us in this room have attended an event an evening dinner out with friends and family where we are not wearing a mask and maybe we're out 2 to 3 hours maybe even longer I'd like to note to everybody a little bit
119of humor but not at the same time the Corona virus does not have an altitude limit so when you sit down it's not hanging out up here saying that I can't be a host to you because you're sitting anyway I'm going to finish this up but I'm proposing that you know at this point I'm you know we're just we're getting closer to an emic can we at least start to use that verbage we've done well with this we have Therapeutics we have ways to get over it and most of all we have a current variant that is not awful I'm proposing the right to choose whether or not your child is vaccinated and also the right to choose Mass be an optional let's thank you everybody let's please stop playing politics with our children's lives
120and take back our parental rights in decision making based on the evidence I have discussed tonight I hope the sasic Central School District understands our parental rights and agrees to vote in favor of choice not mandates therefore resulting in a more normalized future for our children and best of all don't worry I'm done and best of all being on The Winning Side of History thank you thank you good even um good evening my name is shad and goddess I have two children this I District I'm here in opposition to the ongoing mask mandate and any other mandates that the school board wishes to implement in regards to our children's mental physical and spiritual health um I just figured I'd mention that I am a physical therapist and a former professor at ad Dela University I
121was responsible for educating nursing students on the principles of disease and pathophysiology I took a particular interest in immun immunology and I've always been fascinated to how truly complex it is through my studies and ongoing research I've come to realize that when it comes to immunity less is more less Pharmaceuticals less inflammatory foods less stress less toxins natural immunity has always trumped artificial immunity 70% of your immune cells live in the intestinal lining NPR recently reported that one of the risk factors for long covid is dispos of the gut Flora in patients with chronic pain the immune system is particularly vulnerable when the person has too much emotional stress or whose diet is Rich inflammatory foods so much so that MDS treat patients with chronic pain with with Wellbutrin and proac and it helps reducing
122the emotional stress reduces the pain our children will will internalize this pain it will linger with them for years to come and only manifest itself as chronic pain in their 50s potentially whether you perceive it as such masking the kids is a stressor I have heard from friends and my children and children of my own complain of daily abdominal pain and headaches it's obviously difficult to correlate maske wearing in the absence of other symptoms but it does make sense for kids who have a 99.98 survival rate from Co to wear masks all day is causing them to lose out on their education their sanity and their social skills so far the only thing that these kids have learned in almost three years with covid is don't get covid I'm extremely disappointed with the school health
123education department most children in school have no idea that food can affect their mood their well-being and their ability to fight off viruses prioritizing sleep as a way to keep our bodies strong spoken about very little the only thing that this district has manag to teach my kids about this virus is that it's deadly and you have to keep your mask on we we are lying to them we aren't telling them the full story when it comes to Health on top of that we created so much anxiety depression and stress related illness in these children that the suicide rate has increased substantially I'm extremely I'm extremely disappointed in saset I came here for the best education for my kids and what I got was a lot of unnecessary harmful rules that last much longer than
124needed because it seems that some are not willing to stand up for our children's rights you aren't teaching them that fear is only in their mind no you're teaching them that fear is what you feel when the thought of getting sick comes across your mind and you must hide from it you're teaching them that even the most minute risk is not worth taking you should be fostering clinical thinking skills not what that the most morally Superior award goes to the kid who wears the mask properly all day or even where it's two or three you're teaching them that their mental health comes second to Making triple vaccinated adults feel safe you're pushing your irrational fears on these kids and causing them anxiety depression and increased suicide rate we should be empowering our children to become
125resilient in the face of adversity not hide their face from it resilience comes from taking ownership of their health you can minimize illness with the right diet supplements good sleep exercise vaccines and masks are not the only way to stay healthy I would argue that they do the opposite what you will be left with after the dust settles is a generation of children who are too afraid to run for the board speak up for an injustice follow their dreams if the dream is too risky we won't have any leaders I'm very disappointed I know you can do better we have to do better this has to end and I for one will hold all of you accountable you have my kids all day you're not teaching appropriate life skills in my opinion and I think
126we've all had enough um so no masks no mandates that's my recommendation thank [Applause] you hi good evening to all of you um my name is Tanya gats I have one graduate of saset high school last year she's now a freshman in college I have an eighth grader and my husband is a 1976 graduate and my brother-in-law is a 1983 graduate of saset okay so um I want to bring up um not the issue that so many people are although I came here for something else but um who knew um but I will say this though um to give some I don't know a little personal perspective I heard about a pandemic long before this one from my grandmother who was born in the 1800s and who survived the first pandemic the Spanish flu and
127in fact had her first child um but um and my father who was born in 1992 and survived World War II although his elder brother who was born in the pandemic did not um in the Royal Canadian Air Force but my but my father really impressed upon us as children resiliency um in the face of um various um world events that can come at you quite hard he never anticipated in high school having Hitler invade and the British Empire having to go to war he was in British Guyana and listening to London being bombed having his elder brother participate um in the flights over and himself joining World War II and so I understand that you know life events can hit you and my daughter was part of a cohort in high school that had
128her junior year very disrupted by the pandemic and her senior year as well and um so you know it's tough and I also understand that you're not responsible for the mass mandates that is a state law and so that they cannot unmask our children and that I remember well the 1970 seat belt controversy and because I'm I was um you know in school at that time and um and how people fought it fought it to the nail as it's an individual right to wear our seat belt um also remember my mother who is um you know remembers the polio vaccine and and that mandate so I think what I can say here is that it's definitely been a difficult time right and so um and I will highlight in the Wall Street Journal recently that
129and I'm going to read from it in 2019 18.8% of high school students said they seriously cons considered attempting suicide while 15.7% made a suicide plan and 8.9% made an attempt according to a separate CDC Sur survey okay by comparison 13.8% of high school high schoolers reported considering suicide attempts in 2009 now it's quite true in June 2020 survey 25.5% of 18 to 24 year olds said they had seriously considered suicide during the last 30 days and that was obviously just after the pandemic had hit and those numbers have gone up and when last I spoke to the board it was about the later school start time in the high school because I feel it's so imperative for the health of our children and the CDC mentions as lack of sleep the three key symptoms
130that cover in that cover that come from lack of sleep are suffer from symptoms of depression perform poorly in school and engage in healthy risk behaviors such as drinking so when I last asked this and if I could just have a little more time I know Dr Rogers you said the numbers weren't there which is what the CDC says any parent who's advocating for later sleep times will say it's the late buses we can't afford it I understand that constraint and what I'm asking for you though is to look at other ways of adding an extra sleep such as when I looked at the high school F extra help time and your honors geometry class where it's one one of your quote unquote um toughest courses has no after school health sessions and your your
131extra help sessions in the high school begin at 6:50 that is too early and I'm going to drop it here I'm going to try to come back for another followup but that's okay uh good evening my name is ya xia and I'm a Chinese immigrant first generation I have te two kids attending attending Robins Elementary School one um one is the first grade the other one is fourth grade okay here's a little bit background about my history my background I I was uh Wuhan which is original of the this pandemic is my second Hometown I been about 10 years in that City so I'm quite familiar with that City I have friend in that City and I was know about pandemic this Corona virus stuffs being early the most of people in here okay I
132personally I lost my friends family during this pandemic in 2019 and 2020 but I see more tragedy which been caused by lockdown in during the during the pandemic child literally get stabbed in stabed death at home and the and the ELD people cannot get treated medical treated due to cannot get pass can of PCR test they literally died at home they caused more damage to their home the reason I I when I knew the news the reason I get I would get really scared and by the way my my my friend home get lock down for four months at first wave I was scared that because I have the very clear memory about s in during 202 and2 2009 uh 2003 S which has about 10% Fatality and the corron virus because they are on
133same group so we thought maybe another s come wrong we are very scared but right now everything is clear everyone can see the static lbers the F number cross the age is less than 1% for kids is almost zero so I do not see any reason we should keep this mask mandatory for our kids that's my first opinion second opinions course this pandemic things I see so many infri of right from our government government should act during the pandemic but lock down and mask mandatory is not the answer it's GI just P grabbing okay it's just a logical slope sleep slope to infrige our personal right okay so so even it's SAS I strongly against to mandatory M um to do mandatory mask or do a kind of other vacing mandatory then come to my
134actual question to Dr Rogers according to a report by New York post on December 177 2021 Governor K want to M covid-19 vaccine for school age kids by full 2022 which is 6 months away pending legislation approval at the last of the latest status both F fisa and the Moda covid-19 vaccine approved by FDA on eua which is is emergency use authorization which means both company were not being hold accountable for side effect caused by their vaccine the government wanton to compensate for any damage either a vaccine mandatory without accountability is irresponsible and unfair for Consumer so I will not go down the STA number and the medical reason my question is do you support vaccine mandatory for school kids I'mma ask do you support vacine I'm asking this question in term of the morality
135not legitimacy so please don't reflect my question using state law or government exe executive order slavery was legal before 1968 free slavery was been cized racial segregation was legal before 1956 protesting racism was been criminalized Holocaust was legal in Nazi German hiding jurist was going criminal lives legitimacy is not the guide of the morality a simple yes or no is sufficient for me if you do not support it what you plan what you going to do Mr thank you so much hello um Christine Henner I have three kids in sosid schools one in hbt and two in South Grove so these children are our future and to quote uh Nelson Mandela there can be no Keener revelation of society Soul than the way in which it treats its children we have complied with the rules
136we have worn the masks we have socially distanced we have quarantined we went virtual everything right and now it's time to return to normal our younger children have missed out on so many things these past two years that our older children had the opportunity to experience uh the field trips the in-person parties the dances the in-person mystery readers at the elementary schools The inperson Spectators for G games concert plays even after school clubs became virtual cooking clubs became virtual these social activities these learning experiences is what shapes our children's personalities and who they are going to become in the beginning at the start of this pandemic I can understand the G the kneejerk reaction that we had because we didn't know what to expect from this novel virus after 2 years with more and more
137data coming out it doesn't doesn't take much to realize that we need course correct The Masks do not provide the benefit that we initially thought they would the effectiveness of these masks are being shown to be far less that we thought to expect them to be but the damage that it's causing to our children as a result is something that we need to address young children are showing signs of speech impediments because they can't see the facial expressions of someone talking to them chronic headaches and dizziness due to prolong hours wearing the mask increase anxiety and depression amongst our children a major part of a child's Social Development has to do with learning non-verbal communication which you are depriving our children of there are also the intangible side effects that have yet to be discovered
138years from now we will look back and realize the harm that we caused to our children now I understand there are some people that feel we should be vaccinated and boosted mased remote isolated but I am not one of those people I choose Thank you I choose not to live my life in fear because that's not really living I I have friends that are teachers in many different districts including right here in saset and they feel the same as I do one day when the kids do go ma the one day when the kids did go maskless one of the most positive and emotional days many children and teachers experienced as it was a day that it could be a smile could be seen from ear to ear it had been two years since that
139has happened our kids had not even seen um it is the school's responsibility to provide a quality education after all that's what we're paying these taxes for right um it is the school's responsibility that no child be discriminated against bullied or pressure whether masked or unmasked by the students or teacher teachers or teachers cuz I know I know when the state lifts The Mask mandate I am not going to ask permission and I'm not going to ask for forgiveness my children will come unmasked to school and they will get an education hi my name is Teresa morali I have two kids in the district and owned a house here for almost 15 years um I I wanted to actually um also comment on uh one of the board members recognition that you know here in
140our country it's different than other parts of the world where we have this freedom to make choices and come here together and express ourselves and I just wanted to remind everybody of what where those freedoms come from um we have god-given inalienable rights and they are protected by the Constitution the US Constitution um you know the Constitution is there to basically protect us from government overreach um I know all of you up there most of you up there not all but most of you have taken an oath to that US Constitution as part of your your volunteer work so I thank you for that um there are five federal laws and about at least 16 New York state laws that I can think of that really by by enforcing an unenforceable and illegal regulation our
141district is in violation of those um judge judge uh the the Supreme Court judge um neter I'm my I'm blanking because of nervousness netmaker he put it eloquently in his decision he wrote it out or his law clerk wrote it out basically explaining just explaining to us you know we were maybe some of us were a little duped but basically explaining why why it was illegal why it's unenforceable that 10 nrr 2.60 it was never really enforceable just because you say it's true doesn't make it true it was always an a false emergency regulation at least since March 2021 March 5th 2021 when the New York legislature said Cuomo and any of his predecessors or future Governors cannot regulate cannot make laws through regulation or any of their agencies can't do that you can make
142a law through the proper proper channels you can use the legislature and you know introduce a law introduce a bill and and um your regulations can derive out of those existing laws but we all should have known that um we have a US Constitution that's being violated First Amendment fourth amendment US title 42 us title 52 we have a New York Constitution Article 1 Section 2 3 and 8 we have a New York State Office of the professional code 6522 these are some of the laws that we should all be familiar with these are where our freedoms and our our our freedom to gather here our freedom to speak our freedom to to bodily autonomy our children actually have those god-given inable rights um the masks that we're putting on them the masks that they've
143been forced to wear are actually eua devices just like the vaccine most of the vaccines for covid they're also emergency use authorized um these measures were you know implemented you know probably in some cases a lot of cases with good intentions right but anytime we have an eua medical device or medical product something comes along with it it's called informed consent it's required for all medical therapies all medical devices and when you're using a face mask as a mitigating measure that is a medical device anytime you use something like that for mitigation purposes it's a med it's it's a medical device so I think we just need to keep these things in mind um the right to avoid the imposition of human experimentation with emergency use authorized devices and medical products that's that's something that's
144that's been sacred in our nation um I know you know it may have felt Justified because of the situation we were in an emergency but even the state in their response to their to the petitioners in that Supreme Court case um they they admitted yeah we're not we're not in an emergency yeah we know that um November 26th I think there was a new emergency mentioned but even the state me they they even admitted it we're not in an emergency so how can we you continue to use these eua masks in a forced manner um if we're not in a state of emergency um I'm here to just yeah just reiterate yeah I'm just here to say once again I'm here for parental rights to be restored I think I always respect everybody's choices what
145they do with their body if you want to use a mask or you want if you think that's best for your family maybe you live in a multigenerational family how household and you believe it's in your family's best interest to put one mask or two masks on your child do that you feel it's best to give your child you've weighed all the risks and the benefits of the eua vaccines you feel it's best to give your child that vaccine do that just respect if there's somebody else who doesn't want to do that and your Mas should protect you and we just we just like shaie Park said we need to show respect to each other and come together and I think I think we can thank you Miss Morales appreciate it all right we're going
146to we're going to take one more speaker and then we're going to have to close the audience to the public so that we have time to respond to our speakers and we have still uh our ab and C items to go so uh thank you and obviously we invite you back um to the next meeting if you haven't had the opportunity to share what you want to in public um and also uh you can write to the board thank you this is the last one good evening thank you for allowing me an opportunity to speak on behalf of my family our experiences throughout the pandemic and our experiences with sasid school district my name is Yolanda vzo I have one child in first grade here at Willet and I will have an incoming kindergartener in
147September I have been involved in education for over 20 years in Fall of 2020 our older son started kindergarten kindergarten we know how important kindergarten is there's a famous book titled all I really need to know I learned in kindergarten among of many other poems and essays on the topic they include things on cooperation social skills and all the good stuff of fair play but my child and children who have been in kindergarten over the past three years did not learn all of that they've been masked isolated living on the islands of their desks struggling to see here the teachers in the room not allowed to make eye contact with their neighbors they are trying to learn to read and write without being able to use all of their senses it's almost like trying to
148place an order at a drive-thru or understand the subway conductors for these early readers as our children are left to feel alone in classrooms sorting out emotions both happy and sad by themselves behind their masks they are losing so many of those special lessons that are meant to be learned in those early years especially kindergarten they are losing those social skills on how to respond to each other when they have different opinions and emotions the visual cues are masked quite literally in addition to being removed from each other learning how to share Al get along and the Art of compromise have been left to the Wayside the only social interactions our children have are on the days they are lucky enough to have recess or physical education and even this is questionable the ideas of
149playing Fair learning about personal self-space and respectfully working in a group or being hidden behind masks from their islands and through their computer screens let me ask you this what are your memories of kindergarten what are your Fondest Memories of kindergarten sitting at cafeteria tables talking playing with toys going to physical education playing with parachutes and bean bags circling up with a teacher to read Dr Seuss book do you remember all the interactions the emotions both Visual and auditory my son was struggling to sound out words in kindergarten and he had to stare at a word wall to try and decode it on his own instead of in a small group yes the teachers are doing their best I don't blame them they are taking your guidance but you you have allowed this to perpetuate
150in our schools you have taken your Authority and put it to the Wayside for what is easy instead of what is right and best for our children and our schools we all pay some of the highest taxes and I would have to imagine we have one of the best school districts you can find do you think that not allowing parents to have a voice on our children Ed education or their bodily autonomy is going to keep us there all of those skills that were supposed to be learned in kindergarten are now being masked in first grade for my son as this Draconian narrative continues I am proud of my son and all of his accomplishments in spite of all the measures the district has taken to keep our children apart socially inep and hidden behind
151their masks but in September he will be in second grade all of our children in this age group are reaching an important threshold for those lifelong skills that were supposed to be learned in kindergarten why you might ask do you know anything about attitude Theory there are three main components that make up attitude Theory they are behavioral beliefs normative and control beliefs each of these areas explains how a person arrives at a feeling or understanding of what they enjoy or not or how they should behave or not many of these beliefs in regards to education and social norms are set in those early years let me give you an example children by second grade or by the age of eight need to have positive experiences in physical activity and physical education this includes feeling and
152being successful and included in physical activities in addition children need to see both genders being physically active and Physically Active together that's what title N9 protects the research shows that if children are not exposed to a variety of physical activities in both genders participating it will have a negative impact on their attitude towards PE and physical activity throughout their life what we know from research is that those children who have negative attitudes and negative experiences begin to withdraw from physical activity shortly afterwards how does this translate further just look at our society the number of sedentary children overweight or obese and it negatively affects their self-esteem now what we have seen is that they become overweight adults who have negative attitudes towards physical activity now that we are closing in on our second year of
153mandates on our children for Those whom this virus poses little to no risk for whom losing out on the basis of education for which they are expected to grow from what will their attitude not only towards school and learning but more importantly to the Social and emotional aspects of being around others learning the social cues of others emotions and how to be empathetic towards each other this needs to end now so that we can help our children grow and Thrive positively impact their attitudes towards being around each other helping them understand the various social cues through facial expressions to practice those kindergarten skills of sharing cooperation play and experimenting now I can't even imagine what parents are feeling like with middle and high schoolers at this point these formidable years where they are building those
154social skills and preparation for college and being independent adults but instead masking and this isolation has created an increase in students doing harm physical harm mental and emotional distress Milla yes thank you could you just end with a sentence and I don't want to cut you off from but it's time what I ask of you is to think about our children and what's in their best interest their best interest for being having positive experiences experiences in school and how this will lead them to be better throughout their lives thank you hi my name is Sabina Chen I move to this district 7 months ago my husband went to elementary school here and loved the district and that is actually why we decided to move here and nowhere else on Long Island and decided to pay
155some of the highest taxes um I'd like to first start by saying that I am extremely sensitive to the last two years and what this pandemic has done to us we were in no way shape prepared the entire world was not prepared in a no way shape or form am I diminishing the hardships that some families went through and the loss of life but we are not where we were two years ago we are not where we were a year ago we are in a different place we know how to mitigate this virus and we know how to prevent it and we know it is not killing as many people as it was because we know what to do now and as as the months and years go on we will continue to know what
156to do and more science and research will emerge with that said I want to explain to you that my family came from Russia from a communist government controlled world that this gentleman here I believe from China was also trying to explain that we are here because we want to be free we want to have our freedom of speech we want to be listened to and we want the Constitution to be upheld and we want our children to have a healthy future that's all what we want I'm hoping that all of you here are here because that's what you want for our children we have lost our logical reasoning we have to stop the insanity we have to stop this fear driven oh my God the next variant it will come we know it will come
157and we need to be prepared we need to do things like I'm sorry I don't I'm not wearing my glasses so I don't know your last name but Anna um said we need to be prepared before I go into what my recommendation is for preparing I would like to tell you that I'm a non-practicing child psychologist and I study Child Development very closely and these masks are hindering our children's both verbal and non-verbal development I'm not going into stats I didn't write anything I really wanted to come here and listen for the first time of my uh uh residence here in saset my child is in kindergarten he complains of headaches every day he comes home and I ask him how was school today and he goes mommy I had a really bad headache and
158I couldn't breathe and I wanted to go to the nurse and I wasn't allowed my heart is breaking not just for my child but for the other children that are parents are here and are not here and if any of you have children or had children I want you to really think hard how they would or are feeling our children cannot verbalize Their Fear or their emotions we have to take control and make sure they are safe and these masks are not making them safe Dr Rogers I appreciate your studies and I'm really curious where you received those numbers from uh I can tell you some numbers there is a Chinese study that evaluated 50 out of 56 masks they found that they have extremely high levels of platelets that contain carcinogens carcinogens like in
159smoke tobacco smoke or vape um or barbecue smoke or inhaling smoke in a fire do you want to be responsible for the demise of our children's health I do not ever want to feel that my child's health and safety was in the hands of someone other than the parents I want to ask you and I really just need one minute more how many of you have gone to a restaurant a sports game arena concert gathered with family and then come to school and take off The Masks I cannot tell you how many times I come up to the school to drop off lunch for my children and I see inside teachers not wearing masks why if you're so afraid of the children why what's going on why is there this double standard this has to
160stop either put them on or take them off but don't pick and choose please um Miss Sabina I'm sorry I have a recommendation for you as a school and as a district and that is because I've worked in the medical field for 22 years with double and triple board certified surgeons if you want to truly make the air safer in the school and we pay lots of taxes please invest in uvh vac systems they are between $249 to $2400 depending on the square footage they kill 97% of airborne viruses including covid-19 it has been studied in other countries and it works it works better than the masks please look into that because I'm sure everybody here will invest $249 okay thank you for your time thank you and that concludes audience to the public we
161will now uh Endeavor to answer some of your questions all right some of this is thematic some of this I'll try and go in order um m r iano you had questions about how uh the spring differs from the fall when we were in the Delta surge so what I've said all along um and we've said at these meetings is we've been methodically adding back things and then waiting to see what happens before we take another step so last fall we made a bunch of really what I think are very muscular decisions to add things back for example we doubled the number of kids at the high school second we removed the ability for anyone who is uncomfortable being in school to learn remotely so all schools were back to full um strength we moved
162kids from being 6 feet apart to being 3 feet apart we went to nine period days at the middle schools the middle schools uh eliminated the cohort model and started rotating through classes again so elementary schools back to 3 ft and eliminated the remote option so we made a lot of really muscular uh changes and at that time what we were trying to do is digest those changes and see if they elevated risk see if they resulted in more transmission obviously they didn't but at the same time that's when co uh when the Delta variant really took off we didn't know what to expect from the Delta variant we did we had not seen any evidence of outdoor transmission until this fall and then we did have a situation where we saw the only explanation
163for what we saw could have been outdoor transmission So that obviously caused us to put the brakes on a little bit because we didn't want to see that uh continue so that's the difference between the fall and the spring to the many speakers who said the situation now is different than it was a year ago I agree and that was what I think at least half a dozen of my slides tonight we're dedicated to is illustrating the contrast uh between where we were going into spring of 21 and where we are now going into spring of 22 so um with the basketball games as I mentioned uh we've done work with the HVAC system in the high school gym I think it'll be possible to have more people in there I know it'll be possible
164to have more people in there um the questions about um the High School Musical I don't know where that number came from obviously I don't read every piece of paper here but I'll certainly look into it and see how that was calculated but there are multiple uh presentations of the musical so I'm sure it's multiplied by the number of times that the musical is being put on so the okay let me go through the questions I have um so we certainly want to see more parental involvement um as I mentioned earlier and in response to Mr Greco's questions we're working right now we had meeting with the elementary principles again last week to try and put some finishing touches on the ideas for the things that we're going to do at the elementary schools so
165a lot of I'll just go through a lot of the Thematic themes because a lot of the themes were repeated again and you know with slightly different framings but the bottom line is there's a question about masks do they or don't they work so I don't see the point in the end it will be possible to find research that supports whatever your view is on that where we are right now is that they are mandated by the state so you have one Supreme Court Justice that thinks that mandate is not constitutional you have a different Supreme Court Justice that thinks it is constitutional and right now the next level up is deciding between the two of them they're going to have to work it out and then we'll know what rules apply to school districts
166uh several speakers spoke about vaccine mandates and asked that the board not put a vaccine mandate into place so just to be clear the board does not have the power or the authority to implement a vaccine mandate those can only be uh mandated through something called State Police powers and those powers can only be exercised by the state itself so that will not be a choice that falls to the board uh because it's not a power that is within uh their grasp then a number of speakers speakers talked about the recovery rate um from Co and specifically the recovery rate for students and I think we're all grateful and certainly for me as someone who's responsible for the lives of over 8,000 people uh I'm so relieved that this has not been as significant for
167young people as it has been for the population generally but the risk is not zero and the challenging question to wrestle with is how much risk is acceptable and that's what this whole conversation has been about is how much risk is acceptable so all of the work that we've done over the last two years has been an attempt to try to mitigate risk and obviously if we move into a phase where the virus is considered to be endemic we're going to be deciding to live with risk so that's a shift but that's that's a shift that um I think we need guidance on um because I certainly don't feel like I can balance those the consequences of those risks because the consequences could be severe um okay so it's okay okay listen we closed the
168audience to the public but we are endeavoring to answer your questions to the extent that you have any further questions um definitely come back next year next month sorry and um ask the questions then or you can certainly email them but at this point we're doing our best to answer the questions so I'm just gonna say that there are a number of different risks the risk of getting sick the risk of potentially having the FL on come on do listen listen it's not instead of answering the questions we're going to wind up continuing with the meeting we do want to answer your questions but you have to allow us the time to do that thank you so there are risks obviously of death there are risks of getting long covid there are risks of getting
169Mis C there are risks from having this disease but it also is I think apparent that we're not going to have zero Co so the question is how to balance those risks and obviously there are strong opinions about how to do that um then uh lastly the suggestion on uh ultraviolet uh heating ventilation and air conditioning systems uh we do have HEPA filtration uh in the classrooms at the high school and uh the element schools all have MV 13 filters and uh we put in ventilation systems the UV systems are not permitted in New York state for schools so we did look into those but uh they're not allowed by the state education department so it's not an option for us okay uh thank you Dr Rogers um I just wanted to touch on a
170couple of things uh Dr Rogers had already mentioned that there are a couple of um ISS isues that were mentioned at audience of the public that the board doesn't have control over um one of them is vaccine mandates and the other is mask mandates and with respect to uh compliance I know that there was a suggestion from at least one person that we simply not comply and um we're and we're not entitled to do that so we take we take Oaths um when we become trustees to uphold the law we don't have a choice but that now we were asked we were asked um whether we would Advocate on issues like vaccines and issues like masks um and so while I would never get ahead of the board on issues like that um I would
171share how in the past the board has approached advocacy issues to our legislators um so when we've elected to take an advocacy position uh in the past who are governmental uh uh officials the position has always been one that would be uh universally beneficial for the entire District in other words um issues that would not be controversial within the district such as we advocated to the State education department for steps to mitigate the impact for State assessment tests and to mitigate against lust andr Cal time we've advocated to the nasau Industrial Development agency to oppose pilot applications because uh the uh repeat pilot applications and their renewals negatively affect all of our taxpayers when it comes to uh their taxes we advocated to a state senator for Grant funds because we had facilities needs we
172advocated to the Department of Environmental Conservation because there were safety concerns with various uh uh proposed projects and uh again these safety concerns would be Universal but what we haven't done to date is advocated for a position that a portion of the community would be in favor of but not um another uh uh another portion of the community and so um in terms of advocating for legislation that's not to say what we would do in the future I'm just giving you a history of how we've approached that um in the past because uh we were asked and uh the UVA back systems that uh that was the first for me I hadn't heard of that so thanks for that information thank you Tracy thank you Dr Rogers thank thank you everybody who came and SP
173and spoke um listen we we want to listen to you we believe me we are doing everything we can on our end to support the administration we are um we have went up and above we have 8,000 people at the school the students the teachers the staff the administration the custodians the lunch people we're concerned about everything we speak about the reason that all of us volunteer on the board is because we care okay now I have a I have have a a a fourth grader uh every day I have the same conversation with her I I'm very stressed about how stressed she is believe me I understand what you're saying I have a high I have a she went to high school here she didn't have graduation she didn't have the prom she's in
174college now they're still locked down so this is a daily battle for me as a parent I'm not on just on the board I'm a parent also we are trying to do everything we can can we do more yes can we Advocate absolutely Ely that's why we're here we will do everything we can to keep all of our children safe within the rules that we can and you guys know me I've questioned everything um we speak to our attorneys we we are trying to do everything we can can we do more can we get parents in the school we will try to do our best I also 100% agree that the children need more sleep the children need more activity the children need a better diet we absolutely agree with that I just want to
175let you know thank you Susan um so because the school is doing is already in the works planning different things to bring the parents in and to have more inperson activities for the kids I had a whole Spiel plans about about having kids more in person events and getting parents in the building because it's so important but since the school is already planning that stuff do you think it would be possible since people feel so strongly about it that we can get um an update before next month that maybe in your Friday update or something just cuz there's such an urgency to it and just to give a little shout out I know a lot of the elementary schools are having a Valentine's Day party next week or for Valentine's Day and if there's any
176way to figure out how to get parents into that that would be an awesome an awesome thing and I also want to thank the district cuz I know you guys are planning and trying and there's a lot of behind the scenes things that go on that people don't see because it's behind the scenes but we appreciate anything you do to get us in okay thank you uh now we begin a items A1 is the approval of staff changes may I have a motion please um Mr Rolo seconded by Miss latan are there any questions I'm sorry what oh sorry let's just finish this vote and then we'll go back to discussion items um are there any questions all in favor opposed any absts thank you for that reminder um Dr Rogers I wanted to raise
177region examinations because um I know that a lot of parents were confused um when they got the initial letter saying that midterm region examinations were being cancelled and they weren't clear on what was going to be for the end of the year do we know anything more now than we did when that initial letter came out as to whether the Board of Regents is going to um suspend the Regents uh for the ends of the year or uh maintain them we don't know anything more officially but I think it's very unlikely that the Regents would suspend the examinations for the June examination period so uh at this point we're still moving forward with the same curriculum and planning and uh and supporting the exam should it be taken yeah our plan right now we are
178anticipating the region exams being given as scheduled so all of our energy is focused on preparing students to do well on those thank you does anyone else have any questions the next question um is about graduation uh a lot of families are trying to plan um and I I know we haven't set out for middle school or high school yet what the exact plans are going to be um but I know that families um if they can we'll have people fly out um to come see the graduations and I was wondering where we are with the planning and when families can expect to hear the details sure so I'll start with the high school graduation the commencement exercises uh we work with hster as you know every year uh this last year we were able
179to have an outdoor ceremony I personally thought it was terrific um aided by the wonderful weather that we had uh my understanding is that HRA is uh planning on moving ceremonies back indoors again as it has in you know previous years uh I know that there might be some interest in uh keeping the outdoor ceremony because uh obviously it was such a great experience um to do that though um hopster would have to rent the stage again that would be fairly expensive so you know one question would be are there other districts that typically use Hofstra that might also be interested in an outdoor ceremony that could uh share the expense of doing that or uh if not then it's more likely that we'll be indoors and in terms of what the rules will be
180in place uh in June for an indoor venue I I think that's kind of anybody's guess at this point uh for the Middle School moving up ceremonies again a lot of great feedback about the outdoor ceremonies that we had last year uh what whatever we do we would like to try and get the whole graduating class together instead of doing it as two ceremonies so a lot of our planning has been around trying to figure out how to make it possible for the whole class to graduate together both from hbt and from uh uh Southwoods so uh that's that's where our attention and focus has been we're uh looking very seriously at an outdoor ceremony again and so to your question about travel uh if we do have outdoor ceremonies uh part of the uh
181challenge for us will be to identify not just a date but a rain date U for those ceremonies uh Elementary moving up thank you um so again we also saw a lot of really great uh ceremonies Outdoors last year and uses of space that uh we hadn't anticipated using that way but I thought worked very well and again um a lot of schools did multiple ceremonies with you know different sections graduating together and we think that we could do something where the whole class can be uh graduated together we'd prefer to do that I think it's a nice feel for the students it's a nice feel for the parent community so um again we're focused on outdoor ceremonies and we're focused on trying to get everybody together if possible okay great and if we can
182um you know talk with HRA and advocate for um you know more than two tickets a person it would be helpful because I I know families who had grandparents who had to you know fight over which one was going to get to see their grandkid graduate and it's not ideal are there any other yes Susan and then Tom um since the outdoor was great I have three graduations this year but um is there any thoughts to maybe getting like getting our own tent or outdoor facility just so that way we can accommodate all of our graduations on property and that way um we don't have to it could be outside all together but covered so that way we're not at the mercy of the weather I don't know if it's feasible and I don't know
183how much it would cost logistically but just as an idea to throw out there um in the end the the answer to this is going to be that the State education department will not allow us to have a tent of the size that you want um but actually the the tents that we're allowed to have are just the ones that you've already seen on the the school campuses already I think they're 12 x 12 or 15x 15 but they're not very large anything larger than that actually has to have fire suppression systems exit lights smoke detectors emergency lighting and on and on and on so it's just not feasible even it's just a cover yeah and any sort of outdoor structure ends up being treated like a building project and it has to go to
184the state and hi Dr R thank you um I agree with Tracy and and and also with Susan that um last year's graduations the middle school the high school um if we can get everybody together have them outside um was absolutely um great ceremonies that we had everybody was able to come um if we can get everybody together for the middle schools then we won't need as many sections as we did last year and do the rain date that seemed to work out really well um we did a phenomenal job with the photographers and um having everybody have an intimate moment with their child um it was much more intimate than we've had in the past so I think think it was a success and if we can just add more people and have it
185together um and have it outside that would be um that would be great any elementary schools too obviously sorry one last question for planning purposes for people um are the dates that are on the calendar still the dates you're shooting for or are you going to try to move them different dates if they have to be outdoors and you need to plan for rain dates yeah so you read our minds the dates on the calendar were planned as though they were going to be indoor ceremonies so if we move Outdoors we'll have to make the first ceremony earlier so that that could be a rain date so uh we're working literally working on that right now because if we're going to share the facility of the tur field say between the two middle schools and
186we really need four dates uh for those schools so we're we're working on that right right now okay thank you okay uh that concludes discussion items and now we move to A2 which is the approval of 2021-22 stiens and hourly rates may I have a motion Please Mr gersan seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor oppos any extensions A3 is the approval of coaching recommendations for spring of 2022 may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions B1 is the approval of the committee on special education recommendations may have a motion Please Mr rello seconded by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B2 is the approval of committee on preschool special education
187recommendations is there a motion U Mr Greco seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B3 is the approval of student sub Charters may I have a motion please miss kosia seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions before before is the approval of scheduling a public hearing for the budget vote and election for the Sasa Central School District may have a motion please is L Hand seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B5 is the first reading of policy 1900 parent and family engagement 4325 academic intervention Services 4327 homebound instruction 4770 graduation requirements 4850 animals in the schools may I have a motion for the first reading Miss kosia seconded by Miss Chang are there
188any questions okay this will be voted on at the March 21st 2022 meeting so copies of these policies are going to be available for inspection on the website C1 is the authorization for service contracts may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo second by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C2 is the authorization for special education and or nursing contracts may I have a motion please miss kosia seconded by Mrs Chang are there any questions all in favor the post any extensions C3 is the authorization for contracts for federal party funds may have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions C4 is the authorization to reject a bid by have a motion please uh Dr Park seconded
189by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C5 is the authorization for piggy backing may have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C6 is the authorization of the disposal of broken Surplus and our absolete equipment and or bucks may have a motion please miss kushia seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C7 and 8 can be taken together they are the authorization for change orders may I have a motion please miss Falco seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C9 is the authorization for deduct change orders may I have a motion please miss Chang secutive by Dr Park are there any questions all
190in favor opposed any extensions see 10 through 12 can be taken together they are the acceptance of donations of funds may have a motion please miss balov seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor oppos any extensions thank you everybody motion to adjor oh I'm sorry I just wasn't sure if it should be done before after new business but I'd like to make a motion to draft a letter to the governor um requesting met metrics and timeline um which whichever way we could carefully word it and uh I don't think we should wait a month on something like this um anyone else is there a second to that motion Lisa kosia are there any questions Susan can you um specify a little bit about sorry can you just specify a little more
191about what you want to see in the letter carefully wed letter requesting specific metrics just like the ones uh we used to look at um with the previous governor um and the timeline um you know if New Jersey has their March 7 um we would like to see at least movement towards um you know guidelines metrics numbers um a little bit more you know guidance from the state o sorry uh my question question just to the board is has everybody read the superintendent's letter that we're talking about because uh if you don't know what the letter is I would uh move to table it but if you have read it and everybody can have a conversation about it then um great Brian would it be helpful since obviously this is the letter I was talking
192about earlier if I read three of the sentences that I flagged and it's the reason I brought this up I mean this is a letter to Mary Basset uh the Department of Health it's not directed to the governor um but I think that's a a different issue but it says we believe we have now reached the time where the state needs to transition schools out of out from a pandemic learning environment it later says the critical issue with mandatory masking in schools at this moment is the urgent need for school leaders and parents to know the plan moving forward with concrete assurances from the state and then the last sentence I'll read talks it states the state should provide clear guidance on universal School mask requirements and when and how those will evolve the best
193way to do this is to provide reasonable understandable and achievable metrics based on recommendations from medical professionals for when masking rulings will eventually be changed I I think something along those lines is what I was getting at earlier okay so uh I understand your point so I just want to um kind of reflect back so everybody is on the page same page with what you both are asking for and add especially because you made the motion the letter that you're proposing is for clarification on what criteria they're using to determine ultimately when um the Mandate should be ended but to not off for any opinion or advocate for a position mask or no mask is that correct absolutely that's exactly what I was talking about so there's been a a a motion and a second
194and questions anybody else I have a question um I guess my understanding of what Dr Rogers was saying was it wasn't just isolated to the masking it was all of the procedures that we would need to put put in place for it to be safe correct distancing and all the other mitigating factors and the layering it's not just one thing right we we have a series of layered mitigation strategies in place right now um what the superintendent's letter and I don't have it memorized but what they're asking the state for is the criteria that the state are using to make decisions and uh asking for the state to reveal that so that we can watch the the data and the metrics evolve in real time towards that criteria that they've established so um I I
195do believe that in Massachusetts it's beyond just whether the mask as a mitigating strategy is going to be remove but it's about what kinds of mitigation strategies are in place at what levels of transmission I think we okay or conclud more in totality not just one thing right it's to set expectations and to make sure that people Canad see where they're going right okay understood everybody understand okay all in favor opposed any extensions okay uh I didn't count yeah um will we be able to send the letter to the public when we're done to show that we you know what we were asking and what the letter was or is that not something we can do could we could we share the letter with the public whenever we've advocated to any official we've always posted
196it on the website and that's what we would do and um and on many occasions uh Dr Ro as we also put a link in an email update so that uh people can get it thank you okay are we concluded great I turn