CorpusRecord 136514

Board of Education Meeting - May 10, 2021

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Syosset Central School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
23,842 words · about 133 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001it represents a 2.28% increase over the current year budget the chart on the left shows the total budget Broken Out In the state required three-part budget format and the graphic on the right shows the proportion that those three components make up of the total budget you can see the largest proportion almost 77% is related to the program component and that's where all of the instructional program costs reside the administration portion of the budget contains costs for building and departmental administrators as well as contractual expenditures for legal Insurance mailing and other centralized services and that accounts for about 99.6% of the budget the remaining portion is the capital component at about 13.9% it contains all of the expenses for our custodial and maintenance area as well as our security our debt service and capital projects that

002are run through the budget here we have the proposed tax levy for the district the budget carries a tax levy increase of 1.98% which is approximately $675,000 under the tax cap the district's allowable tax cap is 2.31% and you may recall that we were originally predicting that our actual tax levy increase would be right at that cap however due to the additional state and federal funding we received we were able to bring the tax levy down so that it's 675 under where we had thought and if you look at the chart on the right you can see that it illustrates our trend of continuing trend of coming in under the tax cap the allowable tax cap although we are under the tax cap we're still able to continue to support important aspects elements in the

003budget the first is the continuation of all of our clean and disinfecting protocols that help keep our learning environment safer for our students and our staff the budget preserves all of our existing programs and services for students as well as providing some programmatic enhancements such as the ICT teacher in the high school and the additional social worker to provide social and emotional support for our students we continue to invest in instructional technology to support both in in-person instruction and remote if necessary next year the budget also provides fiscal stability to optimize our response to changing circumstances and we saw how important it was this year in terms of our reopening the budget also contains allocations to ensure the continued support and maintenance of our equipment and our facilities most specifically we plan to do the

004pool ventilation system at the High school we plan to do masonry and roof work at the high school and at Southwoods and then we have a districtwide masonry projects revenue is the other side to the to the budget essentially it's how we pay and how we fund for all of the programs and services that are included in the budget the rightand part of that chart shows our Revenue sources for 2122 next to what are sources for the current year one of the most significant changes for this year which is the first line of the chart on the right is state aid you can see that state aid increased by about $2.2 million and the pie chart on the left shows the proportion of all of those different sources of revenue the proportion to the total

005budget and you can see that the tax levy at 84% is the largest source of the district's Revenue going back to state aid you can see that state state aid accounts for 7.9% of the district's budget in comparison to last year state aid was at 7.25 oh that's okay in addition to state aid uh the district received additional feder federal aid as part of the American Rescue plan funds and the Corona virus relief acts and the district proposes to use the that additional revenue for three main purposes the first is to support instructional programs and Services I already mentioned the ICT position we also have additional FTE for the secondary schools for increased enrollment in specific classes the second purpose of the funds was to reduce the budget and the tax levy and we accomplish

006this by moving some of the one-time expenses related to the pandemic from the budget to these one-time sources of revenue we moved out some of the co-pilot teachers into out of the budget and plans to charge to the grant as well as the robust summer school that we originally had in the budget as I stated previously before these adjustments we were planning on being right at the cap so this additional Aid allowed us to come in below the cap the third use of the additional funds was to strengthen the district's financial position and to support future Levy stabilization and this was accomplished by reducing the appropriation of fund balance which enables us to shore up our reserves for subsequent years this is just a little more detail this show slide shows reserves for the last

00710 years or so the district has used its reserves to help support the budget most recently we've used um fund we've funded our capital projects through use of appropriated fund back balance if you look at the chart the first box on the right hand side you can see the amounts that we're planning on appropriating for Capital project the 1 point about 1.8 million we're returning about 10% of the transfer to Capital from 1819 and recycling it back into projects for next year then we have a general appropriation amount of 900,000 looking at the box at the bottom those are our restricted reserves and those are the reserves that we plan to use to support the budget and these reserves typically fund um benefits type expenses now just our restricted reserves our reserves in general are

008money that's set aside for a specific purpose and our reserves are a source of Revenue that help us stabilize the tax levy they're an indication of good fiscal Health an adequate reserves we know lead to better credit ratings that reduce our borrowing costs over time and our reserves are report reported each year to our Auditors they're reviewed by our Auditors published in our audit report and reported to SED as part of our filings and the reserves we plan to use if you can see they're listed at the bottom right we have reserves that help us fund our retirement required contributions to the retirement funds we established several years ago the TRS retirement system reserve and we're going to use 529 to offset the increase for the following year we also have our workers compensation reserve

009and our unemployment Reserve that we intend to use finally we're going to use our ebal which is our employee benefits acur liability Reserve $100,000 and that helps fund required benefit payments when employees separate from the district in addition to proposition one which is the budget we have two propositions and these propositions work together and that they cannot be one cannot be approved without the other the first proposition authorizes the conveyance of a portion of the stillw property from Nassau County to the scasd Central School District proposition three authorizes the investment up to a maximum of $10.5 million two to come from the reserves three to come from Nassau County and the remaining 5.5 to come from the issuance of bonds there have been several meetings specifically related to these propositions as well as as I

010mentioned previous budget meetings you can go on the website to see those previous presentations and all of the detail on the budget and the budget documents the budget brochure was mailed last week and the budget notice to the right will go out tomorrow morning and that concludes the budget hearing for 2122 okay so at this time uh we remain in the budget hearing there will be an audience to the public that is solely for the purpose of the budget presentation and questions about budget later on when we begin the regularly scheduled public um board meeting we will have another audience to the public where any other topic of concern can be raised but for now if anyone in the audience has a question about the budget presentation only you'll come up please to the podium

011you will have um four minutes to address the board with comments or questions and then we'd ask that you take your seat and allow others to come up and have their four minutes when the four minutes uh for everyone has concluded then we will do our best to respond to the uh questions that are uh questions that were asked if after the questions anyone wants a second uh chance to come up to the podium about the budget they'll have another opportunity for an additional form minutes and then again once everyone has completed their four minutes uh we will do our best to answer that second round of questions and then we will conclude audience to the public for budget so at this time does anyone from the public have any questions in connection with budget

012only if you do please feel free to come up to the podium okay uh seeing no questions from from the public on budget we will continue with the regularly scheduled public meeting and uh to begin we have the approval of the minutes of meeting April 20 2021 may I have a motion please miss Chang seconded by Mr Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions approval of the minutes of meeting April 22 2021 may I have a moot motion Please Mr Feldman seconded by Mr Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions Dr rufo can you please give us the treasurer's report in the treasures report that was prepared for the month end March 31st it shows that cash on hand was 89 m998 7869 it shows that bank

013balances for all cash accounts were reconciled to the book balances and were collateralized in accordance with the district's banking agreements and investment policy thank you Dr rufen may I have a motion to accept the treasurers report Miss Chang seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor oppos any extensions okay we've moved up um a couple of resolutions 7.1 is the appointment to tenure for the members of the administrative and or certified staff may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss Chang are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions many any of you are joining us remotely and for those of you that are joining in person um we when you hear your name please stand Amanda Barney Shai Fisher John janova David Steinberg Lauren Allen Amanda anara

014Mariana Beach Ching Chan Kim Courtright Laura d Allison delen Rachel dvo Kimberly Dolan Matthew Fasano Rebecca Garrett Neil Hagen Scott Holtzman Christina hols Weiss Jenny contic Michelle cornelly aristi langum Leanne Lassie Janna nun Jonathan ol Lauren oor Megan UL Grace pson Michelle Rizzo Diane Rorick Heather Shelly maressa tesoriero Erica EK and Carrie Wilson congratulations to all of you you've received tenure because of your continued excellence and you are critical members of our learning community and we wish you continued success here in casset and uh in a non-pandemic year it would be customary for people earning tenure to be here in the AUD Auditorium so that we could recognize them in person and I always take great pride in this evening because we take great pride in our staff and when we identify people and they've

015been with us for four years and they've had tremendous success for those four years it's an honor it's a privilege to welcome them to our family as permanent members of the ioset staff so although they're not here in person I congratulate all of them I thank them for their hard work I thank them especially for the work that they've done in this most challenging of years they have earned tenure in the hardest year of their teaching careers I am sure and it is a remarkable accomplishment we're proud of them to you at home we're proud of you and we're looking forward to many many more wonderful years with you in the future 8.1 is the appointment of Elementary School principal for Village Elementary School Miss Zary McKuen may I have a motion please miss Falco

016seconded by Miss changen are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions Miss mun congratulations we're so happy to welcome you to saset your enthusiasm and your empathy or qualities that we cherish here in this community and um we value them so highly that we know that you're going to be a success here so congratulations again 8.2 is the appointment of Elementary School principal for Robins Lane Mr Meyers may I have a motion please miss falkov seconded by Mr Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions is Mr Myers here congratulations Mr Myers you have already had an incredible impact in saset and um we know that you are going to do great in Robin's Lane we're so excited to have you uh there and to fill um that building with

017the joy that you've already brought to um to our other building so uh welcome again and uh wish you much success thank you so to both of you congratulations on this appointment uh to joining leadership in the case of Mr Meyers and to continuing leadership in the case of Miss McKuen School leadership is not an easy assignment you will find yourself working long hours you will find yourself working hard you will find yourselves misunderstood your North Pole your Guiding Light has to be doing what is in the best interests of kids at all times even when you're misunderstood even when it's complicated even when it's hard focus on that and you'll know and have the confidence that the the decisions you make will be guided by the most important thing that we do we're here

018here to support you we have entrusted you with the children of these buildings because we believe confidently that you can lead the teams of people that make up our faculty in ways that will bring them to new heights of success it's an awesome responsibility but it is also an awesome opportunity I wish you both much success much happiness thank you [Applause] next we have the superintendent report Dr Rogers thank you our first presentation in the superintendent report is going to be an update from the Southwoods Middle School student government student counciler members of the Board of Education administrators and Sasa Community tonight the Southwood student council will be sharing with you A Student Activities update on all the enriching and exciting activities and events taking place in the Southwoods Community here are some highlights South

019Wellness week has been a huge success by promoting many physical and mindfulness activities each day positive mindset healthy eating and varied exercises were enjoyed by the school Community Science Olympiad who successfully competed in the New York state competition placed 10th out of 53 teams congratu Rel a and the science for students are continuing their research and video recording presentations for the upcoming science for a competition six seventh and eighth graders participating in athletes are working together to solve rigorous math problems and compete in monthly competitions jazz band is a Hybrid Club of sixth seventh and eighth graders who have been enthusiastically rehearsing and Performing pieces in a variety of jazz styles ukulele Club has been watching and listening to tutorial of popular songs and learning courts and trets on its fun and engaging instruments the

020Multicultural Club celebrated a very successful Multicultural week every student in Southwoods attended workshops and engaged in presentations focusing on many diverse cultures represented at Southwoods discussions included what students can do to prevent hate violence and racism in our community plast Club is recording a podcast series based on a mystery written by eth grader Trinity woo dance club has also been focusing on multiculturism by learning P and S dances as well as Native American dance C the magic club is continuing learning virtual magic tricks students are loving practicing their magic skills with family and friends the art Club is working in conjunction with the drama club to create posters and original art for upcoming performances the girls who code Club has been exploring and creating coding projects on hatch and python in the hackathon coding Club

021students are continuing to to excel in their knowledge of hatch python Java JavaScript and HTML coding the hackathon team competed in the virtual Long Island hackathon competition in March placing third place sa blood's mock trial students are engaged in discussions about current events in the American legal system and in particular the United States Supreme Court students are collaborating virtually on presentations to share on major Supreme Court cases and issues drama club is working on their Spring Showcase featuring selections of songs and scenes from various musicals their performance will take place on Sunday May 16th outside on the peer leaders and Triple A club just completed a very successful towel and pet fot drive for Rough House rescue additionally students are currently creating an incoming sixth graders orientation video and will be meeting with fifth graders

022virtually to provide them with an opportunity to learn more about Fitz Middle School the girl talk Club created an informative public service announcement on the topic of pay equity in the workforce FL focused on social distancing activities including operation s to a virtual wathon to benefit Rough House rescue creating a positive School environment and contributing to the school food drive the business Club is starting an entrepreneurship competition where students present their business ideas to a panel of Judges the southw book club has read and discussed over half a dozen novels so far this year many which were the first book in a series some titles include the recruitment series by Ka a Riley the Skyward series by Brandon Sanderson gone by Michael Grant and The Hobbit by JRR tolken and finally the student council has

023been enthusiastically working to finalize our our very first talent show Southwest presents Frontline Talent we will be live streaming more than 16 unb unbelievably outstanding and talented student performances which range from musical performances to timelapse art demonstrations the student council is Raising awareness of the tireless and heroic and brave efforts of Frontline health workers during the covid-19 pandemic and encouraging all viewers to donate to the Mount s South NAA Hospital behind the mask program to help support Frontline workers and Families thank you for the opport opportunity to share all the diverse and exciting events taking place at Southwoods Middle School we are very proud to be part of such an enriching Community enjoy the beautiful spring and stay safe # Sy yo [Applause] strong for K if you could just go out of order from

024the agenda and do the superintendent report first and then the diversity and inclusivity thank you and while foran is getting that lined up uh if you've read my email messages to the community you know that from time to time I like to point out a couple of um Silver Linings from some of the changes that we've had to make this year as a result of the pandemic and I think one of those Silver Linings is although we don't get to have our Student Government reports in person we get to hear from many many more students than we would in the past and so we get to see so many more of our students parti participate in that report to the board yeah this is for con this is a year old that's it uh that's

025April that was it TR The Flash that's off the flash drive that I was given um okay um well I will do it from memory and uh we will post the presentation online so there are two things that I wanted to update the board the community about uh first is the remedial action work plan so as you recall the uh board has been following closely a planned development of the former Sero wire site which is at the corner of uh Rob Robins Lane and the uh North Side Service Road uh called Miller Place of the Long Island Expressway uh over the course of several years different proposals have been uh floated for what to do with that property the most recent is for an a warehouse to be constructed on site that will house a

026Amazon last mile delivery station so the property has uh an environmental history and because of that to remediate and build on the site the developer has to go through something called the state brownfields program and that is a program that requires uh the site to be remediated based on standards that the the New York State puts out uh it's been a long process of getting uh the developer seeking their approvals the school district has written multiple letters to the Department of Environmental Conservation commenting on Draft plans the school district has also written to the Nassau County Industrial Development agency and appeared before their board meetings to comment on the uh tax incentives that are being considered for the project uh all of those uh comments and uh in some places criticisms can be found on

027the school district website what uh we had been uh waiting for is to see what the Department of Environmental Conservation would do do with the comments that we had shared with them uh critiquing the draft remedial action work plan that they had posted in December we had made a number of suggestions that we thought would strengthen that plan if they were to go through with it they announced late last week that they had approved a final remedial action work plan and that final plan is no different from the draft plan that was proposed in December so some of the suggestions that we had made were to do additional soil testing to use that additional soil testing to drive decisions about uh targeted soil removal identifying soils that should be removed off site and disposed elsewhere

028we had suggested that they have a more robust Community air monitoring plan a camp uh they are using a generic Community air monitoring plan as part of their proposal and we had suggested uh some dust suppression and dust measurement uh strategies on the border with uh South Grove Elementary school and they uh did not accept those as part of the plan either so at this point I don't know if there are any more opportunities for the school district to comment on the plan we're researching the uh final action document with our environmental Consultants now and I hope to have uh more detailed report for the board at some point in the not too distant future second thing I wanted to raise was that there is um in this year's state budget the school district received

029a universal uh what is called Universal pre kindergarten the word Universal is misleading it is a state program that has aspirations of being Universal for pre kindergarten the grant that the school district would receive is for $670,000 or so and that would fund a program at about $5,400 per student for 180-day year there are several ways that the program can be constructed it could be uh staffed uh by District staff on site it can be staffed by um private staff on site or you can enter into a contract with an organization to offer the program entirely off site does this mean that pre is coming to saset state funded prek the grant allocation seem far too low to support a grant in its a a program in its entirety and the school district certainly this

030year of all years does not have the space to open up additional classrooms to house pre kindergarten space so that said we have been exploring with potential Partners what a model would look like if we wanted to pursue it we have been exploring the rules around the funding this is new um it's uh never never been allocated for uh soset in the past so uh there's a lot to learn in terms of the funding I don't think that uh the complexities as complex as this is this would be like adding a 14th grade not going to be solved by September but we are looking at it because we think we should try to take advantage of the opportunity if there is any way to do so so I did want to update the board because

031we had told you in a previous meeting about this grant that's in the budget we're also look look to see if there is any way if it is logistically impossible to start the program in the first year whether some of that money can roll over right now it does not appear that that is the case but because these are Federal grant funds and the federal funds have a 2-year life associated with them uh there is some hope that that two-year life can be associated with the program as well so more to come on that but I did want to update you that we have been looking at that diligently so with that said I also want to um read a brief statement and then I'm going uh to talk about our diversity inclusivity Task Force

032update so I know many of you are here tonight uh because you're concerned about an incident that we reported to the public on Friday and you're concerned because you want to make sure that the district is taking it as seriously as possible and that we are going to follow our investigation through and that at the end of that investigation we are going to do what's appropriate I hope this statement reassures you for the past 5 days the district has been deliberately and thoroughly investigating a bias related incident at Southwoods Middle School the district has been careful not to release details about the incident in order to avoid leading or otherwise compromising the testimony of students who were still being interviewed as Witnesses I understand that has been difficult and confusing for our community which is

033accustomed to clearer and more detailed reporting from the school district at this point the investigation has progressed to a stage where we can share that there were multiple incidents where different students verbally expressed different types of bias and at least one of those incidents became physical this Behavior has no place in saset or any other school as we've repeatedly made clear in the statement we issued this March regarding anti-asian American hate the statement we issued last June in the wake of a national Reckoning on racism and back in 2017 after our vandalism incident we said and we repeat RAC R ISM bias intolerance and hate have no place in saset Period teaching that lesson must start young and never end what we've done as a district in the last 7 years is remarkable we've instituted

034programs from elementary to high school to teach kindness empathy respect and tolerance we've developed trainings and programs through Partnerships with social justice and Community organizations we've redesigned our code of conduct in collaboration with these organizations whose very existence is to oppose racism and with them our code of conduct not only holds students accountable but also provides them with a path so they can heal the harm that they've caused saset has intentionally defined itself as a welcoming Community for its diverse population and that was one of the things that Drew me to saset and that I have been so proud of for the seven years that I've been here the pta's cultural Unity committee Works to ensure newcomers are fully embraced by our families the Board of Education was one of the very first to develop

035a more inclusive holiday calendar and we provide translation services broadly to make sure everyone in our family is able to access information from the district that is not to say that there isn't work remaining but rather that we are just as committed to continuing as we ever have been and incidents like these remind us of the urgency of the work we have been in contact with local government organizations with partner organizations who have offered us resources so that we can continue to educate our staff and our students about how to make soset the most inclusive environment possible over the last several days I've received a lot of me email too many to reply to from Asian-American and non-asian parents alike angry and anguished that this could happen in their Community their saset I am glad

036I work in a community that is upset by an incident like this we should all be upset and I want to work for people who have that value I'm glad I work in a community that asks that we do everything we can to make their schools safe and inclusive we have more work to do both with our investigation and with our learning community and we will see both through we had already planned uh several months ago we scheduled the presentations for the board meetings um we were also supposed to have a World Language presentation but we understand tonight might probably be a lengthy conversation but this uh presentation has been scheduled for some time we were going to update the board on an initiative that we have been working on as a district with the

037board's support for over a year on diversity and inclusivity this initiative started uh was born out of uh the idea of several teachers and administrators who had gone to a National Conference invited to go to a National Conference by the us uh education department and came back with the idea to really begin to identify ways that we could uh more assertively continue to work on making saset a welcoming Place particularly as our community becomes more diverse so we have a mission statement for the whole District that the board worked on and this guides us all and we want to prepare students to thrive both in what we imagine the future will be but in the one that is going to be changing we as a community are changing and that is our future and our

038country is changing that is our future and technology is changing everyone's future it is making us all more connected and because we are all more connect connected we are all closer to one another and we must become competent and embracing of people who are different from ourselves in whatever way because we are all going to be much closer to one another for the foreseeable future why do we do this instructionally because we want our students to be confident in a changing world and we want them to feel like they can make change in the world too we want we give students a lot of choice and a lot of voice because we want them to know that this is their World to Change what is the task Force's job to build on some of the

039successes that I mentioned earlier and continue the Journey of making saset a more inclusive environment so we build on our strength we have to examine ourselves and we have to make a priority around Equitable access and that is around a number of different issues one of which that we've been working on a lot in the last several years is gender Equity because we've seen in some of our courses that the gender balance has become skewed and that's another uh opportunity for us to find a way to do things more inclusively our community has changed and continues to change the demographic composition of the schools is changing we're attentive to that and we recognize that it is something we celebrate but it's also something that brings with it its own challenges and if we don't identify

040those challenges and have plans for how to meet them then we're going to fall behind so as I mentioned this community even before I came here has been hard at work defining itself as an inclusive welcoming diverse Place we've received awards for the work that we've done the PTA has led beautifully all of our buildings find ways to celebrate the diversity that is in them we were a leader in um creating a restorative uh code of conduct uh something that we worked on uh in partnership with the State Bar Association and uh Mr gross our attorney is uh with us today we'll talk in a few minutes uh later about that and some other aspects of that work and we started doing some uh curriculum writing last summer even though it was in the middle

041of the pandemic we plan more curriculum writing projects uh this summer to look at our curriculum at the elementary schools we use a national program known as Harmony uh and as I said earlier we have to start young and we can't ever stop but it's important that we start young the three secondary schools have been designated no place for hate it doesn't mean it's a label it's work that you have to do to earn that label it doesn't mean and clearly this week has shown that even doing that work will not prevent things from happening but it does show that we've identified what our values are as a building and we're working towards them we have our pride character education program an anonymous reporting app that all secondary students are trained to use to report

042something if they see it uh bullying or Worse choices and consequences a program we do with the nassa County District Attorney's Office programs that we uh do in conjunction with eras racism which is located here in saset and uh for over 20 years the high school has done a holocaust Remembrance Day not just because the Holocaust is an unspeakable tragedy but because the Holocaust is an illustration of what can happen when hate is not rooted out and a more recent uh feature is bookday where uh students have the choice and have picked diverse authors to read as a group uh books together there are four subcommittees of this diversity and inclusivity task force one that's focused on the student experience both good and the not so good aspects of the student experience because if we

043don't work with our students and learn what it is like to be a student here we will never be able to make sure that we are giving them the experience that they deserve and that you all want curriculum and professional learning the state has recently and uh made an announcement today about the culturally responsive and sustaining education platform that they have launched this is enely consistent with the work that we're doing students need to see themselves reflected in the curriculum and they also need the curriculum to be a window into lives that they might not experience themselves and our curriculum needs to be accessible to kids and it needs to underscore that diversity community outreach is the group that is responsible for how the school works with its Community to make sure that we're hearing

044the voice voices of our community but also that we're communicating well with our community and lastly human resources and hiring practices which is the training of our current staff because we can all be better and it is how we go through the hiring process to try and make sure that we have as strong a staff and as diverse a staff as possible so as I mentioned we've been at this work since October of 2019 uh we started having meetings right before the pandemic the pandemic slowed us down for sure but we restarted our momentum in the fall began having meetings and subcommittee meetings again and the board has been anxious to hear an update on where we've been I won't read all of these um for obvious reasons but all these presentations are posted online

045and I wanted to make sure that a lot of what we have been doing was contained in them so that people could go and see and talk to your own principal if you have elementary students ask them about some of these um programs at the elementary and middle school ask the high school leadership team about some of the programs that they put into place at the high school around the student experience and what are the opportunities for Action we're looking at a number of ways suggestions that have come from these subcommittees for things we can continue to do uh to enhance our work one thing that came out of that conversation was a student diversity cabinet the high school has a number of clubs that represent the diversity of the student body at the high

046school and we've begun regular meetings with those students with me and with my administrative team so that we hear firsthand from them what their experience is and what their suggestions are for us as I mentioned the State education department has released a culturally responsive education framework and they have for prongs a welcoming and affirming environment which I think speaks for itself high expectations and rigorous instruction uh that's something we've always cherished here in soset an inclusive curriculum an inclusive assessment uh meaning that students understand what's being asked of them so that they can demonstrate as well as possible their competence and expertise and then ongoing professional learning uh much as we're talking about for our staff to become better at all of the things that we need to do to run an excellent School District

047so we've made a number of intentional shifts in light of this over several years now at the secondary level uh at the elementary level we've really looked at classroom libraries because we want to make sure that we have more diverse uh authors and more diverse characters and more and especially diverse lead characters in books so that our students see people who may not look like them and also who see people who do at the secondary level uh books are intentionally chosen to bring out conversations about race and racism so students are have the opportunity to dialogue about this we as I mentioned do the book days but even in music and art classes we're being intentional to include contributions from diverse artists and musicians in our world language courses There's an opportunity to see the

048world through the eyes of the persons who live with the language you're studying and I met with some students I believe in December of 2019 and they were part of the erase racism student task force and they wanted to talk with me and the then deputy superintendent misss bavard about the curriculum and they one of their critiques was that our science and math curriculum uh could do a better job of being more inclusive and I was puzzled by that statement until they explained it and they said when we teach math we will teach about Renee Dart who's French and we will teach about Isaac Newton who is uh British and we will teach about Einstein who is German but we don't name in the same way the U Arabic and Chinese mathematicians and scientists that

049also inform a lot of what we're learning and I think it was a stunning critique and a note that we you needed to take and so in all of the aspects of our curriculum even those that might not at first uh lend themselves to the notion of inclusivity there are opportunities for us to look at them in different ways so I mentioned we did curriculum writing last summer we have more planned for this summer and we want to have student even more student voice because we will get insights like the Insight those students shared with me we do want to make sure that courses individual courses are as diverse as the student body as a whole or as close to it as possible the board over the last two years has invested deeply in robotics

050classes and in uh business classes called Virtual Enterprise but at first we saw those classes were only being occupied by boys we can't have an investment that only invests in our boys so we needed to find ways and we have of encouraging girls to enter those classes as well and those classes have become much more diverse on gender community outreach as I mentioned earlier so much is already going on with community outreach in saset uh through the PTA through partner organizations that we work with through our attempts and uh efforts to communicate and through some of the social justice organizations that we've worked with there's always more that can be done but our community outreach are the school district is an extension of the community so that community outreach is a two way street and

051we have a number of opportunities for Action as well and again I won't read through all of these but I'll leave them so that they can be studied but I will say that in the last uh 5 days a new opportunity has come to my mind for how we uh work with our community and that is we need an opportunity to have conversations about how the school district handles things that are difficult because the processes are not well understood and that confusion can lead to frustration and that hurts the partnership and the extension of the community that we are so I've asked our school attorney who uh is one of several Attorneys At The Firm who have been supporting us through this and other challenges over the last well seven years but certainly over the

052last five days to talk a little bit about uh how this works and then going forward I think the community outreach subcommittee needs to think about how we communicate to the community about what we do when challenges come up because challenges inevitably do come up in school districts and we have to deal with them so uh Mr John gross uh from The Firm of ingerman Smith should be okay now can okay there we go so I'll start again good evening uh the task of the superintendent asked me to accomplish tonight is to as briefly as I can which of course is always a difficult Prospect for a lawyer to um review uh what the state of the law is relative to uh incidents involving uh children during during a school setting that create uh that

053are in an adversarial uh kind of uh setting so first I wanted to address one of the difficult things lawyers are very often called upon to tell us how do we accomplish something but very frequently I've got to tell our clients and we represent many school districts including having the privilege of representing sasset uh what you can't do and one of the things you can't do is to discuss in public matters involving children and there are four bases why we you can't do that one is New York law New York law prohibits unwarranted invasions of personal privacy generally to the population including adults but specifically as well to students secondly is a federal law the federal education rights and Privacy Act which deals with what is generally termed to be educational records and divulging an

054educational record of a child under the age of 18 uh without consent of the parents of that child is prohibited and and a school district can literally lose all of its Federal funding in the event that statute is breached the third is the uh dignity um act for all students that is known as Dasa uh that itself in laying out the procedure to handle um misbehavior that affects uh or is addressed by its dignity Provisions uh itself prohibits public discussion regarding these kinds of unfortunate incidents and finally and last but not Le least is the 14th Amendment of the United States Constitution which has been applied by the courts to give a what lawyers call a cause of action or the ability to sue in court for breaches of privacy and many cases involving uh

055uh youngsters so we have four very very potent reasons why we can't ever discuss matters involving uh the Dasa stat statute or acts of um bias that are alleged to occur within a school setting involving children so just turning briefly to how do we accomplish investigation of these matters u under the dignity for all students act known as Dasa which was adopted in 2010 and became effective in 2012 we've lived it for lived with it for quite a number of years requires the school board as you have done in policy to adopt um uh student uh code of conduct and breaches of that code of conduct that provides for an extensive procedures how that is investigated complaints are made either by the child or like the child's parent and the complaint goes directly to uh

056school officials who is designated as the dis for me forgive me D dignity act coordinator who's charged with the responsibility of conducting a confidential investigation that occurs very rapidly within two or three days at the most of the report it also isn't just that individual it's other members of the administration who assist the building principal central office uh and we get involved I've had I'm senior managing partner of the law firm we've had two attorneys working very closely with the administration Dr Rogers Mr cardillo the U uh various other Administration officials who are investigating uh this matter and I think anybody who's ever dealt with kids of uh Elementary School age know that you can't do these things rapidly it has to be approached in an appropriate manner we're dealing with very sensitive youngsters um

057who are afraid who want to talk to their their talk with the school officials with their moms and dads so while you can't do it rapidly the law does require some degree of speed and I can assure you assure the board that we and this is very often we're called upon to conduct investigations but in this instance the Dasa act specifies that it's done by the school administration and certainly makes sense you don't want three or four lawyers tromping in and interviewing uh young children so we however have been actively involved and providing assistance uh and I can assure you and we represent a great number of school districts uh the investigation by soset has been uh as rapid as is appropriate has been pointed has been uh given the utmost uh attention uh and

058I think is fairly characterized as an investigation that's currently proceeding that will produce ultimately a result where the facts are known and uh whatever action arises out of those facts will be uh have will have been clearly identified so we then have to turn to what are the consequences once the facts have been induced through the investigation and um there really are two or three consequences that can flow from um adasa investigation the first is um what Dr Rogers referred to as restorative justice um you mentioned that I've been involved in that I headed a task force for the New York State Bar Association entitled the school to prison pipeline that studied uh and made recommendations to the state legislature for modifications of student discipline based on uh we did a very extensive review of

059existing studies and conducted some of our own the panel was made up of school officials including Dr bravad who's the former deputy superintendent um and the critical determination that was made by my task force was that it's critically important that we deal with the issue of implicit bias um and we made various recommendations primary among which was to deal with how New York law is structured in terms of um consequence to student misconduct and under New York law uh the only tool is exclusionary discipline throw the kid out of school treat with it uh by suspending youngsters with nothing much more than that in New York law we recommended the task force and one of the happily one of our clients the soset school district had already through Dr bad's efforts and the superintendent's efforts

060established um utilization of restorative justice which is a technique that doesn't exclude youngsters that provides consequence for acts but involves both the children who are bullied or U on the receiving end of misconduct as well as the perpetrators and it tries to get to the core of what um what caused the problem and and and to treat with that rather than moving towards exclusive U excuse me exclus exclusionary discipline happily as I said saset has an extensive program of restorative justice that's option one and I'm not saying that that is what the board will ultimately choose and the superintendent will be openly choose in this circumstance that's facing the district but it uh is option number one and I don't mean this in ranking order option number two is exclusionary discipline where youngsters are excluded

061and punished by not allowed by not being allowed to come to school I will point out based on the age of the youngsters involved in the matter uh at hand they're going to be entitled to home instruction if they were excluded which is certainly not the equivalent of in school instruction so those will be the options that the uh board um and the superintendent will have at the conclusion of the investigation based on what's determined but I do want to close by repeating that um we have been involved we take our role as school attorneys we represent over 50 school districts very very seriously um and I can assure you and assure the board that the investigation that is ongoing is thorough as being done as fast as is possible and inappropriately uh and I

062am certain will'll root out what occurred in this situation for the board and the superintendent to take appropriate action I'll be happy to answer any questions that the board might have if not I won't take any more of your time and uh uh have a good evening I would just uh clarify one of Mr gross's statements he said the findings will be known uh but they'll be known to the School District administration they not be made public I just wanted to make sure that that wasn't misunderstood and then the last subgroup is the human resources and hiring practices why because there are a lot of studies illustrating the potential benefits that students have from having a diverse uh work teaching Workforce and uh the challenges we face is that uh the pool of people uh

063for lots of reasons is not as diverse as the pool of workers G so there's a US Department of Education study that says bachelor's degree students are less diverse than high school graduates and it goes from there um act I should have expanded that the it's American Association of colleges of teachers of Education teaching education and it says education is one of the least diverse master's degree programs and in New York you must have a master's degree in order to be a teacher so these are uphill challenges that we face in trying to recruit an excellent and diverse teaching Force but we believe we have opportunities for action one of the things that we had worked on before the pandemic struck we had just uh had a bus tour of soset with candidates from uh

064one of the cuni graduate schools of education and Our Hope was to try and create a pipeline of potential Talent from the city schools of Education which were more diverse than some of the other schools of education and we thought with the bus tour the bus stopped here in Jericho in Westbury and um Valley Stream and at Nasa bosis uh would allow these potential candidates to consider uh opportunities outside of New York City as places to go and work uh We've created a mentoring program a robust mentoring program we're looking at having a second year uh and we're working on additional training for people who work in the district so that we all improve our cultural competence over time so that is the report of the work of this uh task force the task force

065is comprised of over 50 individuals already uh many of them were District employees this was originally an internal Initiative for how we could become better uh as a staff and it has uh with the community outreach portion uh begun to take on Representatives uh from organiz organizations in the community uh members of our PTA and uh I know that there's interest uh lots of people are interested in participating in this work which is I see as a sign of health and I do think that we'll need some guidance and direction from the board and terms of how we uh meet that demand but also keep what is already becoming unwieldly from getting more so so um I know we have uh some work to do on how to uh accommodate that demand but uh we

066want to embrace people who want to do diversity and inclusivity work uh because it's incredibly important work for us thank you Dr Rogers there's no question that those who have faced bias and acts of hate in their lifetimes uh feel pain and it is often not new pain but continued pain continued pain not only for their own experience but from the experiences of their ancestors so personal continued and ancestral pain cannot be discounted cannot be dis diminished and it cannot be ignored these truths have been top of mind for this district and since Dr Rogers has come to saset the school district has Contin contined to develop its curriculum its student experience its Staffing and its community outreach with the intentional goal of creating an environment that is free from hate I've watched our Administration

067in action during times of relative calm and in times of Crisis and the organization that we've built has been unwavering in its commitment to creating an environment of unity and its responsiveness to the handling of allegations of bias or hate speech so given the diligence and tirelessness of their uh efforts um to investigate incidents like the ones that uh were reported to the community on Friday it is so disheartening to hear comments of doubt in connection with Dr Roger and Miss berget's commitment and diligence and responsiveness and of course as a whole the district's dedication to all of our community members um I just wanted to share that I'm I'm grateful to have administrators like Dr Rogers and like Miss bergette who lead with empathy and who insist on equity and who understand that serious

068matters require serious investigation without rush to judgment and without presumption because both the victims and the accused deserve that kind of commitment saset will continue to do the important work of anti-bias training and education and we look forward to informing our community of our progress and with that I uh welcome the board to ask uh Dr Dr Roger questions with respect to his superintendent report or uh make comments Miss Chang okay thank you Dr Rogers for your presentation good evening members of The saset Learning Community the recent racial bias incident as s Southwoods has caused a lot of concern for the future and safety of our children here in s it especially if you are Asian yes I'm a Boe trustee but first and foremost I'm a Chinese ameran with three children in our sasis

069schools so of course I too am extremely concerned racism bias intolerance and hate have no place here in saset it's Paramount that the district continues the work on diversity and inclusivity task force as well as antibi highest staff training I'd like to urge everyone to please allow Dr Rogers and the administration to thoroughly investigate what happened last Thursday honest calm open conversations are the only Pathway to resolution and more importantly change our children are watching how we as adults respond and last but not least Dr Rogers we appreciate the work and administration have done thank you Mr Gan uh yes I uh share the sentiments of um Tracy Franco and Carol changen and of course Dr Rogers um this is not a place where anything like what happened last week would ever be acceptable we

070do not tolerate uh any kind of racist acts bias uh everybody here is here for a reason they're here because this sasit is such a great school district and we give such a great education to all the people here no matter what their race religion Creed whatever I have the complete confidence in this Administration that they will in Thoroughly investigate what happened um you've heard tonight that you know we cannot release a lot of details about you know what happens in the course of that investigation and what what discipline what disciplinary action is taken but rest assured that you know you have your elected board members here who you know are constantly in contact with Dr Rogers we are aware of what's going on um we are making sure that uh what happened has a

071consequence and uh Dr Rogers you have my complete you know um faith that you will see that the right outcome comes thank you Mr Feldman yeah thanks for the report Dr Rogers um I concur my fell trustees you know uh uh intolerance has no no place here no racial intolerance and it it will be it's being investigated like has been re reiterated earlier um I want to also say that I've worked with Dr Rogers and Miss bergette for the past six years and they are extremely honorable and ethical people um since they've been here they've worked tirelessly to promote inclusivity and tolerance and I support both of them 100% thank you Miss Levitan I too concur with my fellow um trustees I just want to point out one thing and that is the dangers and

072repercussions of social media posts and subsequent open online discussions especially when dealing with young children facts are often mixed with opinions that could potentially have a detrimental effect on a child's life and well-being our Administration has been working tirelessly following protocol procedure procures and privacy laws making sure they miss absolutely nothing that in itself demonstrates just how seriously this District takes such incidents so I would urge everyone to really keep in mind keep that in mind when joining such spontaneous online discussions and speculate on any school district action or in action in the matter thank you Dr Rogers Miss FAL thank you Dr Rogers for your informative presentation um I wanted to first start out by saying that anti-asian hatred and racism of any kind that has been so rampant in our world truly breaks

073my heart and must stop hatred and racism in any form cannot be tolerated and must end no one should ever be on the receiving end of hateful Behavior All acts of hatred and racism need to be taken seriously investigated and addressed as swiftly as possible based on the specific facts of each case please know that the school administration and the board take all acts of hatred extremely seriously I believe it is of the utmost importance to create an environment where our kids feel safe where they feel they can speak up when they see something hateful happening and where they know they will be protected creating such an environment is crucial to the Safety and Security of our children thank you Miss falkov anyone else okay um Dr Rogers uh you had mentioned earlier that you've

074received some requests for uh participation from community members um to the diversity and inclusivity task force and uh I too and I imagine some of my board members have also received requests and um that just makes me so happy because part of why we do this work is in the hopes that um the work we do reaches the community and has an impact and just by virtue of the work we've done already um it has been communicated and people are interested in joining and that's great um I know that there are already over 50 members and uh we want want this to be a productive um a productive committee and so uh while I don't want to um turn interested community members away I do think that the Board needs to work on um setting

075uh some criteria or parameters for um the uh members of the committee so that we can manage the committee well um and in addition I know that the bird s uh the board serves as a um as a governance role in connection with the committee um but I think that we do also need to work with the board to develop ways in which uh the board can um give their input give meaningful feedback and interact with the uh the subcommittees that already exist um so that we can will really uh have a cohesive understanding of um the work that's being done whether that work is in line with the board's Mission um so that we can all be on the same page uh with where we're going as a community and so um I know

076that the presentation was just given today but um over the course of the next uh few board meetings um I'd love it for uh us to have uh dis ongoing discussions with the board uh an exchange of ideas um on uh the best way to manage um a committee like this so that everyone has their input and certainly given the fact that I'm announcing um that we're going to be doing this work at our public meetings if anyone in the community has input on um um these issues and and how we might uh structure the committee um I'm very happy to receive your emails I'm sure any members of the board uh would be happy to receive those emails as well uh we take suggestions so um with that thank you for your superintendence report

077okay so we're going to begin audience to the public and I know many of you have uh not been here um on in previous occasions and so I'm going to read the rules um that we abide by there are many people here today and so the rules that we create are a way to help us manage uh the meeting respect everyone's time and uh give the board a chance to answer uh the questions and react to some of the comments that are made so those who wish to come up for audience to the public will come up to the podium one at a time you will please introduce yourselves by name and your address and the reason why we ask for your address is because the only members of the public who are allowed to

078speak um in our board meetings have to be residents of the district and uh I believe there's a ledger on the podium where you'll write your name and address so that we know if we need to follow up with you on an answer that we were unable to give we can do that each person who comes up to audience to the public will have four minutes to speak and at the end of those four minutes you're going to hear a beep and that beep signifies that your four minutes are up and I'm going to ask you to take your seat now I understand that you may have prepared something that's longer than 4 minutes and so um in order to give everyone else a chance what I'll say to you at that point is um

079please stop your your comments now and you'll have another opportunity to come up later and finish your comments if you haven't already done so and so um we want to respect your ability to give us some comments but we also have to respect um the time that we have here today so everyone will have a chance to come up for 4 minutes when you're finished you'll take your seat and everyone else will have a chance to come up for 4 minutes as well at that point when the first round is done we will do our best to answer those questions we'll be taking notes and to the extent that uh we receive similar questions or comments we'll be able to react to them as a whole after uh we answer the questions that we've been

080asked I will give everyone an opportunity if if there is time uh for an additional form minutes and um and then when that round is done and the answers to the extent they can be are given I will conclude audience to the public and uh you can come back in the next month and um speak to us again we don't permit polling of the board members and what that means is that if you have a question you can't pinpoint board members and ask each of them how they feel about an issue that we don't do that here um and very importantly uh and you heard from our attorneys during Dr Rogers um speech because of the statutory privacy rights of students and staff we can't talk here about a specific incident or specific students or

081specific staff members but what you can do is phrase your questions in a general manner so if you have questions about investigations or um or uh data or you know procedures of any kind if you can just please phrase it in a way that doesn't suggest a specific person or a specific incident then we will be able to entertain that um comment or that question so you may hear me if you make a mistake inadvertently you may hear me say can you please rephrase that in a more General manner and that's really just to protect our students and our um and our staff and so that we can stay within the uh the law that that we have to follow and with that please do come up and uh share your thoughts uh hi everyone

082uh you might oh yeah it's a little of a hel suck sorry all righty hi everyone uh you might recognize me my name is Jesse Levan I live at 90 Coes run and I'm a senior here at soset high school I have about one month left to go I know that there are a variety of topics that you've all been discussing um throughout this meeting and will discuss but I'm here today to again push for the return of our students this on May 3rd um it actually last week feels like a while ago the seniors had one of the best experiences in the entirety of our high school career I remember uh it was about 2 weeks ago I was sitting down in my second period class at home of course and my student go

083adviser said come on you we have a meeting right now let's go we're planning and I had no idea what this was about and I found out that it was about the commitment day and that was one of the best experiences planning it as a student government officer and for those of you who don't know I'm the Senate treasurer of the school it was one of the best experiences because we came together in one day and established a plan and created one of the most memorable experiences for our seniors now it's May 10th and School ends and I I hate to think about it but it ends in a month and that's it for us Juniors have another year sophomores have more time freshman have more time everyone else has more time but we don't

084have more time we have very few time left and so I know that recently we were lifted the the I guess the uh um the designation of us being in a Red Zone was lifted recently Dr Rogers I know you were talking about that a few updates ago how that is something we'll look for well we're out of it it so now it's time to discuss now it's time to plan let's get us back into school because we have one shot at this and in a few in a month in a few months I'll be going to college and that's it for us you know we don't get another shot at this sophomores have their chance freshman have that chance but we don't I know we've been talking about the fall return and that's all

085great but truthfully it doesn't matter for us because we won't be here in the fall so I hope that you can at least consider that we're out of the Red Zone cases are declining vaccination uh vaccinations are increasing this is our time to finally bring us in together the situation is getting better and let's do what is right for our seniors and for my peers I'm here today to represent them and let's do what's right and that's what I'm here to advocate for if you don't want to do every day I get that I'm you know aware of the situation so at the bare minimum I hope that you can at least give us one day per week that's it's what I'm asking at the minimum one day per week where all the seniors or

086all students can be in school together we've done it once with the commitment day it was one of the most memorable experiences of our high school careers let's do it more and more because soon enough there will be no time left so I hope you consider it I hope you consider bringing us back into school because this year has been tough on all of us and it's almost over so we're just trying to make some more memories with these people that we may never see again and that's what it comes down to so I hope you consider it thank you for this time uh I know you have a lot to discuss but I just hope uh I really hope that you take it under consideration because this would mean the world to us I

087I saw some kids that I haven't seen in 14 months and it was one of the best experiences and feelings that you could ever imagine think about maybe you for the first time saw a family member I know this Thursday it's going to be my first time seeing my grandmother in 14 months these memories last a lifetime so let's make them happen thank you uh hi my name's uh de my name's Devon lewitz and I'm I'm also here to vouch for having the seniors back as often as you can um I just want to start by saying that I second everything je Jesse has to say um as a friend and classmate um I hold his opinion in the highest of in the highest regard um I I agree with him that planning the planning

088commitment day was one of the most exhilarating processes I've had as a student go government officer um I'm senior class president by the way um just knowing all the smiles that would be on all all all of our classmates faces that that was just it was just such a great thing that we could do for our class and I was so excited to help plan it um I after that after last Monday I've had numerous seniors come up to me saying that that was the best day of school they've had in their time at saset um uh it was just it it I've never seen more more unity in in the class of 2021 there there were there were chance being started in the courtyards everybody's taking pictures together everybody's so happy and at the

089end of the day when we were all on all on our new Turf um thank you by the way we had a great lacrosse game on it today um um Everybody uh We've set up long games and typically in the past with those lawn games um some seniors may say oh that's not worth our time let's just sit on the side go on our phones but no everybody's playing everybody was playing the long games and that's just because all they want to do is just be with each other that's they just want to participate in activities that involve getting all the seniors together and I I was so I was so proud to be class president at that moment because I've never seen all the seniors come together in such a way before um it

090was just such an amazing thing to see and I I Can Only Imagine that it's it's possible that we may be able to turn this super tough year around and end it on the highest note by having like having one of the most unifying Moments by having more days where we're all together as a senior class um uh in the in the end of this year um we we just need more times like that we as Jesse said memories do last a lifetime and um this is time that we don't get back and it would it would just be so amazing if um you um if we could make this happen and I really appreciate you taking this into consideration I know you have a lot of other important things to discuss um but yeah

091thank you so much [Applause] hello my name is Christian bonan I live at 19 Hemlock Drive and saset I have a third and first grade child in Village Elementary uh and my comment not so much a question maybe a bit of a rhetorical question is how does this I let me back up actually the code of conduct The Pride curriculum it's it's very cute um but it is completely impotent again against such egregious acts of racism that we are seeing now and specifically because it fails to use the term racism it fails to use the term hate it fa fails to use the term bigotry and I understand that these are uncomfortable terms to use with young children but unfortunately parents in this school district are having to have these conversations and use these terms

092I know because I had to have that conversation with my children my children are of mixed race which brings up its own set of racist exposure we need to address every year multiple times a year on many levels specifically talking about we need to Define racism Define hate we need to Define what the consequences are for the children who experience this the children who are being hared in these instances it's deep rooted emotional harm we've talked about it we we played great lip service to it but they're the ones who are going to live with it we need to explain that to Children these consequences are going to last their lifetime it's going to impact their education it's going to impact their relationships with people it's going to impact their relationships with their with with

093their jobs it is time to stop being so halfhearted halfway about this we need to use the term bullying uh you know I know that some of the principles and some of the administration are afraid to use the term directly I know because I've had these conversations before and there's always this I I I I don't know if I want to Define it that way I'm sorry you have to call you have to call it what it is or it's not going to get addressed it's not going to be understood and you're going to breed a generation of children a brand new generation of children who simply deny the existence of racism because they've lived their whole life committing it and being and not being told that's what that is so in a nutshell we

094need to really look at this curriculum and revise it for the unfortunate harsh realities that our kids are experiencing today that's all thank you [Applause] [Music] thank you I just didn't know if I'm allowed to go there for so I will give everyone a moment oh hi so my name is Jessica Li I live in Hidden rage sasset five the Mills um before I say anything I would give everyone a moment just to take a look at this um so you're looking at a non-conclusive survey the reason being is it's given a very extremely limited time framework and it's extremely limited um accessibility in terms of the poll um and the people who can participate so this is just came up um it was actually conducted by few concerned parents and it was just spread

095online everything's Anonymous it is not public we're not discussing anything it's just individually registering their thought and that's what you're looking at right now and for those who don't have access to the copy I'll just quickly read um the whole survey I think will last a little more than 24 hours that's in including the nighttime and um we have totally together 156 respondents and among them um the question were two questions were being asked one has any child in your household experienced any race based the hate incident or microaggression at school and there are you know 50.6% of the answers are saying no and there are 35.3 % of the answers is saying yes they've experienced a verbal harassment and 7.7% saying yes they've experienced a physical assault and the rest of them uh roughly

09620.5% saying yes they've experien the microaggression the second chart is showing the distribution based on different schools um just quickly read through AP Village takes 2 point um have two incidents so that makes 2.5% % bis Elementary School have n among again among the answered you know participant um that takes 11.1% Barry Hill have 10 un stents makes up 12.3% South Grove Elementary have two um excuse me three um takes 9.9 Village has nine takes up 11.1 what women have five um takes 6.2 HPT have 17 um makes up 21% Southwood Middle School has 23 that takes about 28.4% and in the high school level there are 20 incident like answered again respones um takes 24.7% I know I'm not allowed to pull anyone but I ask everyone who heard these numbers and respectfully all

097the trustees what's the first thing came to your mind again you don't have to answer me right it's not the answer session I know when I saw this I'm heartbroken I understand my opinion is not important but I'm here to address how I feel because I am a concerned parent I chose the school almost a years ago at the time I didn't even have a kid that's a school Age kid I came here with the Full Faith and confidence in this school district knowing what here can provide for my child and when I see this all I can think of is wow I don't know how much of this that your school district know if you guys are not even aware of the numbers that just shows what the previous gentleman said the programs are

098great in name you know probably ways have to be reformed method have to be changed things has to be reconsidered because obviously things are not really putting together a lot of keid are heard they're not the environment is not friendly enough for them to speak up um Miss Lou yeah we appreciate your comments four minutes is up but we'd be happy have you come back sure and I would love for you guys to think on those numbers and get back to me thank you so much [Applause] my name is Kevin McKenna I am a longtime saset resident and I'm also currently a candidate for a supervisor in the town of oyer bay I have been advocating for sasis and town of oyer bay residents for 5 years and um I am here I'm going to

099start off um unfortunately I have no um no other Outlet other than to use this platform I am calling for Dr Rogers immediate termination Andor resignation Mr McKenna we don't talk about specific staff or specific students I went through this um rule in the beginning I'm happy to repeat it now all right I already made my point I'll go on the reason that um I'm going to give you the reasons for for what I just said no you cannot because you're going to deny my freedom of speech I'm going to tell you again the rules of this uh forum and that is there sear such a thing as a First Amendment the First Amendment right and I will I will try to abide by what you're trying to convey so if you allow me to

100go on I will I will abide try to abide by what you're trying to shut me down on well I'll help you in that if you're going to be talking about reasons or anything having to do with a specific staff member or student then I'm going to have to shut you down again well let me let me just say that I sent in numerous emails to this board Board of Education the entire Board of Education including they were addressed to the superintendent Rogers and um I am totally appalled totally appalled at the lack of transparency from the district and I am totally appalled by the deceit by the district on the Sasa taxpayers and let me in a nutshell tell you what happened I think that you all deserve to know and the public that's

101listening online as well as that that's here they deserve to know your I'm going to I'm going to try to abide by what it is that you don't want me to a a an individual that represents the saset school district sent an email to a fellow resident of mine McKenna again you are talking about a so you're preventing my freedom of speech I am preventing you from violating the rules of this you can't prevent my freedom of speech it's a first amendment US Constitution right you can't do that be careful what you say to me Miss Frankl because I have a staff of attorneys I have a staff of attorneys and I have a First Amendment right that's enough and Dr Rogers refuses to answer an email Dr Rogers refuses to answer an email as

102to why the public information officer of the scas school district lied to the public the public information officer lied to the public and Dr Rogers has refused to answer the emails sir you have to leave to the point Dr Rogers that you sent me a letter sir you have to leave accusing me of being a bully and harassing your public you are a disgrace to the saset school district a dis don't you touch me you you have to leave you a trespass e e e can you hear me yes oh okay so thank you for your patience as I said in the beginning of the meeting we have these rules for time management we have these rules for the protection of our staff and we have these rules for the protection of our students and

103um it is unfortunate uh that you had to witness that but I speak on behalf of the entire board when I say uh that uh we have the utmost faith in uh Dr Rogers he has been since I've known him the most outstanding leader that I have ever witnessed I have learned so much from being on the board uh for him being here and I don't know of another leader out there of schools and education that um has the come combination of empathy experience and intelligence um that this gentleman has and so uh we're very proud of him it's unfortunate to uh to hear comments like that um but uh we cannot speak and entertain specific comments about specific staff and specific students for uh their own and so so with that if anyone else

104wants to speak please do I agree with President Franco um when Tracy and I ran for this board eight years ago we ran to get transparency back into Seas it there was very little transparency back there um and now I I consider Sasa to be one of the leaders uh in transparency Dr Rogers ethics is the highest level of any person I know he is uh when you get to know him someone you can completely trust you know his judgment is good he presents both sides of every argument he analyzes and he comes to a logical conclusion um whenever something has to be whenever we feel that there's even an issue of should we should we release some information or not we always air on the side of releasing it you you see you see

105the emails you see the sasid pride you see our open meetings here it's video it's on video you can watch from home trust me please calls for like you just heard are completely outrageous he has my complete con I completely confident in Dr Rogers and um I hope you are too thanks yeah I concur with my colleagues and as I mentioned earlier I support Dr Rogers 100% we're very lucky to have him here as our superintendent he is a person of the highest moral standard and uh like Mr Gerson said I I don't know if I've ever met anyone of a higher moral standard in my life so um like I said I support him 100% cannot agree more I think um I'm sorry Dr Rogers that you it's hard to find words here but

106um I think the community at large and our school Community for sure is well aware of the efforts and just the ethical standards and just all the massive amount of work I honestly I doubt you have get to you don't sleep I don't I think you work 247 so just we're lucky to have you here and all the children and students of this District lucky to have you and thank you for all your work and all your dedication and attention to detail and I just can't agree more with everything we've heard thank you thank you I have had the pleasure of working with Dr Rogers for since he came here as PTA president as involved in all the Committees and I have never ever seen a leader who approaches every situation with intelligence and thoughtfulness

107and he truly cares about every person in this community and about every child and we are incredibly lucky to have a dedicated intelligent thoughtful kind and caring superintendent who works tirelessly the amount of hours and effort that in this year alone he has put in is extraordinary and from the bottom of our hearts I hope you know how appreciative and thankful I am and so many others are and how lucky and grateful we feel that we have you as our superintendent and anybody I believe anybody who has truly had an opportunity to work with you or see you work would feel the same way because it's impossible to see your responses and your behavior and not know how hardworking dedicated thoughtful ethical and kind and caring you are and how much this community and especially

108the kids mean to you so thank you um Dr wers I want to personally apologize because you do not deserve um to be treated this way um all that you have done for covid um leading the team not just Dr Rogers but how he inspires his entire team my whole experience with Dr Rogers has been nothing but the utmost professional um he's a very gentle man he's a very caring man um I I'm it's an honor to even get to work with him and to know him um I really respect him um from the bottom of my heart I see his team um my background is auditing I have never seen the school district uh deny uh any request um again I feel like our transparency um I've never seen anybody been denied anything that

109we've asked for anything that I've always asked for I have I have gotten I have gotten an explanation in full from not just Dr Rogers but the whole administrative team um so I'm proud to be on the board I'm proud of this admin Administration and I want to thank them because this year was so difficult and they went up and above and um thank you thank you Dr Rogers okay Dr Rogers I'm sorry that um you had to experience that which was uh totally um inappropriate and I just wanted to share with the community that uh four years ago when I got on to the board I remember Dr Cohen said to me Carol remember you you are not going to get another superintendent like Dr Rogers just remember that and and I have to

110say that Dr Cohen is so right over the past four years especially since Co started last March I've seen Dr Rogers working 80 hours a week if not more summer and weekends have become the new vocabularies for Dr Rogers there hasn't been a day that he had a break and he sacrificed his vacation days just so that we can get through this together and I'm so proud to say that and we did school had been open since last September even though secondary schools are hybrid but look at elementary schools and middle schools we've been going to school every day and if not for his leadership I don't think we can get to this this point at this time in the school year and so I do want to appreciate everything that Dr Rogers has done

111including Administration thank you I respect all of your time and we are going to go back to audience to the public but it was important for me and I know it was important for the board to um express our appreciation for uh Dr Rogers in light of uh what happened so thank you for that and uh the next person please hello can you hear me uh I'm Billy C and uh I live in 26 Lock Drive uh Woodbury so I want to uh I'm extremely sad uh when I hear the news uh uh last Friday the incident that uh you you you just uh talk about and I just want to share a story uh of my son uh actually happened last year as well and uh I I file a Dasa report uh at

112that time uh and uh it's it's a incident in in the school bus where uh my son being called uh a Corona and uh he's only a uh a fourth grade and uh uh uh he's been called Corona by by first first first gr stent I'm so sorry to interrupt but if if you could speak more generally about your concerns and not speak about a specific right right right I'm I'm I'm I'm I'm reach reaching to it so so at that time um um my my my son tried to get help from teacher uh but uh uh after two days uh I think he spoke to uh maybe two to three teachers uh but uh he didn't get any help so uh we we we sent an email to the principal uh I'm going to

113say I'm not going to say who and uh uh we are not we are being ignored as well so at the end we found daa report and sent it to uh uh uh Dr Roger and I uh uh and and and the board and finally uh the principal take it uh seriously and interview my son and and uh and the and the people are being involved so this happened last year so uh the incident has has has concluded already so as the previous gentleman said uh uh no hate or racist or any word regarding uh uh all all the all the verbal or or the word that uh that child use is is being addressed so the school is just basically conclud as uh the kids didn't really know what what they're saying and that

114that they the uh it's not even using bullying right but I understand because um uh that is from uh first great student so I'm uh at that time I'm I'm not really going to uh try to uh do anything more so that's why I'm extremely sad when I uh hear the news uh uh last Friday because it's not from uh first year grade student is from a group of student which is 10th grade who really know what they're doing and what they're thinking so I really hope that uh uh the school district can uh have a open and transparent uh an investigation uh to to give uh justice uh to to the family who are involved and uh uh the second thing that I want to point out is um in order to prevent all

115this hate and ra racism uh incidents happen uh anymore I know it's it's very hard to stop but we we just want to try to avoid is heaven uh uh more and more so I hope that uh the school can consider something in the curriculum so this month is the Asian American and Pacific Islander heritage month so I know that the school uh you have curriculum uh in teaching about uh the Civil Right Movement uh in jary uh when when uh uh um Martin Luther King uh uh to set uh to remember Martin Luther King so in a School District that we have almost 40% of Asian so will the school curriculum uh include anything uh to teach about uh what's the contribution of Asian in this uh country because we are proud to call

116us our home so when I his students say go back to your country Asian is really making me sad because this is my home so will the school School teach the whole school district all the students what contribution have Asian done to this country thank you for is is important thank you so much and if you'd like to continue uh in the second round please do come up again oh [Applause] I shie park to court I asked said for what it's worth Dr Rogers we we love you don't go and you are spoiling Us by replying to all of our emails on Saturday Sunday any time the week so thank you for that um that's why we keep on writing to you um well um you can see that it's affecting us a lot and

117I believe that we do have to go through this growing pain in order to improve and I doubt that we will ever have the end answer I don't think we will have the perfect answer ever but we can only try to improve right and um I hope that we give each other benefit of the doubt and be patient as we work out the process of that Improvement um I do have a few questions I came with five questions and after your lawyer talked I have seven questions now and I hope by getting the answers to these questions that we will have better understanding of the process of the investigation so we can H we can partner with you with the administration to make this investigation successful and um here are the questions number one is

118in order to help the administration to carry out a good and thorough investigation what informations are pertinent when filling out the Dasa form okay and um what kind of example can you give us that lead to a failed investigation um I'm asking because there were a lot of anecdotal stories of how people made reports but they were swept under the rug and obviously we want everyone who reports to have satisfactory resolution and I assume that they did not receive that satisfactory resolution because there was some sort of failure here uh to come to any kind of conclusive conclusion second is um I understand that when children are filling out that dasao they are doing that alone uh without any parent present and without any support system um it seems terrible to me to think that

119if my child experienc some you know horrific incident at school and and is shooken up he sit in a corner in a room somewhere by himself filling out this form and I don't want to imagine it and I'm sure as a parent whose children had to go through it will break their heart so I want to know why uh that is the case and three um can we establish a way to keep the parents informed of the process of the investigation even if you cannot give specific information keeping the parents updated on we are interviewing this we we're interviewing we're still still in the interviewing process or we have finished the interviewing process and you know so and such and such people will meet together and so by keeping the parents updated on what is

120going on they're not left in the dark thinking oh they're not going to do anything and fourth um I from um the Mr lawyers explanation I gather the process of the Dasa after it is reported that first report is made and then there is a Dasa coordinators are assigned is there one or more and um investigations are carried out and how many people are involved in that investigation and lawyer uh it sounded like from his explanation that lawyers Administration and daa coordinators will be discussing the course of action and so who is are those group of people making that decision oh I'll come back [Applause] good evening uh ladies and gentlemen and the member of O Boe uh my name is away Leo my son's Robert he is attending to hbt for seventh grade um

121tonight I have three question um the first one the Boe member of Dr Roger can give me answer um do you know how many Asian parent in scsd or the question will be do you know how many Asian kids Asian americ in SC SD thank you um you have four minutes to ask all your questions and comments and when everyone has gotten through their questions we'll take uh we'll give answers okay you don't need to answer me I know the second question is how many Asian member in Boe could you raise your hand now of you good so I'm coming here um I checked the capacity for the reason is uh social distance there very last people I don't think this necessary because a lot of Asian parents outside it's necessary for Boe to explain

122and deal with important related education crisis you know what I mean that happened on May 6 rather than being a member of everyone phrase of Dr rer because I hearing every of you say how good the Dr Roger this is not our question we are coming here we don't we know Dr Roger and here is 10:06 p.m. you have family I have family we have kids we hope we can talking most important things give us answer thank you um Tanya gets to a uh Pine Road saset and uh I have two um children in the district a senior at the high school and a seventh grader at Southwoods Middle School um my daughter um just before her High School Orientation had um graffiti on the walls of the high school um buildings that with swas

123stickers and other symol and we are seeing um there are other incidents of that in the high school later and um there was an incident with my son in the sixth grade which I'd wrote to the board about um but the thing is that what's happening in our country um or when our community is mirroring what's going on in our society at large across the country in school districts and in cities we're seeing a rise in Acts of um intolerance both in speech and in deed and it is targeting groups often um it's anti-semitic um anti-asian um and other minority groups as well so um I I see this as a community issue and not just a school issue and so I really think that in addition to the board and the administration the PTA

124has to take a firmer role in this and um I did send to the board um I'm sorry to miss bergette and to Dr r um a um bystander intervention training Workshop that parents can take Educators and there's also stum for youth on how to stand up for others because it does seem in our country right now the bystander is becoming ever more important and um these are offered and they're online and um I did provide the links to miss forette I would also like to address something else that Dr Rogers brought up which was the issue of um hiring of having teachers in the classroom that reflect the diversity of the students and this is an area um I'm a faculty member at cuni and I was very pleased to hear that at last

125the district is recruiting from cuni which has some very fine education schools at Queens College at City tech there are others and our students reflect the diversity of the city and they the diversity of this community and they are the equal of graduates coming out of the private schools and um and I think the district has been behind in that and I think it can really make Headway in that area significant Headway because the graduates are there and so on that note I'll come back and ask questions but I know you have many more because I have a couple other questions thanks well first of all thank you for um my name is Peter Chun Kim uh I live at uh 145 Don um I have two daughters here in the SAS district and um

126you know as as a Asian parent you know what's been happening for the last year plus has been very worrying some and uh you see it on the news and you explain it to your children and you hope that it wouldn't happen in school and the thing that really worries me is um with a school like this that's 50% minority and 42% Asian that when some incidents like this were happening the community and the school district didn't play a little bit more proactive role to make the students understand that if there's anything that they should report it I I don't know if there was but maybe I didn't hear it as much and for anyone that's involved with that for them to report it and take it a lot more serious um in incident like

127this that happens you know it's very traumatizing for the people everyone around it but what concerns me is was this an isolated incident or was there something more what worries me is all the bullying me as as a parent of two daughters I know my kids have faced bullying I know friends that have faced bullying I wonder if those things were stopped a little bit earlier warned a little bit earlier showed how serious these inces are that maybe it wouldn't get to the point what happened last week or or more most recently so I'm really really about you know we don't want to reprimand the kids because they are kids and sometimes you know first first graders Elementary student Middle School student high school student they go through these incidents and they have to learn

128and they will continue to make mistakes but we what we're trying to do is catch this at an early point so that they understand that what they're doing is not right and if there's any incidence of these bullying to make the proactive approach to it make sure that it doesn't ex ex U expand and Escala to the point of it becoming you know where a police officer might have to get involved or May maybe there's a lawsuit you know I think that's best for everyone involved so I really wish as a school community and and as us parents and as a community that we would take a more of a proactive approach to how we would try to stop this before it KS to to this point and maybe have some more policies in there

129to report or educate about bullying especially about racism and making sure that they understand it's very transparent that if it comes to that points that these are some of the consequences and show the strength of it by not saying that we're very tough on racism but actually act upon it and say you know this is what we're going to do and we as parents we want to see fairness we want to see forgiveness we we also want to see be transparent and follow understand where the process is and how we could accept this move forward improve on this and if we need to help with the Improvement process thank you very much [Applause] good evening everyone my name is tianqin I am a working mom of two kids both attending siasia school district last Friday

130I received an email from superintendent Dr Rogers like always the email arrived on Friday sharing exciting news on kids achievements and summarizing progress the Boe has made if not read carefully I could have missed the incident that Disturbed me and the saset community the whole weekend after knowing the details of this incident from multiple sources I feel angry and upset when I started to communicate with other Asian parents I found they share the same feeling as me we wondered how the rest of the community thinks about this incident from this email do they feel the school district provides enough details for the community to understand what has happened do they think the school district takes this incident seriously do they think the school district should take specific actions immediately after the incident happened do they

131think the school district leadership should hold themselves accountable and take responsibility for this incident with the help of other Asian parents we together created a survey to find out those questions now every Bo member has a handout showing the results of the survey I'm going to challenge you to ask yourself without looking at the survey results what would you answer to those questions the survey was sent out around Sunday around noon time in the past 30 hours we received 2023 Anonymous responses from the community I am involved and I can reach out too around 90% of the 223 responses strongly disagree or disagree that the superintendent communicated the incident details its severity and action taken in his first email the survey is still open and the number is still growing in the last last page

132there is a QR code you can scan and see the realtime response details the last question is an open question what do you want the superintendent to provide in his follow-up email regarding this incident I used AI to summarize the active words and you can clearly see the patterns here are asan hate crime more detail action taken I know you are all busy you may not have time to read through all the emails that parents sent therefore we had it we provide this survey to provide you different perspective from all your Boe members from the communities I hope this Anonymous survey can help Boe members to understand what the community thinks about the incident and what is their expectation on you as the leadership and I hope Boe can provide satisfied answers to the public

133in the followup communication thank [Applause] you good evening everyone my name is Lucy Lou I'm a teacher and a mom my son is going to Southside High School in September I appreciate Dr Rogers uh Speech addressing how the our school district uh creates the equity and inclusive environment however I as a Asian mom I feel that our school district can do more to protect our children what happened uh last week happened before in March one kid was verbally abused during recess some kids yell at him beat up all the Chinese kids because they brought covid here and Chinese kids should go back to their covid country this incident was reported to school district however no communication was sent to the community to gain awareness the Community had the right to be notified when such incidents

134happened that could potentially impact our kids so we ask for transparency on this incident investigation we understand lots of information cannot be shared due to the law and privacy protection and we respect that however we request Boe to clearly communicate to the public what information can be shared we request school district and Boe to communicate the investigation progress to the public in a frequent Cadence School District must communicate the consequences of the offenders offenders to the public so that we know what school district means by Zero Tolerance clearly this Asian hate incident is not a first incident happened in our school district yet it goes worse during the pandemic what action had the school district taken to fight Asian hate crimes what can we do to prevent the similar incident from happening again I challenge

135the school district leadership to create short-term and long-term plans to build a diverse and inclusive environment at s at school district the plan has to be actionable and details be communicated to the public as soon as possible we also asked for documented processes to report such incidents many victims didn't report the incident because they faed they could get retaliation or they faed they may not have enough evidence to prove the incident for example when the boy who was yed at go back to a covid country the parents didn't report incident because they were worried that their kids might get retaliation if the reporting process had been documented the student would be comfortable to speak up and fire the incident following the process I noticed um Dr Roger mentioned that you uh school district has a

136app but we don't really heard the app before and I believe School District should promote the apps more and aware the community how to use the app I challenge the school district to create a safe environment to empower students and teachers to report such incidents I challenge the school district to provide guidance and devices to collect evidence rather than pour the evidence collection pressures on the victim I challenge the school district to investigate the incident even if it may not be directly reported from the victim but from witness to truly show your support to the Asian-American Community thank [Applause] you hi everyone my name is uh Inu I live 32 Field Stone Drive um good evening thank you uh first of all for the board and Boe trustees and uh Dr Roger thank you for

137the great work you've done in such an extraordinary environment my daughter looks forward to going back to school meeting her teachers and friends in person however she was shocked by the recent physical attack on Asian student and the rual slur and uh I appreciate the effort the school district has done since the incident occurred um my kid there uh her schedule added a um code of conduct session today by school so I also agree with Mrs burget this is a teaching opportunity um but I want to share some feedback regarding the efficiency of teaching and the potential enhancement we needed right now so regarding the efficiency of uh teaching I don't think it's satisfactory at this moment uh if we recall uh in since 2017 the anti-semitic incident I haven't heard of another uh hate

138incident in our school um since then so it's uh which I believe is attributed to the timely um I mean the and the hate incident targeting the uh semantic group and which I believe attributed to the timely and transparent handling um this is the efficiency what Asian parents expect what our Asian students experience on campus are actually repeated teaching opportunities repeat the bully microaggression and then even hate incidents like this so people may wonder what why is one so effective and one is not so I see two causes one is um I see the red line of anti-asian hate incident is not clearly uh defined so if we all know that yelling the Ral slur plus a beat to the elderly Asian is is a hate crime on Manhattan Street however the similar behavior on

139our zasa campus is only um biased incident I'm concerned about what our students learn from such teaching and the second is I see the consequence is not consequence is not clearly communicated so people all know that uh anti-semitic gravity equals permanent suspension but if you check the list of consequences uh from our code of conduct it it's widely dispersed from oral warning to permanent suspension um it's like estimating the crashing location of Chinese rocket diis uh from North Pole to South Pole so you see our struggle um based on these two observations what that's what I suggested as a immediate mitigation um first we need to enhance the current training framework um create more specific metrics to evaluate Define the severity of hate incidents and Link it to the co corresponding consequences and the second

140we need to build up ongoing monitoring procedure to track the performance of our training programs as uh um people already mentioned in the superintendent report at the end of a speech I want to share a message from our local Asian Community with the board we see this incident more than a teaching opportunity we see this as a watershed thank you [Applause] hi uh my name is B I have two kids uh attending the school uh the school district uh this evening before I came to this meeting I had a short conversation with my daughter she goes to southw middle school I asked her the following two questions how to clear Define hate crime did your school ever teach you about what hate crime is and her answers to both questions are no this deeply surprised

141and disappoint me I also encourage every parent here ask your kids the same question at home I want to ask Dr Rogers and the bo members why these most basic concepts are not in included and taught in our school dni program I'm also shocked that our board couldn't recognize how much still need to be done and I urge the board to be more generous to give the district administrations more constructive criticisms in addition to the compliments we did not we don't want to hear only compliments we also want to hear constructive criticisms I also request the district to schedule followup public meetings to report the investigation progress and hear voice of the communities thank you for attention [Applause] good evening Dr Rogers SI Board of Ed and administrators my name is Tim Lao co-president of

142the Chinese American Association of soset for those of you who don't know who we are Cass is a community based nonprofit organization focused on enriching and cross educating the the size of community about Chinese and American culture which will lead to improved Communications and deeper Multicultural understanding I'm here tonight to show our support of Dr Rogers and the administration with respect to the recent racial bias incident I want to make it clear that Cass is no way participating in the ongoing uh investigation nor is it our role to do so what Cass will continue to do is to partner with the S Central School District to educate people and the um to educate people and and fight racial bias and violence in our schools we are working with the district to help provide educational resources

143that can be used going forward in incidents of bias in our schools Cass understands and acknowledges that the district has a responsibility to protect the interests privacy and well-being of every student in its core in its care particularly uh regarding the daa in alignment with that responsibil ility we strongly urge the district to conclude its investigation as quickly as possible and if the findings cannot be disclosed by law the district should then condemn in strong terms the types of actions that were alleged to have occurred these actions will reassure the members of our communities that the district is committed to reinforcing our bonds as a scos family and protecting our children thank you [Applause] good evening everyone uh um my name is Jason G uh live in number four Alice Drive a long-term resident of

144saset I'm also the Secretary of uh yakoda United Community oriented Development Association our organization's Miss is to protect disadvantaged uh uh minorities and anti-bullying um over the past few days I'm really thankful that brave mom post his story on the Facebook I'm uh imagin it over and again what happened to myself I'm outgoing person and I if what happen if this happened to me me and happen to my two young daughter it is highly probable that my daughter may not tell me and I may not even after I know I may not have the courage to tell the story to everyone so for that reason I want to thank this brave mom so much that he that she gave me the courage to speak up even as me consider myself as a outgoing person in

145case you forgot in December 2017 the high school Griffin uh uh Griff incident five students are arrested by NASA County Police Department and charged with criminal misf first degree aggregated harassment what happened over the past few days has no last damage than what happened in December 2017 for that reason I urge not only the the victim but also the school district report incident to Nasa County Police Department to hold the um uh the person accountable to the full extent of the law and thank you everyone that's my word [Applause] hi good good evening everyone uh my name is way um I live on 24 Irving drive with berry um I have two children one in fourth grade and one in ninth grade that are going to um the Sosa School uh before going into what

146I prepare for tonight um I would like to address one of the comment made by one of the board member in regards to um the risk of using social media especially for incidents um that are involving children um I totally agree with that risk but but I would also would like the board member to think about these questions rather than giving me a statement like that not to use social media I would ask as a mother with the incident that happened last week as a mother why would a mother risk her own child or home her own family identity and to go on social media to seek for help rather than going to the school what is in that Mother's mind so I I would I I would really want you guys to think about

147it is it because she doesn't trust the school will help her and act fairly or is because she just couldn't find the support she need from the school I will stop there in the interest of time I'll go straight into my speech that I prepare for tonight I'm extremely disappointed with the school district initial response to the race hate incident that happened in our middle school last week and I'll tell you why three sentences three sentences were used on the initial message from the superintendent email addressing the incident yes only three sentences I counted it multiple times to make sure I got it right my question to the board is why only three sentences is the school trying to downplay the incident do they think that Asian community in siosa is insignificant will the district

148try to shovel it into the Rock again I'll be honest that is exactly what's going through my mind throughout my Mother's Day weekend and many other Asian mothers mine I'm pretty sure I wanted you to know that it's not that I don't want to trust the school district on your commitment to handle the situation but how can I when there's only three sentences to begin with let me tell you oursos Asian Community it's worth more than three sentences I'll repeat that our Sosa Asian Community is worth more than that three sentences [Applause] now let me provide some constructive feedback for you I wanted to see going forward an individual message to inform parents of any raise hate or microaggression incidents that are happening within schools with highlevel process steps that's going to take place I

149want to see timeline I want to see how you guys are following up with these incidents I wanted to see final decision of the consequences I don't need the detail I just need to know what other consequences that are taking place second of all school should also provide an intuitive Avenue such as survey link for students to anonymously report any race hate related or microaggression incidents schools should use these metrics to improve the current process that we have and also to report out these metries metrics publicly for parents to see on a periodic basis nothing is better to hear from students themselves last but not the least a hate act to one child is a hate act to all our Asian Community will not settle nor give in until we see Justice with this incident

150thank you [Applause] all right good evening everyone good evening Dr Rogers good evening board um just wanted to say uh I I didn't intend to come here tonight uh my name is James Lee I have four kids in sasid I have a fifth grader a second grader a preschooler who's not in the actual District yet and a and a 2-year-old so I was I was asked to come here by my wife to kind of represent and kind of uh give a little bit of a background on on on the uh the mindset of the Asian on the Asian community in Sasa right now so so my backstory I was born and ra and raised in Long Island probably the two kids that were uh Asian in Patrick Medford I had to survive for my life

151I'm not I'm not being dramatic at all so I had a high school of I think a thousand that graduated and 97 and I think my sister and myself were the only agans I did anything and I anything and everything I could to survive to fit in to be accepted to be looked at the same way as everyone else and so I did everything I tried to say I wasn't even Korean I stopped speaking Korean I don't know if that was s you know subconscious or anything I joined the military which I I still am in and I think that those protections I I I made for myself kind of shielded me but I was dead wrong and I think out of my 42 years of my life I'm starting to realize that right now

152there's this implying subconscious bias that's going on in this world that um I think people are starting to see right now I think a lot of people are being um kind of given given the green light by certain people in in this society that it's okay to attack Asians now you know the the the China virus the Corona virus go ahead do what you got to do in broad daylight and attack people so I was actually bullied attacked by my my uh close friends uh you know siblings called uh horrible things but here I am in the middle of Long Island I'm different but now here I'm I'm in saset right we're not different here there's rooms and rooms in this building that that are all Asian I just want to let everyone know if

153you didn't realize that right now people are upset so here I am and I I just want to be a voice for all those people that couldn't come too shy to come and and just let everyone know that so I'm a I'm idealist and I'm uh I'm very reasonable I have full faith in the board and Dr Rogers to do the right thing I know there are limitations with the law I know there are things that can be said and not be said however I'm also in the government and I know that there's not this big machine that just just does things people actually have to take action so here's my challenge to the board to Dr Rogers and everyone please take this as an opportunity to set saset apart lead the country to set

154an example and say this is not acceptable anywhere and everywhere I still have more time so I'm just going to fill it in so so again thank you for your time and um I'll see you uh next month thank you hello my name is uh Charlie Shin I live on 17 Edward Lane I have two boys that are in Village Elementary um I James said a lot of things uh that I wanted to say um I grew up in Long Island I uh grew up with bullying I grew up with racism it was a very common thing I've been called everything from a Chinese menu to things uh um things I I wish I hope that my boys never have to hear as they grew up in this school district um as you can tell

155there's a lot of uh anger right now going on in the community um there's a very strong US versus them mentality right now and um I'm very surprised I'm very surprised that 20 years after what I went through my kids are dealing with something like this um the conversations that are happening inside our homes at our dinner tables are not pleasant um but um honestly I don't I don't believe this this desire for justice and to to go out for blood is the way we should go I think um you know we we've heard about councel culture we've heard about a lot of things to to to bring Justice to justices but um where do all these people go these people that get cancelled these people get punished I don't honestly want as as strongly

156as I feel and as angry as I feel about what happened to um the boy who's Korean and that's the reason why I came out tonight um I don't think anything comes of punishing or or punishing these children um I don't I I think especially Asians we have a very legalistic view of how to deal with situations but I don't think kids I don't think anybody's afraid of punishment everybody thinks they can get away with what they get away with and when when they get punish and when they get caught you know that's that's when they have to uh face the music but uh I I I I you know I'm very realistic I'm not very optimistic I don't believe that things will change the way it needs to be changed thus 20 years later

157after my experience we're we're still talking about this but um I still have hope you know I have hope that you know the lessons that I'm teaching my children to protect themselves to to defend themselves to conduct themselves in in in the the coming years um they don't have to um it's really sad to have to talk about this um but uh I I just hope that you guys do something um I'd like to me mention uh this teacher by the name of Jane Elliott um brown eyes blue eyes I I I I don't know if you guys have heard of that I hope that you guys can incorporate something in the curriculum that's that goes beyond just teaching about what Asia is um I I hope that you can incorporate things into uh our

158children's learning that will allow um everybody to learn more about each other in a way that has more to do with just our history and our culture um I I think things like International night are are great but it I don't think it really serves the needs of what our children need need to be happy and healthy um I came because uh honestly uh I was watching most of the the the the conversations and the speeches uh online and uh I saw the incident that happened and um it's very unfortunate but it it it worried me the amount of um and I I understand why you guys were um expressing your praise for Dr Rogers but uh at the same time I hope that um Dr rogers's self-esteem is stronger than that that uh he

159is open to criticism that you guys can hold each other accountable in the future um I hope you guys do what what it what what it takes and um you know there's a lot of anger um but uh I just hope that it this doesn't become a situation of uh just punishing and and you know just moving on okay that's that's it thank you [Applause] hi my name is Kim Wang I live on 143 very Hill Road good evening obviously the agenda for me to talk about this racial bias um I think what really concerns me um you know I'm not making L of what happened recently um but what I what I want to know is what's going to happen what's going to happen in the future this is the first incident that I've

160heard of since I've moved here two years ago but what I want to know and I have a lot of questions are on mind on my mind as well as I'm sure a lot of parents have on their minds what what will the protocol be um or the process Should students fear retaliation from speaking up up what about threats should threats be reported will they be taken seriously today it's slurs and hitting but will there be weapons used next time should there be a weapon check these are the things that I worry about and these are things that I have to think about for my children that go here I think about should I start enrolling them in karate class so they can defend themselves these are very real things that I think about I

161worry that my kids are not going to a safe place not only is it about you know as anti-asian but it's about bullying and it could be you could be any race bullying will always be there but I think what we what needs to happen is that the kids need to feel that they can safely go reported that there's an open door policy that there's a dedicated place they can go and tell the teacher or counselor whoever it is about the problem and not fear any retaliation what I also find really difficult is that when my children get yelled at being a CO starter or go back to your country is I need to remind them that they do belong in this country and they have every right to be here I think we need

162to teach the people the students here that we all belong here the only people who were really here are the Native Americans none of us were really here this is a Melting Pot I need us to empower the students that go here you know whether you're Asian or Jewish or any minority we all belong here what I really want is Real Change here and not the lip service that I've been hearing tonight that we will not tolerate racism I really want to see change and not this happened 2017 this happened 2018 this will happen 2022 2023 I want to see real change that's really going to happen from this I understand that we cannot eradicate racism but what we can have is transparency and accountability thank [Applause] you is there anyone else who would like

163to come up for the first round of audience to the public okay um if there's anyone that wants to come up a second time to finish what they uh we're not not able to finish please come up um I wanted to follow up on a couple of things um one is there was a discussion that was brought up earlier about um it being a teachable moment um what's happened and and talk about the curriculum and I know Dr Rogers had discussed earlier um meetings with um soset students in the High School about opening up the English curriculum to more diverse voices and um alluded to a discussion of you know we study civil rights and though is there another place for this the history curriculum here um some of the classes could be linked with

164some of those um opening up of the diverse texts and there's a lot of interdisciplinary work that goes on at universities now and perhaps there's more opportunity to for interdisciplinary studies in high schools as well I know you're more limited by state curriculum but I think there is there are openings there for that so that you're looking at a text across the curriculum and I think this strengthens um students understanding and empathy of diverse voices um the other thing that is following up on a lot of the stats that have been talked about um you know alluded to of trying to get satsite I wonder Dr Rogers if there is um data that you and your fellow superintendents share among yourselves about Rising incidents in the last five or six years of um acts of

165intolerance and racial incidences in the different school districts on Long Island and if that information were shared among District superintendents I think it could be very useful because then there's a call that one can make on politicians and media broadcasters that are in some ways fermenting this kind of um intolerance so um I wondered if there was any initiative about that across superintendence on Long Island thanks I wanted to follow up um with that previous question so that was the fourth question I'm going to finish up that fourth question so after all that report and investigation is done then um do all the parties get contacted with the result or due to the Privacy issue only the uh offenders will get the report um and in the types of the consequences uh one being I

166forget the term that he used exclusion exclusionary which I'm suspecting is either suspension or expulsion in that restorative justice does that involve a human interaction of coming to the offend uh offended and apologizing do we teach that having the kids come warning up their mistake and say I'm sorry to the the per to the child and to the parents and both the parents of the uh offender does that person also come to apologize that's my fourth question and my fifth question is is there a system of record keeping to see if the offender is a repeating offender or is due to the Privacy issue is that hidden so that it becomes just a um is that deal dealt with as if it's the first offense every single time um number six you made me more

167questions by the way what are the roles of lunch AIDS usually those are the only adults present in the field and what are their training to deal with something like this whether they can intersect and prevent or are they just Observers uh number seven is there a translator to support the parents throughout the process I know that daa has multiple languages so they can fill that out but during the process is there a translator who's helping them and lastly uh when you're investigating claims involving bias at one point at what point do the police get involved is it the role of the parent to get the par uh the get the police involved or is that the districts those are my questions thank [Applause] you hi uh my name is Tian Ching I just ask

168you I just give you the survey I want to ask you what are you going to do with that survey results um and and also I wanted to uh ask you to pay attention to to the last question that's a open question it has hundreds of uh uh results that coming from the parents they're requesting the uh School District leadership to respond to their uh expectation on what to what information to be sent out in the followup emails I hope the uh School District don't just send out email with the information you think that's important but really include the information that can answer the the parents uh concerns and address their questions thank you and and also put enough details and an actionable details actionable plans there not just putting say uh we think this

169we we think this is zero tolerance this is not uh not allowed that kind of uh words that anyone can say towards any incident but this is a very specific incident I want on the school district to actually say something that's really show that you want to take some actions not just to say hey I am I am doing it but what exactly action you you are taking and to show that fully transparent to your um to your community to the public thank you [Applause] hi my name is Cheryl Lao on my first round um I live at 359 Co spring I have two children in the scasd school system one in fifth grade Barry Hill and another in eighth grade Southwood both virtual this instance that incident that we've been hearing throughout um through

170Mother's Day it's very disturbing and disheartening I would like to say any racial violence on any child is an attack on my child and we will not take it lightly is a district aware of this group that is on Instagram the bip Park asit black indigenous person of color have you read all 44 posts from current students former students and teachers I urge you all to read it please pleas take the time to read frankly for a district that promotes no place for hate has a lot to work on I would like to know how would the district train the teachers and the Personnel to recognize and condemn these attacks be verbal physical or migro aggressions and how would the district ensure a safe environment for the students to report it without judgment per the

1712020 census 62.6% are white American 30.8% is asian-americans how will the school personnel and particularly the school curriculum reflect on that diversity we are not here for entertaining nor asking anyone to step down we don't care for Optics what we do want is accountability going forward how will the district protect our children and take these racial instances seriously thank [Applause] you Mitchell liberman uh Woodberry New York first I want to thank uh the entire Board of Education everybody that's up there tonight all the trustees and Dr rers for I know it's a little bit past 11 so I'll make it quick uh I'm sure you know many of you are probably thinking about some warm beds and a comfortable pillow and um hopefully you get there soon you know I I was sitting and I

172was listening to the to this meeting and I couldn't help but you know really identify with with what it's like like to be an outsider um and I just want to kind of offer and and and hope that everybody can feel that for a moment what it's like to be an outsider whether you're an outsider in in a new job that you're beginning you know whether you're an outsider in a new community that you're moving to um or you know in my case I was an outsider in in a place that we lived growing up and um you know my skin color was different than the skin color around me um later on you know several years later I moved to a place in Queens that was supposedly you know a better Community safer uh

173and I walked around with a yamaka on my head and uh I remember times when that yamaka was tossed off my head uh racial slurs uh and burned so I stand with anybody that's been a victim of racism I stand with the um the people that are here tonight the Asian community and I stand with anybody that's that's been in those situations and what I want to say is we we we talked a lot about empathy we talked a lot about um you know I think taking the input of what's been here tonight um when you go back and and you think about these things and just think about what it is think about the moment in your life that you've been been an outsider at any situation and what that feels like and that's

174what we need to do we need to focus on uh the feelings that are going around and the people the victims are not just the people that were affected the victims are the entire community of people that are now in fear you know that's that's the real damage that's been done there so to that extent I just want to ask if there are any plans moving forward uh I know we have psychologists and I know this has been probably one of the most trying years um if you can even find psychologist but I I know there are psychologists assigned to the schools um but I also understand there are x amount of social workers per school is there has there been any thought to to possibly maybe for the fall or or as soon as

175possible changing the number of social workers uh or in both changing the number of social workers and increasing the number of psychologists that are available because I I really believe that the pandemic on top of everything that's going on has been a very troubling times and um the last thing I just want to comment on and I know it's nobody's fault here but I walked in tonight and I was probably about 7:40 it was maybe two or 3 minutes early or or maybe a minute late I don't recall but I was put in the uh called waiting room there was a large community of people in that waiting room and I know there are protocols and I know probably due to uh covid you know you the board probably thought about these things months in

176advance um you know it's probably too late in the night to matter right now but you know maybe in the future consider some Provisions to that for certain situations because my fear is that some people that were in the room may have felt that they were being isolated from a situation that they wanted to be physically here and not just sitting in front of those uh screens um but that's all I have thank you is there anyone else for audience to the public before we start to provide uh responses going once twice okay uh thank you so much I know that there were a lot of process uh uh questions and um um Dr Rogers and I have both written down as much as possible um the questions that have been um asked um Jessica

177Lou had um said something that struck me when she came up and she said I I know my opinion doesn't matter but I have these questions and Jessica I can assure you that your opinion matters very much uh not only to uh the people who know you but the people who don't and uh we your opinion matters to us uh and you asked a question about the survey you gave us um and I know we don't allow polling of the board but um I can offer you my answer to how I feel about the numbers that you have here and without looking at any of the specifics I can say that anything over zero makes me sad uh that's the goal right and it's a lofty goal but it's a it's a goal to get

178us to zero and uh we feel the weight of um of that responsibility and we hold ourselves accountable for the decisions that we make and the efforts that we plan to make in order to reach that goal of zero uh so uh I can assure you that um uh that we'll take all of the comments all of the criticisms um and uh and certainly take them to heart as we look at the good work that we've done and the work that still needs to continue it's why we have the committee it's why we have our future action plans that were discussed today um it's why when we get new members they will be such an important part of the committee because they can offer more insight um and um and that that work is going

179to continue and um Mr uh chin Charlie chin said that he he has hope and I share that hope um I wouldn't I wouldn't be able to sit here and do the work that I do uh without that hope for a better future not only for our districts but um outside of our our community as well and so um with that Dr Rogers thank you obviously an emotional night for everyone obviously a lot to work on um to miss frankl's point we are listening that is the purpose of this time together we're listening deeply we absolutely have to get this right and I don't say that as lip service I say that because I know it's true I'll frame out some large ideas and then I'll respond to some of the questions and this does

180parallel in some ways the events in 2017 and I'll draw some parallels and I'll draw some distinctions so in 2017 there was an investigation phase but then there was also an aftermath phase and I want to go back to the word Watershed and it will take me time to find it in my notes so forgive me for not attributing but 2017 was a watershed moment this is also a watershed moment I hope we don't have more watershed moments but progress is made through these watershed moments so in 2017 there was the investigation but there were also a number of things that the school district did in the aftermath new Partnerships that were formed groups that were engaged ideas that were shared different things that were tried new um processes internally that were developed that came

181out of that work and I see this as being similar in that way that it illustrates we're not perfect and no one is claiming that we are least of all me we have room to improve your feedback helps us improve and we're committed to that Improvement so we have already started and Mr Lao talked about the work that Cass has been doing to support us putting into place some things that we'll be ready to announce not quite yet but work that we're going to do that's going to be part of that aftermath phase when we finish the investigation phase a lot of people have talked about what you want to see communication wise out of the investigation phase and some people have said they understand the Privacy requirements other people have said that they won't

182feel like uh we've been accountable unless you know the details of consequences and that's a broad Continuum but the law is going to control where we fall on that Continuum and we're not going to break the law but we are going to try to communicate in a way that lets people know that we have done our job and we have done it well and appropriately there have been questions raised tonight about what the consequences could be or should be if some people have said these are children they need to learn from these mistakes punishment isn't a deterrent we don't want them to be Outsiders in society we want to them to learn from these mistakes as children make mistakes other people have said you've used exclusion you've U suspended in the past you should suspend

183now I understand all all of those things I'll draw one more parallel to 2017 um it was mentioned that in December of 2017 the police made an announcement but that incident did not occur in December that incident occurred in August and there were four months of board meetings in this room where people came and stood at that Podium and accused us of sweeping it under the rug of waiting for it to blow over of not caring of not caring because it was an anti-semitic incident and in the end in December the public learned that we had never given up but it took 4 months this will not take 4 months that's not the distinction I'm drawing the point I'm making is the same spirit that animated Us in 2017 lives in us today this is

184serious we try to do the best work we can we try to do it in a way that is responsible that complies with the law that is aware of the ages of the people that we're dealing with and that repairs the harm as much as we can can that's what we're trying to do so a lot of specific questions I know the board is going to talk about returning to school uh so I'm not going to address those comments um there were a lot of comments about how we do training for kids and whether it is specific enough and direct enough and I want to go back and have that conversation with all of our building principles again through the lens of this incident to talk about what we do I don't agree that we

185avoid it in elementary school we do teach a unit on the universal Declaration of Human Rights that unit is taught differently in different schools because they have choice in how they approach it in some schools that is taught through the lens of the Vietnam War in other schools that is taught through the lens of the Holocaust uh it is impossible to avoid the terms racism and hate when describing those two events so it's clearly addressed it may not be called an anti-bullying program but it is certainly something that is addressed in an elementary school but I take the point that we can be more explicit we can be more repeated we have to be age appropriate but we also have to have kids understand what is and what is never acceptable and I want to

186have that conversation with the principles with my cabinet members so that we get that right but that's something that we will revisit and that's entirely consistent with what we've been trying to do with the curriculum already as part of the diversity and inclusivity uh task force so I see that as being absolutely uh part and parcel of that there were some specific incidents that uh folks raised I know Miss Frankle tried to keep us focused on uh generalities but if someone has a concern about an incident please raise it to myself to Mr cardillo Mr cardillo supervises the principles directly uh we'll follow up on it and we'll follow through with you there are a lot of questions about daa and uh Dr Park I'll try and go through your questions so a Dasa form

187doesn't have to be thorough or not thorough it is just a document that starts a process sometimes older kids will write fill out the form themselves sometimes a guidance counselor will fill it out with them or a building principal or a school psychologist will fill it out with them or the person who is the designated Dasa coordinator there have been times when we have talked to parents and said we think you should fill out a Dasa form and the parents have said no I don't want to and we'll fill it out anyway and keep it on file because we want to make a record so there are lots of ways to do it but the important thing is that that what is or is not in aasa form will not compromise an investigation the investigation

188is done by people not looking at paper but talking to other people and that's where we get the information you use the term failed investigation because of the privacy laws that Mr gross described earlier we can't and this is one of your questions tell a victim what the consequences were for the aggressor it's their right to privacy prevents us from doing that sometimes those consequences are apparent because the student is not but we're not allowed to talk about what What occasion that it's prevented by law so it may be that our investigation did result in a consequence and maybe even a severe consequence but the victim may never know that um how can we keep parents informed of the progress of our investigation I've been giving this an incredible amount of thought over the last

189four days I don't believe our first communication was our best and I own that and I take responsibility for that the final line that I am trying to walk is to be transparent by saying that something happened because the community deserves to know without saying anything that will compromise the investigation because let's say for example I said the bad person was wearing a blue hat and if that was in my statement then any student who came forward and said I saw somebody with a blue hat do something I wouldn't know whether to trust what they told us because they might just be repeating what I said so that's why we're careful about what we described because we didn't we still had so many interviews left to do and I wanted to make sure that we

190would be able to rely on the information we got from those interviews because no one would be able to say they were just repeating what they heard the superintendent say but that led to a sense that we were not being specific and we were not being candid that's certainly not the impression I wanted to leave the community um and so apart from this incident we have work to do and I want to do that work with the community outreach subcommittee so that I get community feedback as well I know what our lawyers will do every word that I've read tonight has gone through the lawyers first every statement that has gone out from the district has gone through the lawyers first to make sure that we comply with our obligations under the law but apart

191from this incident it would be great to develop with members of the community a way of communicating about things that we know will not get the district in trouble and give the community confidence that we're doing what you would expect us to do um how many people are involved in aasa investigation every investigation is different because of what is alleged how many kids might be involved sometimes it's just two kids sometimes it's a lot of kids sometimes the first conversation with a child yields some information and the second conversation yields more information and then a third conversation yields more information so we do go back especially with younger children again and again to try and get more detail that takes time it takes more people especially when more people are involved and as we progress

192through the investigation we do share our findings with our attorneys and we seek direction from them as to what the appropriate Next Step would be and and that's important because we want to get it right but we also have an obligation to the internal processes of the district to make sure that we don't make a mistake and so there is no one-size fits-all answer to that which is why we need people with expertise and Mr gross is not a former uh district attorney but on his staff he has several former assistant district attorneys who do exactly this work and they are the ones that we consult directly um to the point about this being not just a school district issue but a community issue I think it's a series of concentric circles the school the

193community the country and there's work to do at all of those levels and I'm horrified by the increase in hate speech and actions and prevalence of groups in the country and completely unprovoked attacks that make no sense and are scared SC and scarier still to people who identify with the victims and we have a lot of work to do what we can control is our community and our school so I'm committed to being part of that work here I know the board is certainly committed to being part of that work here and um I don't have the answers for how to do that well that's why we're going to have to work together there were questions about whether we're taking this seriously I hope by illustrating how much thought has gone into the work we've

194done so far that it's apparent we take this very seriously um again questions about consequences short-term plans long-term plans um I just revisit what I said before we have been working with partner organizations we are doing short-term things immediately in the buildings I asked Mr cardillo who as I said supervises all the principles he brought them all together first thing this morning uh they're talking about um two things making sure that everyone is completely brushed up on how to do investigations well hoping that this will never occur again but wanting to make sure that we're ready to go if it does and asking them to think about how they want to communicate about this in our buildings do we want to support our students we do we have been adding over the years uh since

1952018 additional mental health support staff additional social workers psychologists behavioral specialists and uh we have in the budget for this fall an additional social worker because we too see students coming out of the pandemic needing support but also needing support because of uh what we're going through as a society the say something app all of the students who are in secondary schools that means the two middle schools and the high school have to go through one training on on how to use the anonymous says something app so maybe we need to send them through the training multiple times a year or maybe we need to have QR codes on the wall to remind them but the purpose of creating that Anonymous reporting app was so that there was a way for people to let us

196know without the fear of retaliation the board has an anti-retaliation policy I realize those are words on paper but if we find out if we discover that a student has retaliated against another student that's a very serious offense and we take it very seriously the point was made about evidence collection being the responsibility of the victim reporting to us is the responsibility of the victim and we want to investigate what's reported to us and we do the investigation we try to develop the evidence and if it doesn't feel that way we need to know so Mr Lee said something that I circled and and highlighted and put a star next to he said we could set an example for the country I like that idea I like to and to miss frankl's point I like

197the idea of trying to have zero I like the idea of doing something that we can all be proud of and that is an example for how to do really difficult work M getts your point about interdisciplinary coursework um is right on time the high school is working and will launch this fall an elective course that is an interdisciplinary course between um social studies and um English that is studying Long Island's history uh with an emphasis on the the pressures that have led to Long Island's High degree of segregation so that's going to be a challenging class obviously it's going to be an elective so it'll be students who are interested in learning about that but it is a deep dive into our own history in this region is there data that is shared there

198is data that is collected by the state we all have access to that data superintendents are sharing anecdotal information with each other when any one of us goes through an incident like this we all have colleagues on speed dial who we trust to try and get more perspective ideas what has worked in other places how do we do this well uh this is not easy work no one of us has the answers we try to support one another um there are some veterans who are extraordinary Mr cardillo is one of those veterans who is extraordinary and we're fortunate to have him here I benefit from his experience uh Miss Park the Dr Park the rest of your questions Mr gross talked about the Continuum of responses that uh you have in terms of consequences what

199is restorative justice that was your question restorative justice is in many ways more challenging than exclusionary discipline as exclusionary discipline says that when the disciplin is over the event is over restorative justice says you have to find a way to repair the harm and often that means sitting with the people you've harmed and being accountable for those consequences that is not easy especially when this situation is so severe but there are people who are trained to do this work our former deputy superintendent Miss bavard now works for a National Organization that does exactly this work at a very high level and I do think that there's more learning and more accountability in that process but it takes more skill to do anyone can suspend a kid but facilitating that kind of a conversation takes real

200skill um do we have our own internal system of recordkeeping absolutely do the principles talk with one another absolutely when students go from the elementary school to the Middle School to the high school there are handoff meetings so that uh administrators talk to one another uh if students have uh disabilities they have an IEP there are conversations between the teachers as part of those handoff meetings yes there are a lot of processes in place what are the role of lunch AIDS uh the lunch AIDS are trained um Dr Curry one of the assistant superintendents uh was former director of HR ill built a new program of training for them and it's anything from how to intervene to how to do the heick maneuver so there are a lot of things that our lunch aads can

201do and we also in the Middle School have teachers who help supervise lunch because they know the kids they have high degree of training and skill but there are a lot of kids outside at the same time and no one adult can be everywhere simultaneously is there a translator who is available anyone who needs translation will provide translation so we have some translators we have some people who are on staff who are bilingual and so they serve role as translators but if there is a need to translate into a language where we don't have someone on staff with that skill uh we use a service through Nassau bosis to obtain a translator and no one who wants translation services will be denied and um and then your question about when the police get involved and

202then the last point about training teachers before this incident occurred we have been the Administration has been uh exploring different uh types of training resources around implicit bias uh and other kinds of training for staff and that work was ongoing but it takes on new urgency uh in the wake of what has happened so we haven't settled on a tool yet but we absolutely will have a tool and that's something we're going to work on and then the final point is just about curriculum generally the point was made that this is Asian-American Pacific Islander Heritage Month and that's great and a lot of our I had asked again before this happened I had asked our buildings to report to us what are the kinds of events that you have planned for this month in the

203same way that we asked uh in February what are the kinds of events that you have planned for Black History Month in your school at our last A diversity and inclusivity task force meeting we had a conversation about while we want to celebrate these months and these Milestones by saying that black history is most important during February we just underscore that black history is different history and by saying we look at the contributions of asian-americans and Pacific Islanders to America in the month of May says that it's not American history it's special history different history other history and this idea of othering even though it is celebratory what we need to do is incorporate that through the whole curriculum so that the curriculum is all history including the contributions of black Americans including the contribution

204of asian-americans and Pacific Islanders who are Americans all of that should be every month found somewhere in the curriculum and not something other or different or special or once a year so that's my hope for where a lot of our curriculum writing work will go this summer but this is a big organization and turning this on a dime will not be easy but we're going to work on this and continue to add so I think I've addressed at least thematically all of the questions that have come and we clearly have more work to do we have an investigation to finish and then we have an aftermath phase to plan and to do well but we are committed to this work thank you thank you Dr Rogers thank you for members of the community who came

205to uh share your feelings your comments and your questions with us uh on to discussion items we have uh one item on here and that's the CDC guidance on social distancing and the high school hybrid model and we heard from two students today um uh about a return to school and um I would just share that I thought Jesse Levan's suggestion um that we have more days like Commitment Day uh you know once a week doing what we did before um where the seniors come in and the rest of the school goes hybrid so that they can have these um last weeks doing uh fun things and and reuniting is something that I can really um get behind uh I was so pleased to see how happy um and how great that the planning was

206and um and how much the students enjoyed it and uh I appreciate the recognition that it is um you know difficult and and many people have concerns about a full uh Return of the entire School uh you know days after we get out of the Red Zone but that suggest suggestion by Jesse um I think is something that is uh very doable for the district and so um for me that's where I'd like to see um us heading in terms of planning and um you know uh my concern of course for bringing everybody in is we do have these moments planned uh these celebratory moments these moments we'd like the kids to reunite and because the quarantine rules have not changed uh my fear is that the big moments that these students want to share

207may be uh missed because they may be quarantining and I don't want to see that happen I want everyone to um you know have the special moments uh and the special memories and um you know I've heard from um parents who uh on both sides uh but certainly heard from parents who say we have a few weeks left we've been doing so well there's so much planning to do for the fall how about we you know stay as is keep everyone safe and um and plan for a full reopening I think there's something to be um to be said for that um and in particular the other night I heard uh many uh community members talk about the mental health aspects uh in particular thex society that um kids need to prepare for in uh

208returning to a full school with full uh hallways and full classrooms um with less social distancing and that um there needs to be planning on the district side and there needs to be time for uh the kids to adjust to that that massive change from what they've had for the last year and a half and so um I agree with that concept that we should be giving them time and not 4 days out of a five days out of a you know a red zone to say now we're just all in and so uh I I hope that we can rally around uh uh Jesse's idea of having one uh you know a once a week reuniting of the students in the senior class and um and get them these special moments that they they

209do deserve thank you Tracy for those comments um and you took the words right out of my mouth um I too agree that um we shouldn't rush to bring everybody back right now even notwithstanding the fact that we just came out of the Red Zone um Anna I'm sure you're very proud of your son and I actually thought um he spoke really well and and I too I'm in favor of um bringing the seniors back um if not every day I would say you know once a week every other week bring give them a couple more opportunities to come back and and have their moments in their final year of high school um I think we should one of the reasons I I think we should be extra careful is um if I'm not mistaken

210uh we have Memorial Day weekend coming up in just about two weeks time and I think we're going to have Dr Rogers is the school going to be closed on Thursday and Friday of Memorial Day Weekend yeah so that's five days now um in the past year when we've had school vacations and um people were out for a while they traveled and covid cases Rose uh it I I think it's going to happen again I don't blame people for traveling for seeing family for going places but we're going to see higher numbers after in the days after the Memorial Day Break um and we've worked so hard to get where we are um I think we should be more conservative at this point you know with the goal of having everybody back here in the

211fall get things back to normal let's keep on track and see what we could do for our senior class okay so U I know it's late so I'll be short and sweet so um I mean obviously uh we've been talking about it for for two months now and you know we're finally out of the Red Zone and I'm not going to be repeating um all the facts and obviously all the data and signs pointing in the right direction and clearly um for our seniors this is it and uh they don't have uh September to come back to so and with the um what do we have four weeks five weeks really left um I would absolutely um start you know this Friday if we can pull it off I have full faith in our Administration

212staff at the high school and teachers um I know they could do it um so if we could give our seniors that um that would be fantastic um because I I think they still you know live off of that um the emotions of May 3rd as far as the other three grades um I agree with Tracy that it might be in the middle of fourth quarter a little too drastic to massive of a change and of course we'll have to deal with a lot more numbers in the building um kids in the building building um so perhaps we could give them a moment of reuniting the cohorts and see their friends they haven't seen in a while um how many that is up to um you know um the team to assess the logistical you

213know U challenges of making that happen um but I definitely think that um the vaccination a vaccine available to 16 and older um that would definitely help us mitigate the potential you know quarantine um and Dr Rogers could you elaborate on the um um quarantine um for the vaccinated you know how where the rule stands as of now as far as you sorry um quarantining um for vaccinated um you know close contacts for contact tracing purposes all that yep so the close contact rules that would cause someone to have to quarantine if you fully vaccinated and you come into close contact with a covid positive person you do not have to quarantine so to be fully vaccinated you have to have two doses and then two weeks after the second dose um in addition if

214you have had a positive covid test there laboratory confirmed covid within the last 90 days you don't have to quarantine now we have had some people that were 80 Days uh past and when we talked to the Department of Health they did say to us have them quarantine just in case but if you're within 60 days uh for sure that we would not quarantine um so it's late I'm not going to talk long I love the idea of bringing the seniors back to so that they can have more days up together and enjoy some time before they all go off and I love Anna's suggestion of bringing the other grades back for some special days that' be fantastic I don't know how logistically possible it is given the short time frame but if each grade

215could have a day where they could all safely come back and you know be together before summer that would be fantastic if it's not an enormous logistical challenge that's just insurmountable um but definitely for their seniors it Jess's idea was great and it would be fantastic to bring them back I agree with um Anna and Rob and Tracy and Susan um I just want to share my my daughter stories from last year um she had said to me dad I didn't know was our last day of class um and I said no don't worry about it it'll be fine and and then as time went on I realized how wrong I was because it really affected her um where she was like well I never got to see these people I might never see my

216friend again and she said you know what she her dress is still hanging still now in her room from the prom that she didn't go to um so you forget how all these Milestones um I'm coming of age stay with you for the rest of your life and it's easy say oh don't worry it's no big deal but now I feel horrible for her and um she still hasn't taken down the dress So I know there's statistics and we have graphs and we have all this stuff but at the end of the day uh we're talking about kids we're talking about their feelings and how they're going to feel for the rest of their life so of course we want everyone to be safe um including the staff um teachers but if we can get

217the students together especially the seniors to salvage the rest of the year that I think is important so that's my two SS okay um I agree with everyone that um you know it's a uh to uh to bring the seniors back um one day a week and then possibly bring other grades back at least give them a chance to uh to get together as a as a grade um and also that I would hate to see um some of the students uh not able to uh take the AP exam from my understanding to AP exams they have to come in person to take it and that's music theory and World Language and I do not want to see anyone being quarantined and not be able to come to school to take those two exams and

218so you know we uh we need to finish the school year strong by having the students um to uh to come to school and finish the school this is a very particular year so yeah thank you um you know like uh Tom Rolo I had a son who gradu well he has a daughter I had a son who graduated last year and um you know they missed everything pretty much and it was really disheartening to see couldn't be help um you know the graduation was the best the district could do at the time um you know you walk up get your diploma and leave and go home no one there no prom uh uh no College day um you know he's got a a a yearbook with no signatures in it and he didn't go

219to school the last three and a half months and the spring uh senior athletes missed their last season so uh when I was at Starbucks the morning of the uh college shirt day commitment day I don't know what they call it but anyway uh I saw a lot of the seniors in there with their college shirts on and they were so happy and I felt great I really did I'm so happy for them and I'm really heartened to see that there's going to be some events now for the seniors like the prom and uh the graduation outside and and then so I think that's just great and uh so I really agree with everyone else I really would love to see the seniors come back as much as possible certain days or whatever we can

220work out um knowing that hopefully everyone will stay healthy and doesn't have to get quarantined and miss some of these events that you know they' been worked on so hard but so diligently but uh yeah I'm really hardened by that and I hope that uh we can make that happen one more thing just crossed my mind um I'm just thinking out loud Dr Rogers um would it be possible to give an option for fully vaccinated seniors to come back full-time or is it does it complicate things um because I think a lot of I mean there are still students that are perfectly content um continuing virtually continuing finishing the year um there are students that are content with a hybrid model and then there are the ones that look around you know in the neighboring

221districts and that are you know all back and I I believe correct me if I'm wrong we're the only high school that is still hybrid is that true around around us no okay so anyway many right so I think would would that be an option a viable option for you know or or is it to you know complicated then um I'm looking at Mr gross because um that is a question that I would end up having to have them research for us uh right now we're not permitted to ask a student vaccination status and I don't think that we would be permitted and I would let him correct me if I'm wrong to offer an educational opportunity to one class of student and deny it to another class of student um and distinguishing those classes

222of student by vaccination status would probably get us in trouble and John if I'm on the right track here state of New York has preempted vaccination so you're without power to require vaccination that's controlled solely by the state of New York that's really the absence of authority to do that I think her question was uh even if someone had voluntarily become vaccinated would we be able to offer them a different amount of time in the building as somebody who was not fully vaccinated for example but acceptance of that voluntary act I think still would fall under the preemption issue but there's a Doctrine in the education law of light Services right can't give one group of youngsters a like Services particularly where you have no authority to make the decision based on the distinction Nam

223vaccination so for the benefit of people uh watching the stream what Mr gross said is that there two doctrines one of preemption which is the state controls things like vaccination not the school district and the second is that we have to provide like services to like students and we would not be able to distinguish between two like students and offer them different Services particularly in the case of something that is preempted by the state that we can't control like for example vaccination okay uh thank you we will now begin a items A1 is the approval of appointments transfers resignations and retirements for certified and Civil Service staff may I have a motion Please Mr Gerson seconded by Mr Feldman are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions A2 is the approval of coaching

224recommendations for spring 2021 may have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions A3 is the approval of student Club Charters 2020 2021 may I have a motion Please Mr felin Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions A4 is the appointment of an assistant summer school principal may have a motion Please Mr Rolo second of by Miss Chang are there any questions all in favor oppose any extenstions a five is the approval of a memorandum of agreement with the ca may have a motion please miss Chang seconded by Mr Feldman are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions B1 is the approval of recommendations from the Committees of special education may I have a motion Please Mr

225Rolo seconded by Mr Gerson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B2 is the approval of recommendations from the Committees of preschool special education may have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B3 is the first reading of policies naming of facilities and gender neutral bathrooms may have a motion please miss Chang second by Mr Rolo are there any questions okay these will be voted on at the June 14th 2021 board meeting the proposed policies will be posted on the district website before as the authorization of the nsb's proposed 2021-22 budget slate of officers and members of the executive committee may have a motion Please Mr Rulo second to by Mr Felman are there any questions all in favor opposed

226any extensions C1 is the authorization of service contracts may have a motion Please Mr Felman seconded by Mr Gerson are there any questions all in favor oppos any extensions C2 is the authorization of special education and nursing contracts may have a motion Please Mr Rolo and Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C3 is the award of bids may have a motion please Mr Feldman seconded by Miss Levan are there any questions all in favor oppose any extensions C4 is the authorization to enter into agreements for Builders risk and installation Insurance may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Mr gersan are there any questions Mr R Dr rall yes Builder Risk insurance um is a special insurance for when you're doing construction projects certain construction projects so

227Mr Hamilton and I meet with nicer and we go through the projects that we're going to do for the summer to see what projects might lend themselves to to more having a little more um Insurance uh one that we're looking particularly is doing some of the second floor um HVAC projects which might involve heavy machinery lifting things to the second floor so so there was some so we wanted to understand that Pro the construction process a little more and to review it with them so that those are the types of projects that might cause us to purchase a little more insurance so those project is it fair to say that a higher risk normal potentially or a unique risk like a heavy machinery something like that so I think yes to your point a a

228different risk thank you are there any other questions all in favor opposed any extensions C5 is the authorization to participate in a joint Municipal Cooperative bidding program I have a motion please miss Chang seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor oppos any extensions C6 is the authorization for change order for JP daily and Suns Inc may I have a motion Please Mr Feldman seconded by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C7 and 8 can be taken together they're the award of contracts for electrical construction may have a motion please miss Chang seconded by Mr gersan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C9 is the authorization for deduct change order go1 laser Industries Inc may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo

229Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C10 is the award of of contract for H17 HB construction may I have a motion Please Mr Feldman second to by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C1 is the acceptance of a donation may have a motion please miss falkov seconded by Mr Rolo are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C12 is the disposal of broken Surplus and or obsolete equipment and books may I have a motion Please Mr Rolo seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C13 is the award of contract for h16 a HB construction may have a motion Please Mr Rulo second of I miss Chang are there any questions all in favor opposed

230any extensions thank you very much to everyone who stayed motion to adjourn for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.