CorpusRecord 136515

Board of Education Meeting - August 28, 2023

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Syosset Central School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,442 words · about 70 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right so good evening thank you for coming to the August Board of Education meeting hope you all had a wonderful summer our Administration and staff have been busy preparing for the new school year we look forward to welcoming all students on the first day of school next week and with that um can everyone please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance okay I pledge allegiance to the flag of United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you okay and the first item on the agenda is the approval of the minutes of meeting July 6 2023 and July 25th 2023 may I have a motion please uh Miss Eon seconded by Mr Roto are there any questions

002all in favor opposed any extensions Dr rufel may we have the treasures report and appropriation adjustments thank you um the cash on hand for the month in June 2023 was 77 m771 17816 all Bank balances for all cash accounts were reconciled to the book balances and were collateralized in accordance with with the district's banking agreements and investment policy thank you thank you Dr Ruel may I have a motion to accept the treasures report Miss Val seconded by Mr GLE are there any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions okay Dr Dr Rogers please give us the uh superintendent report thank you uh thank you very much um I'll offer everybody a welcome back to uh what I hope will be a wonderful new school year uh starting tomorrow for our staff and starting next week

003for our young people uh we had the opportunity this morning to welcome the Freshman to the high school and sixth graders here to Southwoods I got to greet a lot of the students as they were coming back on campus and they were so excited our seniors were here to pick up their parking passes and to uh s uh sign the senior sign that is done every year and the excitement of the school year beginning has uh is upon us so I hope everyone had a wonderful summer uh and got a chance to rest and recharge uh because I'm sure we're going to have an exciting school year ahead so just some notes about the school year ahead and then we're going to dive into um a deeper conversation about facilities that the board has been

004engaged in for some time now uh just something has already gone out to parents but I want to uh just alert everyone that uh we will be moving to what a lot of school districts do a Six-Day rotation at the elementary school and this has a number of benefits uh not the least of which is um as we know whenever there are federal holidays they inevitably fall on Mondays and so that means that uh if you don't do a rotation whatever class falls on Monday uh often takes the brunt of all the closures but it will also give us a better structured time for uh specials it will give us more time for uh interventions with students uh therapies that they may need uh schoolwide enrichment that they'll be able to take advantage of it

005actually frees up more time for English language learning uh not just for uh English language learners but also for any student all students who are studying uh the English language and it also gives us a little bit more efficiency in Staffing particularly as uh some of our staff are shared between the elementary schools and some of the middle schools uh having them on a similar rotation makes it a lot easier to do the scheduling and planning and I no longer on uh thank you uh as we've uh gone to having a full-time social worker in every building this will also free up time uh for us to have the social workers uh do some intentional work with our young people so uh that's something to anticipate we'll make sure that the websites reflect what day

006of the rotation the buildings are on and I'm sure it's a transition uh that will uh become accustomed to soon enough uh just want to follow up something that uh the board discussed at the last meeting uh we wrote a letter to the town of Oyster Bay uh expressing some concerns uh about the and traffic implications of planned uh truck development on ad Jericho Turnpike uh the town did uh meet just a week or two ago and decided not to approve the application that was in place so uh we're encouraged that the Town took some of our feedback into consideration as they made that decision and we appreciate that one other thing as we go into the start of the school year the state gave all school districts flexibility to adjust the length of school

007days uh the low State minimums in order to deal with the pandemic we did that here in saset we shortened the high school day uh by one minute a period a total of 9ine minutes in the day um because that uh enabled us to have the traffic flow a little better between Southwoods middle school and the high school dismissals but uh that flexibility has ended along hopefully with the pandemic and so uh we'll be returning to our prepandemic schedule and I do anticipate that um although we were able to do this smoothly prior to the pandemic we all recognize that traffic patterns have shifted since and so I do think that the first several weeks of this new schedule is going to be a week in a work in progress and uh so I ask

008for uh the patients of our staff and families as uh we make this transition and hopefully uh find ways to do it as smoothly as possible um one of the initiatives that was led by our students uh last year was to develop kosher Halal and vegan meals and we created a pilot program at the high school to try and make those options available to students it was great to see students taking the lead and it was uh fun for us as administrators to try and make that possible for them what we did notice however though is as the school year wore on the uh utilization of those options dropped off uh precipitously and by the end of the year uh students were taking advantage of them at all so we're going to re-engage with our

009students at the beginning of the year and ask if uh maybe we need to find more appealing options or if there is some way that we can deliver that that meets their dietary needs but is also uh scalable for our food service folks so we'll be meeting with students early in the year and also aware that there are a number of parents of younger kids who are not yet in the high school who are also interested in expanding options uh in the other buildings in the district and so we'll be seeking to meet uh with parents who have other dietary uh needs or restrictions to see if it is possible for the Food Service uh provider that we use uh to service them and uh just a note for the board uh this is a

010year when we're going we are planning to uh rebid we periodically rebid the Food Services uh contract and so this will will be the feedback that we get from both the kids and parents will be helpful as we develop the proposal for that contract for the coming year uh so that we can serve the needs of the families here in this community uh also a followup from previous board meetings in the spring we had been talking about uh a state requirement for us to offer what's called transitional bilingual education because we have a large population of Mandarin speaking uh young people in first and second grade um there was not a lot of uh interest among the parents in having a separate setting for those students to learn and as a result we did not

011have enough interest to be able to uh keep the program so we notified the state uh that we would not have the program but we are putting in place instead uh other options to support the young people's Heritage language so that the the Heritage language is not extinguished as they learn English here and uh will meet the needs but just in a different way I understand that earlier this week there was a uh a glitch with the provider that maintains our student management system and that uh briefly some rosters were visible on the system before we caught the the glitch and while it I know it would be appealing for folks to learn what the class rosters are going to be sooner rather than a little bit later in the week I just asked the

012Public's patience and Indulgence uh we actually don't set final rosters until noon on Wednesday and uh we are literally uh watching registrations coming in we have class size maximums that we try to stay below and uh we wait until the last possible second to make those decisions so if we were to release rosters earlier they might be out of date by Wednesday and I wouldn't want to mislead any family or parent uh as to who their teacher is going to be and only to change it two days later so uh there are some draft rosters in there you should consider them to be draft but whatever we do on Wednesday will of course be final and then uh just some updates for the board on the summer facilities work uh one of the things that

013we've been working hard at is doing some ventilation upgrades for the pool facility that project is on the one yard line uh you see all the equipment is in place and it's just uh waiting assembly uh we had uh done a lot of work on the old tennis courts several years ago we resurfaced them to try and extend their life by just a couple more years uh but the challenges with those courts became such that there was no resurfacing them any longer so we've completely refurbished them and uh they were out there today uh striping and putting up the Nets and I anticipate we'll be on those shortly uh I also did a quick tour of the Southwoods Library here in this building today that was refurbished over the course of the last year by

014The District staff who did just a remarkable job and I know uh the students and staff here at Southwoods are excited to be in that space and in each of the Middle School gyms uh we removed the hard folding uh partitions that are motorized and replace those with curtains uh obviously the motorized partition uh partitions have the potential to be dangerous and so uh we have eliminated them in both schools and have a much safer curtain option uh so with that uh Mr Joffrey if you could just turn the presentation on thank you great thank you so much so at the last board meeting it was asked a question about the pros and cons of having two high schools so uh we did meet as an administrative team and uh sort through some of the

015research behind small schools uh and looked closely at our own academic program and we tried to uh bundle our thoughts into some categories but uh you know clearly the thing we care about most is academics and uh we also care about our Athletics programs the activities that students have and the cost of uh anything any initiative that we would do on the academics uh you can certainly find some research uh that illustrates that there are some benefits to having smaller schools um New York City notably did a lot of work with small schools although uh The Gates Foundation after pouring a lot of money into the small schools initiative eventually abandoned it uh but uh there are certainly some uh research papers that show that graduation rates at least uh increased in New York City

016as the result of that even though in many instances those buildings were all collocated uh in the same building so it's multiple schools residing in the same site uh here in saset schools are not quite so big and uh we observed that there would likely be some disadvantages to uh having course offerings uh spread across two schools there would be a number of classes that would have to be duplicated in those schools so that would mean that an elective would have to go away in order to replicate a class in two buildings um we also worry that um if we were to push into two schools uh it would probably be difficult to have the same breadth of Academic Program same number of AP classes uh for students to take advantage of for example On

017Athletics um certainly one advantage would be that um more kids would likely participate uh although we noted from other school districts that have feeder programs from the Middle School that would look like what ours would be that those feeder programs tend to not feed the high school as well and so we would probably uh suffer from the same challenges but ultimately uh there would be smaller less competitive teams comprised of more athletes so there might be more opportunity but perhaps less success and uh because there are fewer middle school teams having more high school teams would mean more competitions and there for more Transportation costs um high school the high school boasts 62 clubs uh the wonderful thing about that is literally is something for everyone and uh the challenge would be if you had

018two high schools and you had a fixed amount of stipend that you were able to afford you'd either have to choose to have half the clubs or twice the stiens um right now we have a number of what are called competition clubs uh we think of these as uh our students going and competing in state and sometimes National competitions clearly you'd want to have those at both high schools so you'd have to duplicate those clubs and as with Athletics uh duding the talent in those clubs may impact their success uh with facilities we tried to imagine how we would accomplish this with the existing physical plant the district has and clearly uh reversing the positions of the two middle schools with the high school lend itself as uh the obvious uh first uh consideration so

019that challenge then would be the high school presently houses four classes of roughly 5 50 students uh if we were to reverse that and try to put those four classes into the two buildings that only house three classes worth of the districtwide student body uh there's not there's simply not enough space at the middle school so that would mean that you would have to either build a lot of space at what is currently a middle school or you'd have to think about keeping the 9th grade in a middle school building which is uh considered to be a pretty undesirable um configuration the other thing about the middle schools is they really don't have the facility space to operate what we would consider to be high school level programs uh certainly in Sciences there aren't any

020wet Labs so uh Varsity gyms uh the gyms in both middle schools are really too small for Varsity Sports so uh those would be considerations as well the upgrades that the facilities would have to go through um when we were asked this question uh the administration was cautioned to make sure that we were thinking outside of the box and not uh to just take the existing configuration for granted we certainly appreciate that admonition uh earlier this year uh we had done as administrative team a thought exercise around uh whether a Princeton plan might be a way to accommodate some of the anticipated growth uh that's going to be at the high school in the coming years uh for the uninitiated the Princeton plan is when you collect all the grade levels together in a single

021building often schools do this at the elementary school level where kindergarten and first grade would be in one building second and third grade would be in a different building Etc uh at the high school level we imagined that this would be configured as seventh and eth grade uh at hbt uh six I'm sorry sixth and seventh grade at hbt eth and nth grade at Southwoods because nth graders and eth graders participate often in Varsity Sports so having it located close to the existing high school would be helpful uh so the advantages would be that you wouldn't have to build as much space at the high school to accommodate the bubble but you would have to still build that space somewhere and that somewhere would in inevitably be uh at Southwoods middle school so you wouldn't

022have to build as much space as you would to flip uh the high school with both middle schools uh but you would still have to build some more space and you'd be investing that space in a building that uh served middle school as opposed to serving all of the uh high schoolers in the district so uh after a lot of discussion as an administrative team we didn't feel that the appeal and the advantages of uh a change in configuration outweighed our current configuration but we thought that the exercise was certainly worthwhile to make sure that we weren't uh locked in our own thinking uh by or constrained just by the existing facilities that we had um we also have with us tonight uh h2m our architecture and engineering firm and we also have Elite construction

023managers who have been managing uh the summer work that the district is going through they have been working together as a team with us the administration on uh larger task that we were given by the board at the June board meeting where the board asked us to take the visual inspection report that uh was prepared by h2m and identify priorities within uh that report so certainly not all of the work is uh health and safety related not all of the work is of an immediate nature is it Poss I to stratify this work into uh more immediate priorities and less immediate priorities so that the district doesn't have to take on uh quite as much work and quite as much expense uh in the short term so uh this is the slide that set that

024conversation up these are the enrollment projections that we continue to look at uh at that meeting two months ago we talked about uh the first two columns worth of space and we said we would come back to the last two columns worth of space and that's the conversation for this evening and then um we laid out the overall amount of work that needed to be done so in the visual inspection report prioritization we came up with five criteria the AR Architects came up with five criteria for evaluating whether something would be more near-term or more long-term and clearly improving safety is a near-term uh interest of the district uh second would be preserving the infrastru structure so if there's a um an improvement that needs to be made so that something doesn't deteriorate further and

025become more costly to repair in the future that would be something that we would take on there are some places where modernization is uh not necessary and could be delayed uh but there's some places where modernization is necessary because we need to be compliant with the Americans with Disabilities uh act so uh we stratified those two things and we certainly identified a number of Building Systems that are nearing the end of their useful life and uh what has been impressed upon me is the lead time for um some of the equipment that would be needed to replace that would be needed in order to replace some of these Building Systems is extraordinarily long so it may be over a year from the time we would order a piece of equipment till when that piece of

026equipment would arrive here so uh to the extent that we have have some systems that are critical to building function as they're ending they're nearing the end of their life we shouldn't wait for the the piece to fail because we'll be delayed a year before we'd be able to fix it so these are things that we should anticipate and replace while they're still functioning well uh even if they have a year or two left on their life because not having them might be catastrophic so having gone through that exercise and I'll go into just a little bit more detail in a minute uh we identified about $49 Million worth of immediate priorities that we would anticipate recommending be in the district's next bond issue uh we think that there's about $23 Million worth of work

027overall that we can continue to chip away at in the district's annual budget as we have been doing for the past nine years and uh together that would get us to uh the 88 million doll in work that was identified uh in the visual uh inspection uh this slide shows how that 49 million would break down by school and this slide shows how the work that we would do internally through the District budget would break down by school and I would note that uh there are several projects that are currently underway um that uh are already in the current Year's budget that were also identified in the visual inspection some uh pointing work here at Southwoods middle school and some chimney work uh at Village Elementary School so uh one of the things that we

028talked about at previous meetings is the uh Portables that exist on many of our campuses are well past their uh period of probable usefulness and their uh uh anticipated lifespan so uh we need to anticipate how to replace them uh that replacement will be easier to do at some campuses than others uh just because of the Topography of the the campus and how it's laid out out and uh we are also anticipating again uh enrollment growth and wanting to keep our program the excellent educational program that we have here uh as close to state-of-the-art as we can so we've talked in the past about a number of projects that might lend themselves to that work um so at the high school to accommodate the enrollment bubble that we're anticipating could be uh 10 12 maybe

029even more % additional gym space and we've been looking at uh fabric air supported and uh other Fabrics uh supported fabric structures because they're less expensive than uh building um something like a Fieldhouse we've been looking at options for additional classroom space um two options of similar cost uh but one would uh result in building an additional Library space and uh converting the existing Library space into a number of classrooms uh to me that feels like a more bang for your buck kind of a way to approach it uh the High School auditorium is in need of uh some upgrades and repair the pool is also in has been wellmaintained but is in need of uh some repair uh some point and then uh just anticipating um some of the busing challenges that we may

030experience this fall uh we have some ideas for how we can use the campus to dismiss more efficiently uh and that may become something that becomes a higher priority as uh we uh get into the fall and we see what uh the new traffic patterns are like at the middle schools um the biggest need for enrollment growth is going to be here at Southwoods uh and we anticipated that if uh we vacated the administrative offices here and converted them to classroom space that might cost about a million dollars but it would net us seven and a half classroom spaces seven full size fullsize classrooms and one other space uh at hbt we're probably uh close to our maximum uh pupil growth so I don't anticipate more growth at hbt but one thing we've observed is

031that students at hbt don't have access to the same athletic facilities uh that students at Southwoods have because of their proximity here to the high school uh at the elementary schools uh clearly Walt Whitman and Barry Hill are two buildings that are very tight now uh We've priced earlier in a previous meeting what it would cost to replace the Portables in kind At waltt Whitman uh but we've also talked about a more extensive Rehabilitation uh that would um prepare the uh campus to house any additional growth because there are some properties in the area that have the potential for future growth at Barry Hill uh that's a campus that presents some architectural and Engineering challenges uh it don't have any good numbers for you the board yet uh because uh we are still trying to

032come up with a plan that we think is um feasible without being extraordinarily expensive and uh something that the board asked us to research previously what would the cost be of uh developing Elementary kitchens uh in every one of the elementary schools and obviously depending on how extensive the renovations are to Whitman that uh would be something that wouldn't have to be uh taken care of through that project so I don't mean with any of these to say that the any of these are foregone conclusions this is uh research that was necessary to answer several of the board's questions from previous meetings about what some ideas would be for um approaching the growth that we've had so and the growth we anticipate so uh I do have the Architects and engineers and our construction managers

033uh on hand so that they can answer more detailed questions so I'm sure the board will have questions about how we prioritize the work what kinds of um things would be done what the lead times are for uh construction Etc and myself and the staff are all here at your disposal thank you Dr Rogers for that thorough presentation um are there any questions from the board for Dr Rogers or the construction management Mr asri more of just an observation um for process standpoint do you want to divide up instead of opening the entire presentation up to questions do you want to go Section by section and maybe close sections or do you just want to open it to all comments at once I think we can just open to all you know this way someone

034can just tag along if you have additional questions thank you Mr dri sure so um I guess we could start in the facilities area um I guess the first question that I have regarding the buckets of well okay let me make a statement first from my point of view the visual inspection report um details in terms of tranching it between um current highest priority first of all thank you guys I imagine that was a significant amount of work to um to create that tranching it seems like and I don't know I don't want to pull the board but it seems like there's not much left to discuss with the visual inspection report in the sense that this is work that's being recommended that needs to get done um I mean maybe there are thoughts comments

035opinions about it but from my point of view I feel like that part of the discussion is closed and that we ought to be focusing on the next sort of stages of the construction facilities but budget I I sort of I'm that was part of what I how I wanted to tear the discussion all right so we had a uh we had a meeting uh back in July and we we spoke about that and the construction management they were here too uh but if anyone else on the board you know still has questions about that they could ask to if not you could ask additional questions on this next part so I I did have some questions about sort of the the the next sort of buckets in terms of timing um of when things

036may or may not need to happen either simultaneously or one before the other so if I'm thinking about the the saset high school element right that's the furthest part down in the future where we contemplate it I don't know seven or eight years in future is that approximately the idea okay so those are probably the projects that can be deferred for consideration for three or four years assuming it's a fouryear cycle is a relatively good estimate for the things we need to do unless and this is where the question comes in are there things that need to be done sequentially or cannot be done at the same time or things that need to be done before other things in order for the program growth at the high school to happen so obviously the busing element

037in the back of school can happen any time um the Robotics and the guideance suite that switch I'm wondering if there has to be an order or if doing one project before another stops us from doing a second in other words how much of this can we defer out into the future and how much needs to be done sequentially beforehand I think it's an insightful question question um the one reason for breaking out the two different approaches to building classrooms is uh because you might want not to build them both simultaneously but to build five classrooms see if the growth is on the trajectory that was projected if it is then you know you will need the other five classrooms and you might start that project second but if you build the five classrooms and

038the growth trajectory doesn't go there or there is some other kind of societal um shift like we experienced the last two years that makes all of our enrollment projections outdated all of a sudden because of some economic change uh then we won't have committed to quite so much construction um the we won't have the luxury of too much delay just because of the tremendous amounts of lead time that are built into the process says we of course have to have a public vote but then after that public vote anticipate 40 weeks uh of waiting for approval at the state and the state can't even look at the drawings until they're made and that will often take about 6 months for The Architects to do the actual drawings for uh the projects that we propose so

039it may be a year and a half before we might have approval to start construction and then that construction will be subject to the bidding process finding a summer to start because generally we start in the Summers and um if there are any long lead time items in that project such as like HVAC equipment has really long lead time uh electrical equipment like switch gear has a really long lead time so um that might delay it as well so even though the peak is likely to be 8 years out uh will be halfway to the peak in four years so so I think we'll have to start at least one project for accommodating that growth sooner rather than later so that we'll be somewhere near that and then we'll have the opportunity in a year

040or two to decide whether the trajectory argues for accommodating even more growth and maybe I'll I'll pause myself there in a second and see if uh Megan or Kevin you want to um jump in on that at all as well to amplify what I said will it automatically work hi um I would agree with your statement Dr Rogers that with the lead times and the lead time to submit to the state and do the drawings um it doesn't give you as much time as you feel that you have for the 8-year bubble that is um [Music] predicted working backwards four years isn't a good estimate of the amount of time we need is it six years I'm I'm trying to get a sense of do we have to start tomorrow the sooner there's always better

041I would say um you want to start within four to six years prior to when you need it and uh just because we've seen so much price escalation in the construction Market recently uh the other advantage to to starting sooner is that we experience less uh inflationary escalation by getting started sooner Mr greo um so I have a couple of have a lot of things I'll try to keep them short so in the order of your presentation I agree with your analysis and conclusions with respect to the school configuration and you know I should commend Mr ostri and yourself for thinking outside the box because I love hearing ideas even when they're they're they're tossed away um one of the things I I note from from the information and I've been stewing on it for

042a while is we talk about the Southwoods administrative wing and the cost to convert that to classroom space and I do that as just like onethird of a triangle right you have that as a potential option you have renting space somewhere locally uh for the administration as an option which of course would go along with the first and then you have a third option which is finding our own space I hate to throw out the Woodburry school is an option U but in your presentation you talk about the cost of refurbish the schools so I view the three of them in their own little Universe when we talk about how to add classroom space to Southwoods and and I think the missing component in the spreadsheet is a feel for what rental costs are for

043the room we'd need um and I wonder what that is I I'll I'll pause there sure um Dr rufo has been looking at rental space um actually quite a bit over the course of the last several years when we needed to spread out as a result of the pandemic uh we looked at rental space so that we could spread um administrators out a little bit and have less congestion no pun intended among our administrators so um I think she has a pretty good feel for that market Dr rufo could you answer Mr Greco's question we did act oops we did um research and visit um several locations actually within the boundaries of the district um both both um once pre pandemic and once at the end and prices um and we thought we'd uh see

044some uh decreases more decreases um in commercial property um than we we actually did see um my I I hate to quote it but I thought were you looking for a specific number of how much we we thought my recollection and again I think it was the facilities area and that I'm sorry facilities and Technology um and I think it was 11 I think it was close to 80,000 a year but I would really have to um put a big caveat around that to to look again let me rephrase what I'm asking for so we know what it would cost right now if we wanted to um convert the admin space at Southwoods right a million dollars but of course the we need off office space so that number is you know not as helpful

045in a vacuum and I'm just wondering if that number with the rental with the idea that we may actually own space right now that could be refurbished or rehabed and used for office space should all be discussed together um and that's really all so this isn't let's put Dr ruo on the spot right now for the current rental pricing but uh that that's really where I wanted to go with that I didn't want to you know push I just think we need the three together right so perhaps I could uh I agree that those three shouldn't be considered in isolation because if you're going to use that as classrooms there they're clearly offices that will be displaced and uh maybe the the way to analyze that would be to ask the question what's the mortgage

046payment that $80,000 a year you would be paying to rent office base would pay for in other words how much refurbishment would you get if you plowed that into one of your own buildings instead of plowing it into a rental payment so we can certainly do that work and I know Dr rufo would rather sharpen her pencil than give me any more estimates of uh rental costs in this meeting uh but uh we can certainly come back to you um at the next meeting that I don't think will be a challenging uh effort for us to do and we can put that together and then you'll be able to balance out uh the cost of renting versus the cost of refurbishing uh a facility that you already own right and just for order of magnitude

047what's the square footage we're talking about in office space just like that the Woodbury schools would be accommodating relative to the amount of rent all so I know the Woodbury school is about 14,000 square fet is that right Megan I don't have that number off the top of my head right now but I could get that I I feel pretty confident with that number I'm probably ballpark with 14,000 so and Dr rupo do you have any idea how much square footage is I don't I I don't recall I don't you mean when we looked for it when we where's my where's my pal Greg what does he remember I don't remember I think we'll have to get back to you on that I think to just uh get to your question Jack when I do

048uh order a magnitude a classroom is anywhere between 700 and 1,000 square ft and we would get back 7 and a half classrooms if we did the whole Wing so let's say that's anywhere between 5,000 and 7,000 square ft of space in that building is about 14,000 ft of space not all of it great space um because some of it's in in the tower and the tower is not handicapped accessible and an elevator would be half a million dollars at least to to access a couple hundred square feet to me that's a waste uh so I think to pursue this we should come back to you with uh here's what we think is Ada accessible space in that building how many square feet that is and here's what we're currently using uh at Southwoods and

049then we'll we'll do a little bit more market analysis on the Run Market it's freeing up square footage and other locations and combining offices from Administration from across district and I'm just trying to put the the total in my head um I just wanted to Circle back to um the percentage that we get back from the state when we do projects so just a couple questions I think it was was it 42% that we get back um so of the of the projects that are suggested here for the visual inspection so that 88 million like and the other the other things the future and the growth and all that you may not know off hand but how much of that will qualify for us to get back the 42% from that is it all of

050it is it half of it you know I don't know if you know off hands uh I don't know off hand but um Miss Bato I know can tell you the process by which uh the state department decides what spaces are aable the the term is aable and what spaces are not aidable and even though we can't say with Precision what that number is going to be we can talk to you generally about how the process works so Megan when we're looking to package the drawings um there's certain things like site work which is not aidable um you look to package those projects with other things that are aable so say at hbt the vestibule and the site work combining those together to get um Aid on that site work where if you did it

051by itself you wouldn't technically get Aid on that um so depending on how you package those drawings and what the scope of work is that will predict your not project or project your Aid amount based on um that is there any way to give a ballpark of if assuming that you guys you know have an expertise in packaging it the right way because that would obviously be something we want to do as packages to get the most back that we could um is there any kind of ballpark figure for it or to H ail I think Dr rufa would have to answer that question I think the determination um of of Aid is is even um Megan mentioned one factor which is um uh how something if something qualifies for Aid based on it being

052site work or not site work additionally there are other measures that state aid planning will do to DET determine how much Aid you will get for example um they will look at the building Aid units um just for example if you just wanted to build additional science classrooms not that they didn't make a determination that they thought based on their numbers that were needed not and I'm not saying this because I think that that's what we're talking about here but there are other factors that they look at that makes it a little bit difficult just broadly to determine how much Aid you would you would get um many uh sometimes I think on when we did phase two we made a rough estimate of maybe 75 to 80% when we were first starting out and

053then revised that so we'd have to look a little bit more at the the packaging of the the projects additionally we also have to look at the aid and the packaging of the projects um sort of um more longer term because we may have a plan which um we had in phase two of projects that we wanted to package together but then you may um not have the same level of approval of projects from the state that you anticipated so that also factors into um the predictability of Aid so I I can only speak for myself but I know when I look at this just from a financial standpoint it could make a difference whether or not we can do more projects and you know how we package it so if there is any way

054to say like you know it kind of feels like you know if if you spend $ you get $20 back you know and so it doesn't make sense to not spend the if you're at 65 to spend the 70 because then you you're really only spending 50 yep oh so I just at least for me it would be helpful to kind of get an idea of and also for timing wise I guess if we package it certain ways but we're going to get back 42% of it then it might make sense to do the timing in certain ways to Max maximize what we get back from the state um and then I just want so this I have one more question on that but what you said kind of answers me so I I we

055would I guess lay out we'd have to get funding for the whole project and then we would get back what we would get back because you can't count on correct what it is okay and uh just so the board understands how that works once we do some borrowing to finance this construction we would do the entire borrowing and then the state reimburses Us by essentially paying part of the mortgage with us so the state also wants to mortgage these costs and not pay them in the present so the way they do that is by uh basically piggybacking on our mortgage and they have what are called assumed amortization rates so even if we were to pay it off in a shorter period of time than 20 years the state will reimburse us at as though

056it was financed over a 20-year period because that's their preferred period to pay things back so um and I don't mean to be so in the weeds but because you're asking about how this works I thought you might find it useful to understand that it's uh the state won't give us that reimbursement upfront they will defray that cost over time as we pay the project uh financing back um I oh sorry um I just think at least for me it would be super helpful just because I think if we can maximize that you know it's it's obviously an extraordinarily large project and we have so much we want to do so if there's way to you know maximize what we get back and even with the state ways to know that if that money is

057coming if it's amateurz over the 20 years to play with that payment because then you could use that over the next 20 years say okay we're getting back $10 a year from the state so we could put the $10 towards one of the you know just to maximize it so that less money is coming from us and more money is coming from the state the advantage that we have is um this is the highest our Aid ratio has ever been 42% when I got here uh 9 years and two months ago our Aid ratio was 16% so the last round of work that we did was reimbursed at a much lower level by the state will be reimbursed at a much higher level and believe me everyone working on this team knows that our job

058is to maximize reimbursement from the state uh from this graph if it takes 4 to6 years for the construction to be done by the time we're done with Elementary School does it seem like we don't even need it anymore that's number first question and second is for the elite team um the high school auxiliary gym and the prefab um buildings for the elementary schools what would be the energy cost difference compared to a regular brick structure and um we got three different choices for the auxiliary gym is one better than another in terms of the energy cost and one more for lead team is in Walt Whitman estimate do we have the preed estimate in here or is that not included in this estimate given so while the team confers on your second question I'll

059answer the first um so when we talked about this uh the last time I pointed out that uh the current trajectory shows our two tightest schools Bary Hill and Walt Whitman level in off but not dropping and they're leveling off at a pretty tight level uh so the the next question becomes in the current market it does not seem like the Sagamore property 70 town houses or so of recent construction is generating a lot of students but that doesn't mean it will never generate a lot of students so to me that looks like 70 residential units that have the potential uh to uh have some uh to generate some students and there have been several other projects um on picket Lane and on Jericho Turnpike that have been rumored to turn into um multiple dwelling

060unit housing developments they haven't come to fruition but it certainly occurs to me that those properties remain uh potential uh development targets and so I think if we were in the process of building space we don't want to build too much space and the state won't Aid us that's Dr ruo's point about building units the state won't pay us to overbuild but we wouldn't want to go through a construction process and not uh build to anticipate that there is a potential for um more student generation from some of these large tracks of land that have been rumored to be developed at one point or another so I don't think you would be unwise to try and build in some extra space uh because it gives you space never goes to waste uh but it does

061give you flexibility if the if there is continued growth in the district and uh Mike if you could talk to us a little bit about the different kinds of fabric structures and their relative uh energy efficiencies yes sir good evening so one of the things that we were you were talking about as far as one of the things that we looked at is with the high school construction each of those different facilities that we were examining they could be insulated to different levels it all depends on what is being provided so all them could be insulated to a certain degree as desired and that would be something that would be worked along with h2m to come up with those specifications and all as far as requirements of what we're looking at as far as our

062installation of those facilities second thing is we were talking about as far as prefabrication U one of the things that we did as far as with Walt women we looked at that as far as being new construction versus prefabrication you're able to have your pre-fabricated facilities designed to certain levels also so they have that level of flexibility that you're able to do with the curtain walls and things that nature at the fabrication facilities and that just has to be something that's designed and taken consideration and working along with h2m on that regards um and I think that was that was two of the questions was there a third one ma'am so the estimate that we received it does not include a free free free uh prefab building the estimate that we worked on as far

063as what women did not include a prefab that was for new construction but it does have classroom additions yes so the estimate includes building new classrooms just U Mike is saying that the estimate was done as though it was new construction as opposed to uh that R abson please sorry Dr Rogers just a follow up on what you said about the elementary schools and building and new communities coming um while I totally understand that we do need to expand and easier to do things and make room now and anticipate if it came to fruition that new communities were built on those areas do they necessarily get zoned to womman or whatever can they be can we look for I mean if we have schools that are trending downward can we Zone new construction appropriately so

064that we don't have to overbuild what we have absolutely so the the elementary zones are completely within the discretion of the school board and I think in in the event that something would happen uh you might consider uh approaching the zoning in multiple ways so there is a neighborhood in the district that I think was built about 15 years ago and the school board at the time was concerned about having all of the residents of that neighborhood go to a single School District so that particular neighborhood uh feeds several different elementary schools so um it has been done before it's been done by us uh so you have that option at any time the only challenge with um trying to uh meet that need at a certain point in time is that I've observed that

065the the buildings are they tend to be cyclical so they're all elementary kids for some reason there's a surge but then they all become middle school kids together the house doesn't sell but suddenly the elementary population there drops but once those kids are out of high school there's another Elementary surge again and because changing Elementary zones is so disruptive I I don't think it's an ideal strategy to sort of Chase the bubble by changing zones I think you'd want to anticipate maybe do that once where you would rezone to try and rebalance and then uh we would do what we did now which is enrollment projections to try and make sure that we got it right the first time wait no I didn't mean reone what we have because that scares people and that's not

066at all what I meant so I don't want to scare anybody that I meant if if land was bought like Sagamore and new housing was created instead of like this like Sagamore is At Whitman and we already feel that Whitman is at the seams and when if we are building but we see that other schools are not at the seams if there's a new community that comes in it doesn't necessarily have to be zoned to to Whitman or that was more my question if it's a brand new unzoned new thing not not people in there current because I'm I'm scared of getting that out there so I just wanted to clarify and I understood your question I was just too expansive in my answer I apologize any more questions Mr asri sure so on the

067topic of elementary school expansion I think we have a real opportunity here to think strategically over the next 5 10 20 years I mean the elementary schools have not been meaningly expanded renovated improved to some limited degree yes but to a large degree it's been decades and decades and decades and if we were more thoughtful about thinking in fiveyear or seven-year increments and going through all the schools uh two or three at a time or four at a time so that we get to 10 over a 15 or a 20 year increment in my mind the elementary schools all of them are due a significant series of changes whether they're gyms or cafeterias or improving uh and increasing some of the classroom space there are probably of the seven elementary schools I sent around the

068projections um to all of you in terms of uh the you know the number of students per square foot there are four of um at least over the next 5 to seven years that probably are bumping up against um what what would be considered tight constraints so if Barry Hill and Whitman are the two that are most at um odds you know bis was there three or four years ago I almost wish we the board at that time had this conversation and thought to themselves about whether or not we should be taking the opportunity to expand those facilities um to accommodate uh so that we don't have OT and on stages or in the hallway or art on a card and things like that there's no reason why we shouldn't be thinking in 15 or

06920 or increments for all of the elementary schools it just so happens that these are two that are at the most risk currently but 5 years from now it could easily be bis or South Grove or Robins lane or AP Willets because the number of addresses are distributed relatively equally across the district and where people choose to move and relocate is not something that's subject to easy projection to me this the opportunity here is for us to think in terms of five to sevene increments for all the buildings just happens that Whitman and and and Barry Hill are are the ones in the current difficulties I mean correct me if I'm wrong we're thinking of building four classrooms not 20 At Whitman all right thank you um Miss fov um I know I'm kind of

070jumping the gun a little bit but um in terms of funding for the project is there a way for us to get a broad like General I know we obviously don't know how much we're funding because we haven't decided what we're doing or not doing yet but just to say if you fund you know $10 million then this costs this much to the district and this much to the Community you know just so we kind of have an idea of um the you know the impact that it makes to kind of give us like help us figure out where our budget is and how much we how much we think we can feasibly ask for and spend yeah I would take that as a homework assignment rather than do it off the top of my

071head but for sure yeah I you're great but I didn't think that was coming off the top of anyone's head Mr Mr greo a quick question this I guess Miss falkov gave me this idea but I wonder if maybe in the future not right now and please don't ask Dr rufo if we should be putting together some kind of priorities list now because if we're going to push this out as a you know one large project should we have a priority B priority C priority lined up now like say you know hpts vestibule uh priority a right um you know maybe the library is priority B and maybe the pool is priority C so we could see it all that way and sort of decide maybe we only want to go forward with A and

072B now A and B having more of the space constraint issues um I mean you put them in buckets in a way that I think are it's doing that already but it's not giving me the ability to sort of say let's just go forward with a& B total of 60 million and leave that other 28 million for down the road or just to because fund you know funding go like you know rolls off and comes back on so if you take money and then it ends you could continue it on so just to I feel like if we have a 10-year plan to say okay we're doing a first B first but it's just rolling so it spread over the amount of time as opposed to you know getting the money all in one jump

073that way it could just keep going with the priority list if that makes sense I just I I feel like we should be really cognizant of not going back over and over to the community to ask for money and again and again that we should you know make a plan so that we know where we're going for the next many years and what we want to do so we could figure out the financials of it so that we don't you know in five years we don't say oh okay so now we're going to do this so now we need you know we should try to streamline it so we have like a master plan as Jack always likes to say you know to look forward like to plan it out Miss Abramson I guess my

074was was related to what everybody was saying over there you I felt like it was broken out but I felt like there's a lot of in there's safety and and end of useful life items here and there was a bond that we were talking about um related to that group I was just I guess I was wondering like how do we start the Motions of things as Oppo as opposed to the discussions and also like there were items on there that are amazing and I would love to do them but what happens if we financially can't when they come up well in the end this is exactly the conversation that um we the administration need you as the board to have so that you can lead us because um we can present you with ideas

075we can present you with recommendations and your stewards of the community's finances and you're stewards of the this incredible asset that the community has uh built and uh some of this is um we we need some help calibrating with your judgment what your strategy is for the long term and how what sorts of time periods you want to approach this in and how you want to stratify the work over time and where your priorities are among the the various things that are some some are necessary and I know that a priority you all share the things that are necessary but you also have priorities of how the educational program is delivered both to make sure that there's Elbow Room in the building so that you don't feel constraints and to make sure that the program

076is top-notch because that's why people want to move here uh but at some point there are limits so uh we will'll present you with these good ideas we'll go back and beat the ideas up uh to make them less expensive or maybe um not quite as ambitious uh and you know bring them back to you and then at some point we're looking for you to give us some guidance as to how you'd like to move forward with the community and um and I feel like only you can do that so I just have two questions Dr Rogers one is what I I know we want to get the facilities everything started ASAP because there's years ahead of us so everybody's anxious to kind of get some kind of list so that we can go through

077and get the final numbers and then obviously it has to be addressed to the public and whatnot if we were to take a special vote for that instead of waiting until May if we were able to put all of this together in in a very short period of time if we could do it what would be the earliest would you say time that a vote could take place that's my first question like how soon do do you think we could take a vote or do you think it's not possible we'd have to wait till the may vote because it is extensive and we need that amount of time I think you could get a vote done before May uh the advantage as we did with phase two that vote um was I believe in February

078or early March um every month that we have makes it more likely that we get to use the next summer that is a year and a couple cple of months later but by the time you vote in May you've pretty much lost the next summer so then you're out two more years so that's the advantage of going sooner um so I still think that that is possible uh but uh we'll have to keep at it um in order to get there and just one more question regarding Woodberry school so there's two estimates of Woodberry school to demo it and Woodberry school to renovate it my question is we have to like Brian was saying before we have to start thinking together as far as Southwoods business office if we were to take those offices I

079would assume we wouldn't want to take a rental lawn forever since we have actual space in our district to utilize and when I say actual space I'm saying Woodberry school so for us I think one of the important things that we need to look at ASAP also is if we're going to renovate the school what are we getting out of it because at the top of here and I'm not sure if I'm reading this correctly but it says the square footage is 19,800 could that be right it could be there there's a tower room and then off the tower room there's some square footage that's in like a high ceiling to attic that could be refurbished there's a basement there that is not appealing um so what's in that number I'm not exactly sure I

080know that when we laid it out um back in 2018 we were thinking that there was about 14,000 ft of usable space that we might be able to convert to and for some reason that number stuck in my head so so my thought is if we're going to renovate it obviously it's a high number we have to see what we're gaining from it is it enough space for what we need okay but if we're looking to demo it because that building is sitting there and for every month that it's sitting there and every winter that it goes through as we know with our own houses it just keeps deteriorating and it gets worse and worse so if we're looking to demo the building then that becomes vacant land that we look to do what with

081then are we going to look to build a new facility are we going to look to do try to put like a pre Fab facility how much would that cost is that even feasible would we we be looking to build a new office space if that's what we need some kind of like maybe community space SL office space so I think that's something too that within all of these necessary which the number is very high but these are all necessary um improvements within the district that need to be done I think the Woodberry school or something that's really high priority as well in you know the next set of discussions with this yeah I since we've been talking about the Woodbury School we've always given the board these two estimates in parallel uh because you

082can look at the cost of rehabilitating it but it's really the net cost because one way or the other at some point it will deteriorate to the point of no return it's not there yet so then you'll have nothing no choice left but the demo cost so the cost of refurbishing the Space is really the difference between the demo cost and the other and the cost that's there is kind of a Soup To Nuts it includes an elevator um I think you could get a lot of square footage out of the building without an elevator and the additional square footage you'd get with an elevator probably doesn't justify its cost so I think that there is some value engineering that could be done uh in that site and yes it it's an asset of the

083district and it's an asset that um if we wanted to invest in we could preserve long longer and just a quick comment on that school too is that it is historical and it is a piece of saset the saset Woodbury community's history so to demo it if it gets to the point that it needs to be demoed you know to some degree it's it's kind of losing a part of the community's history so if if we could Salvage it and make it obviously it has to be useful and you know for us it would I I just feel like it would be um it's worthwhile to try to salvage it that's all anyone else with questions Mr asri yeah I mean I I think maybe we're it's time to move off questions and develop a

084process by which we can get the priority list of the board in front of the superintendent so how can we all stand up and say what the priority list is so that that they can actually get working and we can move the process forward what is the process for us to get the priority list in front of the superintendent as a board discussion so that it actually happens we do have the uh visual inspections uh from the engineers and then so to me that's the top priority because it involves the sa safety and safety is always the top priority for for the for the board and um so if the board can revolve around that discussion to look at the uh visual inspection report and then I talk about all the uh different projects in

085that report and then this way will give Dr Rogers and the uh uh construction management companies a good idea of where the board is headed to Rogers needs is a board priority list for the additional Parts what is the process by which we can actually all raise our hands and say this is my priority a this is my priority B this is my priority C and then we can come to a conclusion so that we can give an actual set of instructions to the superintendent so we can move the process forward so um that would be helpful and um perhaps I could build on Brian's uh suggestion in order to get to where you'd like to be uh by we'll work on trying to stratify into sort of an A and C category and then

086that will prompt a discussion among the board whether you agree with our uh ranking of priorities and from that discussion it will be clear whether we have have um ordered them in the in a way that reflects your priorities and if not you'll instruct us that things that we put as a maybe you would view as B and things that we put as C maybe you would view as a but we can prepare for you uh because just just as with the visual inspection I I agree with you I think that the work that's been done is Illustrated the work that must be done and um I I don't we'll do some value Engineering in there but I don't think that there's any real decision making left there um so if we narrow now our

087Focus to the things that require a decision we can prepare a a first cut rough draft and then you'll tell us where we're wrong can you also include in that though funding and you know how the impact and you know if you if we need $10 and this is how much you know people pay or the impact on community so that way we can make a educated decision to say okay we can spend $20 but we can't spend $40 you know you figure it out thanks yeah and I we need a placeholder for Barry Hill oh yeah okay so are we all good so we'll have um Dr Rogers prepare the uh the list for us and then for the board discussion okay thank you okay now moving on to uh the next agenda item

088so the board had a busy summer attending um various various events and they includ that included New York State School Board association annual summer law conference scope dinner new teacher orientation facilities tour facilities meeting and also the tour of a modular building in Hicksville and I know many of many of us participated in these events and so if anyone wants to talk about a particular event um please feele free to do so okay Mr greo so I probably should have done this earlier because it's about the prefab but um Dr Park and I toured uh with Dr Rogers and and Mr Hamilton and I took some notes we toured the Willet Avenue School in Hicksville it's a Nassau bosis building um that had a uh a pre prefab structure uh that was about 10 years

089old so I'll just try to run through my notes fast so you know after 10 years it looks like it's holding up well but it it also appeared to be what I'd call it or Dr Rogers called an economy class prefab structure so for example the outside of the structure didn't look any different than our Portables in my opinion uh and Dr Park is nodding so I think we should have a tour even if it's just a couple of us run out to it prefab structure that is you know the Ritz Carlton of prefab structure so we can get a feel for the difference and then we can price out the difference um the um the Bose's folks that were there were really helpful we were able to ask a lot of questions and it

090it the thing that struck me was almost all of the work is done off site so the electrical is done off site the windows are done off site the fire system is done off site um so very little needs to be done and except for things like it's seems like just hooking it up uh and then putting things like blinds in place so if everything's done off site I think they said this one was delivered in early August 10 years ago uh and was ready for the start of school so you're talking about a 3 to four week turnaround from when this thing is delivered um and then one of the other big things I I noticed was it is 10 years old it was built on a wood wood frame so I guess you

091can you can drop these on a slab or you can put them up on a frame and what seemed to be happen is the wood frame where the beams were you could see the rooms were starting to Sag so again economy scale I'm hoping the Ritz has a better version of this um but you know those were my big takeaways um but you know even though it wasn't the nicest thing to look at it definitely seems if it's priced where we've seen the estimates it's it's absolutely worth something to consider as I mentioned to Mr greo and Dr Park uh I was the superintendent at Nasa bosis at the time that we made the decision to invest in those and the reason why they were an economy class was because the building is a rental

092from Hicksville and so bosis didn't want to invest too much money into someone else's property uh but we needed the space because the program was growing at the time and that was the most economical solution um just one uh slight uh addition there it's on concrete peers um but you were see yeah you said W so um they're on concrete peers but we definitely saw some settlement issues uh along the the gerder lines on the floor so uh they've I think they've held up remarkably well but they were they were not intended to be the best of the best at the time because it didn't make economic sense at the time okay thank you anyone else wants to talk about events we attend it in the summer no all right I I mean I think

093it was super helpful that you guys went to tour those prefabs and that it's actually I mean I had a couple of questions um related to it but in general the summary is helpful for me because I can't make every event that board members can event uh can attend and so having a summary where you brief us at a meeting actually I find extremely helpful and something I wish we did more of that a couple of us go to something and then brief everybody I feel like it's more efficient use of everybody's time because then we all get the same information but don't all have to be at the same things at the same time so thank you for that I I'd love to see us do more of that okay I don't know why

094I thought of this when Jack was speaking but um the other issue which may be a Barry Hill issue was there was a lot of space surrounding where they built this so if these things are coming on trucks these trucks need to get somewhere drop this stuff off put them on these little tanks I think you describe them as tanks and move it into place and then move the next piece into place and then the next piece into place which seems feasible in a lot of our areas of need but then again not feasible at others um so it's it was helpful to see it and obviously if anyone has questions I'll answer it but I think we should see a a more I'm not going to come up with other hotel chains so no

095we we will work with h2m to identify some of their customers and clients or maybe Elite has some clients that have um more upgraded versions of these prefabricated units that might have some uh better finishes and better exterior finishes that you can look at and see uh what but um the facilities director at B is obviously someone I worked with when I was there and our Architects have also said um you'll these will be indistinguishable from regular schools um if you see them so I do think it would be helpful to kind of get a sense of the brackets of the market and um it would be helpful um maybe Miss Bato if you could just talk about some of the challenges of um locating something on the Berry Hill site because of the difficulty

096in getting construction equipment behind the school as it's currently configured and and that's really the thing that's in our way right now sure um we've been exploring different options based on the site constraints and the gray change at that building um so we actually had a pre manufacturer company come in to do a lunch and Lear um for us which was access construction and we talked through our different design approaches with them of how get a prefab on the site in the same location and because of the crane and the trucks and all of the different um requirements that go into the prefab the existing location of the Portables is not a suitable location to rebuild in so we need to find another location to build those um prefab or new construction in so we've

097been looking at the different changes in grades and where we can accommodate that um we believe um there's still investigation to be done on that the one of the fun things about Barry Hill is the hill except it's not fun from a construction perspective it's great for sledding not so good for construction all right thank you Dr Park had a question the uh other prefab buildings if we could take a look at something that's a little older instead of something that's brand new that will be helpful sure we'll look at that thank you anyone else has questions for Dr Rogers or um the construction com okay all right so um thank you Mr Greco for um reporting to the board um right now we move on to audience to public uh you must be a

098resident in order to come to the podium and address the board so we ask that you state your name there's the lock at the podium please put your name and address when you come up and in addition you'll have four minutes to speak initially at the end of the four minutes I'll ask you to take a seat first and after everyone in the audience has a chance to speak once you may come up to the audience for the second time again we don't allow the speaking of a particular staff or student issue due to Privacy Law there's no polling of board members by speakers and we thank you for respecting the rules and procedures with that if anyone one wishes to speak um please come up to the podium hi Danielle sanjabi 9 Elm Street

099um my I have three children going into Walt women um so my question is and I thank you all for being here and dedicating all your time doing all your hard work what is the student per class size that we like to see within our district I know State numbers are different um on the element School building level um I ask this because I am and I'm going to have three students at ww women um my other question is will we have more dedicated space for special services like occupational therapy and physical therapy that are non-distracting spaces because we unfortunately didn't have those dedicated spaces in Prior years and um just a comment about a program that I have seen in another District which was uh space maker it is um a program given during

100recess and it gives students the opportunity to have a more structured activity so the kids are out in recess willing to play or wanting to play but those who don't really have that you know want have somewhere to go uh a teacher for each building this is adopted in other districts just so they have a more structured activity during during those recess hours if they choose to do that thank you okay thank you anyone else would like to speak I'm way out of my comfort zone with this not a public speaker um good evening Dr Rogers Central Administration and members of the Board of Education my name is Leslie schof I live at 19 High Street my children are entering the eth and 10th grades at saset high school at hbt and saset high school

101respectively um I'd like to discuss a topic that has been living rentree in my head since um the end of June which is graduation gowns clearly this does not impact my children just yet nor is it of high priority at this time in comparison to all that everybody is working on right now but the topic deserves a modicum of attention before they graduate in 2026 in 2028 currently Norms regarding gender and gender identification are both ever presentes and ever changing all students and saset are supported by staff Club offerings and open discussions about gender identity should they choose to participate we have become increasingly inclusive and this is something for us as Educators and parents to be very proud of however I'm left to wonder why scasa continues to identify males and females at graduation

102by using different color caps and gowns for their genders I understand that many if not most school districts have two official colors with one in dominance on logos sports gear and all kinds of Swag not just one color scos at high school graduating females wear white gowns while the M males wear red gowns I would imagine that if someone chose to wear a gown of the opposite gender they were assigned at Birth that they wouldn't get much push back and be allowed to do so at least I'd like to think so given um given current climate um and inclusion but there are a few ideas about this that I think are worthy of a conversation as per saset the idea that female high school graduates are expected or encouraged to wear white as they move

103on to life as an adult is archaic to me the color white is often a symbolic of Purity and virtue not for males as it is for females relegating a female to a color that represents Purity and innocence is quite honestly a sexist idea unless the boys wear it too there is a reason why tradition has Brides wearing white and only a few go gr go Rogue and challenge that tradition every now and again and perhaps my thoughts and ideas are rogue as well a solution a few Solutions perhaps at first I thought why not allow students to choose which of the two colors they prefer to wear if that school uses to why not give kids a choice rather than deciding for them but here lies the problem whether a student identifies as with

104their assigned gender of birth or not should they decide to wear a gown of a different color than a signed tradition they may be subject to ridicule or bullying with their peers making assumptions about who they are kids can be cruel regardless of how evolved we like to think they have become I'm sure that nobody wants their child to experience that at the culminating event of their High School experience another suggestion why doesn't saset choose one color for both genders to wear for me I look hardd in white despite having spent all summer outside I still look washed out and wearing white would not be my friend I wore a white gown when I graduated from herrick's high school in 1988 while the boys wore blue I'd have preferred a blue gown if given a

105choice her's graduates wear only blue now I would also choose a red gown now if I was a saset graduate like my husband was in 1988 he wore blue and the girls wore white it has been 35 years since he graduated saset can do better please consider unifying future classes with one color graduation gown thank you thank you anyone else wish to uh come up to speak hello my name is Tony Gagliano two Split Rock Lane and saset obviously I'm here to talk about the boys uh hockey team we've been a club team for about 38 years now my father uh started it it was one of the founding fathers and it was his hope that someday it become a Varsity Sport and get some funding from the school and we are a club and

106we've been funding ourselves and the ice and the ref and the league fees have been going it's extraordinary right now as you can see with all the prices so we wanted to know if like the crew team who's also a club they got some funding for their Sport and we want to know if we would be able to be or eligible to get the same kind of respect for our sport we did win a state championship this year first time I think in scet history it's pretty proud of the boys they love playing in front of the fans in front of their you know schoolmates and it's the most fun they ever have playing hockey um um most of the kids play travel hockey and it costs from $5 to $12,000 a year and that

107doesn't include um travel hotels so when we started I think my son was on the team in 8th grade it was about $1,000 for the club team and now it's about 2,000 and that's with the discount for being a travel player and it's becoming extremely hard for us to pay for the ice the refs the lead just for something to be enjoyable for the kids cuz honestly they really love playing in front of the fans so we would just here see if a maybe you could give us some funding like the crew team that's also a club or maybe make it a Varsity Sport and recognize us and help us with the funding we obviously all pay for our own equipment so that wouldn't be a problem because they all play for other teams so

108we just want you to take it under advisement maybe and think of what you could do and help the team out all right thank you okay thank you anyone else who wishes to speak all right so that closes audience to public uh so I'll uh take the first two and then uh I think I'll defer to the board on the latter um so the first one uh Miss sanjabi I'm going to ask uh Dr Curry to spend a couple of seconds she's certainly looked at some of the space planning as we're going into the fall and uh has done a lot of work on Space planning at Walt Whitman and so um she might have an update that she could share with uh yourself and with the board absolutely thank you um in working closely

109not only with Mr Snider from Walt Whitman but all of our elementary principles we spent a lot of time um this summer taking a look at the spaces that were available and I am happy to report that um we were very successful with our OT PT speech and enl services we were successful in securing both DED dedicated and designated spaces that are appropriate for these Services being provided um so that was something we were we were very happy to be able to put in place as far as our class sizes on the elementary go our kindergarten class sizes we look to um have no more than 22 students in our kindergarten classes for grades 1 2 and three the class sizes do not go higher than 25 students and for grades four and five that

110maximum number of students in the class is 27 and again um those class sizes are consistent across all seven of our elementary schools and regarding the opportunities during um recess time for students to um participate in whether we call it a maker space or some type of alternative activity to the outdoor play We're actually um we actually do have an opportunity to balance both the indoor and the outdoor activities especially as the um the nicer days turn to somewhat more inclement days as fall turns into winter and so on so our teachers along with our school monitors um have really put together nice programs with the help of our library media Specialists also that students will have the opportunity um to do a lot of indoor activities as well but while the days are nice

111we do look to maximize their chances to get outdoors in the fresh air as well thank you m lenov thank you for your comment about uh graduation um it certainly occurred to me that we have two different color gowns and uh that some point someone might uh have some thoughts about the subject um but this is the uh yours are the comments of first impression so I certainly appreciate you sharing them I'll have a conversation with the high school staff to see if they have any reactions to it uh but uh today this is the first time I've heard uh a concern expressed about it but I will certainly reflect on what you've shared with us and uh Mr gagiano I know that um when the crew team came to the board and asked for

112the board's consideration the first question the board asked me was to prepare some information for them so that they were better educated on the subject I suspect M Chang you would like me to do the same thing again so I will take a homework assignment away from uh this event and get back to the board some information so that you can be better informed to make a decision thank you Dr Rogers and and thank and congratulations to the hockey team for winning the New York state championship too this is not this is a great eace to achieve congratulations okay there are no uh there's one unfinished uh business uh business item and that's the selection of uh nispa and no business meeting ring delegate the Board needs a voting delegate to participate in the virtual

113NB business meeting on Monday October 16th at 400 p.m. the board member must attend a voting delegate orientation on October 5th at noon or October 11th at 400 p.m. or view the recording um so may I have a volunteer please for this okay Mr Greco one one second so so I'm I'm happy to volunteer um the only issue uh I worry about is the meeting itself is a Monday during uh business hours so I would do it as long as I had sort of a backup delegate in case something came up and I wasn't able to do it during the day um anyone who would like to be the backup for Mr Greer for this event I know I'm Captain back up okay fine I'll I'll I I'll do it and you said it's during

114the business day so it's at the close okay thank you this is a great example for divite and conqueror thank you Mr asri all right so um I don't know what the propriety of this is but one of the things that came up during audience of the public sort of piqu my interest and I I had a question if if I'm out of order just let me know otherwise i' from from the uh the questions they raised at audience the public okay so the question was regarding recess and so it's one of those interesting things that I I don't think I fully understand and I'm not sure based on the feedback that I get frequently that folks across the district totally understand how is recess structured is it organized differently by building is there a

115central Administration sort of sort of directive or or organizing principle about whether or not activities should be organized or the principles sort of have free reign who is responsible for administering it have we sort of gotten I mean it's it's it's an area where I get questions and and concerns and feedback with some frequency so it's actually a good opportunity I think for us to sort of speak a little bit more about it right uh we do a lot of training with the monitors who supervise the recess the building principles talk about this at their Elementary principles meeting with some frequency uh there are inconsistencies because humans are inconsistent uh although the district's expectations are alike for all and uh some monitors of course are more experienced than others and so they have um there

116there is variety but the goals are the same for all uh Dr Curry uh works with the elementary principles the HR department has arranged the trainings for the monitors and maybe you could talk in just a little bit more detail about how we do that and if and if that level of detail doesn't um Sate your curiosity we can come back with something a little bit more elaborate at a future meeting sure um recess in general what we want we strive to do is to provide opportunities that every there's something for every student to connect to um again when we can we like to have the opportunity to be outside if there are situations that would um be detrimental or prevent a child from enjoying the outside we certainly provide indoor activities um whether they're

117board games uh silent reading um small games where they can work with with a friend or so on but for the most part the philosophy is is that if the days are appropriate weatherwise to be outside we like to encourage the students to do that um the opportunities outside also vary there's both structured and unstructured play please don't confuse that with supervised and unsupervised the students are always supervised um and we do spend quite some time with our monitor team um talking about how to properly supervise um intervening when necessary to guide and redirect play so that the students are all enjoying themselves and that every student has a place to belong um and some cases students are eager to um go out and and venture out on their own whether they're on the swings

118on the slide and and playing on the various um apparatus outside and other times there's actually structured gameplay going on whether it's um in the Gaga up hit for square and all of the other games that the kids um do enjoy playing and in that case the buildings have strategically chosen monitors that would be more Adept in monitoring and supervising that type of play because that can also tend to lead to a little bit more competition out on the field and we want to make sure that that stays healthy um and and happy for all the students um we also train the monitors in um what we what we like to reference as PB is light um it's uh positive behavior um interventions and supports um that give the monitors of skill set in order

119to be proactive in redirecting student energies in a positive direction and hopefully avoiding any type of of negative interaction out there we've also done a lot of work this summer um um in the realm of anti-bullying work that as we begin to roll it out this um fall to our staff then that would include our monitors teacher aids and teacher assistants um talking more about the interventions and the role adults play in helping guide students towards enjoying their time outside and um using their energies in in a positive light and enjoying time with with their peers thank you thank you and thank you Mr as Mr asri and Mr CCO for um representing the boore uh to be the voting delegate backup Mr asri is the backup okay back team back up there we go

120all right the following is new business a items A1 and A2 can be taken together there the approval of staff changes in 2023 and 2024 statements and our lead rates may I have a motion please Dr Park uh seconded by Miss enson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions A2 is the approval of coaching recommendations for 2023 may I have a motion Please Mr greal seconded by Miss fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any exensions B items B1 is the approval of committee on special education recommendations may I have a motion please Dr Park second by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B2 is the approval of committee on preschool special education recommendations may I have a motion Please Mr greo second by

121uh Miss Levon are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B3 is the is the approval of a settlement agreement and release May May I have a motion please miss enson seconded by Miss koshia are there any questions are in favor opposed any extensions B4 is the approval of the district y school safety plan may have a motion please miss FAL seconded by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor oppos OS any extensions B5 is the second reading of the policy purchasing may I have a motion please Dr Park second by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions B6 is the authorization of appointments may I have a motion please uh Mr greal seconded by Miss fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any

122extensions C items C1 is the authorization of service contracts may I have a motion please miss enson second by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C2 is the authorization for special education and nursing contracts may I have a motion please miss L seconded by Miss fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C3 is the authorization for contracts with naso boses for services for the 2023 2024 school year and Fin authorization for the 2022 and 2023 school year may I have a motion please Dr par seconded by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C4 is the approval of the award of nasso County director of school facilities purchasing consortion Cooperative bids 2023 2024 may have a motion please miss fov

123seconded by Mr greo are there any questions all in favor opposed any exensions C5 is the approval of the award bids may I have a motion please Dr Park seconded by Miss kosia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions C6 is the authorization of the Disposable of broken serus and or absolutely equipment in or books may I have a motion Please Mr Leon seconded by Mr greckle are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay member motion to adjoin the meeting okay Miss evingson and Dr far thank you so much enjoy the rest of your summer and we'll see you back um uh in September thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.