001Dr Rogers and the entire Administration for your continued support of our outstanding Athletic program and allowing me to share some of our full highlights including our student athletes we've had the great season that included one naso County quarterfinalist three naso County semi-finalists two naso County Runner ups and four Nassau County Champions and one Long Island Champion with all of their success in the fall I'm also very proud to announce that our student athletes continue to excel in the classroom and all of our teams this fall earned the New York State Public High School Athletic Association scholar athlete team distinction a true Testament to our coaching staff and our athletes commitments athletes commitment to being student athletes so thank you very much to start recognizing our uh outstanding athletes I'd like to introduce um Ian kazani
002he is a three-year starter and captain of our boys volleyball team he was a important member of our County championship team last year and he is one of our three all count uh uh athlet from our boys volleyball team [Applause] congratulations next up is Mr will kley he's a four-year vity football player and captain of the vity football team an integral part of our playoff runs including our run at last um last fall when we played we uh beat F the semi-finals end up playing MP win the championship game will battled all year despite a bad ankle spraying and he represented the team with with class and pride I want to congratulate will Colley and at this time I'd like to introduce our badminton coach Mr Tom Rooney [Applause] hi good evening um this is
003uh part of the nasso county semi-finalist boys badminton team I'd like to recognize the all count athletes first up is uh sophomore Ryan Sue Ryan is a two-year starter and was all count in singles next up is senior ad aarma ad DTI is a four-year Varsity player who was all County in doubles uh his partner is senior sha o who was also All County uh uh next is Ethan Alex who is a two-time all count doubles player thank you [Applause] guys and now I'd like to introduce the girls soccer team and Coach Tyler arnone [Applause] good evening everyone um first I just want to extend gratitude on behalf of sasset um girl soccer program to Dr Rogers the Board of Education Mr stuber Miss Kang um my my building principal for all the support you
004show our program um the girls benefited and hopefully made the community proud with what they did this year um we have three tremendous uh student athletes Alexa Beck Schneider and Jess alessie who won all County with Alexa Beck and Jess alessie uh winning All State honors as well um Jessie will continue her soccer career at Cornell University next year Alexa Beck will be playing yeah Round of Applause Alexa Beck uh playing lacrosse multisport athlete at Iona and Bren Schneider who is coming toward the end of the recruiting process hasn't made a decision yet but we'll be playing college soccer next [Applause] year congratulations ladies at this time I'd like to introduce coach Rich cafiero who coaches our boys cross country team who are New York State qualify as representing Nassau County thank you very much
005uh good evening Miss changen members of the Board of Education Dr Rogers Administration and our Sasa Community Sasa boys cross country team had a very successful season this year the boys were undefeated during the regular season which helped them earn the title of division and Conference champions although on County day the team was dealing with a few injuries the team bounced back the next week winning the state qualifier meet by one point so exciting right to the line it mattered and earning a trip to the New York state championships at the um Queensbury New York race uh at the state championships the boys placed ninth out of 36 teams which helped them extend their season to the prestigious New York State Federation meet the state meet was one of the best performances in our program's
006history the team success is largely due to the boys on stage right now Junior Christian frankis couldn't be here tonight but earned the old County Title for two years in a row Gavin McAn ran one of the fastest times on the right hand on your left my right uh and one of the fastest times in our program's history 1611 at at the Beth Page of course ER all County his competitiv is second to none uh and finally senior Tyler gainy on your right had a tremendous and consistent year placing 11th at the state qualifier meet earning old County honors his leadership was an integral part of the team success thank you very much unfortunately Coach P could not be here tonight so I'll be I would gladly introduce the young ladies who are part of
007our nasso County Championship cross country team for the 13th consecutive season uh also State qualifying Champion I I had the pleasure of watching the boys and the girls compete in the state qualifier meet and I can tell you that this group of young ladies you watch the boys compete you watch all the different divisions and they you see like somebody from your school once or twice the siastic girls came in force it was amazing to see them close the coming around Beth Page and you see him come around the field the polo field and then they make their final push to the to the flat you know to the line and it was amazing all I saw was saset and I knew we were we were winning and advancing representing uh nasau County to stay
008qualifier at the states uh the girls course country team finished a regular season undefeated uh they went on to finish six at the state championship following their County championship and the following young ladies earn All County honors Linda Lynn Ariana sadami Giana lavaka Ashley Wong Melissa teneri Ren fukawa Juliana mesco and Juliana ragosa congratulations thank you very much great season and now it brings me great pleasure to introduce uh coach of our nasau County Championship boy soccer team coach Brett waxon [Applause] thank you Dr Rogers Central Administration the Board of Ed and the high school administration for all your support year after year a special thank you to Mrs stuber for all your hard work and guidance you provide for all our teams coaches and especially our athletes I have to say thank you to
009coach Pini our assistant coach the man the myth Legend to win the Nassau County Championship is such an amazing accomplishment but to win it with such a great group of young men parents and coaches is just special the love and respect this team had for one another formed a great culture and this journey we spent together is something we will always remember for all our lives losing in an enthralling 5-4 overtime match in the long is Championship didn't change how proud these boys should and deserve to feel is with great pride that I call each member of the team's name tonight Chris anona Cameron Chan Alex D Roa Anthony Fury Danny Flynn Jack gobin Zack calman Cody lewitz Xavier Javi Navaro miles nans Sebastian oyaga Chase pendrick Xavier pz Anthony Rizzo Caesar Rubio Thomas rewitz
010Owen sacket John shonesy and Andrew zamit with with such a great team accomplishment we also able to have three boys earn All County Junior Jake tappis unfortunately is just landed from a plan arve from Florida from the soccer tournament he's not able to make it but Jake dpis senior Raphael danieli who also received defense player of the year and Senior Captain Jack pendrick who was also recognized for earning the Ralph Whitney award was which is the conference player of the year he was also news day second Team all Long Island and he was also second Team all state thank you to all our athletes tonight and [Applause] everyone congratulations guys and now it brings me great pleasure to introduce our head coach of our girls swimming and Diving team coach Mike [Applause] cilino e thank
011you I'd like to start with some very big thank yous first to Mr stuber and his staff for all the support they give to our athletic programs to Dr Rogers the Board of Education and the entire Community for all the support you've given to saset swimming and Diving across all levels to an outstanding coaching staff Marudo and Tom Cornelia and of course to a team of 36 swimmers and divers who have been an absolute joy to coach I'm so proud of this group not only for the amazing accomplishments that they've achieved in the pool but also for the great things that they have done for the community at the start of our season our girls team took the lead in organizing a su Across America event to raise money to help fight cancer saset fundraising
012total was over $15,500 and the event that we organized raised over $225,000 in the pool our our success continued where we brought home our fourth consecutive conference one Championship fourth consecutive division championship and finally our third consecutive County Championship it took the entire team to achieve these accomplishments and here with us tonight are Jamie Beck Hannah Chan Rachel Chan haey Chi Sophia chin Amanda chin Allison Chu Lucia Garcia Allison Hugh Caroline Hugh Leila J bear Sophie kill Katie cunn Victoria Lao summer Lee Rachel Lee Priscilla Lee Joelle Lee Daniela laric Madison Lynn Jacqueline Lou Rachel Lou Jackie Lou Khloe in Mia Q Sabrina Shen Carol Sun Emily Wang Jamie Wong and Isabella young it takes a big team to win the county Championship I'd also like to acknowledge our all count and all state athletes
013Rachel Chen All County Amanda chin All County Caroline Hugh All County All State Joel Lee All County All State Jacqueline Lou all count all state and finally Madison Lynn all count all state and she was also honored by news day as part of the all Long Island team great job girls thank you very [Applause] much congratulations ladies [Music] and last but certainly not least our Nassau County and Long Island champion and state New York State finalist girls tennis team led by head coach Shai Fisher Hannah Hannah I'm so nervous good evening members of the board of education Administration and Community I'm proud to talk to you tonight about some of the achievements in the girls tennis program this past fall as far as our team accomplishments this season was nothing short of incredible filled with
014hard work determination and breakthrough moments battling through numerous injuries lineup flexibility became the Hallmark of the season with solid performances in both singles and matches week after week we finished the regular season with an overall record of 16- one securing key victories against tough Rivals like Roslin and Great Neck South and for the first time winning the Half Hollow Autumn Invitational which built confidence and momentum our singles lineup of Junior Stephanie Moret senior co- Captain Zia mcgie and Senior co- Captain sunam meta powered us to a County Championship over Port Washington similarly the depth of our doubles lineup with numerous standout performances helped us defeat Half Hollow Hills East for the Long Island Championship Brighton High School out of Rochester in the state semi-finals as well though we lost a really competitive match in the
015state finals the journey itself was the ultimate Triumph and for the second year in a row earning New York State finalists status ladies congratulations once again Nassau County Champions Long Island Champions Regional Champions and second overall in the state moving on to our individual honors we had three ladies earn All County we had freshman DIA barma and eighth grader Selena Wang they Advanced all the way to the quarterfinals earning All County in doubles and then in our singles tournament junior Stephanie maret Advanced to the quarterfinals earning All County as well congratulations once again Dia Selena Stephanie on your all count recognition and lastly we had two young ladies earn All State honors Junior Elaine Lou and seventh grader Hannah Lang made it all the way to the semi-final round in doubles finishing fourth in the
016entire tournament and earning All State recognition congratulations once again to both Elaine and Hannah congratulations all ladies thank you once again for a tremendous [Applause] season I would be remiss if I didn't thank the people who are in the room celebrating their children the parents and guardians of these outstanding young men and women congratulations uh I know I speak for all the coaching staff that we can only imagine how proud you are of of these tremendous young student athletes so congratulations to the parents as [Applause] well thank you all so much for coming to the meeting and it is the great time if you want to make a graceful exit and you're more than welcome to stay for the presentation so congratulations again and a big shout out to all the coaches and Mr duber
017for their leadership and uh now the board will take a few minutes to uh move to the stage to start our meeting thank you again okay so uh we are going to uh start our uh meeting and the first item on the agenda is the approval minutes of the December 9th 2024 meeting can I have a motion please miss Levitan seconded by Miss fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions and Dr ruol can we have the treasures report please thank you as indicated in the treasures report the cash on hand for the month end November 2024 was 140 m3507 $976 it shows that bank balances for all cash accounts were reconciled to the book balances and were collateralized in accordance with the district's banking agreements and investment policy thank you okay
018thank you Dr rufo can I have a motion Please Mr Roto second by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any abstentions okay and then uh we are going to have uh Dr Rogers to give a give us his uh um monthly report please just two short comments from me because we have some um I think interesting presentations that I know the board is uh interested in discussing uh but I did want to uh just uh notify the community that we'll be sending out a survey later this week uh as you know we've uh invited members of the community alumni to be part of uh committee to help us narrow down the options for what a future mascot might be for the school district and we're going to be soliciting some input
019from community members via an online survey so wanted to let uh folks know that that was on its way and uh we got a dusting of snow today on the ground and it just reminded me uh that I wanted to share that uh as we've done in recent years although the state has made it possible to do uh remote days on snow days if there is a day when the snow is going to be something that uh I think students will appreciate having the opportunity to play in uh rather than have a remote day of instruction we'll just have what is now called a traditional snow day uh as those snow days have been rare in recent years I certainly want uh students to have the opportunity to uh to really enjoy them if we
020have a good day like that but if uh for some reason it's not going to be uh an enjoyable day and it may be impacting on our future uh calendar obviously uh we have the option of the remote day in our back pocket uh but I just wanted to uh to uh signal that to the community in terms of what our philosophy is going to be going forward if there is more substantial snow than what we experience today so our first conversation is going to be and first presentation is going to be uh primarily centered around the transition that students go through uh when they graduate from middle school and go to the high school we call that the 8th to 9th transition there's a substantial body of research that suggests that students experience um
021shifts when they move from one building to another and that uh can sometimes result in a sense of social isolation in going from building to building and often uh the research illustrates shows uh a loss in uh academic uh performance during those Transitions and the better a school district is at all building transitions whether at the elementary or the secondary level uh the more students can have an even experience and not lose their momentum so we've put a lot of energy into the 8 to9 transition starting just prior to the pandemic uh when we put a number of initiatives into place and we've uh redoubled our efforts this year that transition is going to start in the next week or so so we wanted to share some of the changes that have been made but
022uh to kind of set the stage for this I wanted to talk about some of the changes that have been been made in some of our other transitions so from the upk program into the elementary schools and from the elementary schools into the middle schools and that thinking around these building transitions will set the stage for the more expansive conversation around uh the transition to the high school so to start us off is Dr Janette woic who is our assistant superintendent for elementary education she'll talk to us about some of these early grade Transitions and we'll transition from there to Mr Steinberg who will uh walk us through the 8 to9 transition thank you good evening Dr Rogers Dr Curry p education happy New Year um my colleague Mr Steinberg and I appreciate the opportunity
023to highlight an important part of our students educational experience successfully navigating transitions through their schooling our overarching aim is to create a transition process at each level that not only prepares students for academic success but also supports their personal growth and sense of belonging to accomplish this goal we focus on building students confidence and Readiness equipping to embrace new academic challenges with Assurance we emphasize fostering meaningful Partnerships with families through consistent communication and collaboration ensuring that parents and Guardians feel engaged and supported we are also committed to nurturing a sense of community and inclusion so every student feels valued and connected as they move forward additionally we work to align each phase of transition with our District's dedication to Excellence and the holistic de development of every learner these priorities guide us as we support
024and Empower students and families ensuring each transition is successful for all students so first we're going to take a look at our District's effort to support two early grade transitions the transition from Universal prek to kindergarten and from fifth to sixth grade these pivotal moments lay the groundwork for long-term academic and social emotional success the transition from upk to kindergarten is often the first significant milestone in a child's educational experience our approach is grounded in collaboration communication and a shared commitment to meeting the diverse needs of our youngest Learners our district takes pride in ensuring a warm and supportive welcoming for incoming kindergarten families as they begin this exciting new chapter each Elementary School sends a welcome letter to families setting a positive tone for their journey to familiarize students and their families with the
025School environment we host an orientation that includes a guided tour giving everyone a chance to explore the building and feel more comfortable with their new surroundings for students with IEPs we hold transition meetings from cpsc Committee of preschool special education to CSC Committee of special education during which families receive detailed information about the special education supports at the elementary level additionally incoming students participate in a comprehensive kindergarten screening this includes meeting with kindergarten teachers occupational therapists Beach therapists and enl teachers ensuring we gain a well-rounded understanding of each child's unique strengths and needs preparing for a successful transition to kindergarten involves a collaborative and comprehensive approach to ensure that students and F families feel supported articulation meetings with the leaders of each upk site provide an opportunity to align on key transition goals and share
026in sites parent conferences in upk further strengthen this process by offering families personalized guidance and support throughout the transition period families receive ongoing communication including letters from elementary schools with important reference information and for students with IEPs cpsc to CSE parent orientation meetings are held to explain the Continuum of services at the elementary level additionally kindergarten teachers receive detailed C middle of transition folders containing essential information transition from fifth to sixth grade is an exciting milestone for students as they prepare to move into the dynamic environment of our middle schools our district is committed to ensuring that this process is smooth and supportive helping students and families feel confident and well prepared for the next stage of their journey to facilitate this transition each Middle School sends regular Communications to families including General welcome messages
027information about core selections and schedules and invitations to a parent orientation held in the spring during the Spring fifth grade students visit their future middle schools where they tour the buildings hear from their peer leaders talking about life in middle school and they even get a sneak peek into one of the classrooms in August incoming sixth graders have the opportunity to attend an optional orientation this session allows students to practice reading their schedules toward the building once again and it and get to know each other by participating in fwn Icebreaker activities these thoughtful steps ensure that every student enters Middle School feeling supported informed and excited about the opportunities ahead the transition from fifth to sixth grade is a collaborative process involving Educators families and Sport staff to ensure that students are set up for
028success in Middle School guidance counselors work closely with fifth grade teachers to gain a comprehensive understanding of each student's achievements communication with families is ongoing providing updates and resources to support a smooth transition at this point I'd like to welcome my colleague Mr David Steinberg who will be speaking about the transition from middle to high school okay thank you Dr woic uh hello everybody happy New Year um thank you to the Board of Education uh for the opportunity to have this conversation with you where we can be talking about um this pivotal point in our students um uh academic career um before we go forward though in in this story I think we have to take a little bit of a look back um to where we came from here this has been a conversation
029we've been having for some time and um one of the things we've noticed over the past 10 years or so is that the number of students ninth grade students who take an honors level course is on a steady increase it it does rise in the uh as we as we see that data and that has raised questions over the past of well at what expense is this happening are are students um you know choosing this path and are they doing this at the expense of their mental health are they doing this at the expense of other opportunity um something that we really want to be close to so when we look at some additional data on this and we look at another uh piece of data and we and we look at what are the
030overall drops uh over that same period of time and what we begin to see is that the drops have the number of students nth grade students have dropped from these honors courses decreases it decreases to a point that it sort of levels out and if you kind of look at the graph and you take a look at all the way to the right in the 2425 number I just want to point out that that 4% that's not a complete number for this year so that number was calculated uh a little bit earlier this fall uh so we' have to get updated number to that but looking at the four years prior we can see how that data sort of has reached somewhat of a a plateau in terms of that drop so there's encouragement in
031in those numbers as we see them and as to well why is that happened why is it that we've able to have an increase in the ninth grade enrollment and honors classes and been able to decrease the number of drops so in order to sort of answer that question we go back to sort of our philosophy and the conversations we have with students when we're um going through the programming process with our students and families um and that our philosophy is to make sure that we want every single one of our students to attempt the most rigorous program and that doesn't necessarily mean that they have to take Advanced coursework it means it has to be rigorous for them no matter what the level that they're at but we do not want them to sacrifice
032uh the their well-being for that rigor so there's that fine balance that has to come into play and so what has worked for us over the past is that we have workshops in multiple subject areas to provide support for students at whatever level they're they're at they have that ability um our teachers are wonderful in the time provide our students for extra help uh they'll meet students before after school during school to make sure they have the supports that they're going to need and then timely communication with parents which is critical that partnership with parents is very important so that parents understand early that if a student's struggling in a class that they understand what's happening and can help at home also provide the needed supports um any of the accommodations provided for students through
033ipps and 504s at every level is going to be provided for our students and over the past seven eight years we we've established a very extensive mtss framework here that provides an ongoing way to prog to to monitor how students are progressing academically and again no matter what level they are so as soon as that we notice that a student may be struggling whether it be academically or on on a um maybe behavioral side there's recommendations to that mtss committee where then um interventions can be uh uh placed at that point as well and then in addition to that we've been bolstering our Mental Health Services uh to ensure that if students are struggling academically or struggling in a school setting they have the opportunity to talk with guidance counselors we have the opportunity to
034bring in social workers and psychologists if that's going to be needed and that's currently where we've gotten over those 10 years to sort of help support our students as we're noticing an increase in the number of our nth graders taking these courses now with all that said we don't rest on that and say okay we're finished and you know success and that's done that's not who we are as sosid we're constantly looking at how we improve that process and what we understand is that our students are under increasing levels of stress um especially in these transition periods it is a lot for an eth grader to now enter a high school when you're only 12 13 14 years old and you're now going to come into a building potentially you're going to have 18 year
035olds in your building young adults it's a much larger building there's a lot that goes on so part of our philosophy is to consistently look at this transition and look at this planning process and and make sure we're looking for areas where we can continue to empower our students also Empower our families and I have to say and I have to thank our building level Administration our principles and our assistant principles who constantly have their eyes on this and do a tremendous job ensuring that these programs are put in place in a timely way that's going to help Empower not only the students and the parents but in those program choices um there's a lot of long range planning that goes into High School one of the things that we'll hear uh often out of
036the high school is that it's four short years but they're pretty long years there's a lot that goes on so we'll talk a little about in a little bit about the multiple on and off ramps to courses the the the bre the depth and bread of the course offerings we'll get into that in a little bit um and that there doesn't need to be this sort of pressure in that 8 to9 transition of having to do it all in one year okay although it's four short years there's plenty of opportunity for that we'll talk a little bit more about that so you have those opportunities and at the same time we want to empower the students to understand that through self awareness when they need to seek that additional support when so they can judge
037am I in the right course am I am I in the right place for this right now and what kind of support may I need as the student because we'll have that support okay so those supports are there but students will have to learn to advocate for themselves so when we look at 2425 transition what we've been able to do this year and this year alone is we've made some significant uh improvements to the process um the the one that we're actually really excited about is going to begin tomorrow January 7th these are IND district field trips where every one of our eighth graders from both Southwoods middle school and harby Thompson Middle School will visit the high school they will visit the high school over the course of four days so Southwoods will visit
038the high school tomorrow um and on the 14th and the Stu and the eighth graders from hbt will be coming to the high school on the 9th and the 15th where they're going to be led around by uh high school students as the eighth graders get exposed to all the different uh elective opportuni ities that they will have so they will go and visit the human ecology they'll visit technology they'll visit the art department and they'll visit teachers students and they will see the coursework so the idea behind this is that when they get into their program period they have now already been in the high school they've had a touch point in the high school they've seen the high school they got a feeling of what it's like they have spoken to high school
039students and they've spoken to teachers and they've seen and got to hear about a curriculum that might interest them or might not interest them so we're really excited for that to kick off tomorrow that's a that's a um you know a big Improvement and that's taken a lot of work and again um a big thank you to the building level Administration for putting all of that together uh We've also included this year a ninth grade specific curriculum guide so the teams have been hard at work reviewing the overall curriculum guide updating our uh descriptions making sure that uh things are nice and clear for everybody and then the decision was well let's pull out the ninth grade available courses so that it's more accessible to our n to our eighth grade students and their parents
040so they don't have to go through this you know real big catalog of all these courses that they're not eligible for yet they still have access to it you can still access that on the website so you still can see it and what might be coming but yet you can see what's right in front of you in the ninth grade guide on top of that too we made a um a shift in one of our courses our ninth grade peer Educators course which is a leadership course at the high school for nth graders in years past that course met every single day um and by meeting every single day what that does is it kind of limits the ability of of some of the eighth graders to get that in their schedule it competes with
041other courses uh like music and art and things along that line um when we had our articulation meeting in December which we'll talk a little bit more about in the presentation the uh the idea was circulated in that articulation committee which is comprised of the high school and middle school guidance counselors along with teachers and administrators and it was decided that that class should move to an alternate day course because it will open up flexib ability for the incoming nth graders so more students would be able to take this leadership course as they come into the high school and would open up a half uh credit basically for them to take an additional elective so providing them more Choice as they come in so so as a ninth grader coming in they're not getting locked
042into something so they'll have more choice at that point and then we expanded our use of navian which typically is used at the high school to help with uh career awareness it helps with personality trade identification and to have have that at the middle schools prior to their visit with us uh this month again empowers students to get a little bit better understanding of where their interest might lie to help them make a decision about which of the elective courses that they want to choose so those are some of the new initiatives that we put into place just this coming year so as we look at the comprehensive transition program it really begins back in September of this year so if the eighth graders this year their transition starts the beginning of of this year
043through our high school's PTSA curriculum Council the the high school PTSA curriculum Council works very closely with high school administration to choose the content areas that will be presented uh via live stream on a monthly basis and you can see in the presentation the topics this year range from World Language through science and all eighth grade parents are invited to attend those so the eighth grade parents could attend via the live stream the live streams are recorded then they're made available so any any eighth grade parent or student can then watch these and begin to get a sense of what the high school curriculum feels like so again beginning in in that September period of time then our guidance department at the high school follows up with presentations on programming in December and then later
044in February more on the peer leadership program and this kind of process for the parents finishes up on March 20th where the guidance Department hosts again via live stream an incoming n9th grade orientation excuse me where the um the high school then will talk about really all things high school and what it means you know to becoming into the high school so that that'll be in September uh just this past December as I was talking about earlier the High School Host an articulation meeting so that's a meeting where your high school guidance uh mental health professionals teachers administrators come together to talk about the overall high school program and to talk about any changes that might have occurred in the program and give the opport opportunity for the eighth grade guidance counselors to ask any
045questions so they are clear on how they're going to be guiding and the conversations are going to be having and one of the um well there's actually three sort of pillars to this conversation the three pillars here is that there's something for everyone that's that's discussed meaning with the breadth and depth of the of the academic program that that students can find almost anything that they're interested in and then the extracurricular program that has well over 100 groups and clubs and our athletic program and those are discussed as something that's for everybody at that time so all students will feel comfortable coming to the high school the other key component here is being kind to yourself and this is a conversation that the all the guidance counselors administrators and teachers are having with our students
046to be kind to themselves in this process meaning it could be very overwhelming with all of these choices and your first thought is I want to do it all I want to do it all and I want to do it at the highest level I can do it but the but the conversation is you don't have to rush into it you don't have to rush into it because the third piece of this is that there are multiple on and off ramps to the academic program once you're in high school so because you didn't start in a in a an advanced track let's say in a 9th grade doesn't mean you can't get on an advanced track later on in your high school career if you didn't take a certain AP in n9th grade doesn't mean
047you can't catch up and take those APS later there are multiple on-ramps to do that one of the things things that we encourage the students to do is to challenge themselves we want them to get out there and and go after that rigor try something and and you know and do your best at it and we're going to have supports in place and if you don't succeed at that hey that's fine because there's an offramp to that and we can get you off that and get you into a course and get you on a path that's more suitable and the next year you can try again right and you can try again at at the next point so the idea is to to sort of go after that challenge yourself but don't do that at
048the expense of you know your own well-being we want that to be balanced so that is something that um again will keep coming up in terms of what happens within those conversations so we so on uh tomorrow night the 7th we'll be releasing you'll see the high school Dr Dante will be sending an email welcoming all eighth grade families to the high school and in that email he will have a link to the ebook so the ebook is a nth grade orientation book where there is a recorded message from Dr Dante which I highly recommend um that you listen to it uh he's wonderful it is warm a welcoming comprehensive message um you immediately feel welcome to the high school just listening to that and then as you want to learn more you scroll through
049and each one of our department heads each one of our assistant principles has a welcoming message a video message in there as well to welcome you to their Department um in addition to Highlights about the department and the opportunities as n th grader so that ebook will be going out the middle schools then file that up at their PTSA meeting on January 16th at that meeting the Middle School uh uh Administration along with their PT PTSA have a transition meeting it's a presentation about transation to high school and then they will review the ebook with the parents there as well so it's another point for the parents to to get empowered understand what what the opportunities are for at to high school and followed up from there middle schools then go into their programming meetings
050and in those meetings the guidance councils are meeting with students and parents are invited into those meetings via Zoom so parents can zoom in those meetings they could sit in those meetings with their students so parents and students are there making a decision on what's in the best interest for their student going into high school with the guidance of the guidance department so it's a team effort to make sure that that program is going to be balanced right and then in February there's the face-to-face parent teacher conference uh where now the teacher and the parent can have that onetoone conversation so there's all these touch points for the eighth grade parents as they go through this process to ensure that their students are building that that rigorous program but well balanced right and not at
051the expense of their own well-being and then we get to August so the programming period happens throughout the spring schedules are set and then we get to August it's summertime and then at the August um excuse me the end of August there's the incoming ninth grade orientation which is an in-person event where Dr Dante now will welcome each and every incoming ninth grade student it it occurs in two sessions so half of the ninth grade will come into the auditorium in the morning half in the afternoon that's only because we can't get them all in to the auditorium um and he will do an inperson welcome well he will focus his welcome on the three points that we've been talking about that there's something for everyone he will he will review all those options he
052will talk about being kind to yourself creating a well balanced schedule and he will talk about the multiple on andof ramps uh for advanced coursework and for rigorous coursework with students kind of driving that point home he will also focus on the the extensive extracurricular program um and how important that is to a well-rounded High School experience and he will encourage the students to take advantage of all that there is to offer in the high school because there are four short years right and there's a lot of growing that has to happen happen um and uh and it's a wonderful event and so the students get that welcome Message from Dr Dante and then they attend an extracurricular Fair where all the clubs will have booths set up in the main gym and the aux
053gym and the incoming ninth grade students then can walk around talk to other students who running these clubs ask questions they can sign up for the clubs right at that point they don't have to but it's an opportunity for them to learn more about the clubs at that point so that's what happens in August then of course in September well it's Welcome to the high school so now here they are they made it to the high school they've gone through you know almost the entire transition program but the transition program doesn't end when they step into the high school because now they're in the high school and we have to ensure that they're here now and that they're that all the choices they made getting to this point they're going to be supported in those
054choices so the guidance department is very proactive in at this point the guidance counselors will have small group meetings and in those meetings they're basically checking in with the nth graders they're making sure that they understand the activities they're reinforcing the messaging they're reinforcing the transcripts and different services available to them and they're informing the students about the different support groups that guidance offers so there's there's all kinds of groups there's a few listed here um there's groups on Executive functioning which for a incoming nth grade student can be one of the more difficult pieces as you come into the high school and now you're now you're taking on high school level coursework and now you're have to begin to figure out how am I going to time manage myself how am I going to
055do all of this and get all this done um so there's support group for that test anxiety which is a very real thing as we all know um and if someone's new to the district or someone's going through a family is going through divorce so these support groups are there in addition to other mental health supports should those things be needed as well and again to Circle back to mtss that mtss committee uh will meet again um and students will be identified over the course of the first semester that they're here or the first year they're here and if students are identified as students who might be struggling academically or uh behaviorally then they will be recommended to mtss where then the professionals then can come in and and take a look and say okay
056what kind of other supports do we need at that point so they get through all of that and then they're here right and then they're here so that's that's our extensive program and those are the changes we've made to this point so I will just say thank you and open up the floor at this point for any questions or comments okay okay thank you Mr Steinberg and Dr W for your presentation and it's definitely uh great to to know all the resources and support available um from U you from even upk to 12th grade and that's why we have that's inset for all the students so okay and then are there any questions okay uh Mr greckle thank you both um always so helpful uh to hear from both of you on these issues I
057have a question this went pretty narrow so AP World one you gave a figure um with at least one honors course being taken as a I think it was 77% does that include that one particular class and you'll understand why I'm asking um does that include that with respect to the other four core honors classes yeah yeah so those um the honors courses in this data would include the AP world it would include the um Spanish honors it includes um the English honors and it includes uh science and math yeah that that's include so obviously I know so much goes into putting together these presentations and the last thing I'm trying to do is you know critique it at all but one thing that would be helpful at least for me um is when we
058have this kind of presentation and you give us a graph that says freshman taking at least one honors course I'd love to see freshman percentage of freshman taking two three and really what I'm looking for would be four and five I just think down the road we don't need that tonight obviously and I wouldn't ask you to come up with it tonight but that would be helpful as we make decisions in the future to have that presentation and that information um so that's just one very very minor comment the other thing I'll say is the ptsa's curriculum committee presentation I mean they're wonderful right the your work with the PTA to get the the heads of the Departments to present with students the eighth graders that are invited to that how are they is is
059this an email coming from the the building leadership or is it just through the PTA that they're being invited because obviously the more eighth grade parents that are watching that that's very early on in the year and then they realize that there's six of them and then the curric the guidance ones and it's just a great transition into the high school how is that conveyed to them so that that's an email sent out uh I believe that's through Dr Dante's office to the high school's office he sends it out um which is part of that welcome again it's that you know that touch that and and I have you know we have to give a lot of credit to Dr Dante we all know him and we know how warm and welcome he is that's
060part of it so he sends that email out to to welcome them in and if they miss it any of these presentations for whatever reason again they're they're they're recorded and readily available so parents can go back and watch them again so if anyone missed you know tonight they're hearing this and they're saying I didn't know about this and they look back at the and they say well you know the last one's January 15th I missed the first three they can go back and watch them they're available and just to your other point I made a note about your data so thank you Miss dri so actually when I ask a question I wanted to make a process suggestion first which is do you want to separ separate primary and Middle School from High School
061otherwise the questions may end up going in a Time Circle and okay since since Dr uh Mr steinber is here so you want to ask about the secondary first I guess what I was asking is all of us do questions from one set of schools first and then Circle up to the second set of schools as opposed to having it Go in circles back and forth between grades I it's fine go ahead just go ahead with your questions okay um so uh I want to start at primary um I I guess my my number one question is regarding um students that transition from elementary to middle and um IEP consultation so I think the presentation mentioned that folks either admin or some teachers or service providers sit in on the annual review yes for fifth
062grade MH so can you just expand a little bit how often it's service providers how often it's admin responsible if they're attending multiple meetings or or just the annual review meeting so every year for students with IEPs there um we're required to have an annual review and when we have a student transitioning from fifth to sixth grade the fifth grade um IEP team meets to develop the plan for sixth grade um for the student but in order to do that they invite the Middle School staff to come join them for that um annual review that includes um usually this a psycholog ologist comes from the Middle School um often times Miss Waters or um Miss Burke from Southwoods the I um CSC administrators from the middle schools may join um so that there's an opportunity
063for the fifth grade team the child's team to build a plan that fits with the Middle School to so families can understand what supports and services are available for their child when they enter um and transition from 5th to 6th so there is one meeting at least at the annual review where the whole team gets together to build the plan for transition so one of my observations about annual reviews is they tend to be somewhat um dense meetings and so sometimes I wonder if having a representative at that one meeting is actually going to be sufficient because it seems like you're going to have to do a a big step back to preview the student history and and then discuss the IEP for the coming year and then um come up with the plan is
064I'm just curious about why we chose sort of only the annual review meeting is the way to start that transition so that's the official point in time where the plan is made for the child as they move into sixth grade but before that there's a lot of articulation discussions that take place so often times um the guidance counselors from the middle schools speak with the fifth grade teachers um the special education providers If the child is receiving speech and may continue to receive speech in sixth grade th those conversations are happening beforehand so administrators are speaking with one another so while um that seems like the time that everything either begins or takes place there's conversations ahead of time with families um so that they're prepared usually to say like here's what you may expect
065when you come to the transition csse um so it is a big meeting there are lots to discuss and usually there's opportunities where special education supports um reach out after and have conversations with families to make sure and then once families receive the IEP if they have any questions they certainly can Circle back to either team to help clarify I just have one more question about this and then um so how often is it not just the administrator who's in charge of csse who's attending the meeting and and multiple service or at least one service provider from the sixth grade team so it's always a representative there's always a representative from the sixth grade team and it does vary some usually it is the psychologist um sometimes you know whoever if there's counseling involved the
066social worker might be present um it depends on what the child's um needs are so um usually there is definitely a psychologist or representative and then um often times an administrator May ATT as well okay and my last question is how do you assess the upk Tok and the fifth to sixth transition programs are working currently and what is that based on so generally speaking when we look at transitions for students we always we ensure that we are communicating as effectively as possible with families so when we look at that we always make sure that all of our communication is sent um to any fam who are registered if they're um there's ongoing registration we always make sure that communication is sent um it's translated into many different languages um this the assessment if you
067will of how um effective our transitions are are when we see our students come to school in the fall um and they're ready they've they've experienced the school families are prepared with um what they need to be prepared with as far as the upk Tok transition sometimes that's a little bit more more sensitive um with regard to students and kindergarteners um entering a new building it's much bigger than their their preschool um there's warm welcomes the children are happy to join in they know who their teachers are they've been to the school um and the same thing with the sixth grade transition they've met um the school they've been they know their schedule they've been able to walk in so often we see that success or as children come in um but as far as
068an as an assessment you know it's usually anec total as we see how students um engage with one another and with the school as they come in okay okay are there any more questions uh Miss abson okay sorry um there were two things I guess the first was for the upk to the kindergarten transition I don't remember if it was in um a PTA meeting or if it was a another board member um but they talked about adding busing some having a large bus or a small bus at the transition at the screening process so that kids that have never been on a bus before wouldn't get overwhelmed with that whole concept of getting on the bus and getting off the bus and kind of seeing what it looks like on the inside because there
069are students who have never taken a bus before uh and start in kindergarten and they're getting on a big bus with a lot of different kids in a lot of different ages so someone had brought that up and I just wanted to bring that here because if it could be part of the transition process I think it might be helpful for some kids who have anxiety about that the first day great thank you um and then regarding eth to nth grade transition and I don't know if there's going to be an answer to the question or if it's more of a statement than a question but you talked about and I've been hearing this a lot in like the field so to speak but everyone talks about how many honors classes your kids have to
070take and I my kid wants to take all honors classes and they have to do that and all those things and it's a culture and it's become the culture and it becomes the feeling in eighth grade and they all talk about it so I respect everything you said tonight and I hope that's what is being said when they come in here I just don't know how we break that spell because there's it's a two it's a two-prong problem and there's some people have told me that and my kid does not have a stigma but other kids have the stigma where they don't want to drop a class and they're going to stay in the honors class because they're afraid what people will say if they drop it and the other part of the sword is
071they're taking too many and they have nowhere to go from there and they're totally overwhelmed but they feel like that's the way and you have to do it so I just I I really appreciate this because it it didn't seem to focus on that as much but I'm con I'm concerned because it's not what I hear anywhere else and not what I've felt as a parent so I hope that we're trying to move away from that and I hope that we really try especially in nth grade and let them like add more and show progress in different things it's really has to change that we put so much pressure to be in all honors all the time and that's the rigor of it and it rigor it could just be high school so I appreciate
072what you said I just really think that there's a lot of stress on the students to and a lot of pressure to perform in that way and that's not necessarily the best way so thank you but I I really just hope that it starts to show with what the kids start to take as opposed to they have to do this so yeah well thank you and and because that's our hope and our hope in the work is that is that we can help students to sort of break you know a little bit of that cycle we understand you know what those external pressures are and we understand what it is to to be a the student and there is so much opportunity here and when there is so much opportunity right and you have this
073buffet in front of you it's hard not to eat everything on the buffet and then you get sick right so it's kind of sort of along those lines so our job and what we're working very intently on is helping students to AC to really acquire the skills right to make those decisions and that's a lot of oural programming and that's why we focus on that so much in the middle level and then and then reinforce it at the high school level um so they gain that self-awareness and that ability to make those those decisions for themselves and they don't socome so much to sort of this peer pressure that you're you're alluding to that might be out there um whether it's you know on either end of of the spectrum um so yeah it's um
074it's a challenge for us um we we understand that this is this is the program we have um and we that's why we continually are working at it and why on an annual basis there's a review for it and uh the reason for sort of starting the presentation was with the four improvements was sort of to make that point that we understand that this is an ongoing sort of um you know issue that we're facing with our kids um and that we got to just stay on top of it so thank you just one more thing I know it's part of the student information that they're getting but it will also be part of the parent orientation that this is that rigor doesn't necessarily mean 75 APS and honors it means what's best for your
075student and works for them yes so it is it is very much part of that presentation especially the March 20th uh incoming parent um orientation the guidance runs um that that those three ideas of just there's something for everyone be kind to yourself and multiple on andof ramps sort of those three um is sort of repeated in every Avenue when we're having this conversation so that we kind of drive that start to drive that messaging home um that begins early in our conversations the eighth grade councils are having that the nth grade councils are and so we try to get that through as much as we can Miss koshia and Mr Greco thank you um for your presentation I just have a couple of quick questions at the high school level um you said that
076ninth grade peer is going to change a little bit allowing kids to take the 05 elective do the kids have to take the 0 five elective or would they be able to have like let's say quote unquote free period in their schedule in nth grade would that be an option for them yes that's an option there there's nothing to say they have to fill that 0.5 credit that could just be an every other day off period okay all right because I'm just thinking it would force a child who's in peer because it they do rigorous activities in peer to force them to take another class so you're saying that they could have in essence a free in ninth grade which would be homework period or whatever they would want to incorporate it at correct and
077and and as you know for some students that that's something that those students would really welcome in in in that transition year because they give them a little breathing room okay and I thank you but I think I'm G I'm going back down to elementary school that was my only High School question thank you Mrs Steinberg as always for all your hard work okay just a couple of quick questions um for the meeting with the directors and principles at each of the upk sites do we do any of those meetings at the upk sites that we don't host post as saset you know that's in our pool of upk um post sites meaning are we articulating with students who are not in our upk about students who are not in our upk no because we
078don't have uh you know numbers of where students may be so right now if a family's registered with our Universal prek we have that connection and the ability to articulate but otherwise um we generally don't kindergarten orientation allows for that opportunity for us to get to know um and speak with families of students who were not in our upk and get to meet the students and assess some of their um early literacy and pre-academic skills thank you and also I had a question about the which I think would still be you the fifth um fifth into sixth grade I know in August there's an optional orientation for the sixth graders what would you say off the top of your head is the percentage of children that show up for that optional orientation would you say
079it's a high number Mid number low number I'm not going to hold you to an exact number just an an estimated number you know I'm not sure I do believe it is well attended um but it is August right before school starts and I know some families are on vacation um which is why it's not you know mandatory it's clearly optional um but I think students do use that opportunity to come in um look where their locker is learn how to get to it follow their schedule meet meet some of their other peers um but I I don't have a number I can find that out I'm just curious because if you haven't had that if you haven't made it up to middle school yet that orientation is actually really key in my opinion because
080I I'm not sure if the parents I I know that they get the information but whether or not they understand that if you're able to be home for that and send your child to that it's so great for them because to not have any other students in the building and be able to just kind of do your thing as a new student and you know uh fiddle around with your locker and just make sure you have everything kind of under control a little bit before you show up I think that's important but I think that's all I have for now but thank you so much for everything okay Mr greo um these are for Mr Steinberg and and literally just going to follow up on on what Miss kushia just said same question about the
081high school uh orientation in August I mean can you ballpark the attendance I mean yeah it's a busy vacation time and there's only one I believe so just curious what kind of turnout there's there's a tremendous turnout um the auditorium is is packed both sessions the auditorium holds 700 or so I mean you you're getting majority of of the kids and um if you come by the school you'll see it's humming you'd feel like school was in session I mean that's how many kids are there so there's there's a lot of kids that are coming strategically planned to you know with the vacations in mind things along that line so we try to do it as late as we can typically happens the day right before uh we bring our teachers back in for their
082superintendent conference day so everyone's heads are sort of back into the school year um so we do get really nice attendance there um in the event that you know we have people who can't make it for whatever reason they still want to come to the school as long as the school's you know open they come they they you know they'll walk they they're classes they'll walk their lockers so you know we do whatever we can to accommodate those that for for some reason might have had a conflict but to your to your initial question in terms of the attendance very well attended and then to I hate to do this again but to jump on Miss abon's Point she commented about uh a culture with respect to taking honors courses for ninth graders I I
083guess the question I would have is you talk about the off-ramp how easy is it to drop a class and how is that process done is a guidance counselor reaching out to the parent is the teacher reaching out to the parent is the student asking to do it just I mean you could even give me an example of how you normally see this happen sure sure so the first part of the question so um the there is no deadline for a drop which is something unique um to saset um one of the advantages we have being a larger district is because of the the the the uh the breadth of the offerings we have those offerings so if you're in in a smaller District let's say you might necessarily have that so if you took
084an honors classes in nth grade student you might have a drop date like you would have at a university you took a course and you have up to a certain date and you have a drop date so you would have a drop date out of an honors course because they would have to make sure that they get their numbers right in all these other sections so they don't crash sections and all kinds of other Master scheduling issues that come along with that our students can stay in those honors courses um as long as they want and there are times where they it could be halfway through the year you know and they've tried they've tried and and we've provided supports and the decisions made you know with the student with the guidance counselor with the
085family to say okay this is not working out let's get them into a situation that they're going to be successful in right we want them to feel success and do that so at that point we' make a change we make a change at that point and they would move into then the appropriate level and then we' put supports in place to make sure that even in that transition that they're not losing out that they're not going to be you know falling behind in that situation as well so we do that work and so in terms of how that happens that can be the Genesis of that can be from the student the student comes to the teacher and says I I don't know that I can do this right um a teacher W will always
086inquire about conversations with parents they always want to know whe they conversations with your parents are your parents aware of this the conversation will have the guidance counselor the guidance counselors will just want to understand why what's the what's the issue we've seen students who drop out of advanced coursework for all sorts of reasons it's not always just because they are not getting a good grade we have students who are getting a in some of these courses and they say it's just too much I've taken on too much I've got to make a shift you know an tically I have a junior in high school right now okay she'll probably get mad at me for saying this she's taking on too much we're trying to adjust that mid year for her and she's an advanced
087coursework right she's bid off a lot and so it happens right they're kids and and so we want them to make these decisions but we want to be there for them and give them every opportunity to be successful so that's why there is no cut off date for the drops it can happen at any time and we can find a place for them in that off-ramp and then we can onramp them to advance coursework again to try and it might be another pathway right so a student may not be finding success in a stem area but they might then say you know what I want to push myself in Humanities area that they W or or not or not because they're focusing on something that's happening outside of school and that's where their interest lies
088so the idea is to help not only the students but the parents to understand and this goes back to this other point is that we're all in this together right and so it's our job as the school to make sure that we're informing and empowering in this process so that students feel that they're empowered and supported to do their best work however they Define that their most rigorous work and that the parents are also informed and the parents aren't feeling as if they don't have a say or they don't have you know control of this uh you know situation and so that's what we we aimed by having this all these different programs and why the PTA has been such a great partner in this to help us reach you know the eighth grade parents
089that was a big you know up that was a big shift we made a few years back where we weren't always inviting eighth grade parents and it was just sort of a conversation that came to why aren't we doing that and we did it and the and we saw the attendance rise and you know and why we're just on that subject the other decision with those curriculum committees the reason they're live streamed is what we notice is much there's much larger attendance when they're live streamed because people don't have to come into the schools so it's easy for them to just click in and listen so we we have more people learning about the different programs I I would recommend we've already filmed you the last two minutes but you should have everyone in this
090District here what you just said because it's really important thank you okay um Miss litan okay great so um this is directly related to what Lynn and Brian were talking about and it's um clearly a culture here that exists um two-part question so we have the orientations we have the streams it's all great um the attendance is great could you elaborate a little more about um on how an individual student course selection for ninth grade happens because the student doesn't get a chance to meet with a guidance high school guidance counselor until the schedule's already done correct so um C me if I'm wrong but the 8th grade subject teachers in eth grade are in communication with the um ninth grade um guidance counselor about the course selection ahead of making the schedule how does
091this in other words is it eighth grade subject teacher let's say science teacher a student and the high school guidance counselor that sort of like meet and talk or is it the conversation that takes place between the subject teacher in eighth grade and a student and a parent perhaps in other words where is the opportunity and who is it on um to educate the incoming ninth grader especially the first time ninth grader especially if it's the oldest um child in the family um is it up to the eighth grade teacher to explain just how rigorous let's say bio honors is going to look and is it the eighth grade teacher's job to explain the timeline of dropping the course and making sure there is a regular Regent level course in the same period in the
092schedule because what we observing a lot of the times is that by the time it it becomes too late to fix things and that's what creates frustration and that's where you find kids that can't handle a class frustrated waning out and realizing they can't or it's too late or they didn't know so how does that look that process of selecting each course subject by subject and also perhaps my second part perhaps it makes sense to kind of like start learning um the answer to question why why why do you want this buy honor so badly your parents want it your peers your friends are all going to take it what is it so some sort of a data perhaps some sort of an understanding why the reasoning behind the motivation behind taking all honors and
093all APS on the menu um so once we perhaps that will alleviate some of that frustration and pressure and and the kids are going to be taking the the um taking on the work that they can handle and succeed at it I'm just trying to think out loud how we could you know help thank you so thank you and so I'll answer the first question and then I'll get through the other two as well so in terms of just the selection the the process what does it look like for an eighth grade student who's going through through this process so an eighth grade student will start their process now in January okay so we mentioned that they have the eighth grade visits to the High School eighth grade students will come they'll see they'll meet
094people in the high school they'll get exposed to the curriculum in the high school so that'll start them thinking in that process that's Then followed by meetings with their guidance counselors now the guidance counselors are getting basically sort of like a recommendation sheet from the teachers the eighth grade guidance counselors so those eighth grade teachers know their students So based upon what they know about their students they make a recommendation and it's just a recommendation it's a teacher recommendation but it is one of the strongest points for us as a data point to understanding the proper placement for a student in ninth grade because that teacher knows them the best so they'll make that recommendation to the guidance counselor now when the parents meet with the guidance counselors or the parents are talking to their
095students at home and I'm sure you you understand this sometimes those conversations can go away from a recommendation know they can go towards a recommendation right and in the district the parent the students have right to to courses right so even as a teacher recommendation it doesn't preclude them for signing up for the for a different course right so if I'm a a student in eth grade and my teacher says to me okay Dave you can you you I think you're going to be best fit for the bio regions course and I go home and my mother says oh no no no you're going to honors right and then they call up in the meeting of the guidance Council says no you're going to honors I want I want them in honors okay well the
096the guidance counselor can have that conversation with the parents and try to you know talk to the parent about what the best placement is but at the end of the day the family is going to make that decision the guidance council is not going to make that decision right does that make sense so right so that kind of goes into your second part of you know so why aren't some of these students being successful at that point and you're saying sort of you know when it's too late um The Hope is that this when the system's working properly right that there is timely communication from teachers home to teachers to the guidance counsels as term of of progress of a student so at the first sign of some a student that's struggling in any course
097there should be communication it shouldn't wait there should be emails and phone calls home that's the timely communication and that's when conversations need to start and then through that process that's where we have our mtss process that committee that those students can be recommended should interventions be needed so we shouldn't have too many cases where where it's a too late of the situation right where the guidance counselors come in at the high school they do come in early in the process remember in December there's the the what we call the articulation meeting and it's at that meeting which happens at the high school your eighth grade counselors uh will meet with your ninth with your high school counselors okay it gives them an opportunity eventually they they establish their own relation they have long-standing relationships
098so that they can talk about their case loads and they can talk about the coursework and the rigor of that cour work so a lot of our counselors in eth grade they're very familiar with the rigor and what's expected you know of those higher level courses and those conversations will be had okay very similar to conversations that will happen with a teacher I'll give you uh a quick example um when a student let's say is in the high school and a student let's say wants to go to Advanced course work who's not in advanced course work that teacher might recommend that that student go talk to that other teacher of the advanced coursework to get a better idea of what the time on task is what it really going to take you know from the
099students responsibility on that and those conversations the conversations counselors and teachers will have with parents so then again going back to Middle School when then so now you have the articulation with the counselors in December then you get to January and now your students will get recommendations from their eighth grade teachers which goes to their eighth grade counselor then students and parents meet with their eth grade counselors to discuss recommendations and overall program decisions then will start being made on what's the appropriate program for that student at that point so again when when I talked earlier about it's sort of everybody's in that conversation that's a conversation with the school with the parent with the student to say okay this is what we believe is going to bring your students success as they transition to
100high school and the idea of having the supports in high school is so when it doesn't go right for whatever reason because there's so many variables to why something like that wouldn't go right um that we have the proper supports whether they're academic you know Behavioral or if they're mental health supports that they're there to help the student be successful and again make any kind of corrective action if to make that point Mr dri thank you um Mr Steinberg um I've been listening and thinking a lot about the way you're describing the way the process ought to work in your opinion who is currently the quarterback for the students in terms of understanding and having a sense of the total course load work that's going to be required for students for their own curriculum is
101it the students who are responsible the parents the guide counselor it's a collaborative process who's ultimately the person in with the most information about what is being put in front of the students so I would say that responsibility relies on us as the school meaning our counselors and our teachers to relay the information and to inform students and parents to empower them to understand that information and that's going to happen on the front line with the teacher first the teacher teacher understanding that if I'm going to be sending you to an honors course in 9th grade what that's going to entail and if I'm a guidance counselor that when on meeting with the student to also understand that and that's the purpose of those articulations those yearly articulation meetings is to make sure that the
1028th grade guidance counselors are not missing anything that nothing changed at the high school if they have any questions so at that meeting what will happen in that December meeting We'll have each one of our department heads there who will go through the the the courses in that Department as just a reminder typically and then sometimes as you know we have new courses or we have shifts in curriculum that have to be reviewed so the eighth grade guidance council is understand that and the teachers get it too so to answer your question the responsibility to inform is going to fall on our teachers and our guidance counselors right support from Administration and but there is also responsibility for the students and the families to understand that and do their best to make the best decision
103of whether or not they feel their student can handle that level of work at whatever level that might be sure so ultimately each individual Middle School teacher makes a recommendation but none of the other Middle School teachers see the other recommendations that are being made so ultimately it's an individualized recommendation and only the counselor the parent and the student understand what the total uh commitment that they're being asked to make is one of the things that I find interesting is is that it doesn't sound like we're providing parents with anything other than sort of a trust me this is really rigorous bits of information so for example why don't we advertise the average workload in a course at the time in terms of hours uh of commitment a week why aren't syllabi available for students
104when they're making their consideration decisions for uh discussions I guess I'm not sure that students and parents are making informed consent and that may be what's leading to this race to the bottom mhm yeah two great points two great points um we we um have embarked uh this year on a complete curriculum guide review um that we've been reviewing the guides um we are looking at the guides uh for uh improvements in terms of exactly what you're talking about um where are those points where we can further Empower parents this idea of um that you brought up about um uh being more explicit about the workload in an advanced course um would be helpful to parents those are conversations that we are in currently about what that might look like and how we need to
105present that um and even the idea of of of a scope and sequence on our courses um to help further Empower as well so um these are conversations we are in and I think they're they're great suggestions um and to the earlier point that this is a a process for us the 8 to9 transition um and that we're always seeking that next Improvement and so um um these are both duly noted and I appreciate the recommendation thank you I have a few more things that I'm curious about in your assessment do you think there is greater friction for students to move themselves up in difficulty or move themselves down in difficulty in other words when students come to their guidance counselors either for the initial meeting or subse meetings and they say no no no
106no I need to be in seven honors classes out of five or no no no I want to drop down from five honors classes to zero how easy or difficult in other words which way does the friction push I I believe that's really a student by student um answer so it's relatively easy to move down in difficulty and relatively easy to move up in difficulty in an individual course roughly equ I think it's on individual student how that transition works and when that's going to happen so um I don't know it's such a black and white answer to that um for students I do think the jump from uh one level to a higher level is is is when you're not accustomed to that higher level is a very difficult move to make well I'm
107thinking just in terms of course selection not in terms of performance in other words I walk in and I say nope I disagree with all these recommendations I want to do whatever I want I want to go into um regular classes or nope I want to go into all honors classes or I just want to move around which way does the friction push that is easier or harder to move maybe you can help me understand what you mean by which way is it equally easy to change your courses higher as it is to move them lower yeah I think the conversation at that point if if you're coming in looking to change courses I think the conversation that that you're going to hear from our guidance counselors is that they're going to talk to you
108for what's the best interest of your child based upon those teacher recommendations based upon prior performance and so you're going to have a conversation about that so I I would say that it's probably and if you if you you know push me on an answer but I would say that in my opinion that it was probably harder to go to the higher level course as opposed to you know go to the lower level course okay and two more quick questions hopefully they'll they um I'll be more articulate in them in your assessment do you think we should be allowing students and parents to overrule recommendations or not I think that what's really important in this process is that it is a collaborative process and I think it's very important that the parent typically will know
109their child best and that we need to value that opinion in the process so my my opinion and my view on that is that we need to value that voice and we need to have very intentional conversations with parents to help them maybe understand a recommendation in more depth to help them ask ask the right questions but again I think it's a matter of empowering parents in that conversation with the professionals at the school to make sure that together we're making a decision that's in the best interest of the student okay and my last question to you is in your assessment how do you think we are doing with our transition from 8th to 9th grade and what is that based on specifically the reason I'm asking this question is um I note with interest
110that the articulation committee you're describing is internal staff only where you're making the noted improvements and changes that we've made year-over-year the Curiosity that I have is how do we know or why do we think we are doing a good or not doing a good job in transition so I think part of that is we look for certain data points that we can sort of jump off of to tell us a story um and I think that's why we started tonight's presentation with with some of the the data that we looked at and not to say that that data is is the end all be all and that's going to tell us that we're being successful but that is just a point of many points that we can look to and say okay there's a
111story being told here that we do have students taking uh more risk rigorous uh Advanced coursework and we do have fewer drops and we have all of these programs and systems in place and we have a system that we continue to look to where we can improve we also meet with students um so we just recently had a meeting with our Student Government um we met with them and we specifically talked about the 8 to n transition we asked them about and and we had a lot of ninth graders in the room um we do this every year we talk with them about what that looks like what that feels like um so that gives us as as a focus group another data point in which we can understand what the real experience of the
112students were and I'll will tell you that this year we had the conversation it was great I mean what the students told us that the number one factor for them in their transition was having access to older students they said that was the best part of their transition when they came to the incoming nth grade orientation and they were given the um the Tour by the the peer leader kids um they were able to talk to them and get and ask them what you know they'll say the real questions right because they hear the information from the adults but when they start hearing it from from the other kids it it resonates differently with them and that sort of was the impetus to the idea of bringing the eighth graders into the high school starting
113tomorrow and having the peer leader take them around in their groups to classes not have teachers do that so they can then begin to talk more about what the experience is like we see an increase in clubs we see an increase in number of students involved in student activities in athletics these are all other data points points where we say that our students are transitioning well into the high school and they're finding success so we do look at that but with that said we don't rest on that because we also understand that pressures seem to be rising on on on kids every single day and we understand that and it's why that we constantly are reviewing this process to make sure that we are doing everything we can to stay ahead of that and to
114make sure they're having the easiest transition into high school that they could have okay are there any more questions Dr Park thank you I love your three points in high school I wrote them down um something for everyone be kind to yourself and um multiple on and off ramp it's fantastic um and I wish that they will hear about this before before they come to high school and um get into the habit of not stressing out I believe when middle school students eighth graders anticipate on going to high school their initial reaction is it's going to be so hard there already stressed but this three points is amazing and if they have this they know about this beforehand and the culture is different in the Middle School going on to high school maybe they won't
115be so stressed and they won't feel like okay I have to take all honors class starting ninth grade because it's going to be difficult whatever you know knowing that you have many opportunities to go up or down you don't have to stress yourself initially so see how you're doing and then see if you want to go up or down there are multiple steps opportunities for you to do that you're not locked in but then that knowledge has to be um somehow well known in Middle School not when they get into high school I think um and I love you are acting I know our school as a whole district is working on self advocate for our students and I I'm so happy that we are encouraging that and uh especially in high school because that's
116when they really can and should learn to self- advocate um and I'm wondering when they when they are not experienced when they don't know how to ask is there multiple venue for ninth graders to address their concern not in a way that is um that not in a way that may be most effective but somebody can guide them to do that and is that also well known to the students is is that a common knowledge among students that if they have this issue you need to go to this person or that person or uh or all teachers equipped trained to pick that pick up on the uh students hint that they need help and they can guide them to uh do self advocation for themselves okay so um I would love to take credit for
117the three points but but the three points really has something that developed in both the middle and the high schools o over the last few years and uh and I have to say that Chris rafini does a tremendous job when he hosts the articulation meeting and he focuses on those three points with the eighth grade guidance counselors and they use that language so the language is being used in the eth grade um but I do hear you we could always Market that language you know more and get that out there but just so you're aware it is already in there in the in the eth grade um the same piece with the self- advocacy a lot of the the the Middle School curriculum programming is about at that age is about teaching the middle schoolers
118how to self- advocate for themselves become more self-aware and who do you go to in terms of um where we are in do the teachers understand how to help those students that don't necessarily yet know how to self- Advocate and I would say the answer to that is yes um we do an annual training to make sure that teachers are reminded on what is the mtss process you know and then and how do you access the Professionals in the building to get to that process how do you help guide students to the proper Professionals in the building should they should they need to go you know know who to go to so that is an annual training that goes on the building um every building with their assistant principles primarily who are managing all the
119student affairs are constantly a presence in in the hallways as you know um they're creating relationships with the kids and they become the schoolwide presence you know to to help that and that's that's wonderful support because then that winds up where a teacher says you know sees an administrator hallway and says oh uh Mr Steinberg I I was going to come see you about you know uh my student here uh but now that I got you I just want to run something by you and that's when a lot of times the process oh okay so tell me more and then and then we start to pull people into conversations along that way so there is training that happens annually on annual basis so that teachers are reminded and also um refreshed on on on the
120processes that we have in place we have an an mtss districtwide committee that meets so we're constantly reviewing the mtss process and updating that process to make sure that that's up to date and that we're not missing anything there either so we're we're constantly in in in this this sort of stance of we need to continually just stay on top of things look for the improvements because our kids change right their needs are constantly changing so we've got to make sure we're on top of it m dri Mr Ro thank you thank you Mr Steinberg um so I had a student my older daughter went through the whole system um and there's a lot of the mechanics of course load what classes do we take is there a lot of is there you know is
121this a good teacher is not a good teacher so I guess maybe from just looking at the pure mechanics of it like I'm trying to step back and saying okay you're checking off all these boxes but are you learning anything like are you walking away like if you asked I remember asking one of the kids I was like oh have you read any books and they're like no no no we don't have time to read books we have to just get through all the course load so I'm kind of taking a step back in the 30,000 feet is to say hey are you taking a class that you enjoy and that you're going to actually learn something great you checked off all these boxes but are we going back to kind of saying hey you
122know what achievement at school is not just because you took five APS uh achievement at school can be many things so um I heard an example recently where they had a project at school where they had group of kids just like you would do either in college or at work which is not like Dave how did you do on the test and they'd say well that's not how it works at work it works that we all collaborate we all work together so they had a project where they had five students um and they had to write an essay for the Roman Empire but the other thing they had to do was they actually had to build a physical model so all of the kids had to kind of figure out one how to work together
123and maybe yeah you're you're the best reader maybe you could do math def fesses but you have those other skills where you have tactile skills you could build stuff you could work in a group all of these other skills that you need to do in the real world but then also now we have to take into consideration that the kids are just going to look stuff up on chat GPT and use artificial intelligence so now are we then saying look it's okay you're not cheating um this is a way you can utilize your skills quicker um and kind of use all these other tools out there um so I know those are just my thoughts because at the end of the day you want kids that are curious that want to learn that are nice
124um that are going to be able to work with others that's how you're going to succeed and then understand these other tools it it's wonderful points and I think we're we're we're at a point education where we have a tremendous opportunity and as as you're aware you know New York state is talking about uh you know changing graduation measures uh we're slowly getting more and more information about what the portion of a graduate's going to look like in New York state um that's going to provide us some opportunities to be creative in and around um not only the program how we offer it but how we assess it and that's what exactly what you're talking about so that we move away potentially from you know just the standardized testing that we're doing all the time
125and it just becomes you know you lose some of the the love of learning in that process where what you're referring to more of this project based learning is where students really could dig into an interest and a passion right and apply their skill to that and they're being assessed not necessarily on what they know and what they can just regurgitate to us but they are demonstrating that they have these skills right so we we can have a whole another conversation about the portion of the graduate and about what those components look like you know when we talk about students becoming effective communicators and what what are the you know the attributes and skills that they need to to learn to become an effective Communicator which is transferable across all industry right and and all
126life frankly right so yeah I think that that's where we are in this conversation and I'm and that's what I'm hearing tonight is is this idea about us you know trying to see this cultural shift you know away from the pressures of let's just take all these honors and APS and and to use some of the language that was used sort of this race to Nowhere sort of thing and and let's get to wait a minute let's get to teaching you know what what is a what do we want to see uh as a graduate of sasid high school and what and what is that human being uh you know what are they able to do what is their skill set what kind of human beings are we are we graduating right as opposed to
127you know what kind of you know just solely what kind of college they go to and that's is important as well but but begin to have that conversation and I think we have that opportunity ahead of us um you know as the state you know begins to give us more information about the graduation measures I had spoken to recently someone like a hiring manager and I asked him I said what do you look for you know when kids come out of college and he said honestly he's like we have kids that have great uh you know have great GPA uh went to Great Schools but he goes but they not work ready and then we're looking for hardcore skills now so you know kids will walk in and say well look I I did all
128the things that you asked me to I got a high GPA I did an internship I did all these things and then and then the companies are like well we don't need that we want so you know we kind of have to reverse engineer because everything is changing so quickly yeah yeah and that and that's the work ahead of us and that's we're we're going to dig into that work for sure thank you yep all right thank you so just questions anyone have more anyone questions okay Mr asri Dr Rogers So based on this presentation what is well a few things how do you assess our transitions in elementary and also into High School the same questions I've asked the other presenters and what is that based on you have more than one question or
129do you want to like hit me okay so um as with both of them it's uh their answers were we use data and we do some anecdotal work and I use the same two data points so um a lot of I'm encouraged by the board's discussion because I think what we were trying to do right now this evening was surface a lot of the work that we have been doing as a team uh and show the Arc of that progress so as we look at uh kids taking rigorous courses but not finding that they're struggling to the point where they need to drop it or have we done a better job of supporting them in those courses so that the work is not all falling on the students we're seeing more success in those courses
130that illustrates that we've made some good uh decisions and changes over time uh one anecdotal observation is part of the impetus for starting this process at looking at the 8 go9 transition uh came from my own transition here to saset and living the Four Seasons through my first two years here before deciding to make some more more muscular changes to things that uh I had found as that were typical practices soset was a successful School District when I arrived and making dramatic changes to successful institutions should be done cautiously but uh and Mr Steinberg alluded to this I was surprised to see how narrow the role for the e8th grade parent was in building the ninth grade course selections almost a non-existent role um unless a parent had an older sibling and knew to be
131involved in that process there really wasn't a formal uh or intentional way of incorporating the parents into that and what I was learning anecdotally was that often kids would advise one another on how to build those schedules so uh a lot of the work in this 8 to9 transition was trying to uh Empower parents create formal places for them to work uh on to be included in that process and for them to feel a sense of satisfaction in the schedules that were then built for their students and I've gotten a lot of anecdotal but positive feedback about some of those changes and these changes are now SE six seven years old uh but they've sort of they're now almost we can't imagine a time when we didn't do that but we did and we're as
132Mr Steinberg said constantly iterating this uh to make it stronger so uh it is US philosophy My Philosophy is not that we should Chase rankings not that we should Chase test scores not that we should Chase numbers of kids getting accolades Etc but we should do really good education and if we do really good education all those other things will take care of themselves so again not necessarily focused spe specifically on the transitions but if you look at our 3-9 testing data over a long Arc that we've made steady gains and we've made steady gains in subgroups as well uh not because we're chasing the gains for their own sake but because I think we're making smart incremental changes to the program and constantly building on that success so all of those things together are
133reflected in our outputs but those outputs are the sum of lots of those changes made in in several different Dimensions um and I'll just um comment on you know Dr Park expressed enthusiasm for the the three points um and I just want to comment on those three points the point about their being something for everyone is to illustrate that there are lots of ways to be successful in saset not all of them academic so uh trying to have an incredible bread of extracurricular activities available to kids hopefully show illustrates for students that there are lots of things that they can do that they enjoy but that there are ways of being successful those things that they can do uh being kind to yourself um is asking students to have an executive function conversation with themselves
134which is to see their own big picture and that is part of self- advocacy but it is also part of uh their executive function work and then the multiple onramps and off-ramps one of my uh early learnings in soset was that the prerequisites were very rigid and so what that did um from an eth to 9th transition perspective is it meant that if you wanted to take a certain class as a senior you were left with no choice but to take XYZ class as a nth grader so as an eighth grader you were making decisions based on what you imagined you might not want to for close as an opportunity to yourself as a senior and that was driving your decisions around 9th grade so we did a lot of work um again this is
135all pre-pandemic work on this on-ramp off-ramp um idea and it required a lot of surgery on prerequisites uh in order to make it possible to have onramps easy to have off-ramps for more rigorous course work much more challenging as Mr Steinberg alluded to to have ramps into more challenging coursework particularly later in high school but we wanted to make that a possibility so it would take some of the pressure off of the nth grade transition so each of those things was strategic and then just last um a comment on Mr Rolo's uh observation about project-based learning and the the best learning is the learning that is retained and a lot of how the state has structured Success Through the existing and previous graduation requirements has measured Success Through short-term retention of largely factual knowledge and
136I think we're all recognizing that we're moving towards a world where skills are more important than the ability to retain uh for a short term factual knowledge and then produce that factual knowledge in some sort of an assessment so we've been making lots of transitions K through 12 at identifying places where we can have uh cross-curricular work um uh transdisciplinary work and work that uh students perform in groups and in Project based learning because we believe that that the learning is better retained and it develops more skills and the future will prioritize less um the regurgitation of specific factual knowledge so that's a long answer to a question about how do you assess the success of the 8 to9 transition but to me I can't tease out that one thing from all these other initiatives
137because I think they're all interdigitated and uh part of a whole so I'm I'm going to agree with you in the sense that over the long Arc of what we're trying to accomplish that makes sense however what I'm trying to get from you is this is a presentation for us to make make an assessment about whether or not we're going in the right direction or the wrong direction what do I come to understand from this presentation in terms of information that helps us set strategic direction or goals or information or priorities or anything that tells me whether or not we're going in the right or the wrong direction I I I mean I think we're going in the right direction right I hope we are it sounds like we are but I don't have any
138dat dat that tells me that the 8th to 9th transition is being effectively executed here I I think it is I don't know you must think it is can you give me some thing that I can use to help make recommendations for you right that's our role um so this is actually something that is not looking for Direction but responding to Direction the board has already given to us so the um goal of reducing the number of students who uh dropped from honors classes has been a longstanding goal of the board for at least six seven years and in trying to achieve that goal a lot of these other needs have been uncovered the need about how the 8th to 9th transition Works uh better understanding the role of prerequisites and how it drives the
139schedules better understanding what supports are in place for students who are taking challenging cour work um extra help isn't uh extra help is for everybody you can have support while you're taking rigorous courses in order to be more successful so the one thing that we've observed is that we could do a better job with the e8th to 9th transition you ask is it better I think it's a lot better now than it was for 5 years ago and I think after the changes that we've made this year it will be better still and I think from the vantage point of reflecting on this year's changes we'll probably have ideas for additional changes that we'll want to implement in the coming years but I would not say that we're at the beginning of this process I
140would say I'm reporting to you on a process that has been underway for a while and is continuing to iterate I haven't seen any of the iterations that we've made so far that I want to Retreat from because they have failed to achieve what we hypothesized they would accomplish in fact I think they've all achieved what we thought they would do and so we're going to evaluate the uh four or five changes that Mr Steinberg referred to this in this presentation they're about to be underway starting tomorrow and we'll report back to you again and say we hear you Bor you want us to do thoughtful work with these transitions you want us to do thoughtful work so that students can maximize their potential without burning themselves out at the same time we hear you
141on that here's what we're doing about it and I'll come out so I think I've been given a lot of direction from the board this is reporting back on how We're translating that uh direction from the board into actual changes in practice in the district okay thank okay M Brinson I'm sorry I know it's been a long conversation but there are just two concerns I wanted to bring up before we before we're done um the drop rate of classes my concern is while it looks like it's plateauing I think a factor in the in that and that should be considered is that kids don't drop classes because there's not room always to drop a class without rearranging your entire schedule um or there's no room to drop the class at all and so they ends
142up staying in the class and it requires extra help on the part of the parents and tutors and all these other things and they ends up staying there so I just would like that that's definitely at play I've heard it a few times because they don't want to move their whole schedule around they end up staying in the honors the AP whatever it is and overcompensating for it um the other concern I had was about the onramp off ramp and you talked about PRX and I think you were talking about core classes but my concern is kids are still going to pick um not what's it uh classes like different for the Pathways in in term I'm sorry I'm not speaking English in terms of the pathways because we have now started looking at these
143Pathways as the way to go instead of dipping your toe in a million different things and trying photography and trying Tech and trying uh engineering and business where they're almost set they're setting their path in ninth grade to take all the electives to get the pathways and the micro things and that's my concern also because it feels very college and high school so um I know one of the things and Mr Steinberg alluded to this in his presentation the high school works very hard to do is to have step down classes that are running the same period as the Honors that what may happen is even though we leave room in those step down classes if there are two or three other kids that may have uh dropped the honors class prior to you dropping
144it they may have exhausted the room that remains in those classes but it is a very intentional process of having a region class at the same time as the honors class so that there is a place for students to make that choice uh but the later it is in the year uh the more challenging that becomes but what we've never done is um as again we talked about earlier said that this is the final date after today's date we won't let you it's more typical in school districts that they cut it off after about 2 weeks into the school year because they want to finalize their schedules and firm things up and master schedules are complicated and particularly in smaller places it's harder to have lots of sections of regions classes that are not completely
145filled so that you have room for uh students who come in so we have an asset because of our size but even that asset can be exhausted uh at times but it's certainly something we can look at in terms of uh data to see if there are classes that we we can find out whether we're leaving enough room based on historical data and maybe there's a a possibility for us to calibrate that a little bit better um the I think it's a really good point about uh the pathways and on the one hand we're offering students a benefit that they've never had before the micr credentials on the other other hand what we don't want to do is narrow their choices as freshmen uh if not because of what they want as seniors because of
146what they want as microc credentials so um we do have uh planned a presentation on the State's new graduation requirements for you as a board and I think that that conversation this conversation leads right into that assessment of what those new graduation requirements will be and how we as saset tailor ourselves towards it but I do think that um although there's requirements for a handful of courses it's not like you have to take six or seven courses to to be in those Pathways as a major there's still a lot of time in the schedule for students but we can certainly talk about um where that time comes from and you know how students will make those choices early on U one of the things we kind of glanced over it in the presentation but uh
147inviting students in Middle School to take navat uh assessment will help them see where their skills and strengths are but also where their interests are and that may help steer those conversations as well so that uh as they're doing Explorations they're exploring things that are likely to become uh skills that they want to pursue not to narrow their choices but to help them again kind of reflect on themselves as Learners and say what are the things I like to do uh so that they invest their time in things that are likely to be things they want to pursue more okay thank you thank you again thank you both for the presentation okay and then I'm going to uh do the next one then yes this is also a topic um and thank you Mr Steinberg
148Dr wiic appreciate it um Dr rufo is going to present to us on school Food Services um as the board is well aware uh we changed uh providers of uh Food Services uh this year having had Aramark as our food service provider since about 2019 uh we um are required to do an RFP uh by law uh this is a highly regulated um area of School District Operations but in terms of uh the long Arc of where we are going as a school district uh one of the things that the facilities projects that we're undertaking at the elementary schools will do is they'll create a lot more square footage at the elementary schools and some of that square footage in the future will uh ease congestion that might make it more possible for us to
149have much more extensive food preparation facilities at elementary schools so uh I think now is a ideal time to start making uh long-term uh decisions about how we might want to take advantage of that opportunity at some point in the future I think uh all of us want our students to have uh the mostut nurious most appealing and safest school lunches possible and it's a a complicated undertaking and there are lots of ways to do it uh all of those ways come with advantages and disadvantages and this is one of those things where um you have to calibrate between uh the advantages that you want to pursue and the challenges that will come along with um whichever path you choose okay thank you um before before I get into any of the details of the
150options that are available to us I just wanted to clarify the governance because I think it helps to explain um some of the program structure and really some of the challenges that we face so we are um our district all of our schools are part of the national school lunch program and that's a federal program and it's administered by the US Department of Agriculture and so they set most of the rules for the program and then we have um New York State education department uh the Child Nutrition unit and they're the agency that we interact with that administers the federal program in New York so they can they set um the rules for us and we deal with them um on compliance issues and a variety of of of issues and they provide essentially um
151two models um of offering Food Services um in schools and there's slight variations but let's just stick to these um these two now the first which is um which is on the left is the Food Service management company and that's kind of the model we have um right now in in saset and that involves a um a company that um manages all aspects of the program for you you and similar to all other um service providers that districts use we have to purchase those through a bidding process and even more complicated and regulated is we have to use New York State's template for bids and that bid prescribes almost all aspects of the program and we are able to modify it and we certainly do we modify it um essentially to improve the quality of
152food that we have we specify the types of ground beef we specify that we don't want fillers we specify the type of chicken the grade of cheese the type of fruit how often per week so it's we get very detailed and then when you make those adjustments or modifications to the contract it goes to New York State and then they have to approve it again and then we go out to bid and then the award goes um to the lowest bidder and and um on Long Island there are essentially two biders um uh two main that have been around for a long time aramar and witzens and they've both been in um uh in the district and um on in Nassau County about 29 districts use this food service management um company model and if
153I would have to say the overarching advantage would be that you're Contracting with a company in those two cases that has National experience and expertise in the in the provision of Food Services if we go to the self-operated side that involves the school district managing inhouse all of the aspects of the program and that would be um recruiting our HR department would do all the hiring the training all the supervision procurement meal planning all of it and districts that are self-operated typically hire a food service director to manage all of those aspects of the program and there are now 24 districts in Nassau County that have in-house programs and if we wanted to hold on take a look at what would be the most um the greatest advantage to a self-operated program I think we
154would say that that was related to um greater control and flexibility of all aspects or specific aspects um of the program so to try to get a sense of um the variety and the quality of the food which is clearly one of the most important factors in a food service program we took a look at about 53 school districts in Nassau County that post their menus online we um to try to get a sense of a window into the variety and the quality that they offer and so what we found was there's a lot of consistency I guess it's not surprising across districts in what they offer and up you know up at the top you can see it's the you know the typical kids kids favorites but what we also did see is that
155the food service management companies tend to on a given day to have more options for kids on the self-operated side we did find three districts um that kind of shared that level of variety on a given day and then you can also see that a handful of districts on less than a handful maybe a handful altogether a couple on self op a couple Food Service management companies offer Halal and kosher saset seemed to be the only one that offered both Halal and kosher also seeing more um plant-based um options as as well there are some um I would say structurally and organizational structural and organizational aspects um that do differentiate and may impact the quality of of food in in the schools and I think that both Food Service management companies and self-operated um they
156want to provide meals that um meet the needs of kids that are that are nutritional and um the difference here as I said before seems to be the more control that a self-operated program has and I have the example of asai balls to kind of demonstrate the difference which um a couple of years ago they became very very popular and um through a meeting with the kids they said oh can't we have aai Bol so we met with the contractor at the time and they could do it but couldn't make it as part of a a lunch which is what we wanted it to be so that all kids could participate so we were able to write it into the next bid specs now had we been in a self-operated we might have been able
157to introduce that um more quickly so it enabled it enables you to be a little bit more flexible a little bit more um more responsive another difference is the way that both of these um models purchase so Food Service management companies represent lots of schools they purchase from National networks for their network of schools so they have access to Broad uh broad menus U menu items and probably achieve a uh economies of scale food um self op districts usually bid they must bid um but they usually bid in cooperatives with each other the Food Service management companies have um in they invest in R&D they have incentives for continuous Improvement they want to drive sales and and profit and so that's that's good in terms of their they're looking for new products to to um
158to bring but you also have to be careful that you know profit maximization doesn't come at the expense of providing nutritious meals for kids um self up districts have less of the profit pressure but that's not to say that they too aren't concerned about bottom line because you need to have a program that is sustainable and um financially uh stable so both um self op and Food Service management companies um all fall under the same overarching rules and regulations and they if I didn't if I emphasize it enough in the beginning they are plentiful and they should be because they're protecting kids right and we are regulated by federal state and local laws they got guide all aspects of the program from the nutritional content of the food the meal portions the meal servings that
159are given all of the food handling and safety requirements and then food allergens uh food allergies are so important and um that information must be accessible to parents and available as well as nutritional information and we have been pleased this year with our new company um feedback from parents um about the um integrated easy to use allergy information that's available um through their system there are also facilities requirements we get inspected by Nassau County Department of Health they're looking at the water temperature making sure that um looking at the cleanliness the vents all of that and then of course we have the free and reduced um lunch program and all of those rules and regulations so saset um as Dr Roger says witson is the current Food Service management um company um they followed Aramark
160that was in the district for five years and Food Service management companies when they win the bid it is an annual bid that can be renewed for five years and is typical for districts to renew assuming things are are going well for um for a five year and then for five years and then they must go out to bid we offer a full breakfast and lunch program in all of the secondary schools as you know the elementary schools don't have kitchens so meals are prepared in the high school and hbt kitchens and then they are satellited to the elementary schools and they we do that through a variety of the um hot and cold cambros where the food is loaded and then it goes into delivery trucks and then the trucks go into the warming
161and the cooling stations at the elementary schools and um that does limit the satellite program limits a bit the types of things that can successfully transport um or transport well without diminishing in quality um but certain things um that the kids like like grilled cheese isn't ideal um melty products are not ideal so we were very pleased last year to be able to install the countertop pizza ovens in all of the elementary schools so at least on Fridays there's cooking in the elementary school assembling the pizzas so they get um better quality pizzas starting last year and as Dr Roger said the capital work in the ele elementary schools that's um underway could expand um kitchens and the on-site uh meal prep opportunities for the future labor is after after food is is probably the
162next key element of um of a food service program and the food service industry exper has been experiencing labor shortages and that's been happening in both sop and um and for Food Service management companies and there's um many districts um are experiencing um persistent vacancies as well as as high turnover we have some um man uh some employees that have been with us for years and have stayed even though management companies have changed and they've been in the district for a while but when you have a food service management company they um control all aspects of the hiring and the training and the supervision and the employees work directly for for them um they're not subject to the Civil Service rules so they may they have greater flexibility in employment actions the self-operated typically they
163hire um the HR department hires all aspects of the hiring and the training and the employees work directly for the district they're going to be subject to the Civil Service rules and potentially collective bargaining agreements and that could prolong um employment actions and typically make it more expensive oops we also just uh took a uh did a comparison of the meal prices and found that overall meal prices were higher in the self-operated districts and again that likely related to the higher labor costs and perhaps the food cost as well lunch prices were 3 to 4% % higher um in the self-operated and at breakfast it was between 11 to 23% higher but um in saset breakfast accounts for a very small um proportion maybe under 10% of the total meals that that are served and
164um I have the soset um breakfast and lunch price up there as well and also wanted to note in looking at other District menus um they typically or occas Al will'll um charge premiums for they call them premium meals like B's head and the Halal and kosher and scasa does not um have premium prices or charge extra for for those meals whether you're a um a self-operated or a food have a contractor your program revenues need to be sufficient to C every year expenditures and in addition there should be some profit left over because you want to be able to have some money left over to invest in the program so that's through fund balance which is leftover that accumulates over time that's how we were able to buy all of our serving lines for
165our elementary schools all the equipment and then last year we purchased new serving lines for our middle schools so management company because there's a predict predictable Financial term you pay a meal price that um increases um with CPI um and it's a fixed price you're it's a little more stable the contract also calls for a guaranteed return so that they can't really go in the red because that's part of their their contract the self-operated has a uh a bit more financial volatility they have to go out to bid each year um for food so they're subject to fluctuations in that way some districts that are self-operated um need to have allocations from the general fund to make their program whole so in other words their programs don't run um in the they basically are in
166the red so they need to take general fund money from um and transfer it to to close that Gap and in the districts that we looked at we saw general fund contributions that range from just 24,000 to 457,000 we did find um a couple of schools um several in Westchester that are what we termed off program meaning they're not participating in the national school lunch so that means they don't have to follow the uh school lunch rules but they also don't receive any of the benefits of being in the program such as reimbursement for meals or um government Commodities and and things like that so I thought it would just be useful to just show if you can see a a menu from one of those schools and so you can see that they have
167things that um other districts in are in our menu review didn't have like sushi a salmon meal um but you can also see that their prices are significantly more than the you know the $3.15 that that saset um charges and this is not a this is not common and it's typically not um viable for most districts but I just wanted um to make you aware of it so in in looking at this data there are um there are ways to address the um food food quality food consistency um and variety with with both methods um it really um also has to be considered I I guess I would call them logistical means when you look at Labor Personnel determining which is the structure that can more efficiently and effectively um work for for districts which
168is the structure that can better maintain um food allergy information and consistently provide it to parent and all of that in light of what are the financial factors and what are the implications on the prices that um families pay for school meals and then the viability of the um of the program just longterm um in terms of uh Financial stability so that's a um an overview of the two uh two and then that third off program is another example okay thank you Dr rro for the presentations and at this point are there any questions from the board Mr [Music] greo uh just a couple of questions thank you Dr rufo you you mentioned there's 24 districts um right now that uh that I guess are what do you call them self up mhm um are
169any of those do you know our size you know 7,000 or so kids up yes do you know if any of the self op schools sort of have a hybrid or is this an All or Nothing in other words could we do this at elementary but continue to use a provider for secondary the the Prototype contract I believe has two um areas that would prohibit that one is um a provision against competitive Foods so you wouldn't give a contract to a um management company and then have other Foods that's prohibited um the other piece is that any material change to the bid would would not be permissible so in other words if you're bidding only for secondary schools and you get a provider you then cannot run your self op at your elementaries because you'd
170be bidding to buy food separately it's a tricky one I that my question was actually do we know if any of the self up schools run a hybrid so I'm just curious if schools have done that I'm not aware of any Hybrid models um one of the other things you talked about was was food quality um and you had up the chart and it was actually it was more about variety right and talking about how there's more variety if we use a provider I'm I'm wondering if what you were alluding to is that if we were self up we would have you you could assume a better uh or a higher quality of food because we wouldn't be buying through you know a provider on these National um you know bids we would be able
171to Source local food and I'm assuming that means it's higher quality but I think that's what you were getting at um I wouldn't say I don't know that I would characterize it that way let me um local versus na uh National for example we have we currently um our food service management company buys their bagels from Bagel boss it's in our spec that you know we spec out a a specific type of bagel and it's a local bagel and so there's other Bakery products so when we look at um when we look at a self-operated district they they they have to do bids and go with the lowest bidder as well so I don't know that my example what I was alluding to is flexibility more so than necessarily the quality although you would have
172so you can the control on the quality is in the bid specs whether that description is in a bid that you're doing with a Cooperative in a self-operated district as part of a Cooperative you're writing bid specs for the type of chicken that you want versus when we do the we work on the bid for the state prototype bid and we add specifics about the type of chicken that we would want um all is that no that you you've answered my question I okay want to I mean I don't um and obviously we're not discussing this tonight so I just want to just follow with one other thing and you brought up the bagel um not going to name names but the idea is if we were self-operated would we be able to bid local
173businesses to provide food through our self-operated lunch program could we put a bid out to all the bagel stores and get five bids from local bagel stores and choose one of them so if you um If you bid with a Cooperative as most do I can't you'd have to agree on the type of items so then you would not put your scas at Bagel because if you're bidding with another Regional District they're not going to want necessarily scasa you know a local Bagels store so you would probably bid for that separately if but effectively we could not use the Cooperative bidding process for bagels or pizza or sushi and go that route just questions yes I I would I would imagine that you could I don't I don't know exactly the rules it seems plausible
174but I don't know specifically how the rules of the organization there's a there's an organization of self-operated districts that do the bid I don't know if I it would surprise me that it would be an all or nothing but right now I'd have to say I don't know I'd have to get back to you on that but I suspect if I can I take little stab at this uh because um to put a finer point on what Dr rufo is saying the the purpose we doing this would be to improve quality you know that would that and who wouldn't want that the no matter whether it self-operated or done through a food service management company the trick is defining what quality means so we can't write a bid speec that says higher quality what we
175have to do is we have to write a bids speec that says whole muscle meet chicken not ground chicken in the chicken patty or we have to specify a certain manufacture of sliced deli meats by name or a Bagel Company by name if we are the ones that are doing the bid and we bid for bagels because it's a bid by law we have to accept the lowest responsible bidder so if a bagel store in New Jersey of all places ends up having the cheapest Bagel we will have no choice but to import our Bagels across state lines so I I'm saying that tongue and cheek but the point is in the bidding process you are trapped by the lowest bid every time so whether we take when we're bidding out food service management company
176they're getting a quality specification that we're trying to describe with words and then they're able to go Source something that matches our words if we run a bid independently of the Food Service Cooperative or of the uh management company we're obligated to take the lowest bidder who shows up through the door so the the trick of improving quality is how you address those Supply chains the advantage of working with the Cooperative is that you get some economies of scale that help with price the disadvantage is you're going to come up with a bid ECT that everybody in the Cooperative can agree to and you may they may not be as concerned about ground chicken versus whole muscle meat chicken and so then you'd have to go out independently but then you won't have economies of
177scale and you don't know where that whole muscle meat chicken will be sourced from you just know that it'll be whole muscle meat chicken and to put a finer point on it Dr ruy you mentioned that the provider actually has the ability to contract directly with the local business they don't have to bid that they can do that as part of you know essentially fulfilling our bid specs and then they can go and enter into that contract on their own there's actually strangely an advantage to having the provider right our contract is essentially with them we bid once and then we're done with the bidding process until the contract ends so they're responsible for sourcing labor sourcing an all a food allergy website product um they're responsible for sourcing obviously the food that they cook
178and um the menus etc etc so again you take it on in house you have the opportunity to do some things that they may not see as attractive because of profit reasons or something like that so you now have the flexibility to offer siie bowls even though they're more expensive than the other lunch you would have offered um but the that opportunity uh comes with some additional responsibility ities and challenges that right now we delegate those challenges away we would just be assuming those challenges in order to take advantage of the opportunities they provide thank you are there any questions Dr Park Dr R um let's talk about the finance so we received um you said there were about 61 part-time full-time employ employes that are working in the food currently and if we are
179adding not just their payroll but payroll tax Insurance um retirement funds pension what number are we talking about and the cost of the food for the students is that going to cover all of that or just the payroll I don't I don't have figures but but I would say that um it certainly when you add in benefits costs and things like that um it it will be higher than it is now and so um if your if your cost goes up and your program Revenue remains um similar then then you could ultimately have a a deficit that you would have to to fund presumably so other schools that's doing the self inhouse preparation when they calculate the cost the cost of the meal are they calculating based on just a payroll or the whole like
180expenses that come with from hiring those people they would calculate it um all the expense all program expenses and they would they would make estimates of program revenue and program expenses and for a self-operated the largest um um costs would and and for Food Service management companies are food and labor so the option is to raise meal prices because that's a source of of Revenue or um or and or um uh do a transfer from fund balance which would have to be in you know part of your your budgeting your general fund budget and is um breakfast a mandatory are we is it mandatory to provide breakfast it is it is not mandatory to um provide breakf when um to you do a survey to determine if you want to have offer breakfast you can
181if you prefer not to you have to first survey parents to determine if there's a need and if there is a need I I can't recall the percent um that say they would participate then you must offer it and do you know uh whether students are happy with self operating Versus Food Service management do are they happier with in-house cooking I I don't have data for for students on which you know what which students in districts are are happy or not one of one of the the measures um that that's used is is participation rates like how many kids are participating and in speaking you know with our consultant and other business officials um sort of like between 30 and 50% 50% is something is something um to shoot for is a goal 50% of
182students which and and it would generally be lower at the high school um so it's 50% meaning 50% of students are buying full meals reimbursed what are called reimbursable meals so if you're looking at the data of how uh what the percentage of students buying lunch and school comparing Food Service management versus in-house Which is higher I I don't have that data for all the districts I I used publicly available um data and that's financial information and what's available on their website okay Mr Rotella thank you Dr rufo I know you've been doing this for a long time I have a bunch of questions and a bunch of comments so um I've went through the whole District I've served launch I've brought launch I've brought it to Middle School I've brought it to high school
183um at the elementary schools middle schools and high school do you have any idea what percentage of students are buying lunch or not bringing lunch I think most of the elementaries are 50 and this was just recently that I looked at it um and the couple are in the higher 40s if my recollection and the high school and the middle schools as well and I think the high school is is lower again which is which is typical okay then I guess and I've been saying this since I got on the board was you know we're trying to teach Mind Body Soul so we're not just here to have you be intellectually smarter but also as you know obesity has went up continuously that's where we have OIC and our health care course are probably going
184up because of that so um you brought up Boris head they had um breakout of um leria so um and I see the foods that are on here Pizza I went to elementary school I love pizza too but um in either scenario what can we get that's healthier foods that kids are going to eat I serve lunch I watch tons of food getting thrown out um um so those were kind of like my concerns I'm not tied to either one but how do we get healthier foods that kids are going to eat I remember another issue too was again we were talking about this before was kids didn't have tar tee they didn't have lunch some classes you could eat some classes you couldn't eat so then your kid would come home and he you'd
185say well why do you have a headache well I couldn't eat all day well what do you mean you couldn't eat all day could you have no we're not all so I don't know if any of those rules especially at the high school um can be lacked so you know kids can eat and everybody has different dietary restrictions people don't eat meat people want salads um so I look at this as how can we improve the actual not the food quality or healthier foods that kids are actually going to eat the ability for them to have time to eat um I know with the app too um I know at one point that we had an app I know the elementary school um I'm going to have the this many kids are going to have
186a bagel cream cheese this many kids are going to have pizza I don't know if we still do that or through our food service manager if they still provide that um and um I know we're building new facilities so I don't know if this's is something in the future that then we can incorporate since we're going to have these new facilities there okay I will try to do from memory um the your questions um okay the um in terms of um um the issue about um healthier options this particular bid year we added um more uh plant-based options for kids and also added uh additional salads um for kids pre-made salads different salads um um at the high school they've added um uh some uh noodle bars and and opportunities for kids to um select
187item make your own kind of burrito type of of things um so I I think some of it comes from from education um and there uh witzens is is working and we have U monthly meetings we have one scheduled uh later this week and as they've sort of had uh had I would what I call like the transition period we're GNA start having more discussions about engaging students in and because that's part of it too listening to to what they want and and also having it prepared in ways that that that they they want um you also mentioned about the elementary schools and they do not have um do not have apps or or pre-orders the kids go up through the serving lines and make their um make their selections um at the serving line
188and um and you know the first few weeks when you watch them particularly the little ones it takes them a while to you know they're not used to being asked what they want and having that but you know then they they get used to it and they also learn what a portion size is um because you often hear when Child Nutrition uh presents that they say it's the only place that kids actually learn what an actual portion is um uh and so they are asked not only about their meal they're encouraged to take vegetables and fruit because that makes a a full meal is and that's what we're trying to get the kids to have other thing and it's it's and this is It's unrelated but I know you handled this too I know this
189has been like a dream of mine since I got on the board was with the buses well someday can we get an app so if the kids are not taking the bus the bus doesn't go by their house and we economize on the bus route but know it's a SE completely separate thing but since we said the app I know that I've always had that aspiration okay it is a separate thing we're talking about lunch right now sorry but Dr okay all right uh Miss dri hi Dr rfo um so in doing the research do you notice any patterns between the districts that are using a provider and are self operating are there any identifiable things are they in any geographic location are they of any size are they have any wealth distribution how do
190I think about the differences that caused this I did not see that because I was looking for for something and I do not um I do not see that as a um as a distinguishing Factor okay um and then a lot of my questions have to do with getting an understanding of what we can and what we can't do in our bid specs and so I thought I understood but now listening to this I I think I understand a little bit less so for example can we specify the labor that we're doing in other words can we say we want cooks and preps but not servers is that allowed in our bids speec with either independent if we operate ourselves or with a food service management company yes to both you can you specify labor
191in the bid specs when I say labor I mean the the roles not the wages yes okay um what other things are we allowed to specify are we I I mean I I understood or that I think I understand that the challenge that we use the consultant for is to specify put a word I I can't remember exactly how Dr Rogers describe it but put in words a description of something that we're looking for so are we allowed to have a bid spack for certain things and not others in other words are we going to be able to create where we ask for proteins but not vegetables or we ask for dairy but not meat or something like that so part of it is um part of it is specified um I don't think you
192can uh is is laid out by the state so in other words they say this is what makes the lunch it's this much protein or this much um protein subst you know plant-based protein this many um uh this portion of vegetable this portion of dairy so some of it is prescribed in the bit but for example we put in this bid if you're offering protein you have to offer a plant-based option as well okay so going back to Doc uh to to Mr Greco's point can we not specify with the Food Service Company certain things and still specify other bids with a coordinator that we provided internally to New York state with a plan that said we're going to the food service companies for packaged Goods but we're going to the cooperative for vegetables and
193or or or and some other combination in other words this a hybrid approach is that not something in our control I'm not aware of that I don't think you can do that but I don't okay I I think that the when I the contract language I believe precludes that the contract language with New York state or which becomes our contract got it so it's not with a service provider that it's restricted it's with New York State potentially we think but their contct that we must follow has those two Provisions about competitive Foods okay can I interrupt for one second Jack Dr rufo is there another way to accomplish what uh Mr ostri was trying to do instead of bidding from two different sources the Food Service man and management company and the Cooperative could you
194specify in the Food Service management bid you want all let's say fruits and vegetables to be sourced except for citrus to be sourced from within 50 Mi of the school district or something like that so you're trying to accomplish the same thing of sourcing more locally but you would write it into the Food Service management bid I think when you're look talking about um I don't know that would be that would be something that I would have to reach out to Child Nutrition and ask that question because when you are saying we're sourcing it locally um I don't know if that is permissible because I know that there outside of food service you can't always necessarily say with a low bid contract um it needs to be local so it's it's really more a legal
195matter in terms of uh that I'd have to look into okay and then going back to discussions with New York state so I grew up at the same policy time that you do where there were block Rants and pilot programs and things like that are there not waivers for us with New York state to apply for where we could try something hybrid to see if it worked out even if it was at one or two schools or at the high school or something like that where we can apply to New York State and say we've got this idea we want to try to do this can you grant us a waiver uh in New York state Ed law to allow us to try it yeah I I did that with the um when we first
196wanted to Pilot the Halal kosher because that wasn't part of of a bid and so they they allowed me to or gave me permission to do that so I don't know again I'd have to I'd have to reach out to see if that was a possibility okay and then again again what I'm trying to figure out is the dimensions of the of the things that are within our control so when we talk to the consultant to create our bid specs how much flexibility or inflexibility and where are the parts that the consultant comes back to us where the inflexibility exists relative to our flexibility that's the part that I'm trying to get a handle on yeah I haven't had any issues of the state approving anything that was a menu enhancement as as to restrictive
197um these other suggestions that you're making with like are more legal in in terms of of the contract and a and a pilot but in terms of food quality in terms of Labor those are um those are specifications in the bid that you could mod ify and they would just have to approve right and then frequently I I think I understand that we run into trouble with insurance when it comes to providing food or allergy or whatever reasons that we do can or can't um uh provide uh things ourselves or you know um where maybe school maybe our um our contracts don't allow us to bring in outside food except for maybe special events but I keep coming back to this idea about the labor and if labor is such a difficult friction point and
198we can specify um you know that we would have Labor that was prep and cooking but not serving maybe there's an opportunity for us to Source our own local volunteer labor force that could become volunteer District employees that could do our serving to cut down on our labor costs or I just wonder Wonder um if there's more to explore here in a discussion further uh and the next time if there's a way that we can get more information about the flexibility parameters because ultimately I think there's more to talk about in addition um Dr Rogers I think it would be helpful to get um maybe a report from our district Wellness committee to talk about the surveys or any information about satisfaction with lunch as it currently stands I think normally that's a report that
199gets sent over to you periodically that we could I think would be helpful to review uh for a discussion item next time okay um Dr Rogers uh so it we have a lot of information the B has provided a lot of productive discussion and out of that and then in regards to the lunch program um we could uh come back at a later time uh when the data is uh when all the information is collected and then we can entertain this at a later time okay okay oh miss kosa if we're going to come back to this can we can would you be able to just give us a number roughly on I don't know if you can call other districts if they would give you the number a district roughly our size self-operated inous
200roughly what does it cost because we know what a contract costs with a food Management Service but you know I just like to see I think we need to see what the difference is monetarily if it's astronomical because even something else to consider besides that if you're able to get just a couple of numbers for us to to see if it you know where we're at but also when we toured the district when we were looking at facilities we have so many schools that are the especially elementary schools that are so small I I'm having a tough time seeing how having inhouse how we're we're doing all of this right now at this point a time in house before we do facilities projects I think after facilities projects and the schools have more space might
201be more viable because we'll be able to fit you know more people working or a kitchen like a working kitchen but just you know something to think about for the next when we talk about it just wanted to bring that up and then just the numbers because I think it would help us make a decision yeah um Dr Rogers mentioned in the very beginning that um once the facilities are done we have a lot more space and then um that has a lot more potentials so whether we want to bring in you know a fullsize kitchen in elementary schools or or just you know have a a better Kitchen in elementary schools this way we can prepare our own food instead of shoveling from um uh hbt and high school so but um you know
202right now it's just really just the uh the uh we're just Gathering all the all the information and then talking about it and then for the future okay I I don't that's not the sense I'm getting okay have a discuss yeah so we are going to have a you know fur the discussion about we're not making yeah so um two points that didn't really come to the surface during this conversation that I I think are worth kind of uh just lingering on for a second uh either way you operate the both of them have one major Financial drag on the system so in the Food Service management model you have the profit that is a drag on the system in the um self-operated you have the labor costs so in some ways you know the
203the question of comparing the costs is you no longer have to pay a profit to a vendor but you do have to pay for more expensive labor so it's really a question of where that break even Point comes from but one way or another there is this additional cost that exists in in one model or the other the second uh and I think probably um as a practical matter the biggest consideration will be who runs it so when you have the Food Service management company you have an organization that has this as their core competency and you may or may not like the on-site director that you have but then they have a boss you can go and complain to um if you hire your own food service director and you're not happy with them
204the person you complain to is yourself so um we've had good experience with food service directors but my own observation is every time we get somebody that we think is really competent that we like they get promoted out of saset to somewhere else in the company so um I would say with the Food Service management company we can be consistently above average but every time we start to approach exceptional the person disappears so what we've not experienced is well below average so you kind of have um you're assured of getting decent management uh at a minimum so with a self-operated you have to hire from the Civil Service list and the Civil Service list only gives you three choices so it's not like when we're hiring a principal and we can put an ad in
205the newspaper and we can do uh recruitment fairs and we can cast a wide net and look at 30 candidates and narrow that pool down to 15 and then narrow that pool down we'll have three people to choose from and those three people will all have uh two characteristics in common one Nassau County and two they took a test so from that pool of people we have to select the person that is going to do a better job of running this service than the Food Service management company if we find that person um there could be a lot of success but a lot depends on finding this one individual so I um I won't say we're daunted by that because we find great people off of civil service lists all the time but I I
206wouldn't want us to go into this thinking that we have a wide open field to hire from this will be u a delicate process of trying to identify somebody that we think can do a really exceptional job with the work okay Dr Park um so I'm kind of wondering is there benefit of going self-operated in House at this point and if we are still going to talk about L at later time um one information I would like to have is there are regulations and guidelines that you described and we received and how challenging is it to comply with all those requirements and what are the potential fines or um penalties if un unintentionally uh we violate them and could those violations create significant CH challenges and what level of impact will they have in serving
207providing lunch in a daily basis okay thank you Dr Park okay thank okay all right thank you Dr R for your presentation okay thank you okay all right so now uh there are no legislated items uh no discussion items and uh no unfinished business so we are going to do our new business and 11a is the approval of staff changes can I have a motion please miss fov second by Mr Greco are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 11b is the approval of sement and our rates 2024 2025 can I have a motion please uh Miss kosia seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 11 C is the approval of settlement agreement can I have a motion Please Mr greckle seconded by m Levitan are
208there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 11d is the approval of extension of appoint appointment of secretary security infrastructure manager uh can of a motion Please Mr greo seconded by Miss falkov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 11e is the approval of pay rate for overnight field trips can I have a motion please uh Mr Roto second by Mr abson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 12a and 12b can be taken together there are the approval of committee on preschool special education and committee on special education recommendations can I have a motion please mrco seconded by Miss lean are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 12 C is the approval of new policy 1741 homeschool homeschool students students and revised policy 1900
209parent and family engagement in 9550 expression of breast milk in in the workplace can I have a motion Please Mr Roto seconded by Dr Park are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 13A is the authorization of service contracts can I have a motion Please Mr greo seconded by m fov are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 13B is the authorization for special education and or nursing contracts can have a motion Please Mr Oro seconded by Miss koshia are there any questions all in favor opposed any extenstions 13 C is the authorization for contracts for federal Part B funds can I have a motion Please Mr Greco second by Miss Falco are there any questions all in favor opposed any exstension 13d is the approval of student Club Charters 2024
2102025 can I have a motion Please Mr Roto seconded by Miss Abramson are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions 13 e is the dis disposal of broken broken Surplus and or absolute equipment supplies and books can I have a motion Please Mr greo seconded by Miss Levitan are there any questions all in favor opposed any extensions okay we are going to uh move to audience to the public to the public and please just bear with me as I read the procedures the board of the board values Community input and provides opportunities to offer that input via email or in or in person persons who who wish to speak during audience to the public must register online to speak in events of the meeting by 5:00 p.m. the day of the board meeting
211a link to the pre-registration form will be made available on the the homepage on the district website one week before the meeting persons wishing to address the board in person doing audience to the public must conform to procedures adopted by the board speakers remark remarks must conform to the following one all speakers and observers are required to conduct themselves in a respectful and civil manner in accordance to with rules set by the board two speakers must address the board only not members of the audience and or the audience as a whole three speakers must limit their comments comments to issues concerning the School District Operations Affairs and or Board of Education policy four because of Rights protected by state and federal law no no speaker may speak about an individual student or staff member nor
212will the board or Administration entertain questions in public regarding collective bargaining negotiations Personnel matters student matters or legal matters five no speaker may speak about decisions involving specific Personnel or specific students if a speaker wishes to address the board concerning specific Personnel or specific students the speaker must write to the board six speakers may not use epithets slurs personal abuse LW and obsene speech profanity libelous speech threats and or fighting words or gestures any person who violates the rules above will immediately forfeit the balance of their time addressing the board to be recognized to speak persons must must register with their full name and address and attest that they will comply with the rules stated above in addition only residents of the sayas Central School District are permitted to address the board each resident will
213have four minutes to address the board which may be extended or reduced the board will not permit pulling of the board members by speakers after every speak every resident wishing to speak have had an opportunity to do so the board and administration May respond to Residents questions or comments no residents will be permitted to address the board more than once per meeting and no one no and no one may record Another member of the board of the public in a man in a manner that's disruptive or confrontational and with that uh the first speaker will be Tanya GS hi greetings um do I have to give the whole introduction or anything anymore all right so Tanya gats resident of saset um parent of a hasset Jr parent of um an alumni from 2021 and my
214husband is a 1976 alumni and my brother-in-law is a 1983 Alum okay so I'm here because um I was very interested in hearing the transition to high school presentation because when I first addressed this board it was in 2017 during my daughter's high school year having attended an eth grade transition that had very little information and I followed up a lot on that information and I didn't get it so what I wanted and one of the things that I asked was what um had been discussed during the meeting which was a syllabus or some sort of course outline for some of the courses all honors that my daughter was recommended for so um I did come to the board of ed in 2017 and asked that Dr riters conduct a survey of the transition and
215I believe it was done and um some of the um transition things that happened were partially as a result of that survey I think it would be good to conduct it again given this presentation to see what the effects are I'm going to speak anecdotally I did think with my son the transition was improved I don't have time to go into that now but I would be happy to speak about the differences that I observed to board of end members after the meeting um but um I do want to talk about the curriculum presentation for math which I observed in December I really care about curriculum presentations and transitions because I spent a lot of time in my professional career once I left the publishing World US News and World Report where we spent a
216lot of time talking about education and left for CUNY and I've been teaching at CUNY now um for over 20 years and we do a lot with transitioning in freshman year because we educate students from all around the globe literally so um so and one of the things I think is so important our curriculum presentations and the curriculum presentation in math I think was missing some items and one of the things that I think was missing was a focus broader on the majority of the students that are taking um regions classes it focused a lot on the advanced classes and on stem focused students but if you look at the New York State data on AP Cal and um both BC and um ab and then even if you include stats only 16% of students
217Statewide take those classes now I know in saset it's much higher it may be as high as 40% but that still leaves the majority in the Region's program and I think in order for students to choose better they need to have curriculum outlines and I have looked at Shenango Valley and Shelter Island where they do offer course outlines for pre-calculus and other courses I also think we need to think broader about not math departments that support non stem majors in college in the same way that colleges offer math classes for non-science majors and for science Majors Sunni Stonybrook has an has a foundations and pre-cal course new PS has a um math 230 I think it is intros to stats for non-science Majors we don't have it that's it thank you so much um the
218next speaker is going to be May Rosa uh yes that's correct uh good evening everyone this is Myra regosa I would like to thank the board and also uh the parents that are here for opening the floor so we can collaborate as a brief introduction um I have been a part of the scasa community along with my family since 2008 we have two daughters that are a freshman and junior in saset high school and are part of the track and field Athletic program and um what I'd like to bring forward falls under the athletic department and specific to track and field I'd like to um talk to you about the budget allocation specific for transportation now with that said uh there has been um different understandings of of the transportation uh funding and so I
219decided to make some time and look at the uh budget report to understand better how it's uh how it's broken out and specific to uh contract the transportation there is a budget presentation report that includes a general fund category labeled budget account title 5540 which is the contract Transportation allocating it for athletic trips my interpretation of a report is year-over-year there is a known spend for athletic trips which is funding uh through the district which is voted and approved however cross country winter track spring track athletes are being asked to fund the rental of Coach buses for season trips it doesn't make sense as these season trips are not new to the district your track athletes take one trip per season and have been doing so for two decades before I ask my questions I
220would like to highlight your athletes accomplishments sasid high school girls are on a 13 County Championship winning streak having won 15 County championships in the past 17 years last spring season they were County Champions recent winter season they were County Champions and they've been recognized as all state and All American athletes in the 4 by8 to dat district has offered an explanation to parents for the financial change my questions are why has the district changed its vote and not funding the coach busing for track and field is the district investing in other areas of the high school track program in this current school year has the district identified other Investments for the athletic program requiring cutting cost and transferring funds to close the gap I'd like to end with a point that is important not
221as I watch my daughters um perform their best in the field but also important that you've highlighted so many things believe it or not it has been um a new experience for me I normally don't attend a full event in person as usually virtual but you did bring up a lot of good points as far as what kind of graduates are we sending off right what are we instilling in them is it academic only it's not it is sports as well there's a lot of learning that your coaches invest with these students for them to become a team and a lot of lessons learned that they get and so I think it's important that the district and faculty spend some time attend these events these students are in elements of hot weather cold weather rain
222there's no exception and it's important for you to also see under the conditions that they're congregating as they wait their turn to run their tents are old they're breaking down they're not in good condition they're definitely not safe for your athletes it has fallen on them when it rains and so you put that all together and you come back to a single point that it is upon the school to invest the time not only in the um portion of coaching your students but also facilitating the transportation that they need and that they're entitled to and that that the district has voted on thank you okay thank you this closes the audience to the public and uh I wanted to get back to uh uh Miss gats um thanks for respecting the time limit and then
223I know you didn't finish what you wanted to say but please feel free to send an email to the board okay thank you and Dr Rogers would you like to address uh first of all uh Miss gut thank you for reminding me about the survey now I have to go dig it up um but uh that might be useful uh background information but I think you Illustrated the difference between 2017 and what we've been trying to uh improve on ever since uh notably um both with the honors Dro conversation and with the 8 to9 transition a lot of the momentum that we had prior to the pandemic was stalled by the pandemic for obvious reasons so a lot of the work that we're doing right now is trying to regain that momentum um in terms
224of the conversation around um the math presentation and the amount of the presentation that was dedicated to uh different um curriculum and course work within that we certainly uh will talk with the assistant principal who's responsible for math she's new to the district and uh looking we're very enthusiastic about her uh but also happy to give her uh honest feedback from parents about what else they would like to see um the nice thing is that what you're saying is you'd like to see more so that's good um people will like getting that kind of feedback um in terms of math for non- stem Majors um I'll confess I I don't have this part of the catalog well memorized I know that we have we offer um a course called discret mathematics um which is not
225intended for math Majors it's a little counterintuitive for me because I remember I started college as an engineering student and discret math was considered a weed out course uh in the math department so um I I know that we don't see it as a weed out course here I think we see it as as math for non- Majors but that's one of the courses that's offered um we do offer AP stats it's not a cal based uh stats uh class obviously it's college level uh statistics is also offered in um intro to calcin stats uh which I believe is 12th grade course and um when the state made the transition from Algebra 2 trig to as part of the Common Core learning standards they moved from Algebra 2 trig to what is now Algebra 2
226uh they added statistics into Algebra 2 that didn't really exist in Algebra 2 trig uh it's that whole section on statistics and probability is like five weeks long uh but it is sort of embedded there uh in that course uh but certainly happy to look at um the idea of other coursework uh for math that is for non-math Majors maybe non- stem Majors but um you know certainly math is used in the business World there are lots of other applications for math um so happy to take that uh feedback and uh and look into it uh Miss Rosa thank you so much for your comments and thoughts um I wanted just uh broaden the conversation from the track team to Athletics more generally so with lots of the Athletics uh there are competitions that are
227part of Section 8 and are sanctioned competitions they are uh student athletes are expected required to attend uh they affect the teams standing in the county progression towards playoffs etc etc there are also things that the teams do that are not part of Section 8 but there are opportunities that student can participate in and sometimes those opportunities involve travel so what we're trying to do is be consistent and can kind of compare and contrast two things so uh for example our um cheerleaders and uh kick line will go to Florida for a competition it's obviously not Nassau County it's not part of uh the state so when that happens the district will pay for the coaches who have been working with uh the athletes but the athletes are resp responsible for the cost of travel
228Hotel Etc so there is an analogy to things like the pen relay or the Yale uh competition where these are not part of Section 8 they're out of state they're not um something that uh counts towards their standing uh students are not required to attend uh in fact my understanding is that they're not well attended by the athletes and um for consistency sake we're treating them the same way that we've uh treated the kickline ETC so um I do take your points about um checking on the conditions of things like the tents Etc uh I will follow up on that with a conversation with our athletic director Mr stuber so I understand uh a little better uh what the situation is with that but thank you for bringing the points up thank you Dr Rogers
229okay and this will conclude our uh January meeting and that our next meeting is going to be Monday February 10th uh meeting adjourned