CorpusRecord 136561

Board of Education Work Session - January 30, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Syosset Central School District
Date
2025-01-31
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,537 words · about 37 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e okay we got everyone okay uh meeting quality order in the library of Southwoods middle school and it's the work session of the Board of Education uh at it's uh 66 um can I have a motion Please Mr greo second it by um Miss Kia and Miss Falco all in favor opposed any abstentions okay can everyone please stand for the pledge FL of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay thank you please take a seat all right so the board is here tonight uh to uh uh go over some of the uh uh goals that we uh worked on on the past few uh uh goal setting meetings and then we have the uh um

002we're very fortunate to have uh Dr Miguel I'm sorry I was looking around not used to this stud uh to uh to be our facilitator and then before we begin uh Dr Dr McGowan has a a brief presentation to show everyone okay so oh I like how you emphasize brief I promise you I've prepared before uh for you at different times 30 40 slides and realized three slides in that that was not necessary so uh this is really I think a good opportunity to to revisit very briefly what you've done and how we've landed at this place and it actually is I think a really uh simple concept at this point which is to say let's talk about where you are relative to the goals that have been drafted I've received feedback from you but

003now I'm presenting to you here's what seems to make sense and reflective of your feedback and then take a little bit more and make adjustments if you'd like to but really try and move ahead thinking about this in terms of saying here's where we want to be as a board as a district which allows your leaders in the district to have a strategic Direction and to be able to formulate their objectives their work each year the projects that they are uh thinking about the budgeting that they're doing based on these concrete measurable places we'd like to get to this place they are built on your Mission Vision that are on your uh website and published throughout the district really well-developed materials for a place that has been successful for a long time so this is

004really just saying you know you're healthy really healthy and in a good place but you talk to your physician and the physician says you know you're awfully healthy but it wouldn't be bad if you targeted these three or four things to really focus your efforts on so what we did over a period of time is discuss your mission and vision and do some professional development work around that you know what does it mean to you your Core Funeral purpose what does it look like when you're working on those things what are your values around that and had some really good discussions you gave me some feedback on a couple of different occasions and I was able to provide you some drafts in terms of your goals most recently digging into that um even further the

005goals provide is again a more focused strategic direction for the district sort of a measurement tool when you're budgeting when you're planning projects does this align with what the community would like for us and when I say the community you representing as board members the interests of the community it gives staff members Clarity when working on initiatives to meet those goals that these are aligned with what the Strategic direction of the district is and you as board members guide posts to really maintain focus and measure systematically what's happening in the district and then the the community really gets a clear idea of what is being worked on and why it's being worked on the first goal is in your area of academic or academics as it's phrased um in Your Vision the first proposed goal

006uh it's in front of you we will provide our students and staff with the structures and resources necessary to create personalized learning experiences these experiences will balance work in healthy stress enabling students to discover and exceed their greatest potential and some of the the feedback received was around the idea of including personalization thinking about um artificial intelligence as a matter of fact is a very specific way of thinking about technology healthy stress versus balance and stress and some good conversation around that and the importance of stress but understanding the balance that is needed as well in other words appropriate stress we discuss portrait of a graduate as probably something that could come from this in other words the development of a portrait of a graduate would be one of those strategic directions or projects that

007comes out of a goal like this we discussed evolving technology a consistent experience from classroom to classroom instructionally but more so in terms of assessment and practices in those classrooms and then discovering potential kids thinking about what their potential is discovering their own individual gifts talents and potential and being prepared for Life along the way so those were ideas that landed at us at a a draft a revised draft that states we will create individualized learning experiences while maintaining comparability in classroom instructional and assessment practices we will utilize and Foster Mastery of evolving Technologies support an appropriate balance between work and stress and develop aort of gradu that enables each student to discover their greatest potential and be prepared to to contribute to their community so do you have questions on that is there any

008feedback that we would like to consider now any thoughts you'd like to share when you react to that initially anyone I'm sure you don't want us to deal with a grammar and a punctuation issue right now we could save that for another time I think that would be just fine it's entirely I'm not going to waste every ability yeah it's just mindset consistency and it's comparability up there so I don't know which is it's a little different it should be that should be the this is so it should be comparability right maintaining comparability so let's look at the uh we can look at the slide okay so would you prefer the word comparability or consist um oh since uh um just rationale what was there initially consistency well we okay so what was the argument

009K and I discussed this a little bit and um comparability is saying that um no matter what teacher you get an A is an A and the curriculum covers everything that it needs to cover but it doesn't tie the hands of uh if you say consistency of instruction then you might say every teacher has to teach in exactly the same way and that might be two cookie cutter so we were trying to Kevin and I were batting back and forth words that could say um you want to make sure that um there's fairness in terms of the instruction right from class to class but not tie teachers hands to not have their own personalities or their own approaches or their own ways of getting to the standards so comparability was the word that we came

010up with for that consistency was you know a word that came out of some of the feedback that we were getting so we're going to keep comparability okay can we can we in the end can we drop each and make it all students obviously first of all because each is singular and their is plural so it's not accurate but we might as well stick to all instead of trying to make the second half of that sentence singular so it says enables all students to discover their greatest potential sure anyone else on the is it a grammar reason or is it like a the grammar reason led me to the change so it's the substantive change of having it be all because obviously you can't say each student to discover there no the idea is drop

011each now because I think substantively it sounds better with all anyway sure but at the beginning of the goal it's talking about individualized learning experiences which involves an individual and not a collective so there's a slight like mcomp between the beginning thought and the end so again I think there it's implicit that it's each and every right because it's inclusive of all is inclusive of each but the fact that we start individualized maybe it's each and every is a is another alternative to consider each and every yeah each and every so instead of each student it's GNA be each each and every student I don't it's the there that's got you I got you yeah also would it be appropriate in this um space to incorporate that looking at the right thing yeah that's [Applause]

012F right okay okay good okay so um is there any way to weave in um as we emphasize um individualized learning right to within Collaborative Learning the word collaborative somehow I feel like it's um definitely the word of the day in colleges for sure you put it after the word comparability and collab perhaps as much as we um I wouldn't put it there somewhere somewhere that makes sense to English major people yeah so you like you like the concept of collaboration there in terms of the learning objective I wouldn't mix it up with um the comparability because it's right it's a different it's a different thought there so I wouldn't put it there but maybe um like to the greatest potentially prepared to contribute to their community and and their ability to collaborate wait can't

013you list it in the we will utilize and Foster a Mastery Technologies create a environment of Collaborative Learning collabora learning collaborative enir really love that I think it's so important you know um in today's world or support or something another work support do we have together you know yeah that's a good place for it having individual strengths yet you know be able to work in a group M okay get along get along also important pick each other up pick each other up so incorporating collaboration important and then thinking about the structure grammatically of each and every versus there no problem okay anyone else okay okay oh good the second goal um in inclusive and engaging culture climate character we will create the proposed goal originally we will cultivate safe inclusive environments where all students can

014Thrive and successfully navigate evolving challenges and the feedback received was around the idea of creating a kind safe culture that exemplifies Pride spelling those out which we have in the in the updated draft where all students can Thrive develop a greater understanding of multiple perspectives uh through their work in the classroom Wellness balance and inclusivity uh were Again part of the conversation but it was noticed that they were also repeated uh throughout the goals so there was a conversation about how to be a little bit more focused in that the revised draft proposed goal will will cultivate a kind safe and supportive culture that exemplifies Pride patience respect Integrity dignity and empathy ensuring all students Thrive our learning environment will Foster Wellness balance and a deep appreciation for multiple perspectives empowering students to navigate evolving

015challenges with confidence and compassion I was thinking yeah I just no I'm sorry go Ahad oh sorry I just wanted to add something about beginning it in kindergarten and making sure that we weave it through the entire environment or something of that nature through its wellth making it really part making it a strong culture I'm kindergarten through graduation yeah wouldn't that be more of an objective directed at doing something versus what we are doing as a district I is more of a question for you can you say that again isn't that more of an like if we're directing something that's more of an objective whereas the goal itself should be inherently districtwide you start to say it's districtwide does that mean other goals which are clearly these overarching things that are probably happening anyway are

016they somehow narrowed that would be my only point on not wanting to make that change and one concern that I would have is if people move in in the middle of the year like not starting in kindergarten and they feel like oh did I miss something not being here from kindergarten Here my thought with saying kindergarten is first we also leave out the word inclusivity which probably should be somewhere in there but if we don't start whether you move in later or not that happens often what the culture has to exist from the time you walk into the building the culture has to be thought of as part of the nature of the school and it's not tolerated for you to be unkind or mean to other kids this is not a place where we

017condone that it has to be part of their everyday experience that they will they will practice that the pride so I from the and you start from the day they walk in whatever day they walk in right and that becomes part of their being when they're in scasd if you started that sentence with the words from the youngest age and then went through everything else does that get does that move us in the direction of where you'd like to see that go yeah still feels like an objective though but at this point these are goals so they're no different than our vision statement and I'm happy that regardless of what they say but I'm trying to avoid making things be more of a directive because in my mind that is really what an objec is

018about and telling the district how to operate not talking about these General goals but I agree with everything when said obviously I just feel that it's more of an objective I understand what you're saying I just wanted to be so clear that our culture has to be one that exemplifies Pride or exemplifies the things that we talk about and that it has to be interwoven so tightly in who we are from the time they walk in till the time they leave so that that's who the that's the the people they want to be and that's what they associate it with and also adding on Lynn just mentioned um adding inclusive in it so we could also add which I agree is a can heart to have um toal kind safe inclusive and supportive cultures like

019super easy just say that right there If Everyone likes it um I don't really think it's I don't think saying the time period from begin to end of your days here is such an objective CU it's not giving a specific thing it's just saying this goal that we're putting out there is for the entire time you're a sasd student so it's not specific on you know what you should do it's just saying that this goal is the entire time you're scasd student as opposed to just in the secondary grade or just in middle school or you know whatever it's the entire time it's not a very it's not giving a specific Direction like an objective would but shouldn't that be would be we will create individual learning experiences it would be the same thing we'd

020have to add it there and then I guess I'm not sure why it's not implicit in there's it's not going I just don't think it's as prevalent today as it should be I don't think it's as part of the culture starting so young as it should be I think it has to be a bigger part of who we are that we create a culture that teaches kids how to how to interact with each other in a much nicer and Kinder way and I think that there are times we're missing the mark on that so I think that if we start younger and make it the way and we make it part of the the woven tapestry of sasid like this is what it is and everyone walks around understanding that then it becomes the it

021becomes more of the norm and less of the exception I just don't think that we can work on the culture of kindness and the culture of Pride I think that we have a lot of work to do in that area and I think that while it might be implic it a saying it makes it more of an emphasis but that's also why we're doing the goals like we're going to implement this starting whenever it gets released and whatever so I'm with you on what you're saying I think we should give the goal a chance to kind of be out there I'm okay to add what Dr Roger said from the youngest age is fine with but I see where you're coming from with that it's almost like our goals are the thought is that these

022goals are going to start the whole time that they're here from the beginning to the end whether you're here K to 12 or you're here you know 8th grade to 12th grade or second to Fourth you know like whatever your time period is so I I would say that it is implicit in a way that these are our goals for the district so no matter what grade you're in here you go but to to your point if the goal says regardless of what it says if Lyn or anyone else thinks that something's not happening or something needs to be improved that's the point of the objective right so the what everything you said should absolutely be an objective and that makes sense I'm just whever anything I'm not I'm just giving ideas if everyone wants

023in a certain place that's fine I just I I just think there are things that are important that need to be included at some point so wherever they go you that's a very important point and then Dr Roger is it possible to you know make that uh on the top of the objectives you know one of the making K to2 or whenever the kid enters into our district and then to to build that inclusive culture and then in this case sorry go ahead okay in this case L would you be okay that we don't you know we'll just take from the youngest age but then we put that into the objective still under this uh the priority area too okay that's fine but they in including inclusivity can't hurt okay into the thing okay so

024then so we just uh put in the inclusivity and uh what's the other one that you were talking about the Third it inclusivity it was kind safe inclusive and supportive culture right adding inclusive yeah we have that in the next one too okay all right so this one was good right yeah so and I would just say Brian know I'm pry protective of you know the management prerogative and the goal but I I don't hear this as directing Us in any way with the how I hear this as directing us with the what if we want to have a place where a kind warm generous inclusive culture is the norm it's the expectation and anything that deviates from that is not um is not acceptable or not what we're trying to build but that's what

025it says I'm not saying that's an objective I'm saying that's the goal yeah that's I'm saying to add to it to sort of Target different grades because it may not be happening in a particular grade becomes an objective right I didn't see it as objective so much as like an underscore when you say like from the youngest age it's almost just to draw a line under it and say we really mean it my point about from the youngest age was more because then we'd have to address the other ones like the first goal it would be the same problem understood but either way I think it's our job to come back as an Administration to come back to you and say okay if this is your goal it's up to us to figure out how

026to achieve that goal for you when the when the goals are posted wherever they're posted is there any kind of introduction to it or just does it just say board goals and then list them cuz I'm wondering if we could to make it apply to all of them to say the expect something like the expectation is that these goals will apply to children from their first day in Sasa to the time that they graduate and then that way it will cover all the goals in one F like one whole thing I think we can add whatever we want when it's posted I think we can put if that's what we want to do right right just work on a preamble for you okay these are meant to and that way it hits everyone's points okay

027at all levels and all programs and all of our children's experiences we right like just saying comprehensively to to Dr Roger's point I like that idea of an underscore and from the youngest age I love the phraseology I would say sometimes that then could give the impression that you're really focused on that being an elementary objective it almost brings it to that place but if you say maybe even at all levels or something along the just just a thought or from the youngest age until they graduate or something you guys are pretty good with the words the only other thing before we go on is Anna do you think it makes sense to bring your collaboration into the learning environment phrase here and out of the academic one so in other words if we had

028uh the learning environment Fosters collaboration Wellness then right actually what I meant is not now learning as it relates to learning meaning you know in a lab when you work as a group and not kill each other because you know I care about my A+ you think that's different from our learning environment to learn how to work together for the purpose of learning not so much socially and like in a cafeteria and you know not be nice to each other that's culture that's a character no I agree I guess I just don't know why it doesn't fit in our learning environment sentence we're going to have it in the third so the third goal is going to pick up collaborative and inclusively but different it's a different it's it's a different context 100% And into

029where right it's the same words for different context I get right and then you know uh to uh to M Miss Le Point and she's talking about in particular that academic environment correct right and homework test grades that environment correct it can hurt to have it in multiple places to underscore that it's a important sure yeah theme of what we're looking for so are we look good with number the second one okay the third goal is first drafted we will we will communicate effectively with our external stakeholders focusing on creating an inclusive School Community where every child feels valued and has a sense of belonging and then the feedback received was really around the idea of connecting with all families as well it wasn't just this idea of external Stak olders was a little bit

030of a um almost like a distant or a clinical or a term that wasn't as warm I think developing deeper connections for all everyone was the concept we're trying to communicate with everybody staff as well and that's where collaborative came up again the idea of internal communication as well where we landed in terms of drafting this for you we will Foster strong meaningful connections with all families and stakeholders so all and pointing out families ensuring an inclusive and collaborative School Community where every child feels valued and has a true sense of belonging through effective communication and deeper engagement we will strengthen relationships among students staff families and the broader Community ensuring that everyone feels heard supported and invested in our shared success so I have one comment on this I think this is great um

031where it says because we did have a conversation about how we wanted to focus on the whole community meaning everybody involved that's why that changed but where it says collaborative School Community where every child I almost feel like child needs to be person because this goal is focused on everybody feeling valued and having a true sense of belonging so whether you're a Community member you're a teacher you're an administrator you're whatever your role is within this community this is how we want our community to be so my opinion child should be um person but I don't know what everybody else do or go everyone learning everyone feels Val well particularly because this was about a connected community and we did talk a lot about you know it's everybody it's families it's stakeholders it's internal so

032where every person feels valued and has a true sense of war that that makes a lot of sense anyone else can I compliment you you did a great job by the way of distilling all these random things our mission statement our value statement and then throwing it into a goal making our night a lot easier Mr so I know we're going to have more goals under but maybe we should think about like how we're valuing students so are we valuing students because you take five APS so I'm going to Value you more than a student that has different skills so um that's something I think we should think about as a board is how are we valuing it are you valuing it because the teachers you're e easy in class and maybe you have other

033artistic skills so I think we have to really think how we're valuing students I think that's a great point and and you're you're right when you mentioned that that maybe then comes in under the objectives when you start to measure this and think about okay then how exactly are you going to get get at this okay all right are we all good okay so can I just add one thing the repetitive word point I just wonder and I didn't I don't have better words but I wonder when we reuse a word like collaborative is there a better word to use here I think onest point is the word works I don't like being repetitive just to be repetitive using inclusivity or inclusive using collaborative It's a Wonderful website called I think synonym.com like there's so

034many great words we could really use so we are not repetitive I want to throw it out there I didn't actually what I hear you saying is you want to reserve the word collaborative in the sense that Anna uses think it's for her purpose here I think there's 10 words we can use to make the exact same point so not use it right so if we reserve that word we will all know we as a staff will know when we say that we mean it in the academic sense do you want to do that for inclusive too or you like inclusive there I don't know if inclusive has as many I'm okay it I'm just asking but I think collaborative in this sense there's a lot well you're using inclusive more similarly in both than

035and I think inclusivity in this is important as well as the previous one yeah no I'm good with that I was just asking okay okay and your fourth goal trans transparent and efficient operations the original draft we will ensure that our facilities adequately support an excellent education for our students and provide enriching experiences for our community members feedback received was really around the need to reference fiscal operations and responsibil and a longer term plan sustainability right that you're you're undertaking a lot of work right now but what about the longterm let's not put ourselves in a position uh where we're not taking care of these assets for the long term and be prepared for that the revised draft we will ensure that our facilities effectively support and excellent education for our students and provide enriching

036experiences for our community all while maintaining fiscal responsibility and sustainability through thoughtful planning and long-term investment we will create and maintain safe safe Innovative and adaptable spaces that meet the evolving needs of our students and Community for years to come anyone has anything to add to it any feedback on this one I think you did Fabulous really you took you took every bit of feedback and literally freed everything and this is great very exciting we're going to have you back I enjoyed it and you pushed my thinking though I really enjoyed the feedback received and thinking differ each of these which I'll take the feedback from the other ones and and I like that notion of collaboration and how specifically how that's used in academic Excellence think about that a little bit differently would you've

037given me some good feedback to put some finishing topics on to so that's great all right so um thank you again Dr for all your work behind the scene uh this is this is great it really saves a lot a lot of time and you really put together you really all these revised draft proposal go reflect the all our conversations you know hours and hours of conversation into four short paragraphs so this is excellent so thank you so much and then uh um so uh now that we have these uh revised uh dra propos proposed goals all in all different areas and Dr Rogers um with within each of these priority areas would you be able to work with the leadership team to develop a targeted plan uh to guide these actions and then each

038of these actions that will outline the strategy and priorities you know um to reach a specific objective for example Miss Edinson brought out the uh an that point from K22 you know and then put that as an objective and then also Mr Roto brought up something about this you know uh the more welcoming more inclusive environment out of that so in each of these areas uh just you know have that objective and then for the board to consider in the future yeah for sure um and actually we have a number of members of the administrative uh Team here tonight I think it's uh undoubtedly helpful for them to hear your discussion and uh the sense of priority that you placed on a lot of these things so what I would propose is exactly what you

039suggested um give us some time to now take these um discuss them as a staff and you know I'll need their expertise the building principles and the leaders in the district uh to put together some ideas for how we can start to work on these objectives and I liked your phrase um we're we're not bad but there are things that we could be doing to be better and this directs Us in where our priorities are going to be for the things to work on next so that will help me engage the team here in what our next work is and then um so what I propose is I give us a little bit of time to do that and then come back to you with a first draft maybe of some strategic objectives for each

040of these goals that you would react to um as a as a board and give us feedback on how our first trft is okay um Mr I see it slightly different is there a way that when you're going to talk to your administrative staff of course your principles but I mean there should be some staff there should be maybe it's just PTA Council maybe just ask the question where are your priorities just so we can sort of see what everyone says you know and I I I don't know most effective way to do that I'm sure you can come up with an effective way where you can just give us the information so we can start to set what we see are the priorities based on what you're hearing and what you're seeing because obviously

041we could all come up with that right now but that's not effective we need to know what the administration and we need to know what people are thinking uh and I just again you've used things like thought exchange before that probably won't be effective for something like this there must be some way that you can come up with where you can really have people come in give you the information you could just sort of downloaded on us to start making these decisions yeah I mean I think you were saying that in a nicer way than I would have which is we just you know got through having a discussion about a goal about collaboration with all the stakeholders I don't want to narrow the collection of information and priority setting to just the administration there's

042a bunch of other stakeholders internal and external who I want to hear from and I want to hear from them directly I don't want to hear it I want to hear a ton of information in terms of where are the areas that um folks see as high priority or most important from their point of view I don't want it to come solely from the uh from the administrative lens our job is to balance the interests and views of a lot of different groups um and I want to hear from a lot of different groups I think having by having uh you know reaching out to the council is a good start I actually would love to hear from the students too and not just the um super inv valve students but the um General populational

043students to see what what kind of improvements they'd like to see in their environment since a lot of what we're doing is to make their experience better um I would kind of love to see where what where they in an open-ended way not putting anything in their head but what what things they feel we could improve on to make their experience happier more enriching more successful I me we do have a goal that talks about reaching out to lots of different stakeholders for the purpose of doing this so we might as well use that goal and that concept to get as much information as can totally agree but I mean I don't think we should make a list of who to go to I think we should no I'm just among the list I think

044I don't think this should be like a strategic plan 18mon review of thought exchanges and thousands of hours of whatever I mean I feel like this is a relatively shortterm you know shouldn't take more than a couple weeks or months to be able to gather the feedback from a bunch of sources I mean if it's a Google form or whatever you can figure out but so we like Dr Rogers figure it out you know what would be the internal and external and bring it back to the board yeah i' love the students Anonymous it probably be better also agreed Ian we can make it I I'm not really worried about who says it but I want to see no I'm just saying if you want a real if you want students to answer honestly making

045it Anonymous will help aid in that agree yeah anyone else I mean you got this Pro right here that could give you some advice best yeah what have you seen other in when you want to do something quick when you want to turn around objectives in months not years think I think Tom could bet his mortgage payment what he knows what I'm about to say um I do think thought exchange is the way to get that feedback very quickly and I think it provides anonymity it provides a space that um I always like to say Mak space for The Quiet Ones I often remark that in a space like this my wife who has far more to offer than I is funnier and nicer and more enjoy uh would not likely put her hand up

046and her feedback is really valuable so if you give people that space and that opportunity it is a vulnerable space to be in but I also find that people actually tend to handle that better than when they have their name attached to a comment on social media because they get something out of having the like or the click or the response but the exchange gives you a chance to really gather a lot of feedback from groups and people can see what other people think which I also think is important the the analysis is in the hands of the people that are doing it Miss and then miss um I don't know if this is you guys may hate this suggestion you may go not like it but I I would love just to what you

047said like with your wife who's a little quieter and whatever I think that there are a lot of kids who probably aren't going to volunteer their information I don't know if it's especially a thought exchange is so easy and simple if like in the high school English class everybody has to take 3 minutes and you know have an opportunity to write something and just do it English social stories what something that everybody takes and just take 5 minutes or 3 minutes out of the class and just say we're doing this thing we want to improve the school write something that is important to you or take time you know and do it that way and it could be you know a couple day exercise so they have a chance to respond to what other people

048write or however you guys want to do but I would just I would love to get a wider because I think some of the kids who may have the most insightful information might be the least likely to volunteer what they're thinking yeah I mean one of the difficulties though is oh I'm sorry I slipped over I apologize was the piggy backing on what is saying now my my only reservation here not a reservation I mean it's an excellent idea and I agree 100% that that anonymity is key however on platforms such as thought exchange as I know for a fact people create you know 10 different names and let's say hypothetically an angry student will post you know anonymously you know um a complaint or whatever concern or outrage or you know everything is awful

049say it and posted 10 times under different names how do we know how do we protect ourselves from unnecessary um you know bombardments of and can fourth graders use thought Exchange mind if I weigh in I I would say I don't know and I was a second grade teacher and I loved the kids that I taught and I was a primary principal I'm not sure that primary level feedback is as important in this I think you could have within these goals somewhere at some point some way to measure um young kids and their perceptions of school and there's other ways to get at that but in terms of gathering more feedback from more stakeholders and a rapid sort of more comprehensive way um an exchange or some other vehicle right it doesn't have to be

050just about exchange but I don't know to your point that fourth graders are giving the best people in fact I say even as a parent of a middle schooler and two poor middle schoolers I wouldn't ask middle school kids either I would really focus on Junior seniors maybe all high school kids but no I really disagree I wholly disagree sorry I disagree because I think that there's a lot of things that go on especially in middle school that we need to address in Middle School um and preparation for high school and preparation coming in even if you start fifth grade and up I think there's a lot to be said of the I wouldn't discount them at all because I think their experience of moving up and their experience of where they were will help

051enormously in Transitions and understanding the culture and understanding the academics and how we the expectations from one grade to another um I think that we need to includ yeah so maybe it's not thought exchange for students maybe it's just direct feedback from students or parents Lally piece of paper like in the class I know it's like crazy and inefficient but it's almost like how do we foolproof you know how do how do we protect ourselves from like painting a picture uh you know um like it's a um an issue is so widespread and predominant when it's like it could be spread by one person or two people if they do it in gym if they like they all go to gym everyone takes out a Chromebook they fill it out once they're done you're not

052going to get 10 from the same kid right you're going to get one kid experience that's the only way to ensure that yeah I I would rather for the kids I would rather go that round I think there's two things I I don't think you're wrong I I don't know that I was explaining myself well in terms of a comprehensive thought exchange uh we're Gathering feedback from a lot of different groups of people with all their feedback in that space at the same time and people evaluating it my experience has been that middle schoolers don't always offer necessarily the best feedback in that space when they're mixed with everybody else what I do think is important though to that example of you you find other ways to gather feedback from younger kids middle school kids

053for example I would maybe put them in focus groups I would have them talk through certain classes and I would do some survey work as well I think there's just different vehicles I do think their feedback is valuable I was using the tool as an example of a place that their feedback is has not always been great to the point of the 10 people what's interesting about that is in thought exchange for example if if 10 people sign up and or one person signs up with 10 different accounts um and they'd have to they'd have to go to 10 different devices with 10 different ISP addresses right may may that's the scary part but even if their comment was the same what's interesting they'll tell you about it too that's the most fascinating in an

054exchange if you if you get 20 comments that are negative and they're similarly negative about the same topic it really doesn't matter if you have 20 of those comments or 30 of them or 10 of them it's the rating of those comments now they could do the same thing those 10 different accounts they could rate those comments High what I see happen more often is over the period of an exchange when you get more and more people in it tends to balance out and starts to mitigate some of the ways that people try in affiliate exchanges just because the way their algorithm works and over time that basian average they come up with tends to filter some of that out but it's a for a point that somebody could try me anything like that to

055it'd have to go to a lot of effort yeah I I think it would probably be okay I don't I think that they probably it's a lot of work and I think they would inherently not want to put that much work in like the high school students to keep doing it especially if it's a limited time and they don't have such an extended period of time to do it um in terms of middle schoolers the focus groups I think are great but I I don't know how successful they would be like I don't know if kids are going to volunteer things that they're struggling with especially in middle school it's such a hard time and I don't I don't know if they would feel comfortable cuz then you don't have any anonymity you know it's

056you're putting yourself out there and I feel like it's very hard for that age group would one way to get at it actually though is to do then that's a great point to do separate exchanges so you do an exchange with your community your staff adults in one space and then you do an exchange maybe with high school kids because their feedback will be distinct and different from middle school kids and then Middle School feedback yes and then you can evaluate it based on the levels that it's coming from and the particular ways that those Deval levels get out and to be honest I think that you're going to have different perspectives and I think there's going to be it will kind of make it easier to see what's important to which groups I don't

057think that the things that are important to Middle School schoolers or important to the high schoolers will necessarily be the same thing the parents are concerned about you know or that the staff I I think people are going to have very different viewpoints and they're going to be coming from very different places so if you do separate thought exchanges it might actually you know kind of help you you know focus on what's most important to which group as opposed to getting it all you know mixed up together we're probably going down the road where this is going to become a very long process so what I would recommend is letting Dr Rogers sort of give us yeah to do the work to get as much information as you can share the information tell us where

058you got it from and then we we can start from there and then if we start to feel like it's not enough info we need to go out to other sources maybe we take that step and kick that can down the road but I don't want this to turn into the two to three year process which it easily can turn into so it needs to be quick we no more advice we need to move this along right I don't think it's I don't think it's a strategic plan review but I do think it the short term feedback with you and the other element that I sort of want to emphasize is I kind of don't want the data filtered I want individual responses to come to us as opposed to someone collecting it for us

059summarizing it and telling it to us I want to see it raw because I want each person to have the ability to direct their own personal feedback and view at us I don't want it summarized concluded consulted anything like that I want everyone to have the anonymity to report whatever it is that they think is important I think we can do both I think it's actually important for us to have this distilled in way so we understand what are really the high level important factors that we're going to use and making an objective and at the same time we could also have raw data but I do still think it's important to have some kind of summary of what we're getting fine and where it came from because and then I don't mind have the

060summary and sorting at the end but I don't want the summary in the Sorting before the end after everyone gets a chance to have their own individual views represented they could come separately here's the summary and here's the raw then you does it kind of come summarized using thought exchange because then if I like oh I like what act I keep clicking it you go up on so it kind of self filters itself yes the algo does but the point is is that no no I agree but I'm just saying it does filter totally agree with yeah you're kind of going to get a summary as long as the universe of people responding is large enough that they can remain anonymous okay so if there's a category of student third grade teachers right it's very

061difficult for that group to remain anonymous if there's a category of central Administration it's very difficult for that category to remain anonymous and a thought ex streem parents it's easy right students it's easier right teachers it's easy or or staff right but what I don't want is um the inability for any individual to not be able to anonymously send their feedback to us even if it's summarized at the end I don't want anything curated before it gets summarized at the end in a way that people can't report anonymously what they think I see Dr Rogers taking a lot of notes so other comments can I just go just because there were a lot of Administrators weren't here when we were talking about certain words that got Incorporated in here and do you mind changing the

062slides to uh priority area too sure there is a word that we added multiple perspectives and just wanted to give you background story of why we put that there um you know Jack I I'm a slow reader I only got to chapter three but this kind of explained uh this book kind of explained well um so um children in this school district didn't feel didn't feel like they had any answer and they had narrowed down their perspective to one and that's where it's coming from that we can equip our students to see the multiple perspective not just one that they came up with and that's only thing that they see but they'll be able to see broader perspective great you ready to you ready yes okay right thank you so much thank you um this

063going to be a a lot of work for Dr Rogers and the team to do uh but this is a great step great step and then I you know we we look forward to uh getting the uh the feedback from the the leadership te okay all right and thank you again Dr M for all your really really enjoy being with you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.