001e e e for I'm so sorry good evening everybody and welcome to our February 12 Board of Education meeting at this time I would ask you to please rise while our student leads us in the Pledge of Allegiance thank you Hazel misss Jano any changes to the meeting agenda we have one change item 9e 3028 employee disciplinary matter thank you all right that takes us to item 5 a Dr scanlin so we're very uh lucky this evening to be speaking about some teacher recognitions and administrative recognitions in the room so uh we're going to start off with our first uh awarde this uh is one of our outstanding administrators our uh coordinating chair for secondary fiz head and health has been named the suffix Zone health teacher of the year Christina Driscoll [Music] [Applause] thank
002you thank you [Applause] just a couple more all right the New York State education department seeks to build expertise in the teaching and administration of virtual hybrid schools programs and courses the vital virtual implementation of teaching and learning educator program intends to develop a Cadre of expert or vital Educators who are able to TurnKey professional learning content to colleagues throughout the state vital educators will build their capacity to transform learning by addressing students diverse needs including students with disabilities English language Learners social emotional learning and culture responsive sustaining education crse through cutting Edge virtual learning strategies Innovative tools like Ai and more this intensive six-man program offers Dynamic online modules collaboration and professional learning York's Community PLC um cohorts and coaching sessions all designed to empower New York Educators to Champion virtual learning across the
003state we are very lucky to have two of our Educators in Three Village uh our Vital Educators Miss Gina verrai and Janine Lombardo [Applause] one side [Applause] a few more so this year we made nominations and uh if one of them is chosen as New York uh nominations for New York State Teacher of the Year this New York State teacher of year identify and celebrate one teacher per year as the New York State teacher of the year who represent all of New York State teachers at events through the state and at National levels with teachers of the year across the United States we nominated two teachers from the district for this year KD Wonderland and Virginia mcaffrey [Applause] okay [Applause] Flores and the district are Thanking us for doing these award ceremonies because they're making
004a lot of money tonight all right the New York State Master teacher program is a vibrant Professional Network of more than 1,400 outstanding Public School K through2 stem teachers throughout the state who share passion for their own stem learning and for collaborating with colleagues to inspire the next generation of stem leaders one of our teachers has been named as a bright light at the association of suffk supervisors for educational technology asset bright lights are selected due to their exemplary integration of Technology into educational environment so this teacher has gotten both New York State Master teacher program and the asset bright light award Nicollet de Martino [Applause] flow [Applause] okay so do them go so uh if the teachers that are honored tonight in their families would like to depart we understand I know you really
005don't want to stay for the next hour and a half of the meeting so we completely understand if you'd like to leave have a congratulations and have a wonderful evening all right that brings us to our student representative report Miss hazel kohas good evening everyone I'm excited to be back and sharing some updates from our high school after somewhat of a gap since since my last time being here due to break and midterms first off I'd like to recognize the incredible accomplishment of our science bolt team who recently took first place at the Long Island Regional science poow this achievement speaks to the hard work and talent of our students and we're so proud of their success on the top on the topic of science we also have three of our seniors Katie dang Daniel
006Yang and Sean Skinner being named scholars in the 20125 regeneron science talent talent search this is an incredible achievement and their hard work and dedication science is truly inspiring um I just I can't even imagine how much work goes into that um in addition to these academic achievements students wellbeing is also the top priority at the high school recently our team W initiative held a Stress Management Work Management workshop for students it was a great opportunity for everyone to learn practical tools for managing stress and navigating the challenges of school life everyone even got to go home with a cool little package with even with some stress Tools in them in sports news our word mobile cheerleading team has had an outstanding season they play second in the nation for their game day routine and
007six in the competitive division this team has made history year after year and this incredible achievement does not go unnoticed looking ahead to some of the fun events at school after a vote by the senior class this this year's prom committee recently announced the this year's theme of down the rabbit hole Allison Wonderland I'm so excited to see the outcome of the day and of the day and night commitment that the prom Community work that the prom committee Works towards prom being so unique toward Melville is such an amazing event every year that not only brings the whole Community together but has seniors excited for months and even years in advance we've also been hard at work raising money for important causes the student government's Raffles For A Cause fundraiser being one of our biggest
008of the Year raised over $1,000 for the Corey's promise foundation and and the Triumph music honor society's W Melville's Got Talent fundraiser showcased the amazing musical talents of our students both events were a great success and it's wonderful to see our Community coming together to support such meaningful causes another highlight from this past week is the seventh annual career fair which was organized by The Three Village industry Advisory Board in our business classes the event brought together students parents local businesses and Community leaders to explore potential career paths in fields of study a big thank you to miss Litman and the Three Village industrial Advisory board for hosting such a fantastic event as we look forward to the coming days we will once again be participating in the PSI love you day on February 14
009this event focuses on raising awareness around mental health and suicide prevention and our PBIS team along with the student committee has planned a week of activities to support this important cause it's a powerful reminder of the importance of creating a supportive and inclusive environment for all finally don't miss the word mobile players one act play this Thursday and Friday evening at 700 p.m. we also have varsity basketball playoffs coming up our girls team will play Thursday afternoon and the boys team will play Friday afternoon both at 4:15 p.m. it's a great opport opportunity to show your OPP to show your support for the student athletes thank you thank you Hazel great job as always and I will just say Karen and I were at the first prom committee meeting wow it's going to be something
010as usual all right that takes us to 6B our program review Dr Dan raldi hello everyone good evening Board of Education members of The Three Village cabinet and on behalf of Educational Services I want you I want to thank you for letting me present on all the wonderful things that all of our committees have been working on um all year and previous years leading up to our work this year so during this presentation I will be focusing on both Elementary and secondary um highlighting all of the work that we've been doing um we've had many goals this year um including reconfiguration um but uh not just all about reconfiguration we've also been working on other things to enhance our our instructional practices in our programs so I'm not going to um speak too much to
011the reconfiguration piece only because Mr honia Mrs Keem Mr Jansen had shared a lot of information in their presentations of what that will look like for our students but I will go into other areas as well um and and we've talked about this before I know Dr biscari has mentioned this but in absence of our state data due to to The Limited number of students that take our state assessments um we've discussed it before but we're looking for ways to um come up with other data points for our students to see how we're doing compared to um using our New York State Standards with our curriculum so we are using as web and I ready and as Laur perel's presentations has Al have also shared with all of you but um we're looking to come
012up with benchmark assessments that I will speak to Future in the presentation all right this is I think a great visual to show you all so that it may make more sense hopefully I don't confuse you anymore but um this helps me speak to what we do um each and every day in our subjects in our courses so if you want to look at the bottom starting at the visual within New York State learning standards that's what we use to guide everything that we do so looking at our curriculum that is our road map for teachers to use that's what we teach each and every day um and then if you want to go right or left if you want to look at the instruction that is what our teachers are doing if you go
013towards the left uh for assessment we're using that both to help us instruct but also to help us go back to our curriculum revisit it see where there's gaps to move forward and in our work and obviously we're always reflecting we're informing and adjusting so as you see all the arrows that's what it's showing um all contributes to our student learning so now for our elementary program um I just wanted to highlight the things that we already have in place for our students that we're hoping to have for next year so besides you know your our basic um areas of ela math science and social studies I wanted to highlight the other areas um that we that we have in place so our students have art they have health they have Library they have music
014and they have physical education um as far as moving forward this year we had a fifth grade as you all know a guidance counselor to help us transition our students um into our Middle School model so what we've done we've had our library special still with for those fifth graders to keep it consistent with all of our grades um moving forward we're looking to have that again for next year because um we our fifth graders will now always be transitioning into the middle school so having that collaboration between library and um our guidance Department has been truly remarkable it's really been a great asset to uh program for elementary and for fifth graders they will still continue to departmentalize for next year um mostly in social studies and science so we're continuing that um now
015I'm going to go into our math committee work um specifically for elementary so they have wrote curriculum uh last year for for our district and now we're looking to build our benchmark assessments so teach teers um on the committee they came up with benchmark assessments that are New York state standard based so those it's going to be the first time we're giving those out I know Dr mcari has been speaking towards this in this goal and we have done so this year so those students and those grades will be taking the Benchmark in June um and then that will give us information as to how to better our instruction moving forward they've also been piloting um math programs uh we are you know revisiting to see if what we have right now is best for
016our needs right as we've already wrote the curriculum so once we finish the pilot um towards the end of March then April we come back together and we decide on what program best meets our needs our elementary science committee so they have also written curriculum um uh this past uh year and now we're looking for other things to enhance the curriculum that we currently have so they've been they've been reconvening they've been talking through all those pieces and with the science investigations just to explain a little bit about that they're Hands-On Labs um they're not counted on the actual grade for the state assessment for our students but they are um a piece that has to be completed by our students so even if students come from outside of our district we have to make
017sure that those children had either received it in their District or are we going to have them um make sure that they take it with us um and they are categorized for grades three through five and then again for the fifth grade test and then for the eighth grade test they're looped grades 6 through 8 so now literacy okay I'm going to try not to overt talk literacy but that is really our one of our greatest highlights that we have going on as a district because we have made lots of a lot of shifts in this area um and of course it's one of the foundational pieces to what we do so um the literacy committee is a wonderful group of of Educators that we have administrators we we have teachers on the committee and
018we have piloted programs last year we went through many of them and we found the jackpot of what works best for us in our needs so with that we've adopted hmh into reading we also use hegr for grades prek K and one and then we have our foundations and all of those programs um I will go deeper into them as I present but um all of these pieces sorry I do have photos of them um they t certain areas in literacy and how we educate our children and how the how to read part so um I'll go into that a little bit deeper um also this committee though before I move on they've been writing our Ela K through 5 curriculum they've been very very busy because it is a very large task um they
019have been meeting weekly bi-weekly depending on their schedules uh and with that they're making sure that um everything is aligned like I've shared before to the New York state standards so all of um the research right now and all of the discussion over the science around the science of reading these are some of the shifts that we have done as a committee so New York state has given us a lot of guidance um and wonderful guidance so the literacy briefs I'm going to speak to that's one piece the New York State Standards obviously that I keep mentioning the five pillars of reading I'll go into that the big six skills and competencies and also the literacy best practice is for our early Learners and readers so something else that we've been uh visiting as a
020committee we did look into um these two resources we've read we've read um pieces of them together um and it's trying to have that shifting of what what we're trying to have um done in literacy in our elementary buildings I'm not going to go into all the briefs um as I promised the colleague I I wouldn't but um because I could talk about this all day but these are the briefs that the state has given us says guidance so each brief discusses a piece of the science of reading and it really just shows the shifting from what our earliest Learners in prek what that looks like and how it shifts into what our secondary years look like for our students so obviously phonics phic awareness more basic decoding skills happen earlier on and then we
021kind of wean off of that and we look at different things for our secondary students now these are the five pillars of reading um you could see them up there I won't go so deep into it but what the state has done this has always been P practice for many all districts but they've added this sixth pillar which is the oral language piece to uh what we do so it is extremely important there's a lot of research um based around oral language and especially in our younger years we're looking at ways and that's what where hegr comes in that program for our youngest Learners that's going to really focus on um the oral language piece to what we do this is the other document that um goes along with the best practices that I mentioned
022before so each of those six areas the state has broken them down for districts I just pulled up fluency just for an example that um every District needs to go through make sure that um their curriculum is aligned to these these uh six competencies and um rest assure we are very aligned but we are using this to help build out right our curriculum this is another documents so these this this committee these teachers these educators are working through all of these documents to make sure we're not missing anything for our students this here is I think you may have seen it before um but this is our Essentials of learning we've had this for many many years as a district but what is semi- new three years ago we did put this on on the
023internet so if you go to our website you can you'll have access to this I just wanted to show you the visual that um it shows you obviously the learning standards you can see on the left side so it can parents can see what standards that we're working on but then as each grade level when you when you click on them you will see exactly what um an overview of what is covered in every subject area so I do you know would love you to go visit it and see see what you think but it gives you a good overview I'm not going to go too much into this because we would replicate um Miss Keane and Mr janson's presentations but I just wanted to remind us of what our middle school program will look
024like um and just the additional piece um that we've talked about is electives offered for our students is Steam and we have start and I want to make sure that I could highlight that that's a course that is on self-awareness time management achievement results and teamwork so a lot of our executive functioning uh curriculum that has been written will be uh would be used for this sixth grade course and it's really supposed to be there to set them up for Success um it's going to be a wonderful course and I know that the students will enjoy it and it also helps with um the other subject areas of how to how to prepare for a research paper or project or um how to study things like that that will help benefit any student um I
025also wanted to to mention that we had our parent orientations at the middle schools February 4th for incoming sixth and seventh grade students which was wonderful um and they the students also were able to have visits to the schools and and the feedback was really well received the children enjoyed it um and I know the staff did a great job with that um the current eth and nth graders also had visits at the high school so that was a great transition period for them as well so uh all around has been very um successful for our kiddos this is also something I want to share um and a lot of you that have students at the secondary um children at the secondary level you would already have seen the secondary course catalog but I did
026want to at least note it here that our program of study is lives here in the internet um I also want to thank de Ruben shrunk and the technology department for organizing this um we in pinel's office as well uh took a lot of time uh and and a lot of work to get this um the way we really wanted it to be as as successful as we could um okay let me move on um this is what the program study would look like if you clicked on the link that I have below here and again this is the new face for us and it's it's beautiful so I thank the dep technology department for making that um all of our courses are listed within this document now I'm going to shift into CTE um
027for our secondary students and that's Career techn Technical education we already have two programs that I'll talk about but the these courses are work based learning experiences for our students they're handson they're very exciting the children actually they love it if they're if they're in one of these programs and they work through practice and they have application tests that they have to also take to have the endorsement so I know this is really small but again I wanted to highlight this is in our course catalog and it is an overview of our marketing CTE program so it explains exactly what the students would need um and you for 2026 and to 2027 school year we're looking to enhance our CTE programs and have another one in technology um we haven't figured out just yet the
028specific of what that will look like in technology but we know we want it to live there we have a lot of student interest and I think it'll benefit them uh to have it in that area so we're working with the state liaison she's actually a specific um Long Island liaison that has been helpful in getting us all the information that we need we um can apply October every school year that's the date and then it would take until the following year to really get approval and and get things in motion so we're already in the process uh with that there's a oop sorry there's also an opportunity for us to have um the Perkins Grant when you have three uh CTE programs so that would be extra funding that could be useful to help
029support students complete um this endorsement and I just highlighted again the child study one so these are the requirements we have the child's Child Care um program as well that students um can get the CTE endorsement with okay curriculum rating so again I've spoken I think a lot about these things so I don't want to overdue but we did have a consultant that helped us last year reala line what our documents would look like for writing our curriculum so the members on there we have directors we have chair people that were on that committee they did wonderful work around uh coming up with with what three vill should look like so everyone every District does what fits you know what's fitting to them so we came up with our own template and now everything is
030housed in the internet that again DJ Ruben shrunken her team has uh created so it holds all of our documents in this internet for teachers to access and be able to find that tool very easily so um in Educational Services that's our ongoing project um that we want to have every single course even the new ones that are that we create or we bring back uh we revise and we update that that internet okay this you've probably recognized through Laura pimentel's presentations but I just wanted to also highlight that we do have our response to intervention that is what we've called our committee for many years um that looks at student progress and ways that we can um help out in our tiered system so if you look here the green is our tier one
031services so that's support for every student in your classroom um and then as as we look at our data we look at our IMS web our I ready our future benchmark assessments that we're creating um if we need to support a student a little bit differently that's our tier two so it's more targeted um it's it could be classroom based or it could also be working with a provider whether math provider or a reading specialist and then if we need to go the next step to help that student then we we call it a tier three and it's a little bit more intensive uh could be 1 to one could be a few students um but the frequency and ratio would would change so this is what we've always called our team but now with
032um trying to make sure we're capturing our students as a whole which we always do we changed our look um Three Village style to our multi-tiered system of supports so mtss and if you look here it's the same thing I just shared with you but instead of just the academics we also look at students um their behavior we target that and the same thing we we go through tiered services for what that would look like um and then family engagement there that's you know it's pretty broad there's a lot of things that we do obviously with our families but um as far as this we really focus on attendance and how can we support students and parents with helping students you know coming into school and I know we talked a lot about that with
033Miss Pim tell's presentations that um you know we want to make sure that our numbers are are looking good for our kiddos to come into school so we just discuss this at all of our team meetings when we need to and again you can see my theme with the arrows um we always are analyzing implementing evaluating and defining what we do um so sorry I went fast but I was trying to not take up too much time but thank you so much for letting me speak tonight thank you [Music] [Applause] thank you so much that was wonderful does anybody have any questions comments okay thank you I actually I never mind um I just wanted to thank you and uh I this is one of my favorite committees which I'm weird I love talking to
034people that are on this committee because I just think the amount of work that you guys do is fantastic um you know between the teachers and the administrators and just the time and effort you guys put into that it's very appreciated um and very well done um um just a couple of quick things uh the time frame for review do you have um different areas of the curriculum that you look at every year and how do you choose that so there's a few things that we do reconfiguration that um obvious jump to the top right so we actually I didn't I forgot to mention this we have 24 projects going on currently uh typically we do those a lot of our curricul wunning over the summer but because you know time was of the essence
035and also we thought we needed a lot of teachers to be part of this that um summer sometimes you know it's not the best time for everyone so during the school year was definitely the the best way to go so it could be that a reason like that it could be that we're bringing up a course um that either we haven't hand in many years and bringing it back or it's a brand new course that um we have another committee that looks at those and decides you know is this going to be fit into our program or not um it could be um we look at the curriculum but also if standards change that would be another time that we would be doing that timely or every five years is typical for us to look
036at our programs that we use not so much the curriculum but that sometimes can change a little bit of what we do the way like our program could be formatted but typically every so many years if it's not a state change for us like the literacy best practices that just came even though the stand didn't change but they wanted us to look at certain things a little bit more closely then we just we just do it so I don't really have a Define like a definite answer for you but it's all based on what's what's coming down for to us and things that we have to enhance great uh thank you um and then just a quick thing about the literacy program so this is the first year that it's really in play correct correct
037um have you gotten any feedback yet on how they're working out so we have um the program so when Publishers publish they give you so much and that's their job right and then it's the district's job to go through it and the Educators the our staff to what to say what's really matching our standards and sometimes programs are not based out of New York so you also have to look at that um that standards could be different so um the feedback has been great it's been a lot of resources so we're trying to help now as we write our curriculum to just hone on you know what's the most important for our students um using all those different areas that I shared with you thank you it's really hitting all the the pieces that we
038need perfect good thank you very much you got it want to thank you Dr raldi I noticed Dr biscari had to go into for surgery and not be here tonight just to avoid doing this presentation so it is a lot of work that's been done having been the co-chair of the program Review Committee for 10 years when I was as an assistant superintendent I going to tested the hard work that's done by all the teachers and administrators on this committee over the years a former uh co-chair of the program Review Committee is now a board member sitting a few seats down Mr vizo uh back when him and Mr ketti were co-chairing the secondary program review many years ago it is certainly changed dramatically over the course of years of all the things that have
039gone on and regardless of whatever our changes are coming up for next year the state as as m u roughly indicated State always throws us a curve ball while we think 5 years we'll look at something something there's always inevitably something that comes along and that's where when as taxpayers and the community residents and parents look at this and board members um those are those unfunded mandates that sometimes hit us that caused the disruption in our educational budgets as we move forward and this year will be no exception as we have literacy uh being done this year we're piloting math which is next year and then the science standards are changing as well so all of your work in trying to keep all the things going on at the same time has been very admirable
040and we thank you and all the members of the committee that are involved in these changes thank you I I have one question Sue I have a question please so I have a young niece and she started to refer to chat GPT as my mind um have you thought through how you're going to deal with the ability to to generate college level writing college level math at any stage even young nie stage right is is that how I guess it's a very unusual situation that we are in now when it comes to education and it happens at college level happens at every level as far as I can figure out but I was frankly a little amazed that my niece's she will just go to it for everything right and she's quite young she's 12
041um have you thought through how you're going to deal with that so I work closely with d ruin shrunk um obviously and um she has many things in place we have our our uh Tech coaches also that uh support us in anything that we do so we're trying to teach students how to use these Technologies in any capacity that they can but using the right way so we know these things are going to come right even when I was a child you were a child there must have been something different that you know we we had that like we had Spark Notes there's different things that were not the same as AI but some qualities like that so there's always things that come that the children get ahead of um and they understand the few
042things about AI that I can speak to um you still have to you would still have to know what to ask for and what to search for and what to to say to AI for them to even gather the information for you um so that's one of the tools that we one of the ways that we try to educate our students that this is a tool but it's not everything right it's not all all of your experience and all that you're learning in school it's it's um it's something that will should support your learning so I know Miss Ruben can speak even more to that piece but um we work hand inand in in what that looks like like for our students so not to sound like a lite but now it will sound like
043a lite I it is bad as far as I can see right just uniformly negative the impact and Stan may want to kick in here but it's just uniformly negative this particular type of Technology on learning and uh it makes it really impossible to set homework all the homework can be done by computer um I it's I just a huge change and like I thought it was just more or less restricted to high school students and and a and college students but it's now clearly not MH and I I feel like that's going to involve fairly big changes in how you deal with the students in particular it's almost pointless giving homework in this kind of setting well you still have if you're talking through let's say math homework they still have to show their
044work and they're thinking so there's still ways I I understand what you're saying I I do um but there's ways that we can use AI to enhance their learning it's not you know we try not to look at it as 100% negative but ways that they can it's another tool that they can use to support their their learning just add one sentence I totally agree with that I have positive view of that that's a tool that can help improve our life so the reason why I've become a a bit well first of all I love AI right don't get me wrong I mean if I need to write something I just say write this for me and then I use that as a starting point I mean I'm not but I'm not learning how to
045write I always write already write well right I I feel like there's I I'm struggling for the words here maybe I should put it into AI to ask for it but but the things you said you could just say to AI well tell me give me prompts to to approach this and the same with the math I mean you say we got to show all the working you just tell it show me all the working right it's not like a calculator it it will go through in excruciating detail all the logic that it required to get to a certain point I think that's also part of the point with Dr viscar has brought up in several meetings about what we're trying to do in our own School District here is creating assessments that are reflective
046of the work that the teachers are doing like you said you can go to a computer just go home tonight and start talking about something in front of Alexa uh and or you know if you have Siri and then go to your computer and see what comes up you'll see that someone thinks that no one's listening someone's listening the computers are listening to some of these things but I think we you know the symbol in Chinese for opportunity and and danger is the same symbol and I think we have to we have to take into account that there may be a possibility that there are things that we have to be cautious with about this um but at the same time we also should be looking at seeing what opportunities there will be there for
047the students in the future they're certainly going to go into careers as we always say that are going to use these tools as they come out of high school and college and start going into the workforce so what is difficult for us is that we've been very Reliant and very the the people who just honored this evening as an example the professional development we're doing in this District to try to train our teachers in the new way that these tools can be used because for many of the teachers we have none of this existed when they were going through college so that's where we're very lucky that we have the people on and staff that can do this but we're all facing the same problem you at the college level the the certainly the elementary
048and secondary schools and the system and parents at home you know I witnessed my own son one night blurting out his homework assignment to to uh the computer and it was giving them the answers and he was just writing them down like you know it's a tool but this they've got to learn how to use it appropriately and thinking about students with special needs there's tremendous opportunities there for so many of our students who have issues maybe articulating or coming up with ideas and presenting it they can get some of the ideas brainstormed out there but putting it together in a cohesive fashion is sometimes difficult for some another great resource for us so I think it's about anything that we any tool we get that comes out years ago when calculators first handheld calculators
049came out people were resistant to actually using it the region actually banned them at one point you couldn't even use them on the region exams now now they're used very frequently so and there there's a balance to all this and that's certainly one of the topics I think we're going to talk a little bit further down on the agenda about using these things in Balance it's we're not putting students in front of computers and having them learn if that's the case then why do we have all the the wonderful teachers and administrators in our district that teach children on a daily basis why do we have college professors like yourself out there that are giving the opportunity to students to learn in different ways so I think I don't I hope to God we never
050get to a point where we eliminate the human factor in our educational system that we we constantly con uh use that but we also have to make sure that those individuals who are doing that are trained appropriately in some of these resources that they can they know how to use them and how to guide children effectively as they move forward for jobs that we right now probably don't even exist yet that we can't even predict so so one of the things that has increased my litness on this is the there's fabulous math online math teaching programs you know K Academy and um three blue one brown the these are fabulous like things that I never understood I would go on there and I would get a wonderful explanation for how the things are right if
051you look at nap math scores they've declined pretty steadily over the last 10 years right so what the same time with we've brought on all these electronic resources which are just fabulous right they're just these are the best teachers imaginable right and everybody has access to them the actual performance on standardized testing has gone down and but not in Three Village let's clarify so for most of the country did an analysis on yeah we've done quite well here thank thank goodness but nonetheless overall there've been at best neutral right and these these are things that seem just you know incredible for somebody who grew up with really some terrible textbooks and I think that that what you said is right that the personal aspect of it doing things in person having to use a pencil
052and a piece of paper those things Drive learning much better than electronic anything right and I don't think that's going to change I don't think AI I think AI is really not going to help that in any meaningful way that's my sense of it okay and so that's I I know Sher should k kick in here because there's a range of views if you were saying look we need to teach everybody linear algebra right because that's the the math that underlies these things right sure I agree with that and that leads to jobs and so forth I agree with that I'm not sure that that introducing much Tech into teaching I don't I've never I think there's an unconvincing case here that introducing Tech into teaching is helping I think it's a very personal thing
053I think it's a social interaction between the teacher and the student and that that's just vastly more effective than any kind of electronic process quick sentence standard standardized test has been developed many years ago and that doesn't develop over what's have been happening in the technology so I don't think we should use a score to judge what we learn or not the the career has this opportunity for our kids if we limit their access to this newly developed technology where putting our kids at disadvantage compared to all other kids Nationwide okay so so to be clear I'm not saying we shouldn't explain what it is and how it works I'm not saying that I'm saying when you do traditional tasks like English and math that we should be very careful to try to not rely
054on those in any meaningful way right and then the other thing now that we're on this topic because this has become a hobby horse of mine the remote teaching right I I heard you saying well I think it was probably at the council meeting that look we should teach about remote teaching or we get them used to remote teaching is a disaster from my perspective right you we get I get students who have gone through remote teaching courses they've learned almost nothing okay now you could say well we should prepare them to learn almost nothing or prepare them to learn more right but really we should just avoid remote teaching at all costs and tell them look when you go to look for colleges make sure that they don't do any remote teaching right I
055mean that's the way I would do talk to them I would tell them find out how many classes are being taught remotely and go to the college that does the least number of those classes so what I would say just as an affirmation for anyone that's sitting in the audience's parents or our community members um our administrators observe teachers throughout our district so I I can assure you that our teachers aren't necessarily teaching from a computer screen every single day there there's a lot of person I understand yeah so we're we're very lucky that way and all the classrooms I've been in this year and I've been into over 25 for for observations on teachers I can assure you that that Personal Touch is there and we're very lucky to have those Educators in those
056rooms that that do that the same is true with you know even mental health supports you can go online for some of the mental health supports and health supports but you know we're we've committed ourselves in this District to the number of social workers psychologist guidance counsels we have to make sure that we have that personal approach with all of our students I don't think my opinion we should ever get away from that but as I said before it is a balance and I do agree with Dr Lee's piece that we have to be prepared to train our students for a world that they're going into that we have no idea what they're may be going into or may be coming about um and my point about making that statement about understanding teaching about remote
057learning the fact of the matter is um the largest college in the United States at this point is the University of Phoenix that has over 500,000 students the largest oncampus school in the United States is Arizona and it has a 100,000 students on its campus so the online learning world has excelled whether good bad or indifferent um some of it became a necessity because of covid but we the cat sort of out of the bag now like how do we go back and I think there's there's great opportunity there too to learn how this but I want to make sure especially in my role as superintendent that we're training our students for a world that they're going into even if they had the experience of taking an online class not because we have to because
058we're home because of a of of virus or something because we need to show them that this might be an expectation at any level and I don't disagree with it if the colleges start getting rid of it then great let's then we'll go back but even at even in the corporate world there's a lot of online learning professional development that occurs many of our teachers take online learning programs as it stands now from universities all over the world so we've been very lucky that way so it's something that I'm not saying we have to agree with it but I think we have to understand it and sort of embrace it in some capacity indeed and I think that's the beauty of the partnership that that we encourage um it's there right it's there whether we
059like it or not but with strong teachers and strong families to create the guardrails and and the digital citizenship and the appropriateness and the beauty of creativity and and thinking hopefully hopefully we get through yes so I think that that that teaching and learning are both very social people orientated things I think that's what we need to focus on and that that really doesn't seem that seems very resistant to any new technology because the technology now is just unbelievable and yet I don't really think it's helping a whole lot and I I well I'm not you're want to arue you're both right I I it is intrinsically interesting right and so I understand why people want to study it I understand why people want to get on top of it I'm not saying that I'm
060saying for basic schools which is most schools that you're going to learn in primary and secondary that they're probably not going to help much understood thank you thank you for the perspective thank you very much all right definitely not generated by AI we have some budget information from Mr Carlson nice thing well it's not going to be quite so entertaining as Dr analdi however um so we we really start uh board Workshop uh budget workshops with the board in March um but this kind of uh sets a stage for it what our tax cap is um and a few of the uh pieces of information um that we need to to know in order to start building the budget uh and we've gone over these things uh with the bud advisory committee we've been working
061with the uh BAC since late October so uh first thing of course is the tax cap calculation what what it is and and that tells us uh how much uh money other than state aid we'll have to work with next year now this first slide this is the actual calculation uh as determined by the New York State com controller's office um so when we plug in our numbers to this it comes out looking like this so I'll go through these um explain each each line what it is and and how it it impacts where the number comes from and how it impacts us so start in the top right um is the um for the 24 for the coming up years tax cap we start with our current year tax levy right so on the
062top right where it says PRI year tax levy that's the current year we're in now right so that's 174,175 and I put what our tax tax cap calculation was from a year ago uh next to it so next line down is tax-based growth factor that is new property um new new additions uh Construction in the district it's not changes in assessed value like if somebody uh grieve their taxes or anything like that this is new new property that's being uh or structures that are being taxed that number cannot be less than zero as you see last year it was Zero meaning no no increase for that this year it's a 0.13% increase so and and the exact order that these have to go is was on the slide before uh so that 0.13% gets added
063to the uh prior year tax levy next line down prior year pilot pilot is uh payment L of taxes so typically it would be like let's say a a corporation that's in the district maybe does an addition onto their building that maybe they they're expanding their business they put addition on and in Li of getting an increase in their property taxes the uh Town's Industrial Development agency makes a deal with them and says you won't get a tax increase uh for eight years or whatever whatever length of time uh and in Li of that the Ida the Industrial Development agency makes a payment to us and it's called payment in Le of taxes to to make up for that loss of tax revenue now that's not additional money to the district that what that does
064is offset the uh tax levy that that the rest of the that the uh property owners in the district have to pay that's how it gets factored in here so so first we uh where we are we add the prior pilot we're going to get to coming up year pilot in a in a minute next line down uh prior year Capital Tax Lobby now I'll explain what that means um and how that number is calculated in a couple of minutes that's the next slide um but you can see from last year that's a subtraction right so it was 3.3 million uh last year uh this coming or current year this uh for next year it'll be 4.4 million that number gets subtracted from where we are so far and as I said I'll explain where
065those numbers come from because we're going to see coming up years t uh Capital Tax Lobby uh in a minute too now cap the the term Capital tax levy don't let don't think that that means a separate tax levy it's all part of the tax levy um if it were me I wouldn't have called it that because some people then tend to think oh wait a second is that in addition to the regular tax levy no it's not it's part of the overall tax levy uh so then those numbers all get combined that's the on you see in the right column adjusted prior tax levy 17.4 million the next line down Levy growth factor 2% that's the 2% when you hear 2% tax tax cap that's that number right there that number cannot be more
066than two but it can be le or 2% but it can be less than 2% it's based on the Consumer Price Index um at uh the one that's deter there's a number of different Consumer Price indexes uh indices I guess um as determined by the com controller's office for use in uh tax Lobby increases so for uh as you see last year was 2% uh this coming up year is 2% so that gets added uh that 2% gets added to that then pilot the upcoming Year's pilot so that's um the $620,000 that's on there for this coming up year now just so you know the pilot if you look at last year that $568,000 that's the same number that's in the in the 25 26 column for uh prior that those numbers have to be
067the same even if it's an estimate whatever was used as an estimate last year for for the coming up year has to be in that column the next year so in fact when I go on to the uh com controllers website and I input all the data to tell them you know what our tax cap uh or tax levy is expected to be next year and whether we can form with the cap that number is already in there I can't even change that so uh that's that's pilot and then uh add those together it's called What's called the tax levy limit then exclusions so uh what you see in last year ERS that's the employees retirement system so for the employee New York state employees retirement system and New York State teachers retirement system we
068pay which I'm going to talk about in a few minutes when we get the benefits but we pay a percentage of salaries into that it's called the employer contribution rate if that percentage goes up by more than two percentage points the amount that's more than 2% is an exclusion on our tax cap so last year the ERS rate went by up it was an aggregate of 2.1% so the 0.1% piece was an exclusion on last year last year going into this year's tax cap uh but going to next year there it's it's not at 2% so that's not applicable for this coming up year and then the next line after that is the capital tax levy for the upcoming year and you can see it's going from 4.4 million to 7.1 million next year I'll
069get to that in a second but the reason for that is a reduction in building Aid which I'll explain in a minute so when they all get combined together uh you can see the uh maximum allowable tax levy that's the term is for next year 80,473 730 which is a 3.64% increase over this year's tax levy that's with keeping capital projects the same as they are right now we'll get to that right now this is the capital tax levy where those numbers came from in the prior slide this is how they're calculated now have the three years because for uh the tax cap from last year it used the prior tax levy which was 2324 the coming up year 2425 now that number also as you can see from uh in the 2425 column Capital
070tax levy 4.4 million that's the same number that's in the 25 26 uh PRI year and again same thing that number cannot change change from one year to the next so what we have down for next year bottom right 7.1 million uh well depending on what if we keep capital projects the same whatever number that is though for this year that we're 7.1 million there that's the number that has to be used next year even though building Aid uh in the governor's proposal that's an estimate all of the everything in in building Aid so far is still an estimate even when the state budget is done in April and they say that's it State budget's done here's your state aid for next year it's still an estimate it doesn't matter what we actually get it's
071this is the number we have to use we have to use it now and we have to use it next year for when we do the pro year so now I'll go through and explain these so Debt Service uh Top Line that's our bond payments we have a number of outstanding bonds and this is uh what we pay in in those Bond payments principal and interest and you can see from the current year which is the middle column to next year it's going down down by uh a little over $900,000 uh the reason for the reduction is we've uh just now paid off Actually March 1 is the last payment for an energy performance contract that we did some years ago so we have last payment of that that's where we see the reduction in
072next year's uh Debt Service capital projects uh we're keeping the same as of right now our recommendation would be to not lower the capital projects because we always need work in our buildings our buildings are getting old our youngest building is over uh 50 years old uh they always need work um we've seen in the last couple of years we saw last year with um or a year and a half ago now uh with satet the the roof over the auditorium they always need work um so our recommendation is to keep that and really what we'd like to do over time is build that back up prior to the uh budget failing in the uh 2122 year uh that line was at $6.6 million so then the budget failing that number has to go to
073zero so that's why it got reset and now we're working on trying to rebuild it um rebuild it back up to where it was and perhaps higher uh the next uh the so the Bose's capital and the Bose's Aid so Bose's Capital that's our share of easn suff Bose's capital projects in their budget so we have to pay um we have to pay for their administra our share of their Administration costs regardless of whatever uh programs and services uh we subscribe to or even if we send kids there or not uh we pay over a million dollars a year in Bose's Administration fees uh even if we didn't send a single student there and we didn't get a single service from them we'd still have to pay more than a million dollars a year uh
074towards their Administration cost and part of that is this towards their Capital cost so that's that's using his calculation the next line down is building Aid so you can see the building Aid in 23 24 10.6 million then last year went down to 9.6 million next year down to 6 million so the reason for that is we're uh on our 2007 Bond we got all 15 years through counting this year uh of the building Aid on that Bond but we still have a few more years to go on the bond payments um as I've said before when we discuss bonds um when we do capital projects or or uh Renovations through a bond the building Aid comes in over 15 years um the 2007 Bond some of that was a 15-year term bond and some
075of it was a 20-year term bond so that's why we still have a few years left on payments of it but we have we've gotten all the aid in now this year so we see that reduction in the building Aid uh for next year which what what it winds up doing is it increases the tax cap and then the last line on there is our share of what Bose's is getting in building Aid so when you put it all together that's what it comes out to uh current years's capital tax levy which really portion of the total tax levy is 4.4 million and next year 7.1 million as I said our recommendation would be to keep the capital uh where it is of course if cap if the capital projects line was lowered that would
076lower the overall tax cap as well so we you don't have to decide that tonight I do have to submit this to the controller's office by March 1st but it doesn't lock the board into a decision it might still show up that way when when like news day puts out a report or something and they say here's because sometimes the Controllers Office doesn't or Newsday doesn't get updated information from the controller's office once it's submitted as of March 1st but again March 1st is the deadline for I have to submit what Our intention is doesn't mean that's what you have to do so um unless you tell me different tonight this is the way I will be submitting it to the com controller's office but again not locked into anything so now we talk about
077that service so uh so current year uh on the left side of the screen uh 10.8 million next year uh going down to 9.9 million and then how much of that 9.9 million that we'll have in next year's that service here's the years when that will will end up so go when we're here year a year from now talking about the tax cap uh Debt Service will go down by about $525,000 uh the 93,000 that's the um uh we will pay off the uh final amount on the um on the bonding of the uh settlement for the child victims act case cases uh 20 3031 that minus 4,455 th000 that's when we finished paying off the 2007 month so while we see now an increase to the tax cap and it's like a uh oh
078uh in 2030 that's going to be great new well 2031 actually that's going into the 2030 31 budget so it'll be in the year 203 5 years from now planning that budget there'll be a reduction in debt service of 4,455 th000 but not a reduction in building Aid so what I would recommend for whoever's here at the time uh is to at least do maybe two things with that put a chunk of that into increas in capital projects in the budget and the rest of it maybe lowering the tax cap so it can be some of both uh it's a lot of money in one shot to just lower the tax cap bu is nice but we could we really know the money is going to be needed in capital so that would be the
079recommendation then 2032 33 that um reduction of 4 million 275 that's paying off the 2014 te Bond because that whole Bond was a 15-year term uh and that year we will see a corresponding reduction in building Aid because they had the same the building a of 15 years term of the bond uh 15 years and then 20 3435 that's a um another energy performance contract that we did will end now the other uh big uh piece of information that we we once we have all it together helps us in in figuring out what we can can and can't do with with the upcoming budget is the employee benefit section so uh and within that the single biggest item is health insurance unfortunately our uh health insurance Health medical cost not just our health insurance medical
080course have skyrocketed especially in the pharmaceutical end um there's a reason why every other commercial you see on TV is for pharmaceutical companies because they know people are going to watch the commercial and they're going to say I need that and they're going to go to their doctor and say I need a prescription of whatever and they're going to get it and it's expensive it costs a lot of money so our premiums are going up 12.7% next year now we're not part of a nyip which is New York State health insurance plan also known as Empire plan uh which most school districts on Long Island are but even with they saw the big increases last year and the year before so the the uh cost for Empire or N Ship um is still higher than
081our cost even even with this increase that we're seeing coming up next year um and we're working on some things to try to lower uh costs that's not going to have an impact on this coming up year but longterm uh so for our uh health insurance all of our employees that have health insurance contribute towards that and the rate the percentage that they um pay towards Insurance varies depending on what unit they're in and it for the most part it's between 14% 18% we do have a couple of units that pay much more towards that but but those units have very few people that actually get health insurance that's why I didn't I didn't want to I didn't want to skew it and say oh between employees contribute between 14% And 50% because there's very
082few at that that higher end the vast majority of our employees that have health insurance pay between 14 and 18% towards it uh so now in actual dollars the increase to next year is about $5 million based on our currenc Stafford we do all of this stuff based on what our current Staffing is right now um this does not take into um um when when we start doing all the Staffing which uh Dr scanland Dr D bruski Dr mcari are having all the Staffing meetings now with all of our uh uh uh directors and executive directors and building principles um as we figure out if there's a reduction in positions for whatever reason uh then then these numbers can come down if there's less people on health insurance so what actually will go in the
083budget depends on what uh any staffing changes that are made also part of uh employee benefits uh is social security just like any any other employer we have to pay 7.65% of uh an employees wages into Social Security and that's up to wages of 100 for 2025 that's up to wages of 176,177 4 5% and the increase to next year again based with our current Staffing is about $350,000 uh other benefits um are uh workers compensation uh life insurance unemployment disability Dental um and those aren't changing very much and the increase the next year is approximately 38,600 we're self-insured for both workers compensation and unemployment so now the retirement system that's the other big piece of benefits uh now we all of our employees that either that do belong to a retirement system it's one
084of two it's either the New York State teachers retirement system or the New York State Employees Retirement System uh teacher certificated teachers teaching assistants and administrators are in TRS and everyone else is ERS um it's mandated by state law that all full-time employees uh belong to the retirement system um all part-time employees it's optional to it's up to them we can't um not let them it's up to them if they want to join they can but they're not required to and as I mentioned before the cost to the district for the Retirement Systems is a percentage of salaries that percentage is known as as I said the employer contribution rate now TR they do it a little differently though TRS teachers retirement system it's one rate for everybody now there are six six tiers in
085in both of the Retirement Systems uh tier one um well before before there were teers before 19 up to 1971 it was just the retirement system and then in 1971 the state decided oh we need to uh reel back those benefits um uh so they can't change the existing people so what they do is create a new tier say okay everybody that starts as of July 1st 1971 we'll call them tier two and everybody that was already here was tier one uh and then in 1976 they added tier three 1983 was tier 4 uh then it from 1983 all the way up to 2010 was everybody was uh knew that came in was tier 4 and then tier five started in 2010 and then quickly thereafter in 2012 was tier six and that's where we
086are now and each um each additional tier the benefits are a little less right so when when there's when there stories in the paper like back in in the uh 2008 2009 there were a lot of um lot of uh um especially uh school superintendant that had started back in the 1960s they had a lot of years in um all of their sick days counted towards calculating their pensions and you know with these with these big numbers and there was a lot of uproar so it was like well we need to create a new tier um so but it takes takes time for that to actually see some savings um but now it's it's been a while since uh tier five started as I said 20 10 so uh a lot more of our employees
087now are tier five and tier six um but anyway tier one uh uh one TRS is one rate for all all tiers for this coming up year it's uh 99.59% this year it was 10.11% so the rates going down a little bit which is great um but with based on current Staffing salaries to go up so that's why there's still an increase in the cost now some years those rates go up some years they go down um you know would it would be nice if it went down what the the years when it goes down a couple of percent is really nice um but you know that's not this year uh employees retirement system they do it differently every tier has a different rate and um so the rates vary the uh current year from
08811 point and now I'm only doing tiers uh three through six because we have no tier one we have no tier ones in either system uh and we have I think two tier two people in the employees retirement system so I'm not even counting that um so it's between 11.4% and 17.9% this year and next year it's increasing to between 12.9% and 19.6% and when you combine both of those Retirement Systems the increase to next year is approximately $426,000 this slide is I went over this with the uh budget advisory committee meting a couple of meetings ago and this updated a little bit since then because um uh teachers retirement system had originally uh gave an estimate for next year of between 9 and a half and 10% so I usually would take right in
089the middle uh but then they came out subsequent to that meeting till before tonight and said use 99.59% so I changed it so when you add all those things together the health insurance the TRS the ERS the Social Security and the other benefits um and you this year last year and then the difference uh it's about a little over a $6 million increase in our budget and if you go back to our tax cap calculation don't even really look at the bottom numbers uh bottom line numbers because that includes um the reduction in debt service the tax cap actually gives us about $3.5 million more in money that can be used uh to fund our budget not counting the capital piece of the levy so before state aid we have about $3.5 million more in
090tax revenue to use uh and before we've even looked at anything else we have $6 million increase in benefits so that's the quaner that we're beginning our budget discussions with so that's all I have for tonight and of course I'll be happy to take any questions sure okay I'll I'll jump in uh um so I understand it's not your recommendation to lower the capital project line but do you have any sense of let's say if that didn't say 3 million it said 2 million what that would do uh yeah it would be around two uh 2.6 2.7 something like that so that's from 3.64 to 2.7 you when I when I sit down and have my calculator I can tell you exactly that's Clos can't do that one in my head sorry Clos to what
091it was last year CL last right yes who else I just had a clarification question because I've been hearing this around can you just tell us the difference on why we would need to fund a capital projects line if we are doing a bond so we people that think because we might be doing a bond next year that why do we need this extra money in the budget which should be zero sure uh if the bond was his passed October and it passed be different story we don't know that it's going to pass if I knew if I knew it was going to pass I'd be more comfortable saying yeah sure lower the capital projects because we have the bond money coming um but not knowing that that's very that's that's that's what I'm worried
092about but regardless we still need some sort of money in that Capital project line because of things that come up every single year because with the bond that is for specific projects not for things that come up right on a yearly basis right like the ceiling at to to school exactly Dr mckin um just can you another clarification question the workers comp life unemployables um we're self-insured is that how I understood you to say that's correct yes for both workers compensation and unemployment and so what does that mean exactly these are just your your cost for last year that you're covering or what yeah so so what we do with so work is comp so work is compensation let's take that one first that's a bigger one than than unemployment so if you're you're an
093employer uh you have to you have to buy work as Compensation Insurance for your employees um there are very few employers that can self-insure we can so we do because we can and save money um so as an employer in when you when you you buy uh buy into like let's say for instance the State Insurance Fund for work as compensation um it it's not like like when we have health it's that different than health insurance all right like like we have health insurance all right so we pay whatever we pay towards health insurance for year and something happens and somebody has $800,000 a year in medical cost it's covered they don't have to make up the difference their insurance that's the whole idea of everybody pull the money together but that's not how work
094as comp works uh if you as an employer whatever money you paid in to work as comp and by the way this works same for unemployment whatever you paid in for towards your workers comp and unemployment if your employees collect more than that they're going to charge you for the difference not the employees the state will charge you for the difference so you'll always you'll always pay at a minimum um what your employees uh actually collect in in benefits either work as compensation or unemployment and if you had no claims or very few claims you're still paying in you'll actually pay in more because you you'll you still have to pay them in our case because we can we self-insure for both workers compensation and unemployment so we only pay for actual claims so we
095know every year there's going to be some work as compensation claims and some of them last years you know it's not just br new claims for the year um there are always going to be workers compensation claims there are always going to be some unemployment claims we don't have a whole lot in unemployment it's not very much money um but we do have we do have some uh and we do have a reserve for workers compensation and we have a reserve for unemployment insurance um so so we our goal is to really cover that Year's costs in the budget because otherwise if we just say well just paid out of reserves well a couple of years goes by then the reserves are gone and then we have we still have to pay for it so
096um we're not anticipating uh a cost increase in workers comp or budget increase in workers compensation um unemployment if we get to the point where we're accessing people um there's a chance that they go on unemployment if they're being accessed so what we would do is for every position that's being accessed so we lower the salary amount right in the budget we lower the whatever that person's salary would have been we lower the Social Security part for the 7.65% that we would pay in for their salary we lower the uh retirement system line for the percentage of their salary uh we lower in health insurance because if they're no longan go cover by health insurance but we'll add to unemployment because they we they might collect unemployment we don't know that yet so by the
097way the um 2% on the t uh Capital project would still come out to right about just a little over 3% so uh it would take about if we did a million and a half then it would be um it would be about 2.7% I can figure it out like I said when I sit down I can figure it out exactly but it would be about that yeah so sticking with that for a second and recognizing that we want to be partners in this process if we were to say tonight I don't and I don't know whether there's enough consensus here but if we were to say tonight yes would like to knock that down to 2 million um does that help you or hurt you help in what way in a global way in
098your process I mean listen the more that's in the capital projects I mean the the the more com IB of course um but I understand the you know what it means to see a number a tax uh increase of more than 3% I understand that if you wanted to get that tax levy increase down to 2.9% or whatever you know that's certainly understandable that's why we wanted to bring this to you tonight and and and to talk about it to at least you don't have to make a decision tonight uh but at least get you thinking about it and see if that's something something you wanted to do so I'm not going to I'm not going to have a temper tantrum if you say we're lower it if that's what the question was no I
099won't okay I have another clarification question so the rates on the retirement I understand this is very complicated because of the tears right to understand what the rate changes mean but I whenever you say self-insured or we're paying money to the state I worry about future liability so what is the potential things that are do we face any dramatically increased liability for these for the retirement New York state is losing people let's let's put it another way losing people their tax Bas is declining that makes it in most situations where that's happening that makes it much harder to cover public service employment um retirement funds right five years from now 10 years from now would we be facing a potential much larger I don't think so um so we're we'll be seeing a lot of
100retirements coming up soon right so on the one and not just not just Three Village um so there will be a lot more retirees collecting so on that side yeah but for the most part they'll all be replaced um so you'll have addition unlike Social Security where you know if you look at you know back in know 1940 whatever the number was you had five people PID into social security for everyone that was collecting or whatever the number was and now you have you know two people collecting for everyone pay or whatever it is um it really wouldn't work that way with this and um the as as so not to be morbid about it but as the tier one and tier two people die off um you know they're the ones with the richest
101pensions comparatively speaking um you I'll take my myself I'm at the very end of the Baby Boomers right I was born in 1963 so um as the the you have a the whole pretty much all of the Baby Boomers are all retired now um including myself um but so as they you know again not to be morbid but as they die off um that's it's a lot of people that are collecting retire pensions that will cease to be collecting pensions and there'll still be still be a lot of people paying in I'm I'm hopeful by the way I I didn't put it in here but there there was a time way back uh back in the 19 80s into the 90s maybe even where the that rate was now 9.9 59% for next year for
102TRS was 20 2 2 23% used to be much higher but then of course it got it got real low around the year 2000 2001 because a lot of the what drives the rates is not just how many people are paying in bless you how many people are collecting but they invest their money I mean there's billions and billions of dollars in in both of these Pension funds and they invest they have Investments and how well the stock market does drives what the what the uh contribution rate is so back in the early 2000s the rate on TI s got down to zero we didn't have to contribute at all didn't have to pay anything because they made so much money in the stock market because if you remember back you know around you know
103late 1999 22 2001 the stock market was just just boom the economy was booming um so I mean I I don't know 10 years from now but I don't I don't think it'll be much more than this it kind of has leveled off in the 10% range for tier like I said it's been down to zero it's been up to 23% it's been everywhere in between um but it's in the past few years it's leveled off in the 9 to 133% range so hopefully that will stay long term at least it it's much better for budgeting if it's not that that huge increases it's nice when it goes down but it's not so nice when it goes way up one of the factors that we have to be careful with and as the BAC has
104been looking at this um when we try to do comparisons of District to District the scattergram that we provided to the board um we gave you the past 5 years so you could see as the particularly the teaching staff here has been going through we have a large portion of our teaching staff that at the highest end of their experience in years um so yeah they're closer to the retirement age the vast majority of our teachers than than are newer and some of those other districts that people like to compare us to because oh they're cheaper Than Three Village it's because if you look at their teaching staff again the majority which is majority of our budget is for for salaries and particularly teaching salaries we are a school system not anything else um so
105we we pay for people to teach students in classrooms their staff is much younger on the younger end of the system newer and therefore cheaper and that's why their budgets are lower so we are going to start seeing as Mr Carlson just described we have 55% of our teaching staff right now at ma 60 and 28 to 29 years of experience that's very topheavy so as that starts to retire that's where that cost savings is going to occur that's Point number one point number two the average person sitting in the room here probably not paying attention to anything going on in the world with the state um or people watching on on on this program watching our board meeting online if you have issues with the state budgets be reminded that our current budget as
106all School school districts we have caps for reserves in the 4% range the state is sitting on a 15% reserve and their budget so while districts are capped at four the state's sitting on 15 so while the worry as you indicated that people leaving the state population changing Florida Texas are bigger than New York now when I was a kid New York was number one we're now four we're probably going to drop to five or six very shortly in the next census uh if not lower um the the state and of itself is sitting on reserves maybe in anticipation that I'd like to hope that's their plan but I don't who knows what they're sitting on that am money for um but that's all of us paying taxes uh going up there and it's being
107sitting in reserves and if you want to talk to your area politicians about how much of your tax dollars you're getting back on Long Island compared to what we're helping fund three4 of the state from what we're what we're doing here so we're not getting the same bang for our buck um I've heard everything from you know 177 cents on the dollar to 27 cents on the dollar what we get as a return for what we give to the state for our purposes and taxes no I the thing is I didn't really fully understand how the the tax system that the U retirement system works it's sort of like a managed 401K in a way it's it's not like a lot of these Municipal um retirement funds which are pay as you go or like
108Social Security so we're not what you're saying there's a big Capital buffer basically the the both well one nice thing about the New York State uh oh by the way I think I I I think one and a half million on Capital comes out to 2.79% but have that like I said I have to double check that when I get to my calculator um but I think I think 2.79% but okay um but but these Retirement systems are fully funded so not like social security where it's yeah you know there's there is enough in the uh retirement system so theoretically if everything would end today no more schools no more public employees in New York state it all ends today everybody's gone and there's enough money there to pay out the pensions um that that
109they have in place um so it's it's not uh it's not operating on a Sho string kind of thing can I just one thing I want to add one thing I mean we have a lot this year with our budget you know the community it's a lot in our pockets you know all of us so I'm looking at the tax levy and I'm listening to what you're saying then all of a sudden you're saying oh it's it's 3% last year we had 2.84 now if we keep it this way at 3 million we're going to go up to 3.64 that's almost a 1.0 jump I wouldn't be able to sleep with that tonight so I'm going to make it where I would say I would like to see it at 1.5 in order to bring
110that below that 3% at least to and you just said hopefully the 2.79 because then it'll even be a little lower than what we had last year correct yep that's what so shall I consider that a motion I would like to make that a motion if we have four votes okay do we have a second second can I discuss something too before the voting on that motion okay well we got a motion table we got to walk it through hold on hold that thought okay so this this difference and benefits the $6 million that we're oh sorry we got to walk through the sorry gosh that's okay that's okay all right so we have our first we have our second all in favor of knocking it down to 1.5 from 3 million can I ask
111a clarification we have to we have to call the vote I vote for that one two three four okay you got your four can I ask my clarification question there I guess stand gets to go first and then you get to go so the this I guess we already voted on but the capital budgets whether it's 3 million or 2 million or 1.5 million none of that can be put towards paying that $6 million difference that we need to make up correct only be for Capital all right so we still need to find a way to get you know pay for that full 6 million we don't have control over any that and uh in in a bit of good news I was wrong it's not 2.79 it's 2.78 oh so so so yeah but
112but good point uh uh the Capital Money the reason it's excluded from the rest of the tax cap calculation is because when the tax cap first went into effect uh the state legislature at least had the the good sense to say well they didn't want school districts to have to choose between educating kids and taking care of the buildings so that why it's done separately that's that's part of the reason uh but but part of the reason too is like things like Debt Service right so a bond a bond referendum is the referendum is the voters approve the bond so when the voters approve a bond they're approving the projects themselves and the pay the borrowing of the money and the payment back of that money so that's why there's already voter approval on paying
113that so that's why that's not subject to thex tax cap the 2% part of the tax cap so that money can't be used for anything else okay Dr mckinon well you're going to hate this question too um we're putting this on top of an 8% increase or at least mine was I think was 8.2% increase that people saw for their Actual taxes right their property taxes right um do you want to comment on that well sure um so our tax levy uh last year from last year to this year from last year's uh went up the 2.84% 85 8 84% 2.84% that's what we raiseed the tax levy by that's how much more money we're getting in property taxes this year how that gets broken down is a different story so if anybody paid more
114than that that means somebody paid less than that uh so now a couple of things happened uh one was there was a change uh to the uh senior citizen limited income exemption uh by increasing the dollar amounts to qualify for that exemption and and remember that's the whole sliding scale um so that by creating a uh increased exemption for the people that got that that meant for whatever they saved everybody else had to pay for that so that increased everybody's tax the average the average let's say in Three Village uh School tax bill went up by about $42 because of that uh but then something else happened the store program right the stor is New York state school tax reduction now some people um well some people don't qualify because they make too much money
115some people don't qualify on their on a house they uh have here CU you only get it on your primary residence so if you own more than one house you own a rental house you don't get it on that uh and then some people get a check directly from New York state for that instead of a deduction on their taxes some some get the check directly some get the deduction on their taxes either way if you get the check directly or uh if you have that deducted from your tax bill the state lowered the amount that they're paying for Star this year compared to last year so if everything else stayed exactly where it was your tax bill would have went up because of that because they are paying less than they were so that
116means your tax bill had to go up to cover the reduced amount that they're paying so he had that to it and then another thing happened so there was a mistake made uh in the I believe it was in the assessor's office when when we had a call with them they said they made a mistake on when they did exemptions on some Stony Brook University property and and they erroneously were going to charge too much of the school taxes to them there's some there are some properties at Stony Brook University that are subject to property taxes too much was going to get charged to them somehow they caught the mistake before those bills went out but they didn't catch the mistake in time for the homeowners bills to go out so what that meant a
117year ago was your school tax bill was too low now not low enough where you'd open your tax bill and say whoa what's going on why did my taxes go down so much yeah it averag about $185 per homeowner so um with the 2.4 84% increase you would have still seen an increase in your taxes just $185 less than it should have been so now this year when the tax bills just went out a couple of two months ago um they're correct for this year but it makes the increase seem like more because last year was lower than it should have been so we had a call with the tax receivers office uh and you may have seen the the letter that Dr scandin sent out back then in uh December um and now I
118knew the when we were talking with them I knew the answer to the question but I wanted to hear him say it I said well are you going to send out r tax bills for last year and they said no it's too late to do that so okay I knew that but I wanted to make sure of that and then I said well okay now by the way you add all that up to $185 each it adds up to about $2.4 million so I said well okay well who's on the hook for that $2.4 million they said well the town is so the good news for Three Village School District residents is collectively you paid $2.4 million less last year than you should have the bad news for town of Brook Haven residents that don't
119live in Three Village is they had to make up for it so um anyway so what made this year's increase seem like more than you know when you have the 2.84% increase plus the senior citizen exemption plus the where the state's paying less in the star program plus you had the more of an increase from last year because of the mistake made by the town of Brook Haven it added up to maybe five and a half for some I I think on average it came out to about five and a half for a lot of people and maybe if you was eight or but whatever but so you add all those things together bottom line though is our what we're getting is 2.84% more than what we got last year in tax Lobby and then
120when you throw in the assess values you know when when somebody somebody Grieves their taxes right somebody Grieves their taxes and they get a a lowered uh assessment so their taxes go down but what happens well everybody else's goes up a little bit so that's why I use the example you know 10 people go out to a restaurant the bill comes and it's $300 and you say okay we'll pay $30 each and then someone says well wait a second I had I had a you know whatever I had a bowl of soup and a glass of water I shouldn't pay $30 so okay they'll pay less well you only pay $10 well that doesn't mean the restaurant gets $20 less it means everyone else has to pay a little more same thing happens with um
121grievant taxes somebody gets their assessment lowered their taxes go down everyone else's goes up a little bit what is the distri we don't take any questions from the audience I'm sorry thank you you're welcome to stay after if you have any questions so seeing no other questions about the budget we're going to move on thank you Mr Carlson we appreciate it Su Sue I just want to I just have a question how many people was there any nose or it was a 60 no so we had we had 1 two three four David was four who was a no on cutting it from 3 million down to 1.5 were you a yes right you're yes and you were no so Stan was your only no okay that's why I said thanks okay uh moving on
122now to items for board discussion we begin with a Chromebooks Dr scanlin so actually I'm going to turn it over to Mr back if he wants to discuss uh his questions that came up uh sure so this is um this was it's actually related to some of the discussion I think Dave David was talking about earlier in terms of um how we're using technology Chromebooks edtech within within our school so a lot of these is like just a lot of thoughts I have that I want to express maybe have have some discussion too so um years ago uh when you know kids had access to a computer at home they would you know you think oh they're getting ahead they're learning all this Tech now whereas I think things have shifted now where you know
123it's the opposite it's almost like kids who have more screen time restrictions seem to get an advantage later on when they're when they're going into school um in my mind the last thing that young children would need in the current world is is more screen time right and so I hope that when the district is introducing technology in the classroom this is sort of done intentionally and not just um you know other districts are doing it or we have a nice grant that that allows us to do it and therefore we should do it uh it should really be as a supplement to the the education right and so um parents May sometimes get the impression that for example if you have like a Chromebook that gets sent home over a midwinter break that you
124know the teacher is telling you that the kids should be using the Chromebook right um similarly if there's teachers in early Elementary classrooms they might get the impression that if our district is buying Chromebooks and paying for software that they really should be using throughout the year right in my mind this is you know slightly backwards right of course if the teacher sees an advantage in using a certain piece of software that's that's great right but it's it's not like we're encouraging them that you you know need more Tech as you're you know going through the education process especially in in early Elementary um so I know that there are some districts that have you know several hours a day of screen time doing basically gamified learning and I even heard this discussion there's like
125this dystopian future where you just have large rooms with minimal uh adults supervision and the kids are just on computers all day learning things and of course I would prefer to avoid this I think that a lot of people would right so uh it's basically coming down to what was what was said earlier that it's more effective to have you know teacher time have more teacher time and have less screen time um and so Chromebooks they're they're not free right we're paying for them the software uh edtech is not free um I I do worry that edtech is not really shown to be effective in many cases so in our own District we we have you'd had reading software years ago that was basically doing the Lucy cockins literacy curriculum you know I was it
126had leveled reading you had you know look at the picture and guessed the word and there was patterns and sentence structure throughout the uh throughout the book right and then of course all this controversy came up and science of reading became more popular um you know to and you know there's more emphasis on Phonics and when I look up this this this you know software company they they just rebranded they changed their name and now their whole website is all about science of reading right so the uh you know on the one hand this is good hopefully they've seen the light and improved their product but you I think probably the more honest case is they will sell us whatever we're willing to pay them right and they you know they're they're they're for-profit companies
127and that that's their their primary motivator um uh there's other products so there's like Prodigy which is a math game that I think we use in our district right a few years ago they were the target of a FTC complaint from Fairplay which is a child advocacy nonprofit and so they they've made some changes to the software since but what was the complaint right it's it's it's a software that's using a premium model so it sounds like a free math learning game right that sounds good uh but uh this the the the the software would aggressively upsell to students to get them to try to play at home which again was free but then they were free to advertise them to buy a membership and if you bought a membership then you get just cooler
128character that floated on a cloud and compared with your friend you know your friends would see this right and then they'd have some pressure to spend money on the software um and in these types of software there was complaints that students spent little time on math and they were more busy doing things like shopping digging for bones or looking at their pets right um so they still they had research studies right funded internally that's showing you how effect of the game was at at teaching math so so I have a lot of concern for this so it's the point is not you know any one specific piece of software but the sort of General Trend where Ed where Tech is getting into our schools and it's replacing time with the teachers and especially in early
129me elementary I would think it's best to minimize time on screens um and so beyond edtech the next thing is AI and we talked about this a little bit too right I saw some of this at the at the nisba convention where you had different companies advertising look their product has Ai and this how great this is for Education uh and I'm very uh I'm very I think we should be very mindful of how we use this even if they're even if they're free right I worry that there's a real danger uh using AI that we're losing critical thinking skills right these are going to be eroded even further where you can Outsource the thinking to chat GPT or whatever whatever product has has AI embedded in um from from a financial standpoint I mean
130uh we could ask the question are onetoone Chromebooks are these essential in early Elementary would it be worth analyzing if there's any potential savings uh and this includes things like the software that goes on them things like goguardian monitoring that that that our district sort of does and I don't really expect immediate answers on this but uh I think we should have a healthy skepticism of tech and you know AI uh within our schools so I I don't disagree with you but um having been the assistant superintendent for educational servic for 10 years here I've witnessed the the change over and this is my 34th year in education of going from textbooks to the technology um so I don't I don't think we should be myopic in our approach about how we view this the
131technology has a place and I can assure you and all the rest of the board members here that our particularly our primary teachers are not using Chromebooks on a daily basis or in every single lesson they're also not sitting idly in chairs with you know hearing lectures from teachers they're actively engaged in lessons if you've ever been around a kindergartner whether you want them to be actively engaged or not they're engaged they're their minds are moving a mile a minute with a million questions and that's that's a good thing um um but there there's a reality that we also have to face to here we shouldn't vilify the technology because of studies that are being done about certain things what also should be done in the home compare to the school yes the school can
132limit it as much as we can we also have a technology committee that actually has policies and procedures in place for that but the home environment we have no control over um and if Miss Ruben stru is not here tonight um if she would tell you we actually um do uh do a lot of analysis on when we have the Chromebooks at home when students are on and to the surprise is some families we contact them that your child's on the Chromebook at 12:00 at night or 2 o'clock in the morning that is a parenting issue more than the school's uh issue at that point in time if you're going to bed assuming your child is going to bed and whether it's a Chromebook or their cell phone some type of downtime should occur for
133those devices um the one thing I will tell you that is the unfortunate circumstance with some of the textbook companies yes you're correct they they've seen this as a new way of making money um however and giving you an example when we moved to Discovery techbook for the district when we had to replace our science Series in the elementary level uh the cost of the books uh compared to what we uh what we did with Discovery techbook it saved the district $475,000 over the course of a six-year contract that's the reality of what we're dealing with now with the budgets being what they are the books themselves are are actually more expensive than the technology and that's that's a game you're right you know the companies are playing this game where they're making the technology
134cheaper get us off the books um so we don't have to use them as much I'm a fan of books personally just come to my house you can see all the books in there um and I think there's a purpose for that as well if you go to all of our classrooms in the district you're going to see books actual books in use just as Hazel she can tell you where how many books she's reading probably right now for our English class um but there's also some of the some of the series like for our AP courses not all of the books are available in electronic format the college level texts uh from many of them are only available in a hard copy format um which just to give an example one of our science
135textbooks cost us over $250 per book so they're raising prices exponentially in some areas so I do agree with you there has to be a healthy balance to all this and we have to be cognizant of the screen time um many of our elementary schools in particular have gone through things where they've had you know uh techn technology free nights you know you know game nights with your family trying to get all the devices and that's it's not just for the kids um if we look at some of the adults um even in this room tonight how many people have been on their cell phone while this meeting has been going on or on their computers while the meeting has been going on so there's a that we've become a society dependent upon technology um
136and I think there's a healthy balance that we have to strike in there so I don't disagree with you but what I will be happy to do is we'll bring the topic back to the technology committee um I will check on the next date of that committee and if you'd like to attend whoever is the uh I don't think we have a board rep on that committee right now but if we don't we should probably discuss maybe having one of you attend that committee on a regular basis okay thank you I just like to Second what Stan said I hadn't actually realized he was going to talk about the same thing I already talk about I apologize for that you preempted him yes I apologize for that so I just want to Second basically what
137St said unless benefits are clearly demonstrated we should pull back on electronic devices and electronic teaching I think unless you can demonstrate a clear advantage over the old ways of the best then I don't see we shouldn't feel any pressure I both St and I work in Tech fields and what I think what we're trying to say is nobody should feel pressure to adopt Tech unless there's a really really good reason right here and I think people feel pressure to do it to keep up to maintain currency and to give the kids an edge and all these other things but doesn't actually do that and you need studies and hard data to conclude that and I think I think that's what Stan's saying as well and again I don't disagree with that at all and
138again with the just the the classrooms that I've been observing this year um the the classes that I've seen there's been very little use completely of Technology there's maybe portions of lessons but the younger and younger the students and or perhaps the students of High need I've yet to see where it's solely a tech lesson anywhere in our district so I think our teachers understand that um Any teacher that you know that we have understands the concept that it has to be also a balance of things in the classroom and and engagement doesn't necessarily mean putting someone in front of a computer and and having them learn that way I I completely agree with that okay so thank you for that setup that I'm going to use my phone now to read something because I
139forgot to print it at home but next on our agenda is discussing our property analysis committee I will read you the charge for said committee property analysis committee pack is established to provide input and recommendations to the school district's leadership and Board of Education regarding the potential lease or sale of real properties owned by The Three Village Central School District so tonight's the night last night if you are interested in getting your application in we'll be reviewing those and we will make our selections by the next meeting and it is up on the website so thank you all right that takes us to 7 C now security Dr scanland so we have presented at the last meeting the options for the board for consideration we're just wondering if there's any questions from the board at
140this time with those options that are presented and any movement in any capacity with the these uh this topic i' just like to know uh from Jack where are we with the cameras the zero the zero eyes company is actually GEOS spacing all our cameras with GPS coordinates so that when the if the if the zeroi system activates the police department as well as our internal security will know exactly where the initial detection occurred and will follow the detection throughout the building so right now we're GPS location every one of the every one of the cameras it's actually it's actually a very it's a very tedious process and how long do you think that'll take I think we'll be done probably maybe about the first week in March it it integrates floor plans with Google
141Maps it's quite it's actually very it's actually very interesting how how it's all put together um I whomever wishes to answer this but in thinking about um you know all the different ations that we've discussed if we were to arm guards would they be outside only if we were to arm guards would they be outside and inside and what does inside look like um you know do we do we have the ability to create options where they are segregated in the building in other words not roaming we could I don't know if that's completely efficient but we could do that if you'd like to do that you know the I think the element of I don't want to use the word element of surprise I think the element of surprise is is is is more
142advantageous than segregating the security person to a particular part of the building because everybody's going to know where that is eventually you know and I I just you know again you know I I hope I hope that you look at some of the other Alternatives maybe some out maybe outside arming to to kind of you know get us started uh you know I do have I you have a couple of highlevel Supervisors that are law enforcement that roam this District during the day they are not assigned to a particular building you know the I threw an option out to to Dr scandin and maybe having those two individuals who are you know their office is here one's here one's at old dad been building on Nicholls road but they're roving around the district during the
143day you know I'm trying to just come up with some options that you know you may you know that may make you feel a little more relaxed about this this topic rather than jumping you know headon into it we could kind of work our way into the system I I appreciate that because I think you can probably tell from my reticence that it it it's a huge leap um and I personally I I do think a measured approach um might make the most sense if we were to to do anything like that yeah I I agree with soe um I think what would be helpful is if we had a detailed list of what each of these um uh possibilities would be I mean do we need to hire staff how much do you think
144that's going to cost how long the implementation is going to be to get that done I think we need to know the nitty-gritty of all of these different options um including maybe anything outside of the box that you're talking about um because I agree I think we need to proceed cautiously and not just delve into something um but we need to know what that's going to look like because right now we're talking up here and I think we need to know you know down here what's going on and what it's going to be right and I I will will be happy to give you that information uh and share that with you um but you know from our last recommendations there would be at this point in time based upon the current um staff that
145are in within our security unit no need to hire any additional Personnel the trainings uh that we were talking about there's qualifications and things of that nature that might have budgetary implications and things that we'd have to consider right I mean I don't want to go over any numbers or anything CU I don't like talking about that there but just say as an example we wanted outside guards but that might be taken away for people that were inside the building so maybe we did need to hire four more people here or there you I mean I just need to know what that is absolutely and and that would not be the intention of diminishing our our our security footprint inside the buildings at the expense of having someone on the outside of the build building
146um but it's you're you're faced with a quandry in in the sense of when you when you looked at the survey of what the different ties are doing how many are arming both inside and outside how many are arming just inside how many are just arming outside how many are using private companies how many using are own we've been very lucky because our present our hiring practices because of what we've done in the past several years uh who the people are that work for our district right now and their qualifications um we already know a number right now what that would look like like we can provide you that detail um as far as parameters if if the board is charging us to try to come up with that for you we already have some
147things that we can present to you on that what that would look like however um risk it sounding like Jack for a moment that's probably not something publicly you want to address because um you know if we said oh the the armed guard is going to have a vest on or wear a yellow pin well Hazel can tell you and half the students that were here they'll figure that out about 5 Seconds they're sharper than half the adults they'll know exactly who who the guy is with the gun in the building so um if it's just limited to an individual of that nature so we have to be very cautious about what we indicate because just as much as we are sitting here watching this and and or participating in some capacity there are not
148good people out there also doing the same thing and there will be people that will want to know okay if I'm going to go there this is what I'm going to have to try to avoid so some of the things we already have in place place with our cameras and this new system are are pieces of or tools that we are able to use they're one part of a multifaced or approach to security and I think we we certainly can provide further information for your for your edification and and moving forward with whatever the decision is by the board yeah I think I think right down to the Brass tax of what that would be in in humans in equipment in any changes to our insurance any changes at all I think having all of
149that to consider would be important did want to say it is for me again speaking only for myself it's a testament to those people that that you've hired your staff that is the only way I would ever consider it me personally because I know they know our kids they know our buildings and I I trust them so so we've already indicated we've already been in contact with our insurance care there will be no change to our coverages and there is no increases associated with this no changes whatsoever for that so that we've we've already presented a couple of times so you don't have that component there's no cost for the district any shape or form we're fully um covered for any liability and Jack I'm I'm you know this I'm this is a big thing
150and um my question to you is how many gods do you see armed in each building or outside of each building well we don't want to say that I would be cautious and and openly publicly say stating that right now but that could be something that we get in that corre report that we I I have that plan I have that already planned out I don't again I go with Dr scandin I don't really want to address that this evening if there were no other questions I my question sort of to the board is what are what is everybody comfortable with for a timeline and what would be an end point before decisions could be made do you need a public forum I know there have been conversations about surveys what what would you need
151in order to feel informed to make this decision thoughts I would like to know the the cost additional cost so I read the one of the letters that were sent in and they made the point which is a fair point and I I think you're going to read this letter out but so I apologize to whoever wrote it that I'm preempting them again but they made the point that Security Experts should guide this decision but really that they should make this decision I don't feel that I feel that that's paternal IC I I think you can't impose anything on the teachers and the students and the parents here that you have to understand what they think here and so I think we have to get surveys I I just I would not personally want to
152impose anything on anybody without actually knowing do you want to do you want to be protected right I mean they may well say no anyone else I'd like to see survey of the staff also and I agree with that also I think we I think we definitely need survey of at least the staff I mean they're the ones protecting our children day in and day out anyway I would love to know what they think and what they would be comfortable with um and just getting all of the information for every topic that we can I mean there are some things that I'm personally uncomfortable with so I would love to see what other options down to how much it's going to cost what the implementation is going to be and and how we can do
153that so anybody else timeline so I mean my understanding is there was multiple petitions that people had said they were going to provide to the board I don't know do we have those did they submit those anywhere I don't know we do have information from the last board meeting I can send those out to you okay thanks okay anybody else what what are we thinking in terms of a timeline what what is your recommended timeline uh two months ago no I'm sorry sooner the better so you know if there are things that if there are costs associated we're in we're approaching a bud budget season and we need to be able to plan for this accordingly if this is going to take any of our dollars in our budget we need to make sure that
154where is that money coming from so know and as I said March as Jeff indicated you know we're going into our budget season right now so sooner the better in this and I think the I think just exactly what you're hearing from some of the the people in the community is that it's you know there's folks that are for it for folks that are against it but I think the overarching thing that I'm hearing I'm getting the sense of is they just want a decision to be made one way or the other and whether or not they're happy with it one way or the other is irrelevant at this point it's more we get that sense so we will work on these surveys um and have them prepared and out and then uh we'll also
155work on the plans as uh you indicated Jack has already formulated some of those already um and we Jeff and I will work with the costs associated with that as well thank you thank you both all right we're going to move on now to our public comment period uh again District residents who wish to speak must have previously submitted one of these they're out in the hallway on the table you fill it out and you hand it to the district clerk each speaker will have three minutes to address the board and may speak only once during any given board meeting please understand that for the most part we're not going to respond to your remarks at this time as appropriate and administrator will follow up with you privately after the meeting you're also welcome to
156stay after tonight's meeting and speak with any of us please remember that according to state and federal privacy laws we are unable to entertain comments questions or discussions about any individual student or employee thank you for your understanding and our 30- minute public comment period begins now at 9:12 first up to the microphone over here please can John ozerk thank you come on up and just again state your name and where you live uh good evening uh my name is John ster and I'm a parent of two students in the treillage district my younger son attends minaki Elementary and my older son is at Galina's Junior High hopefully both will attend Ward Melville High School in the future uh I recently became aware of a proposal by savian a subsidiary Shell Oil to build a
157large lithium iron battery storage facility in light industrial area between EET and Port Jefferson just a mile from my home and W Melville High School this proposal is deeply concerning because of bar storage facilities POS a significant far risk lithium iron uh battery fires burn at extreme temperatures release toxic fumes and are notoriously difficulty to control as a result they can cause severe health hazards and environmental damage these facilities do not belong near residential neighborhoods and schools the absence of proper fire protocols significantly increases the risk of panic and Chaos in the event of a large scale battery fire a recent battery facility fire in MOS Landing California demonstrated that these risks are real and the potential consequences are too severe to ignore savan has been promoting the benefits of bar storage on social media
158while downplaying the very real dangers of to our community some of our advertising some of their advertising appears to be misleading I believe for example they claimed their project would increase tax revenue for the treillage district but they failed to mention that this would come only after receiving substantial tax breaks and exemptions all while our residential property taxes continue to rise after submitting a Freedom of Information law request to the town of Brook Haven I discovered that sinin has applied for financial assistance from the town's Industrial Development agency and has indicated they will not proceed without this Aid I find it hard to accept the town of brooken can subsidize a corporation that brings significant fire and environmental L risks to our community members of board of educa of the Board of Education the treillage
159school district is a wonderful place to live and I'm proud that my children are driving here however this proposed battery facility presents a major fire risk and serious threat to our neighborhood and schools I urge Three Village residents to unite against this Industrial Development uh thank you for letting me address the board and I would welcome any suggestions to help oppose this project thank you thank you Mr oark um submitted information earlier today and I'll send it out to the board later on thank you thank you very much all right next up Anthony derero hello again and uh uh what's that hello hello K so uh you know I'm up here all the time and my purpose of being up here is to is to talk about the reconfiguration and how I don't think it's
160in our students best interest you all know that uh I'm really encouraged tonight because I mean every time I come here we hear about teacher accolades um and and I know my co my past colleagues they're amazing and our students they received all these Awards so but tonight I heard from do uh Dr Bach I I like your comment that just because other districts do it we don't have to do it great comment Mr vizo I like that you were talking about tonight about ra uh uh going on you know bringing that tax cap number down um and um and there was another comment oh and Mrs roughly uh you had mentioned that uh you know you want to know the nitty-gritties of everything the down to the dollars and that's one of the things
161I've been trying to get to from the beginning because the reconfiguration plan that was um and I bought the original document the first this is the first time the survey was um done and then this is with like the the summary and in the summary it talks about saving a lot of money in in in a form of transportation and in the form of losing uh uh not having the need to have sixth grade teachers so if you need to see this this is originally from Dr scandin but now we're talking about an over $2 million um cost now I don't like getting into the money part because that's not my my my real uh uh expertise and profession but I've been meeting with a lot of community members Sue I told you many times
162that when we had spoken that I keep talking to people and we bring the logic together they constantly are saying well why why why we're doing so well why fix was not broken but now we're going to spend over $2 million and it's not my number it's the number that was presented in the uh uh budget status report as of 1231 2024 this was on your website and it's costing in renovation costs which are not even specific over $2 million to do this um Mr vizo Capital cost Mr Carson you mentioned that today if we would would to limit those Capital costs remember no one's asking us to do this the state is not saying to change our our our uh our configuration we're doing it because we think we're going to give students better
163I have a lot of questions and I also have I would love to debate Dr scand and anyone about the the value and the benefits for ninth graders but if we're really going to talk about that we should have a conversation about the nitty-gritty Mr ruley about the about the bullet points of scheduling about how many kids are really going to get electives when you 25% kids back in the same footprint without really getting into more classrooms there's a lot of questions but we're spending the money when we can bring down that number because we're adding another $2 million that's in the beginning that's not even the full amount so I'll I'll add to that the next time I come up thank you thank you all right next up is Lee gistad good evening good
164evening and I forgive me if I mispronounced that close enough okay thank you yes good evening everybody good evening board uh yes I'm here uh I was here a couple of weeks ago talking about trying well trying to Enlighten you a little bit more about lithium ion battery storage units it's something I really hadn't heard of until two months ago I've lived in St in in this area for 35 years and all of a sudden I hear they're going to build this so I basically I became an advocate and those fellow people over there you know Community for battery freeer targeters sitting right there with me basically I I took a picture and I gave it to the young lady over there you'll probably get that in your folder tomorrow this is what it's going
165to look like and I'll I'll pass this on cuz I get extra pass along it's four over 400 okay 20 foot and 40 foot 40ft containers and 20 foot containers each holding probably close to 10,000 cells of lithium ion storage that's how you produce the electric El this community is coming into the Industrial Age this is an industrialized unit 440 megaw larger than the one that blew up in mois Creek the reason why I'm here right now though is because I'm not going to talk about politics of who's going to get it and what how are we going to do it yes I'm fighting and I'm talking to politicians and we'll see what happens but I just want to tell you some facts here what the politicians tell you I found out is really not
166true in the smoke that's here this was done by a private guy in California okay he lives next to he owns a commercial business that measures biohazards he has a 100 people working for me he went out there and collected samples all over the town and half the state basically is absolutely amazing and this you'll you'll have a copy of this as well okay basically he has a graph here of where his people picked it up and within 10 miles of this unit it was Cobalt lithium magnesium manganese and nickel heavy all heavy metals so when you're talking so right now we are living in industrial area so when you're talking to the politicians Dr scalin I want you to remember evacuations because that's what they've done numerous times why you do evacu ating they
167tell you the smoke is harmless it's not okay now I'm here to tell you that I have four grandchildren I pay taxes here and I expect you to protect my children and that's that's your obligation have You' done that really well okay but I also want to tell you you have to think about the legal terms of this too I learned this from Saum High School who I you know I think you know all right they took it to court okay and on one major issue the New York state supreme court ruled that evacu evacuation is a is an important part of thank you Mr your time is up oh all right so please thank you we'll take a look at everything tomorrow thank you so much all right next up is Alex disag gu
168us hi everyone I was going to come with another speech similar to the ones that I've said in the last few months but you guys gave a great update just prior to this so I just wanted to thank you guys for uh really considering everything both sides of of the topic as I know it is a heated topic to discuss and debate um the only thing I'll use my time now for is just to address the couple of the things that I heard that I just wanted to try to clarify um I believe Dr McKinnon was the one that said that the uh the teachers should vote on whether or not it should be armed guards or not um and the reason the logic behind it was that uh you should consent to being protected
169whe some people may not want that but I've never been asked to vote on anything about as far as my protection goes whenever I go to airports Stony Brook Hospital Stony Brook School any of the public places where I go go to nobody's ever asked me if I want to be protected by the cop the guard whatever the case may be so I don't really think that that's a fairway I would agree with I believe I think it was Miss ruffley that said um the security staff they should of course be comfortable uh absolutely believe and agree with that that if they're comfortable carrying then they absolutely should be or if they're not then they absolutely should not be um and then as far as I believe Dr Bach also Rec uh said about the
170petitions I just didn't know where to send the petition but I'm going to assume I'm going to send it to you and okay so I'll have that in your inbox and you'll have that in your folder tomorrow but I just want to thank you guys for all this I know it's been I've been here a lot frequently since October so I'm happy to see that we're getting our hands closer together and that we can protect our kids thank you thank you all right the last is uh something that was submitted to be read aloud from Vinnie caposio dear Three Village trustees today I want to address a critical issue school security there's been much discussion about increasing the number of mental health professionals in our schools a support that is undeniably vital for the well-being
171of our students however I must ask a simple question how many more mental health professionals are needed to stop a gunman once they have entered to school the answer is clear a mental health counselor's role is preventive and long-term not designed to intercept an immediate threat while we should wholeheartedly support mental health initiatives they cannot substitute for the physical security measures required in an emergency in addition to these measures there has been interest in utilizing AI enabled cameras as part of our security strategy while these cameras offer valuable surveillance capabilities they are fundamentally reactive Tools in an active shooter situation AI cameras can only record and analyze events after they've begun they cannot proactively intervene or prevent an attack immediate on premises action by trained security Personnel is essential some argue that the presence of
172armed guards might make students feel less safe or transform our schools into prisons I have to ask what is more traumatic knowing there are trained professionals on our campus ready to protect us or enduring the horrors of a tragedy akin to Sandy Hook these statements are especially absurd when one considers that our current security Personnel are already trained and capable of carrying firearms to suggest that arming our security guards would compromise our safety is not only misleading but also demeaning to their years of dedication and expertise it's also an attack on their dignity and character furthermore armed security is a standard safety measure in many facets of everyday life airport subway sporting events theme parks and even Tailor Swift concerts do you fear security guards in any of these settings of course not it is
173offensive to imply that schools are uniquely unsuitable for such safeguards an armed guard provides both a deterrent to potential threats and an immediate response where every second counts in previous discussions there was a focus on surveying teachers and students about our security concerns what expertise do our teachers and students have on security we should be surveying our Security Experts who work in our district I'd also request to hear public comment from our head of security on the matter additionally I ask that the board examine the results from schools that have implemented programs such as the guardian program in Florida as well as review after action reports and recommendations from past AC of shooter incidents if not already done I urge the board to seek recommendations from not only Homeland Security but private security companies finally
174I'd encourage board members to express their opinion publicly as one of our board members did at last month's meeting thank you for your time dedication service to our community please let me know if I can volunteer my time to any Safety and Security committee as we work together to ensure the protection of our students and that concludes our public comment section we're going to move on now to our items for board action and I will turn it over to Dr scan the first item is the approval of the name change for Robert kusher Murphy Junior High School to Robert kusher Murphy Middle School okay do I see a motion second all in favor any opposed no extenstions okay that carries B approval of the name change for Paul J galenus Junior High School to Paul
175J galenus Middle School second all in favor no oppose no extensions thank you next approval of the name change from Ward Melville Senior High School to Ward Melville High School second all in favor any oppos no extensions thank you and D approval of elementary school grade configuration from prek to 6 to prek to 5 so moved second all in favor any opposed any extensions no thank you so much and item D is our walk-in resolution Mr mki that's a resolution regarding the 3 20a mattered that was discussed an executive session do I see a motion so moved second all in favor any opposed any extensions no thank you motion carries all right that brings us to our consent agenda now do I see a motion second and we will begin Item B Miss jamano they
176just a minutes from the last board meeting thank you and beginning with C through L Mr Carlson thank you item C is approval of Health and Welfare Services contracts this is uh with two other school districts these are this is for um Three Village resident students who attend private schools located within those school districts item D is the establishment of the Health and Welfare Services rate that we charge to other districts for uh residents of other districts that attend private uh schools located within three village that we bu out for their health services sorry item e is uh approval of agreement uh with the company Farmers fridge this is to place the um uh vending machines at w Moville high school for use after uh after lunch periods are done after school uh that provides
177healthy healthy meals as um was presented to the board uh back in I think it was November by uh when U Kevin finy Christina Driscoll and um krie Kenny did the wellness committee report do you know when those are going into the high school uh well we'll find out tomorrow if the board approves it um so then we'll send that and we want to get started as as quickly as possible and hopefully it's a a big success um next item is Declaration of emergency uh repair at nasake elementary school this is not a just do the flooding back in August this is not a capital project in the sense of like last year we had the satet roof this is a little different because the flooding most of the cost associated with that was clean
178up uh so that's not a capital project so that's not eligible for building Aid however we're working with FEMA on getting a reimbursement and I think it seems like we're actually going to get a higher percentage back from FEMA on our cost even more so than we would have um through building Aid um uh kathern Klein our director of uh Business Services and Jason gry gry are director facilities are working with FEMA on on the claim so uh this is part of the process of that declaring that an emergency uh at a a subsequent meeting after we have uh all of the costs put together um finish everything then we'll come back to the board and ask for a uh approval of a resolution to take money from reserves to pay for that and then
179when we get the FEMA uh reimbursement put it back into reserves because we don't have enough money in the budget not year marked for anything else to pay for this uh without doing it that way uh the next item is well the ne uh G H I J and K are our financial reports for the months of October November and December these were reviewed uh earlier uh well this afternoon by our audit committee um and L is donations uh we have one donation it's uh nine uh brand new uh Apple iPads with chargers from Malloy uh College a College University univers Malloy University um will uh use these for assist of technology for some of our uh students uh this uh donation was secured by Dr bcar that's it for me he has an inside
180connection thank you so much any other questions about any of those items okay M recommendations of committee on special education subcommittee and 54 accommodation plan meetings as dated and N recommendations of committee on preschool special education meetings as stated and for o andp Dr dubraski yes first o instructional uh we have eight instructional retirements three instructional resignations uh one instructional leave of absence um one appointment of U an instructional teaching assistant position several substitute teachers as well as the appointment of of Junior High School coaches annual and hourly assignments P non-instructional we have one non-instructional retirement three non-instructional resignations um several non-instructional appointments including Food Service workers special ed AIDS and child care assistance um and additional non-instructional substitute appointments including monitors lifeguard food service and special ed AIDS any questions so I would I
181would like to then just uh as a result recognize U the dedication and congratulate the following people on their retirement absolutely so we have uh Terry ethd Ward Melville high school English teacher we have Judy foron Arrowhead School social worker we have Miss krie galini director of enl and World Language we have Lisa latcher Mount elementary teacher Darlene Lang NASA elementary teacher Kim Rosner naseg elementary teacher Angela Celli Ward Melville High school speech pathologist and Kim tario W Melville reading teacher so I would like to recognize and congratulate them for this [Applause] service thank you and congratulations to our retirees all in favor of the items in our consent agenda any opposed no extensions thank you that carries and do I see a motion to adjourn second all in favor all right thank you everybody
182enjoy the February break for