001Be impatient just gotta wait for dr. Spence to return to his seat He's gonna do the budget when he's so while we're waiting can I have a motion to come out of executive session Okay all in favor Okay, so up next will be dr. Spence and Kim vile they're going to talk about the the budget Hanging out with us today. We're gonna do an overview of the budget for 2526 year And we'll do a highlight of the things that are included in this budget Remember the budgets a moral document that gives us an idea of where we're going and what we're going to prioritize in the upcoming year So with everything we do we want to make sure that it's rooted in our mission and vision So you'll see that here and again once we
002complete our strategic planning that will also be a framework that we will start every presentation with So a couple of highlights for this budget. What this budget reflects is our commitment to expanding student learning and graduation pathways. Again, we're... Currently in a capital improvement project, you heard a little bit about that tonight, regarding the Korean Technical Education Program. And once that structure is built, we'll be adding additional teachers, supplies, and administrative support, and that's built into this budget. Additionally, we're implementing a strategic technology replacement plan to ensure that our students, faculty, and staff have the appropriate tools to engage in learning. We'll also have a commitment to strengthening our community engagement and we'll be establishing and implementing our family community engagement department to align district programs and force the stronger connections with our families and
003communities. Additionally, in supporting our students and families, we are going to work to ensure that we're able to continue our extended learning day program, our RED program, which has been a success since its implementation in regards to the interest that it's gained in our ability to provide safe spaces for students. We're also again looking at this as an opportunity for us to provide secure some grant funding and I think I probably need to acknowledge here when I say grants I'm not speaking title monies I'm talking community-based grants there's a variety of different grants that people use to support that program so I just want to you know delineate between the types of grants that we're using there just to be clear about that additionally with this budget reflects our long-range strategic plan so we will
004be engaged in strategic planning for the upcoming year and we are really excited about that work. Okay, and as we're going through the budget, we're going to highlight some of the areas where you might have seen some changes, but again, this is the budget by function, and you'll really see looking at these pie charts, there really isn't too much movement or variation from the 2024 to 2025 proposed budget in regards to allocations. Okay, and this, again, the budget by object. Again, in the district, the majority of our budget is salaries and benefits. So here we'll just highlight some of the changes since we have gone through the entire budget once previously. So there was a change in regards to the contractual line and also the BOCES line. We mentioned when we were doing the presentation
005for BOCES that we were looking at tablets for budget vote, and we are engaging in that service at this time. Yeah today we actually just received the OHM BOCES budget so again these numbers are still preliminary for the BOCES numbers that we're looking at so we will be sharing those up a little bit and if we need to we can talk about that again in March before we adopt the budget. The next slide actually there were no changes here these are the same as what we looked at previously. The budget and finance slide We did take a look at the auditing services line and we wanted to make sure that we did have enough funding in there going forward and we adjusted it based on the contractual language and in addition to what we experienced
006this year hoping that we don't experience that again but we wanted to be prepared for that. The other contractual has to do with a multi-year agreement that we engaged in this year as well that's showing a little bit more of an increase in that line. Okay, and again here you'll see when you look at the community and engagement line that really is our commitment to In bolstering family and community engagement in the district So one of the things that we've observed since we've been here remember we did four town halls across the city We've collected a whole bunch of data and we realized that there's a need for position our district in a way that it's amendable to bolstering support with our families and communities across the city, connecting with our communities more broadly. So
007that represents that investment there. On this slide, the two changes here are in regards to the custodial salaries. We did increase that line as we're looking at those salaries and where they're coded. We continue, that's a work in progress. We're still going to continue to work at this and improve how we're coding people in which salary lines. So there is an increase in the custodial salary to support the contractual obligations and the individuals that need to be coded there. The other change here is in regards to the maintenance BOCES line. And that has to do with our utilities as we're getting through this winter. And we're looking at those invoices as they're coming in. We realized we needed to put some more funds in there to make sure that we'd have enough for next year.
008Supervision and professional development. You'll see a few changes here from the last meeting. This is an area where Dr. Spence has talked about his plan coming into the district, which has created some of these adjustments. Basically, we are also building in here the strategic plan that we talked about quite a bit tonight and some other contractual obligations. Okay, and so as you look here, you see the teacher instructional salaries. That reflects that CTE investment. We are budgeting for the teachers that will be working in the CTE wing of Proctor High School, as well as the REDD program. Again, we are looking to continue that program to extend learning opportunities to our students beyond a traditional school day. The majority of these lines that we're going into now, special ed and... These special services lines, these
009are really adjustments in salaries and bumping those lines up to ensure that we have enough funds for contractual obligations going forward as we're working through that budget adjustment. The next slide, 2300s, there was no changes here. Then as we get into 2600 this is where I was talking about the salaries again have been adjusted slightly and the other change here is that computer instructional BOCES line that we keep talking about that hardware replacement plan we did add some additional funds in that line as well as we talked about we're trying to get that line up to where we can maintain a five-year replacement plan for all of our hardware and devices This again this area the only changes here would be in the salary lines And same thing for the total, yep, for this line
010as well, the co-curricular salary lines. Transportation between the red program and some of our contractual obligations. We did increase the contract transportation line is We look at that budget That's an area where if we have one or two McKinney-Vento students or special needs students that have to attend an out-of-district program those those rates and Services that we have to provide can change fairly rapidly So we're trying to build in more money in those lines to be ready for any of those unforeseen things employee benefits directly related to the salary increases. We did slightly increase the TRS line here. And the other line we did go back and take a look at as health insurance, not anticipating a rate increase of the increase here. However, we need to think about the fact that at any point
011in time, anyone can switch from a single plan to a family plan. And we're trying to build that in so that we can accommodate if that's to occur. The Interfund Transfer, this was a line that we discussed at the last meeting, and there was interest in maintaining that RAND line at the same amount that we had in 2425, so we did move that back to the same as we had it to keep that line flat. Here, we'll move into the revenues. This is the newer section of the budget that we have not looked at before, so you'll see our Foundation Aid came into us this year with an increase. The Foundation Aid is really the dollars that come to us that... Don't have I'm gonna call it strings attached as we move into the expense
012driven aids however for us we have a lot of money tied up into the c4e program where we have to account for salaries and How that money is being used and mr. Felchie and I work closely to make sure that we're doing that reporting We'll do a public hearing in June May or June And we have to make sure that we're accounting for that back to the state and the categories that they allocate to us the other lines that we're talking about that Underneath that expense driven of those are monies that we have to actually spend and then we get the aid back the following year in regards to This line really it's a lot of these lines are very similar to what they were last year The current proposal is to maintain a flat
013property tax increase We are allocating fund balance again this year very close to what we did last year the change that you'll see is that we did Pick up the ERS reserve, which is a restricted fund balance that we can use each year as well and just bringing that into the picture as well so that reserve plan that's adopted and reviewed by the board is being utilized and then we can have further discussions and that concludes the presentation anyone have any questions for them not at this time okay thank you okay so up next um would be the pta pto Shared Decision Making, Student Councils, CSC Chairs, Title I, UTA. Thank you. Scott Rogowski, UTA President. Our teachers are dedicated to making a difference in the lives of their students here in Utica. The students
014are the reason we push forward. However, I'm not even sure where to begin, but I think this month we need to inform the board of quite a few things. Did I think we would find ourselves here again? No, but here we are heading down this familiar path. There seems to be a recurring issue in this district, an inability to retain personnel. It's becoming increasingly difficult to attract and keep teachers as well as other support staff. We are facing shortages across the board, that much is clear, but what is Utica doing to solve this problem? The word is getting around to the other districts. Despite everything we've done to address these issues, we find ourselves in the same position. The district made the decision to remove the principal from Proctor, and now the domino effect has
015dragged the teachers and the UTA into this mess. It's not our fault that the district was unprepared to handle the situation they set into motion. Your administration is now pulling two teachers to cover assistant principal payroll they don Scott Yeah, I'm sorry, but we're not here to discuss personnel issues I'm just giving a while I know but you're making a reference to a personnel decision. I haven't used any names. I'm just There's only one principal at Proctor. Do you want to say anything? No, I think you're right I mean you have the rules which are did not talk about personnel matters. So if you want to report on issues or talk about other operational issues? Well, I'm going to talk about my members, right? So again, I'll continue. The UTA was never consulted about this
016decision and the administration cannot direct deal with the teachers. Now these teachers are responsible for regular duties plus the added assistant principal duties, duties for which they are not being compensated. At labor, we were told that this issue had been resolved. But when I visited Donovan last Monday to investigate, I discovered it hadn't been addressed at all. When I asked administration, they claimed the teachers could take on these roles because it was part of internship. First of all, the Board of Education approved the internships back in July of 2024. These internships were specifically for before and after contractual hours, as well as during the summer. Apparently, the administration believes that they have the right to override the Board's decision, bypass the UTA, and entangle our members in the situation. The internship mentor approved by the
017board isn't even in the building anymore. You've put these teachers in a terrible position. The district has assistant principal positions posted, and there are qualified candidates available. Why not hire them? Is there a reason you're choosing to cover these positions internally instead of hiring personnel? Here's a real interesting issue, talking about transparency. All of our unions participate in the District Health Insurance Committee. Imagine our surprise when we received information out of the OHM Consortium meeting that was held this Monday. We were told that Utica was seeking entry into the Consortium. We were informed that a vote was expected as early as March, with a possible policy change set for July. This was stunning news to us. There was no prior discussion about this in any health insurance meeting. When questioned, I was told I may
018have been misinformed. Yet I was able to obtain documentation showing that discussions about this began in November. This is a mandatory... Wait, wait, wait, Scott. I'm sorry. Because we're just hearing something basically for the first time. Who told you? About something about OHM BOCES? Someone who was attending the OHM consortium meeting on Monday. The someone is someone from our district that was there? No, it was not from our district. It was another union who informed me. Well, okay. The reason why I'm asking is because, like, we just spoke to our, you know, the brokers. And we, just before we, at 5 o'clock. And there's no discussion about that whatsoever. So I don't know, so. I mean, I don't know who, you know, if they said the word Utica, okay, I guess, you know. I mean,
019I can show the memo from November where the district. Mike, can you, like, our point is that that is not, that's not even a discussion at this point, okay? Fantastic. Great. We continue to receive workplace violence reports, and at the committee meeting there were discrepancies. We do not come to work to be slapped, kicked, punched, bitten, or have our hair pulled. When someone calls PESH and files a complaint, I assure you my members won't need to be disfigured, dismembered, or die in order to file a complaint, like was stated at labor. There seems to be some disconnect between the buildings and administration. As far as the time cards are concerned. Members are expecting payment per the payroll schedule, and it doesn't seem to come to fruition. Scott, I don't mean to interrupt you. I'm sorry.
020But, you know, I'm on the BOCES board, and they came in and they talked about what the legal standards are. And I think that there may be a disconnect between what the perception of the legal standard is and what the legal standard is. I'm not saying that anyone should have to go to work and, you know, be... be injured but on ever but the you know that act doesn't really cover what people think it covers and that and i and i've been through at least two presentations on it by people that you know make presentations all over the state so i i understand that people might perceive that act to to work in a particular way but Unfortunately, it doesn't. So, you know, again, I apologize for interrupting you. But, you know, and then you
021got all of the issues with, you know, children and how they're to be taught and managed and things like that. And then they have to be balanced against, you know, the... protect the protections for employees. And so I, it's a super complex situation and I'm, you know, again, what I got out of the two presentations were that what we thought it was. and what it actually is are two different things. Well, we must be hearing something totally different. I think you might be. I mean, I spoke to Pesce personally. I understand what you're saying, but we'd be more than happy to bring in another presentation where we can all sit and listen to it. ask our questions and hopefully we'll get some clarification. I'm more than willing to do that and I'm sure that the
022administration would probably be willing to do it too because, you know, again, we're interested in keeping our, you know, our people safe and, but on the flip side, we want to be able to comply with the law and I think that there are some issues with this, you know, that act at this time and the way people are interpreting it. So, but you have an open invitation to have us put together a presentation and, you know, we're happy to have. I mean, I'm sure NYSET would be willing to have presentations. I mean, we've offered. Well, no, no, I'm saying, I mean, I'd love to have NYSET maybe and then somebody from another, you know, just in case there's two competing, you know, competing interpretations. Okay. I mean, the point is the people just, you know,
023they don't want to have violence in their workplace. We're doing everything we can to not have violence in the workplace, right? We can go back and forth all day. Can I continue? Sure. Awesome. Appreciate it. There's still this, let's see, when Jones and General Herkimer Elementary Schools were conducting searches for principals, teachers were involved in interview process. They felt valued and appreciated for assisting. Now we talk about Columbus. Here we have one of the largest elementary schools already dealing with the aftermath of a tragedy, and yet we don't have them involved in selecting a permanent replacement for their principal. Our monthly labor meetings provide little to no answers to the issues we raise. Month after month, the same problems appear on the agenda. And the response we get is we will circle back to that,
024even though we provide the agenda seven days in advance. We've been requesting a diapering policy for many, many months. All we want is clarity on what the policy is. We still don't have that answer. Our Committee on Academic Excellence continues to lack the required administrative placements as clearly stated in our contract. When they arrived Monday, their reserved room was unavailable, and they were left to wait downstairs until a space could be found. Even more stunning was at a prior meeting, they had to hold their meeting in the admin lunchroom. What are we doing here? Teachers continue to be an afterthought in this district. We are the backbone of this district and we stay here for the students. Our teachers do their best, care deeply for their students, and would do anything to protect them. We
025stay because we are dedicated to the kids. If this is the direction we're heading, be prepared the teachers are not going to stay silent. As one teacher who left this year put it, I took an almost $10,000 pay cut and now will lose my health insurance, but my mental health was more important than staying in a position with no administrative support. You may be upset, but we'll be surveying our members and I can tell you the results will be enlightening to this Board of Education. The Utica Teachers Association contract expires at the end of this school year. We have a lot of work ahead of us. It's time to start negotiating. Thank you. Thanks for coming in, Scott. I just want to say, I just want to say one, thank you, Scott, for sharing your
026thoughts. And we'll continue to have the phone calls and conversations that we have. Scott, I know you and I speak and we speak about these issues and we understand that they're issues and we will continue to work together and collaboratively. You know, I'm looking forward to our Wednesday evening meetings that we scheduled with you and I talking and we'll continue to talk together about these issues. I know we spent a lot of time up until this year and we. We're working through it, and you know that. We've done that. So I appreciate that. I appreciate you. Thank the membership for coming tonight and voicing your concerns. And, look, we'll work around the issues. There's no animosity or feelings towards any issues. We'll work around them. We'll continue doing that. And, again, thank you all for
027being a partner in that work. I did want to comment on one thing. I have to be honest with you. I don't really agree that you think we take the teachers. for granted or that we don't care and I know for a fact that's not how the board feels so you may have opinions but that's not I mean, I cannot believe that. Wow. That is horrible. UAA, UTC, Teamsters Local 182, SEIU Local 200, Mohawk Valley Buildings and Trade. Okay, so let me get back to it again, I just want to appreciate the fact that our teachers are interested in our educational process and There's part of that they attend our board meetings and share their experiences Okay, so we're going to, Dr. Spence, would you like to say anything about your superintendent's report? Okay, you
028want to make a presentation of your superintendent? Can I have a motion to adopt Dr. Spence's superintendent's report with an additional add-on as page 42, which would be the, application for the extended field trip for the Proctor High students who are going to the Leadership Institute and I think we're pulling page 30 those at 36 it's only 36 yeah 36 bottom no it's good so based on pulling page 36 bottom and adding Item S-171 is page 42. Can I have a motion to adopt the superintendent's report? Move it. Need a second? Okay, all in favor? Opposed? Passes. I need a motion on... Actually, we're pulling it, so... We need a motion to table it. First, we need a motion to... Oh, I need a motion to put it out, so... Need a motion on that
029item. Okay. Now... Motion to lay it on the table. Yes. Need a second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? It's laid on the table. Okay. So, I went to the BOCES meeting yesterday. That was about a three and a half hour or fun time going through the adoption of the BOCES budget. I shared the information with our staff. We had some spirited discussions about things. I think at some point there's going to be some discussions about consolidations and things like that for any number of... school districts at some point and so that hard to find teachers in for certain courses they're going to try to come up with a way so that the kids can be taught without everyone having to be in one place yeah like a regionalizational approach so there's going to be
030there's going to be all kinds of discussions about things to try to adapt the educational landscape to the way things are going to be in the next century or decade or so. We have been dealing with audit finance. We haven't had any meetings, but we've spent a lot of time. value you know since the last meeting which was only a couple of weeks ago but you know we've been talking about the various items in the budget and you know hopefully this budgets going to come out and you know it's going to be flat real property tax this year so that's where I'm at on that Anything at Capital Projects, Buildings and Grounds? All right. CTE? PEC? March. PEC Committee? March. Okay. Communications? Yeah, we just had a meeting a couple of weeks ago. So we're
031working on progress with the upcoming art show at Proctor. All the communication that went out, we did a great job so far. Black History Month and showcasing everything that the schools were doing. One part of our equity concern for this year was field trips, PTO's accessibility, and especially that end of the year sixth grade field trip before they're leaving elementary school. So one of the initiatives this year was to make sure that every sixth grade had a Field trip that was extensive outside of the area so that we give these students a chance and opportunity to experience things outside of our vicinity and So that's in the process and so far we have every sixth grade is going somewhere outside of the areas That's a big project over this year So just getting updates on
032that calendar updates and starting to get ready towards the end of the year with projects that we do. Good. Thank you Policy Committee, we have discussions about policy quite a bit. One of our members has volunteered to go through and evaluate all of the grammatical errors and other inconsistencies in the policies. I have a feeling this year we're going to be adopting a number of new policies. You know, we'll probably be having a meeting in the next, you know, four weeks or so. So code of conduct, anything to report? A meeting in March. Budget status reports from IAIN? You know, I have to say that you're one of the most patient people because you always are at the end. And you know I want to I want I would probably should move you around a
033little bit because you know you give such a good report nice and short So like I mentioned last meeting God we received our last tax payment from the city So I'm currently working on the reconciliation of that and then we'll have the final report in March Um, I also enclosed for your review consideration, the general fund budget status report, cafeteria fund, budget status reports, and the cash balance reports, uh, for all district bank accounts for the month ended December 31st, 2024. Yeah. And that's about it. And can I ask you, I want to quiz you for a second. Sure. Could you tell us about what, what, when you say you you're working on the reconciliation, what does that mean? So they I have my report that I give you guys keep track of the weekly
034payments because we're getting the weekly payments now and then when the city sends their final payment, there's a their balance sheet just kind of making sure that our sheets match Okay, and now do you have to do that for a number of different things? Just not only the taxes you have to do reconciliations and other things That's with my cash balance reports. That's my bank reconciliation. So I do that. And, you know, is that something you have to do every single day? How do you approach that? I'm just curious. That's a monthly activity. Usually I spend a couple days each month working on the bank reconciliation. We have a lot of money in the bank right now? We do. Okay. Good to know. Keep up the good work. And you're investing it? Yes. Okay. We
035made some recent investments this week. But I don't mean investing it, you know, like, you know. And he's when you said a lot of money in the bank. He just clarified that. I just went to Albany and said we're poor. And now you say we have a lot of money in the bank. Well, we have collected our money. It's other people's money. All right, thank you. Anybody have any other questions for Ian? Thank you, Ian. Thank you, Ian. Can I have a motion to approve the minutes? Move it. Second. And that's from January 30, regular and executive? Yes. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Any continuing business? Any new business? Yes. Okay. I have a motion to go into executive time. Okay. Move it. Second. Aye. All in favor? Aye.