CorpusRecord 137250

Audit Committee / Board of Education Meeting — 2.3.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Voorheesville CSD
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Albany County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,312 words · about 74 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001that's your internet or my internet that's not good are you there there can you hear us oh my internet connection is unstable I don't have inter okay Lisa can you hear me I just heard you all right I think we're just having intermittent internet issues yes I see you okay yes yeah the internet's not working very well here sorry everybody okay all right Lisa why don't you start the aut committee with Kathy and we'll try to get through it until we lose you again holy C okay [Music] sorry what was the first item on the agenda was [Music] it hold on I don't have the agenda the minutes and then the claims auditor report so review December minutes and then claims auditor report would it help if we just saw her and didn't that do

002you mind I'm going to re this there's 75 Lisa we're going to lose you for a second you for I'm sorry that's adorable all right Lisa you're muted can you hear us I'm sorry what all right we're good to go let's go through it first is clim 's report okay at this time I did not receive one in time for the meeting okay the next item is the 2425 Revenue status report the next item is the 22 2425 Revenue status report okay that I included so you can see how far we are in collecting our revenues right now now we are right on track there are not any um revenues that are lagging at this time the next is the appropriation status report summary with history that's a very small document unfortunately however it summarizes

003where we're spending this current year and where we have spent the past three years and again our expenditures are right on Trow we're doing fine okay the next is the lunch fund profit and loss yes I reviewed the profit and loss with the district Treasurer and we did change a few items as you can see right now the lunch fund is operating at a loss there are more expenditures than there are revenues however we do have uh a grant Revenue that will come in in the amount of like $9,000 so that will offset that loss and we will continue to look for other Revenue sources um the um what helped last year was the state had a um an additional Revenue Source because the cost cost of goods were going up and they gave us

004like a on shot revenue and that helped the lunch fund but unfortunately there aren't any one shot revenues yet from the state to assist with the lunch fund and middle school can no longer use Java heart Lisa are you aware of middle school students not using the Java Hut no I am not I was aware of nor do I think that's true but okay another conversation but I just know is there a concern that came up Rachel yeah I I was told this was while I was under the weather that they're no longer allowed to they were previously no long from my own child okay um that they previously were not allowed to get caffeinated beverages was my understanding but now they're no longer allowed to access the a Hut at all I don't know

005if this is factual this is non you know no I didn't get a second Source or anything so the Java Hut for those who don't know is a coffee shop sorry you've heard that as well I heard that as well yes that that's our Revenue I can ask the principal that question and she can respond back to you guys regarding that that would be great it's a r Source I'm unaware on that that was our that's how we sink money back into the pot my recollection yes um okay thank you I I think I'm living in an echo right now so my apologies if I sound weirder to everyone I sound weird to myself uh the next item do you want me to keep going yeah because the executive budget 2526 executive budget for Aid

006to education the quest our state aid planning information yes I included that document so the board could familiar arize yourselves with the um executive budget proposal the most important thing is that there is a 2% increase in Foundation Aid and that is exactly what boresville will receive under her proposal okay um are you ready for next item yes is the update on debt service borrowings from District financial advisers the 2526 expense budget will be impacted with the first payment for 25 million Capital project and EPC project voters advised of a two and a half% tax increase in 2022 So Lisa the gentleman from Bernie again are here so if you want to introduce as well and I'll leave it over to you guys okay thank you very much uh it's my pleasure to introduce Chris

007and Jason who are partners and Bernard P donigan they will be presenting the the debt Ser [Music] presenting long range financial plan so um go ahead Chris and Jason take it away thank you everybody I'm Jason schz the president D Incorporated cut out de service budgeting pack that we're going to go through with you tonight uh just kind of high level in more detail during the audit committee meeting is this what is in the paper yeah I don't um and then a lot of this information will also then flow through into the long range plan that we're going to be presenting uh later during the actual board meeting so um we'll kind of we can kind of just go through at a high level with the Deb service budget then you know if we want

008more detail we can dig into it um basically this is the a document that we put together for all the districts we work with each year to help with the capital planning part of your budget which of course is very critical to manage you know this tax cap ER with cap exclusions that you get and how that impacts your tax cap calculations so uh what's on the screen here on the on the front page kind of call the one year snapshot um so this is all the different pieces of your de when you look at the pull packet there's underling sleth up to that total if you want to double check the map but on the front page here basically what you got going on in 2526 uh this top line here seral bonds for

009school construction that's all your existing debt from prior capital soal lock uh seral bonds for bus purposes that is kind of a mix a blend of existing and projected so you have a few bus bonds that you've done in the past as well as a few uh new bus bonds that we're projecting both the one that you voted last May that we're getting ready to finance right now and then also projections for this upcoming budget year um so that's what's in that bus purchase line and the next two lines relate to the the current capital projects um so you've got the um current School construction project you have a ban outstanding for that that you issued last July that will be coming due this this coming July uh so we know that interest payment of

01052,000 and we're projecting uh a principal payment of 290,000 that number could change if we wanted to that's kind of up to us but that was long range plan that was sized try to get to that 2 and half% increase thatly been told to the public as well as the energy performance contract that's kind of goes hand in hand with that project is running in parallel so we're planning on financing that this spring and having interest payment for that as well next year and then we also have $100,000 Tamp La projects do cash project transfer to Capital and then down on the bottom part of the summary page you can see the projections you get a little over a million doll in building Aid and just under 200,000 Transportation help pay for all those projects

011from the state that me the tax levy of 76,000 so that is that piece that goes into the capital exclusion the tax so that's the onee snapshot then like said there's all the details in here if anybody wants to go through it has any specific questions just a few other things we would your I'm really good at scrolling so this is kind of the summary where we put it all together so we that single snap on the front page helps you know District know what to put in for next year's budget this is kind of more like a long range planning tool use sum page kind of see are there any spikes in the future are there any you know dips where we should for Capal project not really too much to go through in

012detail on this just to point out that is a tool that we use and update each year with the district kind of see oniz there too late to it thats us always planning forward and this local share setup is kind of in line with our understanding of what was presented to the public on the current capital project in terms of having a two and a half% increase in this up for about 15 years and then it drops back down to a lower like 1.1% increase as that then you want to go to I just want to really quickly and I think Chris Jason for this and Lisa and I have been talking about it is this really helps us understand when that fall off is going to happen when we have to reset it and

013so when did you say are probably our next capital projects going to have to be probably within 5 years you should be thinking about now what you want to go out to vote and then it takes about five years so going out to a vote within three years makes sense so that way when they hit the fiveyear mark the debt is there that way we're not trying to play catch up later on um which occurs from time to time we're just doing it right when it all occurs in the right moment of time correct there's a Del she nodded Sheed she doed all right I just want to clarify that you could you wait wait could you differentiate between the green and the blue here on this y the blue is for the um building

014project and the green is for the buses green tapers off as you go and that's really just we had that note there that we only project it out for the next five years of purchases technically if you for okay thank you any questions before we move on to 15 um I had a question you may be getting to it later about reserves because I I thought I saw and I can't find it quickly right now where res it looked like reserves would be wiped out maybe not in and that's always the Doom and Gloom of long plan in the future so they'll go through that so like the wiping out of reserves is like yeah okay we're not witing I can wait Frank it but just kind of to the visual picture of where we're

015at with the open project so this event isent toage projects to get that 68 69% back from the State Building terms we got for all that top and just in terms of the financial had million you issued July that's coming July 10 25 so our current is to that in July 25 and go out to July 26 so that renewal will not impact the 25 26 budget at all be in the following year 2627 but when we have that b payment coming and UL convert to the B have the building a start flowing that will help offset that so we're try to match those up as well and then on the next page just kind of the othering into place shortly uh and that will have interest only the first year and I want the

016building as we CL that out we willp that's current fining and then talking budg exg proposal theils july1 govern not those havil final by database but you will receive that money if you close out cost reports so see lines if you were look at the ex budg proposal for next year the Govern only Pro 637000 on the building for you as a district and we would Bud plan based over the million we have that what you will receive out those final cost reports the Govern have that's why we always kind of show our work based know and with the capital construction project we do have a set date where we will be able to close that that out so we just have to work with our construction manager you have to make sure that all

017of it does go into fruition to make sure that we get those deadlines to close out so Aid can work so it can be so that Aid can be budgeted for post start of fiscal year as long as we submit so it can be this is based on as long as we file final cost reports by right so the phase two we're not projecting anything yet B but phas as asile forms by 25 re Lisa yes anything that they missed or that we're good with or any followup or statements I think that uh page 14 is extremely helpful just to know that whatever is in the governor's proposal we know that there are additional Aid building aid funds out there and I thank Chris and Jason for this um um presentation it's extremely helpful for

018the district for the current upcoming fiscal year and long range planning so thank you for your assistance thank you questions so there's no other specific questions on The Debt Service itself said this verion this will also beange but also some of other questions discuss um the next item on the agenda is that the external audit dates were established for May 12th and 13th and the week of July 21st yes we're all set and we're looking forward to the upcoming audit fantastic and then the last thing is that the next audit committee meeting is scheduled for April 7th question mark uh 2025 so all right with that um we can move directly into our regular board meeting right you good with that Kathy yes okay thank you Lisa for joining us she's gonna stay on yeah

019we'll see we'll see you we'll talk to you again soon you guys wait next so we'll have a quick roll call of Trustees um Rob was not able to join us tonight as was our student board member Joey uh Russo will not be with us tonight we hope to see him again in March hard to believe next month is March uh with that we're going to go to item 1.4 there's a flag at the corner of the room over there pledge the allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America Justice for All We Have have a number of items uh for the good of the order I'm going to ask Frank to bring us one item which is a recent one all right so um if you haven't seen our

020recent school messenger uh we did send out a press release um regarding an incident that occurred on Thursday January 30th um there was members of our school Community were found in possession of th Vapes um the principles immediately and luckily they found this um right after school and addressed the situation very very quickly uh contacted parents enforced our code of conduct and went through it but after they did that they also found out during this investigation that those Vapes were actually brought on property by a non student who was an adult older than 18 or older um so they've been working with law enforcement so after Thursday it was an ongoing law investigation um a police report was filed and today uh we were notified that the indiv ual who did bring those Vapes on

021property to the students after school was arrested um so I thank Aly County Sheriff's Department for working so diligently with our staff and quickly um within a few days they were able to get the evidence that they needed to be able to um address this person who was taking advantage of minors on school property and and doing the situation so I appreciate their support and I thank the principles for their fast action and addressing the situation but I did want to kind of bring that forward literally because we just were made notice of it to tonight that the arrest occurred so that's why we did send it out a few days later but we did not want to impede the investigation by doing so prior to that thank you any questions um also for the

022good of the order we send congratulations and kudos to uh Coach Joe saf yenza who was named the chapter 2 athletic director of the year so many congratulations to Joe uh for this honor and lishment definitely good guy uh then there was an uh talent show at the elementary school and I did not get to see it I don't know if anyone here did were you able to get to it yeah so I did actually get to go to it I'm a little biased so uh being a former music teacher I I I think it's just I I love watching kids be talented and showcase their talent I thank dollar for Scholars for putting this together each year it's a great f fundraiser where they give over $30,000 to our graduates each year so these

023fundraisers are great and this is a great Community fundraiser um grades K through five were involved including our teachers who did a weim away which was awesome like thei fantastic I'm biased because my daughter sang in it and I help play piano so yes I was there kind of biased again but it was an awesome night and Jeff avenio did an amazing job as the um MC supporting the students in the school Community I got one EXC so the um advisory Council to the school counseling program again in January and I just wanted to highlight some of their work in terms of the Care Corner that is in Mrs good or Good's office um it's basically a pantry for students who have a need to stop in and OB personal care products snacks those sorts

024of things and it is being used not as much as we would like um but students are and have started to request certain items that they need which I think is great um the same is happening with the elementary school P has been up we got to visit year it's amazing Rec surveyed the community for interest they received 36 responses which um that's great but again we think that there's more need than we're seeing so if anyone who's listening to this does someone who does feel free to spread the word all of us can be accessed confidentially and is a great resource for our community thank you thanks for bringing that forward and I believe that there's information if you want to access it or support it or um in the newsletters that the principal

025sent out yes were there other items are we placing vets on Thursday that we supposed to get a couple inches of snow right during morning Rush about see how it goes okay I have three snow days on file so we're we're ready to rock delay um with that we have the opportunity for the public to be heard there's a Podium over here we welcome any member of the public who has um topic they'd like to bring forward to come to um we are we welcomed Chris and Jason here during our audit meeting and during the audit committe meeting and we now have a long range planning presentation 3.1 um and franks the keyboard so before Chris and Jason go on with this uh Lisa we're about to start the long range plan um I don't

026know if you want to say something but I will really quick um Lisa brought was um when she came on as intern business official we looked at our our financial planning and she brought Chris and Jason on board we we we went through and we're working with them now um to work with a longrange financial plan and Analysis as we look at our budget I have to say working with them this year Lisa is nodding her head I been very impressed with um the plan and this debt Services plan that you just looked at in the audit and with this long range financial analysis as allowed Lisa and I to really look at this budget in a new light and truly understand what we have to do this coming year and how we utilize this

027information to set really strong procedures and deadlines and timelines on borrowing and when we borrow and when we don't borrow to make sure that we're keeping the district even a better Financial stability than what we have been so I really appreciate their efforts and I kind of presetting you guys a little bit Lisa anything you want to say in that regard and Lisa I'll good okay all right so we'll leave it on to you guys you just point at me and I got this it makes life a lot easier thank you we've already kind of gone through some stuff so now we're going to talk more about the long plan addition budgeting and the and how we use that from a capital plan perspective uh we'll talk a little bit more on that but also

028just talking about from the general fund projection as so I'm g go through a quick run some information as well I'll up kind talk the fun balance and the future projection but so just to start especially since this is our first time being presenting this information uh if you don't have a background on long range planning or what is it purpose we um you know a couple things to to just be aware when we talk about long range plans you really what we're trying to do is is take a look over the next five years at what our Trends are and what our projections are for revenues and expenditures and then you know what we might have to do in terms of reserve and fund balance use accordingly with that um and it really helps

029us kind of you know project out in the future and see how things are going uh see you know financial help of the district and also just be aware as we're making long-term comms Capital program uh you know Staffing uh educational program things like that if we're bringing new things on we can Factor those into the long range plan and see you know how do those things impact the future uh as we roll forward uh a couple things to just uh distinguish you're going be talking about your budget tonight as well uh the long range plan is not the same as the budget right we are trying to take a look at you know what i is a more uh realistic or or um direct look at what we think going to happen so when

030we talk about 2526 in a little bit we're not saying take those numbers and build your budget based off of that right there's any number of reasons why you would build your budget differently um we will talk about some of the things in terms of like tax Gap and and uh Capital exclusion whyde you know how that should impact your budgeting but in terms of like building your actual appropriation budget you have to be a little bit more conservative when you build your budget because there's things that come up during the year uh that you can't project for and they're not in your then you have no flexibility right you don't know if students are going to move into the district mid year if there's going to be an emergency project that comes up uh

031things like that so uh naturally your budget may be a little bit more conservative than what we are going to look at in the long range plan tonight uh the other thing is long range plans are not static documents right we always want to be updating them you know ideally annually but at Le you know every other year um as I'm sure you're all well aware you know educational Finance changes very uh you know just since back before um the pandemic started you look at just like what's happened with Foundation a in terms of it was being fully phed in then there was discussions of 20% a Cuts then there was being fully faced back in again and now there it's back on the table for whether it might be you know cut in the

032future in terms of safe Hara so things change regularly and they change rapidly so you doing that update annually helps you always just kind of take that fresh look uh it's kind of a little bit of a joke I me you know plan is only a 5e plan when it's presented the next year it's now a fouryear plan right so you have to constantly update if you want to have that 5year projection looking forward so it's always good to to update and track me regularly and see how you're turning out better what changed you know what new programs are there and new manage and stay in account for all those so uh with that I'm going to turn over to Chris he's G to kind of go through some of the stuff we already went

033through with the um the budgeting and also some of the initial projections and I'm offine again we back to you guys hope join us y okay all right so a lot of these pages that I'm going to go through are going to look very familiar there some of them in the de service document a little bit ago but again your $25 million Capital project um just including our ccial plan for that again the top part of the page is here okay perfect thank you so again the top part of the page has our uh project numbers to the theate by phase so phase one your transportation facility um youest the approval back in January 24 awarded contract that and the goal is to get the final cost closed up at December 25 again that's the

034point of time we building flowing on Capital project phase two you received approval back in May of 24 so understanding you're out to bid now and planning to award bid shortly for for those projects within that phase uh based on the timing of that is that would close out for final by december6 to get blowing in the 2627 year for phase so the bottom half of the page the the pink boxes represented B anticipation notes or short-term financings that we do while you're in the construction phase of the project um so the district issued the first ban 122.5 million note back in July of 24 that comes due in July of 25 at which point in time the plan is to renew that note and pick addition funds as needed for phase two um and

035then the plan would be then to convert that into permanent financing or serial Bonds in June of 26 so the goal would be to structure that that service in alignment with how you're building it is flowing by each the basis for the project uh the next slide again is your energy performance contract so again targeting a lease financing in uh spring in the next couple months here uh to get that rolling to give you funds to start paying for that project as based on the timing of that project the expectation we doing finals in December 26 so again like Jason mentioned earlier that service document is lining up the principal interest payments with how the a is going to flow starting in F year 26 27 uh the next slide is a look at your

036your building debt so the first third of the page is all your capital projects your existing projects as well as projections for the $25 million project um so we've got your debt service in colum a your building in coming back in column B and the local share with sitting l in column D um e through H is your is your energy performance contract so the total debt service in B build building you coming back in up and your local share in column H and then again we um you've been doing Capital only projects 100,000 projects and once you start doing those projects keep them going keep them momentum going so we including a projection in there for those $100,000 capital outl projects which $668,000 per year for the prior year out project so that's spitting

037into local share as well um the real takeway from the slide in in the 25 26 year is the change going up is about 2 and a half% increase and that was that's an alignment with what was projected based on the prevote planning that was within the $25 million Capital project so that's the first step into the impact of that project and then just graphically the building need um the local share look like for your Deb service for your capital projects um so just a graphical look at that local share L is we take that step up in 25 26 to the the full impact 2% increase that proed voters back that project you to see should uh the next slide in the report is each of these shaded boxes represent bonds that have been

038issued in the past through your previous bus borrowings that you've done so all the Shaded ones have occur we are currently targeting a March closing for your uh for your current bus purchases so $350,000 seral on closing in March of 25 and then on this page we've included um for year 25 26 potential borrowing for that 2526 plus purchase in August of 25 as well and then again just like the buildings um your de service does have um for bues there Debt Service and transportation Aid coming back in on that so your debt service for your existing bonds as well as the projections up for the future bus bonds principal interest in columns A and B with the total Deb service in column C uh we're getting Transportation aack on our purchases that's being shown

039in column D and what's hitting local shares in column only projected bus future bus purchases through May of 29 so nothing beyond that this point that's really just within the five years of the some of the pages that we'll go through coming short and just a graphical look at the local shair for your bus uh the next page is a look at your fund balances so it's in the top part of the page is um some of your reserves uh as well as for capital reserve tax some of those individual reserves you have the real focus on this page that we like to look at is what is your what is your fund balance doing your your general fund balance and you can see at the bottom of the page and you know we're seeing

040um some surpluses being generated in each the each the budgeting years 22 23 24 so that's a good thing um and really the focus here is that your your unassigned fund balance is is right at the 4% which is allow for that assign falance category on a going forward basis I can't see you have a reses forward that we get theend one thing to call this the reserve highlighted thatp a little bit of the money over that was approved as part of that $25 million capital correct Lisa back in general it's a good idea you know you think the public support to EST good to have you're not obl to fund it ites you opport put M away help the next slide that we'll take a look at is your state projections for the next

041um so we've got the actuals in there for 23 24 and the latest numbers for 24 25 and 2526 25 26 being based off the latest Governor runs that came out um going forward for6 going forward we' projected a 2% increase in Foundation aid but have kept all the other Aid categories flat um just to be conservative um and within this page we do highlight the building Aid and the transportation Aid separately in Orange those differ from the state the governor's runs because we've taken the values from The Debt Service budget estimates that you have in front of you and we've applied those going forward since we have a better idea of what our building and our transportation will be based on the timing of closeup final crosss and the future purchases of pluses that

042we have so we we've overrode those values going forward in that work shaded can I ask a question about interest are our loans fixed Ori ones that you have they're fixed based on you we go out to B for the low interest cost so they're fixed they are typically thereally call language built in to bond so either or 10 years after that bond is issued if it's a 15 20 or 30 bond that Bond can Bean bu B typically a ter them not attracted to the market it's a b usually not the interest is fixed so all your existing that is fixed for the current prods you're assum cons for BS say that's Now High typically the the market of the industry is for a 15 bond is an8 call so8 years after you issue

043it that's when the bond is call that's we financing it so we do always monitor the market and see opportunities if there's an opportunity we present that to you and see service one of your BS right now want so then starting to look at the the four projections you know Chris already went through on the state a side of things break that L there are so many categories that go into that now this looks at more of the full Revenue picture so that you there's a couple different lines here obviously that other than State the other big one is your tax L that's the other big piece of the revenue side budget and the one that you have the most control over albe you know still within the confines of a tax G um so

044what we have here technical difficulties okay uh you'll see across the top here in the blue shading um that we're assuming that in this long range plan that you are going to go to your maximum tax cap number in each of the five years right so you can do whatever you to talk about planning some dist you you go flat go 2% whatever this is what we're projecting the tax cap will look like over the next five years and we have a page later on that supports this but this is assuming you would go right to the cap is what is in these tax increase numbers one thing we did break out just because I know this is you important with the project coming on you'll see you know in the next year 2526 the

045cap is projected to be at 6.4% partially because of that 2 and half% increase for the current project and that's excludable because of the way the tax dep is set up and then the remaining piece 3.91% would be just kind of from what you get with like the growth factors and inflation everything so that's more in line with what you'll see in the other future Years you'll see after we take that one step in 25 26 for the capital then we're at that level and stay flat no additional increases needed for the capital project Beyond this upcoming year so we did want to break down and just give that distinction um other than that most of the other revenues we've left fairly flat um use of money in property that's like interest earnings we did

046bring that down just a little bit from what you've earned the last two years because the F has been cutting rates so we still anticipate fairly you know decent interest earnings maybe not quite uh but everything else other than what we've talked about on the state a tax caps is is relatively flat one thing to call to your attention on this page and we'll have the same thing when we talk about expenses we take a look at what's that average increase and that's important to you know understand with how this all works when we put it back together and look at the fund balances so your average increase on the revenue side over the next five years is 3.83 based on you what you're allow to do with the cap we're projecting on St so

047if we want to go to the next p looking at the expense side of the budget uh so this is a highle look at at your expenses and basically we're taking you know where you're anticipating ending this current year and projecting forward based on historical Trends to just using averages for salaries and other categories and health and again we have all the debt service projections as well uh so the key thing here is when you look at it with all the projections we're making on the expense at just under 6% 5.97% so that that is a common Trend we see anytime we do these longrange plans you know as a school district in New York state you have uh a lot of people and that you know you want to be competitive so that's you

048difficult in terms of salaries and benefits and all that and that's a growing cost we all know how high you know health insurance is right now whether it be for you know K12 Finance or on the private side it's just a very difficult cost to absorb right now but we'll see the B page is because the expenses grow at that pace while the revenues kind of lag behind and we only have so much revenues with the cap and state being out of control you start to see kind of a further and further spread if we don't make adjustments so when we go to the next page the fun balance projections a couple things to talk about here so as we on the top part of the page is kind of the Year toe snap shot

049of revenues and expenses so you see those are r s projecting deficits because of that difference where our expenses are growing at a faster Pace than our revenues that's not uncommon when we see these this is a common projection and really what you're trying to do is you know manage to the best of your ability to kind of make sure you're maximizing those revenues wherever possible we're going to talk about in a minute kind of the impact if you don't go to the the C uh and then also trying to manage the expenditure side however we can you know in terms of looking at our our program looking for opportunities cost savings cost sharing with other districts municipalities anything like that to try to continue to push those off so you know one thing I

050will highlight is as we look at the bottom when we look at your overall fund balances the good news as you start to look out you are still solid for the next couple years right there are times where you look at these and the cliff is much closer because districts haven't been going out of their cap they haven't been building those reserves uh to help offet so you are in a good you know strong position as a starting point right now this is eye opening exercise as you make any kind of longterm commitments to know that if we are not going to the cap if we are increasing um expenditures things like that that those red numbers could start coming at us a little quicker so we want to make sure we're being cogniz of

051that uh this is also the page I think this might have been what you referring to earlier where this would look like your reserves are being spent down we did show the capital because we know that one's getting used this year so we show that going to zero the other restricted reses we Haven basically those would be that's why you set those aside those retir reses things like that so that if you do experience this over the next couple years these deficits you can start to tap into those and use some of this restricted money to push the the red on your unappropriate fun balance out further as you evaluate your program kind of see if you have to make any longer term structural changes to maintain that of healthy Financial picture you have right

052now not to when you guys look at this there far less red than you thought would come forward typic we seen other yeah that's a POS Le red is good and there's a lot of things that can that can change this too right we haven't projected any other increases on Foundation besides the 2% um you know I think health insurance projecting like 10% so that could get you know controlled a little bit better and come in under there's there's some you know room for mov to the positive but these are you know I will say conservative but not completely unrealistic expectations as you look forward and just a precept budget conversation when when we're talking about budget a lot of us we're giving you assumptions on our budget presentation because we do not have set

053numbers either so get the idea that they're guesses right we're always to be conservative in our first guess and then March will probably be a little bit more understanding so a couple other things to kind of highlight look at this is the our projected tax C page this is how we're arriving to those tax Lev increase numbers there's a lot of you details on here but basically we're just kind of taking a hisorical look at what your growth factors have been doing and what the allowable Levy factor is factoring in the capital exclusions and all that the real key takeway from this page is right in the middle there we have that line that says no super majority votes needed so we're not anticipating in order to make this plan work we do not have

054to go for any Tex override we're staying within the tax cap limit in each year as we go forward and then on the next slide just as a thought exercise we went to I believe the district has traditionally gone you pretty close to your cap number if not right at it so that that's a good thing you've gone under not were okay so you kind of go you might be under but going at least not necessarily maybe um this is just kind of a thought exercise to show you what happens if you go under the Gap right so as we look at the long range plan on the top part is what if we just win at 2% into the next five years you know that's that's a a common like uh thing that people

055tax cap was rolled out it's a 2% tax cap you know it's never really a 2% tax cap L of factors that go in but that's something that's out there in the public a lot of people think it is uh so if you use that as a bench compared to going right at your full maximum cap what does that look like and there's there's the year-to-year impact of what you're leaving on the table right so you know 700,000 500 300 whatever it is and people think about that number but there's also a cumulative effect of not going to the cap because you start from a lower number the next year and that's what drives the formula is your starting level so you can see when you actually run out the full numbers if you went

0562% for the next five years instead of at the projected maximum number you would be leaving 8.7 million in uncollected revenue on the table that you can't get back without going for an override in the future so when we look at that fund balance page it didn't look that bad there were rent numbers for sure but the the real impacts were four or five years out if we don't go at the cap if we you know leave that money on the table so to speak then those numbers start to come back up a lot quicker so that's something to think about as you're planning especially in this upcoming year when it's a higher number that you might be a little bit but we know that we have to use two and a half% of that

057for the capital project increase so if we're not going that cap that we're kind of leaving revenues on the table that are not there to help fund our oper our you General educational program instead of just a Capal Fe so that's just something to think about as you really get into part of your budget discussions this year is that long-term impact of not going up to those Capital numbers and what that means for that fun balance page go to the next page um so then really just kind of wrapping up with the the same thoughts we've already kind of hit on that um certainly you know the pictures although there's some R numbers there it's you know in good shape compared to what we see in some of these other presentations but it's just something

058to continue to evaluate you know as you look forward and think about you know when you have um when you're when you're planning in terms of your program what are the opportunities for cost savings from uh whether it be shared services with other districts bosies that or just evaluating uh you know as your filling positions kind of the need or the ability to kind of use those with your program um so that that's kind of the overall picture any questions on any of that information we run through tonight we kind of thre a lot at heard Lisa anything to add I think that they did a great job I think the slides at the end of the presentation tell a story that the board may not realize but it's something to keep in mind as

059we plan for the future 2526 budget and going forward thank you Chris and Jason thank and thank you Frank and Lisa as well there's a lot of information to gather to help us put this report together and back and for app as I just have a question is this is the first time you've seen something of this magnitude do you find this to be useful in our in our planning understanding and also transparent for the community and looking at where our funds are where our de services are and really where we look as a fiveyear plan going glad thank you okay well a couple things going on behind the scenes if you see me on my cell phone got here tonight because you're having some internet issues and we don't know why so he's he's

060he's working through it as we're here and I appreciate you L that's good thing I don't know where the yeah and I appreciate everybody's patience as we work through the technical difficulties that we're having um I also there was a question during committee about middle school students not being able to access the Java um I did text Paul frini and Brian olon Paul frini being our food service person principal Ranna is going to clarify our school Community she said students can use it during their lunch period students cannot have C Caff drinks we had students grabbing drinks on their way back from tea and bringing drinks into class and arriving late so impacting the instructional moment so maybe that is why they're being told they can't use it anymore because they were using it in

061times that delay their ability to get classes on time um so and that's always been simal Rule and this is also will be reaching out to the school Comm clarify and please don't ask me any other questions that I don't know you have questioning the Middle School structure what the princip I have no CL okay so moving on next well I do believe it's also coming from staff members coming class yes so my report um Capital project update so and we're going to do a budget report short I will be short because Lisa and I will be talking longer hopefully Lisa will be able to speak she's got a lot of things that I don't know how to say correctly so Capital project update the transportation facil is moving along the panels are going up

062so that is positive we should have all the panels up on the building by the end of this week after the panels are up they are on one side and the other then they put the roof on because if not it's like a giant sail and we live so panels first then roof we're going um they have heaters on the concrete down there because they're heating it up and I'm not a construction person even though I sit in these meetings and learn about it as much as I possibly can but our construction manager and Engineers doing everything with right when they exp the flings um but they are going to be pouring the footings this week and working through that again not an engineer not a construction person but we do have people overing all

063of it and then after that's done we should be able to move a lot quicker because then we'll be able to get the roing in and moving quicker until now it looks like a June occupancy date so we should be able to getting there June final completion in July um and that's where we get our Co now is in July but we should be able to start transitioning in June that means we do have to do a lot of work on our end about Surplus the transportation facility now some of the lifts that aren going some of there so we do have to clean that up a lot as well um so that is something you'll be seeing in the next couple months you'll it um we I'm going right now so you're you're totally

064right on board Kathy thank you and so we went out to bid and for the elementary school project um the bid documents and bid projects all stay late June start so we were trying to get in and do the site work a little bit early but given the June time and bid times and everything else we're working to making sure they get out the bid should be back at the end of February then you find March at the board meeting we should be able to award the bids as well um at the March meeting for us to start from June at the trans at the elementary school um so that's going to be everything across the board to fully understand where we are my goal is that we're going to start this in like June

065close the elementary school down completely um that means the site itself will not be occupiable by anybody because of the fact that there's going to be so much both site work and inside the building it's going to be a lot a lot of work for our staff to get everything done and we're also going to be pushing the time frame of starting school um we are pretty sure we'll be able the start on time you know I've done this before I've been in buildings at 3 o' in the morning and having kids come in the next day like sometimes when you do capital projects there is an issue sometimes when you do capital projects there's buildings that are still unfinished and the buildings occupied that does happen um but we're doing our best to plan

066accordingly and then that back up plan back up back up so crazy question yes no crazy questions when it comes to C project adjusting to people then can maybe even get a little bit more work done um it really depends on when the fids come back and where we stand those two days aren't going to save us a lot of time because we can do a lot of we can do site preparation getting everything outsite for two weeks before school starts and start planning out it really is going to be how much time and how on schedule will those construction people get that work in July and August so then we can move forward that one or two days early isn't going to help us that one or two days on the back end where

067I may have to take a profession superintend conference and maybe we have it scheduled for March and move that to the front load of the year I may have to do that right that might come up as a oh my gosh I can't start school I need an extra day to get teachers in building I may have to take the professional development that we had scheduled and switch it forward or one of the 182 or 181 instructional that we had planned we can by law it's 180 days instructional days and 176 176 instructional days four confer we have a couple extra days as part of our contract maybe I make those non school days for students but have them for Teacher so I have backup plan on top of backup plan on top of the

068backup plan hopefully never gets to that point and the original plan works but the goal is to get it done get it started and we at least OCC the building um depending on the way the bids go the site work at the elementary school can go two ways when it comes to our our back fields we're doing a lot of trans we're doing some of the drainage work which is a large part of the drainage work that has to get done and then there's feeder drainage work so we're doing the large part and then on the far end of the elementary school is very very well if you ever notice that when it rains it's almost like a mud field when it gets closer to where that is so as part of the Bas that's

069going as well an alternate is to rip all of it off and replace some of the 30y old dra that is on top of it because there's there's two levels of drainage not an engineer going to speak specifically to it if that happens completely um there that field will not be occupied until probably spring because we'll have to make sure it's SE done correctly and being able to have opportunity for to grow so and I've been speaking to the community groups that are so we plan to have just in case the worst case any questions on it's exciting and it will be amazing when it's done but Capital project and building work is never easy and it can be pain but when it's done it's fantastic and as they noticed before um to make sure

070that we align with our debt services and that's why we're seeing that 2.5 this year because our debt Services isn't completely aligned to make sure that we're align we will have to go out for a project in the next two years so that way when our debt Services falls off in 5 years we don't see a tax Lev impact and it's automatically adjustable to the that's why this long range plan is so important to help moving on any questions C project okay uh the cell phone updated proposal so that actually is the governor's cell phone updated proposal I just wanted to talk about it briefly um Community wise because it's out there and I think I don't think people fully all the time when things are said by the governor they're not set in stone

071so if they say well we're going to do a ban on cell phones that doesn't mean it's done because it's got to be go through the legislation go through it and the bill has to be approved but that's the proposal that she has that out there so I want to clarify a few things in the governor's proposal it is no internet enabled devices by students during the school day does not include proms as far as I'm aware of those are School providing Internet devices if the internet works we got yeah it's but I want to clarify someone did ask that question it's personal student devices um parents and Guardians are supposed to be told that there different ways to communicate this is part of her proposal and that has to be set up so like

072if you want to get a hold your student the school has to tell you specific ways on you being able to do so um The Proposal would also require at least one method for on-site stores for students this is the important part um it does not mean that the schools have to buy beyond their backs okay it can mean that lockers would be a permitted method of onsite storage so having a locker for a student permittable onsite stor if the student refuses to do it having the safe in the office to hold that would be another permissible based off of this proposal I heard somebody said well we don't re wants everybody use the under that's not what the proposal is um you know I know that they're pushing towards a lot of those that

073is not what it is there is supposedly money in the budget for those things right but so I wanted to really clarify there they say lockers can be utilized um there are students can leave their phone in their locker correct okay that's what the proposal say um there are exemptions to that is what the governor said when authorized by a teacher or District or B specific for educational purposes for management student Healthcare we have students who have diabetes and they look at their goone to be able to manage the their luxur levels uh emergency situations which is OB if you can't use it that's going to be interesting uh translation services or where required by law so there are abilities to do this I think an important thing that people are missing on this is

074the reporting component of this that is also in there in 2026 school has to report the non-compliance aspects of it so if you had how many students that you had disciplinary issues or non- compliance of the cell phone components so 25 26 do it year 26 starts then you have to report how many interractions you have of students being caught using their phone which I think is very interesting um but it is in in The Proposal uh our district advisory committee has met they discuss the district advisory staff on it also students the principal's going to be working the High School principal's going to be working to get student surveys out I think the initial thought process by our staff andte is that we can use lockers as means to teach students an appropriate way

075to utilize cell phones not under pack and make kids force them to use it because you know as I was told people will buy burners you know people will buy harb magnets and this is just going to be the prohibition all over so I think it's an opportunity for the district which they've already been doing because the Middle School said that you know they did it this year they stopped Ving the cellones they went through some bums in the road but they're training our students now so it's a great opportunity to use that model to build into the high school to teach kids an appropriate way or time to use I apologize I said I'm using my cell phone I apologize but I wasn't using it for any other purposes right teaching kids teaching people

076how to use it is is important you know and making sure there's guidelines so I think we could do that well within the policy I think we're already leading towards that way anyways this Governor proposal will just get questions I just kind of want to clar reporting requ I haven't heard much about the reporting requirement that was my own little kind I was looking at it reporting requ not catching a lot of can I get it to understand the interaction from from basic conversations with leg understanding what has been said I do believe you know it is even kids are 100% on board something has to be done about our students conversation here to be able to teach than just to be able to Comm disciplined and you know I'm always for the teaching component

077more so than the modifying Behavior by displ in the end that's not right because as soon as a child leaves if they don't learn it they get them in bus they're on at 24 hours right when they're home they're doing the too so you know I get it I understand it I respect it I've seen the data on you know the reasons why I have colleagues who utied the great success in their districts I think in our district there is a possibility of moving forward without using those and just creating a good structure and getting a lot of stakeholder voices questions and in how is it out mid so at the district advising commit there was Middle School staff and principles and I asked that same question because you know sixth grade they got that

078online seventh grade couple little bums here there eth grade I think it's a little bit harder because the kids have not that expectation so and that's to be expected with an Implement implementation so as we're moving forward we think that you're going to see that sixth grade mentality travel seven and after a few years it will be a basic expectation we have a spot I'm sorry we have a spot in the middle school and I think this is the most amazing thing in the world it's down in the back over where the pack is so if you go to the middle school hall and all the way down it's there's a stairwell that goes back and there's doors and it's completely it's open right we tell the kids don't go back there I've never once

079caught a kid back there right there's an expectation this this is not what we do our students for the most part they understand the expectation they respect that expectation we monitor that area we watch our camera there's never kid back there you know so if you can set that expectation up as a standard within your building and as a practice of expectation kids would hear to and I think that's it's that basic respect and I think that's what you'll get to withell on and the last thing is a speed limit change so near Route 156 this has been a long time I have to say um I do want I'm not going to say the parents because I did not get permission from the parent say there parent Community has been helping me with this

080and I appreciate him for doing so for the past two years he's been helping me contact people and work with people um if you ever notice at our elementary school in 85 going up 43 Road there's speed Li change 20 M hour route 156 there is not a speed so it's kind of awkward because it's built in so we've been petitioning to get that speed liit change especially now with Anthony my Ros and other you know the traffic get even more we want to be able to have it there so en forced people understand go slow for the school year um I was told by V that it was approved they will be giving me a letter about the sign fing up so it's positive after almost two years of conversations and planning we are

081going to be able to have that change to a 20 you know school speed Z in that area 156 so that's positive I do want to thank the parent call let know again I get permission comfortable but there was a community help and that is all I have all right Lisa Lisa tell you're there I'm here it's budget presentation time okay so this is me and you do you have the slide show up I fear that if I show it to you I'm going to yes I do okay I do I'm a little fearful that if I show it that I would lose you I apologize I'm going to do the slideshow and feel free to talk and I'll point to you as we go okay thank you all right so the first page as

082you know is our vision statement and I and I think this is important Reon I talked about this a lot and I really kind of want to go through because as we're looking at the budget and as long your BR plans that is like we do have to look at you know how what our spending is making those decisions of cost savings or if we have attrition or what we offer to make sure that we can level up our year toe spending as a district right because it is a business and we got to make sure that what we do is sustainable so this vision statement is important because it guides a lot of our decisions as along with our mission St you not going to read it um so our goal statements and our

083budget align so when we're looking at our goal statements they Inc student Achi Staffing financial responsibility that's the conversation communication and safe supporting learnings all of those goal statements lead into how we create a budget so the goal of the budget is to provide many sustainable programs for students that limit the impact on taxpayers to only what is needed so if what only is needed if we use that as the tax that's what we're talking right and support says well if the tax cap is 6.4 and we don't feel comfortable doing 6.4 then have to understand this where does the board want to be so then with our taxes so then we can make those decisions to still align to meet the needs of our students and that's that balancing that we need to make

084sure that we're constantly doing as we creating bu questions so far Lisa you want to take over sure yes okay so obviously we've been meeting with Administration since probably beginning of December and in January they were supposed to um provide and they did provide information on their individual building budgets and Department budgets and we've been going over facility projects the safety um mental health supports recomendations stem from the district levo recommendations that align with Bo goals so on 6 20th we're looking at two large 72 passenger diesel buses did I L Lisa one Mar there's an IRS initiative as well the diesel buses are Eed over five years and the electric buses are aided over and this is incorrect I apologize it's 12 years I believe there's a proposal to have them at it over

085eight years how there for the first yes yeah you you broke up a little bit so I just want to clarify there is a proposal out right now that I think is giving a lot of traction I think is going to happen to drop it down to an 8year Transportation Le ratio so it is 12 for electric buses but as you know there's basically a 10e warranty on those buses and that 8 years is basically the maximum of some the battery lights so there is a large push from a lot of different groups um I put more more of the groups that has been advocating for this um to change it over I do believe you're going to see that change to anear Transportation ratio concern e buses um Lisa you still there I'm going

086to answer this question I just want to confirm you're still there so then I'm hoping she comes back on and I'm hope want to go do something here yeah going do all right I'm going to call Lisa and then I'm going to answer your question here I'm I'm just going to put you on speaker phone all right just talk really loud and hopefully I'll put you next to a microphone okay all right so I'm going to answer the question about electric buses so let me give a quick tutorial and we're going to go through there uh the government put out a proposal that we have to buy electric buses come in a certain time frame there's been a lot of Lobby legislation that has went out regarding this um also there's California's initiative that went

087through with clean buses and clean trucks and everything else so everything's tied together I just wanted to say like it's bigger than just New York um getting into it is there's been a lot of lobbying over here saying we're not going to be able to need e mandate to make you know to do the switch over as the governor wants to do and it's not only just in just the need of the buses it's also with the infrastructure that is out there so the electrical infrastructure the school infrastructure not all schools are building brand new Transportation facilities to meet needs right you know wee in future proofing where we're going and and also I speaking to senator overacker who is thing I went he brought up something very interesting he's on the transportation committee he

088said think about the bridges the electric buses are very heavy not small Brides in New York state can meet those needs so they have to be recertified and red so I thought that was a very interesting thought process that I've never really thought about before you know it's not only for schools it's how does it impact everything so given all that information is it going this the Mandate going to go away no I don't believe it's going to go away it might be delay a while they might shift it it might be changed over years but I don't think we're going to see e buses go off the table or CL buses go off the table what I think we're see is transition of how long it takes you know you know what the mandates

089are of you know pushing it out a few years I'm hoping you're going to see some of those shifts you know as the technology gets better as the initiatives get better as the buses get lighter as the batteries get lighter I think you're going to see that change and the prices will go down right on these you're going to buses coming like 10 years ago I if you asked me were we going to have electric cars like we have now I would say no but they're here right elri charger more more often we had electric Chargers in our parking lot you are seeing that inion so I think it's going to slow down I don't think it's going to go by the way side I don't think diesel buses are going to cover future think

090buses or buses will be the way maybe GRE hydrogen other things that are out there um but we're going to see a change in the way that we do things and I do think that it's fiscally sound for us to look at you know utilizing what we have now to meet the Mandate that's currently out there too saying how do we offset costs get grants and anything we can to be electric bus and to do it I'm not going to be one of the people putting in 50 Chargers in the back and presetting and not being able to support dist funds not going to do that so my question I guess I'm looking alls come I still say we buy a bus yeah I yeah I understand so to clarify we put in for EPA

091Grant we're also putting in for an IRS if those funds aren't there and the district has to be able to support that give the ratio back do we still buy an electric bus currently the Mandate is still there for 2027 if we don't that mandate still stays we're going to be H so we still have to do that and right now the M's there I see no if buz about Chang supp I get it 100% this is the balance that we have to ask these are great questions because it's not our money we're playing with we're playing with our taxpayers and our community members money and with a long range planning for our district think they're great questions am I okay to go Wi-Fi here yeah you should try it right and I moved it

092out from behind the giant speaker with the giant magnet Lisa I got three bars so we might be able to have you come right back on if you want okay so why don't you try one more time I'm going to hang up and if it doesn't work I'll call you back and I appreciate the bo being so um good about our if I was in a classroom I would just PIV do something else let's just do it but nobody's here yeah let's just do it this way let's keep going all right okay sorry about that no it's it's better this way actually I can hear you just fine okay all right so okay slide seven yep okay so this is the first draft of the general fund budget we'll go over the revenues the tax

093cap state aid others um really brief discussion about expenditures talk about fund balance and what's the difference slide eight so we wanted to talk about the tax cap the 25 six tax tax cap is 22 mil 343 524 the 2425 the current one is 21, 114,000 so it's a dollar difference of 1.3 million and change and a 6.4% increase which is the worst case scenario again this is the 50% plus one it does not require a super majority and the major increase for the tax cap is 2.5% strictly for The Debt Service um you may or may not remember our last board meeting I said that we would have a significant increase for Debt Service next year and unfortunately we will need at least a 2.5% tax cap increase in order to support that new

094debt service for the project that was approved in December of 20122 so the difference between the worst case scenario of 6.4% tax cap increase less than 2.5% is 3.9% remaining for all other expenses that means salaries that means benefits polies everything else so the way that I'm that I had to understand it best I because I had to put it in a term that I can easily understand is like a promise right so if someone gives you a promise ring it's like you're entitled you know that someone's going to eventually say yes this is what's going to happen so we went out with a vote saying that we're going to have to take on 2.5% you know 2.5% of the capital project taxpayers so that 2.5% promise has come due so that's where that is

095so that that is there we need it it's going to be there for our debt Services if for us to go year over year with our general fund just small couple additions very tiny it's 3.9% that we need to do that based off of our current understanding there are things that we don't know yet and this could go down but the 3.9 could become 3.2 right which would bring that down9 we're not sure yet but right now given what we have year over-year with very small increases for a couple sapping things it's at 3.9 plus that 2.5 brings us up to that 6.4 I just want to be very very clear that it's not 6.4 and we're adding all of these things it really isn't that it's that 2.5 is important because that is our

096Capital PR so any questions on that it's just I want to keep hitting at home and any communication that we share and anything that comes forward is that because of our services that we were that's why I'm saying now and I have a newsletter going out next week that will actually have the information on moving on Lisa yeah I'm on slide time all right so i' like I'd like to just show you where our estimated 2526 revenues are as of last Friday state aid is at 9.6 mli other Revenue sources 669 th000 the tax cap that I utilized was a 6.4% of 22 million appropriated Reserve capital and you see I have an Asterix there the district appropriated 3.3 million excuse me three million for the uh December 22 Capital project so that appropriated Reserve

097obviously it's not needed for 2526 so is showing zero fund balance I left at 862 059 and again that is something that we can consider changing um as soon as you know closer we get to finalizing the budget so I've had a total income sources of 33.5 million which is a decrease of just under a million 970,000 questions okay the next slide is very disappointing um I do not have a total of estimated expenses yet the TRS rate just came out on Friday I just received an email today about another expense going up so I will have that by the end of the week however this is where I really need the board and Frank to give me some guidance about the tax C amount to be levied does the board feel comfortable with the

0986.4 what does the board feel comfortable with appropriated reserves I know that ERS and TRS those two budget lines are going to be increas it next year and I know that you have an appropriated um reserve for ERS and TRS what would the budget look like if we you di into that specific reserve for Retirement Systems appropriated fund balance does the board feel comfortable with the 862,5kg [Music] health insurance rates and bothy Services I need those final numbers and those are big budget categories in order to finalize the budget unfortunately I don't have them so Lisa you and I did have a conversation and my recommendation TRS and NS we would use the reserves yes so if we were to use those reserves that would lock knock down that Levy from 6.4 down over correct

099that would and we have money in those reserves that we put in for to be able to do yes absolutely you cannot you cannnot use a reserve outside of its intended purpose you have to use it specifically for an increase in those expenses So Lisa in terms of where any reduction in the 6.4% would come from is that going to come from reducing the tax cap Levy or reducing the 2 and half% that was well I think that one you have to Levy at least 2.5% that is that is set in stone when the voters approved that project in December of 2022 they were told that it would be a 2.5% tax cap increase um you can see that from the long range financial plan where that fits in the question is the difference between

100the 6.4 and the 2.5 where do you does the board feel comfortable and I'm not looking for an answer tonight but it's something that you need to consider and have further conversation in March and possibly through April my question is going to be is that we can go to 6.4% right now Reserve stay where they are spending stays where it is or do we look at ways for us to limit that down so our burden on our tax payers is not 6.4% this year and that would be the operational cost so we would use TRS and ERS reserves which we have already that would help limit that down a little bit we would look at our operational cost no program no people everything stays the same I would be very very clear on that you

101would any of those operational means but maybe you would look at your maintenance fees instead of buying a $50,000 V track this year we would wait hold off on that maintenance component and then push it off to another year so that lowers some of your operational costs so would the board feel comfortable at 64 or do they want you to look with Lisa and get us down to a lower level we typically went out anywhere between 3.75 and 4.75 to our community do we feel 5% where do we feel the bur can be our community or do we feel veryify with the 6.4 and saying our community will support that I think I can look at cutting that down a little bit but truly it's going to be at the direct when would we expect

102to have the the actual rates for that last line trss health insurance Etc I'm hoping that I'll have all that by Friday I would feel 699 I mean you know there's a reality are and you know start to look at C know but I would be in favor of reserves if we have of this but you know we're already to the 2 ibody gas I do want to clarify and I said this this year I don't believe F balance if we do 3.5% is 62,000 I don't feel comfortable increasing that because you start getting into a very slippery slope by increasing those funds yearly and yes you're going to get that money back one year but two or three years down the road you're offsetting taxpayer Levy you're offsetting cost and then you're going that

103is going to go away so I do have major concerns with that I has that would be something new would look at we do need to establish reserve for the next right we know right cutting into our appropriate so don't don't forget the board itself cannot establish a capital reserve the capital reserve needs to be established by voter approval so if you're thinking about that the board for you know upcoming years perhaps you should have a resolution on um the May 20th to establish a new capital reserve we'll talk about that the truck iSell the do the other and not all that's actually in this budget because we we already had to take some of that up because we knew that we were already at64 so it it's a hard balancing these are hard conversations

104better than programing people right that is the last thing I would like to cut and not there this year we actually add programing people is but it's that balance are you sure okay um I just want to be clear so of the 6.4% I understand that 2.5 is set so the remaining 3.9 is that simply what's allowable or is that already allowable and account for based on estimations and currently in the budget using our TRS and ERS reserves that would lower that 3.9 down to 3.5 but that was my question is it just theoretical as where we can go to or has it already we gave you worst case scenario and now I can Windle it down at and look through and find two of those but we wanted to be very honest coming into

105this yeah we're if we go at to 6.4 we're at zero Gap we're there right everything's great but we don't know if that's the best decision to make for our district I'd like to tell the board that this has not been a very easy budget to develop I think they're getting on that one and the reason why is the whole Capital project and The Debt Service and the planning um as to when are the taxpayers actually going to incur that debt and how much are they going to incur uh there's been an awful lot of conversations about that so this has not been like an easy rollover budget it's been going through every single line item and making sure I've captured everything and haven't been too conservative so it's it's been a be and you've

106done fantastic thank you Rachel so I've been trying to recall my understanding was that was it last year we worked really hard with Jim to keep the at 2% with the understanding was it the before we never it was we were never was it that we we were careful and considerate knowing that knowing that we would incur the debt services so we kept it below the below what we were CA at not by much but yes because of the fact that we knew the community vard on that 2.5 right so that it was overall we had like a cap of but the debt didn't hit them as anticipated by so now we are looking at the Imp now the debt is going to hit in a year that we you know we had anticipated it

107hitting andt it lower went lower then we still would have incurred that 2.5 now it doesn't matter because we had incur that the year that it was low then it would have been fine but we didn't Ur the that right so that correct Lisa y you've schooled these so well that I can speak without you tonight I'm very proud of myself yay so yeah that's the problem is that yes we kept it low even if you went up 5% that year we would still beting that 2 2.5% to spent that because if we were going up 5% have a need to spend two and that would be program which we would end cutting if we had to so it's that sustainability component that's super important absolutely understand that we were trying to anticipate that did

108not hit as anticip and then the other question I have is about the community's growth and how that impacts the actual percentage that are hit with so the growth factor is great Lisa hit that would you please okay that is like a two two part first the growth there's a growth factor that's assigned to the district from New York State and that's part of the tax cap calculation which by the way Bernie D was very surprised at our growth rat and they haven't that other communities however the second piece of the growth of your community will show up in the assessed values so I will call the local assessors on March 1st and hopefully they'll call me back um in the two weeks following to provide me with preliminary numbers as for assessed values I'm

109sure the board understands that final assessed values don't come out until July 1st but they should be giving me a good idea of where the district is as far as home starts and businesses thank you so you may have a 6.4% theoretically tax cap increase but that may translate into a lesser tax rate increase so even though it's 6.4 it could be 2.5 depending on Equalization rates cor and assess values correct Y and when do you need our input on this I need you to mull it over in the next month so that way with the March presentation we have a better idea if the board feels comfortable with you know a 3% three and a half 4% where where you are going I would like personally right now is an understanding is do you

110want me to look at options for us so that we can look in really understanding you're bringing it down to 4.5 or 5.5 or you like no 6.4 we're good like as Kath you said 6.4 shocking and I saw that at least it will tell you I kind of what you know because again taxpayer I live here too know so I get it you know we all live here um so my question to the board is do you want us to dig deeper to look at maximizing that maximizing that to say where can we get that L to comfortably knowing that we're still leaving money on the table but too much money on the table to still understand where we're going or are you guys Point adss things like that I will say there are

111two things built into this budget now that I want taking away um that are additions that I that I feel very important keeping in one is going to be an assistant principle at the elementary there are 575 students at that elementary school um the DEA students is great and wonderful to have that but they really do need the support in the assist principle down there duties and expectations that is not a large impact because you're not having a homeowner position the de goes back into the other position so that free up one salary of a teacher position to be added to the administrative line so only adds about $30,000 into the budget and if you look at retire e coming back in or going off on a rollover it really do it doesn't add too

112much into that budget so that one is not a huge budgetary impact um after looking at our services and what we are able to offer and Supply right now again my principles have given me a list of things that happen there's a couple of things that are armed at possibility of adding so if I am able to get this down 55 but maybe I can add this position it might go no it might be 6.4 because I want to add this position so but these other positions are in now um is a social worker gr 5 through eight we have over met our needs for our social workers especially 6 through 12 the case Lo they're doing I counseling almost fulltime all the time that doesn't allow for you know groups it doesn't allow for

113all the other components it doesn't allow for at risk or or specific counseling to support kids because there's just not enough time in the day for people so that social worker is actually really needed in the building to be able to help support based off of case Lo data so it's a need it has to happen there are a couple other positions and supports that we're looking at but it really is dependent on where can I go with this budget so say I get this down to 59 but I look at having an AIS position as we talked in curriculum 6is m well I can get this back to 6.4 if I add that so I really do want to look at the budget understand exactly where we are and there's some hard decisions and

114conversations to look into um but those are the two specific added value positions that are in it right now no the de would go back into the position so it do money because again BR down was saying this it's allocation resources how do you combine how you develop with still being able to offer program I'm never say we should figure out ways to save money taxers M at the same we I think at least some members of our community expect us to get there said a lot this it's a coming up thatan we have a here second complex we want to get there with that so I I think we just sat 45es long range planning and Debt Service presentations and out going hurt ourselves years out but I think if know reserving and planning

115and figuring out how to be as effective as possible even if we come out I think that's responsible we know where we're going to end up Lisa and I will really dig deep look at understand exactly where we are and really look at our options and if we were going to go down to like maybe less shocking which would be like9 you know or something we give options of how that would be really understand I don't see us getting lower year over year we're 3.75 to that's our year over-year average right and with 2.5 you're already there so you know we might be able to get down a little bit but I'm not seeing us getting down that much anyway just because of where we typically are year which you can and and to me

116personally I I don't think that find Point put on it you know said is that you know in some ways sets a limit that if you do not go up to that limit you are then costing yourself one years as opposed to pre tax cap is one year you could choose to stay at zero if you want it and you're not penalized for them the next year you know maybe maybe having you you need to have foresight and and invest publication it yeah and I think you just said really probably important for communications compon because the tax capap is what you're supposed to be going right that's kind of this is the max that you can go as Community I think that's an important communication help people understand it's not but you should or shouldn't

117it's here's what you're allowed to do and that's why it's there to stop that 12% that people were seeing prior to the tax this commun did see % increases before tax I mean that did happen 2 2002 there were those increases before Equalization rates so any further questions comments thoughts I will state Lisa is right when she's saying this is the fa of the budget she is not kidding um she's been Lisa our business office myself have been putting a lot of time to really fine tuning this budget this year and work to it it's not an easy one what we got to here took a lot of effort from work so like when you see 6.4 and you're going well that's shocking please trust me it was a lot higher before we did that

118so you know the efforts getting into this and we're going to continue to work on Lisa any closing thoughts no I think you said it all thank you very much for your patience so the bu calendar is all there Avail with that we're going to move back to the agenda item1 minutes January anyone like to discuss who in red would like to move it I will and second I all in favor with that we have a treasur report1 discuss second all in favor um 5.2 is the person and we have number of re uh we have six retirements for a toal 137 years service Ted Sim Miss who is only years old but yet she has worked here for years Lori Kelly rer Brook sale and Lor sa are all on docket and all have

119served this District so well and marvous Next Step um we also welcome everyone else who will be joining us but with that would anyone like to move [Music] on yes yeah so we passed the board policy um also so yeah when you see that choreographer and play director the club pay those directly but we we want those in favor um if it's all right with all of you we can move forward items as a consent agenda 5.3 54 and theist the CSC CSC recommendation sub andus all in favor we have a contract with the boys of basketball and also cont I'll all in favor okay with that we have the old business of the A and curriculum committee met the curriculum committee met and a large portion of the meeting we were joined by Jones

120who went over our special education programing that we have you heard Frank mention that we'll be adding A6 not on the docket to add but it was there so there were a couple other positions that were discuss curriculum a special education 1211 class and .6 Math teachers that we're looking at but are trying to find ways to fund them ta that we currently have which they currently there's not we have is what I have in the budget currently and then things to be added yeah so there are some proposals of things that we could do to enhance our special education programming um we also took a look at our languages um some good news we were able to they've been working I know this is quite the process to do is to get the Seal

121of by literacy uh for our graduates and that could be a student here that has moved all the way through our Spanish program or if we have any of the school Community any students who may be Heritage speakers of a language at home they could also earn that seal literacy um we are always on the quest to try to find some way to add possibly another language um which always goes to is there some way to share resources with another District um possibly with the languages of either Latin or mandin um but the thing is always we would need to align with someone else's bedu and make everything align not easy and I am currently in conversations with school district to see if we can do that looking at our schedules and purposes and again

122maximiz budget be to support it not losing any program for people we have here but adding program and shared services um it's going to take a month or two to be able to figure out if it's something we can offer but crossing my fingers you can can I do can I give one quick update um we did meet with bkw on a certain note and we are looking at we do have a couple courses that we're looking at pairing up so offering courses to their students and our students offering give courses from them because they offer different ad courses that we don't have in different courses so mutual benefiting each other um so that's a good possibility to add program to our students and still support each other without adding budgetary have to do not

123much really there's not much there's a committee that will meet and Karen Jones is heading it right now since it's only one child and and it's really based on the students there's a lot of work on the students and then for they have to have someting project that they present to this board as um the board for the um and that's part of the comp Y and then that has that and I've talked to a couple districts some districts have their assistance construction doing it some schools have a department leader being overseeing it so sometimes it just gets included with other duties as I go we only have child I have 250 students who receive the bacy have one so it's going to be a drawing program we hope um along with new we had

124a new proposal that we looked at um something titled ap7 on um which could possibly in the future be what our current English 10 honors is um and the idea behind that is is within that AP seminar course students would learn skills that would then benefit them in further AP courses in 11th and 12th grade and we had one proposal submitted for our uh redesigning learning which is again change in instruction accomp by different seating say in the classroom as so talked about people that were working with on the grass fields thought were okay um we're looking at the bridge for different options because we did somech on the bridge it was specifically made to not have gaps in $4,000 specific for that reason so we're looking to see if we can put track there's

125a lot that goes into Bridge so still working with our if we could just take it off and put trucks on it would be great than you I Wasing transcript there's no transcrip from the hour and seven minutes lost yes that was all about if you don't know we the owl that we I didn't realize my computer was above it and I looked up and there was a little red button and I said oh my gosh I think we have been muted the whole time and we were so if you look at an hour and seven minutes in you'll see my head going like this and then be kind of like going oh my gosh and we tried to recap the last hour yeah I was say so when the audio started iemp to do

126a recap and basically the first part of the meeting we students and that may not come back to the board for another six to eight months so it's it's getting pushed down now to get St we can yeah sorry was not my best moment like I said I tried to do a recap and then the other things that we got2 the updates there basically to do updating the policy tole the model rules for from the committee government for broadcasting and recording meetings and then agenda we just madees tocy in2 so it was on our radar had agenda all theit outside this that you guys ready to go to 7.1 acceptance of donations any questions M uh2 resolution sement would like to that as municip than we're it's not my we're we are in the Cal

127super we're all looking at how to help one another because everybody's struggling these are just one of the steps forward the go I appreciate it but that's a if we had to do just from a neighboring School we will do the same for 7.4 we have the board organizational meeting and would to that allor discussion orve it second all in favor with that we move to it 81 the opp for the public anyone and I'm not can I say something I just want to say was great tonight with that also you have noticed and we've had complaints from our community regarding our setup for board meetings that has been very difficult to hear um we Bas on Lin recommendations we have new camera system and we have new systems that we're getting that will look

128like this these microphones which R said 100% text message I got so we should not be hearing complaints from our community and they should be able to access everything especially internet issues tonight right I you but thank you for your attention to that it's it's nice we use this for a lot of other things too so abely we're in a good place rest of the equip comes in you won't see these yeah this will post you want to watch it I have a good feeling it's great there's a lot of work that went into preparing everything for this meeting and just a lot of appreciation go to inv that the dates to remember I believe March 3rd is our next not March 6 um so mark your calendars all here to see um and thank

129you all for being here tonight anyone a second all in favor [Music] yeah this is really nice are I can't get over good they that

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.