001to [Music] to the roll call everyone is here we understand that our ex offici member is very extra [Music] won IED Al to the flag United States of America with that we move to order with that we move to the opportunity for the public to be heard if anyone in the public would like to come forward all right with that we invite our our counil coun for district ran us basic Lon could you please turn on the screen thank you this works I apologize the Audi try not to have that back to you these folks here so thank you uh for having me uh I was invited to talk tonight about student discipline as a component of professional development for you as the board I appreciate it I don't often have that opportunity so uh
002I I always like when the client's interested in the LW uh you can't hear me okay so tonight we're talking about student discipline um I'd like to give you kind of the 30,000 foot View because there's a lot of uh minutia and intricacies of this aspect of the law but I think that having the conversation tonight is going to be a bit jumping off upon if you could Advance the slides please one more time to the superintendent so before we get into what the law provides and what role the board plays in your Administration plays I think it's important to take a a moment to talk about the current state of student discipline in New York state and I start the conversation with reference in State schools passort so obviously s is the state education
003department in Albany they started in 2019 I believe gathered together a task force of stakeholders to look at what steps the state can take to make schools safer but also to consider reforming School discipline they issued a report in December of 2022 uh which came up with some uh recommendations some observations these uh columns here this language taken directly from the report and it talks about exclusionary discipline when we talk about student discipline more often than not we're thinking of exclusionary discipline that's not just a suspension from school it could be exclusion from a classroom as well what's important for school district purposes is this comes from s it talks about the harmful effects according to S of removing students from their education there have been studies that talk about the lingering effects of exclusion
004all the way to diminish graduation rates and if you look at the second column it talks about US Departments of Health and Human Services and the Department of Education they deemed that it's consistent with their missions to prevent limit and eventually eliminate exclusionary discipline practices so historically when I was in school and my parents were in school U suspensions were very common they weren't thought of twice corpal punishment was a thing when my parents were in school um you'll see here though that for the first time in the last 10 years now there's been a real focus on not just limiting but doing away with exclusionary disciplinary consequences that is a new consideration this is again a 2022 report but that is something that you as a board need to be aware of I do
005believe that the trend going forward in New York state will be further limitations on a school district's ability to impose these types of disciplinary consequences on students so that is something to be cognizant of advance and then we see around this same period of time a decision of the commissioner of Education in 2021 the facts aren't particularly relevant I I include this because the commissioner took this opportunity to speak to the same types of considerations that were set forth in that report that came out a year later if you look at the underlined language I added the underlining the commissioner didn't do that but the idea is that suspension should not be punitive these disciplinary consequences under the education law that your code of conduct speak to is not a punitive measure it's a corrective
006measure it should be a restorative measure but it should not be punitive you as a board if you look in the left hand column second paragraph As is a federal law that we're all subject to as a public school there is specific language that speaks to limiting and being cognizant of the overuse of disciplinary practices that remove students from the classroom you as a board that reviews your code of conduct every year generally in the summer months the expectation is that you're looking at the data considering the information that's coming across across the superintendent's desk and making sure that your code of conduct are taking those steps to limit the overuse of exclusion in the second column we talk about and Essa talks about the commissioner expects that you'll incorporate Progressive model of student discipline
007that they be age appropriate and you'll hear talk about restorative practices restorative practices are the direction that the state wants public schools to lean into heavily to take the place of these exclusionary practices some of our challenges in public schools is that when you have situations that result in disciplinary proceedings right now under the education law your your superintendent's options are limited and they don't allow for the unilateral implementation of things that you might feel would be in the best interest of the child you can't unilaterally impose the require for counseling or or drug counseling or whatever the case may be that the superintendent may feel is most important in this particular situation right now under the education law if we're at the point where we're at a super superintendent's hearing which we're going to
008talk about the options are exclude or not exclude so their law does need some tweaking in my opinion to allow for more opportunities for the imposition of these types of restorative practices right now we're relying upon on cooperation from families and and not every family is open to that idea but this is the decision of the commissioner I think it captures where she is and where the education department is uh quite well even in 2025 and I do see us moving further down that road uh in the future any questions about that so so there's different procedural safeguards for in school suspensions it does follow on that umbrella of an exclusionary consequence though so we're going to talk about the due process students have many rights which is appropriate uh which makes sense but there
009are many rights that students have before consequences suspensions can be imposed but under the umbrella of exclusion would be removal from a classroom to go to the principal's office removal from the classroom to go into a ISS or an in school suspension room and then what maybe most folks would think about which is removal of a student from the school grounds to go be home for however many days whatever the case may be all of that though falls under the same umbrella that s is concerned about if sets guidelines can we have to stay within those guelin it's a good question so what we have to guide I'll say us but really to you the board you have the commissioner's regulations that speaks to and establishes what needs to be in a code of conduct
010your code of conduct has been around for 25 years at least it's reviewed every year by the board it's supposed to reflect the values of your community within the confines of the regulations that establish those codes of conduct as it relates to what's an appropriate consequence for a given situation you will be somewhat limited the law only the only time the law ever speaks to a specific time frame is firearms in a school that's a minimum of one year that's the only time that you'll actually see a time frame established everything else will be governed by your code of conduct your Community but more importantly the commissioner of education has the ability to review these types of consequences that are imposed in the old days I get calls from school district superintendents building principles to
011say this is the conduct what would this what would the commissioner support as far as the consequence is concerned under the same fact patterns over the course of the last 15 years what I have been able to advise clients has significantly decreased I have found our office has found that the commissioner not surprisingly based on what we just saw in those last three slides has a limited appetite for long-term suspensions or removals or exclusions except in the most serious situations generally involving violence or or or serious threats or credible threats of violence meaning law enforcement is involved um or weapons are in school primarily so with that my my advice to clients has been changed over the years and these exclusionary practices have been uh meaningfully reduced and that's all subject to where the commissioner
012would come down if it were to reach her office uh and the consequence there is that she would dismiss those uh those decisions of the board or the superintendent being arbitrary any other questions before we move on to the due process component if we could superintendent under education law 3214 there are due process protections for every student in a school prior to being excluded in this case we'll talk about suspensions your code of conduct will speak to remov from classrooms the educational speaks remove from classrooms uh in school suspension is different these are out of school exclusions or suspensions before this can happen at the building level let me take a step back the only person person who can suspend a student or exclude a student from school is the in the first instance is
013the building leader your building principal an assistant principal can't do it a dean of students can't do it it has to be the building principal they rely on your code of conduct again that's where the board intersects with student discipline every year you're looking at that code of conduct a student engages in behavior that the principle believes is contrary or in violation of your code of conduct he or she can then determine what's appropriate consequence your code I believe has a bit of a menu depending on the specific facts it gives the principle some discretion because not every case is identical it's almost impossible to have those come up identical so it gives some discretion there but within parameters established by the board but if the principal determines that disciplinary consequences are appropriate that would
014include the exclusion from school they have to engage in these bulleted steps Each of which is to protect the student and their rights it makes sense if you think about it in most general terms it's it's notice of what happened it's an opportunity to be heard and then it's a right to appeal that's that's pretty much minimum due process so I know that your District as I've seen your letters before comply with this obligation under the education law it notifies a parent of the intention to remove a student from their education it will inform them of the reasons why in most instances it invites them for the opportunity to come in before the implementation of that exclusion so they can be heard so they can question Witnesses and better understand what's happened they might come
015in and tell us Ryan wasn't in school that day you have the wrong student that's great for us to know before we impose any sort of sanction and thank you for that that's the process working we might better explain to a parent that this is what happened here's why we're taking this position and they might better understand and be satisfied with that what's important is that they actually have the notice there are steps that have to be taken before a student could be suspended that the parent receive written notice of the concerns and written notice of that invitation to come in and speak to the building leader again I've seen your letters your letters comply with that you've been very good in making sure the parents get those before the suspension is implemented there's an
016exception to that rule if if your building leader believes that that student poses a threat they're able to suspend first the letter goes out second and then that meeting occurs in in prompt fashion so there are exceptions to that rule about notice and then suspension and it will turn on the nature of the behavior and do we believe there's a continuing threat or danger you want to jump to the next one again this is an informal conference opportunity as a parent you might want to hear exactly what happened you might want to be able to tell your child's side of the story or allow the child to tell their side of the story and that's what this informal conference uh conversation is this is as it relates to what I'll call shortterm suspensions although I
017recognize if you're a parent any period of suspensions feels like a long time but a short-term suspension under the law is five days or less and you have that obligation and the parent has that opportunity to have this convers ation this is not a lawyer meeting I don't ever attend those students don't have a right to bring their lawyer to that it it really is an informal conversation uh opportunity to understand what happened uh and the basis for that determination by the building leader and then there's the issue of a right to appeal so what you'll hear throughout this conversation when it comes to due process is that right to be heard that right to be understand what's allegations are and then appeal rights because there are several rights of appeal in voreville you'll see
018here this language says that you can either again speaking to short-term suspensions you can either go to the superintendent on appeal or you can go right to the commissioner of Education many districts incorporate into their code of conduct the appeal to the superintendent before it goes to the commissioner if there is a basis to overturn the decision of the building leader there's a value to having it done in District with the superintendent in boresville that is what you have chosen as a board if if my student is suspended tomorrow for three days and I'm not happy about that I would have the right to appeal to the superintendent of schools to be heard on that issue in other districts where that is not available to me I have to commence uh administrative litigation before the
019commissioner of education so you folks here though have chosen as a board to have the superintendent be the basis of appeal in the first instance for a short-term uh suspension and that language is in uh that language is set forth in in your your letters that you use any questions about the shortterm okay long-term suspensions if the behavior that's a concern is something that Administration believes warrants more than five days they can't just go through that same process that we just described because the way the law views this appropriately so this is a more serious impact on the student which requires additional process so if you want to advance for me superintendent anything more than five days would require what we refer to as a superintendent's hearing again under education law 3214 it's an administrative
020proceeding it takes place right here in the district once again it's it's predicated on on notice written notice to the family that talks about all the various rights at this stage certainly you have the right to be represented by council at any hearing the district Bears the burden for our clients it's not uncommon at all for us to be in some cases the hearing officer will talk about that or I will be uh the one putting on the proof I have to prove in that instance or your building leader has to prove in in any hearing by substantial evidence preponderance of EV evidence that what the district says happened happened so more likely than not or that there's some substantial proof of that so we have to tell the parents that we bear the burden
021they don't have to say anything the student doesn't have to say anything the district would have to put on evidence be a testimony or or video or written documentary evence any credible evidence but parents would also have that right the hearing officer could subpoena Witnesses parents would have the right to bring their own evidence and proof it's I don't want to speak in terms of of criminality but it's like a little trial it's an administrative proceeding but there's a hearing officer who presides the strict rules of evidence don't apply so things like hearsay and whatnot could come into it if it's relevant and credible but the purpose of this is it's twofold it's a two-stage process the first stage is did this happen as alleged in the correspondence and the second stage is if it
022did happen what's an appropriate consequence in accordance with with your code of conduct if you could advance for me please so these are our phases I don't necessarily like using the expressions of guilt and penalty it seems too too much like something under the penal law for my liking so I would do uh a fact finding phase and then a consequence phase but that is what the law speaks to is guilt and penalty there's procedural safeguards throughout this process is everything has to be recorded verbatim so there's an audio record of everything occurs in any hearing held uh before a hearing officer or the superintendent other procedural safeguards include no reference or Reliance on the students's prior discipline if any unless or until they're found to have engaged in the actions that's because we don't
023judge whether someone's guilty or not based on what they've done in the past so that's important to protect the students rights and then there's a written determination which is also important that that creates the record your charge letter a hearing officer appointment letter if that's the case and in that regard the he the superintendent has the ability to either preside themselves or to appoint a design so it's not uncommon for me to serve as the hearing officer to make the recommendation to the superintendent who will ultimately be the decider of of whether they agree or not with whatever the recommendation may be but that would be part of the record the audio recording any evidence that was submitted and then the determination so the parents would receive a determination letter uh that would spell out
024the findings and then if the parent is unhappy if the finding was such that the student is subject to additional consequences and they're not happy parents can appeal that determination to you the board so in addition to your review of the code of conduct which is a policy it's on your website I saw it an hour two hours ago you also are an appeal Authority so this really would be the first time you the board would be cognizant of involved with aware of a student disciplinary matter in any specific manner on an appeal it is my recommendation that you give the parents an opportunity to submit a written position to you as opposed to having a parent come in to speak to you the way I'm speaking to you right now I think having a
025clean record also giving parents the opportunity to collect their thoughts and and state their position is beneficial for everyone and then in any appeal process or hearing you as a board um outside of the public session because this a quasi judicial proceeding would listen to that audio the board has if it's a three-hour hearing down below you have to listen to a three-hour audio recording um but you would hear everything that occurred in that room you would review all the evidence and then you would act as an appeal authority to make a determination of whether that determination at the superintendent level is supported by substantial evidence down below if you could so that is your role there's two correspondences involved in that the first is to invite the parent to submit something in writing and
026then the second is your determination as a board um and then from there if the parent is unhappy with assuming for this example that you upheld the consequence and the parents unhappy within 30 days they can appeal to the commissioner of educ ucation and the commissioner would review that appeal to determine whether or not your board decision was rational or was it arbitrary they'll look to your code of conduct this is where we talk about the consequences and what I said earlier which is the commissioner is sensitive to duration and length so you as a board might feel that a particular length was appropriate and the commissioner may say that's not where New York state is any longer and that's the purpose of that level of appeal if the commissioner were satisfied with the board's
027conclusions and the parent was unhappy they could take what is called an article 78 petition against that decision and challenge the commissioner of education's review of that appeal so parents have many layers of review and many protections to make sure that school districts get it right just quickly as it relates to exclusion students of a compulsory age or classified students have a right to continued educ ation even if they're excluded from school there's we call it tutoring um but it's continued education it's been increased uh from where it once was it's now 15 hours a week you can advance by excuse me it's a requirement it's it's something that your district has historically done always um even when 15 hours wasn't required I know that you've been um open to providing additional time but any
028students who's excluded from school is entitled of three hours a day 15 hours per week of this instruction that's lately in in many districts it's virtual since co uh historically it used to be at the library or at the high school or wherever the case may be but that is an obligation and those requirements were just increased uh last summer maybe two summers ago at this point so now it's 15 hours I don't want to get too in the weeds with regard to class ified students but what the Board needs to understand is that there are in addition to all the procedural safeguards uh that we just discussed for all students students who are classified as students with a disability whether it be through the idea or 504 the Rehabilitation Act have additional procedural safeguards
029uh makes perfect sense when you look at what they are uh but in its most basic terms and and we can certainly get much more Nuance with this but maybe not tonight because you got places to be I'm sure what the law speaks to is if a student who is classified as a stu having a disability is removed from their educational placement what would be more than 10 times so that might be a long-term anticipated long-term suspension that would take them past 10 or it might be 10 individual removals or disar changes in placement but if you get to that number before that student could be removed from their educational placement again irrespective of what the allegations are against them there needs to be a manifestation determination review which is a specialized team who know
030the student who outside of the context of the disciplinary proceeding it's it occurs at the same time and I'll talk about the process but with that team there's a analysis to determine whether there is a Nexus between the students disability and the behavior giving rise to the disciplinary proceeding the thinking there is with a few exceptions we'll talk about we don't discipline kids because of their disability so if if there is a connection between their disability and the behavior that's an issue for the committee on special education that child would not benefit from being excluded from their instruction that's if there is a connection that's found if no connection is found then we would proceed as we would with any other student going through that process we talked about in the first part of the
031conversation uh which would be the uh at that point the consequence phase so just so you can put this in a in a place in a time with a classified student we talked about with a general education student you had two phases which is again the guilt or innocence and the consequence in in the situation uh here it would be guilt or innocence if there is finding the behavior occurred then we would go to the manifestation determination review and if there is no manifestation found we would discuss consequences if manifestation is found it becomes a csse matter and not a disciplinary matter with three exceptions we're getting there the three exceptions being even if a manifestation is found if the behavior involves a serious bodily injury drugs or a weapon then there's also the opportunity
032for a district to impose consequences uh where they otherwise would not be allowed to do so so that's a it's a it's a specialized uh process it's it's heightened due process and protections uh and in its context and as you see it play out it makes perfect sense again because we don't discipline children based on their disabilities can I see what the next slide is this goes a little bit into Weeds about manifestation it's it's available to you I'll leave the slideshow with you all if you want to read it I'm happy to answer any questions that the board might have afterwards but for tonight's purposes I think I'm just going to give a a general overview which this might be a little too uh in the weed so to speak this is our exceptions
033we just talked about those R3 and then we can we can stop there but these are just common mistakes and and not surprisingly they're all primarily procedural because we have to respect students procedural rights and protections that is a brief overview of student discipline going back to where we started which is the landscape is changing significantly um you you as a board will always have oversight of your code of conduct but I can tell you if I were to forecast the future I mentioned uh superintendent I mentioned that a decision just came out where the commissioner of Education said that under no circumstances could a preas student ever be suspended or excluded I would anticipate at in the future uh that will be expanded to include other Elementary age students I imagine in the future
034that the law will be modified to discuss that Progressive approach with restorative aspects and exclusionary uh consequences will be limited to very specific circumstances probably along the lines of weapons drugs alcohol or serious bodily injury so you as a board should anticipate having a limited ability in the future to exclude students from instruction and that that's can be challenging um but that will be the reality in New York state if I had to place a bet on that what other questions might you have for me while we're together pleas the end of I can certainly go through whatever you like Go creative forms of discipline and I know that restor of justice has had a lot of time in Spotlight but I don't know there's any research that's proven efficy Effectiveness and I'm curious to
035whether not theion has been doing person has research demonstrating and the best ways to so I can certainly tell you two things one is that the commissioner has devoted a significant amount of time in looking at exclusionary practices and forming an opinion on that which is a very dim view I can only surmise based on correspondence and guidance coming out of s that there is constant work being done on the restorative aspect of this I know that is it's being pushed tremendously by S um I don't know and I can't speak to tonight what type of data they've collected and what type of results they've come up with from that data but I do know that it's been a priority for at least half a decade with s it to the creative solution part I'll
036just say that there have been many hearings where I wish nothing more than the superintendent could impose you know meetings at spark for addiction recovery or something like that for a student and they're not able to do that that might benefit the student much more than being home on the Xbox during a period of suspension but those are the types of things that without parental consent and buy in we we as a district just can't do I hope uh I hope you feel educated on that topic I'm happy to come back you have access to that PowerPoint which goes into a much greater depth uh but I appreciate coming out and and having that opportunity okay so I want to give an update first on the capital project um as you may have seen we've
037made ton of progress on the building the scaffolding I giggled and I asked he was walking I please steal that so but that is up so you should shortly so we are still on track be exciting um given that part of it we are now moving to going on to bid for the elementary school so our bid is going to go out January 23rd start seeing that in the newspaper shortly and then February 13th is the awarding of the bid so that way by March Bo meeting you'll have the the votes to be award the bid contracts and then the goal is by June where you will start understanding the scope of project start so where we are the whole streamline this is getting done next is going to be the elementary school it's going
038to be a full court press the elementary school until December January of next year and then we should be seeing being that point where we start projects um we are currently looking at other projects now as you know we do $1,000 project yearly it's project we get funds back on that so it's aable um so we look at those yearly as well closed out the V deal in the high school I think sometimes people forget some of the things that are happening so that Middle School V deal was done last year the high school best was finished this year completely done believe closed out as of today so that's now closed out so we're now forward project just update on one last thing I want to talk about quickly it just came out and they
039posted it the New York State science exams are 5 and eight releas the scores um it's posted there over 580 School Districts we in the top 100 um know our staff PR diligently with our students outome that curricul change I think we just did a great job and I just want to kind a little bit that they did awesome our this is also attached all right so the purpose of this is to really just get us started on all the things that kind of go into a budget some of the things that kind of fact into the budget as we start we're still January pretty early there's still a lot of things going on um but one of the things that we want to talk about show them to and you know them already is
040that things that guide us the vision Vision our mission and I'm just read I think it's powerful the school district is D all students strong Foundation of knowledge and experiences in the safe supportive environment prar productive members of global society and to Value lifelong learning and then we have our goal SE one focuses on student achievement again know Staffing financial responsibility communication and safe and supportive learning I think it's important because what I want to talk about with these is these conversations aren't just statements these Vision things aren't on the Shelf these are what are used to guide every decision that's made in dist we look back and say can we go and say this fits to that goal can we say this to that go conversation regarding budget a lot of our decision makers
041great are planning for the future we try to F into those those quads those goals is this doing this our financial responsibility for example as we did this best use smarts because we realize we had that fund we use Capital project money we didn't want to go off and put another tax were we fiscally responsible are we utilizing grants to the best of our ability are we making sure that we're using at least a schedule schule end all these different things can maximize what we do so for example schedule end so we talking about door hard now let's upgrade our door hardare cost $40,000 can we get that through schedule end get reimbursement for it so when we're having these conversations about safety we're also looking at financial responsibility and being good fiscal stewards of
042our commun taxpayer dolls we are primarily taxpayer of all of you are and you know we want to make sure that we're doing our best with the fund that we them every year we don't have unlimited funds they they are what they are and they don't increase exponentially so we know that we have to really use these goals to out any questions so what you see tonight are numbers too early to provide you numbers and based on my experience sometimes when you present a number it gets fixated on and it comes up meeting after meeting so right now we're just going to talk in Broad terms as to where we are in the budget process what we're working on what are our expectations and by February we will have um your preliminary budget so although
043it says January 31st she releases her executive budget proposal numbers I know January 14th at 1 pm she will be presenting the State of the State and I will be listening to that uh attentively February 3rd our next board meeting will have a draft budget proposal presented to you February 24th um Board of Education candidate petitions are two March 1st submission of the tax levy and I've already started working on that we'll see that on another slide next please in advance we start looking curriculum or planning or Personnel um then come November December the building administrators Department chairs Department supervisors supervisors of Department itself like Transportation facilities Food Services Tey technology um they also start working on the budget proposals they reevaluate see if that your responsibility and maxing out what they currently have and
044then understanding what they could be looking for in the future to help their needs um they start meting Poli myself um we started in December started November December and we're still continuing to meet with building administrativ throughout the month of January to finalize their budgetary request and understanding where our outcomes are understand when I put a bud together exactly um these topic are interest from facility projects safety initiatives mental health supports break room supports Personnel you name it it kind of looks at all aspects of of the district for us to be able to create a s budget um when I create that budget and put into it this is not my own responsibility I'm not saying this is what we're doing it's coming from alls the district taking those views working and understand into
045a bud not based off but that's how basically that budget will work and that's the process that we current any questions on that okay so you can expect to see a vehicle proposition for the May 20th um we have reviewed the bus replacement plan and we need to up it a little um we need to look at how we are using our vehicles and I'm embracing that project so we'll be looking at two 72 passenger diesel buses and one large electric School Bus the diesel buses they're aided over five years so even if you pay cash you're ated over five years our district um excuse me bville bonds does a um statutory installment bond for five years so your Aid matches your bond payment electric buses are currently aided over eight years however you'll see
046in the further presentation that there uh is a recommended change on that eight years okay next please we don't always on all these things based off of our needs but I hopefully optimistic that we'll get something to that to help do that so we are be able B off to make more could you refresh our mind Rec anyone else who might be useful for what the requirement is for this for the school buses for the electric school buses in terms of I think that by by X year purchase by only I believe this7 change um we and again I don't have so I could be off by year 2027 we have to only purchase zero Mission school buses which right now electric bus in that and then by 2031 or 32 put in the 2030s
047I don't remember I'm top my head um you you're supposed to fully switch3 fully switched over have change so they're not giving a h window to that but we have to start thinking about that in long term there are incentives that are out there again depend District how many get and also infrastructure right like not all school districts have the infrastructure that we have we were um to be able to develop infrastructure that can future proof the district for this um and that's what we're doing again I want to clarify one thing and this is important our financial responsibility is when we put the bus garage in place we have conduits run throughout the whole area but we are not running the electric we are not running the systems we will run those as we
048purchase the buses technology changes things change over time so we put in the ground workor and all the ability to do it but we're not putting everything out at so it's a very scaff approach by forite the foresight is there that's great because and you're ahead of the curve because most districts are trying to catch up so that's great for a small District you're you're doing well next please okay just Brief Review of the tax cap I can't believe it's been since 2011 wow um 14 years amazing so as you know I'm not going to go through the the details as us nerds accounting nerds love but it has many many calculations okay what do we know now the allowable Levy growth factor I haven't heard what it's going to be that's the that's the
0492% okay last year it was 2% I'm not sure what the number will be it's based on the CPI for the previous year the second number that we do know is the tax based growth factor and if you know what this is I apologize but I'm going to educate you it looks at bville school district and the um property and it comes up with a determination a a a calculation as to what is the rate of growth in lorville and right now as of December 31st that rate of growth is 1.01 75 and that's a tremendous rate of growth you know you live in this community your community is growing um many rural districts do not see that rate of growth that will only benefit the calculation okay next um that's briefly so as soon
050I have started working on the tax cap I'm gathering the information as soon as I know more I'll have that that baby calculated okay Foundation Aid history and I'm going to bore you to tears but it's very important that you understand where we started and where we may end up so back in 2007 that I remember this they Consolidated a bunch of Aid categories and created this Foundation Aid um it was to provide a sound basic education it started at 1.6 billion and it's up to 24.9 billion in 2425 and it represents just a little over 70% of the general support state aid for school districts okay so you know 24 billion is a big chunk out of the state budget and the governor is a little hesitant to provide additional funds past that 24
051billion so they um they confirmed the Rockefeller Institute they asked for input they've done many many overviews and oversights of the formula because it's just not an easy formula like the tax cap is seven steps this is convoluted so in Fall of 2024 the Rockefeller Institute recommends changes in Foundation Aid whether these changes happen that will be up to Albany but right now this is the recommendation eliminate the guaranteed minimum payment of $500 per student reduce the use of save harmless and researchers found a c clear relationship between spending and student performance on New York State assessments and the Regent test okay one of important points of this if you remember last year after concerns right School District wereing about rural School million do in the whole $1.5 million we don't know what the landscape
052going to be of but we know that at least with the recommendations are we can have a basic understanding of what the landscap is going to look like what Happ I haven't heard anything yet but I'm sure I will on January 14th we all will that um yes okay remember I said something about zero emission buses the electric buses um The Institute recommends they fully underwrite the cost of the mandated transition to zero emission buses and that's something you don't hear a lot anymore about unfunded mandates that used to be a Hot Topic about 15 20 years ago but that's kind of Gone by the wayside um using rolling averages and multi-year phasin to improve predictability and reduce volatility amen some of the uh averages and years that they look back might be 10 years
053old as far as I haven't looked recently but they were not using current Census Data the Census Data they were utilizing in state aid formulas was from 2010 ah let's see reduce allocations to school districts with large Reserves uhoh required districts retaining more than 10% of their budget is a yearend balance to apply the excess as an offset to save harmless allocations I asked um the superintendent to please look at our fund balance policy and our Reserve policy and just make sure that we are following our policies and they are up toate I have a strong suspicion that this last bullet will come to fruition I've heard many discussions at my level the business officials level that um she's looking at fund balances so we need to be prepared uh let's see reductions of State
054harmless student performance measures replace the regions with a three-year average districtwide pass rate on new York State Ela and math exams in 3 to8 this one was surprising create separate Aid categories to address needs involving students with disabilities and small enrollments and enrollment growth well we already have Aid categories that uh address student with disabilities needs so maybe they're talking about expanding that um so that that would be interesting sorry uh last just to remind you that our budget calendar was presented on December 9th and approved and we've been talking about it here we are we are doing a budget planning presentation uh the 15th the administration and supervisors directors will have their finalized budgets and I'll be crunching numbers late into the night my husband bought me a banker's lamp so I'll be us
055utilizing that uh February 3rd that will be an important meeting you will have your draft budget and you will also have a long range financial plan that will be presented by the fiscal advisors and that will give you a really clear picture of what the district's fund balance looks like and projected expenditures three to five years it is eye openening it's not to be scary but it's eye openening and it's something that you should use as a tool when you develop your future your budgets again February 24th your board candidate positions are due I will submit the report card you're going to have a meeting unfortunately I won't be here on March 3rd my son is getting married um April 7th we will have a final presentation of the budget if need be we can
056go further next one please further into April April 23rd and and April 25th is the last day for the board to adopt the budget so April sounds like far away but it's not um one thing that I would like you all to do a little homework assignment is School Board Association put out their position statements for 2025 this is what was presented or this is what they're going to present as far as the executive budget policy recommendations very interesting so I just ask that you go through it and think about how it will impact for resil thank you that move to1 [Music] service app AUD committe have that have offered to the district before we say thank you in to my name is Michael Wilson I've been associated with gloryville for over 20 years um
057I've been living here for four my wife graduated from this school my wife sitting right there she graduated from the Middle School grade school high school all that good stuff I'm not the most educated man I ain't stupid either I I sat and I listened to a lot of what was said here today and know you were saying a lot of things I'm not going to lie to you I'm just have no clue that guy that was standing here he had a lot of words I work for CDTA I'm training coordinator I'm not I'm just Michael okay the biggest concern that I have here in case you haven't been paying attention I'm a man of color I know it's hard to see that but I am my son goes to this school my son um
058is an awesome young man okay my son um got the principal Excellence award this year made my day he's on the honor rooll he plays for for modified he plays for uh C I'm his coach on C we we've got our Roots here in Voris bille and I have no intentions on going anywhere I'm not going to get into names obviously because I can't do that but I was listening a lot to the well we have to protect the children I got that I have children okay but my issue is is when do at what point are we going to put the other children in danger because of one child I don't want anything to happen here in VV but let's keep it 100 okay let's keep it real we've already had in two excuse
059me in 2025 we had over 81 mass shootings how many school events have we had where kids have died let that marinate for a minute the situation that my son had to deal with being called out of his name other situations going on where the child that I'm talking about and it's well known it's not no secret I'm not going to say Nam standing here now but this is not the first time I've had to hear this child's name I understand we're supposed to protect the children and their right to have an education I got that but what am I supposed to do if there's no metal detectors in this school right now that I know of what happens if this young man comes in and stabs my son in the back or Goes Around
060by the time it's corrected my son's dead I pray to God that does not happen but at the end of the day if this child has emo I'm not a psychologist I don't play one on TV so I'm not going to sit here and try and get into anybody's Psyche on why this child is having the issues that he's having and I'm sorry that he's having these issues I'm sorry that he's having these issues but at the end of the day I'm gonna be real with you I could care less about that I want to know if my son is going to be safe when he comes into this Boysville School period that's the only thing I care about I want my son to get a good education I want my son to be safe
061and if one child out of however many's in that class is having an issue then I think you need to deal with that child that's my opinion it may not agree with everybody else in here I could care less I'm not here to be friends I'm here to make sure my son is safe there's not a lot of kids in here of color it is what it is I didn't make it that way it is what it is I still love this community and I'm not going anywhere and and I want my son to be safe when he's here but it's not just of color the the the particular young man that I'm talking about is talking about Jews writing stuff on bathroom walls go ahead okay but I understand what I know all have
062he from anyone who has something they want to say absolutely but we also want to make we don't speci specif so that people don't I understand okay I'll try my hardest but the problem that I have always since I've been on this planet I speak to my heart and it's very hard for me I don't sh this so to my son the world he's the most important and if he's not safe I'm speaking up okay so I understand without too specific I got that but at the end of the day specifics don't matter to me I want to know if my son's going to be stabbed back or something's going to happen to my child and that may not be a concern for you but dam is a concern for me I okay so I
063don't know what more to say because everybody not everybody a lot of times I hear this situation people want to sugarcoat things people want to oh sweeping under the rug I don't sweep nothing under the rug um Mr yes yeah can you wait for after meeting abely so I'll done until the next person no problem I'm sitting here waiting for you what's your name again good than hello uh my name is Stephanie rert and I am also here with similar concerns um I do have a few questions after listening to Ryan that I just want to pose uh to the board I don't know if maybe you know these answers I'm not expecting you to answer them now but I'd like them to be considered in the future which is one in terms of suspension
064both short-term and longterm uh do non-school days count for example do vacation days count so if a child is on suspension uh right before a holiday and then vacation happens are you counting those dates I'm seeing no okay um just wanted to clarify that and I'm also wondering if you have scho day it's the days in session of CH would be going to school so if I was suspended on Monday Tuesday break is wday Friday will be Monday Tuesday if it's Frid day will be the next Monday Tuesday Wednesday my next day that will be that Thursday uh that's um also it occurred to me that I do have some questions about what is considered proof of violence I'm not sure that's very clear maybe it is somewhere but maybe just some clarity for the
065community for what constitutes as proof of violence is it over hearing a comment is it um is it physical attacks you know what is the proof of violence um similar to what Michael was saying just if there's a verbal threat is that proof enough or are you wanting it on video uh via text like what kind of concrete evidence do you need to show proof of violence um and this is just a general question not speaking to any incident it's just a general question that occurred to me after listening to Ryan today um another question I have for you and I'm sure this may relate to some of the code of conduct that Ryan was talking about it sounds like you may have some room for changing the code of conduct to enhance the discipline
066policies at boresville if that's something you're considering or at least that's what I maybe took from what he was saying um is there a a certain number of suspensions that a child can have before they are removed from the district I don't know if that's an answer you have now but that did occur to me in hearing Ryan is if a child was suspended let's say four times in a year is that grounds for removal in the future or what is the cap on that or the scope of the suspension expulsions who can't remove a child from attending school especially iful age they have a right to fre public education I'm just this is the law you're saying let me just repeat back to third right you're saying that a child can only be suspended
067once in a calendar year no no they need to be suspended for a length of calendar year oh so let's say Frankl MC is suspended for two days and then there's a superintendent heing and Frank MC is suspended for 10 days the next time it comes it's more of a succession he gets 30 days the next day the superintendent says I'm going to suspend you for that would be the maximum that you could suspend job to one full calendar but um how many incidents can happen before child is removed there is no like expulsion there is no expulsion propuls you have to fin is that the New York state law or is that that's New York State okay um thank you that those are my suspension questions and I just have one other comment um
068and suggestion I don't know if this is possible but I think that there's lots of confusion about the incidents that are happening at school and how they're being dealt with I think that there's a lot of rumors going around about I and I'm not going to say them because I don't know what's true and what's not but it does question my ability to trust the school district and my son's safety at school just because it's not clear what the discipline is that's why I came here tonight because I knew that it was on the agenda I am here I love this District but I am challenged with trusting it um just based on what I'm hearing I don't know what to believe and I would really like a statement from the board from the school
069district of just this incident happened I understand you have to protect the child if my child had something going on I wouldn't want his name thrown out there I totally get that but I want to know this incident happened at school and this is how we dealt with it because otherwise that's how you get nastiness and rumors starting so I don't know if it's possible to do that um but I can tell you some of the things that I have heard are horrendous and I don't know what's true and what's not true so therefore I don't trust the district um and I'm sorry to say that but that's my truth so take that uh with what you will and I hope that there's some clarity in the future sorry go ahead my name is Stephanie
070that's thank you very much thank you Stephanie apprciate um if your student is in Middle School yes Middle School student Miss Miss will out okay thank you thank you very much you anything else this is the second opportunity for the board to be heard thank the people who came forward to be heard and also thank ran always for your presentations wishing everyone very happy New Year we do want to note that um our next meeting is which is all in favor thank you all have a great night