001please stand I call this board Mee order I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and Justice thank you for joining us this evening please be advised in event of a fire emergency and alarm will sound please know all emergency exits and evacuate well away from the building at this time we request everyone please turn your phones to silence and thank you for your cooperation we are going to start the meeting with addition additions deletions and changes to the agenda Mr Milani yes under additions 523 5910 general fund warrants School fund warrants Federal warrants CSC recommendations extra class treasury report and under 1112 under Personnel appointment of a long-term substitute special education teacher thank you we're
002moving on to um item number four administration of oath we will be administrating the oath um to Dr Chanel in anticipation of her starting her superintendency February 1st Sue could you please do that please stand raise your right hand repeat after me I Rebecca Chanel do solemnly swear I Rebecca Chanel do solemnly swear as of February feary 1 2025 I will support the Constitution of the United States of America as of February 1st 2025 I will support the Constitution of the United States of America and the constitution of the state of New York and the constitution of the state of New York and I will Faithfully discharge the duties of the office of superintendent of schools and I will Faithfully discharge the duties of the office of superintendent of schools according to the best of
003my ability according to the best of my ability congratulations thank you congratulations next moving on to the consent agenda 1 through 10 resolve that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent approve the following consent agenda items 1 through 10 can I have a motion please so moved can I have a second second any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed that motion is carried next we're going to move on to Communications um as we just saw Dr Chanel take her oath we have a transition period going on here at calonia and that means that this is Mr malani's last board meeting with us um and I could not let that moment go um go by without doing nothing um and I invited some of his family here I'm not sure
004any of his family's been here for a board meeting probably outside of maybe a championship ship or never I didn't even recognize him I don't um it's a Bittersweet night for us Bob's been at the helm as our superintendent for 14 years he's been with the district for 25 um and over those years he has led us uh with some fantastic leadership and has been very stoic in doing that um and thinking about a way which we as a board could sort of Honor that for Mr malisani I thought about statistics um and I did Bob's career stats or some of your career stats as superintendent um this tonight is going to be your 206th board meeting as superintendent I know it only feels probably like five ex um you started as superintendent on July
0051st 2011 um if you're wondering how many days that is Bob uh on the 31st of January you'll have been superintendent 64 days um I had that number going through my head all day 4,964 you have leted us through three capital projects or I'm sorry you have led us through two start to finish capital projects 2016 and 2019 and you have started the 2025 Capital project along with that since 2018 you have done a capital outlay project every year and that um is seven Capital Outlet projects you've developed 13 budgets with the district and the board um there's been 23 section five championships one as you as you were superintendent 533 students enrolled in prek during your superintendency and 846 students graduated you saw 13 graduating classes um these statistics are just a piece of
006your influence Mr monani uh you've led the district through many successes and challenging times your stoic and reliable leadership has been much appreciated I can't say enough good things about you and I'm going to keep this brief and pass it to the board so I don't get too sentimental um this is this is a I I appreciate is there any other words from the board can I can I um I'd like to repeat I you probably all don't know so I just want to tell you this I I chose my uh board members this story um a little while ago um I had my uh kids home for a number of years when I was homeschooling them Stephen and Christopher came back into school in Sixth and eth grade and that was 2001 and so
007they had just started back in school um in September of 2001 and then September 11th came and their older brother Mark was over in New York City at Cooper Union as a freshman um in college and when all this happened um I wanted to be able to tell Stephen and Christopher that their brother was okay and so I I guess I I mean I don't remember this part really that much but I guess I called over at the school I said Can Can somebody find find them someplace and tell them that Mark's okay and I found out later well from them that Mr malani had gone to the cafeteria to find stevenh and Christopher to tell them that their brother was okay and that just meant the world to me so thank you well now
008that you gave me chills um I had heard that once before and it it doesn't surprise me for a second uh I've had the pleasure of being with this man for all of his 25 years and it's it's been a pleasure I if if if you if you asked me what what I would think or what I would say or or he he's he's become a friend Bob is a friend of mine yes we're colleagues yes I was President for n or 10 years yes I I could call him yes I I did the business from Syracuse for 11 of 17 years and I I could always I could always count on Bob the whole District could count on Bob for anything he he wore a hundred different hats but to to to to to
009say he's going to be missed is uh it's it's an understatement cuz he's he's the only one he he's he his his shoes are going to be hard to fill but but but he you could just count on him you I i' I'd be working on I in construction for several years at several different places and and the name miles would come up oh he he's he's your superintendent right it's not just these are people like from area cod 315 it's like how do they know who Bob is and when I was trying to come up with like some official words this morning and uh cuz as as my wife said you can't just sit there and and talk CU um you you won't shut up um my my go-to I have there's there's Ronald
010Reagan jnf Kennedy and Jerry Garcia are my my three go-to guys and I I found something the Jerry wrote in 1983 B Bob he he he wrote this and he wrote this about you he wrote this about you I'm sure he did if you are able to enjoy something to devote your life to it or reasonable amount of time and energy it will work for you this suggests that dedication and passion toward something you love essentially hard work will lead to positive outcomes this this District this district for 25 years we we we got the positive out outcomes we we were the beneficiary of all of these positive outcomes and in in my my parting my parting notes I just I just want uh I want I want to ask go God to bless Bob
011and his family for every step and every direction your next life takes you west north south or east you you've got a tremendous family and you you guys you guys know you guys know what you got and uh we do too so I I I just I'll hug you later and just I'm sorry that uh thank you thank you um thanks John it could have set it better Bob I will put an end to this for your sake our uh technology teacher and class have made this nice plaque for you in honor of your 25 years of service um and I'd like to present it to you today um and thank you thank you so much well I'm not going to actually do a speech because I actually here do the board word so just
012real quick obviously you know John used the goto so the go-to people are right [Music] there the people that make me tick these kids when you're superintendent you make a lot of tough decisions and not everybody likes them I always got my standing by going sitting in a classroom and say why did I get into this business 33 years ago and it was for kids and uh obviously you don't always make you make the best decision you can people don't always look at it as as the right decision but when you look at it collectively and how it impacts everybody uh and how things grow tentacles and so forth uh you got be able to put your head on a pillow and sleep at night and I've worked very hard with so many talented staff
013members teachers our support staff members board of education has allowed me to grow professionally and for that I will be forever grateful the best decision I made was back in 1999 in November when they offered me the job to come here to be a middle school principal professionally it's been the best thing I could ever imagine uh best education I could provide for my children and uh didn't miss it but thank you it's been an absolute honor and privilege to serve this district and I know this you are in great hands with Dr Chanel and her leadership with the team of the the adults that you have here uh caring for our children and the support our community provides our school district I think uh we are I know we will continue to flourish and
014with that thank you again thank you thank you thank you Mr um we will move on to correspondence we'll start with Raider points of Pride some of us are hard to get this figured out the annual Elementary Winter band and chorus concert was a success despite a Sur a surprise snow day the concert showcased students musical talents and the dedication of their teachers families and community members filled the Middle High School auditorium in support the elementary school family crafting night kicked off Hometown holidays families came together in the elementary Auditorium for pottery painting wooden ornament and cookie decorating the evening was made even more special with background music provided by a few of our elementary banded course members adding a magical touch to the crafting activities those in attendance sipped hot chocolate and did some
015last minute holiday shopping at the book fair this event exemplified our school's commitment to fostering Community engagement and creating opportunities for families to connect at our school working together and making memories last month Senator helming was treated to a performance of the song Happy of the Elementary fourth and fifth grade chorus the Contemporary hit song was a part of the Winter concert program during the Senator's visit the elementary school also presented their new steam program fourth grade students demonstrated their bridge building project and explained how they use coding Concepts to complete it our middle school math team took second place at the genese valley bosis math competition we had the privilege of Hosting Senator Pam helming New York State state senator for the 54th District we showcased our art career and Tech steam physical education
016and music programs the senator concluded her visit with the class of 2025 as they engage in question and answer session I'm sorry see Mr M that's why you're here a 2025 hosted our 32nd annual seniors for seniors event the evening was highlighted by performances from our cheerleaders jazz band and rock band vocal numbers by senior Ryan Murdoch and freshman Abby hunt and of course some great jokes our amazing Raider Cafe staff cooked up a delicious dinner which was served by the class of 2025 Smiles laughs and a wonderful time was had by all the Middle School page Turners won their chapter 2 match and the High School chorus hosted the Potsdam pointer comp Sunni pot Dam's Premier albaso Acappella group with voice with voices ranging from tenor to bass bass base and a Calum 2023
017Alum Tommy Murdoch who is a sophomore music Major the the counts put on an impressive non-stop 45 minute performance in our Auditorium and finished by answering questions sharing their Journeys and talking music We Are thrilled to announce that three of our Raiders have been selected to perform in the Chester philarmonic orchestra's 2024 Gala holiday Pops concert congratulations to Hannah Harmon Laura rennolds and Ryan years we hosted the mentor finale for our sixth grade and Senior Mentor program we are excited to announce this year's calonia VFW Post 10844 Patriots pen essay winners First Place Logan Ashley second place Rosalyn strub third third place Caitlyn Wy and the Varsity Boys Basketball and cheerleading teams had their home debut as we hosted Danville on Camp good days and special times teddy bear toss night congratulations to senior Hazel
018Nickerson who secured her 1,000th Rebound in the varsity girls 63 to 37 victory over Wheatland chiling of note is that he also has a th000 plus points so that's not um common and also in your board package you have the honor roll for uh December 2024 six 62% of our kids earn the honor high honor roll in grades 9 through 12 also Nikki Flint uh tonight was actually yesterday morning but tonight it aired was a the Apple Golden Apple award so congratulations to Nikki Flint also this Friday uh Congressman Holly and congresswoman B will be joining Dr Chanel and I at Cal mom uh at 10 o' so we will be we're not having a full-fledged presentation as you did with Pam helming it's so close to region exams but we are going to have
019a tour of the district and share some of our legislative objectives as well this Saturday at Elba our legislative committee from the board and myself and Dr Chanel will be working with all of our legislator um at Elba for legislative practice so those are some things that are happening thank you there's no formal guests of the board tonight but we um as a District like to honor our seniors by asking them or we have seniors joining us from government class welcome and thank you for coming um we like to ask you if you haven't been do a meeting before if you're comfortable introducing yourself and maybe saying a little bit about what your plans are we understand that plans are not solidified right now and you may not have any and that's okay but if
020you're comfortable introducing yourself we would like that hi I'm Kate mowan and I plan to go to Al College next year for pread history studies I'm Maya Roger and I plan to go to Anderson University in South Carolina for biology General Studies I'm Mackenzie Richard I plan to go to college for child psychology I'm Miner and I plan to go to Cosmetology in cos Brianna ly and I plan to go to college for biomedical Sciences um I'm and I to go to college for biology good I'm Charles main College all right thank you uh next on our agenda is public forum we have one person signed up Mr Rich licki public forum is next this portion of the agenda is for district residents District staff and or parents guardians of students to speak to the
021board however the board members will not respond this is a time for the board to listen and one appropriate responsibil provided individuals who wish to speak must sign in state their name and address prior to speaking and limit their comments to three minutes all speakers are to conduct themselves in a civil manner obscene language liabil statements threats of violence statements advocating racial religious or other forms of prejudice be tolerated Mr rich liy I promise I won't swear hello my name is Arie Rich licky I like to do things by protocol so I would lik to join in with my buddies here but officially I couldn't so I had to do it this way um and then to continue the little uh vocals uh thanks Liz for letting me know about tonight and also congrats to
022the good doctor uh good luck in your endeavors you will as always be great first I would like to apologize to the board for not running for another term in the last 365 days I've had about 300 various trumpet gigs so it's a live music is alive again um I couldn't commit enough time to the board because of that but I truly miss you folks secondly I just wanted to say congratulations to Bob malisani as a wonderful of his wonderful career he led the school to become extremely successful I was there to approve him to become superintendent and was always so glad I did he is all for the students and I always appreciated that he was always there for for Student Activities and it brought the best out of them when he would show
023up the big football guy trying to squeeze into a little Auditorium seat just to see a concert or a musical it's pretty awesome I'll never forget his compassion for those poor kids that passed away at the North Road intersection years ago I'll never forget his compassion for me when I lost my parents I'll always appreciate his friendship and how our families of three kids of Peace paralleled here at calone mixing in professionalism and working with him on the school board along with our friendship was the perfect recipe you will only find in a wonderful small community such as ours good luck to you Bob and just think now you can run for school board and me thank you thank you AR thank you before going to Old business I promised Julie that I would give
024her a way out unless you all Mr miles's family stay and for the rest of the business but this would be a nice time to leave if thank you for coming I'll scoop too have a good night thanks AR yep safe travels we are going to move to Old business adoption of budget guidelines for the proposed 2025 2026 annual school budget Mr M would you like to speak on that yes so these are um guidelines that we put together uh files board policy 5110 in terms of budget planning and uh I think there were three or four that were new as I shared the previous meeting is that we simply bundled them a little bit differently what the board will do with the tra team will do and so forth to meet our mission so
025thank you resolved that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent approve the budget guidelines for the proposed 2025 2026 annual school budget per board policy 5110 budget Planning and Development may I have a motion please I move second second any discussion all in favor any opposed that is carried moving on to new business I am going to put um if the board is not opposed one one through three together so this is the approval of authorization to hire employees pending board approval as of February 1 2025 approval of authorization for business matters in between board meetings as of February 1 2025 and approval of authorization for all other business functions in between board meetings as a February 1 2025 and this is for Dr Chanel or design Mr son could you just
026say a word or two about that yes real real quick obviously the first one's pretty self-explained it's already higher employees there's times where staff members have to leave uh uh for whatever reasons maybe a Family Medical Leave Act whatever the case may be where we need a hire a long-term substitute whatever the case may be this provides that provision allows Dr Chanel as the board has allowed me for the last probably 10 years to do so nothing becomes official until that candidate comes to the board of education and then you officially approve them at the very next meeting uh the second one similar in terms of just authorizing Dr Chanel and and Mr nardone to really have the authority to conduct necessary business matters uh whatever they may be to execute their respective functions uh
027during that time period um it's pretty much the same thing with three in terms of moving transfers and monies and so forth so that they can operate um you know in between board meetings and again as this board looks and and develops a relationship with Dr Chanel right now we have one board meeting a month unless you're in the budget season if you go to two board meetings you know I still think these are still necessary a lot a lot of things happen within two weeks but uh that's the provisions there all right new business 1 through three uh approval uh to authorize Dr Chanel in these capacities can I have a motion please so moved a second second any discussion all in favor say I I I any opposed that is carried number four
028approval of merged boys soccer team resolved at the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the shared service committee approved the merged boys Bar City JB and modified soccer teams with the Leroy Central School District upon lcaa in Section 5 approval the board authorizes the superintendent to fix his signature to a three-year contract may I have a motion please yep second second a discussion so uh Leroy's Board of Education will be also be taking action tonight um should that be approved which our anticipation that it will be we'll have correspondence going out to the student athletes and their parents stting that uh all three teams will be merged and they shed in the backup notes to you if there are large numbers other than probably the varsity team but there's large number at the modifier
029JV team and probably will'll have a sweat team very similar to what we did with modified football and that merge but that'll upon your approval tonight and Leroy will have correspondence going out as early as tonight or tomorrow morning informing parents and student athletes Mr malisani are you aware of when the next shared services meeting is or is it are you and uh Mr Meritt trying to get that out so Mr H and I will will'll connect tomorrow for yes may H we will connect tomorrow tomorrow for a date for the Shar service board members and the administration to come together uh we did have an initial meeting I think it was back in November or December we talked about what worked well what didn't work well do we want to see differently in our
030sports program specifically that was for cross country of Varsity soccer and then the football program so we have now since added modified um wrestling to that mix so originally in terms of our contract it says that meet in the month of November or December but modified rest of just started so we agreed that we would push that off so I will get that scheduled for the Committees uh it'll probably take place by by the end of February at the very latest thank you uh all in favor say I I any oppos that motion is carried number five approval of inter Municipal agreement as listed be it resolved in the board of educ I'm sorry yes be it resolved in the Board of Education of the Calia mufford Central School District authorizes the attorneys designated by
031The ROC to negotiate improv DPA for software and or technology resources and to be further resolved the calonia mford Central School District Board of Education grants The Roc and is designated attorneys the authority to negotiate the terms and conditions of DPA and take such actions so as to effectuate the purposes and intent of this resolution certification it is hereby certified that the above mentioned was approved by the Calia mufford Central School District Board of Education at its meeting uh held on January 14th 2025 may I have a motion please yep a second second any any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed that motion is carried number six presentation of extra classroom annual audit report Mr nardone we're going to ask you to do that for us please work here wonderful all right
032so every year our Auditors mangle Metra bar uh conduct many different audits for us one of them being the extra classroom audit this is an audit of all the school district clubs so anything from senior class to baseball club anything that we have that's run by our Central treasure is included in this audit our Central treasure is Mrs Murdoch in the high school office doing a tremendous job uh keeping us aoat and uh making sure that the Auditors do not find too much to write us up about in the management letter I will preference it by saying this the Auditors have to find something I was an auditor for four years they think if you don't put anything in the report they're not justifying their job so they got to find something all the stuff
033they found was very little so just going through the report really quick um you know table of contents their unmodified opinion qualified opinion on the audit uh then we get to the list of all the different clubs that we have this will tell you what the beginning balance is as of July 1st 2023 the start of the fiscal year all the receipts that went in all the dispersements that went out and the ending balance is a June 30th which is the end of our fiscal year um at the end you'll see that number there the $97,000 that ties out to our bank statement minus any reconciling items and it does Auditors look at that first if that matches they know they can continue with their audit and then just going through um this uh subsequent
034event here is um based on when the yearbook pays their final bill so uh a lot of school districts run based on an acral accounting method extra class is more of a cash basis so because the final bill is actually paid at the start of the 2425 school year they want to make mention that hey this should have been accounted for in 23 24 we have it every year by the time you uh sh up your books and have everything set and ready to pay this bill it's at the start of the next fiscal year it's something we've always had and it's not considered a finding they just want to bring it to the board's attention going through the report a little bit more so we had two comments and this year's management letter we
035had a few instances where sales tax so unlike the school district extracurriculars have to pay sales tax on items that are not intended for resale if they're intended for for resale New York State wants to cut of the bigger pie so you don't pay it on the purchase but then when you uh collect money and actually sell the goods you're supposed to remit sales tax on those goods sold the good thing is with any sales tax comment you can actually fix this when you do your yearend sales tax um uh tax return that is done School District does one for uh school lunch and then extra class does one as well so we're able to fix this that's usually done around the March time frame second comment is based on Raffles so uh whenever the
036Auditors see raffle or games of chance they write it up they don't want anything in there about you know you know any kind of games of chance uh we think that this is not really a raffle it's just the words used by our advisers so it's really teaching our advisers to use you know not use those words or pretty much what they are are donations or they donation gift baskets that are that are then given away it's not actually something that the clubs are buying and then putting in there for games of chance uh so those are our two comments and then the other item in here is the inactive Club anytime that you don't see receipts or dispersements they'll point it out to the board hey it's an inactive Club you might want to
037look to close it there's reasons The two clubs that we had were in active either you can't fill an advisor or you can't get student involvement for the year um but those clubs are going to be evaluated throughout the current fiscal year to see if they should be closed moving forward so and then prior your recommendations Auditors like to tell you when you did something good so when uh there was an issue in last year's management letter that is now fixed they'll actually put in here as a prior recommendation so you can see what we've corrected from last year's audit with that do does anybody have any questions awesome and then did you want me to get into the uh corrective action plan right away okay go through so corrective action plan again as I
038mentioned with the sales tax that's something we're going to look to correct on the unine sales tax return and then also with the Raffles we're just going to notify our advisers please do not use those words donation sounds a lot better and uh it's something that we definitely don't want to do so we want to encourage our advisers you don't want to do games a chance you don't want to do anything with lotos or Raffles so make sure that you you stay away from that so that'll all be communicated I've actually already had the discussion with the Central treasur and uh we'll look to get those on the prior your recommendations next audit and then inactive clubs as you can see like I said throughout this fiscal year we're going to monitor them to see
039if they need to be closed or if they were just inactive one year due to as I mentioned tough to find an advisor it is sad that there's no science clo seems like we need a science clo and then after that is our single audit report so um single audits are only needed if you have more than 750,000 in federal Awards Federal money Federal grant money uh usually starting in 2021 is the first year K mum actually needed a single audit the reason is is because your normal federal grants do not exceed $750,000 but what happened in 2021 we got all that Federal stimulus money that's Federal money so we had to start conducting extra classroom or single audits I'm sorry uh I think I mentioned to the board probably two years ago that the
040single audit will go away once those uh federal grants are gone actually now that the state uh allows uh all schools to be C for school lunch and that means your school lunches are now free for all students you actually get a lot of federal money through that so chances are you're going to have that single audit going forward every year because you're going to get $2 to $400,000 alone just off of that school lunch that you wouldn't have gotten if we went back to paid so single audit's going to be around uh for uh probably years to come now and it's good as long as that's free for our students it's the best for our students and it's actually good for our school lunch fund as well um so again their their qualified unqualified
041opinion and all that is is in here and then we get to the schedule of federal Awards this is all the different grants that the school district has and the total amount is in that final column I can use right over here so again you can see with that art money 605,000 we used up the rest of Art in that year minus there was 51,000 that carried over but pretty much AR was used up and then uh it'll show you how much we use in the uh food service down here and then all these section grants and title grants that the district has as well so you can see we had a total of just over 1.4 million and Federal awards for the 23 24 school year at the end they'll mention uh where is
042it here right there number two and number three there are no current year findings and no prior year findings if there are findings in federal audits sometimes you have to give that Federal money back so you want to make sure you follow your budget it's not hard we make sure we do that every year and uh the Auditors check on that and a pening board approval at all three of these they will be uploaded to the state portal it has to be uploaded and submitted by January 15th so that's tomorrow so I'll upload it and uh get that submitted any questions on any of the audience thank you all right thank you thank you very much number seven board resolution to accept the extra classroom annual audit report resolved at the Board of Education upon
043the recommendation of the audit committee accept the extra classroom activity fund annual audit report for the fiscal year ending June 30th 2024 as prepared by mangle meker bar and Company LLP can have a motion please y John second please second any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed that motion is carried number eight extra classroom activity funds corrective action plan resolved that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent accept the extra classroom activity funds corrective action plan for the year ending June 30th 2024 may have a motion please please yes second second one um any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed that motion is carried number nine acceptance of the single audit report resolved that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the audit committee accept
044the single audit report for the fiscal year ending June 30th 202 before as prepared by mangle Metar bar and Company LLP motion please yep second second any discussion all in favor say I I any opposed that motion is carried number 10 com controller's audit approval of corrective action plan resolved at the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the a committee accept the corrective action plan of the New York State controller's audit report I have a motion please I move a second second any discussion just so you know the difference so obviously the count published our report that's why you don't necessarily have to go through it with respect to the corrective action plan the board seem seen the draft all of this will also be on our website for a community review as well
045as sent into the com controllers uh tomorrow morning that all in favor say I I any opposed that motion is carried next we're going to move to Executive session resolved at the Board of Education adjourned to Executive session at 6:40 p.m. to discuss the employment employee history of particular persons confidential Student Records protected by fura and Collective negotiations with the cmta may I have a motion please yep a second second any discussion all in favor I any opposed that motion is carried Dr chel uh we're going to have Dr Chanel join us again for executive session as she has been for the prior two meetings hope that the Board of Education return to a regular session at 7:44 p.m. can I have a motion please yep second second all in favor I that's carried we're
046going to move to Personnel 1 through 12 one second please resolved at the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent du appointment of coaches number one two resignation of teacher for purpose of retirement three appointment of director of physical education four approval of substitutes five appointment of middle school high school inter and principal six appointment of middle school high school interim principal appointment of archery club eight appointment of play Target Club advisor nine approver School the work students 10 resignation of teacher for purpose of retirement and 11 appointment of data Protection Officer in 12 appointment of long-term substitute special education teacher are you comfortable with that I am uh motion please so moved second second all in favor say I I I any opposed that is carried we're going to move to adjournment
047resolve with the Board of Education adjourn the meeting of January 14 2025 at 7:45 p.m may I have a motion please y y second second all in favor and oppose that is carried have a good night