CorpusRecord 137931

Board of Education Meeting February 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Hamburg Central School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,168 words · about 101 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] right okay can I have a motion to approve the agenda for the February 11th 2025 board of education budget Workshop as presented so move by laa seconded second by Mary all in favor opposed and passes we're into our budget Workshop um Tom just has got a couple quick words sure uh good evening everybody thanks for joining us uh you're here to uh be able to observe and uh watch the Board of Education work as we go through our budget Workshop we've got a presentation for you from Christine youngberg who is our business official wanted to share with you a couple of things that we've been doing a little bit differently this year with regard to uh the budget uh for one over the course of this school year um we've been issuing monthly Financial

002reports for the board to review um we began our budget presentations a little bit earlier we started those in January uh and today continues that uh we have uh increase the time for these budget workshops so that'll run from 6: and our regular meeting doesn't start till 700 normally that would have started at 6:30 so uh there will be plenty of time for questions uh as they come up during the presentation itself um there's a good amount of training with regard to uh onboarding for new members uh questions from within the board uh there's on uh onboarding training that involved financials uh to our new members of the board and uh there's been um certainly time for dialogue and uh with regard to talking with our building leaders and department heads uh about the budget

003itself so with that I know Christine's been working awfully hard at this so uh Christine thank you for the work that you've done in putting this uh this first presentation on the board together uh and you can take it away from here thank you okay thanks okay um so today we're going to go through um um the January I'm sorry February budget presentation first we'll talk about the executive budget proposal from the governor that was issued the third week of January will review the tax cap and um I'll explain the calculation for it um our draft revenues to date um there's a lot of work yet to be done on expenses but we'll go through what we do know and what we're still working on and then what you can EXP expect to see at

004the March budget presentation okay so um here is the January executive budget proposal as per the January state aid runs from the governor um the first aid category is foundation Aid and we'll be getting 21, 1882 420 that is a dollar increase over this current year of 41 15,34 that's a 2% increase which is the due minimum so that is the minimum that any school district in New York state um would get and because we're not high poverty sparsity rural sparsity District we're getting just the 2% Transportation age is the next category 3,484 209 it's up 334,000 current year um and basically in addition to the increase that we pay year to year to Fisher bus we get Aid on the fuel too and fuel costs have been Rose from the prior year building Aid

005um this is a big increase 5,199 385 is the proposal and this is actually you won't see this on the state aid runs until after January our fiscal advisor gives us this because we issue our final cost report on the first phase of the capital project and then that is due December 31st but the state doesn't put it in their runs until uh much later after they check everything so that um is a dollar increase of 1.6 68596 or 47.2 6% now that Revenue will help offset our debt service expenses our princip and interest payments that will be due on the capital project and the ban so um that service is going up um 1. so they're covering 1. 668 of that the next category is our BAS Bosey Aid 2,725 349 and that's up

00626284 or 10.67% both Aid is given the year after you incur the expense so it's the expenses we incur this year and then the aid is given the following year next category is public excess high cost 578 504 which is um an increase of 58829 or 11.32% so special education students who attend the district or a bosis program that exceed a certain dollar threshold we what they call stack them and then we get extra Aid because they have services and things you know cost more so the private excess cost a is the next category 75917 that's actually a decrease of 1,371 or 2.36% these are special ed students who attend a private school or a special school um same thing they exceed the certain threshold so we had fewer students in that category than the

007previous year our software Library um textbook Aid 270 928 it's down $222 or 74% and um those Aid categories are flat dollar amount given by the state based on enrollment so there's a slight decrease in enrollment so there's a slight decrease in that Aid and then the last category is Hardware technology Aid 52455 or a decrease of $948 just like the aid categories above it it's a flat dollar amount based on student enrollment um uh so that percent difference is a negative 1.78% so year-over-year um we're getting 2,783 $175 more from the state than this current year budget but again most of that is uh building Aid and transportation Aid if you take out building Aid it's a difference of 1, 49,7 79 or 3.75% are there any questions on the January Governor's proposal uh

008I have a couple um the foundation Aid yep is not necessarily A Hard number yet correct that's going to be that's part of the proposal and and so that can that's not really necessarily the number right right okay um in the building Aid just just so we understand you know why we're we're seeing that increase that's usually because we've had projects come to completion uh that have gone through the approval process through S and the aid for those projects have started to flow which usually if I recall it's about 18 month right process correct so there's there's are these part of the most recent part of it so we filed the final cost report report for phase one okay so that's the only piece of that 80 whatever million dollar project that's in there okay

009thanks any other questions yeah well I I sorry did somebody else have one um so the building Aid always confusing es me so we've filed for 20 so that payment is not strictly our capex in 2324 school year rather it's potentially from the 2223 school year and 2324 so building Aid is based on all of your principal and interest payments on projects that H that are still being paid for so when you Bond a project you get aided for 15 years over that the life of that project right so it's some right okay so we're still getting aided on the 2016 project so if we were done and didn't do another Capital project for three years we'd still be getting building aid for Pro for this current capital project we finished it would just be

010declining balance right correct is it linear no no no um what the fiscal advisor does is the puts our bonds out to bid but what he does is structure our debt to keep it as level as possible so some years you may have a bigger principal Prem than other and interest should always be obviously declining because you're paying on the principal that's left but he he works his magic to make sure that it's level because you don't want big spikes because it will um affect the tax cap like you could have a negative tax cap or you could have a 9% T and you don't want that you want to keep it as level as possible okay um thank you on the Bose's Aid um is that directly proportional to our spend in 23 24

011in other words was our Bose's spend this year roughly 10.6% higher than our spend the year previous you get Bose eight our Bose a is 61 % but not every category gets the full Aid Bosey salaries are kept at 30% for Aid or I'm sorry at $330,000 for Aid so if you have let's say a Bose's classroom and you have a teacher and a teacher Aid in that classroom that you're sending kids to you only get obviously they make more than $30,000 those two positions with their health insurance and TRS and ERS expenses their pension expenses um but we're capped that's the state law so it depends we've done a really good job of of bringing kids in District not you you know but if you have to have a you know the placement form

012it's the appropriate placement um some softwares they go up every year and sometimes they go up 2% sometimes they go about 5% it's a huge part of our budget our Bose's budget is over $7 million so sometimes things they don't do anymore sometimes they add new things it's yeah I'm I'm not at all trying to criticize our spend on bosies you'll see that in a resolution later um I was more just trying to get to the you know is the is the spend it's more or less proportionate to the amount we use bosis right if if for some reason we decided we didn't need bosis for a major service we yeah I mean I've never in any school district this one included that I've worked at you never spend less than you spent the year

013before that's for sure right and in turn our our Aid our Aid increases proportionately Loosely I understand that's probably not dollar for dollar but yeah okay I'm good sorry Mary if you want to go ahead how about now just needed a second um a couple of questions uh I also had a questions about Bose's Aid uh I just want to make sure I understand uh what this is saying it might actually be really similar to Cam's question so this might be a clarification question when you say Bose's Aid this is money that bosis is getting for us to spend or that we are getting from bosis no this is all state aid right so the state reimburses districts what you spend with bosis okay year the year before so it's really not so much that

014Hamburg Central School District is getting the Bose Aid it is Bose one is getting this Aid and then we can spend it through them I'm sorry so so can you say it one more time okay so we spend over $7 million a year with bosies great okay every month yep every month we we send bosies a check great and then we get re bur from the state based on the prior years spend ah and so that to your question if we spend more with bosies do they you get reimbursed more and to you were saying not really no I really you get more but every line item is different like technology for example got it if you're buying software or Hardware you're getting the full B Aid because people aren't involved got it you're paying

015for a person or capped at the 30,000 okay that that seems reasonable thank you for clarifying how that works that's kind of confusing um but that makes sense um so I know I kind of talked to to Tom about this earlier but I'm still going to ask you so that I can understand all of this is state aid on this chart yeah uh yes on this on this particular chart can you help me understand and I know it's a small per percentage how federal aid is calculated I know it's different right so this is the um what the public votes on is called the general fund or what we say the a fund okay the federal fund is called the F fund the F fund and we don't know what those um grants are going

016to be because our request so the aid will come out let's say July or well well after of the budget vote okay they'll say okay your title one is 1.5 million or something like that right and then we have until August 31st to file with the state how we're going to spend that money it's just like the spending plan for that Grant okay okay do we get federal funds directly or does it go like how does that get allocated does the district get it does it the treasure actually sends reports to the state because you only get um money back after you spent it okay oh so you get reimbursed you get reimbursed yeah okay so we put some let's say some AIS teachers in the title one Grant right so those salary expenses so

017then we'll send like monthly reports or quarterly reports if it's a small Grant like title two okay or title four it's not a lot of money Title One is definitely the biggest and then the idea grants which are special ed grants grants right um are also federal funds and it's a reimbursement program right so okay I appreciate you clarifying that so you can ask for um some money early like to help with payroll and we do do that right but once it's caught up I mean it's it's a reimbursement program you got to spend it and you get it all back okay that's a bummer if I may editorialize a bit that's a bummer um okay and based on conversations I had with Tom that's a a small I mean that's like a pittance compared

018to what we're talking about here right like $2 million federal funds compared to our 80 some million dollar budget okay and the voters don't vote on it like no the state tells us what it is we spend it they give it back okay thank you for clarifying sure um the last question I had was just regarding software um that line um spoiler alert uh just regarding with what's going on with Google um and our contract changes does that knowing that the state is negotiating our terms with Google does that how does that play into the software budget like this is only the aid this is software budget so the state only gives you X number of dollars per student that's it are we I guess we spend way more than that on technology I guess

019my thought this is more of a an application question than it is a how this is never mind I will withdraw the question you can defer that to are you trying to ask if we'll still have to pay Google even though we can't no I'm just I'm wondering if if we are no longer getting the same amount of bang for our buck as it were then like if teachers are having to go to other sources would they be costing more like it's now this is me thinking out loud like will they go to other things will we be finding another using money on different software to make up for the thing that we have lost that we used to get from Google you can see now I'm not talking about budget anymore now I'm talking

020about application and it's also kind of out of my wheelhouse so that's why I'm trying to stop myself and failing okay but that's a great question for Brent Not Me Right add that more 100% yeah okay next we're going to go through the 2526 tax cap calculation um so it's a seven step formula or one two three four I don't know lots of steps um so you start with the tax levy from the current year and then you multiply that by the tax based gross Factor this per this 1.004 is given to the district by the department of Tax and Finance and it's really like the growth in your in Hamburg so they have that data they give it to us and that's what I have to put in the actually it's already hardcoded I

021can't even change that uh number if I wanted to and then you add the pilots receivable for the current year those are payments and L taxes so they those are companies that pay taxes that are are not on the tax role right they get a separate bill and they they pay that bill minus the capital Levy for the prior year the bond and interest payments and all that um that this is why it's important to keep your debt service level because it's used in two parts of this calculation then you multiply that by the allowable growth factor or CPI so the tax cap law establishes a limit on the annual growth of property taxes led by school districts to 2% or the rate of inflation whichever is less so inflation is more than 2% last

022time I looked it was over three 3.1 it changes all the time they put out new stats every month um but obviously we've been stuck at 2% for a number of years because inflation has been higher than that so that is given to us by the Office of the State Controller I can't change that number either okay and then we subtract out um the pilots receivable for the upcoming year we get this from the Hamburg Ida they have the schedule of which companies are on Pilots or payments in Le of taxes and then the tax levy limit before adjustments and exclusions is 41 mil 758 560 now we get into the exclusions so it's not common to have the first three exclusions last year there was uh an exclusion for the employees retirement system because

023the increase was greater than 2% but it's not greater than 2% for 2526 can you can you take a take a pause on the TRS and ERS sure so so these are these are numbers that are set by the state and told to us and I think what you're saying is if that set number this year is more than 2% higher than it was last year we get to we get exempt from the difference we get to exclude the difference the difference over say it was antra say it was a 3% increase we could exclude the cost of that 1% increase in ERS or TRS for the following year that's correct because those TRS and ERS numbers are actually like 16 and what are they 16 and N is that coming um the Employee Retirement

024System is going up 1.3% let me see if I have oh it's on the last slide 16 yeah yeah and the teachers retirement system is actually going down 0.52% so those rates are also given to me ahead of time so we know and and those are like some nebulous calculation that's sort of loosely based on the market is it not it it is based on the market so so that's why the um the the Office of the State Controller I believe is the only person like whoever is thee of that is the only person who monitors this or says what the what he needs for the pension systems right so so those it's interesting that one's up and one's down if they're they're obviously managed very differently if they're both supposed to be based on

025the market and I I think it has to do too with how many people are in the system how many people are still paying what percentage like there's different tiers now it used to be everybody was in the same tier now they have tier four and five and six and the percentages are all different so it's much more complicated than it used to be that's for sure yeah sorry I'm good one's also going to depend on because they want to make it fully they their their goal is to have those funds fully funded so part the best pension system in the country okay all right so um so we have no exclusions except for the tax Capital Tax lovey for 2526 which is 2, 7211 so when you add that in our tax levy limit

026is 44 million 479 561 or 3.49% so this calculation I actually already submitted because we have all our numbers finalized is due to the office's State control or March 1st but I already submitted it so this is the the limit that you can raise taxes and more than 50% of the voters you know vote on it and it's approved if you exceed 3.49% you need a super majority and you need 60% of the voters to approve your budget in order to exceed the tax ly limit any questions just can you um just go into a little bit more detail on the capital on on the capital tax levy portion of the addback why why we add that back and and and where that number comes from we add it back because that's the calculation but

027where the number comes from is so I have a Debt Service schedule and I um make sure that Rick gansy our Capital advisor has the same numbers as I do we make sure that we agree so it's the principal and interest payments that you are paying in that current year that's the the bottom the the top is um or I'm sorry the budget year the top is the current year that we're in but also added to that is Bose's Capital so Bose's um school districts the component districts vote on the Bose budget not the public okay so if Bose does a capital project the component districts in arie1 bosis all get a piece of that but you get to exclude that in your Capital Levy C calculation as well we pay for it but we

028we um it's in our bosies bill in that 7 million $7.5 million right the expenses but we get eight on it on the bosis um as well in the same year which is nice so that's a little different so it's our debt our principal and interest plus Bose's that we're paying them in our Bose's expenditure bill so that's what's on that schedule there are some minor things in there so um next year we will have a building condition survey so you get eight on that um the following year uh the lead testing um for the water testing you get Capital Aid on that as well and that's every three years now that's that's not an exclusion that's just just get you get yeah you you'll get it you'll get the increase in the um in

029the capital from the on it'll be on the um Governor's runs April 1 if it's in the year that you're doing it that's basically our yeah you get the building something that the voters it's been voted on separately voters approve and and it's law like you have to test your water every three years and do your building yeah oh yeah yeah yeah right correct make sure that doesn't die oh I already advanced okay so now we'll go through the draft revenues um estimated as of uh the end of last week so based on the previous slide if you take the the tax levy plus the pilots so the 44 million sorry need to put my glass 44 milon 479 561 plus the $85,000 in Pilots you get 44 mil 564 561 so that is an

030increase of 1,486 209 over this current year the next um Revenue category is Ary County sales tax um on budgeting $5.25 million a decrease of $50,000 the last two years we haven't seen um those revenues at 5.3 so I want to be conservative so all all schools in Erie County receive quarterly payments from um Arie County based on the sales tax collections so the collections have not been as great as they you know projected two years ago and we haven't seen us meet that budget line two years so I'm decreasing it a little bit the next line is a catch all miscellaneous and it's a lot a bunch of um Revenue categories continuing education tuition Bose rent they rent some classrooms in our buildings um Bose's refund so bosis can't have a s Surplus so

031their budget if they made some money at the end of the year like we can have fund balance they can't they have to give back to the districts proportionately um so our refund and Bose's already gave me that number so um Medicaid that's money that we get for our special education students um and then interest income so it's up a little bit $ 9,715 our state aid that ties to the state aid the first slide 34 million 252 267 it's an increase of 2,718 375 and then here's what we'll talk about in March use of reserves and use of fund balance in order to balance the budget buet it's a little too soon right now because expenses we still have a lot of work to do last year we offered up 6 42501 from reserves

032and then 1, 177187 of fund balance a fund transfer so I'm budgeting $145,000 this year it's an increase of $45,000 what this is is um Revenue to the general fund from the C fund so the C fund um we don't put like cleaners and people who do their payroll pay the bills accounts payable business office staff in the ca fund we're all in the the general fund so we can charge back based on an indirect cost rate that the state gives us it's about 10 point some perc of all those people's salaries to charge back to the SE fund because we're cleaning their cafeteras taking out their garbage paying their bills paying the people so you're allowed to do that so um that's $145,000 so the total draft budget for 2526 in this first iteration

03386 m3903 um which is an increase of 2, 38961 over this current year any questions on this slide so the no no I'm I was going to get into the reserve okay all right so here's just a a comparison chart um of our estimated draft revenues for the upcoming year compared to this current year um based on the percentage of the total revenue budget so it's pretty similar right so if you look at like state aid for 40% versus 38% um but really the building Aid is what drove that up to 40% for this current for this coming year taxes and Pilots um are 52% of the estimated budget where this current year it was 53% of the estimated budget everything is pretty pretty much the same sales tax 6% miscellaneous Revenue 2% versus 3%

034and that's 3% this current year only because the budget was smaller right the budget is going to be larger next year and then inter fund transfer it's not even a percent it's negligible any questions on the chart okay so the expenditure budget so there's we're working through it there's some things we do know we know that um the non-instructional pension expense ERS is increasing from 5.2% to 16.5% that was given to us from the state the instructional pension expense or TRS is decreasing from 10.11 to 99.59% so that's good news um workers comp is decreasing by 68,276 right but each individual District pays their comp Bill based on a three-year look back your total salaries um and your claims history right so we had a bad bad year fall off so that's why our um

035comp is going down by 68,000 so that's good news utilities will increase um I'm not quite done with utilities we this may change a little bit but right now 66,6 195 due to approve rate increases for both electric and gas if you got your home gas and electric bill this month uh you probably saw the increase I know mine went up over $50 for gas and I heat by wood and electric same um went up significantly those they they've been asking for these rate increases for the past few years and we knew this was coming us business officials because we talk about this at our Bose's meeting there's nothing we can do about it um hopefully gas prices will go down and that up so maybe we won't see this big increase I don't see

036electric going down aren't we aren't we part of a Consortium that fixes prices so what you can do is you hedge right yeah so what that means is like they'll they'll recommend a percentage um that we Hedge and we rely on it's fluent energy is the uh consultant for the Consortium and so they look at every not every district is in the Consortium but the districts who are they look at all of their utility bills and they do the budget forecasting based on the rate increases and your spend and I mean maybe we'll we won't see that increase in electricity because of all the LED lighting for example maybe we'll we'll it won't be that high but they forecast based on what they're looking at at the current moment the consti the Consortium only protects

037us against Market fluctuations wild Market fluctuations in the moment yeah it doesn't protect us from annual I think they said two years in the history of it's called smack School Municipal energy Consortium that they kind blew it on the Hedge oh it just something just wild happened that they did not predict but they're pretty good they're pretty conservative um if you look at our um budget status report UT at the utility line now you'll see we're doing really well although our January bills were pretty high I mean just like your house bills were um and then I said this before dead service will increase 1 million 867 856 over this current year due to the projected payments on the borrowings for the capital project and that's offset Again by the building Aid um that we'll

038see so that's what we're working on now that that service for the the 20 on the 21 Capital project that's really just interest at this point correct we're not paying principal on that yet yeah we um yeah no right yeah because those are still that's still in that's still in bands yeah it's still in bands so we won't Bond until we're done right with the project yep okay so the next steps um we will assess Staffing levels according to enrollment and then enrollment and then update salaries when you update salaries obviously then you're going to update the pension expenses because they're a percentage of salaries baa because it's a percentage of salaries um so those will be updated we'll finalize our Bose's expenditures we just had our Bose participation meeting on Friday and went through

039all the things that we need our special ed placements the software we need to buy um you know student management system our financial uh system there's there's a lot in in it um so I have to enter those numbers in a program so that's what I'll be busy doing next week and that's that was only our Eerie one bosies we cross contract with other bosies um so one example is we're in a pharmacy Consortium with the Albany bosies and that's how we've been getting our really good rebates in that Consortium we cross contract this current year with ca bosis for a special ed placement at Pioneer we are not going to do that next year we're bringing that child back into District so that's a good thing um we cross contract for Questar bosies for

040for financial things it's not a lot of money it's like $3,800 um I can't think of any others off the top of my head but obviously Erie one is a big one and then Erie 2 we do have some special ed students at Erie in Erie 2 like we have a Holland Elementary um so we'll be working on those numbers too we will finalize our health insurance expense my first meeting actually is next week we on with our new health um Insurance Consultant to do our budget um we will finalize property and liability insurance expenses I'm hearing that's going to be about a 9% increase I just sent our um you know they they ask the same questions every year how many pools do you have how many diving board how many students how many

041vehicles you know every year and you have to fill all that out and then they'll calculate our premium based off of that plus insurance is going up everywhere car homeowners everything so that's what they're telling me 9% um transportation expenditures we haven't even started that yet um transportation expense their increase historically has always been what CPI is at um May May 1st I think we get so we kind of have to guess but you you know you look at the April number and hope it doesn't change too much so th that's like one of the last things to to be done transportation and then update the state aid revenues when the final runs are re are um released April 1st so maybe that 2% will be more not sure um we'll see we're hoping and

042praying and then balance the budget and what what that means is if expenses are more than reeven Vues then we'll talk about we'll have to talk about use of Reserve funds use of fund balance because you have to have a a balanced budget any questions go ahead my question is just I know you said um I know you said that we're going next step is assessing the Staffing levels for based on enrollments um I just want to make sure that we are looking at and assessing that in a proper timeline last year we unfortunately at the May meeting I know that's when we made that very like heartbreaking announcement that we were laying off some of our teachers um yes did I did I missp speake oh my gosh thank you yeah the March meeting

043so if we're not looking at numbers until March I assume we can we're not anticipating having to make any announcements at the March meeting or how will we like I guess what I'm saying is how can we how can we know what we're announcing if we don't look at the numbers until then so I'm continuously working on the budget and salaries I don't think that that's going to happen based on this was much more complicated than last year because um obviously our instructional staff is the biggest part of our budget and when we negotiated the contract with the teachers the first two years were kind of like a you know pretty I mean they got increases but it just salaries and not on this is the first year 25 26 where increases in longevity and

044stiens for you know uh all kinds of things you know department leaders and Athletics and so it's taking a lot longer but the basic salary you know I could look at we only had um three retirements and we have to replace them all they're not you know um so I don't see I don't anticipate any layoffs agreed agreed I just want to just make sure that that that that's clear yeah we'll be taking a look at enrollment and Staffing we'll be giving the report about it but no this will not be there's been steps that have been taken uh that will uh we will not be in the same situation that we were in understood nope understood no completely understand actually yeah this is uh uh even though we're not reporting on that now it's

045going to be it's going to be a no surprise exercise for us for for March anything else any other questions okay so the March budget presentation like we said earlier um we'll have detailed enrollment data um staffing needs we'll have a draft of expenditures and then we'll have a discussion we'll probably have a recommendation and then you guys have a discussion on the use of fund balance and reserves to balance the budget you know things may tweak even after that like with Bose because a lot of times vendors aren't giving them like their software renewal prices until April 1st or something like that so there's always a little bit of tweaking but the budget should be pretty pretty much solid by by then okay thank you just so we have just so we know the

046the the the you know the full timeline so in and you know that's what we're going to do in March April we basically finalize and it and vote we vote on the budget to approve it onto theate the April state aid runs right for April I think there aren't there two meetings in April yeah yeah we have have to approve the bosies budget too right cuz we have to we have to approve the budget I believe it's 30 days before the vote correct yeah I have it on that is me we got a great was it the PDF we just got okay uh just just want to go over make sure everybody understood kind of what the process and then obviously in may we the third third Tuesday in May whatever that is um the

047vote okay thanks okay all right being in encourage to ask a question that I don't quite have uh yeah no we're all trying to I'm sitting here thinking about what I want to ask and and the reality is like you said the next time we talk we're going to talk about expens expenditures and so I I'm sitting here with some tables because you were so kind to send the the table um and I did a little finagling because that's what I like to do and I I I can't ask any more questions because I don't know how we're going to spend it and that is ultimately the import essential other half of this equation absolutely um so I I want to ask more questions but any question I ask is going to be you're going

048to answer with I don't know uh so and and that's valid and I can't feel any other way about it I I mean I have my anxieties about what's happening at the federal level you don't know uh nobody knows um and I have anxieties about Staffing you don't know uh so it's it's I mean I can get into like the minutia of like why are we spending Less on this or why are we getting Less on this or or more on that and all of it's a guess anyway I mean educated guess you because it's a proposal and it's all subject a budget right yeah it's a budget proposal based on information that you would like to happen and that you would suspect might happen and it could all go to hell anyway um the

049one can I make a it's not a question it's a am I thinking along this the right way and you can tell me if I'm off or not um I was doing the calculations between the proposed uh difference between next year and this year which I did calculate to get the same calculation of a 2 million 389,000 difference and that is about one a little more than a million less than the difference of the previous two years I know that doesn't make any sense that's a hard numbered concept to follow my point is is that um we are going to be spending we're gonna be asking we're gonna be getting more that much more than last year this year in Revenue that much more which is a little bit less than the previous year we

050had to lay off a bunch of teachers to to make budget we aren't going to be able to make it up it looks like does that sound right to you what do you mean make it up um it would be so cool if we could make up enough money in Aid that we could hire back a bunch of teachers it doesn't look like that's GNA happen yeah I don't see because of the 2% minimum well not just because of enrollment but just because we're not going to make it back like it's it's not like G to magically happen yeah the idea that we would get enough Aid back to hire back all the folks that would and that would be you know and that would be sort of like the there would have been some

051some poor planning to let everybody go and then be like oh you know that was that was a a serious step and we people who are who we but we like that there haveen to not put us in that but be able to sit here and say like no we want to hire everybody that's not where we're at that's not what's happening that's not where we're at and like we are going to be because I'm breaking this all down and like we're getting more money in tax like we would be getting more money in taxes like if I'm looking at this right for sure not enough to make up for it not at all and and and I'm not setting my feelings aside the math ain't math and is what I'm saying and so I'm

052just trying to set realistic expectations for what we will probably be walking into as a team yeah we're not looking at march to be this great surprise of things we're going to be letting people know about enrollment is and we're going to be letting people know where we're at and what we're borrowing out of out of reserves like we want to be able to clarify that yeah but when I say there's no surprise in terms of the March we're not heading towards another situation but that's because of a lot of the decisions that were already like the painful decisions and the painful experiences that you know the community went through and and and honestly like the the the the hard stuff with that was to be able to come here and be able not have

053to do that sort of thing right again right no I guess that's what I'm clarifying is that you we're not anticipating anything terrible we are also not anticipating something like we saved the day like it it it is merely reality right and it's all based you know on the money that they give us from albony right you know we at the legislative end of it you know we're always asking for more B's Aid that to save harmless 1.004 the least amount they could possibly give us that's what they gave us so you know legislatively we're always asking more Bose a you know and and and you know to change this formula you know to give us more money so you know we want to build our reserves and we want to you know get more

054money from Aly but it seems impossible so that our problem is down in ay you know it's it's it's really not here my opinion so yeah it wasn't a question it was more of a processing and I wanted to see if anybody else was processing it similarly I guess I I would just if I could I would just like to add a request for the next meeting um given that we're going to be looking at staffing needs and in light of what what everyone's been talking about that we did see some staffing changes primarily at the secondary level um if when we look at the Staffing we could do and and believe me I don't need to see the class sizes of of the hundreds and hundreds of of sections that we probably have at

055the middle and high school but if we could have some sort of aggregate readout perhaps that with a with a narrative I fully understand right that that would help us understand maybe what changes we've observed at the secondary level and how that has impacted if if any way positive or negative um the the students there um in in the in the vein of staffing needs right right no understood and that'll be that'll be part of what we present in March can I tag on one last thing if we're presenting some of the things we're hoping to get at the March meeting too um hopefully I think I'm directing this you Brent are you who does this for us oh you all work on it all right well then directed to everybody um will we be

056able to get a breakdown on those guidelines of what we like our class sizes to generally look like for our grade bands like in that K to2 or K to3 and then the yeah I'm just making sure we'll get those because I I was having a hard time tracking them down um just looking at you know the numbers what what each grade level is looking at like echoing what Cam said like what is our k 1 2 3 four five in our Elementary School classrooms yeah and what it looks like in each of our elementary buildings so what's armor looking like what's Charlotte looking like what's Union Pleasant um I just left somebody out Boston Valley looking like as well um is there are there any Trends in enrollment in these buildings are there any

057bubble classes that we're looking at like across the district um looking at our Middle School and High School classes like where are our biggest class sizes at like are there you know rumors fly uh with how large or small these classes can be like are there actually any classes that are 30 plus students does that exist I just am curious I'm not in those buildings I don't know um what what subject areas are seeing those larger class sizes so like you know math Ela you know social studies be whatever it is there um and I know last year I had asked if our TLC like were we collecting data from there on what subjects our students visit for and are we using that to like decide Drive our decision- making for our staffing needs there

058so those were just some things I was hoping to get answers to at the next meeting thank you uh any other questions on the budget at the moment uh seeing none looking for a motion to adjourn the hearing for February some by Rich second by Laura all in favor opposed passes we are adjourned for that we will rejourn for the regular meeting shortly thank everybody for coming uh we know we're a little bit delayed thanks for adjusting the change from 6:30 to 7 but U appreciate your patience and uh really looking forward to hearing from our than you hey let's uh um call the meeting to order uh we're going to start with the pledge again I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it

059stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all I have a motion to approve the agenda for the February 11th 2025 Board of Education meeting as presented so may Dave second by cam all in favor opposed passes uh moving right into our Union Pleasent uh building uh building report hello everyone and welcome to Union pleasant we are super excited to get our chance to present tonight and share the incredible things that are going on at Union Pleasant so we wanted to start with connecting to understand and understanding to connect and we want you to know that this is not something that we developed because it's just sweet and it sounds good this is a Creed that we live by every single day because we know that when our families and our students and

060our staff come together to do the work around what's best for kids that's where the sweet spot is in the work that we do so I could spend an hour plus easily talking about the really great things that are happening at Union pleasant but I'm going to stop talking because we're trying to keep it as close to 10 minutes as possible so here we go I'm Shannon kav I'm the assistant principal here at Union Pleasant and tonight we're going to be talking about an upcoming sensory room our interactive math hallway um connecting through our music classes and the creation of our Musical and the creation of our musical is done by our students stay tuned thank you you're welc sorry there we go hi I'm Marie Hennessy I'm a speech pathologist at Union Pleasant and

061we are thrilled tonight to be sharing with you uh a project that is a labor of love for us um for for some time um we are going to be building on the foundation of a sensory room that we have right now we're going to be building on that and this this is a collaboration between our staff our building Administration um District administration and PTSA has donated $113,000 um to our school so that we can build on our sensory room um this started about 18 years ago I tried to figure out when when this began um we needed to create a space for some of our students that were having trouble managing a typical classroom environment um as it was so we started with just providing a quiet space for them that was safe and

062separate we added some soft flooring tunnels and some other things some toys it was sort of like an indoor recess room and then we um got some PTSA grants and were able to add a sand T some weighted blankets and then eventually a swing and a crash pad and now um as I said that we are going to be um really building on this with this PTSA grant that we've been given so I'm going to pass it to Bri to tell you a little more okay my name is Brianna baringer I am one of the special class teachers here at Union Pleasant um and this is just a slide showing all of the different ways our new sensory room is going to reach all of our Learners at Union Pleasant not just necessarily those who

063may have some sensory processing needs it's really going to reach any child in any grade um and our goal is to really help the students further their emotional regulation skills their self-management skills and really further their um support with any anxiety they may be going through whether it's just a test that day or maybe it's something that happens more frequently um and through that you know we'll see the mental health of the students improve and increase and also the academic performance and successes as well I get to Share the Fun slide um I'm a made it I'm a third grade teacher here at Union Pleasant um as you can see what we like to do in our classrooms here is not do a one-sized fits-all approach so that's the goal of our sensory room too

064we're hoping um you could see the ocean type visuals over there to provide a calming um really just low stimulation sensory space for students we have the pressure for students that need more sensory input that's a physical or tactile need um and then you could just tell I mean just look at the picture of that boy in the in the chair just that time to decompress um like Marie said this has been a real labor of love and a vision come to life and we're really excited to invite you all back to come see it once it's actually completed once it's in its space and we appreciate the time and I think I stuck to my time I'm going to pass it to April to talk about our math hallway thank you right now it's

065located let me take this I don't really need the mic but I can use it um it's in a smaller space um we kind of work with what we got here so right now it's just in a space off of the gymnasium away from different hallways and stuff like that our goal is to create like a permanent classroom space we're hoping now that we have this new technology and equipment that will actually be able to solidify it solid space where it's accessible to all students because like Brie said it's not just going to be for students with special needs we're hoping it can reach all genad students all grade levels and just be accessible for all students so right now it's near a gymnasium in the um Pleasant Avenue side of the school so feel

066free to check it out now if you want to see the before because I think the after is going to be a lot better and I'm really excited and this is April thank you and I'm here to talk about the math hallway um and this is something that will be um painted right above us here on the second floor on this Union side um and over the past couple of years part of our building plan is to focus on improving students speed and accuracy with basic math facts this skill is crucial for building a strong foundation in mathematics as it helps students tackle more complex equations and computations as they progress and here's a sketch again um thanks to the funding of our PTSA Union Pleasant will soon have this mouth hallway this space will

067have equations and various types of number groupings along the wall and then the floor will give students a chance to use a hopscotch a number line and fractions to P practice those math skills and this base was planned with the help of our AAS Math teachers um with all their expert because they of course know the program better than an art teacher would and so that all of our ker 5 students will benefit from this hallway and of course we'd love to have you all come and see that once it's all painted upstairs too and now on to our Orchestra hi my name is Deborah vaski I teach band and uh band is a group comprised of students from many different classes that come together to make music but also to strengthen ties with the

068community and their classmates at a time when digital media use is high playing a musical instrument offers a constructive and creative Outlet band is fun it's also very challenging did you know that there's a part of the brain that gets stimulated when we do challenging things and it helps us to take on even more challenges and the great thing about this is when you play a musical instrument it stimulates that part of the brain and it grows and it enables us to face challenges in music but also outside of music so there are musical rewards and there are rewards that take place in the classroom such as hard spelling words math problems our band kids can approach these difficulties thanks to the challenges they face in music and Mrs Dinger was talking about connections as

069you know our students perform concerts in in the winter time and the spring it's a great way to Showcase uh their talent and hard work but it is also a way to to connect with the community our students at Union Pleasant love to put on performances uh they do so at the beginning of the school day and these are informal performances kind of in between concert time so throughout the school year they put on little performances in the fall we love to play marching band type music like let's go band the hay song and Seven Nation Army if you've been to a Bills game or have watched the Bills game you know Seven Nation Army our kids love to play that song and yes they're developing important musical skills but in addition to that they're

070also forming these great bonds with the other students what a great way to start the day on a high note did you catch that pun when you come to school and you feel great and you're laughing and smiling watching them musical performers in December we perform musical uh music that is uh festive holiday music and uh or that's in December and then H for our 100th day of school in February which is coming up in a few weeks we will be performing celebrate by cool and the Gang another great way to excite the kids uh in December our fifth grade band put on a very special performance and holiday sing along alongside the chorus and Orchestra and that performance was just for the kindergarten buddies uh our students L to play holiday music that's a

071great time of year for them so they also prepared to play for the Hamburg holidays parade another great way to connect with the community unfortunately this year the weather didn't cooperate so we were unable to play the Hamburg holidays parade but we have plans to do that each year uh forming that important bond with our students and the community our students are love doing patriotic music year round and they are uh working diligently to prepare their patriotic music to play on the morning announcements at school they're preparing those same patriotic songs to play at Union Pleasants Memorial Day observance in May and our students are working on uh music to play during band independently during band time we have independent solo time where students can select music of their own choosing to play for the

072group uh helping them to develop Independence and helping their classmates to develop listening skills and patience and support um our students just love performing on so many different levels when you think about playing an instrument sometimes we think about uh skill development individualized and that is true but there's also the social component that's so important these days so uh um oh our students today they performed at the middle school alongside all the fifth graders districtwide they formed a band and they got to listen to the sixth graders perform interestingly our sixth graders were giving words of encouragement and advice to our fifth graders and they told them stick with it when it gets tough that's that part of brain workking that they know it gets tough but if you stick with it there are rewards

073and what a great lesson in music but in life so I'd like to thank you all for your support this is a supportive Community for music and as you know we have more musicians coming up so thank you for your time hi there uh my name is Kurt eery I'm a general music teacher here at Union Pleasant um and I'm so excited to present a unique uh and a great tradition that we have here in upes and that is our uh our School Musical on April 29th our fourth and fifth graders will be presenting the crisis on the canal um but what's unique about this is that it's a stud it's a an original production meaning it was written uh by it collaboratively by a team of fifth grade writers and facilitated by myself uh

074and Mrs Lewis it's over here um uh this is a this is a tradition uh that Spains over 15 years in fact it was begun by uh my counterpart our general music teacher here at Mr berer um we were just talking today that the very first one was a an adap adaptation of chery Silverstein's poems uh into a musical and uh these days uh Mrs Lewis and I are thrilled to to be able to carry on that tradition um the most common question that we get asked uh is is just how do you go about doing that where do you begin in writing a musical and uh the answer is having a dedicated group of students who are equipped with a sense of teamwork and most importantly a can do attitude um our writing process

075begins back in September uh when uh we ask put out a call for writing samples from any fifth grader who is who is interested in being on the writing team uh from there we choose our writers who and this year we have Charlie kazlowski uh Adrian Doo Finley Iker Emma Dugen Tessa rice and Kaylee Conrad they're here to share a little more about the creative process the first part of our writing process is brainstorming settings we brainstorm settings by coming up with tons of ideas of where our musical could take place we narrowed our ideas down by asking questions like could we make this into a musical and would this be able to be portrayed on a stage once we felt confident about three settings we eliminated two by picking the one that we liked

076the best the Eerie Canal the next step in our writing process was brainstorming characters we would see in certain settings in the setting of our musical the Erie Canal we might see families engineers and fishermen eventually we selected our characters we had so much fun coming up with the names such as Maggie and S Carson Teddy doitt and slug aini then after narrowing down potential settings and characters we started brainstorming different conflicts that might occur in certain settings some conflicts that exist in stories are character versus environment character versus character and character versus self the conflict we settled on for a musical is the competition of the Eerie Canal versus railroads part of our creative process of writing is saying no to ideas one idea that we explored but didn't end up using took place

077on the subway when we realized that silly dancing rats would have to be a part of the show we knew that it was time to n the idea and move on part of the rating process is deciding whether or not a story idea is actually practical to put on stage this is is another part where we start to get rid of ideas for example one story idea of ours where books have their plots jumbled up in the library would have been hard to portray in a 1-hour musical such a complicated thought our chosen idea was exciting because the setting was very doable and the conflict was realistic to show on stage finally it was time for writing after 3 months of writing editing revising and rereading together we wrote Our musical for 2025 the crisis

078on the canal a story about a small town on the edge of the Eerie Canal thriving on making the best brooms until a railroad Tycoon tries to sabotage the Eerie Canal so the citizens of broomtown could only use the rail roads will Teddy Maggie and STI be able to save broomtown and the Eerie Canal you'll have to come see our show on April 29th to find out I'm Mrs Lewis I'm one of the AIS reading teachers lovely job girls I'm so proud of [Applause] you I have to do a little shout out so making the script come to life is our next challenge that isn't possible without a dedicated team of students and teachers our students rehears for four months learning original songs written by Mr abser and Mr biter staging acting and dancing skills

079taught by Mrs mauba one of our third GR teachers and myself our art Club led by Mrs Hans Smith who we heard earlier who's incredible works very hard creating our set and our props even Mr shimento and Mr B a man of many talents of course use their handy man skills to build incredible things that help immerse the audience in our experience this year we have tasked them with the challenge of turning the front of the stage where you are sitting now into the Eerie Canal and also constructing a boat so we'll see how that comes upart we are extremely lucky here at Union Pleasant to have this opportunity every year to create something we are so proud of thank you and that's the end thank you so much for sharing it our joy at

080Union Pleasant [Applause] I think it's neat that this is the building that creates its own musical I've always found that very interesting well they're um shuffling along uh our next item is actually for we do have a executive session uh topic um so looking for a motion to enter into executive session for the purposes of discussing child victims act cases pending against the District Sub sub cam second second by Dave all in favor opposed ad passes we're an executive uh should be back in about 10 minutes or so uh end executive session and return to regular session move by law second second by cam all in favor opposed passes moving to our informational items uh our board briefings basically uh meetings from the last uh our last meeting um just a couple information items at

081our desk here uh future meetings our March meeting uh will be in the Middle School um starting with a budget session following a regular meeting uh listed here is 6:30 but I thought the 7:00 kind of worked well so we'll probably update that um April meeting is at Armor um same uh six o'clock budget session probably a 7 o'clock start for our regular meeting and we do have uh a second regular meeting in April um mainly to approve I believe the Bose budget um and any other um items that come up uh meetings workshops uh nisba Lobby Day is coming up um tomorrow I don't think anybody's going um and as always there's the nisba classes online that we can take uh there's a couple budget uh transfers uh that are just for information only

082small enough we're not voting on them uh so moving on to board committee uh reports I'll start with our uh student rep beep it's going to be no you're good oh all right I thought she said it was going to beep but no all right all right so we're planning our spring project and that's like the main thing student government is doing right now it's called threaded together like the threads of clothes and it's a free clothing store and family fun event that's taking place Saturday March 29th at the high school 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. um we will we will be collecting new and gently used clothing the week prior and we're working on getting donation bins in every school in the district so like each Elementary School the middle school the high school

083um I'm working on that and then so basically just keep an eye out for more information to come it's like moving along pretty quickly um we have a lot to do but it's exciting um so things up on um public things will be publicized about the event on like Hamburg student government's Instagram page and like hopefully the high school's Instagram maybe like our website and the district's um Instagram page so keep your eyes out keep your eyes peeled um it's pretty exciting that's all from me hi uh my only update is from the uh it's not transportation technology uh the technology committee uh excellent technology committee meeting uh Brent gave a very thorough update about uh what is happening uh with uh what oh sorry uh what's going to be happening with the uh Google

084contracts which I know you're going to be talking about more right little bit so I won't give too many details about it my only superintendent is going to talk more about it the only thing I would want to say about it um from my experience was just you gave a really really thorough report like why it's happening um and uh how Pat Worley is going to be and all the other how the students or how the faculty are going to be mitigating the effects uh of now that the students AR necessarily going to have access the same way that they did before like how it's going to be how the teachers are going to be able to adjust to that and that just makes me really happy that like you're adjusting wonderful um but also

085that a lot of these things are happening to protect our students um and the the state's response to Google is a is a protective measure and I am editorializing a little bit but I like that like I I like that it's a it's not necessarily the best thing to adjust but I like that it seems to be in the interest of student data privacy protections and I can't fault that so you know students first so when you hear more about that keep that context in mind that a little bit of inconvenience is for the protection of our students and their safety so keep that in mind um I attended the Arie County Association of Schoolboard legislative meeting on January 23rd it was very well attended um you know every school in bosei one seemed to

086be there um also was there was Grand Island superintendent Dr Brian Graham and also um akan superintendent Andrea um curtain um Jane Sullivan um and the other and our you know committee met with seven state legislators belong Burke galin Ryan McMahon River and Conrad as we talked about Foundation Aid the tax cap increasing Bose's Aid they just wanted to know about one thing cell phones the cell phone ban they no matter what our committee could do they kept on turning back to the cell phone um issue I'm not going to go over the entire thing I'll save it for our discussion on cell phones but they really seem frustrated that I legislators that's all they cared about was you know the cell phone ban that was being put up there if you ask me I

087think it's a distraction so we sto asking about tax cap and Bose's Aid and foundation's Aid and that formula that we that we all read the the Rockefeller Institute report and you know we know that you know that has to be changed so I won't go over the different points that we discussed uh the meeting was an hour and a half for an hour of it we discussed cell phones um so I'll save that for the cell phone discussion here um but yeah the uh Capital conference um and their trip to albony is tomorrow February 12 so they're already on their way they're already there and their wrap-up legislative dinner is May 22nd and something interesting is DPO David dph pretty much refuses to speak to um our legislative committee um and he represents a

088good part of this District so um you know that's that's a little alarming so we you know maybe you know we should all get an email out to him and see why he doesn't want to talk to our legislative committee um um so they you know they talked about Bill track 50 where we watch different bills that affect education um and but then again we just the whole the whole meeting was cell phone so I'll save that for our discussion um and that's all I got you got on your uh Cam and I were at the uh Academy of Finance uh board meeting uh one of the things I thought that was interesting in that is that and I realize it had to be re uh reapplied for or recertified is the their CTE status

089so that uh students uh in the aof program uh will get a CTE designation on their U on their diploma um other than that I think that's about all I got um yeah related to the finance Academy I was going to mention that as well so they're they run an annual fundraiser in May so that's what the finance Academy's primary contribution in addition to the mentorship um is the scholarship that they offer uh through the through the funded primarily through the board um so that's something we'll be talking a little bit more about as that approaches um I'll let I'll let Ashley cover the building visit um finance committee so Tom mentioned we we met and I think you know what we're seeing tonight is is a result of of some of those changes we

090discussed in the finance committee so we talked about you know some changes to the timing you know we've allowed a little bit little bit longer to discuss these these sessions um I think we've generally sort of slowed the process really creating um some additional educational materials around that um and you know trying to improve the oversight you know again I think demonstrated by the additional reports that that we get from from Christine each month so um I think that's a positive development and I thank my my colleagues on the finance committee for that um we've also uh the Ida which I'm also the the board representative on the Ida we have our reorganization meeting tomorrow um where I anticipate I'll be staying on as the Secretary of that board um so I'm also a part

091of the executive committee on the Ida and the Land Development Corporation so just to let the the board know that that I intend hope to to continue that um and then you know just been at a number of of different School events over the last month uh mention the finance Academy um they had they had a number of things going on uh went to some basketball games went to a bowling event which was which was a riot uh the senior the senior game at at the Nike Base the hockey game uh Frontier versus Hamburg was awesome uh the Middle School Musical uh I didn't didn't get to stay for the whole thing my kids weren't in it this year but um I did get a thank you as I sat down here for our donation

092uh we did sponsor that that event the entire board did so wanted to to relay that thank you to the board um and I also had the honor of being the spelling be pronouncer at the middle school which was tons of fun uh not the hardest word but the final word because I get asked a lot was accommodation accommodation so is there two C's two M's both I can tell you George knew so go George yes George knew yes so that's it I was so disappointed that got rescheduled like four times four times so I couldn't the fourth time it got rescheduled I couldn't judge so I'm glad that um you were there uh I was at the Super Bowl challenge at um the Middle School sponsored by parent child connection last week which is

093always one of my favorite things to do because it brings Frontier students and staff Hamburg students and staff and Randolph Academy student and staff together some of which have forged relationships where now they see each other more than just at the Super Bowl um Rolph Academy won the golden Ladle this year but there were amazing entries from everyone and alongside of that was a great program um on mental health so um I it's always a great event and it's nice to see everybody be together and I'm stuffed from all the soups um I have um I think it's in two weeks I'm going to something that I think is going to be fascinating um at UB it's a conference on safety but not under the guise of hardening school buildings but more along the lines

094of recognizing um signs in students um mental health and other things that may help us to identify um a child at risk and preventative measures again other than hardening the schools but more of along the lines connections and what we can do in that way um so I'm I think that ought to be really good I'm looking forward to bringing back good information um I attended a law conference a few weeks ago um which was really um interesting that talked about some of the state's different procedures in regards to suspensions and moving towards eliminating suspensions in the elementary level which you know we we don't see here we have other ways that we um support our students than keeping them out of the school Community but there's a lot of other schools that are still

095using those measures so um that was interesting as well and that's all I got uh the district Safety Committee met on February 4th and um the uh we have such great Community Partners around us within this area uh the police and fire and all those folks I mean they they continuously get together and try to figure out how to keep Hamburg kids and staff as safe as they possibly can so I'm always so impressed with those people um you know they it was a pretty much standard meeting I mean the uh you know there were some goals specific uh for this meeting to review and um some of them are just you know things that they want to make sure that we're always doing better all the time you know with ECT to um entrance

096procedures and the types of documents that we use whether they're paper or digital forms um for you know it could be some for parents coming in specific or some for um substitute teachers and you know those types of folks um you know that the nice said really wanted to emphasize the fact that we you know we communicate very well to um our community with respect to drill s and emergency responses that type of thing and you know I think I've said this a number of times but um it's been reiterated over and over again by um Chief Fitzgerald but you know Hamburg school district is so far ahead with respect to safety compared to other school districts I mean I you know some of the conversation that we have in these meetings I mean I'm

097so shocked really because to me it just seems like a you know things that should be done and yet um you know Chief Fitzgerald's you know constantly says that you know you'd be surprised how many districts are so far behind what we do we just take it as you know everyday things that happen here and it's no big deal but in fact you know we are pretty far ahead and we do a great job so um the some updates and uh you know the camera system is still being implemented and installed I think um you know we're at the middle school right now now and that they're about 3/4 of the way complete installing those cameras and then the next school up for the installation of the cameras would be Charlotte and um and I

098think the goal is to make sure that you know we have all the the cameras installed in every school building um by sometime this time by this time next year you know to have it all done you know so like a a soft um um time limit there but um so you know other than that you know we're still talking about drills and making sure that we are we're performing all the drills according to you know what the state requires and um you know very specific things making sure that the announcement of those drills go out to the staff and the parents uh so that everybody is informed and um fire inspections are coming you know we have to do all these things this is all behind the curtains type of work that the average

099parent probably knows goes on but doesn't really pay too much attention to because they know we're here making sure that it gets done and and it is so uh annual fire inspections taking place um our district safety plan um you know the the state with nid and and the school districts you know they talk a lot about terminology and what are we going to call this this you know um this problem or how do I we identify it like you know shelter in place and those types of things and uh they're still working through um you know the details on that so um you know so no changes but yet but there's there's some coming and um really um and there was some talk too about and it makes sense you know when we talk

100about drill S I know we drill for the kids and the staff during the day right but what about you know our building operates in the evenings for adult aded and that type of thing you know uh there was some conversation about actually having some type of a drill for the individuals that are in the buildings in the evening you know so um so that was I thought that was a great conversation great idea to make sure that that uh um you know those talks can continue so um other than that the safety plan will be presented to the board by Chief Fitzgerald uh in June and U that is all I have is it working yeah all right uh Laura thanks for covering everything for PCC uh no that I'm saying thanks great I

101have nothing to report on PCC that Laura did not cover uh PTSA we have not met since the last board meeting however you can still get your PTSA membership if you need a link feel free to reach out to any of us we are happy to provide it um and also the middle school is having a meat raffle you can s if you cannot get your ticket you can get a ticket you can get a table um you can sign up to work it or you can make donations for baskets um if you're looking to support in that way I know our Middle School desperately uh needs help in their fundraising so any any way that anybody can contribute is greatly appreciated and I will be sending out an email with a QR code following

102the meeting with all that information um and for our building visitation committee I don't want to pull everybody right now originally I thought that was a great idea now I'm reflecting on that we had two potential dates in March uh we were looking at March 7th or 28th and we were just looking for a quick like what's your best time of day Dave I know Fridays are terrible for you I didn't pick Fridays I'm sorry I know those are both Fridays 7th and 28th All right so maybe the 28th 28 the 28th is there a better time of day do we like mornings midday mornings Mary we can't have evenings we're there to see the children I don't disagree oh after lunch first those mornings do we want to Doodle poll all right you got

103enough information from us on that uh also I just wanted to say with building visitation uh in being here tonight and I attended the speed boarding at bosies back in November and I got to talk with like board members from all these other places it was really inspiring to see how often their boards got out into their schools like it it was impressive from the one guy was a little bit insane in like want only in in the sense of I was like oh my gosh how do you get there so much but he's there he told me he was there almost every day and I was like wow um but then in places more like East aora or park they were saying they try to get out to each building once a year and

104I know in the past we've been busy um unable to do that unable to make schedules work but I was hoping maybe looking into next school year to possibly add a few more buildings on because in being here I realized I was never in Union Pleasant before and if I wasn't here tonight I might not make it here on our current schedule if I can only see one Elementary building each year um so I was hoping to try to inspire people to get a few more building visits in next year even it can't even if it can't be all seven of us I think it's important to get out and remind ourselves why we're doing this seeing our teachers seeing our students you know getting a feel for the culture just you know the nice

105fluffy stuff that I like I I mean I agree that is what we used to do that and I I think I think why not right like do it and if three board members show up so be it I just cautioned there was a time where I think I was the only one that showed up once or maybe it wasn't me somebody else was the only one who showed up once so we just have to make sure we we can definitely talk Google Calendar it or something so we can all at least get three board members it's a little awkward being walked around by four people yeah I don't want to be sure probably wouldn't use that word but yes all right so I agree we should we we should do that next year yeah

106just I mean I'm not saying we need to get to everywhere just maybe increasing did four schools a year and that's all right thank you that's all my committee reports Cur have for this year two one Elementary and Middle School Rich that means if I I in my term here I would only get to three elementary schools I want to see all four yeah I want to get out and see them well Co yeah [Music] all right thanks outage think that we could one this year that's what everybody wants to do put maybe we can go during one of the plays what did we do Boston we did Boston [Music] I mean I feel like that's at the end of year not if it's the same day as Charlotte field day because I'll be there

107but I'll stop by if I'm loud all right I don't that's it that's all for me okay thanks moving on to our uh Capital project update thank you Brent say on check check perfect well good evening everyone it's great to see some familiar faces uh for those of you who don't know me my name is Christian I an engineer with Turner Construction I'm here working on the phase 2 Capital project along with my teammates um just a couple of updates I wanted to uh give here tonight so basically one of the biggest points tonight is uh last week Friday uh phase three and four have reached have been submitted to S so uh kudos to the design team for getting that in um so game plan for these next couple of weeks we're going to

108take full advantage of the breaks upcoming breaks coming up so February break and spring break we're going to be in the high school taking advantage of uh school being dismissed to handle some upcoming construction work some of that includes uh replacing some carpet in the one room continuing on with the uh High School data and it work so I'm happy to report as well that we're on track to finish in February the it new it work that we're doing and then we're also going to be placing erecting uh steel for the new uh rooftop units over those brakes as well and then of course uh NCI is going to be continuing on with the maintenance building over by the Middle School uh some safety metrics I just want to review as well so manh hours

109we're at 675 we expect that to go up over the brakes as well and then just to give a quick engineering summary so we're progressing through the punch list as well through the elementary schools we're about 1% of the way there and we're working through that diligently are there any [Laughter] questions you'll see a lot more done once uh the brakes hit but that's essentially the highlights over the last since the last board report so what's sorry if you said it and I missed it what's the occupy date for the uh maintenance Barn so uh over on the schedule Milestones we're projecting that we will be finished with the mile or I'm sorry with the maintenance barn by the end of February um that is it that is what we are and that means we

110could it's useful we're moving it we're in yes yeah okay so that's the current game plan um or what we're projecting going for is there any other questions no so like to direct your attention to the PowerPoint slide so that's where we're at with the maintenance barn and the top left uh that is NCI staging their equipment and getting their vehicles and temporary construction fence in place over on the right we poured the Footers and they also place the new rebar for the stem walls of the foundations on the bottom left there you've got the foundation uh forms in place for the concrete and then on the bottom right that is the Footers and the new stem walls for the foundations complete and poured so those forms are now off and now we are just

111waiting for the concrete brakes to come back to confirm that they've reach strength and then they will start back filling that so in the next couple of weeks you're going to start to see the seal go up and then they're going to start you're going to see the steel go up and they're going to start you'll physically see the barn starting to be put in place so then moving on to the next slide so this is uh top left there you see the the trim work over in the Charlotte Music State uh music room excuse me so that is the wood wood trim that you see there that perimeter wood now in place top right you've got Union Pleasant's uh Capital outlay project that is one of the rooms fully complete with the new ceiling

112the bottom left and right photos are of the Charlotte art room uh storage new ceiling as well as uh the excuse me Cabinetry shelving and then just a recap of the schedule so for phase three and four we are now in SED review we're in the queue as I mentioned earlier so that is now being reviewed by S so the idea being for phase three we will get approval um come later this year projecting roughly mid spring mid the late spring and then phase four projecting SD approval towards the fall and then just a schedule overview of the building conditions survey as well as for the next referendum are there any questions but the maintenance the maintenance bar completion date is February 28th this year yes this this Barn the one that with just the

113footer yep you're going to have that whole thing done in two weeks is that right they're pushing along so uh it's it's oh okay yeah but it says complete like it's all done wiring and everything and so their contract is only doing up to so much they're putting in the building and then some of the oh okay all right oh good all right good job then thank you everyone to our superintendent report uh Mr Adams thank you Mr Flynn thank you everybody thanks for your patience uh and really appreciate the conversation uh that's been going on already today uh some things to talk to you about first but let me just like give a couple highlights in this very space right here just uh less than like a week or week and a half ago

114was a math B that was astounding it's right not a spelling be but a math B uh and that was just one example of the joy value connection that you see and that was the work of so many adults and the the the enthusiastic participation of so many students as well and I could go on I could repeat the wiie Wonka Jr uh armor find Nemo the high school is 39 steps there's so much more than that but all those things add to the lives of not only the students who are involved but the staff who work with them and all of us who get to go see them and see just how involved and how changed the kids are from that and changes us too uh and it's um just every day is a

115chance to see that in our schools so I want to want to thank you for that I I want to talk there's a few things to talk about tonight um one is the Google service that Mary had mentioned uh we use as a district for teaching learning experience and for some operational things lots of operational things we use Google's basically Suite of services we there's the Google core Services uh many of which you know Google forms uh Google uh you know Google Docs uh Gmail things along those lines then there's what we call Google additional Services uh and basically there's been a challenge with some of those Google additional Services of which YouTube is probably the one that is most on our students Minds right now uh and that is the fact that we cannot

116um the state's not been able to get uh a um student privacy uh agreements with those companies um that that are part of the Google additional Services uh families are going to receive a a uh a mailing from me tomorrow that outlines this in more specifics but basically and we'll just use YouTube as your example for this students will not as of March 1st be able to access YouTube on their Chromebooks on their student issued devices that doesn't mean that teachers won't be able to use YouTube in their instruction uh and Mary alluded to it as well um we've had you know our our Tech committee certainly pworth uh is is such a huge part of that has provided um resources for teachers to use to be able to embed YouTube videos within existing applications

117or services that we already use so it be able to be embedded within Google Classroom it'll be able to be embedded within something called edpuzzle which a lot of your students are familiar with it's going to be a change in the way that they the kids do business teachers will still have access to it but this is like the really important part teachers can't share any of the student data within that um I can I can try to answer more of your questions of that following the meeting but I just wanted to make sure the board was aware we've shared that document that went home uh that went to staff it'll go home to parents and families tomorrow though okay so I just wanted to cover that uh and I agree there's been a great

118amount of foresight on the part of our technology crew to be able to sort of see around the corner of what needs to happen to make sure that instruction and learning experiences aren't unduly impacted by that I I want to talk to you about some of the things uh that we've shared with staff uh with regard to um a lot of the news that's out there uh one of the first and things and and I want to say that uh I'm speaking uh for myself I'm speaking as superintendent I'm speaking as as somebody who's representing the board right now and representing our district um there's concerns about what might happen to students of ours or families of ours that might be undocumented all right I want you to know that we abide by the fact

119and we recognize the fact that uh in 1982 there's a Supreme Court case called pler versus doe which said that undocumented students uh had the right to education under the equal protection Clause the of the 14th Amendment that's stuff that I wouldn't have been able to tell you 3 weeks ago all right quite honestly but we've been all been doing a lot of reading about that uh and that equal protection Clause really matters we also uh I want to make sure that you understand that um that our registration process does nothing in terms of asking families about their immigration status it doesn't touch that that component at all uh I want to make sure that PE people are aware of that um another item to bring up because there's all sorts of concerns about whether

120agents of uh uh for Immigration and Customs might be coming to buildings and yes that was Absolut like that fear was absolutely real on the part of some and possibly many um that's nothing that we've heard of happening uh around us and we I was just at a conference on Friday where there was a representative from the Department of Homeland Security who pledged to us that ice agents are not in the business of coming to schools all right that's nothing that we can expect however if we happen to have somebody come to one of our schools I want to tell you what our building leaders have been told um and that is something that's been very much uh laid out I think the national school boards Association uh put information about this as well but

121our message is consistent if somebody comes asking about a student's whereabouts a student's immigration status and they don't have anything like that first of all that question should elicit a response of I need to talk to the building principal and that building principal needs to talk to me all right and then I need to talk to our counsel all right our legal counsel about that situation um there's certain stipulations that would be involved before you'd even consider having anybody talk to by that but again it's not something you know sometimes you try to play out what's the worst possible outcome or What's worst possible thing that can happen and play out how you'd respond that's how we're responding with it is that our building leaders are going to talk to folks if they would happen

122to come to our buildings contact me we'd contact a lawyer I'd get myself over there and we would make sure uh that things are handled um as carefully as possible we don't anticipate that happening though all right um we understand why it's a concern but it's not something that uh um that we believe will be happening I I take great Fai great comfort in the fact that the gentleman that spoke to us uh last week uh was was Earnest in in his telling of that um the second thing that I wanted to address uh again it's on behalf of the board that I'm saying this it is stuff that I feel personally strong about as well uh there is the question of whether or not students are made to feel comfortable here uh we're talking

123about students who might be part of a marginalized group uh there's been a lot of talk about executive orders and things along those lines I want you to know that here in New York State uh Public Schools we abide by What's called the dignity for all students act that lists several different categories protected classes of people um who we need to make sure aren't being unduly harmed with their treatment or being harmed At All by with with their treatment at school that dignity for all students act requires us to fill out paperwork document it with the state and requires us that we take steps to make sure that those individuals are protected um those definitions of those protected classes are wide all right I'm not going to go into like the full details of but

124I want you to know those definitions are broad all right those definitions are inclusive of all of our students um I want to share as sort of like my my last component about this uh when I came to the district I want in 2019 uh I spoke to students by grade level and I spoke to students by their their grade levels and mentioned the ideas of Dasa uh of protected groups and there were students who came up to me afterwards and asked if they could start a club and that club was going to be a club that looked out for the interests of kids who were marginalized the members of our Board of Education at that time took that idea and took that club and said yes we want to have something like that at

125of Middle School we're not just going to keep it at the high school we're going to have one at the middle school as a place for people to feel welcome and that's I think the the the message that I want to send more than anything is that uh this notion of welcoming and belonging is not something that's new with me by any stretch this is something that our community of Hamburg puts out and shines with and our board reflects that light and you can't tell where the light is emanating from but that is the purpose of this place and that's what we we are doing and that's uh I'm I'm proud to be sitting at the table um with these folks today so I wanted to address those items uh and certainly again I'll be

126around I I will be around after if you want to talk I'm not sure if you're going to want to stick around longer than that but uh uh if you'd like to I I will be here and certainly you can can reach me uh in my office or uh via email or however uh however works works best for you uh the the finally component for me is about the executive budget um we heard governor hokel executive budget which is a proposal um it's the executive budget is the executive budget it's what is hoped to be passed by Governor hokel when she presents it but the the the executive budget includes like the foundation Aid increase of 2% which was the the lowest the lowest increase you could uh that's what we received the free breakfast

127and lunch You' I'm sure you've heard of that that as well and then and then the uh the distraction free schools and that has to do uh largely uh shorthand version It's the cell phone policy uh or Internet enabled devices as it's described uh I want to tell you what our practice is in the district right now and then I want to open up to the board for comment and then we'll be moving on for the for the rest of our of our meeting but uh um our practice in our schools right now and this was outlined it was a conversation that was had among the board in the summer of 2024 it was outlined a letter uh August um Mr Cornell sent that out and in your elementary schools the cell phones are either

128in a backpack or they're in a cubby or some other storage area um uh for the students at the middle school 6 through 8 uh are phrases away for the day uh and it is something that is abided to as well as middle school students will abide to any rule that you give them all right for the vast majority it's abided by and there's some who Miss on that and we work with them uh and I can say that after having lived there for 5 and a half years uh at the high school it is very much teacher discretion uh and you're going to see them used in some classes for educational purpose you're going to see them out in some classes in some classes they're going to be basically a fix to a door

129where they have like a calculator holder and that's where the phones go but we give like that the staff has has discretion with that so it's really at the 9 through 12 level that this would have the largest impact should the executive budget become adopted by the state legislature as well and become the final uh the final proposal but with that uh that and that's that's just shared for information sake for everybody uh the board certainly aware of it um comments and give the I'm certainly going to give the board a chance to to share their thoughts on it and uh we'll do that and then we'll we'll make our move to the next part of the meeting so who would like to begin we don't have to go in order or anything like that

130David is catlike quickness for the microphone da can't wait I can't I've been working on it did it beep yet okay there we go hey one thing I forgot to mention this Thursday um NYSC is having a um on Thursday February 13th at Casey Middle School all the way in East Amherst but n who has already come out in support of a cell phone ban uh Statewide is going to have uh uh disconnected it's called West New York convening uh join us for the impact of cell phone social media and Technology on Children's Schools and learning so if anybody wants to that is Thursday February 13th this Thursday and uh I have the information here um at the legislative meeting um quickly um I said that the meeting just turned right to cell phones um

131and we discussed it for a whe a very long time most of the meeting um most of what we uh discussed I got some quick items here um this is another unpaid mandate uh they're talking about $1 13.3 million that's around $18,000 per school but the big five will eat up most of this and how we going to get it next year and the year after that I doubt it so another unpaid mandate coming from Albany we have fear that this ban could be tied to funding a all over again and we remember what a disaster that was so if if this is tied to funding if you don't follow you know some sort of plan that they're going to hold money back from us from Foundation Aid um and again it's just another distraction

132to move the discussion away from funding and and into the culture of cell phones and social media um the Grand Island members talked about angry parents at meeting we all remember the parents with the covid mask right it's going to be that all over again people are want to know parents are going to be mad and they'll be here at this meeting um wanting to discuss that if there's a lockdown there's an emergency they want their students to be able to contact them and and we they referred us to um a com um a story on wkbw.com and she read some of the comments underneath it from parents and most of them were were militant and angry comments that no one is going to take away my child's phone um and again how do you

133enforce this band we um were at the speedboard um seminar Ashley Laura and I and lacana gave a presentation about their their cell phone band um and and it it it was very involved very expensive and it didn't really seem to work after they talked about it at the meeting the lacana board member spoke up about her band and um I said your assistant principal said I chase cell phones all day long I don't think that's what we want our principle doing is chasing cell phones all day long she was really mad at me for saying this she gave me the stink guy the entire meeting and uh next meeting I'm going to bring Mary with me in case she gets rough or something um but you know IEP students would be able to use

134their I know you would um IEP students would be exposed you know they would still have their phone we'd be exposing the IE you know bullies might try to use their phones um ell students have translated on their phones I know now these are other districts um some districts like GL Shore put hall passes on the phones um you know cell phones monitor diabetes this was brought up um you know this band cannot stop bullying because students have their phones after school um and uh in the Grand Island and so Dr Bram Graham from uh Grand Island he you might have seen the letter that he wrote um against the school band um and so tomorrow um as they head to alony they're going to bring with them this letter um to talk about taking

135control away from um from the local schools that that maybe a program to educate parents is is better um and and and to take away the administrative burden that this band would cause um and so they have I don't know if you all got this letter from IR County Association School boards but you know they were trying to stay neutral until this meeting when the discussion turned to um cell phones like the entire meeting Frontier other um districts are having stakeholder meetings trying to get ahead of this and talking about if this is put into effect you know how they would handle it what they would do so I realize it's early but I think we have to get ahead of it just like the other school districts and and get an idea of what

136we would do or just get an open discussion with teachers and other stakeholders on on what their opinion is and um you know is it really a problem and if it is what we would do about it I love that you gave this to me you know yeah I know so um you brought up a lot of interesting points um and you said them in a way that sounds really scary but I I've been following this for a long long time and I've already sent you a bunch of details about this so you were prepared to have some conversations um the Mandate or The Proposal isn't actually done yet it is it's on her desk it's still being deliberated but the content of it isn't necessarily a situation of we want you to do this

137it is here is all of the evidence that having these internet enabled devices facilitates distraction it facilitates um all of these issues in schools it has a tendency to high highight dis uh discrepancies so class discrepancies uh the halves and the haves knots um it can sometimes enable bullying fights and I'm not saying that that happens in Hamburg there's all of this evidence and data that is Nationwide that this is this is you're ultimately teachers are are fighting for attention it's a it's an attention e uh economy right there's boatloads of evidence that that these are not good for students uh in a classroom setting uh so the governor has gone you know what we're going to do what we can to kind of level the playing field for our teachers so that our students

138can be successful districts I'm going to ask that you figure out how to best implement this it reminds me a lot in how in higher education you have different Regional accreditors that say here are the standards we need you to follow figure out how to follow them and go about it it's it's very much left to the districts to figure out how to implement it's that they need to implement them and I know that you are concerned about funding obviously obviously I think a lot about how we are funded and where that money comes from so but I really one of the things that I am heartened by is that I'm really surprised to hear that there is so much concern coming from some of the regional areas because when I pose this question more

139broadly in New York you're not getting the same kind of like Fe people are like yeah obviously we got to do this like the data is there uh people are starting to do this even without a mandate um it's something that we've heard from the public that there is an interest in are you going to get people concerned about how will I contact my child in an emergency yes that's why right in the the legislation it says one of the things the stuent the school districts need to solve what are you going to do with this how are you going to keep the um the devices safe and from being accessed how are you going to put in a plan so that people can be contacted an emergency like these are the things that are

140outlined in the actual legislation that we have to come up with that decision I think that it is appropriate like you said to get the appropriate stakeholders now in the room in our district to solve those problems and I think that lacana is it lacana that's doing it yeah lacana not surprisingly the first time you do something it it's hard I mean ask every teacher the first time you teach something it's like you know so yeah you have to iterate I mean that's that's part of any process but I don't think that we already have a school that practices umal stands [Music] for social emotional learning um and it's there's data to suggest that that is best paired with an environment that reduces distraction this this would go along with what we would want to

141do anyway and instead of you can do this in a lowcost way like this doesn't need to be a high cost implementation like this can be done intelligently as long as we are willing to get the right people in the room to work together and my fear is that worrying about cost and making rabble like people get mad when they we don't have a plan people there's always going to be every single person in our district is wonderful and perfect and it's random not crazies that will give us crazies but I'm just saying you're always going to get somebody that's going to be mad for mad's sake I think you're going to get less of that if you can articulate a plan and say like what a great question how are we going to AR

142contact you an emergency here's how we're going to contact you do an emergency and we can't do that unless we have a plan and start working on it as soon as possible so my oh and in terms of like outing people uh I mean anybody that has glasses is outing themselves as a with eye disability like I don't think that's like the Panic emotion I people that's I I don't think that that's I'm gonna toss this in there uh I have to I I just want to say I don't think I I feel like saying we're outing people like with disabilities um or just differences is really not the right way to approach this like you you mentioned diabetes so I'm going to run with that one for a quick sec because I'm going to

143tell you having my cell phone available to me is not what outed me as a diabetic um you know what I mean like people knew that before my cell phone they know it after also there's accommodations that we make for students and we don't think about how does that out them like we have students that get a distraction free testing environment that means they up to they can get up and leave and go take their test somewhere else that's not outing them it's providing them accommodation that they're entitled to in an IEP or a 504 plan you know the same thing is going to apply for students that get those phones and those students aren't going to want to be like if if I'm the diabetic in the classroom I'm not going to be like

144oh yeah I want to get out my phone and scroll YouTube so everybody knows I'm different I'm going to keep my phone in my pocket until I need it and that's what we're going to encourage those students who are able to use their phones to do is use them for what they're designed to be using used for and this fear of outing people over being able to have a cell phone I I think it's I think you're opening a rabbit hole to say like what does the accommodation we're giving a student like do to them in front of their classmates I just don't think it's a road we want to go down and as part of our Seal program anyway like we have a whole curriculum designed to to deal with like hey people are

145different they have different needs and accommodations to you like we we have a whole sensory room we have whole Comm like we have a whole curriculum across our district that deals with people that need different things to be themselves like I don't I don't think I think we can handle it like I there's always going to be bullies like there's always going to be something to deal with situations like that but I think we are I think we have the faculty and the the staff to like to deal like I I think we can deal with it we just we need to start coming up with a plan so we don't get caught with our pants down like that's what I want to start doing so I like that bit I don't want to fight

146it I want to get to work so that's what I want to say on that do anybody else want to talk before I I prepared all kinds of stuff for everybody in expectation of being able to discuss this new distraction free environment so are you sure oh lord it's long okay so I just want to remind everybody that here at Hamburg we've always been TR Blazers in mental health we place a high value on our students social emotional wellbeing we just were talking about that um and as a board we're responsible for setting policy in our district that is most beneficial to our students and that's not a job that any of you take lately or I take lately um and we should be using data to drive our decisions for that and we need

147data to support what is best for our students so I was hoping to take an opportunity at some point tonight to ask if maybe we'd consider setting up a committee for this because it sounds like it's going to be um an undertaking that we're going to need to spend some time on but I also wanted because we like data to um share some with everybody here so research shows that teens spend s to nine hours a day on screens and four to five hours a day on social media studies of um studies of time usually excuse me studies routinely find that the average teen reports spending more than seven hours a day on screen-based Leisure activity not including school and homework a third of teens say they are on one or more major social media

148sites almost constantly 45% of teens report that they use the internet almost constantly um this is means that they're spending about 16 hours a day 112 hours a week in which they're not fully present and doing whatever is going on in what's going on around them we are trying to educate students here the constant buzzing is causing attention fragmentation I mean I've been out in schools I observe student teachers for my job and I'm watching students like their pockets buzzing and I'm watching these kids in the rooms and they they're not paying attention to this even if they're not getting the phone out they're like you can tell they're distracted wondering what is that who is that what could that be and I think we all want what is best for our students so we

149should be collecting this data seeing what our parents want seeing what our teachers want I mean New York state has showed or I mean we've come back New York State teachers union saying that they want distraction free environment we'd be remiss to not discuss what people are telling us based on a few fears and I'm not expecting us to rewrite policy tonight or next month but we have a mandate that is potentially out there and even if we don't we're Trailblazers here why would we not take the time to consider what is best for our students what data showing is best for our students I think it's really important that we at least have those discussions I know it's hard I know there's going to be people that get mad and I know there's going

150to be some hiccups in the road like Dave presented like what are we going to do with that but that's why we have lots of great minds we're going to come together around the table think about the challenges think about Solutions and think about option A B and C and what that might look like for us so I'll end with hopefully we can start a committee to gather like data from our stakeholders and talk about um what our plans could look like I'll pass so you said a couple things there um I agree that Hamburg um Central we're Trail Trailblazers in a lot of different ways and the thing that we um we want our students to thrive upon the most is that Joy value and connection piece um I think that comes from the

151incredible teachers that we have the relationships and the connections that they're able to develop with support staff and all across the board it shows in our region scores it shows in um all of the activities and different offerings that we have for our kids I'm of the mindset that I don't ever want to be um I don't want to micro manage our teachers in any way shape or form and I feel like um the teachers should have the autonomy to do what they want to do in their classroom particularly at the high school level um I also think that we talk all the time about you know when our kindergarteners come in we talk about what year it is that they're going to be graduating and what's going to be coming around the bend and

152we want them to be able to adapt to what's happening in society and we are in this technical field my kids grew up in the age when social media came about I want to be able to show our our kids how to adapt to that when use phone use is appropriate when it's not appropriate because it is part of our culture right now um I think that our teachers now do an incredible job of they all have different um policies that they use within their classroom at the high school I think that also helps students know that they're going to have different expectations in different places that they go um when I hear the word ban it immediately puts me on edge so um I want our kids to have all those relationships and connections

153and I know that um you know we're talking about data but there's there's a lot of things that go into Data besides just numbers and I think that our kids that our teachers know our kids best and that they're able to make the decision that's best for them in their day-to-day classrooms anything okay obviously this is this is just a uh a proposal as part of the um part of the uh annual budget um I think it's interesting that she put a dollar figure on it as opposed to just saying she wants it done uh putting a dollar figure on it in my mind makes it something that uh is a one of the chess pieces uh on the board for uh for the budget so something that can be put on put off um

154nisba uh as a reminder nisa's position on this is that there should be local control um and that's what they're pushing for U which tells me this is obviously not a not a done deal um I mean my feeling on cell phones I have a 17-year-old he has a phone um I agree with Laura I mean we're teaching young adults here um they're going to be going from we we want to think that we're preparing KS kids for the next step uh cell phones are going to be part of that we use them in work um in colleges they're going to use them more um uh as a learning device or is some for organization in in in college um I think taking that away is is not necessarily our our leading them down the

155best path um I think empowering teachers to make sure that they are um engaging with students um if you have engaging if you have engaging uh teachers um the kids will be engaged um I do not want to see spending a lot of time with teachers which I think are going to or administrative staff trying to chase down cell phones we we couldn't we couldn't really enforce a hatband let alone of trying to get us cell phone um I mean I wouldn't disagree that maybe it's something that needs to be talked about uh deeper but um I'd be very hesitant of just having an out andout ban I like what we do right now with um Elementary in middle school I think it's it's appropriate that they have the devices put away um I think

156that uh is our kids are turning into uh young adults um they need to be able to learn how to handle this this is part of it um that's really all I got [Music] schol don't allow alol don't have [Music] time contr and is figure out how to do it um well I just like to hear from our student Raptor she thinks that cell phones are a distraction and what her opinion is on the um what do you think about um honestly honestly it really is like a lot of teachers do different things like it's a big thing in math like they'll be like put it away I don't want to see it some teachers are like put it in the door like when you walk in like you know you have to put it

157in the little holder and you're like see you when class is over and like it does make you focus but I mean PE people like will focus like I feel like it's a big respect thing and teachers that don't take your F teachers that take your phones it's kind of like I don't know it just shows that they don't trust you um I have one teacher that I had last year and everyone just respects him so much like you're not on your phone you like you just want to soak in every last word like he has to say so it's a big like respect thing and some classes like we use our phones more than I thought we would in high school like for various things I don't know they'll be like pull pull out

158your phone look up what blah blah blah and then we'll like use what we find um also we use our phones when we go like they're like our haul passes someone said that but that's what we do in high school it's kind of annoying but I mean like I kind of like the paper passes but I mean I'm not for an all band so I like if I don't know um but the phones are an easy way to like do a little you just scan the QR code before you leave the classroom and you're like I'm going to room blah blah blah and I guess they like can track us around the school so that's one good thing about like a digital world cuz with paper passes you wouldn't be able to do that um

159yeah I like it up to the teachers and it's my thing is it shows that the teachers like I said respect you when they're like I don't know it's a big mutual respect that's about it those are my thoughts all right let me let me say one my thing I've been thinking about this as everyone's been talking so I mean I I think I appreciate what what you just said right and I think that matches my observation that when we go through the high school in particular you know the students are are generally using their phones for for for something I would consider productive right they're doing something the teacher has has asked them to do or they're researching or they're taking a photo of their notes or they're communicating where they're going to be

160at some a certain time um and I I mean of course like of course we want to understand what what our stakeholder groups want like I I appreciate that you're saying that but it's a bit obvious right like I of course we want to understand what do our teachers want what do our students want what does our community want but I think in asking that we have to think about what are we going to do with what we find right like I think we can probably all agree we're not going to hear from you know 100% of our teachers say yep I want I want cell phones gone right we're not going to hear that and we're not going to hear from 100% of our teachers saying oh yeah the kids should be able to

161use them whenever they want and the same goes for all of our stakeholder groups right so we have to ask ourselves what are we going to do like if 20% of our teachers want phones in their classrooms are we going to take them away if 80% of our teachers want phones in their classrooms are we going to take them away I me personally if it's 1% I mean it feels to me like that justifies giving that teacher the autonomy to to have that phone in their classroom if they want it so I mean I I I appreciate that we're I appreciate that we're we're seeking more data and I think probably what we can all agree on is If This Were to be a mandate however likely any of the board members think it is

162I don't think it's very likely but it's not zero so yeah we should probably be prepared with what does that look like in our high school on the 1% 10% .11 0 one% chance that it's going to happen I mean sure it seems like it's a good planning exercise I guess I would defer to Mr Adams as to whom should be engaged in that discussion and for Mr Adams to bring to us some type of a recommendation for a plan that we would or would not enact based on the feedback we reive sound good yeah yeah just way uh I think we've we've heard loud clear first of all we've heard from board members who may have had different opinions on things and be able to share them and listen and that's a that's a

163positive thing and I don't say that for any other reason that I just want to observe that and note that and uh I'm a fan of that uh and the second thing is that you know what what uh what cam had to say makes a ton of sense so that's going to be my charge with it uh is that we will will begin the Gathering or continue we've got got plenty of qualitative uh we'll we'll we'll seek some we'll seek some more um information on that and that report I gotta tell you march is looking like a pretty stacked uh session I would prefer if we could do an April report because we'll know a heck of a lot more about whether or not we're talking about hey what should we do or is the

164is the question how are we going to implement because we should have some more clarity on that by the April meeting that that would be just what I would have to say and that's something that uh that that certainly can be um you know we can communicate about that another time too all right but thanks so much everybody okay thanks good discussion um moving on to the business items for tonight um starting with our consent items uh G and financial items H um this time any board member can make a request to withdraw a specific item from the consent agenda for individual consideration from the g& items is there such a quest at this time uh hearing none can I have a motion to approve all consent items G2 through H4 and could I just

165add something before we get to that I just want to well let's approve it first and then I'll say something showing myness without my apologies so move by cam so uh I just want to uh congratulate the folks who uh have put in their retirement which were just just approved they'll be staying with us for the rest of the school year but to uh s and cousins at the high school to Jen RoR uh the elementary side of things and then uh as two wonderful teachers who've spent their careers at at Hamburg and then car Karen kisani uh who's teachers Aid at the high school and she's been at some other buildings as well uh she was in the middle school when I met her and she's tremendous as well so congrats to them sorry

166about that time [Applause] all in favor opposed IEM passes uh moving on to our action items um action item um i1 going to have a motion to approve uh affiliation agreement between hambur central school districts and the University of Buffalo School of Psychology for a psychologist interns effect of January 5th 2025 through January 4th 2030 no moves s by Mary second by law uh questions discussion is this something this is something new right I mean typically we've had an intern um for all year this year we've done it a fall semester spring semester so this AG okay uh all in favor I opposed item passes item I2 can I have a motion to approve updated uh salary schedules for part-time and substitute Personnel for the 24 25 school year so move I C second second

167by Dave questions comments I'm assuming this is based on our research in order to recruit how does this compare with other districts that is some research that Al's not yeah so sorry uh we're very competitive so one of the things that we make sure we do is uh make sure our sub rates are competitive what you'll see on this is a change that we have a retired nurse sub that will get paid an additional amount of money um and then we also have a cook manager is the other big change that will get $20 an hour so those are the two changes from when it was originally approved in July but we are competitive with our sub rates for sure thank you any other questions comments all in favor opposed it passes item I3 can

168I have a motion to approve upon the recommendation of the superintendent a settlement agreement with Goldberg sagala LLP in regards to a CVA case against the district as listed so move by Laura second by Ashley questions comments all in favor opposed item passes item I4 uh can I have a motion to approve a pharmacy benefits management agreement uh Amendment between Hamburg Central School District and Express Grips Inc effective January 1st 2024 so move by C second by Rich questions comments yeah on the question um Can Can someone just sort of walk me through the process I mean this is this is a this is a challenging one to read so can someone just walk me through the process for reviewing changes and assessing the impact as we as we renew these agreements I'm going to

169defer directly to miss youngberg on that Christine we got all the microphon yeah they worked their way into the middle of the room somehow so they actually are no changes to the agreement prior to this one this is just a change in date and we did hold off on it because we have a new health care consultant um that was hired by the board um at the January meeting so they reviewed the agreement as well and recommended that we approve it and then as they work through the year with us us if they see anything that needs tweaking then and then they will bring it to Express Scripts for the next agreement but right now they recommend we approve it they don't see anything you know off-the-wall of line they review these for other school

170clients as well so it's just the date okay thank you there questions comments all in favor opposed item passes item I5 can I have a motion to nominate Cameron Hall as a candidate for the election to be held on April 22nd 2025 to serve as a trustee for the board of for the board of Cooperative Educational Services first supervisory District of Erie County in a term beginning July 1st 20125 through June 30th 2028 couldn't even say anything by Dave second by laa uh well I I feel like I need to say something here so uh first of all I appreciate the nomination uh obviously I requested it um but this is an open seat it was actually vacated by Andy L uh most of this board knows Andy L he previously served on the Hamburg

171School Board many years ago um and left his position as a as a Bose member in the middle of the year so there's an open seat so I I didn't certainly wouldn't want to run against the incumbents I think they generally do a pretty good job um so this is an open seat I think it's probably good for Hamburg if we have some representation on a on a governing body you know where we send a good number of our students um exactly how many hopefully I'll learn over time um but um I hope the board considers me for this I think it's I think it's a good opportunity something I've been aspiring to for a while and it seemed like a good time other questions comments all in favor opposed IAM passes thank you moving

172on to public expression we have yeah than um just uh we have one uh today um Keith Carlson okay hi I had uh sent an email a couple of weeks ago and Tom was kind enough to call me back and uh address that with regards to class sizes in the schools here I have two kids here at Union Pleasant and one that's being registered for uh prek hopefully full next year um I Tom explained me to me how the uh what the process is that it's always something on your mind um and I just this is the first board meeting I've been to as a uh parent um so I appreciate everything that you guys are doing I just wanted to get an understanding of how it works Tom did a great job of explaining

173that and look forward to just seeing that hopefully we can kind of get those class sizes down a little bit and More in line and evenly distributed across the the school and uh thank you um sorry we got one other one uh Liz Houston hi everybody uh Liz Houston Hamburg school music boosters uh parent of two kids here now um one that was here music Ed because she had such a great experience here that's what she's doing I just want to commend um all of our music department and the students the performers the directors everybody that really worked on the musicals that happened wi Wonka was I mean if you were there it was a world of Pure Imagination it was fantastic and um you know Finding Nemo kids just keep swimming and they were

174fantastic over at Armor but if you didn't see any of those performances the excitement has not ended we would invite you to go see some of the wonderful Productions coming up Charlotte Avenue's Magic Treehouse they have two shows of the night at dawn March 19th and 20th Boston Valley has the Jungle Book kids March 26th and March is music in our schools month so that would be a great time to go visit some of these wonderful performances Union Pleasants crisis on the canal is April 29th and I think you saw some of those kids earlier I had to sneak out for another meeting for a little bit but if you didn't know the Erie Canal has a big anniversary coming up so I think you know Union Pleasant is just ready for that ahead of

175time it's a big preview for that so I think it's 250 years something yeah so yeah big deal so come out and see that one and of course the high schools play Mary Poppins May 2nd and third um these Productions you know my kids have been in all the drama Productions big music kids um they provide the kids with absolutely invaluable experiences in teamwork creativity confidence building and boy oh boy are they tired after I know Em's that firsthand um I know they would love your support not just in the ads but in the audience they want to see you there come see them they're pretty amazing kids and they do some amazing work um you just can't be the work that they do and if musicals aren't your thing there are a ton of

176concerts coming up come and see the kids there there's an awesome um guest artist cont concert um I think it's March 5th I didn't write that down but on behalf of the music boosters thanks for your continued support of the kids and music in our schools we'll see you at a performance soon [Applause] say uh seeing is there uh no other business uh for the board this evening that was our last uh person for public expression uh looking for a motion to adjourn so move by Ashley second by Rich all in favor opposed item passes thanks everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.