001good evening and welcome to the work session business meeting of January 9th 2025 please stand for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all I'm going to start by opening up um the meeting to the public to speak on any of the listed agenda items Mr Ferraro we're coming out strong in the new year happy New Year everybody thank you Happy New Year um I was going to ask if the board Joe can you introduce yourself my name is Joe Ferraro and I live in putter Valley um I was going to ask the board to take a position on people leaving their Christmas lights up P this week um but
002seeing as you have a new policy on the docket to review that seems to be out of line so it's not a Christmas it's not a tree in all seriousness I I I I know you'll probably address this I just want to make sure that uh um when we look at this that this talk about this Pol new policy that um if if it's it looked like online it it was part of West P's effort to kind of or one at least their help was was put into place for it I just want to be I think about all the possible ways the policy could be used as a wedge in ways that the district may or may not want it to be used uh primarily kind of the extracurricular stuff that the district does
003um like honoring uh veterans or or um First Responders that are not necessarily academic or connected to Al those all you know a lot of the nice uh add-ons that we do as a district um that when we review the policy that we look through all possible ways that somebody could say you're violating your own policy by doing these things that are not necessarily educationally focused um so that that's kind of uh what I wanted to make sure that that at least was on the radar I'm sure West put and everybody's looked at it but that's I look at it when I'm thinking about people or persons or organizations that might want to use the policy that you adopt as a wedge thank you thank you it always helps to have another look at it
004from Another Side um okay so we'll start with the consent agenda resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to approve consent agenda items number two through 7 second questions or comments the consent agenda includes approval of the prior meetings minutes an updated substitute listing for this school year approval of additional or unpaid work hours for various staff members approval for sale auction or disposal of building and grounds equipment extending the long-term substitute position of Cameron cruy through the end of the year and approval of csse CPS placements thank you any other questions or comments on any of those items all in favor I opposed abstentions the resolutions pass um reports um we're GNA is that right yeah okay students so we'd like to welcome um Marissa I'm sorry say your name for me
005Marissa Toro say your last name again katoro well thank you Koro um so we always love to have student voice um and student opinions and so we're so glad that you're joining us um so welcome thank uh so do you have a report you and Haley uh yes so yesterday was the High School chorus concert featuring the concert chorus and the mixed choir and next Wednesday January 15th is the high school band concert showcasing the concert band and the wind on Ensemble tomorrow is a big day for our seniors with information going out about prom and how to start buying tickets and looking at all of those prices and an interest meeting is being held for a girls flag football team to introduce a new Varsity Sport to our high school IB dance is having
006a master class with the rockats next week on Friday to learn from professionals and help them with their submissions coming up for their IB tests and James apostolico a senior has just received a scholar athlete award for his academic and basketball skills and he's the first student to do so since 2009 nice outstanding outstanding um so prom yeah are you exciting it's exciting it's our prom is going to be June 12th at the Grand View in pipy nice Grand View that's a beautiful spot okay well thank you very much um Dr Lu did they steal your thunder they us us do it's all right first I want to begin by welcoming Marissa uh normally we see her up on the stage next to heli so we know both of them well um so much of
007my updates this uh evening I wanted to focus on the upcoming Capital facilities project uh right here you see on the website we there's a link right on the main page and there's lots of information that's accessible from this uh main page including the poster uh other handouts links to presentations uh what I really want to do is just provide a quick summary as to how we ended up here our website's not working so well right now it's uh spinning yeah I had a trouble doing it here too so this work is really the culmination of two years of work uh that began with the convening of a facilities planning committee which is constituents from across the community teachers parents community members staff members all coming together we reviewed a wealth of information including our
0085-year longrange plans we did building tours we developed priority lists we started putting budgetary numbers to those priority lists which means lots of things get eliminated because you spend lots of money really fast but this project is the final work of that group that went on for two years the most important piece of the entire project is the fact that it is tax neutral so what that means is by virtue of using several different Revenue sources including $9.2 million of state aid $2.5 million of our Capital res Reserve fund as well as replacing retiring debt that we're able to accomplish the entirety of this project without raising taxes uh it's not to say that your taxes will never go up our regular general fund budget will likely result in some tax levy increase but that
009tax ly increase will not be attributed to this facili project which will be cost neutral uh information's available everywhere all over the website we have another listening hour coming up next Wednesday before the 4th grade concert no before the scho high school the high school concert or something else before the fourth grade concert it's a different meeting um lots of meetings so next Wednesday before the high school band concert there'll be a a listening hour here at the high school upstairs so anyone who has inform would like more information or has any questions we encourage them to stop by and a mailer will be going out to every address in putam Valley within the next week or so I believe they're going out tomorrow so who however long takes to mail it deliver them from
010there and again that has a ton of information absentee ballots are available uh on the website or by contacting our district clerk Moren Bolino and I encourage everyone to seek the information they need to make an informed decision and cast the vote on January 28th from 6:00 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. at the elementary school okay I'm sorry jerman can you go over why it has to be that day why it's in January sure so the timing of the vote coincides with when the construction must begin in order for us to bring this project online at the same time a previous project is being paid off that's what allows us to complete this work without raising taxes so in order for that to happen our construction start date has to be the summer of 26 being
011a school district the obvious construction period for us is really July and August so $14 million of work completed in two months in the summer of 26 and two more months in the summer of 27 is a significant amount of work to accomplish in a very short period of time we don't have a year- round construction cycle we have to have our buildings open and accessible at the end of June and back open and accessible in the beginning of September so it's a very short period of time where a tremendous amount of work needs to get done so in order for that to happen it's about an 18month process from voter approval to use the funds to breaking ground so if we do the math that brings us back to the winter of 25 for
012when the vote must be held I know there's some inconveniences for some of having a winter vote um ourselves included right it could snow that day the vote still goes on and it's Our obligation to ensure that our campus is accessible and voters can make their way to the polls to cast their pallot so the reason for that is um in order to start in the summer 26 we have to have a vote that is in the winter of 25 if we wait until May that brings our construction start date into September which cost us an entire year CU we can start construction in September uh in an occupied building so that's the reason for the winter vote date thank you thank you any other questions about the project so sorry I skipped my first
013part I did want to start by wishing everyone a happy and healthy New Year because this is the first time we're back since then we uh continue to have debriefs and follow-ups from a security incident that happened prior to break and I didn't want want to lose sight on those efforts continuing uh we continue to work with the sheriff's department as well as our school security consulting company our buildings are scheduling their next round of trainings as well as our district Emergency Response Team and that work continues as always we also are looking at the possibility of another energy performance contract which includes the installation of more solar panels at the elementary school so the way those projects worked is essentially the savings that's generated from the sustainable energy or green energy is used to
014pay off the cost to install it so that's still in the very uh beginning stages but that's something that we are continuing to explore to find our to find ways to make ourselves less dependent on outside utilities I thought we had maxed out the roof space where we could put solar panels at the elementary school we max out the roof space that's not that's end of life we don't consider a roof to be until it's ready to be replaced because we wouldn't rip up a new roof to put solar panels in so that work typically coincides with when a roof needs to be replaced that's the opportunity we also wouldn't um if a roof's 5 years from being replaced we wouldn't put solar panels on it because then that increases the cost we have to
015take the solar panels back off in order to fix the roof okay so we're looking at uh a wing of the elementary school that's it's actually out of warranty now but the roof itself knock on wood is not having any issues but we know that could change it any any time so we're trying to line up when that roof needs to be replaced an opportunity to replace the roof and install solar panels without there being any cost to the taxpayer because essentially the savings of the um solar panels would pay for the replacement of the roof and again it's it's not a done deal it's something we met with a company right after break but it's something or over break it's something that we continue to explore so we hosted a family holiday potluck dinner
016and I want to thank our community aons uh for putting that together uh Maria and Judy they did a fantastic job there was a great turnout much uh many different options of food to choose from uh they had some outside vendors come in and share some of the resources they can offer to our community and it's something that I expect will continue year-over-year and hopefully continue to see more and more support from our community we had many concerts our Middle School had their concerts our elementary school had their winter sing along along we had our High School Coral concert next week is the band concert uh we welcomed our puton Valley High School alumni back for breakfast up in the library then they have the opportunity to speak with our Uh current seniors about what
017life in college is like I don't know if I should be happy or sad to report not much has changed in the many years since I graduated from college lots of comments about the food choosing your roommates sleeping Arrangements lack of privacy and what a waste of money it is to buy all the textbooks which is very sad but was definitely the case when when I was there as well um make sure you need the book before you spend all the money on it so also on to those capital projects I've mentioned before we continue to have meetings we've had faculty meetings at each of the buildings we met with the PTA last evening we've held Q&A sessions at each of the buildings we have had had a listening hour and another one scheduled for
018next week There's a mailer going out to every household in puton Valley we have trifolds that'll be available in public spaces throughout the community there's posters in the buildings for all the activities uh youth basketball uh High School sports everything that happens every time there's a concert or play anything that's going on in their buildings there's posters available for the community to see and that's it for my recent events some of the upcoming events we have I mentioned before next week is our high school band concert and the week after that is the fourth grade concerts Wednesdays are a very popular day for concerts around here and that's all I got right now thanks okay thank you very much so we're going to start our presentations um the first presentation um is our 2025 26
019budget presentation um so good evening everyone it's me again I'm going to lose my voice uh so so this is really the kickoff for our budget season and I'm really going to do a quick introduction and I'm really going to turn this over to Dr Grace Chan our new assistant superintendent for business administration and she's really going to lead this show throughout the budget development process um so I'm just going to start with a quick reminder of as always our budget is built around our district vision and core values so child first and foremost building a foundation for the future and our core values Community opportunity res and empowerment those are the conversations we have throughout the budgeting process to ensure that we're putting our money where our priorities are and these are really what
020we use to guide those decisions a very not inclusive list of some of our priorities we wanted just to sort of touch some of the big ticket items that we anticipate on supporting during the get ready for this 25 26 school year the numbers getting too high to comprehend uh so as always we're looking for ways to find new teacher leadership opportunities we're continuing our investment in the science of reading so we've done a tremendous amount of work over the past several years investing in our Scholastic Reading Program as well as fundations and the hegerty program uh we continue our expansions of the middle years the IB Middle years program our Middle School is scheduled for authorization this spring likely end of March beginning of April and our high school just received their confirmation that
021they are now a candidacy school for the middle year program so as was our plan all along as the Middle School comes Online The High School begins their work uh likely in two or three years the high school will then be looking to come online and that'll offer our students technically 612 in puton Valley realistically it's a 512 IB Continuum for students beginning in fifth grade of the Middle School straight through their High School experience and really it's our belief that the middle years program will better prepare our students for whatever um uh depth they go into the diploma program here at the high school we're continue our work at alignment of math instruction utilizing programs that are transitioned seamlessly from grade to grade uh DBT dialectical behavior therapy is something that we begin this
022year that will continue next year again trying to get to the root cause of issues uh specifically student behavior issues and um really making connections with students uh work on writing Continuum from grades 8 through 12 that's work that Jackie is leading with teacher leaders throughout the buildings that uh making sure that we're providing students with prerequisite skills for the grade before to be successful in what is ultimately a very writing intensive program once you get into the high school uh focusing on culture we have Dr Holly will be coming in to speak at upcoming superintendent meeting continue our future of Education work around generative AI artificial intelligence and advanced learning Technologies and know we've provided several updates on that that work will continue uh continuing our focus on Executive functioning this is something that
023we don't think this personally not not you two but some students not board reps are are lacking uh executive functioning skills it's feedback we get from parents it's feedback we get from teachers it's feedback we get from students themselves uh it was actually a focal point of the alumni when they came back there was a lot of conversation about time management not procrastinating they're going to give you a month to do it don't wait till I won't name names but I a picture um who was saying it all right don't wait till the last minute to do the project you had a month to do so uh again executive function extremely important uh starting at early grade levels but certainly more so as you approach adulthood uh restorative practices and behavioral monitoring this is something
024that we continue to see not in put Valley but across the region students and schools there is a mental health crisis uh a lot of it focused on social media cell phones uh as much as I appreciate the governor's efforts I don't think Banning cell phones in schools is going to fix the problem because students use those cell phones way more at home than they ever do in school and that's where most of the behaviors most of the issues we're aware of start outside of school and then make their way in afterwards rarely does it ever start in school and then some of the facilities work as we've shared at previous board meetings uh by next year we hope to be completing the scheduled Field track and fencing replacement here at the high school uh
025so putting down new Turf resurfacing the track and replacing the fencing that's essentially falling down and hopefully next year we'll also be talking about the designning planning and awarding of the upcoming infrastructure project that will be up for public vote on January 28th so that's a quick look at our district priorities and at this time I'm going to turn over to Dr Grace Chan to talk a little bit about what our budgets look like thank you thank you Happy New Year everyone I just want to give a shout out to my team Moren Karen Debbie and Matthew because everything I do is representation of my whole team okay so I'm going to start off with a little bit about the historical data of the district basically I'm only going back 5 years um you'll see
026on the screen the bottom line is the tax cap in red and the percentages each year are aligned there and the budget change from year to year is the blue line on top and you'll notice that when the blue line is up there like for instance in the 4.94% year the tax cap was only 1.49 so those years the district had to make up the difference in Revenue in other sources which we will get into but I just wanted to show you what happened in the last 5 years and this you might be very familiar with it's how do we calculate our tax cap but I try to summarize this because the formula is actually very long and I don't want to bore you with it maybe there are some items that you wouldn't understand
027what's going on there however anyone who wants to know more about that is free to come and call me at the business office I'll be happy to show off everything that we know to start with we always use the last year's approved actual tax levy which in this case was 41 milon 330 and then where we have to timeses it by the tax-based growth factor which is specific to putam Valley every single District gets their own number which is this 1.02 the reason that's specific to your district is because it's actually a factor based on the physical changes in the taxable property such as new construction homes stores and offices is not just the mere change of the assessed value of the property existing then after we multiply that we come up with a sub
028subtotal which is 41,43 to that we would be subtracting is what they call the net prior year tax Capital uh Capital exclusion this 1,204 there's actually a few lines that go into this number this is a number that was produced from last year then up to this point we have the prior years tax levy limit then the next thing that we multiply it by is what you call the allowable Levy growth factor the lesser of 2% or CPI and this is what you read in the newspaper when people come and ask why does the newspaper say is 2% and our percentage is not 2% it's because the 2% the newspaper is talking about is this number right over here and I'm just going to make an assumtion [Music] sound say D I didn't give you
029the sign that's what I was thinking this is the first time that's ever happen write this [Music] down hi again it's me again um so after we multiply by the 2% and I'm just putting this in here now as an assumption based on what I'm reading in the newspaper about the economy then we come up to this number of 41 million2 to that we have to add the current year Capital exclusions again this is several lines that go in here this is part of Where The Debt Service comes into place when uh Dr Lu talks about this in the Capital Improvements we also subtract um any building aid from here and then we add back any Capital exclusions some Bose's Aid it's a few lines that go into here we don't have that number yet
030right now which is why I put it as to be determined that will help me uh decide what the 2526 allowable tax levy is if you notice I have a little Aster here because historically putam Valley does not go to the actual total allowable tax cap we go a little bit under that okay which means we're not asking the taxpayers for everything we're allowed to and then I usually show you a percentage change in the tax levy uh this tax cap will be uh due March 1st so prior to that you will know the information um that comes out of this so the job of the business official and the the tax and our department is to make sure that we come up with a balanced budget so we work on the expenses which we're
031doing already which include instructional programs we look at the administration we look at supervision we look at Transportation the facilities and other Capital Improvements we come up with a number when I come up with that number then I go back to this side and see okay what's my allowable tax levy then we look at state aid which at this point we're not really sure what's happening with the foundation Aid it's another to be determined figure then we have miscellaneous local revenues for example when you invest in the N class uh in the last year there was a substantial amount of interest income that was earned uh we're our hands are tied we can't do things like invest in the stock Market we have to follow the school laws the other thing that would be in
032your local revenue is like when you charge a tuition to the Garis and students that come here that would be a local Revenue that we gain then we have some fund balance that we can use to help uh balance this budget so sometimes we will use that because we need to to uh balance the budget because we can't ask the taxpayer for any more than what we were told in this allowable tax levy and then finally we have reserves which are meant to be used specifically for what they were put away for and I like to pull those out and use them because I think that that helps uh the expenses that went up and we need to make sure that the uh budget is balanced we would need the revenues from some of those
033reserves from year to year it may change so in the budget development we have a lot of challenges that are pretty similar every year and pretty similar for most districts first and foremost is the contractual salaries which have an increase of anywhere from 2 to 6% um that's probably 75% of my budget you know because align with that are all the uh benefits that come with it then we have to contend with the inflation which at this moment is not too bad inflation is about 2.7 but in March it was 3.6 tax cap is basically going to be around that 2% and then we have the state aid Foundation formula which I said is going to be determined by what the governor decides um then we have health insurance premium the increase right now is
034closer to 3.9% the pension rates we already have the ERS is at 16.5% it's up from 15.1 last year and the TRS is 10.11% most of these do go up they I've only seen one year where the TRS rate actually came down then we have special education costs which are unknown it's the increase between the in and out of District tuition Transportation cost is going up we have a contract but I think I spoke to Dave spittle was something like 3.5% um then the last piece is that the AR Federal stimulus funding has already ended where you were able to depend on that money as additional revenues to balance your budget that no longer exist what's the next steps in the budget development well we have to have a meetings the cabinet will have meetings
035with the principles we'll have to identify efficiencies to maximize savings and I know in the business office we have already started doing many things um this year we are instituting educational data and time piece those are software programs will work efficiently and we'll need less people to do the work that we're currently doing we'll be able to buy supplies at much lower rates because we're part of a Consortium that will go out to bid for that um then we will finalize Personnel Staffing and then we will finalize the allowable tax cap and then we will resolve the state aid which is to be determined and we'll finalize the budget which will be due by March 13th another thing that's happening is the budget development top uh timeline we have on these dates these people these
036departments will be coming to do presentations so this is something that you might want to put on your calendar to tune into Until the End by May 20th we will have the vote and we do this for the kids thank you any questions when will we know our incoming kindergarten [Music] class so the tial answer is September 25 um we I could tell you already there's 50 something students that have already registered which is better than last year uh we typically push for a big registration drive and start our screenings in February so we typically get a few more students that sign up in order to make it through the screening process in February but the reality is is as that's sort of that's const constantly a moving number when we get to March February
037March we're going to have to make a determination based upon sort of historical Trends what our anticipated Staffing is going to be so we know how to budget accordingly for that so we had a really small class this current year a smaller than usual class the year before so we're hoping to reverse that Trend to start getting larger classes back in but I think February timeline we'll have a better idea where we stand but I do know as of right now we have about 50 something students it was 50 but you know there's been a couple more since then so uh that's where we stand right now I'm going to put you on the spot on something I don't expect you to know this number if you do I'll be impressed from their enrollment beginning
038of September to now any like how much have we increased any idea yeah I don't know that number off the the top of my head I know we co reversed a trend which was neutral right we would lose 30 kids we would gain 30 kids we would lose 60 kids we would gain 60 kids after covid I think the 18 months after covid we gained 165 students more than we lost so that was certainly but those kids were spread out across 13 grade levels not just all kindergarten students it's my belief s that since that time we've continually gained students not at that same rate but we definitely gain more students than we lose um they're just again spread out across many grade levels I can we do have that number we track it on
039a spread app I just didn't look before I came what is it7 97 see Dan's got access to it um that's how many we gained but you don't you don't know how many we lost no I don't that's gain I don't okay okay so it's 97 minus however many lost but we it's as number of students who remove left the district is much smaller than that number okay thank you and Garrison students when will we know that number so it's not official we have been notified uh for sure that there's nine students that are committed um maybe a 10th is coming on their way so that would be 10 additional students on top of the 13 we had this year and the three I think we were up to the year before I know we
040gained some students after their freshman year so that continues to far exceed our expectations I know the first year we were hoping for like just like one brave soul give us a shot and uh we got two and then we had a third one and then the next year we got 13 of like 18 kids and we were like holy smokes um we were ready for this but we I mean I would take all of them I I would I would love the opportunity to and I have to say the feedback we get from them we had the opportunity to go present at their board meeting uh obviously they come here they visit our schools the feedback we get from both the Garrison students and the Garrison parents is they love the feel in the
041culture of our building they love that our students are taking them on tours when they come for the parent evening they love being able to partner up with our students and to get tours their buildings and those who are interested I think we had 15 students who spent the entire day here in putam Valley shadowing a student so that's that's a tremendous percentage of their students that are at least interested so we hope that Trend will continue Transportation remains uh an issue for them it's a long day the way the transportation works for them is they essentially do high school runs like we would and bring every kid back to Garrison and then all of those students split up into three buses for a second bus run every morning so they pick up all of
042their kids they bring them back to the building and then they get on either a Hing a puton valley or an O'Neal bus for the next step of it now we have students that are in sports and now they have late buses so distance is an issue I'm actually really curious to see what happens when like that large group of 13 start becoming seniors and driving and are they taking the Juniors with them and I feel like that would alleviate a lot of the transportation uh concerns that they have are we're going strong great thank you thank and I'm sorry one more question uh Grace you mentioned the District Operations efficiencies um will that information be included in one of these budget discussions probably not we're that's already in place right now and and we're
043pulling it up but I can answer any questions you have one of the uh vendors that I brought in is educational data which a lot of districts have that and it's a bunch of school district that they represent and go out to bid for everything so we're already buying those supplies but now we're going to get a much lower rate and also the the way that we buy it will be done very efficiently because once we have purchased everything the first year the records will be there and it'll be online website the teachers won't have to put all their orders in before they rush out for the summer holidays what happens is that once the budget is passed we would open that up it's a separate website and it's web based so they don't even
044have to be here then they start ordering what they want and they will have a limit that was placed on that by their principal and then it will go directly to the principal to approve and then it'll come into the business office and then when it's all approved this bulk order happens in the summer all the POS are created by the company so no none of the work is happening on our end any longer whereas we used to have to show that we would get three uh quotes find the lowest price this this is the lowest price so we won't have to have the main office secretaries do any of that work and then every year at the end of the year they will prove to you that you saved money and I've brought this
045in in many districts and um I'm really thrilled that this is something that's going to happen this year so this is already happening as an efficiency model for us the other thing uh that I have been bringing in and we we're almost there is the time piece which is a mechanism toay pay people overtime whereas you currently pay them by having time sheets signed physically by everyone and at the end of the day the superintendent signs them all and it's a pile like this that's being taken away and is done electronically now it also will speed up the process that the payroll person will be able to pay people on time right now it's a mad dash to get all those papers in figure it out put it into the system there a lot of
046work that happens behind the scenes after somebody hands the paper in it's all done in the business office and the administrators who have to sign this and sometimes when they don't get to it it holds her up and and she can't pay the payroll and that that includes people who don't even get overtime so that's been a stress on her she's planning to retire in 2 years and I need to make that job very streamlined so that whoever replaces it I mean we have to use technology we're already in 2025 so so those are two things and um I'm trying to slow down what else we do because it's a big change for a little District when you've had the opportunity to do things in a different way for so long but honestly um in
047all districts that have much more students and teachers and Personnel it can't be done this way and it isn't so that's why they created this thing that's time piece and and we're already on board we started this process back in in July already and we're almost ready to uh roll it out right out of the gate thank you first time I jumped in front of Sam so go ahead Sam yeah thank you uh real quickly I was a little alarmed to see the the one post of salaries 2 to 6% and I have to tell you 6% is not tenable in this economy within our community where did that come from so they contractual it includes step so the contractual increases so as you know like teachers go up a percent over the year and
048they go up a step so there are salary increases when you consider this incorporates the step percentage and the step I'm glad you clarified that so the contract to contractor year-to-year increase is more like 2% but there's also a step that has to be figured in some a budgetary standpoint we have to budget a 6% increase it it wasn't clear the way it was put because it somebody I made her change it she had 2% so yeah somebody's base was 6% and I'm saying who do we pay at 6% a year based upon last year we also gave the full percentage which was percentage end step I didn't want to be I didn't want it to go the other way and say we said everyone's only getting a 2% ra I understand and then if
049you do the math you see that people are getting much larger ra you may for transparency purposes you may want to State base salary around 2% we that so people understand thank you thank you Dr Chen questions thank you thank you Dr Chen thank you I just want to thank you for bringing some um just fresh perspective to the business office about ways in which that they can be more efficient and work smarter not harder um I think that's just great the creativity that's gone into it um yes we are in the century we're in and sometimes we just do things the same old way because that's the way they've been done and we're comfortable with that and change can be good so thank you so much that's great I've received very positive feedback about
050what I rolled out so far good keep going good job thank you okay I'm just lining up for the next one so our next presentation is the first reading of the policy um 2075 maintaining District neutrality on non-school related matters so I could just provide a quick overview I don't know if we intended on reading the policy uh I'll lose my voice before I get to the bottom of it so someone else will have to do that um so this policy is just really meant and I appreciate Mr far for bringing up uh a way to look at it that I can't say that I've considered so now I want to reread it through that lens of Are We is the policy precluding us from doing other things that we typically do do uh so
051I'll certainly reread it to make sure that's not the case but really what this policy is meant to do is to capture what we have said time and time and time again in public meetings that um every employees personal life is their personal life and their professional life is their professional life and never shall the two cross especially when it comes to talking about controversial issues uh political social or economic issues so it's it's an understanding it's our practice it's something that everyone's aware of we talk about it from new employees orientation through the year they retire but we didn't really have a policy that pulled out all of that into one a succinct piece and that's really what the intention of this policy is this isn't a change in practice this is what we're
052already doing but this is essentially codifying what it is that we practice which is there's personal beliefs uh religious political social don't have a place in school and unless it's directly tied to the curriculum should not be a topic of conversation amongst our students and staff and the um again the the force of this is comparing a regular phone call to a text message well I got a phone call and um uh I didn't understand it you know ah but I got a text message it's in print now I understand it this is important we need this in writing for all our employees and uh you know uh School District related officials to understand that this is our our district policy on neutrality on non-school related matters and and Joe I I I do not
053believe it will stop us from recognizing our veterans or our EMS people they're part of our community and uh to to show respect for them I don't think that interferes at all uh but as Dr said he he'll reread it uh I've read it quite a few times I like it I think this is what we need something in writing that's there that's uh we we can send people to and take a look at it this is this is our district policy this is important and I thank you Dr Lu for preparing this um students what do you how do you feel about teachers being neutral or students being neutral or and still having opinions I mean like how does that do feel between student teacher opinions like between the student and the teacher well
054yeah or students in class or teachers in class or well I think that any political religious or any beliefs that they have should be kept well obviously outside the classroom and outside a conversation between a student and a teacher because I just don't think there's any room for that in the classroom especially with everyone having different beliefs nowadays um I think it could strike problems within the classrooms in the community unless it's a part of the curriculum that's been assigned okay that's what I feel about yeah I feel it's hard because there are some things that are put out there and you never know where anyone's getting their information either so having unwarranted conversations about specific political views and things like that in a classroom it's just not an appropriate setting for some of those
055conversations and I think that this is definitely important in making sure that staff members know this thank you yeah good thank you great Insight yeah yeah I agree so maybe we all need to reread this before we read it out loud I I I I I think as is I would really like to adopt this tonight uh the longer we wait you know we can have an individual come to us and say I never knew about this where's your policy that states that we need to be neutral in the classroom we don't have it this is it we need this on the books tonight uh we we've been dancing around this issue now about 3 four months this has to be part of our policies this is important we we need this neutrality especially in
056the classroom um we can't risk uh that that uh my boy that slippery slope and Sam we it's on the agenda tonight to approve the first reading and in two weeks it'd be on the agenda for the final right MH well that's what I'm saying let's not stall it let's let's do that and uh approve the first reading and then uh you know if somebody sees any changes on this I don't see any changes I think this is excellent and our two students certainly represent this point of view uh we need to have this on the book so that an individual can't come to us and say I didn't know about this what are you talking about you spoke about it when did you speak about it like I said a phone call means nothing
057you have it in writing like a text or an email that means something we need this in the books really I I'm very adamant about this I haven't heard anything that would lead me to believe that we wouldn't continue on the path we already on right we approve the first reading now and then that'll line us up as we typically do uh to approve it the next meeting and yeah it would be then it would be in the book so I don't think there's even if we made changes we can make changes between the first and second reading so uh I agree with you I think it's in pretty good shape but I have no problem taking another look at it um but that again that if that was the case we made changes we
058could wait we could do another first reading and then we the second reading next meeting to not slow it up anymore um Dr L can you just review the policy distribution what the plan would be for that so I mean obviously all policies are available to anyone in the community online uh they're also uh embedded within our student some of them are embedded with our student and faculty handbook so Our intention for this policy would be to embedded in the next printing of our faculty handbook so faculty handbooks handed out each year or signed off by faculty each year and that would be our way to receive sort of authorization that everyone's aware of it another policy we spoke about doing was once the board adopts a new policies so we're finishing up our complete
059review of all policies once we finish our code of conduct and as the board continues its policy review process our plan is to then send out updated policies as they come along uh to faculty and staff and that'll be our way to keep them up to date of any changes we can't do that when you're changing hundreds of pages at a time like we have been this year uh but once we get to just the revision process that's our intention is that we will continue to update them policy by policy as they change moving forward but in this case we anticipate this being part of the faculty handbook and certainly something we could send out to faculty and staff via email will there be a conversation around this um with faculty so that they understand
060the intent and the spirit behind it um I I think it's clearly written but someone else may not right um and I I think that that's important because it it can be a place of sensitivity for some people and I think that they just understand that we are we are doing our due diligence as public employees we are protecting all of the students in our building all of the faculty members in our building by remaining neutral when we're in our positions of official District capacity exactly um and I think that that's that is this that is the spirit of this I think that that just needs to be clearly communicated um that that's what this is about and I I do think that it would be good to have a conversation in that light if
061possible um if that's not advisable then that's fine but uh I think that it should be more than just distribution sure so I have no problem of having a conversation with my building principles about incorporating this into an upcoming uh faculty meeting it's my honest opinion I don't think there'll be one inkling of surprise from staff this is what they've been told since the day they were hired this is what their expectations are day-to-day maybe the only surprise may be that it's not already a policy so I don't expect there to be really much push back or surprise amongst anyone but I have no problem of um letting the computer go to sleep um I feel like I should know the password but I don't oh is it written in front of me sorry if
062you don't want me to know you shouldn't print it on the computer um this is this is not a typical meeting I apologize you know we get a couple weeks off all of a sudden the wheels are falling off batteries are dying computers are going to sleep um so yeah I I think there'll be no surprise amongst faculty and staff but I have no problem of finding another way to make sure understand really what the intention of this policy is okay and again it's important to have it in writing we don't and that's why this is necessary I agree good thank you again Dr thank you okay while you're there you want to do the calendar discussion that's why I'm here okay um okay so this evening we're going to talk about the first draft
063of next year's school calendar so this calendar as always is based off of the draft Bose's calendar that we were provided we want to be as in line and in sync with bosis as possible because we obviously share students between those two institutions and it B serves as sort of the model for all of the districts in the region to help standardize when instruction takes place this is a pretty typical uh calendar there's not a lot of surprises at the end of the day once we meet our 186 day contractual requirement it leaves us about two days um that are sort of floating vacation days or floating recess days and when they may be utilized so we'll talk a little bit about those when we get there uh as we have for many years now
064we would start the year August 2728 superintendent conference days we would give faculty and staff the Friday off to extend the Labor Day weekend uh in September we have schools opening the Monday after Labor Day we have the Russia Shana holiday in October yapor and Columbus Day November our typical conference day during election day as well as Veterans Day and our Thanksgiving recess so in December you'll notice this calendar reflects School recess days on sept on December 22nd and 23rd in this calendar that's where those two sort of floating recess days have been placed that would give faculty and staff and students two full weeks off for the December break alternatives to this calendar would involve making the 20 2 and 23rd instructional days and then moving those recess days somewhere else in the calendar
065um so if you're wondering like well what would happen if we add this day those are the two days from this calendar that would sort of be up for grabs December 22nd and 23rd we could have the first day off to be uh Christmas Eve on the 24th and some schools are doing that then we have uh MK in January our February break is typical uh superintendent conference day actually coincides with Eid on in March for any students that celebrate that our April spring break is early so from the LA end of March to the first week in April and then we have Memorial Day and then the last day juneth on the 19th with an anticipated last day of school being the 26th of June as always the give back days would be four
066of those days uh during the spring break everyone except for Good Friday which we have ta obligations to give off and if snow days there's two give back days if we use utilize no snow days those give back days are always around Memorial Day so it would be the Friday before and the Tuesday after and if we only have one snow day it would just be the Friday before 182 student days four superintendent conference days a total of 186 total days questions comments suggestion on the 22nd 2 third of December you could put one of those days on Wednesday the 26th of November as you did this year and the other day uh put it on the 22nd of May which in the past we've done before had the Friday and the Monday off for
067Memorial Day or the Monday after Easter or the Monday after Easter right those are all possibilities yeah this is just based upon uh obviously both our CCA and our teachers union uh gave feedback when they would request but it's ultimately the board's decision the board sets the academic calendar for the school year what what is bosis doing do we know what their calendar looks like both is a little different because they're giving days uh uh religious holidays off that we we haven't had the same uh requests for they're closed for dwali and for Eid so that's those two extra days that's how boses is utilizing them let see um this I think it was last school year uh there was a little bit of a conflict between Passover and uh Easter and the way the
068dates fell has that been looked at yeah and this calendar year I know Mar I looked at it it falls during the I think it's April break yes I think it's I the spring break so yeah it this year captures both Easter and the beginning of Passover oh yes in the Lunar New Year which is a New York state required holiday falls on a Saturday this school year so there's no obligation to give an additional day off for it so that's one day you typically would see um that's not on this year's calendar I have to say both these went forward and did the next few years the 26 27 calendar is going to be interesting Labor Day is very late it's like the 6th or 7th of September yeah will likely be uh looking
069to bring students back prior to Labor Day cuz if not not you're going to run out of days really quick we would lose our February break or our spring break almost in its entirety is is it possible to bring back the suggestion of uh giving them the Wednesday off for Thanksgiving and the Friday off for Memorial Day to to our employees and and see how they react to that uh and and the reason I'm saying that is that that's two straight days right before that long break and it is a long break uh I I thought it was great that we brought our people back for Thursday and Friday right after the break and speaking to some of the teachers cuz I attended the senior uh said youer you weren't getting yelled at like I
070was no they my your way back no they they they said you know this this really gives us time to ease into that you know to kind of phase in into the school year again um so so I don't think there's any need to bring it back to the unions when I meet with them we just they know the options right they they're well aware of what the options are I mean myself as you know working here before I I would have loved to have that Wednesday off guaranteed almost every year because that really helps for Thanksgiving and then Memorial Day it's summer you want to get away and to do it on a three-day it's given the Friday it would really I I I think be beneficial so I don't disagree with Wednesday before
071Thanksgiving because that's I say but you have to think from a parents lens um giving them off the 22nd and possibly the 26th and the 27th that's a lot of days those parents um have to take off of work for um for the kids if if they're not in school what what was it you mentioned May 22nd and if we have to give back snow days that would then would be I assume the 26th and the 27th correct so that's three days oh I see what you're saying so that's that's just a hardship on famili sometimes that we have to keep in mind I think that all of these ideas are great I will say I did hear a lot about the two-day comeback versus the five-day comeback being a much better transition yeah than
072the 5 day but again some people really wish they had had the two weeks off during the holiday season so you know I I think that it really is what our employees need and and if it works out well for children I mean that's number one always but I think all of these options pretty much do with with the exception of that consideration for for May maybe we want double think thought just based on the snow day piece um and perhaps the Monday after after Easter being a consideration for another option um which like if you host Thanksgiving or Easter the Wednesday and the Monday matter so I will just say that publicly that that's a good point I would have problem that was the decision that was made this year the reason we came
073back to Thursday and Friday if you look at this year's yeah calendar was we had those two extra days being the Wednesday before Thanksgiving and the Monday after Easter right but that was what the the unions had um preferred for this year I I I have no problem with the Monday after Easter or and that Wednesday so yeah you're right uh Janette I agree with you about the Memorial Day not a good idea right because it's snow days but the the Monday after Easter and uh that extra Wednesday uh Thanksgiving um for me if I were working here I'd love that yes you would but I I don't work here anymore if you were cooking you would love it even more this is the easiest thing I do all all year long it doesn't matter
074as long as the numbers add up I don't care what days we pick yeah and I don't think it's too challenging for parents I think it's very similar to what we have done in the past and also to what surrounding districts do so yeah those options seem good I agree so maybe what we'll do is we'll draft a second calendar uh that has the 22nd and 23rd as being in instructional days yeah add the 26th of November and the 6th of April as days off right and then the board can essentially vote between the two next meeting and then we'll adopt a a calendar at the next meeting will you get you'll get input from the unions about I I I don't think I need to I mean they're welcome to I've already met with
075them both we discussed all of the options beforehand okay this this reflects what the what the request was but I don't know that either was strong or passionate about this versus what you guys are suggestion I have no problem reaching out to them and seeing if they have feedback on it this I typically go with what they what they request because it makes my life easier than if if this is what they prefer for next year then I would ask the board to consider that we give that to them because it it's not any easier or harder on parents either way um it's going to be what it's going to be the days or the number of days um and I think what they what our employees need right now for their breaks is is
076the better decision to make so I have no problem we'll create the other the second option okay I'll send both options to both our CCA and our teachers union and I'll just ask them if they have a preference a b or indifferent between the two and then I'll just share that information one may pick a the other one may pick B and the board's still going to have to decide okay I I but I have no problem of sharing that information I it would be my guess that a lot of people didn't realize that um you know utilizing the 22nd 23rd for the the Thanksgiving and the Easter break um you know might have even been an option so they may have just looked at this and said oh wow two straight weeks yeah right
077and now given that other option to extend Thanksgiving and Easter you know the the Passover Easter break um I think they they may jump at that but I don't know so essentially our conversation is Friday before Memorial Day Monday after Easter Wednesday before Thanksgiving Christmas break pick two so they're well aware what all the options are the yucky part of this is that Christmas Eve is the is the would be the first day off it it right and that's where I think the two weeks matters to people some of the concern is what's the instructional what's the academic rigger on the 22nd and 23rd of December leading up to same type of riger that we had the Thursday and Friday when we came back at least the holidays were past us at that point again
078I have no problem of coming up with the second option and sharing it and I'll I'll provide whatever feedback I receive from the unions uh before the next meeting thank you okay adopted tonight table get that resolution okay yeah okay all right thank you all thank you okay um so we're going to move to new business okay resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to accept the resignation of computer support specialist Laura shwood from the district effective the close of business on March 31st 2025 for the purpose of retirement as per document 10025 attached to the agenda and official minutes of this meeting I second very reluctantly uh questions or comments yeah going to be a great loss Laura has been a a steadfast advocate of of all things Technical and computer-based and
079it been a great resource uh I I remember when I was at the the Middle School how important her role was in getting the kids to get used to the laptops when we first Ed hesy first brought that into the district so she's been a real star in that and we'll be greatly missed how difficult is it to fill that position in March difficult I would imagine really very Yik so I do want to acknowledge uh obviously Lord will be a tremendous loss to the school district I noticed is something that she um was not looking forward to doing uh something that she um really thought long and hard about before uh making the decision uh but I having once lived in the technology world have the greatest respect and appre appreciation for the technology
080staff we have here in Pon Valley and the amazing things that they can do from the hardware side of the software side to the data side um I just I want everyone to understand in some districts that's three people um that Laura and Dan and Alex and everyone else does in this District uh one per building so uh Laura will certainly be a tremendous loss it'll be nearly impossible to fill the shoes she leaves behind behind and uh we'll see we hope we get a strong candidate someone who is willing to put in the effort to uh match uh her um success she's had here in the Middle [Music] School all those in favor I I opposed abstentions the resolution passes number two please resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to accept
081the resignation of Campus monitor Denise pelino from the district effective the close of business December 20th 2024 as per document number 11-25 attached to the agenda and official minutes of this meeting second questions or comments all in favor I I opposed extensions the resolution passes number three please resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to accept the resignation of put Valley Middle School teacher Daniela Mary from the district affected March 31st 2025 as per document number 11425 attached to the agenda and official minutes of this meeting second questions or comments I think it's always hard to lose somebody in the middle of the year or you know she not at the end right she's actually she's been out a leave she's the decision to resign to stay home with her kids so we
082have the teacher who's been in her place uh for the beginning of the school year will remain in her place for the remainder of the school year so that actually in this case there'll be No Interruption for the students okay excellent uh all in favor I opposed abstentions the resolution passes number four please resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to accept the resignation of teaching assistant Stephanie shelab from the district effective the close of business on January 15 2025 is per document 11625 attached to the agenda and official minutes of this meeting second questions or comments along the same note Stephanie is completing her teaching certification and needs to complete her student teaching portion so uh she's been fantastic for us we would welcome her back in a second but she needs
083this time to complete her certification so she become a certified teacher sure best of luck and she's going to stay in the district right she doing her student teaching um is she doing it here okay I would have to get back to you I'm not sure if she's doing it here okay all in favor I opposed abstentions the resolution passes number five please resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to appoint Roseanne bracket to a 4-year probationary term as a teaching assistant commencing on February 3rd 2025 and terminating on February 2nd 2029 in the teaching assistant tenure area on step seven of the ca salary schedule Miss bracket holds teaching assistant level three certification second questions or comments all in favor I I opposed extensions the resolution passes number six please resolved on
084the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to appoint Lisa Jennings to a probationary appointment as a school monitor effective January 6 2025 with a probationary 52 weeks January 5th 2026 at the elementary school on SE three of the ca salary schedule second questions or comments all in favor I opposed extensions the resol resolution passes number seven please resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to amend the appointment of Melissa Clemens approved at the business meeting of December 12 2024 as follows appoint Melissa clemet to a six-month leave replacement position as a special education teacher at the elementary school effective January 6 2025 through June 30th 2025 or sooner at the discretion of the board of education on Step 1 MA of the pbft salary schedule Miss Clemens holds students in disabilities B through
085uh birth two and six initial certification second questions or comments uh she was originally appointed at the daily rate of pay pending uh receiving her certification so we've received confirmation of her uh credentials and now she'll be moving on to that step all in favor I I opposed extensions the resolution ution passes um number eight please resolved on the recommendation of the superintendent of schools to appoint the first reading of policy 2075 maintaining District neutal neutrality on non-school related matters as per document number 110-2 attached to the agenda and official minutes of this meeting second questions or comments all in favor opposed extensions the resolution passes we are going to table number nine can can I make a request uh for number nine we never asked the students input what they okay they think sure
086do you have the calendar in front of you uh yes you heard the recommendations that were made yes to take those first two days of the Christmas holiday and put one at Thanksgiving one at Easter or Memorial Day what what's your preference what would be your preference um and that happened this year this calendar so far right well it's very Sim what happened this year except for this year we came back for the Thursday Friday right yeah I thought that was great I mean me personally when I came back on the Thursday Friday it got me into the ease of everything without having to do the long awaited 5ay comeback as opposed to the 2-day and then have the weekend to really come back to the school and get a you know get back into
087things um I mean it was pretty various between other student students I mean that was my personal opinion some people wanted the longer break um but I don't think it really has too much of an effect on students rather than it does staff and everyone above what I think it was nice actually that we did come back because we came back to a block schedule so we were actually able to get stuff done in our 80-minute classes rather than just coming back on a Monday and kind of doing oh what did you do over the break and do more we actually were able to complete certain things I mean I had a quiz on Monday when we came back for a test we went over the material in the 80-minute block good so the big
088difference next year is you're coming back to a 5day block regard yeah that's the only problem the two days fall at the front of the front end of the vacation but I think the same thing those two days give you time to you know all the Friendship things that go on prior to a long holiday like that would be taken care of and then you come back and boom you press well the day before was also well needed too before the Thanksgiving um I agree I think that was very um efficient yes I agree especially if you cook yeah as crystal said my my daughter did Marissa was baking pies left and right yeah I just want to say my daughter did also mention coming back to a block schedule was a dream for her
089so I don't know maybe we should consider that regardless on the day that we come back maybe we can do block scheduling on day ones one and two Mr melow if you're listening thank you thank you need a motion to table a second okay so so move to table next meeting second questions or comments all in favor I I thank you maren thank you Mar yeah um so public comment on any topic oh Joe still Joe Ferraro still live in puton Valley um just more on the on the policy I'm I'm I'm full in favor of the policy pretty much as written I just I I'm thinking about as Devil's Advocate and unintended consequences uh something that comes to mind is why are we doing a pledge of allegiance in a classroom because that is
090not educational and you know tied to um I mean so somebody could argue that right so that would be uh something that might be an unintended consequence that a parent or a group could be this does not fit within curriculum why are we doing it in a classroom being directed by the school um not my my problem is just a matter of thinking outside of just kind of all the things we assume would be the right thing are not necessarily for everybody going to be the right thing thank you thank you J uh okay um upcoming meetings so I just looked at my sheet and every saw all the things that I skipped during my presentation um so before I talk about the upcoming meetings I'll talk about some upcoming events so our science research
091has their PowerPoint practice night I believe next Thursday Tuesday Tuesday Tuesday uh so I know that's coming up our science research PowerPoint practice night is coming up our I spoke about our superintendent's listening hour at the high school 6:00 p.m. next Wednesday School band concert uh 700 p.m. next Wednesday the elementary school PTA fund fair is scheduled for Saturday January 18th from 2: to 400 p.m. and I had mentioned the fourth grade Winter concert the following Wednesday the 22nd at 700 p.m. and the next board meeting presentation is scheduled for January 23rd and that is our combined curriculum instruction presentation facilitated by Miss Jackie LaVine um co- facilitated by our building principles so they will all be here curcum instruction budget next meeting plus there's a PTA meeting on the 13th yes yes right General
092PTA I heard the superintendent will be there to talk about the capital project it's busy it's a busy week next week no doubt okay um board member comments I just want to again uh compliment our our music department uh every which way to Sunday the elementary the Middle School uh and last night uh the High School chorus was phenomenal they did uh you know works from leabra the the play and and um Saigon um misson excerpts from that and some really outstanding mus musical Renditions uh a lot of spiritual and and folk stuff that I just love my only recommendation is they need to do look to the rainbow from Finian's Rainbow in spring right we're going to avocate for that look look look to the rainbow follow it over the hills and I love
093that song now we're definitely that really we have I wish I took a picture of the girl faces I wish I would have recorded that record we can watch this over and over again and we could zoom in we have a phenomenal arts and and music department here and it's just so prideful well I'm always I didn't go um dealing with other issues but um I'm always impressed by the the variety yes um music from other cultures from other other countries from other eras you know it's it's just the variety and it allows students to to see all the possibilities that are available in music so um I think our music department is amazing so it is magnificent another piece of that though is um like our theater tech department I just want to give
094Susie a shout out um she's just so great with our kids and she certainly has put put my daughter to work and she loves every moment of it how she did that I have no idea but um she really gra kids gravitate to her and she really teaches them and she's on them and she reminds them and she's teaching them about those executive functioning things time management you got to be here on time you can't be late they're depending on you I mean it's just really beautiful what happens in that theater overall so I don't want to forget the people who are behind the scenes um making those shows really possible POS so thank you so much to Susie and all the work that she does there uh any other comments um not that not
095since the last meeting we Jeremy Dr L had mentioned um the elementary school sing along along the holiday sing along along right before school was out and they did a wonderful job and the district office employees like Mike played in the band yeah and they just did an amazing job it really got you into the spirit holiday he did such a fantastic job we let him go home an hour early I I missed it because it was at 10: and I couldn't get there at 10 I I wanted to attend that because I love it those kids and Dr podesta comes in just waves their hand it's like magic they sit down they're quiet and then they get into it you know it's really great I would tell you who to blame but I have
096to go to a meeting with all of them tomorrow cuz P of Valley was open for the full day till the last minute needless to say there is absolutely no snow and no reason to dismiss an hour early so I apologize to those parents whose days we ruined it's okay yeah and the sing messed up the timing of the sing along I know okay you had a crystal ball yeah stand on my record I'd like a motion to adjourn the work session business meeting so moved second questions or comments all in favor I good night outstanding and happy New Year good