CorpusRecord 138476

BOE Meeting, February 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / West Seneca Schools
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,626 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001hello uh thank you everyone for being here for the Tuesday February 11th 2025 regular board meeting West Sonica Central School District um I will begin with the pledge if Adam and Emily from East Senor could step up to the podium and lead us please [Applause] I pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you hey we're going to move on to roll call when I call your name please stay present I do want to mention that Loren is joining us via Google meet because she is attending the capital conference in Albany tomorrow's Lobby day in the legislative office building where she is advocating for issues that are important to our students

002and schools and thank you so I will start with Mr vanderlip here pres Mr Maloney pres Mrs porac sorry sorry Mrs Greenberg pres uh laoren I can't see your name t Pres pres um okay I'm going home Laura present Ed present I am present pres thank you now I'll hand things over to Dr Cruz thank you happy to share my superintendent's Report with you if you don't mind pulling that up please thank you some exciting news uh just earlier today we had a surprise presentation here at West Elementary School with Dr Kristen frowley um Dr Fry and also photographed in this picture is Taran nikasia a special education teacher here at West Elementary they pursued a grant um for the school and they were uh the the award recipients of it there's several grants that

003the New York State retired Educators Foundation Awards and most of the grants are $11,000 in nature the grant that was selected for West Elementary is a $2,000 Grant to help them to buy supplies and materials to continue their community service projects that they have with their special education students so congratulations to Kristen and Taran and thank you for your leadership and your pursuit of those Grant funds also wanted to highlight um if you have an opportunity to visit the Western New York Credit Union the lobby of the credit union is featuring some amazing artwork from our students so art teacher Chris gy from West Senior uh has helped to facilitate this project so congratulations to them there are some amazing performances going on in our schools uh just earlier this morning at Northwood Elementary our

004first graders had a Valentine's Day performance where they invited their special loved ones to come and see them recite poems and do songs and it was a beautiful event um that I was happy to be part of this morning it is also the season of school musicals uh just recently West Elementary performed the music man we also had The Adams Family performance at West Middle School and the amazing performance of lay Miz at West Senior High School and all of our students certainly Shine On Stage um the real culmination I think for us to be able to celebrate is the efforts at the elementary years and and middle school years and what that ultimately leads to at the high school level if you had the pleasure to see lay Miz um I I shared that

005this is my fourth time seeing lay is um one of those experiences was at Shay and buffalo with Off Broadway actors and our students and that performance was better than the performance that I experienced at shaes the the number of talented students um was exceptional and such a pleasure to witness and I know some board members were there as well and I'm sure concur in that yeah uh right now Elle Elementary is celebrating one school one book to encourage reading so schoolwide all families and students are reading the same uh book and that's a way to promote uh literacy in the home and to promote the importance of reading recently I hope you were able to catch this on wgz news I have uh linked the segment for you here Channel 2 News was out

006and featured West TV and the television production uh that occurs on a daily basis at our high school so it was wonderful to see our students uh shine on local news as well and Clinton Elementary made Valentine's uh to deliver to senior citizens so a lot of wonderful things going on um both to support the community and just to celebrate the good work in our schools I would like to also publicly highlight and help spread the word of a new bus driver referral program that we are launching in an effort to recruit and retain school bus drivers we have a new school bus driver referral program if an employee refers a school bus driver on the uh completion of their probationary period the new school bus driver will be eligible for a $500 incentive and

007bonus along with the referring employee so we hope that upon that completion of the probationary period we are not only recruiting and attracting new bus drivers to our district but also promoting the retention of bus drivers so we encourage anyone uh who is interested to find out more by visiting our website uh West senas schools.org jobs to find out more about that program it's the season for upk registration upk registration is now open and families are encouraged to apply prior to the April 4th deadline that is the deadline to ensure participation in the lottery certainly people can apply for upk after April 4th but that would be Post Lottery so if families really have a preference on getting into the site of their choice they're encouraged to apply early so that they are in and

008fully registered by April 4th for the upk lottery and then I just wanted to share with the board some updates uh we just recently passed the midyear point of the school year and uh it's a great time to look at the progress that we've made so far as we reach this midyear Point our strategic planning committee has been meeting through throughout the fall and winter and this is a a cross group of stakeholders who are each sharing their diverse perspectives to help steer The District in our strategic plan the outcome of that strategic plan will be a long-range plan for the district that will help guide our goals and help guide our resources but in order for us to identify thoughtful and purposeful goals we really started this fall with analyzing data in what way

009are we performing well and meeting expectations as a district and in what areas do we have opportunity or room for growth so to help us with that we have analyzed thus our student attendance data our in school and out of school suspension data not only the rates and frequency of suspension but the nature of the behaviors that our students are engaging in that lead to suspension our 3 through eight New York State assessment data for ELA Math and Science our Regent exam data and graduation rates so we have gone through and done a a really deep dive and Analysis in a number of different data points and our next steps will be based on what we know and the analysis that we've done what are some proposed goals that we would like to articulate to

010help uh make some strategic improvements as a district I anticipate that I'll be sharing with the board by our June meeting and update on that strategic plan our proposed goals and also action plan which would really be the steps that we're going to hold ourselves accountable to meet those goals by our June meeting additionally this fall we launched a budget advisory committee meeting which is again a div diverse group of stakeholders that has been meeting uh throughout the fall and winter the goal of that committee is to increase transparency and communication around the budget development process we recently launched a thought exchange and the question question is posed here on the screen what are the top priorities that we should keep in mind as we develop our school budget for 2526 and Beyond and so

011if something like advocacy around class size or advocacy around clubs and activities whatever it may be that is a priority for our stakeholder that they would like us to keep in mind as we go through that budget development process I would participate or encourage the participation in the thought exchange so that that feedback can be shared with our leadership team and also with the budget advisory committee that thought exchange is open and we will keep that open for the remainder of the month and then lastly I just wanted to get on your radar some upcoming events we have another Community closet that will be held at the Ebenezer building where families will have access to winter coats and clothing and things of that nature uh the dates and times are listed here for your reference

012we also have um we enjoyed all of our wests side school musicals and now are are coming up the East Side school musicals so Shrek the Musical uh will be occurring right after the February break at East Senior High School so uh information on how to obtain tickets are available on our website also some upcoming meeting and events that I wanted to make sure you were aware of uh later this week on Thursday evening we have our next redistricting committee meeting um on Saturday night there's the East versus West hockey game at the harbor Center at 6:30 I've been advised to get there early because there's also a Bandits game that night uh we have our winter recess February 17th through the 21st the next board meeting is a work session on February 25th and

013we have a board of education meeting on March 4th so thank you I appreciate your attention I'll turn it over to you Ed thank you that was a lot of great things going [Applause] on move on to board president's report um again my report is very basic I want to just point out the board members and all our activities again you're are you currently in Albany are you already there yes excent wasn't going to drive after the meeting thank you excellent um uh again we're making a point to attend uh 10 different events and I believe we're all doing a great job of uh sharing that work um whether it's interview committees um different committee meetings I know we had one before the um meeting today where you guys came early for it we have

014our safety committee meeting um I've see people at the musicals sporting events um is there anything that the board here wants to that I haven't highlighted that we've done whether it be Erie County bosies or anything that we're failing to mention at this point well it it again again a it's appreciated how much effort everyone's putting into all the different things so we can work as a team so thank you on that um we'll move on to public comments um is there anyone here who would like to speak I do not have any names signed up currently if they do if they want to come up to the podium excellent you saved me 3 minutes of reading something I think um we'll move on to our school Spotlight um East Senior High School our school

015Spotlight for this month is Adam and Emily if you guys can come back up to the podium did a great job with the pledge so we'll bring you up for some more are you going to perform something from Shrek I can't wait to see that hello we are Adam and Emily scripsi we are both students at West an East Senior we are here on behalf of roppa we're talking about our contributions towards Black History Month next one uh rap is the social studies National Honor Society the senior it was established to promote scholarship and to recognize Excellence amongst high school students in the area of the social studies its mission is to encourage interest in understanding of and the appreciation for the social studies an important component of this organization is to provide service to

016others in our school Community the following slides our group's contribution to and celebration of Black History Month in our East Senior Community every day we have an announcement following the Pledge of Allegiance these are all written by members of roaa on a special committee one of the announcements that I wrote is from Mya Angelou and it says do the best you can until you know better then when you know better do better these are the wise words of Maya Angelou she expanded the diversity of literature and theater across the world she was the most influential African-American poet and writer of the 20th century sharing her story with the world and promoting civil rights and doing the things she loved Miss Angelou has taught us that one needs to look at the past to help improve

017the present and future thank you for teaching us the value of doing the things you love in life um throughout throughout the month of February we also hold many uh scheduled events for a student body to enjoy um one of the these include uh door decorating which we had had a competition for this past week um today we had uh which I know Dr kruer participated in a hiop workshop Central uh tomorrow we have a after school movie ride to Freedom the Ros of Park story and on uh February 25th after February break we have an African drumming workshop with the africanamerican cultural center of Buffalo uh these are our winning doors this year these were uh on the left was the door from uh Miss Cala who is our uh AP biot teacher at

018West sen East and then on the right is uh was inspired by princess in the frog that is uh Mrs GLA our AP US History teacher door so and then these are some pictures of our some of our students hard at work uh decorating our doors so again this is a picture of last year's hip-hop Workshop this year I heard it was more fun than last year and it was just a better course it was it was more fun everyone enjoyed it it was a great way to get the student body together with about 35 students participating and yeah it was a great experience I as I uh previously stated this year's feature film is uh ride to Freedom there a Park story uh it's we're going to uh hold it in the library it's

019about an hour and a half long hour 45 so um I think we have 30 35 students signed up as well for that and these are some pictures from last year our movie last year was hidden figures which focuses on African-American women at Nasa and we enjoy snacks after school have a great time watching and learning about African-American history and then this year for the first time ever we'll be welcoming the African-American cultural center of Buffalo to teach the US the art of African drumming you're very excited to experience this since as I said it's never been done before at our school and uh that's all so thank you uh board for allowing us at from each senior Rapa to show you what we're doing to celebrate Black History Month at EC so thank you

020thank you thank you thank you great work so did you guys if you don't mind me asking a question so when you did the door decorating did like the class kind of come up with the theme or the teacher or how did you guys so we got in groups of two to four and we picked a teacher that we wanted to decorate like I picked my French teacher Mr O'Donald shout out him if he's listening I doubt it but anyway uh so uh anyway millions of viewers so um we we picked you know uh important influential African-Americans to uh Spotlight on our door so uh for example I did KY mbappe the French Soccer Star uh another door we think there was Katherine Johnson from the hidden figures movie uh yeah there's many others right

021I yeah just curious about what the collaboration was like thank you yeah sorry for the question great great work well done [Applause] guys yeah okay no just check um sorry just checking to make sure we got a photo of that um we're good so we will move on to four Personnel um certified I give up um may I have a motion on agenda item 4 a I'll make a motion Vince I apologize motion to approve sir yes okay I'll second all a second um is there any discussion on 4 a uh all in favor I anyone opposed pass the 70 so now we will move on to 4B may I have a motion on agenda item 4B I'll make the motion B makes a motion to approve for B may I have a second second

022or seconds okay is there any discussion on this good okay uh all in favor I anyone opposed passes 70 now we move on to 5A create classified positions may I have a motion on 5A should we go the trifecta I make the motion oh jerem me motion to approve sir yes motion to approve 5A may I have a second please I'll second It Go with the second from Albany okay any discussion all in favor I anyone opposed pass is 70 we move on to a consent agenda consent agenda are items 6 through 10 uh may I have a motion to approve our consent agenda I'll let you guys flip through if you need to I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda motion to approve consent agenda items 6 through1 thank you may I

023have a second if anyone's ready no rush if you're not I'll second I'll second the consent agenda Jeremy second it and you're third in it we got you um any discussion on any items throughout here we typically don't discuss consent agenda I know I want make sure everyone's right through it and we're good okay all in favor I anyone opposed pass 7 Zer all the way through to the [Applause] back okay now we will move on to 11a I'm looking for a motion on 11a please I'll make the motion Jeremy motion to approve 11a may I have a second Laura second any discussion on 11a obviously it's um uh several uh several hires any discussion on that coaching positions no okay all in favor I anyone opposed anyone abstaining I passes 60 with one person

024abstaining got it we move on to 12 new business yes and we're going to do the introductions perfect Sor now now now we'll do some introductions though before I move on thank you Mr viian my favorite part I can't believe I skip it on tonight's agenda uh the just took action to approve some Personnel appointments um some of whom are in attendance tonight so I'd like to ask Dr John cervone to to join us um to recognize some Personnel who are in [Applause] attendance I really love this I really do thank you so much uh Board of Education uh Dr Krueger uh excited to welcome several Personnel appointments to the West senica family I know I'd like to I know the top one is here for sure U Mrs Brady would you stand for a

025moment I'd like to recognize Mrs Robin Brady who's been appointed as our director of humanities she currently serves as our principal of Winchester Potters congratulations principal Brady you have some some supportive uh friends and family here would you like like to introduce who you have with you oh yes yes I have my this is my son Warren and my mother Chris my son Christopher and my husband Joe nice thank you all for being here and supporting we are so excited for you to take this new opportunity and I know Winchester pot Community will miss you but they'll still have you around in a different capacity so congratulations thank you so much my understanding is no other appointments are here but if someone is here if you please stand to be recognized all right I'd also

026like to note uh there were several uh permanent appointments tonight and are classified and also sever of our retirees which we will recognize at a later meeting uh so I just congratulate all those folks uh and different milestones in their career so uh you'll see our list of retirements here and typically it's in our June meeting Dr Krug and I have already started conversation about what that recognition process will look like I like this one um and I don't believe unless are any our retirees here don't believe so oh oh he didn't know Mr the please stand be recognized thank you congratulations having the chance to work side by side for several years I'd like to thank you for your service to our district and all your work uh throughout your career in education and

027Beyond so welld deserved congratulations I think that's all I have wonderful thank you thank you John lot lot of great people up there they can come back at Subs right thank you for that and we will move on to 12 new business may I have a motion on all business which are items 12 a through 12 l hopefully a motion to approve I'll make a motion to approve I'll motion to approve 12 a through 12 yeah I'll second it got it second is there any discussion on anything we um my favorite thing again is the trips looks like we have one World Language going to Puerto Ric go softball team is going to Cooper toown that's that's actually a good place for softball team to go yeah excellent where is it further down uh letter

028k h i j k oh nice the Yorkers Club I think they performed here once a couple at some point right no am I thinking of someone else no I'm thinking of someone else yeah I think there's someone else good to go okay I'm done with discussion all in favor I anyone not in favor pass [Applause] 70 13 is informal informational documents and we'll go on to 14 that are in here yes she is sure for the next agenda item which is our school calendar Dr Sharon logren is welcome to join us at the table for the discussion of this agenda item U one of Sharon's responsibilities is facilitating um with our union leaders a discussion around the school calendar and so I'll let her share some background on the development of the school calendar

029for the 2526 school year uh that's before the board tonight for your consideration thank you I didn't see you behind Jen that's okay Stadium okay so thanks so much for having me up here thank you um once again we um each year we meet with our committee which is representative of all the buildings the levels and the different unions to talk about the upcoming school year and reflecting upon the one that passed we uh utilized the Iran bosis um um as a framework because um they really um work with all the local districts and give us the the dates that they are proposing to be off which then subsequently we do our best to mirror so that it doesn't impact our students attendance and any of our boses or special programs so that is the

030framework and then we work backwards within our contractual obligations for work days within our elementary folks um the holiday as well and the proposed professional development days of the Bose's calendar um which you'll see those there's four days that are in red um and then those do count as student attendance days up to four can count as student attendance days um in addition to that we also worked with our W wsta leaders because um in order to uh begin the year in August that is um something that we negotiate with them and um it did match the Bose's dates so we did do that and they were in favor which then helped us gain days uh at the beginning of the school year and started the our student proposed first day is um Tuesday September

0312nd which matches the bosis calendar and our other uh local school districts so that worked out quite well um in addition we um were able to keep the Wednesday um before Thanksgiving which has been a favorite over time for the past few years so that stayed in there and um we really looked to um in conversations about the half days of perhaps being something that was a little bit more um Troublesome for for coverage for families over the school year so we did eliminate some of those um minus the work days related to the elementary trimesters which we do have built in and still try to meet at least one half day or two for um our other uh secondary families in December which was close in proximity to Elementary day as well and then

032we're able to also keep in this year the uh Friday off before Memorial Day and um and then certainly um we always have to build in our snow days and again we have uh three built in for this school year um as in the couple years past we were fortunate in the sense that when we did have snow days and we were over um with the governor declaring a state of emergency that kind of gives us a clean slate and so we've been fortunate for that but we still had our three days built in and um I know just to of note um this year we did have the Lunar New Year um added as a day off and I just wanted to in case anyone was wondering where that fell this year it falls

033during our February break on Tuesday uh February 17th so therefore it was already encumbered into an existing um break for our students so we didn't have to build that in but in case you are asking where it was just of note do you have any questions on that at all we're good I just wanted to first of all thank Sharon for her leadership and facilitation of the process and working with the calendar committee on this and also to to thank Wista our West senica Teachers Association because contractually they are not obligated to come in in August however doing so for our two superintendent conference days gives us much more flexibility during the school year we will be starting school as Dr l um mentioned on Tuesday September 2nd which um is is generally you know

034starting school after Labor Day but given that that's uh September 2nd that's really one of the earliest starts to the school year um that we can possibly have in in any of the calendar scenarios so uh this is really a a great calendar in terms of giving us some flexibility building in necessary snow days and I think we were really responsive to feedback that has been discussed at the board table and also feedback that we get from families regarding the strain that half days caus families for child care and so we really are in this calendar meeting our contractual obligations there is contractual language regarding half days for not only parent teacher conferences but also for report card and progress report uh preparation but trying to be responsive to the needs of our families and

035I think the this calendar does accomplish that um I just want to say again thank you for everyone with their hard work especially on the around the Christmas I know um I think the day of Christmas when I realized my kids had to go to school later that week it was I think it was tough but I don't feel like they got a lot accomplished anyway so I really appreciate you you guys working on that um the other thing I really appreciate is the uh I guess you would call them maybe takeback days um where if we have too many snow days they come back um that's something you know just over the last several years I think we've started to do and I I think that's a great I think it's a great thing

036to know I really like it that we post it and talk about what they are so families can be aware of it the question I have is and it this is probably the the wrong way to ask it is Good Friday a legal holiday like are we going with the 10th and 9th because Good Friday is like a holiday or is it for a takeback day if we need it am I clear on that question like what I'm asking Friday I believe is the third this year yes I know the 10th would be the first one to go which is the following Friday so I was wondering why the third wouldn't be the first one to go is it because it's good Friday it's a holiday okay that's what I was asking yeah I wasn't

037sure it who celebrat yes just don't why anyone and the first one day called back would be the Friday before Memorial Day and then backwards from there I know we in the past have looked at potentially February however the weather is still is so unpredictable in February that it doesn't make sense if we were trying to pull back from there and then we're still under yeah I think it's days so yeah and I apologize I thought you all had this in your folder already so we were pretending like we were following along but you were such active listeners because you didn't have it so thank you um so yeah again I do appreciate it I think it's a great idea and I love that we post it um anyone have anything else on the calendar

038just um I know we talked about the Bose calendar and I can't recall did we February break the bosis they've talked about resending that week and adding that week into the spring yes in this calendar because school can start really one of the earliest States possible you you can't go any earlier than that with Labor Day being Monday September 1st this is the most advantageous calendar for the maintenance of the February break but there is discussion that in subsequent years we're really bookend as a school district with Labor Day and then the region exam schedule and with the addition of the lunar holiday and also juneth that's two additional days that we may need to schedule in it depends on where they fall just two years ago juneth was on a Saturday as an example

039but if we have a scenario where Labor Day is later and we also have to account for the juneth holiday and the lunar holiday I anticipate I mean that the reality in the discussion is there's simply not enough time between those bookends of Labor Day and region exams that that the February break may be reduced in Niagara County Schools where they often still maintain a two-e break uh to coincide with the Easter holiday their spring recess is two weeks they get off President's Day Monday and Tuesday so it's an extra long weekend in schools back in session Wednesday Thursday Friday so I think that is a reality that we will be faced with in future years but not this calendar however if you look at the December break where Christmas and New Year's Falls this

040year there will be the solid two weeks so that's really nice too the way that that fell I like that so I'm not looking to upset anyone but are we working towards having heat days is that a thing so those would be also the ability to have a snow day really it's an emergency closing day due to inclement weather and so having a calendar that allows for heat days is something that that we need to to be prepared for that could occur either in September at the onset of the year or come May and June I mean it could be October around here so you never know um but we are I mean that's an that's a active thing this upcoming year that we have to deal with starting September okay yes so it was

041on tonight's agenda as a presentation for us to have some dialogue and discussion as you know from the agenda this is not an action item tonight we wanted to get gather any feedback and then we'll put this on an upcoming board uh agenda for the board to actually adopt the calendar annually the board does adopt the calendar so we'll uh work as a tenative calendar at this point assuming there's no feedback from the board I would anticipate this would come before the board for formal adoption at at the next meeting cool any other feedback I'll make my annual comment on uh January Regents week and the need to have students in school as much as possible possible during that week given the the number of students who are taking regen exam should be reducing every

042year um obviously we had a weather event this year that created a scenario where you had to get them done in a couple of days um I just feel like that needs to be looked at I think that seniors and other there's there's other opportunities for students to do things in school than opposed to being just out of school for that week I also to kind of follow up on the discussions that we're having among superintendant regarding the February break I think that is also a reality in our future as the portrait of a graduate and the Blue Ribbon commission and evolving graduation requirements it allows for more Pathways for students to obtain their diploma other than simply the passing of Five Regents exams to obtain a diploma and so with that um students may

043have other Pathways to get their diploma and won't need to come in for a January Regents exam should they not pass an exam in June or in August so I think I think that is something that is on the horizon as well okay thank you I just if I could ask a question kind of off of that for my awareness and for clarity of anybody listening or watching how long is a region six down if it's one subject on one day they have to take two hours have up to three hours unless there's extended time written into I okay so it essentially would be a half day and we're losing a whole day even for all students morning and afternoon which is why it's the justification behind it but our numbers of kids taking exam

044has put it under question for us the last couple of years yeah thank you I just want to confirm that I I agree with Vince in that meeting more days in the classroom in the reg Region's exams being cancelled or not the regent exams those days being off days for anyone not taking the exam is in their room so thank you I appreciate that great question so because of the snow event this year we ended up moving them all to one day or something like that or so the snow days um if I'm not mistaken were Tuesday and Wednesday Regents exams that were scheduled for those days we were able to push to Thursday Friday so the Tuesday exams were administered on Thursday the Wednesday exams were administered on Friday we still had until Monday

045for the scoring and rating of the regent exams so we we do get guidance from the state on how to respond if there's a noow closing and what's allowable by the state those are secure exams that generally are given across the state on the same day but if there is a closing of school or some emergency circumstance we do have the flexibility to reschedule those in a window of time any makeup or rescheduled exams had to be done by that Monday okay so we're not choosing regions week to be the way it is because of us locally here it's a Statewide kind of thing the state actually outlines which exams occur in the morning and in the afternoon it may be earth science in the morning and Algebra 1 in the afternoon and they map

046out that entire week it's a 4-day testing week Monday is a holiday 4-day testing week for those exams okay excellent thank you for the info sure are you you good La I guess just to follow up on that can I confirm is there a contractual obligations for the teachers that those are days off for them or no there's no contractual language related to it but the one um reality of the circumstances we do need individuals to Proctor the exams uh testing site proctoring ofam exams for students that have uh individualized education plans they may need certain accommodations test read separate location extended time and then we also have to have teachers available for the scoring of exams so should we have students in session during that time we would likely have teachers out of their

047classroom for a day half day but potentially multiple days if there are special education teacher who's administering testing accommodations so we would have teachers released from their classroom for proring and scoring assignments and substitutes in their place thank you sure great thank you anything else on this good okay you may be seated thank you Dr lock thank you thank you very much you're welcome we will move on to um a presentation from Young and Wright or discussion uh Tori and Brandon if you guys want to join us up in the I think we've got your name tag right over here thank you and I think we feel is also going to join us um for this for the the financial aspect of of what we're about to share oh sorry thank you so to to

048get us started um I'd like to discuss and young and Wright is here um to add some detail regarding the current status of our middle school and high school auditoriums um to to remind everyone this was something that was in a proposition to voters uh last winter just over a year ago um that proposition was a three tiered vote for our community and the first proposition was was supported and that involved replacement roofs and the redesign and restructuring of the West senior parking lot um however the proposition related to school auditoriums was not something that was supported by our community at that time and so we're sharing some additional information regarding the current status of our school auditoriums um and our plan to respond to that which is really investing in our future and investing

049in our school facilities so the current status there's really three main areas of the auditoriums that we're going to talk about tonight the first being the rigging system and the rigging system is the pulley system that occurs backstage to allow us to raise and lower any of the props that we have backdrops lighting fixtures things of that nature all four auditoriums so our two middle school auditoriums at East and West Middle School our two high school auditoriums at East and West senior high schools are all original rigging systems to the building um more than 50 years old and so those rigging systems are beginning to fail and so what that means is we have sections of the police system that simply do not function any longer we have to work around them for any of

050our theater Productions um at West Senor for example I was on the stage and got a demonstration when you move one police system and raise and lower a backdrop another one inadvertently moves on its own which it should not be moving um there are some sections that are simply inoperable which really does limit what we can do on our theaters um and and limit the creativity of our Productions our lighting system there's really two sections of lighting one is the house lighting and the house lighting is the lighting that is above where the audience sits the other section is the stage lighting and that theater lighting that would be spotlighting our children who are performing on stage in both situations both the house lighting and the stage lighting are in dire need um at all

051of our schools um the house lights are original to the building the bulbs are at such an age and such difficulty to get that we are having to buy them on on a secondary Market um where we are paying between $4 and $80 per light bulb and when these light bulbs blow they don't just fizzle out um I was talking with the course teacher at East Middle School and while we had students in the auditorium one of the light bulbs burst and that that literally is an overheating of the light bulb it bursts the glass containment of the bulb shatters and Falls below at that time when that particular light bulb blew there was no one um sitting directly below it but there were students in that space we use our auditoriums every day as

052instructional spaces for our music programs and in some cases even for study halls if we have large study halls so they are used all day long um as I'm describing you know as you can see our system is old replacement bulbs are difficult to find and very expensive there are some pieces of our lighting equipment that we cannot get replacement parts to so we have dead zones on our stage uh areas on our stage that are simply not lit and while um as I passionately talked about our performance of lay is I was also really looking at that through a lens of functionality and some of our shining stars on stage were in the shadows they were not shining um there are dead zones on our stage where there is simply not lighting or the

053ability to to replace those light bulbs so we have dark spots on our stage where whether it's a band performing an orchestra or a a theater production our students are really not um being shown the way that they should be we currently spend approximately 10,000 a year on supplemental lighting because our lighting is so poor we are renting and bringing in additional equipment to supplement the equipment that we have that is operable and that expense of 10,000 a year has really been put on the backs of our children um through the fundraising of our music department uh through their theater Productions they're taking proceeds when they host a School Musical instead of those proceeds getting reinvested into costumes and and equipment for the stage and props our students are having to spend money from their

054musical proceeds to rent theater lighting so that they can have more appropriate theaters and then lastly is the current status of our sound system uh the sound systems are not original to the building but in all four schools they are more than 20 years old and again finding replace Parts is becoming more difficult and more costly as things are no longer in production and the current system is really unreliable so that is the current status I'm going to turn it over to our colleagues from Young and Wright um who also conduct our building condition survey and know our buildings really well um what is in dire need in our buildings to be replaced or repaired and they're going to add some detail to the overview that I just shared with you so I'm going to

055turn it over to Tori and Brandon and thank you both for being here tonight of course thanks for having us um yes so as Dr K me mentioned this scope was included in the 2023 Capital Improvement project and the data that was pulled from that was based on your BCS um so once Dr krugger brought to our attention that this might be an item that you're interested in addressing sooner rather than later um we had our BCS team pull the records um that they were just able to get done this past WI winter um so that way we could look at the current state of the theaters um not much has changed obviously since those previous records um but the images that you'll see here are from those recent um BCS records um so the

056pictures that we have shown here are focusing on those three items the theater house lighting system sound system and Stage rigging um so these images are from East Middle the next slide shows it at West Middle so you can just get an idea of the age of this equipment and then the following slides are um East Senior and West Senior so across the board um they're all in pretty much the same state um and condition so this potential project could address those three items um and then thinking about schedule just to get an idea out there for you guys to see what this overall timeline would look like um if this was to vote in may we would start the design thereafter and there's kind of two scenarios up here so the design is shown

057in green and then in red is the S review time the one on top is the typical review time right now we're showing about 6 months luckily SE review times are coming down quite a bit but you know that's always a moving Target so that's just something that we'll do our best to track but we'll keep our eye on it is that um is that due to the fact that they did that thing where if you pay them extra money they'll quicker yes the third party review so the scenario below you'll see that red bar is a little bit shorter that would be a thirdparty review if you guys wanted to expedite the process a little bit we could go through a thirdparty review to someone's pal and we're good exactly yes so this is

058just a preliminary schedule that we work with you guys um and then it could go out to bid and uh construction could take place and I I have had some follow-up conversation with our colleag from Young and Wright regarding this timeline and if there's any way we can trim on the design process and that design timeline ideally I I'm going to push I I want us to to be experiencing Construction in the summer of 26 um we're really kind of hanging on by a thread here in our theaters and as you can see our costs are continuing to escalate the longer we wait not only will the construction costs continue to escalate but also the equipment is continuing to escalate this project today will cost us more than had it been supported um just over

059a year ago that's the reality of the situation every year costs of Labor increase and cost of equipment and supplies increase and so I am really pushing on in what ways can we trim down that design time use the third party review process to expedite the New York State Department of Ed red section of the timel line that you see there so that we can really try to have that construction starting in the summer of 26 um which will just benefit our kids sooner so I don't know if there's anything you want to add to that yep so since that request we've reached out to our Consultants so for this type of project we'd have a theater consultant electrical engineers and Structural Engineers that would um we would need their assistance to design this so

060we reached out to them to see what their timeline would be um we also reached out to the theater consultant to see how long the lead times are for this sound equipment and um um all the lighting equipment um so I'll let you guys know when he says that um and we also reached out to our construction manager to see what's feasible to get done that's a lot of work at four theaters I don't know if one summer could get all four done or if maybe we could do two a summer or if it there's a way we could work during the school year um start with the worst one and work our way through all four so we're looking at different options like that that we can present to you guys and you guys

061can kind of see what suits best for West Sona two questions for you on there the um the third party review um it's a private like kind of review and it moves quicker because it's not the actually state do so there's um firms throughout the state Jan and Wright is one of the firms that reviews it we can't review our own unfortunately but so it gets sent to another architect and engineer and they review it and then gets sent back to SC and they can decide if they want to do QA QC with additional architectural and Engineering comments okay so is that is that a guaranteed bump up on the timeline or and have you seen any experience with it so far where it has given a has failed um we've seen it go both

062ways so it started again this past October we've had projects that have gone through really quick they say about 8 to 10 weeks and we've experienced that we've also had projects that are still waiting to be approved that were submitted in October third party third party but would they have probably taken longer if it was through the state or you not sure it depends yeah just curious I once paid an extra $100 for overnight shipping and when it didn't come I needed it and they're like well we'll give you your money back I'm like I needed it right so I was just curious like there's no guarante there's no guarantee yeah and now we're seeing the typical SED review times have come down quite a bit um I believe it's like six to eight weeks

063now for engineering which it was approaching 30 weeks not suan ago so okay and this this may be a you guys question but when when you present us if we're going to put it up for a vote we have to decide before that which route we want to go or nope it's really just before it goes to SED okay perfect great just curious y so we can re-evaluate at that time which route we think would be the the most expeditious route and and go that pathway the other question I had for you is if you're putting it out to bid are you do you typically bid one company to do all four or do you do four companies to do each item that's another thing that we could take a look at that could maybe

064potentially help you to do all four theaters at once we could break up the contracts so one contract could do East Senior West Senior the thing with that is you would end up with different contractors which could result in different equipment so and and I would I mean I would almost think if one contractor was doing it that would help with cost because of materials and labor on if they're all four at one time you're running an issue at one let's go work on something else at this one so and again is that something we discuss or you just present different ideas or how do we like you you'll present a couple of options yeah we'll present a couple of different options for a schedule and things like that how we could B it decided

065before or after we decide to put it up for a vote that can be decided after okay just curious y thank you for your answers I just want to go back to something Dr Krueger said earlier and it sounds like this is also a St issue for our students right so not taking action on this sounds like it's potentially a safety hazard um and it sounds like we've been fortunate and that nobody has been hurt up until this point and so um sounds like it's a really important comp and I would like to just I I agree I I want to just respond to that in that if we truly felt that it was unsafe to the point where someone could be hurt we would not allow individuals in that space but the reality is

066we're approaching yes the longer that we wait the the worse the condition is the more our expenses go up um and so that's that's really where I feel a sense of urgency to update the board on what the status is the situation is no different um than you know a year plus ago it's it's gotten worse however but the needs are the needs are still there that were there you know 14 15 months ago yeah we just added more band yeah yeah I would uh similarly several years ago I believe at one point before we replaced the track at West it was within a year of being told we can't use it but it wasn't unsafe at the time it was about to be unsafe um and you know I mean it's it's got to

067be done and we use these every day I mean I yeah I mean and that's like someone said to me just don't do musicals I like first of all you kidding me the amount of kids I mean even the middle school went up to Cel Miz and the amount of kids that are impacted by that is amazing everything from Tech to singing but okay fine let's just type okay we'll do the musical somewhere else we use those every day for teaching we use them for the kids practicing we I mean I've never been in a building where someone's not in that Auditorium so I just don't see how this isn't a great investment and I really believe that our school facilities are not owned by any one of us our community our taxpayers own our

068facilities and our facilities are used by our community whether it's a dance recital that comes in to use our auditoriums I I was recently told a story about a local dance group that used our Auditorium for one year and decided to revert back and use another Local School District's Auditorium because the condition of our Auditorium was such that that they did not want to return and that's a loss of Revenue when we have outside for-profit groups that use our facilities uh we charge for-profit organizations to use our facilities so that is a loss of Revenue one but it's also an inconvenience to our families if you have a a local dance group that wants to use our facilities and now they have to go to a neighboring Community um you know that that's a level

069of inconvenience and I think quite honestly a lack of pride in our school facilities that that they're such that even our own local dance studios have reservations about using them I I I think that it's a community entity and we're asking the community to invest in it and we're ready to illustrate what their uh what that investment yields you know we we've seeing that daily so and that's likely a great segue to what what the investment would be the the finances of this so I'll turn it back over to Tori and Brandon to give the estimated budget to be able to satisfy the needs in all four Auditorium So based on those updated BCS records that we did this year um these are the budget estimate numbers that we're looking at per building um so

070East midds about 2 million West midds 1.7 million East Senior and West Senior are both coming in at 2.4 million so that's a total of 8.5 for all four theater Scopes when you do these budget estimates is that on today's cost of the cuz I mean if there's the potential of this not getting done until the summer of 27 so are we running the risk then of you know the cost of quite a few things going up and we can only do two of the four schools this night yeah so our BCS numbers comes with just a unit cost and then we add um contingencies and incidentals and escalation to get us up to that 2-year Mark so that it should represent numbers two years from now y so with this estimated budget of 8.5

071million uh our business official will feel has worked with our long-range financial planner uh that the school district maintains in order to map out what the funding for this project would look like so I'm going to turn it over to to will to describe this to us um thank you um I think the best way to describe it is to make this taxpayer neutral we will use taxpayer dollars but we'll use taxpayer dollars that are already set aside in our capital reserve so I don't want anybody to say that you know we're not using taxpayer monies we are it's just not coming through the tax rate it's money's the district has set aside in a voter approved Reserve just for this purpose so the the other easy way to explain this is that the state

072AIDS us on our debt service principal and interest to the tune of about 76 cents on a dollar that is the reason why if we put $2.1 million Capital reserves against an $8.5 million project we're in effect borrowing about 76 cents a dollar for the project so we we're reducing the amount of debt we'll take on by using Capital reserves that way we line up the building Aid with the debt service at a lower amount so we're we're making this as as straight forward as possible um you can see on the numbers on the screen we the estimates are we'll get about 8.9 9 million in building Aid against about $8.8 million of total debt service so that's close to break even without you know trying to over sharpen the pencil and you know break

073the tip and use up the Eraser I I also want to make clear that in the long range planning for the district there are several Debt Service stepd Downs um where older projects age off the building aid from those projects comes off The Debt Service comes off um our plan in the long range long run is to use those step Downs to do additional work in buildings um but we're not impacting that with this strategy we're preserving that for a longer term it's it's clear that our buildings um and we'll all see it based on the BCS we need more than $8.5 Million worth of work so we're preserving our ability to move in a longer term at the same time by using the capital reserve in this instance so so you know we're excited

074about being able to do this and you know make it taxpayer neutral and get these uh really highly used spaces um back into the condition where you know they're enjoyable places to be for our students and for our our parents really well said will and and if I can just give kind of a an analogy if we were to compare it to our our house um you know maintaining level debt maintaining Revenue back from state aid is the imate goal in school finances and financing the investments in our schools and Renovations through Capital Improvement projects so I would compare or liken it to if we are just paying off our home equity loan that might be the ideal time to go get a new car because you're used to making that payment of debt now

075you're making that payment of debt on a new debt as opposed to paying for your home equity loan and also the new car simultaneously so there is both an art in science to the timing of debt when One debt comes off that's the ideal time to incur new debt so that that M remains steady and constant as a school district for our long-term Financial Planning and then also having that Revenue stream of your state aid coming in so will has worked as I mentioned with our longrange financial planner on the the timing of this and it really is an ideal time for us to have this project not only because of the dire need that have in our four schools but also because of those factors with our debt service especially if that car that

076you're buying is replacing an old clunker that you have in the shop every week and you keep putting bad money in or good money into I I just said that to will it's like throwing good money after bad right um we really are banding something that is is beyond a bandaid you're not doing it just because you know you're keeping up with your neighbors you're doing it because it's a necessity and we're getting a nice maybe Ford tourist not wor taking care of the lights and the rigging we're not we're not pres that's really I I agree and I I want to just I guess also underscore what's not included in this project I wish I could say that Aesthetics are included in this project replacement of carpeting replacement of seats in the auditorium because

077those are on the horizon for us as well but that is not included in this project it's nothing aesthetically it's not ceiling and wall paintings and carpet and seats it is the critical things for the functionality of that space and to utilize that space um as an operational uh operational Auditorium so just to kind of summarize our auditoriums are used daily as instructional spaces they are used by our community for community events they are in need of replacement equipment and systems to be functional and to be reliable and um you know I I certainly hope that the board and also so our community supports the enhancements to our Auditorium so that our our students can continue to shine on stage um so I'd like to offer if there's any questions from the board and following

078your questions you know I'll just preview next steps from here of of where we would go if this is something that the board does want to entertain as an addition to the budget vote in May so any any questions first before we segue to next steps I think you all probably expect it um this is so near and dear to my heart as um someone who grew up in the theater and I just want to make sure that the community is clear so we don't have if like we had before where they're not understanding what that is and least I want to thank you for doing a good job of explaining but I'm wondering if we can maybe at some point before the vote get um without me being the want to do it getting

079someone into to explain what a rigging system is truly capable of and how that's going to help you know our students and our Learners and the community because it just sounds like oh dude we need a rigging system that is so crucial to the Arts and I won't get on M pedestal about how the Arts and Music leads to successful students and graduation rates this isn't just something that we're doing for fun um you mentioned the safety piece but I'm going to I'm going to say this now when you already mentioned lame this I have been a professional theater like work professionally that production beat many of the ones that I have been involved with and I just want to commend our students our teachers our staff the families that came together in this community

080to make that possible the Arts are something that brings students to the classroom without it just like it might be sports for some others this is such a key piece that I want to make sure the community is fully aware of what this means and why the need is there what the return on investment would be you mentioned classes it could be anything this isn't just something we're doing it could mean revenue for our community for the district so absolutely I support this I look forward to additional conversations with details for the community so that there are no questions when it comes to loing time why this is needed and how important it is to our students which is the reason here thank you any other questions or comments besides what's some I have I

081just um wanted to drive home The Point again with the redistricting SL reconfiguration talks that are going on all four of these auditoriums will always be used in the district so regardless of what happens there all four of these auditoriums need this work done great reminder thank you yeah and I I believe um I believe correct me if I'm wrong but and I'm really big on this the changes we're looking the improvements we're looking to make are not something where 2 or 3 years from now we need to replace a heating and cooling system and the lights need to be torn out cu they're in the way or roofing issues like what we're doing is something that's going to last hopefully hopefully you don't need it the last 100 years but yeah I mean I

082I think return on investment in past we should if we take good care of it the way technology is currently I'd hope it would last you know again I want to be 100 years but I don't want to be like making any choices now that are going to be have to you know right we're good on that okay there's nothing weird if anything comes up we would review that with you to see what makes sense long term for the district and I'm only speaking for myself and the rest of the board can jump it or not I do need to make sure we do this project where all four of it happens I would I do not want to get into any kind of situation really do our best where oh now we can only

083do two because we will never be able to do this a second time I mean just my opinion again I I just want to make it clear I really hope we can plan for the worst and then celebrate when it's the best I think this is the time to do it based on being you know V the neutral for taxpayers um the return on investment potential the both these aable factors that are part of this we need to as a district maintain our buildings and facilities and part of that is maintaining Capital project if we let things like this go it's additional cost later on we already said by not doing this over a year ago it's additional costs and those were aable dollars then too it would have saved us that much more money

084had we been able to do just the the basic updates to keep our facilities working that's all we're looking for right here is to keep things going so that our kids can continue to benefit should have done it I guess the biggest question is why is it so expensive 8.5 million ion doll I just it's just interesting so I'm sitting at home watching this board meeting we're just kind of throwing around figures here 8.5 million just so I don't know if there's an answer to that that's that's a that's a quick answer but I just think it's worth I think it's worth explaining absolutely why something this nature which we're saying is not aesthetic it's it's it's foundational um what is the what is behind that that cost so those unit um those costs are

085broken out in the BCS record so you can see what the unit cost for is for the sound system the lighting system the rigging system um with the rigging system there are some structural implications with that too that we need to have our structural engineer take a look at so there's some contingencies in place to make sure that those unknowns are covered at this point um and also these systems are you know original to the building they're really old so it's not a simple one for one replacement there's a lot of design that goes into it um for these new systems but we can provide a cost breakdown for you guys you can see how that adds up I think that would be telling and I think it would be educational for us and and

086defending in promoting the the investment y absolutely G are the days where we show up on the weekend and put in some new new lighting system and Monday morning it's good to go yeah um the other question I had for you is there I think in all the theaters but I know definitely West the seating has little lights in them um in the aisleways do you know what I'm referring to we're not that's not being affected in any way we're dealing with overhead and rigging and then the other question is when we're doing rigging we're just doing rigging we're not doing the physical things that we lift and bring down or the curtains it's just the rigging correct okay yeah is that uh anyone else any fun interesting questions so in terms of next step

087we wanted an opportunity for the board to have some discussion tonight get some questions answered we can follow up with additional information that that's been requested in order for this to go out to voters should the the board choose so it does require the board to uh to develop that referendum language and to adopt as a board that this will be added to the May budget vote and that would occur at the March 4th meeting so we still have our February 25th work session where we can have additional discussion and dialogue around that and again even on March 4th if needed before the board takes action but in order to add an additional piece to the vote in May it does require your action and your approval to do so so then what would go

088before our voters in May would be our annual budget for the 2526 school year the bus proposal for the purchase and replacement of school buses potentially the theater Auditorium proposal and then the election of any school board members is what our community would be weighing in on on May 20th so we do still have two opportunities both on February 25th and March 4th for us to have open dialogue and discussion for you to get questions answered so that you feel really informed prior to taking that action on March 4th so get break okay you thank you thank you both for being here [Applause] tonight now we'll move on to budget development um well he's already here so we're good I'll hand it over to you great thank you so we have been building and adding

089on to this presentation so that it's comprehensive in nature and continues to grow throughout the budget development process so the first slides that you're going to see see are really a review of Prior content but just so that we're consistently and transparently communicating where we are in the budget development process um we continue to add to this same uh document so that it's a running document throughout the budget development process and so uh with Will's assist of course we have in bold text everything that we have completed thus far so the tax cap calculation discussion and submission which is listed for February of uh 25 is the last item listed there chronologically in our order of the budget development process and then you can still see what's on the horizon and what we'll be addressing

090at future board meetings around the first draft budget second draft budget and ultimately the board of education's adoption of the budget and that is that final number that will go out to our voters in May so our budget goals this this slide is unchanged these are the budget goals that we have reviewed with you previously through this development process our budget guidelines which include the priorities that we have articulated instructionally for our operations as a school district and also long-term Financial Planning and sustainability budget development guideline number four related to Communication in my superintendent report I shared the work of our budget advisory committee meeting and one example of that is our current open thought exchange where we can elicit feedback from stakeholders so that they have a voice in this budget development process I

091may have missed this do we have a list do we know who I know we know has it been communicated who's on the bud budget advisory committee yeah I can um be sure to include that in our next either superintendent report that I share with you or the budget presentation so that you have a list of everyone that's on the budget advisory committee thank you no problem I'm just going to make a note of that so I'm going to turn it over to will to share a breakdown of our Appropriations um and some additional information on our budget development process thank you um if you want to go ahead and flip ahead to the next slide thank you this is a slide that uh has been consistent uh was presented to the board I believe

092two meetings ago it uh projects forward our our salary and benefits uh based on the information we had at the time um this will be updated again in March for any consideration of uh new positions and for retirements that we're aware of in the system and I believe that uh the teacher retirement rate has changed uh slightly to our benefit so those numbers will be updated probably in the initial uh March presentation these are the other codes uh this is in summary form uh this is the first time you're seeing the budget 26 uh number column uh in the previous slides you saw the 25 and 24 actual the highlights I just highlighted a few of the what I would call more aggressive movers so the uh board could see uh you know like the

093middle column 2025 a total increase of $3 million over 2024 2.6 million of that is in the highlighted columns um in the 2026 budget almost all of the increase is in the highlighted blue columns so um these are like obviously the fast movers so we begin a very hard look with the buildings and department leaders um at pretty much everything we have here some of which are more flexible than others obviously there's not much we can do about utility bills um our debt services our debt service our payment to Charter Schools our tuition for private placements for you know special education students those things are are pretty much you know in stone but there there are other items that we can we can move on and we'll begin reviewing and uh to try to pair

094down uh the year-over-year increase uh as best we can uh in the lehand column I highlighted a few of the ones that stand out more to me uh we have uh for contract transportation we saw a large increase last year just as a result of the bid we were required to do for the new five-year first student contract uh we have the ability to take additional buses under that contract this number does include those additional bu uh buses but we are in conversations with the leadership Jennifer Jones out there to see if we could handle that in-house um we've had some success in uh bringing in bus driver candidates under Jen's leadership and uh we're excited about the possibility that we could reduce the contract Transportation line uh to this a year-over-year inflationary impact and

095not have to lease additional buses from first students so that would be a nice savings for us um based on some questions we had a previous meeting I wanted to include some statistics um the tuition line uh currently 80 students uh privately placed out of the district uh in special education locations um two years ago that number was 41 so that's a pretty dramatic increase uh and uh you know we've certainly had to make provision in the budget to accomplish that uh Charter School tuition is something that's relative new on the concerning front uh the pace of Charter School enrollment is increasing we're up to 20 students um 10 years ago we were at 60 students so it's definitely uh something we need to look at and talk about I know uh in our budget

096advisory committee we had a pretty good discussion about you know what could be the reasons for that and you know is it neighborhood Centric um as opposed to you know some of the charter schools may be Reaching Across the borders and you know hitting specific neighborhoods and trying to recruit kids so um that's something we're going to be looking at but again that's one of those expenses that we're at the wrong end on they have enough money to run commercials they run commercials on TV yeah and we fund them at $112,500 a student yeah that's exciting so this hopefully in March we'll begin to see some of the lines move as we uh try to make progress and U and moving back um obviously if we move down on the equipment line uh we're saving

097money this year or next budget year but we're just postponing a need so these these would not be permanent reductions except for say you know not leasing the five additional buses that would be permanent so we'll try to identify where we're postponing and where we're actually saving the BOS budgets a large item for the last uh three years we've tried to maintain it relatively flat uh that's the goal this year we really just in the beginning phases there uh we have 200 CTE students that's up from 171 the year before that's an additional $300,000 of expenses um we use both these for our alternative education program for Home Hospital instruction for students who can't attend school uh most of our software where possible comes through bosis we try to buy equipment through bosis because we

098get the bosis Aid on those purchases it's it's the most effective and efficient way to do that we also have special ed tuition students there we currently about 36 placements um we do not get Bose's Aid on those placements that's done through the stack system and you know it's a public excess cost and then of course uh Bose's rent which they turn around and pay back to us and revenue on the uh Winchester uh building uh administrative and capital costs and I believe there's a vote on the Bose administrative budget that'll come up in April I think yes um general fund totals right now we're up about 5% to 164 million you can see by the categories broken out uh salary and benefits is by far the greatest expense um that other category we focused

099on the list of Many Many Items is 24 million um Bose at 12 Debt Service at nine and then transfers to Capital and special ed uh the transfers to Capital fund the $100,000 uh Capital outlay project which we're allowed to do every year and get $76,000 of Aid back and special some of our grants don't cover 100% of expenses we have to funnel out somewhere in the 20 25% range so that's the Genesis of the transfers that's where we are at the Appropriations lines now the they'll obviously change as we go forward and like I said we're going to be aggressively focused on the $24 million and other expenses we'll take a quick uh look at the revenue side of the equation um I break it out three ways local share uh state aid and

100federal aid um and we we have some representative uh charts in the in the next couple slides that show how local and State compare over time and how much they fund our budget and they fund obviously the Lion Share of what we're trying to do [Applause] here this is the history of the tax cap including the draft 2026 tax cap um the current draft amount is a $1.9 million Levy increase that's a 2.75% this number started 3 weeks ago at a little over 3% um it's moved down as we've gotten additional details on the governor's budget and we're able to work through some of the finer points of the actual calculation so we're currently at 2.75% with the levy reaching 71.9 million up from 69.9 million the big difference in the 2.75 versus last year's

1011.95 and the 2024 2.48 is the change in the capital exclusion the capital exclusion most simply stated is The Debt Service of the district minus the building a it's the taxpayer portion of the district share of a capital project the one we're seeking to eliminate on the 8.5 million vote the capital exclusion last year uh went from $2.7 million to $2.5 million that was to the benefit of the taxpayer the levy was reduced by that amount so we ended up at 1.95% um you can you notice the history of our Levy increases since 2002 a little under 2% then two and a quarter almost two and a half little under two 2.75 really it would have been more ideal from my perspective to draw a string and have another 2.48 last year and another 2.48

102this year but the timing of the debt and the building Aid um in our capital projects you know worked against us a little bit there um so the 2.6 million is higher than the 2.4 so there's a little bit more into the levy this year um we've presented previously I believe the uh state aid runs from the governor's proposal historically the district budgets the state aid number from the governor's proposal last year at the bottom left of the page we budgeted almost $ 65.4 million against 65.3 from the governor's proposal um this year's proposal up $3.9 million um with 2 million that uh in the growth of the expense based AIDS uh additional Transportation building and uh that's really the The Lion Share of the transportation and building Aid Foundation a was up 4% which

103is a solid increase and we we were happy to get it that number was certainly uncertain right up until you know these state aid runs came out in the middle of the night so it was it was good to see um budgeted revenues for this is the 2025 breakdown because we don't have all the numbers for 2026 but you can see it's pretty close uh the tax levy versus New York state aid and then other Revenue codes many of which are local um you know make up the difference uh the lines in the middle of the page represent uh how local Revenue has changed over time from 60% in 2021 down to 55% in 2025 um State revenues have increased making up the difference from 39% up to 44% and federal revenues which are really

104our Medicaid reimbursements um um have remained flat as a percentage of the budget they've been increasing but flat as a percentage of the [Applause] budget this is the capital exclusion I spoke of and the this is the uh actual calculation um building Aid at the top and transportation Aid on our transportation Capital purchases that's our bus fleet gives you a total uh building and transportation Aid of about $6.5 million there in the middle of the page the anticipated expenses that's our Debt Service Plus our $100,000 Capital outlay project which will probably roll out to the board at the next board meeting and a presentation and then our our bosies our our uned portion of uh Bose's Capital costs that's the $122,000 number so we're spending 9.1 receiving back 6.4 and that's the capital tax exclusion

105of 6.4 2. six being the difference and you can see the trend in capital exclusion the outlier most recent years being the 2025 year we talked about the timing difference there that that lowered it and impacted the tax levy and we had the 1.95% um last year uh question came up at the last meeting about health insurance uh is clearly something we spend a lot of time trying to focus on um $18.4 million is a is a lot of money um I just wanted to break it out uh 424,000 is for the uh administrative benefit trust that's paid out by virtue of the labor agreements it's a per member per month payout uh WIA benefit trust uh is $9.8 million again that's a per member per month so it's it's based on our total FTE

106and our teaching teaching unit and our self-funded plan which uh covers uh the this the remaining units of management confidentials supervisor and directors um all the uh senior administrative Team all our CSEA members um so that's at $8.2 million for over 500 members teachers units uh over 500 close to 600 members and uh administrative unit is 22 or 23 members next steps uh budget advisory will be meeting uh in a couple of weeks uh in advance of the 20 the February 25 and March 4th meetings for the board um we'll have the final tax cap calculation at that point we update our progress we will most likely roll out our uh our Capital outlay project for next year will Define the terms of the bus proposition uh for this year's vote and uh we'll begin

107to work towards the documentation for the $8.5 million vote which requires uh a bond resolution and a Seeker um regarding any environmental impact and then on the March 4th meeting we'll have our first draft uh most of the numbers you've already seen they just haven't been or organized as such we'll identify a funding Gap remember last year we had about a $6.3 billion funding Gap that we covered with Reserve we can talk a little bit about how we see the outcome for this coming this current fiscal year uh we'll identify potential Reserve use to cover that funding gap for next year's vote and uh we'll talk about action items what we found uh a little about the discussion we had about the other codes which ones we think we're moving on how much we think

108we can reduce and as we move towards will be a final funding Gap that we will have to cover by reserves we're in we're in a structural deficit situation and we're we're moving forward hoping to shrink that year over year and uh you know use the reserves that we built up uh during the pandemic to uh to fund our operations over the short term that's basically where we are at if you have questions I'd be happy to try to answer um but uh Dr krier has proven to be a a strong budget partner and it's it's I can't tell you how happy that makes the business guy trying to pull together the budget so she has as many questions as I do and it's uh it's made it a made it a nice process well

109likes it when he's not the only one that has to say no gets old we've really tried to be um financially responsible this year um you know what I've come to know is that in years past there was additional staff added regularly throughout the year and we have really tried to be prudent as we're getting notifications of retirement um before we just automatically roll over and post a position and fill really analyzing should that position be a position um that through attrition that would be the time so you're not laying someone off is that a position that through attrition we can responsibly not fill that position and in some cases as you're hearing about the needs that are growing with special education students the board is well aware that there is limited um opportunities for

110us to place our high need special education students in community settings in agency settings or bosis we are running and dealing with many weight lists in those we may need to increase our special education staff to respond to those needs uh next year and in increasing special education ation staff it's not just teachers but it's teacher aids it's often the related services that go along with that OT PT and speech services and so if we have increased needs in one area where can we have offsetting reductions so that we are budget neutral um and so we're looking at every retirement every vacancy that we have now and on the horizon of is it critical that we fill that position or might that be able to be an offsetting uh measure for where we do have

111increased need and increased expenses so we are still actively going through that process now and as we do that you know these these numbers will become Tighter and more clear um from that that fuzzy first look we tighten that focus and the picture becomes more clear on some of our final budget projections I think what would be helpful given what you just uh said there about this year you know obviously last was a very painful budget season and uh there were reductions I would love to see for the last three years Staffing levels and from you know the end of last year July 1 to let's say March one what has been what positions have been added and how do that how does that compare with previous years and where are we Staffing Wise from

112in all of our areas um and our buildings our very important Cecil workers our csca workers our our transportation department um our teaching staff our Aid staff it' be just be would I think it would be really helpful to see where those numbers are um because I know that those positions will tell a story when you see an increase of 30 teacher aids yes that's because students who were bringing back so so those things would be interesting just to look at for year to and I'm not looking to go back prior to the pandemic but maybe in the last three years I just think it would be very telling um because as as difficult as last year was I'd like to know where are we now with those with those Staffing levels and are we

113right back into the same spot that we were last year as we end just right now entering the budget season I can assure you we are not we have really been and you know the board is well aware of any positions that we create um and I I think you have a sense that we have been incredibly responsible in that area but I can certainly um see I don't know if we'll be able to have the July to March comparison for every previous year we can certainly do that snapshot for this year I just think so where we are where we are now as opposed to last year um I you're absolutely right yes we we it would just it would be helpful to see it um broken down by okay what this are the

114number of positions we had to add this year because that and when we're being as fiscally responsible as possible we still have positions we must add you're absolutely right and and every year that's part of our budget development process we anticipate that there will be additional teachers needed we will get an influx of children at fourth grade that weren't anticipated and in August we are adding a a teacher or a section because class size is warranted so we do have those surprises um but we account for those with with having some allocation in the budget to be able to respond to that you know just like you know in your home finances you have to be prepared for those emergency expenses that come up um we also are having to be prepared whether it's emergency

115expenses uh of equipment or supplies and materials or that of of personnel because of increased needs or things um that that weren't anticipated so uh we certainly do account for that but I can certainly work with Will and and with John cervone on getting some information related to personnel and the number of FTE that we have uh both administrators teachers and also CSEA just to give a snap of how that compares over maybe aear is what I'm hearing the request for I think that I think for me that would be very helpful thank you add to the importance of capital projects in this because that lessens our emergency cost that we're overtime planning meaningful improvements to the district so that we're not having to have as many unexpected costs if we plan with atttention improvements

116over time we're not going to have to add as much of that compeny for those those sorts of things that have been a problem these last few years too yeah ongoing maintenance again just like in your own home ongoing maintenance of our facilities is is critical to avoid the emergency dire where you're you're paying emergency rates um to to get something responded to um Vince I'll just also let you know um in case the rest of the board or you have any questions um Len and I are the board Reps for the budget meeting um for the budget development thing so if you guys ever have anything outside of these meetings you want reach out to us um you know anytime I think we've attended both of us have made all of them right whereing

117the yeah yeah whether it's through the the computer or um showing up in person depending on whether there's snow or not um yeah we made them all so if there's anything we can do to help um with the process just give a text or a call and either one of us can walk you through it yes that very dedicated budget advisory committee we even met on a snow day uh remotely via Google meet so I I am grateful for their time um some of the members Nancy are here in attendance tonight I'm grateful for the time that they give to be part of that process any other thank are we taking a deeper dive into uh possibly bringing some of these special ed students back to District just because I mean that cost at 80

118students you talking over $60,000 per student so I mean if it was a 611 or 1211 that you added it would definitely be a cost saving yes um under Jackie F's leadership um she and I have recently met with a building principal where we anticipate um having two additional special ed classes next year to be able to respond to the student need and and not only does it benefit us financially if we can have a program in District that's also what's best for our kids because they're not on these are our most vulnerable students um with the greatest needs and we want to avoid them being on a lengthy bus ride and uh obtaining a program out of District if at all possible so we are actually right now in the active planning stages of

119which uh we're looking at two classes of high need that we'd be bringing in District and then some other increased need where we we have special education needs already but yes we are working on that right now we want to identify the teachers and staff that would be working in those classrooms because it is a high need population and we want to ensure that we're preparing them with the professional development the support the training the the resources so that that can successfully launch in September yeah and what I would ask with that because this is very close to my heart um that often times we look for spaces empty spaces for these children and they get put in places where they should not be placed that are not operable for them no or for their

120classmates um really have to set the physical environment up so that those students are in a place that is going to be they're going to be successful and that they're going to be uh welcomed and they're going to be um um that everybody else is not um put out either you know it it's a very it needs to be very planful it needs to be strategic and it needs to be um and and it may create other other moves that have to happen within a building and I'm speaking as a building principal who's done this and I I don't I know how buildings work I also and and and a lot I've been in this classroom for a long time well this classroom is now going to be needed for a different for a different

121student body a different class A different teacher and just need to be ahead of that and be thought thoughtful about that that's that's my commentary on that really good point Thank you any other if I can just say real quick up to what Vince said I think that's why it's so important that as we look at the redistricting committees um what they're coming back to us with I know that that's in their Forefront of how we're going to accommodate that so I think it's so important that the community understands that these students are top of our list they are not an afterthought so when we look at the different options that are put forward by the redistributing committee it is for these needs so it might look a little different but it's because we're putting

122thank you and just to preview of February 25th which is our next meeting and work session we will have an update on our redistricting committee process and along with that I think we should have some discussion around the long-term plan in use of the Winchester building and also the long-term plan in use of the Ebenezer building um particularly the Ebenezer building because it is there are no no students in that building we are not eligible for any state aid on any Renovations done to that building and I shouldn't even say Renovations maintenance for example replacement roof we are not eligible for state aid on that because it is not a student occupied building so I think there's an opportunity for us to be really strategic I agree V's really strategic and thoughtful around the use

123of that building and or the use of the Winchester building in our redistricting plan so that your Appo Vince our our most needy students are in fit in nooks and crannies wherever we can place them throughout the district but there really is a comprehensive plan of where should programs be placed whether it's Universal prek whether it's special education a and also our our district offices which have moved a number of times um or so I've been told a number of times over the past two decades you know really having some long-term plans that will not only be good for kids but also financially wise for the use of those spaces and and having the least revenue from bosis is something that we have enjoyed and despite bosis looking at an expansion um building for them

124they will still have a need for integrated Bose's classrooms in our district so partnering with Bose's is still a possibility for us it may just look different than what it looks like now where they're utilizing the entire Winchester school so we can you know certainly I would love to talk with you more about that at our work session on February 25th look forward to it cool anything else we'll move on thank you well thank you sir um we'll move on to seems like we do this all night Board of Education discussion I do not have anything listed under it uh does anyone have anything they would like to um discuss or even add to the next meeting to discuss if they're not fully prepared tonight uh start anything sir why did you point I'm going

125to start and go around just to check I'm not anything anything no I'm actually very good tonight thank you great I know uh the state passed that we're going to have to ban cell phones so I don't think they have given a hint of any kind of Aid to put that in place so I was just wondering if we have started to explore cost and ideas around that so I can put that as would you like that do you think as a work session to have some discussion around it I think that's a good idea um there's there's supposed to be a little bit of of money that others can apply for for for some Aid with that but um there's also been some talk among some of the High School principles in the area

126and what that looks like because we do have a few schools that have implemented a plan that would fulfill the state requirements so it might be good to um have some that participate in that meeting may be part of the discussion or at least to to kind of get some Fe from that as well um did I did I see a hand go up on the screen I didn't I think I was just doing that there was there was I don't know if it was tonight tomorrow night some night this week like Thursday if you check your email schools is having a discussion on it so informative that helpful um I'm hoping to find out some more information about that tomorrow during our lobby time but there's certainly a lot of steps being taken to

127address what that means at the moment there is no funding in the governor's plan so like I said hopefully I'll have more information tomorrow I can that with great thank you and I'm assuming as this process moves on we're going to have to look at policy and all that fun stuff cuz I'm sure kids aren't just going to all leave their phones at home and there'll be no problems right it's anticipated that we're going to get guidance from New York State Department of Ed more specific guidance but what we do know is that it's um being referred to as distraction free learning environment where in a sense phones are away for the day um during the instructional day away for the day um you know there certainly are products out there that can lock your

128cell phones during the day which could be pouches and things of that nature which could be a solution for that but there are already schools are middle schools as an example that have a policy of a way for the day and students maintain their cell phones in their locker throughout the day where it is locked it is safe during the day um and so whether it is buying a product like a pouch or it's simply the enforcement of it's away in your locker during the day I think we can talk through what that means for the management and the logistics of that um and with that parents need to have a way to reach their child during the day so it's likely going to go back to when we were all in school how did

129our parents us if we were in school before the days of cell phones but there will be some logistical details of course for for us to work through I have a child most often in the middle school I get an email occasionally when she needs to get a hold of me and something more sensitive she uses the office so work so hard and again like you said we all survived without phones and we did okay if you recall last year I I did take uh I was against the idea of allowing kids to have one earbud in and was kind of like students had come up with that idea and we put that into our code of conduct so I don't know how you can have a distraction free day with a earbud and that

130only works when it's connected to a device so again I'll go back to that I don't know how that's helping this year but um I hope that's something we we have to clean it up there will likely I would anticipate need to be revisions to our code of conduct to to align with us can we maybe get copies of school districts that are currently c as a policy just to see as we're starting to have these discussions what that looks like yes thanks laana launched the Yonder pouches this fall and I've had conversations with Nadia the superintendent there and and can certainly reach out to get policy regulation things of that nature and if if they're helpful I'd be curious what happens when they don't follow the policy like you know I could see uh

131principal having to take a $1,000 phone away you people thatp about that too so yeah sobody just curious if they have any input on that and quite honestly it is a point of frustration right now by many administrators that this is um you know we've lost local control here um some school districts like neighbors that you mentioned have based on their school community and what their either Board of Education or leadership team uh wanted to do they imposed limitations on cell phones but when it comes Statewide in a one- siiz fits-all manner it's not really responsive to the local needs or us having local control so that that is the reality of of the situation that we're facing here and I think there is some frustration among administrators that instead of them being instructional leaders

132that they will be cell phone police throughout the day um and so it's like any change there will likely be growing pains with this we are still awaiting further guidance that'll I'm sure influence the next steps that of what we have to do versus what we as a school Community really really want to do no I think what we could do as a board of education what all board of education do is have unwavering support for their administrators and their teachers and their staff we enforcing the policies that we set so we set the policy they have to enact it so if we don't back them up 100% we're not doing our job no that would be much appreciated because as you meant board adopts policy administrators are to enforce policy yes and we know

133if we catch the kids in the bathroom using their phones they're not going to flush those so at least any other discussion I I'm just wondering how much of an issue is it in our buildings cell phones those three back there I can I can speak for my kids sitting there but is that your kid yeah okay I know my daughter like takes her phone to school turns it off during the day keeps it on her but like it's her safety net um but like I don't know how many phone calls are teachers making home to parents and um how many cell phones are being confiscated like what what is the level of both this fall and then again just yesterday I had lunch with students at East and West Senior High School and you

134know they're in a room with a superintendent that they don't really know well so it usually starts out with crickets you want to get high schoolers talking say what do you think of the governor's proposal around cell phones that gets high schoolers talking and um you know out of the mouths of babes really insightful um some really do acknowledge that that it is problematic and that they or their classmates are regularly distracted however I felt what was most insightful that was shared with me is that the reality of their world is they have to navigate the use of cell phones responsibly 24/7 and our job as Educators is to prepare them for the next step so seemingly they could be in high school in lock down of cell phones and then go into the workforce

135and go into the college setting and now have unfettered access to it and and what is that bridge to help educate our students around no when you're distracted self-regulate turn it off during the day if you are being distracted I think we're losing the opportunity to do what we do which is educate and how can we educate our students around having a a healthy relationship with the cell phones that we all carry and knowing when you're distracted and being able to put some self-imposed limits as opposed to external forces requiring that of them so I I worry that we're really missing a important educational piece here and I mean did she so I just ask Lisa if any of the students had talked about and obviously we said like it's not a Statewide One Singular

136answer are we finding in our district that it's um the use is leading to planning flights or planning those kind of things or used for the social emotional kind of matrial or is it just distraction that they're on serving the web or watching Tik Tok like what what is our community's concerns around them what are our students concerns around them unique to USA I I think there's concerns of all nature um you know concerns social emotionally how our students are doing um the the use of cell phone for inappropriate activity during the day um whether that's you know inappropriate pictures things but those things exist outside of school and then they come into school and we we're dealt with cleaning up those those pieces and those messes so limiting it during the school hours won't

137necessarily make those things go away it may just hit the pause button for the seven hours while they're with us but I think that the challenges that we deal with around cell phones will still be there it's just going to be interrupted for some hours every day unless we really are committed as a society um partnering with parents this cannot just Beyond school districts but partnering with parents around appropriate use of technology and healthy and safe limits with technology anything else on that anything else you would like to add to the evening no Mar no Len anything else you'd like to add to board discussion I think I've said a lot tonight thank you you so we've talked a little bit about the potential for a board retreat right so um I know we haven't

138had time to go over goals that we reflected on uh as part of our midyear process um so I'm just wondering if we might be able to consider using a future work session to do that as part of a retreat I think it would be either the work session in March or we can add a retreat in March so I don't know if we want to decide that tonight or if you want me to put together an email with uh options um obviously my favorite help person to help me in the world Nicole we have a nice um Google shared Google doc that can help us to see if there's availability or not um you guys want to decide something now or you want to get the email out and kind of look but I

139100% support that idea I think we do need Retreat I'm sorry just because we have not had the time to like reather about like our mid evaluation looking at potential goals goals just general progress so the goals we were going to put on till next year goals yes but our midye flection might be a good time to actually have a few minut talk about that yeah again if we can't pick a different date we can maybe do it at the end of the work session at the next one or again if there's no interest at all then you know four people don't want to do it at all then we won't do it so I just didn't know if you wanted to decide that tonight or if you want me to get something out and

140we can talk about about it I'm open to whatever you guys you know whatever the consensus is I think an email would be helpful or to spell out kind of what what we want to accomplish there to Jeremy's Point um I think thinking about the goal is obviously very helpful but perhaps not this part of the year um not to create goals but just to kind of reflect back yeah of course I agree with that yeah okay yeah I'll do that and then we'll report on the email conversation because we don't want to do anything not in public we'll report on the next meeting of what we talked about and how it went that sound like a fair fun idea yeah okay thanks for bringing it up anything else um I got nothing tonight I

141just to report that I will not be present at the March 4th meeting March 4th I'll I'll be out of town and I I'm not doing that well we appreciate the advanced not uh anything else may I have we're not going anywhere we're not going to another room or anything Chang in the last 5 minutes we're good may I have a motion to adjourn motion to adj may I oh jerem all in favor I anyone oppose oh Len's opposed passing 61 I said I no no no it's official if our students in attendance need a document side you're welcome to come up here and get a signature [Applause]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.