001good evening everybody Welcome to the Tuesday January 28th 2025 work session um if we can begin with the pledge will would you like to lead us on the pledge sure IED us to the the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands Nation indivisible liy and justice for all okay just want to let you know that um Vince is going to be a few minutes late joining us and Mara is in the process of logging on Via the whatever that's called the cloud um I'd like to just take a minute and mention that Marla is joining us in a work session virtually um the work session was scheduled for last week she was planning on being here in person and when she found out that she was traveling when we moved
002it because of the storm she was uh just a little disappointed she could be here in person so I just want to point out that she has made every effort to be here on the online and I appreciate that for it again I appreciate everyone's effort and um when she joins us and Vince joins us they will just uh start participating thank you everybody we'll do roll call and we'll start with Mr Maloney pres Sarah here Len present laa here Ed here superintendent here excellent and I will begin with new business may I have a motion on new business which is items 2 a and 2 [Applause] B I'll make a motion to pass 2 a 2 B I'll second for a second any discussion on [Applause] either good to go all in favor I
003I anyone opposed nope okay it passes 5 to zero again two members not present did I skip you good discussion topics board meeting dates um can do you want is there I know Vince was a part of this and Mila is there anything oh I don't want to use the words not important but is there anything we need to discuss that they can join in um I hate the if you'd like to change the order of some of our agenda items we could certainly do so if you're waiting for Mara and and Vince to join us yeah I mean the first few are definitely things that they've discussed with me and I'm sure they discussed with other board members I don't want to like derail the meeting but um and I know they can go
004back and watch so is there anything that's more of a discussion that we've worked on I think the board meeting dates though the conversation leading up to let's have established board meeting dates is something that you know obviously Vince has advocated for in the past so he'll be happy to see that we're not we're not voting on the dates yet we're just discussing that this will allow uh other groups to schedule around Board of Education meetings making it possible for West Anica residents and employees to attend our meetings more easily because there won't be as many CET sure and I I love it and I'm in support of it I know Mara reached out to me with just a couple concerns okay um so I mean I can tell you what her concerns were obviously
005um should I get this right her concerns were she likes the idea of setting the Mee perfect timing Mara hi hi sorry it was an internet issue I'm good now that's okay um What's the phrase we can put a man on the moon um exactly we were just uh moving on to topic three a a discussion on board meeting dates and I was about to speak for you with uh questions or concerns you had um we're kind of looking to set um kind of I don't know my opinion and I I think opinion of several people is kind of set the dates not in stone but put together a plan that's continuous throughout the years like everyone knows these are the dates and then if we have to change them for any reasons the board
006obviously always has that Authority um and I know that you and I had started a discussion that we were going to continue tonight so did you want to speak now sure can everybody hear me yeah yeah that's good okay thanks no I think that that makes sense and I appreciate what um the goals that we're trying to achieve um by doing this include um I think I would just question whether that's in line with our policy because I think at our last policy meeting when I was reading through it I think it said that we needed to approve it at our annual rework meeting so I would just double check that and then um you know as somebody who joined the board uh with the schedule that was preset you know there were challenges uh
007in making that work with my schedule has being virtual a couple of times so I would just you know I think it's good to make sure that the board the future board members see except there are any future board members um understand what the commitment is and what um they can pencil in the dates but there may be conflicts um just given we don't know what our board will look like next year so yeah um so so my calter to that and anyone can jump in at any time was we're putting together now which I think helps people who run for the school board because I've been part of several conversations where board members have been sworn in and then they're not available for like anything um and it's like did you know we meet
008the no I had no idea so I think it's kind of nice like Nicole can put it right in the packet that they get when they're looking to run or when they turn in their um their signatures that sort of thing just to kind of give them a fire their heads up and I definitely would think we should look at the policy but I also think we can still approve them at that meeting like do a final approval but if we kind of put together the grid work now there's a lot less stress because the thing I think screws us up the most is that July meeting and we're changing dates like again you've already like in July you got it elected and now you're planning your schedule and then that meeting we start changing
009stuff and I think that actually came to fruition a couple times where a board member set their schedule after they were elected and then that meeting things got changed big time so um we I think we still can approve it as a final at that meeting but we put together a good work the Pol she's right the policy is we officially have to approve it at that first uh reor meeting however it doesn't prevent us from having a very concrete draft going into that so and I think I think that's I think by having the concrete draft that I can publish for our Music Department our athletic department will allow us to plan events around it and certainly we know a date might change when we come together at the organizational meeting in July when
010we have new board members on but know that if we should change date there could be conflicts within our schools but I think this provides adequate and ample time for whether it's rpta it's our administrative units um our Athletics all of those groups to try to work around our board meeting dates and really treat those as blackout dates if you will to avoid those when scheduling because they do start planning events um in the very near future for the upcoming school year anyone anyone I think that would go to what Vince has always wanted was you know priority on board meeting nights of not having a lot of I know Sports and I know certain things have to happen sometimes um so I think he's a positive on that um if anyone disagrees with that
011uh anyone got any other comments when would we vote on this if we decide to kind of go with the plan it would be typically at the organizational meeting in July oh no no I mean when would we just say we're cool with the dates you've got um like we're cool with this like the draft [Applause] I we looking to say it's good for tonight or make official an official oh so there's no official at all until that meeting but okay so this is just a draft that we're going to work off of okay if if you see any conflicts or know of any conflicts now or in the next few weeks we can certainly make revisions to this but I will share this with with our administrative team and with our leaders of the
012music department and ask that they plan events around these drafted dates I will say the one that we've kind of looked at um the last two years that November 4th will be election day and we've talked about not having it the same night as a board meeting the same night as elections so that people have the opportunity to get out and vote yeah I I do agree with that November 4th would be one that we want to not have um and I'm assuming these include all of the mandatory Boose these type dates even though we don't know them all the time right or are they is it set in stone every year okay okay we can I mean again we can figure that out as it comes but I I love everything else about it
013thank you I never would have thought election day so we'll look to make a change then from the November 4th which is election day potentially to move that back a week to November 11th how are you is that Veteran Day okay we'll try that again can you remind me what the um the uh board meeting schedule is in October the first one in October it's a Tuesday right not a Wednesday yeah we have October 1st is a meeting and the 14th is a work session oh it is wedn be the 15th yeah okay it's October 1st you said yes okay um that's the one thing there's uh so the uh there's a high Jewish holiday um called gor that's on the 1st that's the only date I would ask that we move can I ask
014that can certainly be moved because October 1st is a Wednesday and so I don't I don't think that's accurate thank you should we do September 30th is it since it's that close to October or that three September well I mean by one day though but do the 7th and 21st I like that suggestion 7 and 2st and it's not a holiday nothing weird I know we're giving a lot of extra holidays and stuff did you hear that Marla 7th and 21st for November so October October I'm sorry October 7th and October 21st yep is that cool thank you Vince if you uh want to get caught up we're going over the calendar we all kind of agree to get something set in unofficial Stone um I believe that helps support your goal yeah it's a
015very wise decision I'm glad we're doing it appreciate all the work you have done bringing it up over the here do you want to look at that November date then since we're on [Applause] it I think what we did this year was just have the one one meeting in November because the two holidays oh yeah what was the month though that we wish we had two wasn't it November that we wish that we had had two one Thanksgiving the 27th or at least one on I think we said we wanted one on the calendar that we could have declined than trying to add if that's I believe that's what it was I mean do we want to do the 11th and 18th 11th and better oh that's the yeah I mean we could do 18th
016and 25th and then if we can back off the 25th that will be for everyone yeah it be an eem yeah we need it great if not so the 25th would be the work session yes y 18th sorry was up for November yes 18th and 25th thank you and the only other thing that we may need to give consideration to is the June meeting dates uh so right now June 9th is slated to be a meeting June 23rd is a work session I don't know if our principes have selected the high school graduation dates but June 23rd could potentially be a graduation date there tentatively on the calendar for 20266 they're on the calendar you're correct correct I think it Tuesday yeah I mean who knows if I'm here I my daughter will be graduating
017that year hopefully so let's not do a board meeting on that night if I'm here if I'm not here just do whatever you want of 26 right so we could look at June 9th and then uh potentially June 16th as a work session if needed okay yeah cuz um when was it that we did the board retreat with the new board members was it June July it was so that might be a nice oh yeah nice time to make it one that night or okay cool do we want to discuss anything else with the board meeting dates anyone I feel better about this good yeah I do everything good with [Applause] that about grad she taking Starbucks orders or and right I just want to confirm though that December we didn't want a second date
018just in case no I think it's too no I I know I agree just in case you never know you know how much I love meetings I'm not good we're good it's easier to cancel one than to get one on the schedule I'm only asking yeah it's pretty easy to be all right I mean again I'm going not be here so figure it out I mean before you were on the board we added what nine meetings in uh in a short period of time time made it work so we have to we can always figure it out if we need to entire weeks for interviews cool okay so no vote on that we're just going to unofficially mark it in stone okay and I love it again thank you of course for doing this thank
019you for pushing for it Ben um 3B calendar dates Lisa thank you so in your packet and excuse me I sound a lot worse than I feel um you can believe I guess the bills gave on Sunday so in your packet is the Western JMT Regional School calendar JMT stands for the joint management team this is basically all of our bosies in the region so niagar Orleans bosies irie1 bosies Eerie 2 bosies come together to develop a regional calendar for Western New York the mindset behind this is because some of our students although we're situated in irie1 bosis we do have students that attend programming in Eerie Tu bosis and so there was um an effort years ago to try to have aligned calendars so that all bosis had similar or the same start dates
020superintendent conference days so that we had the least disruption possible to student calendars so what you have before you is not the draft West senica calendar but rather the Bose's calendar they will be voting on this uh in the next week or two and so then we'll be able to better build our calendar from that we do have a calendar meeting scheduled locally um for our school district but this gives you a sense as to what breaks are being slated for irie1 Bose for next school year what's been drafted irie1 Bose Board of Ed has not yet adopted this but I wanted you to have eyes on it first in case there was any feedback from the board that I can take that to our upcoming calendar meeting Dr logren will be facilitating that calendar
021meeting and certainly wanted the opportunity if there was any feedback from the board before we have that calendar meeting and then when our calendar is drafted we'll bring it forward to the board for your review and ultimately for the board's adoption is um I know the kids are off tomorrow for Lunar New Year is that not on there do they not do that or so the lunar un New Year is celebrated when it falls on a day Monday through Friday okay and you so you'll see um last school year for example the Chinese lunter New Year fell on a a Saturday I believe it was two years prior juneth fell on a Saturday and so it's only recognized in our school calendar if it falls on a weekday Monday or Friday then okay great okay
022I guess my only question is and you said that this isn't ours so we may have some different dats I was kind of excited to see where Labor Day falls which means that Tech teally school would start a week earlier based on this however they put two weeks not say that's how it works for December but yet still potentially going to the end of June so with that week ahead I would think that we get out a little earlier but that's for West to decide what we would be doing corre correct cont so teachers contracts very District to District we can bring teachers in prior to September 1 with a agreement by our teachers union so I have um previewed this calendar with the President and Vice President of wsta so that they can get
023feedback from their membership about coming in those two days in late August prior to September 1 uh if that should happen it does give us some flexibility within the school year additional snow days builtin if we need snow retrieval days but really the end of the school year is our school year is usually booked by Labor Day and then the Regent exam schedule so we're really um kind of determined when our school year ends based on the region exam schedule this is not far off I mean we're typically historically it's always been between the the 21st and the 26th anyway so and built in there there sudden it's two full weeks for the December breakdown So that obviously few days no it's just hard for someone not from New York state to look at that
024that's that's the hot time and you know we that's another topic of you know the temperatures are rising so that's just always hard for me to look I couldn't agree with you more yeah that's beyond us I'm just asking it's be and you know what it it's it's a it's an issue larger than this joint management team here it's a state issue and that's where I wonder because we know that there are changes happening with regent exams and cred accreditation for so is there any conversation about moving those exam because as you explained we're locked in so because we're locked in you you you can't do be creative you can't make Intelligent Decisions that would end the school year earlier like if I had my my way I would get rid of February break it's
025not great for kids any kids that playing a winter sport you have February break you're not off cuz you have to practice if you're a teacher you're not off cuz you're coaching right or if you're a coach you're not off so that February break is not really conducive to uh solid learning we we just came off all these days off and then we're going to go on February break and then you're going to have a call to the end um so I guess my question is not so much for the calendar I was surprised I thought that bosies was talking about doing away with the February break yes I did too so there has been discussion I think this is one of the the best calendar that you'll see um in upcoming years in that
026we don't have to account for some additional and newer holidays within the calendar but if we get and we're starting the earliest possible Labor Day being September 1 so we're starting school potentially September 2nd you really can't start earlier than that based on most contractual language but if you have a labor day that's later than what this calendar is and you also have to to account for juneth in Chinese Lunar New Year and and some of the newer holidays we've had to respond to I think we will see that inevitably we have to look at reducing breaks in order to accommodate some of the holidays that we're now required to schedule I just what you what you brought the the light there to line is that that hanging on I see are two High School
027principles here and as a former High School principal trying to hang on to those seniors so that they don't implode in the last couple of week cuz they may not have exams very few have actual exams that they have to pass we have to have them in school we can't have them have any stumbles toward the Finish Line it just would make a lot of sense to end the year when earlier so thought I should mention I think my kids should go year round that's a separate conversation I'm just kid SE um the one thing I I want to point out is I don't ever and I love my kids going to school actually I hate holidays at all um but the December break this year I think was horrible as far as those two
028days um it's just I don't know that my kids accomplished anything like it just seems weird can we try to get similar to this for December like I I mean I hate I hate to say I don't want my kids in school but I don't think those two days were super productive anyway and it was just such a punch in the face I I think having the two weeks at that Christmas break as as we're seeing in the straft calendar would certainly be feasible if um we can start school actually start school on Tuesday September 2nd which means that we would need to have the two days in late August whether it's the 26th and 27th or 27th and 28th of superintendent conference days if we cannot do that then our first student day would
029be Thursday September 4th and it would be nearly impossible to have enough snow days built in and flexibility in the calendar to have a full February break and two weeks uh between December and January okay if I had to pick I would pick the December one just one it's wony I mean because we try to and go 22 23rd [Applause] like that okay cool uh how many snow days do we plan on building into our calendar in the future so the the advice that we're given is to um take the average of the last five years of snow days that you've utilized and try to build that into your calendar um so generally speaking we're looking at 4 days 5 days max you'll see in our calendar this year there were three days built in
030and then three additional snow retrieval days as a plan if needed where we would pull back days from the February break or the April break which often schools do and they'll put it on their calendar sometimes it's the Friday before Memorial day but they let it be known up front that we've built in 3 days if we go beyond that here's our plan of how we're going to recoup days on that note when it's our average is that the average counting if there wasn't a state emergency because I feel like the past two years we've had State emergencies and I don't know that we can always depend on that so when you say we've averaged three or 4 days really it's another five days right so it the guidance doesn't get into that level of
031specificity of state of emergencies or not but you're absolutely right last year and this year in particular the governor declaring a state of emergency means that those days do not count against us in the same way for um the counting for 180 days of student attendance yeah so I I think it would probably just be prudent for us to kind of consider that with those weeks just in case it was just Eerie County and not all the St right yeah I she I think she did state of emergency for the area not yeah no you're right but I'm just what if she didn't no right yeah no I agree yeah cool just build a dome over West Sonica um do we need to officially do anything at this point or no this was just a
032discussion item next we'll be bringing you the draft W Sena student calendar for the upcoming school year and that will be what you actually adopt and that will take place after our calendar meeting just looking for some initial feedback at this point do we the initial calendar meeting um have you discussed your thoughts on half I know you've brought it up lots of times but the half day thing is there any are we even concerned about that at this point there not a future thing where half days kind of stink off of so half days are typically mapped out in that calendar so if there's any feedback regarding half days I would I would welcome that feedback going into that meeting okay yeah when is that meeting uh January 30th if I'm not mistaken it's
033th Thursday afternoon we think can get the data on absenteeism um on the halfway before a break don't look at me like that I I just do all have well yes but specifically at one of the conferences they were they were talking about the significant drops on the half days before a break we don't have a whole lot to happen before a break I I think the what we talked about the P especially in all year school there's heavy half days that take place throughout the school year um um and you know the parents it's you know Child Care concern they have to to work out and then um in addition to that you know like are they are their teachers able to utilize that time the best way it just creates a lot of
034questions but that if we have look say four half days we can't make them two days because it doesn't count the same way right that's whole kind correct we can have up to four full days as superintendent conference St year you can have up to four they call them shorten session days four in each semester so four in the fall semester for in the spring semester so you can have up to an additional eight half days with kind of this asterisk requirement that we still have to meet the number the minimum number of instructional hours per calendar year which is 900 hours at the elementary level 990 hours at the secondary level so as long as we meet those requirements we are on Solid Ground for state aid purposes in this year's calendar for example
035for elementary students we have seven half days and I know the middle school last week didn't I don't know what days were the snow days but I think Monday was a holiday and then Tuesday Wednesday was a snow day correct and Thursday I think was a full day of school and Friday was a half and and again I I don't know how much productive the kids are on the half days but if our attendance draw is poor on those days they're not learning anyway but it still counts for us even if a whole bunch of kids don't show up that's right as long as school's in session right and I I think you're posing the question of what counts for state aid reimbursement purposes versus if it's truly a a meaningful high quality instructional day
036CU I was surprised my kids go through their whole schedule on a half day I can't imagine that you know lot's going I know yeah I just wanted to bring up one more thing before uh on the full calendar um and at the risk of EX communication from the church I think we should stop following the Easter calendar and I think we should set a spring break that's consistent and in a good place for schools because this Good Friday this year is very late April April 18th next year it's April 3rd it's been times where it's March and it's all over the place and how do you plan like plan for a good school calendar when you have that variable so I think it's worth having a conversation with at the at the bis level
037or even at the the local level um so that we're consistent we know where our spring break Falls and it falls at a place that is good for students and good for school I think that's a a really valid point for advocacy with our bosies and the regional bosies the risk if we were to break from that now is that any of our students that participate in a bosis program or they go for the half day CTE our break not aligning with their break would mean that they would have twice as much disruption in their schedule so it makes a lot of sense to follow the Bose calendar even even though your your points are really valid yeah I understand that I guess that's where the a because you would lie in looking at other
038parts of the country that that do that follow that in the Northeast not you know not just a southern calendar um I think it makes things I think we should plan calendars that work well in educational terms and that's my that's my stance on that I just wanted to add for clarification Ed my question about absenteeism on those half days is for The Chronic absenteeism for those students that are missing a lot of days that that's just kind of like an extra day that they're not I agree with you on that yeah okay I just want to make sure that that was my ration of why I'm curious what our members are yeah and that was my point too like the kids aren't coming cuz why bother you know what I mean they have day
039but unfortunately we still get the credit for it so I don't know like the Statewide I don't know the it's about the students that's that's I'm saying it's a you know it's right you know the students aren't really learning but we can't say okay we're going to hold their office and we don't be proud of so and as the board knows we were really closely monitoring both staff and student attendance on January 2nd and January 3rd because we were concerned of of what the attendance rates would be I if you're curious about the data and attendance rates on half days that's something that I I can get to the board I can um include that in a weekly update if you'd like and we can discuss it further here in public if if you so
040choose but it sounds like there's a curiosity City around is attendance drastically different on a half day just if there's if there's a pattern if there's something we can do to whether it's going to help the staff cuz if we don't have staff and can't get subs that's not good for the students or if there's a bunch of students hasing that that doesn't make sense well I don't think a half day would affect the staff as much CU they're still working the full day but also how' you like to teach the first half of the day and then have to go into meetings and I just I'm just that whole shift gear thing well it's an economy of time you have to get work done things that you have to get done you have to
041make those decisions no I just would like you know hopefully we're working towards not doing that's just bringing it up anything else anyone want to discuss on that before we move on to C okay how about see okay so um exif ficial student board m MERS I'd like to invite Mr Brinker from West Senior High School and Mr Wii from East Senior High School to join us for the discussion they're welcome to have a seat at the table we even have name tags for you gentlemen um as the board knows a little bit of background uh by September 1 of 2025 we are required to have student ex officio board members at our board table to participate in board discussion so just to recap what that looks like as student board members they're intended to
042have a voice and to represent the student body and weigh in on matters sharing their insights in their opinion however there's things that they are not privileged to for example student ex official board members would not enter into executive session with us and they would only be privated the same information that the general public has access to so they would not have access to Personnel records for example uh they are not a voting member of our school board but they can and should participate in discussions so this is a requirement that is uh effective September 1 as I mentioned and we will adopt a policy related to the student ex official board members what we should have a discussion around is how we go about selecting or choosing the students that represent their high schools
043we can have more than one student and so given our our size of our school district it may make sense to have one student from West Senior one student from East Senior but how the student is selected is what I'd love for us to have a discussion on there's really three common ways in which school districts have a student ex officio board member one is by popular vote of the student body so when we hold our student council elections or class officer elections this would be an additional position that someone could run for and would be elected by popular vote of the student body a similar but slightly different way is that you get this position by default so for example you are the senior class president and also the representative at the board table
044representing the student body as the ex officio student board member again that pathway would be by by elction but rather than being a standalone position it's incorporated into our one existing officer positions and the third common pathway that schools take is that this is something separate from student elections and we post if you will or advertise the opportunity for students to have a leadership role being a student ex officio board member those students that are interested Express their interest through an application process some schools have students submit an essay for example up to 500 words or whatever criteria we establish as to why you want to serve as a student ex official board members some schools handle that as it's application and paper review only you can also set it up where the board president
045High School principles or the board president and the superintendent with high school principales interview the student candidates that are interested so there can be an interview process as well so those are really the common Pathways that that schools um have selected their exofficio student board member it's a local decision that we make here then we' archive that in our policy and ultimately the board would adopt that policy so I'd like to just with that background invite you to have a conversation regarding it look like you're in trouble or something guys are no they're they're uncomfortable um I guess my first question is did I is it a senior or is it any kid so it has to be a junior or senior um and has to be a student who's been a member of our
046school Community for a minimum of three years oh really wow so so not someone let's say who moves into our school Community their junior year okay I would be for like an application and maybe not so much an interview process if you know unless we decide that but something where they do sit down either with somebody from the board or uh one of the principles just because we're here so often I would want them to understand you know the commitment if they really are interested like it's twice a month it's in several hours you know most often so I I would want them to know rather than to come to the first meeting and be like oh yeah I'm done I'm not going anymore so I would want to make sure they were aware of
047the potential commitment maybe like a couple board members on a principal or something like that I mean I like that idea um I would I don't know how they would apply like we Whittle it down if they put it in the the process that we go through now we don't have that traditional our school government isn't President we don't do those anymore you know we basically have a council and we have multiple within that Council making decisions so it's not your typical I want to be president or vice president uh which I think encourages a lot of collaboration and interest so what we typically do is ask counselors who's interested in the board rep right now and the counselors give us a bunch of names I reach out to a bunch of students TR to
048whittle it down that's how you get your two reps from W Senor this isn't too far away from what you're asking for what we have to do I like this I'm not a fan of the voting we do that at proms we it's and it's they can get goofy you know but if we do something serious we reach cast a net and we have kids that really want and Paula alch from Las sen is pretty good rap of who and Jacob Knox those are your two reps those two kids want to be leaders they want to be participating in this that's do you think it'd be worthwhile for after the counselors get that group of 10 for you guys to see who would be interested and then doing like a presentation so they knew what
049the commitment was absolutely yeah it's very important that they understand this level of commitment because we've had you know student GS in the past where oh gosh I didn't realize it was going to be twice a month this many out you I've got to work and just like you were talking about setting the board meeting so that candidates know what they're getting into same thing for the ex official student members would be important right and I generally we pick students that are really engaged so does Paul go to bowling or is she here is she and that's going to be a problem cuz these students generally are HS they are involved in it one of things field hockey so um are we saying we want it open to just the council or do we want
050to it open up to any Junior Senior did have to be nominated or something or like what if you're not on the council and you want to be at Paul and Jake are not on the council so so I would open it up to any Junior Senior that would want to come in here and it may it may open it to a student that's not involved with that they just you know what this is interesting I'm interested in local policy making and so Richie Rich I just gonna say Richard sha is all over the news now he's got a commitment he wants to be involved and maybe there you know this isn't our three sport athlete who's also in the play because they're committed to a lot of things so I think that would be
051a great way to go about it I think in the past some of our student reps aren't weren typically able to make it because they had right you know again maybe less of that'll be scheduled on I guess that would be my next question too is when you get the individual from the school is it possible to have like an alternate or is it just set that it has to be one just in case you do have somebody that's heavily involved in sports or musical and they can't make it no that's we need to because when Paul's down here Jake when Jake and that's kind of the selling point of look at I I know you're busy it's mandatory one but I think we could have I think we could do 40 if we I
052I think that I think what a good structure might be is having a senior and a junior alternate and that way you have a junior behind them learning the ropes from each school that's what we were just talking about that's the idea I don't want two I don't want one and one we need to and have that rotating yeah and then if if it's a tie I think if you make them watch a board meeting and whoever is awake at the end can we automatically gets it faces that's an endurance task that you know that could be something to be said about actually having them come at the time of the meeting so I think you have a different appreciation for what that looks like at 6 or 700 p.m. than you do at you
053know 9:00 in the morning at school but the kids we ask when they come back I mean they're Blown Away with the this the reps are so excited to come here you I talk to them the next day and the fact that you're listening to them and you're talking to them they're very proud of this so if we have two students and they you know alternate they're going to be there was a couple years ago I'm not sure when it was Sansbury was a rep at one point and we were having a whole conversation and she was involved in it I completely forgot she wasn't a board member at one point she was so engaged um she was a junior so we had her for two years yeah it was great but she also had
054a lot of other stuff going on but I mean the people that have been here have been really engaged so I think this is going to be I think it's going to be great great we got to come up with any other decisions or so so based on the feedback that I heard there would be an application process um ideally we would have a senior with the junior as the alternate the junior would be making really a two-year commitment to this so that they can experience it a bit as a junior and grow into that as a senior I think the the only uh final thing for us to discuss is what if we have multiple applicants how do we select who is the one selected senior the one selected Junior from each of our
055high schools might we have couple couple board members and a principal each side so in the event of more than one junior senior applicant from each school there would be an interview panel if you would that's repres presented by a board member an administrator we could leave it flexible and and somewhat vague to give us give us that flexibility two administrators one from each High School yeah it adds an element of formality to it also s like that right absolutely um I I would ask if I know that senior and the Junior's an alternate but few of the meetings they can both come so the Junior can my oh all four they can come to all of them I think for the management we would probably want to just have two seats at the table
056and the others could be sitting in the I just want to make it clear that they would be welcome they're not alternate you know like like for the Bose's budget meeting she might go and on the alternate I only go if she doesn't go but I do would like to see them invited to you know the official yeah just them to a two-year process potentially of learning following along the development of a policy or the different discussion threads that happen and this way if they are called upon to sit at the table they were there last month they know that certain questions were asked and certain topics are pertinent so that they don't need to be brought up to speed they're up to speed already right I like it so I can work on drafting
057a policy and and I shared with the policy committee this was discussed at a recent policy committee meeting the policy committee got to see sample policies from other districts neighboring districts that have student X official board members and got a sense of how they go about selecting their student board member what I'd suggest for policies that we designate that it's the board president or his design and the high school principal or his design um to be able to you know your alternate could be an assistant principal and and Ed you could uh designate anyone on theard board so that we have a board rep and a high school administrative rep from each School sounds great to me okay any against it like Marla you good yeah I love that plan I think it sounds great
058thank you um I think that's it Mr two we detention and we'll see you in a mon thank you both you thank you so again no official Vote or anything on anything like that how you doing um we will move on to D auditoriums thank you one of the opportunity to share with the board my apologies um that M all you got to hit that I don't know if it's cutting it right now screwed it up on January 21st we had a meeting with young and Wright to review the building condition survey and specifically the building condition survey it wasn't the entire survey specifically to our auditoriums our high school auditoriums middle school auditoriums which as the board's aware that was something that was put up in a referendum to voters about a year ago
059was not supported by our voters nonetheless the needs are still there and and the needs in many ways are growing um because of the age of our equipment we we are running into extreme difficulty with replacement parts uh the light bulbs that we utilize in our high school auditoriums the house lighting if you will those are are running on the market when we can find them anywhere between $30 and $60 a bulb and they are not high efficiency LED lights they are lights that are going with regular frequency and need to be regularly replaced there's concerns with our rigging system which those of you if you are not familiar rigging system is the weighted police system that we utilize to raise and lower any of our props our lighting uh our lighting stands those things
060on our Auditorium stages um so the building condition survey really looked at what needs to be done we are not considering anything aesthetically at this point so not replacement of seats not replac of carpeting or painting of the interior of the auditorium it really is looking at those things that are critical need and critical replacement around rigging lighting and the sound system and so in meeting with young and Wright they gave a complete and thorough overview of this uh the total estimated price is $8.5 million it's approximately $2 million per Auditorium High School schools are a bit more expensive than the middle schools but about $2 million in Auditorium for a total price of just over $8 million on Friday we'll the met with our our financial advisor on how we may be able to
061present this uh if we should go out to voters with a referendum uh this may and what the timeline could look like for that we do have Capital reserves that could be used to offset that but I wanted to plant the seed with the board tonight uh because I'd like to invite young and Wright to do a presentation to the board to go over the details in in much greater detail than the overview I'm providing for you tonight of all that would be included in a potential Capital Improvement project uh what would be included for each of the four auditoriums the breakdown of the replacement costs and uh then we would get into how we would actually Finance this and the utilization of capital reserves so that we can present this to our taxpayers with
062no local impact on our taxpayers a zero impact correct I mean we would be using Capital reserves to offset the local share right is that just for this year that we're offsetting it cuz how are we offsetting $8.5 million over the term so how we fund our Capital Improvement projects is we borrow that money UPF front so we would incur debt there's a debt service that goes along with that and we're able to repay that debt through the money that we get back on state aid so what's left then is the local share and that local share is what we would have to cover um either by asking taxpayers to contribute to that or using money out of our reserves and so we would be ble to to cover that local share through the use
063of reserves so we'd be be initially taking out debt for the for the the capital Improvement project I mean I think this is a no-brainer one those auditoriums are used every day not just for one show on a weekend um classes are held in there right I mean I've never been in a building that's been open without something going on in an auditorium it's a grading so it does count for St a and all that like yes awesome okay it they are used daily as an instructional space um which is problematic in some of our auditoriums where the house lighting is failing um at East Middle which I was in uh just about a week ago uh they're trying to hold their instructional classes during the day with house lighting that is failing yeah and
064I mean we're renting lighting and spending a lot like they don't manufacture these light bulbs and what I understand stand is whoever hoarded the most is now selling them for whatever they can get um plus they're dangerous if I'm not mistaken last year's musical in West a light exploded and this year's um somewhere I think at East it's exploded and I don't mean like exploded like a bomb I mean exploded like it's not safe um and the money we're spending renting I think is crazy sometimes to do what we're doing so I think it's 0% tax increase but I think it's going to save the district funds or save our theater Department funds I I don't know where the money you know who pays for what but I I think it's a again no brainer
065we just have to get out of the community and explain it well um I think especially like a presentation of the senior center something like that explain what we're investing in we're not just wasting money it's also a benefit to the community because then we'll enhance the the usage from Community groups for this right uh dance recital uh community events can be held there if all of the equipment is updated just to you know current standards and to your point Ed we are um I I was recently in touch with the music department to try to get a sense of what our our rental expenses and we are spending thousands of dollars uh to bring in supplemental lighting equipment for our school musicals because we don't have the the capacity right now in our current
066lighting system and lighting board that's needed for our school musicals yeah and I just want to reiterate that this is a safety issue this is is like downright a safety issue I would be cautious on the way you say that because if it's a safety issue and it's the that severe of a safety issue I would say that they should not be utilized then until it is corrected only because if we're acknowledging it's a safety issue and it's that severe the safety issue are we then liable as in the district if we allow them to use these until it is repaired now I mean think about if you have a light I'm just saying's making an excellent point point but pops classroom I I think what what's saying it it is safe now we're not
067we're not putting kids in Jeopardy but it's an eroding issue correct that is going so me you're you're both absolutely right but I just want let me correlate it to our tracks remember when we our tracks were one year away from being told we cannot use them anymore cuz they will be unsafe we're probably we're probably there hitting that I think that level of detail when when young and with the board support we would have a a more detailed presentation on this during our February 11th meeting where you can have a detailed overview of what was revealed in the building condition survey if anything truly was unsafe for student use we would immediately shut it down I think the reality is though that that day is is likely in the near future for for us
068um that we've been limping along as far as as long as we can and trying to get replacement parts for as long as we can many of uh these equipment pieces are original to the building meaning they're 60 plus years old and getting replacement parts are are just no longer feasible so we we're to a point where we don't want to continue to throw good money at at bad and to to do a full replacement because our ongoing repairs our escalating costs for repairs and also our rental expenses continue to rise and that this project will cost us more today than it would have costed um you know everything escalates every year so had this project been been approved a year ago it would have been done at those dollars as of a year ago
069we are now all dealing with the escalating prices of not only a equipment but also labor yes so that's why I say it Jeremy is that no I'm just saying I get what you're saying anyone but again as the nurse stop throwing a Band-Aid on this when you know we've got to go to surgery that that's really what the situation is and the public has to be aware of that we are a celebrated music Community with our musicals with all of our programs they use them for education so to sit on this again you know I like we just have to make sure the public is aware this is a need and not just a pretty I think it's more than a safety it's an economic issue that we're throwing bad money toward we're throwing
070good money to bad to a bad situation right um and the fact is that yeah it's going to be more expensive than had this past last year but last year we were also asking for contribution of ta of an increase in taxes from from our community this time we're not we are refiguring and and doing it a going a different taking a different approach to paying for it um it's still it was a number two last year the roofs were a number one it was a number two now it's the roofs are set it's our number one so we need to address it but I I would like to see the long-term uh budget for the reserves and for the payment of this because I understand we're saying it's not going to cost you know
071an increase this year but I don't want two three 5 years down the road all of us saying okay we have to increase the taxes by this much because now we don't have the Reserves to cover the cost of this loan we took out so uh let me just get a couple clarifying questions so if it's 8.5 million what percentage is state aid is it like 70 or 80 or 76 so 76 so 76% of that's covered automatically so the other math person in the room helped me out 24 24 but what is that of 8.5 million like 2.1 so 2.1 million is all that we have to figure out how to cover put that in up front we put that in up front and I understand that but does that deplete us too much
072so what if we have a main sewer line go bad or something catastrophic in one of our schools which could happen any day are we going to be that depleted that now we have to take a loan out to cover that as compared to have it in the reserves still have 2.5 million in capital res and capital reserves can only be spent on capital reserve projects correct and a sewer yeah and the sewer thing wouldn't be part of that right well if we had a catastrophic failure of a roof a sewer there are Avenues to do emergency projects um and and we could pursue an emergency project which is is not what we're considering in this situation this is something that would be a capital Improvement project going out to our voters um but I
073I've made some notes Here of and you're right like the these are choices that that the board will need to make um both shortterm of what what our urgent and immediate needs are and what the long-term implications are of that because certainly if we use our Capital reserves for this project that will be lesser dollars that we will have available for some other project that is that is the reality of it but I do believe that the needs are that critical right now and we are continuing to see our costs escalate for repair and replacement and Rental that it that it's something that that we really need to address and so uh what I'm asking for your support is is for that time at the February 11th meeting to invite young and WR in to
074do a more thorough overview of the building condition survey the conditions specifically of the auditoriums and then with that what is the financial plan for how we would go about funding that project and and with your feedback you know we can can certainly look at what do we have in reserves all together what we would plan to be using for this project and what that means for us long term and not for anything but if they were updated to Laura's point we could get have some Roi and begin getting money from organizations utilizing that space so that would be what I would post yeah for potentially for Community use we used to have have a clear picture that's what J was asking yeah I guess the last thing I would have is and it's going
075to be more of a young and right thing is this 8.5 million is this worst case scenario because we all know with every project that comes up they find you know things that have to be added so is our 8.5 going to turn into 12.3 you know I that's I want worst casing like this is what we're thinking but this is worst casing and that's how I think we should be looking at every project because it always goes up it's never oh hey it's 85 5 oh no we came in at 4: no it doesn't go that way and it's 8.5 and it's going to come in probably at 10 or 12 so that's my concern and in that app it's now your reserves are gone so yeah well I also don't want to be
076where cuz you can only spend what's approved I don't want to be where okay we're just doing the high schools we have to cut out the middle schools now you know because we'll never get those we can't go back and do another one for the there are significant need something Happ that's why you have to get them done yeah but if you remember several years ago the roofs were taken out cuz cost and then they were done again I don't think we could do that with theaters um it's been a lot of time long aori in my entire life but again the last couple months with getting ready for musicals with kids um there's some some big needs for sure yeah and I think it's just going to be um a point that's going to
077be have to D be driven home to the community is that regardless of redistricting reconfiguration re whatever you want to call it coming up these four auditoriums need to be done regardless they're staying open and'll they're going to be used good point well I think the biggest factor for is the 76% that we get reimbursed by the state because I mean before I really started getting involved I had no idea so when you say 8.5 million like it looks like Hey we're pulling 8.5 million and today it's not going to affect you by Will down the road so I mean that's something huge that people don't understand and I think the point I've made in the past is if we don't take the 70 whatever per from the state the state doesn't turn around and
078give it back to us as Citizens so let's get whatever we can to improve our local District out of the state money because I've never yearly yeah every year yeah it's it's really really a shame that we didn't do more catapal Improvement projects over the last 20 years um really a shame yeah I mean that's but I mean another way to look at it too is even though we're taking it out of reserves that's still taxpayer money it's not it's not our money that it's the state's not what I'm saying is the state's not lowering our taxes if we don't apply for these for that so we use it or another District asks yeah that's what yeah I understand that but I just Stadium you understand that then it will one day have to be
079replenished so it at some point will cost it's not they use the word Revenue I use the word taxes think like a tax pay if you can think like it's your money at think like a student who wants to be on the stage Jeremy I have no problem with doing the work as long as we do it the right way yeah spend the money wisely and that's oh the other point with young and right they can approach or discuss I want to make sure everything we're doing isn't something where let's say the world all of a sudden we got a ton of money and we're redoing the theaters we got to tear the lights back out again like everything I want to be I want this to be the last you know like I don't
080want to I don't want to spend money redoing things that in 5 years say we have to redo something else that okay we got to tear these lights out and I'd like it to be long-term continuous Improvement like step along bettering the theater like saying because you need new seats now you need new lights too yeah yeah so does that make sense it does it does well we're not you know we're not kicking out a wall in 5 years to expand it so therefore another ring L that sort of thing so build we're not building a football field and ripping out a baseball field not having a baseball field football field yeah like that that' be good I'd appreciate that happen I happen not by us though um any other Mara are you good yeah
081I'm good with that discussion excellent thank you Sarah's not causing you any problems there you're good um any anything else on this discussion then tics no I meant on the Atari everyone's good okay we'll move on to E would uh Starbucks please come on up and join us you you can sit with it you have a name tag I have a name tag you can go up there that's fine all right I'm okay hi everybody thanks for having me thank you for come okay um so I did watch the board meeting um from last month and there was a lot of questions obviously um I just wanted to make sure that I was able to go over a little bit of the history of combining of schools cuz I'm not sure how many people know
082it um it is actually a New York state policy combining of schools so we are held to rules and regulations within that and it uh we're allowed to combine schools for one of three reasons one it is to Foster the emergence of a new sport so we currently do that with uh girls flag football and some of our unified teams um so the second one excuse me is to support a school that has a declining number of participants this is typically what we have fallen into and then the third one is financial reasons um the guidelines for this is it has to be approved by the Board of Education that's step one uh must be approved by our league which is the Erie County league and then it has to be approved by the section
083the section will not hear any of the requests if it isn't approved by the board or the league um applications must be submitted with all signatures uh classifications um that's determined by a graduated scale which I'll kind of get into a little bit later and then there's a vote by the athletic Council the athletic council is made up of our four different leagues plus the Erie County Superintendent reps uh the Niagara County Superintendent reps and then the actual section committee once that gets approved then it's combined for a year at the end um excuse me it's combined for a year you you have to fill out some paperwork and then um you can readmit if you want to the timeline right now is fall sports are no later than the March meeting I actually have
084all of our applications um on the next agenda I think we just submitted them for the next agenda which then they will go to go here for the next agenda and then go to the section following that winter sports is no later than the May meeting and spring Sports is no later than the September meeting I know somebody asked um previously if what our combinations for our for the spring we actually approved all of our combinations last year so nothing unless it's an emergency situation is changing which I will go over that too um at the end of the season I'm required to submit a combining of schools end of season report it's a detailed report that takes the rosters they want to know how many kids from each school they want to know how
085you did were we dominant did we destroy every team in our bracket what were the scores um what accolades were there and what our projection is from next year at the end of that season what happens is there's a combining of schools committee um Mr sortisio the Eden superintendent is in charge of that and I believe he's got five reps on that and that committee looks at basically they take a look at your combination how did you do did you dominate um are you uh uh a team that has a lot of sophomores and you were beating every team by 10 goals um do you really need to combine is there 15 kids from this school and 15 kids from this school what are your reasons they take a look at it and then they
086make recommendations in fact our section uh athletic Council we just um had to approve two uh two mergers that are being bounced up to the next level because of their competitiveness um the section can uh reserve the right to deny your application that is typically done uh if they're going to deny it they're going to deny it based on your classification um us we are in the highest classification we are two large schools that are merged so we are always going to be at the top tier um people that might be moved up would be your smaller schools you could take an Eden and North Collins they may be down in the B bracket or in the C bracket so they may get moved up but we are always with all of our combin because
087it comes down to beds numbers we are already at the highest here um these are our current combinations so I did put the years next to them um this is based on the programs girls ice hockey and just so everybody understands girls ice hockey uh for all the teams in girls ice hockey they are all combined we actually are merged with five schools on that one um girls bowling has been um since 2015 field hockey 2019 girls swim went back and forth a little bit um but has been steady since 22 girls FL like football like I said uh since 22 since the Inception of it modified cheerleading was a pilot program sort of that was added last year so that is in its first year of being combined girls soccer was in its first
088year of being combined girls tennis bounced back and forth a couple times we had emerged due to low enrollment uh same with girlss cross country country boys swimming boys tennis boys golf have all been since 2015 boys wrestling 2018 boys soccer 22 and then boys bowling and boys cross country are new this year all our unified teams are combined um that is Unified bowling unified basketball and then our unified Bachi club/ team um and then our co-ed modified swim team and modifi co-ed modified cross country team are combined this is our numbers for the fall um the x's in there mean that we didn't have that team they weren't a combined team so you can see um you have the total number for each of those I broke them up into East and West um
089they have the varsity the JV and then the modifi I believe you were given the packet um you can kind of see some of them are even some of them are not I'd ask you to look at girls field hockey uh where's another one girls swim cuz I'll come back to those in a little bit am I okay to move on okay um and then these were the winter participation numbers our current season right now again girls ice hockey looks small but we are West Anica East West Anica West H Hamburg Eden yeah we're back to four we were at five last year um and then modified swim on fi thing okay um some of the concerns when it comes to when it comes to combining in talking with the kids and kind of looking
090at our numbers one of the biggest concerns is the lack of identity some of our own kids feel like they are visitors on their own team um transportation I believe Mr Maloney brought it up last time but transportation is a concern with our combined teams because we can only practice at one facility so we have to have a shuttle we have to go pick them up we have to we have a bunch of some teams practicing at West some teams practicing at East we also might have some modified kids that have to come up so Transportation does get a little tricky on that um there are certain programs that we do see an increase in athletes that are cut um but we the bigger concern is the increase of trend of athletes quitting doing due
091to the fact of they may start out the season where they have six friends that they are in school with that are going over to the other team and then all of a sudden three of them aren't there anymore then two then we're down to one and that's why I kind of pointed out the girls field hockey we're seeing less and less um this is the third year in a row I've only had one uh girls field hockey player from East uh we see that on the other side uh with girls swim we have a high number of participants from the East side we have a very low number of participants from the west side we just had that happen with modified swim um our East numbers were great West uh was at 5 and
092as of last week I'm down to nobody um from the West Side can I ask you a question y so in a case like that where it's one student who wants to participate you have to have had that combined application in like almost a year ahead of time or could would they make an exception so usually I can get an exception for some of those so um if it's something where we haven't let me take a team um where it wasn't anticipated yeah so let's take let's take last year's um we were able to form jve softball okay so let's say I wasn't didn't have enough in that situation where we ended up having three or four ninth graders come out um and they weren't Varsity level they weren't modified level that would be something
093where I have looked at the West Side um and then said okay okay Is it feasible do you want to go over there and we've done this before we actually did this Mr Bey and daughter was part of the soccer team we had to do an emergency combination with that but we've been able to do that I've I've gone to the section gone to um the superintendent first said this is what I want to do I want to try to do it can I ask the section for an emergency merger usually if I go to the section and you plead your case about an emergency merger they're very good on that um because our big thing across the section is we want the opportunity for kids we're trying to increase the opportunity for kids um
094and then I do I am very honest with the parents as far as here's your options you can stay on your own home side you could move up be with the varsity team playing time is probably going to be very minimal um but here you're at least with you're learning the program we could go down we ask our league for a 789 team which is the model talk to the parents say okay we're going to do the 789 model we have a um approval for that but a lot of times our ninth graders don't want to go back to middle school or we can work on getting you over to the West Side combine but you're with girls you might not know sometimes they take advantage soccer we were able to um we were able
095to make it through a season we had enough but that was kind of the The Last Resort where we're like okay now we have to finally combine we did look at that um before in the situation of softball the year previous and I had nobody interested in going over to the west side but yes to answer your question in those situations you go to the section with an emergency merger um they do that side note if I think um Girls JV Basketball for East we were set to run we were going to run it wasn't until 7 days into the season we're like we can't do this if that was a situation where it would have benefited to to merge with West we I would have asked for that one at that point in talking
096with the coaches the kids we had other options that was more beneficial for them to stay and us to go a 789 modified in a Varity team so um but the section is very good on those late ones um so my proposal is for next year um basically I have no new combinations I am not looking for any combinations I've looked at our numbers um I actually I want to demerge I want to demerge for modified winter cheer um our number skyrocketed which is great um fall they would still be combined the fall numbers are not they I think I'd have to go back and look but I think I was around 28 um which is actually a healthy number can I interrupt you can you teach me about cheerleading fall cheerleading is this not
097the people that cheer at the football games no fall yeah good question it's a separate thing right no no fall cheerleading is your football okay so that is football chair but it's called fall cheerleading so again I I was at football games and there were kids on both sides did you say they were combined or they weren't just modified just modified so that's the that's like the so modified jvv okay okay and I was never in Le that's okay what I would like to do is Dem merge for winter um we had we had a lot of girls try out we had we had to make cuts on that so I think um I think the interest is there so I would like to offer a winter East chair and a winter um West chair
098um we also we have three programs that we've just I've watched these numbers for two years now and we have a lot of girls that are interested on the west side in playing volleyball our number that came out this year was a 50 um you can only put six girls on a court so the coach did a great job coach bado did a great job she kept a very high Rost um but I would like to add a modified B West girls volleyball team and then I would like to do the same with boys basketball on the east and west side our basketball numbers are growing it's wonderful um but we're we're cutting a lot of kids and I think the interest is there in offering a B team and then um I'd also like
099to explore um this is the first year the section is going to offer a 789 U modifi girls flag football team we weren't ready yet I would like to try that for next year flight football yes and I I know the reason and again if I'm lying about this tell me the reason we didn't do two teams was it was a new sport there was only 10 openings because we have a ton of kids playing it wasn't because of it wasn't because of participation so this is a great way to yeah it's a start it's a start in the right direction so yes the reason we did a combined team to start was uh number one in emerging sport still un looking we have a lot of girls interested in flag football but the Comm
100the full commitment for the season I don't know that it's there yet because we have a lot of Dual Sport athletes um so that kind of takes away and then we have a lot that were they weren't um I wouldn't say they were fully fully committed what we're looking at this year is to see for the 9th through 12th graders we have a roster now we have a new coach we're looking at keeping 28 we're looking the Dual Sport may not work out this year because it's very hard with the increase in the amount of flag football games um so we have to sit down and talk about that um but then what we'd like to see is I think I have enough um because of all the uh continuing ad programs and the um
101wreck programs that are going on with younger kids playing football flag football I think we have an increase in that and currently we're not allowing seventh and eighth graders to play it and I've had kids reach reaching out so I think it's an emerging sport that I would like to see our modified numbers then if those numbers if I have the modified numbers and the varsity numbers are still around 28 then I think we're in the right direction to demerge yeah there seems to be a lot of girls there's a lot of interest um that dual sport does complicate a lot of things because there's only so many days in the week to play a game so I would I'm trying to figure some stuff out this year but I'll know a better number set
102it depends on what the other sport is too um the there is no boys flag football there's no boys no boys even as a like it's football or nothing okay and there's no there's soccer soccer yes football football um no mention of are you am I interrupting maybe inter murals I don't so I don't oversee intermurals those are out of the buildings okay so I have a question about it do you want it now or I can try to answer it well the question is and I would think there's a lot of people like me who maybe did more theater stuff um who would never play a professional High School sport all that well unless maybe a lineman um the inter murals is what I really enjoy yes um we have offered I know you
103had mentioned we were increasing our intermural programs how are those and if you can't answer it can we just get an update at some point everything I've seen is um I have to say the building principal have been great and working with Will and supporting them and the PE teachers at the buildings have been running a ton since I this would probably be the most the past two years the most that I've seen I know I know at West Middle we're dropping off Cameron um four days a week I know they had a Friday night fun night I know the elementary schools are running them all the time Mr Overton has a triathlon he's got a swim in her murals I I think think we're honestly I think they're running them I don't have the
104exact dates or the calendar but I could get it for you but this is the most in the five years that I've been here yeah I I and it seems like if we've got a high like volleyball we had high interest you like yes maybe I already know the answer and I'm just trying to say accolades to the board and the district for yeah I appreciate it it does not come out of my budget I just know that what um I know what I'm hearing from my people I know what I'm dropping off at school I know the gym trying to rearrange schedules I know that part but I know that the principles have been great and if the if the coaches the teachers want to run it they go to the principls with a
105proposal and we've been able to make it they've been able to make it happen it's been wonderful I just I just want to say this makes my heart so happy especially with the modified teams getting B Teams because I know at least on the west side over the past couple years I think I was told like 48 boys Bo tried out for basketball this year and you can't keep that money and you don't want to lose them and a lot of kids don't come back out the next year that's and then you know you end up with a basketball team this year that the varsity team has eight seniors and two Juniors so like how are we growing our program and I think this is going to go a long way to grow those programs
106love it that's definitely a step in the right direction I I'm I'm very excited for it again it's sometimes it's just watching the trend of the numbers to make sure um it does it is a little difficult um you know I'd like to pre-plan for these which is why I put it in my proposal I think these three teams especially actually Four with with cheer but I think these ones have shown that they have the numbers um and planning for it will make it a lot easier as far as building the schedule building the practice schedule making sure our parents our kids are known for um adding it after makes it difficult um especially with the schedule purposes but I I'm very confident in these four I think it's a step in the right direction
107I think um keeping our middle schoolers active and within the program I will help us with some of those that drop off in nth grade that have caused some of these um other combinations just to make sure I did clarify these are the addition I the other programs are still set to combine so you'll be seeing those at the next board meeting so just in case I did not say that the right way um I know you touched on it before but you said when we combine the teams we at the top level so essentially we're playing different teams than we would if we were separate schools so for East yes so typically our schools that's a great question so we are in the Erie County League ECC and right now there's 29 regular schools
108we do have I shouldn't say it that way there's 29 schools that have been there and and then we've been given two Charter Schools but the charters sometimes um don't fit totally in all of our section West is always at the top bracket West it goes um and I should know this I've worked on this left and right it goes Lancaster then um Orchard Park Frontier will North then Clarence then us right now and that's by beds numbers and you have your division two um which typically will be sweet home Williamsville East Williamsville South Star Point well Sona East has been a bubble and we've been in that bracket or in division 3 West is always used to playing these schools so when we merge it's nothing new for West when we merge with East
109it's very new for East it's new for East families and it's new for um east east kids to now go from playing a will South a will East to an Orchard Park to a Lancaster um how competitive are our combined teams great question so let me go back so we're seeing growth boy soccer I will say and I should have brought my other slide because I'll get to that in a second boys soccer their competitiveness is growing um this was probably most competitive soccer year I've seen in my 5 years of being here and that was them being separate and now them being together I think they are headed in the right direction um are we are we winning in that division no but we are no longer losing 10 nothing um West sen East
110when it was separate and in the lower division they were still losing 10 nothing 12 nothing 15 nothing um this was by far the most competitive soccer boy soccer season I have seen in my 5 years and I did have um uh parent emails compliments of it girl soccer is in its first year um so I hate to use any data on that they're relatively new but I will tell you if you take a look at our girls soccer scores from separate again we were 17 nothing Wan East first Williamsville East um was Sonica East vers will South it was 10 nothing so we are in competitive games where we are losing um I think our game against Orchard Park was 5 to3 um Frontier 2 to one um so I can't say with them
111with girl soccer I need more time boys cross country girls cross country uh boys were very competitive they won this year um girls we are working on getting our numbers back up field hockey again they are actually very competitive but we only have one person from East right now um girls swim they are individual sports are hard to say because you could have Devil's Advocate you could say okay but I took my individual scores and I may have done better versus an individual from a smaller School than the higher school can I ask a different question sure how competitive are teams that aren't combined so I could give you both the positives and the negatives um and it and it really depends um it it depends I guess let me tell you from this way
112I'm gonna I'm going to side rail this conversation to go a different direction right now I'm in I'm in we're in the Erie County league and we do everything based on beds numbers he knows this I am fully against that I don't think that we should be B faing anything by beds numbers because again um I think what we're seeing in High School athletics is the halves and Hales Nots if you have the means for travel leaks you're you're you will do very well if you do not um even if I can open gyms and have camps and all this stuff I still have to be able to get people here and um transportation and just you know the ability we've got it's just different and I think in an effort to save High School
113athletics across this area I think the league as well as the section needs to start breaking schools up by competitiveness I have formed a committee um it's schools in schools in need it's I haven't worked out a great acronym name yet but it's schools in need basically um and we have our first meeting we have our first meeting on Thursday um at Iran bosies and it's how can we help schools that are struggling going how can we if you go um girls soccer is a great one that I like to use out of the 29 ecic schools eight of them have no JV program two of them don't even have a girl soccer program anymore those eight with no JV program they're pretty soon they're going to have no soccer program anymore and it's only
114going to be left to the schools that have the needs to compete because what's happening is if you get beat 15 nothing for 4 months they're not coming back they don't want to work I don't blame them they want to go make money they want to go home and have fun they don't want to get beat again the next time around and I've been trying with a couple other schools to convince other ads that if we don't change this and make it more fun and make it more competitive we are losing our kids across Western New York so question so why do they do that for girls with so gr lacrosse is Federated so great question gr lacrosse is Federated and they have the schedule that I absolutely love and Federated means that just like
115football the section generates their schedule boys ice hockey football girls lacrosse girls flag football are all Federated Sports we are based on our league I've already said it to multiple people if I could leave and be a league of one I would be a league of one um because West Sona um boys basketball right now west boys basketball is my prime example um it took 5 years and we finally was able were able to convince the league to allow us to go independent while I think our record right now is five and five five and six five and six thank you um they're playing right now but the games they are losing are competitive they are I'm seeing enjoyment I'm seeing learning I'm seeing competitive games and kids that want to come back the next
116day um not to say that we always have to be that way but we should be trying to let our kids um play within their competitive rates like we try to set them up for success I don't know what better way to say it but so that's my that's my push I don't have a good answer on are our combined teams more successful than they're not because it it depends on the division that they're in it depends on is it a team sport is it not a team sport um I can tell you that when it comes to combined teams there's a lot of things I have to look at I have to make sure that we're putting out a healthy and safe roster if there's a soccer team that requires 11 on the field
117I cannot make it a full season with 13 kids because those 13 kids aren't showing up every day those 13 kids are now becoming you're going to have injuries we have academic eligibilities you have absenteeism um and they're just they get tired so now we're down to nine nine is not a healthy number to put out there it will get us hurt especially because West is going against your Lancaster's orcher Park Frontiers East is going against your will South and your will East and your your hamburgs and your star points I have to make sure that we're putting out a healthy rostered team I don't want you to think my question was uh to imply it's all about the winds that is absolutely not what I meant I just wanted to know if by us
118combining teams are we now just getting blown out because we have higher number of questions it's a it's a great question and I've gone back and forth especially like on girls soccer um and that's why that's what I'm still looking at but boys soccer I've been to so many boy soccer games my five years here and it I think we're really going in the right direction I've seen competitive games and again me a competitive game we're still we may lose through nothing but um we had I wish I knew the sore I think it was Clarence and we lost want to say 2 to one or 3 to one but it was 0 with like 10 minutes left in the game to Clarance like those are the things I'm like okay we're going in the
119right direction this is going in the right direction so I honestly think we're at a good point with our combin me personally we're at a good point with our combined teams it's not I'm not like oh my God they're combined they're going to be combined forever if we can get our numbers back up and we see our numbers grow we're back to separating um my big push right now is to try to get our league our section to understand that they need to change how they do business it's it's baby steps right now um like I said with the boys you know I've asked for independent stus for a number of our teams I was finally able to get boys basketball there um but I think we're growing in certain areas and we need to
120keep exploring that make sure we're adding our teams and then um you know look at scheduling differences well you know Merissa you and I have talked a lot about this over the years I've had a front row seat for a good 10 years now and ECI yeah I mean you how hard you work just to get what you just described to finally get them to agree to letting one team go independent I have zero faith in the ecic changing the the way that they do business in the next 5 to 10 years zero so it's I believe that we need to dictate and make decisions based on what's best for our kids when you talk about those rosters that are safe rosters and I I want to know how many how many football players on
121the west side and the East Side play both ways how many players on the east baseball team and the west baseball team are pitchers and how many innings are they pitching and how are how how are they doing and developing as athletes in our current model of having them separated because when I look at it our current model is you have a varsity team on each side you have a JB on each side you have a modified on side my contention is if you combined you could have a varsity team team a JB team a freshman team an eighth grade team and a seventh grade team so instead of having six teams you would only have five teams but you would have teams at every level where you don't have to have on Varsity sophomores
122playing because they could play JB where they belong CU there's enough Juniors and seniors to roster of varson Team freshman don't have to play JV or as we currently have a freshman playing on a varsity basketball team probably a little bit out of his out of his end you wouldn't have to have that um I understand the downfalls of of the combin and the loss of identity but as you also indicated that it Rising you know a rising tide will will will boost All Ships and when we start winning and stop losing we start developing kids then we'll be better off and you know when we look at what we don't have combined what we don't have combined is football what we don't have combined is lacrosse baseball basketball nice hockey and and volleyball and
123the only one there that's doing well on a consistent basis is volleyball so football obviously has had their had their moments but I think it's worth looking at what would it look like for our students and our athletes in our program developmentally if we had a combined one combined team across the board so come I answer so I've looked at that I I'm Sports junkie and I don't have a lot to do so I look at a lot of stuff um I I looked at basketball after last year and said what would happen if I did combine and and I do believe me if if somewhere in the future we were a combined high school and all together yeah I could see myself running modified a modified B freshman uh JV University but when I
124looked at the current numbers for basketball specifically girls and boys and it was like I could probably build a winning team but there's only so many kids that could make the team and I looked at it and I really did not feel comfortable offering that option because of the kids that I would be cutting um from the girls program and the boys program and I said me my conversation with myself cuz I do talk to myself um I said I'm going to I'm going to roll with it because I think we can be competitive um on separate sides um let's try for the independent um East you know started off the season 4 and0 they're they're playing some tough competition right now but they're also changing their identity of the program um I looked at
125the girls numbers and I'll be honest I've got West doing doing excellent knock on wood they're playing staro right now for first place um I looked at East and we've got a young freshmen we've got two young freshmen actually who are phenomenal and I looked at okay well what could I build great those two young freshmen they could help out west but what about the rest of them what are the rest of them going to do and they're not going to get that experience and I just don't I don't know that we're there yet um because again that identity piece I feel like some of those girls and some of those boys would just say it's not my team I'm not going there and to me I wasn't ready to make that pitch to the
126board um because I think I can offer like I said boys uh East they they just beat loana last week they've got you know they're getting some quality wins I think they're at five or six wins right now boys and then yeah we're developing our JV program our East modified as phenomenal I think the girls yes they're getting some some non- League wins um but I really looked at the kids that wouldn't be involved in the program and I just don't know that they would have stuck it out being that they're not in the same class so if something was to change down the line I I could do it I I could absolutely do it I can build a freshman schedule I can do all that but with two two separate four separate buildings
127right now I just don't me personally I don't think it's the best for all kids across the board that thank you um and I do think by building those modified programs on both sides of town that is the way to to build it so I appreciate your thoughts on that thank you um couple questions concerning just uh one do you track the amount of kids that do not make the teams so we yeah so we have not in the past um um we were going to start so it's a little it gets a little tricky but I've looked at that and I can absolutely do it for the future we have a number of kids that register but then they don't show up day one so my numbers I was trying to take the registration
128numbers but those aren't truly who's trying out so I would have to go by what actually not what but who actually shows up and I could get those in the future but I don't I have not tracked it yet I'm not giving you an assignment that's other just I would love to see okay 50 kids registered 30 kids showed up we have 12 on the team so we had to cut yeah 18 yeah well then everyone gets cut they kind of disappear so some of them disappear so I don't know how you say that like our F our first day of actual non- preseason participation we have this many you know yeah what what I could definitely do it I don't know that it would be 100% accurate cuz I will tell you like some
129just don't show up dat too yeah um I I'd like to just see what the trends are but again it's just me saying that that would be all you guys decide if you're willing to do it or not I can do it like I definitely had a roundabout number on the sports that I was monitoring like the girl soccer and stuff um would you want that for all would you want that for I'm not telling you to do anything I would love to see it for I I just like us to have that as a track thing because my opinion the more data the better if you seen that 50 kids are registering and then no one's showing up for the actual tryy out there's an issue what is it I don't know I it's
130just maybe it's the moms filling out the forms great that's a lot of times again I I have five kids I know what it's like I'm just I'm just asking again I just want to be clear though it's not an assignment this is between you guys to discuss if you're interested but I I like that sort of information I like the data but just I'm not giving assignments um the other question I had is protocols combined teams especially how do you decide which side of town how do you decide um you know again I believe you combined girls soccer was it Varsity yeah uh all three um last last year when the the most recent one y that um and I want to be clear my daughter did not make the team um when you
131combine that how do you decide which side of town SP football was amazing I think but it was a little frustrating they did one week West one week East one week West one week East yeah great for the girls it was just a little confusing so those that's a great question so um Turf time as you can only imagine is at a premium and it's definitely difficult to make a schedule so what we try to do is honestly we try to take a look at the teams that are offered and the schedule that it is and what um the coach can work is it a coach that can start at 2:30 is it a team that can start at 2:30 there's a lot of our teams that can't start at 3:00 or 3:30 because of
132bosies is it what does our transportation shuttle schedule look like are we going to have a lot of kids that need the shuttle or are they driving over um do we have uh boys soccer for instance they were primarily out of East because coach bow he's like you know what I want the later practices I can get a lot more from kids I want later practices so we're going to do this where now we had flexibility uh field hockey she wanted early practices she could start right at 3:00 so it usually depends a lot of the coaching availability the turf being open we have tried to do um the schedule where it's one week here one week here that was more problematic um so what we have done though is try to at least get
133games on both sides of town um so that if it girls soccer they were primarily out of West we had two I think two games over at East boys soccer though we had primarily out of East and then we put two two games over at um West again because of turf time and the number of teams we do have it does make it a little difficult but out of you know some again the identity with the with the kids we want to try to accommodate both we have only offered swimming um out of the East Side uh primarily because they like that pool better no offense Mr Brinker um but they like that setup a little bit better so boys and girls swimming is out of East we also due to the tennis court conditions
134um we have elected to stay at East I'm happy with the decisions and there I was just curious like was it based on where the coach resides or if you have 20 kids from West and it's the West team like so what I'm asking is sometimes you said there's a disconnect if one girl's coming over one boy coming over from East I can totally get it but if you have 15 kids on each side it's you know is there still the disconnect are they going under the you know the West it's a West Sena so our colors right we don't have logo because we don't have a mascot I should say um because I did not want to get into the mascot with a combined team so right now we are just west Sonica um
135Dr Kruger is doing redistricting you might as well throw a m um we've we've kind of played around like um soccer did West Sonica United was super cute I loved it I've kind of G them the freedom of we are going to the the basic colors it's try to incorporate everything but if you if you look at some of the jerseys you put black you put yellow you put blue you put Green in there it gets a little confusing so some of ours have gone to black and yellow some tried to with the the they did a nice Crest um so it's got the W and the E we just kind of when people say what are you we're just west Ana United or just Wasa um so we have definitely again will was great
136with my budget um nobody um is playing if it's a combined team they are not wearing a warhawks jersey if they are combin team they are not wearing a Trojan Jersey we have new jerseys um and uniforms for that so so there's not a situation where if they're combined it's the West team allowing East no if it was an emergency situation it would be different um but no we've been able to do all the jerseys that way we don't have a true mascot um the the field and the location of practic and stuff I am cognizant of it and I feel a lot of times it just comes down to availability again with a coach I some a of District coaches that can't start till 5:00 so it's whatever venue is available but we do
137try to at least get some games on the other side appreciate since Ed's handing out assignments I thought maybe I would uh or you did you say you weren't giving no I wasn't I want to be clear I was making you said it four times I thought you said it differ yeah um I have a curiosity about e the number of E great athletes that don't go to our high schools and rather go to private schools when they leave number when they move on to nth yeah so they when they go to ninth grade they go to St Francis time and St Mary's Lancaster you said athletes do yeah just from our team so if we have you know 8th grade kids I know what you're saying I'm trying to think I'll have to see
138if registration can help me get the exact numbers we don't do an exit survey um I do I will say we've had a handful more than I've ever had actually transfer back this year um I did have an eighth grade parent reach out to me about options for next year um we are seeing more of a return which is nice um but I I'll have to check with registration because they're the ones that have to send the packet um so I'd have to get that list curiosity I guess we could also add in there the number of how many kids we have in eth grade that do leave General too I I and and that may be a more accurate picture just to see in general what eighth graders are leaving why they're leaving we
139may not know excuse me if it's due to Athletics or some other reason sure it's getting worse as so you didn't to talk much um any other Marlo you good any other homework good you're quiet cool well thank you so much thank Youk you Grande Cafe thanks for coffee Grande Cafe Mocha I'm job can I make a motion for a 5 minute break no cuz I was just going to give us a six minute break no really can we take a break everyone sure I don't think we need a motion um again thank you for the break everyone's back here 1 two three four five six s Marlo good good to go we will move on to Mr theel with our budget development conversation thank you I just want to first off say I don't
140normally shout answers from the peanut gallery and I apologize for that but the questions were good and they're on point and it's part of what we've been reviewing and thinking about internally so I just wanted to you know numbers that were at the ready I wanted to just throw out there so thank you I apologize for you know just being like the voice in the background um you're good so we're in the budget process now lots of input coming in uh I get that thing to work there you go uh so we we're Bolding the steps here as we go through them uh we're a week late with this presentation we have received the state aid Revenue Outline by the governor and we're looking at that now and we have done sort of a first
141look at the tax cap calculation uh we don't have all the data that's available that we need to do the final calculation but we have done a first look at it we we have not updated those because it's very quick turnaround um in this presentation but they will be in the next one so this one is just really to focus on some our initial uh salary projections for next year and then does sort of show some of the things that have been moving inside of our budget that aren't salary and benefit related in the past and then next presentation you'll also see those cost drivers and what the requests are from different areas and departments and buildings for for the coming budget year so we've went through our budget goals if anybody has Revisited them
142and come up with any questions or concerns over about about them I'm happy to address any of those those questions now of again it's about you know trying to find that right level of Staffing that gets up gets done we have obviously limitations on what we can do we have contracts trying to maintain our facilities our services um in the best possible order we can uh capital projects certainly help that and uh you know hopefully we'll continue a positive uh push there um budgetary decisions uh there there possib there could not be a possibly more confusing time than there is right now um at some point today federal funds were suspended uh by the president of the United States um and later in the day a judge intervened to say like you know not so
143fast so how that shakes out apparently Medicaid sites shut down in various states around the country and people couldn't you know get reimbursed for services so there's going to be a great deal of confusion as a results in in federal funds we get several million dollars of federal funds so it's obviously a concern as we try to plan for the year ahead and we're trying to do our best to be open and communicate um there's a budget postcard that's going out it has a QR code on it that takes people directly to the budget information page we're posting all the presentations we're posting agendas from the budget advisory committee there we have another meeting on budget advisory next week um we're we've got a email set up I think it's budget weschools.org we'll be monitoring
144that and try to answer questions probably not directly in the email but probably in our presentations going forward uh so I would people can feel free to start submitting questions on that basis Nicole you know can you when tell me when the postcard goes out um just waiting for um finish our list addresses okay so over the next two weeks there should be postcards arriving uh around town can I ask a weird side question where do we get a list of addresses from like does it go out to every property in the school district yes we get them from the post office oh cool it's a lot I'd be curious how many postcards go out just 24,000 plus we got 21,000 21,000 was a guess um we have our budget guidelines for instructional all that
145operations uh Financial stability and Communications which I just sort of talked about Al together again stop me if you have questions on on any of those [Applause] areas numbers wise salary and benefits initial forecast so this is basically a steady state we rolled over all our existing position um adjusted them for contract contractual increases and you can see on the top section of a chart it's about a 3.28% uh increase in salaries um the reason it's a smaller increase than last year is because last year remember we added a lot of positions that came out of the federal grants into the general funds as a result of the expiration of the pandemic funds um so the number of FTE is not increasing as dramatically as it did last year so on a steady state basis
146about 3.28% um if you look down below at the benefit line um those are the actual percentages that are charged in that so that's just a function of doing math against the salary base uh workers comp has been a continual $1 million budget line item we are usually in good standing there um healthc care plans is are really the biggest uh the biggest challenge managing our self-funded healthcare plan uh right now that's focused you know the health funded side is focused on about a 10% increase which is what we've been running um our health our self-funded healthcare plan funds our csca and others uh our teacher unit and our administrative unit have separate benefit trusts that they run so we have fixed prices that are negotiated with them that we pay per m per month
147um on the self-funded side we pay the actual claims so we set a budget and then you know react as the actual claims come in how often I I mean I understand you're self-funded but you still go through a group correct like Independent Health or un something The Independent Health uh manages the payment of the claims both Pharmacy and medical when's the last time that was actually bid out we haven't bid that out since I've been here and this is my completing my fourth year because that's concerning I mean seeing is is the 10% increase more or less from the self funded or is that from the it's the claims the actual claims so the administrative fees and we I can get you a break out as we move forward in the budget process the
148administrative fees are not increasing at a rapid rate we have pretty favorable contract there um but these are the actual claims actual dollars paid to doctors and hospitals and and things like that I understand I understand I understand I used to be on the board for the town so I understand for the healthcare so I understand the whole self-funded and all that it's just to see a 10% increase anticipated this year plus I mean going back to 24 or 15 you know we're just keep going up these large numbers it's it's time I think we have to evaluate the healthcare and come up with a different plan because to sustain this I mean we're going to be over 20 million probably by 27 the bulk of the increase in costs of our high cost claimants
149claimants with very serious uh medical conditions what's our stop loss cap at um 175 I think right now so I me that's that's a good number so I mean after we have over 20 high cost claimants at the current time they obious I'm just saying I think there's other avenues we can explore to um either save money or to at least mitigate such a large increase each year and I I think it's time that we really take action on that because a 10% increase is just way too much okay when we can look at uh the contracts as we roll through the process and uh like we have three two main contracts in Independent Health runs the pharmacy and obviously their drug arm Pharmacy benefits groups runs the pharmacy Independent Health friends the Medicals are
150and it's pretty standard like that rate unfortunately you're seeing across the board we've been around two to 3% a year in the town so and that might just be that you're fortunate without the high cost caiming so there's nothing you we're part of a group that combines I mean we're I think there's I want to say close 15 to 20 different groups that are part of it so we a captive are captive lmhf yep okay so lmhf is a Consortium of of many different uh Municipal Partners uh it's called the Labor Management Healthcare fund i' I've done a lot of research on it and done work trying to drive um other districts to that fund um one of the issues with the fund is is they they won't take somebody like West an schools unless
151everybody in West Anica schools is a part of it and we don't have that luxury with our administrative group and our teacher group it's so it's a great fund and a great opportunity because in essence you share claim risk with everybody else who's part of the fund and the biggest part of that fund is actually the county of Erie so their claims and hundreds of millions of dollars give you a space to sort of if you're having a bad year you're buffered by by having a greater coim base and then your your premiums get adjusted on that there's a similar model in Shaka County that uh the Shaka County uh healthc care fund for school districts where all the school districts in Shaka County belong to it and we shared claim risk there everybody we
152set a rate based upon what needed by the Consortium and so if you have a bad year you have high cost claimants you or you're buffered by somebody else who's having a good year and not doing that so it's a good way to mitigate risk I totally agree I wish we could be part of lmhf has the conversation ever been made with wiissa or the teachers uh that would be an item to be negotiated I know that uh WIA has a a very lucrative uh healthc care benefit trust that they run and uh I'm not aware where they would be interested but I'd be sure to I can certainly have the conversation yeah just even if it doesn't go that Avenue there's there's definitely something that needs to be done about the health insurance it's
153just it's a huge it's a $20 million cost essentially right now I mean it's it's $18 million but I mean you might as well call it 20 um which is a large portion of of the budget so um if we were talking $2,000 I'd be like okay it's nothing but I mean with the gradual increase and it's not going to slow down something needs to be done before uh it it just tips the scale yeah I don't know how much you're going to find though like if you went to a commercial or something else the cost of the drugs um are out of control right now so it's it's a bigger conversation in every District's dealing with it every company's dealing with it um being in a self-funded world I can tell you it's stripped
154down doing the best we can so really but if we're not looking then we're not I mean if we're not trying to make a change then we're doing it disservice to everybody rfps out there that's well I mean I'm going to object a little bit there we we do look at our formulary every year we do look at our coverages every year but we have you just said you haven't bid out since you you've got we have out bid with our Consultants all they do is process the claims what we do meet with them and adjust what drugs are covered what drugs are first here uh access to drugs like some of the more popular drugs that were originated for diabetes and now are being used for weight loss we don't cover that but we
155have drawn lines and try to adhere to that all that ends up nibbling around the edges when you have people with serious medical conditions and it's unfortunate but the population we do serve is an older population and probably averaging an age somewhere around 55 so are we in essence we're I know we sell fund but we're also the decision makers on what we pay for meaning like we help we help in what rules are established okay I I don't sit in review a bill from Wild decides we pay 28 or 32,000 on it got it okay and is there a reason so uh you said WIA has a they handle their own thing and WIA and WIA both have is there a reason other group doesn't have that is it against rules or something or
156do they want to r no rules okay I just didn't know the benefit trust concept is not that widespread um in my previous districts that was not the case I mean everybody you know at Frontier everybody buys from the same path the same self-funded plan and that plan runs about last time I looked it was about 13 to 14 million a [Applause] year but I take your case it is a an expense that's increasing and uh we now have a main consultant LLY Benefit Services who's the same consultant and lmhf so we get the same level input um so the total benefit change is about 5.62 so a total salary and benefits of $118 million up just under 4% again that doesn't include any retirements that'll be received and the impact of those doesn't and
157it also doesn't include any new positions um that were are being requested and those are being gathered now and reviewed well for the workers compensation is that just what goes into like an account line or is that insurance that we put what is uh the workers compensation um it's a million dollars set aside for claims we're self-funded there as well you can see back in 2023 we spent 673 th000 in workers comp um the 2024 number is less than a million I think it was closer to 800,000 where we have a good budget Year we will work to try to um negotiate out pay out claims that have been on the books for a long time um and try to you know work down the the number of open claims we have a thirdparty provider
158that was bit out before I got here um that uh monitors the claims and reports on it to us are we self-funded to a like limit or is it fully self-funded no we have a we have an excess workers comp coverage there as well anything else on that slide oops wrong way so I no this is tough to read and there's certainly a lot of information I really just put it up there to this these are our object code expense categories that are not related to salaries and benefits um and I just highlighted a few lines that uh that have been moving in recent years um some more dramatically than others I'll focus on uh the Top Line the purchase of buses again that's done with our bus Reserve how that's actually done in the
159future um given the dramatic increases in costs for electric buses and the uncertain financing and Aid terms on electric buses we're going to have to consider alternatives but for right now we still have the uh bus Reserve able to fund our annual requirements um contract Transportation um last year we went through a rebid of fiveyear long Transportation contract uh so it took a a dramatic jump uh as we reset the rate um that rates in effect going forward for for five years at escalates at cost a living allowance um it does give us the ability to lease additional buses for first student and it we are we do have an agreement with the Union that's capped but we do have an agreement to at least additional buses if required so we're in those discussions now
160with our transportation unit as to how the best serve uh serve the needs of the district you a question just and again I hate I even have to ask this but that that mandate that I don't care for from the about the bus situation that's going to apply to the private school bus companies also correct yes I believe it applies to everybody okay so cost will so are they running more routes or like what is that dramatic increase of a million thank you that's the same question oh we had the ability to increase uh 10 routes in the contract with our CCA we increased five routes and the price increase which that that's what you see there the now is that because we are underst staffed at bus drivers or is that just the need
161we have there's two things one finding our own drivers is a challenge and maintaining that is a challenge two um the number of routes we have to run given the transportation to Charter Schools non-public schools and other special ed uh tuition based schools has it's got done like a giant spider work so we've needed the capacity uh that's why we increased first student if we if we could do it all in house and have you know 80 plus drivers I would imagine that would be our choice and then is this based on like a day-to-day thing that we're getting charged by them because I can tell you from both high schools which inevitably has to trickle down to the middle and elementary they're combining buses nearly every day I don't know if it's West senica
162bus or first student routes that they're doing this for but if this is for student routes are they then going to refund us a certain amount of money for both West Anica routes and first student routes get um end up being combined um they have what I would say similar challenges with uh driver retention um then everybody else they're not immune to it yeah it is my understanding that if they do combine routes that we do get we do get a get a refund of sort am I mistaken in that I mean that's my exp I wouldn't call it a refund we're we're negotiating with them right now as to how the relationship Works going forward okay it's always been a contract that's been divided into 10 months and and paid they're also doing other
163runs for us so if they if they have to combine like a high school run uh for the for a drive home or AM or PM um they may also at another time be running a special ed run or uh other balances out right now we think it balances out uh we've had a meeting with them recently to try to drive the relationship to a higher level um having uh Jennifer Jones on board has certainly been a help in that regard she's taken a very forward leaning posture and working more closely with the contractor um we're looking for a greater deal of of access to them operationally so we can have better communication with our parents because she's the one who has to deal with all that input coming in from the parents so um
164any dollars we spend on contract Transportation along with the rest of our transportation is aided heavily by the state um and that's something that we certainly count on when we negotiate these agreements that was actually going to be my next question is that like 71% that I think it's a little higher now I'll know the final percentage once the detail on the governor's bud is that based on dollar spent or is that based on mileage driven dollar spend cool um two other quick questions about the bus and costs uh I know at one point a few years back we were looking into some of these special ed routes not being buses used but like Transportation vehicles that didn't require CDL licenses was that ever like look is that just not a feasable thing or are
165you was I making that we only have one or two vehicles right now that we we would do that with one is uh a longdistance run to Rochester um there's been issues on that run and we've bid that out you've actually approved the contract tonight with Western New York bus another bus company to to do that run for us okay um that's better than a setting a bus to Rochester right and we have uh Transportation has purchased a greater number of 30 passenger buses to try to accommodate the low attendance runs if you will uh remember on some of our special Aid runs we also have to accommodate AIDS and uh in some cases a nurse so it's it's car settings or SUV settings might not be appropriate for for that type of run cool
166um if you go farther down the West uh the first Blue Line the second blue line Sorry 471 is tuition that's tuition paid for out of District special education students um you know since the pandemic uh there's been a dramatic increase we've talked about that here at this table in previous year's budget sessions it's affected both Staffing um and the tuition line it's it's certainly an item that Dr Krueger's up to speed on very very quickly and you know be part of our staffing discussions going forward before we come to you with a recommendation I can tell you that this trend that you see there will continue um in the 2026 budget year do you have and you might not know this uh but do you know approximately how many students that is that are
167I do not have an FTE number um we can get that for you Dr Fowler would have that immediately the total number of students that are out of District incurring that tuition expense you can make a note of that to see that it would be interesting to see that by grade level I'd also be curious tuition's different than charter schools so none of this tuition is unmated meaning like we're not paying for tuition someone to go to St Joe's no or this is tuition for like special ed yeah Special Ed period like period Charter Schools or F School autism um Services you know those type of schools Baker Victory um the next line down payment to Charter Schools it's another line that's been accelerating um you'll see at our next presentation it's accelerating again like
168I can tell you that during the current budget year we are already over the budget and pulling resources from other lines to fund it enrollment and Charters is increasing that's another thing I'd be curious about is how many and what where's the charter schools are K through 12 some of them some of them are like I'd be curious what we have where but then if we have kids go to Charter Schools and we have to pay for it and they come back do we pay still for the whole year or is it now you pay several increments over the course of the year and we only pay to what the equivalent FTE was so if they were there for 5 out of 10 months we pay okay and then Charter Schools generally don't send kids
169back until right before stay testing after bed yeah yeah got it you made a just for clarity the beds numbers I'm a nurse I'm thinking beds as how many people can you fit in there is that what that means how many students B educational data uh statistics so it's a annual count that comes in October and it's kind of your your measurement for the year that everything else is based on so your bed's data is the number of students it's kind of a snapshot in time like heads and beds it is it well it's butts in the seats on a specific not it's not I just want to make sure day in October yes we're required to report our enrollment okay and the enrollment of West Anica kids in nonpublic schools you know the enrollment
170of Charters the enrollment of special a you know Charter or tuition kids both at Bose season it's a large complicated reporting that uh that we do in the district but it sets a lot of things it's used across the board to try to Level Playing Fields even though it's a snapshot on a given day everything that's really enrollment based even some of our state aid dollar amounts that are based on a per pupil amount a lot of things are based on that that magical number that we that we capture in October and report to the state it's one day out of the whole year it is and and the logic behind it is that at the beginning of the school year there is a lot of transition and influx kids who register late and might
171not be there on the first day of school and so they don't do it intentionally in the first few weeks of schools so that hopefully those things settle down but you know different schools have different transient rates throughout the year and your number is never constant all year long so they do pick a date in October and that day is the day thank you sorry if there's anything else on this page um the only thing I'd say is that next month you'll see the 2026 column and uh I believe we're going to give you the full fully requested 2026 column so it has some wishes in it and then you know we'll work forward from there to do what we got to do to come to a budget have we seen I don't know again
172what categories these fall under um I know there was a major shift in printing um our budget numbers reflected that where we're not printing certain like a lot more like are we are we is it a positive or negative or how are we looking on that with our budget uh I think was difficult uh to close the the shop I don't need that answer now I don't know if it's something but it was difficult to close the print jop but had an impact on people yeah um but from a financial perspective couple of things one I think our print costs have gone down um the amount of stuff that we print it now gets a high higher level of scrutiny and uh so we've pulled back on stuff that we print in the volume that
173we print it U because now it's not viewed as being a quote unquote free resource like oh we just send it to the print shop now now you know we have one person Manning a digital print shop downstairs who does a heck of a job um but we have a we have I would say greater controls as yeah I was curious about like also the we didn't go out and buy a whole like ton of printers and then now they're making textbooks out of the smaller printers in their buildings or no like we okay just curious no right no we had two larger we bought two larger production machines to replace the the old uh ink four-color and twool press presses so um bef in The Print Shop does a fantastic job managing it and
174we we've been wrestling it to the proper end just curious thank you I know more about printing now than I ever wanted to make y wrong way again um bosei Services last year we held bosei Services flat uh the goal this year is also to hold them flat the Bose's budget kicks off Friday with a long uh meeting with our bosis representative and we'll begin to construct it um it spans everything from our data system software uh legal advice and services policy Services uh special education uh tuition for CTE programs you know we have 200 kids that leave our high schools every day and go to bosis for half day programs um so it's it's a far ranging budget covers me much territory so I end up being the guy who sort of shuffles the
175cards you know Special Ed gets their cards curriculum gets those cards the high school gets their cards so but the goal is to try to hold it flat so it doesn't uh contribute to uh any budget shortfalls I I know over the years we've increased um and you know I appreciate the effort of the district and the board and everyone put into increasing the amount of kids going to bosies do we find a lot of non-continuation of going to bosies with kids is there is there a huge cuz I know that we do pay for for the year because they have the spot is there 200 kids starting bed's day are we getting a lot pay for the whole year if a student drops charged twice once in the fall once in the spring so
176I thought that would count as two yeah okay so I'm just curious do we have are we having 200ish kids fully participating in bosis or is it um the 200 kids is actually a last year's number so they charge us you know it's kind of like a onee removed okay so it went up I just got the letter today I just got the letter today um for 200 the last year we paid for 171 okay uh so it's a pretty significant increase in terms of dollars in the hundreds of thousands yeah and this could be more of a question talking about things in the future I what Kate Welker is our you know CTE person and I sent her all the data today so it's during the process we can review with you if you'd
177like you know what programs they're in yeah what schools they come from you know how many pro people who were in program one took on program two their senior year um you know we we try not to let kids jump around because it's a junior senior thing you know if you start one small animal science one you should do small animal science too in order to complete whatever it is you're trying to get accomplished so great program they do great things yeah I also handed out an Easter year stations uh a publication that came from bosis uh talks about West senica's relationship with bosis and how much we do together um that came from bosis so um I just uh wanted you to have it reason uh Debt Service we we worked with our financial
178advisor as Dr Krueger mentioned um for Debt Service for this year you'll see that number again um the next time we meet um it reflects the additional borrowings to complete uh $75 million 2018 project and some borrowings to support the $23 million 2023 project and then we have we're responsible for like 20 % of special a Aid c special ed cost for certain programs um that's what you see at the bottom in terms of transfers and then the transfer to the capital fund that's the $100,000 Capital outlay project that also generates state aid at about $75,000 a year so you know we spend 100 we get 75 backs so the net cost is 25,000 pictoral representation of what our budget is you can see that between salaries and benefits we're in the 75 to 80%
179range um you know Debt Service 5% Transportation 5% you know other 10% but you know that's a historical number 75 to 80 that's where we we always are [Applause] any questions [Applause] there uh we have budget advisory I think uh this coming Monday so we'll uh review some charts with uh those folks and we look forward to February 11th where we'll talk about the state the governor's proposal for state aid um how we budget state aid here um a first draft of the tax cap calculation again we don't have all the numbers they won't be available till the middle of February but we'll you know we'll take our first run at it and then we'll all those uh expense codes that you saw today you'll see the 2026 column uh based on requests not based
180on Final so we begin to feel like where we are revenues versus Appropriations and uh what needs to be done any other questions I'm sure the boss has lots to say but she's not capable of thank you will will and I were supposed to co-present so thank you will for taking this everyone good can uh move on to number four Board of Education discussion and I am looking at the long list of items um does anyone have anything they would like to add to that b most of items there's none I just want to remind everyone that I will be um in Albany on the 11th so I'll need to be virtual thank you for doing that yeah cuz the 12th is the uh advocacy day on Capital Hill so I have you decided you
181are going to do virtual or will you what work with Nicole to make that yeah yeah she's aware yep St by just I just know where to talking about travel and stuff like you're going yeah I'll leave early enough so I'll be yeah [Applause] nice anything else youer no Mara excellent okay we will move on to the next thing number five anticipated executive session may I have a motion to enter into executive session for discussion related to the employment history of a particular person I'll make a motion to go into executive second second and any no no we don't do discussion all in favor oh do we do a discussion no do I ask if there's discussion okay but I'm not okay F all in favor I anyone oppos 70 okay we'll be going into
182executive and then adjourning out but we will not be more than likely conducting any public business so thank you sir thank you everyone at home or in your car or wherever you're watching have a great evening know