CorpusRecord 138478

BOE Meeting, January 7, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / West Seneca Schools
Date
2025-01-08
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,676 words · about 71 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001hello everyone and welcome to the uh January 7th 2025 meeting of the school board uh we are going to start by welcoming our students from West Middle up to do the pledge [Applause] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you next we're going to move on to roll call when I call call your name please State present Mr Maloney present Miss P warik present Miss Greenberg present and bar all right Miss barich uh and Dr Kruger of course um our uh board president is absent this evening and Mr vanderlip should be here a few minutes late so he should be here shortly uh I'll turn it over to Dr Krueger

002to do the superintendence report wonderful thank you very much good evening everyone happy to share a few updates with you uh first of all throughout this fall our colleagues from Young andri Architects have engaged in our building condition survey building condition surveys are required by New York State Department of Education and they analyze various aspects of our schools from the condition of our roofs to our Windows to hvac's and uh young and Wright has been studying all of our schools and we'll have a very detailed report for us uh very soon for us to review that report will help to guide our next steps for fut future Capital Improvement projects so young and rights team has done the inspections at all nine schools our transportation facility the Winchester Academy that we currently lease to bosis

003and also our eboner offices where many of our Central offices are located we anticipate that we'll get the results of the building condition survey uh later this spring and as I said this will help us to inform our priorities on things that we really need to address in future Capital Improvement projects in addition to that we have embarked on a facility focus groups and facility F focus groups have occurred uh throughout our schools uh and this team uh entails myself will'll the our business official uh representatives from the buildings in Browns Department the leadership team of mbar and Joe far and we are meeting with every building principal and sometimes other stakeholders have been brought into those conversations such as head custodians or the SRO if they wanted to show uh safety issues at a

004particular school and from that this is kind of developing what are our desired outcomes at our schools instructionally safety things that may be beyond the actual and bolts of roofs and windows and things of mechanical in nature so some of the emerging themes that are are coming out from these facility focus groups at our schools at the elementary level there is um kind of a unified feedback of some Renovations in our cafetorium that we have um utilizing that space a bit differently potentially removing the risers that are in front of uh the steps that are in front of the uh stage area so that we can have some greater space and renovations to our libraries some of our libraries have not seen Renovations or updates in decades and that was a theme that has been

005emerging across the elementary level uh additionally we have some spaces that are really not utilized as they were intentionally designed for example at several of our elementary schools the locker rooms are not being utilized for fizzed changing spaces instead the locker rooms are really being utilized for additional storage there is some storage need uh at the elementary level that was relayed to us the simple um desire to have screens on all of our Windows came up at several of our schools we have children as you can imagine with allergies to bees and be stings and we have several of our schools that do not have screens on all of their Windows of course we can't have screens on Rescue windows but outside of that rescue window having functioning windows in screens seems like a pretty

006basic uh request out of our schools and then outdoor play areas from fencing around play areas such as our playgrounds to ensure student safety to renovated equipment and I I'll talk a little bit about that in a few minutes so at the middle and high school level again some enhancements to our kitchens or cafeterias were expressed again improvements to the libraries at the high school level in particular those of you that have visited our high school there is um a pretty dire need to make some re Renovations in the lavatory facilities that our students use at our high school um particularly at East Senior there's some advocacy for improvements of the athletic complexes at uh at East Senor specifically baseball so that it's on par with what we have at West Senior and concession stands

007again so that it's on par with what we have at West Senior at our middle school and high school I think many of you are aware that we did put forward a year ago a capital Improvement project that would address the needs in our auditoriums and unfortunately that aspect of the referendum was not supported by the community and by voters nonetheless the needs are still there we have some pretty significant needs when it comes to our rigging system which is a weighted police system to allow us to control mechanics like backdrops and Lighting there are some safety concerns related to the age and the condition of our rigging system and so that is very much a priority that was expressed To Us by not only the high school administration but also our music department the

008lighting system and seating within our auditoriums are something that that we asked for Community Support a year ago we still have those same needs and so we want to do a better job of articulating what those needs are so that our Community is fully aware of the needs that we have in our auditoriums but if I had to sum up you know some of the emerging themes from the facilities focus groups those would be some of the big categories that were expressed uh to us through those visitations at our transportation facility our transportation facility has not had any improvements in decades and um unlike educational spaces we do not receive state aid on our facilities um our transportation facilities in the same way so that has been neglected the location of our fuel tanks is

009less than ideal to say the least it it's truly um a concern for safety our buses have to back in to back up to fuel tanks and the location of those fuel tanks make it very difficult for traffic flow and parking there are limitations with our current bus garage and certainly as we look on the horizon to the Future of zero emission buses preparation for that and an investment in our transportation facility is something that we will likely really need to contend with so I mentioned earlier the condition of our playgrounds in a very general and Broad sense but I want to draw your attention specifically to the condition of the playground at Northwood Elementary um Northwood elementaries playground is is our oldest and uh in a condition that is of most dire safety concern

010these are a few pictures from the Northwood Elementary playground where you can see where railings once stood in place those railings have deteriorated uh need to be in replacement but the age of the equipment is such that we cannot get replacement parts and so you can see that there is actually wood paneling that is covering spaces so that children uh don't fall through those particular areas [Applause] if you can see in this uh particular the upper leftand picture shows where the the railing has actually disconnected from the center uh structure and post thereby causing either a a sharp edge or a concern for student safety that that railing is not truly secured to prevent a child from Falling so with these concerns and and the other picture is right in the middle of the playground

011area there's a beautiful tree but all of the roots are exposed which poses a regular trip Hazard for our students so this has become a top priority for us to address the safety concerns that we have at Northwood Elementary and while I would love for us to to be able to wait for a future Capital Improvement project that really is not in the best interest for student safety and so we creatively put our heads together to come up with an immediate but an interim solution and with that immediate and interim solution we are going to be repurposing two pieces of playground equipment that are currently located at our former East Elementary School we will have a professional team of playground installers remove that equipment from East Elementary and relocate it to Northwood Elementary leaving behind

012a Bank Of Swing swings and two other pieces of playground equipment so it can still be enjoyed by students who are in the bosis program at East Middle School and and for neighborhood students uh who might enjoy that that playground equipment but this is an immediate and lowcost solution for us to have an immediate impact on the hundreds of children that enjoy the playground equipment at Northwood Elementary realistically I'm seeing this as a 3 to fiveyear solution it is a Band-Aid to get us through until we can have a greater long-term solution for our playground at Northwood and at other Elementary schools so these are the two pieces that we uh are going to be relocating from East Elementary School they are in beautiful equipment a piece of playground equipment and One Bank of swings

013I have also an aerial view circled in red are the two pieces of equipment that we'll be relocating and the other pieces of equipment will stay behind so that there is still playground equipment on campus there for the neighborhood to enjoy so I just want to underscore why this is a I think a priority and something that we need to address with a long-term solution the benefits of outdoor play and recess I I cannot speak passionately enough about and I think we learned through covid when our students were spending way too much time in front of screens not enough time interacting with peers the need for our students to have interactive play with peers and unstructured time that's not facilitated by adults but just kids being kids and playing outside and playing on equipment the

014gross motor core strength balance coordination com combating childhood obesity these are all benefits that we get when we have daily equipment for our students to have outdoor playtime with each other and the social emotional benefits um are undeniable if you're interested in learning more about this I have linked a research article for your review but I think that this is something that we really need to look at when when we're delivering a highquality comprehensive educational program both our fizzed program and the equipment that our students have access to has got to be a key part of this so some other updates that I'm happy to share with the Board of Education are under the realm of safety we are presently uh evaluating two online monitoring tools one is titled gogu Guardian Beacon it's an enhanced

015version of Gog Guardian the other is Gaggle this will allow us to um have greater monitoring of our students online activity so as you know our students in grades K through 12 have a onetoone device all of our students have access to a Chromebook and there's some limitations presently on our ability to monitor students activity online so we're evaluating these two tools and hope to have a decision uh in the very near future and then we'll be looking to implement uh one of those two programs later this spring additionally under the direction of Sharon lochran who is our uh director of PPS and overseas District safety we will be investing in threat assessment team training for our school uh School threat assessment teams the Virginia threat assessment model is really known as the gold standard

016of threat assessment tools and trainings and we have a national trainer from the Virginia threat assessment model who will be coming to West senica for our spring superintendent conference day and working with our school-based teams and that may very school to school but we anticipate the team to entail School administrators members of our PPS team like School psychologists social workers counselors and of course our school resource officers when we're evaluating threats they are a key part of that and so those teams will participate in that training together so happy to share those safety updates with you and then lastly just want to highlight some of the awesome things that are happening in our district and throughout our district uh before the holidays West Senor hosted their annual Santa on the bridge which was a fundraiser

017to benefit Roswell Park Cancer Institute um earlier today in fact we had e senior that hosted a blood drive for the community to participate in so kudos to the leadership team and National Honor Society at East Senor we have uh an event actually tonight last night was our varsity teams participating in coaches versus cancer and tonight our JV basketball teams both girls and boys will be participating in this event which is a fundraiser for the American Cancer Society so we appreciate their leadership I think this is a preview to our awesome visitors who are here tonight representing West Middle School um but very soon you'll be hearing a little bit more about The Adams Family Musical that coming up at West midle school January 23rd through the 25th and looking ahead some other important dates

018that I just wanted to get on your radar and make sure the community was aware of um we have some key committees that will be meeting in the near future our budget advisory committee strategic planning committee and our redistricting committee will all be meeting within the next two weeks uh for board members who may be interested Hodson Russ is hosting a school law conference that we are invited to participate we have two upcoming holidays where school will not be in session the first is January 20th the Martin Luther King Jr holiday and I do also want to point out that on January 29th students will not be in session for the Chinese lunar uh New Year which is observed that happened to fall on a Saturday last year so it was not a holiday that

019was observed last year for schools so I wanted to draw your attention to that and then later this month we have our fifth grade Musical at West Elementary so as usual lots of wonderful things going on in our school just want to pause to see if there's any questions or feedback from the board of bed I just had one on the playground I fully support it but just wanted to publicly have it out there because there was a misconception perhaps misunderstanding misinformation several years ago uh when when it was Winchester before it moved to Winchester potters and at that time the sitting PTA was notified as was the community that money had to be raised raised from the PTA and that the district could not provide monies towards that so I just want to make

020sure moving forward that that is clear that you know that came up on a vote that didn't pass last year and there was confusion within the community of where those funds could come from because they were led to believe it had to be fundraising only so I just think this is a good time to get that out there I really appreciate you trying to get clarity around that so that there is no confusion and and while I wasn't part of that conversation at the time there are School communities in which PT or PTO May fund raise to help supplement the cost of a playground but when you're talking about a school playground that serves hundreds of children kindergarten through sixth fifth grade it it is often something where you're looking at hundreds of thousands of

021dollars and to put that on the backs of our ptas would likely take them decades to raise those funds by the time the funds are raised their children would likely be in middle school or high school and so while we are appreciative of all the fundraising efforts that our PT do to help enhance our programs and enhance our equipment I think in this day and age to expect a PTA to fundraise that is is quite a lofty burden to place Upon A PTA in addition to that we have the ability to tap into state aid on playground equipment or any equipment enhancements of that nature sure that would be under the umbrella of physical education and playground equipment so rather than putting that burden onto our parents to fund raise which some of our school

022communities may be able to fund raise uh better than other school communities I think in order to provide Equitable opportunities and Equitable equipment to all of our students us having a role in that as the school Community I my opinion is that that's that's important for us to to show our support to be able to provide that equipment to our schools just like we would not ask our our music boosters to fund raise for rigging and lighting and seats in our Auditorium that would likely take them decades to do that we have the mechanisms to be able to do that through the support of our community and reinvest in our schools thank you because that was the frustration so that's very good news to know moving forward yeah I I would just ask that um

023because I think you're I'm glad that you're putting a focus on that that and I'm glad that we're we're getting away from the different PT being the sole providers of those equipment because once that equipment's purchased is there now budget lines to maintain the the equipment that that was there here at Westell you know a beautiful beautiful layout uh 20 years ago and now it's it's showing it's wear and tear who's responsible for the maintenance of that equipment and where do those funds come from to provide that maintenance that maintenance is really should be viewed as any other maintenance that we have of any of our other facilities or equipment in District and that would fall upon us as a district to maintain that specifically It generally is our buildings and grounds department and their

024budget lines which have some maintenance and Equipment um funds to be able to support that but just like if a piece of equipment breaks in our weight room or in our gymnasium having that same mindset that we have a responsibility um and a to minimize risk and liability to the district to maintain the equipment that we have great questions thank you thank you all right we'll move on to odly the bo vice president report for today um so I just wanted to reiterate some of the things that have already been mentioned event wise um we do have ice hockey basketball bowling swim wrestling and indoor track taking place uh we have some of our events will be listed in the public agenda um but then you can also see those through our district and school

025websites and as h a side note I also want to bring up the musicals again it's great for our community to come out and support the West Side musicals during uh January and early February and then the East Side musicals will be coming a little bit later in the spring I think that's it for me okay thank you it's now time for public comment do we have anyone that would like to speak to the board I would okay so I'm just going to read the the rules quickly for you uh the board will now entertain public comment for 30 minutes with each speaker given 3 minutes when called please step up to the podium and state your name and address please be respectful in your comments and do not divulge any personal or confidential information

026for example names specific situations Etc you would please come up and state your name and address hi my name is Betty Rey I live on 1084 Minal Springs Road and when you may brought up the idea about PTO and PTA getting involved with the playgrounds I did with my kids my daughter does with their kids if you want to have a fundraiser why can't you have gazebos or little Huts where kids can't be in the Sun for the Wheelchairs and students that can sit and relax and watch other people play I think that could play a role in making this so they can be for the kids also it's aw thank you thank you welcome do we have anyone else that's interested or signed up for public [Applause] comment okay we are going to move

027on to our presentations and our first is going to be our school Spotlight this month which is West Middle I'd like to call up Mr Trevor galowski up to the [Applause] podium good evening uh my name is Trevor galowski my co-director Jessica hunger is in the back and we're extremely excited to represent West Middle today but more uh specifically represent the upcoming musical of Adam's Family the cast and crew have been hard at work with casting happening at the end of September and then rehearsals have been going on four days a week all of October November December and finally our show month is here and so we encourage everybody to come out shows are January 23rd 24th and two on 25th with tickets available online with that link we'll make sure is up on the

028district website tonight we have two of our cast members they do not dress like this normally during the school day um we have Sienna lace and Jacob swed who are playing characters in our show and who are uh gracious enough to perform tonight for us but let me give you a little opening of our scene here so our scene tonight opens uh to Young Wednesday Adams an irrepressible bundle of malice enjoying some quality bonding time with her brother Pugsley Adams Pugsley seems to be attached to some sort of deviant device and his sister happily operates such Contraption Pugsley just found out that his sister is interested in Lucas a quote unquote normal boy from [Music] Ohio a k i s i n g first comes love then comes a ah that was intense do it

029again do it again ah this Lucas guy still coming over for dinner tonight yes oh Pugsley ever since I met him I just want to laugh and cry and everything seems right and wrong at the same time and then sometimes I just want to kiss him until he's [Music] dead I don't have a sunny disposition I'm not known for being too am my demeanor loost in one position see my face I'm Inus suddenly however I've been puzzled funny rabbits make me want to cry all my inhibitions have been muzzled and I think I know why I'm being pulled in a New Direction but I think I like it I think I like it I'm being p in New Direction through my painful Pursuit somehow birdies took FR and all the things I detested impossibly [Applause]

030cute God what do I do hi my little birdie wow got some real issues mother always said be kind to strangers but she doesn't know what they destroy I can feel the Clear and Present dangers when she learns that the boy has got me ped New Direction but I think I like it that was good that was good I think I like it do it again do it again being in a New Direction and this feeling I know is impossible so I'll conf find that I try but I can't let it go it's disgustingly [Music] true just watch me p in New Direction if keep insisting I'll stop resisting just watch me p in a New Direction I should stay in the dark not oy Every Spark but the boy has a fight better far

031than his and you better to do what's truly as I hold New Direction thank you thank you both again thank you and we hope to see you at the show that was great I don't know if I would have been brave enough to do that in middle school so great job this might be more intimidating than actually being on the stage with everybody else in the uh cast and crew um so again please go see the musicals for sure I've heard a few of those songs around the house lately I'm sure you have too H oh yes all right um up next we have a budget development presentation from Dr Krueger and Mr the our business official thank you very much and thank you Mr field for joining me [Applause] good evening everyone I am

032joined by my colleague will F who is the school business official here in West senica we're going to share an overview of the budget development process uh we are embarking in budget season this will ultimately culminate with a school budget vote an annual election on the third Tuesday in May and we wanted to share an update tonight so that the community and the Board of Education had an understanding of subsequent presentations that you can expect on the horizon uh so that we can approach our budget in a transparent and comprehensive way um and seeking feedback from the board throughout the process so a few Milestones that um we have maed out in key dates for the Board of Education to be aware of in our budget development process have been outlined here for you those

033that are already highlighted in bold font uh really represent the stages that we've already gone through at this point so we did this fall form our budget advisory committee the Board of Education recently adopted our budget calendar will has been working on the per pupil allocations to buildings and that was shared with building level leadership in December and presently meetings with the department heads so that we can get feedback on the priorities goals and needs from each of our departments is underway the things listed below that such as as anticipated state aid revenues the tax cap calculation the first draft of our budget where we seek feedback from the board fine-tune that further for a second draft budget and then ultimately leading us to the board of education's adoption of the budget will take place

034in April and then this culminates of course with the budget vote in May that we will put out to our community and stakeholders of residents here in West senica so this is our timeline that we'll be following in hearing to throughout this budget development season our budget goals that we have mapped out I'm going to turn over to will to highlight those budget goals for 26 uh school year first of all I was told by the staff we would have to assume a Adam's Family character and do this in character so I was going to do lurch but I will do Martia okay I don't think it'll go well with Lurch so I'll just be will which is enough Lurch for everybody so um our budget goals these are General goals sort of overarching guiding

035principles um first is providing a staffing plan that supports our uh Services supplies and contractual obligations that support our instructional goals and we'll get a little bit more into instruction as we go forward here second one deals with what I call the spinal cord of the district uh facilities transportation technology you can add cafeteria in there although it's a separate budget done in a separate fund and it's funded differently um looking at ways to enhance the educational experience in the district by uh improving uh the atmosphere we teach in the our environment uh the conditions of safety uh getting kids safely to school and back uh three is to make decisions that are consistent with plans for long-term Financial uh sustainability um the district has built fun balance to a solid level certainly not lofty

036in terms of our neighbors and ours our our Western York area but uh the last year was the first year fund balance dropped uh this year we would expect fund balance to continue to drop we're investing the fund balance that we acre during the pandemic Aid period back into operations as we try to bridge the gap between our revenues and our expenditures so that's an important thing to keep keep in mind as we make decisions going forward and fourth is to communicate these needs to the public in a transparent process we hope the budget advisory committee is a step in that direction and uh Dr Krueger has certainly taken the lead of expanding our public footprint through branding the district you know getting our message out and we we look forward to continuing the budget

037process under that guides thank you welcome so our instructional goals are the first goals that we are focused on addressing through a budget our budget should be responsive and reflective to the instructional goals that we outline and so prioritizing resources so that we can accomplish these instructional goals is going to be key and critical as we go through our budget development process so these goals are not one-year goals but really three to five year goals where we are continuing to improve our literacy instruction and F Fus on literacy k12 and the utilization of academ academic data the board is well aware of our adoption of programs and tools to assist us in this such as I ready so that we can be monitoring our students academic performance and responding with academic intervention and high quality

038tier one instruction for our students maximizing student achievement through that mtss model where we are analyzing students that are achieving above grade level standard at grade level standard and those students that might be in need of additional academic support is key in that strengthening the social and emotional well-being of our students and really focusing on creating that inclusive culture for our students culturally responsive practices is something that we've invested in professional development um so that all of our students feel welcomed in our schools included and have the ability to thrive We are continuing to analyze the impact of technology on instructional P practices um at my opening day comments to faculty and staff I reflected on that we were all thrust into becoming onetoone School communities during the pandemic and now we're at a point

039where Educators should really be questioning what do we want the role of technology to be do we want to be handing every 5-year-old in kindergarten a Chromebook if so our budget should be reflective of that if we believe that there's other more developmentally appropriate ways for our students to learn then we may question our continued investment in Chromebooks at those younger youngest levels and I think this is work that we are continuing to analyze what is that best dosage if you will of technology for all of our students I have yet to meet a teacher who says you know what our kids need they need more screen time right I have yet to find a teacher who has said that and I think that's causing us as Educators to really reflect on the role of

040Technology the best use of technology and how we want technology to show up in our classrooms and to be part of our students academic program and then continuing to focus on professional development so that we can achieve our instructional goals would you like to talk about the instru program well or the operational rather so we had a question earlier about maintenance of our facilities and Equipment um during covid it was difficult to actually buy equipment to buy vehicles uh in some cases it still is what where there used to be a state uh process for acquiring Vehicles it seem to have slipped away I know we've bid on several Vehicles we have we've never taken ownership of because the supply chain just ate it up you know as uh as Vans become available they get

041absorbed you only have to look as far as the Amazon delivery to your your doorstep every day to know where every single white panel van in America has gone so you know we have struggled to to purchase things we have we do maintain the funds available to do that kind of work um there are a great deal of needs and I believe that as young and Wright uh unveils the building condition survey you know we'll see you know that the items that we can pick off in a future Capital project that would lessen the burden on the budget as far as technology goes we've we've been buying Chromebooks on our on a four-year cycle uh since the uh Co experience and we do that through many pockets some of which is uh instructional materials Aid

042which is 100% aided by the state some is uh installment purchase agreements where we get Bose's Aid on on the purchases and we Finance them over 5 years we've done some major Renovations through the smart schools Bond act and we use erate which is a federal project and capital project so it's a combination of the budget and many other things to try to get us to where we need to be technology wise and uh we're taking a hard look at at all those expenditures as we move forward Transportation we're excited about our new leadership and trans Transportation um we have a dedicated staff out there working hard to get our kids to and from school safely um and securely we have mechanics who are often taxed um to drive and it puts a lot of

043pressure on our operations to maintain our existing Fleet the credit to those individuals who putting in the time and the effort to make sure that our Fleet is maintained the standards we've had an aggressive Fleet replacement program we are not yet at the electric bus phase that will change the replacement uh dramatically and many of you are are well aware of those costs through your uh nisba uh influences um we are looking to really manage our own roots and our contractual relationships to ensure we're being as efficient as possible we have a meeting with first student coming up in a couple of weeks to really try to make sure we're on the same page and we you know our new leadership has has taken an aggressive uh turn and trying to communicate to meet with

044our drivers and get more feedback on our root structure and I think we'll see that continue as we develop roots for the 2026 school year as far as uh budget guidelines Staffing we always review Staffing for Effectiveness uh we we look for efficiency but uh we we there are several areas that we just cannot touch and there are mandated areas that continue to grow and you'll hear in the future conversations about the needs in special ation and related service work uh most of you have some of you have experience directly in those fields and I know you understand that this is really a critical situation in this whole area uh go ahead and then we talked about financial sustainability uh state aid we'll learn more about at the end of January from the governor that's

045usually the first time we we get a number there's uncertainty obviously with the foundation Aid study that's taking place as to what that number will will be our hope is that it's emphasized to the governor you know what's essential and what's needed in schools as opposed to of you know given our you know our ratio when it comes to our wealth in our community compared to others around us so the tax cap um is something we've been dealing with for quite a few years now it it will hit its 2% ceiling inflation is obviously well over the 2% so our buying power is reduced immediately just by the mathematics um so that computation will be laid out for you in February at the latest um contractual obligations will be negotiating the CCA contract this year

046starting next week I believe and other contracts mature 2026 to 29 um we should have an estimate of salaries for you either later this month or in February to begin the process that estimate is key because for that estimate comes our retirement system estimates uh TRS rates are pretty flat ERS rates are going up so employee benefit costs will continue to rise and our Healthcare benefits uh in our own self-funded plan we've seen some double Jed increases lately um there's no reason not to expect another one in the current year we have a large volume of high cost claims given the age of the employees uh that participate in that uh fund and uh it's it just is reality and uh in some extent I do believe personally that it's postco so it's a lot

047of complications any questions on the budget side of things finan finances the communication start turn do we carry stop loss for the health insurance so at first okay yeah so communication I think is is critical in this um we want to operate under transparency so that our stakeholders understand what our goals are and what our vision is in our classrooms and how we utilize our budget funds to to fulfill that mission and to accomplish our goals and so Community input um will be solicited welcomed throughout the de development process of our budget the budget advisory committee which we launched this fall is something new for our district and we stakeholders from all bargaining units that are participating in that budget advisory committee again to promote communication and to promote transparency we will uh participate in

048public presentations not just in the boardroom um but also public presentations outside of the boardroom to increase awareness of our budget to uh propose what the tax levy will be to taxpayers and so that they can better understand that as we embark on the budget vote publication of documents the board has already adopted the budget calendar um we will continue to post things on our website and make resources available as we have presentations in this forum and in other forums agendas and presentations from our board meetings are always made available through our website and recordings of our board meetings are available to the public the uh budget complete budget document um we will be sending out uh usually it's it's a flyer or postcard that goes out to Residents which gives a summary of things

049um with some additional information on where they can get deeper information if they so choose and the budget newsletter which contains uh really detailed and descriptive information and information that we are legally required to provide to our residents into to our Comm community that will be distributed to all residents and taxpayers in May of 2025 so with that I just want to SU arize some next steps as we look ahead on January 13th we have our next meeting of the budget advisory committee and then in subsequent presentations to the Board of Education we'll be focusing on various aspects of our budget so for example for the January 21st work session we anticipate being able to focus and do a deeper dive on our costs and the anticipated costs and our estimated costs as we look

050ahead to next year's budget will already shared that we do have our ERS and TRS percentages for next year that is the Employee Retirement System and teachers retirement system so those are now fixed and known numbers that we can calculate into our budget we are anticipating and estimating any increases in health care expenses contractual increases so if we were to employ all of our employees that we have on staff today next year what would th those salaries entail so doing that calculation presently we're already forecasting and know of some retirements on the horizon so that we can account for retirements and any breakage that we may realize in that salary differential and we'll have further discussion about budget guidelines and priorities based on feedback from the board but the next presentation that you can expect

051will be a deeper dive on our anticipated costs and those things that are fixed costs that we anticipate in the budget and then we'll have a subsequent um presentation that focuses on the revenue side of our budget what Revenue are we anticipating and projecting when it comes to state aid Foundation Aid other forms of Aid that we receive or grants federal grants Etc in addition to tax levy resources so each of our subsequent budget presentations will'll take a deeper dive in those areas so tonight was really the 10,000 foot View and overview of the budget development timeline and some future presentations that we anticipate but I'd be happy to entertain um either will or me any questions that you have or feedback from the board um so my question with regards to community input and

052um you know we have that up top and that's great what would be the the way that we would get that input how would we solicit that I think as we move forward we need to get a little more concrete with that um because there needs to be an actual uh process for folks to share those share those ideas up front before we get too far because I when we get to public presentations it's like the meal is pretty much cooked right and we're presenting it this is this is what it is so those questions that come up at that point you you don't see people go back and and rework a bud so that input I guess one of my qu questions is suggestions would be on the budget advisory committee do we have

053any members of our community on that advisory commit we have stakeholder groups within bargaining units but do we have any business owners local business owners do we have any people that are just your John Joe taxpayer um that can sit on that committee and provide that input up front so we don't get too far down the road and then it's well this wasn't a transparent process I think we need to be proactive in making sure we get get those things get that input early on thank you I appreciate that and we did invite um some various Community stakeholders that have not yet participated in meetings but trying to solicit additional voices to to be part of the process I would go to the next person on the list I would go and find somebody and

054make sure that um they understand the importance of it people from the the chamber um business members and the Comm Unity um that would really bring a different point of view to the table thank you any other questions or feedback from the board thank Youk you [Applause] thanks okay we're now going to move into our voting portion of the agenda uh please look at item 4A abolish certificated positions specifically the director of ela World languages ESL and enl I'd like to have a motion on agenda item 4 a I'll make a motion I'll second is there any [Applause] discussion right remember what to say all in favor all in favor I I Cole didn't write that for me opposed anyone opposed all right it continues then we are going to look at item 4B create

055a certificated position um this position is the director of humanities I'd like to have a motion on agenda item 4B I'll make a motion I'll second it okay any discussion just that um I made mention this prior that the as the as these positions evolve is there is there do you have the ability to add on other duties outside of the area of ela World Language ESL and andl to that position as you move forward yes uh pretty standard all of our job descriptions is other duties as assigned by the superintendent certainly we anticipate this position which was previously the laundry list of director of ela enl World languages is now under that umbrella title of director of humanities but the responsibility certainly could evolve and shift you know within reason we still want the

056the core focus of the position to be similar to what we are posting recruiting and a Contracting the right person for but certainly other duties as assigned by the superintendent is without a correct you could add those on without having to S pay out a stien for for those duties it would depend on what the duty is and and the significance of that Duty um how much time and and that would entail but certainly that could be a possibility yeah all right thank you anyone else all right all in favor I I anyone opposed passes [Applause] 60 all right now we're looking at uh line item 5A create a classified position uh this is a part-time labor position um and it's in relation to a student um need at Trans in the transportation department and

057a uh labor parttime position sorry the first one was bus attendant second one labor parttime um it's a staffing need in buildings and grounds so I'd like to have a motion on agenda item 5A I'll happily make that motion did you get a second or you want me we all tried Marlo take a second okay any discussion happily made that motion any discussion all right all in favor I I anyone opposed passes 60 moving on to the consent agenda we're looking at items 6 through 10 take a moment to look that [Applause] over i' like to have a motion on consent agenda items 6 through 10 I'll make a motion hear me I'll second it all right lorine seconds um all in favor I anyone opposed passes 60 we have we do should I call

058on or Dron that'd be great thank you Dr saon you want to share anyone who's with us for acknowledgements this [Applause] evening would like to recognize people celebrating Milestones tonight as we do every board meeting uh we have people tonight be retiring and leaving our district and thank you for the service I did not see either of these ladies here tonight unless I'm mistaken also have people being appointed to the Board of Education uh appointed to our district whether it's a joining the district for the first time or promotion and also receiving tenure and I do believe our tenure recipient is here suzan if you want to stand up congratulations do you have a special guest with you oh yes this is my daughter Hannah awesome suzan Suzanne's a speech teacher at North congratulations huge

059mome and we have uh some other Personnel appointments and do see one young lady that was a student of mine when I was a principal at East I believe and has joining us as a special education teacher among other uh people uh who are joining our district uh I don't I don't I only had acknowledgement of one person being here but is anyone here that is being appointed this evening if you could please stand and be recognized aome well congratulations to those individuals thank you for having me thank you thank you [Applause] you sure I'm not missing anything all right we are on to line item 11 new business uh we're going to be reviewing 11 a through C [Applause] may I have a motion on all new business which are items 11 a through

06011 C I'll make a motion to approve 11 a through C thank you I'll second thank you any [Applause] discussion did you want to review any of this before we move i' I'd be happy to if there's any any questions related to it um the first was the resolution with the winny Rick which is the regional information center presently each School District under edlaw 2D is required to enter into privacy data contracts with any vendors which has access to student data so for example power school which is where we house all of our student demographic information student grades things of that nature we enter into an edlaw 2D contract with power school and various other vendors that that maintain student data privacy right now it's been on every school district to individually engage in that

061contract with these organizations but many of these businesses do contracts with hundreds of districts across our state so to streamline this that is going to shift through the regional information system the winny rck through bosies so that they will maintain a contract an edlaw 2D contract for districts within New York state to take advantage of and be under that umbrella protection as opposed to every individual School District trying to obtain that contract so it really is I think streamlining and bringing about greater efficiency there's also cost savings to the district because we have our attorneys Have Eyes On on each of these contracts and rather than us managing many many contracts Within individual vendors the Winnie Rick is going to do that on behalf of local school districts so there is also a cost benefit

062to local school districts so this is a a wonderful movement on behalf of the Winnie wreck anyone have any questions very supportive I think this is great and it also standardized the contract language and it it's just makes a lot of sense that I'm surprised we haven't done it previously but I'm I'm glad we're at this point attorneys making money no more privacy attorneys specifically I think this is great it's a great Comm for our district thank you I agree right then we'll go ahead and vote all in favor I I anyone opposed all right passes 60 I I wouldn't be doing at any honor unless I mentioned the donation that we have for uh this evening which is the parents of West seniors boys hockey team uh made a substantial donation toward bus and

063hotel fees for a hockey tournament [Applause] and then 12 is our financial documents for your [Applause] review all right we're moving on to Board of Education discussion uh Tori and Marissa are here from Young and Wright to give us an update on Capital Improvement project 2023 [Applause] hello thank you all right hi everyone thanks for having us tonight so Marissa and I are here to give an update on the 2023 Capital Improvement project um so we're going to go through phase one and phase two and as always feel free to interject or interrupt if you have any questions about what we go through today so now you're familiar with seeing me and Sean um but I brought Marissa with me tonight um so J and Wright has a full staff that works on the west

064enica project so I thought it would be nice to bring someone else that you haven't necessarily seen before um Marissa has been at y andate for about four years um she's one of our project coordinators which means she's really involved in the construction documents that we put together for West Sena um I'm sure you'll be seeing more of Marissa but I just wanted to bring her tonight to introduce you guys to her um so the 20123 capital Improvement project was the project that was voted on in December of 2023 the overall budget for this one is $23.5 million phase one of that is $15 million and that consists of replacing some roofs at Northwood Elementary West Senior and East Senior um so these pictures shown on this slide are the before pictures so as you

065can see these roofs were in dire need for some um repair construction started last summer um and we got about halfway through which is right on schedule contractors were working up until the end of fall um when the weather wouldn't really allow them to work anymore so these pictures were taken in about October of last year as soon as spring hits they'll be back on site at all three buildings and wrapping up the work um we anticipate this construction to be done at the end of this summer any questions with phase one roofs aren't that exciting but it's important to have the warm safe dry building million exciting so exactly yeah okay so phase two of this project um this is the security cameras at the elementary school and West senior's parking lot reconfiguration um

066So currently we're in s review right now we just submitted this to SED at the end of the year right before the holidays um and this was submitted as a third party review um so we'll get into the schedule and a couple more slides but right now current SED review times are 14 to 16 weeks so we discussed it with the district that it made sense to get this into a thirdparty review so in hopes that we could get some construction started this summer so we could use this summer and next summer for construction um the budget for phase two is $8.5 million so after working with the district this was the overall master plan that um was designed for West senior's parking lot and the original scope of work for phase two was just

067to address the Bus Loop and parent drop off so this footprint is much larger than what was anticipated for the project um so in order to tackle this we broke it out into alternates so hopefully you guys can see this but basically base bid would be the Bus Loop and the parent drop off area and then all the extras or enhancements that we talked about with the district that the district wanted to see potentially take place um were designated as alternates so alternate one would be an additional driveway around the parking lots and an entrance off of the streets alternate two is to um redo the tennis courts and potentially pickleball courts that were impacted by the expansion of the parking lot alternate three is redoing the parking lot at the athletic entrance and Alternate

068four is that Center parking lot area that would be a a lot more additional parking for um the high school um so on bidday this will set the district up for as like a safety net and allow for flexibility to be able to add to the project as much as the budget allows essentially um the district would be able to take any of these alternates in any order it doesn't really matter about the numbering that we show 1 through four if you wanted to take two and four and the budget allows you would be able to do that so if I can just interject there Tori so what we envision Happening Here is after we get the bid on what the base bid would be and each of the alternates we'll really have to reconvene

069to prioritize how did the come in where are we financially we assume we'll certainly be able to address the base bid but it will really be a question of how many of the alternates can we include in the budget that's been allocated for us and the prioritization of that you know in a perfect world we do the base bid and all alternates that may not happen depending on where where our bids come in so we'll certainly keep the board a breast of this as we get our our bids in and our evaluating next steps and which pieces of this we may be able to do so Dr where did the 8 8.5 come from for that project so for phase two so are you asking specifically for phase two how much of that is the

070phase two so the parking lot for that project is at A5 yes so that's what we have to work with exactly and that came that was voted on exactly yes and that is not only just for correct me if I'm wrong not only for the parking lot but also for the elementary security camera expansion yeah that's correct yeah okay yeah so we have a we probably have a number on that where that's going to be it's it's a matter of material cost and labor cost at that time exactly yep um so moving into that there's a lot of factors that are going to go into the construction schedule and the bids for phase two um so up here we outlin a couple different scenarios um so to highlight some key points that are kind of

071up in the air are the SED review times um so obviously we did the best we could to get that into thirdparty review to really expedite that review so we can get that out to bid sooner rather than later another um up in the air item is the availability of site contractors for this summer um RCM team has been talking to local site contractors to see their availability and if they're interested in this project as of right now there is a lot of interest in work this summer however that could change depending on other projects that go out to bid this spring in Western New York so that's kind of um TBD um another item is materials for the site work um there's a lot of underground piping that's required for the drainage system for

072all this site work and those items it's not an incredibly longly time but they could be about six to eight weeks so that's also going to have an impact on the schedule um so we put together a couple different scenarios that could play out so scenario 1 a on the top here is we like to say like the best case scenario so we'll say we get SED approval um by the end of February we could get it out to bid in March and um sign contracts and get submittals going and the contractor could get going this summer so maybe they could do the Elementary School Camas this summer and the Bus Loop area and then next summer they could do the parent drop off area and potentially any alternates um that the district also is

073able to do um since the site work is such um extensive and depending on the alternates could really impact how long the construction will take so scenario 1B kind of shows a different approach if the contractors aren't able to get all the material required to do the Bus Loop maybe they could start with just the elementary school cameras and some of the alternates that you're able to take maybe they could tackle the tennis courts or the additional driveway this summer and then next summer able to have all the materials and the labor ready to go so they could really get the hit the ground running in the summer of 2026 and then the third scenario that we outlined would kind of be um the backup plan so let's say we are able to get this

074out to bid in the spring but contractors aren't available the pricing doesn't come in um favorable for the district we could always repackage it and put it back out to bid in the fall um for contractors to do next summer so there's a kind of a lot of moving pieces that are up in the air that we won't really know until um we get the project out to bid and obviously we'll keep you guys up to date and posted with um any sort of updates with that is there any questions with that that's a lot of moving pieces do you think we will be able to fall within the 8.5 range or do you think it's not possible Right now the ments that we've been putting together the base bid is definitely a possibility to

075complete that would be very feasible um I don't foresee being able to tackle all the alternates but you never know with the bid day if you know contractor could come in with really competitive bids and we could do all of the alternates the um elementary school security cameras will be procured off of State contract so at least those numbers are pretty set in stone so it's not very high variables with that scope of [Applause] work oh got got a B okay I do it any other questions okay thank you you thank you both for being here tonight thank you for the update yep all right I am going to have Tony Day from the Western New York educational Ser service Council who is here to give us an update on [Applause] [Music] redistricting evening 2025

076see my thank you thank you thank you so I just wanted to give you a brief uh update on our this committee to work from last month uh last month we I gave you an update on work through November uh about 3 days later we had another meeting uh and I don't know if I know that um you had been given packets to add to your binders um I know the minutes came out uh just before the break uh I did give you a copy of the minutes here just to look at um and then uh I also have for you the agenda for next week's meeting where we're heading just so you know uh as we begin to last month you know one of the things that we review all the time is what

077are the parameters the goals the problems the parameters and the possible resources so this sheet that you have in the towards the back is like the third last sheet this kind of colorful pack this is kind of a one sheet One-Stop summary of the issues we're trying to address through the redistricting process uh the blue are the resources where the space resources are most available in the district and then the green are the potential strategies that uh the committee has at its disposal to try and address the issues and so we you know I've we've spoken of these before but I think it's just helpful for a one page in fact some of the committee members said this page was pretty helpful is to have it as a one spot cheat sheet uh we began

078after we kind of reviewed all those pieces we began I felt it was we started our process of looking at different options by looking at just the possibility one of our parameters from the board is to deliver a plan that just that does not use reconfiguration but uses redistricting meaning reassigning students or repositioning specific programs um so that's where we began uh the committee that was in existence in uh 2022 23 and in the beginning of uh 2324 had a had created Five uh possible scenarios at the elementary level for redistricting um and had brought one to the attention of the board in a presentation in September of last year so what we did is what I felt it was important to look at take that work and honor that work and we took the

079this year's data and put it into inserted it into each of those five there were four plans that were not promoted by the committee at that time uh and then there was one that was titled C1 that was deemed to be more uh potentially advantageous it's important to note that those Elementary plans created last year were designed with a in a bigger concept of a reconfiguration into a one high school district so those were K to four um schools so they weren't built to be but we popped in in this at this point in our process we're looking at keeping k5s 68s 912s so the committee we I put those num those the student data into it we brought that data and had the Comm you know I did a presentation had the committee looking

080at it and uh there was unanimous agreement that while we may have made some some of the plans created some gains in the biggest problem area in the elementary is Clinton uh which is which is in meat of more the most space but Allendale in many cases didn't get enough space or in some cases gained students and thus would have been more challenged because it's Clinton and Allendale that the two biggest issues um C1 which was the pro uh the goal that the plan that was most promoted uh that was T we looked at that a little bit more in depth and you can see in your in the minutes it lists out some of the feedback from uh people on the team uh but there was General agreement that it did not while it

081did help Clinton um it did not really address the issues at Allendale enough uh and you know and so therefore it f it was one some of the groups and when you look at the minutes you see some the group the letters represent the groups that were offering feedback uh and so but you can see three of the group said no one said maybe and Group B didn't really respond so then in order to kind of highlight where we're what we're trying to do at this point I offered a pot an option for consideration and if you look at the I believe it's the second last page in the minutes package it's called proposal one and it just uses redistricting and repositioning and so what it won uh it highlights the challenges in trying to

082accomplish the tasks that you've given the the parameters you've given to the team through simply redistricting in fact that was a comment that was offered several times is like is it even possible to accomplish all of these things by just reassigning students but in this place in this uh option you know there were you if you look at the the diagram about about a third of the current Clinton District was reassigned to either Northwood or to West L um Northwood and Winchester Potters have a small amount of capacity currently if they maintain the other programs that operate within them Universal prek uh and self-contained special education classes however they don't have nearly enough capacity to be able to take the number of students that Clinton needs to be would be need to reassign in this

083process which would be approximately 140 of their 600 kids would need to be reassigned to have a chance at achieving all of our goals so this plan reassigns students um and then in Allendale Allendale needed approximately uh 75 students to be reassigned and so Allendale reassigns um in this plan the segment that is detached from uh that's really attached to Winchester Potter's residential area that's repositioned to um Winchester potters and some to Westell and actually uh some of West L going back to Allendale trying to keep West Elementary from becoming a 750 student elementary school so because that's one of the CH it is the biggest it is the most resource capacity uh there's not a lot of evidence that says that the most effective elementary schools you know have 78 900 kids it's a

084very large Elementary so um in this plan we also you know we Al the plan was also Al contingent upon phasing it in over a 2-year period uh to try and minimize the number of kids that would actually have to be repositioned uh and it also required in order to create capacity it suggested moving Universal prek and the self-contained classes at um at the Winchester potters and um Northwood to other locations as the only vehicle to create capacity so uh in the end the process you know had some successes when you put the numbers in and run them over the phase in Period um the class size averages that you can see in the minutes uh they become fairly um consistent uh in terms of the capacity to be able to meet these needs the

085student the sizes of the building except for West Elementary because of its size becomes fairly consistent um and the number of students so would actually have to be repositioned um in one setting would would a total 260 out of a possible 2,200 elementary kids so it red it's it tries to minimize the number of impacted students um and it maintains the neighborhood configur the neighborhood configuration it maintains k to5 um you know but there are some challenges there there that I acknowledge but the team found saw right away West L becomes bigger than it already is and there be and in order to where the space and the capacity is the repositioning of self-contained classrooms the eight one the 12 ones would go to West Elementary so you could highlight and continue to integrate them

086into those students into general education settings the six to ones without you know the in this option rather than put them in West out when have all the self-contained settings operating Within West Elementary uh this option offered to put them over at um the old East L building uh currently in East Middle uh with the idea that the 61s while first of all many districts don't own don't have 61s in District many 61s are out of District placements I think it's great that that West Anica does that uh they are the smaller the number the smaller the ratio the more challenged it can't not that it can't be done the more challenged to integrate in a meaning away um and so the idea was to put them at West at East Middle because that's where

087the Middle School 611 program is and it res reduces a transition for those students clearly though the best practice for special education is it self-contained students and self-contained classrooms are set within general education settings to allow for integration you know and this goes back to the the concept that I've been talking about in order you cannot have your cake and eat it too there's an opportunity cost to try and do all of this so the opportunity cost here is the size of West L 61 611 students not really losing the same age peers in order to be able to um integrate more closely uh and also one of the one of the in order to create the space in Allendale uh taking the 15 to1 self-contained settings and going to what's called a small group

088instruction mechanism for 15 to one so instead of a separate classroom students would be integrated into classrooms but they would be pulled out into small content settings and taught by special education teachers separately so that would take remove the need to have a room for 15 to1 students would be embedded within and it created more space and you can see when you go to um when you go to the the questions you know there are questions like you know uh what EX would the boundary lines be and where would all the offices go and the questions really are you know is there if we if we take all of this on you know are we ready to do self-contain 15 to1 within the buildings it's a good question uh is there an is there is

089really 611 in in isolation is that really the best mechanism to to do it um so you know but those those were the questions and the team uh was really engaged and it was really a a a very positive experience for them to start to understand the many moving Parts uh in order to create this in this model we did not yet consider the reopening of Winchester uh that's a topic that I want to talk about with the team because the opening reopening of Winchester comes with it sustained costs that create that create a need for sustained Revenue you know and that uh and that's something that has to be talked about in Bri bried with the committee cuz when you talk about reopening Winchester as a full building to students it's principal nurse social

090worker counselor um and probably just by uh the loss of some um size efficiency issues some teacher aids and that will add up probably close to a million dollars in sustained expense and what is and will the budget you know be able to maintain that not for one year you know some districts might consider using reserves but if that's a sustained expense there needs to be a sustained Revenue that you can see headed with it and that's something that I've always told the team that's not our belly Wick but they have to understand that when making a recommendation about Winchester there are fiscal implications that cannot be um denied so um that was the elementary plan and so the plan for next week is to have the team is to take some of their feedback

091and try to rework that Rec that plan with their feedback to show what's possible what's not and then to have the team begin to brainstorm what are some other options that could not yet get into reconfiguration that you might want to have somebody take a look at and propose uh the second the second piece that we also did we also offered a Middle School uh option to try to balance Middle School that Middle School option if you turn to the I believe it's the very last page of the minutes the area in the very West excuse me east of Union Road South of the creek um that that area was you know was the option the possibility of moving having those students over a three-year period transition from West Elementary to East Elementary in order

092to help West Elementary mdle SCH excuse me middle thank you you just get kind of bogged down and Confused in order to help the middle school out the Middle School needs probably seven to eight rooms in order to accomplish what they need for space or proper spaces for foreign language uh and special education instruction so that would really require almost probably a 100 students to move from west to east uh and so this option talk showed how over a three-year period with six graders every year so any student that ever started at West Middle could finish at West Middle and you would transition over a period of time uh you can see it actually East Middle uh becomes a little larger in size they become pretty balanced in size um and you look at about

09350 students a year would be reassigned via sixth grade uh and the biggest issue that was brought up that you know it's a cost is some students in some of the elementaries at fifth grade would part and some would go to the west side and some would go to the east side you know and that was something that was uh Brooks that's the the opportunity cost so with this middle school reconfiguration then they would follow suit into those high schools that was the idea they would continue on then the question is which this plan didn't get into is what would that do to the the enrollment at East Middle at East High School and could that expansion of enrollment be handled in that capacity which is something that you know I'll kind of try to

094bring the best answers uh an early look is the number of students that East uh High School would end up having F you know that would be if you think about it would take seven years for all of that to work through um but they would add probably about 175 students that would take them to about 900 students uh and at one point 10 years ago East High School had 900 students in it now that's that was different remember there's a lot of things that are different 10 years later in terms of enl instruction and the rooms needed and social emotional support so that's a question that we still would have to address but you know in both Cas none of the the neither is perfect but a lot of people said is it possible

095to do everything we want with just doing redistricting said well it depends what you're willing to give up to get it you know so um but when you look at uh our agenda you know we want to spend some time taking a look at the plan and try to look at some of their feedback and what can be what can happen happen uh then we want to re considerer other possible redistricting repositioning ideas and we also want to give the teams time to begin to explore reconfiguration so one of the one of the at one meet two meetings ago it was the idea was broed about could you have a 5 six intermediate campus on both sides of the district you know and then you're pulling a grade level out of the elementaries and then

096you create a 56 setting and then you move kids to a 78 setting which could benefit creating the the issue the space issue at West so we'll try to look at that a little bit and then when we look at that then also say what are some other possibilities that you think we should consider going forward so we're still it's early in the process but the team's starting to Grapple and for anybody that's happening to watch or listen none of these are like definitive these are all just ideas that are starting to be toyed to try to achieve the goal goal of creating capacity for the buildings to manage to have more balanced enrollments and create capacity to be able to over time bring class sizes to a place that you would like to have

097them in your district one question thank you for the presentation this is really helpful um so in terms of The Proposal one and proposal two for elementary and middle school I appreciate that things could change but is the intent for them to be separate proposals or could there is there a possibility of them being com combined into one proposal where they're both my vision would be is we bring we bring you plans that are comprehensive and show you how they play out K12 so that these would come together as one plan right cuz one thing feeds into another if you build if you take this then you got to make sure you understand what the plan is as it moves up the way thank you I certainly appreciate all of the work put into this

098one it's just you know kind of a little sigh when you realize forward thinking it's always going to be those you know I know it's not set it's just an idea but always that handful of students um at West and Allendale are always going to be leaving their friends come sixth grade so that's not just over the next three years that's future until something changed so I know this is one proposal and I look forward to seeing what the other options would be with some reconfiguring of grades to elate one of the ideas that came out was in some of these like it's like there's a small like a small number of kids you have to move and that usually creates more of a an emotional response then the idea of like well every fifth

099grader has got this experience you know it's like all versus some there's an emotional response and that was T that that feedback came out a lot you know there there ways to instead of doing just these kids have to be repositioned when we think about reconfiguration that is kind of like raw in us together and it creates more of a unified and they felt it might be more emotionally accepted as we kind of move in that direction yeah well I just think people wouldn't want to buy a house in that area yeah well NOA I live in that area so I'm looking at this thinking of my second grader and what that would look like for us as a family and that's concerning so yeah I'd like to see what else is out there for

100sure um I know you looking at reconfiguration looking at I know traditionally West and East have done this split and Chang at Union Road but there's a lot of other ways to still have kids very close in proximity to elementary schools and being able to kind of look at those grade levels and be able to not just think about things in a East and West literal split but also a you know where are we with maybe reconfiguring North and South this way rather than this way correct uh but the more you do that then the more kids you're causing to move like so like the more kids you move the more kids you I like the idea of reposition CU nobody's moving there's you're repositioning it create it'll create more feedback you know um and

101the challenge with having five elementary schools is at some point you got to and you also have space your space needs your space um resources at the middle and high school level are flipped you have more space at on the east side at the middle level and you have more space on the west side so to rethink that with just five elementary schools uh would be challenging but you know not to say we can't do it but we're gonna do we can and with that is why we need to dive deeper into the idea of open reopening Winchester and what's that's going to mean that has to be put in play we have to research that and play that out what that would mean you mentioned the use of East uh East Elementary for some

102classes so is that be considered an Annex how how would we get away with that not requiring a principal orur well it has it has the building has a singular beds code for the whole building uh we'd have to you the district you know if you had you would have the configuration of that beds code there would have to be an application made to stay at in order to change it and amend it so in whatever for whatever purpose but that's an area you know your biggest space resource the two biggest space resources are East Middle M and Winchester from a pure space capacity right those are the so you got to figure how do I you how do use the resources that you have to solve the issues that you got uh and you're

103right Winchester has be looked at but you know in a building that already as a principle of getting changing the beds code configuration um is takes a lot less funding than it does to reopen a building Okay so keep at it appreciate you know and hopefully you know we're trying to be pretty detailed on the minute so that somebody that's not there tries to get a kind of a feel through what's going on over this is great and certainly not an easy job so again thank you to everyone in the committee this is excellent you know I just will add me I want to thank every so many people are being really helpful but Jess Shanahan has been like she is so helpful making sure that these things get out timely and she pushes and

104nudges and she's really doing a great job so all right thanks every awesome thank you Tony and thank you for recognizing Jessica because I was going to to do that as well I I think it's a the way in which we're presenting the summary of meeting resources the minutes any handouts the agenda so that you don't have to be in the room to get access to all of that information has been has been really critical so that we are trying to operate in full transparency and let people know the work that this committee is is doing along the way so that we can be seeking feedback thank you do we have any other items for Board of Education [Applause] discussion we're going to hold off now for for a little bit on start times to

105uh reconvene on that conversation I think so we had we had obviously have some work to do and figuring out um but it is something I want to continue to for us to discuss what the process would be after we discussed last uh last meeting that there's actually you know there is an appetite to at least um pursue the idea and begin formulating a process for that yeah I think uh similarly to how we are handling redistributing reconfiguration it might be nice to have an outside resource do the research and work with us um and we have time you know at 25 26 school year and then to be able to to kind of look at everything so I think if we see through this process first and then open in the spring to another

106conversation um that'll give us due diligence on what we're doing right now y I'm good with that for now I know I know anyone else um I just wanted to see if um sometime in the the near future we can get like uh a list of the Combined District teams for each season um going along with redistricting and I know I've had a lot of parents asking me if we're having one team or two teams for all these different sports in the spring and I don't have those answers um but I know that was a big part of parent concern is fewer kids being able to make a team or participate um so just the numbers or how many teams we have combined um and if there have been any other instances like JV football

107at East um not being able to sustain a season so are there any other teams where we couldn't feel the team and now we're paying for coaches and things like that yeah I believe that's happening at East right now with uh JV girls basketball I believe it was planned that they were going to have a JV team I don't believe that they do um and I think those are things that happened those weren't planned for that some of the and and I Marissa can certainly speak to this but um you have to if you're planning on that ahead of time you have to have approval to have those combined teams and so spring those would already have to be approved there's that it's a matter of okay we plan on having a JB baseball team

108but we only have four kids coming out then we're we're not going to be able to run it so it's not the I think there's teams that are already planned to be combined and then there's those that happen as a matter of necessity and I guess to piggy back off of that is there ever the option if there's an overabundance of kids trying out at one of the schools and not making the team but the other side of the district can't feeli the team instead of combining to one can we have kids from one school go to the other side I think we need to look into that with transferability of students and if section six would allow a student from the West Side to participate in a sport on the east side I I'll

109need to look into that I don't know offhand if if that's allowable I mean I think as a whole we've discussed numerous times that we want as many students to participate in as many areas as they can so I think of um what was it the the middle school cheerleaders you know that team is absolutely gigantic and it's a combined team so next year that potentially could separate and that's where I think parents if they can rest assured it's not that we're trying to punish anyone we want these kids to play it's but they need to come out so they can feel a team because now those four kids or the the basketball team the girls at East Middle they don't get to play period so you know we're trying to find a Happ there

110no JV team and all those girls get pulled up to Varsity and they can't get on the court yeah but I think all of us have talked numerous times we want them all yeah to have that opportunity if I if I may that there needs to be a real conversation about unifying all sports and having one sports team and people can throw all the the reasons why they don't want that to happen there's a we need to look at what a plan would look like for one West senica team in teams across the board because you could have it where kids are getting more opportunity there would be more opportunity for children to participate in sports if you had a single District team across the board because you could have two modified teams you could

111have a freshman team you could have a JV team that wouldn't require you to have uh sophomores going up and playing on a varsity team because you'd have enough players on a varsity team to fulfill that and a sport L football where you have how many kids play both both Sid the ball in football on the East and the west side I guarantee you it's at least half of the team half of the The Starters play both ways so but is that more on the coaches having a push cuz they want to win so they're just playing those kids so I don't believe unifying sports teams would do that for instance I can use East hockey from this year I've learned that the FED coach when we have Club teams at the varsity level level

112kept 30 kids on his roster and you are doing a complete disservice cuz he's probably going to play 12 kids consistently and you're going to have 18 kids sit in the bench so yeah they might why not have two teams we do we have three we have two Club teams and he took them all from the club teams and said no come play for me and to me that's a complete disservice for those kids cuz yeah they might get a better practice they made not but to be on that team and to sit the bench you are going to have kids that are going to quit and never play again totally agree and that's I I think that's why the conversation has to have to pull out those realities those things that are happening like

113that though because until you really have that conversation and put it all on paper and look at the numbers you're going to get well this happens over here and that happens over there we have to be purposeful and intentional about looking at that athletic department from top to bottom because the number of sports that we have already combined is well well there's way more combined than our in in the um in the fall the only sports that weren't combined were football and volleyball everything else was combined all the girl sports were combined right so winter right now we're seeing much of the same thing we're seeing a huge disparity between what's happening at West and what's happening at East right so West has you know I I watched the Western versus East girls basketball game

114and it's it's it's not even close there's no there's no balance between the two teams and you don't have a JV team so how are those girls going to get better and how are they get in the development to come up and play at a better level I just think the entire thing needs to be really looked at without saying we're going to do it but to see what the outcomes would be if you did and that's what never happened when we talked about this last year because our athletic director never had the opportunity to address the realities of what it would look like if you had a modified a and a modified B where seventh graders play on the modified B eighth graders play on a modifi a you have a freshman team you

115have a JB team and you have a varsity team what would that look like on paper and then let's have that conversation what the reality is because because it could be very good for kids it could be very good for kids and you know how a sports minded minded person I'm not just talking about a competition level I'm talking about developmental level development developmentally getting kids ready to play at the highest level my only question and I I welcome that I want that conversation um are there other um districts that have that so they have an opportunity to play well we have we you mean that combined that are have two like us no they that if we had a and the like a ninth grade team or anything oh yeah those teams are absolutely

116the lancasters and Orchard parks and clearances all have two modified teams Frontier for years had two modified basketball teams with one was seventh grade and one was the eighth grade and our seventh and eighth grade combined team couldn't play with their seventh grader so I'm just we we have to on when it was like the wkins just playing Frontier Southern graders yeah so there's just a lot there that and and I I don't want to like R is not here to speak to this but we've had these conversations this is not I'm not pulling this out of my hat we've had these conversations and uh it needs to be really examined a larger level might it be helpful if we consider a future work session around this where Marissa could be present you've given some

117some feedback on specifically Sarah's request was a list of the district combined team team what combined teams did we have this fall what combined teams do we have this winter and what's anticipated for the spring so we can get a snapshot of of what the reality is and invite her to the table to be part of the discussion and and to respond to some of the questions that you have or if there is a plan that you're seeking of what would this look like on paper uh if we were to try to make some changes what what might this look like we could um potentially have that January 21st or we could look at our February uh date together we only have one meeting in February because the discussion items that we have on the

118horizon for January 21st of course with young and Wright and Tony day here today our discussion items for January 21 are not anticipated to be too lengthy we have calendar as a discussion item um one other discussion item but budget yes budget present um but I we could certainly carve out some time on January 21 or at the February meeting which would allow some time for Marissa and I to to gather some information around the questions that you've posed and I would say one other thing to take into consideration with the redistricting is right now I believe West has something like 300 more students than East does so now if he's saying it might be a shift of 175 students you might level out the sports end of it so it might not right now

119would be the time to you know go continue to this isn't something I would even you know I'm I'm a little hesitant to even bring it up but since I don't really um I I I want to pull back but I think that uh no I I just want to have the conversation and that's a part of it that that should certainly play into it um because that has played a role there's no question numbers numbers being there oh yeah make the difference okay see if we could try to get in on the 21st that way it's plenty of time before tryouts start happening and yeah okay the other discussion item that we have on the 21st is the ex officio student board member And discussing what our internal procedures and policies going to look

120like related to that how will students be selected to serve as the ex officio student board member so but I but I think all of those are reasonable discussions for us to have f one agenda on the 21st okay anything else well since we're on Sports I think it would be nice to acknowledge we have you know Shan Doak just named first team allamerican I don't know if we really understand what that means for a West L kid to rise to that level first team allamerican in football um and then we had a couple other of our our young men from the uh from the fall Sports First Team all Western New York in volleyball Ethan skeli from the East side and uh I know it's Cody Brown say the wrong brother's name Conor Brown

121yeah okay um from the west side so I think those are just want a little shout out for those thank you that's awesome coaches and everybody that's been part of that that's amazing all right if that's it I'd like to make a motion to convene an executive session for for discussion related to the employment history of a particular person anybody like to motion I'll make a motion to move into executive I'll second it thank you uh all in favor I anyone oppos we are going to um we are not going to conduct any public business after our executive session thank you thank you everyone thanks everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.