001good evening everybody and welcome to our Tuesday December 10th 2024 regular board meeting um just want to let everybody know that uh Vince will be joining us shortly and Marlo should be joining us any moment via the worldwide web somehow she's remote um start with the pledge of the flag me know she's would um can I have students yeah we have students here um I'm sorry I was just looking for them you guys want to come up and join us to do the pledge of the flag um Reed and Fallon would you like to join us please how' I do I do at the name failen I'm sorry forgive me I pledge Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under godible with
002liy and justice for all thank you so much okay guys uh we're going to start the meeting by doing an official roll call um we always take attendance but we'll do uh we're to start doing it by a roll call so if I say your name if you're here say here if you're not here don't answer me Vince here Jeremy here Sarah here Mara she went to sleep she went to sleep and Mara is joining us uh remotely so we'll get going on that I don't see her yet if anyone wants to give us a hand with that I will skip Marlo for a moment move on to Loren present La here Ed here Dr kruer [Applause] pres you want me to give you a minute on that [Applause] excellent hello can you hear us
003excellent um are you are you present Marla yeah can you hear me I can't you guys we can hear you wonderfully thank you she's here okay all in attendance great thank you Mr bant uh it is my honor each month to highlight one of our schools and this month we um have students from East Middle School who just let us through the Pledge of Allegiance they're going to be highlighting some amazing things that are going on at East Middle School and Mr Mar Yoli the school principal at East Middle School thank you for being with us tonight and you're welcome to come up and share some of the awesome things you're doing at East Middle [Applause] thank you very much Dr Krueger and the Board of Education my name is Jason maroli proud principal of
004West Sonica East Middle School and I'm really looking forward to enjoying the pleasure of sharing the East Middle School Spotlight with two exceptional students who I'm going to hand the floor over to now good evening my name is Reed spdy I'm an eighth grader at was senica East Middle School in Fall I've done football and winter I'm doing basketball and I also enjoy the Capstone program that we have hi my name is failen Torres I'm in e8th grade I participate in Orchestra student council the drama program and njhs thank you for having us at East Middle there is always a great deal of excitement happening on our campus there's a great deal of teacher guidance and we are thankful to to enjoy very supportive Community East Middle School has a great deal of opportunities for
005students to experience led by the seventh grade social studies teacher Mr Paul gleo the Yorkers Club focuses on giving back to our community to honor our veterans students in the Yorkers Club set up banners in front of the campus recognizing their service the Yorkers Club also lined our campus walkways and bus loops with American flags to honor our veterans we are also currently in the process of collaborating with Home Depot to beautify the Eric g j Orlowski Memorial located in the front of our school lance corporal Orlowski was at West senica East graduate in in the United States Marine who passed away in 2003 during Operation Freedom we want to make sure he is always remembered for his service to our community an additional shout out to to our Yorkers club for sponsoring a canned
006food drive our Yorkers members collaborated with the West senica food pantry and the West sen West senica School District retiree wbd allesandro to collect dry goods to be donated to our local food pantry thank you to the West sen Alliance club for their generous clothing donations to our community they have been wonderful supporters of our towns and families on Thursday December 12th our East Middle PTO will be hosting a spaghetti dinner fundraiser in the East Middle cafeteria from 4:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m. both dine in and take out are available all are welcome our East Middle School njhs students will be helping with this event greeting and seating guests and assisting with cleanup as well this is a great opportunity for students to earn some necessary community service hours while also working directly Within our
007school Community for our fall sports highlights our modified football team was seven had seven wins and one loss our boys modified volleyball team had six wins and five losses our girls modified soccer team had eight wins and five losses and the district cross country showcased 35 Runners and we want to give a congratulations to the 2024 East Middle School girls modified volleyball team enjoyed an undefeated season with a record of 14 wins and zero losses our winter sports season is officially underway we are proud to share that between basketball wrestling swim indoor track and bowling we have over 75 student athletes participating our Capstone class is taught by both Mrs Stacy lutman and Mr David papy students are currently building cardboard arcade machines such as ski golf ping poool flick ball and flip a frog
008the strategizing that is involved in the construction process while also realizing progress is an awesome component of our Capstone sessions on Friday November 22nd we held our quarter 1 honors breakfast sponsored by students Services team in Paul's Donuts this breakfast was designed to recognize our hundreds of East Middle students who achieved honoral status for quarter 1 our holiday concert season is here East Middle students worked on two to four music pieces in a span of a couple of months they take initiative and show prepared and professional attire for their concert performances our dates for the concerts are Thursday November 19th 7th and 8th grade fall instrument instrument concert Wednesday December 11th grade 6 holiday concert and Monday December 16th grade 7th and 8th holiday concert something rotten Junior something rotten Junior's show dates are Friday
009March 2st at 7:00 p.m. and Saturday March 22nd at 2:00 p.m. and 700 p.m. it is hosted in our East Middle Auditorium something rotten is about two brothers who set out to write the F the world's first musical in this hilarious mashup of 16th century Shakespeare and 21st century Broadway at East Middle we like to participate in spirit week on Monday December 16th we have feeling Frosty and we wear white Tuesday December 17th holiday sweat sweater favorite Hol where we wear our favorite holiday sweater Wednesday December 18th is Candy Cane Lane we wear red and white Thursday December 19th is holiday chaos we over accessorize and then lastly on Friday December 20th long W's nap is holiday PJs the students at our school love to participate in in spirit week and it gives them an
010opportunity to express themselves and be a little silly I guess we would like to give a very special thank you to Dr Krueger and the board of education for giving us this opportunity to let faen and I make a presentation on talking about how awesome West senica East Middle School [Applause] is thank you Reed and failen you not only make us proud this evening but each and every day thank you for representing our school so [Applause] well thank you so much we love hearing of all the exciting things going on in our schools and thank you so much to you and your families for being here tonight it is my pleasure to share some updates of things that have been happening within our school district and some things uh on the horizon for us so
011my first uh exciting news is we have been um so happy all fall since we learned that our very own Sydney stery uh is on the voice if you've been following her journey and her story she had her final performance last night and the results will be airing tonight um your very cool superintendent of schools is sporting her team Sydney t-shirt that was made by the students at West Senior High School so we are all rooting for Sydney and can't wait to see the results tonight um in addition we had a number of our athletic teams this fall that earned scholar athlete status in order to earn scholar athlete status the entire team needs to have a combined average of 90% or greater academically and we had 15 out of our 16 varsity teams that
012were awarded the New York State scholar athletic teams so congratulations to all of them we had um some great things happening throughout this month in our schools Northwood Elementary students celebrated World kindness day we also had two of our vocalists um who participated in the nisma conference uh they were actually selected not only for Erie County and Regional Regional uh but they made it all the way to the state conference all state conference for mixed chorus and vocal Jazz so we were so happy and proud of both Faith flattery and Jonah Higgins for their selection and their accomplishment check out that amazing gingerbread house I I thought I did pretty good with cutout cookies but this is one of our very own students who took home first place she's a culinary student uh who participated
013in the culinary uh program through bosies and was in a competition at the Niagara Falls Culinary Institute and she won first place isn't that amazing as you heard from our students from East Middle School um we had a number of student events that went on this fall where our students are giving back to their Community our students at um East Middle School participated in a canned food drive we also uh had students who took part in the Polar Plunge to benefit the Special Olympics upcoming events that I wanted to get on the board of educations radar and for our community is we do have a community closet coming up uh that will be held on December 11th and December 18th we this is our second time offering this we had an overwhelming response a few
014weeks ago when we held our community closet where we uh gave at no cost to families winter coats boots jackets and we are doing this again and we are grateful for our community and our faculty and staff who donate gently used items so that we can give that to those that are in need in our school community and then lastly I wanted to share with the Board of Education the long awaited results of the Rockefeller Institute study and Foundation Aid we just received the results of this study about a week ago and uh this was something that was commissioned by Governor hokel to study Foundation Aid um which has long been under criticism for its outdated calculation for how school's Foundation Aid is calculated so this commission uh was this study was commissioned by governor
015hokel and it was intended to focus on Foundation aid but in fact they went well beyond just the scope of foundation shade and had a much more comprehensive and thorough study that was done um which was to both my pleasure and my surprise to be quite honest the thress of it the document itself is over 300 pages in length and there's a number of recommendations and considerations that are recommended to the legislative body I've got a just a few things that I wanted to highlight that I think are positive and key advancements in this study and one is that this zero emission buses while a noble um movement and certainly one that I think we can all say in in theory is wonderful but the practicality of it is that the buses cost four times
016more than a diesel bus and the infrastructure needed is absolutely overwhelming to schools and so this study recomm recommends that if New York state is going to require school districts to do this that New York State fully underwrites the costs of doing so and not put that on the backs of local school districts because inevitably it would mean us reducing programs or other Staffing opportunities for students or potentially our facilities in order to respond to this unfunded mandate so that was a key Point um additionally it is re in a lot of the ways in which um our school state aid is calculated it is based on poverty data that is from the 2000 census and certainly over a 24e period the demographics in most School communities have changed whether that's the number of students
017that we have in poverty that we're servicing our special education rates or English language language Learners and so we've been getting state aid based on outdated data and so this commission really um is recommending that we look at more updated ways in which of calculating state aid for schools there are some limitations to this um is that if these recommendations went into effect in one year it could result in drastic changes for schools and not giving us much opportunity to plan and respond through our budget development process so there is a recommendation that this that any of the changes be made over a 3 to fiveyear phase in Period that by having that phase in Period school districts can better respond and plan for through the budget process because there may be very significant implications
018for the budget development process it does acknowledge that while most school districts across our state have experienced some decline in enrollment that doesn't mean that our expenses have declined most most of the decreases in enrollment are so minimal in many school districts that it doesn't mean that you're closing a school and therefore reducing the number of Administrators School nurses cleaners custodians and teachers that it's uh a minimal decrease in enrollment and so we need to be mindful of that so in short as a result of this um study that was done by the Rockefeller Institute the recommendation and the results of that study is now in the hands of the governor and the legislative body and I think there's really one of three Pathways that we could see nothing comes out of this study and
019there are no changes or at the other end of the extreme there's sweeping changes in the way that Foundation Aid and other forms of Aid are calculated for schools or someone somewhere in the middle that some of the recommendations may be adopted so really what's going to happen from this study is to be determined um but the governor has been on record acknowledging this stud study and and I think it will have an impact in a positive way and I'm optimistic for what that means for our future budget planning purposes so looking ahead incredibly busy time of year it is concert season uh the school closing last week on Thursday had a ripple effect of some changes so I would encourage everyone to look at our website or our app for the latest details on
020all of our concerts that we have um but some other events that we have coming up we have an academy night at East Senior we already held our West Senior Academy night uh we have a half day for all students scheduled on December 12th December 13th we have no school scheduled for elementary students to support our parent teacher conferences our redistricting committee will meet next on December 19th and we'll have an update on that uh from Tony day and the redistricting committee later this evening we have our winter recess December 23rd through January 1st in school will resume on January 2nd and a Board of Education meeting on January 7th and then other dates in January we have our high school information night for current 8th grade students at East Senor on January 8th and
021a redistricting committee meeting on January 16th and then lastly a board of education work session on January 21st so that's all I have thank you Mr bant thank you you're welcome we'll move on to the board president's report um just want to just want to touch base on a few things that um I'm happy to be moving forward on that um Laura and I have been working on and the whole board um if if you go back 10 15 years ago there wasn't a lot of ways to get information from this board or to Share Board even stuff between each other because you know technology wasn't where it's at now very impressed we're able to have Marlo join the meeting from Antarctica I believe she's you know I'm not sure where you are but um
022she's able to join the meeting with us here um another thing we've been using is the super eval um the board docs and I know we're looking to improve some more stuff we do with the board docs online um sharing our some of our files on uh Google Drives and stuff that we can access as a board the reason I bring this up is obviously uh Vince and I our seats are up at the end of this year and who knows whether we'll be back or not but it's nice that there's five of you that will be continuing so what I'm hoping is we can continue building more of the um the documentation of what the board is doing so new people if they're here can get up to dat better um better on things
023um we have a we're keeping a a little file um of the the we the monthly meetings with some emails that are important so we can pass it off to whoever will be president next year um if it's not you know someone from this room um Laura's handling the the super revil process because then she can carry it over past this year so again I just want to point out to everybody that the board's working really hard on documenting everything we're doing one way or another so the members can work well together and so the public still has access to a lot of stuff that they didn't in the past and I want to thank everyone for doing that um I know it's not really a report but it's just a comment um Nicole puts
024in a lot of hard work the board members do Dr Krueger and uh everyone hears me talking to the voice in the sky um we wouldn't be able to go back and watch our meetings if he didn't U make sure this was done every month so we do appreciate it and thank you sir too for everything you guys do with the microphones and the recording I call it videotaping but I'm assuming it's not videotaping anymore it's some sort of digital thing so that being said Thank you guys and uh I look forward to increasing the use of this technology um we will move on to public comment um I do not have any names in front of me if anyone interested is there anyone in the room that is interested in coming up to the
025podium okay so that makes it easy I don't have to read that speech um we will move on to our presentations and recognitions we are going to hear um about academic data yes thank you Mr ban so at the request of the board and in response to that request our assistant superintendent caralina PCO is um going to be presenting tonight on academic data and one of the things that that we were responsive to at the request of the board was that it was simply not an overview of data slides but really more insight as to how we use data as a school district how we use that data to inform educational practices how we use that data to get feedback on on student performance and also interventions for our students who may be in need
026of additional support and assistance and so that's been embedded in tonight's presentation the presentation is lengthy um and you all have access to the entire presentation many of the data slides Karm is going to to Simply go through in a you know kind of freezing through them if you will so that we can really focus on what the board wanted us to focus on which is how do we utilize the data for Effective Improvement educationally to benefit our students so with that bit of background I'm going to turn it over to K to lead us through the presentation and we will make the presentation available um any of the presentations both East Middle School's presentation and this academic data presentation will be made available for anyone who wants to review it in Greater detail thank
027you K thank you good evening everyone thank you for the opportunity to present the academ academic data presentation to you I wanted to acknowledge the directors uh that we have in the room um we have John delbo and Carol Bush and Franco de Pasqua who also contributed uh some of the information that is um contained within the presentation and they'll be available to help answer questions as well um throughout or at the end of the presentation so academic data what data do we value as a district we value that data that provides us with the information on how well our students are working towards achieving the standards this data can take on a number of forms whether it's a universal screener with the progress monitoring that's associated with it diagnostic assessments that provide additional information
028on specific skills the Milestone Summit of Assessments that we're accustomed to as beginning middle and end of year assessment Ms pre and post tests midterm exams final exams realtime formative assessments so those assessments that we give that help to drive or inform our instruction as we are teaching the content in the classroom those can be quick checks problems of the day ongoing assessments and then lastly performance-based assessments such as with the Arts the why behind the assessment data we examine assessment data sets in order to provide a snapshot of student performance related to progress on a given standard or type of task to Target student specific skill deficits or hone in on strengths allow for informed decision- making regarding teaching and learning and having multiple measures of data whether those are formative or S summative
029are essential to create and complete that picture of student performance so we're not just looking at one particular assessment but a variety of assessments the what behind assessment data essential questions help us to plan for next steps when reviewing the data we ask how can we use the data to improve how we approach student learning needs what can we learn from student responses what structures and processes do we use to begin data informed dialogue at the school level so when we're looking at the data we're looking at the strands we're looking at domains and standards we can also learn from student responses where there are gaps misconceptions or strengths and the structures and processes that we use vary from building level team meetings grade level meetings department meetings depending on the level Elementary Middle High
030also mtss meetings where we are addressing students concerns and also faculty meetings as a whole so the multiple measures of assessment data that we'll talk a little bit more about tonight are categorized into one of three things Universal screeners so that is such as the bance screener at the prek level I ready assessments K8 diagnostic assessments that give us further information of where there are intervention needs with students such as Dibbles the dynamic indicators of basic early literacy skills the developmental reading assessment also known as Dr phological awareness screening tool the past and do the math last lastly but not least is the academic assessment component which are related to the core instruction in the classroom Benchmark Advance assessments New York State 3 through eight Ela and math New York State 5 and8 science which
031were new this past year and Mathematics formative and summative assessments the universal screeners um that were mentioned on the previous slide start with band screener this is used mainly as An Early Education tool to evaluate key predictors of school Success for our youngest Learners the tool evaluates physical development language development academic skills and cognitive development and self-help or social emotional skills the Brigance is given twice per year both in the fall and the spring to provide a Baseline and to measure growth the I screener is a used as a tool to measure what students know and have not yet mastered in basic mathematics and reading skills so the domains that the I screener evaluates for reading our phological awareness phonics fluency vocabulary comprehension and in math we have numbers and operations algebra algebraic thinking measurement
032and data and geometry the I quick question what what what grade do you start iing kindergarten start kindergarten for both math and reading yes k through eight the I ready is given three times per year in the fall winter and spring again to provide a Baseline and to measure growth the I ready results helps teachers along with the Diagnostics to plan for targeted instruction and also intervention for areas of need the Dibbles are the dynamic indicators of basic early literacy skills is used with students who have gaps in phonics and fluency as measured by the universal screener so in our case ready Dibbles is given to further measure literacy and reading skills acquisition the assessment is comprised of multiple short fluency measures that allow interventionists to monitor development and identify risks so these can include
033subtests that focus on letter naming fluency phic segmentation fluency nonsense word fluency and word reading fluency so again the fluency is the ability to read with proper speed in accuracy and our phonics really works on connecting students sounds and spoken language to the written symbols the developmental reading assessment or the Dr is used for students who have gaps in vocabulary and comprehension as measured by the universal screener so on the I ready if those are areas of deficit then a Dr is often given to assess individual student reading proficiency it measures how accurately a student can read the words in a book book or passage how fluently they read and whether a student can understand what they have read so the Dr is given as a Baseline and to measure growth again three times per
034year in our younger grades and that is conducted at various points throughout the year and two times per year for grades three through five once in the fall and once in the spring if the student is given this assessment based on the need from the screener the past or the phological assessment screening tool is used with students who have gaps in phonological Awareness as measured by the diagnostic screener there the I ready it's individually administered assessment tool to help determine the point of instruction for students and monitor progress made it measures and understanding of a student's pheic awareness their understanding of syllables rhyming and sentence segmenting and also the ability to differentiate the sounds of the language the past is given twice per year both in the fall and the spring again as a Baseline
035and to measure [Applause] growth the do the math program is used with students who have gaps in basic mathematics computational skills the math assessments are part of a comprehensive program that identifies specific areas where our kids are struggling with particular math concepts the key points of newe the math are focus on Intervention the beginning of module assessment which is used as a pre-test in most cases targeted instruction which is specific to student gaps and then progress monitoring which is ongoing do the math is used with AIS students so those students that have already been identified as needing additional academic intervention to build that numerical reasoning confidence so it's very repetitious giving them that ability to succeed and be confident in the math so the diagnostic assessment data this is data from our diagnostic one which
036was given back in the fall um our we will be conducting diagnostic 2 in January so this is our Baseline and then in January we will have the same results so that we can measure have our students grown where have they grown are they still showing deficits where is that and then how do we intervene so if we are looking at the um K1 and two you'll see that there are areas of green yellow pink and then red so our dark green means that our students are at Mid or above grade level our light green means that they're early on grade level yellow indicates one grade level below average pink is two grade levels below average and then the red would be three or more gray levels below average you'll see that in kindergarten there
037are no red and that is because a student in kindergarten cannot be more than two grade levels behind so the results here on the slide show that our kindergarten students as such are performing higher than the national and New York percentages our first grade same higher than the national in New York and then in grade two you will see that um our students in second grade are significantly higher than the national and New York Norms so that is good data to have can I can I ask a couple questions about that sure so New York so that's not the entire State that's just those who use I already correct okay we know how many schools districts use that or is that I don't have the number the name of the districts who do but we
038can certainly get that and we can get numbers of kids who actually sat for the diagnostic as well all right so that's that's just that's not like a across every District cor corre just the the students in the districts who are utilizing I ready so this is given three times yes a year I correct so the first um Administration was in September and then how do so then when that's when that's given it's determined whether students are on a path to get additional intervention yes so how's it decided between dibles Dr and based on the area of deficit so wherever the deficit is they use that corre for the next so okay um so then they're not assessed again until December or January as a diagnostic screener correct so they wouldn't have have an opportunity
039to get any additional support between so there's no progress monitoring that occurs in October November December or students who were not found to be have a deficit yes that would happen in the classroom with the classroom teacher who would differentiate instruction um this is just Bas this is a baseline for us from where we start so that's why we use the multiple measures whether they are diagnostic that gives us more intervention for the students who showed gaps on that Baseline assessment or are they formative assessments that are being utilized as part of the curriculum and program being taught in the classroom are they summative assessments end of unit things of that nature correct all right I'll ask okay can I ask you a question real quick sure is our sample number there comprised of students
040from um all of our buildings all of our elementary building yes yes correct it's so it's every student takes this yes okay um I have a question about this before you go on sure so this is this year correct um this is the first year of having this program right this is the second year second year however in middle school it's the first year Middle School is the first year correct So in theory over the next couple of years we will see the results for the kindergarten group yes and their first grade group do and again this is probably nothing you know now does is that the way it goes from no pink to a lot of pink does it is it is that consistently with because it's more material they're learning or like I
041know it's a different grade level now different groups of kids but what I'm wondering is the kindergarten kids in two years will there be a lot more pink typically um you know is it where we're starting to see more the pink is two grade levels behind so when you're inart you can't be right that's that's what I'm that's what I'm saying is you'll start to see more like so in in in kindergarten it's difficult to catch the issue but we all want to do early interventions and I know you got multiple different ways to do it but is it does it get worse as it goes on every grade all the way up or is this just because you're going from a kindergarten assessment to first so I think it depends I I understand what
042you're saying Ed and there's a couple slides on here that will show you um last year's versus this year's first diagnostic hopefully it'll help to answer your question you're welcome so moving on to the third fourth and fifth grade data here and just to point out that the current fourth and fifth grade students were what were deemed as the covid kids so we're still kind of writing out that wave here but third grade you'll see that based on the percentages here that they are significantly higher on this diagnostic one than the national and New York students who are taking this assessment in fourth grade they are also higher than both and in fifth grade the same if you take a look at this slide it will show you um K to five so the results
043are relatively consistent so if you look at to your point if you look at the kindergarten 23 24 column versus the 2425 column they're pretty evenly matched it's consistent all right same with first grade a little bit of a difference in second grade pretty consistent in third same in fourth and a little change in fifth grade but if you take a look at the kindergarten students for example um in 23 we had 27% of the students in the mid or above grade level category the they would then be hypothetically with some exceptions the first grade class under the 2425 column and you'll see that there's 19% so that would indicate there was a little bit of a dip now again they may not be the exact number of students or the same students for that
044matter but typically you could see where that has changed right if you look at 23 20 the 23 kids at first grade the kids in the green was 23% so they would for the most part be this year's second graders and that group is 37% so that group of students looks to have made some gains on some of the assessment on the diagnostic one again the content is different um from grade one to 2 or k to one but to give you that sort of comparative data both K 20 3 and 24 and then if you look at those students in 23 assuming they all moved over to first grade what was that difference just to kind of highlight I think what you were asking for yeah thank you you're welcome so if we're looking
045continuing looking at the reading we have sixth seventh and eth grade this was the first year for sixth seventh and eighth grade for I ready um so there is no comparison to last year is because they were still doing the map assessment but sixth grade is is out standing they're um above the national and New York numbers and slightly below the national Norm the seventh grade the same same exact vote and in eth grade approximately the same so if you look at the numbers across um the areas they're were pretty consistent with their like peers across the state that are also taking this assessment switching over to math again in kindergarten there are no pink or red because they cannot be um under two grades or below in kindergarten but looking at our data for
046kindergarten they are above they're performing above national and New York numbers first grade is approximately equal to you'll take a look there at first grade um the New York and National slightly below National normed and then second grade is also above in third fourth and fifth grade third grade is approximately equal to national and New York fourth grade is above national and New York looking at the green there and then fifth grade is the same we have pretty consistent numbers of students being assessed um in the 400 range across all of those grade levels so again uh back to your question Ed when we're looking at math and we're looking at the distribution how have our placements changed from Fall to fall they are pretty consistent again um across the board there from last year
047to this year some es and flows there so if we are looking at for instance if we looked at second grade we would see that we have 10% of students in the green if we were to surmise that those second graders are this year's third graders that 10% Rose to 12% so there's slight gain there and we can do that comparatively this is a crosssectional analysis how do the district's placements compare to the Benchmark so for looking at 6 7th and eth again um first sixth grade is above national and New York slightly below National Norm 7th grade is slightly below and eighth grade is below national and New York so eighth grade we might want to do a little more digging there in the math to see what is the root cause there um
048but for the most part in math and in Reading we are consistent with the students in our district are consistent with their peers Across the Nation that are also taking the same assessment so just to highlight a couple of grade levels for you and looking specifically at the above mid or early on grade level so West senica in Reading at grade two we have 37% of students in the above mid or early on grade level New York's percentage is 23 the national percentage is 26 and the national Norm is 27 so in Reading in grade two just to highlight that's really impressive we're at 37 and next closest is 27 so a good 10% percentage points on that administrative I'm sorry that um diagnostic assessment in math in grade two West Sona is at 14%
049which indicates a 4% increase from last year um reading was 8% sorry I didn't mention that earlier New York is at 9% National at 11 and National Norm at 12% so again higher grade six the same in Reading we have 34% in the above mid or early on grade level New York is at 29 National at 31 and the national Norm at 34 so we're right on there and then in math as well 27% in West senica 26 26 and 28 New York and the national our academic assessments so K to five Benchmark Advance reading program assessments we have interim assessments that are administered three times per year and as a result we have a detailed item analysis that provides our teachers the information needed on specific ific skills tested which would then inform our
050instructional decisions the qsa or the quick spelling assessment is administered three times per year the qsa can also be used as a quick whole class screener at the beginning of the year for a baseline um but it can be used to confirm that the student has learned phonics decoding skills and can apply those when spelling words with the same pattern in mathematics we have a few uh formative and summative assess ments that we utilize as part of our core instructions spiraled common topic tests that are administered every four to six weeks so they give us real information in real time they're aligned to the nextg standards to measure proficiency on those particular standards those are given in K to8 classrooms our common midterm tests and assessments are administered halfway through the school year in January
051typically for grades six seven and 8 we do not have midterms for our elementary grade levels those tests are also aligned to the standards and measure where the student is at at that point in the school year gives us good information in real time that we can act upon and inform our teaching from mid year to the end of the year and then our common end of the year test assessments are administered once per year at the conclusion of the school year um in K to8 and those tests are also aligned to the standards show how the student performed over the course of the year on the grade level standards [Applause] the New York State Ela and math assessments um grade three through eight for ELA and math and five and eight for science last
052year's assessments were brand new um based on those investigations those tests um were highly touted as being tests of reading um and also utilizing that science content um together it was a challenging assessment as such the Science assessment scores were not part of our accountability status this year they were only based on Ela and math but this federally required test is one measure of the multiple measures we've discussed um that guides the classroom instruction and they're administered annually in the spring over the course of two days for ELA and math in one day for science they serve as an additional measure on how well our students are performing on the grade level standards they're also used as a tool to help ensure our students are that need academic support receive them they help identify learning
053needs that a student may have related to standards measured on that particular test and they give us a snapshot of how our kids are performing compared to their peers across the state the K to5 Benchmark Advance interim one building assessment data I have this here by Strand and by building so you could see the scale here um red is 40% and Below orange is 41 to 59% % yellow is 60 to 79% and green would be 80% and above the strands are language standards reading standards for informational text for literature foundational skills and then also writing so you could I what would we consider proficiency 65% I'm sorry the 65% okay so because this scale is 60 to 79 so I'm not sure how that you know like why would that be a scale from
05460 to 79% when only part of that's a proficient level yeah that that is true um Carol maybe you could help to answer that question is the proficiency also 65 on these inter room assessments so Benchmark advances created a scale that conserves the scores because the national set standards excuse me so um so our standard is 65 but Benchmark standard is 60 that so the yellow would indicate per efficiency tool that you're using the tool that tool considers that bandwidth yeah okay all right thank you so this is the pre-test which is also then used as a post test um and this table shows the average score if we look at by Strand and grade level across the district you will see that that we have um mainly orange and yellow a couple areas of
055red and then some areas that we don't have information for and that is uh particularly because in grades K and one we don't assess the writing standards as they call for picture drawing and emergent writing skills so those are not assessed in those two grade levels and then in grades three four and five the reading standards for foundational skills stops at grade two so there is no data for for that particular strand academic assessment data just to highlight some of the K to5 mathematics topic one assessment data so by building and by grade we have proficiencies and these are the percentage of students who are scoring a 65% or higher on the math assessment again I just highlighted grade two just to be consistent with the grades that we highlighted as part of the I
056Diagnostic and you will see that on this topic one assessment our students did fairly well looking at grades 6 through 8 on topic one we have also I just highlighted again for consistency grade six they are also doing fairly well on that first topic assessment moving on to the Spring New York State Ela assessment right here on this slide we just have the percentages of students by grade level and where they scored on that assessment level 1 2 3 three or four on this slide we have the number of students who participated in that assessment and again by their performance level one two three or four this chart has a lot of numbers on it and it shows you the total of students who have taken the assessment based on um compared to those who
057did not test and then their levels of proficiency and then a combine level so it's important to note here that on the ELA in Spring of 24 we had 81% of our students tested or participated sat for the assessment and of those 81% students 39% of them were proficient or scored a level three or four I think that's important to note that we had 81% participate in the past our numbers have been much lower so we are trending upward which is good for when we are um having students sit for the assessments and when we're looking at the participation as part of the Essa accountability status the more students in that end number the better our scores and accountability are so looking at the spring Ela current and previous year so again we put them
058side by side so that you could see in 23 how our students performed versus how they performed in 24 in the spring um the the blue is the level four so that's the highest level three is the second highest and combined blue and orange give you that um proficiency level so grade three we had 41.8% proficient and in 24 45.2 so a little bit of an increase our students did better um in fourth grade we had 40.7% in 23 and that went up to 43% scoring proficient and then in grade five it was pretty much the same with a decline of 6% do we know how this Compares with the state not on this particular slide but we certainly can get that information from all all the schools take yes yes yes it would be
059nice to know how we compare so we're comparing ourselves from last from year to year for the last two and there's definitely been some increases and also been some increases in the cohorta but they' been yep we can get that for you no problem and then the same side for sixth seventh and eighth grade pretty consistent um over the past two years on our student performance levels jumping ahead to math again these are just the number of percentages of students who performed at what level from 1 two three or four these are the actual number of students and how they rank between level 1 2 3 and four for the um total number of students who were tested 76% of our students sat for the math assessment and of those 76% tested 53% were proficient
060levels three and four this is the side-by-side comparison of 23 and 24 again pretty consistent a slight uh jump in grade four grade six seven and eight again pretty consistent a slight jump in grade seven proficiency levels and then science we have the distribution of levels 1 2 3 and four and then the number of students taking the assessment and their distribution levels and then our science slide shows how many students tested so we had a combined 71% test in grades 5 and 8 in science and of that 71% 45% were proficient on that assessment our data analysis process so taking all of this information and then how do we look at it it's ongoing it occurs a variety of ways across the district so across the district we have grade level meetings department meetings
061faculty meetings dayto days individual teacher reflection on those assessments each level whether it's elementary middle or high looks at the different data as pertinent to their instruction staff are involved in reviewing and analyzing data in a variety of ways at the building level this can look like a grade level a department faculty meeting to analyze a variety of data assessment data which is both formative that that which is in real time and summative that's more cumulative towards the end of a course or unit and then that diagnostic data the universal screeners that indicate the targeted support that a student may need vertical and horizontal data analysis is conducted as part of a school's regular operations in order to inform that teaching and learning so as a Grade Three teacher we may all get around a
062data set and look at it as grade three but then we also in that building look at our data K to5 how did our students perform vertically so those vertical and horizontal discussions are happening at the building level moreover we have data conversations that happen as an embedded component of our mtss meetings at our buildings where we're looking at perceptual and qualitative data such as surveys interviews and other quantitative data important things like attendance demographic data those are also conducted regularly at the building level in addition to the data analysis that happens at all of our buildings staff engage in data review collectively as a district we have three districtwide data days half days that are intentionally positioned in the fall in the winter and in the spring to align with those diagnostic assessments and
063then we look at that Baseline diagnostic data at that First Data day and also in the middle school and high school we look at that Summit of data from the previous school year and at that first session we review the data we look for Trends we know gaps we a we notice areas of strength and we reflect on best practices there's um and Linked In the presentation is a sample day-to-day reflection form then based off of that data analysis teachers in that course or in that grade level work to develop an action plan again I've linked an example there in the presentation and that Universal diagnostic data is reviewed to help develop grouping so you may have students who have similar deficits and they would become a group um also serve for a basis for
064additional diagnostic assessment so if some of the students were flagged on that Universal screener we do those further probes to assess how are they doing on those particular domains Andor components can I ask you are those action plans tied to a goal yes based on the data that they review there may be a standard or stand s that have shown across a grade level or across the district for instance that students are falling short on so the goal would be to help students improve on that particular standard and then as teachers they develop the steps that will help get them there and then they re-evaluate so they monitor progress of that action plan that was written in the fall in the winter how are students doing on this now midterm assessment did our students show
065growth on that particular standard or standards so at the end of the day today is do buildings walk away with a goal for an improvement goal yes do um like grade levels have an improvement goal our elementary grade levels predominantly look at that I ready and Benchmark data so that is their action plan it drives their instruction at the secondary level we're looking at that midterm assessment data um also coupled with that diagnostic data to help tie those things together like I'm looking for the the goal though like what are where are the goals and what is the Target that we're trying to to reach it depends on that particular area so if a final exam highlighted um a weakness in vocabulary for instance in biology of tier two or three words then as a
066a department in biology we have the goal to strengthen vocabulary in those areas so what are some of the strategies that we're going to put in place we may decide to have a common assessment that we're giving across that course across both sides of town that we're then looking at how did the students perform based on these strategies that we put in place between this period of time and the second time that we're assessing it does that everybody walks away with an articulated goal and an action plan yes and at the elementary level we're using I ready because we have um students who follow the my path and they have specific learning geared towards their learning gaps okay the final data day looks typically at um the second reading and math diagnostic data versus the
067final reading and Mathematics Di diagnostic data that's at the elementary and middle so we also looking at the first diagnostic the second and then the third so how did they go from first to second second to Third and then how did they do from 1 to third so looking at all of that data previously developed action plan steps and strategies at the high school level as we just sort of discussed um how have we made progress on the steps and strategies that we put in place to help make improvements with our students achievement so again that d notic data is reviewed to measure growth between assessments and administrations students are preliminarily identified at this third dayto day for academic Support Services moving forward for the next year and action plan progress monitoring including implications for
068future instruction are noted using that data analysis process we identify students that need academic intervention again the diagnostic the screener it's just a baseline for us it sets the the parameters or the metrics and then within that what are the tools that we utilize and those are some of the assessments that I discussed previously the New York State assessment data how did the student score is it a level one is it a level four the dras if that student showed reading comprehension deficits then what how did they perform on that diet developmental reading assessment the Dibbles and so on and so forth we look at all of these things to make a final determination that data is then used to determine Staffing for AIS and we have metrics in place for the first time in
069a while um on group size frequency and sessions per week so we cap that session number at 35 it's similar to what speech uh teachers use and we take a look at the percentage of students in the red so those again were the students that had three or more grade levels below average as a starting point at the elementary level we have group sizes that range from 3 to 5 based on input from teachers of the number that works best and at the middle school level 5 to S the range gives our teachers most flexibility and how they're grouping students and the number of times they are seeing these students per week can be two to four times per week at the elementary or every other day at the middle school level because that is
070the structure that works best within the middle school schedule and within that there are flexibilities that the interventionists have um grouping kids with same deficits Etc and then we allocate the FTE so if you look at the example I have here on this slide if we had 38% of our students in grade six in the red and every other day are the days per week where they're getting intervention the group size 5 to S at 35 sessions that would calculate to 65 FTE so we utilized these metrics last year to allocate our um teachers for academic intervention and it did have some shift in Staffing Personnel at various of buildings and I think that is it apologize for the length of that I have Carol John and Franco here to help answer questions as well
071if there are any additional questions yeah actually I had a question about Mathis okay so when does Mathis begin what great right writing kindergarten I'm sorry right in kindergarten okay okay so what is the delivery model like in the middle I looked at 8th grade so 117 kid students in eth grade for leaving eighth grade under not performing at proficiency M so what happens to those students when they get to their freshman year how do they get do they get AIS in the high school what does that look like so the students in 9th grade are also given the map so that still is happening in n9th grade so they are getting a universal screener diagnostic there are meetings that happen between AIS teachers in eth grade in nth grade math teachers to know who
072the kids are that need to have that Focus AIS Works a little bit differently in the high school in that we have FTE allocated based on students who were not successful on the Region's exams so that is the key thing but if we have students who have deficits they're also put into AIS if they're at risk of failing so like yeah I me that's would be a huge concern would be those freshmen coming in that have not yet were not performing at Proficiency in e8th grade they're coming into the middle school and then on top of that you do have you I'm glad you you mentioned Matt because you have 276 eighth graders who did not take the test so how do we determine where their level is through the other measures we use in
073the classroom so those common spiral tests those midterm assessments the topic assessment tests um so they get an AIS period every other day them if they're if they're in that typically yes and they're also differentiated instruction with in the classroom as well so we're trying to get at them at various opportunities and not just rely on one interventionist how are we working in tandem together to help support the student and using those multiple measures when is the final assessment given for the I ready in May in May and then if we still I mean obviously we still have students that are below their grade level are any Services provided for them throughout summer so we have in the past have had summer programming in elementary middle and high um past couple of years we have
074not had it available at elementary um for a number of reasons um availability of Faculty to teach that over the summer um we also have middle school and high school that have been digital um during covid and then we went back to iners but that is mainly at the middle school it's a remedial so it does address some deficits that students have had over the past year or years in middle school and in high school again it's targeted specifically at the students who have failed uh required assessment for graduation and need to pass that to graduate high school we are looking at how can we continue to support students in an extended year format if you will um we're having conversations about that right now and being um how can we provide that support over
075the summer moving forward I have just one more comment if there's nothing else question um so for students who aren't necessarily in the red what but they're on the bubble yes what interventions or supports are available or in place for them other than differentiated instruction within the classroom So within the pro The Benchmark Advance program there is a toolbox that teachers have access to where they can provide extra lessons that Target that deficit within I ready every student has a path so it's individualized towards that particular student's area of strength Andor growth so if you're looking at the the um the picture that typically has been a a a diamond a pyramid now we're looking at the diamond so we're looking at both ends how are we helping to meet the needs of the students
076who are excelling and Performing above grade level as well as those students who are in the red to kind of piggy back off of Sarah's question so on those graphs s when we were looking at this year to next year but say it was last year's kindergarten to this year's first grade or last year's first grade to this year's second there was some significant numbers of increase in red so is that what you're thinking is normal summer drop off or is that where we really need to focus on the elementary levels to make sure that we are keeping that low because I don't want to see the red going up right correct so I think it could be both right and I think that we use multiple measures for that reason so that is the
077starting point so we're looking at um we're looking at Ed beian data and he scored in the red but how has he been traditionally as a student how has he performed traditionally as a student if maybe he just had a particularly rough day and he didn't perform well is this um consistent with his performance in the past so we're having those conversations but yes if this again shows up in the January assessment window we have a large number of students then we need to start looking at the instruction and what is happening in the classroom across the district across the grade level or whatever the case may be so did we just do that mid year not yet in January okay so then at what point do we decide that that's a pattern that it
078was just a bad day for someone versus a districtwide pattern and that not having summer school for elementary is no longer an option it's a need yeah so I think that with the second Administration and all the assessments that have happened in between so when we're having those day-to-day conversations whether we're looking at that diagnostic data or we're looking at the interim classroom assessments where are all arrows pointing is there is everything pointing in the same direction and we're having we're falling down in a certain particular area then what are we going to be doing as a district to remedy some of those gaps and deficits I really appreciate your question and in particular the early intervention Focus it's pretty clear in research that if we have a student who is at a reading deficit
079at third grade the ability for us to close that Gap uh is unlikely that those pivotal years of early intervention at prek K12 are critical and I additionally appreciate so so what will we do then for the intervention is it extended school day is it extended school year meaning a summer Intervention Program what are we going to do to close that deficit and to do it with a sense of urgency in those early years because typically a reader who's struggling in third grade they will continue to struggle as a reader throughout the rest of their Elementary years middle school and high school years because that's when we shift from teaching students how to read to really expecting them to be able to read to access the content that's when we start exposure to you know
080more traditional science and social studies and non uh non-fiction reading to access the content so those early interventions are so incredibly critical and if I can just add on that from learning and doing all the things I'm doing as a board member right now and as we're advocating for things the kids who don't have literacy are the ones who grow up and it affects their mental health it affects behavior and then we get into crime so like I just want to make sure that it's not just about reading to pass a test this is an actual life skill and to be an active member of the community so it's that important that I don't want it to just get kind of brushed under the rug that we can't afford summer school like that needs to
081be a priority yeah I would go beyond that I think that the resources need to be poured in prior to getting to a situation where summer school and that was my concern with already and the lack of progress monitoring that happens with that so the the youngest students are going one two 3 four months before they're being reassessed and only after they reass are they considered for intervention that was my question I had written down was these other conversations related to data outside three data meetings is there consistency across the district and when they're happening what the format of those meetings are how are decisions being made because I think that it it sounds like there's important decisions happening three times a year but that in between piece across grade levels across specific skills related
082to buildings like it would be nice to know what what is being used to evaluate and make decisions and if if teachers are being given appropriate time to to work together use the resources that are already available and make decisions based on that in between those those big three tests yes th those three um assessment periods are just touch points there are things that are happening in between so right out off the first Administration we are identifying students that need that assessment they're working with intervention almost immediately in addition to that we have given our teachers new tools that they haven't had access to in the past with I ready and with Benchmark in the whole Benchmark Universe the assessment the toolbox and I ready we have a toolbox and I ready that all teachers
083have access to that was a feature that was just turned on a few days ago they been trained in it have they been trained in it trained on how to use it no so they will be getting training however we just had it turned on a couple days ago but my point is that there are resources and tools that our teachers have not had in the past that they do now have and I think that everyone is working in tandem cohesively to help support the students um nobody wants to see any student fall down or not be successful literacy is huge I think I even mentioned earlier that the science assessments from this past school year were more an assessment of reading than they actually were of the content so we all recognize the importance
084of having our students be literate we know that the early grades they're learning to read and then from grade three on as Dr kruer mentioned they're reading um to learn so we have to make sure that we have strong program and that tier one intervention there for all students that Universal instruction is really key and so having a solid core program in Reading is going to help us make gains anyone else I made a few notes of the the questions that were posed tonight that we need to follow up and get responses to so we will certainly do that but I appreciate the discussion and the questions that that you asked and thank you Karm to you and the directors for your preparation of this thank you can we add for data that we'd like
085um like the students that are identified for AIS and and what the frequency for AIS Services looks like um building by building sure do you mean specifically the number of students who are currently receiving AIS Service and the frequency schedule of them sure sure thank you anyone else good Marley you doing good over there excellent thank you yep thank you okay um I actually would like to have someone if not I will do it make a motion to move into executive session to discuss employment history of a particular person I'll make that motion Jeremy would you like to second I'll second excellent any discussion on it all in favor I anyone opposed no okay what we're going to do is we're going to go into a brief executive session everybody when we come back we
086will be performing more uh more board business so um don't leave and what time is the show on tonight 9: 9 we we're very cognizant of that but obviously this is a very important stuff we got going on so um we will be back as briefly as we can thank you we will move on to number four create certified position May I have a motion on item number 4A for all of four we do all four no well there's only one for I'll make a motion for um to approve for 4 A I'll second it motion to approve motion to Second um is there any discussion on 4 a all in favor I anyone oppos pass is 70 thank you we'll move on to five Personnel classified may I have a motion on item 5
087a just 5A or 5 a just 5 a Marla made a motion Mara Mara made the motion may I have a second to approve 5A I'm sorry motion to approve 5A may I have a second I'll second it Len okay is there any discussion on 5A okay uh how about all in favor I I anyone opposed pass a 70 thank you now I'm looking for a motion on 5B create classified position I'll make a motion to approve 5B or a motion to approve 5B may I have a second please I'll second it Len Loren will second any discussion on net 5B perfect thank you uh all in favor I I 70 if there's unless there's someone opposed perfect passes 70 we will move on to our consent agenda and um consent agenda is going to
088be all items from 6 through 10 if I may have a motion I'll make a motion motion to approve consent agenda 6 through1 may I may I have a second second Laur second and there is no discussion on that so all in favor I anyone opposed perfect consent agenda passes 70 and we will go with number seven now certified wait no is where screws we'll go to number [Applause] 11 10 11 May I have a motion on item 11a please I'll make a motion to pass uh 11a motion to pass 11a may I have a second on that I'll second it Jeremy will second um any discussion on 7A 11 a oh sorry it's late um May I any discussion on 11a thank you sir just that I'm going to obain yes sir thank you
089and that would be the reason we separated it okay no other discussion all in favor I anyone opposed anyone abstaining bin so passes 60 with one exstension L that brings us to new [Applause] business I am looking for a motion on 12 a through 12E I'll make a motion to approve 12 a through e Sarah makes a motion to approve 12 a through 12E may I have a second please I'll second it maren seconds any discussion policy update in there we have some donations the Spanish trip is going to Canada yes okay yes I sure I got that I um I I I'm pretty uh I I think it I think I actually I went with Spanish club to Toronto once the high school used to do it when we were in school yeah like
090it's a good cultural team bonding experience and I don't know I I think we went through fight sir what was that are there bull flights there no no there's not I think we actually went to the Spaghetti Warehouse when I went so I don't know they banned in Barcelona now too you cannot see them Medieval Times Medieval Times medial times that's what it was when I was in high school I'm happy to see kids getting a chance to do something as a group um Absolut yeah I I it's kind of cool though um donations I always like to $1,250 from Anthony Goya to the West Senior Softball program um that's awesome $2,432 180 from the west sunic east Spirit Boosters club to the senior girls volleyball program that's awesome $500 from the Winchester Potters PTA
091or um from the Apex fundraiser to be used towards their school store that sounds really cool too I appreciate all the all the donations um I know we all do um thank you everybody on that and I see the marching band is going to Chicago will will you be a chaperon you get to go possibly that's a that's sounds like a fun trip is it like a parade or a I think yeah the electric show the electric show Magnificent Mile parade yeah yeah I believe it it was postponed the year my daughter was involved in it might have been weather I'm forget what it was but they did go to Orlando at one point what a great trip um indoor track is going Washington Heights cool um so that's enough with the discussion anyone else
092I have one question was the motion for A and B the motion a e a through e just want to make sure we were talking be thank you are you good any other discussion or you good with that no I just want to confirm because there was more there so excellent okay thank you um I guess discussion is over all in favor I anyone opposed passes 70 so now we will do 12f a motion to accept 12f obviously we got time for discussion oh no a motion on 12f you you can tell me if you want to accept it or not I'll make a motion motion to 12f approve 12f may I have a second Sarah okay any discussion on it um you guys had a chance to look at the budget calendar um I
093believe this is what we worked on last what day was that was that this week or last week last we met on Wednesday Wednesday of last week okay oh did you I'm sorry were you referring to our agenda review meeting or the budget advisory committee meting the budget advisory committee meeting advisory committee meeting was Monday was Monday okay a week ago a week ago Monday um yeah we work we worked on the calendar I'm I'm quite happy with it did you guys get a chance to review it and any questions on it or anything good okay um we got some good representation on that committee so far um I appreciate uh appreciate that so uh a second Sarah second um so any other discussion on it all in favor I anyone opposed passes 70 this
094is the uh District's fund balance plan uh may I have a motion on 12g please I'll make a motion to approve 12g we a motion to approve 12g may I have a second I'll make a second to oh Marlo Marlo is making a second to approve 12g any discussion on this um did anyone have a chance to review that or have any questions on it everyone good with it good okay all in favor I I anyone opposed passes 70 and again we do not vote on the 13 stuff and we'll go to 14 our Board of Education discussion um we have a couple of items on there I know um Tony and Vince before we get to the two items on there I just want to make sure does anyone else have anything they want
095to add on for board discussion anything they want to talk about we modified the dates during our agenda meeting last week for our board evaluation self- evaluation so that'll be due before our next meeting I'll send out an email to remind everybody and make sure you have access maybe you could try to check today before you leave and then um in our work session on the 21st we'll um do a midyear evaluation discussion for Dr perer just so you know the timeline everything else statewise is similar to what we talked about when we met with super B okay thank you great and thank you for your work on that very much appreciated um so we'll move on [Applause] to school start times um Vince were you interested in starting that conversation or do you want
096me to go with what I well we we I brought it up before that board discussion but a a little bit impromptu time and I wanted to bring it back up people had some time to kind of process the idea and do their own research and you know generate some more some more questions around the the topic um clearly I'm an advocate for starting High School later in the day and flipping the elementary day to start earlier um I think that's more congruent with where kids um are their Optimum level of performance I think that's you know there's tons of data and research to to back that you see more and more High performing districts move in that direction and I would like us to at least begin the process of investigating that and what
097that would mean for West Sona and especially at a time when we're already looking at the redistricting and reconfiguration of our of our school district I think it would make sense to sync those two things and uh if we are going to make certain changes so if they're two different changes were going to happen per se we want them to happen in conjunction with one another as opposed to okay we made this move and now okay two years later we're going to we're going to look at another another change so that's all I I I'm really uh interested in the process um in beginning to generate that conversation and begin the um looking at the pros and cons and um what that could mean for us okay so want I just want to clarify to
098kind of break it into two sections one you would like to find out if the board's interested in moving forward with investigating that process of flipping times to then once we decide to investigate it then the implementation I think would be a whole separate whether we want to implement it at the time of other changes or future I mean I think that's are two major yeah there are two different things there for sure there's there's is it warranted is it would it be beneficial and if so what does the impl implementation process look like okay yeah and again I'm a huge proponent of not being afraid to discuss anything I I like um I like discussing stuff so that being said I will lean over to the other five board members and see what your
099thoughts are obviously if four or more people want nothing to do with it great and or do we want to look into it like what are your thoughts um I think Vince and I have discussed it enough but feel free to speak but anyone here I'd ra you've heard enough from me on the topic I support it holy I I mean I remember gosh when I first started college that was a big deal so you support looking into it I support looking into it the science is there the data is there um based on age and how their minds work so I absolutely support discussing it for now I wouldn't mind getting more information but I would like to keep it separate from redistricting configuration just because I don't want to derail progress there by
100having two conversations I feel like that's something yes and I want to be clear I think the last time we brought it up we decided keep it separate I'm just I'm just looking at the timing of right and I it might align later but as far as correct I don't think no I don't want to muddy this work with that being added to it but if it can that's great I just what you're saying is you don't want to make Tony add that to his agenda weend well that might be a conversation I was just looking to see if he was here before I said that I very much appreciate the perspectives that have been shared I think our redistricting committee has been given a large task to explore redistricting slre reconfiguration options with ultimately
101the The Hope and goal that later this spring I.E before the end of the school year we have a plan that's presented to the board or multiple plans in the board ultimately adopts a plan for implementation having said that it would be implementation as you know not in the fall of 25 but the fall of 26 because we anticipate that there may be depending on what the plan is that's ultimately adopted there may be significant Staffing implications and transportation implications to pull off whatever the ultimate redistricting or reconfiguration plan is having said that I think think us exploring start times simultaneously this spring separate from redistricting is something that could occur simultaneously because truly you would need that full year for the implementation plan is it reconfiguration SL redistricting one or the other or a
102combination of both and also adjusting start times all of that would need to go into mainly that would have major implications for Trans Transportation so it makes sense to have whatever model for start times and redistricting reconfiguration done ideally by the end of this school year so we have a full year to work on the implementation yeah so um Sarah any thoughts no I'm good you're okay us just starting to figure out a way to look into it sir I'll stand behind my I'm not a huge fan of that personally but I've never used my personal opinion or thoughts to make a decision that the board wants to move forward with but I would stand behind this is something that would potentially be catastrophic to some families I guess a good way to put it
103so I would say I I'm not a fan of online surveys I know we did that with uh or thought exchange I know we've done that with redistricting this is something that if we were going to move forward to with it I would want something mailed to every single household that is within the district not just individuals with kids because you might have some that are planning on having a family or what have it or just have really small kids at this point they're not in the district yet because it could have implications on them in the future so I would want everybody to have a voice when it comes to this whether it be it's just a postcard saying hey we are going to have this uh you know survey online but something so
104people know because when we just pop it up and use the district Communications a lot of people are unaware of things that are happening within the district that it years down the road yeah and Facebook right now has agree with with that um well there's I don't want to do anything that doesn't have full like flush out the pros and cons right and okay we we them out and be realistic for the people who live here yes the people who live here you know and and yes a lot of the so the concern that may will most certainly come up be ready to have potential solutions for that like that should always be okay so we're creating we're creating a situation where we think that it's going to improve certain things but at a certain
105cost so what do we do about those things that it now created a problem are there solutions to that that might and then add it all up and see are we in a better place or is it not worth is it not worth all of that we're not going to change everything because the gain is not worth the cost right you know so again I wouldn't want to do anything that doesn't really flush all those things out I would fully expect any type of committee we put together has all the negatives all the positives the reasons why we should or shouldn't so my my my thought process here is if we're interested in looking into it let's figure out who's going to lead it and then get a small group of people to figure out
106all those other things how we're going to communicate how we're going to run the committee we and we can do that to prepare to present the ideas that say the next meeting um but I don't know we necessarily need to get into the weeds here on on every aspect of it um but we have to figure who's going to lead it who's going to who's going to run this process how you know again thoughts on people what do you think do do you want me to handle something Vince do you want to be the leader Lisa do you have ideas how do you guys want to do that [Applause] can't have a committee without someone in charge as part of it too um I think we should also make sure we're considering and exploring the
107budgetary impacts too Yes yes again what I what I would think is the people we start with let's figure out all the things that we want to address Budget you know there'll be time for input on that whether it's through you know postcard surveys we don't want to do surveys want do phone however it is but we got to start with who's going to and feel free to speak up why only take the time between now and the next to come up with that before just jumping and saying who's going to run it who's going to lead it I appreciate that no there's no need to try to figure that part out right now so what we just figured out is that there's actually an appetite to peek into this a little bit more deeply
108right so we could begin to um lend get help from other districts that have gone through this process and look into those districts what was their process what did they do we don't have to recreate the wheel here perfect we can we can begin to explore what that process would look like sure and then find out what mistakes they made so that we don't make the same mistakes and then again sit down get input even on that part of it we would be getting input from other stakeholders while we're doing it you know there's going to be there's going to be other people are going to say hey I appreciate excuse me sorry I appreciate the opportunity for us to give some thought to the facilitation of it because we have launched two already large
109and consuming committees this year our redistricting committee which if I'm not mistaken has about 34 stakeholders on it so many of our administrators serve on that committee also this year we launched our strategic planning committee um that I am facilitating and again it's a large group of stakeholders a number of our administrators serve on the strategic planning committee as well so I'm just sensitive to us spreading our resources too thin and want to be able to do that important work of both redistricting and strategic planning to do that well and to make sure that we have the right stakeholders and representatives there so whether that is um you know that this becomes a committee of the board led by a board member whether this becomes another committee led by an administrator or whether we look
110to get a facilitator that might be able to serve an consultant role to help us do that because we were doing some really great things but I want to be thoughtful and careful that we're not spreading ourselves too thin and not doing all of those things really well right and thank you for saying that so again when I say pick a leader how do we move forward in the next step do we task Lisa with collecting the data and figuring this out or do we want to hand I'm not talking about like forming the committee and running it I'm talking about collecting whether we want to do a facilitator whether we want Lisa to run it whether we want a board member to run it whether we want you know I don't know Santa Claus
111to run it Lisa what do you think what is what is your thought on how we should approach it take time to think about that over the next few weeks and reconvene next meeting okay appr some proposals some ideas so just to be clear at our next meeting We'll add it to board discussion to figure out how we want to proce come up with ideas of moving forward so we're not going to do any groundw work between now and then personally just thinking and coming up with ideas okay Co I just I just want to make sure cuz uh the last time we did this I promised I would do some background work and I don't believe I didn't I apologize about that V remind you you remember that you didn't do what your I
112just said I would start looking at ideas of how we're going to handle it and then you know we busy we got a lot going on you way L going on show yourself some Grace you're okay okay thank you that's I so we at the next meeting we'll all come personally with ideas and thoughts on how we're going to handle it cool good okay we will now move on to Red disting um oh you know what yeah I screwed up so I mean again every meeting I got to screw up at least three things um letters numbers and words um personal recog Personnel recognition my favorite thing of the whole meeting besides donations and I missed it I apologize thank you I appreciate the opportunity because we do share these slid out um along with
113a link to our recording and it's nice to be able to recognize some folks so in your personnel um agenda items tonight you just approved the retirement of David RoR who's a Fed teacher at West Senior High School it will be effective at the end of the school year so congratulations to him on his retirement and much gratitude for his years of service to the district additionally we had a number of personnel appointments um correct me if I'm wrong Dr cvon I don't believe we have anyone in attendance Who was appointed tonight um but we certainly welcome all of these new team members um to the West Sena Central School District family so congratulations to them we're good great thank you thank you and again I apologize to anyone who's watching at home waiting um
114sorry yeah um okay now we will move on to redistricting with Mr Tony day thank you Tony is here to give us an update on redistricting uh Tony is from the Western New York Education Service Council and um excuse me Nicole sure that would be great thank you I'm comfortable whever wherever you want me I'm already here how about I just stay right so so thank you move me along if I'm standing uh so um thank you for having me back just a come bearing gifts uh everybody got a binder so what what I wanted to kind of do is make sure that you had every material that the redistricting committee has so when you open the binder you see they're tabed by meeting date uh just so every month whatever the materials and most
115of I believe all these materials are shared on the website on the redistricting page but some of them are much easier to work with and understand when you can see them on paper as opposed to um just on a screen uh I I'd asked to direct you to the green tab which I'm not smart enough to figure out how to make those little tabs print on those little tabs so I will get you a little tab um for NE for next time but uh when you open up that that this is really taking a look at where we're heading this month uh the goal tonight just to give you a quick update uh on where what the committee worked on last month and where we're headed and then to answer any questions that you might
116have um first of all I just want to thank publicly we I'm getting so much help in support from so many people in the district um the principes John delbo uh Jackie um fower John saon Jess Shanahan Joe far Melissa Shrum and they're just that's just a starting point and helping there's a lot of different resources trying to come together so I'm just really thankful for the support uh that people are giving to me in that effort um last month we spent some time starting with the I remember we talked last uh when I was here last time we talked about whether or not to what extent um trying to De redistribute at risk highly at risk kids more equitably across the district to spread them out to what should that what level of priority
117should that be um when I had reported you I had said the committee felt they did not had enough time to consider it so we dedicated about 45 minutes to the question uh there's actually some resources uh in the last one's meeting that if you care to read them uh some research uh literature on that area in the end the decided to do exactly what your thoughts was was to make it an important if possible priority that it wasn't a critical priority that had to be done but it was a an important uh but if possible priority and you know in your um in your packet from last month there's a Nifty little um one pager that looks like this and this is what the the group uh uh we reviewed this and the group
118of proved and understands that these are the um parameters that they are working in the parameters that you gave them and the committee is really the informal feedback I've gotten is the committee members are very uh appreciative of having some very clear guidelines to work within what we worked on a lot last month was defining what how do you define capacity in a building because what I've said is our goal is the goal is to be able to create the capacity for each building to have class sizes 18 to 20 at primary 21 to 23 at intermediate and above not to guarantee it but to give the opportunity to should budget and Staffing allow so in order to Define capacity there's it's important to know your square footage in the number of rooms but you
119have to recognize that some rooms are useful for some things and some rooms are useful for other purposes and that for instance um an 8:1 classroom doesn't necessarily have to operate in a full-size 700 squ ft² classroom it can work within a smaller 400 squ ft setting so what you will see in your packet uh in the back for every building I am working with the principles on how many fullsize rooms are there and we've kind of defined that a 700 Square ft or thereabouts how many are half size and how many are smaller spaces so like for instance if you take a look the second page is Allendale and it kind of shows you in the upper right hand corner how many full-size classrooms there are how many uh half size and how many
120very small rooms are currently being used for instruction because that becomes an important designator of like how many what can you do in those rooms cuz schools know only have to have a room for the kids to be in for their core classes but you need interventionists and you need we have self-contained classrooms that have to fit in you have enl in uh some in some buildings you have upk in some buildings so in order to calculate capacity you have to know what are the resources of space that you have available and then to what extent are you able to meet the needs of the current population given the numbers that you have so when you look at the Allendale chart at the bottom you can see there's 32 fulls size rooms and across the
121top you can see that there are right now there's 24 classrooms uh that are being run by Dr Quinn over at Allandale there's two self-contained rooms there are three they call them special needs it's really na Area art music um uh there's usually an art Music Room sometimes there's a second music room for lessons or general music as opposed to uh instrumental pieces uh and then you also have whether or not there's upk and you total that up and you can see that you know there's 21 um there's really in order to have all the things that they would really need they would benefit right now Allendale runs four rooms where they have four teachers running intervention simultaneously and that is not really uh at best that's asking people to use about 135 take 700
122Square ft divided by four that's really not enough room to have five or six kids working in especially if there's three other groups around them Al and D would benefit by having in their current setup three more rooms for intervention so you add all that up and you can see at the bottom they they're short and that's why at the bottom right now their difference to capacity is about 91 kids so in order to really generally speaking you probably have to remove have 91 fewer kids to have any chance to be able to meet the parameters of 18 to 20 in a room 21 to 23 and then have the suitable space they need for self-contained settings and intervention yes Mr is that just for clarification on numbers is that set set the building up
123at 100% capacity or is it more like a 75 80% this is set up at a low-end capacity like I mentioned last time you're always going to use every room right but it creates the it's set to the lowest Target so there's room to expand just want to be clear on that so it you know and it's said you know you could and the district at some point could make decisions we're going to expand past 21 to 23 because some days you might some years you might have to go to 24 because it doesn't make sense to add a section another teacher just to pull it down because the next group coming through isn't as big but it gives you that cushion to be able to do that so we've done it for every I've
124accomplished it for every Elementary and the elementary principles has been fabulous in helping me make sure that it's accurate uh and then and um John dalbo John saon really helping me with keeping Power School data current uh so we can try to make sure that it's as accurate as possible uh you'll also see in the sixth page Winchester is in there like Winchester how many rooms does Winchester have how how many are fullsize rooms how many are half-size rooms how many are small size because Winchester is a resource a space resource that needs to figure into the conversation so one of the things is you I've now begun to work uh West the the hot points in the district are Allendale Elementary Clinton Elementary West Middle School those are the hot points where uh the
125class there's not enough room and it results in large class sizes or if there's not enough room and people there are not dedicated spaces for people to teach their discipline like foreign language um or uh some self-contained settings so we've now I'm working with uh principal Cain and principal maroi on getting their numbers correct uh because really where the space is in this process you have to know where the need is and where the spaces the space is at East Middle the space is at Winchester and the space is at West L because we're also working on the board and board had great feedback let's pull the let's pull program we talked with the the group about repositioning taking some programs in let's pull them out do the best job we can for the biggest
126majority of kids and then strategically replace using our space other things like upk or enl or self-contained so we talked a lot we talked last time about the concept of red districting and this was really a good function of your conversation last month redistri is going you keep things the way they are but redraw the lines and so one of the things we're pledged to do is give you a plan that really relies on redistricting but keeping K to five schools 6 to eight schools 9 to 12 so how can how can you do that you know by redrawing the lines well you probably have to redraw the lines and reposition some of the things like self-contained classrooms enl you PK where do they best fit in the big spacial pcture picture so last um
127last month we worked on taking a look at how to help Allendale and we just you I created a potential solution that helped that could help Allendale and what actually when you look in your materials you can see there's a there's a map but the western part of Allandale that is actually surrounding Winchester Potters what I did is I took that piece and said if that part was removed from Allendale what would it what would happen how many kids are at every grade level what would then happen to the class sizes and and it's hard uh if you look in last month's materials it's somewhere there's a map that looks like this and it's got a little drawing it says polygon because I'm not good enough yet to I just learned how to put put
128something there that says this I could make that something other than says polygon but when you take this section out right here which is this is that little piece of of Allendale that's over you know just the other side round wind pip when you look over here here's the number of students that are currently assigned to every grade so if you come and if you're looking for it still it's hard for me to say it's right above the middle it's keep going Mr no the other way the other way keep going keep going that so what this shows is if you if those students were redistricted to somewhere what would then happen so here's the number of students and then we then started taking a look at what Allen Dale would look like which is
129the page before if you took if those students weren't there what would then happen and you actually get you know where the page before you see a column called sample that would be at the end of that process when you take those kids out what the what was helping the committee understand is when you do that and you then put it back into these uh capacity maps and there would have would have 24 to the good but then what I posed in the group was okay so now in order to do do that you just move 117 kids out of Allendale where do they go we didn't go there because of what people then begin to realize okay well where is the space or how do we create space where would be the most logical
130place for those kids to then attend school and what would happen if you started to try to move them in and I you know the two places that would seem most obvious would be to Winchester Potter or into West L but we didn't go there because the committee started to understand there's in to do redistricting and you start moving at especially at the elementary level when you move some kids out to help create the space and you can't move a few kids out because if you don't move enough kids you don't create rooms you just drop class sizes so you have to drop enough kids to to not need one more teacher that they can go that teacher goes teach somewhere else but where do they then go and so we I did that to
131help them understand redistricting requires when you move these kids out out they've got to go somewhere and they will have an effect in the next building so we didn't NE in the coming meeting uh next week I'm going to present to them a possible plan that could work based solely on redistricting now I will tell you that having worked on this I've spent myself probably 8 to 10 hours just on the elementary plan in the calculations of building capacity and moving students it is not something that group of 38 can do but what I want to show the committee is this is what it could look like and in order to do this keep five elementary schools with K to five this is what it has to look like so when you look at the
132Clinton sheet like if you ever if you go back into the back and you dig out the Clinton sheet which is probably the fourth or it's the fifth one in the pack 138 kids minimally likely have to come out of Clinton in order to hit their targets so those 138 kids have to end up somewhere alendale 91 kids have to go somewhere else so just do your numbers 220 kids have to attend school somewhere else but still leave those Targets in place and so to do that you know and I'm working on this is what it could be but this is what it this is what the cost is your lines are going to shift and so that's what I want to kind of show and then get their feedback about is that worthy of
133continuing on we're going to look at a middle school example as well if we try this redrawing of the lines here's what the new numbers look like this is what it could look like these are and but but in order to do it you might have to do this because middle school has scheduling issues that are very different than Elementary the way you schedule students in a secondary school is different than when you schedule an Elementary where kids are staying together as a whole class so you have to take that into account as well and so those won't be the answers but that's what I then we'll say okay this is what it would look like in take what are your thoughts and reactions do you have any other suggestions that would rely on just
134redistricting and then what we're going to begin to do we also toward the end of the meeting this is the Natural Evolution that happens in the thought process uh one of our team members said hm did we ever think about swapping West L with West Middle School this building used to be a middle school did we ever think about doing that so people start to naturally do some brainstorming about possibilities another idea was expressed at the meeting said what about if each side of the district had a 56 Academy so fifth grade weaves but they join six graders somewhere and you have like an intermediate Academy so we didn't that the content we need to give the team more time to do that sort of creative brainstorming to create a set of possibilities and then
135begin to say which ones have the most potential to be doable and have success which is why we have such a great Committee of parents administrators teachers that really have a broad perspective on school that they I trust them to be able to take a list of brainstorm maybe and start to whittle it down and say which ones and then give me homework which ones should we take a look at and say show us if this is doable which is kind of going to your point Mr B we're not leaving anything on the table one of the questions asked could we have a hybrid could we keep it the same in some places but reconfigure grades which is what Mr um bander was talking about last time when you read say we're going to do
136something different with one through grades one through four or we're going to do something different with 5 six can we do a hybrid and said sure all of those are possibilities so that's where we're going to begin to head I want the team to begin to understand the challenges of just using redistricting to create the goals that you've established and what the it's called in you know we teach the kids in economics it's called opportunity cost in order to get it you're going to give something up there's going to be a cost to it so like when you look at redistricting using redistricting to help Clinton the line of the Clinton residence area will move dramatically it has to move dramatically in order to do that so places that have been Clinton people for a
137long time would have to we'd have to give in order to get that you have somebody would have to go to a different school but and then what we'll do is show this is what it look like and here's how many students would be how many students and families would be impacted and what would be the likely impact going forward so it's an i is creating ideas to start traing what are all the ideas that can use redistricting reconfiguration or what I call repositioning like upk like say we needed to create some capacity to assist in repositioning Clinton students maybe upk comes out of Northwood and is repositioned somewhere else because now you've just created two places that you can now have 21 students right but then where's the best place to then reposition we've
138talked to uh Mrs fower about some of the self-contained settings pull out build the best plan possible and then where space is available what is the best place for the kids in those programs but also the district to rehouse those kids and that's what we want the community to start brainstorming those ideas so that we can start to create you know we're pledged to give you one that relies on redistricting and at least one if not two that can have some combination of both things so that's what next um we're going to talk next week with the team about that and next month I'll share with you what some of those ideas were and some of the team's reactions to them the feedback and then get your feedback as well so in that's a quick
139summary but I'm certainly willing to answer any questions that you might have right now anyone no I appreciate all the information I think moving in a thoughtful direction for sure so as these uh ideas start to come into to a little bit more a concrete and firm up what would be the next steps I mean obviously it'll be presented to the board will there be any Community Forums on any of that I just as I look out there I see a lot of empty seats right now and you just made a comment about the lines moving at Clinton which I guarantee will fill up a few more of those seats um in coming week so that part of the I'm interested to know well I've spoken with Dr kru I believe that we probably have
140after the if not after this meeting but maybe after the January meeting it's time to put together another video an update video and have another opportunity to invite people in uh we are trying to share every the minutes are written up and given to every uh family in the district uh but that doesn't mean everybody's reading or understanding them so I think it's important to communicate all the way through uh to let people know where we are there's been no decision about anything at this point right but it's better so that people hear the kinds of thinking that's going on I think we have you know like here's where we are what's your thoughts and feedback and what that feedback not just to you but to the committee as well we've done that in the
141past with a number of different things we still hear a lack of transparency lack of you know input and all that as we inch toward the the goal line here and um I just want to continue to make sure that people are involved in the Forefront of the of the conversation so they understand exactly what we're talking about that there's going to be a change at some some level so please be involved in listening now and being present in the conversation yeah unfortunately I think we're not going to get a large group of people until someone's affected by it I unfortunately just my experience doing it at least we know we're putting it out there and I would say keep talking about it I love the social media post and the that sort of thing
142I don't know if there's going to be any articles in the b or not that um but it's a um it's you know it's it's kind of it's going to suck no matter what because when we get to the point where something's being said that's when a lot of people probably will be taking notice unfortunately I andan I'm guilty of that in my own life too about things um I don't pay attention and then I'm upset about something I just think it's important to make the effort and let people know that the conversation is going on uh because the feedback that I kind of got is that it some people may not have known it was even being discussed and all of a sudden to them it just emerged out of nowhere we will you'll
143no no matter your best efforts there will be some people that will say they never heard anything about it and and you you try to minimize that as much as you can but I think there'll come there will come a time where there'll be some more focused opportunities we start to get some of these ideas like some of the ideas that are presented the decision point is going to should one of should either one or both of these be considered for what we call a deep drill like let's this is kind of a general look let's really drill down and say is this doable and will it really can you can you with pretty good certainty Say it'll check the boxes you know and that's a different that's a whole different look you know and
144that's even before we get in that's to get to the semi to get to any sort of round before we go the real deep dive and said these are the this one you got to really make sure that there's a utility and a really likelihood that it can be successful what you're saying is this is the round where we hit our button and turn our chairs no you drop through the floor I just had a question with all the change well not all there's a big change with transportation is someone from Transportation on the committee especially as we're like this is great just looking at some of this examples of U of the maps so I just would like someone from transportation to be sure that Transportation be an unbelievable we valuable resource um because
145when we right now they are not but there will be a point where like say the elementary plan the committee says let's look at that like one of the plans you know uh the Middle School plan will have a phase in right it's going to say this area will will shift but it's going to be what you know so if you are going to school in this place you can can you can finish there and will phase in that work that's a question for transportation do you have the resources to be able to transport some kids from this area to this school but some kids have to go to that school that's where we need but to ask them to do that for almost everything is going to be super challenging great but I'm just
146looking even at the maps of how they would do a bus run so that it's on time and looking at some of these Maps it might like would you potentially go in a neighborhood where you're picking up for more than one school that's but I wouldn't want to ask them to do it for every idea that comes out they need to do it on a small number cu what you're asking them to do is challenging and difficult in the midst of trying to make sure that we're running the buses properly day want make sure they're involved they this can't I can't do my job if they don't help me yeah they'll be involved in the Deep di but I will tell you they're very helpful like when we are looking at splitting the district in
147half clearly the transportation people were the ones that pointed out the elementary schools on the east side are all the way North that's a long bus ride you know so I believe that again it they can help with questions but the Deep dive is and the program is actually very similar to what they use as far as plotting out the families and the bus routes so um you're absolutely right stakeholder has an opportunity if they want it is all I'm W listen I can't I can't with any sort of fidelity bring you a plan that has not been checked by Transportation okay I wouldn't do that cuz that's a if you don't have that set whole thing could collapse and be a complete disaster I can say with uh pretty good certainty that if the
148elementaries students go to school earlier they'll be lost travel that could be part of our Pros I mean I think I agree with f you got it it it ties in it does tie in thank you very much everybody Tony appreciate it so listen it's you should the team you should be very proud of the team they are really engaged it's a really good group of people I clearly know people on the team and I've had nothing but positive feedback back just in conversations and I will tell you what I love is when people in the community talk to me I could say check out the board meeting from last month look for the part where Tony starts talking and it's been very helpful um very helpful so appreciate it great have a great night
149everyone thank you Tony so just to recap just to recap next steps uh the redistricting committee will meet again next Thursday December 19th as we've done you know following every meeting we will send out the agenda meeting minutes and many meeting resources um and certainly as Tony mentioned following the January meeting we're looking to do another update that would be a video update to share some more detailed information so that if people are not reading meeting minutes there's another Avenue so that we can communicate ask one more question do it Tony um we're going to hold on to these individually and then you're going to bring us new packets to add to it each month okay great thank you cool okay um I guess we'll double check any other things for board discussion anyone want
150to talk about changing the mascot or the name of the district really are you just trying I almost made a joke about that redistricting start time in Mascot could be like a trifecta in one year but let's let's not go there those Trojans okay I am going to um if I may have a motion to enter into executive session for discussion related to Collective negotiations pursuant to article 14 of the Civil Service law and the employment history of a particular person I'll make a motion make a motion thank you Sarah second uh any discussion all in favor I okay thank you everybody um we will be going to executive and there will be no public business performed afterward and I will remind everybody you have 14 minutes to get home and watch The Voice