CorpusRecord 138626

Williamson Central School BOE Meeting 12/4/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Williamson CSD Youtube Channel
Date
2024-12-05
Location
Wayne County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,826 words · about 111 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening everyone we have no anticipated ex session this evening I don't believe noten open uh announcements this evening uh Ash m not here this evening are there any other announcements okay how about student highlights that is the and the other here and coming to you want you want to move the they were at music over here so too um I could kind could I have like two minutes I'm going to text Christine see if they're still what we would like to do uh is move up the 10year appointments in front of reports to the board so that people aren't here all night long because very lengthy meeting tonight so page but that's me too all right need a motion to approve the 10year appointment of Laura Robinson High School special education

002teacher so Mo thanks any discussion would all right perfect well I just prepped something so Laura is not here because she's officiating in Section 5 swimming right now um but she is all over our community Laura came to our district with 25 or 26 years of experience so she although is just getting 10 here tonight is very much a veteran educator um she's been leader at the at the out high school and uh has taken a lot of teachers under her Wing she tutor students uh in off hours and does a lot of amazing work for us so we are just excited to extend the relationship with her and have her be part of the high school for many years to come great thank you all in favor pass 4 Z toora all right I

003need a motion to approve the 10e appointment of Emily Hugh elementary school teacher discussion yes I'm ask you to come up me EMB you a little this is Emily HT and when we hired Emily she was Emily fro she hasar and her husband Nick and her mom are both here tonight um Emily came to us with five years teaching experience she taught for a few years in private school and then three years years at the Rochester City School District Emily came in a really interesting time she came after um one of our teachers had a um accident so she came in for a long-term sub for that teacher by Christmas time we knew we needed to add another section to third grade based on enrollment so I was really fortunate to be able to hire

004Emily midy year that year um and finish up the school year as a third grade teacher awesome job at the end of that year I asked her how she would feel about going to first grade Emily has an incredible passion for literacy um that's just I could go on and on just about her literacy skills and her instructional skills in that area she she is a lifelong learner she always is asking me to attend sessions to learn more and she could teach all the sessions at this point she joined the first grade team she's been on the first grade team for three years has been a wonderful addition to that team in addition to all she does with literacy in first grade she's also one of our co-directors for Marauder care notc job thank you

005very much and she is just one of those first people to sign up for any of the district committees the building committees she's been a great asset in addition to the thank you I'll cautiously ask all in favor I [Applause] pass thanks for yes congratulations okay so moving back to uh student highlights after this I think I'm GNA stop talking I have got two young ladies with me tonight this is McKenzie Grace and this is Anna I got to bring them up G stand in front of you Mr we are very excited for the first time the elementary school is going to have their own yearbook um Mrs Baldwin from the Middle School is um our adviser and she gave us that option and we decided to go for it and have our own year

006book this year so we had a contest for the covers the front cover and the back cover and these are our two recipients so this McKenzies I'm going to let her hold it up sorry honey and this is Anna's Mackenzie is going to be the front of the yearbook and Anis is going to be the back of the yearbook girls you want to say m you want to say anything about your drawing I just tried it to include everyone and how about you an anything you want to say um I decided to include a t you presents our school mascot yes they both did a great job so congratulations you're going to be the very first Elementary yearbook front and back cover job the parents I'm thank you thank you thank you and thank you

007both for coming I'm going to take these back thank you very much or you can stay the entire time hry [Music] okay basketball's on its own reports to the board uh student Representatives winter sports are starting up the boys basketball team has their first game today it's at the high school and it's 7M and playing wi uh nor track team has their first meet on Saturday at Nazareth um on Saturday the RPO is coming to the high school um to perform a holiday concert and the tickets are free so if you want to go you can go for free uh next week the high school is having two induction ceremonies uh trium is on Monday and then the National Honor Society inection is on Wednesday and lastly uh the Thursday before winter break the de

00819th um the high school time our holiday concert there's two awesome thank you that means K has to come back thank you ladies you guys are welcome to leave thank you very much the okay thank you all right reports from District administrators from the elementary school okay just two quick things um Finding Nemo Jr opens this weekend Friday night um those two young ladies are both in the show it's a great show we're really excited we're taking the whole building over tomorrow for a preview um big kudos to Mrs Fon and Miss wander for dirting our lovely young children they're very excited and then second not sure if I'm going to steal your thunder um but I just want to thank Megan France for her organ organizing the Buffalo Bills drum line to come to

009um the district it was a great thing for all of our kids and um they end of the day we doing a parade in our Bus Loop um and the kids just loved it it was a great great uh event for K12 but then just for them to see those individuals and be able to talk to them about how they got to where they are right now was it was fasinating to me too so wanted to say thank you to Megan thank you any questions from the sex great and from the Middle School Miss Taylor you did not steal my she has so much Thunder there um good evening everyone I'd like to highlight uh two individuals one of them being talk about a little ceing of Thunder I would also like to highlight for

010name is katua Baldwin Mrs Baldwin she is our art teacher at the middle school and she uh when we interviewed her I said all we would like to see is Art throughout the building and she has taken that and run with it in fact she has made lemonade out of lemons so some of our Capital project thing that is not done she's taken and made gingerbread house out of it so art is work artwork of students is all over the place and also we have two young ladies in the Middle School who also have um one the covered of the yearbook design so that is El weer and biona Johnson so each of their drawings will be on each side of the yearbook for the Middle School yearbook so I'd like to highlight Mrs bald

011as our art teacher and also I'd also like to highlight uh Paul Donahue I had the pleasure of observing Paul Donahue uh last week for his observation and um sometimes he is not flashy but the the level of learning from students and their work and their investment and their engagement is topnotch and Paul done a Yan's work but he does an amazing job and um he actually if you know Paul he was cracking a few jokes and um he just he does a great work he's dedicated and he works very hard thank you Dr Snider from the high school yeah so I want to first uh thank Karen for leading our building through a 10we data review it was my first time going through it and so that was a great way to dive into

012our students and get uh profiles of some of our students who are not always finding success and looking for opportunities to help them along the way so thanks to Karen for that um I also want to shout out our counseling team we've been working with a couple neighboring districts to examine ways that we can take advantage of the career development occupational studies um pathway which is an alternative to the five traditional regent exams that you need to pass to graduate um so just exploring new opportunities to make sure we get as many kids as possible across the graduation stage and help them uh move on career in college ready um so shout out to them and then I want to just point out our honor roll numbers which I believe Rachel will be talking about

013a little bit more later but um across all of our four of our cohorts we had over half of our students um find themselves on honor roll uh as high as 80% of our Juniors were on honor roll um and so just a huge shout out to the teachers and the students because that's hard work on both of their parts to get them thank you very much Karen Hy coordinator of MTS mtss yes I um had to Great it down also because I had so many nice things to share which is exciting um so this past couple days the assistant principals Kate Taylor Bridget the Community Schools coordinators and myself attended a Community School Conference in Rochester um and it was just a good refresher for us to get our to wrap our heads around

014again the theep the prise behind Community Schools and the work that we can continue to do um and we have Regent hail there and a gentleman by the name of Obby Obby Fernandez from the national Center for Community Schools um what's really interesting is what started out as a Wayne County Community Schools action has now transformed into the three-way Coalition because now they are going across the straet across the state so it's just kind of exciting to know that W County was on was the lead for all that work and and now they're going across the county or excuse me across the state and it was a good refresher for us um and speaking in line in line with the Community Schools I know I talked about it the last time I did a presentation

015about how many how much how much we benefit from the donations that we received and I wanted to note the donations some of the people that have donated um for our Thanksgiving baskets our holiday baskets and Toys for Tots and to further fund the pantry and the closet it's just been just the most amazing experience um so I'd like to thank publicly the International Association of machinists and Aerospace Workers Local 588 United Methodist Church of Williamson United Methodist Church of Colville toys for to the Wayne County chapter Sodus Success Center food um food link Peak Off Road in Sodus Ceno Farms The Living Word Church Assembly of God out of Ontario um the uh school district is going to be doing a celebration of giving so they are going to be donating the staff and

016student or not students the staff will be donating as well um and to Lisa and Aaron for coordinating all of that hard work for us we have we landed on 120 kids who benefited from Toys for Tots and anything associated that was purchased for that and we have 62 families that received um Thanksgiving baskets and we Reed Christmas baskets the food so it's just it's just been amazing can I answer that real quickly because we unloaded you weren't here today we unloaded lots of uh more things thanks to Kelly Dixon and her mom at C provision um it's I I can't even tell you how many things we've unloaded but the families all were going to get a game donated to them um as a family they they don't enough games that every child will

017get a game in addition to the things from choice and tats and blankets for the family it just it was incredible thank you so much because I I you weren't there today I I'm so glad that you brought that up too and if there's anybody there was just there's been smaller donations too like it's it's impossible to name everything that has been a contribution so it's just been such a wonderful experience you and director of people Personnel Services Kelly um hi everyone I really just want to highlight tonight all of our special ed um staff and our PPS staff for all they do to support our students with disabilities I know we just had our first marking period report cards came out and IEP Benchmark progress notes come out as well um and I love

018reading every single one of those progress notes just so I can see how well students are progressing with their goals and the services that they're given so kudos to those people who go above and beyond to meet the diverse needs of our kids thank you very much and from the office of the ASI Rachel good evening um I did share with you a copy of our curriculum Council report I just wanted you to have it for your reference I'm extremely proud of um all of our content area Specialists and all of their their colleagues within their departments for the work that has gone into the start of the school year um around our Focus point of literacy and reading so when you do get some free time which I know is not a lot um

019and you're able to look through this this just really highlights um um only some of the content areas because some of them presented live to us and gave us really cool uh demonstrations or artifacts indicating what they've done to support literacy and reading within their classrooms um so what you have are those content areas who will'll be presenting in the springtime but really it just highlights all of the great work that we are doing um which is all streamlined and um focused according to our essential objectives so I really just wanted to take a moment to highlight all of their work thank you and lastly yeah thank you I just want to recognize Alexis Hugh she's recent graduate Williamson uh she's working in our facilities Department she's um doing well she hit the ground running

020and um you know she's still learning a lot but doing great so far so happy to have her on board thank you any questions for any of our other District or building L leaders okay I'm not on a timer tonight I mean that's not up for your two minutes I'll really fast okay I do have quite a few updates just want to make sure the bo you don't that fast okay I can actually slow down and Bre okay I do want to make sure that the board and our community is aware of a number of different items and so the first I want to bring to the boards and the community's attention is the uh release of the Rockefeller Institute Foundation Aid study so you'll recollect that after budget season last year the governor Commission

021the Rockefeller Center with conducting a research study specific to the possible recalculation of how they are right now figuring out of calculating Foundation Aid and so the study came out uh it's just over 250 Pages I'll share with you I have not read it in depth yet um however uh the summary uh statements that we're getting from nisus and from other uh uh instructional uh organizations are um if literally every recommendation and the report were enacted the state would actually spend more money on public education not less I think that's important to note so again if the governor and the legislature were to support all of those recommendations it would actually be greater level of funding for school districts I think another important one for the board and the commune to recognize is that the

022recommen there was a recommendation made in writing that school districts will face and I'm going to actually read it out loud enormous costs from the mandated transition to zero emission buses and recommends that New York State Should fully underwrite the cost of the state initiative to transition each local school district to an all electric bus F uh caveat of course the legislature and the governor do not have to accept any or all any or all of the all or any of the recommendations uh the study also recommended that stability and predictability and funding for school districts is going to be vital moving forward um that changes and using multi-year rolling averages uh for some a factors has not been helpful for us in the past and we're really looking for stability moving forward uh this

023is really an interesting one they recommended that there were special uh special education funding formulas so rather than embedding that into the foundation formula they recommend that it actually be left separately just because of the increasing need and demand for uh services for special education programming they recommend a strategy for expanding Mental Health Services for students recogn recognizing again the enhanced me in our school districts and they also recommended the elimination of using outdated measures that currently are part of the formula it's also important to note while all that sounds wonderful uh there certainly is some recommendation that potentially could impact school district in an adverse way uh they talk about reducing save harmless funding for districts which would impact Williamson Central School District if in fact they did reduce that um they also talked

024about um holding stent districts accountable if they ended the year with fund balances in excess of 10% of your over overall budget so there is some potential uh impact to the school districts uh if the governor and or the legislature were to move forward with these recommendations the other caveat to the report they just talk about how each and every one of the variables is potentially are dependent upon one another and so by selecting and picking and choosing others there could be un un unanticipated and unintended consequences as a result of picking and choosing so at this juncture it's very unclear how this study will be utilized in the decision- making we all know that uh come January we expect to see the first executive Aid runs and we're hopeful that this is factored into

025the decision- making when we get those Aid runs as you know this has definitely been a source of um angst uh for certainly our business official but frankly for everyone in public education recognizing that January could be a gloom and doom financially for us any questions about that okay I'll move on uh I wanted to bring up to your attention uh the regionalization discussion uh we received an email on November 26th unexpectedly in fact even the district superintendent would say uh she was not privy to the fact that the commissioner was going to push out a communication uh indicating that districts no longer had an obligation to participate in the regionalization U meetings that are forthcoming uh in fact those districts that did not participate in the survey submission I have the option now of

026opting out as you'll recollect we actually submitted ours early thanks to the uh collaborative efforts of Rachel Jeff myself and our data coordinator um so we don't have the option of of taking that back however we do reach a threshold where we have to make a decision uh we have been tasked by the commissioner to work with our boards of Education to determine if you'd like for us to continue to engage in those conversations and so I would respectfully ask if the board has any sentiment positive or negative about our continued participation it's important to note a couple things number one our participation in the conversations does not direct or require or mandate that we then have to take any of the potential uh actions that might be a result of those conversations uh number

027two I thought it was important that you know uh what's happening around the region so I did bring you the data so uh at this juncture in the Wayne Finger Lakes Region 64% of the districts are going to participate in those convening meetings 36% are unsure so at this juncture they're still waiting to have conversations with their boards frankly we were part of the unsure because I did not know I didn't want to speak on behalf of the board uh data submission of those who did not submit 5% are saying no they were not going to submit the survey now that it's there's the option for an up out 50% said they were still going to submit or had already and 45% were insure remember the deadline is December 6 and we had already submitted

028ours and then lastly an opt out entirely meaning no thank you we're not going to participate and survey or conversations again that 5% yep we're opting out completely 80 82% are saying no we're not going to opt out and 14% were uncertain so just to give you a pulse on what's happening in the region uh I think I've been sharing openly in my communications uh both with the board but also with the community uh I'm interested in hearing the I'm interested first of all in hearing in seeing what the data is and and certainly would like the opportunity just to see what opportunities that might provide for Williamson but again as the uh governing body of of the district it's important that the board weigh in and um assess what you what your feelings and

029thoughts are specific to our continued participation so if I'm understanding correctly they can opt out of submitting the data but still participate in the conversation without providing data for their District actually I don't think that's true I think you have to opt out entirely I think you have to opt out so there's the 5% rate represents one district and I'm not going to sh which one it is but there's one District EXA if you didn't submit you can't say we want to come to the table have the conversation but they're not opting out because they don't want to share resources with other districts I don't think I think they're opting out because the language that it's used in the I agree with you I think it was because it was framed as an emergency regulation

030and they were questioning whether it was really an emergency and at the time that they pushed out the information specific to the regionalization survey and the following or subsequent convening meetings they were saying it was an emergency specific to financing and trying to address the disparity and access that we have across R the state around programming for our students and I think that the challenge was the language to your point around the emergency and so there's one District in our there's currently one that 5% represents one distri District y 24 to 24 out of 25 reporting so um I I'm not going to speak for the entire B everybody to aigh in but my personal opinion is that we are not being fiscally responsible if we say we are not interested in understanding what what's

031available what could be potential outcomes of that what does that mean for Williams and students um I for one would really like to know what the results of that study are and what kind of recommendations um come our way I agree you have to look at what the options are yeah I mean being a part of the study doesn't mean that we have to act on the so it's just more information it's the same it's the next like the next step right is which is further down in the conversation tonight but is talking about doing an actual study with another District that still does not mean that we have to move forward with any of that recommendations but as as we know with the client enrollment in the region not just at Williamson but in

032the majority of the region with State a formulas in question right there's two things happening at the same time here how are we going to handle uh budget deficits how are we going to handle declining enrollment and if you look at what's happened in our time on the board the volatility in that formula and the declining enrollment like I think if we're looking 10 to 20 years out which we should be as we're creating policy and talking about what's happening here it we'd be really shortsighted to say no thank you because things are good now that doesn't mean if we watch the trends that things are going to continue to be great here at William and we don't know and so to me it feels like we really need to look at every option yeah

033I don't think there's any harm in that and and I think you're right it's it's a responsibility that we should take I mean that's how I I feel I I think it's not just a fiscal responsibility but an obligation to our students there might be opportunities that they won't have access to if we don't look at it that if we participate you could find there's opportunities that we could offer them that we otherwise would not be able to offer them if we didn't participate Jeff anything you would add no I think that hits everything you know that's it's easier to make decisions when you have more data thank you so just so you know you're not left in tonight so we would have to submit you would have to pass a resolution which you be

034able to do at that first meeting in January if you were to have a change of heart so at this juncture what I would say is we're good to go and I would plan on participating in the convening meetings that are due to or scheduled to start in January however if if you were to so choose and wanted to put it back on the agenda for I guess it would be considered old business at this time um on the January agenda then we could certainly revisit that and you'd have to pass a resolution that would have to be submitted to the commissioner if you were to choose to opt out of the uh continued participation so thank you have to do that if you opt out correct no actionary you don't have to do correct

035okay a couple other items just wanted to give a very quick Capital Improvement project update we have the opportunity to meet with uh as an oacm committee that means everybody assembled at the table today uh pushing her to wrap up the schal Improvement project you might recollect actually our completion date was November 30th we're not done uh Watchdog is pushing our contractors uh pretty uh uh vehemently at this point trying to wrap it up and say at this point you might recollect our actual contract with watch doog is actually over like right now Todd laar is working uh off the clock on the clock for us out of contract for us because our contract with watch doog was actually done November 30th and he is uh seeing this project through uh because he is so

036committed to this school district and wants to see you know wrap this up neat and tidy with the bow a couple other quick items uh we are working with our financial advisers uh BPD and we did actually submit early Aid start requests that's good news for us that means we can start seeing revenues on the money expense for this project uh as I think I put in writing that I want to keep anchoring into we are working on the corrective action for the mezanine seating at the Middle School uh we we anticipate installation of new seats and those uh rows four through I'm sorry I think I have wrong three through six three through seven 3 through seven thank you very much three through seven uh du to be replaced in January and uh last

037two updates on the uh Capital Improvement project the Middle School boiler I brought to your attention uh last meeting just because there was some concern about potentially having to replace the Middle School boiler uh we did have somebody come in and inspect and they believe we are in a in a safe space to have it be serviceable at this juncture and not have to do a replacement so we will not have to worry about a replacement boiler replace I'm sorry an emergency boiler replacement at this juncture as part of the project we can uh uh push that off to the next project the good news there is that allows for us to actually still consider doing work with our high school band room uh again at this denture we will not be able to do

038the uh initial projected which was absolutely beautiful with the ceilings and whatnot uh we will be working on having uh three different tiers brought to us at our next meeting uh so that we can look at what would have to be scaled back for us to do any work in the high school ban room but that's good news just so you know we will in we intend on bringing Patrick into those conversations so he can see what we would be stripping off the original scope of work for that so that's good news uh along the same line of facilities I think it's important that the board know we are experiencing heat issues uh getting a lot of emails about heat uh that is a result of the work as that's uh part of the capital

039Improvement project so Johnson Controls is currently working on our heating issues I think like every time we get one thing uh rectified we seem to have four more things pop up we have numerous places frankly in all three buildings and district office where frankly all of the staff that I work with are wearing coats most of the time um and so they are working on that today during our oacm meeting we did ask the question and all I can say is they're working as quickly and as uh effectively as they possibly can um and I don't have a definitive answer on when the heating issues will be corrected so for my building leaders regrets please keep expressing our thanks and gratitude for the patience uh we know and we are trying to get that taken

040care of for you another thing the board should be aware of and maybe you are uh we experienced significant roof leaks so prior to the inclement weather coming and we had significant rain I don't know if you remember a couple weeks ago we were dealing with all that rain which back then seemed like wet and now we had the snow which uh actually now I rather have the rain uh we had roof roof leaks in the high school library the high school band room Elementary School gym and Elementary School fourth grade Wing it's important that you have an awareness of that certainly it's on my and justff radar when we're thinking about the next Capital Improvement project it's going to have to be attended to and not in the long term this is something before

041five years from now so didn't ruin the new floor in the library not that I've been made aware not that I've been made aware of I was just made aware there was a roof Lake actually S no not that I'm uh that's a nice lead in uh thinking about the next Capital Improvement project uh long range financial planning as part of our strategic plan and our essential objectives uh we did commit to engaging and work with our financial so we are working with BPD uh in our meeting with oacm today uh Sarah who is working directly with our district did say to us committed that she would have a draft to Jeff and I by the end of this month so we will have a preliminary meeting with Sarah and Nick who works closely with

042her so we can look at the one to fiveyear trajectory for the district that will help better position us for Budget season um I did ask Kelly to schedule a session with the board so we could have a workshop so that you can go through the process of what that looks like with our financial advisers and I think she was successful in scheduling that for early January uh it is important to note that while she'll provide a draft to us in December and then to you the first week in January we will have to go back and update that once we get the executive Aid runs because of course it's un unclear at this time what the executive Aid runs will bring for us so uh no problem basically as soon as they do the

043draft they just plug in what our actual Aid is based on what the uh executive Aid runs uh present couple other quick ones almost there District safety I want to thank every the entirety of the team for the the ex extremely successful execution of the ganade drill uh frankly my first one I'd never even heard of a ganade drill until I got here and we started talking about and I felt a little anxious about it outstanding job Dr Snider Kate Tyler Ellen whose building was actually over in Kate's building they just did an outstanding job extremely well organized huge shout out to the transportation department uh we did have a debriefing following the drill and I would say uh the feedback included we had issues with our radios a lot of chatter and a lot

044of them not working uh love the suggestion our c our buildings said we really need to have uh Spanish uh uh I'm sorry informational sheets in Spanish so that some of our uh Spanish speaking students have access had access to the information uh sweeper assignments in some of the buildings and then dismissing our buses sooner but outstanding job to the building leaders for their coordination of that drill I was very impressed thank you very much um and then lastly according uh specific to District safety uh I have a a small subset of the district safety team meeting with me next week on Wednesday and also with Andy our athletic director and we will be working on putting together an extracurricular in athletics emergency response addendum uh we are required Now by regulation to have an

045addendum to our emergency response plan and we have eight folks along with Andy and I who will be leading that work to put together that response plan and then last one uh maximum temperature regulation I think it's important that the board know but I think it's also important that the community know that right now there's a bill that was passed in both houses specific to maximum temperatures and what that means for school districts is uh as classrooms reach a temperature of 82 degrees districts will be required to engage in what they call mitigating measures things that frankly we've already been doing um uh turning lights off making sure we have fans Etc the impactful part of this regulation is that if classrooms reach 88 they would be deemed uninhabitable which would mean we would have

046to have an emergency closing potentially if we don't have sufficient uh HVAC for students and faculty and staff to be accommodated in such a way significant impact school districts and it's not the it's not a Rockefeller study uh myself and a couple colleagues met with the governor's office two weeks ago expressing Our concern about this unfunded mandate uh and talking about Creative Solutions so we we are hopeful that the governor uh will be responsive to our concerns uh we actually are trying to get into her office again before she has to take action which is December 15th uh and then last thing is positive I gave you all a copy of the celebration of giving fighting for fun here folks fighting for fun so starting on Monday we're trying to do uh fun things with

047faculty and staff every day there's opportunities for prizes there going to be fun prizes uh in in the buildings uh and that's that concludes the superintendent report for today thank you thanks for sticking to your 20 seconds District committee reports District Safety Committee I think you kind of reported on that uh curriculum Council was the 13th and policy committee tonight was at 5:30 District events end of 10 week Maring period was November 8th Veterans Day celebration November 8th Veterans Day new school on the 11th Elementary picture retake Day November 14th upk half day and parent teacher conferences uh was November 14th report cards available November 14th Middle School picture retake day the 19th upk to four half day in parent teacher conferences was November 20th Thanksgiving holiday was the 27th to 29th and upk for

048half day and parent teacher conferences yesterday or today I miss a middle school one uh okay Four County Schoolboard Association Angela and Bri you guys went to a dinner Jeff okay anything fantastic to report back no nothing that we didn't already know and Bridget got more in that twom minute um synopsis of the rockerfeller study okay would be pretty much not 100% surprising but okay thank you for do PTSA hi hi I'm going to stand over time um so I will try to keep under two minutes T fast um so last month we did finish up our Fall fundraiser uh it brought in over $1,200 for us so it was a nice big jump over what we had in our Fall fundraiser last year uh a lot of people really like liked the what came

049out of it a lot of people that did not get orders are like all right when are you doing it again um so we will be doing it again we're going to try to probably space this one out because people don't need boxes and cards every year um but we will be getting uh this one to go with us again um also thank you for the to the district for publishing a story on the PTSA yesterday um working with Georgie mcken and Lauren Kos from the Kos Kos from the the fingerlakes Posies building was absolutely fantastic totally would work with them again thank you to Ellen as well as Nancy Miller who Who provided different perspectives um to be included in the the new story about their experience with the PTSA both from an administrator

050standpoint as well as a teacher and parent standpoint so that was really nice to have the timing of the publishing worked out really great because um we also published that we received two awards from the New York State PTA um the first one is the 2024 2025 Trailblazer award um we were only one of 15 winners in our PTA District um our district consists of about 75 school districts so um it was really nice for that and then also The Savvy membership award for October um and we were one of eight winners for that award so no money in it but recognition which is nice to have as well uh upcoming we have Hospitality at the Holiday concerts next week and the following week um we'll be doing our normal cookies and punch um and

051then we also are taking advantage of a new opportunity that was recommended by Dr Snider here about doing flower sales prior to the concerts um and we'll do that right inside the lobby um he had stated that the PT at the pfield building he was at would work with Wagman get flowers at a discount do a small markup and then just keep the proceeds from that um so we are partnering with Lake winds florist um to this out and hoping that it works out well uh proceeds from the funds that we collect during the concerts all will go directly into our bucket for teacher appreciation we keep all of our teacher appreciation funding completely separate from everything else we do that way our goal you know being to support the students is not affected by

052supporting the teachers which still deserve everything and more um also we're really excited to do our first movie night which will be on Friday the 13th up at the high school um we'll be showing the Grinch the 2018 version of it uh we'll also be working with Joelle R thank you um who he had done he's a high school senior year and had done uh movie night as one of his NHS projects uh so we're really looking forward to working off of his experience and seeing what we can do to help improve it for any projects that he has moving forward for us moving forward um and that way we can expand on as well during that um we are asking for families that come if they would like to donate either a new or

053gently used toy that we can then provide to the community center to help build up their toy shopping reserves for families in the community and then um just for fun we'll have a small concession stand there as well no pizza locks I don't know um yeah uh we have a couple busy weeks um but we're loving every minute of it and looking forward to break i' like so that's awesome everything you just said and I really like the idea also of the flowers because there's so many times where we get up to a concert and look around like no flowers especially um in talking to lak winds because of having brains clothes they luse all of those flower sales there so we're like we can help fill small Gap that might be great for musical

054as well if this same same concept yeah absolutely with the musical I talked to um christe and she had mentioned that the Girl Scouts often do like the wooden flower sales and so we didn't want to mix into our mess with any of the stuff that's already been working for that which I mean it would be awesome to do yeah because I know I would go to be like same thing because we' run down the greens real quickly but yeah yeah so hopefully we'll help fill that g see how it goes with a you know test run on Tuesday and I would I would look at it for high school I don't think I've ever seen I don't think so either that would be great if it works well awesome cool thank you thank you

055all right moving on to board reports I need a motion to approve CSE case SU second any discussion all in favor iOS passes zero I need a motion to approve the October treasurers report so second any discussion here um not too much normal salaries and benefits on the appropriation side um one of the there is one strange thing as far as dispersements is uh bosis bills districts over 10 months and and they messed up their invoicing on September so there was two months worth of Bose expenditures and on the appropriation side on the revenue side taxes collected $5.9 million and uh that's about it okay thank you all right reserves report we got a vote all in favor I oppos passes 4 Z thank you I told you you're going to have to E thank

056you okay the reserves for rep anything that's me I'm report yep can you pause the presentation please there it is um so um much of this presentation might sound familiar is uh we've talked a lot about this when well a little bit about it when Mike D was out here presenting um so now that the prior financial statements have been audited that's complete um just want to have a quick status update on reserves go ahead uh next one so in simplistic terms Reserve funds can be thought of savings plans with very specific uses um reserves can be used to provide stability um help with unexpected losses reduce District's Reliance on debt um insulate the district from liability Financial loss provide a buffer against spikes in certain uh contractual benefits like trss um and receive a

057you receive a higher Bond rating if the more reserves you carry so then thus you play paid less in interest um it's important to note that reserves are funded from an unexpended Appropriations therefore budgeted surpluses are necessary for maintaining uh a a healthy Financial operation go ahead to the next slide I ask a question so with the Rockefeller study where they're talking about not being able to hold more than 10% fund balance your year so you be penalized if you were over by 10% which we're not even close to 4% we're four we're 4% yeah I thought that we had to be I thought right now 4% is so recommending moving it to 10% that's what is the recommend recommendation would be you could receive less Aid if you exceeded 10% so a lot of

058boards across the state they will approve more than 4% and the C TR can't really say much about that U because the board made the decision right and you know board can say well this is our school district we know how to affront it um and a lot of boards do say that in Williamson here we we do keep the the recommended 4% by the yeah I know in our reports we get always like good for you guys like yes yeah we at the 4% y but so basically the state will OB ding you if you the recommendation is that if you have more than 10% potentially impact your a allocation they so we're not going to give you money well you're too good at you're too good at so we're going to penalize you

059so in controller audits that are happening across the state um the control is being very they're looking at that at districts to make sure because you know it's it's kind of a do as I say not I do kind of mentality like the states keeping up they have historically High reserves yeah and and they're saying the district well you can't have that great you don't have roofs to fix your right right boilers are dying okay yeah so again on on this Slide the comproller uh sentiments echo my comments from the previous slide is establishing and funding reserves can significantly benefit school districts and the community um in fact in the second portion on the slide that's second paragraph uh the comproller recommends using non-recurring revenues as a way to build reserves um I've added some

060excerpts that you see from the com controller as well as links an additional resources ources for reference the local management guide for reserves as well as the multi-year financial planning go ahead thanks um so this slide's a summary of our reserves and I'll go through each one of them in upcoming slides on the left column you have the beginning balance then utilization contribution uh interest earn and fin the ending balance as of 6:30 2024 overall you see an increase from the beginning of the period to the end of the period one of the primary reasons for that increase is due to the thoughtful utilization of one-time funding opportunities related to the pandemic um districts across the state received this one-time funding a sign a significant amount of that funding fell off in September 2023 uh

061the remaining amount of that funding fell off in September of 2024 on the bright side uh depository rates have remained pretty favorable overall uh I'd like to bring this up because it wasn't that long ago in 2021 school year uh that number was around that 466 was around $122,000 so um it makes a big difference depending on where depository rates are so how much how much will we look to how much are we going to lose next year that would come from the F we won't get anymore um so that's a good it was stretched over it was multi-year funding is like threeyear funding so they get one exact number and we spent a different amount in different years because some were fading off there's not one exact answer that and it depended when you

062spend it all um but overall we received almost $3 million in funding over that three years but I don't know if I would say like we're losing funding because we didn't plan on that in the first place right it's kind of one of those unexpected windfalls that the controller talked about right and so and that's like when we talk about not not using that kind of funding for uh salary positions because it does yeah so um the unemployment insurance Reserve is used to reimburse New York state for payments made the claimants during the last several years the district has experienced more unemployment activity unfortunately uh the ideal balance is the value to cover 40 positions which is approximately 15% of our labor force for 26 weeks $54 which is about you know $1 13,14 per

063position uh the contribution to this Reserve was strategic due to New York State's communication on the uncertainty of their how they're going to fund education um should the district experiences uh experience shortages in Foundation Aid uh it would be able to use this Reserve to offset um unemployment obligations the state's projections for upcoming budgets we're just talking about this uh right now is around a billion dollar to finish this year deficit and you know it billions in the future so if required the state with would withhold funding to school districts to close that Gap and for people who've been around uh long time doing this for a minute you'll remember the Gap elimination adjustment the Gap elimination adjustment was to eliminate the Gap in New York State's budget not school budgets and so they withheld

064funding to do to close their budget uh TRS and ERS reserves are for payment of retirement contributions These funds can be used as budgeted Revenue sources each year to help offset contribution costs is needed uh the ERS fund allows for three years of budgeted contributions well TRS allows 10% uh eligible payroll uh year-over-year we see combined increase in the two reserves with increased depository interest rates playing a significant role in that right so you see utilization you see contribution and that's really what the contoller wants to see if if they come in and audit uh the district's reserves they want to see that you're using them and replenishing them using them that's what they're for go ahead uh the employee benefit acre liability Reserve is the payment is for the payment of benefits due to

065an employee upon separation from the district uh this resered is used to help fund future payment obligations with revenues from that period the ideal balance of this reserves approximately 700,000 which are the compensated absences on the audited Financial stat I don't know if you'll recall but Mike did mention that quickly um uh this fund has remained relatively stable over the last several years hasn't changed too much and and we do we have used this as a funding source the liability Reserve is similar to the insurance Reserve uh which we're going to talk about next the liability Reserve can be for property loss and liability claims aging infrastructure and increased risk of lawsuits have contributed to the need for this Reserve as you can see a sizable contribution was made to this Reserve Williamson is like

066many districts across New York state is experienced an increased risk uh for litigation this um this Reserve will help insulate the district from Financial law should we uh have an unfavorable outcome in litigation so insurance is next so uh the insurance Reserve can be used to pay judgments claims professional Services the amount that can be paid into the reserve during any given fiscal year is 5% of the annual budget however there is no limit of what may be accumulated the ideal balance is an amount to mitigate exposure for any number of Adverse Events events that could happen um similar to the last Reserve this Reserve also helps insulate the district from uh substantial loss one of the articles I was just reading the other night was on um as that was on cyber security and

067the average cost of a ranwar attack and it want to say it was like it's across the nation so it's not I don't think it would be this high for Williams was like 500,000 a day and I was stunned by that next up the TX tertiary tax tertiary Reserve was created to offset the potential for the need to pay back property taxes that have been collected uh the district is currently in a tax ciary case with Walgreens still Walgreens is disputing their assessed value as such there is a possibility that the district would need to pay back uh collected taxes as you can see this has remained consistent um the district feels relatively insulated against that claim capital reserve uh exists to help pay for any purpose for which bonds may be issued generally speaking

068that's for Capital projects the district's true Aid rate is Approximately 80% this means that for every dollar spent the district receives 80 cents back in building Aid advertised over 15 years the district uh used $2,625 th000 to pay for the local share of the current project that is nearing completion about a year and a half ago the district received its building condition survey which identifi necessary infrastructure and mechanical system updates as the district completes this project the planning for another project will begin spr I mentioned uh bus purchase reserves exist for purchasing vehicles that transport students uh in the past the district used uh variable rate short-term borrowings called bans to purchase buses in July 2022 uh the district was in a position to move away from purchasing buses this way that move was a

069cost savings measure to save on increasing interest rates Bond rating fees ADV fees legal fees due to this change in purchasing and to meet the increased cost of purchasing buses the district added proposition language to create a transportation vehicle Reserve uh should be noted that due to the electrification Mandate that we are a couple budget Cycles away from New York State requirement like Bridget talked about again she hit a lot of this um of needing to purchase electric buses at this time electric buses um come with a significant cost increase um and so District's trying to strategically position itself in the most efficient cost effective way possible um so at this level District be able to buy uh eight buses which is about two years worth the replacement in comparison to other school districts do

070we have a high reserve for school buses no so that's a good question I'm going to actually wrot down some notes and talk about that later so districts usually carry about 3 to 5 years um if we were going to stay in the current path in we'd be in a good position because busets would still cost about 160 to 185,000 a piece um for diesel bus for a diesel bus um if we're going to be moving to an electric bus it's going to cost anywhere from $400,000 to $450,000 per bus that's not including the infrastructure that is not including infastructure that's just a bus and I keep waiting for that price to come down it's not happening for some reason and I was just curious that we would be penalized by the state for having

071too much reserves for buses they may give us less money it's just my thought they they won't um so they're more osc's more likely to to be critical of non- capital uh reserves because different districts have different levels of capital all the time you almost have to remove them from the equation when you're comparing districts because we're not in going into a while we are going into a new uh Capital project in soon um so we have a higher level of somebody who just put out you know put money towards their Capital project they're going into they going to have much less in the reserve so it really just depends you know com making comparison at the same time but you almost have to remove capital from it uh this Reserve is the de service

072reserves used for death service payments on outstanding obligations the contribution here is directly related to recent death debt issuances for uh current capital project this fund can be used as a budget Revenue mechanism to offset future debt payments youve see me add those in budget presentations as a funding source uh as well as help mitigate those fluctuations in the tax cap capital exclusion right when I when I do tax cap calculation you'll see me talk about those exclusions um making sure that uh Aid payments are out performing debt obligations right you eliminate that exclusion and the fluctuations in the TA in the tax cap where you would go out uh the the formula would force you to expect more from your tax paers well we don't want to do that we want to have those

073fluctuations mitigated at level increases um you may notice there's no interest earned in this fund the accounting and Reporting manual by osc n state says that school districts are not allowed to recognize interest in the B fund so it gets recognized in the capital fund from before um finally this last slide I added this is just a summary to break out some of the uh same all the same reserves we just discussed and show them by use um I just wanted to draw attention to the capital section for all the reason we just talked about a large portion of our reserves are in the capital portion to support capital projects and bus purchases for which we receive building Aid right so there's a Aid Source tied to those two uh expense driven AIDS uh building

074a at 80% Transportation a at 85% our most recent building condition survey identified $65 million in capital needs um this level of reserves would support about onethird of that work uh being completed without future tax implications to the community um and like I said this uh level reserve for bus purchase would support about two years worth of purchases for electric buses it's crazy yeah um it sell there good things and could be better things I think it's great you've done a great job I'm just still stuck on the bus thing that we don't have a say in and we can't afford it's a tough pill to swallow state is a mystery yes it's frustrating as a business administrators just got us off using debt right to buy buses which is saving us money and now

075they we're go back potentially have to go back it's very frustrating it just seems the state penalizes district for being physically responsible yes which is baffling to me that's because they are not I I can't say that out loud okay thank you very much Jeff nice job than all right fall sports report I have a two minute timer or I'll try I'll try to wrap it up I'm going to take it personal I'm the only one who has two minutes like I try to get through I'm pretty competitive so till the fall when you have teams participating into you know mid November end of November and individuals participa and kind of turns into winter season so it was a long fall season but a very successful um fall season for our Marauders um I'd like

076to thank uh Vicki at the bus garage and Barb for um put putting the puzzle together and getting our student athletes to where they need to be um and getting them there safely it's a lot of work and it's difficult and but they do a great job and somehow make it work so it is appreciate I'm apprecia with that um our building a grounds team um Patrick Gary with his artwork you know makes our field look nice and then um Andy cwell taking care of our fields and making sure they're ready to play when we have tremendous amount of Rin getting out there and rolling into were able to host our sectional games this year so um that is I'm appreciative of them um our SRO Deputy Dennis who has been a presence at some

077of our games who was at our basketball game right now is um a nice addition to overall safety and just the support of our athletes so um that is appreciated as well uh there my clicker thanks buddy uh so our boys and girls cross country team had a great season we were um combined with Marion this year our head coach was Pat Tyler and our assistant coach was Dave ccoy and our mod coaches were Becca Oliver and lindzy clemmer our girls record were 17- two on the year we had 10 participants our boys record was 15 or 14 and five on the season with 18 and our mod numbers um are growing it's the highest number I've seen in a while at 12 participants and they are NVA scol athlete team which means 75% um

078of that team has 0 invol so we're taking care of in the classroom ex thank you so our postseason awards for the girls we had first team out League Hannah Governor U she was a League champion the section five Class C Champion um in the state meet she plays eighth place and I believe at the open me meet that Federation she was eighth place uh no no yes yes yes okay making sure I know she did very well so that's what all that comes down to and she was first team section five and she also was I can't really post it until the 70s but she was going to AGR first team allra of Rochester First Team um Lily Jacobs was also um first team for way she did an awesome job just this year

079as well third team was Bri shaver and F atwat and sectional SE Shields coming in top 10 at section Hanah governor and Lily JC great SE and L was able to go to States as well what's that was at States as well too yeah so have two athletes go to States as well as our some of our boys to go there we had a very good try at States um First Team all League was Aaron Meyer who was a Marian student participating with he was a Class C champion and the state me meet e place 10th place and Michael Cera second place Class C sectionals and 30th at the state me um I also got an email today saying that Aaron Meer was also um elected to the first team of alra to Rochester so

080great job with our cross country teams this year boy soccer um they lost to ER in the semifinals of sectionals but that was a very competitive C1 class and they played extremely well our our head coach was Al furland uh with a 12 six of one record then had 20 kids participating or 20 athletes participating JB coach is Jeff Van Hoover with a 1011 record had 22 kids on the JB team and our modified head coach was Gary Hoka with a 542 record um for 21 participants so our numbers are great for our soccer program um and they were also a n with scholar athlete team so our postseason awards for boy soccer was first team all League were 10 red storms and Ben Burns second team out League was Kon hilliger and third team

081I League was Mikey ishler Ethan Niles and Moises arga Martinez Timmy nil and red stor were named to the all sectional team for class C1 and also the senior All-Star team girl soccer uh they were our class C1 sessional champions in a very exciting game advancing on PKS um to the crossover game against Byron buron which I lost to 2 to one but that was the eventual state champion so it just shows how competitive our class was and how competitive um girl soccer is in section five had a great season um they Wayne County champs as well uh our head coach is Sarah Clement who won um coach of the year so that's a very good accomplishment for our coach uh 16 4- one had 22 participants or JB coach was John vone 7 of

082five record with 15 participants and Joanna Alexander with Squad um nine and two with 14 participants so great numbers um thisa scholar athlete team the Wayne kind Champions and classy one Champions so very successful season for our girls soccer program uh girls soccer postseason awards first team was Lauren schmul she was also the wing um County CO MVP um Katie Co Audrey Murray Kendall FES and Sarah nil are also named for the first team second team my league was Natalie schm P for bridge Madison story and third team with Ryan hoodie the C1 tournament team um consists of Lauren schmelt ktie Co Audrey Murray and kendle fer okay girls volleyball um this is what in athletics we call the rebuilding season um we had our coach our varsity coach uh our last varsity coach leave

083to another job so Coach B stepped up and brought along his wife with him to help with the the JB program um so we had 10 participants for both squads um k B who did our mod program had a six and8 record but had 17 kids so the numbers are growing and hopefully we can rebuild them those participation numbers moving forward um we did have some um all League teams so thank you swards uh second Team all leag is Brianna B and honorable mention were Emily floss and Jessica Shanley for volb um golf was coach Baker uh they were also merged with Maran this year so we brought a couple athletes over from there to to help us fill out our Squad so numbers were growing went from five last year to nine with a

0842 and 10 record and not up there is they were also a thisa um it's got our athlete team so taking care of it I believe believe that's it yeah we're just rolling into our winter season we got basketball going on tonight said there's a track meet um into our track meet this weekend as well as a wrestling tourament in aoka Alo we're hitting the ground running and staying busy so I'd like to confirm that was longer than 2 minutes I know it was a lot two and a half still pretty good recognize two and half so that's all right slow timer let me know I'm going to head back up to RC basketball game so awesome thank you very much all right quarterly achievement report you have two minutes too I'm sorry oh there

085um so I I really wanted to kick off this presentation by um really outlining all of the work that we are doing in terms of our academic program that is um explicitly aligned to the essential objectives so the very first slide is a slide that you are all very familiar with um and that outlines our district essential objectives uh tonight I'm going to focus just on our first pillar which is around student achievement um where we are talking about um performance higher levels of performance on the New York State assessments higher levels of performance on student mastery and graduation rates so specifically our district really is working on our tier one instruction which I'm going to dive into in just a moment um but our Focus areas around tier one instruction really are around reading

086and literacy math standards based instruction grading practices um Project based learning portrait of a graduate and then continuing to provide those enhanced opportunities for CTE as well as that continued refinement of our mtsf systems so um looking a little bit uh more deeply at our tier one instruction at our elementary school specific to reading and literacy um our elementary team has been very busy this year um and they done such a great job at all of the conference days at their grade level um meetings their department meetings they are just continuing the work every time um so it's been very streamlined um and very I would say very rigorous on their part um but we've done enhanced uh an enhancement of our phonic instruction upk through 4 our upk is uh just coming on board

087but our K through 4 is I would say actively involved in the process of um supplementing with phonic instruction um or the enhancement of it our second grade is doing an implementation of six which is a component of our collaborative classroom um which in the past has been a level or a tier 2 intervention and we are now implementing it at tier one um and then our fourth grade is actually engaged currently in a pilot um for clle classroom which is um an offshoot of their making meeting um which is a a large component of the program um in addition to all of that we are continuing to have ongoing conversations about academic intervention services in regards to reading um and how we can continue to make sure that students are being identified through that

088mts's process as requiring AIS and making sure that the interventions provided within AIS are targeted um and that we are monitoring progress in regards to math um we have just kicked off the exploration of a new math program so our elementary team uh met on Monday had a great conversation our Middle School team actually meets tomorrow um so we are in the process uh Kate Ellen and I um have we did a lot of research uh based on student performance data um and reaching out to our colleagues across the region um just to kind of get a sense of what are what what programs are out there right and what programs would best support higher levels of student achievement um so the three of us really took some time to dig in and do that

089research and we um focused our research on five program programs we have narrowed that to three and those are the three that we are presenting to our committees at both buildings um so we are we have quite a lengthy process that will take us right through the spring to determine um if it is indeed uh a need for us to um look at considering a new math program and what that math program would be um in addition to that we are also continuing to work on AIS opportunities for our students around math instruction for standards based instruction the elementary school it it looks a little different they're um they're at a different phase in the the cycle because they are teaching all of the content areas so um they last year they started with math

090of unpacking all of their standards and really um using a data driven um protocol to dissect their standards so that they know exactly what students need to learn in order to achieve each of those um this year um knowing that they're teaching everything we wanted to keep it streamlined for them so they are now doing Ela and unpacking all of their Ela standards which is in alignment with all of the other literacy work that they are doing and then um professional development um is something that is ongoing um and we are continuing to individualize that per building uh to make sure that our teachers and other staff members are getting exactly what they want and need um and then uh data review uh we are really um striving to have those more collegial conversations around

091our data so that we can continue to improve instruction for our students at that tier one level so that's what's uh going on at the elementary school which is pretty busy um at the middle and high school our reading and literacy Focus uh has really been on how do we support our teachers and integrating literacy across all of their content areas because each of them are so unique in nature um we've had to be really intentional about how our teachers are able to integrate specific strategies and practices to support students in gaining access to their curriculum um so that's also been ongoing our middle and high school teachers have also worked during conference days and then um continue that work during their department meetings to make sure that those conversations are rich and that they're

092continuously coming back to strategies that they're trying as a department how those strategies are working how are kids responding and then how can they build on that from there um for math uh this is specific to fifth grade they are part of that exploration of the math program um we haven't decided yet if we are going to extend to sixth grade um so we're focusing right now on K through 5 sixth grade if you remember when we adopted our Uh current program program of envisions sixth grade came on just I think about a year later yeah we St it one year so it'll probably K through if we adopt K through five and the following year will be six um and then for standards based instruction for our middle and high school staff um they

093have unpacked their stand standards for the course that they teach we had them all start with one course just because it can be an overwhelming process um so this year they are working as a um they're working in isolation to a degree but then also within as a department to identify the priority statements based on assessment data and what we know kids absolutely need to have um it doesn't disregard all of the other standards we are still covering all of the New York State learning standards but we're really trying to identify those priority ones so that we know how we need to maybe allocate time throughout that scope and sequence of our curriculum um and then once they've identified their priority statements uh they are then digging in even deeper to to outline what those

094learning progressions are for each of those priority standards so they are kneed deep in that work um and that's a year-long process that we are engaging in that um and then same similar to the elementary school um again trying to personalize professional development opportuni as much as possible for our middle and high school staff um our coaches are doing a fantastic job at all three levels of really being able to provide that input on how they might be able to support their colleagues in their buildings um and then again also having those data review conversations data driven conversations to support that instruction at the tier one level so given all of that um that really kind of sets the tone for uh the data that we will um look through I'm not going to address

095every I'm going to show you every single slide so that you have a minute to look at it and if you have any questions certainly um stop me along the way um but I won't necessarily have points to address on every slide um so the very first one is around our high Achievers um and as Rob had mentioned earlier um huge celebration overall we have seen progress from every single um grade level when you look over time on the next slide but um really just a celebration for the percentage of students that are um on a high honor Ro honor Ro or Merit role when you look at the percent achievement over time um I put the arrows there specifically to be able to outline for you the progress that has been made so when

096you look at our uh seniors specifically um the the progress that they've made since since they were freshman is outstanding um and we've also seen that actually with with every single well 10th through 12th um so just phenomenal um I would say and when you look at the grade n cohort um sometimes that transition from middle school to high school can be challenging um but the high school has done a really great job of of um implementing freshman foundations it's in year two and they've made some revisions for this uh school year and so I think we are really starting to see um you know the the impact of that this next slide is going to show you the Middle School achievement points so on this slide I really wanted to outline for you um

097again looking at the each of the cohorts over time um seventh and eighth grade uh cohorts have made some really nice progress over the years uh sense being in fifth grade and remember fifth grade um is just a little bit different because they're focusing strictly on those work habits so we do tend to see naturally a a decline um from fifth to 6th um but again a nice progress for our seventh and eighth grade ports the next slide will show you the elementary school achievement can I back up a second yeah the the dip between the natural dip between fifth grade and sixth grade is that because I know it's a different school about the grading is that slightly different as well is that the and the and the way that we report out yep

098yeah just to help yeah it's also the shift between Elementary and non you know Middle grades it is a big shift yep so for the elementary um overtime um noted progress is defin has definitely been noted um for both second and fourth grade um and again you can kind of see a natural dip between grade two and grade three um when you look at the the um shouldn't say the rigor but just the difference in the curriculum that is presented um as students like the shift in the standards so to speak um so natural but um but certainly noted that progress in the second grade and then the fourth grade cohorts Rachel I'm sitting here looking at all these high Achievers and those are um we talk about standards based raing is a potential Topic

099at some point right like these are not those we don't because we're not doing standard based gring necessarily right so I don't it's hard sometimes to correlate like Achievers with proficiency right am I yes okay yes so like I I can't help every time every I look at this have that question in my head of like what does this really mean yes and what does this mean for our kids so I think those conversations are extremely important and I would say going back to the uh data driven dialogues that we are having with all of our staff at every level those are those are the really great conversations that are coming up um because you can have them either as a grade level or you can have them by Department to really see like what

100are the grading practices behind what we're seeing here um and how consistent are they um and you know when you think back to some of the conversations that we've had at our grading committee all there are so many different factors that play into that that I think continuous conversations and um education about those factors and how they can potentially potentially skew data one way or another is really important yeah extra credit alone right like you think about so you know you mentioned that there were um 50% of our kids or whatever onot right what does that really mean though that's great and I think back to like when I was in school all my parents cared about was being on high Ro that's what you had to but that didn't mean I knew anything right

101depending on how the teacher cre it and so like I think maybe I just don't take it I know where you're coming from and I think that's why um the group that we've had to try to stabilize grading um because you can have a student who is a 70% student in a traditional sense but oh look at me I did some extra homework or I did some extra quizzes and suddenly they're a 90 are they well that's why like some colleges aren't looking at class rankings anymore because you can artificially change the data right um so I will say in some cases which you'll see a little later on um there is alignment between our current grading practices and what we're seeing from our I ready benchmarks and our state performance data um which is

102telling for us because that that puts together that big picture if they were opposite that' be conversation there right and I think you know there certainly are those areas where we're continuing to dive in and that's in part why I think the grading committee is so important um for for the most important thing being opening up those conversations because even the extra credit conversation alone we had teachers the very next day who said oh my gosh I never thought about that you know um so we also need to be like we can't be Front Runners in the region necessarily because uh when you're comparing kid like District to district and looking at some of these reports they don't take that into account so I'm cautious how far we push and and our reasoning behind like

103the reasoning is great we should be looking at proficiency but with the whole region or state for that matter is not using that as a benchmark then our kids fall behind in a sense right like by looking at an overall grade that's right right so if we can get everyone proficient and everyone's an 80 an 80 might be way better than 90 the next next District or 95 and the different but it doesn't look it doesn't look that way right so we have to cous how we move that I think that's the impetus uh Shifting the language in the essential objectives around going from standards based grading to looking at grading practices because we can absolutely look at greting practices without having to yeah I think that's Dr SN was in Penfield when they shifted

104to a standards based grading model and within two months they quickly abandoned uh the initiative so that's why we absolutely want to look at grading practices and make sure that they're accurately reflecting proficiency but that doesn't mean we have to be the first to go to one two three or four High School level that's right it makes me very nervous to think about being the first to do something like that but also um like what does it once we do or even as we're warming up to that idea what does that mean for our kids if the greater Collective of education is not doing that right like I don't want put our kids at a disadvantage but I also don't want to look at inflated like hey half our kids aren't on a role I

105love that but also like what does that really mean and our like is that really reflective of our kids abilities yeah I agree like I I'd want to see an honest answer right like are kids really learning or are we just inflating their grades to a point where yeah they're passing but we don't know if they really learn anything it has to reflect I think you see that sometimes when you watch a grade go go and you watch that grade that whole class advance from grade to grade to grade you see the um very academically proficient class and then you see those classes are not necessarily that way and you can watch it go so you can you can almost gauge it some of so that's why you can tell where right but you could

106tell like that 11th grade cohort right now with that class they are doing I think it was 80% they had honor rooll but if you watch that class every single year going back academically they're strong they just have a good solid group going all the way through um so you can see that going another good data point is to look at the performance of students grades so that it reaches exam scores the year I don't know last year top I have um but that's always an interesting indicator because if we have um I don't know 80% of our Juniors get 75 or above on the US History exam this year then maybe 70% of them are honorable students um but I also agree that grading practices are also hard to compar in a district where

107you only have one US history teacher or you only have like one algebra teacher and you start to like really think about are we being consistent with other districts gets harder to do that um it'll be easier when you're in a building go to four or five people to the same subject that's right great thank you I'm sorry that's absolutely fine so in these upcoming slides um they're they're just giving you the opposite story so I'm just kind of showing you the same uh picture when we look at 12th grade um and I and I just kind of picked on 12th and eth grade just because we would have cohort data all the way through for them um to next so this slide is uh specifically breaking down uh proficient below proficiency by course um

108and I uh took some time and compared this to first quarter from 2023 um and was really just extremely proud to see that across all of the content areas we saw a a decrease in the below proficiency rates for many I mean at for ELA every single grade level decreased in the number of students that were below proficiency um in the area of social studies two of these areas or courses decreased um uh High School one of them had a significant decrease and uh same thing in math so just overall really proud um and and again it goes back to that really that first slide all of the work that our teachers are really doing and the commitment that they are uh putting forth uh not just this year but every year to making sure

109that things are really targeted for kids and that we're really trying to work as a collective effort to make sure that kids get what they need um um so the next slides will take you through the middle school below proficiency so again here I've outlined 8th grade just so you can see over time so that means that they're increasing in the amount of students that are not proficient so from the 2324 school year they decreased the number of students not proficient but they but it's been a little variable because they were 38% 57% non-proficient 67 and then now they've gone back down to 57% not efficient 2122 was still were we in school then 2122 we were in school we were in school was it like it was full I think president question was if

110you look at grade eight over time the number of students increas yeah I'm sorry sorry so yeah to me that's alarming I don't I don't I hate to point out obvious sometimes but to go from 38 to 67 in two years that's a significant jump I I'm grateful to see that the trend is coming back down in eth grade I'd be curi serious to then see next year where our nth graders fall on the proficiency scale in fact if you can make a note maybe y next year for this slide to kind of keep us up to date are we continuing the the downhill Trend um I'm just thinking out loud during those same two years I think we had less students participate extracurriculars as well and I think there's a disconnect in general in

111society and I think it might be in a little bit I think we had less participation I don't know I think in general um I thought our parp have been increasing year over year it started to increase now I think more right I think we were we were going less for a couple years AG not I'm not sure I don't I thought we increasing participation but regardless that's I mean that's a huge it's not quite double what this this is also the class that in what third and fourth grade they missed a t right because of Co so those are really big years is what I'll think of I don't know it's a definitely something to continue to Monitor and have further conversations see that continue back down as they get I definitely do I

112don't know I will tell you that this a class um particular this year I have seen a great level of maturity I was concerned for that for years and they my gosh it's happening they're growing up um and again I don't our measure of non proficiency is at the um below 75 I'm not sure if that's the high school non proficiency level that if they're measuring 65 Etc so our standard of non proficiency is higher and I wondered if you compare Apple to Apples but even if you look at the next year's goart right so this be this year's nth grader so 39 right to 46 it's still I don't I mean it could just be the riger likeing and we talk about this all the time like until you look at the data to

113dig in but there's definitely a fifth sixth seventh change I guess it would be neat to see like what was it like before Co was it their same uhing we saw that since I've been on the board right like we always talk about increase in rigor it's change from single teacher to switching classes to just more demands the other thing I might if you have a gap in proficiency levels and each year you're adding in another year Gap so by year five maybe I was reading at fourth grade level in grade six now I'm two years behind by grade seven I might be three years behind so the struggle compound that the student is experiencing in the dayto day while the rigor is increased and the content has increased has become that much greater so

114there is a greater likelihood that that young person would which is why it's so important at the elementary level to be at the the comp as the compounding yes is what we're seeing thank you so the next slide will outline specifically um Middle School below proficiency by course um and I I did the same thing as I did with the high school um and found the the exact same results so all of our um well still maybe not where we want them to be those uh below proficiency levels um all sell decrease so all of the courses in ela um had a decrease in the below below proficiency rate our social studies um Department saw a decrease in two of their um courses science had a decrease in three of their courses and proficiency um

115math I'm sorry had a decrease in one of their courses so definitely um continued work which is you know we we continue all the work that we're doing as outlined in the very first SL but um it was nice to see that there we are seeing that decline I don't remember what it's called but do we still do the extra math period math extension extension do we still do that we do at fifth and sixth grade every student tier one level has math extens what about moving into seventh and eight uh seventh has it for our accelerated students they because they're doing two courses in one um and then that's all we are able to cuz then we start getting into World languages then we start getting into it there's no space there's space so

116it's very difficult but that's where like when you look at math 8 right like that subset of students have all the accelerated kids pulled out of that correct because they're over in the algebra column and to your point Jamie I would say like again if you look at particularly at math particularly at 6 7th and eth I would say that as reflective again it it matches to what said the state test which I don't like no no no but that tells you that accurate it's a line yeah and then you have some students take them some students don't take them that is improved okay but that can also change that's why yeah that's e it's so high because all of the high achiever I just asked because I knew when we did that I think

117we started at fifth grade and then expanded it or started it at sixth grade expanded it to fifth grade because there was a big issue in sixth grade and that helped when we did that so that's why was but the the ones that are taking math seven and they fall they would be the next slide will outline the elementary school not proficient next up so the next slide is outlining um non proficiency over time and again similarly um I looked at the fourth grade cohort to be able to map that back that below proficiency so um work in progress and um you know fourth grade has definitely shown growth which is what we want to see uh but to your very Point Jamie continuing to see that decline um over time so looking at next

118year's fifth grade data and what that looks like will be extremely important the next slide will be new for you um because we made a change on our Elementary uh report card this year so we broke down the reading and math grades uh into two grades so we now have a reading skills grade and a reading comprehension grade um so I'll give you a moment to look at that um um so I just want to clarify grade one under reading skills yes reading skills 56% of grade one is below Proficiency in reading skills they're getting level one and or a level two and level two is 80% I have this conversation every you guys are going to missed when I'm not having this conversation it's my I'll enjoy it a two is 80% and we're

119calling that proficient I I just I really struggle with that so 81 is proficient so 81 is a three 80% higher lower so they have to be at 80% to get a three 80% of what proficiency so what measurement multiple measures but yet we recort them as non coefficients because as ra mentioned a range up to 80 right right so they could be anywhere on that range right my point being that like let's take the standard at the high school which I'm assuming is 65% corre so a student who's getting 79 if we quantitatively say it they're they're on this report reported it's not proficient at high school we would be like great even at the middle school even at the middle school we would be they 75 so they move from grade to fifth

120grade in elementary school and you see this yeah I'm sit here going oh my God you see the sky falling when you see this but it's not necessarily that way it's just it's where is that established I'm just curious because to your point if every other building is 65 not the Middle School 75 they're all three different they're all three different look at anything below 74 is non-proficient at at the middle school so if you're again grade wise if you're below 74 that counted non Prof where is that because we want to set High that is on the 1 2 3 4 scale so where is that articulated I'm just curious it aligns with the state assessments that's how it was that's how where it was B so it used to be a 65 at

121the middle school also but it was moved a handful several ago no longer deliver the module so it might be time to revisit that but it does reflect the state test right so for those numbers to match up corre you kind of need it to do that how come the state test at the middle school is there another the state test at the elementary then what do you mean 75 74 verse 80 good question I mean I do like the fact that you want to set at 80 as a higher bar as opposed to Let's Get By as a 65 everyone's 65 but we're all passing 80 let's push them I do like that but it is and you go across the cohorts it's hard to follow the trend when they move to a different

122building because the no I agree with you it's it's different I do like a higher bar though I like I like having a higher bar if if we did that in all three buildings we were consistent at whatever number we want to create follow necessar and would be interesting to see so I'd like to see this isn't compared to I and the other and the other piece of the puzzle is the state test that starts at third grade yet we we're assessing our first and second graders just the same way we're assessing and there's no State assessment and those are are developing Learners those are the you know our six-year-olds are the ones who are just getting into learning how to read right so we're saying that 56% of them can't or are at a

123not professional level but I know everyone I like setting a higher bar that ad is proficient I love it um I reason I love it is especially elers you're getting those core skills that you need for the other grades and if you set the bar 65 in elementary school that's where you're going to see the compounding expansion do is make those numbers look better on the screen know the results are no different you change that you're right J and is it for I mean I know what we do every day in and out at that building but yet this comes up and well yeah you can see us all of us over here like so with the two of us and Karen who helps us with ncss and who helps us with special ed I

124mean there's so many pieces of the puzzle for all three vs I'm not just saying the elementary but I said today the elementary data on this report is by far the worst in in the district is there a way you can actually so if the public actually looks at this is there a way you can just put on proficiencies 80% so at least when someone reads that they oh 79 so that's howed on that's the key rep so that's that's and I'm G stop talking that's why I have this conversation every single year we recording but you put so if I'm looking at this online if I'm looking at this online not everyone and we have one sitting right here not everyone who looks at this data on our meetings is a parent right who

125sees a report right so if the bar is different when you look at the high school data versus the Middle School data you literally have three different bars that you're measuring against that should be on here least like noted somewhere for high school this is what proficiency means for Middle School this is what proficiency means for elementary school because it's three different things in each building so some parents might think Community person or someone looking even not be in our community but looking to look at our school if they go online and look at this they would say oh it's by far the worst but is it really because you're measuring apples and oranges and bananas all mixed together you are right and there's a kiwi there St talk about yourself we will yes we

126will definitely do that in future and we're not picking on you in your building no no I I and I'm really defensive of the people in the building who are doing work this doesn't represent no but that's why explaining saiding hey the bar is 80 in this building 75 she does it every year I know but just remind that's why when ell's retired and not here to say it if it's on the chart for that could be my legacy if I'm the average citizen and I see this I'm saying oh my gosh 56% of the population in first grade is below a 65 that's what I see if I'm Jose say and that's not true and that's not true so that's why you got to put something on there so when someone looks at it

127is there a way to get data for 65 for every building even if we leave this the same so it is Rachel has included that for the Elementary in a further slide where we looked at just once and that would be 65 or below in the elementary it would be a one um so the next slide is going to do the same thing it's it's new this year so it's breaking apart um our math grade into two separate grades one's one around math fluency and one around problem solving you will see that there is nothing noted for grade one or two um in math fluency and that's just because they're not at that point yet um so we are only you only measured it at third and fourth okay the next slide will outlin uh

128writing uh which again includes level one and two um so you can see the glob proficiency for our students at elementary school at an 80 an 80 yeah wait what was the threshold again it's been it's been a long time um so as Alan mentioned the next slide be included just to be able to um next um yes so this slide just breaks down the students who performed at a level one only soel just pointed out that in grade three it's a 75 but it drops to 17 you at just the one yeah which is below 60t and so when you look at this sta you say we need to really make sure that we're giving our second graders support this to me is a more accurate picture of where need sidebar just important to

129know Ellen and I are just talking about the grades are recorded as standards based one two 34 the elementary so I'm even curious about how we have a numerical calculation for this so that is definitely grounds for conversation because if they're reporting the grades 1 through four on the report cards It's Curious to me how we're coming up with a numerical like accuracy wise how we're reporting I'll Champion your f um so then we get into our I ready data this is our first window of diagnostic assessments um so we'll start with the elementary school um so the pyramid on the left hand side will'll just break down how many of our students are showing um the ONG grade level um versus needing more support at either tier two or tier three I looked back

130at 2023 at our very first window um and the numbers were very comparable at 20% tier one 50% tier 2 and 29% at tier three the right hand side will uh shows you the the breakdown by domain um so those are all of the areas that are tested throughout the diagnostic assessment um and then the next page Will Show You by grade level how our our students performed overall it's not broken down by the domains I could but this is just specific to the tier one tier two tier three when you put that graphic on just just cut out grade five that's not oh right well I included it because we do have three fifth graders in our building yeah during the selfcontained classes okay yeah I know that's put the N number so we

131know so it's interesting I said in the earlier slide I would have liked to seen I ready next to grade one and when you look at this slide next to grade one I mean they are comparable you got the yellow and red it's nearly comparable and I would say already in our street results are comparable right line yeah you definitely do Ellen we we're not bingiz no I know you're that I you know me I'm a dog with the bone or qii so moving on to um Elementary uh I here I'm sorry Middle School reading um so again left hand side when you compare that back to our first window of 2023 um comparable results 26% 21 and 53% at tier three and then that shows you the gray bubble breakdown moving to math so

132the first um section is elementary school and um a little different there aren't as many domains that are tested under math but you can see those listed on the right hand side I'm sorry what is tier one tier two three mean is that like tier one base level tier two higher percentage or what does that mean so tier one will tell you that students those students are performing on grade level um tier two is saying that they are one or more grade levels behind or two or more grade levels behind according to the diagnostic assessment okay the next slide will show you the grade level breakdown um the next slide will show you the the Middle School data so I'm sorry I didn't give you the comparisons from the last one but for this one

133uh they were also comparable for the elementary school but for this one for the first window of 2023 um it was 20% Tier 1 42% tier 2 38% tier 3 and then the next slide will give you them the breakdown moving into State assessment um performance results so for bla um in grade 3 through 8 we had 423 students at um as a whole so on the left hand side you can see those are the number of students in each of the uh grade levels and then the right hand chart tells you how many students at each grade level were actually tested is the assumption that the difference are op do yes yeah so that's definitely again the participation rate has increased yes yeah so when you look at the next uh slide that will

134tell you the breakdown in terms of performance levels so yellow is a level one two or blue is a level two purple is a level three and greenen is a level four your threes and fours are considered your proficient um so for grade three we had roughly 36 students 36 students I'm sorry 36% um students proficient fourth grade we had roughly 27% fifth grade we had 30% sixth grade 46% 7th grade 23% and then eighth grade about 41% Prof fishing so again going back to some of those previous slides you can definitely see their that alignment according to our I ready data and then our quarterly achievement data moving into math um so again leftand column shows you the number of students in each cohort the right hand chart will tell you the number of

135students who were tested we did have uh a larger number of students who were not tested in math due TOS um so when you look at the breakdown for math for the performance data um we had about 45% proficient in grade three 43% proficient in grade four 26% proficient in grade 5 50% proficient in grade 6 about 36% proficient in grade seven and 4 about 48% proficient in grade 8 so pausing here um and just kind of wrapping up um going back to that first initial slide where we talked about all of the different things that we have in motion currently aligned to our essential objectives I think a lot of the conversation that happened here tonight as we went through this data certainly reflects back the importance of that continued work um so that

136we can continue to make sure that the academic programming for our students is individualized targeted but it's also pushing students to be able to perform even better so when we're looking at grade eight for the the math performance and the read or English performance y back to that one they have a greater proficiency of all the other classes one both of those but when we look at the data for how they've done over the years they've been one of the highest non-proficient grades and this year they're they're below uh their proficiency increased from previous years I noted that for 8th grade ELA um I go to the by course yes they definitely um still showing 29% Bel proficiency I cannot off the top of my head I apologize remember what the proficiency was from last

137year but um definitely a decline but these kids are not the same kids oh right yeah I that eth grade is last year's even until you're seventh grade um Francis yeah same thing like the uh Prof rate decreased from last year um and on theate on the state test you're saying um yes but also when you look from last year to this year for proficiency data all of our Ela courses have performed better not to confuse anything so the data between third grade and 8th grade is a set data data it's not like how here for our district we have through fourth grade is 0 is proficient 70 no a state time five because it's state so what do they consider proficient is there what does a two mean what does a three mean they

138don't equate it to they don't they don't equ it to a number I know but for someone who not meeting right for someone who likes to see a number because they were raised in a number way is there a way to explain that it's not meeting striving towards meeting and exceeding one two three four y but just so if anyone ever watches this or or has that question I'm at that I'm at that generation where I I know numbers and I know what a a 50 is a 75 and a 100 is um and is changing parents who are at a certain age at my level older maybe to to to understand what a one two 3 4 is so if you look does that make sense if you look at all this all these

139different data points um are they all saying the same thing or are they saying different things I guess is the question maybe that's some of what Jeff is get to I guess right do I know that if you're in the blue area are you oh my gosh this person is doing terrible or are we like oh we're just a nudge and will be in the purple she's so uh Kate was trying to she just reminded it is numerical but it's not one through 100 there is a numerical uh equivalent but it's it's a different scale than what we're used to the one to 100 so when parents actually receive the formal notification specific to how their child performed they actually get to see where their child was relative to that two or three uh and

140the thresholds the cut off between two and three but it's not thank you it's not one to 100 I stand correct our but our our report card grades when we do 1 through three like we there's a number ass when we think proficiency there are numbers Associated non proficiency again below 75 and then you know a two is roughly a 50 to a 74 which is crazy because if I got 50 versus a 74 for our generation of grades I thank you and Francis to answer your question about the alignment I would say yes there is alignment it may not be perfect across every single grade level or content area but um what I looked at our quarterly achievement the I ready scores on the diagnostic and the state assessment scores they are relatively aligned

141which indicates to us that the work that we are doing continues to be important and we have to keep we have to keep doing it and then I guess to break that down even more and I know I'm beating a dead horse here but how you know if we look at the the the level two how many of those are closer to level three as opposed to closer to level one we can we can we certain we have that data we can certainly provide that in the future to give you a clearer picture of what that really looks like and this is a test that's given once a year or is it t once once so we won't know until next year this time correct and the target is mov I mean the assessment has

142changed numerous times over the last five years and then factoring Co so it's tough to even look at it from year to year because it's a moving Target yeah yeah any further questions all right Rachel thank you for putting this together I know that we beat you up it feels like we you up every every time you present this just because I don't think any of us would be here if if and then I just wanted to see those numbers continue to De Cline um that's what but to understand what the numbers actually mean I respect that I appreciate that um and I have made notes so I will make some of those changes for the upcoming um report thank you very and then just to clarify is a I know is a building decides

143what their threshold is for each grade 8075 based on the St I think that's something we could explore because again to your point if it that was identified or calculated During the period of time that we were administering Common Core and the modules I think it's probably worth revisiting and having a conversation she probably do it before Ellen retires so she doesn't have to right now we're try I will tell you the decision was made when I was not principal there you go see it's all time to look at it again I have a question for the board I'm Wonder about the academic achievement report I'm wondering if this would be an agenda item for our winter uh Workshop not Retreat uh just wondering uh if there is differing configurations of data you'd like to

144see or if you'd like to continue with the same format I I myself have some questions or thoughts I I think one of the things that we talk about every time we look at this is uh in the perfect world would be an overlay of like what we're seeing classroom vers I ready versus state standards to see that by grade level to see because that would help us I think reminds e that the classroom they're aligned in the same page would answer the question do they align yeah and I and I also when I'm looking at one year data that isn't as helpful as looking at multiple years because you Sky growth or agression or I want to see right so was a like to discuss further do we feel like we've given her enough

145prompt for the subsequent reports I think enough prom I think she's ready give her plenty of time to okay thanks Rachel yeah and to the building administrators who feel attacked every time we don't please don't feel that way I don't feel please don't yeah I I'm defensive of the teaching and the instruction in the elementary of course we're just trying to understand what it means as all we also just all want Excellence so y okay um I guess we are not the capital project update I feel like unless you have questions I feel like provided plus you should have in your uh report in your packet Watch Dogs provided an update then I suggest we move on to the superintendent's entry plan report so we need to have you thank you very much does do

146people need a break because this is not going to be two minutes um three minutes I believe in over under promising overd delivering I don't even know if I can do it in 15 yeah let's take you want we just can we pause our e e e thank you all right thank you it's my pleasure to provide an update on my entry plan since arrival July 1 and so this evening I'm going to take you through a few report components I'll first talk a little bit about the entry plan design talk about meeting data the strengths or perceived strengths that were identified as a result of engaging in entry plan meetings areas of growth or perceived areas of growth and the next steps next slide entry plan aside next slide thank you so uh this

147slide should look familiar uh when I presented uh both to the board of education but also to instructional staff onset of the school year uh back actually back in July uh basically just was I was trying to provide an articulation surrounding what were the things I was going to be looking at uh upon entry to the district and so things like uh working with the Board of Education that first week of arrival here or spending several days together engaging in Workshop to understand the direction and vision of the Board of Education moving forward uh looking at different uh policy plan procedure and then I put a green star next to you the focus of our conversation this evening really is only going to to be about the actual entry meetings and the qualitative data obtained

148as a result of engaging in those meetings next slide so the purpose of those meetings is a multifold and so thinking about having conversations with both instructional staff operational staff external stakeholders uh IE families parents and also Community Partners uh it's important to develop a contextual understanding about the State of the State as a new superintendent you think about your entry point and there's just so much you don't necessarily understand uh about the State of the State upon arrival and so having those conversations with the differing stakeholders allows for the opportunity to develop contextual understand understandings it also allows for the opportunity to meet with various stakeholders and identify their perceptions of how things are going both good and bad good bad and indifferent uh and and recognize it that those are their perceptions uh

149I would say probably one of the most important uh takeaways from engaging in the entry meetings is identifying and clarifying the perceived gaps and needs for the district moving forward because those will factor into the ultimate development of a strategic plan for the district which uh we're on Deck to start doing in January uh also important for building relationships and Trust generating areas for further exploration meaning it's not a oneandone uh providing the narrative for the district and then lastly as I already alluded to guiding action plans and decision making next slide timeline for the entry plan meetings was July 1st through December 1st been engaging in meetings since I got here uh the mode for those meetings has been one toone so individual one-on-one meetings but also small group group meetings and I would

150argue that uh many of the internal meetings internal stakeholder meetings they had were actually small group Department uh differing a small groups so an assembly of individuals having the conversation next slide uh the design was a common prompt so every group had the same set of questions it was really this describe who you are in the district what's your association with the district and then what are those points of Pride that you want to make sure that as your new superintendent I work to protect and preserve as your new leader in the district and so those become your areas of strength or again and or points of Pride the second prompt was in a safe manner what do you perceive as areas of growth or opportunity for the district in your respective role as a

151stakeholder uh a couple caveats or disclaimers to this group you know when I entered into the meetings I would articulate out loud a number one um that I would be sharing out loud at during a public meeting and that I would also be using all of the qualitative data obtained during my cabinet and future Council meetings because this is going to be the source of uh strategic planning as well as developing actionables but then more importantly uh they were assured that it would be remained confidential that I would not identify any one group or any one individual specific to what they believed were the greatest strength but probably more importantly uh eliminating any vulnerability by sharing what they saw as perceived areas of growth for the district next slide important to Anchor in uh perceived

152strengths and areas of growth which I'm going to share in just thematic just in a thematic approach and not with any great depth and not with any great specificity this evening it's important to note that it's based on perception uh what I will share with you this evening does not mean that it is uh T capital T truth what it means is that based on the perception of the stakeholders that I had the opportunity to meet with that's what I'm presenting with you this evening next Slide the data next slide uh over from July 1st through December 1st I had 87 plus meetings that doesn't mean the number of people that I met with because I as I already alluded to many of those meetings were small group meetings and so I've given you the

153broke down breakdown here I'm not going to actually read them for you but you can see it was my intent and objective to try to meet with as many internal and external stakeholders as possible they were all voluntary meaning even for our internal staff they were not directed they weren't told that they had to meet with me they had to actually agree to come in uh scheduled the times uh through uh through the collaboration with Kelly Dixon to make sure that everyone had a meeting time and then people basically just showed up next slide so before we move on to perceive District strengths you have two Post-it notes in front of you I would ask respectfully that you take your orange Post-It note right now and I would like for you in your own mind

154to think about what do you believe I learned about the district I was say your District so it's my district now too what do you believe I learned about the Williamson Central School District as perceived strengths and you're just going to identify your top two do you guys want to play along to I you post it sure okay I'm steal boot soon H I'm G steal your boots soon fre you they're a little sweaty at this point okay so I'm going to respect if I could have just a couple volunteers to share what they believe the perceived strengths you will see in just a moment next slide I will actually give away the story if I could have a couple volunteers what do you think toy participation from Community anyone else I Community any staff

155members I said strength in the community okay I number opportunities that we have for students is great for the size of our district I also said But I geared it more towards like the community that they have like the culture maybe necessarily of the district okay hold on to that thought for just a moment next slide here are the top 13 strengths perceived District strengths as identified by all of the stakeholders so it is important to note that while many of you use the word community that came up and is embedded Within culture um and so what you see here is a thematic approach to what was identified also important to note that while this isn't a quantitative data analysis for a uh theme to be identified on this slide it had to be uh

156represented multiple times greater than five five or greater so anything five or greater meaning brought up during meetings uh FaceTime with stakeholders had to be at least five times or more or did not make this slide that does not mean that there were not other identified strs it's also important to note that within each of these themes there are also uh subsets of that so for instance uh culture I heard a lot of uh the The Hub of the community um uh I'm sorry I heard things like uh just the love the culture of care things like that is what was articulated under culture collaboration and collegiality actually I'll go to I'm sorry next slide I got ahead of myself I apologize uh these are this is a word spash specific to your uh number

157one strength which was culture and these are just words that were identified uh by differing stakeholders surrounding why culture became the number one perceived strength for the district next slide for the number two and number three perceive greatest strengths collegiality and programming these were some of the words directly uh taken from my meetings with uh stakeholders I think it's important to note with collegiality uh internal stakeholders uh very very much uh reported that they felt very strongly about the culture the community around their individual departments which is why it became its own theme the collegiality piece I.E the special education department uh the athle Athletics and everybody involved in athletics was a strength uh collegiality Administration administrators also reported that that was a strength for them the level of collegiality and then programming those are

158the words that were provided to me uh Within the the meetings from stakeholders any and again not going deep with this the depth will come from the taking the input and working that into the strategic planning uh next slide please same prompt actually before we do that we had people saying Community how many of you nailed it with at least one or more of your perceived fabulous let's see how you do with the next one before I share with the perceived areas of District growth and again we're going to say perceived it's not capital truth it just means how folks were feeling please identify on your blue Post-it what you believe might be uh the top two perceived areas of growth for the Williamson Central School District and similarly I would ask if we could

159just have a couple volunteers to share what they believe you might see in the next slide as far as a perceived greatest areas of growth for the district anyone shared Staffing okay achievement Financial I said safety and financial okay anyone else board I have achievement and communication thank you and now for the Moment of Truth next slide please okay these are the top eight themes that came up in those 87 meetings and again please note I'm only going to take you through in just a moment number one and number two in more depth U uh but each of these again has subsets therein uh so to your point um you talked about communication it's important to note that a subset would be there was a a question about communication between internal and external stakeholders there

160was also a question about communication between and amongst internal stakeholders I'll give you a moment to look at the slide and again same metric meaning to be identified as a theme to worthy of bringing to your attention and identified on a slide it had to have at least five data points meaning it had to come up in no fewer than five conversations I can share with you number one came up in about 50% of conversations and and that's why I'm going to share a little bit more about that in the next slide please identified area number one um giving you quite a bit of depth I think there's no surprise when we look at up at the top reading and literacy especially after having reviewed the academic achievement reports uh this evening reading and literacy

161was on the mind of not only internal stakeholders but came up in external stold meetings as well I think it is important to note in particular Ellen as much as she's defending her staff it was very much the voice of her staff that was bringing forth almost unanimously reading and literacy being a necessary area of focus for the district similarly and I apologize this is not clockwise but next elementary math program uh that came up consistently uh in particular at the elementary but almost all instructional staff members uh hence you'll see that was of such an urgent nature that we actually are already moving forward with and math pilot because that was not one to sit on before we created a strategic plan to address it uh advanced level courses came up uh quite frequently

162uh AP classes additional Gemini classes you'll see over on the left hand side I also included the words enrichment when we were looking at Elementary uh instructional staff they would use the word enrichment but almost unilaterally folks were concerned about uh whether or not our our students had the same number of options that other students might have in differing districts uh special education came up pretty frequently so these are numerical I apologize they actually are numerical going reading and they're not numerical in order I'm sorry I should have actually done it one through eight they're not they're not weighted uh special education came up quite uh quite often um with differing concerns specific to Clarity around our programming Clarity around the Continuum uh we'll certainly be having further conversations to identify you know what action

163steps as necessary specific to special education academic intervention Support Services came up uh across the board prek-12 our instructional staff are very concerned about the level of academic intervention Support Services we have as well as we parents who met with me and then lastly a Career Tech pathway uh came up consistently and then to the left are the ones that are lesser weighted meaning there weren't as many data points so the six you see here are the ones that came up more heavily weighted they were coming up with consistency ac across the board and then over on the left this list they came up more than five times um but not quite to the extent that these other six did questions about that just out of curiosity and if you said it I apologize of

164all the stakeholders you spoke with what was the percentage staff members in comparison to community members much more staff so there were 87 meetings I if you could go back a couple slides I'm sorry there was one I actually put down the numbers keep going keep going that one uh inter I'm sorry external I had eight parent meetings and then I had 14 like Community partner type meetings and then the rest was all internal I did have three student meetings I talking to three students thank you you're absolutely and now you can go back forward please next slide uh identified area number two uh so that was programming number two Staffing your reductions cheer Point Rob uh the reductions and the shared staff came up quite a bit uh so the categories that I'm going

165to share with you is number one the impact of those reductions that were taking going into 2425 meaning the impact on the actual humans uh who were attached to those reductions uh secondarily but equal uh in as as far as the number of times that were coming up was uh the impact of the reductions instructionally meaning what was the potential negative impact on students uh if we didn't have AIS instruction that was adequate at any of the levels uh number three uh specific to Staffing was articulation of professional responsibilities uh an absence of clarity in some cases for some specific R and that certainly will'll make um a strategic plan moving forward to delve into that a little bit further and then on the minds of many people as the notion of where we are

166with Staffing the Recruitment and Retention of Staffing given the State of the State not just for Williamson but across the state as far as the absence of availability of certificated staff but also uh you know Jeff uh Jeff Patrick and I Jeff Vicky and I have been talking about Staffing for transportation and Facilities often we are not fully staffed and we have not yet been since the beginning of the school year and any questions there next slide identified area number three uh the questions or the perceived questions and concerns were is there adequate support in the buildings to address student management issues uh are we adequately communicating both uh with our external stakeholders but then also internally and then lastly uh absence of clarity around what constitutes classroom manag versus office managed uh behaviors next

167slide and then identified area number four professional development uh just asking for uh a more personalized approach looking at what the needs uh what instructional staff uh needs are to move the needle specific to uh getting the academic achievement for students questions next slide next steps uh there's not oh I'm sorry before I do that how did we do how many of you nailed it as far as what you put down for perceived concerns strengths surprisingly to your point in that and was it Kate talked about budget Financial didn't come up did not come up I found that fascinating because it was an open-ended question and people could have mentioned anything and especially with all the conversations we've been having about Foundation a and potential uh reductions and a I found that surprising but it

168did not come up uh so next steps reflect consider and explore further next slide uh we are going to look at and ask the question specific to all of the identified areas is it a question of clarity communication meaning is it really is the perceived area of growth or opportunity because we haven't been clear enough specific to what is happening uh that people don't have a a sufficient awareness around what is happening or what the district practice or policy is and so that could be something that is a simple fix meaning let's just make sure we communicate it out it could generally be that there is a problem of practice and if in fact there is a problem of practice then that's something that's unactionable and then we will have to address that moving forward

169as an administrative team and we'll work through the through those items and then I don't want to rule out that there could be others right so there could be actionables there could be just Clarity and communication there could be other probably actionables next slide so thinking about moving forward what are the tangible actions uh again going back to long range financial planning uh just as part of the entry plan so we had the entry meetings but part of my entry plan was also looking at our financials and so long range financial planning which I already mentioned we should have a draft report at the end of this month uh development of a draft strategic plan that's on deck and my hope would be to bring something forward to the board and to this group in

170January of 25 and then we'll continue to do work with that with other stakeholders in the spring uh we're wrapping up the Sip completion and then we will be looking at facilities planning we've already alluded to I think Jeff has alluded to and I'm trying to bring forward it's very clear to me we are going to have to really position to move very quickly into the next project we have to take care of the roofs and there's $65 Million worth of other TLC that needs to happen to our facilities uh number four continued work around regionalization and consolidation um as outlined in the essential objectives and then lastly a continued review of practice procedure and policy as outlined in our plans and policies next [Music] slide I think I did that in 10 minutes did

171anybody tie me it was over three thank well you did good thank you okay so not an indepth but just a glimmer of themes that emerged as a result of engaging in the conversation certainly helpful in framing my thinking and understanding about the Williamson Central School District I've been saying to those who were closest to me and I'm going to say it out loud now I have slept very well since July 1st you might think otherwise the truth is there is been so much input and a lot to think about when I had hits the pillow I'm tired and I'm sleeping very well um questions considerations thoughts I would like to hear the next steps strategic actions strategic actions okay thank you for taking the time to do all that that's a lot of work

172and a lot of meetings a lot of listen I think it brings out things that board has talked about as well so I just wish there was more participation from the community there would have been interesting to see you know 10% eight people right and you had several months and you kept asking and kept asking um it's hard to know how to interpret that I mean again being new in the district it could be because there was a new person and there's a factor of not wanting to necessarily engage with a new person it could also be if I might when we were experiencing Co if you'll remember when the initial onset of covid I don't know what you guys did here I was doing town halls and they were full initially I mean I'd

173have hundreds of people participating in those remote town halls but as we became effective in navigating covid by the end I had under 10 people showing up because they understood and they had confidence in what was happening so I might reflect back and say the reason why we didn't have so many external stakeholders might be because there is confidence in what the district has been doing in the direction and vision of the board you know I don't know I mean these are just the how I have thought about it U because I was a little bit disappointed not to have more people take me up on it I'm thrilled for the number who did and I felt like their contribution was very meaningful it helped shed light on what's you know what they perception of

174what was happening at the Williamson Central School District thank you absolutely good work thank you all right I need a motion to approve consent agenda items 6p through 68 as recommended by the superintendent second any discussion here all in favor oppos pass moving into Old business uh the regionalization workshop with Lynn rutnik our Bose's district superintendent um I believe the last conversation we had um we Ted Bridget with uh reaching out to our neighboring School District to give a little update on I would love to so uh we reached out to uh Wayne We reached out to Sodis and Maran and Maran is the only District that accepted our invitation to participate in such a study uh Wayne and Sodus respectfully declined not because of anything to do with Williamson but just not in a

175position to want or need to do so okay so that leaves us with a single decision to make right and that decision would be um should we choose to move forward with um doing a regionalization study with Maran we need to uh vote to do that do we need if is that something we vote tonight so we need a motion okay first I'll have a discussion about that for what is the cost cost I believe is approximately $50,000 shared and we have the potential for a grant that would not those FES would not be available announced until spring that would cover from I understand 50% of that cost so that reduces our cost to about 12 12 and a half yes approximately you think that ashon should be here to make this decision yes well

176I think that if we take a pulse and if we are split of any kind then yes she should be here if there's a majority we just are voting we would be voting to decide to meet with Maran about that is it that Mee which would cost zero that's right it would happen Okay and would I believe the way Lynn laid that out to us if we want to move to the next step and vote to have that meeting with Maran we would do it in an offsite location at bosis so that it's not at either of our districts the public is invited but it would be in objective neutral but then later on you'd have to actually vote again to if you want this is just to meet this is just to meet to

177even see if in the same room together we feel like we can move forward with taking it back to our community to our respective boards to vote to do the study so it doesn't hurt to sit down with them this be a study of centralization not of an you do have the possibility of including that you would have to be up front and stating that you would want and anation or just consolidation as part of you have toy from both districts to do that imagine you could have an open conversation with see I mean you can optimistic I mean how would you feel I guess the question is what what's best for the students right what would be best for the students I apologize I missed his question I'm sorry what would be best for

178the students and as a benefit would be you could have additional classes that a District offers that we don't um we go we talk about academics right shared resources but I think what Francis is saying his question is which would be better for students both both options could offer opportunities for students whether you centralize or Annex which one would be better and I would make the argument you won't know the answer to that question unless you study them both but you can't study them both unless both districts agree to study them both I don't and that's not likely to happen I don't think we would feel good if we were asked that question I I can't see why a district would actually say yeah let's that's right and so like I guess you know I

179don't I don't feel comfortable personally moving in that direction um we're thinking about a ctive effort um do you feel prepared to weigh in on this tonight as a vote call a motion for a vote to meet you need more time to think about it or so I guess my question is you don't think that the Maran School Board would want to possibly years in the future merge with our school district no that's not what we're saying okay about a hostile takeover and that doesn't feel good to no I wouldn't want to do a hostile okay okay that doesn't feel like that I would no absolutely no no that's no I would want to Doos that's what annexation is I I understand that but I'm are we having a vote to see if who actually

180sit down with the Varian School Board yes so I don't understand why that's a complex vote why is that a complex vote to have a conversation with them well Fran asked if we should wait until Ashton's here and I think if we're all filling the same way we don't need to to wait till the next board meeting to that vote so I I would motion um what's the here I didn't know that this was going to be an option so I didn't add it so well I need a motion to approve uh the investigation of a meeting shared meeting with Maran at an offsite location to discuss rization study with ly rutnik with ly rutnik pres second or you're asking for a motion I'd like to ask for a motion I'll move thank you can

181I get a second I'll second any discussion all in favor I okay that passes 4 Z Kelly thanks for adding that into our agenda I don't know why we made this so complex I [Music] mean hold on I'm stilling if s or Wayne had come back and said that they wanted to do one would we do multiple we can you one at a time we can do as many as we want we can also ask them to come in and do a three-way shared and contribute but they're not interested so there's no sense in even talking about that okay thanks Kelly all right moving to new business I need a motion to approve the tax collector report is prepared by and so um just a little bit so this represents about a 3.96% uncollected percentage

182so it's is up about 34 of 1% so not a huge increase but uncollected yeah pretty typical this time yeah it well it was higher before Co I went back and looked it seemed higher before Co then it it di down probably because people were getting money from the government um so now it's again so thank you all in favor I opposed passes for zero I need a motion to approve the 2025 2026 budget calendar sir second any discussion all in favor oppos passes 4 Z I need a motion to approve the resolution for me evaluators for teachers second any discussion here all in favor I I opposed pass 4 Zer I need a motion to amend the appointment of Emily H elementary teacher the elementary school who a longterm subredit second any discussion all

183in favor opposed passes 4 Z I need a motion to amend the appointment of Cy sheets elementary teacher Elementary School do to long-term sub credit second any discussion here all in favor I opposed pass the score zero I need a motion to amend the appointment of Nicole shine elementary teacher Elementary School long-term sub credit so any discussion here all in favor I opposed passes for zero I need a motion to approve the surplus of the following equipment items a 2009 Chevy Suburban second any discussion yeah this is our 3/4 ton Suburban it's uh just the mechanics of the bus SC it's severely rusted rusted bre it's very frustrating for me it's rusted brake lines gas lines it's the differential uh portable drive is messed up it only go like 10 miles hour uh and the

184cost of repair is getting to the point where cost benefit is not worth it so one of the things we're talked to that we've enacted is getting the undercoating on these vehicles it should still be fine uh it's frustrating that we have to do it when we purchased it we did not do that moving forward in the vehicles that we have now we are doing that um just because they they don't travel a lot and they should last longer of the practice before my arrival or way before 2009 was here but was not to do that so we have started doing that okay is the plan to replace that vehicle uh yes um we we do plan on doing that yeah okay y all in favor opposed pass is for Z I need a motion

185to approve the district level a plan so moved second any discussion um the AIS plan is required by New York state to have posted on our website and will be um it outlines the data points that we use when we consider students for AIS as well as the procedures and the practices around including and dismissing students from AIS um each building has also um taken the district plan and interpreted it at their building levels as well thank you all in favor I I opposed that's is for Z I need a motion to improve the impartial hearing officer compensation rates resolution second any discussion all in favor opposed passes for zero I need a motion to approve the addition of Escape from Camp 14 to for the 11th grade English language arts for 2024 2025 second

186any discussion all in favor I I opposed passes 4 Z I need a motion to approve the addition of carry by Stephen King to the instructional materials for 11th grade ELA for 2024 2025 so any discussion all in favor post I need a motion to approve the memorandum of agreement with the Williamson faculty Association through June 30th 2025 regarding professional learning opportunities on Saturdays and during break periods thank any discussion here looking for Creative Solutions to provide professional development to instructional staff we're running into difficulties providing any release time during the school day because of the absence of substitutes available so looking to pay for them to participate on the weekends as an option and or during breaks do we do we have a sense from the staff that that's what they want or they

187are willing to do to get more participation or unit leadership was very excited about the possibility okay um all in favor hi [Music] is 4 Z all right budget transfers Jeff anything information only one for CSC field trip one for formative math fluency program but just informational okay uh moving into meetings upcoming District committee meetings there's a grading and assessment committee where we are going to just destroy all standards based everything and not all at the same time uh upcoming District events Elementary School Musical December 6 to the the RPO concert which is a free concert for the entire Community December 7th at the high school at 7M trim induction ceremony December 9th at 7 p.m. fourth grade Winter concert December 10th at 7 p.m High School uh National Society induction ceremony December 11th 7

188p.m. and 78 grade Winter concert December 12th at 7.m end of the 15we marking period December 13th the 5th and sixth grade Winter concert December 17th at 7 p.m the high school Winter concert December 19th at 7 p.m in terms will be available December 20th and winter break December 23rd to January 3D closing items do we have any Board of Ed highlights this evening I'd like to highlight our Tech interns as you saw that the separate list of concerts and musicals our Tech interns are there Larry's been here since like 2:30 today 3 so we we have um I think we have eight that are are really dedicated a few that are learning and and but um there there a lot of things I want to thank the students that are working with them and

189Mr prey is the new tech inter coordinator and he's he's been working well with them too so anybody else okay moving on to public comment the Williamson Central School District Board of Ed invites public comment at this time on matters on the agenda of this meeting please limit your comments to two minutes or less the board of V has a lot 10 minutes for public comment prior to the adjournment of meeting written remarks may be provided to the board if time expires before a speaker completes the remarks we ask individuals to State their name and specific agenda item they wish to address prior to comments and to provide the district clerk with their contact information for purposes of followup although the board will not respond directly to individual comments at this time items brought to

190the attention of the board may be taken under consideration for future response action or followup with speaker issues related to specific District students or employees whether positive ative or neutral must be brought to the attention of the superintendent of schools privately in order to safeguard privacy the board reserves the right to terminate a speaker's comments if their comments are in excess of two minutes are repetitive or not appropriate for discussion in an open forward form all visitors are reminded to abide by the district code of conduct and to be respectful and courteous both as speakers and as audience members we are Community focused on bettering public education for our students some of whom may be present thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.