CorpusRecord 138733

February 11, 2025 - Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Williamsville Central School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,287 words · about 108 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I call the regular board meeting to order all board members are present vice president pulin would you please Us in the pledge of allegiance to the flag iedge Al to the flag the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for thank you may I have a motion to approve the following resolutions Rel to Executive session resolved that the Board of Education of the Williamsville Central School District hereby authorizes the production of a particular person's personnel file to be presented in executive session on February 11 2025 and resolved that the Board of Education of the Williamsville Central School District hereby votes to enter into executive session on February 11th 2025 pursuant to education law section 320a to discuss matters leading to the

002potential discipline of a particular person and to also discuss Collective negotiations motion Please Mr Manor SEC Mr Mana second Dr Spicer all in favor motion carries unanimous ly we will adjourn into executive session e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e for e e e e for e e e e e e e e e so congratulations may have a motion to return the regular board meeting to public session miss blinger Mr Mana all in favor motion carries unanimously during executive session action was taken regarding the 302a process and as we return to public session all board members are present good evening and welcome to all in attendance this evening please be advised

003that in the event of a fire an emergency and an evacuation should be necessary and alarm will sound please know all marked emergency exits and evacuate well away from the building at this time we request that everyone turn their cell phones and other electronic devices to silent thank you we are on item number three recognition Dr Brown Hall I turn it over to you thank you very much board president so tonight we begin our recognition at Forest Elementary School Dance Forex dance is the school's annual PTA partnership event allowing students to build community and be involved throughout our district the ptas and ptsas provide incredible enrichment opportunities for our students and Lasting memories please welcome principal Keith wing and assistant principal Claire Lata Michael from Forest Elementary to share more on this important partnership with

004the school and PTA [Applause] thank you Dr Brown Hall uh the longer I work in education the more it solidifies for me that school needs to be fun and I think what you're going to see is a great example of that um especially when you can have a project that Partners the PTA with our school community and our teachers and students and we're able to come up with um great opportunities that are highly engaging for kids and get kids involved in moving and uh creating meaningful memories so I'll let Mrs Lata Michael talk about some of the stakeholders involved and making um dance Forest dance possible so dance Forest dance is something that we look forward to every year we could not do it without our amazing PTA our supportive teachers our wonderful parents and

005our students again it's just a time that our students come together have fun create their own dance moves and just really celebrate what a wonderful place for us is so we hope you enjoy the video thank you are you guys ready to dance today dance for Dan is a time where the whole school Community comes together and we raise money for our school so our school Community alongside with our PTA worked together for a really incredible fun fundraiser students come in the gym during their specials time and they dance for a solid 45 minutes we turn the lights off we have music the kids really just get to dance to celebrate their accomplishment it's really a chance for our students to meet peers that are not in their classroom so it really just builds community

006and it's a really fun event for all of our grades to be [Applause] [Music] together people like raise money for like to hold T school I really feel like proud because like I'm like a part of it it's like very fun our dance Forest dance has been going on for 5 years it's something that our kids really look forward to our parents really look forward to and our teachers really look forward to it's a really really fun week one of my favorite things about dance Forest dance is the week of we have a spirit week it's a really a time for our school to come together and on Friday is Forest day so during dance Forest stands all of our students will be wearing our forest colors and just celebrate what a wonderful School Forest

007is the really cool part about this is It's become a tradition so you see kids who started off in kindergarten and now upk is a part of it as well and they're able to do this every year they look forward to it every year it's been great it's fun to watch these kids and they are really dancing their hearts out it's incredible the support we have through the community we've been able to raise funds that contribute to all the enrichment programs and author visits different events throughout the year so it's kind of brings excitement to the kids it's not just about raising money it's about the community coming together for each other it makes me feel good cuz you're helping to get um like a school better you get to dance with like a lot

008of people in your grade that you [Music] know the dance is a celebration of coming together really as a school Community it's just a time for kids to really be kids um to be in the gym having fun laughing you will see a lot of teachers dancing a lot of adults dancing with the kids absolutely love it's a time really just to have fun and to celebrate our huge accomplishment and to just really be together as a school Community it's a really really special day inde dance Forest dance thank you if I could add I the layers on to Forest and we had the PTA meeting last night and they announced that they um raised $ 47,7 through Dance Force [Applause] um just thank you to the co-presidents of the PTA um especially Megan Hungerford

009I know she's been working tirelessly past few days delivering all the gifts and everything and if I'm not mistaken they're hoping to purchase a GaGa ball pit so awesome that's the record for our district and raising fundraising fund so it's pretty incredible so congratulations that is great that is great great work over at Forex Elementary our next recognition takes us to Maple East Elementary School each and every day students are welcomed by staff providing a positive interaction with a trusted adult before instruction begins this idea has continued to evolve with a student L dance party on Fridays it is truly an incredible way to start the day please welcome assistant principal from Maple East Christy Gardina to share [Applause] more good evening everybody thank you all for having me here and thank you so much

010to the board and Dr Brown hall because watching the school Spotlight each month is just it's such a joy to see all of the amazing things that are happening throughout our district that we might not see otherwise so thank you so much for acknowledging that um at Maple East as Dr Brown Hall said we have started what is called the welcoming committee I'm out of a desire for kids to have a lot of different connections with multiple adults so that they felt safe when students feel safe they learn more they retain more they become better humans so that was what our goal was here um and I in the theme of dancing I would like to also add a little bit of dancing in our video as well so thank you again for having us

011thank you for recognizing us and feel free to come and be a part of our welcoming committee at any time thank [Music] you our welcoming committee was born out of a desire to make sure that every kid had a connection teachers are strategically placed throughout the whole building to make sure that every student has at least a few positive interactions before they even begin their day we want them to look forward to coming to school and be excited about meeting new friends and getting to see people that they might not see all the time morning guys good morning it's a great community and everybody's in a good mood and positive and they're really here for the students and to make them feel happy and welcome and just in a good place when you build Rel

012relationship with kids it just leads up to a great day a great week and a great school year we don't know exactly how everybody is feeling every day they come in but when they come in they know they're going to get a positive reaction from an adult that's here and it makes them feel great keep going happy Friday our newest edition is the Friday dance party where you would see all of our students coming together encouraging each other giving each other a positive start to the day Friday mornings have a agous energy everybody is dancing and excited and it just truly puts everybody in a really good mood it just feels nice to like see all your friends before you just go to your class because sometimes you can't see all your friends before you

013go to class but but during the dance party you can see friends and you can also dance with them I never want to miss a Friday students run in here because they want to get get to this dance party it is fun they can dance they can sing they can see their friends and then they are pumped up and they're ready to start the day and ready to learn dancing is super fun in my opinion and it just helps us get pumped up for the day yeah it gets us ready yeah it gets us ready for the day of school to start with the diverse student body that we have there's a lot of different backgrounds and music is universal these students come in and they see the enjoyment on other people's face it's contagious

014and they just absolutely love it and when you see the smiles on their faces it can't help to make you smile as well it has transformed into such a beautiful tradition here at Maple East it really has brought our students to take ownership of that Community here that truly makes my heart so happy to know that they're creating this environment and will continue throughout their life to create these environments that are very inclusive of every body awesome great work at Maple [Applause] East president I turn it back over to you thank you Dr Brown Hall are there any board acknowledgements Mr buan uh yeah I I went to a unified bowling event and I just wanted to point out the great uh the greatest thing you can do everyone seemed to be happy they were

015playing Clarance I don't know who won I don't know if they know who won but it was was a a great time and I would encourage all the board members to go to unified events because it's it's the best thing you can do with your day that's all was thank you thank you any other board acknowledgements Miss blinger I was able to see the music man at at Williamsville South this past week and then just congratulations to an amazing performance um was very talented and it was very fun to watch so great job thank you any other board acknowledgements okay moving on we are on item number four which is public expression I call on parliamentarian blure to review our public expression format you welcome to all who have come to observe this regular board

016meeting for policy 1510 the board allows up to 30 minutes for this first public expression period and then 15 minutes for our second public expression item 19 near the end of the meeting this is a time when we invite members of our school Community to share ideas of opinions and concerns with us while we are here to listen carefully and we take your concerns seriously public comment is not designed to be a discussion therefore please do not expect us to respond tonight instead you will receive a response by email after our meeting because we want to maintain mutual respect and civility please ensure that comments are delivered in a respectful manner to the board directly also under state and federal privacy laws we are unable to entertain any comments related to employee Personnel information or

017any topic that may disclose information about about a particular student on these matters we ask that you go through the appropriate administrative channels please note that individuals are required to sign up prior to our meeting and each speaker is allotted three minutes for comments you will be signaled at two and a half minutes so that you may conclude your remarks at this time we'll begin public comments after I call on you please step up to the podium and state your name first person I have here is Eric Borstein Eric good evening everyone it's it's nice to see some old friends here this evening and thanks for this opportunity and by the way I'll go off script for a second when I was on the board like Morin I also had Forest Elementary as my liais

018on and I remember when the PTSA proposed a dance Forest dance program it sounded wonderful and I loved the name a playoff of the Forest Gump movie run Forest Gump so congratulations to all you guys I'm thrilled that it's it's succeeded so I'm Eric borenstein 577 North Forest Road in Williamsville I'm here this evening representing the board of directors of the Amherst Symphony tonight's agenda includes a vote on an agreement with the Williamsville Central School District that would allow the ASO to move its concert season to South starting in in September the ASO has been serving our community since 1946 that's even before South High School was built the move to the newly updated and rebuilt music facilities would be transformational for the ASO the Concert Experience would improve dramatically for our musicians and for

019our audience but it also has benefits for the district it will highlight the district's efforts to partner with other Community assets especially in the Arts bringing thousands of concert goers of all ages to South High School highlighting the wonderful improvements made by the district and reinforce the reputation of the district and South High School as strong advocates for music and the Arts I hope you'll join us in approving this agreement that will have such a positive positive impact on our community and again I thank you for your time this evening thank you Eric next we have Jillian Leonard all right good evening members of the Board of Education superintendent and community members my name is Jillian lenhard and I am not only a parent of a first grader and soon to be kindergarten student at

020Forest Elementary but also a pediatric speech language pathologist and owner of a private practice here in Williamsville New York I work exclusively with children from birth through Elementary School age with various speech and language delays and disorders I have firsthand experience in how sleep attention and regulation directly impact Learning and Development and I'm here to voice my deep concerns about the propos start school times and their negative effects on our youngest Learners this proposal has been framed as a necessary adjustment to support high school students but in doing so it unfairly places the burden on Elementary School students and their families where is the data demonstrating that earlier start times are beneficial for younger students the research that Williamsville itself has provided on the district website and presented at The Forum shows little to no

021conclusive evidence supporting even earlier start times for younger students as a necessary change for their well-being instead much of the research highlights the need for further study before making changes the American Academy of Pediatrics recommends that Elementary AED children receive 9 to 12 hours of sleep per night to support cognitive function emotional regulation and learning my own children ages 4 and six are asleep by 700 p.m. and 8:00 p.m. respectively which is on the early end of recommended bedtimes for their ages they currently wake up naturally around 7:00 a.m. giving them 11 to 12 hours of sleep within the recommended ranges my son currently gets on the bus at 7:35 a.m. under this proposal he will have to get on the bus around the time he currently wakes up naturally moving their start time earlier

022forcing some children to wake up at 6:00 a.m. or even earlier directly contradicts this recommendation if the proposed solution is to have my almost 7-year-old asleep by 7:00 p.m. while still fitting in any extracurricular activity such as his piano lessons or baseball practice dinner homework nightly recommended reading and meaningful family time especially for working parents I have to ask excuse me have you ever realistically attempted this in your own home for families with more than one child this becomes even more impractical the idea of enforcing such an early bedtime is especially unrealistic in the spring and early fall months when the sun doesn't set until 8:00 p.m. or later as a responsible and engaged apparent I make evidence-based decisions both in my profession and at home evidence-based practice by definition incorporates scientific research clinical expertise

023and personal values and preferences it is not solely based on Research alone our current routines are already well balanced and reasonable and there is nothing broken that needs fixing conversations within our community overwhelmingly reflect the same sentiment among families in similar situations Dr Lisa Meltzer one of the nation's leading sleep researchers clearly stated during our Forum my perfect solution is every kid starts between 830 and 9 but with Transportation Logistics that's not feasible this underscores the reality that not only the only obstacle preventing a truly beneficial schedule for all students is logistics not child well-being furthermore Dr meltzer's own research inclu including changing school start times impact on sleep in primary and second secondary school students acknowledges the significant gaps in evidence regarding regarding elementary students as she states I have one more one more

024paragraph future St studies should examine how early is too early to start school across development no Studies have concurrently considered the impact of changing start times on sleep for students across grades from kindergarden through 12th grade as a result there remains significant need for rigorous longitudinal research we have a full public expression thank you so [Applause] much next we have Mo majda cus hi good evening members of the Board of Education and superintendent Dr Brown Hall my name is Dr Mo de capis I'm a general surgeon in the community and a mother of three children in the Williamsville School District I'm here to express also my concerns about the proposal to change school start times I was initially very excited about the idea of our kids getting more sleep um but I feel that the

025times that the The Proposal have listed are inadequate for the well-being of all the students in the district again particularly for the elementary school students there's been a great deal of focus on adolescent students um and their sleep requirements but the effects on elementary students have not been as well studied we know that there's a little bit of research but it really shows mixed effects on these students and even the American Academy of Pediatrics says that the majority of evidence for elementary students is anecdotal at best and more studies need to be done the Circadian rhythm of elementary school students does exist and it puts them in a sleepy time at about 8 8 to 900 p.m. adolescents get sleepy later as we know around 10 to 11: p.m. but the key other the other

026difference in their sleep is that the duration is different the younger students aged 5 to 10 need a duration of sleep as Jillian said around 11.5 hours on average adolescence need about 9.5 hours so if you kind of lay that all out and and put kids to sleep at their bedtime 8 to n and give them their 11.5 hours actually when you add it all up you got all the students kind waking up naturally around 7:30 to 8:30 um a.m you give them 60 to 90 minutes to get ready eat their breakfast and and get on the bus um and everyone is arriving somewhere in this window from 8:30 to 10 a.m. um at the virtual Forum Dr Meltzer even said herself my ideal solution um and this is a quote from her is that

027every kid starts between 8:30 and 9 and so clearly even the experts agree that there's some room for improvement with the times that been proposed um if you actually try to get everyone into the school somewhere between 8:30 and 9:30 with a 30 minute turnaround for the buses you could you could get everybody there 8:30 9 9:30 um and even with a plus or minus 15 minutes all of the students in our district could get adequate sleep so if changing the school start times is really about the well-being of our students which I believe is the intention of of the board and the district then we need to consider the well-being of all of the students stents in our district including our youngest Learners I know other school districts have kind of sacrificed the sleep

028of the early or the elementary school children um but that doesn't mean that it's right um and I think that we have the opportunity to show that we can do it better than those other districts finally I've heard throughout discussions of this proposal and we've been having so many um discussions throughout the community that you know this this change is going to be harder on the parents than it is on the students and I just want to say that you know as parents in this District it's it's it's kind of an insult to us because we more than anything would would submit to any change or hardship for our kids we're here because we love our kids we want what's best for them and we don't feel that this proposal serves that purpose thank [Applause]

029you next we have Safa Le frosby I'll just get going sorry pardon me okay good evening and thank you for the opportunity to speak my name is safala OAB I am the proud parent of a forest forest elementary kindergartner and practicing obgy and physician when the school starttime proposal was first released to the public I approached it the same way I would any medical intervention or surgical Innovation by working through the supporting evidence to better understand the intervention itself its intended results and potential complications having done so I would like to bring to your attention several issues with the research methodology in forming the proposal when analyzing research and evidence based studies in the scientific Community an early and crucial step is evaluating findings from specific sources within the context of how those studies were

030designed the school starttime committee clearly Drew from multiple studies to draft their proposal but is not clear that an analysis of the quality or strength of that evidence was performed the importance of analyzing the strength of research articles and making decisions has been endorsed by the Department of Education for almost a decade issued in 2016 and updated in 2023 doe released guidance on utilizing research to identify worthwhile interventions that document is attached to your electronic meeting agenda on page 12 doe defined an evidence-based intervention as something done in the best interest of students supported by an acceptable level of well-designed research strong moderate and even promising evidence categories are well defined spanning a range from randomized control trials to correlational studies with statistical controls for selection bias the best example I can provide of strong

031evidence in forming an evidence-based intervention are those conducted by Dr Meltzer interrogating delayed start times for adolescent students these studies were well designed and adequately powered to produce reliable repeatable results but what about interventions in areas where research is lacking you can still proceed with an intervention however doe advises there must be a program in place to monitor its Effectiveness once implemented it is in this category that moving Elementary School start times earlier belongs there are no studies that meet the criteria for strong moderate or even promising levels of evidence that demonstrate a benefit of earlier start times for elementary students like literally none in the school start time presentations in FAQ it was stated that early school start times improve attentiveness in elementary school students the singular study from 1990s Minnesota referenced by The

032Proposal in support of this does not rise to the level of any best practice evidence standards it was a focus group where teachers gave their opinions on Elementary student attentiveness when school start times were changed from 9:40 a.m. to 8:40 a.m. it completely lacked any statistical controls its findings have not been replicated in the 30 years since it was published and its design is inherently prone to selection bias current literature demonstrates at best no net change and at worst K to3 students may sleep less see lower test scores and have higher levels of suspension and tardiness the decision to move elementary schools to earlier start times is clearly not an evidence-based intervention it's a calculated decision satisfying the logistics of transporting students in a cost-effective manner for the district and yet because the Assumption was

033made within the proposal that this change would be beneficial to elementary students The Proposal did not provide any plans for monitoring the the effect of these changes on our students this is not the greatest science and does not adhere to guidelines laid out by the doe for this reason the current proposal should be rejected by the board and if allowing all students adequate sleep will increase Transportation cost these costs should be added to the budget so the community can decide if they want to pass it thank you Safa okay thank you again for the opportunity and your work in service to children [Applause] community we have uh Carrie O'Brien good evening my name is Carrie O'Brien I'm a mother of two Casey middle schoolers and a special education teacher at Maryville High School my two

034boys are very involved at Casey currently in participating School sports music and student government if the school start time changes as proposed while it may not impact them at Casey I am concerned that my children will not have the opportunity to be well-rounded student athletes once at Williamsville North and need to choose between their sports or extra curricular activities my concerns are not without reason as an educator who has firsthand experience with a late High School start time I feel compelled to share my observations and caution the board before making such a significant districtwide change when my district implemented the later start time we saw several unintended negative consequences that we tried to fix every year unsuccessfully student athletes frequently missed instructional time due to early dismissals for games and competitions there was a major

035decline in student participation in clubs and after school academic support time for our needest students teachers were struggling to stay after school due to family obligations limiting their availability to students we saw no improvement in attendance or tardiness students who were late at 7:30 a.m. still came in late when the start time was 8:30 a shift in high school culture from one where students were deeply engaged int extracurriculars to one where the Halls emptied quickly after the bell ring unless the district is prepared to make substantial structural changes to the school day I am confident that we would see the same challenges here in Williamsville during the virtual Forum it was mentioned that some clubs and activities would be moved to the morning before school starts but this directly contradicts the very research being cited

036in favor of a later start time if the goal is to provide students with more sleep how is it Equitable to ask some students to wake up early for activities While others benefit from the delay this approach seems already flawed to me high school is about so much more than an academic schedule it's about extracurricular involvement Athletics jobs and Community engagement a later start time will disrupt that balance that makes our schools Thrive I strongly urge the board to reconsider and explored alternative solutions that support student well-being without dismantling the high school experience Williamsville high schools have a strong vibrant culture not to mention consistently rated as the number one school district in Western New York and I fear that implementing a later start time will undermine that Foundation let's try not to fix something

037that isn't broken thank you thanks [Applause] G Richard Thompson good evening I am Richard Thompson the starttime change proposals disregard and disadvantage many special education students in Williamsville high schools I am here to point out the problem and suggest a solution and I expect the board to follow up with a response showing that it is continuing to support its neediest Children and Families my wife and I have lived here for 22 years my sons will attend North High School for the next four years the older one is a super senior we are all grateful to the board the superintendent and the district for your ongoing efforts on behalf of students and for giving stakeholders the opportunity to address you in this forum my older son needs continual adult supervision he cannot await board or exit

038a school bus independently under the current proposal moving his start time later means that a parent needs to stay with him that much longer this is an impossibility for many parents we would lose our jobs we should not be forced into this circumstance as the star times that we signed up for are the longstanding ones that exist now not the ones proposed The Simple Solution I see is District provided before care before expanding on that I would like to make a couple of points for context about the affected students and their families first this problem affects many students who should already be on your radar the district budgeted two new self-contained High School classrooms this year after an audit found that students needs were not being adequately met my son attends one of all of

039those students much of the life skills group high schoolers with physical disabilities and others in the secondary level special education population have similar supervision needs it would be egregious to move back to under supporting them it is baffling to me that the district's extensive written proposals and webinars make no mention at all of special education issues or students second the families of special education students are already making enormous lifestyle sacrifices on behalf of their children when there was no Aftercare provider in the district to serve these students my wife took an 85% pay cut to work in your food service and be able to get our son off the bus throughout high school we have received no fewer than a dozen calls during the work day asking whether we can pick him up something we

040never expected from trained special education instructors I know of others who have gotten those calls who are in single- income households and who have taken jobs with minimal pay and hours so that they can devote time to their children the proposed changes would be another blow to families who have already taken a beating creating and on-site before care solution for these students would soften the blow I was hardened to learn that there are already High School groups meeting regularly at 7:00 a.m. or earlier so opening the buildings is not a concern if each high school plans to have a supervised room where students can come at 7:30 and stay until the rest of school starts it would go most of the way toward meeting the needs of these students and their families the cost is

041an extremely minimal addition to what has been proposed and it does not seem that there are significant obstacles to designing a setting that is appropriate for this population as you plan for next year please do not continue to overlook your special education constituency remember that high school before care is a need high school before care understand the burden borne by the families of un needest students and let the public know how Williamsville will address these issues thank you thank you Richard Julie Emerson good evening members of the board superintendent and fellow community members my name is Julie Emerson and we moved to this district four years ago and my children are th ding in this District as it seems that most students within the district are so when the information was released for the school

042start time proposal my first reaction was why does this thriving number one District need such a drastic change and I and as I and so many others asked that question I noticed that there were no clear and concise answers and that lack of communication and transparency is very concerning to me throughout this time I also realized that the teachers of our district were not considered in this proposal these are the people who are responsible for the academic lives of our children and who guide and mold our children in so many ways that we rely on them for and I believe that they deserve to have more of a voice as they know what is working for our children and what is not working for our children and their quality of life I believe should also

043be considered by this District I'm also concerned that the parents and the students of this District were not given more consideration for example parents of young children who cannot stay home alone will now need to pay more in child care if the district were truly concerned for the well-being of all of our children their parents financial situation should be considered also high school students who need to work were not given any consideration how their lives might be negatively impacted not everyone in this District district is wealthy so to be told that everyone will just adjust is showing such a lack of concern and care for those in this District who are not in the same Financial situations I hope moving forward that we are given full transparency and open communication from this district and I

044hope that our extremely valuable teachers and the parents and students of this District are given more care and consideration and not just the wealthy and not just those with students who this does work for and not just for those parents and children who will just adjust to this with ease if we are a district that considers all of its children I hope that when the board makes its decisions moving forward that you consider the needs and lives and feelings of all of our number one district teachers parents and most of all students thank you thank you [Applause] Julie Dana Hensley hi my name is Dana Hensley my husband and I have four children two of whom you're going to hear from tonight I think it's pretty clear on the school start times that the community

045has spoken this is not a change that is wanted or needed and you need to put it to bed you need to understand that right off the bat this devastates student athlete by drastically impacting scheduling Mr Mia's comments during the webinar about sports practices simply shifting from 3 to5 to 4 to six is an outright lie if you believe what he said is true you're either woefully ignorant or choosing to ignore the truth second how could you even imagine that that would work Turf scheduling is so incredibly complex you have two Fields you have eight to nine teams that are competing for equal practice Time game time as it is students are on the field until 9 or 10 o'clock changing the start time of high school is going to put kids on the field

046until 11 or later and that directly violates promises that were made to Williamsville East families that live backing up to the Williamsville East Fields golf bowling hockey Unified sports teams they have limited practice time and location availability you can't simply push their practices and games later all golf matches is are at 4:00 Clarence par the late start District dismisses their entire golf team at 2:45 they have two to three matches a week from September to mid- October you're talking about students missing their ninth period class 14 to 21 times during the first academic quarter alone Beyond Turf scheduling other teams that don't use the turf aren't going to finish practice until 6:30 or later that takes away opportunities from high achieving student athletes this directly limits students abilities to participate in both Athletics and UB

047math volunteer work and working for pay it directly hinders those who are excelling stifling High achieving students isn't just bad for them it's bad for society we need these bright driven individuals to reach their full potential this policy does not support them it holds them back as for Senate Bill 26 31a that has been cited the reality is it's going nowhere I spent some time Friday and on Monday speaking with staffers from every education Senate education Committee Member bill is not on the agenda it's not going to be on the agenda or any calendar and one legislative director told me that this bill is as close to Dead on Arrival as it gets there's no State mandate coming from Albany you need to vote no and focus on pressing issues Williamsville North is short almost

04820 AIDS we don't have an absentee problem you can't waste time and energy and resources on a proposal that is going to take opportunities and money away from students the Mandate of the school is to educate and that's done by attracting and keeping the best possible staff with only so many hours in a day this proposal should not be your priority go back to your core mandate finally the health and well-being of children is ultimately the responsibility of parents including their sleep that's my job not yours I appreciate your concern but we have it covered [Applause] have Savannah Hensley good evening I'm Savannah Hensley I'm a junior at Williamsville North High School there are so many issues with changing the school start times but I'll highlight a few I am a student athlete myself with

049a job my hours are already limited to after my sport ends and ending our school day at 3:40 will push back my Athletics and therefore push back when I can start working it is New York State labor law that minors ages 14 to 15 can only work until 9:00 p.m. and 16 to 17 year olds can only work until 10 p.m. clearance has been brought up many times as a successful earlier starttime school however according to the US Census Bureau the median clearance household income is 121,000 and the median household income in Amherst where I live is 93,000 that's a difference of over $20,000 Clarence also has a period Zero from 7:30 to 8:30 where students can get exra help complete their Gym classes and prsh participating clubs during the virtual Forum the South principal

050voiced his desire to prevent clubs now in the afternoon from switching to morning Club s sessions with the new school times both of these advantages Aid Clarance in dealing with a later school start time the majority of students in Williamsville plan to pursue higher education myself included and for many of us paying for that education is our responsibility alone after school jobs provide us with an opportunity to save for college this time change will not create a significant change in the amount of sleep that student students will get pushing back the times also pushes back all of our clubs and sports we will still have the same amount of time from the end of one school to the beginning of the next to complete activities homework study work and eat this initiative will not be

051adding an hour to the day for students to increase their sleep students who will stay up late on their phones just as they do now students will still sleep in and Be Tardy but students won't have as many hours to work and as many opportunities to participate in athletics musical groups youth groups and clubs don't change the school start JS thank you thanks [Applause] snah L [Applause] Hunsley hello I am a school I am a student at William Old North High School I am also an athlete I do cross country indoor and outdoor track throughout my high school career and in my school time is I I froze you can read it you have it you can read it yeah yeah okay take your time not the clock you're good you're good one of the

052time one of the problems of school start times is that for every single School sport everything gets pushed back that cuts into everything else we get to do for the rest of the day from having other extracurricular activities to sleep to studying and everything else we get an hour less if this gets pushed back from what we currently have and in addition uh for the sport that I do uh indoor track uh we have Friday meets which we cannot do if this gets pushed back they go in into till around 8ish o00 and started around 4: and if we or five and and we can barely make it at this time and if we push it back further we we can't make it and then we have to start cancelling it or not being able

053to do it and every other thing that we have to do is delayed thank you thank you [Applause] Eli feldstein before I begin I would like to thank the board for their amazing work and Leadership so far this year I know I speak for everybody when I say that Us in the district appreciate the board's leadership and work I'm Eli feldstein and I'm a junior at Williams East over at school where has been going around about the district's plan to delay school start and end times and I've come to share perspectives I I've heard from students on this issue after I saw the initial presentation of the plan for delaying the school star times from the board committee I knew that parts of it would be deeply controversial with the student body so I made

054it my mission to get some kind of way for kids to voice their thoughts student to student I initially only spoke to some 20 or 25 students in my school before I realized just how high the percentage of students that would be opposed to this plan is I was a approached to get help to get signatures for a petition against the change in our school so me and a couple of other students went around the lunchroom when we were off class to present to students this initiative and gathered their thoughts on the changes in the couple of days in the week prior to this that we collected signatures 488 kids signed a little over half of our school student body far exceeding uh you know our expectations from our time and reach constraints all of

055them are here personally I was able to talk to about 200 or 250 of those students in a couple periods at the time and less than 10 of all those students were actually for those changes many complained to me about how late clubs or sports or their homework would end or how they would have to quit extracurriculars or where they they couldn't work certain jobs that they would need to help pay for college later on almost everybody had something to say regarding it as a district it seems these changes have appeared out of nowhere I truly wish we did educate kids more on the importance of good sleep hygiene and putting Electronics in such a way before going to sleep this would be quite simply uh simple for the to do and then go back

056and analyze and see if we had to make future changes and to speak a little on the maryv Val time change I found a quote from the uh superintendent of the district at the time while back they said they had many negative educational impacts that were felt mostly at the secondary level finally my most severe concern is that students and families don't even have a full year to adjust to these changes that have been proposed for a large change like this for the board to be voting on it now I think a lot of people would expect that the board would have started Gathering student and family opinions in a representative matter on this at the beginning of last year the focus group started late October of this year and the sign up for them

057was announced over the summer for only 21 days and I'm convinced that this impeded any chances of getting a representative group of students and parents on the focus groups worst is that the board may not even be voting on this issue until the next meeting leaving only six months for students and families to get adjusted to these changes no doubt this will exacerbate the negative reactions the district will receive and provide a much greater shock to families than is necessary than if we delayed this for another year or two so as my final statement I would like to ask the board on behalf of all the students that I know and go to school with each and every day to hold off on making this decision until more representative surveys can be conducted and families

058can be prepared for decision they know had their interests and ideas in minds and to let the voices of children and parents in this District speak more than studies that were conducted thousands of miles away thank you thank you El [Applause] we have three more lefts um it's been 30 minutes so we're going to continue the other um people that have signed up at our next um session well can't we extend this for 15 minutes by a vote may make a motion to extend it I make a motion to extend the uh public expression by an additional 15 minutes per board rules I second that only three more favor of there's more they should talk motion carries unanimously thank you madam president okay Suzanne Wagner please good evening everyone mental health is a priority we

059all recognize and yet the ongoing uncertainty surrounding school start times is creating unnecessary stress for high school students they are trying to balance academics extracurriculars Jobs and Family responsibilities while also facing the unknown the lack of a decision is already affecting their well-being I am not here to persuade you one way or another on the issue of school start times I am here to ask that you simply make a decision tonight Clarity is just as important as the decision itself students families and Educators need time to prepare for any changes and delaying this vote only adds to their stress and uncertainty if a vote is not taken tonight when will a decision be made is this issue being set aside for yet another year if not waiting any longer will not allow families enough time

060to adjust for the start of the next school year I respectfully urge you to take action and vote tonight our students deserve that consideration thank you thank you Cohen good evening I'm a mom of two students in Williamsville and I'm a school social worker so the topic of mental health is what I've been working on for 25 years so my kids went to Transit middle school and clubs and groups were before school so they were already there at 8:00 then they were there all day for school stayed after for sports drama club musicals and got home very late in high school the other night the panel said well kids will have clubs before school so then kids would be coming in high school at 8 o'clock which is only 15 minutes later than they already

061do then clubs and after school activities will happen later which then they cannot work they will not be able to do some fun things after school besides just homework and they will suffer socially emotionally elementary kids having worked in an elementary building for many many years they already don't go to bed early enough they come in they're sleepy they're tired getting them up earlier starting their day earlier will lead them to have more emotional outbursts and an overall decline in their social emotional well-being I'm asking the board why are we trying to change school start times instead of working with kids and their families on good sleep hygiene time management skills and healthy lifestyle choices those things will continue to have positive effects for all students and their families for years to come the way

062this proposal was rolled out felt that it was not forthcoming and to not give honest transparent communication to all in the community students who were asked to attend focused groups in the high school were vocal about their opposition to the change staff were not asked enough a community Forum was held but it was a virtual Forum that was run with pre-selected questions the chat was disabled and the raised hand function was disabled I'm not sure why are we listening to school experts from Colorado when we know it doesn't work and it was shown to be ineffective from a neighboring District in marville as a mom and an educator I Rely heavily on asking those around me what works and what doesn't and we already have that example thank you thank you Carmina prits sorry about

063[Laughter] that good evening my name is carita pritz I have a daughter who is a sophomore at Williamsville East and I just have a very specific point I wanted to make um was really interesting and these are all wonderful points that have been made um by the parent parents and students um my specific issue is with um the fact that East still doesn't have a lunch a designated lunch period And if we're talking about making a change to um the time um I feel like this has been a long-standing issue it's been brought up for over many years and I don't understand if we're talking about social and emotional well-being how we still haven't when considering a huge change like this considered the fact that Williamsville East does not have a designated Lunch Period many

064of those students um I know really fill their schedules some of them don't have any free periods and so if you're asking these students to come in later to go through all of their periods rush to their next period because I believe the Pastime has now been shortened to two minutes um and then go right into an activity or go right into um a sport um I just think that's going to create more stress and that doesn't consider something that has been an issue with parents for many years and I feel like to me that kind of just leaves a bad taste thinking that this has been something that's been talked about that's been an ongoing you know I don't want to say complaint but it's an ongoing issue and it wasn't addressed during such

065a time that seems to me would have been obvious to address it um I just personally will just share and I know everyone has their story my um yeah and and what happens in their house my daughter um right now I pick her up from school and she she does a sport in the fall it does a sport in the spring and when she's not doing sport for school she does a sport all year um that is the sport she trains for and um one of those is one that she does for school as well um now she has a about 30 minutes where I pick her up she comes home she takes a little power nap she gets changed she eats she's really hungry because her freeze during second period so she doesn't get

066a chance to eat until after school so she basically has a dinner then and then a dinner after her sport um now she would have to literally change in the car I'll have to I would have to bring a snack and it would be something rushed and I just don't feel like there's a need to do that um and that's just my personal experience and what I think could happen so um my thing was really the lunch at East that I wanted to mention thank you thanks for sharing that Lee Butler Lee Butler oh sorry well this was this was great I didn't think you were going to get to me um my name is Lee Butler I live on Chasewood Lane um here regarding the school uh starttime changes and in opposition to it

067um it seems like a good idea on the on the surface but then you have to realize that the high school kids don't exist in a vacuum so when you've got Afterschool sports or you've got a game that start like football games start at seven if they're going to start later all of a sudden their family their little you know if they got little brothers and sisters now your keeping those kids up later and compounding that by saying and you got to be at school earlier tomorrow so you got to keep in mind how it affects family Dynamics I'd also say to the kids that are doing uh after school in this case Sports um if you'd like to encourage a family dinner hour and you're going to have kids practicing till six o'clock or

068later when is that family dinner hour going to happen so you don't want to you don't really want to hurt those family Dynamics um also uh our experience now our kids have all graduated from Williamsville south and east um they had after school jobs um my two youngest worked at a nursing home in the kitchen they would have been very hardpressed to get to work or hold that job because dinner prep is at a certain time at a nursing home and if you don't get if you can't be there on time you can't have that job so I think you need to look at what you're doing to uh students that have outside jobs and the last issue was a little bit of a sore spot with us that live around the perimeter of Williams

069the East um and maybe I don't want to talk too much about all the details but there was a board meeting where it was pledged promised promised to the residents around Williamsville East High School that those lights would be off at 9:30 period end to discuss session so either the board's word means something or it doesn't and if you're going to have events that start later you're not going to keep your word but those lights are supposed to be off are supposed to be off at 9:30 and they have trouble meeting that sometimes so for those three reasons and all the other reasons that were expressed by other speakers I'd really urge you to deep six this is that a warning 30 seconds really deep six this uh this uh change in school times thanks

070very much thank you [Applause] Le yes that concludes our public expression Dr Brown Hall than want to say one thing um besides all the adult comments I really want to give a round of applause to all the students who had the courage to get up in front of a group of adults to really share their experiences their opinions and data so if we can just applaud those [Applause] students because that's how we Elevate student voice thank you very much absolutely I would like to move to amend our agenda so that item number 7A school start times occurs now before item number five and then we will continue with the remainder of the agenda is there a second Mr buan all in favor motion carries unanimously so we are now moving to item number seven school

071start times um just like all of our community members were given the opportunity this evening to share their views I would like to ensure that all of my board colleagues have the opportunity to speak on this issue so what I would like to propose is starting one by one going down the table and give each board member the opportunity to share their thoughts um Miss blinger would you be willing to start that please absolutely um first of all I'd like to thank everyone that showed up this evening and came to the podium and showing Support also those that have sent emails in I know we received over 600 emails from parents students and teachers and I have personally read all of them and I appreciate your concerns and the issues raised I think the committee

072now has the opportunity to look at those concerns and issues um when they are updating the the times um also looking at what the State Legislative has I think that gives us an opportunity too um to modify our times in line with the parents concern so we appreciate your time and and responding to the feedback thank you thank you Miss BL andure Mr Manna oh thank you I thought you were going alphabetical I'm going down the line thank you um around this might be the first you know round of comments that we all make tonight um but whenever we're done making the comments I'm G to make a motion to reject the uh um start uh the the the change of the start [Applause] time for a lot of reasons that you know the 1600

073comments that we received the on the uh District's web page the hundreds of uh emails we've received the hundreds of texts and comments at the grocery store we've received we all live in the community we all see everybody you know our Roots Run Deep in in in in this little uh room they call the Williamsville Central School District so um you know we've heard it I've heard it um this is a solution in search of a problem the change of the start time this district is the Envy of every School District in Western New York we can always do better but the proposed start time change is not the help the students need I think we could spend whatever money it would cost an additional Transportation on uh we could spend in the classrooms we

074could help address student mental health issues maybe smaller class sizes more access to mental health professionals maybe we could spend that money providing shuttle buses for modified Sports I think that's a better value it's the kind of change that makes a real difference so um again thank you for all your comments thank you for for you know shining a different perspective and we all have children or grandchildren in this District we've all gotten kids on the bus and been to their their sporting events um so we understand you're not talking to you know I'm speaking for myself you're not talking to people who don't haven't been through exactly what you're you're going through um so whenever the time arises I don't know what motions are going to take precedent but my motion will be again

075to reject the change of the start time and then if we need to reinvent this uh uh um then maybe that's a time to get more Community input to put a longer implementation time in there but for now I think it's time to put this uh issue to bed thank you Dr Spicer thank you um thank you we're all going to say thank you but I'm going to do it again um thank you to the community for your feedback um it's important that we all say it because we've read it as Miss blinger said we have taken this very seriously um we have read the research we have done our due dilig diligence and will continue to do our due diligence and thank you to my fellow board members for um the hard work that

076you've put in um I appreciate the community also because we have 30 day 30-day comment periods for a lot of different things so I do appreciate the fact that so many community members engag engaged in this particular comment period um and keeping in mind that there are 30-day comment periods for a lot of things it's always wonderful to hear voices and I EO what Dr Brown Hall said um I love to hear the student voice so I was thrilled to hear students tonight um I appreciated the virtual Forum in that it showed us something that we don't know and that we have not talked to folks that have done this change um so I appreciated seeing something from a different perspective Ive I am a parent of two children who are in this uh school

077district and are in our school buildings um so I'm coming at it from a parent perspective as well some of the things I took away from that virtual town hall is that um other school districts one of them Webster in particular recommended looking at each issue Athletics Transportation Child Care clubs all the things we've talked about tonight and drawing that out and spending some in-depth time having presentations done around each of those issues that depth of knowledge is what I'm seeking um and still feel like I am seeking that so I'm coming from the perspective of needing more information right now tonight um Sorry I took some notes so I would stay on track um and then one other piece that I took away from the virtual town hall is that some of these other

078districts actually dedicated professionals to Flushing out an athletic schedule in full de detail flushing out a transportation schedule in full detail those are pieces of information that I am looking for also um so thank you for the opportunity to speak and um thank you again to everybody uh here tonight and out in the cyber world as well thank you Dr Spicer Dr sing please um thank you in addition to what my colleagues have said earlier I uh I also want to thank all the community members who messaged me met and communicated their strong opinions at Social Gatherings and U any actually any Gathering and I like most of my board colleagues I have kids in the school district so I know firsthand when my daughter went through High School how sleep deprived she was I'm

079not disputing the signs that adolescence need more sleep but at the present time I I agree with Dr sorry Mr Mana that the way the proposal currently stands doesn't uh would not meet my approval there has to be changes if we going to go ahead with implementing uh modified start time it has to be Equitable to all students in our school district not just the high schoolers and and at the cost of the elementary school kids and I've done my own research and more than what was posted on the website and like what most community members said today the information regarding the benefits for elementary school kids is minimal like there's I mean there's no serious study to say it's beneficial to them as far as I could see and there have been two states

080I think Florida and California which have already implemented early start sorry delayed start time I think 8:30 for high schoolers but they haven't really gone into the mens for elementary school kids every school district is different and every school Community is different I think we need to spend more time to see what we need here come up with a better proposal and then we can decide to go ahead or not with that thanks thank you Dr Sing Mr Helen um thank you uh first of all thank you all the community this in my three years on the board this has been the most controversial issue coming up it even s s to my poker game and they were very vociferous in my poker game about how they felt which I thought was great um Dr

081Brown Holland I hope you don't mind said something to me that I think is very at he said to me is the juice worth the squeeze here and I don't know if it is I don't know if this is a problem that needs fixing and I think as a district we did not do a good enough job selling this did we didn't inform the the benefit we didn't have the sports schedules the busing schedules I think that in that sense the district failed in getting enough information to quiet the the concerns of parents and I tend to agree with uh Mr Mana I just don't think this is a problem that needs to be fixed at this moment now it may come from a state mandate and I don't think that we should jump the

082gun until the state maybe makes this decision for us because why change it twice and why go through this problem twice because their their proposal the bill that we could argue whether it's Dead on Arrival or not I I can't say that for sure but I I think that we we need more information we the the parents need more information the students need information and I think also the time frame for the switch would be too short um but I am not in favor I don't think of table lising this indefinitely and saying oh let's just push this down the road I think we need to make a decision and move on because what purpose does it serve and just get down the road and waiting for something else to happen I don't know but

083I think that there are many issues I I will say this though I work in a district that did change School times and I am a golf coach and I personally have not lost one match to Darkness in the three years has Chang so there are concerns but can it work possibly golf is just a really small microcosm there my bigger concern is actually the indoor sports in the fall and the win in the winter basketball and how many courts you have and things like that and practice times and actually at the unified bowling thing uh one of the coaches said to me you know unified usually gets the first court time and now you're pushing kids who are at most at risk further back in the day and changing their schedules even more dramatically

084and so that was something else that I was thinking about but I guess in the [Music] end that we just haven't done enough to alleviate their concerns and prove to me that this is a problem worth fixing I do not like Dr Singh I don't disagree with the science at least for the high school level I mean that's almost irrefutable I'm not a doctor but I have read it and it makes sense to me but to say that for middle school and the younger kids it's nebulous at best and I'm not sure that does a service to those kids so I just don't think we're in a position to okay this now or maybe even in the future unless again there's a state mandate and one other thing then I'll stop uh I have a

085sibling who lives in Florida where they mandated this in Florida almost every district is trying to get like an exception to get out of it because they just don't think they can make it work for busing or for staff whatever so not that Florida is our you know where we should look for Education I'm just giving that as a as an example so I I I tend to agree with uh Mr Man I I think we should take a vote and reject it and move on Mr buan Miss Fletch okay I really don't like having to go almost last because everything that I wanted to say pretty much um has been said too I I too agree Carrie I'm I was very happy with all of the feedback I think that is something that I

086hear that really bothers me is when people say you know decision's already made or nobody listens I mean this if this doesn't show that we listened we really did I mean I know I lost sleep I've been reading every email and and I I do have to say I went into the forum with an open mind and I was really I was waiting for something to wow me um but I just I can't get on board with it um I do have a sophomore I have a daughter that graduated I do have a sophomore right now and I do some days he does stay up late but that's my fault because if I fall asleep before him and I wake up I mean I just feel like that's my fault for not paying attention to

087what my my child is doing so I will take that that on me um again just from everything that was said with the busing and the sports and the elementary and I think mental health is extremely important and I would love to to use the money that this would have cost to to look at other areas to to help improve um those areas in the district so I I have to agree that I I can't get on board either [Applause] miss fles Mr Balia uh I as well want to thank all the community uh for their input comments um the people who stopped at my house at 9:30 to 10 at night um which that did happen um I had something written but I think many of you know who I am uh I as

088a single board member individual board member uh I extremely embarrassed uh I asked multiple questions in January's meeting to no avail there was not really answers provided um I have excuse me a wife and sister-in-law who work in marvale which I'd go home and hear the multiple problems that occurred in that school district including tardiness because kids had to stay home to watch their younger siblings um to hear that these are just anecdotes they're not they're people that live next to me with us down the road they're my parents who uh just yesterday or I'm sorry last week my mother got up to help get my preschool son to Country Parkway slipped on the ice and hit her head um 6:30 in the morning who what neighbors going to be up to see her fall

089um it's embarrassing to me because of how the was done um I want to thank the committee for their work I know they worked hard and and that's not the embarrassing part they they worked their butts off everyone knows that I don't think this was a malicious thing or wanted to pull the you know the wool over anyone's eyes but ultimately we should all be embarrassed as a board that we try to let this happen in a month um something like this takes time we heard it at the Forum um in terms of California as we looked up yes there is a state law that says California have their start times changed High School no later than 8:30 middle schoolers no l Middle School and Elementary no later than 8 AM meaning that all uh

090schools sorry yes um but in that law if we do recognize they need a zero period and they can apply for waivers um in such areas and this does not apply for Rural districts so that would include like you know where Josh alen's from um so there's just there's even if you bring up those States I reached out to a friend who I've known he actually went to Williamsville uh lived on the street that I grew up on MacArthur uh their District actually got a waiver in Florida to get out of the start times so there's there's instance in in Florida I don't know the percentage but he said I don't know of one area in Tampa Bay School District that had a change to the Earl uh to the later start time um so

091again I will not say the science is wrong I'm a teacher I believe in science and studies and you know again those studies are correct about adolescence and high schoolers um but I also teach in the Middle School uh and I can definitely say that if we're going to be in they should all be at similar times you know to start and now all of a sudden we're pushing Middle School back um another example my wife's home sick right now and I'm feel like a single parent But ultimately I was trying to get up this morning um I have to be out the door at a certain time my preschooler who I had helped my son yesterday with homework he wasn't understanding something and my pre preschooler is is kicking and screaming this morning even

092though he went to bed at 8:30 when he normally goes to bed at 8 it's a half hour um I don't think there's enough studies with the elementary age um um I I know that the Senate bill I too have very friends in very high places uh I don't know if it's Dead on Arrival but I will say that it won't happen for a while would be my guess so why don't we see what the state has in terms of guidelines before we jump uh the gun I also asked in January when about Transportation prices I believe and I could ask again it was around $700,000 increase 600,000 some something around there um you know that that was a concern of mine now then and it is now um could that be hiring more behavioral

093specialists for for special could that be uh maybe it's using that money towards more studies on how we can make it work for school times later on um year two three years down the line um I I just don't think at this time with the public feedback and the fact that I had concerns before that weren't really answered um I felt embarrassed by that and I know I keep saying that but um I want to make a decision with all the information possible and I feel like I'm getting like 10% of the information so ultimately I would have seconded Mr mana's um motion whenever he does it uh do I say this shouldn't happen in the future no and I've had discussions with people that I believe it should but if we're teaching our kids

094to do things right make uh changes the right way and go about it the right way and being transparent I think they should see it fully and honestly and I don't think we did that um so that's kind of where I stand thank you Mr Balia pin I just want to again say thank you to to everyone as well um I'm gonna back up just a bit because it has come up so many times why are we doing this um and the why is because we've been asked to we've been asked over and over again by students and parents to look at a later start time so so that's that's the why and that that's why we as a school district decided to do this um I said last month when we that I was

095anxious to see the comments and the feedback that we would get and I am and I was and I wanted to see that feedback to know what are the questions what are the concerns what are the answers that we have to have before we can can move forward on anything like this I think it is important that we do validate the science that we do provide the best opportunities for our students I sit here at every board meeting with our mission and belief statements in in front of me and the first very first belief statement is students are our first priority and students will always be our first priority but we have to find a way and I as well I think this is important we have to do it right and I we're not

096there yet so I I would definitely like to see us do it right um to spend the time to get all the answers that we need to make something that is very equ Equitable and not a burden on anyone um and meet the needs of all of our students and if that means we need to push it off a year or so then that's what we should do thank you Miss Pand Dr Brown Hall can you maybe uh address some of the comments that have been made thus far would you mind doing that can I do it after you oh sure absolutely I will go next then so again I would like to thank all of the community for coming out tonight I would like to thank you for speaking during public expression um sending

097all your emails all through the the form I read every single comment and have also lost a lot of sleep over this decision in the past month really wanting to again because I I was the public face of this I came out saying that I was in support of the later High School start times and honestly I still am in support of later High School start times I believe that the science supports later Heart High School start times I also hear the many concerns that were shared tonight and through the other forums um that maybe we don't have the best plan for our district at this time um personally what I would propose and I know Mr Mana stated something different um I would propose that we send this back to committee not necess neily

098the school start times committee who already did enormous amounts of work and I do appreciate all those involved in that I would uh have a committee of Administrators who could look at all of the logistical information and provide some more of the information like Dr Spicer was uh speaking to um so that we could ensure that before we make any decision we know all of the information Mr Balia ALS o spoke to that as well and then I would also I know that there is no way if we do that at this time that it would be ready for implementation in the 2025 26 school year so my suggestion would be to delay it at least till 2026 27 so those are my thoughts on the matter again I think you heard from everyone we

099we appreciate the community feedback we're hearing you and Dr bronal would you like to speak now thank you very much thank you very much board president and all board members for their input and all for community members for the 1,600 um replies that we got the endless number of emails that we got and I I want to adjust a few things because it was stated several times that this was a solution in search of a problem the board and the superintendent don't go looking for Solutions in search of a problem the reason this was brought up and the timeline was given it was started in 2324 when I arrived in the district at listening tours it was brought up at Community forums it was brought up the board had received emails and letters in the

100past about school start times so when I first started in 2021 there are other items that we were working on at the time a strategic plan A diversity Equity inclusion plan there's been many of things and so we developed a timeline beginning in 3 24 where a committee would form look at the research and then move from there so it wasn't us just saying let's do this this was something as late as the March 2024 Community form where parents asked about us exploring later school start times and that's what we were in the process of doing so when things are brought to us from the community for example two years ago at a community Forum the idea was brought up about how do we get more cultural and religious holidays identified on the school calendar

101that have been brought to the board several times a Dei calendar committee what subcommittee was formed those recommendations were then presented to the board the same thing happened here every time recommendations are presented to the board we Institute a comment period a 30-day comment period And the reason we do that is to get Community input at that time now I get it right 23 to 24 was the research year 2425 was the development year we presented at the January meeting had a month for comment and then looked at a fall implementation it wasn't a one-month implementation I never want board members my job as a superintendent is to make sure that the board does not operate on fragile knowledge so I never want board to feel embarrassed because their questions weren't answered or to feel

102that they don't have enough information to make a decision that is my job as a superintendent to make sure the board has enough information to make a decision what I never like doing is saying no many times it may be a not yet and again that is for the board to decide if there comes a time where the committee must go back in the future and revisit later School start times we have a basis already of what the community was not in support of so the committee doesn't need to go down that same road again I appreciate the amount of public involvement many districts don't get this level of public involvement in anything that they do I appreciate the level of public involvement I appreciate the level of Board of Education involvement in a decision

103of this magnitude and this is a huge decision what I would do though is ask that you look at our data deep because I know that we are a higher performing we're the highest performing School District it's not the case for all of our students when we talk about absenteeism issues and you look at our 2023 and 2324 attendance reports that are in this board packet you will see that especially at the high school level our chronic absenteeism is increasing when you look at our graduation rates not just for all of our students but for some of our subgroups we do have issues there that we need to rectify now many times we say can this be improved by teaching better sleep habits or by removing cell phones from kids at night I don't think

104it's a either or I think it's a both end and if the community in the board is saying this may not be the time that will be the board's decision right and that is informed by what they have from the community if theard says delay this a couple of years see where it goes because other states are gaining traction and more work is being done we can do that also but again it'll be a board decision but I wanted to make sure prior to any decision being made that we do all we can to educate our public and provide information that is what we try to do every step of the way if we haven't done a good enough job in some of the particulars then that fault is on the district ultimately me as

105a superintendent and I'll take that blame and we will work together in the future whenever this comes up again to realize what Mis missteps we made and how to do it better but ultimately we will support whatever decision is made by the Board of Education this evening and then we'll be on to the next topic that we have to tackle as a district as some community members laid out this evening so thank you very much thank you Dr BR house I will open it up to discussion is there any discussion at this time I like to make a motion before you make the motion can I see if anyone has anything they would like to discuss is that okay with you well I think sure Mr Balia we we keep saying uh so I also

106have the mission statements and our beliefs right so Williams the mission State Williamsville School Central School District is committed to educational Excellence that empowers all students to develop their unique potential and Thrive as Learners citizens and learn uh leaders in a diverse Global community that what gets me is all students we are not thinking of all students with a time change I will keep going back to your uh elementary students and your fifth and sixth graders in Middle School um whereas a lot of the mental health issues as I teach seventh grade occur about the start of end of fourth grade fifth grade A as as kids start to change and and and I've seen it myself and a lot of the mental health issues begin then and then are just compounded as they get

107older um and that's my dilemma if it's our mission state says all students we are not doing that in these studies in this time change um and I guess my question would be is as I said before I'd be on voting you know Mr Mana said a motion to vote it down but it I also said this I don't dat the science is wrong I just I I my fear is if we just kind of say we're going to table for a year later do all these studies look through all the data I just fear it's it's going to be rushed again or something's going to come up where I just I think it needs a couple years or four years or like what the state says watch what they say first before you actually

108make changes that's that's why I would go with what Mr Mana said can I just just if I may say something just thank you uh and Dr bronal you make excellent points and I agree you know it's it's to me I'm gonna say no not yet I'm gonna say go back and try again and I think the Board needs to have more of an input now that the committee if there is a future committee on this and I think there should be doesn't have to throw away all the information they've received over the past year or so they can build on that um but I don't think the community needs the sort of Damocles hanging over their head as to like when this community is gonna spring another one month surprise on people and when

109Mr Balia says he was embarrassed you know I Echo that and I'm angry and I'm sure the committee the community is angry about the fast roll out now I'm going to tell you something blame me I made these decisions I voted on this timeline shame on me and I promise if it comes up again we're going to do it better but I'm still going to when it's time make the motion to reject the committee's recommendation I think the community needs to put this get this bad taste out of their mouth that I put in there and start over again see if we can do it better go ahead Dr Brownell and I I appreciate that Mr Mana but I will again say this I don't want you you or anyone depending on what happens this

110evening to think that the committee is waiting around waiting to pounce right on their next opportunity to put something forward that will not be the case it will when it does occur again in the future whenever that may be it will be board initiated okay are there other comments at this time Mr buan I know you want to say something go ahead I guess I do have a question because we you know we talk about The Chronic absenteeism and I guess I'm just wondering what exactly does that mean like does one to three minutes or one to five minutes like because I know all of that is that's tardiness absenteeism and chronic absenteeism as described in the report is when students have missed 10% or more of the school days so for example school day

111is 100 80 days if students are absent more than 18 days they're considered chronically absent and if you look at the reports over the last couple of years our students at the high school level we have increased chronic absenteeism I and just to add to that no that's fine I I have the data here from in 2023 2024 18.74% of our high schoolers were chronically absent meaning they missed 18 or more days of school and I I did the state was setting a goal originally of all sub subgroups of students having 5% or less chronically absent students our high schoolers at 18.74% f&t rates have actually increased since we went to a later start time and I teach a first period the same five kids who are late right when we had the early start

112time are the same five kids or six kids who are [Applause] late couldn't agree more with Mr Man I I think that we just have to make a decision I know it's a rare thing right um could agree more we I think we just have to make a decision and go forward because unless we have a state mandate I'm not sure this is worth fixing but I do want to recognize there is a group of people out there who may not be as vocal as the people here or online that are in favor of this and that I I don't want them to be think that we haven't heard them too there are people that we have that have supported this the numbers are not as vast as that are against it but I think

113it's important to recognize that are people in the district who are in favor of this and just may not be as vocal um but again I have to agree with Mr Mana we I I don't think we should have this you know knife hanging above us waiting to like spring on this community and again if we do we have to have if if if the board chooses to do it and like sen a badge committee I think there have to be action steps that have to be done along the way it just can't be this thing waiting in the dark it has to be like oh we're going to do this this is and this to bring it to the community and say hey we have the sports schedule we have the busing schedule would

114how it would look like Oh you mean like develop a timeline well yeah timeline yeah like we had yeah okay so so I understand the timeline no no no I'm just saying I just want to make sure because what we can do is communicate it better yeah I hear that and I think I hear that I think that that's where and and I don't want to be repetitive but that's where we fell down because our job as a district is to educate the people to say hey this is why we're doing this and ab andc are in place we don't have AB andc in place right now I just want to a comment if I may Dr Spicer sorry um I I do um I stand by my earlier statement of the information that I

115still need um I do also want to give voice to um that we need to represent all students in this district and when we're talking about mental health when we're talking about absenteeism tardiness and school refusal that is often a very silent population because they are struggling to navigate those those things so to to the voices of people who either supported or are just struggling silently because they're just trying to get through day today um those folks are out there and um I've had many conversations with them so I stand by that what everyone is saying that we I don't have the information that I need to vote on something but I wouldn't be sitting in the seat if I wasn't representing all students and and that needs to be said out loud thank you

116Mr bis and I agree with that I actually taught in an alternative school that was uh actually converted into an it was originally an alternative high uh hallway to a high school they included middle schoolers because of that um I taught kids who had chronic tardiness chronic absenteeism mental health issues and what we ended up doing was it was an offset of one of the high schools the high school and it's they still got to go to lunch in the cafeteria with the with the pop you know like the rest of their friends but then their start times they altered the schedule where they didn't have to be in school till 9:30 they were in smaller classrooms of like eight to 10 kids and it actually produced and help things too so I do want

117to say that I when I say all students I do think of them as well I that's my point there's alternative things we could be looking at at other districts in this area that did things like that that could help the school start time and including helping that um chronic absenteeism student or uh School hesitant or you know not hesitant I'm sorry uh refusal refusal it's just not it's not it's not humorous is is my point I'm not making it no I know you're not I I totally agree with you I I that's why I wanted to say when I say all students I only said elementary middle school but I do think of them as well those are those studies that I think should be done before we're just in you know placing it

118upon the community um that's that's all I I didn't want you to think uh that no I appreciate the dialogue Dr sing I mean I want to thank the committee for spending so much time coming up with these recommendations but in my opinion I think it was the transportation that ended up end up uh with coming up with these times for Elementary and Middle School uh start time and I don't know if we'll ever find an optimal transportation schedule without spending too much money that will be Equitable to all students it seems like a big task for our school district I mean unless we have a state mandate that forces us to do it I really don't see this happening unless we willing to spend money and maybe some other resources to it okay just

119one last thing I I would like to say was there anyone else I didn't see anyone else to okay so I would like to say again I would like to consider sending this back to a committee not the original school start times committee but a committee to look at adjusting the start times so that our elementary school days are not starting as early as 7:50 as they currently are that are middle and um the if legislation went through as in other states it would likely be Elementary no earlier than 8: a.m. Middle High School no earlier then 8:30 a.m. adjusting our End Elementary time so that they wouldn't be let out any earlier than they currently are which is 2:15 for the for the earlier release elementary schools and that high school would release no

120later than 3:30 again moving everything up um and in doing that um preparing and evaluating a transportation survey so that we could look to see what exact start times we could um come up with that would be within those guidelines um and then also looking at the other pieces that we're discussed tonight in terms of athletic schedules and ensuring that there's CH appropriate child care where needed for the community um Etc so that is where I land with this it sounds like we have differing opinions here which is well let's let's I mean to me I me I'm going to make the motion to reject the I will say this though before you do that we will still be time I've Tred to shoehorn the thing I know no no no no I I know

121I know you're you're going to get your moment I promise I would like to say I'm along I understand and my understanding is with Robert and I know we don't follow Robert's Rules exactly but with parliamentary procedure you can't make a motion to reject you have to make a motion in favor of something and then vote no in favor of rejecting can I say no you take I I I think making put fine a point in Roberts of orders we reject bids okay um I I think it if if if you mean you you you you run the meeting Madame President and if you want to say I cannot make that motion I'm just saying that typically emotion is in the in the affirmative not How would how would one phrase rejection in the affir

122that's what I'm trying to figure out in my head right now half heads together my half and your one while you do that I will say we are going to still do the transportation study only to be more efficient with our bus rout so that piece was not I don't want to conflate the two and that was not tied to this he'll be doing that what what what president uh kmir bagner said is perfect yeah you would table in definitely and I don't want to table definitely well hold on the what was presented to the community in January was a board to vote on the recommendation okay that was the verb and if you looked at our FAQs on the on the school on the District web page it said action to be taken at

123the February 11th meeting so the motion would be to Pro to um approve no you approve the proposal as presented accept accept the proposal what what accept I think motion to accept yes the proposal as presented and then you vote and then you vote you vote whatever way you want somebody somebody's going to make the the motion to accept the proposal and then if the majority votes against accepting it is then rejected I know that anyone at the table wants to make a motion well if there's no motion then it there's not then it's fails AC so you would call for a motion is there a motion to accept is there a motion to accept the recommendation there was there wasn't a motion on the table but you're the as the president you should you

124maybe you want to say is there a motion that way we can sure absolutely absolutely so I see what you're asking me I'm sorry I wasn't understand and if nobody seconds it then it dies may I have a motion to accept the school start times proposal as presented in our agenda item number 7A no motion guys if nobody seconds so there was there was no motion fails second so the motion fails you found a found the right way to do it that's the right way to do it okay and now we can move on with our agenda again I have question I do too I have well we're let's moving on Mr Bo no no I just question of procedure or a question on the procedure yeah on the procedure I just want to know

125what that that means that this is now dead right correct make sure okay thank you that all okay confing president kmir bner is right you have to have an affirmative if there's no second then the motion fails either by no second or by a majority voting against it no motion we're all good okay now we can we can our agenda because we have a lot to get through and it is 8:45 Okay so may I have a motion to recess the regular board meeting to conduct our budget work session miss pullan miss Binger all in favor motion carries unanimously I call the budget work session to order Dr Brown Hall and Mr Kelly I turn it over to you for our budget development report and presentation thank you very much board president I'm going to

126turn it over in the um appreciation of time I'm going to turn it over right to assistant superintendent of Finance Mr Kelly and he can go through the presentation great if we can get the presentation up we'll uh spend a few minutes and talk about the budget development process um I want to just reiterate that this is a process that started uh a while ago and in January we had our first presentation about the upcoming fiscal year in school year budget this is a continuation of that budget discussion and budget development process so if we can move to the first yes uh first slide here this is our program continuation slide at the last meeting we brought this slide up to folks and to the board and to the community uh and began our discussion

127that was our initial sort of uh development of this and what it would take to continue the services that we are currently providing in the district at that meeting in January we had total cost increases of $654,500 31,37 and you may be asking me well what is prompting those cost increases recently the district met with ar1 bosies and the district now estimates that our total Bose's cost will increase $545,500 these increases include 20 additional students over what we have in the current fiscal year for occupational education as well as annual cost increases so we meet with bosis bosis develops what it's going to charge districts on an annual basis and they share that with us and they say well our costs are increasing 8% that's just an example and you have this many more students

128that are going to participate in our occupational education programs therefore these are your projected costs for next school year so we've added those additional costs based on those conversations and that we've had with the with our local bosis um I should note that the Bose budget is not finalized and that more changes are possible we we will finalize as a district the Bose's budget in March so next month uh at this point the bosies I'm sorry the District budget increases in total these include all of the things that we talked at the last meeting as well as you know the health insurance increases uh the bus transportation increases and the employee salary increases total 11,7 77,4 this represents an increase of 5.06% over the current Year's [Music] budget this next slide uh a very critical

129component of our budget development this is the tax cap Levy uh on this slide we always start with what the current year's tax cap Levy is so many of you will recall that for our current Year's budget that Levy was set at 144 mil1 100,000 the district has a growth factor of one the gross growth factor is determined by the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance you'll see that on that second line on this slide next we have the Consumer Price Index which is factored in this is capped at 2% and you'll notice in the margin the consu we have the Consumer Price Index U again this comes from the New York State Department of State moving further down below we see the districts available carry over this totals 1, 154,000 and this

130is from last year dollars that we didn't capture last year that we've carried forward into this year finally we see the proposed tax cap Levy of 48,8 45,2 this represents an increase of 3.29% over last year I should note this is a preliminary tax Gap Levy and the budget's not F finalized last year we had a preliminary tax cap Levy and it ended up coming down a little bit compared to where we set it at the February meeting uh that's to be determined for the upcoming year I just want to point that out and give po give folks a little bit of context in terms of the budget development next up we have our Revenue budget um I'm happy to report that state aid revenues are up nearly 7.4 million from the current year this

131is a pretty healthy increase and I think as a district uh we should be happy about that again these these state aid numbers are not finalized and there could be potential changes further down the road uh Transportation Foundation Aid and building Aid saw the largest increase for the district moving down below state aid our pilot uh income is down slightly from where we are this year as our sales tax and interest income these are projections based on what we see in the current environment these will be finalized as we continue down the budget development process but where we stand today uh we're budgeting both sales tax and in interest income down somewhat from where we had them for the current year um next up we have our fund balance last year for the current fisal

132year we budgeted $3 million in fund balance for the proposed budget where we stand today we've budgeted $2.5 million in fund balance for next year's budget the the property tax levy comes next again I've already mentioned that that's $1 148.8kg SCH 242,656 below that you'll see total expenses which equal 244 m517 again we always want to present the district and the Board of Education a balanced budget at this point in time our budget shows a deficit of about $22.2 million that means we have more work to do as a district we're going to have to refine our Revenue numbers we're going to have to refine our expense numbers and close that Gap as we continue down this process of developing the budget but as of today based on our Revenue numbers where they stand and

133our expense numbers where they stand we're showing a $2.2 million deficit that we have more work to do I want to note one important factor when we're looking at this deficit our retirements that we're we're sort of talking about today and we'll know more next month are not factored in here and when we factor in those retirements we do expect that there will be savings and that our expenses will come down and that will help us close that budget Gap can I just while we're still on this page I just want to mention because the building Aid and transportation Aid we have seen greater increases and those are reimbursable Aid category from our expenses in the prior year so we all know we entered into a new sta contract our transportation increase um expenses increased

134and our building Aid we completed our um security project and that's where the reimbursable Aid comes from and that's why the increase in our building Aid thanks so much for pointing that out I really do appreciate the context one okay on the next slide we sort of have a summary of where we stand today we know our working budget totals 244 mil5 2017,18 per. our tax cap is currently set at 148 m845 213 this is a 3.29% increase our New York state aid increase right now stands at almost $7.4 million our current working budget deficit is that $2.2 million that I referenced as I mentioned a moment ago retirements are not included in this working budget and the budget is a work in progress we have more work to do we're working at our Bose

135budget that's going to be one of our next major pushes we'll refine our cost there we're looking for potential Savings in the Bose budget for next year as well we're working with our uh special education department our instru ruction Department our technology department on what those costs will be and then we'll finalize that for the district uh I'm excited I think we're gonna have a great budget for the district and at with that I I'll turn it back over to the superintendant the board president to see if anybody has any questions um on the budget thank you very much Mr Kelly Mr Mana Dr s no brownall you can correct me if I'm wrong but I think we had some revenues coming in the previous budget from online gambling as well well no well we

136didn't that was through the governor's office right through the governor's office and it was a surprise to school districts across the state about that online gambling and the amount of money that was uh earmarked in that category but that's not something we can expect every year right no okay no Mr Mana well I mean what you say Mr Mana I've been betting you can expect a lot so I have a question Mr Kelly on on the pilot okay uh the payment of taxes I'm sure you I'm referring to so are is it true that we're $429,000 less than what we anticipated and my question is H how could that be so far off because I would assume that the pilots are spelled out we know what they are we know what they're going to bring

137in yeah so so the pilots change every year in in it for folks that don't know the way Pilots work there's an agreement made and it comes to the district and it's over a set period of time over a number of years so every year some Pilots may fall off as they sort of expire if you will and other new pilots come on board which may not be the same dollar values that we had in the prior Pilots so that's where the variant come froms with our pilots and what we're seeing right now but still you you would expect that that you that you'll be able to narrow down that number because you know which ones are coming off and you know that value so what you don't know is the ones are GNA come

138on in between we get not criticizing at all what what happens is the town sends us a report every year we keep very very detailed records of the pilots and over the course of the year we update them and this is what the revenue for the pilots is projecting for next year that's what you're seeing thank you and and I asked in um November of last year what the cost of the district is for those Pilots that you know because every every time um an entity gets a tax break that means you know a dollar less taxes is coming out of their pocket and a dollar more is coming out of your pocket so I think the answer I had what for 24 and 25 was the district has been deprived of $488,000 because of

139those Pilots which is not a small amount right yeah and I do remember you asking the question I know we provided that I I really wish my memory is good enough to tell you exactly what that might thank you Mr Kelly Mr buan no it's sorry here's my question if we were relying only on retirements to close the gap of the budget what number would that be to make a balanced budget J can you tell me that or is that I don't know that off the top of my had because right now I think you know as part of the agenda for the Personnel we have somewhere in the neighborhood about 25 retirements that are on there but these are the folks that I believe as I understand it are eligible for the retirement in

140ctive as well and we're going to have possibly another group of employees that will come forward for next month and folks that would not necessarily be eligible for that retirement in s up so that will potentially add additional numbers to that so it would really be guess word for me to speculate on that right now we we want to also stress especially when it comes to teacher retiring ments because it's not as it used to be right you retire someone at TOP Step you hire someone at the first step well we have to pay the retirement incentive so that comes out of any savings and it's very rare nowadays that you're hiring someone at First Step because of the teacher shortage we're actually recruiting teachers from other districts that are coming in with a significant

141amount of teaching so they're not starting next step one so that change that Delta is getting increasing smaller every year for each retirement that makes sense Mr bcal um I just add a comment and a question uh my first year I remember being on the board God a long time ago now um I saw a big deficit and I I asked questions about losing services and teachers and classes and things like that I just want to say um you know Dr braon Hall came on and has done a wonderful job Mr matki has and I know Mr Kelly as well is continuing that Trend uh Williamsville is is a district that continues to truly work as hard as they can to get a budget in line and provide what our students need and deserve um

142so when you see you know I know family members would see you know $2 million budget oh my god there going to be Cuts or this or that you guys work extremely hard to make sure there's no cuts to services classes teachers Etc um and I know that Gap will you know eventually you know be narrowed down so I just you know compliment you all on that work I guess my question question is and you might not be able to answer this in terms of the Rockefeller I know we had information prior uh in other uh board meetings but is there any other word on exactly how that's gonna I mean was there I know she came out with P because I know we're considered wealthier district and that's my worry is is a lot

143of the findings are they're going to take money from the wealthier districts and I I I guess it's not even this year's budget is more down the line well how they're going to do finan foundational Aid I'm sorry and we don't know down the line yet but the governor did take some of the recommendations some of the ones and she did Implement them this year the the beauty of the Rockefeller uh report is that she is able they they did not develop a New Foundation 8 formula the governor is able to take what recommendation she felt would benefit school districts and some benefited some school districts some didn't so even in our region some um districts didn't um have as high a percentage as they need right I heard from one superintendent their percentage increase

144won't even cover their um increased health insurance costs so it was different from for every District how the pieces of the Rockefeller Institute recommendations that were implemented impact each district so we again going back to looking at our increase in Aid it really came down to yes we did get a little bit more in Foundation aid but because of our transportation Aid and our building Aid that really gave us a significant bump are there any other questions regarding the budget I just wanted to make one quick comment on Friday I attended the nisba capital conference and one of the items that they mentioned that was not included in the governor's executive budget proposal was the Bose aable salary cap what I did not know I knew the current cap was $30,000 that was set in

1451992 which I did not know and they talked about how many more students are accessing the Bose's uh Career and Technical education occupational Services um areas and how because this cap is set so low districts are bearing that cost so I just wanted to point out there there uh is group organization um nisba being one of them and other educational conference board groups that are advocating for fully increasing to uh the actual average current median salary is around $84,000 to so to increase it to the current level or if not to plan a phase in so that is on the table hopefully we can get that through the legislation so just wanted that comment anything else okay we will now have our public forum for the 2025 2026 budget only anyone wishing to address the

146board regarding the budget may approach the podium at this time there is someone approaching the podium from back yes from the back welcome and when you arrive at the podium could you please state your name for the record oh sure James Hanley uh 51 stable run um in East Hurst uh just a question on this budget process you know if I look at what the budget allotment is going to be or I should say estimates going to be for this year or for the coming school year it's based off of the old school year and then looks at the Del Deltas expected Deltas so my question is for this school year there is this uh status report and if I'm reading this right um the projected um budget was well around $234 million but it

147seems like there's like 39 that may not be spent is that correct can you L at the 39 I guess that's what I'm I'm trying to read so what it shows is that um you have it now so I can't really I what I recall is at the end of December 83 million has been spent for this school year so far and then there's an expected maybe 103 or something like that expected for the rest of the school year leaving 30 roughly $39 million not expected to be spent and so if this next year's school year is sort of based on this year shouldn't you be taking that into account basically is my question so so what I would say about a lot of these numbers here that that 38 million a lot of these

148are are um reserves and so some of this money is in reserves a lot of is in capital reserves some of which we're going to be spending for our AC project which is really ramping up now and the board uh approved the spending for that which will use some of these reserves for the project coming out as you may know um that project in total is about $87 million so it's a huge cost to the district fortunately we're in a a pretty strong position with our reserves to uh fund that project over the next several years and that's where you'll see some of these monies will be drawn upon for the AC project I hope that answers your question I'm not sure but I guess I'll just get myself more familiar with these these certainly

149happy to have a conversation with you offline too if you you know ever want to call my office we could certainly we could sit down or we could you know have a conversation you know and talk more about this and kind of the way these reserves work for the district because a lot of people I know would look at that and say boy that's an awful lot of money how come you know we have that but there there's certain things that happen and we're you know authorized as a district to have so much in reserves in different areas and we try to meet all of the ratios with all our Reserve accounts okay yeah I'd look forward to trying to sit down with you sometime pleas but you can have your form [Laughter] back thank

150you for so much for your question um is there anyone else that would like to speak regarding the budget at this time okay may have a motion to adjourn the budget work session and return to the regular meeting Dr SP Spicer and Dr Singh all in favor motion carries unanimously Dr Brown Hall turn it over to you for your superintendence report items 68 through 60 wow it's a lot tonight so thank you very much board president so we'll start with our community update for February 11 2025 first slide we are going to skip M our second slide deals with the cell phone policy so as many of you know Governor Kathy hokel announced her proposal for distraction free learning environment so that proposal is something that all districts are going to have to comply with

151by August 1 2025 so no internet enabled devices allowed to be used during the school day we have to provide a plan to the state by August 1st for implementation by September 1st so principal Andrew Bowen is leading the distraction free committee and we thank him for his anticipated work with that a notice will be sent to families and students or has been on February 10th for their interest and so they can send the interest form by February 14th if they' like to be considered to serve on this committee administrators and teachers will also be on the committee zero eyes I just do want to say that we are working with zero eyes and the district is now utilizing zero eyes technology as an adct security enhancement so we're always looking out for the Safety

152and Security of our buildings and so by having zero eyes present present in our buildings that adds to it it uses artificial intelligence to detect guns and alerts law enforcement and District school building officials within seconds so that's an added layer modified flag football this is great news we were the recipients of one of the grants from the Buffalo Bills so the mill Williamsville South will receive the grant for modified flag football in the spring it is a $3,000 grant for flag football equipment and an opportunity to participate in coach and player training events at the Buffalo Bills facilities so this is huge and this is great for our district PTSA Council scholarship so the PTSA SC council is offering 12 $1,000 scholarships all students enrolled in Williamsville high school for a minimum of one

153full year and will graduate from Williamsville High School in 2025 are eligible the application can be found by clicking that link in the community update and the deadline for applications is April 1 game day with the APD very similar the Amherst Police Department we appreciate them for partnering with us they have done this in years past during midwinter break so the game day with APD will be Thursday February 20th from 11:00 a.m. to 1: p.m at Transit Middle School all ages are welcome parents must stay meet with officers and play games so this is a really familyfriendly event so we thank the Amherst police department for partnering with that Williamsville Central School District UB Spirit day so show your school spirit on Saturday March 1st for the UB Bulls women's and men's basketball double header

154so the two o'clock game is a women's game the 4:30 game is is the men's game so the women are playing Eastern Michigan the men are playing Toledo students and faculty and staff are free additional tickets for friends and family are discounted at only $10 per seat a ticket will get participants into both games of the double header tickets can be secured by clicking on this link in the community update we are proud to celebrate Black History Month this month and so we do have individuals of significance listed on our website and remember there will be no school on Monday February 17th to celebrate President's Day and then the rest of that week is our midwinter recess we are going to uh begin partnering with the Williamsville Education Foundation so uh board member blinger is

155a liaison to the Williamsville Education Foundation and I spoke with her and Nick filipowski the Williamsville Education Foundation has been for a long time um trying to figure out how we can begin a Williamsville Alumni Association the first step in doing so is to actually collect information from alumni so we have a link here for East alumni North alumni and South alumni we do need to adjust the form though ni because I I want to make sure we indicate if individuals who are submitting their information are willing to serve as an executive member of the alumni committees and so they can just click a Bots if they're interested so William High School prior to 1967 that's that's specific to South correct so I encourage you if you know someone friends and family please click on

156the link and submit your information so we can begin to build the database for an eventual eventual Williamsville Alumni Association and then we will have separate alumni associations at East North and South alumni associations do contribute a great deal to the workings of a school district and their specific high schools the AIT Community update for February 11th 2025 any questions board members yes had a question um I just thought important to underscore the PTSA Council scholarship at least two scholarships go to each of the high schools and then the rest of the the difference there's 12 in total so each of the high schools get two and then the applicants get the rest um I think that's important because I know they're always trying to drive more applicants to that scholarship so I just wanted

157to good underscore your point Thank you and that's a considerable amount yes $1,000 that ain't no chump change absolutely Dr Singh no I just wanted to thank you for creating the alumni it's a great networking opportunity for all our students absolutely it'll go long way thanks yeah and we're still again this is still in the infancy we're talking with the Williams Education Foundation about what that will look like because we're looking at maybe having um an alumni coordinator at each school but that's something the Williams Education Foundation will work with us with on how that position will be funded so we're still in conversations and um with board member blinger being the liaison we can have conversations too on the district end thanks absolutely any other questions we're gonna move right to 6B which is

158the review draft of the 2526 student calendar so that is in the board packet for individuals to please review um you will see that this year again we did get feedback when I visited many of the PTA PTSA meetings um but this year Erie wosi the JMT develop calendar has two weeks off at winter recess so other school districts in our region I know last year was just um ourselves and I believe Alden but many more schools because of the way the days fall we'll have um the two weeks off at at the winter recess can I ask a question Mr um um I I guess I I want to see if we can add Russia Shana to uh the calendar as a day off and because I noticed that the Lunar New Year does

159not fall during the school year it would be the same at least during the school week it would be the same amount of days as this year for these kind of holidays and I would also I guess make a motion to push it back to the committee to reconsider to add Russia Shana and to include Russia Shana and yam Kipper as days that we recognize as days off from Williamsville schools so is that the that's the appropriate way to do that correct right so the Dei calendar subcommittee is a subcommittee that presented the recommendations to the board last year based on um uh legislative items that were sent through the state never made it to the governor's desk but that would be the correct way to do it but I will say that it would

160not be the same as this year it would be reducing the um calendar by one day reducing the number of snow days I just want to make that clarification so do I make that motion you can make that motion to have that recommendation to have rashash Shana considered because both yam kapor and rashash fall during the school right that won't happen again till 2029 right but we can definitely uh make that motion to have it sent to the Dei calendar subcommittee so you made that motion is there a second Mr Mana is there any discussion I have a question so if it were to go back to the committee how long do you think it would take before the recommendation would be ready for us to vote on good question because next week we are

161in midwinter recess so we probably have a meeting schedule at the beginning of March it probably would not be ready for the March 11th meeting but I would encourage the board to adopt the calendar at the March 11th meeting when the recommendation comes from the Dei calendar subcommittee they can then amend the calendar or leave it as is can I ask a question yeah can we just do that can we just make that of the policy of the board to include those holidays as days that we that would not be school days I I would not make it the policy of the board I would definitely go through the same process that we did not saying that you can't but I would definitely go through the same process that we did and then have it

162brought back to have it voted on and I would just say we would want that to happen for anybody else who would bring forward potential for another day to be added so I think to be consistent right I I guess this is also the same committee that didn't have russan on at all last year so are we dirting them to consider it or to add it I to add it they've already considered it to add it I I guess to add it yeah my understanding was if if and again this happened back in December of 2023 when we originally approved the non-public holidays and added them to the calendar my understanding was at that time rash Asana was not one of the ones that they had considered am I correct that is correct because it

163was not part of any of the legislative items that were sent to um the the state legislator for consideration and that was part of the discussion that happened at the table was ensuring that whatever holidays we add because there could be requests in the future for other holidays that we use the same process so we can ensure that it's Equitable so I I believe that's the the proper way to go but obviously the board may feel otherwise Mr Balia how many snow days are built in five five five to this calendar yes well and we don't want to um we got to be careful we don't want to call them snow days anymore we want to call them emergency closure days because with the heat index days we will probably be using we we had

164to do last year when we had to send KS a half day I just I asked that because you know obviously the 180 days has to do with funding as well and it's now with new legislation with the heat you know I respect the Jewish holiday I don't mean to say no I just those are questions I have um and then in terms of if those happens is I know in snow days uh if it's considered a state of emergency you can technically get that back but it takes a doesn't it take a year the process or well this is a funny thing that you bring that up because apparently there is some question around that question around when an emergency declaration is declared are the snow days really can you really claim them if

165you didn't truly had to call a so there's a lot of discrepancy and discussion about that at the state Ed level and at the governor's level because if you look at the emergency declaration it was for a period of over a month and they said all of those days do not count so it there's some technicalities around it but the it can affect your funding in the future because if you don't meet the 180 days then you fill out the correct form to then have those reconsidered so there's a process you go through but we're just finding out now that the emergency declarations um have to be very careful and pay attention to those so if it was an emergency declaration and was called in school on a Wednesday that the day you get back

166it couldn't be the whole week because it was considered a St is that how you're kind of explaining it well no what I'm saying is we have to even if we declare a snow day during a state of emergency we have to fill out the form and it's not guaranteed that okay because as you know during the state of emergency we still had school on one of the also you know so the consideration will be was it necessary for really be closed a friend of mine sent me an article discussing this very thing that's saying just because there a state of emergency does not mean that school has to be closed and that's where that's where that's where the difficulty and understanding comes from okay so I'm gonna move us back on track so we

167had a motion for uh this to be sent to the Dei calendar committee to see if Russia shaa can be included moving forward in as a non-public holiday on the calendar correct and we had a second and we had discussion and now we're doing all in [Music] favor okay so I have uh Dr Singh Dr Spicer Mr Mana Miss Binger myself Miss pulan and Mr buan in favor of sending it to the Dei committee opposed I have Miss Fletch and Mr Balia opposed motion carries 720 I will jump to 6 C and um our attendance report so by board policy we actually have to present this data is by policy 7110 very similar to how we present discipline data every year so what we were doing is playing a little bit of catchup in here

168you will see the attendance reports from 2022 to 2023 and 2023 to 2024 broken down by semester broken down by school and then the aggregate for the entire year for both of those years you will get the 2425 report at the same time we provide the discipline report in August and so that will be a regular August occurrence um I know we spoke about chronic absenteeism because that is one of the measures through New York state so I would encourage you to review the attendance report look at The Chronic absenteeism so we can have further discussion in the future at the board table about the steps the board or the district is taking to try to reduce some of our CRA chronic absenteeism any questions about that or may I move on to 6D he

169move on thank you so 6D what you will find in the board packet is our Strat IC plan goals update you will see that there's a January 2025 tab not only that you will see that there are ratings because we want the community to see how we are progressing on our strategic plan goals and our goals are at the proficient level so we are very pleased with that very proud of that um I was going to go through and highlight some of the areas however it is a very detailed plan and I encourage the board and the community to go through and look at the January 20 2 highlights and look at the ratings that were given for each of the goals and goal activities and we are very proud of the work that is

170taking place in The District in regard to our strategic plan after 6D I'm going to turn it back over to the president um of the board to move forward with the agenda just one quick comment I I really found the the rating scale very helpful awesome so I appreciate the district doing that for all of our strategic goals thank you and what I want to do is public thank Dr Marie bellan uh Linda Ru and Danielle alterio for their work on that all of our uh leadership team members who reconvene their committees to look at each of those goal areas and look at the rubric and develop the rating for each of those so we have committees working on each area of the Strategic plan and then providing the updates from our school buildings our

171principals provide that and then look at the ratings so there's a lot of work that goes into it so thank you very much president absolutely absolutely thank you any other comments before we move on okay moving on we are now on to item 7B may I have a motion to approve the student board member proposal as presented Miss Fletch miss blinger any discussion Mr Mana thank you welcome um I'm concerned that the election is going to allow both students and staff to vote I don't think that uh uh the staff the teachers should be bothered to vote they have enough on their minds I think it's improper for the students to uh Lobby teachers or or administrators to vote for them teachers have enough things to do um and the law does not allow in

172my reading of IT staff to vote it lists five or six different ways that the student is chosen one of them is election by the student body not one not one part says by staff or bus drivers or the maintenance people or the lunch uh people so um I would amend the this motion by striking staff and that it only be students as the law allows any other discussion on that so you're making a motion to amend yeah well yes to amend and you know there there a second but I'd also like to hear from people on the committee like why they came up with that okay thank you comment on that as the chair of the committee and I would invite the other members of the um board also this was a request of

173the students that staff be allowed to vote their reasoning for wanting staff to be allowed to vote was to mitigate the popularity factor and that was and we are wanting to elevate student voice so um I did not feel that that was appropriate to say that they could not vote and they don't have to vote don't have to choose not to so they're too busy or don't feel like voting they that option too well I'm I'm gonna thank you for that answer again I'm I'm gonna go back to the the you know I I want to elevate following the law and Elevate the direction of this school board who I think uh in October list Ed the or created the method by which the student will be elected it says that we all voted on

174it unanimously students selected by their student body and selected by their High School principal I understand the the principal part of it he's gonna be part of the the the the what was that I said Ori ory um deciding who will be on the ballot but nowhere in the board's votes does it say teachers and I understand the students want to involed teachers you know but you know we have to follow the board rules and follow the law students want to create their own tests and then grade their own tests and then put their grade on their own paper we have to follow what the guidelines are and my concern is besides the staff being harassed uh uh by students seeking their vote is that if I'm a student and I lose the election by

17510 votes and the staff votes could be determinative of me losing that that vote I'm going to look at the law and look at the board resolution and say what where does it say that the staff can vote it doesn't so we shouldn't be I think the first thing you want to teach a student who's going to be sitting on this board is you follow the direction of the majority of the board and you follow the law that is the most important lesson to be taught here not that this is what the students want so again my my amendment is simply to follow the board resolution and the law and that it's an election by the student body any further comments on that okay is there a second for so the motion is can you

176repeat sure sure my motion would be to strike the staff being allowed to vote okay so as presented with striking the staff being allowed to vote correct okay may I have a second Mr buan all in favor Dr Singh Dr Spicer Mr Mana myself Mr Balia Miss Fletch and Mr buan opposed miss bullan and miss blinger so vote uh carries 720 two 7 two Sor I I was correct right okay I'm not always but oh Goa than you just sounds weird seven I know it was my my fault sorry okay it's not you let's keep moving on we didn't motion to accept the proposal as amend amended yes yes okay thank you so much I was looking back where we were may I have a motion to approve the student board member proposal as amended

177Mr Mana Dr Spicer all in favor motion carries unanimously now we are on our events our community forum is scheduled on March 25th after our 6 PM budget work session 7 to 900m in Casey Library our after school with staff conversations with the board of education is also in casy library that will be on April 22nd from 4:30 to 5:30 p.m. we had school visits on February 4th Maple East and maple West and on February or I'm sorry January 16th we visited East transit and Country Parkways during those visits we learned about building initiatives we viewed the ongoing AC updates in the schools that were receiving it and we also observed some very engaging and impressive instruction in our classroom so thank you to all involved in those School visits M KY will coordinate dates

178for onboarding committee meeting in March uh for the Board of Education retreat in April and for rescheduling our January 28th policy committee meeting which was cancelled our upcoming School visits are all listed in board docs and are there any board member comments or questions regarding any of these items Miss Pand um in regards to the stud student board member we will need a policy for that so I don't know if that goes to the policy committee or because that was not in the purview of the committee to to develop the policy thank you for bringing that up we will make sure that that happens thank you I and so the PO was do you recall if there was a date that the PO I know that it it's implemented by July 1 so as long

179as we have the policy approved by July 1st okay thank you yes Mr just as a note for Miss Carrie uh I'm not my name's not on the uh after school with staff conversation maybe I didn't reply but I am going you had said no did I really yeah all right now A yes I'm changing it to a yes I said it might have been my fault sorry my apologies okay any other comments or questions before we move on okay 7D 7e board candidate information and vote information items are in board docs any questions or comments regarding that 7f and 7g are there any questions or comments regarding ecsb or nisba items does anyone have anything to report under liaison assignments we've received correspondence from community members on school start times student safety transportation and

180hiring practices does anyone wish to speak to any correspondents received 7j er1 Bose's call for nominations the nominations for er1 Bose's Board of Education must be received honor before March 21st our nominations for the e1b board will be on at our March 11th meeting it will be on our agenda under agenda items 9 through 15 minutes Personnel business and finance exceptional education special needs and Student Activities District's facilities and support services instruction curriculum and other business may I have a motion to approve these agenda items as presented miss pulin Mr Balia any discussion all in favor motion carries unanimously at this time I would like to thank the following hes for their service to the district Randall ball Forest Elementary School with 27 years of service Lyn baglia Heim Elementary School with 36 years of

181service Julie buer North High School with 23 years of service Linda Carl Casey middle school with 33 years of service Carla Catalano East High School with 21 years of service Monique Coro country Parkway Elementary School with 28 years of service Jane Filmore Heim Elementary School with 21 years of service Nancy folz Heim Elementary School with 29 years of service Susan hanifen Maple West Elementary with 18 years of service Katherine Canali Maple West Elementary School 31 years of service Linda K school counselor sorry school counselor at Maple East and Dodge for 20 with 24 years of service Laura Kennedy South High School with 28 years of service Claire May Casey middle school with 22 years of service margarite McDonald East High School with 30 years of service Harry masana Heim Elementary School with 32 years of

182service Marsha Orman South High School with 20 years of service Joseph pman himim elementary school with 29 years of service Linda ruay director of professional learning 14 years of service David S I hope that's right school media specialist High middle school with 29 years of service Heidi shatz uh Casey middle school with 31 years of service Michelle safransky Casey middle school with 21 years of service Annette trb trbo Mel middle school with 21 years of service Renee Zant South High School with 26 years of service Cindy wolf North High School with 30 years of service dorine Zach social worker Forest Elementary School with 35 years of service employee number 0 3320 with 30 years of service and Lisa hinka human human resources department with 34 years of service all right may I have a motion

183we are on item 16a may I have a motion to take from the table for the second reading of policy updates 7510 7521 and 7522 as presented Mr Mana miss blinger any discussion all in favor motion carries uh with then note that Miss Fletch is not at the table so it's 8 z0 um may have a motion for the second reading and Adoption of these policies Mr Balia miss pulin any discussion all in favor again motion passes 800 z may I have a motion for the first reading of policy 3421 as presented is pulin miss blackener any discussion all in favor motion carries again 80 may have a motion to table policy 3421 for the second reading and adoption at the March 11th meeting Dr Spicer Mr Mana any discussion all in favor motion carries

184800 Z Item 17 Committee of the whole are there any matters under Committee of the whole to discuss seeing none we'll move on to our second public expression if anyone in the audience would like to speak at this time please make your way to the podium there is no one in the audience who would like to speak at this time our next regular board meeting and budget form will be March 11th may have a motion to adjourn into executive session to discuss the superintendent midyear evalu ation Miss Fletch and Mr buan all in favor motion carries unanimously

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.