CorpusRecord 138734

January 14, 2025 - Board of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Williamsville Central School District
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Erie County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,128 words · about 85 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I call the regular board meeting to order all members of the board are present Mr Mana will you please lead us in the pledge of allegiance to the flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice may I have a motion to adjourn into executive session to discuss employment matters related to particular persons and collected Collective negotiations Miss Binger Dr Singh all in favor motion carries unanimously bottle that makes me sad e e e e e e e e e e e e e for e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e e may I have a motion to return the regular board meeting to

002public session miss Binger Mr Mana all in favor motion carries unanimously please be advised that in the event of a fire an emergency and an evacuation should be necessary an alarm will sound please know all marked emergency exits and evacuate well away from the building at this time we request that everyone turn their cell phones and other electronic devices to silent thank you at this time we would like to honor former President Jimmy Carter and two of our staff members Marie adado alares a teacher Aid at East High School who passed away on December 9th and Lori cianetti executive assistant to the superintendent who passed away on December 31st we offer our condolences to their families friends and colleagues including those sitting here tonight I ask that all in attendance please join us in a

003moment of silence for President Carter miss arado aaras and miss Kian thank you item number three we have recognition Miss Dr Brown [Music] Hall should we go ahead and move with forward with our school Spotlight for high Middle School there's someone here from home here to speak thank you step on up thank you sure tonight we begin our recognition with Heim Middle School Heim gives back is an annual event allowing students to create and send thank you cards care packages and donation to those in need right in our community they also send care packages to First Responders and members of the military please welcome Adam buffamante principal at Heim middle to share more information good evening Dr Brown Hall good evening Dr Brown Hall board officials and Board of Education and uh Williamsville Community we

004appreciate you having the Heim community and myself come today to talk about himim cares and what we do with that initiative Heim is a school that is meant for building meaningful strong relationships not only with students but also with the community members and I have two of our teacher leaders that are going to be able to explain a little bit more about the process of him cares and what we do with that initiative so I'd like Morgan Altieri to come along with Jen [Applause] Moore good evening um well we can share a little bit about what Heim gives back is it's it's been going on for eight years now um it was really driven by our Wellness at asset survey uh with the 40 developmental assets seeing that students really needed that to be used

005used as Service as Sur members of the community they need to learn what what's important as far as you know in their personal lives but also giving back to those around them um and with their busy lives of families and themselves sometimes they don't get that opportunity as much uh so we really have it so it's built in to their school day so in December every year for the past eight years we've taken a day in the morning about an hour of their H time and teachers and students come up with a community service project each time time so each Home Room there's about 40 of them or so chooses a different activity of what they want to do so it's really student driven the students come up with the ideas of who who they

006want their craft to go to what craft it is that they want to make and then it goes out into the community this year we had a student who had an uncle that was in a Memory Care Facility in the village of Williamsville so he's like can we give some of our things to that to that senior home and sure enough we did that um so every year it's something different so if Morgan will talk a little bit about where we where we this uh so this year we took a lot of things to different nursing homes in the area and we also um shipped some things overseas we have a teacher at our school whose niece is deployed and so we sent some things over there um and it was really cool for the

007kids to see that it was people that we knew that um the items were going to not just you know random nursing home it was nice to see that it was going to someone's uncle or someone's niece so that was really nice for them a big community that we've kind of serviced in the last couple years has really been the VA hospital we started going there a few years ago and the reception that we received from the members of the VA that worked there but also uh the patience in in and out was beyond anything that we've ever seen before so and that was something um the smiles and the kids really we you know went back and we talked to the students like this went to this person this and we actually got to

008see where some of the actual crafts that they need went um and that's really important to them too so it's been a really great experience for the last eight years and the kids get excited about it every year they ask when it's going to be so it's something definitely that makes time even more of a family than we already think we are um so and it kind of shares our family with the outside Community as well awesome so very nice so here's our video [Music] him gives back is a day where students take time during him time and each H time will come up with their own community service project those community service projects can go to local nursing homes police and fire veterans association Meals on Wheels and all of them are delivered the

009week before winter break to brighten everybody's day and give back to the community around us we are going to make a blanket this year we're giving them to Meals on Wheels the purpose is to show kids that their Community is really important outside of the school and that it's so important that with everything that's going on around us that you not forget to give to others and to really brighten someone's day bring a positive attitude that's really important when you're trying to build good character in in students and in children is teaching them the value of being kind to others and feeling compassion and giving back just kind of put a little snip perfect we're giving back to the community with projects that we're making it just kind of makes your day brighter because then

010like when you give you don't necessarily need something back it just helps you like see the world in a different perspective we take our time to work on these different projects so that we can thank our community I think it's really cool how we do this I like really like it and just makes my day better because I know that somebody else's day has become better and their Spirit might have been lifted this home room is making lucky buffalos for a teacher's niece who is deployed and these lucky buffalos are going to be for her and her unit but hi middle we not only focus on academics but focus on making kind citizens people who are going to give back to their Community later in life and this is just one way that we as

011a school work really hard to make sure that kids are seeing that there are places is that you can give your time and your effort and your skills to help to make somebody's day brighter they got to create their own project it was all student generated what they wanted to do so they took a lot of ownership in that what' you make I like it we're so proud of them they work so hard and when you walk the hallways during him gives back you see everybody's working and they're doing something to help and to make it a better experience for everyone around them it really brings joy and happiness when I I give back to the community it really like brightens my day and it brings a smile to my face and the people around

012me yeah I'm proud of my school a lot hi middle is a family both in our building and in the surrounding areas and this activity speaks to a high middle family I'm so proud of them and how excited they get to do it and it's one of the great things about working with students especially in middle school is that you can really motivate them and that motivation in Middle School can carry them into adulthood awesome absolutely awesome buffamante Miss Moore Miss elter thank you very much we appreciate that so next our next recognition takes us to Mill Middle School collaboration is key to any project especially one that includes nearly 100 students hundreds of lines music notes and dance moves suso the musical was an absolute hit and would not have been possible without strong

013administrat support incredible dedication by our teachers and hard work of our students please welcome principal Chris McDuffy at he's principal of M Middle School to share more with our teachers I love the shirts come on up thank you for that Dr Brown Hall and good evening leadership team and Board of Education uh I'd like to just start by saying how truly proud I am of our drama club director uh drama club advisors and also our students who uh took part in this year's suso Jr I think sometimes we see the finished product and we really don't realize or appreciate how much hard work effort time commitment truly goes into you know the successful production of a School Musical and and as you mentioned Dr Brown Hall when we think about the idea of close to

014100 cast and crew members that that is something that's truly remarkable and something certainly that we want to you know not only recognize but certainly celebrate so as you mentioned we do have three out of our four drama club advisors here so I'm going to pass it over to them to let them speak a little bit more about suso Jr in depth um we have Mrs Melissa Powers Mrs Jennifer Olen and Mrs tanil trenchard with us um unfortunately Mr Matt tishy who's also one of our drama club advisers could not be here with us but we certainly want to recognize him as well and with that said I'm going to pass it over awesome hi everybody um we would like to start by thanking all of you the Board of Education and the Williamsville Central

015School District for allowing our students to participate in drama club this year this year our students performed susal Junior and it was a total hit we are so proud of them um approximately more than 85 is students participated um and that included stage crew it included student directors and of course our performers it takes a team to create Magic on stage and we could not be more proud of each and every one of them so I'd like to pass it to Mrs trenchard good evening again thank you for having us so I guess we have two of these um drama club as we know is a place where students get to Showcase their talent they get to build confidence they get to make new friends it's just a place where we all have so much

016fun together we are looking forward to taking all of these students with us um to um in the spring in June to get to perform again at Shay's 710 theater and they get to come together with other area schools for a day of the junior theater celebration and they're going to be with a whole bunch of other kids their age where they're going to get to perform again a song from susal Jr and during the day they're going to take workshops and learn some more singing acting and dancing techniques to further their talents so we're really looking forward to them and Mrs Olsen hi everyone I think one of the neatest things about doing this in middle school is the lessons that you watch kids learn um throughout the show as we know Middle School

017is a time of growth and development for students to figure out their passions and interests susal Jr is such a beautiful journey of Discovery optimism and acceptance what some of the characters have to go through can be directly applied to real life and as Oscar lamb who is our Horton the lead elephant says drama club is my home it's so important to offer so many opportunities to students at this age to feel successful and accepted lastly we would like to thank our Administration our colleagues and our wonderful drama club parents thank you thank you so much for all your support this season um but most importantly we need to thank our students their talent on stage has been an inspiration not only to many students watching them but also to their directors um thank you

018again and we can't wait for many more musicals at M middle school thank you NE [Applause] [Music] um susal Jr is filled with many characters that we have seen through Seuss's books it's a lot of lessons about being yourself and to listen to your [Music] heart we have close to 90 total students involved in stage crew and in the cast this is a team and it takes so many parts to tell a story because that's really what a musical does and in order for that story to be successful we have to work together a person seems to know not a person seems to care there is no one who believes a thing I say with musicals I gain new family members like it's just a beautiful experience because of drama club where everyone just gets

019to have fun and get to work together I would say quite a few of my friends are now in different grades than I the I love having the opportunity to do the things I love and and just be with great people I've learned so many like new things to help me with my singing and my acting I was really shy before I've like started any musical things but and I was like so scared to perform for the first time but gradually I've like gained so much more confidence about myself when I like go on stage I'm not like as nervous anymore most people don't know how much work goes in behind the stage we have like over 30 songs that they have to do they have to learn all the choreography all the lyrics we

020have people backstage we have people doing music lighting we have people even doing like projectors I love doing this and I love helping out and seeing how when I help out like the product that comes out I'm really proud of myself that I've gotten to this like level that I'm able to be like trusted by all these adults and I'm able to put as much effort as I can possible there's so many invaluable skills that musical theater lends a hand to self-confidence empathy creative thinking critical thinking all of these skills develop as they get older and it preps them for high school now we're hearing from our high school colleagues saying wow you guys have done amazing things there at the middle school and you really prepared them there's nothing more we love than to

021watch these students get up on stage think about think about the fact that we were able to put on three magnificent shows is just incredible I just really really feel blessed that I've been given this opportunity to channel this energy to tell this story to the audience I love taking part in musicals drama club is my home [Applause] awesome very much I turn it back over to you board president thank you are there any board acknowledgements this evening Dr Spicer I just want to add on to recognizing the musical um not only the great performance but the fact that um we had a snow day and whatever happened behind the scenes went very smoothly as a parent um where they very easily pivoted their schedule so they still had three shows so I very much

022appreciated that thank you Dr Spicer anyone else okay we'll be moving on to item 4A public expression I call now call on parliamentarian BL inure to review our public expression format thank you welcome to all who have come to observe this regular board meeting for policy 1510 the board allows for up to 30 minutes of public comment a time when we invite members of our school Community to share ideas opinions and concerns with us while we are here to listen carefully we take your concerns seriously public comment is not designed to be a discussion therefore please do not expect us to respond tonight instead you will receive a response by email after our meeting because we want to maintain mutual respect and stability please ensure that comments are delivered in a respectful manner to the

023board directly also under state and federal privacy laws we are unable to entertain any comments related to employee Personnel information or any topic that may disclose information about a particular student on these matters we ask that you go through the appropriate administrative channels please note that individuals are required to sign up prior to our meeting and each speaker is allotted three minutes for comments you will be signal at two and a half minutes so that you may conclude your remarks at this time we will begin our public comments after I call on you please step up to the podium and state your name I have Damon pyu hello pek I just uh came here to talk about uh the lack of use of textbooks in math classes and science classes throughout the district I have

024two daughters in the district and this has been something that I have talked to teachers and the curriculum specialist about in the past um really the packets that we get I brought my daughter's packets they're missing thorough instructions they're also missing a glossery an index it makes it very difficult to help your child study for a test or pick up curriculum if they've missed it for a illness or uh a scheduled music lesson so it it's very difficult to find terminology in here because of that so if I'm looking for let's say do main because I haven't done it in years there's no index I can't look it up it takes us hours to help them study especially for a midt you know grasping Concepts is very difficult for students sometimes and we're told to

025use Con Academy or the internet we don't have any solid reference material to use which there's not always the reference material on COD Academy or the internet and you can't always trust everything on the internet and frankly if I'm going to use Khan Academy why am I sending my daughters here for educational instruction and why wouldn't we want access to a more thorough explanation and additional problems uh the packets also require students to be extremely organized which they're not given those skills they're not taught those skills in math class how to organize this they're not told how to organize this and you know I believe the district is relying on students to look for outside help as far as where we go to seek help so I've hired tutors I've gone to online resources which

026are very difficult and really wanted to bring this to the attention because like I said I've already spoken to the teachers I've already spoken to the math curriculum specialist but I don't seem to be getting anywhere thank you very much for your time thank you next we have s s um Ahmad ah close enough so hi my name is sakib Ahmed I'm a professor at Buff State uh my area is uh physics and Engineering so I might appear a little cuckoo but pardon me uh so um I just put on some points um just not to stray of course um off course rather so the context of discussion is the opportunity for Muslim Students to offer one of the five obligatory prayers during school time uh this is particular uh for shorten days which are

027November to March uh during other times of the year the day is long enough for the students to offer this midday prayer upon coming home um and prior to the start of the next prayer timing but from November to March which is the daylight savings particular period there's no way students can Avail this midday prayer other than offering it during opportune time during school hours the actual prayer takes 3 to 5 minutes and this has been something that Muslim Students have had no issues in observing during school time by taking a permission slip from the teacher for example um prior to this 2024 or 2025 Academic Year but since the beginning of the said year um this time taken out for prayers has been prohibited with the inaction of a New York state law that

028has strict guidelines um against non-instruction time being granted to students so lay of the land done given the short preview a few comments moving forward first of all uh the first one the obvious um that since November daylight savings time kicked in um our district has had scores of students who cannot offer this this particular prayer I know that multiple families have gotten in touch with teachers guidance counselors principles a few board members and the superintendent and I realize that this matter is not new to many of you secondly as many of you know my family and and a few other families over the years have been quote unquote a conduit or interface uh between the rapidly growing Muslim Community and the district I can tell you that there's a strong feeling of confusion disenfranchisement

029frustration to name a few things that Muslim kids and their families have been feeling since the past November we myself and these few other Muslim interface parents if you like call them have done some due diligence in the meantime to better educate ourselves we have met slil SLB on calls with multiple multiple individuals the past few weeks other New York state district Personnel from New York City all the way through here to understand how they are managing this situation as well as many individuals from our own District multiple middle um High School principles teachers gu guidance counselors Etc um the few highlights from these meetings have shown to us that other school districts have certain methods slm models in place that ensure that Muslim Students do get their 3 to five minutes to offer their

030midday prayer B this sentiment of students to be allowed to pray has been resonated by 100% of our very own teachers principles guidance counselors that we have met who have suggested models SL methods SL ways of uh to manage the situation and have Elegant solution Pathways that ensure adherence to the New York state law and at the same time ensure that this core religious practice of prayer is not compromised um lastly I leave you with this last note I realize that you are taking care of multiple kinetics including new school hours for high and middle schools and I ask that there um that as you settle on these issues kindly involve these Muslim interface parents in your discussions be through the Dei committee or any other format that you deem feasible not only can we

031offer the proper context and perspective but we can also allow we can also offer granular Insight which might be a game changer thank you Mr Med oh that's it okay cool well thank you for your time moving on to item 4B Dr Brown Hall and Mr Kelly I turn it over to you for the budget development presentation thank you very much this one is uh this presentation is really focused on repair reserves and so uh I will turn it over to assistant superintendent Kelly to discuss the projects that we are proposing for this summer 2025 usage of res Reserve repair funds totaling no more than $950,000 yeah so for those that have uh followed the way Williamsville works every year this is a recurring item that we see every year and these particular items are

032repairs and Replacements of different facilities and components that make up our buildings across the district um typically these would be done as capital Pro or capital projects but in this situation these are smaller in nature and they don't warrant being a capital project where we might have to borrow and get uh SED approval so these are smaller in nature and they allow our facilities and our buildings to stay operational for years to come after they're completed so this year we went through a process of evaluating our buildings and our facilities across our our school district and we came up with a list of projects um and hopefully we can bring them up here oh I'm sorry this is the the budget presentation but um I think we might have taken these so out of order

033today they we did and that is my fault because Court president gave me the proper segue into budget development and I jumped into repair Reserve so we're gonna get this together we're gonna stick a pen in what Mr Kelly just said and we're gonna hold that in our memory until we get to item 5A and we're gonna backtrack to the budget development process that was on the screen up there all right so we're going to give together this evening our promise so Mr filipowski if you please put up the budget development process we're going to stick a pen in what Mr Kelly was saying about the repair reserve and it doesn't total more than 950,000 we'll remember that and then we'll move forward with the program continuation and budget development assistant superintendent Kelly please take

034it away thanks so much um similar to what I was saying a moment ago this is also an annual process that we do every year and this really kicks off our budget development process in Earnest you'll remember going back several months ago we approved and adopted the budget calendar for the year and as part of that process the first step at this January meeting is actually taking a look at our current programming and what it would take to continue that programming going forward and this second slide here really takes a look at that and uh delves into it for us so we can get a sense of what our upcoming budget is is going to look like so when we take a look at this slide on the left-and side we start off with our

035current budget so we you'll see the amount 232 740 574 million that's what our current budget totals this year and if we go down uh this side of the presentation you'll see the employee salaries Social Security and FICA increases health insurance bosies bus transportation and cyber security these are the areas that we've identified at the beginning of our budget development process where we will see significant cost increases and in order to continue doing the programming at the current level these are the areas that we see significant increases going forward for next year's budget that will allow us to continue to deliver the same programming that we are currently doing at the district so the first area our salary increases total a little over $6 million uh next up we have our social security increases or

036fiker increases we're at about $384,000 uh next up is health insurance again these costs are largely out of our our control and inflation driven this year we're looking at about a 10% increase for health insurance for the district next up we we have our bosies increases again a lot of these services are contracted we continue to look at our services from bosies every year we evaluate it we decide if we want to continue doing the same Services if we want to add services or if we're just going to keep the same services that we have right now at this early stage of the budget development process we're looking at an increase of north of $650,000 for bosis bus transportation as most people people are aware we contract out 100% of our busing for the district

037with a company called student transportation of America known as sta every year they have an increase um we're looking at a few things that might also add on to their percentage increases this year and one of those will be talked about a little bit further along in tonight's presentation we talk about school start times but at this point in time we're looking at an increase of about 1 .7 million for transportation and for cyber security typically we see an increase the current year we saw an increase of a few hundred, right now we're looking into that and if there is going to be an increase for our cyber security program that's going to be to to be determined over the course of the rest of the budget process but the the real important number I

038really want everybody to focus on the increase in that line down at the bottom the total required expense increases total about 11.3 million to continue our programming as we're currently operating this year when we add that to our current budget we get a an initial budget total of $244 million uh this is the number that you know we have sort of developed at this initial stage and what we think the budget will be close to now I want to point out to everybody that the there's a good chance this number will change it could go up or down a little bit and there's a number of factors that could drive that including the number of retirements we see in the district for teachers and other Personnel um when we compare this increase the $ 111

039million increase to the current year budget it's about a 4.8 almost a 4.9% increase by way of comparison last year the budget for the current year increased about 4.2% so that gives you an idea of what the budget uh costs are going to total for the upcoming budget year the 2025 26 fiscal year or school year now on the right side we've projected out our cost for the year after next year so these would be the costs for the 2627 school year and again most of these categories continue year over-year and a lot of them are contractual in nature including the employee salaries as we know we're going into contract negotiations with our teachers this year and those are getting underway um and we anticipate some contractual cost increases with them over over the length

040of that contract term uh so you'll see an increase of about 4.2 almost 4.3 million we're projecting for the year after next uh you'll see a you know corresponding increase for the social or fight or increases again health insurance these are estimates and guesses but we're also projecting about a 10% increase the year after next we see a bosis increase um we had a presentation at the last board meeting where where some folks from bosis came and spoke to us about adding a new building and that there would be additional costs for the district uh you're seeing some of those costs in the proposed budget for next year and in the subsequent budget for the year after that uh again bus transportation we're looking at about a 6 and a half% increase that's totaling north

041of 600,000 we'd be looking at close to an $8 million increase projecting out for 2627 and again if we look at the total that would be almost a $252 million budget for the 2627 fiscal year and then again the percentage increase that would be about a about a three and a qu% increase if we project out for the year after next if there's no questions on this slide I'll just go to the next slide and I can also entertain questions on this next slide or after this slide okay so if we take a look at this next slide really these are just some overall themes as we go into the budget process again our working budget we have that total of 244 million this is our initial projection of what we think our expenses will

042be for the upcoming fiscal year and school year that's an increase of 4.88% again our retirements are not finalized and those numbers could you know swing that number a little bit it could come down if we see more retirements or you know we could see it increase also if there's less retirements uh again the Bose's budget will not be finalized until March so we could see some changes in that initial projection that we presented tonight uh one of the big unknowns with the budget are the revenue estimates expected with the governor's budget proposal that should be coming out this month and we should get a better idea of what our Revenue will look like for the upcoming fiscal year and school year how does the governor's proposal change the foundation Aid formula and that's really

043what I was just talking about um we know that the study that was commissioned by the Rockefeller Institute suggested some potentially big changes from what we've been used to for the foundation Aid formula if the governor is going to take those recommendations and Implement them we should find out more this month uh once we get that we'll start working on the tax C calculation and we should have Revenue estimat at the February meeting for the board and the community at that time thank you very much assistant superintendent Kelly are there any questions before I turn it back over to president to our board president I turn it back over to you B president I don't know why we bother because I'm turning it back over to you for the proposed summer repair reserved projects absolutely

044so we're goingon to pick up very similar to what Angelica said in Hamilton on the song Satisfied we're going to rewind so we're going to re wind and take it from where Mr Kelly picked up when he was describing the repair reserves and the projects for summer 2025 great thanks so much so you know we were we were sort of unpacking this and then we shifted gears and now we're taking a look back at this but these these repair requests uh we're we're requesting funding totaling no more than 950,000 and we think this is a fair estimate of the repair and Replacements that we would need across the district in order to keep our facilities running and operating at an optimal level um some of the repairs and Replacements include uh repairing and restriping athletic

045tracks and crawl space abatement work at South High School fixing cracks and repairing Tennis Courts at East High School Transit Middle School we're going to repair or replace the generator as needed as we look at that and determine how much more use ful life is needed or is left with that particular generator at Casey Middle School we're going to be replacing some folding doors at Forest Elementary School we're doing some paint and aesthetic work above the windows if you're familiar with that building if you drive by it you see there's sort of a green is shoe above some of the windows and we took a look at that and working with uh principal Wing over at the school we explored some ways to enhance the look of the building and to you know paint that

046and make uh the energy panels look a little better for the community around there we've had some comments from some folks that live in that area and we think we have a real good solution for that building to address those needs uh over at Lawrence Bell this is where our facilities department operates out of as well as our food service operations we're going to be doing parking lot resurfacing again when we look at these projects a lot of times because of how technical they are we do have some Associated architectural work and Engineering work that goes into to these projects again we don't anticipate that costing the district any more than $40,000 um a little later this year we'll look at our repair reserves and if we need to add money to that repair Reserve

047account but right now we have a healthy 4.8 almost $4.9 million in that account and these $950,000 would come out of that funding that we have set aside for these repair reserves uh I would be more than willing to entertain any questions or comments folks might have on these particular projects thank you very much assistant superintendent Kelly now I will turn it back over to our board president thank you we will now have our public hearing for the proposed repair Reserve projects only anyone wishing to address the board regarding the proposals may approach the podium and sign in to speak at this time seeing no one approaching the podium um I did want to make note that the approval of the repair Reserve uh projects is in agenda item 13A which will be later this

048evening now we're moving on to 6A and 6B Dr Brown Hall I turn it back over to you for your superintendence report thank you very much and I will get through the community update we only have a few slides because I know many of the individuals who are watching and many of the individuals who are here with us are excited about our school starttime presentation so I'll do the community update first want to remind families and students that on Monday January 20th we will have no school and observance of Dr Martin Luther King Jr day and knew this school year we remember last year the governor signed into legislation that Asian New Year will also be a Statewide School holiday and that will be um noticed on February sorry January 29th the last Wednesday of

049the month so Wednesday January 29th there will be no school for students also kindergarten so if you have little ones at home or your neighbors have little ones or family members registration will open in March for the 2025 2026 school year so please complete the district census that website is available here for you to complete and for any questions please contact Jennifer lavry who is our district register by calling 716 62681 we are very fortunate this year that we were able to exhaust our waiting list for upk because of the partnership that we have and we know that that prepares our students to enter kindergarten very ready for their academic career here in Williamsville so again registration for kindergarten will open in March for the 2025 2026 school year we wanted to list our January

050Regions exam so that families have a list of the exams what dates they're offered and at what times we know that our schools will also be sending out communication to our families but we want to list that here and so that will begin the day after we observe Dr Martin Luther King Jr Compu comp based testing so this year all of our grades 3 through eight students will be participating in computer-based testing in the spring of 2025 parents will still have the opportunity to determine their child's participation in the 3 to8 New York State spring testing while testing does not begin until April our students will have an opportunity it says in January but it will be on January 23rd to be engaged in a brief technology systems check so anticipate spring testing dates will

051be shared by the elementary and middle schools very shortly our speaker series is continuing in partnership with the PTSA Council we will have our next superintendent speaker series on Tuesday January 21st it will be on Ela and literacy and our director Christy Carroll will be presenting on Thursday February 27th director Kevin lasy will be presenting science technology engineering and math and then on Tuesday March 18th our director of mathematics and computer science Dr Chris McGinley will be presenting and we have archived the presentation by director Jamie pitell on the ARs so all of the speaker series are virtual and they will all be recorded and housed on our district website so that you can see at your leisure in the future our lost and found so our transportation department asked that we please plead with

052our parents and families to visit our law and found it will be cleared out on this Friday January 17th unclaimed items will be donated so please stop by 533 Mill Street between 7 AM and 4 pm or give a call at 716 626 8397 there are many items there we we know our students leave many items on the bus many of them are um high-priced items that they may not have told you about as a parent so I encourage if you if there's something you haven't seen your child with it's possible it's at the lost and found so take us a stop by there and that is our community update so thank you for the opportunity are there any questions about the community update I didn't think so so the star of the evening we

053want to welcome our school start time members of our school start time committee to come up and present the proposal for a change of school start time for the 2025 2026 school year I want to welcome the chair of the committee principal Keith bourman the principal of South High School we have principal Dan wall the principal of Transit Middle School we have director Christine Harding who is our district medical director and we have director Chris mua who is our director of Athletics and physical education for our district we also have a member of the committee in the back Dr Chris McGinley who is here to support his colleagues this evening I turn it over to principal Keith bortman yes thank you for having us uh here tonight even though Mr mu is hiding behind the

054pillar over here um but uh yes we're ready to uh present this has been a a fairly long process and I'll I'll go through the timeline uh when he pulls up the uh when the uh presentation is pulled up but it's been about a year and a half uh process for us uh and we're uh happy to present it tonight finally um so going through you want to use this one here you go all right I'm sorry oh turn the volume now I've got two so I'm just gonna flip back and forth there we go uh so uh the timeline for this actually uh we began about a year and a half ago we actually began talking about it in the summer of 2023 in the fall of 2023 is when we get began to

055put the committee together uh and really began to uh pull up a lot of the research that was out there um on the material I want to make sure we recognize the people on the committee um there were 15 of us total on the committee so there were six administrators two from each level six teachers two from each level uh plus we had three um uh district office administrators including uh Chris mka and Christine Harding and Dr McGinley um all of whom we sort of felt brought a unique perspective we certainly knew that if we were talking about school start times and end times uh we needed to have our athletic director on there uh and Christine was able to provide us a lot of information and interpret some of the information the research out

056there about mental and uh and physical health um so it's been a a nice process um you know anytime you have a committee like this it's always kind of an interesting thing because you know you're you're digging into a topic that is uh you know probably going to um make some people happy make some people unhappy anything anytime change comes that something uh one of the things I appreciate about all these members of the committee we began the process by really saying um okay our job here is to put our personal feelings aside and that's difficult when you're talking about this because as we're going through and talking about school start times and school end times and those things those are things that have Direct effects on us uh and so um I really appreciated

057the people on the committee who were willing to kind of put those personal thoughts and those personal feelings aside and really look at the research uh and that is really what has driven this process is examining the research and and ultimately um trying to find you know first whether a change uh should be recommended uh and then ultimately when we when we did determine that U really making sure that we're putting students first here and what is best for students and so I appreciate that a lot um as we went through the fall uh the fall and winter uh uh last year we Contin we were meeting we were looking at the research and really looking at a lot of uh different pieces of that uh in the summer we began the process of creating

058focus groups uh we also um this past fall attended there were six of us who actually attended uh the national uh school starttime conference uh in Baltimore um and then finally going through meeting with different uh focus groups uh so we had multiple focus groups as we went through we had two parent F focus groups a teacher focus group and a student focus group uh and many of the members of the committee actually attended those and and uh were there to hear what uh each of those groups uh said uh and then finally going through completing our final proposal which uh is really um a kind of a two-part structure once you've looked at the research for this and you've determined okay this is what we want to do then you begin coming up with

059okay here are some of our parameters that we're really interested in what the research is telling us we should be looking at what we want to make sure that we are following uh and then you actually get into the next step which is okay but can that be done and how can it be done and you start really looking at the logistics of the those issues and so um this is really a multi-step and even through uh you know the last few weeks we've been really examining breaking down issues trying to find those things where um this is how to do it the best possible way to make sure that we're meeting all the needs for what we want to do uh obviously uh you know uh the January was the The Proposal with the

060the idea of the time on the timeline uh Board of Education vote and then a lot of information uh you know and that's been something we've been working uh very carefully with uh filipowski and I want to thank him for all the time he's put into this um obviously there was information that's that we're now presenting now there is a lot of information uh as over the you that'll be coming out uh tomorrow for for people and then uh ultimately if this is approved uh the the communication with everybody in the community uh as we move on well thank you everybody for having us tonight we really appreciate this opportunity um reviewing the research so let's talk take a look at the research to better understand the evidence and recommendations that exist to best support

061our students mine works unlike yours Keith all right reviewing the research student health and wellness based on the scientific evidence the American Academy of Pediatrics American Medical Association and American Academy of sleep medicine all endorse a school start time of 8:30 a.m. or leader for our secondary students as you can see there's a plethora of organizations supporting leader start times for adolescent students listed are eight that were reviewed supporting this recommendation um such as American Medical Association American Academy of Pediatrics American Academy of sleep medicine American Psychological Association am American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry Centers for Disease Control National parent teacher Association and National Education Association okay um the American Academy of Pediatrics states that the evidence strongly implies early school start times before 8:30 a.m. as a key modifiable contributor to insufficient

062sleep in our adolescent population they also go on to state that a substantial body of research has demonstrated that delaying school start times is an effective countermeasure to Chronic sleep loss and has a wide range of potential benefits to students with regard to physical and mental health safety and academic achievement scientific evidence also tells us that insufficient sleep adversely affects our teens further the AAP recognizes insufficient sleep in adolescence as an important public health issue that significantly affects the health and safety as well as the academic success of our nation's middle school and high school students such as poor attendance and increased hardiness increased depression anxiety and suicidal ideation decreased emotional regulation increased substance use and abuse increased motor vehicle crashes increase risk-taking Behavior decrease concentration and cognitive efficiency and a decline in academic performance

063optimal sleep for middle school and high school students is between 8 and 1/2 and 9 and 1/2 hours each night teams getting less than 8 hours of sleep per night report significantly higher depression symptoms greater use of caffeine and are at greater risk for making poor choices for substance use I'm going to turn it over to our colleague Dan wall principal of Transit metal thank you good evening I'll continue a little bit with a review of the research so one of the logical questions in the research and uh that we received in uh in our review is if you make school start times later won't the students just stay up later you know and it's a reasonable question and the research says no the scientific evidence clearly shows that moving the start time later increases

064the amount of sleep students get multiple Studies have shown that for every two minutes of school start time is moved back students gain between one in two minutes of sleep so the research suggests a closer alignment between biological circadian rhythms and environmental demands on our students so it's this closer alignment that helps students access more quality sleep coinciding with the benefits of more sleep multiple studies show that schools with later start times see better overall attendance to school as well as a marked decrease as much as 400% in the number of taries to first period class so so oversleeping or my child needed to catch up on sleep is a common excuse we see in our tenants offices regarding the academic benefits districts who have moved to later school start times have seen an increase

065in graduation rates in their high school students students with increased sleep report fewer incidents of impaired executive functioning so this is to say students experiencing more routine sleep can better access their working memory attend to planning and organization problem solve manage their time better and persevere through challenges these are many of the skills that parents and Educators work to build in their formative years and that we hope to see applied more independently during the high school years so the last finding we wanted to highlight relates to the economically disadvantaged students the magnitude of the positive effects of the later school start time on academic outcomes is larger for economically disadvantaged students including higher course grades Higher Achievement on test scores reduced tarties improved attendance and reduced suspensions I'll turn it over to Mr Borman with

066a recommendation for proposals so for the last two weeks I'll I've had people in my building just walk by me and throw times out seeing if you know if I'll reveal anything um and um we want to make sure that you know everybody at least gets an understanding of what times uh what times we we chose and and why we did uh so the proposed start and end times uh beginning for next year um if that's the uh Choice really what it comes down to Elementary is going to shift to an to an earlier slot so elementary schools and and we've kept the uh we did explore at one point actually moving all six Schools elementary schools to the same time uh but that wasn't feasible in terms of how we were going to do

067this so uh the Four elementary schools that uh currently go at the same time Dodge Forest H and maple East uh their time will be 7:50 a to 2m uh the other two elementary schools which have traditionally been uh different times already uh will be 8:20 to 2:30 they're sort of in line in the morning with the middle schools like they are now the middle schools will be 8:20 to 3 p.m. uh so but if you look at the elementary uh and the Middle Schools they're really kind of moving uh the start time back about a half hour and then the end times are a little bit different uh and then at high school we see probably the most significant change uh High School would begin at 8:50 a.m and would end at 3:40 PM

068uh in addition one of the things you may notice if you're looking at this uh the actual times of the days for the elementary and the high school uh have changed and I'll talk about that but the Elementary uh time of the day is about 10 minutes longer the high school one is about 10 minutes shorter uh just so people have a sense of what that actually looks like in terms relative to current schedules uh what I have here are your current times for these schools and then the proposed new times uh for these schools uh one of the things that uh you know we'll talk about I'll talk about two but one of the things that was important to us was to try to get these schools in line as much as possible especially

069in the in the various levels you'll actually notice um if you're if you're looking at the the various different times uh I think Elementary we we found out there were three or four different start and end times uh amongst the schools even amongst the schools that were actually scheduled at the same time uh at the same time the middle schools were probably and the high schools were both fairly well aligned although um over the years randomly there had been one minute added into himim and one minute added into uh East in terms of the high school uh student length of day we wanted I wanted to mention as I mentioned it's kind of 10 minutes shorter uh so the the actual length of day is 10 minutes shorter um it really doesn't uh result in

070much of a a reduction in the classroom time actually South and North there will be no reduction in classroom time our periods are 42 minutes as they stand right now uh that time will actually be garnered out of period uh extra time that was in a couple of the periods for instance at South we had a longer uh period we used to do video home rooms uh video announcements in home room so we had a longer first period so we're able to actually take that that time out because we don't do the video announcements anymore uh in North there'll be a little bit of a reduction for the same thing in the first period plus uh they have some passing times that are five and some passing times that are four uh at East East

071per uh the East uh length of periods is 43 minutes so at East it would be one minute out of each period uh in order to accomplish that just as a sample this is sort of a sample um bell schedule that we we would look to do uh the plan is and I've spoken to the other High School principles we would like to have our Bell schedules all aligned as it stands right now they're not um the Bell schedules are actually different at all three buildings uh so what we're hopeful for is that uh with the Bell schedules better aligned that'll make it easier certainly for our traveling teachers and also understanding the schedules uh one of the things that was interesting with Elementary start time and we've gotten the question before um you know

072wouldn't it make sense to push everything back you know move move things much later and actually a lot of the research that uh is out there and we uh we talked to quite a few people down in Baltimore at the at the conference uh indicate that there are actually some some benefits for elementary students uh moving earlier uh and i' I've even used Mr filipowski as the example uh he has young kids my kids are a little bit older he has uh much younger kids and I said hey isn't it fun when they're that young and you know like 615 a.m. they're inyour face awake um you know and that that is one of the things you find is that the younger kids tend to be more incentive and and they're actually ready for uh

073learning earlier in the day um it also allows those schools to maximize uh schedule opportunities uh moving it into an earlier day um they they found the research has shown that there are no negative academic effects for moving elementary students uh earlier while there actually are significant uh academic U benefits for moving high school kids uh later uh and actually um one of the one of the other pieces that could be a potential um benefit is a decrease need for morning child car and fewer transitions uh for students um we wanted to mention I mentioned the fact that the the elementary length of day that this uh we talked about that it would be 10 minutes more actually that wasn't part of our committee's charge but concurrently at the same time I know there was

074a discussion amongst District leadership uh about adding uh possible time into that day and so we are presenting that here a as part of it because it does make sense to if we're going to do this to kind of put it all together um so concurrently that was a discussion that was happening and we were able to bring it into um our presentation one of the things that was very important as we discussed it um and uh Dr Brown Hall agreed and was adamant uh was um and it is a concern that we actually saw in the research that if you move Elementary to an earlier time what you're actually talking about are elementary kids potentially waiting outside earlier um I know at least you know for my school we have um bust pickups as

075early as 6:35 um we didn't feel like that was something that uh we wanted to have for the elementary kids so one of the pieces one of those parameters that I talk about as you're going through and you're figuring out the puzzle of school start times and going through there uh was actually making sure that no elementary students were going to be picked up before 7 AM and so that was one of the pieces that we were able to work with our transportation department as we were figuring out all these pieces um so there will not be any pickups for elementary students prior to 7 a.m. 7 a.m. would be the earliest uh pickup time for an elementary student another piece that was mentioned to us and the committee was very um you know very

076adamant that we make sure we explore this too is um what changes this might bring in before and after school care um and obviously given the change you're moving Elementary earlier so what does that mean probably means you're going to need more after school care as opposed to the morning care uh although we still might need some morning care especially with the two schools that are going to go later um so we did actually through a process I know Dr Brown Hall worked with it uh this process too of calling all the different um as some people may know we actually have buses that do drop off at Afterschool care programs we also have just for kids in our buildings um so we have spoken to multiple over uh over a dozen after school uh

077care programs and different programs about whether or not they would be able to accommodate any changes that we were going to make in those situations uh with an overwhelming response of absolutely we're ready to accommodate those things uh even so much as we can open up a new room in this place we have a room that's available for it um but we do know that just for kids will also be something as we explore they have indicated a positive response to us for the ability to fill uh any needs that we have for that um in terms of using just for kids in the afternoon uh and I'm gonna turn it over to Mr mua for the Athletics piece thank you Mr bbin uh couple things quickly about Athletics uh the reason that I was

078on the panel was to see what times work for us in athletics andural so as you can see from the first slide uh while these programs will obviously start a little bit later uh the changes will not affect uh athletic offerings or extracurricular offerings there will be limited light outdoor games uh I think of things like Golf and bowling and ice hockey where we don't control the venues we've already started conversations with those groups to make sure that we have all the offerings that we have currently uh for all three schools a later dismissal a good positive for this is that we have a lot less unstructured time for those of you that don't know a 245 dismissal for a team that starts at 4mm because their Coach Works in the private sector or they

079work at a middle school we've had an hour and 15 minutes where we've had to come up with creative ways to have those kids stay out of trouble so to speak so um it's one thing that we're really looking forward to and the next slide athletic busing uh actually with this proposal uh the busing will be better for our our students in 7th through 12th grade the biggest number of ridership is from our elementary schools followed by middle and then high this will free up bus runs at 3:45 currently the earliest bus we can get for any sport is 4 pm which which is why most of our start times are 5:00 pm 6 PM 7 PM so this will free up bus times earlier in addition to that we've had a lot of requests

080over the last couple of years since covid to have sports shuttles at the middle level which we're looking into this will allow the kiddos from Casey to go over to Heim Heim to Casey Milan to South because we will have more buses available and middle school and murals I've already been in talks with our fiz Ed staff both middle and elementary school we will still have the same robust offering of all of our intermurals we will get creative with the before schedule or before school schedule and have intermurals after school as well one of the questions that came up and certainly as a high school principal was important to me was making sure that um we still have students who can access the bosis of the Harkness program that we have um and this is

081one of the areas where it does become a little bit interesting um and really it's the morning Harkness program the morning Harkness program starts at 8 AM uh we did consult Clarence currently has an 852 start time uh Clarence high school so we did ask them you know how do you do this um and it will mean that those kids will actually start a little bit earlier they'll have to be at Harkness at 8 o'clock um we still are responsible for the transportation making sure that those students have the ability to get there it will not cancel any programs though students will still have access to those programs um and uh really the the Middle School the middle the midday run really doesn't have much effect at all uh and the end of the day

082run is something else that we're looking at um it will mean um I know for South and possibly we're we're looking at it for the other buildings um whereas right now we actually the the the last run so the end of day Harkness that we call it PM Harkness uh when the PM Harkness comes back that's actually at the end of our school day uh that actually wouldn't be true now they would actually be coming back and there would be a ninth period uh class after that so they would have the ability to be in a class at that point um some of our students in those situations have early release but um they'd have that opportunity to continue to do that um the one thing we wanted to make sure too and and I

083know that um when this was released on on board docs today there were a few questions I was out of the building on a field trip today and I came back and this was one of the big questions was uh before school activities um you know and as we said some high schools already have before our school activities my school definitely we have multiple things that actually even with a 7:45 start we have things starting at 7 am sometimes um and while we already have them we do want to make sure that we make efforts to honor what we're doing here which is um honoring the fact that you know moving School St time later um is something that we feel is important because the students are getting more sleep um and so of course

084some of the people who have morning activities already are like so we can't have any morning activities that is not what we're saying um in fact I would guess that we'll probably have a slight increase in morning activities um based on the 850 start time really what we were saying with this was and it was something that was expressed even by a couple of our teachers um and parents um was that if you do this what we don't want to see is everything that used to be after school gets moved before school and then you really haven't accomplished anything um by doing that um and so when we say we you know efforts will be made to limit those activities we're going to be monitoring that we want to make sure that like I said

085we are honoring what we've done here and honoring what the research has told us and uh I know the the six of us who went to the conference um you know obviously when you're immersed in something for several days um you know you kind of go into that um as we sat there and we listen to the stories of the people talking about these things and talking about um the the benefits that they've seen and what it does and what you can actually accomplish with those things you know we became more and more confident in our need to do this um as we were going through and we want to make sure we honor that and we aren't just simply pushing a problem to the morning and that brings us to the end of our

086school starttime presentation and we'd be happy to answer any questions that people have well first let me say thank you very much for that thorough presentation thank you very much and I want to thank everyone that is listen did on the school start time committee for all of the work and the time that was put into this all of the questions they ask is that really push the thinking so that was very important but I do want to make clear and principal bourman said it in the presentation the addition of time at the elementary level did not come out of the school start time recommendations that is a district initiative that we have been looking at it just happens that during this time it will fit fit well in the transportation schedule so thank you

087for bringing that uh up also principal bortman so are there questions board members for for the for the committee that's presenting I go no Mikael was first it's whoever you call on President Cas uh thanks for the presentation it was very thorough um I guess I just had a couple questions repeatedly it was said during the presentation adolescent uh middle school and high schoolers benefits yet I'm seeing the Middle School times decrease uh they're getting up earlier when in studies do show and I have researched this that that's actually the most critical age especially in terms of Behavioral development um and that's a concern of mine uh looking at these times um hopefully that was researched I also uh researched and talked to some people um including some school districts in Canada that have looked

088at that um study some studies show that a lot of these that have uh been in these studies they uh academically we lower achieving school districts which shows a higher Gap to achieve this you know what we see is academic progress not to say that all studies are bad I do believe in the science I'm not you know I'm not Discerning that but um that would be another concern of mine if I'm thinking out loud looking at the time changes um because a lot of the studies look at lower income lower uh performing schools where they have that Gap again like I said to improve um those are just a couple areas of concerns another area of concern in terms of um bus pickup times I very I appreciate the 7 o'clock thing or 7

089a.m. uh pickup that it won't be before that but a concern of mine is a safety concern as you know uh some elementary students have to be picked up at Corners some of these places are called the sacks um they don't have sidewalks and that's a concern of mine in daylight savings time it's still dark at 7 a.m. it's a safety concern of mine as I think through this and process it in my head um the only reason I bring up these concerns I like people to hear as a board member where my thoughts are before decisions are made um and voted on um there's always positives and negatives to everything um those are just some concerns that I didn't know if maybe some of those things came up in some of your studies or

090if you saw some of those or had answers to those concerns that I had which would help me you know better understand it yeah I mean we've all of those things have come up and and you know I think you know certainly what you're trying to do is address them as as best you can um when we were in Baltimore one of the things that was given provided to us was actually a a list I don't want to say it was 53 different districts and so we spent a lot of time examining uh other districts and and you know what the benefits are I think you know overwhelmingly while you're right in terms of some of the academic achievement pieces they may have happened um overwhelmingly though the research um the research itself in terms

091of the the health benefits and I and I want to say I mean the school starttime uh the school starttime conference that we went to focused quite a bit on that um and really you know while the academic achievements I mean you know there were other things in there you know for instance one of the things that they talked about down there that we didn't include in ours was um you know one of the one of the districts had actually seen they had examined a they did a two-year examination of um Sports and athletic injuries and found that when they changed it they saw a reduction in that whether or not that's actually you know you know a cause and effect that's tough for us to say they certainly uh believe that um you know

092I think one of the things that that we really focused on uh was the the health and mental health benefits and it does say adolescent um what what was very clear down there though was it's a sliding scale just like Elementary can move earlier um you know you want to you certainly want to have middle schools um as you know especially as looking at it as late as possible what's interesting about Williamsville is our middle schools um are 5 through eight so you're really actually seeing an elementary and a middle school level um you know in in terms of other places um and so so we have that sort of split um piece for that but what what the research is pretty clear on is that the the kids who benefit the most from late

093School star times are the high school and in high school they were talking about traditional 9 through 12 High School uh that's what the the research is focused on uh the 5 through eight you're right especially the seven eight kids would benefit from it um one of the things that we actually did as we first started this and this is where Logistics gets into some of those pieces um is we we really looked at 8:30 and I think I think you saw that in the slide that uh Christine Harding um um presented we looked at 8:30 which is what most of the research will talk about as the time we want to get our high school and middle school kids as close to as possible um and really that's where we kind of started uh

094in fact I think I think our first sort of thing as we were playing with things was an 8:30 to 3:30 for uh uh for excuse me yeah 8:30 to 3:30 for the high schools um then you start getting into well okay how long do you need between bus runs and what does this look like well if we start high school at 8:30 and it's 30 minutes between bus runs that's now Elementary starting at 7:30 that doesn't seem doable so now you start looking at uh at figuring those things those things out um and so yeah we tried to get those middle school as close to that 8:30 Mark as possible can I bring up two things if I may so I also want to stress because we know that what we've seen over the

095many years is a increased need for mental health supports in our school buildings and the research was clear that the movement of times really helps with mental health supports for students I also want to talk because I appreciate what Mr Balia said that's why we were so adamant that no student will be picked up before 7 am. we are also what we fail to mention implementing a transportation efficiency study so what we haven't done in the past was send notice to families to see who really needs Transportation what we do is we develop bus routes for all of our students and many times that's inefficient that's why we have high school buses arriving to high school so early because we've routed a bus for 75 students in 12 ride right and so it leaves a

096lot of inefficient time so so with us surveying our parents and we will be doing that in April and May of who really needs Transportation it allows us to make more efficient bus routes so it will reduce the amount of time we need in the morning but right now saying that no student will be picked up earlier than 7 o'clock helps us that may eventually be 710 7:15 depending on how many students really need Transportation when you drive by any of our schools in the morning or at dismissal you see the line of cars that are lined up dropping off and picking up kids we need to understand what that looks like and how it will affect the transportation need of our district because that will also affect those morning times probably pushing the elementary

097pickup times to later so thank you for that point if I can I just want to acknowledge uh the board members comment about and agree with uh it there is a diff a disproportionate um impact on economically disadvantaged students so those studies will definitely show that um conversely making these changes those impacts increase uh those those proportionally more the magnitude of of change for those students is significantly more one of the key studies that we learned about in Baltimore Cherry Creek School District in Colorado it's a good one I worked in it in the early 2000s it's very similar to Williamsville although it's 50,000 students but demographic wise it's one of the top performing suburban school districts in Denver they were one of the case studies that we were learning about while we're in Baltimore

098and it's a good example of kind of maintaining the high standards of a high quality High performing School District while also making certain adjustments to also uh support all the students throughout the district thank you principal Mana I mean board member Mana I'll take the promotion thank you um you know excellent work um I expect nothing less out of this district and and the stakeholders that attended the the meetings and had the input and you know what what I'm struggling with is is the feedback push back from families who who are saying I need my high school aged child to be home early for the middle school and Elementary School child and and I can't it's it's too much of of a of a it's too cumbersome to send my Elementary or middle school to

099daycare for the hour and a half because right now the elementaries are you know 210 215 release and maybe they'd be home for a half an hour before the high schoolers come home now it's an hour and 40 minutes quite a difference having an elementary uh uh student home waiting until the high school uh um sibling comes home and I would say that's probably the number one concern or complaint I'm getting that you're that you're really gonna mess up my daycare situation and I don't know if I have a question yet but it seems to me that I have to wrestle with you know how are we giving a positive impact to the three high schools and what is the negative impact to the 10 other schools and the families who have children in those

100schools so maybe my question is you know what feedback did you get or what experience did you hear about from the either the conference or the I think Cherry Creek you mentioned you know C can you tell me because because the science is irrefutable basically yeah you know no one here is going to say those I mean I am not going to say that those studies were were were fake or skewed it's you know how does this house of cards work for every family in this District so my question would be what was the feedback or information you received yeah and we've had those conversations also um and and right now there's actually the elementary some of the elementary schools get home before the high schools um currently and you're right it would be yeah

101it would it would be a longer time there um and it you know I think one of the things that that is one of the things that we looked at it's one of the reasons certainly why we were looking at um you know after school care and what that could look like and what the what the need for that um would be I think the most difficult piece of that is and it it's it goes along with one of the things um I had some of my teachers say well why didn't you take a poll and ask people what they wanted um and you know my response was well because if you take a poll and you ask people what they want it's it's not based that research um it's based on well what is

102my situation here and I get that um you know and I think I think that's one of the things that's difficult it's one of the things that anybody who's having a change is going to have to is going to going to struggle with uh I think you know for us one of the reasons why we really wanted to reach out to those Afterschool care programs and look at those and make sure that those things were there is because we it isn't acknowledging you know hey is there something there it's acknowledging the fact that there will probably be changes for some people um I can tell you I've had teachers who you know teachers who have known that they were going that high school was probably going to go later who looked at me and were

103like that's great that fits my life perfectly and we'll have Stu we'll have families like that um and I have teachers who are like oh my Situation's going to be different I'm GNA have to figure that out uh and I think that that is the the the difficult piece of it um as you're going through uh and I wouldn't I I wouldn't characterize it as the high schools are benefiting and the other 10 aren't um I actually think that there's a lot of benefit benefits for all of the levels um certainly you do know that the the research shows um in terms of the high school kids um uh their benefiting I think when you're looking at the overall picture but yeah uh you know anytime you're making a change like this you're going to

104be looking at depending on your your own situation what does that what does that look like and that was why even with our committee when we started um I can tell you for absolute certain there was a member on the committee who um looked at me before all this and said I don't want to change anything um and that's why we asked everybody to really look carefully at the research and what is best for students um you know we're talking about almost 10,000 students and what is going to be best for those students uh as they're doing it and it's why a lot of those pieces that we put in there um came from questions that we all had uh as we worked through the the work on the committee saying like well what about

105this what you know this could be a problem um we one of the things we tried to do was examine as many problems as we could find and how could we ensure that those problems weren't weren't as big a problem uh as we possibly could and I would just add that um there's going to be pluses and minus to either way we look at that problem for some I know some families and parents approached me and said great now I can get to work on time a little bit more earlier in the morning and my older child can get my kid on the bus not that we're recommending our high school students are up at 6:00 a.m. getting their kids on the bus because that defeats the purpose of them sleeping however um there is

106an element of uh some of our families too acknowledging the fact uh they're looking forward to getting to work and it's shifting their daycare needs primarily to the afternoon um it's not going away but it there is definitely be some shifting for some families thank you I just have another comment that I have heard and I'm just wondering if this was brought up or anybody thought about it too a lot of kids have mentioned they have after school jobs and they're very worried now how are they going to to get there at 4:00 or how are they going to fit Athletics and this or clubs and this yeah absolutely um we we looked at that a lot and one of the conversations I had um even with a group of of my students um when

107they were talking about it and um you know I think some of this is It's it becomes perspective right um I had a group of students who said well you know no jobs um start later than you know 3:30 and I said well you know I said that that's an interesting one because Clarance doesn't end till 3:30 right now so do none of the kids in Clarance have jobs is that what we think there will be some some adjustment for that now I will say for the high schools we still do we still would have early release which all three high schools have um so there still would be that that ability for students even though the day may end now at 3:40 um you would actually have um for students you would have the

108ability for them to leave early um I fully expect and I've I've even talked about it with to my counselors who are seeing that there's been an increase in uh seniors asking for uh not having n9th period classes that's not a surprise to me at all um even now currently uh with a 245 end that tends to be uh one of the one of the things we have more students right now um who ask for early release than ask for late arrival uh at South High School I don't know what north and east is but but at South that's true um so I certainly would I I think that that probably will be be something um but you know again I go I I sometimes go back to there will be adjustments uh being made

109but I know that kids from Clarence are working um and their day is going to end about the same time as as ours um you know and and so it can be done but certainly part of that is making sure the community is aware of what's happening and what this looks like also and just one more question about Athletics this has come up too is that right now I can only speak for North I don't know about the other schools but there's a huge struggle to get time you know there's so many people that need to practice and there has to be some creative so now now what happens yeah that creativity piece and just I'll I'll go back and say I wasn't invited to Baltimore and I don't hold it against this group but

110uh I was not at the conference in Baltimore but we will have to get creative we will um middle schools will have to become more available to us and we've talked with some of the principles about that we do expect to use our grass again out front at north for example the winter will be a challenge but it's a challenge that we're willing to take if the research and the committee and the people if this is something that they do want um but it will be a challenge for sure sorry one more question and now are there different people I don't know like different um outside sports teams that rent space or lease space sure so what happens with that then they just won't be able to no we're going to lease space probably a

111little bit later like uh our bowling groups our hockey groups we have hockey practices anywhere from you know 3:00 now which will become 4 4:15 uh we have games at six o'clock at night 8 o'clock at night nine o'clock at night um we'll still do that bowling we have four o'clock to six o'clock rentals golf courses we're going to fight time yes but um we'll work with the golf courses on that venues that we can't control but yes do you mean outside groups renting our spaces um so during the school year outside group rental is pretty limited um because quite honestly we use our uh you know during the school year right we use our time so um it's really rare for outside groups to do it we do have some uh in the winter

112in particular with some gyms and and things like that um and so you may see a little bit of that um I think you know and even we've actually spoken you know one of the things that we've been looking at is um so for instance South is one of the schools when that when I think of uh late fall early spring South is one of the schools that I think could be more adversely affected than possibly North or east north or east actually have uh lighted fields that are larger as opposed to South which has the the singular field um so one of the things we've already uh begun talking about I I spoke to uh Chris about it I was speaking with Adam Ericson when he was here um was are there other avenues

113for us if we need them um ECC is in the process of potentially um you know building a field that's an option for us Damon is in the process of building lighted turf fields that would be an option I don't know how much we would need to and you know and that is part of this process is some of this will be us discovering that as we go through uh what does it look like in terms of sharing space are we going to have to be more economical with that I think we probably are and I think you know those are things that you will uh you will probably look at um you know but it was interesting because one of the things we were very concerned about uh initially when you talk about sports

114was well now buses are going to have to leave that much later I think we were all looking at it as it's 2:45 we get out right now it's 4:00 if we get out at 3:40 now we're looking at 5:00 before buses can leave um and we actually think it's possible that buses will leave earlier now um for away matches than they did than they currently do um even though the school day is 55 minutes later Dr s I just want to thank the committee for all the hard work and research in your conference meetings did you ever come for was there any question of how the students adapted to the new time change and was there how much time did it take in in case where you had s Improvement in mental health and

115Improvement in grades was there like it it happen first year second year after the time change or was any discussion on that so it wasn't discussion so some of the research I mean most of the studies were done fairly quickly after the changes were made um and then there were some longer term ones um you know certainly um you know one of the things that was uh apparent was when you make the change the Sleep begins to change almost almost automatically um because of the the way that it actually works so um I think I think Dan mentioned it in in his slide for every two minutes you adjust the time they tend to gain about one to two minutes they actually said it's closer to one and a half to two minutes of time

116uh that you're going to gain in terms of sleep so those sleep factors are going to you're going to see those AO uh on a sort of automatic basis um there really wasn't anything I talked about the time frame in terms of academics um but a lot of the um a lot of the discussions in terms of um the benefits the pro uh in terms of mental health and other things really went along with the academic results so I would ass I would assume without seeing that actual piece that you're seeing some immediate reactions uh for those things and we are setting up time for some of our students to visit um Alden High School because they did that move a couple of years ago just so that our students can have conversations with those

117students and we're also setting up time for some of our students to meet with students at Clarance to see to get some of their student questions answered about jobs about extracurriculars because clearance starts a little bit later than even our proposal go ahead no I want first Mr belan um I just have two things um as a person who just went through this and the place I work in I was sort I was against it there and I almost don't notice it anymore and I'm also a golf coach in where I work in the five years since we the few years we've done CJ I've never lost a match because of darkness and we we do travel um I guess my question is is there any research that goes against what you're saying did you

118find any that credible research that said no you're you're doing the wrong Say by moving times back not as it relates to the medical field which is a lot of what our conference was about so physiologically talking about what students need when it talks about sleep deprivation um and what students need with their circadium rhythms as they uh move into adolescence uh the science is pretty clear uh legistics there's things that school districts have to manage and deal with so the only negatives have more been case study stories about uh school districts inability to maybe attend to some of the logistics Transportation daycare things that you know are unique to their uh environment or their you know locality I just love I'm sorry do we have any idea what percentage of our students have jobs

119after school is it like are we talking I was talking about with another board member earlier is it 3% is it 28% like do we have any idea we don't I don't I would say this I don't believe it's 3% it's higher than that I'm just curious like that's a concern that parent I mean my phone's been popping off throughout this meeting and and that's one of the concerns I'm seem to be getting like but what how many what how many kids are we talking about like that's you know a legitimate question I think a lot I'm sure I don't know s but I'm sure employers will adapt right the the need for employees is out there they're not going to say no because you can't be here 15 minutes earlier I don't need you

120we're being very flexible in District with how we hire right so I think um it goes back to what principal bourman said earlier this is a change and one of my colleagues said it best yesterday we were in another meeting change is never easy but we learn how to do hard better right so it's about making sure the community knows what we're doing and they will also help us adapt because there are other districts looking at us Statewide you know just like very similar we looked at oan we looked at Alden we looked at um districts that have made this change and how they went about it we looked at districts outside of the state and people will also be looking at us um about how look how we do it and I think having

121you know having spoken to high school kids having high school kids of my own I think employers are already flexible um I know when like you know both of my sons and they would play in their Sports Seasons they wouldn't work and then when their Sports season ended they'd go back to work and so I I know there is flexibility certainly this is this would be a change for them though a board member of escalia I'll be a principal can I [Laughter] take um I with my comments before I I do want to say I I agree with what Mr Mana said and I understand the studies and I I don't want to you know I you guys did a fabulous job I I don't want to take that away with my concerns of what

122I brought up I just try to think out loud of all concerns that you know many people have and as we were discussing this I I came up with two other questions um one is it affect the budget with Transportation it does that's that yep it will just to follow up when when just to clarify too when you talk about the opportunity for those shuttle buses I I want to make clear that's not we're not guaranteeing it's going to happen correct that my second one so thanks but they but absolutely but when we spoke with Transportation it is more likely because we will have the ability because the middle schools um ending early and many of the middle school buses for example that serveice Mill also serveice South right cost it well it's it's a

123question of the timing and the cost but it looks like it's more in line with what we need to have happen to to be able to have those shuttle buses and as far as cost I know that uh Mr Kelly gave us preliminary estimates of around 650 ,000 realizing that 64% of that is reimbursable transportation aid but that's why the efficiency surveys that we send out are so important because if we reduce our ridership and we know that we can reduce our bus routes also because this will add some bus routes but we're able to reduce those when we realize how many students are on the bus if we Route 75 to 90 students and only 12 are writing there's opportunity there for sure yeah again that's another just talking about how the rock profile

124Center or study and all that that's a fear of M what's going to change with foundation and and another I would a concern I won say it's not a um a lot of things came up while problems would have been with districts that have logistic issues and then years later they find out that abnc is happening I guess I not saying this change is bad or doesn't need to happen it just seems like it's happening very very quick not thinking of all every single logistic thing small small little fears of mine that's all I'll just say and I I I share the story of do with the studies either I don't want no one of it's funny because one of my buddies at the gym came up to me he's a parent at whims will

125East and he said my son tells me you guys are thinking about changing the studies I'm like where have you been the last year and a half because this is something that we've been discussing for a year and a half so I I don't want anyone to think that this is something we're rushing into we haven't provided enough time to study it and explore all of the logistics about it but we do realize also that no matter how much planning how much study you do a lot of logistics are answered once you get into the process and we have to reserve time for that and we have to reserve ourselves to understand that that that may happen also so I just ask you know board members and the public to understand that I agree and

126I ask those things for responses like that I think to think that way and just you know as as Mr Mana said in terms I did have one individual come up uh they're in tears talking to my wife at Wegman's um and I think as we grow in diversity in The District in general there tiers where I can't afford child care anyways I don't know what I'll do if this happens and there's it's you know I I'm a teacher I want to see every kid be successful and academics to grow I totally agree with that I I get it it's just that's where I struggle and I want to say I because I'm an individual board member um that's where I struggle when you have that as we're changing you know there it's hard it's

127a hard decision because you guys are 100% accurate by there's plenty of positives there are great things that can you know are the outcomes but then you get those small little stories and negatives and you kind of makes you pull back just a little you know what I mean right no and I I completely understand understand that I completely get it because um you know even during the time when I was finishing my dissertation at UB one of the questions kept coming up and I know board members have mentioned it before also when we know what's in the best interest of students when we know when studies are done and there's clear evidence what will benefit students why does it take so long for a K to 12 to adopt or adapt when we know

128what's in the best interest of kids and so we have to start to understand that I know our board has been very strong with supporting what's in the best interest of kids look at our class siiz initiatives right our board many years ago adopted class-size guidelines and there's definitely not as much research supporting that as there is supporting this and we were the leader in that right so we understand that we have to sometimes make sure we keep the focus on what's in the best interest of KS according to the research according to what we know is in the best interest of KS and I appreciate all the questions and there will always be questions there'll always be anecdotes but we have to eventually look at this is the research this is what we know

129is in the best interest of kids are we ready to make that commitment for our students and I will say um during right after uh the channel 7 story I think it was or the Buffalo news they came out about the same time whenever they were in it must have been October um I I spoke to uh you know a district administrator from a from another district and um you know the comment that was sort of made was look we all know this research is there and we all know it's better for kids but it's a lot easier not to do this um and you know it strikes me that um you know it is you know I I sort of joked with people I'm like you know I have four year four and a

130half years till I'm eligible to retire it's a lot easier for me not to do this and just WR off I don't know if that's what's right though and I think anybody who really looks that that research knows geez this is the right thing to do but what is difficult is when you have 13 buildings and you have however many employees 2,000 you know 3,000 employees and you know 10,000 kids and all those families um yes there's this is going to um you know I I I sort of joke it's like a lot of decisions we make at the building level um where we do something and it's you know it's it's it's the you know it's the curve you're going to have 20% of the people who absolutely hated that decision 20% of the

131people who absolutely love that decision and the 60% in the middle could sway either way and I think that that is true there's there's no doubt that this is this is a difficult decision I just wanted to highlight one point about the research just looking at all of our research articles the these Dat Back to 2014 2017 so although we've been exploring this for the past year and a half this research is old right we are we are catching up now to to that research to that information that existed for all these years so just wanted to highlight that point Thank You vice president pulin yeah I haven't wanted to comment because I did have the opportunity to go to Baltimore and get immersed in the um soup as they as they say um but

132I know as a board member this is my fourth year on the board this is the first year because we were taking action that I haven't gotten emails from students and families saying when is the school district going to look at doing things to make this more change the start time of school it's too early um so that that's been on my mind for the years that I've I have been on the board we've heard it at Community forums when we've had Parents speak to us about that um and I I an educator um at heart I've been in education for a long time and I've been hearing about this my um grandson who graduated last year and his friend said why didn't you do this when we were in school I said you know

133it takes time it takes time um but I'm also thinking about our our community and it we are asking some hard changes for people and I look at the community also and think you know for a third of the people in our community it's not going to be a change because our middle schoolers who are moving into high school they're going to be virtually starting at the same time that they have been so that's not new to them for our fourth graders who are moving into our middle school they're going to be starting at virtually the same time and for our kindergarteners who are coming in it's all it's all new so we have some newness there to to build on as well um I'm I'm very I'm very hopeful and I'm anxious to hear

134from the community um their concerns so that we can address them and hopefully um do what's best for our kids I also early on in my career here as a board member we started hearing so much about student mental health and I raised the question what is it we are doing as a school district to create a situation that is causing mental health problems for our students and one of those things is the time that we start high school so I'm I'm glad that we've have come to this point and um hope we can work through the logistics that we need to to make this a good situation for all of our students and I think it's fair to say that although we've kind of lived this the last year and a half we're glad

135that you guys have to make the decision thank you very much thank you for all of your work and thank you for your phenomenal presentation and answering the questions tonight we greatly appreciate it thank you very much so much [Applause] board president I turn it back over to you thank you we are now on item 7A the board goals midyear progress report is in board docs board members are there any questions or comments regarding our goals no okay 7B our policy committee will meet on January 28th on December 19th board members visited the new Maple West temporary classrooms that are now in use other events and building visits are listed board docs and are there any board member comments or questions regarding any events meetings or building visits okay 7c vice president pulin will you

136please provide an update regarding the student board member uh yes the um student board member committee M did meet um via Google meet this afternoon um we looked at the three proposals that had been presented by all three high schools and we did come to a consensus and vote on on the process that will be utilized I will um have a finalized document for the board at the February 11th meeting which will be finalized but the um overall process does mirror the process that is used for the selection of board selection and election of board members who are duly elected members of this board they are going to be use utilizing a um short form application and asking the student to obtain per uh petition signatures of 4% of the high school population which will

137include at least two staff members um that will be followed by a um interview process that all those students who have completed that process will be interviewed by a committee appointed by the school building administrator which will include an administrator two teachers and two students those that process will identify three potential candidates who will be then elected from the general population of the student body oh student and teacher body the teachers will be asked to vote as well so awesome I have a question wonderful Mr Mana thank you thank you for all the work you've done so you know I read through the the three proposals so yes if I could get a sneak preview of the answer I appreciate it so I saw a couple of them had a grade GPA attached to it

138you had to have a 75 and one school one was 85 is that is that still is that going to be your final recommendation no not it's not not a part of our recom not a part of the process identifiable there so that's not a requirement for um because the law says you gotta be there one year basically yeah the law says you have to be there one year yep um how would the election be conducted it's going to be an all school election so they will utilize the processes that they have available whether that's through wits or a student ballot they will or that will have to be managed in each school okay was there an attendance uh one of the schools so you have to have like a 95% attendance that was to

139that was potential to that was a potential criteria to apply but no that we did not include any of those why why is teachers voting that because the uh it came up in the conversation today that the um person who was on the board would not just necessarily represent the students but that they would be conduits to the whole school community so um that was their that that is what is going to be coming to the board the recommendation that's the recommendation I find interesting that teachers get a vote Voice on that too well they get two votes then if they live in the district they get to vote for a student get to vote for the students can't vote for us but they the the teachers can't vote for yeah students can't vote for

140us but the students vote for themselves and the teachers can vote for the students even if they don't live in the district but students can't vote right but right but teachers who don't live in the district even though they teach in the district can vote for the student but they can't vote for the board right if you don't list your teacher no no I I no what I was saying but I wasn't making a big deal out of no no no I'm just saying I was following your train of thought because then I said then lots of luck right all right my thoughts exactly but then the but then the students are non voting members I was just it was just circular in nature but I hear what you're saying yeah they're not voting members

141they're not voting me thank you for that well it sounds like we're going to have a lot to mle over to and to decide at our February meeting so yes that's amazing any other questions before we move on okay uh item 7D and 7e EC ASB and nisba items are in board docs 7f board members please remember to check your upcoming leaz on assignments and try to secure a substitute if you are unable to attend 7g this past month we received correspondence regarding school start times prayer breaks classroom temperatures and a bus concern are there any questions or comments regarding items 7D through 7g we already asked some so I don't see any more we're moving on to Cass consent agenda may have a motion to approve agenda items nine minutes 10 Personnel 11 business

142and finance 12 exceptional education student needs and Student Activities and 14 district facilities and support services as presented Mr buan is flat any discussion all in favor motion carries unanimously at this time I would like to thank the following individuals retiring on July 1st for their service to the district Whitney Abbott school counselor Transit middle school with 30 years of service Norma Jacobs teacher M middle school with 33 years of service Diane Keefe teacher Transit middle school with 19 years of service Jean Valley teacher Forest Elementary School with 29 years of service Lynn banza teacher Dodge Elementary School with 18 years of service and I would also like to thank the following retiree for their service to the district Denise graser for food service helper Maple West Elementary School with six years of service thanks

143to [Applause] all okay sorry my stuck here 14a may have a motion to take from the table for the second reading of policy updates 7130 7241 7554 and 7555 as presented miss pulan Mr buan is there any discussion all in favor motion carries unanimously may I have a motion for the second reading and Adoption of these same policies Mr buan Dr Spicer any discussion all in favor motion carries unanimously 14b may have a motion for the first reading of policy updates 7522 as presented miss blinger Mr Mana is there any discussion all in favor motion carries unanimously however Mr buan has left the table may have a motion to table these policies for the second reading and adoption at the February meeting Dr Spicer Mr Mana is there any discussion all in favor again motion

144carries unanimously 800 items 15 and 16 there are no matters to discuss under instruction or legislative matters item 17 are there any matters to discuss under Committee of the whole seeing none we're moving on to 18a oh I'm so sorry Dr Singh I just had a question on the committee as a whole yes the governor announced Universal free meal for all students for schools would this come under the governor's budget or something under the foundation anything it's the governor's proposal it's not been adopted yet and it would come up my understanding it would come out of the the bud the state budget correct let's yes let's not forget she's in an election year so she could just be saying anything wait was that for lunches great I'm not saying it's a bad thing I just

145it'll be phenomenal I just can't Bank on that right now phenomenal I mean no one announced it cost that's right yeah yeah an [Music] election all right any other matters under Committee of the whole okay we'll move on to 18a Second public expression if anyone in the audience would like to speak at this time please step up to the podium I do not see anyone so we're moving on to item 19 our next regular board meeting and budget work session is February 11th may have a motion to adjourn the regular board meeting Miss Fletch miss pulin all in favor motion carries unan unanimously thank you and good night everyone good night good night thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.