001all set thank you good evening everyone and welcome to December 19th regular business meeting of the horse head School Board um I ask that you stand and honor America and recite the pledge Al I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all I'd like to uh wish everyone a uh happy holiday season and a successful New Year and I will end the meeting by doing the same thing um very festive in here tonight with the decorations so Center Street did a nice job in wel welcoming us um and now we are going to adjourn to Executive session so I need a motion to adjourn to Executive session for the purpose of discussing individual tenure
002reviews and an individual instructional Personnel matter second all in favor I I oppos exstension all right so hopefully we will be back by 6 o' that's our plan the pledge prior to adjourning to Executive session so we are reconvening to public session and our first order of business is to approve the minutes of November 21st can I have a motion please Curiosities discussion comments I have uh one um Amendment I'd like to make under section 12.01 under the presidence report um in addition to shiman Canal being in the last sentence as a sponsor of the dinner I attended um how packaging was also a sponsor so I'd like to have them added to the minutes please thank you and all right all in favor oppose exstension all right the next section we have is community
003comments and questions and I am told uh we have no comments from the community tonight Terry um gave me that information that nobody signed up to speak tonight so now we will go to the report from the student representative and tonight I am the student representative goes back a long time in history so MIA uh cannot be here so I have her report um first of all spirit week is happening at all of the buildings and the high school had ugly sweater day today and tomorrow is Pajama Day uh Polar Express occurred at Garden Road interact members read Christmas stories to elementary school students within the district many clubs such as interact and senior class officers roll the bell for the Salvation Army uh Kettle in the community junior class has announced that their prom
004theme will be golden Galla horse heads United Raiders held cookie and ornament making last Monday which your sports have all had a great kickoff to their Seasons correct Mr yes sir uh horse said jazzband Orchestra and choirs had their Christmas concerts this month the jazz band and Winter Guard participated in Sparkle the football team laid waths at um woodon Cemetery in honor of recent Across America for the veterans and the Green Room players are hard at work practicing for their play and if you would like to see Mia more than you would like to see me she is the witch in Into the Woods for the spring play so go out and support Mia and you'll get to see her and you don't have to see me so thank you M for your report all
005right um next we go to our presentations and 5.01 how we use data to support the whole chat there for am I accurate and that this is like a continuation from last month we're on the same path to give a more complete view what okay thank you yes so we had planned for a three um cycle you got the introduction we're going to take you along a journey to what we're do next and then in January we'll do another um round and kind of talk a little bit more some we're going to talk about today which is the data uh the information about students so uh really it's about that all child approach and the work we do in the multier system of sports I can't reiterate enough this is not by any means new
006work that we do um we've been talking about the system for quite some time and the importance of it and the learning that we're doing on ntss New York state did uh release some information on mtss and their RTI model the response to intervention a couple years back and um there's a little bit stagnant but we had to move forward regardless because of the important work that it is you recall that this is talk about wrapping not just the academic world that we often find ourselves in but the behavioral and the social emotional world of our children and what that look like to support them in all aspects it goes back to a 2015 statement of the invisible backpack and what people bring every day so today we're going to just kind of go into
007our ideas of and the work that we're doing on um this work and I do have a team behind me that's going to be coming up at various points uh you recall all this work culminates in will we called Port of a graduate this is what we identified as a district through thousands of inserts and data points about what we want to see as a good human right what is a hor heads kid going to leave us with thousands of pieces of input and they were drilled down and this was deated dur Anin process to determine this is what we want now it's our goal to create assessments and look at information that revolves around these pieces New York state has created their own you might remember I mentioned that last time we met and
008presented we are going to see how we kind of crosswalk with them because this comes from us this is too important uh to our work so with that I'm going to hand it over to Joe right so as we continue to Circle back to mtss in our in our next steps you whether that is with our instructional leadership team with our staff and as we continue to outdate the board it's so important that we continue to Circle back um to our why remember why this work is so critical for us you know as Tony went through the POR of graduate indicators they really do shine that light again and the focus we are placing on the whole child Beyond just the academics and that those are outcomes that when students graduate for say we truly
009want to achieve for all our of our students last month as we talked through this you know we acknowledged that well those are the outcomes we want all students to reach we know that our students don't all learn at the same speed they don't all learn in the same way and they come to with such a wide Continuum of strengths and of needs so if all really is going to mean all when we say we want all students to get there this this work is so grounded in equity for our students you and ensuring that all students truly are going to receive the supports they need when they need them to continue to work towards meeting those outcomes um those Concepts you see here I won't reread this but as we bolded some of these
010terms in our in our y statement that is carefully crafted over time you you see those terms pop up and really Capt concept of what we're trying to do as we continue this work so this was kind of friend this is our essential question that will we Revisited and we'll continue to revisit as we continue to work through the parts of this process the big picture question we continue to work towards um is how do we create a system that really does ensure that all students are going to get those supports they need when they need them we can guarantee that as a system um so that all are high levels and academically emotionally and and so what we want to do with the board over the next two meetings is is really place the
011focus on how in the we're we're talking about this system and all the work that's going into it then the bottom line is how is it positively impacting our students all the way down to the individual student problem so this is this is a fictitious example that's up on the board this idea of me Jenny here's an example of a profile student we might work with see up here the gr four student strengths include reading skills enjoyment of reading and good comprehension challenges more on the math side math concepts and problem solving and perhaps we also know about this student that we see her beginning to withdraw from school affecting her social emotional wellbeing and overall engagement in learning so you can kind of see the Continuum this is one example of a student that
012might present with that ranges that academic that social and that emotional you know and what becomes critical in terms of what these supports would look like for this particular child is what is the information we are using the data we are using to really drill down and understand every child's strengths because they all have every child's areas of need um and again from academic to social to emotional and so tonight is kind of the start of when we think about a particular student and we plan to come back in January and share some more specific case studies that really walks through what would these layers of support look like for a child with this particular profile our guided question for tonight that comes starting to take you through how we use various sources of data
013to gain that information um from a big picture standpoint all the way down to how we support an individual child um to get to support the whole child reach our students so I'm going to turn over to Tiffany to start that conversation okay so when you think about our data and what we're doing we have such a robust system of Assessments and I think our goal today is really just to kind of break those down for you so when we do share these key studies with you you'll be able to really understand how we these pieces together to drive what we meet our students and those individuals but before doing so it's really really important as we think about our curriculum work as we think about our students we have three types of learning rules
014that we want to make sure that we are giving to our students and that they are doing well with these I'm going to give you some analogy so we have this funn and I shared this a little bit last year but I want bring in the length of the mtsw we have this funel in a fire where you open up the students brains and you're going to funnel all that information in it's really import want them to know formulas vocabulary those are important Knowledge and Skills that we want students to learn very important we also have this meaning making we want students to take that knowledge and skill and go ah we understand we're making connections we get it you learn the word stop and then you go out out in our community and see
015what's those are some examples of what we're trying to get students to learn and then in addition is those transfer that's a deeper level we want to pack in a few a few strong standards priority standards into suitcases so students can take those with them and really start to make those connections and recall those and do it independently so when we say all of this it's so critical that we have assessments that measure and show evidence of all three of these learning gos some of the different types of Assessments we currently have in the system and we're going to get through a little bit more deeper into throughout the presentation we do have of course our New York State assessments we we have what we're currently working on developing Cornerstone performance task and I'm going
016to share with you what those mean and what those are we have some common assessments performance tasks throughout assessments throughout some of the units of study and then we have Benchmark and screener assessments diagnostic assessments and then ongoing informal assessments I know that seems like a lot but we're going to break that down for you all of these assesses are critical for all of our students we need all of these you can't do one without the other they're all important they all provide us some data to support what we need to do for so Tiffany Shar I continue on the different tools that we utilize throughout this work and we're going to spend some time just walking through each one and kind of highlighting what it is the data it provides Us and how we
017use that data and continue to work to build capacity to use that data as way possible to impact our students so starting big picture the New York State assessments you know we do know that these cover a 3A assessments at the end of the year Ela and math as well as a grade five science as well as our reg exams up at the secondary level and we think what information can we glean from these assessments really the value we get out of it it provides us end ofe information and we can boil down and really look at how our students did question by question and standard by standard you know and start to looking that Beyond just one year but also longitudinal so that if we look across a threeyear trend are there certain learning
018standards that we seem that continuously perform well in comparison to our region G analysis reports we get um that show how we do all the way down to the standard level and also the flip of that are there standards that we also seem to underperform you know over time in comparison to region and if so you know looking at how we use that data how can we then start to take a deeper dive into those standards you know if there's ones that we are consistently exing in let's talk about what we're doing instructionally and practic I and try to grow those practices and build that out if there are standards that you know you seem to be underperforming in let's take a deeper dive into the language of that standards look at the types of
019questions and make sure we're clear on what's really me is here one thing we talk about on our end you can take 10 Educators sometimes to read the same standard and interpret it 10 different ways so that's important work to not just know what our standards are but really understand what they mean what they're asking our students and how we would you know be the same page what do we mean when we say evidence about proficiency that's what we Contin to do um and also you know while in terms of how it impacts our work with students it does give us an end ofe data point that can almost serve as a screening type measure to say here's a student that you know might be but along with other measures might be a student that
020would benefit from Intervention support the following year the important limitation of these assessments and that continue to highlight is that we get this information when the year is over and so we we we we can't use this to to intervene on that student while they're still within our course or within our unit um throughout the year but they do give us that of your data point that might inform supports for the following but I say that because that is where the rest of this continue become so important but a sample of a gap analysis report this is meant to to get into the weeds and get overly Technical and we did share an example of this last year and I mentioned that the idea of you're looking at Trends and this comes from our our
021Gap analysis that the earth science team and this you see kind of a range of questions and if you look at the fourth column over you see the Year this ranges over the past 3 years the region has spend administer you can you can see for this specific standard this is how many times that standard was assessed on individual questions over the last three years it becomes valuable to look over time how have we done here if you go all the way to the column on the right you see this column titled Gap to bosis and you know the quick way to try to explain this is just that when we compare the total percentage of points that our students and forets earned on each of those questions in comparison to all of the other
022Bose districts that would have taken this assessment it gives the Gap in comparison you know and we you notice that what is highlighted in GRE is any time that we outperform the region by 10% or more on a question related to The Standard you can see this is a standard we're pretty consistently perform the region and by significant amount um so this would be an example of one of those part te to look at and say you know this is a celebration let's talk about what we're doing instructional that appears to be working so well for our students and let's just continue to raise awareness and spread good practice on our team and learn from each other again there's also the opportunities where you find the Trends on the opposite direction where we might do
023a deeper dive to make sure we understand andat um for our next steps to continue to improve there so there's implications for our teacher teams there's implications for our curriculum coordinators when we look at are there areas that you know perhaps we can continue to revise our curriculum to be stronger in some of these areas so it can inform that program level work to um but I emphasize again that this isn't information that you're getting in the moment with students while you can still act up that's where the rest of our assessments will walk through I also just wanted to sh the New York State Assessments in the region that's more the choir in the meeting making you're not going to see that transfer level of of learning goals as we dive into the Cornerstone
024assessment this is something we haven't developed yet these are things that we really want to get our teacher teams together to start to develop these are something that we would probably look at transitional years one great example it's not currently but we could look at our M interviews as an example but have more intentionality behind those those we want cornerstones to show indicators of our for of a graduate that we're being good humans that we're independent we want to make sure we see growth in students over those indicators so this is something futuristic that we're really excited to dive into they're not there yet but I think this will be a great opportunity for students to really show evidence of transfer once we get these developed and then what we will also do is our
025end go that Port they walk out we want them to have some type of portfolio or something they whatever field it is whether it's a Workforce or whether it's college or any of trade schools that they have something that they can be proud of here's a resonate here's what I do here's how I highlight myself this is how I can get a job so that is our end goal through all of these Cornerstone assessments I just put up an hypothetical of something that we could work towards again this needs to be you need to have our teacher teams at the table to help develop these and really look at some of some of the work that our students are currently the next type of assessment we like to speak about is Comm assessments these are
026something that we are working on um our teachers are working very hard on we currently are having our teachers develop performance tasks performance tasks truly measure that transfer they're going to get to that deeper level of learning Beyond just the acquir and theing that is our goal through this we want kids to go beyond the standards to really be able to apply it in an authentic way so those are one common assessments if if our teams are in the curriculum cycle that they're developing after each unit so that they can apply their knowledge in the in skills in an authentic way in addition we're also looking at Comm assments throughout the unit we want to make sure that students are growing throughout the unit and we're not just waiting to that end endit so if
027there are some areas that we need to work on a common assessment can assist with those those common assessments will can do acquiring me making you may not get to that level of transfer so these are ongoing they're not always perfect we're always going back and revising those and we're looking at our student data we want to make sure that we can provide opportunities for extension by looking at the data as well as is there any early intervention that we can start right away in our classrooms and just some of the samples this is a grade five math sample it is a DOA puppy event this is a performance Tas so our team of teachers developed their curriculum unit and then they they decided at the end of the there are two or three priority
028standards that they truly wanted to assess but they wanted to do it in a meaningful way and I will give you we can give you an actual copy of this you can see it this is just a visual up there but it really should get kids to think about what they've learned and apply it in an authentic way some way that they've never experienced before so that they can carry all of that information in their suitcase and take it to the next unit we do ask that students are graded on a rubric for this for their performance task just so that we can really see where they're at and if if something's going on we can also intervene there and and assess those standards that they might not have done so well so the assessments
029we've touched on to this point are really measuring the outcomes of align gr level standards level outcomes and so what we also need when we think that mtss we'll have some students that haven't yet learned prior skills one of the foundational skills and so we need a way to quickly assess and and identify where might some of those gaps exist for our students that we can then dive deeper on that really becomes the role of our Benchmark in streaming assessments again not not so much the purpose of grade level skills but ways to get brief and Norm reference measures that are going to uncover foundational gaps in an efficient way whether that's academic skills social emotional or behavoral and typically these are screeners we administer at set points throughout the year often fall witer spring
030usually times a year an example we shared with the board last year one we've used um for a number of years is am plus this is more our academic that helps to uncover quickly um students that might be flagged for potential foundational deficits in literacy skills math skills that continues to be a part of the system um you'll notice the the assessments we've shared at this point have been mostly academic but when we started this we said this is full child work it continues to be so one thing we'll share with you in a moment is the example here intentionally you see this example reference the social skills Improvement system or ssis social emotional learning we're starting to look at what Benchmark or screening tools are out there that can also start to identify where
031students are at with some of the important social and emotional skills that been defined as critical for success for our kids we'll share an example of that in a moment but again this is this is meant to be efficiently and administered and just as kind of dipstick for all of our students that we would then dive deeper on any students that might be FL potentially having foundational deficits in any of those areas and that's where we going a diagnostic assessment that will talk about in the moment but again I'm covering gaps from prior years and so this example I referenced and I I would preface this that we are in the very very early stages of this um you P sire is always overseeing some of this with our student services and specifically our school
032psychologists across the district are just starting to get the to in the water of pting some of this so nothing that's gone out on any kind of large scale yet um but you can see some of the skills highlighted here um by gastle has these seal competencies that's the collaborative for academic social emotional learning skills you see skills like self- awareness self- management social awareness relationship skills responsible decision making and motivation to learn alongside the academics and sometimes there's there's that assumption that those are just skills that student should have and they should just come to school those skills already in place and really that mindset shift that those are skills we also want to develop in our students and teach and help them develop over time and they really live inside our portrait of
033a graduate so an example here a self- Awareness on this tool not to take a deep dive into this rubric by any means but what this tool potentially does for us is Define what those behaviors look like and also Define a Continuum as you see there from levels one to five of what how it would present at each level along that Continuum for our students so you know we get a read on where students are at and developing their selfawareness for example as a critical social emotional skill and then you know inform an instructional plan response what would it look like to then provide supports for students who are not yet there in 7 of these critical skills as well so pushing ourselves it's so easy our comfort level as academics in this work to
034really Define what these skills look like sound like and what does it look like to teach them and really taking that on our so just a little sample of some of the tools we're starting to explore at a deeper level to to build our own capacity ex monitor those skills our another assessment we is is diagnostic assessments and this is really just at the up level these are really meant to be if we get those screeners and a student has AED FL so our team our experts are diving deeper that's what this means diagnostic means dive deeper let's figure out what's going on let's diagnose how we can best support our students so they will give we have a whole list of different diagnostic that we do after students have been either fed on the
035screeners and we don't necessarily just look at the ASW data we also look at teacher observation we look at how they perform in the classroom and then we're like okay we really do see that we need to dive deeper so we then offer these different Diagnostics throughout our academics um not just like Joe said not just the academic side but we're also looking at to Define these on the social emotional Behavior side as well it's it's super important to help us for to intervene as well as for extensions if we can see students doing quite well in the green and in the blue how can we provide those exensions for them in the classroom this is just some examples of the work that our teams have done they put together we really worked hard on
036the ELA side of a flowchart so if they you know if they are flagged what does that mean and what diagnostic tool do we actually use to help students so this is just one example we have the same on the maap side of things that we've worked through and this is our goal is for the social emotional behavior and this is just an example of one of the diagnostic tools that we use till the past and that's more at the elementary level so our assessments to this point have really been the more formal moment and time assessments that are administered what we don't want to leave out of this conversation it's so critical too it's just the ongoing informal assessment that happens with our teachers and staff on a day-to-day basis we all the way
037down the less rather that is learning tasks that happen in the classroom what we observe as we watch students work we learn so much day to day that gauges how students are progressing towards these learning outcomes within lessons and across lessons and so this this information plays a critical role for our sta it's on a day-to-day basis and when Go full circle back to where we started with New York State assessments and what that gives us and what it doesn't we reference that this doesn't give us information that we can use while we still have the students in front of us this does all the other talk through and here all the way down to the lesson level so just the power that provides our teachers that when we structure class in such a way
038that we're learning where students are at in their progression toward clear goals we can provide them with that specific And Timely feedback from our expert teachers while learning is still occurring and Inspire that growth in the moment um and can inform the intervention supports that can be provided while we're still in the unit we don't want to wait until the end of the unit or the end of the year to find out a student might describe over right we have systems to we work to continue to build systems to still make sure they get that support but you see the term follows the best intervention is prevention how are we learning about where students at whe we still live inside that unit and can intervene and address misconceptions before they become biger before finishes that
039day-to-day inform assessments to we use there and also gives us as our Educators a continual rate on the effect of our own instruction there's also that how are the strategies that I'm using working for the students in front of me have that collaboration share what's working well for our kids um continue to to share best practice and grow each other um with our our teams deps so examples here this can look a lot of different ways you know you see in the bottom left there the teacher that's observing a child building the blocks conversations having down pre level what that looks like to go those opportunities um the class work that occurs throughout questioning you see the TIC concept I I can think of a recent visit of a math classroom where the last few
040minutes of the class the teacher has reviewed the goals of the lesson the practice that just occurred and the students are each given a few minutes individually to answer one question and just turn it in and the message to the students is this is not for a grade this is a chance to show after the practice we just engag in where is your learning at right now so I as your teacher can collect that get a quick read on where everyone is at and per the teaching for the following so also taking some of that threat out of the learning process for the students feel safe take RIS I'm going to have opportunities to continue to learn and receive feedback from my teachers so looks a lot of different ways um but the power of
041being able to inform our instruction on a day-to-day basis and be as responsive as we can for students that completes the so needless to say an expression I've used before is drip where data Rich sometimes information for right we have lots of information at our disposal the ongoing informal assessments members do on a daily basis that's a lot of information coming in to help identify what happened to the student and how to assist the student in the moment as well as right up to that New York City of assessment that one time 2hour exam snapshot of how that student might be doing that particular course and then how we are doing as a system and Trend want to will work so much going on here as far as the acquir making me and our ultimate
042goal we want students to transfer and just a reader at that point I always think it's helpful to give some examples and I wanted to share this one before so there would be a moment so I remember being tested at New York State assessment on the Pagan theorem and I remember having to remember a s plus b squ c s I think we all remember that we it's drilled into our heads as a in the process to which we take we also know that that problem can be solved like 174 different ways but we do a couple different ways with our students and they acquire that knowledge and then they do that work on a regent exam to show that they've done that work and perhaps theyve you know at least show an acquired skill
043the question then takes it a step further and takes it to making some meaning out of it it might be more in a um a questioning of a a scenario or a problem set or part of a larger thing they have to manipulate it a little bit differently and make meaning and and you know shift it and make it their own in some way still possible in theate assessment and not in the multiple choice probably but mostly later around it certainly could be an Choice and then I'm on the job site with my dad and we're doing a a deck and he says we need a right angle measure 3T and 4ot I oh I know this you're doing a bment theorem and D had couple exp tips for me but he basically said yes
044I just whatever it's called we need a 345 triangle right now so I can make sure this is a square and so I started to all internalize understanding I transfer that knowledge to a real life situation in the moment that was once just sitting there somewhere stuck in my brain in just an equation and I sometimes now I'm really actually I made a connection in a meeting and I then I transfer it to something else where it wasn't originally a static two dimensional world and it's a skill that we want to see students transfer it's critical thinking and that's how we would measure that when we think about that transfer skill in P Port of graduate I've done that some of the highest levels of critical thinking there um you know and taking that information
045to that level that's what we want our students to be able to do and we want to figure out how we measure that and how do we make sure that reaching those those levels n that's not to Discount require nor transfer excuse me or um making meaning those are very important but in the ultimate we want to take our essential standards most really important things that we want students to know 10 years from now and we want to make sure that they're they're transferring and making making it for home and seeing it in the bigger picture to hit those portional graduate so as we move forward we have a lot of work here to do as a system to identify and figure out what are these data use and how do we use them appropriately
046we often school districts look at the New York State assessments because they're they're you see them everywhere they're they're an accountability exam but they really don't tell us much about the day-to-day learning what our students are doing and how we can assist them and we're looking to strengthening some of these common form assessments this performance task that New York state has put forward that we are already on and creating which is awesome and looking to that next step which is the Cornerstone Assessments in our transition years and to identify how we're measuring appr appr of the gred graduate over several years and would it be awesome if we have something as Tiffany said students are showing how they've achieve these highest levels of of uh transfer on these postal graduate what we think are important
047is a system that our graduates leave us with so I can't you know so the really the core we look at as a system is how are we using the information at hand for our students and how is that affecting and how we supporting our students through all the vast pieces of data sets we have so what you're going of course for us on our end um the staff learning our principles have been wonderful in the engagement and their home learning and and tring that to uh staff as we move forward and the the the capacity of the district to understand all this process um it is does take quite a a large lift to keep this moving forward in the learning that's required so you'll see we're working on those common definitions to make
048sure there's understanding of what these different tiers are the tier one two tier three you see in the picture on the right as well as you know uh what the academic social emotional behavioral supports that we need to provide that'll be happening as we go into January through March with our staff as one of our district polls when we talk about on this work and you have to start with a common base and strong base next we'll be looking to show you some student cases and case studies and how we use that data and how it informs our work uh to ensure we have those high levels um for all students um also there's a third piece to that right not only we looking at a case study but you remember we talked about how
049we use these exams um especially the high stakes ones as a means of trend analysis to say okay what happened here we can look at it by cohort or we look it by the individual school year year-to year regardless of the cohort and what is it telling us about the instruction the curriculum that we're building and we're working on WE constantly revising and what this tell us we need to do differently to best support the students and we are called our essential standards um we talked about that in previous um presentations so we'll look for the January normally we sit up here and we give you a a dump of information I put up a graph that shows the third grade assessment the fourth grade assessment math Ela and I spend an hour talking about
050a bunch of different assessments and I'm asking the group of people to try to make sense of a lot of information New York state has approved their website they provide a accountability and a measures um website for All State exams it's all call through it better than I can probably present up here it's all available I think what we want to make sure is important to the system is that that's just one thing we don't discount it but we know there's more important things we do with our students that lead us to those higher levels of meaning and um Mak can transfer of information knowledge and skill sets towards the portrait of graduate so not as a discount to those exams they're important but it's not the driving factor of our work um but we
051will certainly always use them and we're going to show you how we use them in our uh in the January meeting as well as how we use these things in a case study of a student so that's what we're building towards capacity is that have staff and our principles and our instructional leaders look to how chairs of our departments at Great levels how we look at what information are we looking at and what are we doing with it remember an assessment isn't valid what you do with the information it provides is the valid part right they these assessments have a valid use it's when you take the information you extrapolate you try to make get use in anything it's these have very particular measurements of something and we have to make sure we are using
052it appropriately to adjust to need the student need so it's the validity of the data it's presenting and how do we use that as intended um and that's the work that we have in front of us and that understanding of that Val use of what information help students and how do we do that not at the student level with our staff but at our level in the curriculum that we're creating with staff if I can add it it's important to understand as Tony said this is an ongoing process and it is a process that a lot of Staff members have never done they know about it like when I think uh Joe was talking about the Gap elimination I'm sorry I'm talking Gap elimination that was Bu The Gap analysis the Gap analysis is really
053effective but it can scare the hell out of people you're going to point out all my GS the best way to use it is you have to help people understand why it's important how we use it so that individuals features departments and levels can look at the Gap and the data and say huh we didn't know that that's showing like you saw the green chart outperforming within 10% and you saw a red where we were underperforming Administration we can look at it we can tell people hey you got to do this but the power behind the data is when people self-reflect we have to teach that and we have to also start getting to that point that it becomes comfortable for individuals across the district right now it's commencement outcome but it goes all the
054way down from kindergarten all the way up we have to teach that that's way to take time but no matter what we also have to start with our commencement outcomes and people are starting that but it's not going to be something to do it just like that if we have a problem in math or if we have a problem in English it's better that it comes from the teachers that are there identifying what the concerns are because they're probably more AP to develop the best solution faster in consultation with Administration instead of administration that could probably do it quicker going and saying you're doing this wrong that's not what this proceeding is about it's about developing this SK set this this capacity so that the people closest to it are helping to inform the final
055direction as well as the curriculum and adjustment that's what this is all about and it's going to get there but we have to look at it for everything and that's how we also set goals it's very easy to say hey I want 100% of the kids passing every single subject is it realistic no I like to go by what commissioner Mills I just very fond of commissioner Mills he came out and said every school should compete at 90% success and 10% value as long as you never give up on the 10% value to make them a success and you know what that is time and time again shown that that is where the state tends to be at its me level that may level may be entirely different different level but that's how you set
056goals and you did I can tell you right now are we at that level we're close in some areas or not close in other areas and those are the areas that most likely need the Urgent Response but we have to work with them to get them there so they're not scared but that they understand that they want to perform just to the highest level as everybody else and that's part of all of this but it's just one piece not the whole yeah to that excuse me one piece we even myself and in our conversation we find ourselves in the comfort of academics and this is so much more right is using the available resources we've been provided as a district over the last couple of years whether we are councelor social workers and all the
057work that we do in the social emotional world and really identifying their work in the classroom material one interventions they can provide and support alongside with our staff and what does that future in that multier system of supports academics is the easy one because that's the that's a bread and butter but the challenge of this this look like our social emotion behavioral world is certainly some exciting work and challenging work got question oh I don't have a question I just I just wanted to say this is great work um oh he got to turn off I got power um I just want to say that I think this work is really impressive and it's it's nice to more more it's nice to see what you're doing um you know I hope there's lots of community
058members watching tonight and and listening to this as well because it's um the amount of work that's going into making sure our students have all the supports that they need to be successful at every grade and when they leave forets is is is really incredible so thank you for all the work that you're doing and I know that there's a ton of staff that are working with you on all this as well so thank you for all that dinina um this is great work I've been a part of it too you guys went through it over the past year um my question is when we start to see the student who was continuously failing who was continuously in the aim struggling and say RTI and this and the interventions that we have don't seem to
059be making a difference in the Gap do we have other means to try to figure out how to make a switch or how to PIV it or or is it something that we have to say Okay like yes we're focusing on the science agre right now but maybe the science agre with this particular student isn't working so we have somebody within the district that teaches it another way and then we can scoop that child over and put them into another area because they may have a different do you know what I [Music] mean that's a great question um that is exactly what our teams are doing they're always looking at is this connecting with kids so I think we have a whole our goal is to build them a whole tool BLX of intervention and
060what can work it is important toity too that we're trying those and we're implementing those and if it doesn't work we have to go back and that is the power of bringing our team together and talking about all the time looking at their data if they're not making growth and they're back at the table thinking okay let's try this let's try this so absolutely and we're always looking to grow that intervention um that's that's one of the things we talk to them all the time about like what are we missing what do we need do we need more writing components more so yes that is something that we're always looking at our teams are so good that our principles have some of those discussions as well as our reading teams and our intervention teams as
061well as we also through this when we think about you know unpacking what the is providing some tools for to come but yeah absolutely you just got to wait till the master control turn and then another followup to that how do we as a board in as far as like budget goes and understanding like you know you guys might say this is your budget and these are this is what you have to work with and these are your parameters and those parameters might not be what you actually need saying you need to have completely certified reading instructors instead of people who are teacher assistance filling in at the RTI level maybe you need to have more staff on hand in that social emotional or wherever how do we find out as a board when we're
062making our budgetary decisions the needs the true needs to scale to make sure that we're having that in our Forefront for our kids go ahead and say that's coming up in the discussion it is well you know you know what I have to do in my report you're right on the topic what yeah to talk about next year's bu right and I your your dead on some of the things you said are conversations that we have ongoing about Staffing and how we use Staffing and uh effectiv and efficiently will always the comp the the confines and are parameters of a budget you know we'd love to do everything and anything we can but we also know we have confines that we have to so how do we use the resources we currently are blessed with
063to to do that we do you'll no doubt here as we go through the budget process the time will all to where we think we should shift or make if any uh to make sure this goes because we're we've been doing 4 years 5 years some of those mtss work in deep learning we are very much committed to know that this is the right work to do so it's not a it's it's deep in the work that we do as a system so we have to prioritize in how we do it right short answer is we'll we'll tell the board what we need or place it in the budget uh depending on how we develop the budget that's really the long and short answer if we had unlimited resources I can tell you we can
064build a budget and get exactly what we need the question is the confins of the financials then there has to be decisions and that isn't going to be something that's easy the board doesn't usually do it because they're not close to it but if we're told you just can't get there this time what do you what can you do we end up having to make recommendations to the board for I mean but we'd love to be able to do what you're saying and put forth what we actually need to keep what we have now and expand the problem is I think our financials with the state is saying that we're getting no extra M which then puts it on the local we have a great Community I just don't know where that confine is going
065to be once we know we put together best I just want to add I think really to your it just came to listening is the capacity I think our first goal was to get the learning and everybody understanding the system because if we can get all those arrows going in the same direction and those that we have right now understanding what the end goal is and how we're trying to get to this uh por of graduate and ntss work that's confined there build from within to start and then figure out where our needs are in addition and that's where as Tom said we we would go from there but our first goal of course is what do we have and the resources we currently have let's educate and get the capacity rolling like we do
066the curriculum start with a small group get them moving and then the system follows behind so similar to the mtss we're at that point we you're right we have to take it to the next level what does that look like in the capacity oh you got to raise your hand then he'll turn off his button your blue button work thank you it's wonderful it's exciting it makes me want to be back in the classroom as long as it's a hor School District you can that Kay really do and one of the things that you said and it's been said over and over but I know you really do it is not just looking at test scores thank you for that because that's been around far too long and thank you for giving me a little
067motto for the upcoming semester because I always like to say something to my students like a coach so I wrote it down best intervention is prevention that's going to be our M for thank you other all right thank you for a very comprehensive presentation all right moving along on our agenda we go to section six and we have a report from the superintendent Dr dou thank you president I'll try to keep it as brief but we got some several things to go over uh first of all all the things happening in the school the choir concert you know the reframe of Hallelujah the band concerts the good natur things that all of our staff and our kids are doing goes without saying thank you to everybody and what you're doing for our kids and modeling
068and also doing for our community uh I think uh our student Representatives uh report says a part of it but there is so much more that's going on and uh we just can't get it all out there but you know this is the true meaning of forets our schools whether it's Center Street Gad Bridge Ro uh big plat it's the intermediate school middle school high school kids are doing things actively to participate along with our staff and we are we can't be more proud than what we're doing especially at this time of the year uh with that we have to respond regularly to the State education department and the State education department is sort of in a state of flocks or turmoil because finances are finances budgets are budgets busing is busing uh funding for
069special programs and everything is the same thing at their level but when they look at districts they want all the districts to really think hard about how they can become a regional school and they put forth a concept over the past 6 months that was supposed to be mandated in other words hsees every other school district your mandated get together and come up with a plan to tell us how you're going to make schools better for everybody else that maybe even your cost but it won't affect somebody else's cost well a bunch of superintendent on the island got together and sort of said what most superintendent probably feel at times no and because New York City and Long Island have a little more sway in policy development all of a sudden the Mandate became optional
070of course it became optional right after we submit our report uh which was 48 pages how many days of work done I mean couple weeks of work uh and draining of resources the hard part is is the concept of regionalization is not bad but for the most part that's what BS are there for is to help regionalize and try to see if there's Partnerships and so forth one of our biggest ones that looking at D is our career development program everybody buys in everybody works at it everybody gets benefit and everybody has some type of Coster what regionalization is about is that say horse has has a wonderful AP program and we want to open it up to everybody else but we aren't charging everybody else but we're willing to pay for it for the
071smaller School that may not happen that's the concept the hard part is when they said no the concept is going up the air that now it's optional for distance so we are supposed to just consult with our board but our recommendation is that we're going to do any type of good solid regionalization that we can that we are not in the how would you say the mood or the position capacity wise to keep doing work for everybody else and we have our own work to do so by January 15th we have to notify them if we're going to mandatory participate or we're going to opt out and our administrative recommendation is that we expect to opt out and that we would participate in good B with whoever wishes to do it I can tell you
072a lot of the districts in the area are now going to take that same procedure because of the fact that we already do this at both so that's going to be our recommendation I'll just the board to give me direction if you're you seem to understand what we're saying and we're okay with it uh it has no impact on the district has no Financial strings on the district if anything it has resource brain and potential cost for bigger districts less so for smaller districts and that's really what was from because the state does not want a mandatory cause mergers and that's what this is about uh the state needs to decide what it wants to do with the districts that are very small and Rural and we're considered a large rural school so we don't
073have as many problems as everybody else but we still have problems so that's one thing um we can just bring it up at board comments just to see if there's anything so you think about it uh Retreat announcement I'll let the president talk about that but it is January 30th is the date from 4 to 8 or 4 to longer it needed we are trying to get a facilitator however uh two of the main facilitators that we were looking at that were recommended uh Unfortunately they are already scheduled for other work with other districts uh and we have one that's reviewing all the district's information right now and seeing if they can put together a plan for how they can assist the board in this uh discussions debates and understanding and interactions uh so that
074would be more to come I've already talked to Mr Christmas as if that facilitator is not necessarily able to do it or chooses not do it because they do do the research beforeand uh I think we're going to look at a corporate facilitator that does not have the school experience but maybe helps with Dynamics and interactions and interplay among uh groups that are in a government's position so please everybody mark that I think U Mr con will verify that as well uh I know also there will be a self- evaluation ad hoc committee later just be aware if you're interested in that uh Mr con will state that a little bit later but uh get the Terry no later than tomorrow afternoon if you're interested once that's brought up for discussion as well as um
075we were talking about budget development at this the thing we are well in the budget season here as a district uh we are out meeting with Department starting to put together an assemble requests possibilities but right now we usually approach it a certain way and really what happens is and we can talk about this a little bit later is we are looking for a little Direction uh from the board in regards to what we would love to do and what we would like to do I will turn to over to Katie to give sort of a brief example of what we're considering to try to get things out at the very beginning build the budget potentially of what we feel we need and what we desire to keep and be the effective school so we
076don't get to the point that and we may still get there that we have to make very difficult choices from the administration on how best we run the business um any other things please go to the master control that hello okay so um in your past the way we've approached the budget um with the exception of last year we'll get to last year separately but we've always started the year um kind of roll everything over putting in the salary increases um some of the known things it's starting out with the the large gap that we typically see at the start of the Year departments present they talk about uh needs of their Department um kind of their wants of their department and then those things are discussed and added along the way um we maintain
077our toolkit of Revenue sources the tech ly reserves fund balance until the very end um to balance the budget um in years past um again before this latest year we've been fortunate uh to have our financial situation where things have worked out very well for us um in the end we've been able to add a lot of really great things to The District in our programs uh last year um we all know was challenging we had to make a lot of difficult decisions um and we had to approach the budget a little bit differently given those reductions that we had to consider so this this year for budget development looking ahead um we want to essentially accelerate the schedule of how we present the budget we still want you to hear from the Departments and
078hear about their their needs and their wants and their concerns and just how things are going within their Department uh but we have other things this year that we have to consider um not only just general daily operations of our district as if it was a typical budget year we also need to review the reductions and the decisions that were made last year um because we've talked about some of them aren't sustainable uh some of them might be a one-ear solution so that needs to be evaluated as well on top of everything that needs to go along with the consolidation going from four elementaries to three elementaries everything really developing and things of that nature so there's a lot of components that need to come together this year we have currently five budget workshops scheduled
079uh so we would like to approach the budget a little bit differently um instead of slow progression over time let's start right from the getg go of building in what we know we need uh for uh each department each building to do what they need to do uh let's right off the bat put in that tax ly so we know exactly at that point in time what we have um it's not necessarily that excuse me um the board can still have that same discussion about challenging the tax cap or going out less um so it's not not um to say that any decisions are firm from the onset um but I think it's worth um providing um more information earlier um accelerating the budget process and giving ourselves enough time to have those discussions we're
080going to need to have uh this upcoming question season any questions on oh she has to turn off I just think that that's a great idea I think that we need to definitely start the process a lot sooner so we don't have that feeling that we had that last year I think you know um that's a lot of pressure on you and the business office as a whole to have to be handling that at the last minute and I know that you know departments they all have wants that they want to have but I think that it's important for the board to have the Forefront of their mind the needs of the students and the staff in the beginning and then to say you know going down through and that's those are the top priorities
081we're keeping these at the top and you can have those discussions much sooner so I really do like this and I appreciate that you know you guys are coming up with this idea to start it and to start it now and then if we need have if it if it's looking to you like it's going to be a difficult budget season then let's just go ahead and build in more meetings right away let's say we got to have two a month so we can really work into it and to have a lot of good discussion about it to make sure that we're able to have it in front of people to encourage them to come out and voice their concerns ahead of time about the needs that they might have so that we're all in
082the same F and I think it's really great so thank you Katie thank you Katie for my administrative team coming up so on with that um the last piece we have good Segway because it's the consolidation piece The District administration has been working with its consultant on busing busing still has a little bit of cleanup but I can sort of give the board a little understanding of what is is uh transpiring I mean we've gone through probably four or five or six different types of options with technology uh I can tell you our goal is to meet the board's goals the board's goals was trying to get everything under an hour possible trying to make sure that we have the emergency uh recovery time for fifth through 8th grade that we can exit that building
083all at once uh it was also trying if we can possibly develop even though it's an extra cost the district after noon runs after the school if possible that is the last priority um and then also fitting within reasonable time of what we've established already somewhere around the 720 725 is and we know it's going to have to go later than what we're doing right now because we've added an hour to the day so we're trying to look at how in the future can you look at be in coordination with both these at 720 or 8:40 so we're trying to use those as the guidelines in the prank uh with that being said we've looked at three tier we've looked at two tier we've looked at using exactly what we have right now which we
084already know will not work because currently it doesn't work as it is uh in the system I'm trying to get my access but um currently right now we have a problem with the fact that if you try to do what we're doing now we have start times that are in conflict with each other when the high school starts at 7:45 the I mean 750 and the middle school starts at 7:45 you can't logically get 27 buses or 30 buses from one place to the other so the buses are always running behind that's why at the high school at the end of the day it takes 20 to 40 minutes just for the kids to catch their bus and leave when they were out of 302 and our goal is is to try to get it
085so that all buses are there they get loaded and they leave within 5 to 7 minutes that helps minimize as much time on the bus as possible our travel times are also going to be as they should be measured the time that the students are actually on the bus and the bus is moving it is not the time that they wait because they got there early or the time because their transfer it is the ride time from the time that they get out of school and they get home so that is our goal right now in our current setting we have somewhere around ride times that meet that standard 91 to 107 minutes we know that at least the three tier uh situation where you deliver to the high school you go out and pick
086up everybody deliver to the Intermediate Middle School you go out pick up everybody and deliver to each of the elementaries we know that every ride time will be under an hour we also know that using our start times to able to do that recover that time frame is probably going be too wide for what our community would probably say is appropriate and I actually know that even though it meets every single goal but we have to consider that as an administrative team when we look at our current schedule the only way our current schedule is going to work is if the high school or the middle school gets dropped off first and then it goes to the next school there has to be at least a 10 to 15 minute offset which means the other
087schools in the afternoon or in the second part of the Run get pushed out even further right now both of those schools start at 8:15 you can't be at an elementary school at 8:15 and drop off at the intermediate school at 8:15 there's probably roughly a 15 minute separation that's needed there so you're looking at at almost an extra hour to an hour and 15 minutes to change between one drop off time and the other so we're looking at that now you could stagger them all but remember unless they all have the same exact length of day the Stagger gets affected by the offset so the high school has a 7h hour Day next year the elementaries will have a 6 hour and 46 minute day and the middle school will have a 6our and
08850 minute day which basically means that they go a shorter amount than the high school so they always have to be on one end or the other you have to either pick them up a all first and go home first or you have pick them all up last and go home last you can't put them in the middle because it will sort of push the schedules out and so we considered that so we're doing some finalization on that there is another schedule that's a two tier that does have significant promise uh and what happens is that works around a 720 to 7:30 time frame for uh probably 66% of our students and that is one full trip out around the district and back and taking care of Intermediate School through high school and then there's
089also the elementary piece where we take one trip out for each of the boundaries that means you really need roughly about two maybe three start times with one start time being just offset and so forth that one tends to work within that 720 to 840 timel now what we have to consider administratively is the cost the three tier cost requires about I think it was I can't get my computer up but that's what I was working on between about 3 to 4:30 today because we were busy doing other things um unfortunately and what happens is that time is an issue because the number of buses you need currently we put 59 buses on the road to do the process of what we need now to get what we have done our three tier I think
090puts about 52 or 53 buses on the road uh the two tier which I think is probably the predominant leading choice that we're going to have to strongly look I think requires I think no more than 50 buses it's somewhere around but as you can tell there's Savings in the amount of bus routes that we would have now why is this important if you don't have the bus drivers you need less routes uh so no matter what I will tell you schools across the state one school just shifted to 7: to30 in the morning and their Elementary is going at 9:30 because they don't have enough bus drivers to do both routes and this is becoming a factor of why they're doing it is because by doing it they can use the same bus drivers
091that they have in a longer day to do the rout that's not what we're talking about here we have an outstanding transportation department we have the driver but we have to look at how is fiscally prudent as well as time prudent but there are going to be changes but no matter what the change is going to occur because there is an extra hour in the elementary 8 through six day that goes into place next year so we're going to end up setting the final time from Janu and then starting to communicate it out parents have already been notified of the new schools we've received very little communication back we were very happy that people at least know and it was everybody got that communication I will tell you I had one email and it was
092really about oh this is ridiculous Center Street shouldn't close I know the person I called Welcome a message I know you're making a statement but please give me a call and if you want had several conversations with this person on many other issues and I know the person well and the person hasn't called because I know they were probably more frustrated in making a statement but that's to the point exactly where we've been people know and they're getting the information so we want to try to get them what the final start times are because it is predicated on what we've already done and it is what it is that uh so we will be bringing that to the uh we will just be announcing that to the it's an operation decision that has to be
093made so and it will be something that's budgetary so pretty much that concludes my report at this point uh we will need to go back into executive session to talk about an individual midyear uh checking for individual Personnel right going to uh section s Finance it for actions uh we have no audit report this month so we need an action vote on 7.03 through 7.14 can I have a motion please second Curiosities discussion comments so [Music] I okay anyway we still need to correct I think it's 7.11 the contract for Health and Welfare Services it sets the 5th day of November 2025 it should be the fth day of November 2024 I we can just okay that's all I want to say other did have several questions that I emailed over and I wanted to
094say thank you for answering those questions it's always very much appreciated um and then just uh because I want to see it for the record I said I did want to see it for the as far as the claims audit report goes the things that are La of blank for um the purchas order approval process should be completed prior to requesting good Services I do feel like we should have corrective actions filled out into the boxes but thank you very much for answering the questions yeah and just I know Katie we we already the answer that question but there is no requirement at that point it's nothing it's just so the audience knows the payment was due the process was followed and not followed now we have to go and clean that up with the
095Department which we do um but the payment was made no issue with that's just more so thank you okay I'm going to be voting no to the set for the change order log and that is because we don't have the codes for the contract summaries and just so that the public knows the reason the codes aren't there is they being tested which is normal process I'll be staining on uh 7.11 and um because the just historically the idea that a program is in place in September and we're approving it in December doesn't sit well with me I understand Katie has explained why it is I appreciate it I may be naive but I was trained in HSE heads and due dates met things in HSE heads and teachers don't get to submit their report card
0964 months late and I just think it's wrong but I understand and I will obain and we can move on ear it's ever B right so just to add to that K if you can P for a second just for a second in interest just because for the public to know that has been on ongoing thing we've had in several board meetings but uh it's a debt no matter what contractually we have to pay but Katie will also explain so the public knows this isn't just anything Katie does or the board you explained it I not it's just me being naive and may be stubborn on the point understand um just a um a piece of information that absent contract if there is no contract there's still an obligation for uh a district to provide
097and there still an obligation for a district to pay not so formal formal process I completely AG we'd rather have them just put forth on July 1 and say we're going to charge you we don't know how much it is here's our agreement but nobody will do that all right all in favor except for what we discussed opposed we have those and we have the exension so I think we all CAU up is that correct yes all right thank you very much moving on to uh Section 8 personal items for Action we have the HR recommendations 8.02 can I have a motion please Curiosities discussion comments okay so um under the uh HR recommendations uh section F instruction substitutes I would be voting no on number two and number three and as I have said
098many times in the past is not anything person either of these two candidates who I do not know that they are not certified and they do not get a degree I just want to to say that I am um abstaining from letter P the whole section just so that just so that you know so that you know p is not a vote that is notification only any transfers are not subject to V just so all right all in favor I oppos abion just so that you know uh part of the transfer process part consolidation uh we'd like to congratulate everyone on their requests and the ultimate uh removal for the start of next year I know that is not easy for everybody but I think U everybody pretty much got exactly uh the location that
099they wanted to really be at in the process for our instructional staff I know we are working on our non-instructional staff and some of that will delay uh as well as we have just completed uh our administrative staff and I know Miss Malone is here who's doing a wonderful job of the inter Garden Ro and I want to thank her and she is now coordinating and working for next year's activity this is Patty Sato who will be moving to Garden Road so Patty thank you that is communicated out the part of our cultural team is that for the month of January faculty meetings will be primarily held in only the three Elementary buildings so that the faculty and staff for the next year can get together and do some bonding over the time as well
100as starting the cultural team process as well as with the administration so we're pretty much meeing our time L and that everybody will be doing prop the same thing correct so congratulations to everybody thank you all right I would just like to say congratulations to Mr Russell on his retirement that was in HR recommendation also congratulations to Mr Sax who starts tomorrow tomorrow as theing excited I know that and also thank you to Mr Harter for uh bridging us through the transition from when Mr D left until when Mr Sax um takes place tomorrow we appreciate all Mr Harter did for us congratulations to Mr Tio on your um change um and congratulations to the districts for uh teaching assistants on their probationary appointments and congratulations to the winter coaches being appointed and we know
101they'll do an outstanding job as they always have in the past a lot of positive things on our HR reports uh this month and congratulations to all all right section nine we have an action vote on 9.02 and 9.03 can I have a motion please second inquiries discussion comments I will be abstaining on 9.03 for the same reason I abstained on the other one it started in July and we're approving it um in December so all of staying there for the same regression call a question all in favor I I oppos substantial all right section 10 board policy first we'll start with our policy committee report from Mr Chris thank you we uh met as a policy committee on December 5th and we had two first readings policy 6100 annual budget and 6110 budget planning
102these are all part of the chronological review we're in the 6000s right now and working through there number of sequential policies that relate to budget planning and budget development and we did have edits as you see in the materials primarily just around clarification of language and trying to make the policies a little more streamlined and comprehensive but certainly welcome any feedback from the board on those and then second readings we had two 41 excuse me 4741 class ranking and 6,000 fiscal management those are the same as they were presented in their first readings or approval and then uh no good to the order and one table policy that's it thank you so um under Section 10 we have two policies to be voted on 10.03 and 10.04 can I have a motion please second inquiries
103discussion comments I'm just going to be voting no on the changes for 10.04 other question all in favor oppos exstension all right section 11 as Mr Christmas indicated these are first readings and do any anybody have a question that they would like to be have or have brought back to the policy committee for discussion on 11.01 or 11.02 I will say there are some questions that I received through an email and I forwarded them on to the board so I think Mr Christmas is now aware of them take those back as well um but that's just an issue ofar yes we will bring those to the next policy committee meeting for discussion all right section 12 um we have first of all a report from the board president myself um I'd like to start for
104a second um Mr theor is with us tonight now was going to start with we have um he is submitting uh energy rebate from n and um my understanding is it would be somewhere we're seeking between 40 and $50,000 in terms of lighting rebates for things we've already installed in the construction project if you want to if you wouldn't mind informing us a little bit more is that all that needs to be said uh I would just say first I would thank uh um Josh Benjamin from elri and Matt har from kimle because they're both foret brand and they went above and beyond they gave me all the specs for all the capital Project work that was done in 2024 and so with that information I went through very extensive process and yes we Katie
105I don't know if you haven't checked your mail you should have a very friendly uh Christmas card from Frankl energy uh the first first one is $15,400 so um that's best Christmas card I have you got that Christmas card yet I haven't either I got the check number phone right here but yeah you didn't address it to the wrong District I did not send it my house no um but it it'll be minimum yeah I I think between this is part of our grant work which is really right this is this is a lot of time a lot of effort that you not engaging in the past and so St wrot the grant we started this process but yes I would say 50,000 very good time you're welcome if you have any question thank you
106and also with the uh construction project at this point in time the plan is for the bids toh go out on the high school construction project and the rro construction project in January hopefully that's the plan and then hopefully um after all of the uh well they said hopefully there'd be a proposal in front of us in March to vote on this so hopefully all right we're going into the holiday and New York State education department likes to take time on okay all right then I'd like to uh acknowledge a few um groups in our school Community um as Mia said uh the football team participated in laying of WS at woodlaw National Cemetery in the um reachs across America program and uh in total uh at woodon there was close to 6,000 reats that
107were placed uh on the graves of Americans who served our country and I thought that was uh very nice to the football team to uh honor those who serve and give her their time the cheerleaders teamed up with Catholic Charities to hand out cookies to the homeless and and they um took stuffed animals and uh donated those stuffed animals to Children um this past month and on December 28th um the boys swim team is swimming laps to raise funds for ALS in honor of Mr Brendon McCarthy who we all know and we know his wife teach his within the district so uh those are some nice things that people in our school Community are certainly taking time to care about others in the community at January's uh Board of Education meeting there will be a
108resolution presented to create an ad hoc committee to uh revise review and form a new board of a board of education self- evaluation document for you in June when we uh evaluate ourselves so we want to create this new document if you are interested in serving on that committee uh as Dr Douglas said um report please email Terry tomorrow so I can put that I will select the committee I'll select who's on the committee and then they can do work and the uh resolution will'll have all the particulars on it in January and then um as Dr Douglas said on January 30th um we will be having our board retreat um part maybe of the complication we're receiving is we sent out 21 dates but January 30th was the only date where all nine board
109members uh said they could uh attend and that was one of the um criteria we used um that online members had to do it in the past sometimes if somebody couldn't attend we met with a this time we said online had to be there so some of the complications we're running into with getting people is because we only have one date to offer that is all I have to uh say and we have now you're okay with us presenting that plan and then the other thing are you okay with us doing what we need to all right so I guess I was under the assumption there was no hard push back on Katie's presentation about the budget so I'm assuming we're okay with where Kate everybody okay with what we've sort of discussed I don't
110need a vote you're just telling me that you're okay that we sort of go away because it's the superintendent requir so all I want to know is that I'm not upsetting the Apple it's not necessarily needed if you guys said nope we don't want that we ar going to do it but it sounds like for the most part the consensus is people seem to be okay with what we have our Direction now between now and okay and then Dr Douglas presented an idea about reg regionalization and uh should we go with the state's plan or kind of go with what we've been doing and how both have been operating all along and the recommendation was to go with what we have been doing currently and and ignore those things so we okay with doing what
111we've normally been doing and if I if if I can add it's not doing what the state wants are doing with bosies we're basically telling the state thanks but no thanks but we're going to craft it in a lettera that says but we're also going to still pay attention to it it's just we're not mandated to comply uh that's all it is is just letting the state wants to know who's going to do it who's not going to do it so they give proper credit to the districts that are but we're still going to participate just not in that's really so for me this is like a discussion about it and it's for me with learning it's better to be able to see documents and to read it over and to have a little bit
112more of understanding because I'm not sure if by not doing the regionalization if we're going to miss out on opportunities for our kids that you know might have other things at other districts I know that we had talked about um driver's ed or you know I don't know all the different opportunities so for me I can't give direction until I get a little bit more information that's just me so I like be able to see it and tell you this there's nothing to see it's whether or not we want to participate or not we do not feel in our best interest of resources financial management as well as the draw on our staffing we're no budget season do this work it doesn't mean that if somebody comes up with a great idea sort of like
113what you said the driver or something we're not excluded from it in other words there's no harm for us it's just that we're not going to expend our resources and that's what I'm going to also put into Le State at we're still going to participate but we're not going to be the D driving force behind it if there's something that makes sense for us makes sense for our kids we're going to battle ourselves to see that's the best part about this that's what it what the real issue was is the state saying no you have to do this and that means we have to expend our money our effort on other people's initiatives this way they can put together a plan for the region and we can choose what is in the best interest of
114that's all we don't lose time that's do that okay but would you be able to send over more information there is no more information that's that's how we've been expained the state has put it out and said there's a 57 page plan that we filled out which is data from the state saying what our information is that they already have and there's no other information I just have to cons so the state gave you guys the 57 page plan okay so maybe we could see that just to look it over that that was what you were given if theard wants to I think it's absolutely a time it was for us we weren't to fill it out and we didn't have we just bu out well I can't I'm just saying I can't make decisions
115not it decision from there all right so um my understanding is we have seven of eight that say continue to do what we do they force mostes to do it and leave it that's all we don't lose the beauty about them making it not mandatory is we don't have to expend any resources or effort but still get the benefits of anything that's developed here or say somebody in down state develops an idea that we didn't think about and then all a sudden the B says hey you like that idea we still get to partipate no you have to you have to provide a fre a charge in other words we have to use our resources for other people to benefit all right now we move to uh board member comments Christine so I just want
116to um thank some people on the district we had um The Mark Stevens uh wrestling tournament and was 15th anual wrestling turn happened a couple weeks ago and um just a huge thanks to Damien and Jamie um just so great to work with and you know Damien was pumped up the entire weekend which was so much fun um Mike's entire facilities team I mean they just did a phenomenal job getting everything set up um being there providing everything that we needed and then also uh Bill J Hoy and the technology team um because we had you know all the live streaming that we did we had four different mats going so live streaming on four different mats and all the computers that we needed and stuff so it was just um a really really well-run
117weekend and we got a lot of comments from the refs that it's one of their favorite events to work at we got comments from all the teams that were there how they love that tournament every year because it runs so smoothly and it's just a great a great um location so just thank you to everybody in the district who who participated in that really really appreciate it others krina I just wanted to say thanks Dan Mr deloro for all of your hard work very continued hard work for all the stuff with the energy rebat that's really great so I know it's a thankless thing and you're just doing it because you're a great human and you always have fun so thank you they are paying me well I mean the grant is paying you it
118is the grant the Grant and the reates are you but that's all like you know so thanks like for putting time it's appreciated and um the the Center Street had a really wonderful choir concert and a really wonderful variety show in the meantime and the staff did an awesome skit and presentation and it was a fabulous performance of Queen and uh py did a great job that was really fun to watch and um and I just wanted to also say um not they are a part of the horse Central School District um but the Horse Village fire department right now they're doing the rounds with um the Santa sightings and it's really a wonderful thing and they're still going on for the next two nights and I just want to say thank you to them
119for all of their hard work because you know there are people who their kids have come through hor they graduated the families are still continuing the tradition and it's just such a wonderful thing and it's really nice to be a part of this community for those reasons so thank you those are all my comments um I have two things one from Intermediate School uh if you weren't able to catch it we had our first um show of A Christmas Carol we started with 70 students and ended with 60 who learned not only how to act on stage but how to also produce the show they produce the whole thing themselves at the end you would have thought they were on Broadway they were so happy and excited um so I want to thank C and
120uh Mr Boswick for all their help making that come to reality as well as Mr Chris Shone for his help with our sound um system and bill and his team for the it support it was a team effort anded amazing um I did want to reiterate that the Garden Road PTO is hosting the harlon Wizards on uh January 22nd and we have two guest referees which is sitting to my right Dr Douglas and Andy MOSI will be repping the game so if you Andy yeah he get the water I don't as well as a number of Staff members from each building um it's promised to be a really fun event for all ages those tickets are on sale um and are available visit the gner road um main Facebook page and other than that again
121a huge thank you to missone and her leadership um at Garder Road uh it's going really well this year and the kids are super happy um with how things are going and I can't wait to see them in all of their uh blue and gold tomorrow for spirit I just wanted to add one thing that I was going to put when I spoke earlier but um last night I had opportunity to attend the Winter concert and Mr Shone as usual did an excellent job but I thought more importantly than pointing out the singing and everything is that when I get to speak um at the beginning of the school year to new teachers coming in I always say you know your lifeblood you new people coming in you have new ideas um and I thought
122Mr home did a very nice thing he had a student teacher and the concert is kind of I would Envision you know a big event in front of the community and you're showing what you're able to bring out of the students and he allowed the student teacher to conduct four songs and I thought that was uh very generous of him and uh very generous of his time and I thought it was a nice thing that he did so I'd like to commend him uh for doing that because I know he always brings out the best in his students but he also I thought brought out the best in his student teacher so all right um with that said um we're going to have a motion here in a second to go into executive session to
123discuss an individual contractual matter but before I make that motion uh I'd like to wish everybody a happy holiday season a happy and prosperous holiday season I hope you get time to spend a lot of relaxing hours with family and friends and get to recharge and thank you Mrs cero for uh decorating the stage up here it's lovely and very festive for the holiday season I watered every plan all right so with that said have a happy holiday season and I need a motion to go into executive session to discuss individual contractual matter can I have a motion please discussion comments inquiries no mo no action to be taken afterwards all in favor I know why you complain about