001good evening everyone welcome to the September 2024 board meeting um for the pat Medford School District would everybody please rise the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag the United States of America and to the rep it stands one nation God indivisible and justice for all we have appointed uh Dr Coleman as the interim um district clerk for this evening and he's going to now he's he's now going to get the meeting started I'm going to review uh welcome everybody to the September 16th 2024 Board of Education meeting just to go over the safety message this evening in the event of an emergency please use the emergency exits located at the front and rear of the auditorium to exit the building do not attempt to drive away as you may impede the arrival
002of emergency services please be advised that smoking in the use of vaping products is prohibited on school property at all times when addressing the board during public comment periods each speaker is limited to three minutes with no sharing of minutes you will be warned when 30 seconds are left and you will be asked to conclude after the 3 minutes have elapsed please refrain from discussing specific students or staff members to protect their privacy these matters should be discussed with the appropriate administrator all questions or comments should be addressed to the Board of Education president thank you Dr Coen would you like to go over the ground rules please I I think I covered it with the time on the public comment in the three minutes all righty so we're ready to start on agenda item
003number seven which is the presentations and reports Dr Jones sure good evening Mr President members of the Board of Education to all of those that are present PM AA is out in force tonight and good evening also I see my pmct uh president here as well as uh csca operational president a lot of Union representation here love to see that and Welcome to our community members Etc uh we'll start um we know that our student representative has some other uh conflicts this evening and have requested to go first so we are going to start with Emma if that's okay trusty Ella yes absolutely I'm sorry it's very important most important dance that's great is my presentation on here or do I have oh you go you can give it back you want to do that
004one slides um can we bring up the ex official members uh presentation please we per hello hi it's so great to see everyone again um Welcome to our September 16th at I know why it says 15th but September 16th business meeting I am the ex officio student member of the Board of Education my name is Ella mccan for those who don't know me and tonight I will be discussing what has been going on in our buildings from the beginning of September there we go perfect in the beginning of the month we had our first day of school in all of our buildings Eagle Elementary shares a new schoolwide theme for the year River Elementary holds a back toschool play date and many of our schools hold Patriot Day Celebrations and honor September 11th to start
005here are some pictures from the first day of school at Bay Elementary as you can see the students and faculty reconnected and began their new school year Oregon Middle School also welcomed new staff members into their building Miss wood for health Miss Hastings deau for French Miss capo for chorus as well as two Patrick Medford alumni teachers Miss verie and Miss Mero next Eagle Elementary schoolwide theme is lights camera learn be the star of your learning thanks to our generous PTA they purchased shirts for all students faculty and staff which everyone proudly will wear on Mondays also a huge thank you and shout out to the custodians and secretaries who were very busy this summer getting the school ready to open and shine River Elementary also held a beginning of the year fund on September
00612th their play date was the kickoff to an amazing year of connections and memories for all students back at Eagle Elementary they celebrated Patriot Day on 9911 with a schoolwide zoom read aloud held by Miss Gill she read the book September 12th we knew everything would be all right in Miss Harrison's class this book was written and illustrated by first grade students of H Bron Master at elementary school in conut Missouri Eagle came together as a school and supported each other on this day similarly to other schools on September 11th Miss P's class placed Flags in the courtyard in honor of the this in honor of that day at the petrick midford high school great job to all for taking a moment in their day to remember those we have lost and with that thank
007you for listening to my portion of today's meeting and I would like to welcome all of our students and staffs back to school I look forward to a year of great community and growth for all thank you thank you are you ready Dr Jones sure thank thank you so much Mr President and thank you Ella for that wonderful report we appreciate you did oh okay so next is we have uh traditionally at the start the first uh meeting in September we have our back to school reports from our assistant superintendent um we as the cabinet have worked very hard over the course of the summer uh preparing the school schs along with the administrators in general and uh we're going to ask each of them to come forward and provide us with a look snapshot
008into the work that has been occurring over the summer so we will start with Mrs ketti and we will follow with all of the assistant subps in their respective orders of their reports okay okay good evening trustees as Dr Jones said I am going to start this evening with some updates on the office of curriculum and instruction Dr Coen will um then update you on HR Dr Lucas has a variety of updates from PPS and uh superintendent conference day and Mr Mazy will update you on plants and Facilities so as you know much of the work that we did uh this summer really revolved around the goals that Dr Jones has outlined for all of us um as well as the board of education so we want you to know that we reviewed all of
009these goals at our admin Retreat and we're going to uh intertwine them into our department meetings our faculty meetings and you will also see them in many of our success plans and District Improvement plans so this year we had several different committees we had a progress report card committee that I um really co-led with Mr um Santa cochi who is right behind me he helped and assisted with our elementary we had many of our teachers directors sit on that committee we also spent a lot of time our building principles and our directors wrote their school and District success plans we also had a committee that wrote our district comprehension Improvement plans and South Ocean had a committee that wrote their school Improvement plan the board has seen those plans we submitted them to you for
010uh board approval at the August uh meeting and they are listed on our website we are required um by law under uh New York state law to have our Improvement plans posted as well as South Ocean School Improvement plan so they are listed on our district website at this time we also spent a lot of time updating our report card comments and we have a lot of report card comments and at sometimes the report card comments got very repetitive and we really wanted to approach this committee by taking it from a place of positivity and even when there were areas for improvement make sure the wording was more supportive in nature the board has uh some samples of some of the comments that we updated and we actually grouped our comments to assist our teachers
011this year so we organize them by comments that would be more I would say um positive comments more comments needs of improvement in addition to comments for students who are on homebound instruction or students who are new to our country so these are just some comments it's probably easier to read on the cop that I shared with you in front of you but these are all new comments and I did uh submit a memo to all of our secondary teachers that really shared with them all the new comments and how we are going to be organizing them the committee had a lot of teachers sit on it and um it is important to know that we did discuss as a committee that we will recom uh reconvene the committee next summer and get feedback from
012the teachers as how we organize them and any additional comments that they want to add for next school year so this is an ongoing committee uh we did receive a lot of positive feedback from teachers regarding the updates to the comments and appreciated the organization to the comments District Improvement plans just wanted to share with you who sat on our uh DP this summer we had some teachers we had building principals directors and we also had a Community member the district Improvement plan has three priorities many of these PRI priorities were priorities that were embedded in our superintendent goals and we just really carried them over into our district Improvement plan really focusing on students taking ownership of their learning there was a section on our seal and also we we talked about ongoing profession
013professional development for student engagement so those were some of the three areas that we focused on and also really focusing on in our DP you'll notice if you when you reviewed it there was a lot that had to do with Community engagement and having parent series and educating the parent about some of the new programs um and we actually started that with our enl department actually held a community workshop at the patcho Medford Library a few weeks ago and we had almost over 200 families attend that uh Workshop series Summer Academy and summer school we were very busy over the summer you can see here our building principls and directors once again assisted with running our summer Academy and summer school we had over 150 teachers working this summer um throughout the district we also
014uh opened up our door to some of our prek students who we screened who had not sat in a prek setting to get them acclimated before they came into kindergarten we had almost 50 of our uh former prek students we had over you can see 779 students in grades K5 we had 114 students in our Middle School we had over 300 students attend our summer school at the high school so overall we had over 1,200 students uh really enrolled in our schools throughout the summer so it was a very busy summer our schools were very active I always like to share with the board some feedback I do give a survey to our administrators our teachers and our students just to get feedback about the Summer Academy these are some of the comments that we
015received from our administrators about what they felt was the most beneficial part of our program um really you will see the ongoing message that we receive from our directors in the building principles is that really it keeps students immersed in learning there's no summer slide so some of our most atrisk students are engaged in Reading Writing socialization throughout the summer so when they transition back in September it's very seamless uh our attendance is excellent so when I ask are the kids coming to our summer Academy you can see excellent to good the majority of our students did not miss uh some Miss only two days 3 to four days so our students were coming to our summer Academy which is great to see and you can see from the feedback uh we had very few
016behavioral problems in our summer Academy this summer the students really were appreciative that they had a safe and uh support supportive place to attend at least for 20 days over the summer teacher feedback we asked them if they felt that this was an effective program you can see 78% of our teachers say it was excellent and 22% said it was good when we looked at student engagement teachers told us that kids were very engaged in the work over the summer um and that there was no response that Stu said students were not engaged so students were eager to come and eager to learn then we heard from our students the most important and we asked them about what are the lessons engaging and you can see 92% of our students felt that the lessons and
017the material that we presented over the summer was engaging and we did have 8% that uh disagreed with that so we also asked the students tell us what are some of your best learning activities this summer and you can see uh they gave us a variety they love their math lessons they love doing research they really enjoyed playing soccer uh we had a uh olympiads that they were involved in the Olympics over the summer math games so a lot of Buddy reading going on we learned some solar systems in science and a lot of projects and really the most important thing is the one on the bottom that talks about just being with my friends so the students really appreciated uh having the opportunity to socialize with their friends over the summer I just like
018to share pictures these are all pictures that I received from our teachers and building principles throughout the summer school and Summer Academy and you can see that kids were actively learning throughout the school day we always want to know what we can do to improve so we do go right to our students you can see that they would love more science and art I actually thought the second comment was very interesting so we had some of our fifth grade students tell us that they would really like to be focused on what they can do in sixth grade rather than focusing on some of the material in fifth grade so I thought that was really great feedback for us in the future insist uh you know really assisting our most atrisk fifth graders with that transition
019so I thought that was great feedback um something I will look to do for next school year I love the fact that they would love to switch classes because we do do some switching during the school year they missed that during the summer Academy so that's something that we might be able to easily do next summer uh and they want rooms with AC so I did talk to Mr Mazi and next year he's saying all fully aced classrooms for the Summer Academy so thank you Mr Mazi for that um and obviously um they would like breakfast a little bit earlier and better snacks so we always get a few comments about eating earlier better snacks but uh they also talked about really uh field trips that is a little bit hard with the transportation over
020the summer but maybe we can look to do field trips between buildings not long distance and um many of them said nothing it was great so that was great to hear from the students just uh some more pictures these are our little prek students then I will move on to sumic curriculum so not only were our teachers and directors and principles busy with Summer Academy we also had an additional 100 teachers some did both who completed over 14400 hours of curriculum development so we had many projects going on this year you can see in all of these different subject areas there were curriculum updates enhancements we had some new actual courses at the high school that we needed to write curriculum for so our directors and our teachers were actively engaged in many curriculum projects
021this summer many of our curriculum projects um and the cost of these projects are funded through a variety of Grants as well as through our general fund this just gives you a little breakdown um we also in the summer had many professional development as you know trustees or teachers are required to do six hours of after school professional development as part of their contractual obligations in addition to starting that in this uh September we do offer workshops over the summer that our teachers can be involved in this just gives you an idea year of several of the C uh professional development workshops we ran this summer there were quite a few others but I did want to share with the uh board that we had 120 workshops being offered in the month of July and
022August that our teachers could participate in we had over 568 teachers and teacher assistants participate this summer in their professional development we also had 219 of our teachers already completed their six hours of required PD over the summer and I did break down so you can see many of our teachers do take advantage of our summer workshops um to start uh accumulating their six hours in addition we do um this year all of our teachers are required to do a mandatory 2 hours of AI the artificial intell elligence and we had 227 teachers already completed their 2 hours of AI over the summer and we had another 30 who were close to completing their two hours of mandatory those two hours are embedded in the 6 hours so of the 6 hours 2 hours have
023to be in AI so Raider Academy so this was uh really exciting our Rader Academy opened their doors and you can see Dr hburg did an incredible job really decorating our uh hallways in a welcoming manner for our students so right now our Raider Academy we have 16 students who are attending our Raider Academy I've had the opportunity to visit them frequently eat lunch with them um on a regular basis I've had the opportunity to eat with them two or three times so far since we opened their doors and I will say uh the students I will say are very appreciative of the program and feel safe um and Dr R and I will were were really talking about it the other day and I'm sure uh Dr Lucas will share it it it was
024just really incredible to see students who haven't come to school in over a year or two finally walk through our doors so these are students who had some school phobia they may have been on home and instruction and they're regularly coming to school um and the nice thing about it is you'll see we have some um obviously motivating uh bulletin boards in all of our classroom the teachers have embraced this program um very supportive of the students who are attending our program and the nice thing I will say is that in our cafeteria sorry I just want to go back uh we have a cafeteria and in our cafeteria there are six or seven cafeteria tables but when I walked into the cafeteria you would think that all the students you know a student here
025a student no they were all sit around the same cafeteria having conversations and the first time a group of students who may never have met each other at the high school were actually talking about what they may want to do over the weekend together as a group so it was really uh special to see that having conversations and making friendships in a very short period of time I know uh we had some hesitations within the community about the program but I would welcome any of the trustees after this evening happy to walk you up there to see some of these classrooms and really uh very impressed with Dr hurg and all of our staff and making this a huge success office of bilingual education we've been very busy um in the office of bilingual education
026just wanted to give the trustees uh an update uh right now we have a total of 262 students that we had a screen for English uh enl Services of the 262 students we had 163 qualify to receive uh enl Services I've given you a breakdown by building where we have placed our students we offer due language programs a traditional enl program we have a transitional bilingual program for our newcomers and then we also obviously have our students who were non-els which tested proficient on their screener I also wanted to share with you some Trends so you could see um over the last four years the number of students that we have um screened as a district these numbers are based on June so you can see in terms of the intakes back in 2122 we
027screened almost 600 students 578 from September to June this year we screened about 262 students as of right now so um and then you can see the next graph shows you of the students screened in those intakes how many qualified for for enl and how many uh were deemed proficient on our screener so you can see each year our office of bilingual education is one of our busiest offices in addition to registration through the district um and our directors and their staff are doing an outstanding job we're screening students and placing them very quickly within our district and that is all I have and I am going to turn it over to Dr con I have oh I'm sorry I don't know if you know this but what is it was one of the activities
028Jim G gim kit what is that gim gim kit kit know that it's a program that we have like a technology program okay yes okay thank you why you want to teach it I just want to thank you Mrs Kennedy uh very brief quick uh update for you regarding Staffing and a few things in HR so we had a series of administrative changes I'm not going to read them all but if you take a look at the slide there were 12 different administrative changes uh thus far this year there may or may not be one additional one forthcoming uh so but we are very excited about the admin either changes or new hires that occurred and the wonderful uh shifts uh that they'll make in their respective departments and buildings some other Staffing updates we
029hired 61 teachers this year that's a picture of them in that frame there seven teaching assistants five full-time clerical six full-time operational eight part-timers one nurse two guards and we have been continuing to hire since we opened schools so we're still in that process and still uh moving staff into new positions we held a two-day new hire orientation on August 26th and August 29th it was really a wonderful two days with our new hires giving them uh input into our district priorities and a number of other procedures and uh priorities for our district you'll see we had uh presentations on implicit bias tier one supports which has been something we've been talking about for a couple of years the importance of classroom management uh Mr tulan provided a wonderful Community presentation with the history of
030patch Medford that was extremely well-received and actually anyone who hasn't seen it Mr tulan I'm sure would welcome the opportunity to provide it because it really is rich in historical perspective for Patrick Medford um we also did uh trainings on cultural competency provided by Mr vasby and Miss Moser using the books out of my mind in esparon arising and they additionally did a wonderful they modeled a hexagonal activity that can be easily replicated in the classroom that the teachers found very useful um we provided technology updates and Dr Lucas and Mrs Kennedy provided updates for their respective departments as well uh at this time I'm going to invite up uh Dr Lucas who's going to share a little bit about uh Dr Marx and the feedback that was received and the only other thing that
031I would say just to go back for one second for the new hire orientation is we did survey all the new hires and I did send that in the board update to the board but if you looked at that feedback you will see that it was extremely positive across the board for all the presentations that were given so while it is a lot of information it is very well received and appreciated by our new hire cohort Dr Lucas okay so we welcome Dr Bryant marks or Reverend Dr Bryant marks to our district for our keynote as well as some breakout sessions for our staff the buyin was there immediately from the staff I heard from many people that they thought they were going to be resistant to this presentation and that was not the case
032at all right away he opened up letting us know he was a New Yorker so that right there started for siayan he's now transplanted Down to Georgia but gave us very real um examples such as Mets or Yankees what is your bias to that and removing things of gender or race and getting us to understand what biases we have he used the term that we are all good people we just had disproportionate exposure so our families may have over exposed us to cultural norms or thoughts or processes which we've then inherited and made our own implicit biases he let us know that this is a work in progress not a oneandone gave us homework many many times throughout the presentation and shared with what are the most known implicit biases believe it or not um
033bias towards the elderly is actually the bias that we all do the most um out of all the biases that are out there um I could not walk the hall without any staff member telling me he's great when he's coming back I want more one-on-one time with him please have him back clerical guards operational teachers AIDS across all of the units the feedback was overwhelmingly positive and in line with our district initiatives four and a half out of five stars uh the respondents thought that they were in line this is just some of the feedback we got from our survey um Dr Marx did give a reference to are you a thermostat or a thermometer and that was much of the feedback and the way he Associated that was if you're a thermometer you react
034to the situation by rising and falling with your emotions but we want everyone to be a thermostat where we're the constant we're keeping steady and we're setting the tone for those around us once again we ran extended school year you remember prior to 2020 we had a contract with bosis for this so this was now our fourth year of having our own extended school year for our students that are severely disabled we did give a a survey out to the staff that worked this summer not just the teachers but all of the staffs including the AIDS and overwhelmingly they felt that the communication between teachers administrators and parents was uh five out of five so the program ran for 30 half days in alignment with state regulations we had 101 kids 14 teachers 17 teaching
035assistants and 32 aids for all of our students it is housed at Barton for a k through 22 experience all of the students are in the same building Raider Bean did run this summer allowing deliveries of cookies and coffees mostly iced coffees for the summer to go through all of the classrooms our students participated in the announcements at Barton really allowing for a nice inclusive environment for everyone again the feedback what worked well we put new arrival and dismissal procedures in place overwhelmingly the teachers and staff thought that was beneficial for the students the administrators were out and about in classrooms Hands-On I spent many days there myself because our students are just infectious and who does not want to be with our Aces kids um Dr hburg and Mrs at put an assigned playground
036time they created a master schedule almost if you will for the summer something different than yours past which allowed for more Equity to accessing the outside for a recess or playground they put themes in place for each week and we saw nice collaboration between our staff members each class had OT speech and counseling push in for the students rather than engage in pullout sessions but what to improve good news I heard that Mr maisy's approving air conditioning for Mrs Kennedy so I'm going to jump on that bandwagon because every wanted air conditioning air conditioning and more uh the teachers are asking for the AIDS to be the day prior than the students that way it gives them ample time to go over behavior intervention plans classroom routines strategies so that's something we may look through
037next year it absolutely makes sense similar to Mrs Kennedy's um survey feedback they wish breakfast was served a little earlier it seems to be coming about an hour after our students started so we were already into routine but we did start earlier than Summer Academy and um just from one of our staff members they were impressed with how well everyone worked together as a team whenever anyone needed assistance I did see calls for assistance and everyone was Hands-On ready to jump in and support each other the program really ran great and you know this individual said it was a pleasure to come to work every day which some of those days were over 95 degrees that's really nice to hear registration we've been busy um just as Mrs Kennedy showed you the office of bilingual
038all of those new students fed through registration a little bit of our summer our student enrollment during the 20 23 school year so if you look at the chart on the left that is all of the months from February 2023 that we enrolled students for the 23 24 school year we start in February with our kindergarten students then upk students so last year um for the 23 24 school year we had enrolled 898 students well starting again in February this year we're only up to September we've already enrolled 934 new students for the 2425 school year so we are seeing uh a greater number of people coming to enroll however we've also done over a thousand so far transfers changes of address and withdrawals so just as we're adding new students we are losing some
039students as well or they're transferring amongst the district we are very busy as I said we did put a new um application in place it's calendly a lot of colleges use this for like college visits doctors appointments use this and what it is is it is right on our Central registration web page parents can click on it and they schedule the day in time that they want to come and see us so it really eliminates a lot of the back and forth phone calls what's nice about this is it does translate into 20 languages based on how the parent or family member has it in their browser and then once we have the person's phone number it sends text reminders out your appointment is at this date and time please make sure you bring these
040documents similar to how you get reminders from your Physicians office that's what this application does the feedback from the parents has been overwhelmingly positive and a much better system for our office than trying to return many phone calls and tracking someone down or language line to try and communicate with the parent it also allows us to vet out information before people come we get sometimes addresses from stum or South Country or Longwood once we have the appointment in our system we're able to vet it out and realize the person may not be a registrant of our district you know allowing them not to come in uh and waste their time and our staff's time registering them falsely and Mr mey good evening um just a quick note uh while I was sitting here I contacted
041the bank and unfortunately I'm a little overdrawn so I won't be able to provide air conditioning just quite yet for everyone they said are you're overdrawn now yeah they said maybe maybe one or two not 555 but we all work on that um yeah it was a very busy summer again in in our departments and uh what I've included here is just a couple highlights of some of the bigger things the more notable things that we've done uh over the summer um one of the first was we had a meeting with all of the administrators in the district uh and we covered some of the topics that you see here um in a meeting myself and my operational supervisors what we do is we take the time to go through significant changes or important reminders
042uh and we do that each summer to share with them and get also get feedback from them as to the things that are we want to make sure that we keep on the radar that are very important for us entering the school year so um I spent some time going through the different facilities use enhancements that we've been talking about um with the board uh since last year the some of the things that started with the extracurricular committee and some of the improvements we made not only to policy but also changes with within the um uh MLS program so things such as the introduction of the new help address line the uh frequently asked questions that we put on there the U new clarification regarding suff County department of health food serving regulations and the
043reintroduction of the seasonal window that provides for district groups to allow to uh uh make their reservations earlier and just kind of slows the the the infiltration of the outside groups we do that on a seasonal basis uh Nicole selo took time to go through some important purchasing aspects things related to confirming orders things that are related to contracts and when those contracts uh should be uh how they should be approved and when they should be approved before we embark on any services or receiving any Goods things of that nature uh Mr irn went through some changes with food service so specifically we reinforced uh our participation uh in the community eligibility provision and how that provides free breakfast and lunch for all of our students um which like I said everyone really jumped on
044last year but but now it has you know another caveat is that we know that it ties directly into tital one grant funding at this point in time we've received no other direction so we're still looking to get support from uh our buildings from our departments from everyone in the district to make sure we still have parents fill out those forms so that we don't have a drop off in that Aid Source just yet he also uh introduced uced the lifeback choking rescue devices so this is something that I saw when I was in my CPR training and I saw this device where you know we talked about here at the board several board meetings how students had to be rescued from choking right River and I believe Saxton and when I saw this during
045my training contacted Dan and we went out and purchased these these now travel kits are at every cafeteria in the district um and it's very it's a very simple device to use you put the attachment on and it's really a suction device to pull the the lodge food right out of the out of the victim's uh throat so it's really wonderful um Mr Rich Roth went through some Department updates in technology specifically um laptop repairs and the change that was in board policy with that with regard to the accountability and the fee structure uh he also introduced uh changes to the ticketing system that we put in help requests for all the technology devic uh we went through some important Ed law 2D reminders That's the Law just to remind you that covers uh personally
046um identifiable information and the importance of safeguarding that information in the areas that it covers and then also class link which is the uh one the single sign on to all the different technology platforms Mr Ahern went through security upgrades specifically our weapons detection systems and how we're going to be employing those now uh throughout the school year um we purchased A-frames for the schools to use to notify um people approaching the building when they're going to be in use and in accordance with board policy when those uh announcements are made or not made to staff and the public and also the Vape detectors The Vape detectors that was part of our ARP which is also the next thing on the list that Mr nun went through but this is something that we did as
047part of that Grant to bring in the the different security safety enhancements so he went through such things as uh the new classroom locks um yeah the new door the new new the new door safe bolt locks that's the single button push to throw the bad bolt the new lockdown Shades the window screens uh and as I mentioned the metal detectors Vape detectors the security gates there was a lot going on with that some of the other summer projects though that Mr nun staff was involved in directly these are just a few pictures just to show show you some of the things that we've done but the uh they call it the Barton apartment but that's the new Asus room that takes place at Barton that's for the life skills you'll see there for the
048the housekeeping services the kitchen Services it's really a beautiful state-of-the-art room some of the board members got to see these facilities uh on our board tour at the end of the summer one of which was the Oregon gym which was just repainted and the new uh red white and black stripes that are going throughout the building uh the sax and wrestling room so we talked about this you know two budget Cycles ago how we had the idea to renovate that that started with actually with uh Mr Cox at the time to take that space and re renovate that and bring the three teams together and over the course of the two budget Cycles now um and Mr K's um guidance as well working with my office uh we've got now a state-of-the-art wrestling room just
049below us and then the um the one I'm particularly proud of is the high school bath renovation I know some of the board members got to see that that day on the walk but that was all done by our in-house staff to really tear them down and rebuild them up um and really took something that's really a focal point when we have award ceremonies musicals all kinds of events at the high school taking place athletic events and now we have something that we should be proud of for you know ourselves and our community to use and then just you know close it out you know we're always busy in the business office you know the the year end fin Financial audit takes place every year it is extremely uh intense uh for our offices especially
050accounting and um in particular but to add on top of that we had our part-time unit we had the retray that was a result of our um contractual obligation once we settled that we did that retropay and completed that over the summer we also processed all of the teacher Amazon orders so they really adapted well but that in and of itself is a very time consuming process and then we had our staff roll over every year you heard Dr Cohen go over some of the numbers of the new hires uh we have to do that to get them set up and also roll over the existing staff to the new rates and then the last thing was our operational supervisors and myself were busy with Board of Education policy we reviewed and made updates to
051over 70 board policies over the summer months and you know just a quick shout out to oh I'm sorry one more thing um we we commenced the board project meeting the bond project meetings so we're busy soon as that was uh voted on and approved we commenced a committee that consists of Mr Nunan Mr manelo Mr richworth Mr Brinkman Mr kraco and myself but we also have uh members from our architectural staff our construction team um and also from Ze Communications and we meet bi-weekly to go over that to move that project forward and the board is going to hear more about that in the upcoming months as to where we stand you're going to see the new timeline on the website uh very shortly because we are moving fast and furious on this and
052um or probably even Hadad of schedule where we thought we'd be so the last thing I'd say was just a quick thank you to our staff because it goes without saying that you know you heard all the different programs that Miss Dr Lucas and Miss Kennedy are running and our staff work in and around these programs to make sure the buildings are ready each and every year and they did an admirable job really great job to make sure what you see today and what the kids on day one was ready for the first day of school oh yes sure oh I'm sorry this last uh the the schematic yeah just show yes those are those are not we're in the design stage right now this I happen to have because if you remember we did
053this when we did the bond advisory um committee and we did that that initial push out of what it could look like so we just started you know tweaking this a little bit cuz the IC projects and the music projects will likely happen faster so we already had a head start on this so I thought I would just share it but to answer your question once the design phase is completed which we are nearing the end of for uh for Bay we're going to share out similar similar things to show the community what can be expected so we can we think no um trusty creger your point is well taken and so we will add that soon and I will will confirm a date um hopefully the next board meeting where we can uh invite
054and share out where we are we can also do a presentation to the Bay Elementary School I don't know if it'll be we'll talk to Mr Mendes to see if it's yeah he's here he's here he you can share with them at the PTA meeting that we did discuss it tonight and we can either invite them to the board meeting or bring a presentation to Bay so that they can hear the updates for themselves they've been more than patient so um oh I'm sorry at Summer Academy and we do it part of my reports and have do it 9 yeah I would tell you you want to do it we'll do it so yeah you know and one of the things and I and certainly I'll work with Mr irn on that one things you
055remember is our food service department staff with the exception of Mr deliva and Mr bastro is say last name G right you two people so we we only have we don't have for instance staff at each building over the summer they only work you know through the school year so you know Mr Del will make the you made the deliveries by yourself all summer so he's start up north and go down south yeah we'll soly we we we're going to take this feedback now and work on it to make sure we improve upon that for next year students the AIDS get their 15 minutes or a half hour depending on their shift that we approve them for um before the students but with the teacher feedback was they're asking them to start the day before
056so go over bip so rather than just having them start the first day with students which we've to the day before y so they are there before the students because we want to make sure they're there before arrival but giving them time and an opportunity to see where the supplies are in the classroom where um you know we can have like a break understand what PEC symbols we're using or symbol sticks things like that so we've never had that before with the AIDS only the teaching assistance but we're looking to do that with the AIDS for next year so yes for now um so in summary I just want to thank the assistant superintendent for an amazing report I'd also like to thank all of our staff members there were so many administrators that were
057very busy at work and I say that um there's a lot of them here tonight but whether you were an administrator or a teacher a director of security a guard uh a CCA member whether operational or clerical or part-time there were so many of our dedicated staff members out and about and we could not complete this type of work if we did not truly have a dedicated staff uh trustees it's important to note just how much of the work is very much aligned with the board's goals and the superintendent goals so that it drills down and that everybody is aligned with the work that we're doing and the importance of it so I truly want to thank the board for their support because we could not do this if the board didn't support the goals
058that um were recommended and approved by the board and if the board did not approve each of our success plans we wouldn't be able to move forward so thank you for that so any any further fur the questions on the presentation no everyone's good thank you so much so um I know there have been a number of presentations it's been presentation heavy but um there have been things that we really want to make sure that we start the year out sharing with the board and since our meetings are recorded and many of our community members watch these meetings afterwards it's important to know what's going on so I'm going to ask lastly for Mrs connetti to be very brief um in not going through the presentation Mrs Ked and Dr Lucas but perhaps responding to
059a few of the questions relative to the grading policy that trustees have heard um either directly or online uh some concerns that were raised and we can pull up the presentation if a particular slide speaks to the issue then we'll speak to that issue but I think it's important to start uh if we if Mr President if I may with going down the line and trustees asking the questions that they have heard to dispel any U misconceptions about the purpose if you would like me to start with discussing what the purpose and intent of this was or share or ask Mrs Kennedy and Dr Lucas to share the intent of the change to this grading policy and then to respond to any questions that the trustees have okay okay so I will ask Mrs kedy
060and Dr Lucas to come up and to just briefly um share what the intent of the policy change was I know that generally it was to provide Equitable supports to students districtwide uh through the lens of grading and how that each teacher has their own perception and how that plays out and impacts students so um Mrs Ked and Dr Lucas if you come forward and just generally explain from both a special education and General Ed education perspective what the intent of the policy change is or has been and um to dispel any rumors relative to that and then trustees um can ask specific questions and we are recording this so that this can be dropped into our secondary parents Square to share with secondary parents relative to this so I I did put one of
061the slides up this is the presentation that I had shared with uh the trustees a few months ago and the community really going back to why we started this policy and I think the slide really uh spoke to the consistency between a student who can be enrolled in a course and have three different teachers and have very significant different course averages so I did speak to uh all the trustees in the community and I actually had shared an example and I tried to run through an example of the three different students if we looked at them um from a perspective of having three different teachers receiving the same exam scores but what will happen to their final average in each of their classes depending on the teacher that they had based on the teachers's grading
062policy and so that is really where we started from a an a place of equity it was very um imbalan between teacher to teacher and it was actually impacting final averages for students depending on the teacher that they had right um if I if you don't mind if I can interject a little bit so you guys did an excellent job I know you worked very hard with this to you know create some type of consistency I think that was the main point with this whole thing and I think create fairness across the board uh and I think he did a wonderful job with that um the concerns that I'm hearing you know and I just want to you know address these concerns uh from the community is is the perception that this is a test
063heavy grading policy um you know it says was it 50% summative and 30% formative uh and I think that's where the community is a little concerned for for those kids that aren't good test takers and stuff like that so I think we also need to outline um you know what summative and formative is for the community just kind of dispel some of those concerns a little bit as well sure and and again that could depend on the course itself right so we actually gave a an example within our policy of what could constitute a summit of assessment Summit of Assessments could be project-based right depending on the course so it doesn't necessarily have to be a pencil and paper test um that may be appropriate in some classes but not appropriate in other classes a
064summative assessment could be an essay that is student is writing it could be a presentation that a a child is given so we gave examples of summative uh assessments within the POS uh policy but it also said but not limited to right and we our policies speaks to the fact that teachers can collaborate with their directors to say would you consider this summative or um you know more of an informative assessment because I I'm sorry if go ahead apologize no I mean one of the things that came out with Labs right so in science clubs labs are very important so we heard from our science teachers that hey this needs to be more of a summi of our labs are very Hands-On projects so that may be a summative assessment for them in a science
065class versus a test as classwork as well can be considered corre in the same way cuz I I think what you know some parents are hearing what I what I've heard from them is that they're concern that it's you know 50% test 30% quizzes which makes 80% testing and that's that's a concern and I understand the concerns that that's you know a way somebody decides to go so I you know that's just wondering if we have some type of you know sure I you know obviously I don't think many of I think that was happening already yeah um with our classroom teachers right I I do think by the nature I think the purpose of this policy was to bring consistency and to make sure that no one test whether it be a Project based
066a presentation or an essay was counting so much that it actually impacted a a child's exam average you know if you're giving an assessment and within a marking quarter you were only having three assessments those three assessments weighed very heavily versus another classroom teacher that gave maybe eight different types of Assessments where kids could actually prove Mastery multiple times right so I think the policy was actually trying to not do that to say hey no one test should be counting more than 20% you have to be regularly assessing students how you assess them really depends on the course that you're teaching but we have nothing to quantify how many it is you know how large a sample size is going to be s a teacher what I'm saying is a teacher has the ability though
067to kind of uh put minimal amount of Assessments on there and that's that's I think that's my concern I think that's some of the other people's concern that you know based on that that there is going to be there can be possibly a larg in you know um could test and the one thing I right I I think the one thing I will point out is we actually change something um to offset that for um if you read in the letter that I sent to the community we actually changed when we were assessing kids within a marking quarter so often times our a day bday classes run full year within the first marking quarter they're only really seeing their students for five weeks rather than 10 and immediately we're trying to say give them a
068test and give them a grade we're we're actually saying no if you have an A Day bday class and it runs all year we're only assessing you twice the second quarter and the fourth quarter so we're not overly testing students and we're spreading it out over 10 weeks rather than over five weeks so the policy actually addresses that it gives those teachers more time rather than trying to cram in so many different assessments within a shorter period of time if that makes sense does I'm going to just jump on Fran Here I think the problem lies in a misconception of what formative summative means because I I'm getting you know we're we're moving away from standardized tests but now we're making you know the all of our classes be high stakes testing and um we're
069trying to set up our IEP in 504 special ed kids to fail and you know I sat on this committee for two years and I'm trying to Wrangle like misconceptions I think maybe like what Dr Jones just came around and said is maybe we need to do just a breakdown this is what this is this is formative this is summative like they got the letters they saw the Le letters I mean I I was getting comments from kids that have high schoolers who have had two that went through the school already through the system and they're like this is crazy and they're a special ed teacher in another District so I just think they it went a little bit over people's heads and we need to break it down into smaller information and I would
070I would uh encourage the staff to go to the link that actually directs them back to our policy cuz it does give them some examples of formative and summative that was included in our uh letter that actually brings them directly to the posit the board policy I was sent the link uhuh too and told that they can't make sense of the link again from a specialed teacher in another District can you just give an example of what besides quizzes what else is formative again for in formative assessment formative assessment are quick little check-ins right so it could be you you mentioned a quiz right but a teacher may do I'm just going to give an example of a cahoot right where kids are doing that it could be that kids are doing just a a
071draft of an essay that they're you know grading an essay and at various points within that final document they're submitting little pieces of their work right we're we're just checking in on them and then assitive it like I gave you an example our science teachers felt labs are actually summi of assessment it wraps up a lot of the learning so in science classes a lot of their sum summi of Assessments may be the labs that they're doing in their science class not necessarily just tests but it could be a lab all right in a math class it could be a little 10-point quiz it could be an extended response question one question where we're just checking in to see did kids Master this concept and are able to apply it to a specific you know
072life example within I would say an extended response is like a multipl step word problem where it's just a quick check-in and we call those like exemplars we're asking kids if they can do a multi-step word problem thank you uh I think what I'm what I'm picking up is that um uh this we we may be using words that non-educators are not understanding and um and and and it's and that's creating stress um that's been an issue a long time using uh using words that non-educators don't understand um so I think that we have some work to do there that we can there's room for improvement there also I I wonder um I remember hearing the the the first time that we went through this that you explained it which I think is a good
073I think it's a good rework I really do um but that this is also Department specific so it's not correct the Board of Education and the district office have said this is the way it is each department then has their own opportunity Y and I actually posted that on the website too so I actually created an Excel sheet for transparency so every parent can go on to see what does English 11 how are they assessing kids how are English 12 assessing kids kids so even within a department every course had the opportunity to have a very specific grading policy so it was the same course within the same department so oh trusty Jen I I think the other concern too was the fact that they take like very short tests so it's like almost like
074you got a 10 question test you get to wrong so I think for a lot of the students there that was kind of the issue of more the anxiety that was going on because you know they're only taking 10 question test or sometimes five question test and so as it gets higher you know now their GRS are going to get lower because you know so they I think that was their also their concern for that so trustees what I he is an opportunity for us to take the community engagement feedback which is what it is they have voiced confusion or being unclear with the new policy and it's incumbent upon us to make sure that we clarify and sometimes that requires multiple discussions to unpack it we had a similar situation with the Raider Academy
075we had to talk about it multiple times and multiple settings in order for everybody to feel comfortable with this process so what I'm hearing is that we have some more work to do in clarifying I I would ask that you give us an opportunity to take this back as a Cabinet discuss it also with our administrators and develop a plan whereby our teachers can be very clear I was just going to add and I'm you know I sat on the committee with you and I did all the work and I could speak about this till I'm bleue in the face but I'm hearing from high school students and high school parents that the teachers are not on board and they're saying that the directors just are telling them what to do and I I keep
076explaining to people that we had students on the committee we had teachers on the committee we've had multiple discussions amongst ourselves um so I don't again I think people need very clear concise information to understand things yeah and I would say that we have some more work to do with making sure that all of our stakeholders are very clear with the expectation the intentions and and change takes work to communicate it takes time to vet the process and to tweak if necessary um we've been down this road many times when there's something new but I think that all the feedback is very helpful and we we will take this all back and try to begin to make sure that we dig deep into making sure this clarifications with our teachers the delivery with our administrators
077uh how we deliver to the parents so that we can be on board with this nobody has done anything wrong it just takes some time to get accustomed to a new process so we will work on that and we will send back even even if it requires us to do um some type of session where we speak directly and respond to their questions and talk to them if you just give us a minute to figure out the best delivery mechanism we're happy to do that um and so we'll talk offline if that's okay and bring a plan back to the trustees and the community and I think it it just to to share um myself and Dr Lucas as well um Mr tulan and members of his staff we actually met with the high school
078staff um to get some feedback um and we actually followed up and if you remember I actually proposed some changes to the original policy based on the feedback that we received from that meeting and that was embedded in the feedback we got from the high school staff which really is what impacts the children the most at the high school right um and I know Dr Lucas met with the special education even beyond that so in terms of teachers we have been um listening and having meetings with them and make some significant changes based on the feedback that we're getting from the teachers I think I think what I'm hearing though is that although we have placed things on the website and had conversations things get lost in the sauce sometimes and not everybody reads um
079what's up on the website and of those that do read some have a different take on what they've read and we need to clarify it and so once again we will do what we need to do and bring back uh a game plan with a date for which we will Outreach to the community and share um and make sure that we clarify that will be forthcoming very soon I and I again I just want to CL I stand behind the policy I worked on it for two years I understand it um I've spoken to Dr Luke Dr Lucas and I were talking about it less Friday night at like 10:00 at night about it I mean it's it's just dispelling myths and rumors and you know so misunderstanding so you know I back it and
080I'm with you guys I just think there's some stuff out there that we just have to jul noted and we appreciate the feedback of both the community and the trustees and we will get right on it thank you thank you okay we're going to move on to um item number nine which is public comments on the reports um Dr Cohen hi I know have four minutes now right three minutes sorry fam minutes on Dennis said four he said that was his last will and testament message to me no I'm kidding I'm kidding um welcome back pam pam Peterson welcome back everybody thank you um thank you for those reports I have to say as a parent of my youngest going into the high school it was a very smooth transition going into the high school
081as the nth grader um she got lost once so thank you to everybody there for all of that um I just want to get right into the grading policy because I too have been sitting on instructional for a lot of years and um I also heard a lot of these same questions um and I also had some teachers speak to me so I'm not sure um if there was professional development for this if it was discussed with every teacher um one thing I just want to ask Lori that I don't remember by the way I love your shoes but one thing I wanted to are regions are the regions exams now included in their final grade the regions exams have always been included in their it it counts as 8% so that's always been the
082case we're actually one of the lowest um remember years ago it's it actually I think at one point may have been 20% Then it was 10% now it's down to 8% but I do think a lot with the blue ribbon committee and the information that we're going to be hearing from the state A lot's going to change within the next 2 years as it pertains to graduation requirements right okay because I didn't remember the regions being a part of the final grade sometimes we wouldn't get the regions until later that's been traditionally okay so that was that was something um but I think that um you know something that we did discuss is at the bottom line with all of this through assessments and everything is for the students to understand the material to master
083the material that is given for them to be able to be successful and I think that's what um the teachers are focusing on I think that as an instructional committee we need to re-evaluate this like maybe through a survey with the teachers and and parents to re-evaluate this grading system um I think that um bernardet said it very very perfectly clear that um there are educational terms that are used that unless you you're in education you don't know what they mean so I think that is something that can be confusing and intimidating to parents a policy comes out they look at a policy they see a whole lot of numbers and a whole lot of change and they don't understand it so I think maybe um you know that would be better to clarify in
084that way because honestly telling somebody to go to the website and find the link is even challenging in itself to try to find the policy so I think that maybe if we um try to clarify this for parents and maybe Teresa and I can kind of help with that um with Council to maybe get some some parent meetings together um where we can possibly have a grading policy Forum I know that you host these and not all the time do we get you know the people that we need but there has to be a point where we say listen we're providing all this for you you also have to take a part in learning what it is um but you know again I think maybe for instructional we can also reevaluate it and ask the
085teachers learning workshops we're trying to do each month for parents I have a notation that this may be one of those first workshops that we do just to educate people on the formative and summative assessments again you know it doesn't speak to written tests like an oral presentation a PowerPoint many of the things that are more Project based and handson can fall into the those categories right so right I know was there professional development for the teachers on 30 seconds we had um like as I said in terms of professional development we've reviewed the policy in small groups by Department I myself met with all the teachers Dr Lucas met with all the teachers at the end of the year last year all the directors met with the teachers to start crafting their policy so
086I would say that we met with the teachers uh multip times on this policy yes perfect thank you thank you Mr Peterson any other comments okay so now we'll move on to item number 10 the cons approval of the consent agenda can I get a motion who is the first I'm sorry Kelly Kelly and then Francis and we also need a roll call vote on the consent agenda including items a through y just give me one second vice president andr yes truste denafo yes truste creger yes president Negan yes trustee Salazar yes Trust trust Smith yes trustee Jennings yes and the consent agenda was approved thank you Dr conen okay we're going to move on to item number 11 which has actually been renamed or re designated it's going to be um items that have
087been added to the consent agenda for a separate vote Dr Cohen you want to take that yes first and foremost there were no items removed from the consent agenda but there was one item added um it was to appoint the district clerk I'm going to read the resolu resolution for that be it resolved that the Board of Education hereby appoints Teresa deliva to the position of district clerk effective September 30th 2024 for completion of a one-year term ending June 30th 2025 at the pro-rated salary of $85,000 I need a motion to approv the district clerk I'll make the motion I'll second it thank you and we just need yeah yeah take picture we uh all all um trustees in agreement yes yes I any opposed motion carries okay so now would I would ask now
088that our district attorney Matthew Menard swear in uh Teresa deliva as the district clerk effective J uh September September 30th it's in her [Applause] report no not yet got to do can we take a picture with her want me one the okay our next item is uh number 12 information items uh a policy first reading these policies will be circulated for first reading if there are no changes the policies will be included on the October 28 2024 Board of Education agenda um the only one for this month which is a breather for us 61456 attendance deportment and academic eligibility for for participation in extracurricular activ activities um number 13 we had no actions arising out of executive session and number 14 is superintendent's report Dr Jones thank you so much Mr President good evening again
089first I'd like to congratulate our newly appointed district clerk I know you do an amazing job you're a hard worker dedicated employee for 15 years truly invested in in this district and we look forward to welcoming you on to this very important position you certainly have big shoes to fill but I know that you are more than capable and competent and we look forward to your great success and many rewarding years in this District congratulations so also we have so many administrators here this evening so I am most delighted to announce that we have appointed the board has approved and my recommendation to appoint chrisy Pia as the new assistant principal of Eagle Elementary so we are very very excited for her is absolutely so welld deserved um I have a statement that is prepared
090to go out and uh the coordination up here behind the scenes you cannot imagine we didn't want to announce to the staff before this was approved uh but I want to read what will be going out to summarize who she is and how delighted we are for her to be appointed dear Eagle Elementary School community and this will Dr Coen will be sending out simultaneously to the staff in a few minutes while I'm sending a message simultaneously to the eagle community in a few minutes um we are happy to announce the administrative appointment of Christine Pia as El Eagle Elementary School assistant principal effective September 17th for over a de decade Miss pia has served our district as a dedicated educator establishing a strong inclusive educational community and fostering impactful relationships with students families and
091staff in all of her roles Miss Petty Alia was previously the district elementary stem department chairperson and preceding that role she was building stem an instructional coach and the building curriculum and instructional liaison at Barton Elementary School I could go on and on the message is rather lengthy because there's so much positive messaging to report so we're very very excited about this appointment and we know christe you will do great things Eagle Eagle has lost a a great man and once again big shoes to Phill christe but I have every every great confidence that you will do an amazing job in your new Ro congratulations to say um I know that I had sent an announcement we have also Stephen Santa cochi who is now he's here so for the record I will celebrate and
092salute his appointment to Barton Elementary School I don't have the luxury right now pulling up that long uh that long announcement of uh how welld deserved that position is but um for everyone in in attendance just trust and believe he is very welld deserving of uh leading Barton Elementary School um and I see Francis here and I didn't announce that um anybody else new I I think everybody else has been around a while Francis we welcome you I hear so many amazing things uh about how refreshing it is for you to be on board and how excited everyone is and delighted with the changes that you are making to improve um all of the instructional protocols within your department so we're excited about the new energy and what it's going to mean for our district
093so congratulations to all of our new administrators and thank you so much for so many coming out from pmaa I did challenge them as part of our community engagement to be more visibly present and they took it very seriously and I couldn't thank them enough for being present tonight so thank you so just a few other quick announcements um I think Mrs ketti already mentioned that as part of our community engagement goal we have been taking measures to do whatever necessary to make Community connections so going to the library as opposed to always having things on District property if that's what helps to make some of our community members more comfortable then that's what we'll do and so we were delighted to hear so so many families came out for a recent um uh Spanish-speaking
094family evening at the library with over 200 families represented uh that is an amazing accomplishment and we expect to continue those types of initiatives there was a question at the last board meeting about who receives AED training for for the school year and I just wanted to resp respond to that question for the record that all of our coaches are required to be CPR and AED certified in accordance with state regulations and Human Resources also ran a mandated training for all administrators also Sean Harris offers CPR and AED training as part of the district professional development offerings and our nurses are also required to re have their annual training so that responds to a question from last month's meeting I also wanted to announce for those that may not be aware that um inspector sumwalt
095is retiring and I'm not sure if you all were aware of that he is the inspector of the fifth Precinct um he has worked collaboratively with our district during countless times of Crisis and with our resources resource officers and John aorn they have been in the trenches supporting our school district he he has really really worked hard even when he had had been out on sick leave at a time when the district was in crisis he was still responding to my texts of all days and and type uh times of the evening to make sure that we were supported so I just wanted to publish publicly wish him well and on behalf of the district we'll certainly uh write a letter um wishing him well on his retirement so I I did want to publicly
096acknowledge that and there is going to be a two ribbon cuttings one has already been marked for Eagle Elementary it's on the 19th at 10:15 a.m. there's a new front entrance way warm and welcoming it's absolutely lovely um I intend to make it my business to get over there so I will provide more information for any trustees that are available to attend and there is also one at uh it's going to be toward the end of September it's going to be at Bon Dr Lucas do you want to just [Music] so tentatively right now it is scheduled for September 30th I'm just looking to confirm that with aaria from z& um we are opening up the aces apartment Mr Maisy gave you a little snapshot of what that looks like it is a fully functioning
097studio apartment that all three of our Aces buildings at the elementary level will be able to access um I do have to give a shout out to Dr Goldstein and Mr maisy's crew because they were instrumental in making this room come to for thank you so much Dr Lucas I believe that I have already thanked all the unions that are present today and I think in our back to school report you could see um how busy we all were to prepare for our students um I think that is all I have to report for this evening Mr President thank you Dr Jones Okay so we're going to move on item number 15 uh discussion topics some of the items that the board would like to uh present and discuss uh the first one up is
098going to be committee board committee requirements so I'm going to hand that over to vice president and so before you do that we do have the memo if you still need it um for the purposes do you need me to just put this in context before you start the discussion so so the purpose of what we're about to talk about is for criteria for our various committees whether board level District level um whoever our volunteers are if they're students and they are receiving service service credit they should should be a criteria for how many meetings they attend in order to qualify for truly being a a member of that committee uh likewise for volunteers um at uh for any of our district or um uh committees or board level what's up for discussion uh is
099when we recognize them at the end of the year what constitutes recognition if you've been to one out of 10 meetings where some have have really pressed their way no matter how busy they are we want to distinguish not that we don't appreciate all service but distinguish what constitutes a recognition or what constitutes something worthy of a student getting service credit for attending one meeting out of a year versus attending 50% or more so uh the assistant superintendents were charged with coming up with some recommendations to provide and so I have provided the board with a memo from them with some suggestions for their consideration taking all or none Okay so I I'm going to just chime in and so when I originally brought this up I think what I've seen in in committees board
100committees so for me this is solely about board committees I don't have any jurisdiction to say in you know and administration how you guys want to have your requirements is fine board committees are are different so just streamlining attendance so that if a CH student is using this for Honor Society or for whatever service there's a requirement you have to be 75% attendance for a meeting something like that I I think that's very valid I think all of us have experienced that sometimes students will sign up for five committees and show up to one we don't want that happening um but there's a big list here and where I'm hesitant with this list is I do not want to deter our community members from participating and start taking attendance for them or if you don't
101come you can't participate or if you you know like at the bottom here to me feels like a greeting policy actively participate in community discussions and activities I mean I feel like people either if they want to participate they participate if they want to just listen they listen like I don't think we should be monitoring that or even thinking about any of well I just want to clarify um so from the perspective I get what you're saying um trusty Andra I think the intent of that is that you know sometimes you have someone that may miss a couple of meetings and then when they come to the meeting they want to be brought up to speed and it takes away the time from the work that has already been done and then we have to
102re explain so it makes it less productive I mean think we have minutes that we all take so if the minutes are sent out to the Committees then it's we can all I think all of us we can explain at the beginning of the meeting that we'd like you all to read the minutes if you're going to miss a meeting I I just again um I don't want to say to someone well if you can't come to 95% of the meetings then you can't be on the committee if they can come to three meetings and they have valuable input I but can it be that maybe that they whatever they come they come but when it comes to recognition for I mean that's fine if we want to make a I I don't know if
103we might to make a criteria for recognition that's up to everybody else too I think in I'd like to say I don't really have any problem with this as as someone who before board service I served on a committee um like okay so here's some basic understandings of what you're expected to do when you sit on a committee it's pretty basic like participate um it's pretty basic and I don't think there's anything that I this would not have stopped me and I don't think it will stop any other person adult from joining is this more for students I or it no it's for it's for both for community members also and arriving more than 30 minutes late or leaving more than 30 I mean there's been numerous times in my committee where parents are leaving
104for games or coming late because are coming from a game I mean it wasn't it my experience our experience I don't think it wasn't disruptive for us but I thought that this came up as a topic for students that were on multiple committees for resumés in college applications now now it's turned into a corre you know a a full-blown everybody with a busy schedule and their so there were two let me just clarify there were two issues there were some of my commit IES um where there was a student participate uh participant that showed up for the first meeting and then was able to use that for the rest of the year that they participated but they didn't come to any other meetings so we want we want student we value student voice we want
105to know that the student before we start is committed to this process so that we can get valuable feedback from the student because they want to be on the committee so it's really just really trying to consider some ground rules for what we're looking for so that they understand what what is required if you will to be on this committee so they know if know what they're getting in for I mean sorry I don't want it to feel punitive although maybe that's how it's Landing but it I mean I had one student that said last year when I recognized her she didn't know why she was being recognized because she didn't even know which committee she was getting recognized for and she returned it saying a can in good conscience accept it because I only
106went to one committee well then that's our job then to do a better job with attendance and and you know we do sign in so if someone's getting right but but because there's no uniformity of expectations you can have one saying well why is she getting recognized and I'm not and so this provides an opportunity to unify and uniform uh the expectations I think the hardest part is missing two consecutive meetings can result in removal from the committee a lot of our students are athletes are are in band or chorus and sometimes our meetings fall on that so it's sometimes that they can't make a meeting due to that part because it's hard to schedule these meetings so I think I don't know it could be an excuse absence because you know but then it
107falls into like a kind of like a a school thing more than that cuz that's maybe can we change the word can to May no but let me just say for the record there's enough activity to go around and there are many students that are under subscribed and there are many students that are over subscribed and they can't physically commit because of their music and athletic obligations and if they can't it really is okay because there are other students that are willing and have the time because they don't have the overc committed schedule and they are more available so just kind of spreading the wealth a little bit um so that we can really have student voice on our committees I mean for what it's worth the board of education has a a practice that
108if you mix Miss X number of meetings consecutively you can be removed like they unexcused absences so like to put that onto a of Education committee I don't see anything terrible about it all right so I again I I think I think you're talking about two different things and I I've said this Dr Jones so everybody in the board knows what I've commented on this um I'm totally against this requirements from a board committee standpoint I think it's ridiculous to start to ask volunteers that they have to have requirements for volunteering you know um however from the student side of it it's not a board committee requirement it's a requirement of the Honor Society or any of the academic parts of their student life that says okay they're going to be recognized for being part
109of a you know board committee or any volunteer activity that they do that they have to put in certain amount of hours now we as committees record every committee records their attendants so if the principal of any of the schools or the high school asks for a copy and we can do that as an automatic thing saying we'll send you a copy of all the students who are on committees and here's the uh attendance of them at the at the meetings if they showed up to one meeting and that accounted for an hour of volunteer service then okay they get an hour of volunteer service if that committee runs three hours I hate to say sometimes committee meetings do run a little bit longer then that's 3 hours of service I mean that's very very
110easy for us to support the students in that way as far as community members you know look if if you were on a committee and you're being recognized and you really didn't do anything for that committee I'll tell you my experience and that's that somebody shows up to one meeting and makes an excellent recommendation or comment but they only showed up to one meeting so we're not going to recognize that person but that person made a huge contribution to that committee but now we're not going to recognize that person because they only showed up to one and then I know we have community members who are on several committees and we we went through this a few years back where we had a tremendous amount of applicants which of course unfortunately we don't have as
111many applicants as we had at that point um which is another question and we had to start to decide oh we're going to have to not allow so many people to be on a committee and there was good reasons for that right you can't have 300 people on a committee it doesn't make any sense um again that didn't become policy that just simply became something we decided we were going to do that year to kind of segregate how many people could be on a committee so I know there's seven of us and we all have our opinion and that's fine that's why this board works my opinion is I'm a no to any kind of board requirements for you know for Board of Education committees if you want to volunteer and you want to come
112to a meeting and be part of that committing meeting we're going to try to make it as as rewarding for you to be part of that committee and and always make sure that we're respecting the committee members input and like I said sometimes that's one person showing up to one meeting and they make a great comment some come in and they don't they don't say a word they come in and they just sit there for the whole time and they're absorbing and that's fine too um because because you know part of what we said we wanted from committees was to have more of the community involved in what's going on in the background in each of these different subjects whether it's Finance or it's instructional or it's buildings and grounds whatever it happens to be
113you know wow that's great we got have people that understand better what the school district is doing and you know we always say we think that if people don't show up to committees it's because hey we're doing a good job nobody needs to show up up and and question anything and maybe that's true you know or maybe just everybody's super busy and they just can't be involved and and they're maybe they're volunteering on the PTA level or some other level and they put their time in there I always said that there's that small group of people that are always there volunteering right we all know this we all been through this probably that's us in some respects at at Oregon back to school night I would stand up as the the president of the father's
114club and I would ask in the order orium for every parent to give me one hour just give me one hour you know what we could do if every parent in this room gave me one hour no it was the same 12 to 20 dads that participated every time it was just that's the way it worked and that's the way it works probably with all the schools at some level so to start coming up with requirements that people now have to meet and kicking people out cuz that's what's going to happen you oh I'm sorry you didn't make the meetings you're out or I'm sorry you don't get recognized yeah but I but I attend tended two meetings I'm sorry that's not 75% you're out I'm a no may I make a suggestion can we
115than you thank you um I I'd like to suggest that maybe these are the the the for the students we have the requirements like because there's there's there's res but there's resumés that need to be built and and some kids are trying to build resumés on things that they're not able to fulfill the commitment that they made um but with the we we never we decided that several years ago when we had the 4,000 people wanting to be on EXC committees um that was a meeting um U and we determined at that time we would not restrict the number of people that wanted to be on a committee under no circumstances anybody that wants to serve on a committee can serve on a committee and I think that's a good practice um I also remember
116a call several years ago there was conversations around for my time on the board the the expectation was there are expectations for people who serve on the board so maybe this is not requirements and yes we're going to kick you off if but if you're going to serve on a board here's the expectations you're going to show up and you're going to participate and if you can't get there because X number of reasons we you know as adults we send emails saying I'm not going to make the board meeting make the committee meeting and it's just as adults that's how you communicate and the kids were teaching how to participate in this kind of a process does does that help so just to clarify bernardet so board members requirements to be on the board of
117education is New York state law that's not our policy we don't set a policy for that and even within that standpoint it's still only a recommendation of whether a board member misses three consecutive meetings without making any kind of of notification that they wouldn't be there it's not like if you miss three meetings you're out no but there is New York state law Duty it's it's a d it could be right and again the board could then recommend recommend to the commissioner that a board member be removed and then it's a commissioner that will make that final determination so it's not our policy that sets that up just just to clarify thank you for that um so I think we have two points of discussion here first is the the the rules for the kids
118and the second is the expectations of the adults is that what that where we're at here yeah and again on the on the side of the students I think that I I agree the students have requirements if it's if it's an honor Society program and the Honor Society says you got to get x amount of service time for something then and the students have to bring back a form or something I mean we do that remember we used to have and Dr Jones you probably remember right we used to have students had to go to board meetings it was one of the activities they could do and we would sit here and at the end of the meeting the students who were in attendant at at the end had to come up we had a
119sign and it was actually I think Dennis the district cleric who was you know able to sign and say maybe the superintendent not necessarily board members right yes that wasn't our policy that was the policy coming from the you know so I agree if there's anything we can do to help those students to gain their service Time by recording the time that they serve on our committees then I'm all for that but again it's not our requirement of how much time they have to spend so so just for clarification purposes so I think we're clear that as it relates to students we will do what we need to do uh to talk with the Honor Society to make sure that that's clarified so that students are truly providing the service if we're signing off as
120it relates to District level committees that are not board committees we can have some type of similar protocol that works for us um as District leaders so and we will do something similar maybe soft in the tone but similar so that when we meet well the ground rules are clear for everyone and they understand what the commitment is the time frame Etc um it would just mean that any board committees will just be different than everything else and that is fine if that is the board's pleasure so just to clarify what's the other committees you're talking about so we have many district level uh committees that meet um the charge could be could be an AIS committee it could be a a district uh deep development committee it could be any particular committee that anybody
121special education audit anything else that we have that are district type of committees that are not board committees we would have the license to create expectations so it would only be the board level committees that would be different than all the other expectations so you're not so you're not asking the board to approve the requirements that you're setting for those District committees that's something you're just doing on your own I can do that on my own I wanted to bring it to the board such that there would potentially be a discussion about everything being in alignment but if the board feels some level of discomfort with their committees having any kind of ground rules or expectations then I am fine with providing some clarifying points so that the other committees that are district operated I
122would be able to feel comfortable when I send the volunt recognition um that they have met the requirements and then the board members committees I'll just send everybody a thank you note and acknowledge anyone that signs up so so I think that the um and again just Frank just to clarify the audit committee is New York state law okay that does not f fall under our requirements that's New York state law that sets the audit committee so we can't put that into the requirements right that's not a committee that you can rule over that's that's totally separate where we talk volunt recognition we look that's understood shows up well we should we should of course you know recognize them but the other thing Don you're talking about was the whole aspect of um expectations right
123which not a requirement but we do that one of the things that was requested way back when was to and we did I think uh president O'Brien actually I think it was he that put out a uh um a piece was it you Kelly that did it where we we talked about what each committee did and what you'd be you know again not required to do but what it's all about do you do you really want to be on the finance committee because this is what we do and it's like oh maybe that's not something I want to do so you know we we had talked about that that's fine I mean we should always be putting out and I think maybe we do in the applications say you know this is this committee and
124this is what this committee does plus this is when this committee meets um we don't do that part okay well I mean that all that also that's why I did I did that live you did right you did the live thing it was Kelly okay and and that's good because we want people to be able to participate you know to participate but not to give them requirements of of participation so then if I may I I think if we have um practices policies come up with whatever word you want to come up with so it's not our Board of Education policy but I think it makes sense to if we're if we're deciding that the Stu the students should have certain criteria fine and then that could be like for Board of Education committees as
125well that needs that's not our that's that's our committee but that's not we don't have the justification to tell the students what they have to do to be on a committee I mean you understand that they're get no they're getting credit from the Honor Society not from the Board of Education there are students that do this that are not on Honor Society not doing it to get Honor Society credit don't get into Honor Society until May right but so but what do they get same an Honor Society same thing with the community member what does the Community member get they get a little certificate at the end of the year saying they participated in the they put it on they can put it on the college resume I feel they participate in in a commit
126to listen I I think I I think almost like golf I think you have to is that be honest the Committees are trying to move stuff forward correct that's what our our charges and I think that the way a committee works is consistency and if you have the same people on a regular basis and they put the input in then you can be consistent when they're not consistent it it it I don't think it works I mean you think it makes a difference oh I remembered what I wanted to say I mean it's always better when people participate what the other thing that U when I was first it was a while ago the the practice was you are on a committee and you get to vote if there is a vote made during the
127committee if you wish to as a community member come to said committee meeting you can come to any committee any Community member can come to any committee meeting whether they wish to be on the committee or not they're a guest and if there's ever a vote within the committee only the committee members get to vote on it that is correct that was the practice for a long time yeah not vot speak not really voting it's speaking that's correct right that's correct is a guest but again the voting aspect of this is more of a consensus of a recommendation to the board right right so just so we're all clear cites have absolutely no power other than to make a recommendation to the board of education so you can call it a vote but it's not
128like it's a vote no it's just within the committee to move suggest okay so and you can come and you can learn but as a Comm you have to be a member of said committee committee to become a member of the committee it's within this period of time so if someone didn't make it onto the committee but they want to learn more about the legislative something or other they can come in December and just listen sure they miss the deadline right but those are the that's the practice of the committee if the practice of the committee is we want our kids to be here for X number of time in order to be acknowledged for whatever reason that they need acknowledgement and we want our adults to be here for an X number of just
129show this is basic to me if you're going to say I want to be a member of a committee this is some basic expectations this isn't we're going to slap your hand and send you home if you miss the third meeting yes it does says you're off oh it doesn't okay this is I I have I feel we have beaten this horse into the ground okay no this wasn't a vote it was a discussion it was a discussion about practices so so then as of now we're not putting this into place but we could still talk about it so I just the only reason I brought it up for this meting meeting is because the committee deadlines are September 30th so trustees will start meeting with their committees once the rosters finalized September 30th so
130having this conversation would have prepared for prospective meetings that will start in October and then there would be alignment of purpose and charge Etc expectations but Dr Jones you're putting this out for your District committees either or right like it's a done it's a done thing yes okay thank you so I'm putting it out for those that are under my domain and so if the trustees want to do something different I wanted to share with you what I was doing so you would have the opportunity to opt in or out no pun intended I'm around all right so we can continue discussion yeah can can I just ask a question about since we're talking about committees so do we need we need to approve the Committees before we can have start with our committees correct
131is that approve them like we're supposed to put them up for for an approval so do you me the deadline is September 29th or September 30th we cannot start meetings until October 28th when we approve them at our board meeting well can you approve them on the 7th when you have your meeting that's okay right so we're the intent will be to cut off on the 30th approve on the 7th so you don't lose a second month of school um and then you can proceed in October so we will make sure that happens we would just need your permission to make October 7th work session a voting meeting which I will advertise in the well now I have here you go a district so we yeah okay we good yeah all right we're going to
132move on all righty um we already talked about the grading policy so the next thing up is the uh New York State School boards Association resolutions so those of you that have been following along over the last couple of months um actually started last year we submitted two resolutions um for uh consideration at the 2024 annual business meeting and to be adopted by the voting delegates and we had our request of the for nisba to advocate for the minimization of field testing and School District decisionmaking rights to refuse to participate in field testing without penalty from the New York State education department that has been recommended so that resolution is moving forward right now um the second one the second one um which was that we advocate for 30 to 40 minutes per day of
133recess time being officially recognized to be recognized as an alternative form of instructional time in elementary school and counted towards mandated minutes schools can then allocate adequate Time For Recess each day to ensure the social and emotional well-being and the whole child development of their students so we submitted that one and trustee Jennings was actually in the meeting when this came up and it wasn't it wasn't supported but Miss Jennings would you please share what the conversation was um so this one is part of the one that's not recommended and in order for it to get recommended um someone has to make a motion and then second it in order to bring it to the table if not it doesn't even bring to the table um aside from that at the nesic legislation meeting they
134talked about it and some of them were on board with it but they say it's still a little dicey just because you're putting recess an instructional time and some teachers may feel that it's going into instructional time you're taken away from that kind of Freedom that the students have and where are they going to fit it in because it's now taken away from that free time that the the kids have to kind of play more than so they they were all kind of on on board with it kind of in a way so it's so they're not they're thinking that we want recess to be instructional not no to be considered instructional well you want to be you want to be recognized and that's a form of instructional time an alternate form of instructional time
135right but some people might and they're looking at it like gu it's great but it's still on that the kind of like that teeter totter of does a teacher need to be in front of them doing something correct because it's like instructional so a teacher might have to they're thinking that maybe it will have to come up with some kind of plan to go out there and play and kind of like give them rather than that child having that free access to come up and kind of play but they were in kind of at least n suffix um I know de Dei um was had no position for it just because it's not kind of in their wheelhouse so if you see that the Dei says no you know opposition it's just because it doesn't
136have to deal with with them um but it was a it was a hard sell on on on either side I also made a couple of phone calls to find out what I could find out about this because I'm the one that's going to need to say to to move to try to move it forward during the meeting um and the the feedback that I've been getting is it's not just like we would very much wish to be able to have uh more F flexibility with um recess speci especially in the younger grades um and and and the limiting uh requiring X number of instructional minutes throughout the course of a day and a year um uh made that difficult to have more flexibility with the recess time for the kids um and uh what
137was push was was presented to me is like there are districts that re need every minute they can get with the kids um the way I paraphrased it was sort of like well your privileg is showing tuck that back in because our kids may be doing fine and may need some more and some play time but requiring it to be in in in in uh in recess and the school districts that really one don't have a place to put the kids for recess they're in the hallways there there there's no place outside yeah but we're not asking for it to be requirement we're asking it to be recognized as alternative I know but that's that's the feedback that was got was got to me understand that like there are districts that are struggling mightily to
138get their kids up to grade level and saying you can make this recess time was counterproductive to those districts so that's that's the push back that we're getting yeah well so anyway and I think it I think there's I think it's valid so the next phase before we go to try to push it Forward at the actual business meeting is to present or submit a rebuttal to their um non support and I put together a rebuttal I have a bunch of references I have to submit it by September 20th at 5:00 I gave everybody a copy of what that rebuttal was I have had nothing but I'm sure you guys all on board with it all right so then I'm going to submit it and if it doesn't get approved through the rebuttal then it
139would have to be made a motion by uh trustee Smith at the actual business meeting to have it recognized is that correct Kelly okay can can I see that for a minute please so that's where we're all hang on a minute please in order for me to bring to the table we are the last one on the page so hopefully there is a quorum because last year we we went all the way from 4:00 in the morning till to to almost midnight hopefully they have a quum if there's no quum won't make it to the table um but just remember we we are not voting on The rationale you are just voting on the um resolution right so they don't even look at the rationale no I know but what to get it to the
140next level correct without going to that um at the at the dinner meet I'm sorry at at the 10 yes which is almost like if the rebuttal is approved then it would get to be heard without the motion yeah and and just as a point of reference um in in our meeting with Regent Tillis at Eagle Elementary he said and I know principal skill will back me up on this he said he felt that was a good idea that's something that should be an option for that for a certain amount of recess time because again you know we know we've been challenged with how much recess time we can give the students and the whole concept of okay eat lunch go out to and how much time is left and he felt wow that was
141a really great suggestion and something that he would support okay we're good yep F all right so I have one more thing um on discussion topics it was actually on last month's um agenda and we didn't get to it so I'm going to get to it now so it to be quick we have uh a Community member uh by the name of Bruce Meltzer that graduated um in the class of 1969 that would like to donate to the school district a proclamation type of award to an All-American athlete award um and the first one he he want to recognize was a bob Figaroa who was a graduate of here in 1968 and um he has a whole Accolade of many many sports accomplishments along the way a matter of fact it was even mentioned that
142he had had comparable times with Olympic gold medalists and silver medalists Tommy Smith and Carl John Carlos back in the 1968 Olympics so he was a world class athlete so what what he proposes is to be the donator and do all the leg work and research for any Pat chog Medford graduate that has acquired All American status so the discussion here would be would we be willing to let him make that donation to hang the plaque or to put it in the um showcase I did not know this was going to be discussed tonight well we said last month it would be discussed tonight but the it wasn't on anything in correspondence so I don't know if we're all ready to have this discussion I'm just more information about who this guy is what he
143wants to do why do he want to put it in our building so he wanted one plaque for I just want to get it right he said he wanted to donate a plaque correct and the name of the award would be the Bob Figaro allamerican award oh and Bob graduated from Pat meded yes in 1968 yes okay and then they would add a series of other um all Americans that were named for school district and and then we continue on cuz I mean like where do we stop and how far do we go back to figure out how all Americans are cuz I that's what I'm just saying I'm bringing here for discussion so that that I'm bringing it up so it's something we need to talk about sounds to me like something that the
144Hall of Fame would want to get a hold of but I think he wants to display it like in I don't know where wherever our Sports trophies are I mean right by the gym I know where they are I just can't think the gym and then put it right in there or put it like you know they have the class records or whatever they have there too and then put all American up there but do we have something like that already what's that do we have plaqu that to say who all all Americans are I don't know do we have a picture of this thing that he wants to put in oh we're going to ask Mr CCO do we have that can you come up to the microphone because it's being recorded and we
145know you love microphones thank you hi so um the reason for um this award coming forward is uh there have been several all Americans over the years that have not received recognition um I know someone one of the trusties mentioned the hall of fame um when this gentleman reached out to me he explained that because this was a student athlete that was very accomplished but kind of lost track of over the years um you know there was no one to really build a full Hall of Fame profile talk about his community service he wasn't necessarily recognized and there were other athletes that fell into the same boat to to achieve an All-American status is it's the highest level an athlete can reach so this is a way to recognize someone that perhaps maybe should have
146been in the Hall of Fame already maybe they're not they didn't get in in the first class um put his name on the award and then any All-American that comes from patch o Medford would be recognized on the plaque we do have some plaques in the corridor for athletics with that are like the adaline plaques for students that that reach a certain level so it would be align in that um he did say he would leave it up to us to get the plaque made designed it he was just willing to pay for it yeah so I mean just going back to the hall of Fame concept so when the Hall of Fame started it wasn't just like oh the Hall of Fame and it's done all right I mean it took months and months
147and months for us to go through Dr Jones knows the process and I know we have Hall of Fame members here and understand that and there's a whole process that they go through what I'm not understanding is that you know okay a lot of the Hall of Fame members have to put together that information and yes sometimes it's you're losing track of things or whatever um but they get the information and they put it in they submit it and that person gets you know nominated and and becomes part of the Hall of Fame it almost sounds like with all the information that's already being provided for this first individual that that wouldn't be a hard thing to do and we already have a process in place on how it's done and we don't need a
148donation from someone to do it appreciate the donation of course we always do but we really need to follow the process cuz what this is asking for is for to set up a whole new criteria on how to accept and put people you know on this on this plaque so I would recommend that we just process this through the Hall of Fame and let them them do what they do so the original conversation and and my first conversation back was through Manny Fus of the hall of fame um he had he had put the gentleman in touch with me the since then we've actually had a couple of separate meetings um that I know um Mr neger and Miss Jennings were both present at to talk or to look at the criteria of how the
149selection process for the Hall of Fame was made um because there the rubric has kind of changed over the years and um certain weights are given to certain areas this this really came about to recognize just the athletic accomplishments it's not covering community service it's not covering contribution to the patch Medford Community well so does the the Hall of Fame teams that won the Hall of Fame award many teams over the last several years those weren't really Community contributions other than that was a great team who won the state championship right I think they would have for a for a track athlete though it it wouldn't be like this is someone that's as accomplished as they come as an athlete don't we have a track athlete Mark in the Hall of Fame yes so I
150I don't understand you ran in the Olympics F love me yeah so this is just a list of our all Americans right that's straight essentially it's just a list of the all Americans my only my this is my only concern and that's it is that I just want to know a little bit more just this individual before we start naming an award after him that's you know I think that should be it other I don't think there problem with it just so you know I got the letter directly from um Mr Meltzer but it was ACC compan with email from Manny fusus who is the president of Hall of Fame now the Hall of fame's criteria is such that it is set the way it's set this particular award is for straight up athletic all
151Americans there was no other criteria am I correct yes it's just a list or all- American athletes right Dad graduated from here yeah award it's just a list of the names of of of outstanding athletes in the district being all americ is a big deal come on it's like know that are all Americans canes I'm sorry I don't want to I don't want to start about concerned Cien that's what that's my point was we don't know I don't know who this that's not listen that happens listen I'm not trying to be adversarial about I'm just saying that these are accolades that were accomplished at the highest level in amateur Athletics he was an All-American in the sport or you know so to recognize him separate from the Hall of Fame that has its own criteria
152it's not just Athletics it's community service it's Integrity it's a whole so this is a totally different thing is this something I think fadette means because I speak fluent bernardet um I think she means then where do we stop if somebody comes in with the Arts or somebody comes in with like where do you draw the line of people wanting to put a plaque for something in the school well I think I think if we keep it within our like if it's Athletics and it goes to Mr CCO and he's overseeing it not someone externally if it was in the music department and Nate was overseeing something you know if there's an equivalent to that then I don't know I don't want to put another job on your plate but that to me makes more
153sense that case by case sounds like it needs a little bit more un packing in discussion what this was my recommendation for whatever that might be worth is the upcoming Works work session it on okay all right so that's it on the board topics correct Community comments okay now we have Community comments Dr Coen uh Miss Julian Peterson you have three minutes please direct any comments to the board president go okay um being on um board committees for many years I just wanted to touch base with a few of those um to add to your discussion as um I I definitely do feel um what Tom said was was pretty accurate with the students um it is very difficult to get members the one year that we had 400 is because they were Zoom if
154people have to come out personally into the meetings you don't really get a lot of people um I do feel that there should be something written up saying what you feel you know what is what how what each committee is is with their charges um and that you know these are the expectations but I don't think anybody should be removed or or anything like that and no disrespect to recognition night but and I don't I don't need the accolades I don't need the but I sit on multiple committees and get one recognition and I'm not looking for that I'm just I'm just adding to the discussion um you know a lot of people go through social media when with our committees maybe we can encourage them to come as opposed to putting everything on social
155social media uh board committees are really supposed to be run by the school board member with District members as liaison goals are supposed to be created um by the committee with looking at the the you know this September 30th now just um and and Tom you know being legislative we used to go year round with some of them just a suggestion maybe have these applications the end of June approve them in July and then you can start right away in September because personally our time is valuable and if I'm attending these meetings and we don't have a meeting for Christmas or we don't have a meeting for this we're getting it took two years to do a policy with instructional you know and review something which might have been a little bit faster um so
156and not that people want to meet over the summer I'm not saying that but if there was something like going through a traffic light and meeting with a legislator over this summer you can have the committee there so this way it's consistent and that we're making progress we're we're we're doing something that we can say hey Community look you want to join us because we're doing something we're making things happen um but I definitely feel that a combination of the things that were discussed today I definitely feel that with the students um they get the Honor Society credits maybe touch base with um Reagan I think she's still the one who who is the head um talk with them at the high school and see if that's something that's that's still you know still whatever
157and as far as the Hall of Fame the rubric has been the rubric I wrote the rubric it is same rubric but it can absolutely be modified because we do have modifications for people who have passed on or athletes who the community service is doing that ath that sport so that is a community service Integrity is something that you just can't step away from that's what it is but um anyway thank you thank you uh oh sure good evening Kevin tulan P for Congress of teachers I just want to say uh with any policy specifically the grading policy there's always revisions and right now I think the policy was Set uh Miss Kennedy as she said shared uh a lot with the high school teachers um we did make some changes before you adopted it
158and I think last year at the high school alone we generated 10,000 grades and at the elementary uh the mid the policy doesn't impact the elementary school and somewhere at the middle school we're probably sitting around 7500 grades of course the whole year um I believe the teachers are going to look very closely at how students are progressing at the end of the first marking period and there will be plenty of noise if things are not working out I think we're dealing with right now a lot lot of teachers that are um adjusting to how the policy comes out and maybe you know maybe I gave 40 grades in a marking period and the colleague down the hall gave 10 and they have to meet in the middle right that's that's what this policy is
159dictating so there are some Growing Pains amongst my colleagues as this is rolling out and they're adjusting um so I think it's going to take a little time but I know Miss Kennedy Dr Jones and I will re-evaluate probably somewhere around Thanksgiving saying this is or is not working we're not going to wait until June and have children that are high and dry you know without a diploma so I I think that we will work very well together and and monitor this as it goes on and I'm sure we can do a good job of adding to what formative what summative is in in the very near future thank you thank you Mr tulan anybody else okay board comments you can move on to board comments we start all right so uh first off um
160congratulations to uh staff and faculty and administration for a successful starts of the school year I also want to congratulate all our administrators that are newly promoted congratulations uh and I want to congratulate Teresa on her new appointment we look forward to working with you and uh that's it thank you very much thank you oh I'm sorry I forgot to thank uh Miss Ked and Dr Lucas for you know helping clarify some of our concerns and continuing that too trusty quer okay um I just wanted to say that the building walkthroughs were great we saw some great stuff over the summer the community concert was awesome uh better it gets better and better every year um I did miss the convocation because I had my own back to school stuff at bosis but I heard
161such great things um my brain's a little fried CU you know eight days back into school it feels like it's about two months already and having two high schoolers now one being a girl has pushed our wakeup time to 5:00 a.m. so um I just want to say congrats to all the new positions I'm happy to see six Pat Med kids in my electrical class this year at bosies which is fantastic cuz we only had one that was put in late last year as well as a Raider Academy student in my bosis building which I thought was fantastic at bus study the other day um I want to welcome everybody back and looking forward to a great year and then lastly I just want to say thanks to Dominic Thorn legislator Dominic Thorne one more
162time who put a no left turn sign at the the half circle in front of St Francis so you cannot go left now onto South Ocean you can only go towards the district office so between that and the crossing guard that he got us we really uh might see some even better safety things going on over there and I think uh La Martina had something to do with that too trusty Smith I think it's highly likely Mrs lamartina had something to do with that I think she did um um uh congratulations to uh uh Miss Padia and Mr Santa cochi and Mrs deliva welcome I'm very happy for all of you oh yes um and uh welcome back to everybody the I did do the walkth through um uh custodial and maintenance buildings are gorgeous
163thank you very much there was a lot of work that was done over the summer with the uh upgrading the bathrooms at the high school which I've been complaining about out forever and they're beautiful um and um um uh thank you welcome back and um um Mrs Kennedy and Dr Lucas thank you for your work on the new um policy with the grading policy I do anticipate it's going to be I I do know that it was some very important changes that were made um and it's just little tweaks here and there about why the community doesn't understand we have been working on how we're all communicating to each other for a while and I think we're getting better at it but we can always get better um so thank you very much trusty Jes
164um just to do piggyback on that congratulations to all the staff and administrators and uh congratulations Teresa I look forward to an exciting and fun year to work with you trusty dinael you're good okay vice president Andrade oh she's got a whole thing of notes Here you got two PS minutes read all this sorry um what did you say three minutes okay minutes um well first I just wanted to say that being that we're gonna feel the power uh talk about committee on the 7th we we our first committee meeting for extracurricular is October 9th at 5: PM so I just wanted to say that because we can um the second thing I wanted to bring up and I hate to be you know the one that brings this up but um so I looked
165at the class sizes for some of our you know younger kids classes and some of them are you know it's when we talk Equity there it's it's it's all over the place so I'm just wondering is there a plan in place for those numbers that are like in K through two especially that are 26 27 25 and then there are some that are 14 and 15 is there and anything we can do about this so you know so that's an interesting conversation I and a little loaded I know um but I will say that there are some parents that are very clear that they would rather their child be in an overcrowded classroom than change schools that's a big deal so we have that a lot at bay where there's a weight list and we
166have to cut off at the the required contractual amount of students and and that's why the numbers are so high at Bay until we add additional space there but it doesn't matter those parents they want to be at Bay they do not want their their school changed and that is something uh Dr Lucas knows Miss ketti Knows Mr Mendes knows all too well that this is a challenge we have and there is space in some of the the larger schools because they have more space it is a challenge but without moving children from one building to another which takes them out of their Zone and sometimes they have siblings that are going to that same school and parents just would prefer the siblings remain together so my point trusty Andra is it's a little bit
167more complicated than just equalizing because that requires moving children yeah I I mean I of course you know me from my head I I wasn't even suggesting that of course my first suggestion would be let's add a teacher and open up but if you're saying there's no room in the building then yeah that is a little more complicated yeah and I think when about money too language programs Dr Jones I think one of the concerns is just so the trustees know we we do have a TA in our uh K1 du language classes because they sometimes get a little bit higher than our non-o language classes so right now the kindergarten section that you're looking at is BAS do language right so that that one particular class General Ed has 26 and the Dual language
168has 25 so both of those classes T Tas in them then right we have we have kindergarten AIDS in kindergarten general education but we did add the Tas in the due language class because that's where we tend to get larger amounts of students because when an enl student qualifies for um services in our district the due language is their primary placement they have to opt out of it so if we have an L come in we must mhm by law place them in a bilingual program unless a parent opts out of it most of our parents don't opt out of it because it's an amazing program so that's why we put the Tas because if you go back to that slide that I showed you about how many students right and in a du language
169program we also have to make sure we secure the appropriate staff and and making sure that the staff that we hire is bilingual so it's not just about opening up another section because the sections we need to open we would need to have a certified teacher to open that teacher so it's it's a little bit more which is not that easy all the time to find so it's a little bit more complex than meets the eye no I'm I'm I do not think it's easy I just I you know I'm just looking at these numbers and looking at you know when one school has class of 14 and one has 26 you know how just everything small instruction the time you're spending with kids we want you know we want to get them ahead and
170everything and then you're dealing you know that's your point is well taken the challenge is you know there there are multi faets to the challenge Dr Lucas did you want to add I did I just wanted to add the two classes that you're seeing at 14 are both ICT classes or inclusive co- teing classes so right now in the beginning of kindergarten there's very few students who are identified that require integ graded co- teing so we almost have to save spots six in each class for students that will become identified and need to go into that class so very often our ICT classes um so the two classes at Barton that are at 14 are because of that the other class that's at 14 we just had two students enroll to go to a charter
171so that's why that's there um so there's no no General aded class at Bart Barton and kindergarten there is it's at 17 at 17 okay yeah I mean 17 is very different than 26 sure but and keep in mind Barton 2 is also the central so that will now start to take all of the overflows right and that's historically what's happened the last couple of years but B just to give you a a little bit of information has 16 kindergarteners overflowed right now yeah good my turn I'm okay I just want minutes sry I'm not going to go three minutes you're all good um I just want to say thank you to everybody for everything all the administrators that are here thank you for everything that you do every day to make sure the programs
172work the way they're designed to work um without your direction and your leadership um it wouldn't happen and thank you Mr tulan to every single teacher that comes to work every day with the the goal to make a difference in a child's life because that's why they went to school to make a difference in a child's life and to welcome our two new administrators that are going to add to this team and Teresa best of wishes to you and we're looking forward to working with you on a regular basis we'll be talking on the phone quite a bit and remember that um you support the superintendent office as well as the Board of Education and um you're the face of us now so thank you for stepping up to that and uh with that we
173can make a motion for an adjournment okay need a motion motion who was the second I want to stay any opposed none opposed all in favor all all right we are adjourned