CorpusRecord 139266

Board of Education Business Meeting December 16, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Patchogue-Medford Technology
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,069 words · about 45 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone I'd like to call this business meeting of the board of education for December 16th 2024 uh to order everybody please rise for the bud Mr lever would you please go over the safety message and the welcome ground rules sure good evening and welcome to the December 16th 2024 meeting of the Patrick mord Board of Education in the event of emergency please use the emergency exits located at the front and rear of the auditorium to exit the building do not attempt to drive away as you may impede the arrival of emergency services please be advised that smoking and the use of vaping products are prohibited by law on school property when addressing the board during public comment periods each speaker is limited to 3 minutes with no sharing of minutes you'll be warned

002when 30 seconds are left and you'll be asked to conclude after 3 minutes please refrain from discussing specific students or staff members to protect their privacy these matter these matters should be discussed with the appropriate administrator all questions or comments should be addressed to the Board of Education president thank you and have a happy holiday thank you Mr Lea all right we're going to move on to item number six on the agenda presentations and reports I'm going to hand it over to Dr con thank you Mr President it's my pleasure to recognize our December employees of the month going to begin with our CSC chairperson Janine oconnell Janine come on up Janine you can just wait over there on the side Janine this recognition stems from a parent uh communication that came in really recognizing

003um and appreciating Your Enthusiasm and depth of knowledge about special education the parent noted that you were very thoughtful and respectful in your approach and that you took a vested interest in their child's Journey really learning what the child's interests were and incorporating that into the plan moving forward so the parent noted that um you showed demonstrated clear support and helping her child move forward in meaningful ways we appreciate the way you're making you made those meaningful connections with the families and with the students and we're happy to recognize you for employee of the month and you could just wait right there jine next up I'd like to bring up Linda kasic Linda Linda come on up so Linda is retired but Lind really never stopped working for the district she works as a substitute

004in various capacities up at our high school um Linda you received multiple nominations for this unbelievable uh for the unbelievable work ethic that you exhibit on a daily basis your commitment and versatility to fulfill multiple roles uh is greatly appreciated your charisma your positive energy resonate throughout the building you often deliver words of wisdom to support colleagues and you are much loved by the staff and I could truly say that I I see that when I'm up at the high school so you know for all of those things we're very fortunate to have you consistently fulfilling various roles and we're honored to nominate you for employee of the month and finally I'd like to bring up Karen trovich Karen come on up so Karen has been providing home instruction to a traymon student battling leukemia

005the student was not able to enjoy a traditional Halloween and the earlier in the fall with trick or-treating as her peers in order to lift the spirits of this student and provid her with that opportunity Karen visited her in the hospital and created a mock trick or treat setup in her hospital room complete with 24 different buckets with treats talk about making an impact and I have a picture to show if you don't mind Joe if you can pull up that picture of what the hospital room looked like and I have I have permission from the parent to show this picture and if we there you go so really just lifting the spirits of Esther that's Esther and really lifting her spirits Karen going above and beyond I can't thank you enough we can't thank

006you enough for your sincere generosity and the genuine gift that you provided Esther during a time that she didn't get to celebrate with the rest of her peers congratulations on this welld deserved recognition mayor I just want to commend each and every one of these three employees they are uh very special in their own unique way um and we are very fortunate to have each of you on board Linda you retired and and I I used to see and experience all and know your work ethic they broke the mold with you and you being back here just really speaks to your commitment and dedication and um for you Karen I don't know what to say you are one of our exemplary kindergarten teachers you put your heart your soul your energy you're all in to

007everything you do uh but this goes above and beyond and this just speaks to your character um and I'm I'm just we are very blessed to have employees such as you guys and Janine uh awesome congratulations for um employee of the month and all that you do to make uh this District uh Stronger in the area special education congratulations to each and every one of you well deserved I invite up Dr Jones and the board to take a picture with our employees of the month I have a token gift and a certificate of appreciation e good [Applause] yeah I learned how to turn it off by you okay um we're going to move on to item number seven a report by ex official student member Ella mccan [Applause] good evening everyone welcome to the December

00816th Board of Education business meeting I am the student ex official member and I am so happy to be here as always before I start my monthly report I'm proud to share that I've been working with Miss Kennedy on creating a form to encourage feedback from students on the grading policy more on that will come in future meetings however I just wanted to share it with you all that we are making ions towards hearing directly from students across our district via form with that let's see what's been going on in our buildings the past month firstly I was very lucky to take part in one of the two concerts held at the high school which were very successful our district clerk stopped by the Canan Elementary and stumbled across this absolutely adorable setup in the

009kitchen Miss Chrissy senior food service worker at Kanan outdid herself the students were so excited about this in River Elementary kindergarten students received a special visit on November 7th by two veterans the veterans told the students all about the military also kindergarten students celebrated Thanksgiving by having a parade through the school based on the book balloons Over Broadway Oregon Asus students during Buddy's Club wrote letters to seniors in an assisting assisted living home for Thanksgiving they were very appreciative of their letters that they received and it was a fantastic inspir for all involved at Saxton stem students visited the Brooklyn Bridge where they embarked new experiences outside of the Middle School walls great job to all involved above are photos of the newest members of the Oregon Middle School's peer leaders this was an induction

010ceremony that they had with the students parents Dr Cohen and Council Council Man Neil Foley the students all pledged to be a peer leader after they completed a two-day training here are also photos from the ases students that made all of the Oregon faculty a Thanksgiving meal m Mr Lake and Mr Petrino enjoyed the meals with the students this was an interactive and Hands-On activity for all of the students which was highly successful continuing one Oregon Middle School student and two Patrick Medford High School students were honored at the brookh Haven town meeting to congratulate them on winning the Brook Haven town recycling poster contest there are amongst hundreds of entries to be selected for the town recycling campaign this is an incredible AC accomplishment and we would all love to congratulate them Tron has

011also been been very busy this month throughout November they hosted Pat Medford library representatives to celebrate family literacy month representatives from the library completed lessons in each classroom that focused on enhancing our children's experience with the new branch of the Patrick Medford library the representatives also provided ideas for ways to celebrate family literacy month at home children and their families were encouraged to visit the new branch of the library and were given scavenger hunts to be completed completed at the library for prizes currently they are in the midst of their I ready holiday celebration contest plui is up and around the building as an elf encouraging children to go onto I ready and compete for prizes teachers and staff have also participated in a holiday giveback organized by Miss Bruno to provide families in need

012with Christmas presents and enjoyment for this holiday season South Ocean held an unforgettable eighth grade field trip to the LT Michael Murphy and Navy SEAL Museum where the students learned about the meaning of our campus worked collaboratively and had a great day also they held a sixth grade concert with the orchestra band and chorus as well as the seventh and eighth grade with the orchestra band and chorus this was an outstanding night of music that we saw amongst all of our buildings but we just wanted to feature this one in Kanan Elementary they honored students who exemplify positive character traits each month teachers nominate students who display these qualities and the selected students are celebrated during their monthly PTA meetings also there is a celebration of day of code in their Library class to introduce

013students to technology associated with coding and in robotics students demonstrated their abilities to use coding and to operate small robots these robots followed the desired paths that the students developed in each lesson coming from a CTE background their principal was motivated to join in as a group in their activity in honor of November's National family literacy month Eagle Elementary School also organized an interactive program that featured families participating in literacy activities with their children every Monday through Thursday the school selected at random a family who success yly fulfilled their pledge from each grade level to receive and a visit and prizes from the eagle read reading prize control congratulations Eagle teachers and Mrs Guzman met with bilingual parents to discuss supports and resources for working with their children at home in order to build a

014stronger school and Home Connection the next meeting will be Saturday January 11th 2025 at 10:30 a.m. at the Medford library also Eagle participated in a fun interactive assembly celebrating dance and music their teachers rocked it and went viral on zand's social media with over 20,000 views of their awesome moves the teachers participated in a fun and interactive embly and they they celebrated all of their moves they rocked it so what an incredible month and I wish everyone the happiest of holidays and a great start to the new year thank [Applause] you thank you Ella for that comprehensive report okay we're going to move on to item number eight and I'm going to hand it over to Mr Lea we are open now for public comments on reports and agenda items please be reminded that you

015are limited to three minutes with no sharing of minutes hey good evening my name is Kyle roderman um my wife and I prepared a statement together and I'm hoping that I can read the first half within the first three minutes and she can follow up before you go I just want to ask is this in relation to the items that have been presented and are what's on the consent agenda at this point yes yeah yes that would be addressed the next part of public comments at the end of absolutely but it's not part of this part of the okay sure thank you no problem thank you okay if there are no other comments we'll move on to number nine uh consent agenda so we need a motion to accept the consent agenda second all in

016favor I I opposed any abstentions consent agenda is passed thank you everyone okay we're going to move on to item number 10 that's on page 12 there were no items removed from the consent agenda for separate vote moving on to number 11 informational items we have a first policy reading of number 2410 table of administrative organization and B Poli have a second reading that would be 61456 attendance deportment and academic eligibility for participation and extracurricular activities number 12 there were no actions arising out of executive session and then moving on to item 13 the superintendent's report Dr Jones Thank you Mr President and good evening to all um my report is very brief this evening I just wanted to uh make the board aware that um as you all know the Rockefeller Institute report was

017released at the beginning of the month it is a 314 page document uh that essentially um the legislators had directed as part of negoti iations for last year's budget agreement with the governor that uh organization be tasked with reviewing the foundation Aid formulas as they believe they were Antiquated so it's a 314 page document that essentially makes recommendations to the legislators as to how the formula can be updated in order to better distribute state aid and to improve the formulas and there's a lot of recommendations in the report I have been reviewing it very carefully in order to understand how this could potentially affect our school district there are some things in the report that are at this point recommendations we don't know which ones the legislators will take up but it's better that we're

018fully prepared to understand how this could potentially affect our district so we can plan accordingly I will continue to review and unpack this report and as we enter the season of budgeting you will hear more about this and we will be providing a a summary of the things that we think could affect us how they would affect us so that we're very well informed about the Rockefeller Institute and what it entails so more to come come other than that I wish to extend my best wishes to all in attendance um uh at this meeting this evening for a wonderful joyful peaceful holiday getting some rest well deserved rest and uh looking forward to a happy healthy and productive new year thank you thank you Dr Jones okay we're going to move on to item 14

019uh discussion topics and we have brought forth for tonight's meeting so we're going to move on to item 15 which is committee reports uh there was the the yeah oh you want to bring them up now for discussion thought save for the community comments I thought that was but we can okay that's going to be after my apologies I thought you missed it I I didn't forget my apologies it's all good I just want to make sure well we didn't forget gotcha okay so we're going to go to commit reports so I'm going to start with buildings and operations that's trustee creger you're going to have to come back to me because I'm having technical difficulties not a problem you let me know when you're ready okay all right next will be um Finance which

020is a Mr trusty dinael so we have our tentative as I said in the last meeting our tentative date is set now for January 16th uh 6:30 at the high school room 214 and an agenda will go out to the uh the committee uh as soon as Frank's back from being out so uh he should be back hopefully in a week and we'll be able to uh send out the agenda but again the things that Dr Joan talk talked about are some of the items that are on the agenda because those are critical to the overall Finance of the district thank you trusty dinar for you okay up next is um districtwide technology which is my department um technology has not had a meeting in the month of December because we had one late in

021November but we're very excited to announce that today the district launched its redesigned [Applause] website uh the redesign was Guided by feedback from parents teachers staff and students the goal was to create a streamlined and userfriendly experience that focuses on most frequently used areas the stream light design was based on a cleaner less is more type of theme um to approach and simplify the na navigation through the website next is an updated calendar which is enhanced filtering options to narrow selections including team athletic specific schedules there's also contact information which is easier to access um to key contacts through across the district but I'll you can always reach out to Miss Mrs deiva for any information that you may need on contact and there have been many other upgrades features um and informational links and

022tabs added to the website it's very very very comprehensive um I'd also like to add based on the fact that this is technology and it is my committee um we also added a detailed text copy description and a video explanation section discussing the board committees so from now on you you can go on to the website see the board committees the minutes what's going on what's coming up next when the next appointment is um as well as um just to give you an example of how that works okay real simple so you go on to the uh the Board of Education website I'm I'm sorry the district website then you go to the Board of Education tab when you get there you're going to click on board of education then the next screen you'll come

023up and you'll click the red bar and it say in this section okay then you would click on board committees and then next you do there be an introduction to each committee and then a text and video comprehensive statement about what each committee does as well as how um what the initiatives are that's in in conjunction with adding minutes and the uh when the meetings are and so on and so forth so this is a really really big um addition to the website and it was very I did it today as soon as the um the website was launched I went on Bing Bang Boom it took less than 30 seconds to get to where I wanted to go so it's really really comprehensive and it worked so thank you very much to the technology

024department and Mr richworth and his whole team um so these these updates make it easier for you to find information you need to enhance communication across the district um hopefully we'll get some more feedback um people that are using it can let us know what they think if there's anything else we're very open to that conversation okay and with that our next meeting is going to be February 5th in the South Ocean conference room at 4:30 p.m. how you doing Daniel trusty kriger all right so I'll move on no problem okay so now we're going to go to extracurricular program which is going to be both trusty Jennings and vice president Andrade um we haven't had a meeting yet um and December meeting was cancelled so our next meeting is January 8th at 5:15 thank

025you ladies okay um next is instructional instructional and student support programs which is going to be uh Franc uh trusty Salazar uh really there nothing to report since since our last Board of Education meeting we have not had a meeting since but we will be having one in January the date I don't have I was looking for it do we have that one off the top I was looking for I didn't see moving on okay the last committee um January what 9th 9th there we go January 9th we will be meeting uh South Ocean Middle School uh was 12 was it 4:30 yeah no I know 4:30 I was trying to get the room in the in the conference room thank you yes in the conference room that's the room thank you trusty Salazar no

026anytime okay moving on to legislation and that would be truste Smith um uh legislation did not meet um because our meeting was going to be basically within a day of the releasing of the Rockefeller report and there was a lot of information to come in that we needed to uh distill so we sent the information to our committee members and our next meeting will be um uh the first week in in January and trusty Sal and are and I having a spectacular job for getting dates Dr Cohen do you remember when our meeting is what's that first day we come back first day we come back great and it'll be a zoom meeting thank you thank you trusty Smith trusty creger okay I'm doing this memory and our of the um we did not discuss

027a next meeting because we are January February we're skip because we'll be right in the of budget season and we'll have a buch of budget meeting so we're take a break that thank you trusty ker Sor okay we're going to move on to item number 16 so I'm going to hand it back over to Mrs deiva to go over the ground rules okay this is the time for public comments you're limited to 3 minutes you'll be notified at when you have 30 seconds left no sharing of minutes please address all comments to the board president all right um my wife and I Elizabeth are here so uh we want I'm sorry again to interrupt up before you start just state your name and your address Kyle roderman uh to Gail Lane in he batog um

028Elizabeth roderman um so we here to express our concerns regarding the district's grading policy and the uh newly implemented Ela curriculum um while these initiatives may have appeared promising on paper we feel their real world implementation has revealed some unintended challenges um we want to share our sons experience to shed light on these issues and propose a shift toward uh better supporting the students individual needs I understand that the district's grading policy was designed with good intentions uh aiming to create Equitable opportunities particularly for students are disadvantaged however uh we believe the curriculum the current approach is too generalized and does not prioritize the differentiation of instruction um which is essential for addressing the unique needs of all students my son uh Shay who's here tonight is a seventh grader at Saxon middle school and

029while he's a strong and diligent student he does struggle with or organization time management and test anxiety despite these challenges he works hard to stay engaged and produce quality work his report card and progress report comments reflect his dedication um we've been told he demonstrates positive qualities is cooperative and well-mannered meeting grade level expectations produces excellent work demonstrates excellent classroom habits and is a positive addition to the classroom environment um he also made the honor roll this this period so we're proud of him for that um but as you can see our son consistently contributes to class and completes his assignments his classwork grades are typically 100 and he rarely misses a homework assignment however despite this strong effort he has consistently struggled on tests often failing due to anxiety um difficulty focusing and poor

030time management the disconnect between his efforts and test performance has negatively impacted his grades the district's current grading policy which heavily emphasizes test scores does not accommodate students like my son who may understand a material but struggles in a test taking environment after speaking with his teachers and regularly supporting him with homework and study sessions we're confident in his understanding of the content however the grading system does not always reflect his understanding and the weight placed on tests undermines his academic confidence it also reinforces a damaging belief that his test scores Define intelligence when in reality effort and understanding are equally important previously teachers had the discretion to allow test corrections giving the students opportunity to reinforce their learning and reward effort this practice was beneficial for students who demonstrated consistent work but struggled on

031tests I understand seconds I understand the importance of holding students accountable but I also believe we should trust our teachers who are highly trained professionals and know their students to make decisions that's best support their learning rather than imposing one siiz fits-all policies that limit their ability to differentiate instruction while equality and Grading policies may sound fair does not necessarily equate to equity Equity ensures that each student receives the support they need to succeed which often requires individualized attention unfortunately the current grading policy fails to account for these differences my wife is going to follow up with the second half thank you for your time thank you Mr roderman good evening my name is Elizabeth roderman um I also have concerns about the new Ela program savis uh my son is in seventh grade so

032that's the ELA program they're working on this year um the district introduced this program with the goal of uh improving state test scores but after reviewing the content I believe that it's not appropriately tored for students grade level expectations uh the reading passages and questions are often too challenging leaving students struggling to keep up for example my son and many other students have been working on a unit for over a month only to receive a 50 on the unit test does this mean that even a high- performing student is only expected to grasp half of the material well I appreciate the administration's decision not to count the first unit test due to its unfair difficulty the subsequent quiz was equally challenging and unreasonable at parent teacher conferences I had the opportunity to ask questions about

033savis and I found out that all reading is being taught through these online passages and that there's not really time uh for novel units I'd like to point out that teaching a child to read means teaching them to think deeply deep thought is provoked when a student is interested in what they're reading uh this is not the level of Engagement that we will see with these articles uh we might create better test takers but it does not equate to better readers um I urge you to consider revising both the grading policy and the curriculum to better support the diverse needs of all students uh this might include re-evaluating the emphasis on test scores and giving teachers the flexibility to implement differentiated strategies based on individual student needs um I'd also like if you could reassess

034the reading program uh to ensure that it's aligned with grade level expectations and truly help students improve their skills uh I do appreciate your time and consideration I do understand that there were committees put together um to discuss both both of these topics um the last time we were here we were told we should join a committee and while I know that uh our input would be very helpful we are contributing to our community in other ways like uh running Girl Scout Troops and holding band practice and uh coaching wrestling and you know the as parents just because we're not here doesn't mean that we're not involved and that we don't care so I I appreciate the committee's work but I hope that you can take our experience into consideration thank you very much for

035sharing that Mrs rman hi good evening I'm Christine oo 57 MS Drive good evening members of the board Administration and Community my name is Christine oo and I'm here tonight as a deeply concerned parent and as an educator with a broad perspect perspective I'm a proud Pat Med Alum I serve as a 22-year veteran teacher with an administrative certification teachers union vice president and instructional coach in a neighboring School District these roles provide me with an insight into how policies shape the experiences of both students and Educators I'm here to address the new grading policy which while undoubtedly well-intentioned is being implemented without the necessary systems and structures to support it policy implementation as you know is not merely about making a decision it is about ensuring the conditions are right for that decision to

036succeed leadership principles emphasize the importance of creating systems that align with organizational goals and ensure the importance of creating systems that align with the Readiness for this change when policies are introduced without adequate preparation or stakeholder involvement they often cause unintended harm and this seems to be exactly what we are seeing here in PetMed the phrase building the plane while flying it seems to come to mind it is an apt metaphor for what we are experiencing implementing a major change like this grading policy without the proper systems in place has resulted in confusion inconsistency and frustration among Educators parents and most importantly our students and our children this is not a criticism of the intent behind the policy but rather a call for better planning and execution effective implementation requires several critical steps first the

037clear communication policies need to be fully explained to all the stakeholders teachers parents and students must understand not only what is changing but also why this critical change was necessary and how it aligns to our Collective goals as a district in this case many parents and I'm sure some teachers feel left in the dark for example we attended the Saxon open house and we listened intently to all of our child's teachers not one of the presentations mentioned that alternate day full year courses would not be given scores for quarters 1 through three not one so we were surprised when just days before report cards were released to find out that we were not going to see grades for those courses the second critical step that seems to have been missed is the professional development and

038training teachers are the ones who are implementing this policy and they need thorough training and resources to apply this change effectively without this the policy can become burdensome and rather than a tool for improvement in my own District when we revised our grading policy we spent over a year building teacher capacity prior to this rollout here it seems that this critical step was overlooked it is for this reason so many parents are complaining about teachers creating Summit of Assessments with three questions three questions on a summit of assessment that seems a little ridiculous there's inconsistency in allocation of similar tasks to different categories which seems to have harmed some students averages clearly teachers are not adequately trained on the implementation of this policy which leads me to my last point the lack of the support

039system when systems are not in place to address these changes chaos ensues for instance if the policy aims to create Equity by reducing inconsistencies in teaching assessment practices what systems have been provided for addressing these resulting workload increase so now I'm going to yield to my husband thank you for sharing your thoughts and concerns G oero 57 Matson Drive Benford um good evening members of the board Administration and Community my name is gaso and as my wife stated I too am an educator I've taught Global and US history as well as many elective courses at hunington High School for the past 17 years I've taught these courses in both English and Spanish so I am no stranger to the needs of a diverse population of Learners like we have here at patmed which is why

040I'm here to speak on the topic of the grading policy the repercussions of implementing this grading policy prematurely are already evident teachers are struggling to manage the new expectations leading to inconsistent applications and inappropriate assessment of students the exact opposite intention of the plan 's creation parents like myself are frustrated by these unintended results and unclear communication eroding trust in the system and most importantly students are caught in the middle with some feeling less accountable for their work and others receiving mixed messages about expectations or Worse their own self-image as students our son who is a high achieving student and takes his grades very seriously asked us to convey this sentiment he said it makes me feel like I did all that work for nothing in the first quarter I worked really hard and I

041know I have good grades in those classes but now it doesn't say that on my report card so it doesn't even count now our son doesn't need you know 100 on in his course of financial management or Bann it won't change his GPA significantly but what about a student who needs that 100 to boost that GPA what about the creative child who's art class is always his high or her his or her highest grade and now that alternate day class isn't going to show up on the report card why because their art teacher is one cumulative assessment short this quarter we urge this board to pause and reflect on the principles of effective leadership as stated by Michael fulan as he States effective change is not imposed it is embraced when stakeholders are part of

042the process let's take the time to involve all voices teachers parents students and administrators to refine this policy and first build the systems needed for it its success let's start by allowing our Educators to create the common assessments needed for them to assess students before we mandate that they do so we owe it to our students to get this right educational policies should never feel like experiments they should feel uh you know and be well planned Frameworks that provide Clarity and consistency we are asking for a commitment to review this policy and ensure it is supported by the systems our students and Educators deserve thank you for your time and we appreciate your dedication to the success of our students and children thanks thank you Mr oo all I'd like to share based on the

043uh conversation and the concerns by the par par the rans and the OS that we're going to take this under advisement we will have a conversation and discussion and we'll report out in January okay thank you yeah absolutely go ahead I'm sorry thank you for all the comments I appreciate the feedback from the community just wanted to point out that uh we did have a committee this policy was uh a 2-year policy that was worked on through our instructional committee so um that consists of community members teachers administrators and students sat on that committee so the policy was in development for two uh years before it actually went to the board for readings in terms of feedback from teachers I work very closely with Mr Tulin our president of the Union uh we sent out

044multiple surveys to all of our teachers regarding each area of the policy asking for feedback regarding the percentages on the formative and informative we ask for feedback on test corrections we ask for feedback on extra help all of those surveys were reviewed by the committee and obviously changes were made even when we got those surveys from what we initially put in um as uh Ella has indicated we also are now in the process of putting a survey out to our students and I have been examining data to look at the uh student failure rates this year versus in years prior and looking at any differences in actual GPA scores so I want you to know that we are constantly looking at a policy to see if there are any changes that need to be put

045forward I will say in terms of uh differentiation we support differentiation and that has to come from classroom instruction we have to be very careful uh about giving students different exams when we're assessing them on a report card so that is one thing that we we do support differentiation in the delivery of how we work with our students but when students are giving an assessment the entire class should be given the same assessments extra credit uh is allowed and I think that's something that I want to be very specific and I've said this at multiple board meetings that is up to the teachers the policy does not say extra credit uh test corrections are not permitted we are very specific in that policy but it does have to be agreed upon so all students in

046a scho School within a course have the same opportunity for extra credit so I'm happy to report out in a larger Forum some of the concerns brought forth but I think it is important to know um as a community that this was not just a policy that was created in isolation this was a policy many um surveys and it actually was a 2year commitment that we made for revising our grading policy thank you Mrs kenned because allow if it's allowed to everyone but an Ela teacher in sou ocean can't take care of her responsibilities and also communicate ELA teachers in oron and ass to make sure that everyone's the same thing so by having this broad sweeping pool it's very difficult for them to respond individual child they don't have the ability to make sure

047that everything isable so they just follow the policy a thank you for that I on the committee if I can share with you there was a lot of discussion specifically from the parents who sat on our committee about the three middle schools and many of the parents add really specifically that they felt that it was a must that all three middle schools should be be consistent that a child up at Oregon and a child in Saxon and a child in South Ocean there was huge discrepancies in how teachers were grading amongst the three middle schools We Are One district there is many opportunities for our teachers to collaborate we have faculty meetings monthly we have department meetings each year they have a professional Learning Community period every day right but they they they have common

048professional learning communities within their Department every day so if at the end of an assessment we are debriefing on how students performed on an assessment that can be immediate it can be immediate because we built that in on professional I would say that this year and I would have to go back to look at the PLC schedule and I will say that this year we try to make a commitment that English teachers in Saxton have the same PLC periods as English teachers and I see uh Dr Kelly CU that was something that our building principles worked on because we knew we had a new program this year and it was our first year that was a priority for us so second period English teachers professional Learning Community period is the same period across all three

049middle schools we specifically asked our APS to build that um and it was challenging but we were very committed to the new roll out and we wanted our teachers to be able to collaborate it we wanted our directors to be able to zoom in and be able to speak to the teachers at the same time so again I acknowledge and I appreciate our Community coming out and sharing some of their concerns I took a lot of notes here and I look forward to you know sharing some additional information with you at Future meetings thank you Mrs Ked and I don't to Beed I'm sorry passionate but it's because I'm passion about education and my children and it it isn't a reflection on how I feel about anything personally um I don't I I do understand

050the desire for everybody to have equal opportunity but not before we consider individual needs because my child's teacher shouldn't have to ask permission from all of the other teachers across the district in their Department if they can modify something to meet my child's need they're all professionals we trust them we are very happy on the most part with everything that we've experienced in this district and and the teachers need to have some autonomy to be able to meet the students where they're at re re we will report out in January uh we are taking seriously under advisement all of the things that you have shared this evening and we will further report out in January thank you any other comments okay thank you again for your thoughts and concerns okay we're going to move on

051to um item number 17 which are board comments so I'll start down at the end of the day is Trusty salar yeah um I want to thank Community for coming out and speaking their mind and letting us know how they feel about what's going on and we do take this very very seriously uh I do want to assure you that I I am in the uh instructional committee and we it is a to I of conversation that we are going through and we reviewing it and any type anytime you're putting in a new policy there are bumps that need to be Iron there are things we need to examine and you know we are we are looking at and we are taking it very seriously you know so I don't want anybody to think that

052this is something we brush off um so I do want to thank everybody for coming out and letting us know what's going on uh I would also like to um you know wish everybody here and along on the de and in the crowd a very happy holidays um I want to uh take take time out you know spend their families enjoy it and uh enjoy the break and we'll see you guys um next year thank you thank you trusty Salazar truste kriger okay I just the same thing I wanted to say thank you for coming out it is good to hear the voices of everybody in the community quite a few of us are parents as well so we hear it so we know what you guys are thinking and hearing and we bring it

053back and it is discussed um I just wanted to give a little bit of a shout out to uh the high school for their Spanish Theater Company production which was great um and I'm working on my Spanish right now but I did understand what was going on and it was a fantastic production um and then also the concerts I went to quite a few Middle School concerts and the High School concerts and it's always amazing to see the difference between the Middle School 6 and then the 7th eth and then the high school and I can't wait to see The Littles in January so um happy holidays to everybody hope everybody enjoys the break with your family and your friends and we all come back refreshed thank you trusty creger trusty Smith I will be

054brief happy holidays um and and thank you for coming out and that's nerve-wracking that microphone I get it thank you for taking the time and the effort to to do that because it's important that we we we we do take these comments very very seriously um and and thank you for offering your words um and uh happy holidays and you did excellently in your concert I saw your special appearance in the concert and in your Saxton night a little rockar thank you trusty Smith trusty denel sure again we all appreciate you coming out and and giving us the feedback I know Mrs Kennedy appreciates that and as Mr salers are said you know this isn't just like a knee-jerk reaction hey let's throw this policy out there they spent a lot of time on it

055and it's understandable that you know maybe not every part of it is going to be worked out 100% but you can see how certain aspects of it they are thinking about it they're saying we we have to we have to have a cohesive Department view when you're talking about that I looked over toward Dr Jones and we're like saying it's department-based it's not school-based so but those things may not from a procedural or functional aspect work be working 100% you know at this point um and I appreciate you're saying unintentional because certainly that is true nobody here is trying to do anything to hurt any student uh the board spent a considerable amount of time with the review of the of the policy and Mrs Kennedy did an outstanding job of presenting options of different

056ways of doing it and how the way that we were looking at it would actually benefit more students than not but the other aspect you're talking about is what I call authentic learning and I think that's the hardest part of any large education system um I don't consider myself to be a teacher in the sense of a professional teacher I am a trainer I do do training for for my business um but one of the things that I strive for is nobody leaves that room until they understand exactly what we're talking about and that's hard when you're dealing with a group of students who all may or may not be learning at exactly the same rate and I think that's part of what you're talking about here from student to student and yeah we do

057need to have systems that allow us to say I want every student to go from you know section one to section two and they understand everything in section one before we get to section to and that doesn't always happen in many cases student goes on they go to the next section they don't quite understand everything that happen in section one now they're in section two and that that kind of wave effect that cumulative effect means that when they get to section six there's a lot of pieces of sections 1 2 3 4 5 that they didn't quite understand um and it's definitely something that I know we all strive for not saying that we just like you know throw it out and don't care about it but it is hard and as Educators that we

058have out there you understand that you know you have students that you know maybe needs to come for extra help because they're not quite getting it and I'm sure you offer that and you're sure you work with them and those are some of the things that I mean our teachers do the same our teachers have those periods where they can you know have students come in and as a community we all work on that I know again as parents we made sure that if our child wasn't you know meeting a criteria or if they got a test and they didn't do well the first thing was go get extra help on that you know and don't don't just go past that and not understand it so those are a lot of the things that we

059need to again focus on you know I'm not big about grading uh it's it's not a contest although it is a contest and I always found that to be one of the problems in in our system everybody gets a grade you know somebody is going to be number one do I really care if somebody's number one or somebody's number 250 or number 650 I what's more important is that what they took from this education system and I know was Pat medrad you know moving on in your life and being able to be you know functional adults and and have a prosperous life uh is important and hopefully we've given our students all of that so that they can move on I know when I gave my president speech at graduation I said that you know

060we're going to have successful students not not just the doctor or the lawyer but you know the husband or the wife who's a homemaker who raises their children you know I mean all those things are just so important um so you know back to the testing I know we'll look at it I know we'll make it better I appreciate as you say you can't be involved in everything you're involved in other things and that's great because we need people involved in those things as well oh absolutely that's why you're here that's why you're not sitting at home tonight and not you know participating in this and we need more of that and I know this board has sat up here and said that over and over again we so appreciate it when the community comes

061out and when the community doesn't come out what do you think we think oh everything's okay well that even doesn't care but everything's okay there's no problem you know but we do need to hear that and the administration takes that to heart they don't just think oh you know and look if nobody said anything Mrs Kennedy would think hey my system is perfect don't worry about it so we really appreciate it thank you very much for coming out thank you everybody who came out tonight again ditto everybody have a great holiday hopefully you know get some time with your your children with your family and uh we'll get rolling in uh 2025 thank you trusty dinar I'm going to say one last thing and for what it's worth everybody up here started doing stuff that

062you're doing say trusty Jennings yeah I just want to say um thank you for coming out and hearing your concerns um because I know what the struggle is like as a parent of a high schooler for this quarter so I know it's something that we have brought our concerns and definitely it's a working document that we're constantly working on um just really quickly um back to at my Bose's meeting we talked about what's coming up as the science of reading and the science of teaching so now we're now looking to the best practices of prek to three um to support so next fall sorry Dr Jones all superintendants will have to have an acation form to focus on the literacy that will align to the standards and the science of reading and there'll be s

063seven bulletins which are fny Mech awareness phonics fluency vocabulary comprehension print print concepts and background knowledge so that would be next fall and then on top of the regionalization update um commissioner Rosa did send out that clarification letter that was due into um Regent Tillis who to told her to make it more so that more parents and Educators and board of EDS would um be able to understand it more the frequently asked questions will be updated and then bosies will have a formal conven of all who have submitted the survey um in sometime in January thank you trusty Andra okay yeah thank you to all who came out um I just have we don't have to answer the question but maybe just was wondering when the survey will go out to the students that you're

064working on with Ella and if it could possibly be ready by the our next so the survey is created uh we we have all the questions uh we made a few revisions last time and we're sending it out once we get back from vacation it was just a very busy time and due to my absence I wanted to make sure a thorough letter went out to the uh teachers and we had one of the things Ellen and I spoke about is the survey is only as good as the students who take it and we had many conversations that sometimes we give a survey to students and they don't take it right so we're not getting great responses so we talked about you know different ways that we could maybe really make sure the students are

065taking it and make sure it happens at a specific period during the day or in a specific class that it's you know coming from me that it is a requirement that the students answer it to the best of their ability I am also working with Mr Tulin and we will be creating a similar survey for our staff members uh I did just want to point out one thing I'm not sure one of the community members did mention the ad day bday courses I I did write a letter to the community at the very beginning of the year it was a letter from me that went out to all the community members about the a day bday courses and I know you get a lot of information at the beginning of the year but it did

066go out on a parent square and I specifically explained to the parents what was happening with the uh ADB day full year courses thank you Mrs Kennedy really quickly about parents square is there any way to really emphasize that important stuff because I feel like parents square is great but a lot of the important information gets lost and I'm saying not even as a parent like I'll say that for me I know the ring day happened this week and I was like we didn't know anything about it because it comes in the beginning of the week and then it's like gone and then you're like scrolling through so I'm talking about the ring day like ring flyer cuz hold debacle with that but it it's it's like on parent Square and then it gets lost

067and then you have to like find it so is there a way to like something like that to be a highlighted thing that you know it could be easier one of the things we can do is something that is applicable to more than one school that has a level of District level importance can come out from either Mrs connetti or myself I often send out messages that go District wide and they typically are well reviewed so maybe we can send things out and then it can be reinforced at the building level so that it's more than one time that is received this might be a technology question but is there a way to differentiate within the app that this kind of information is that color and this kind of information is that color which might

068help the parents with the that's is a scheduling thing and that's blue and I I think that could get challenging if you have more than one child because if you have more than one child the colors may lose their meaning depending on what gray level what color is reflective of what you you are you saying I just want to make sure I understand high alert oh you could do that that for sure but also like anything that has to do with a calendar issue would be xolor anything that is an important information from the superintendent's office is that color I could also work to make sure um if if there is a letter um again I could make sure nothing else gets sent out on parent square that day um other than my letter right

069we can make it a priority like today unless you have anything that's the only thing that goes out so it's only one thing the parents are looking at rather than maybe multiple items on parent Square so I can certainly work with James to see if that's an option if something is coming from me that I need to make sure that the the parents are reading it that we limit anything else on parents Square do that we just have to that might be a better uh just another option to consider we can definitely do that we've done it before continue continue sorry okay um teacher survey Anonymous all the surveys are Anonymous even the student survey okay great um okay and I just I don't know if this is a question or a statement but I

070know when my boys I think both of them when they were in middle school they definitely read three to four novels and I really do hope that between sorry I don't know what's happen we do novels and I just want to point that out novels are built in we actually did curriculum work because there are some novels that are excerpts from um in savis that are actually the novels we read so it's a natural match so to say we are we are doing novels I want to make sure that the okay so I think we just need to speak offline because I would like to know what what teacher is telling you that because we have a very strict uh curriculum that we wrote over the summer and novels are included in that so I

071don't think this is the Forum to to speak about that but I'd love the opportunity to know what specific teacher told you that information that would be very helpful so I I I'd like to know you know again personally who who share that with you cuz that's sharing false information to the community and we have to be a little careful of that so I'll speak to you up going to point the finger at the teacher she's trying the best she can to I understand that but by by saying we don't read novels is not accurate when novels are built into our curriculum I would have to look up the scope and sequence uh which I was trying to pull up right now but we have multiple novels that were changed over the summer y absolutely

072and then if we could just share that information with us we can share it absolutely appreciate that Mrs ketti perhaps as part of the presentation for January weekend but I I do think an offline conversation would be helpful um because I know that novels are definitely a requirement in the scope and sequ sequence so we want to make sure we understand where the disconnect is thank you okay and the just the last thing that I wanted to say about Ela and savis and I don't know if they're still I ready doing for me you know it's always been important that we we have those novels and we're not doing all the reading online so I don't know really what it looks like right now so maybe like I said sharing a little report of what

073it looks like in a day of how you know how the program how are we balancing the online reading compared to the hands in the book reading I would be very curious to have that information the board we we did actually add time cuz we went to uh a double uh Ela block to add more time to offer our uh English teachers the opportunity to cover more so we actually have a period and a half of ela uh this school year yep thank you the double the the period and the half that's six seventh and e or just sixth and seventh sixth period has a double period every day seventh has a period and a half eighth grade still has one period and the high school all the classes are a single period I got

074you okay okay and everyone happy holidays okay I just wanted to share that on behalf of the board and the administration that everything we do is to maximize student outcomes and their ability to achieve at the highest level so the fact that you brought your concerns to us tonight shows that there's Community engagement we need as much of that as possible so we can continue to move forward um like I said earlier we'll have the conversation and Mr Kennedy already said that she would report out in January so we'll move forward with that but most importantly having the community here sharing their thoughts is what makes change so if you think that there's something that you need to bring bring it and we're here to listen that's why we're here okay so obviously you can't

075can't change everything in one day but we have to start somewhere and you brought it here tonight and we started the process and again Mr kenned will share it in January um I want to U reiterate what everybody said about the holiday concerts at the middle schools and the high school they were outstanding you know listening to the high school play um in all their different capacities is like going to Broadway it's an amazing thing and if you haven't acknowledged it or seen it because you don't have a child in the high school you should go it's an amazing um time um as far as the holidays are concerned we're here we wish you all a very healthy and happy New Year and enjoy the holidays with your family and to ensure that the time

076you spend with your family is is maximized to its highest level because it only comes once so thank you for all that okay all right so with that I need a motion to adjourn I'll second it who's Diana and bernardet all in favor I thank you enjoy

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.