001All right. So we just need a motion to come out of executive session 701. And I'll second that. All in favor? Aye. Motion carries. Then just a motion to reconvene the public session at 701 as well. Make the motion to stand second. Second. From Stephanie, all in favor? Aye. Aye. Motion carries. We will stand for the pledge of the black. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. We will go right into our agenda and Mrs. Smith is going to tell you about new policy. All right, exciting new policy for first read for us tonight. This policy is a policy that addresses the artificial intelligence and the use of in the district.
002So we know it's here. It's already all around us and probably in our pockets as well. It's in current systems that we're using, such as Microsoft Copilot. And so being proactive about how can we leverage and use appropriate AI to increase student outcomes to help. production across the district to leverage work that staff is doing, but do it responsibly. And so how do we teach our staff about these tools and how to best use these tools to move the needle with and for kids, as well as how do we teach our kids to use these tools responsibly because many of our kids are probably using them much more than we are already. And then how do we do that maintaining academic integrity and ensuring that the applicable laws, regulations, policies are being upheld. So with
003that, here's our sample policy. Jeff, Patrick, and I met with our Director of Technology, Matt McCall, as well as Chris Klester, who is our Director of Data Security and CIO, and I'm missing something in his title, but he really assists with ensuring that the tools that we're using are compliant, especially when it's pertaining to the personal... personal identifiable information. And we met with Bill Greeter, NTUT president, as well as with Brett Sommer, and had a roundtable conversation about this drafted policy, did some wordsmithing, talking about trends that we're seeing and really how to support everybody again and appropriately using the technology that meets what our standards would be. So the overview speaks for itself. It's here. teach folks how to use it responsibly. The scope of application, you can see there that it applies to
004everybody, including our contractors. And then there's the two definitions, and those are important because there's traditional AI that's been around for a long time that's based on algorithms. And then there's the generative AI, which is creating new things based on information that is there. The bottom of the first page outlines three risks and limitations, which again helps to educate folks because there are risks with AI on what those might be and things that we should be aware of, especially in the world of education. And so the first is the generation of false information, whether that be printed or pictures, videos, infographics. The second. It's the reminder on bias that may be generated based on AI because as some AI tools start to learn certain preferences, then what it's spitting out may lean toward those preferences,
005creating bias. So some warnings in there. so that folks are aware. And then copyright, making sure that anytime we're using these tools that we are abiding by copyright. And then also then too, we need to teach our kids how to do that as well. The second chunk on page two speaks explicitly about the privacy, security, and copyright. So it does pull out specific state and federal laws and policies by name. So FERPA, Ed Law 2D, Labor Law, State Tech Law, but is not limited to data protected. So those are the main, but we don't want to be limited by only those four. The third page has a couple of paragraphs about the student use and then the district personnel use. So again, it's giving our teachers the allowance, the latitude to be able to use
006generative AI, but then also the expectation that They are responsible for instructing students on how to appropriately use the tools that are approved, as well as discussing the appropriate and responsible use with our students on how to be using those responsibly. The district personnel use, same. But in the end, ultimately, that person... I am responsible for the product. And so I need to be vetting it and also that it wouldn't any final review or decision making the judgment piece is on us as the employees and contractors, not allowing generative AI to make that decision for us. The last chunk on page three, the training awareness and support, Patrick was sharing at our meeting last week that both BOCES have offerings on using AI in the classroom. And so we have offerings out to our teachers.
007And then, of course, as we continue to learn the new tools that are out there and how they'll enhance our work with kiddos, how we can offer even more so that our staff is prepared to be able to utilize it and help kids to best utilize it. And then the last page on the back is another reminder again that when using, we must comply with all applicable laws, both federal, state, regulations, policy, and that those documents include but are not limited to the district policies in our Code of Conduct. Any questions? Did this... From BOCES or did it came from BOCES and NSBA? Okay. Yes, BOCES and NSBA. And then the Office of Technology at the federal level. released in like 45 pages, as always, right? But in the fall of 24, but it really
008does move through risks and limitations, but it also moves through how AI can really be used to leverage the work that we're doing with our students. And so there's a lot of helpful tools in there that we'll have to get into the hands of our peer coordinators. A lot of the resources we're already using are starting to embed this right within the resource. Jeff and I saw with ThoughtExchange, absolutely amazing in the last eight, nine months, what they have built up with their AI. I was blown away with what they can give us and how accurate it was. And I don't think this should go in the policy. I guess I'm just curious, but do we... Like, is there a thought that maybe when we're starting to teach students about like research, right, like they
009go to the library or they get on their computers or whatever, they have tablets, right? Like whatever, whenever we start to teach them about researching. Is there a thought that maybe we introduce AI at that point, right? Like, is there sort of a generic presentation the district could put together that teachers could maybe tailor to their subject, to their research project? Yeah, that's a thought on can we develop something on how to utilize the tools for the purpose of research? I'm sure. between like our peer coordinators and determining when is that yeah when is that introduction point when is it and it's probably different at nti versus the middle school versus the high school right like research is a little different as you get older but i'm just thinking like like if they're going to
010start to use this if they're going to start to like if they're starting to use this and maybe like, oh, wow, it can spit out information about this subject. Or I know like when I went to the leadership conference over the summer, they were talking about putting in rubrics versus like what the student wrote and having AI help compare your essay to the rubric or the prompt. And so just like, it just seems like those are maybe the times to start introducing sort of like. Like as we're talking about other types of computer literacy or researching. Absolutely. And then vetting it. How do you know what it spit out is accurate? We had teachers on our committee that we were all talking about this. And certainly some of our high school teachers are already doing
011this work. So bringing it to the other levels as well. The kid copies and pastes from ChatGPT and it says like ChatGPT on the logo. Yeah. The link's getting a new TM tag. It says ChatGPT now. I guess from a approved, obviously we have all the components of what it has to be approved by. Do we have a list for them of, I'm assuming Copilot's probably the go-to with it? I love Copilot. But I don't know. It's amazing. We'll have that ready to go for. A lot of that, we end up getting filtered. So it's not wide open in our district to be using this. So I think people, you know, obviously they can go to their phone, go to other places to use it. Where the AI is easily used is, for example, ThoughtExchange.
012Now, we use that, you know, how many times a year, but it's built right into the software now. It's there, whether you use it or not, it's there. Co-pilot, even if you go to it. on our surface and this and that, I notice that most of it will not even work. We've got, we're pretty. Brett Summer mentioned one that he uses. So it's a short list of approved and actually accessible right now. I know that Matt McCall has our software committee and they're constantly looking at all new software and new things to either unfilter or filter. I don't even know if I'm really using the right terminology, so forgive me. But those will need to be conversations moving forward. And I think we're envisioning, too, our peer coordinators assisting and taking the lead on tools
013that they see could really leverage the work that they're doing with kids and then taking a careful look at those. Yeah. There was a thing called School AI when I went to the conference back in October. The big thing was is it doesn't have the open outlet like what chat GPT does. So it's built for schools, made for schools, and the information received and put into it is not put back out to the web. That's how Copilot works too. As long as you're using the private version of Copilot, it doesn't share that information outside of your organization. I want to say that when Matthew and I were talking, obviously AI, there's a lot of good with this too, but I want to say he was looking because the license that we need in the district
014with all the security measures is not, obviously it's not the basic version of office. It's a, and they've changed the tiers of service. So it's got a more expensive, but I believe he was saying that we added the co-pilot, the artificial intelligence into this. I don't know that it's feasible for us to support that for the district. Very expensive. Anyone else on this? Thank you. Great. So we will roll on down to 6.1 to recommend the board of education approves the personnel agenda as presented or if there are any additions, deletions, or changes. Not in tyranny. I will make a motion to see a second. From the KV, all in favor? Aye. Motion carried. uh so we'll go around to 7.2 so recommend the board of education for all personal items in section 7 as
015presented just in motion from stephanie in a second from katie uh all in favor aye any opposed motion carries All right. So the next one is our open vacancy seats. So thank you for the two of you that are here, of our applicants that applied. We have a few folks that were interested. First things I'll say is the person that we chose to fill will serve through the next election. So if they're May 20th. However, we would also like to say we would encourage anyone to run for the full seat, which we'll probably be putting out petitions pretty soon, within the next month or so. So we would certainly recommend and would like to see some faces for that. So just want to put that piece out there. And I have everyone's email address, so
016I will send out to they do a new prospective board member training through the Niagara-Lean School Board Association. So it gives you more information about running for school board, what to expect, all that good stuff. So just want to put that out there. We did talk. It was a tough decision, but we'll roll on at 8.1. It's recommended the Board of Education approves the appointment of Melissa Kimbrell to build a vacant school board seat until the next district election of May 20, 2025. And we will take a roll call vote. Katie? Aye. Yeah, I hear. Aye. Okay. Aye. Aye. Debbie? Aye. Stephanie? Aye. Pete? Aye. And an aye. So motion carries. And then anything for the good of the order? Well, we have everyone. And then we got anything? Jeff and Ann Mearson. Yeah, I
017think we're done. All right, Josh. Well, talked a bunch. Well, again, thank you to everyone that was interested in the vacancy. We appreciate everyone that, you know. that put their time and effort into applying and we hope to see everyone's faces for the next election cycle that is it will be here before you know it um but with no further business to come for the board education just need a motion to adjourn at 7 16. from stephanie in a second katie all in favor all right my motion carries thank you