001Second. Second. Second by him. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Okay. And can we stand for a play to apply? um hi good evening Stand here? Okay. I'm Christopher Cook. I'm the art department coordinator at the high school, North Carolina Window High School. And I want to thank you for the opportunity to come and present to you tonight. We're going to talk about the impact of art in our schools. So a wealth of research suggests that arts can invigorate the learning process in a variety of ways. This is not, okay. I was going to say that was something I didn't want. So learning through the arts promotes the idea there's more than one solution to a problem and that there's more than one answer to a question. So art is anything but standardized. And we
002teach the kids, what do you do when the answer isn't A, B, C, or D? A good art program develops parts of the brain that other subjects... Do not. And as our teachers, we're here to inspire critical thinking and challenge students' developing minds. See, the brain's a muscle, and it needs to be stimulated in a variety of ways. Go on to the next one, please. And then the next one. So, you know, as far as developing and stimulating the mind, we'll give them a simple concept, like one point perspective. We're trying to show objects going back to a point. And then what do they do with that? What's the next step? How much more complicated or complex can they make that? And again, it's just a simple concept. And then taking art that they've learned
003or concepts that they've learned throughout the year. So strategic plan, innovation, engaged learners, workforce preparedness. That's what we're gearing towards. That's what a good art program can gear towards. Innovation is defined as creating and using new ideas or using new methods. And it's interesting to think art education was incorporated into the schools in 1871. We were losing the war with the Industrial Revolution to Europe. And we need to do something to invigorate our economy, to innovate and create. So we decided, let's put art education into the school system. Over here, we have kids using, we talked about a variety of methods. We're using stop motion animation to create art. We have an animation class in the high school, brand new this year. So again, we're using new methods, new ideas, using old art concepts, but
004with new ideas. So over the last 30 years, there's an overwhelming research suggesting how important art is in their developing minds and what we can use to create that art. Einstein said the greatest of human achievement is to... to create. And our program works hand in hand with that strategic plan that the district set out, innovation, engaged learners, and workforce preparedness. Go ahead. So Steve Jobs put it right. He said, as a nation, America needs to invest in developing creativity. It's funny because he's saying that, and that works hand in hand with what happened back in 1871, right? We're losing the war in the Industrial Revolution. And today we are competing now with many more countries than just Europe. So he understands that we have to develop in our creativity. A lot of the skills
005that we're developing, we're helping develop the children are not just for art. OK, we're talking about other careers, biomedical illustration, urban planners, product designers, engineering, architecture, skills that are 21st century skills. digital media. So now we're looking at some of the art programs that are art skills. So our district wants students to be prepared for the workforce. What skills are we giving them? We're giving them skills that for jobs don't even exist today. You know, there's kindergartners that are going to school right now. We're giving them skills. We're developing these skills so that they can compete in the global economy, in the global world with other countries in years to come. And finally, what does ARDOT do? Stimulates imagination. It strengthens cognitive thinking skills. Adds to academic achievement. It's been proven to do that. It's
006been proven to raise SAT scores. Kids that take art. Appreciation for different cultures. We need that more than ever. And also help troubled youths after school programs. Alternative destructive behavior. So on behalf of the art department, I want to thank you for having us tonight. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank
007you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you Good evening, everyone. Thank you for the opportunity. Mr. Cook, fantastic job. Obviously, always going back to that strategic plan is so important for a lot of the conversations that we're having in the building. They have it monthly in their department meetings, and that really is driving what new courses we're offering to make sure that we're preparing our students for the 21st century. making sure they're engaged, and we want to make sure we have innovative classrooms. So that was a
008great presentation. I know that Dr. Jack Luski, about a month ago, had asked buildings to present to the board about some amazing events. highlights of the year that happening inside the building. And so I reached out to Mrs. McAndrew and her photojournalism class, photo one and photo two. Those are newer courses at the high school. They're really driving that 21st century workforce preparedness element, meeting with them and really highlighting coming out of TNT. You know, I know a lot of people in Western New York, they hear about TNT, but you've never really experienced from a student lens what is going on in that building. I think it's really hard to understand the power of that week as Lumberjacks. It really does make us who we are. We truly do come together as one Lumberjack family
009during that week. So it is an amazing event. So, you know, I am not the star here. It absolutely is the students behind me. So I'm going to turn it over to Mrs. McAndrew and the students. Thank you. Yes, I'm also not the star, so I'm going to talk very quickly. Savannah is with me. I will just say, Savannah, she is a senior this year. Unfortunately, we'd keep you forever if we could. She has taken 10 art courses with us. I'm not sure how she did it, but she did. So my name is Hillary McAndrew. I'm the yearbook advisor, photojournalism, studio and art and ceramics instructor at NTHS. Thank you for allowing us to show our stuff. and the hard work that our photojournalism students in particular have created through this video. My photojournalism and
010yearbook club students hold a special place in this school. We quickly become one big family, having snacks, making sure that we're all working together. This one is working on this page and then they flip over to the next page. And they really work together. It's a huge team effort. For those that aren't aware, they start with 192 blank pages. And then they turn those into our full yearbook by the end of the year. Well, actually by the end of March. And then our photojournalism students are responsible for our photographs, designing of the spreads and pages, design of the cover, all the interviews, polls, appreciations, dedications that are put into every book every year. We currently have, and I checked this yesterday, it could be different, 5,877 photographs in the yearbook program. So it is no
011small task and they really rise to the occasion in our yearbook. database. And that doesn't include the photos that they didn't feel made the cut. I'm not sure how many photos they have on their drives that didn't even make the cut. Their efforts are tireless when it comes to recording all the events and happenings at NTHS each year. And this course, this art course is a little different from the rest. The yearbook staff impresses me every year with their dedication, focused hard work, and motivation to create something that is not their own, but to record the memories for everybody else. The photojournalism staff members that are here is Savannah Shingledecker. She's our editor-in-chief. I have Eleanor Stevens over there. She's our copy editor. She's going for English. So she is the one that reads over
012every single word in the yearbook. And Reagan Troxell, she is one of our photo editors. We have two photo editors and she is one of them. And each of these students are not only dedicated to creating the yearbook, but have invested themselves in all of our art courses, really creating that culture and community that we cherish as teachers. And this year, all years are tough, but this year is going to be particularly tough at the end, for sure, with all of these amazing students. So thank you for your time. And Savannah has a few things to say before their amazing video that they created. Hello, my name is Savannah Schengeldecker. I'm the editor-in-chief of the High School Yearbook. I've been taking art classes since my freshman year and have taken a total of 10 of
013the many art classes offered at NTHS. I've been passionate about making and creating art since I was young. Because of my wonderful teachers and their amazing classes, I have chosen to take a variety of art classes. There are art students who are passionate about art, such as I, but there are students that learn that they love art when they're introduced to different projects. Art classes bring out creativity of my world. with wild thinking outside the box and away from the traditional classroom ideas. I've been involved in creating the yearbook for the past three years. Photojournalism being a new class for the past two has helped me be more engaged into the culture of the school. Teamwork is incredibly important to the success of making a piece of memorabilia that will be kept forever. This class
014is like being part of a big family. Photojournalism will be a class I'll forever cherish from taking pictures to creating a book filled with pages of hard work. This class has helped me further expand my experience and techniques and yet in another art form using skills that can be incorporated into a real world career. Thank you for letting me speak today. I'm dying to see. I'm dying to see. I'm dying to see. Any questions in regards to the programming? The amazing talent of our students. I've got to say, the pride as a building principal to be able to work with them and see the talents here on screen here on stage Monday and Wednesday of next week. We have amazing lumberjacks. And you can see the pride they have of being one lumberjack family. And
015that means a lot for all of us. So the kids did a fantastic job. Thanks. Very nice. Great. Nice job. Follow that. Right. Good. Wow. It's not as exciting as our programs are. I promise not any more slides. No, I think. Like joking aside, the budget's really important to make sure we support student learning and achievement, ensuring that the great experiences that you just saw and that we saw last month, and I'm sure the other principals are about to showcase in the upcoming months, that really that can be supported not only this year, but in the future, because we've had such tremendous traditions that we want to ensure that the experience the kids are experiencing right now is very similar to how. students had success 15 years ago and 15 years from now, you know,
016we'll have that same sort of success. So thank you for giving me the opportunity to talk about this, the budget development process and our reserve plans. I think this will be a little bit more surface level at the beginning, just to give you everybody an idea of really the process that we'll go about this winter and early spring. So, of course, our objective is we need to utilize the district's fiscal resources to support the student outcomes for the 25-26 school year and beyond. Budgets oftentimes will build into each other and be strategic, and how the allocation of funds in one year will impact district finances multiple years from now. So a couple of things we look to accomplish. First and foremost, we have many strengths we should recognize and really celebrate in this current year.
017Our current budget factors, historical budgetary views and expenditures, and in terms of a percentage of the overall budget, just to get an idea of where we have historically allocated funds. The general fund budget development, what are some of the drivers that we look at immediately? and what are some of those drivers that we look at in the future things that we can control things we can't control but we know that they will impact our decisions and whether they're short-term and long-term and do we have any flexibility and variability with some of those expenses or are they mandated and fixed and it's just something that we're going to have to work around and then also a brief review of our district reserves and those reserve fund balances as well So a couple of strengths that are
018really important to note. First and foremost, I think we had a really strong audit presentation clean of any management. issues to address. And I'd just like to really give credit to some of our purchasing clerks, our account payable, and our senior account clerk, and our extracurricular treasurers. They really do a tremendous job ensuring that the audit process at the end of the year that we see as a clean audit is really a testament to their hard work that they do all year round. Because purchasing is really complicated and making sure that we are appropriately spending all state and local dollars appropriately. So there is that trust that we're doing the right thing. A couple of years ago, we completed an energy conservation project that we're still enjoying those benefits of and will continue to enjoy.
019Our building infrastructure behind the scenes that you don't necessarily see on the walls or going on in the classrooms, but things like the boilers, the air handlers, our kitchen equipment is in really great shape. Our roofs or any sort of deficiencies we may have, they're being addressed in the current capital project. And that is why that five-year building condition survey is so critical to make sure we continue to have strong infrastructure so we're not spending dollars unnecessarily supporting a building. And instead, we're funneling those dollars towards instruction. With that, we have our current capital project that the voters graciously approved last spring. We have our still continue to be a community eligibility provision district, as where all students will receive a free breakfast and lunch daily, regardless of income status. And we will be a
020CEP school for at least the next three years. And then finally, the district was awarded a very competitive P-TECH grant. I believe only 11 or 12 districts across the state received that grant, and we are one. thanks to Mr. Tambroni's office and Mr. Rolls and the work they put in to secure that grant. So a couple of budget facts for this year. From a revenue standpoint, you'll see this is fairly historical. Our state aid and local levy will approximate 90% of our revenues. We use some fund balance and reserves for about 5%, and then we have some other revenues as well that make up 5%. What are some of those other revenues? Things like interest, earnings, rent. If we dispose of excess inventory, that's obsolete on our purpose. We may get some additional revenue, but
021not a large revenue. And certainly there's some variability. On the expense side, approximately 75% of our expenses are geared towards the area of salaries, benefits, and other instructional expenses that support the classroom. Those are things like supplies, equipment, textbooks, software, BOCES services in some areas. And then approximately 25% of the district budget supports other areas such as debt service. transporting kids to and from school, from the heat on the buildings, or then just central office operations. Yeah, great question. In the expenses, so you've got instructional salaries split out. Does buildings and grounds transportation do those with their salaries? That's a good point. So the buildings and grounds salaries are coded within the buildings and grounds percent that you see. Same with transportation salaries. The bus drivers in attendance are coded into the transportation as well
022for transportation. like a third party, like a first student expense. If we contract out those expenses live there. I wanted to break it out in the fact that like what we do here is to support learning instruction. You know, certainly I wanted to just, you know, highlight that area as, you know, an important part of the budget. So from a historical revenue perspective, I took a snapshot of over three-year increments. So this is a seven-year view. So every third year to look at what the revenues were. And you can see that approximately 90% of our revenues have very much historically stayed in the New York state aid and the local tax levy. While the budget may have grew, the percentage and the proportions remain fairly stable. And again, the appropriate fund balance reserve and some
023of those other revenues that we spoke about. has been fairly constant around 10% combined. And with that, we want to take a look at the expense. So again, that same look back over the last seven years, every third year, to see what the expenses would look like. And you can see that the instructional side, whether it's the salaries, the benefits, or the supports for instruction, again, like the textbooks, the supplies, the equipment, contractual funds, is approximately 75%. There has been one noticeable growth I do want to just highlight, is that the transportation. has increased over time from approximately 3.5% of our total budget to this year projected 6.2%, so about an 80% increase. A lot of those costs we'll see in a couple slides are some of the budget drivers, but also the cost of
024a contractor as well. So the general fund budget development, a couple of things that we want to look at. First and foremost, we want to look and analyze with our directors and building principals, what are our student needs that we need to plan for? And with those student needs, we review staffing to make sure we can meet those needs. And then the staffing drives some of the fixed costs like benefits. And then we want to make sure we review all of our support areas. Kind of thinking of it, I would say when you're creating a general fund budget, it's almost like. where you live. Like there are some things that are variable. Some of the extra nice, I'll say the flowers in the summer, but some of the fixed expenses is your, say, mortgage. And
025then a mandate would be the insurance that you must have to protect your fixed expense. There can be, understandably so, some confusion when you talk about the general fund budget, which is what our community votes on, because other areas, and we talked about them as strengths just now, is like our capital project that we have. That is a different fund that is separate from this process. Our special aid grants fund, whether it's from like the state or the federal government, like our title funds and 611 funds, those are separate. And then also our child nutrition program that we talked about, like the CEP, where every student has a free breakfast and lunch. Technically, those are separate budgets. Are there ways where they can somewhat influence the general fund budget? Sure, of course, but by and
026large, they're separate. So some of our internal budget drivers is as the district works with different unions to settle new contractual agreements, there may be some relief in certain areas of the budget, but also be new additions or requirements that are placed on the budget that we need to make sure we fully encapsulate. Our student programmatic safeguards is the one area I really wanted to highlight, and this relates back to the transportation need, how that has grown. We've seen An increase in some of our students with disabilities and making sure that we provide them the appropriate placement as a result of the CSC. So that might require some additional transportation to other locations and centers. So, of course, when you have a bus going to a new school and requires a new route, that's an
027additional cost. And also, we've seen an increase not at just our district, but across the region of students that are experiencing and fighting the negative effects of being homeless. So the McKinney-Vento status students like those require additional. transportation runs. So a lot of those expenses are attributed to those two areas to make sure we meet those student needs and those safeguards. And then also regionally as well, due to global geopolitical events, we've seen a large influx of students who are English language learners and making sure we meet those student needs as well. So those are certainly some programmatic safeguards that are driving the budget. Our tax levy and our tax cap, the ability to potentially at a local level increase revenue, which can potentially continue program or expand some programmatic offerings, and then working with
028our principals and directors about programming costs as well to maybe meet more than just the minimum student needs, but how to engage and innovate. Some budget drivers, I'm viewing some of these as short-term and long-term, and sometimes they can be a little bit of both at the same time. So last year, many districts across the state, there was the potential of the reduction of safe harmless, which would impact our foundation aid. That's something I worry about right now. It could be something I worry about in five years. It could be both. Lower interest earnings, that talked about that other revenue, like that is certainly something to worry about where some of our interest earnings could go down, but there's also the ability as we bond our capital projects, we might enjoy some of those lower
029interest rates as well. So it's a little bit of a give and take. We have a new third party contract that will eventually be coming online. Health insurance and especially our ERS and TRS retirement contribution rates, those are set by the state and those are just a fixed percentage of payroll. That is just something we work with and we know those are budget drivers. In the long term, in the year 2035, as of now, it is expected that all of our transportation buses, whether it's us or contractors, be fully electric. That is certainly something that's far in the future. we'll blink and it'll be 2030 and it'll be more of an immediate short-term like, hey, what's our plan? And then also recently there's been some traction within the past about 18 months about classroom temperature
030regulation and making sure that some of the buildings aren't too hot. Again, that's just something we need to consider so much as now in the building condition survey, which we referenced earlier in the presentation. It's now a new piece on the building condition survey as a building or a district's ability to potentially support air conditioning is something the state wants to now ask districts to report on. So the last piece, touching on reserves. So reserves are certainly a benefit, and I think we're in a pretty healthy position where we could be. Could reserves be better? Well, I think the answer to that question is always could be yes, but also the point that reserves serve a really important purpose. It's to weather some of those storms that we're not in control over and that we're
031really at the mercy. So we reference the ERS and TRS contribution rates. If those rates double in the next two years, that's going to be really hard for any district to support. That is where some of those reserves can ride out and smooth out the peaks and the negative impacts of some of those effects on a budget, which ultimately could impact instruction and student outcomes. Some challenges with reserves. People look at the dollar amounts and say, well, you have money, but they're really only for legally designated purposes. So it's important that we follow the reserve, but also talk about trust and having a clean audit, all those things tie into each other. Reserves are really designed to help supplement historical general fund budget appropriations, not completely supplant. It's important that you still make sure you're
032funding your obligations so when those spikes eventually reside, then you are, you know, where you should be in a good spot. So some of our balances, I won't go over all of them. You can see them, but I would just like to reference a few. You'll notice our capital reserves, both in 2019, that was established for some of our buses. That was fully funded. It's nearing the point of depletion, but that was planned by Mr. Montoro back in 2019. And the capital reserve that was established in 2021, as of this fall, was fully funded. So that is awesome. You will notice... in approximately 18 months from now that balance will be reduced by about six million dollars earlier this fall we had young and wright and buffalo construction talk about the first phase of the
033capital project the district will be saving tens of thousands of dollars in interest earnings because of that capital reserve and being able to use it so the district now can funnel those additional dollars back towards instruction and so that is a tremendous gift that we have and that we are able to utilize and then That capital reserve, the remaining dollars, can help really address some of those far-off long-term needs we talked about, like electric busing or potential heat regulation in buildings. We are in a position to meaningfully talk about and look into what do we have to do from a responsibility standpoint without causing dramatic swings in the instructional program because of those reserves. And I just really want to take a moment to highlight that. And the last area is the unappropriated fund balance.
034While not necessarily a reserve, the state legally expects that school districts maintain no more than 4% of the general fund budget, kind of in a separate account. That is the maximum. In a recent report that was released, approximately 37% of districts don't follow that, and they go beyond 4%. And that will frequently be cited by the comptroller. There's talk about like the Rockefeller Center and like having penalties for that. So it's really one, we're lucky that we're at 4% too, but it's also very important that we don't go beyond 4% because in the near future, there could certainly be penalties for doing that behavior. And some of those figures are referenced and verified in the audit that we had in October. So some of our next steps is anxiously awaiting the initial state aid projections
035from the governor, because that will certainly be one of the big pieces of the budget development process, and reviewing some of the other revenue codes, the calculation of the tax levy and the potential tax gap that could drive additional revenues into the district. reviewing the programmatic continuation. I don't necessarily like to call it necessarily quote a rollover budget, but what do we need to do and what are some of the known expenses and then also any sort of contractual agreements? What are the implications that we know of the next school year? An area is the development of the BOCES budget. That is a fairly significant part of our budget. It's approximately... 9% give or take, but our local BOCES doesn't release the figures until mid-February approximately. So it is a little bit, we're going to
036be along the budget process and then the BOCES budget will be released. So it is going to be a little bit of a forecast of what are the trends during the last couple of years. And then of course, just internal budget discussions to meet the programmatic needs of students and no year is the same. So with that. That was what we had. I promise not 84 slides. Are there any questions or anything that you would like answered? I guess outside of the state, the whole promise side. That's probably the biggest risk. The state foundation, that's probably the biggest risk. Outside of that, what would you say our next risk is? From a revenue side or an expense side? Revenue. Potentially the lowering, a dramatic lowering of interest earnings has been an area where we work
037with a program called NIFAS, which has been earning very healthy interest rates, but approximately. I think four or five, six years ago, some of us who have been here, the interest earnings were truly almost 0%, where we've been enjoying some fairly healthy interest rates. And the long-term forecast is interest rates are going down. So we've been enjoying some of the benefits of that. That could certainly be a hit to some of our revenue codes. Revenue in many cases is a little bit more stable. Outside of foundation aid, I would say the next one, and this, again, is not something we can really control, is what's called expense-based aid. So when we spend a dollar in transportation, we get aid back the following year. Or when we spend money on BOCES for like CTE programming, we
038get a certain percent back the next year. There has been talk in the past of can we cap how much expense-based earnings and revenue a school district could have where it's like no more than maybe what you have earned or... it's really just an impact on the state budget. So that would certainly be a risk, but again, something we really can't control. We have made a really concerted effort over the last handful of years when possible to buy from BOCES because we get aid back the next year. An example could be, we could buy a conference phone for $200 or we could buy it from BOCES and get kind of like a 60% rebate the next year coming back in. Same phone. It's just being smart and how you buy. And again, giving credit to
039our account clerks and purchasing clerks. They hold me accountable and I hold them accountable. Make sure we really are maximizing every dollar we can or potential revenue the next year so we can really support and push the instruction. Does that cap on the expense revenue that we get from the capital improvement projects? Typically, from my understanding, working with other colleagues and my mentor. If you have a project in the works or it's already being aided and bonded, they would. kind of grandfather that aid, but then going forward, it could be a change. And I know there could be a recalculation of like a regional cost index, the wealth of a district based on like everyone's tax returns. Oh, there's a lot of complicated factors that go into it. So there could be just a multitude
040of ways of which that could be impacted. So it is something we are aware of and, you know, pay very close attention to. Any other questions? well thank you very much i appreciate the time tonight okay we will jump right into our agenda 8.1 um it's recommended that the board of education approved the agenda ordered as presented are there any additions at least to george chambers 9.19, the consent agenda approval. It's recommended that the Board of Education approve the consent agenda as recommended by the superintendent of schools. Do I have a motion? So moved. Gabby, second. Oh, sorry, Stephanie. I'll second. Gabby, second. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Carried. 10.1, the approval of the personnel agenda order. I RECOMMEND THAT THE BOARD OF EDUCATION PROVE THE PERSONNEL AGENDA ORDER AS PRESENTED, AND ANY ADDITIONS,
041RELEASES, OR CHANGES. IS THERE ANY HEARING OR NOTION? SO MOVED. OKAY. SECOND? SO MOVED. ALL IN FAVOR? AYE. AYE. CLOSED? CARRIED. 11.23 the consent personal agenda approval. It's recommended that the Board of Education approves all the above personnel items in section 11 as presented. I'll make the motion. Do I have a second? Second. Second. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Carried. Then we've got our policy. We have actually one of our appointees is here tonight. Our new director of transportation. I'd like to introduce him. Mr. Eric Wood is here tonight. Hi everybody. The two second reads, we moved through these for first reads last meeting. The first is our pre-referral intervention strategies policy. This was an existing policy that we had. We did do some tweaking with naming the teams in each building who are
042really responsible with collaborating with each other and communicating, gathering information about students and how they're progressing toward state standards and benchmarks and naming those as our student. review teams, our SRTs. And so really this policy serves to guide how we're really taking a look at students, how they're progressing towards standards and benchmarks, and then interventions that we're providing that are provided prior to referrals to CSE or the Committee on Special Education. After last meeting's first read, we didn't have any questions at that time. or is like last meeting no yeah i know this though i know it was the first grade but like did we you're thinking i think possibly of our rti policy the response to intervention yes yes so that one we did move through last year okay um so this policy does
043intertwine with that Second policy is our comprehensive student attendance policy. So this is a required policy by law and regulation. We've had it on the books, but we're taking this opportunity to examine the policy and then also outside of the policy to take a look at different structures and frameworks that we can put in place both at the district level and building level to increase student attendance by making sure that our climate and culture is on point, that students are wanting to come to school, that we're having the right level of programs and activities to support their interests and to support their academic learning and growth and to increase engagement. So for this, we moved through a few different subcommittees to take a look at the language for this policy and did our first read
044during our last meeting. The major changes really begin on page five, where now the definition for chronic absenteeism is now embedded into the policy. The New York State Comptroller just released the most recent chronic absenteeism audit in October of 2024 to really point out that chronic absenteeism across the state and across rural, urban, suburban, small city, largely all of it. is not declining and really imploring districts and BOCES and communities to think of new strategies and interventions to help get our kids to school and to get them to school more regularly. So that's an added definition here. The attendance incentives is also a new section. So one of the conversations that school districts are having and BOCES are having is what are some What are some things that we should be continuing that draw students
045to school? Like I know Brad went with TNT week, the daily attendance rate was, I will say through the roof. I mean, the kids were coming to school more regularly during those times. So what are things that we should be continuing because they really are drawing our student body into our doors? And then what are some things that maybe we haven't tried yet that we could? to then see whether or not it has an impact on student attendance. The last section that was last two sections that were tweaked are on page six. And so intervention strategies. So how are we identifying patterns related to student attendance, whether that be individual student attendance, or whether that be across a grade level across a building. And then What are we doing to discuss those interventions or strategies
046that we might put into place? Some of those also might be within our own resources, such as utilizing Kim Capriati at our resource family support center or reaching outside to other organizations such as North Point Chant, linking families with resources, and then also leveraging our relationships with our SROs. So that section has been added. And then also at the bottom of page six, you'll note that review of attendance records and further fleshing out and growing the existing framework that we have for that. Last meeting, Patrick spoke a little bit about everyday labs. I anticipate, because part of this policy is a review by the board of our attendance patterns, but really being able to leverage this tool that helps us to better. mine, collect, disaggregate the data, and then it's the what do we do
047with it. And then the other benefit of this tool is the parent communication piece and some of the capabilities that it has as far as pushing out different infographs and different messages that help to, yes, communicate that, hey, we really want your kiddo in school, but then also here's the impact when they're not, if you're missing. two days a month or if you're missing four days a month than in the long-term impact. So I don't know if you want to say anything. Yeah, it will give a comparison, a friendly comparison to that particular student to other students. What is the average missing of school attendance? So we just started doing this. A neat thing, they reached out right before the Thanksgiving break and they said, Patrick. Would you like us to push out one additional
048one, a text, just to reinforce the importance of student attendance during Thanksgiving recess week? We have two days, Monday and Tuesday. And ironically, I was in a few classrooms and I heard some of the high school students as I'm walking in and going, we don't need to be here. It's a short week. Why do we have to be here? And yeah, I can see it firsthand. David, I was in your class. So I saw it firsthand. I giggled because the guy called a spade a spade. He was spot on. So we're making it tough as a district to say it is important. You need to be there every day. If you're not there, you know, it's going to become a bigger problem down the road. So it's something we're going to use a lot more.
049So our next steps based on. even beyond the policy is to really take a look at the framework that we have at the district level and then build in levels to move into the looking at the data and developing plans to hopefully move the needle incrementally. And it's more than the daily attendance rate. The daily attendance rate could be 91%, but that can be misleading if your chronic absenteeism rate is 26%. Thank you. both on freedom um recommended that the board of education approves all policies second reads as proceeded in substance following yeah all those in favor aye opposed here we deserve four goals following our retreat I can pass on the three topics that Matt gave me, and that's actually kind of going from there. So based on the retreat, he had three topics
050in mind, and they do kind of correlate all together. One was mental health, well-being, and social and emotional learning. The aspect of belonging, right? And then the third one was looking to increase our graduation rates. And then how do we support that? I need transportation. So the activity that that mismanagers shared by current school weeks and things like that. Yeah. So those are on my mind as well. Of course, you know, the belonging and of course, the graduation rate. And so I haven't heard anything about this because what how would we work that into a board goal? I'm like. supporting those in the district to do things to support those goals, which is great. But what we do as a model policy, which is their biggest influence. I would love for it to be a
051board goal because it is important, but I don't know what action items we would take. In general, you would be supporting the staff in the exact right amount from some of the areas and for any policy that he mentioned. So they are fairly general, but certainly things that we are working on in conjunction with the work that are supposed to be another hall of work graduation rates with transportation, right? We know there's Dr. Janice shared the rising cost over the years of transportation, right? you know if you look in at those budget numbers and we look to increase the mileage or or get creative and stops or whatever the case may be right to get kids more kids to school um again it would be our job to support those numbers that we made to
052think of that happened i just pulled up the ones from last year WE HAVE ONE FOR COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT AND WE PHRASED IT AS BY JUNE 30, 2024, INITIATE ACTIVITIES TO INCREASE THE AMOUNT AND QUALITY OF COMMUNICATION BETWEEN THE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND THE GREATER NORTH TOWN ALAMA CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT COMMUNITY. AND THEN WE PUT EXAMPLES LIKE THAT. AND SO MAYBE THAT'S LIKE, I DON'T KNOW, LIKE SUPPORT. increase graduation rate like that doesn't yeah it is important that we should be focusing on it and the goal that would make our our priorities so i do think that it should be a goal i just don't know the best way to put it if everybody is on board with those topics you could take the time to frame it up and you know, multiple room clicks at
053our next meeting. The January meeting? Yeah. Or the January. We could just... Or the three again? Mental health, well-being, and social and emotional belonging and graduation rates. Or maybe, like, increasing a sense of belonging. Yeah, I was going to say, did you have any, like, additional thoughts on that? He just gave you this. We talked about that at our retreat though. Yeah. We did it on a vision. So everybody should have that in their emails. It was like restorative in community circles, DEI committees at the district level, SEL, and child informed training. expanding partnerships with outside resources to help with sel that could be something we could work on expanding partnerships with outside resources while very involved in the community and increasing school spirit which are all very important but how do we as board
054members do other than you know and the goal could just be written as supporting those in the district doing those things um i'm not opposed to those but i i i wonder if there's a i feel like if we increase the sense of belonging attendance and graduation rates will go up so i just wonder if there's like maybe a fourth area that we want to play with like before we break the goals so that like in case we find ourselves like having written the same thing, essentially. If we want to pick three goals. I mean, it's fine if we end up with two, but if we want to have three, I just wonder if there's maybe... Essentially, fixing the first two or working on the first two should increase the graduation rate. Maybe a goal
055could be analyzing graduation rates, analyzing graduation rates, and then all the actions we could take. You know, would be supporting the other things would be a goal. Historical graduation rates. And that would be following the policy that we just. What was our second goal last year? Other than policy and. Yeah. So we had community engagement, safe and healthy environment. And then board policies. Which technically board policies are still. In is still going. We said, yeah, we said by June 30th, 2027, complete a full appraisal of all board policies, establishing a four-year review cycle for regular and ongoing assessment. So we could like, theoretically, that is still ongoing. We could have two. I definitely think graduation rates should be one of them. I agree with that. So I don't give us two bills in one. I
056agree with that. Thank you. But I think a lot of that trickled into the graduation. Yeah. I also don't know that we're going to see a change this fast, right? So like we might have another sort of long-term. We're coming up with this in the middle of a year. So like. maybe this attendance or something belonging or graduation rates isn't by the end of 2025, right? Like by the end of this school year, maybe it's by the end of next school year. So it's a year and a half. I would agree with that. Dr. J, maybe we did, I don't know, I'm not even planning on doing it now, but maybe we can look at kind of historically where we've been at. Yeah. You can touch some benchmarks. We'd love to see, you know, based
057on other districts and those little polls, what does the better best look like, right? Absolutely. I think annual graduation rates is like, it's just everything. It's transportation, it's mental health, it's belonging, it's, you know, it covers everything that we've talked about. And if we do that in policies. at least to get us started, at least we can dive into graduation rates. You know what I mean? And all that goes along. Right. Yeah, I had it in 2020, going into 2027. It is just so fast, we're flying through. The other thing you might want to continue is community engagement. So maybe to your point, Gabby, right? The graduation rates piece ties in social and emotional learning, the belonging, right, transportation, policy, right? That's a big goal. And then we need to raise strategies for engagement and
058I still think there's plenty of room to go there. So maybe it's those three with those topics. Right. And even though we're kind of recycling one and keeping one going, our third new one is a big one. That's a big one, you know? So you don't want to take on three huge goals at the same time because where do you start? You know, do you need to vote on approving a new one or just, um, you know, recommend you? Yeah. Yeah, so maybe I can take a stab at writing them based on that and send it out and then come to the next meeting and take action on that one. I can give you any of the information you need for graduation rates, comparisons, other school respects, year-over-year comparisons. That would be a great start.
059Right. Appreciate it. 14, is there anyone in attendance that would address the board? about any topics within the school district. We ask that you just come up, state your name and address, and we'll move into the mobile ads. My name is Michelle Ledmister. I currently live in Niagara Falls. I've been a district employee for 31 years, and I teach Math 8 at the middle school currently. And I just wanted to maybe make a suggestion, having listening to you talk about your goals. We are, we, the boots on the ground, the teachers are doing the best that we can to try to create that culture. And we've had lots of other supports that have been built in and that's been great. But I'm wondering if anybody's ever asked or talked to the students who aren't graduating
060and ask them why, what's happening? Why aren't you attending? My gut reaction is, is that We don't have, I know you did a second rate of attendance policy, but the reality is I have students that I had them as seventh graders who attended less than half of the year, who got passed on to eighth grade, who are not attending now. They'll get passed on to ninth grade, where now all of a sudden all of those credits count. And they're not doing the work. They've missed two years of material at least. And I can bet that it probably goes all the way back down to kindergarten with our extreme cases. Right. And now all of a sudden they're in the high school and every single credit counts. And if they're not coming, if they're not being
061successful, like this is a pattern they've had. And we don't have anything more at the building level to my knowledge. to get them to try to come to school. I have a student who just got placed on home teaching that I have literally seen six times this school year. And if you add up all the time he's missed, he's missed over 200 days of school in the past three years. I can't, we can't teach that. I can't help that child become successful. And there's obviously bigger issues. This isn't a busing issue. This isn't like there's more going on. So when you get to those top tiers, it's why. Why are they not coming? Yes, I'm sure some of it's busing because I do agree that our two miles radius is way too big, especially on
062a day-to-day. I bet if you looked at all the schools, their daily attendance would probably lower than on a day when it wasn't snowing and 30 degrees outside. But I just think that maybe if you actually, and maybe that data is there and I'm not aware of it. Again, I fully recognize that piece, but I think asking why, because I think it definitely goes. more beyond the idea of a sense of belonging. Because I feel like we've come a really long way in that aspect in the district. I've seen it over my career. So maybe start trying to get some of that information. And maybe that can help gear some of the goals and plans of trying to increase all that. So thank you for your time. Could we put like a thought exchange together
063that has questions like that, that we send specifically to the families who are dealing with some level of chronic absenteeism to get some anonymous feedback? And cluster the responses. And how can we catch this sooner? Because obviously it's not just a weird thing that these kids, it's something that is trickling from, you know, elementary to intermediate to the middle school. So how can we, and is that with our new? Yeah, it's a good point. Like when we first looked at this. A lot of the conversations are touching what Michelle just said and what you just said about transportation. Can we be more strategic with stops and pick up points that we can get students to school? And we were, I took Josh, I took you, I took Brad Rolls. We went to a neighboring district
064that was having the same difficulties. And the more we talk, we say, well, wait a minute, why? I get it. Like Michelle said, it's very important at the high school. But if we're sending a message as a district, how about that family that has a kid in the high school, but maybe a third grader at Spruce School? Why are we going to be texting them, emailing them, sending them letters to get better attendance and not do anything where the root of the cause is? So we took a different approach. We're hitting K-12. It's going to be a process. But to your point, recently we had one of our administrators doing a home visit with a kiddo at, you know, fourth grade or I forget what grade level. But one of our SROs, the police captain
065has, or police chief has requested SROs start helping us with home visits. Well, ironically, here's our principal for one kid. Here's our SRO at the same household, same time for a different kid. We didn't know that as a unit. So that's where this program is going to help us get better. You know, so we're in the infancy, you know, of learning how to do this. The good news is I've seen the middle school already. They're dabbling with different reports and structures. And it's so much easier. It's so much easier than what we were doing before. Going through e-school and searching all this information and, you know, the chronic students, it's literally a click of a button right now. So, no, I don't have all the answers for you, but I do see some promising tools.
066You know, and now it's going to be for the district here to get a bigger committee together and get consistency from K all the way up to 12th grade. Well, we can always create surveys for situations like that. For severely chronic. Absent students. It's really about us as a school district developing relationships with the family and having the conversation because it's more than a survey where you answer yes and no and give us a little bit of information. We have to really learn about the family and their situation and what they're going through to be able to figure out what those supports are to get those kids to school. So it's a lot. It's going to have to be a lot more than that. just answering a couple of questions. It's developing that relationship, understanding
067why they're not there and what we can do to make them feel that they need to come to school, feel that they are safe in school, provide the resources necessary to get them to school, and once they're in school, to move them forward. So it's going to take a lot, but I think it's more of using our manpower to get that information and do it versus... just getting a little bit of information from a survey where it's good to have the information but what are you going to do with that information afterwards and it's really developing those relationships with those kids with those families so now we have the tools the good thing is we have a great tool now to let us know exactly who those kids are and where they're trending and their
068families so you know we're in a good position to have that information um but then building on it after that's going to be really important I guess my other question is, and this might come off a little harsh, but if there's a child that is missing, you know, 50 days, why are we pushing them through to the next grade level? I mean, that's setting them up for failure. You know, and not being here for a long time, not knowing all those answers, but from previous situations, you also can't have a... student that's in eighth grade that's 18 years old. So, you know, there's got to be a point where they are going to move forward. It's really what we do as a district to provide supports for those students as they move forward because there's
069social promotions and there's... general conditions that we do. But what are we going to do to support them when they're in that next grade level? Or if we are going to retain a student, what are we going to do differently for that student if we retain them? You can't keep a kid in seventh grade. and just keep them there another year and do the exact same thing that you did the year before. It didn't work the year before. Just because they're a year older doesn't mean they, the switch goes on and they don't do it. So if you are going to retain a student, you need to have a really good plan of what you're going to do differently. And then also looking at the options of different programs for students, whether it be an
070alternative program, different placement outside of the district. I mean, a lot of different options out there. But really, all those options are after you get to know the student, get to know the family, get to know what their needs are. But it's always a tough problem. You don't want to just promote kids, but you also don't hold kids back unless you have a great plan for what you're going to do differently the following year. So figuring out that balance is important. Are we consistent in our engagement like that today? insisted in the engagement with chronic absentees and with the family? It's absolutely something that we're working on and we're getting much better with school resources, resource officers, building houses, administrators, mental health staff visiting homes, making those outreaches to families via phone. So we're definitely
071getting back. I mean, there's always work to be done there. We did, one of the nudges went out and I meet with them, I believe, Friday again is the next meeting with Everyday Labs. One of the nudges, it gave you an option. If you were a family that you weren't sending your child to school, why? Why not? Three weeks ago, four weeks ago, when we reviewed it, there was eight responses. There wasn't a lot of data, but it could be housing, it could be transportation, it could be medical, it could be, you know. There wasn't enough data to say, oh, this is a pattern yet, but it's something that we plan to continue to use. That's a big question. Big task. Yeah. Is there anyone else that would like to address the way? We can
072go around the table. Start off with David. First, I want to say thank you to our art department. They had a very nice presentation, and there's a lot of hard work. hard-working individuals in the department from the teachers and students there's a lot of passion there and you got to respect that greatly um also you know we're talking about having the students be involved within the building i figured i'd just touch up on our sports i know there's a lot of passionate individuals that are wrestling and basketball and swim As a member of the swim program too, I can personally say there's a lot of people in there who are passionate to come to practice. They're passionate to get that extra inch and they're really trying to work hard. Our first meet is tomorrow and
073I can tell you there's a lot of exciting individuals there. And from my experience talking to other students who participate in sports, it's a great way to keep them involved and it makes them want to come to school. So credit there, credit is due. I think that's just a bright side of today's discussion. So we also have our tree auction ceremony tomorrow. I think it's a good community event and I would encourage all to attend that. Thank you for all the presentations today. And the tree lighting is tomorrow, so I'll be there. Also grateful for the art presentation. Definitely at the tree lighting and excited to start the budget season. I really am. It's one of my favorite times of the year. So this was a really good overview. It's a lot. Budget discussion takes
074a very long time, but I'm happy to do it. Yeah, appreciate the presentations. Love seeing from the photojournalism class. Congratulations to Eric and welcome. I'm going to miss tree lighting and tree auction tomorrow, but I hope everybody has a great time. And I know this is the time of year for holiday concerts and things like that. And I also wish everybody luck at that. Also, tomorrow night is our opening of Doc the Kangaroo at the middle school for the musical. So along with the tree lighting tomorrow. So that's exciting. Also, winter sports kicked off last night with basketball. Our boys did a great job winning against Roy Hart. Great to enjoy that game last night. Looking forward to swimming and diving and also our wrestling matches as well. So very cool. And myself, I just
075hope everybody had a nice long weekend. I took the time to regenerate and re-energize, right? I didn't get back this week, so a couple more weeks of school and then we get another break outside of what everybody else shared tonight. So I appreciate it. With no further business to come before the Board of Education, we have a motion to adjourn at 7.44. No, we're all sound the same. All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Sorry. Barbara, thank you for your help tonight.