001good evening I'd like to call the meeting to to order um we have an exciting night planned we have leg you who's going to give us a presentation the board was there this morning we had a great morning so I will start with the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge [Music] allegiance United States of America stands one nation God indivisible liy and Justice all thank you I'd like to do roll call I believe we're all here correct yes all right moving on to approval of the agenda I'll take a motion to approve the agenda for tonight I'll make a motion thank you Dennis do I have a second second was that Trisha thank you Trisha all those in favor I that was a firm second um I will move on to announcements do we have any
002announcements I mean approval of the minutes approval of the minutes for the January 13th meeting anyone have any comments if not I'll take a motion to approve the minutes from January 13th I'll approve um thank you Mike do I have a second thank you Don all those in favor I I announcements do we have any announcements from the board none tonight hearing none correspondence I don't have any correspondence right now um unfinished business we have no unfinished business so Dr frame we will move on to Red Dead recognition thank you Mr boli um about a year ago the board started uh a practice that is our favorite way to begin meetings uh and that's Red Devil recognitions we'd engaged the community on characteristics that matter most to our school Community here in Clarence and the
003four different things that that really jumped out were Red Devils who are hardworking respectful kind and compassionate and so we have rolling submissions and we have a group that meets and reviews these different nominations and it's been a really meaningful way for us to start our meeting so we have uh four different Red Devil recognitions this evening although a couple of them have more than one recipient and here is our process um I'm going to move over with my microphone in front of the screen with Mr boli our board President we are going to call up the recipient as well as the person who nominated them and if the individual's principal or supervisor is here tonight we're going to have them come up as well uh for a photograph and we're going to read you
004parts of the nomination uh submission and we have a CO a couple token things of things that we like to give and then our Communications person will put together uh a blast for our school community and and want to share people who are really going above and beyond when it comes to teaching and learning here in Clarence so we are excited uh our first Red Devil recognition tonight um is for Mrs shaunessy and Mrs Braun um who lead our unified program in the high school they were nominated by Mary Joe duncle if MJ is here tonight um and I see the high school team is here as well so the high school team can head up uh to the stage as well [Applause] [Music] [Applause] we thought Matt Collins might be with you tonight he
005was was he busy he couldn't couldn't be with you and actually Beth and Kathy um I wonder if we read the brief submission but have just a couple questions for you on the final thing that has brought us all here tonight so we'll put you on the hot seat and um a nomination that was made by Mary Joe duncle a colleague in the student support services department and one that was echoed by the high school leadership team and I'm just going to read a brief bit of what MJ had submitted and then provide just a quick comment or two and then see if you have any final um questions or information on the whole experience this past uh this past winter um so in MJ's um nomination she had written I can't explain the amazing
006amount of time and work that Beth and Kathy provided to organize and fund raise for for the Special Olympics Polar Plunge Beth and C Beth and Kathy are always willing and supportive of developing programming clubs and activities for students with disabilities both are also active members and coaches for The unified clubs and teams they also provide a great environment for all students in the high school they're true role models for us all uh to look up to so incredible Educators incredible human beings but for those who don't know this past year had organized uh a Clarence Polar Plunge team um and first year participating had raised more than any other school community in Western New York it made a m Collins joke because he helped lead us into the water on a really really frigid
007day um as a number of board members can attest um I was going to ask though the total amount raised by the Clarence team for the Special Olympics in Western New York close yeah 35,000 it was close yeah 35,000 so I think when you first announced that you were meeting with our board of education for their tour and you said we've set a goal of $5,000 the high school administrative team is going to participate and I thought oh man they're nuts uh they're that's going to be a stretch to get there just blown away um as importantly uh the environment the expectation you set for making sure that all students all students here in Clarence have a wonderful uh experience and then maybe to give people a quick sneak peek the pep rally that's coming
008up later this year what are the thoughts and the planning on that so we are planned for May 22nd to the pep rally it's going to be during school um we have pemr is going to come and participate with us I just hired a DJ so DJ is going to keep the sound pumping in the gym and I'm happy to do it thanks for the invitation I've got my Neil Diamond record collection ready to go um so just to kind of bring more awareness to our building with our uni kids well you're on the front lines of making sure that we continue to be an inclusive environment and just want to say thank you so if we can give them a round of applause and will scooch in for a photograph and thank you both
009again so come on in yep and if you want to head this way just to shake hands with board members and thanks again uh next up we have Emily Gordon uh who was nominated be by Bethany Hower a colleague and I see Mr bachio come on up congratulations thank you congratulations so a nice theme this evening we started by talking about our unified program The Polar Plunge a unified pep rally coming up um and a lot of connected tissue with the second Red Devil recognition tonight uh for those who don't know Emily she's a faculty member special education teacher in Harris Hill Elementary School she was nominated by uh by Bethany how a colleague uh who works with her on a regular basis and Bethany wrote Emily is a dedicated and warm-hearted teacher she really
010puts in the effort to cater to the diverse needs of her students taking the time to understand each one of them and their unique strengths not only has she introduced some essential life skills lessons but she also seamlessly weaves in instruction for math reading and writing all while all while supporting her students during specials science and social studies what's truly special about Emily is how she Fosters personal connections with her students thanks to her support they feel confident participating and engaging their learning our Board of Education had a chance to connect um with Mrs Gordon and some of her students not too long ago and just incredible the work that you're doing so if we can give uh Mrs Gordon a round of applause I said thank you for all the great work that you're
011doing why don't we scooch in this way for members would love to next up we have Kelsey abramsky who was nominated by Marcia bramski come on up hey Kelsey hey Marcy good to see you here if you come stand right here so we love uh recognizing all sorts of good things that are going on here in Clarence um in a really special nomination you'll see once I read it uh of Kelsey abramsky a high school student here in Clarence by her mom Marcy so Kelsey has always treated staff coaches and students with respect through years in Clarence uh Kelsey was involved in plays chosen for the treble choir not only played Varsity tennis modified and JB basketball but she still attends Varsity games and roots for her team she always truly enjoys giving her time
012and is dedicated to older students with disabilities and coaching unified basketball she is emotionally int ENT and self-aware enough so that she can sense when a student is in need she responds to them as a peer or assists them in utilizing their family counselor or guidance Kelsey has overcome shyness and difficult experiences since she was young to assist her grandfather in Brook Brooklyn through 16 years of lung cancer and spend the rest of her time in Buffalo with her grandmother as she lost her ability to to eat speak and breathe from Alzheimer's uh she's learned a lot and more since um they passing since less than one month apart in 2023 kelse addresses people with compassion uh and she um her involvement in community memory care and in Childhood Cancer Awareness uh came after losing
013a friend a year before he moved one year ago learning how to manage loss is part of who she is and what makes her so compassionate to others she stays to help teachers after events and she's more than worthy of this award she wants a career in a field that helps people she volunteers she wants others to be happy she's hardworking kind and compassionate she is her younger sister biggest fan she always says she loves me because I believe well I most certainly believe in her and what she has and will give back to society I believe that Kelsey deserves this award because she's the quiet person that people know they can go to especially freshmen and kids in her grade who've experienced trauma I know she's my child but I think staff might agree
014she's more of an Angel than a red devil thank you and I want to tell you what what jumped out when the group read the nomination one we love them more of an Angel than a devil uh but more important importantly uh that theme of inclusivity tonight with our unified program a special education teacher from Harris Hill and a recognition that we have a truly inclusive environment when students like Kelsey show up and they make sure that every student here feels like they're seen and cared for uh here at school so we are so proud of you Kelsey congratulation on this well-deserved Red Devil recognition congatulations [Applause] and Kelsey if you'll walk this we our board members would like to say congratulations and last but not least we have Mr Smith Mrs mampy and Mr
015Coniglio and they brought a team of high school leaders so if they join me up here on stage it's Sarah Morgan Naomi Samantha Addison and Gabby I Believe come on up ne ne ne ne come on now so I'm going to read a short bit of the nomination that Mr Smith Mr kigo and Mrs mampy had passed along and then just add a couple couple brief thoughts so this is a group of senior leaders uh from the high school and Mr Smith and his team had ROP these are the student leaders that planed and coordinated the women and stem seminar on Career Fair their amazing students with outstanding leadership skills were so proud of the work that they have done here in the high school and look forward to watching them grow and become Future
016Leaders uh and would just add a couple notes that when we look at uh STEM related professional fields in the United States we see an incredible disparity and have for quite some time uh between men and women in the stem field and a lot of people will will recognize that and acknowledge that and this group said we're going to get involved and so they organized a really powerful stem panel uh for our female students right before holiday recess uh Blown Away listening to a panel of Clarence graduates talk about their professional Fields uh their paths to leadership and what they do today and from top to bottom the event was organized by these students in terms of coordinating with uh the different speakers communicating about it all the different um shirts that were ordered and
017every single bit of the organization was done by this team of leaders and again when we talk about the type of environments that we want it's a a school district where we're here for students and they're the ones that are shaping things and just so blown away uh by who you are as young leaders in the high school the future is bright uh because of people like you so we're so proud of the work you're doing here in Clarence wonderful job with our our stem projects and we'll offer them our congratulations yes does it not matter I don't all on side or do you want being the center doesn't not matter we're good we're good we're good all right so we'll get um certificates mugs and then we'll have you head that way so that
018our Board of Education can say congratulations and thank you all for being here tonight congratulations conratulations congratulations [Music] if you could join us in one last round of applause for this group of recipients tonight and for our Red Devil recipients just so you're you know you're more than welcome to stick around for the rest of the meeting more often than not though uh people have an early start to school tomorrow and we won't be offended at all if you want to duck out uh thank you Mr B Lei that's it for Red Devil recognitions thank you Dr frame we'll give everyone a second okay moving on to board reports policy committee meeting the policy committee met on January 15th uh James Bley o myself and Dr framer in attendance the following Provisions were recommended for
019adoption the first is policy 7220 graduation requirements this was revised to move accelerated an online coursework to separate policies aligning with re recent legal and Regulatory changes the second is policy 5661 Wellness this was updated based on New York State's wellness policy assessment tool and will support the pre-establishment of the district Wellness committee the third is policy 42.1 organizational chart these minor revisions reflect structural changes in the student support services department and finally the fourth policy is of 7553 hazing of students revisions were based on the district insurance carriers recommendation the policy reinforces a commitment to Safe productive and positive learning environment and its content aligns with existing District practices thank you Adrian does anyone have any comments or questions on the policy committee meeting if none I'll move on to CF on we just
020had a quick planning meeting for the faculty basketball game which is March 20th doors open at 5:30 p.m. we'll be sending a flyer home in the next couple of weeks thank you Don yep PTO meetings who's attended a meeting since our last um meeting um the Clarence high school PTO met on February 4th discussion items included post prompt gift G sorry let me try that again the post prompt gift Gathering party which will be held at Murphy Browns on March 4th from 7: to 900 p.m. senior lawn signs which can be ordered now through April 18th um the pictures for senior collages uh can be dropped off from April 1st to May 20th and finally the sheta chicken fundraiser that we all look forward to will be held the day of the budget vote on
021May 20th thank you Adrian do I have any other PTO meeting announcements I think they were last time thank you buy County Association School Board Representatives any updates yes uh James on Friday I attended the virtual uh New York State uh school boards Association U uh virtual uh Capital conference and uh that ran from 8:30 to 12:30 four hours of just packed a lot of information we it started with the conversation with the State education department some of the senior administrators there uh then A Brief Review of the executive budget uh that the governor has proposed um we discussed with some representatives from the governor's office uh we met with uh the chair of the Senate and the assembly legislative uh panel the education legislative panel there was interesting a round table with three reporters
022uh from Albany and then finally um a couple of the uh advocacy officers talked about how to when you do meet with uh uh the Senate and assemblymen uh you know how to go about it how to plan for it so it was it was a very interesting virtual meeting this past Friday thank you Dennis any other announcements for the ER County Association School Board James I had um a couple meetings this past week both executive board and finance committee for Erie County School boards we just discussed General items in budget planning they did also ask that we um make the community aware that they do hold a prospective Schoolboard member um workshop and that um flyer will be available on our website but that event is March um 22nd for anybody that might be
023interested in running for school board thank you D yep any other announcements hearing none Dr frame I'll turn over to you for the superintendent report thank you Mr boli we have three different reports uh tonight um the one that we've been most looking forward to is our presentation from a group from ledg viiew we had the pleasure of gathering there this morning for a tour with Mr kuck we had the chance to visit some classrooms but we're really looking forward to hearing from our students this evening second presentation um uh involves our uh budget planning update we have a series of three different budget hearings and then uh we'll finally adopt later on the spring and then our student body uh report as always so Mr KCK I'm going to turn it over to you
024and your team without further Ado first of we first of all we wanted to thank the school board for coming to LED you this morning we're so excited to show you some different classrooms some of the interesting stuff that's going on you know I was really impressed with the high school leaders we saw today but I think you're going to be equally impressed with these fifth grade leaders that are part of our leadership team um they do a lot for our school they're going to talk a little bit about that in their presentation today um and they organized some stuff they wanted to share with you into the ABCs of ledg viw so we have a little something for each letter to share with you today I also have to give a big shout out
025to thus back here thus was not in school today because he was getting casted from a a fall yesterday and he told his dad and he insisted that he uh wanted to still come tonight we certainly could have planned beat it um but we were super pumped so uh I'm impressed with that dedication and that's really what our leaders are all about at ledg viw so super excited and we're excited we're a little nervous to present to you tonight but I couldn't be more proud of these four and our whole entire leadership team and thank you parents for bringing them tonight so we're going to share with you the ABCs of ledg viiew Welcome to our presentation this evening my name is Luke story when I learned to read I started with my ABCs hi
026my name is aver Bristo after I learned my ABCs I started to put the letters together and they form words hi my name is thadius Taylor after I learned my words I re I read sentences and paragraphs hi my name is Finley fitgerald after I learned to read paragraphs I learned to read books and it was the greatest feeling this prepared me to continue to grow on my journey of learning do you know what else helps us continue to grow on our journey of learning the best El school ever that's right why has been an incredible place for us to start our journey so sit back and relax as we share with you the ABCs of legs view a a stands for assemblies our student leadership team plays a huge role in our assemblies as
027MC's tech support lights stage crew and demonstrators of good things we highlight a healthy habit for kids each month this month we are focused on on putting first things first it is so cool to look out and see all the ledge view lines actively enjoying every minute of our assemblies b b SRA Bandon Orchestra our instrumental music programs are always rocking research has shown that studying an instrument in a band or orchestra program how has improved brain development memory language mental health physical health and social skills it also teaches us things we cannot put into words music is the sound of our emotions we rocked our win winter cost concert last month and look forward to playing New pieces in May at our Spring Concert C C stands for counselor our school counselor is Miss
028garaz once a month she comes into our classrooms and teaches us important lessons we learn how to set goals have empathy and how to express our feelings these are important life skills d d stands for Dave stink our Rockstar custodian he is always available when we need him he clears the sidewalks collects our recycling is on call for mess cleanup and keeps our school running like clockwork we always we love how he always goes above and beyond and we are very grateful for Mr Stang e e stands for equality this year as part of a new social studies curriculum first graders learned about winter holidays celebrated in various cultures they participated in lessons in each first grade classroom in December to learn about dwali Ramadan Quanza and Hanukkah it was extremely interesting f f stands
029for fun days every June our fabulous physical education teachers plan outdoor activities that are exciting simulating and help us celebrate Fitness I love the Earth orbit relay I can't wait for the fifth grade togle board championships this year it is one of the most cherished Traditions at lvw g g stands for goals we set goals daily at LED viw but each year we have a schoolwide goal to raise money for our PTO at the colorathon we are accountability partners for each other we cheack our progress and then we celebrate with color lots of color we have added a pavilion and picnic tables recently with the money we raised H H stands for hola hoopla this year we had an awesome schoolwide celebration after filling our PA of Fame bulletin board the entire school was challenged
030to a Cooperative activity we had to get the hoop from one side of our class line to the other we laughed we moved and we cheered on our Lego Friends even the teachers participated too watching Mr flasar through a hoop was hilarious I stands for integrity officer Pino officer Pino is our school resource officer who displays Integrity in all that she does you can find her helping out with dismissal monit monitoring the cameras reading a book to a class or roaming the school daily at ledg viiew officer Pino greets us with a smile is always willing to help and support us in anything we need and she keeps us safe Jay Jay stands for jokes jokes jokes every Wednesday on our announce video announcements we like to start out morning with some fun telling a
031Wacky Wednesday joke always makes W Wednesday wonderful we even include jokes in our assemblies hey dadus why does it take a pirate so long to learn the alphabet I don't know because they spend years at [Laughter] c k k stands for kindergarten play workshops it sure is good to be a kindergartener learning through play is the best it builds imagination language skills and strengthens friendships the current technology department created amazing play structures to help the kindergarteners have purposeful and engaging play experiences it is so awesome that our district came together to help shape the best learning experience for our kindergarteners our school board members got to see one in action this morning during their visit at ledg viiew l L stands for leadership team our school leadership team is made up of motivated fifth graders
032who want to make a difference at their school and and in the community the leaders plan and fill morning announcements help run assemblies clean up our building help in classrooms after school and complete a few community service projects each year it's great to be such a big part of what happens in our school I know several fourth graders that are looking forward to this opportunity next year and we absolutely love working with Miss nto and Mrs Stevens who are in charge of the group m m stands for mascot race the ledge viiew mascot race is now an annual event each year our school comes together to learn about voting and then we can watch the fun unfold with a captivating video of the race to the Finish Line these characters know how to make a
033smile and laugh out loud laughter is the best medicine n n stands for new says Leu has the best teachers and staff we are so excited to have Miss Bello and Mr swante join not only our L lying Pride but our fifth grade team already they have added spunk and Pizzazz to our daily lives Mr swantek even completed the famous pirate SHP Challenge and fed class oh oh stands for outstanding PTO thank you for creating awesome events at ledg viw like our Fall Fest winter mie night hoo's birthday the book fair and even the student parent dance this past Friday for our fifth and fourth graders they help make lasting memories for us here at l view we appreciate all the time they put into our school P P stands for Paws paw prints are
034schoolwide initiatives and this year there are some new color Paws we can earn we work hard each day so that teachers teacher aids bus drivers cafeteria monitors and Mr CUA can catch us doing positive things and living the seven habits of healthy kids that we learn about we live the habits daily and display our paw proudly on the pause of Fame bulletin board at our assemblies we pick a red paw winner that a class earned together and they can earn recess with the principal principal positively awesome q q stands for quality art show our incredible art teacher Miss Deo creates a colorful creative and inspire ing art show Miss steil fills our school with every students's artwork showing our ledge viw Community the creativity and talent we have in our school we hope you can
035make it this year r r sentral robotics in the in the library this year with Miss Greger we are using Osmos that we borred from the Eerie one bosis pilot program we use iPads to code solve problems with tangrams and practice our spelling and math it is so much fun for all students from kindergarten to grade five s s stands for service projects this year the fourth graders at LED viiew raised $1,000 for the punt Foundation supporting pediatric cancer by making and selling bracelets some kids made over 50 bracelets to sell kindergarten also had a giving party they made PL place mats door hangers and put together blessing bags for Brothers of Mercy the clarents food pantry and Children's Hospital our students learn the importance of giving back to others T te stands for therapy
036dog Snickers is our school therapy dog who visits us every Tuesday with Mrs Stevens in fact kids's eyes light up when he comes into their room we get to pet him hug him play Rock Paper Scissors and share snuggles these snuggles help calm us relieve our stress and give us Comfort having Snickers visit US Weekly teaches us about empathy and how to nurture others you you stands for upk we were so excited to welcome two classes of preschoolers to ledge viw this year we love including them in some fun activities their favorite spot to visit is Mr Den's music class to participate in movement and music they also love popping visits from the Snickers and the lady they call Snickers [Laughter] mom v v stands for very cool School celebrations when we fill our paw
037print bullet bullettin board we earn a schoolwide celebration last year we had a dance party in the gym with strobe lights and VIPs that wor glow bracelets this year our office staff helped us win a hot cocoa cart it was delicious it was so much fun that we could celebrate our achievements as a whole school w w stands for weekly morning video announcements our leadership team creates Wednesday video morning announcements we inform our students about the lunches of the day birthdays Buffalo sports updates jokes and more making our video announcements is one of the best parts of the student leadership team we feel we are making a difference in our school x x stands for extracurricular activities Le VI has the best after school programs some of our favorites are Nitro ball Club Snickers bracelet
038Club chess club and and competive games why why stands for yearly fun track meet Every Spring all third fourth and fifth graders have the opportunity to participate in our districtwide all elementary track meet over 140 students can run jump and throw as they show off the skills they learned in physical education what a fantastic way to bring all elementary students and Clarance together C C stands for our zesty mascot Leo Leo the Lion is spunky energetic has the best dance moves and loves to keep the energy at LED you roaring you never know when he is going to show up and it always seems to be a mystery as to who is inside of that lion costume thank you for taking the time to listen to our presentation we feel so grateful to go to
039school as wonderful as Leg view the faculty staff PT and Community create the best learning environment for our students we would like to leave you with a bracelet made by our fourth graders as to thank you for all that you do for a school and District go clearance and go legs viw I just want to say thank you very much for the presentation we had a great tour of the school today did all of you do the pirate ship challenge did all of you try that yes you did I it also and I'm working on it this year L thank you so much thank you great job thank you great job thank you I just want to say you guys must be super special that you got Mr Stang to come today thank you so
040much any before our student leaders take off any final questions or comments for members of our board well ledgeview has just about 500 students to be picked for this team is a big deal but after your presentation it is not hard to see why awesome job tonight uh and you had a chance like Mr cook I think was saying we had some senior leaders that were recognized as Red Devils uh this evening that doesn't happen by accident in their senior year we've got leaders all the way up so wonderful job tonight we are so so proud of you we're going to give this Dr FR I just want to thank them for the bracelets they look great absolutely [Music] all right second up for reports this evening we have our second uh budget planning presentation
041uh I'm going to go through a series of slides tonight I'm going to focus on areas that are new if the slides look familiar and then we are going to dive a little bit deeper into three different operational parts of our organization this evening so as always just to give you an agenda to look at again we're going to give some updated assumptions things that will become more specific the further along the budget planning process we get and then we are going to tackle three different departments in more detail tonight uh if you have questions or comments uh I'll do my best to uh respond to them and uh Dr grupka I'm sure can provide additional invitation as well so we always go through our budget timeline recognizing that our proposed spending plan that will
042eventually go out to the Community it isn't uh something that's pulled together in a week or two this really is a process that begins in the fall and goes through the budget vote in May so you can see we're in many ways about halfway through that uh through that process so we often times when we uh provide updates talk a little bit about Revenue projections in terms of where funds come from uh anticipated expenditures uh because we have such a large organization we'll focus specifically on uh different items that we think have the potential to impact our spending plan and again dive into more detail with three different operational items uh departments tonight so uh on the topic of uh Revenue projections uh since the last time we had met the governor had given her
043stateof the state address and about a week later had offered what are called the governor's run so uh she'll make a proposal in terms of what she thinks makes sense with regard to education funding in New York State's budget and then the foundation Aid formula is the primary driver at this state level of funding public school education in New York state there is a long complicated equation that was reviewed uh by the Rockefeller Institute over the past year and it really is looking at the foundation Aid formula that runs to provide school districts with what the state believes is an appropriate education for school districts I would just make a note that uh when you look at different School communities there funding their Foundation Aid amounts differ greatly based on uh a number of factors
044in their school community so we actually were pleasantly surprised I was reviewing some notes from about a year ago when the governor had come out with uh her initial budget proposal and runs she had made a couple minor changes to the foundation Aid formula that had a pretty big impact uh in terms of this year the Rockefeller Institute put together a very detailed uh report and you can see on this slide that when uh the governor had come out with her calculations close to a 5% increase when it comes to Foundation Aid and New York State Clarence was a district that received for this current year the same amount in Foundation Aid that it had the previous year and so we were anticipating a fairly level year-to-year projection with regard to a foundation Aid and
045received a pleasant surprise that when the governor's runs came out the district uh would receive under the governor's proposal close to $800,000 of additional Foundation Aid funding so that sets aside different formula uh AIDs that exist in New York state but when we look at anticipated fronts from New York state that's good news I would just make a caution that if somebody is uh skimming a newspaper article and it sees that Governor's runs that's not the amount of money that would go to public schools certainly not a clearance it's the first step in a budget conversation so we would expect a one- housee budget from the assembly and from the Senate a negotiation will take place and eventually we will have uh School runs that come out for districts we're lucky to have strong Advocates
046uh working uh for the district is a partner in Albany uh and would just like to acknowledge and and recognize Senator gallivan's office for being with us tonight and for your support and advocacy as we move through this process so when we think about funds coming from New York State have received some information since the last time we met it's balanced with a recovs grant that we received about a year ago that was a uh a sum of just over $800,000 dollars payable to the district over a two-year period to support mental health needs in the district important to just acknowledge the fact that in the fall that funding will go away and for most public school districts right now uh we're receiving on a regular basis updates from Washington DC uh we don't receive
047the bulk of our funds from the federal level but changes in messages regarding Federal funding has school districts watching that very closely we've seen reductions in a couple federal funds over the pre previous couple years uh and we like a lot of public school officials are watching that information closely as we pay attention to title Grant so that's that middle bullet thinking about funds that we receive from other sources than our local school Community the bulk of our funding for schools comes in the form of property tax revenue right here in the Clarence Central School District the property tax cap is due March 1 uh there is a state portal where districts input a lot of information some of that information is pre-populated some is entered by Dr grupka it'll generate our property tax cap
048that we should be able to share with the Board of Education as we get ready for our next um our next budget hearing the one part of our um our property tax cap formula that we're watching is our growth factor here in Clarence we believe that'll be uh finalized by uh the end of this week beginning of next week and then we should be able to uh calculate what we believe our Pro property tax cap will be and then we don't anticipate any major changes from uh Erie County sales tax so that's an update in terms of uh projected Revenue with regard to expenditures assumptions that we're making at this point in time uh first and foremost uh looking at our contractual agreements just important to note that when we have contracts that are in
049place it's it's relatively easy to anticipate what some of those financial needs may be uh it's typical in a school our size to be to be negotiating one or two collective bargaining agreements at any point in time uh and while those are in process it's not we're not able to uh predict with as much certainty uh what those assumptions will be with regard to healthcare we have some good news the increases that we're predicting this year are smaller than what we have seen in the past couple years but there's still increases and need to be accounted for I believe the TRS ERS rate information utility special education and liability Reserve information are similar to what we had shared in our previous previous presentation I would maybe just pause for a second to talk about liability
050insurance as an industry we're seeing increased premiums for school organizations uh go up and this is not a small item in our budget this is a significant Financial commitment when we think about liability insurance and part of that contribution will come up in our transportation department when we go over some of the uh line um increases that we're seeing in different parts of our budget so there's an update in terms of projected revenues and expenditures the real Focus tonight is to do a little bit deeper dive in three different areas and then see if there are questions or comments from members of our governance team we've gone over this slide before it gives us an accurate sense of uh the scope and responsib ilities of our transportation department that's the first area that we're going
051to talk about this evening you can see our different Rider responsibilities uh listed on the leand column of the slide you can see the number of District employees and we also know from previous reports and conversations that we have currently 22 runs that are uh privately contracted something that we see in most larger school districts here in Erie County uh and hoping to take back some of those runs with uh an aggressive recruiting uh push this uh this spring and summer summer so I'm going to pull up a slide that'll go over different components of our transportation department budget make a couple comments on them uh and we'll uh tackle questions and comments from the the governance team as we move forward so uh what you can see here are anticipated staff increases we do
052have a specific number for this current school year at this particular point in time because we are moving through the collective bargaining process uh it's hard for us to estimate with certainty what the final uh cost will be for the 5 26 year so that's why you see TBD listed a couple different times on this slide uh we do again have in some ways a hybrid Department we have individuals who are employed directly here in the district and we also contract a number of runs out with a a private organization Western New York bus so we have in many ways a hybrid bus fleet uh although the majority of those Western New York uh runs have private runs special education runs and a couple now in some of our different uh parts of our school
053Community uh so moving from staff to contra Ed runs you can see uh an anticipated almost 12% increase year-to-year um we are hoping to move from 22 runs to 20 runs next year uh we enter into a multi-year agreement with an outside bus company and those contracts are subject to CPI increases so as we move toward next year we'll need to keep an eye on that so there's the number of runs as well as the CPI factor in our agreement with this outside partner with regard to contractual cost you can see a relatively large uh percentage increase there of just about 25% uh some of the reasons for that are partnering with a group through bosis that has been able to come in they've provided an audit or in the process of providing an audit
054of our transportation department have provided and continue to provide ongoing assistance for uh members of our transportation department uh provide professional development and uh and continued guidance and are really appreciative of that relationship uh we have software costs with a routing system and different training and uh uh professional development responsibilities that come with that part of the uh that part of our budget and then a fairly minimal Supply uh cost so that's our focus on Transportation uh a bit of information just on that item of note and again it goes back to the CPI which would be attached to our contracted runs uh with our transportation department when people go to the polls in May they'll also see a a proposition for a bus purchase there's a recommendation for three 70 passenger buses 2 35
055passenger vans and one snowplow maybe just a quick comment on that middle item is that uh although we have an outside uh bus company that is providing some support they use our buses uh as they make their runs what we have found though is that because we have individuals or small groups of students or teams that go to different places it's nice to have smaller Vehicles some of which don't need to be operated by individuals with a CDL so that has provided a uh that has provided some additional flexibility so that's why you'll see the recommendation for 2 35 passenger vans so our first Department of focus is our transportation department this evening our second is a focus on our buildings and grounds Department again you can get a sense in terms of what the
056uh department does in order to make sure that we're a safe and dynamic place to learn and then the number of District employees that are involved in the department again as we go through this uh expend this projected expenditure line uh right now as we move through the collective bargaining process you'll see TBD uh for staff members under the 2526 category you'll see some anticipated contractual cost some utility cost and then a supply cost and I want to spend a little bit of time talking about what's in that Supply section of our buildings and grounds uh our buildings and grounds budget as an overall comment it's important to note that when we put together an anticipated spending plan we can anticipate some things with a high degree of certainty and some things are much more
057challenged ing I'll give an example of utility costs we'll put in our budget an anticipated expense for utilities hoping that at the end of the year there's some left over that can be applied to other parts of the budget we're seeing projected increases of 15 20 30% when it comes to Natural Gas and Electric right now so it's really important for us to tighten up that part of the budget and anticipate with this High degree of certainty as possible about what our utility costs will be next year so I make that comment because in the past we've had the ability to move some funds from utilities to supplies we don't anticipate that happening next year and so we've made some adjustments to the supply part of our budget in addition to that uh we also
058anticipate spending $60,000 for security door upgrades and camera upgrades security camera upgrades out of this part of the budget important to acknowledge the fact that uh there is a safety related part of funding from New York state where we would receive Aid back on that $60,000 expense um and we also have taken on a number of U maintenance projects in different buildings whether it's outside Landscaping projects uh whether it's painting different classrooms office spaces or hallways whether it's sidewalk and uh parking lot repair that wouldn't be included in a capital project those are all localized projects that our team has undertaken outside of a capital project so those expenses have been uh built into the budget as well and then just looking at the impact that inflation has uh that inflation has had so when
059we think about supplies our paper comes out of that part of the budget our postage comes out of that part of the budget and we've seen increases uh as they move toward next year and one final note uh our board of education has talked about uh as because safety is a priority adding a fourth school resource officer uh if possible moving into next year and that would come out of the contractual section of this part of the budget and again some of those different notes that I had just talked about uh as we think about our buildings and grounds Department the final Department to focus on tonight is our technology department again you can see their responsibilities with regard to the uh technology in the district you can see the uh team members uh that
060are responsible for this work and then again some changes uh that we'll comment on that have to do with supplies equipment uh and contractual parts so I'm actually going to do this I'm going to ask you to take a close look at this slide and then I'm going to move to the next slide just to talk a bit about what's different as we move from this current year to next uh year because you'll see in the equipment section and the supply section in particular larger increases for anybody who is involved in public education spaces or the world of technology they'll remember a time when districts came out with pilot programs for things like onetoone devices well most school districts have moved beyond that and have one-to-one environments in which all students and staff members have
061the those devices and school districts have had to put together purchasing plans for those devices that are forward thinking that have replacement cycles and so for us that's meant taking uh these budgets back in or taking these uh devices and the funding back into our general uh education budget our general fund budget so that they can be provided for from year to year and also a recognition that when Investments are made in the field of Technology they may be made at a point in time and you may not have to make them again for 5 or 10 years years but they're expensive and they're important when it comes to running an organization the size of the Claren Central School District and so those are things that will that we anticipate impacting our budget next year
062to focus on a number of them specifically first and foremost is thinking about our onetoone device program uh Dr grupka has been working with Mr rir and our partners at bosis on a long-term plan for replacing those different devices and what we plan on doing is entering into an IPA with bosis where essentially we pay for devices over a 5year period it's sort of like a lease agreement where we would contribute a little bit over $100,000 a year and at the end of that period would own the devices so it's to try to avoid a significant hit in a year so we we look at the expense that would go into those different devices we also need to recognize that while the onetoone devices may be the most visible part of our instructional work in
063in a public school district they're supported by servers that very few people have access to so we have more than 60 servers in the district uh that that enables us to run all of our different programs um here here in our buildings um and they have different components in them so if you move from the first bullet to the second when we think about different computer cost and anticipated software cost for next year there are your regular vendor increases our VMware uh it's it's been moved from one company to a next this is our software that runs all of our servers and so this is a significant financial uh commitment for a technology department but an important one as we think about running those different servers we also have uh projected um increases with regard
064to Hardware in our technology department and an e- rate project just under $400,000 so we talked about with VMware the switch in terms of company that's essentially the software that runs our servers when it comes to the backbone of our servers and being able to communicate with them and between them that's when we would think about an e-rate project and an e-rate project uh is covered um with about 40% in federal funds that pass through bosis so while the initial cost may be close to $400,000 for the district almost half of that will be returned using federal funds but this is maintaining a server system that has been in place for about a decade so we haven't had ongoing cost for some of these servers we're trying to take care of some of the work
065in a capital project to use some eate funding Bose funding and to build it into general education funding I just have a question just watching what's going on should we be concerned that those federal funds may not be coming uh I would just say that public school districts right now um are watching it closely uh we had all read about the freezing of federal funds and very quickly uh there was a change we're reading uh different things in the paper now about uh what the education department at the federal level might look like and it's speculation at this particular point in time I had gathered with a group of school superintendents on Friday there's a Professional Organization for superintendents there's an expert in terms of uh legislative action and school financing that was with us
066to provide a report and said it certainly is something that he's watching closely and communicating with superintendents across the state about my guess is that different Professional Organization for teachers support staff members business officials are doing the same so anything that we are looking at with federal funds we're watching more closely so this is something that school districts haven't had to think a ton about uh in recent years and now are following very closely I'm just thinking about planning forward we shouldn't rely on 40% so we just be cognizant that that might not be there sure uh and again that the challenge for us with some of these cost is trying to figure out when they need to be addressed how can we do it in a way that makes the most sense as long
067as that funding stream is there it makes sense for the district if that were to go away we'd have to Circle back to look at how to support what really is needed to uh to keep us function with regard to hardware and software in the district and mat those data switches will those work with the new servers that we're getting as part of the capital project correct correct yeah and as a member of the facilities committee thinking about the capital project that uh we're moving forward with planning on after its approval this past December that's a part of it so looking at the previous Capital project looking at some of the work that is uh that is ongoing it's trying to be creative uh and as cost effective a way U relying on state aid
068reling on relying on E rate funding uh to to make sure that our our system is capable of supporting what it needs to I should also just not as we're talking about eate funding and what would be returned to the district um in addition to that in addition to some safety related funding for upgrades on doors and upgrades on cameras when we talk about Transportation expenses a significant portion of that comes back to The District in Aid and that's noted on the budget sheet or the budget so we'll get more accurate numbers as we move forward correct in which particular area with the the aid money that's coming back also I guess I have two questions on the transportation section you had mentioned that we have the on the bus Bosey service is that something
069new uh yes that's a partnership brand new expense correct that's a partnership that we had started this year okay and then in the you said insurance is up the liability insurance is like that's a high percentage of that increase a significant uh significant increase and that's something that we're seeing in the industry and across the state there it's not unique to Clarence it's something that all public school districts are experiencing how does it work with the liability with the contracted runs does that cost us more in liability do we have to pay for them and for ours and I just I you can get back to us on that in a Dr gr may be able to answer tonight so we would we would be paying to ensure the buses no matter what so um
070yes we do pay to ensure all of our vehicles we pay to ensure all of our our vehicles um that being said what we're saving by using our vehicles and Far Far outweighs what we spend on insurance but in addition we have we have the security of knowing that our kids are driving on newer buses that are well conditioned in good shape we have somebody out there checking them regularly um we have them inspected by our own mechanics so it gives me a little bit of um a a feeling of security knowing that our kids are on on our buses we we control that um if you look at some of the buses that vendors are using they're far beyond 10 years old um they're not well-kept they're not quite frankly not always clean on
071the inside by using our buses that ensures that our kids are are in a nice environment on their way to school in terms of next uh steps we'll continue working with uh members of our school commun to to narrow our Focus uh in different parts of our budget again we'll finalize the tax cap calculation we will reach out and and engage with our elected officials not only Senator gallian's office but also assemblyman Bologna's office um we'll wait for those final state aid allocations we hope to have that by April 1st although um oftentimes they're a couple different days late uh and again working with our team on a spending plan that we think makes sense for our school Community with regard to vote day information uh you can see it's Tuesday May 20th uh 7
072uh to 9 no changes in terms of uh the time and location uh the first proposition would be the 2025 26 proposed budget the school vehicle purchase plan and then two Board of Education seats uh that are up uh for next year I maybe would just offer one final comment and then to see if there are uh as feedback or questions or concerns from the Board of Education with regard to technology again challenging as districts are finding ways to integrate regular um regular needs into their general fund budget recognizing that there are spikes and we're going through that right now as we try to find cost effective ways to maintain the servers that are so critical for our learning environment here in Clarence and also a recognition that when we think about K12 education often
073times school districts would wait to do some end of the year purchasing to put together um what was needed for uh technology for the upcoming year and we all know that Tech is such an important part of what we do every day that those costs have got to be have they got to be built into our general fund budget and so that's not a one-year process it's a multi-year process of end ofe funding has been used to support different things so um just wanted to acknowledge the work that Patty and Bob have done uh to bring these things into the general fund budget so that we can uh budget for them in the future in tighter ways when it comes to percentage increases year-to year so there's an update for members of our governance team
074questions or feedback I'd be happy to provide some thoughts or turn things over to Dr gra and I do have a just a comment if you could maybe talk to a little bit I get constantly get asked in the community why we would buy buses if we have to go to E Vehicles do you can you talk to that a bit yeah why don't I turn it over to Dr grub because she is quarterbacking uh that required process with regard to electric buses so while I I know that we do need to go to E Vehicles the reality is we're not sure what the what our capacity is going to be at this point so we are going through the study there are some districts that are doing one and two at a time but
075the reality is I don't know that that we they have not said to us whether or not we even have the infrastructure to move forward so we will be replacing our buses in the regular cycle until we can figure out if we even have the infrastructure to do this and if we have the community support So if you think about this we're going to need to have Chargers we're going to need to replace the Chargers more often than you replace the electric buses is that something that nobody's really talked about too much um we have to have the electrical station installed that's something the electric company would have to do for us um we're just not quite there yet so in the meantime we are going to be replacing our buses so that our kids
076are not on buses more than 10 years old appropriate too to note uh the role that advocacy should be playing on this issue I know that uh Erie County has an effective legislative team I know that this is one of their articulated areas certainly for superintendents and other professional groups across the state uh there is a real Upstate downstate divide if you're in New York City and you're having a conversation about electric vehicles it means something very different than when you come above the Hudson Valley and you certainly get into Western New York the North country and the Southern Tier um and it doesn't seem like that message has fully gotten through to elected officials in Albany recognizing the financial strain that this would put on Upstate communities in particular and so never miss an
077opportunity to advocate and hope that Senator Gallivan will take that message back to Albany I had a conversation with assemblyman bolognia a couple weeks ago I believe that he's working on a piece of legislation uh that would tackle this issue and just stress The Divide between Upstate and downstate you won't talk to a school official in Upstate New York who sees this as a realistic path forward but it doesn't appear that it's picked up the level of traction in Albany that we would anticipate it having done so we hope that that level of advocacy will ramp up uh certainly in the months to come it is definitely a legislative priority Yeah final questions or comments for members of our governance Team all right thanks everyone and last up is Olivia for a student representative report
078so the week before break is always the hardest to get through but um pushing through it next week we're going to be a break sleeping in enjoying life but to start off the first week or the first winter homecoming was hosted this past weekend by the senior class it was a very fun night and atmosphere with lots of Chick-fil-A um the senior class also held a Spirit Week leading up to the dance where uh we had r devil day on Friday and the devil walked around the school and took pictures with everyone various art students from the high school were able to Showcase their art at UB and Damon in an art show and that showcased the amount of talent at Clarence I saw some of the pictures on Instagram amazing work I don't I
079couldn't even fathom doing that amazing job the NHS induction took place at the high school where 86 students were inducted to the Clarence High School chapter the high school band concert the concert symphonic and jazz band performed at the high school this past week and the course will have their sacred concert tomorrow at UB at slee Hall and the wi Ensemble also took a field trip last Friday to the BP where they um saw classical music being played and last thing for the high school is last week a student panel of seniors uh shared their experiences with Williamsville students about our late later start times and at the panel many great conversations were held and I hope that Williamsville students were able to connect and uh get ideas from students like myself who love late
080start times and love sleeping in but yeah so I hope they learned something from us the middle school held their Hollywood dance where they walked the red carpet and took Celebrity level pictures and the little Little Mermaid took stage or should I say C but um this past weekend and everyone had a swimmingly good time good that was good she'll be here all yeah like like I'm such a comedian um the elementary schools participated in formal Friday a day where students and staff showed up to school in their best looks and Sharon Hill held a food drive for the Clarance food pantry and also Candy Bar Bingo that's all have thank you thank you you thanks Olivia and that's it Mr bog LLY for reports this evening thank you I don't believe it excuse me
081any public comments correct no public comment moving on we will go to um Finance Dr grupka wait is there a public comment sure there's uh there's usually a a signup card that goes to Mr ble so that's how we know if there's public comment would you like me to wait till next month no all right I'll make it snappy that I'm sorry I didn't realize we had to do that this um my name is Michelle bronberg I'm a recent retiree of the district my daughter goes to the high school uh I'm just really here to speak on behalf of our CA members so I just wrote down a few things that I wanted to read uh from my phone and I apologize for having to look down and not look at all of you but
082I don't want to forget what I've written um but before I do that I do want to thank everybody that is up here I know that you guys have a very difficult and important job that is not often acknowledged and probably not understood well as well so I just want to preface my thoughts with that and also had to acknowledge the ogoc Olivia C over there um again my name is Michelle I'm here to speak about the invaluable work done by the support staff in our schools uh the smooth operation of school district relies on the collective effort of a range of dedicated professionals each playing a critical role in ensuring that students and faculty have the support they need to succeed throughout my career as a school psychologist I have had the privilege of
083witnessing firsthand the significant role these dedicated individuals play in fostering both academic success in a nurturing School environment our teach teacher aids work alongside classroom teachers to provide a consistent and stable environment for all students particularly those with varying academic needs or emotional struggles when when substitute teachers are in the classroom it is often the AIDS who provide the continuity and familiarity that is critical to the student day-to-day experience in many cases these individuals are often the ones who know the routines schedules and curricular demands as well as anyone else students form strong attachments to these staff members often seeing them as teachers themselves many of our crisis teams are made up of these AIDS deep knowledge of their students allows them to handle difficult situations with calm and effective responses de-escalating crises and and
084offering a listening ear when it is most needed beyond their critical role in academics and crisis management teacher aids are also Central to maintaining school safety and building a positive School culture their presence and dedication to our students Fosters a sense of community that cannot be overstated our School nurses respond to emergencies manage chronic health conditions and promote overall Wellness their presence ensures that students and staff alike are safe and healthy but all all while minimizing disrup to learning the clerical staff are the backbone of school administration managing communication schedules and paperwork their organizational skills keep day-to-day functions running smoothly making it possible for all to focus on education our cleaners and custodians maintain a safe and sanitary environment which is critical for both health and morale a clean well-maintained school not only reduces the
085risk of illness but also creates a positive atmosphere where people feel welcome and comfortable bus drivers are often the first and last point of contact for students ensuring Safe And Timely Transportation the role is vital for ensuring that students arrive at School ready to learn and return home safely at the end of the day it professionals are the silent force behind a school's ability to harness technology to improve teaching learning and overall operations their expertise ensures that the digital aspects of Education function seamlessly making them indispensable to both the present future of our school district together these professionals create a foundation that supports the academic and emotional well-being of students and enables teachers to focus on what they do best educating and fostering growth the collaborative efforts of all School Personnel are indispensable to the
086success of the entire district and the future of every student I can say with confidence that our schools would not be as successful or as vibrant without these hardworking individuals their contributions both in the classroom and throughout the district are vital to the academic excellence and positive culture that we strive to create for our students thank you for your time and for recognizing the importance of the support staff in our schools they are truly a Cornerstone of our educational system thank you thank you very [Music] [Applause] much so hearing no further public comments we will go to finance Dr grupka thank you today I'm going to ask for approval of our December financials schedule of bills and check warrants um um approval of a Perma sensory deescalation Grant I wanted to thank Angela gup Nagel
087from Perma for helping with this also Mr picachio and Miss rich rich Reese who worked on the grant with me um I'm asking for approval of our ties coordinator contract that is a person that is for a person who assists with our special education finding placement for our students um approval of the contract for Buffalo construction and Caden architect for the upcoming project approval of a bond resolution for borrowing for the upcoming project we will not be borrowing right away as we're using $3 million of repair Reserve first um and then a resolution to use repair Reserve to repair the high school pool and panic button and to install Panic buttons thank you Dr gep any comments or questions I F1 through f8 hearing none I'll take a motion to approve items F1 through f8
088I'll make a motion thank you Denis do I have a second a second thank you Cindy all those in favor I I the motion passes Personnel Dr Mr Michelle uh first our instructional we have a few resignations coaching position some clubs and two instructional positions prior appointments this month are just for a regular substitute teacher that was already in place as a long-term sub appointments this month we have spring coaching positions a mentor position and M uh Middle School AIS position in the tree house P4 curriculum writing projects from Dr overhal as well as we have P5 with presentation compensation P6 are changes to our substitute list and p7 is extending the date of a previously proved Mo MOA from the CTA thank you Mr Michelle any questions it P1 through p7 hearing none I'll
089take a motion to approve items P1 through p7 I'll make a motion thank you Don do I have a second I'll second thank you Adrian all those in favor I hi hi the motion passes um Mr Michelle non-instructional we have five resignations one is for retirement thank you Mr Kowski for 17 years of service to our district prior appointments we have clerk teacher Aid lifeguard labor and a substitute bus monitor appointments for this evening we have an additional clerk a few more monitors and a maintenance mechanic and P11 are the changes to our substitute list thank you Mr Michelle any questions items p8 through P1 hearing none I'll take a motion to approve items p8 through P1 I'll make a motion thank you Trisha do have a second thank you Dawn all those in favor
090I I motion passes special needs miss sheska the committee on special education met for 13 days and is asking for approval on the recommended services for 35 students the committee on preschool special education met for8 days and is asking for approval on the recommended services for 15 students thank you Mr any questions or comments on S1 and S2 hearing none I'll take a motion to approve items S1 and S2 motion thank you s do I have a second I'll second thank you Adrian all those in favor I I the motion passes Dr frame board development yep uh there's a recommendation uh to approve a music field trip to Connecticut uh a model un conference to Washington DC and then four different information items the um first reads of four policies that were presented earlier this
091evening any questions items B1 through B6 hearing none I'll take an it a motion to approve item B1 and B2 I'll make a motion thank you Dawn do I have a second a second thank you Dennis all those in favor I I the motion passes on committee the whole items we have a schedule upcoming meetings our believe our next meeting is March 3rd and then upcoming events they're in your packet with that I'll make a motion to go back into an executive discuss to discuss a Personnel matter do I have a motion I'll make a motion thank you Dennis do I have a second second thank you Cindy all those in favor I I