001hello hi hi everyone the board has returned from executive session and there were no actions taken may I have a motion to open the meeting Lisa may I have a second Heather all in favor thank you um let's rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all perfect so we're going to go slightly out of order um and start with uh the Lloyd Harbor student presentation so you're up Lloyd harber come on up h good evening Cold Spring Harbor Board of Education thank you for having us here tonight to speak to you I'm Maddie Durk student council president last October we had many student council happenings occurring
002to start off we had a spirit day to wear pink for breast cancer awareness month speaking of spirit days every Friday at LHS we wear Colts Spring Harbor or Lloyd Harbor School gear to show our spirit for Halloween we ran a treats for troops candy Drive students donated WRA candy which we sorted so that the troops spread out across the world could enjoy a treat for all their hard work which we appreciate every day after collecting all of the candy the pacy family dropped it off at a hospital which was collecting for the treats for troops cause we advertise all of these things on LTB during our Lloyd Harbor School morning announcements the four of us have gotten accustomed to running LTV every single morning every week we have an assigned job this week my
003job is live stream meaning that I stream it on YouTube and work on all of the transitions other jobs consist of teleprompter assistant and sound which we have been taught how to do by Mrs odonnell Mrs sherf and Miss steel who help us run LTV students of all ages can be an anchor or singer on LTV they can also do a what to read Wednesday segment or words of wisdom we recently added a new segment called try something new Tuesday where kids can demonstrate something some of their talents we have learned sign language and how to write Chinese words other things we have advert other things we have advertised are different drives such as the Thanksgiving food drive which Riley our treasure is going to talk to you [Applause] about thanks Maddie good evening I'm
004Riley Luben Lloyd Harbor student council treasure for the 2024 to 2025 school year this year all the students were informed about an extra credit assignment called operation Greenlight for this assignment students had the opportunity to put up a green light outside or inside their houses to show their support for the veterans they would then have to take a picture with the light and the pictures then were shown on the LTV episodes another thing our students have done to show their appreciation is making the veterans thank you cards for Veterans Day students Dre patriot patriotic pictures wrote famous quotes or wrote like letters to show their appreciation the letters were dropped off at the ve off dropped off for the veterans at the VA hospital in Northport we hope the veterans know how much we value
005their hard work and sacrifices we continued our annual Thanksgiving food drive and it was a huge success we were so lucky that our community was able to help put food on the holiday table for other others that that are less fortunate we filled so many boxes with pasta cookies canned goods and much more we had so much fun this November and now Annabelle will tell you some of the winter fun that's that's happened this December thanks Riley I'm Annabelle Kelly Lloyd Harbor school's secretary and I'm going to be telling you a little bit about what happened in the L in Lloyd Harbor in the month of December to start off the month the student council held a toy drive where students could donate brand new toys to kids in Need for the holidays these toys
006were donated to the help donated to the Helping Hands Rescue Mission the donated toys B brought great joy to the kids that were less fortunate this holiday season to show how excited Lloyd Harbor school was for the upcoming holidays we created Spirit Week to show our holiday spirit for example the first day of spirit week was a holiday hat day the first um I particip I partici I participated by wearing a Santa hat we ended the spirit week off with a fan favorite by many Lloyd Harbor students Pajama Day Pajama Day includes wearing comfy holiday clothes or just your favorite pair of pajamas on Friday before winter break all Lloyd Harbor students and teachers gathered in the gym for school assembly this assembly was run by me and my fellow student council officers Additionally the
007entire school was involved with the secret snowman activity a Lloyd Harbor a Lloyd Harbor staff member was assigned to a class and provided three clues for the students in that class without telling them who they who they were at the assembly at the assembly class representatives got to share their class secret snowman's guess and the student council officers told the Reps from each grade if their guess was correct after all classes finished guessing we had a fun holiday sing along keeping all Lloyd Harbor students very entertained and now I'm going to pass it on to CJ who will tell you more about multiple drives and other events going on in Lloyd Harbor in January and February thank you Annabelle hello Cold Spring Harbor Board of Education I CJ pacy Lloyd heror school vice president and
008today I will be talking about Lloyd Harbor's current fundraisers and a special surprise on our bulletin board the two current fundraisers at Lloyd Harbor consist of the animal shelter Supply drive and the super bow drive for the animal shelter Drive the student council is collecting supplies such as laundry detergent towels treat no toys treats laundry detergent and beach towels and paper towels all the way to shampoo and conditioner that would be used for the cats and dogs baths the Kids Place their items in a Box near the front and back Circle entrances all of the supplies will be donated to the local animal shelter in Huntington secondly we have our yearly soup herbal drive for this drive even though the name of the drive is the soup herbal Drive we've been collecting canned goods from
009soup all the way to things like beans like the animal shelter Drive the students leave can leave the cans in boxes near the entrances afterwards the cans will be sent back sent to a stock food pantry at The Helping Hands Rescue Mission in Huntington also for the Super Bowl drive we cont we coordinated a spirit day with the students and staff who were colors or jerseys of this of the Super Bowl team that they wanted to win as a special surprise we have a kindness tree set up in the bulletin board in second grade hallway for this schoolwide activity we gave Paper Hearts to each teacher to hand out to any students in their class that they that they gave out to anybody in the class showing a helping hand after that they would find
010anybody who did an act of kindness they would hand them the heart and they would write their name and the act of kindness that they shown at the end of this week student council will go around and collect the hearts from the different classrooms then we will hang them them up on a bulletin board as leaves for a tree we hope you have enjoyed hearing all about the Lloyd Harbor student council has been doing so far this year the student council and our advisers Miss Cooper and Miss glass thank you for your support thank you for inviting us here speak to you have a great rest of your night thank you thank you Lloyd Harbor students that was wonderful you've been so busy i' I'd like to invite our superintendent to come up and tell
011you all where he's where he's been he may have some some news for you 2our delay opening T all right so he was sending out the the text message to everyone about a 2hour delay for tomorrow so so far so far it's it's two hours so far so far two hours it's two hours so we skipped recognition could be here for that and just went into Lloyd Harbor okay um all right so we are going to now actually go back to the recognitions from the beginning of the agenda I'll turn it over to you thank you so much oh yeah do you want to send the Lloyd Harbor K on or should they say Lloyd Harbor you want to go home you you can sleep late now it really doesn't no no but you it's
012going to be a long meeting you should probably go home if you want to if you want to okay thank you uh recognition recognition of excellence in colb Harbor tonight we're proud to honor two exceptional students and one outstanding teacher for the remarkable contributions to our community our student recognitions Teddy and Spencer bosov you guys here come on up they also just came from being honored at the Huntington Town Hall where Dr Barnes you only sent me 20 pictures so you were kind of taking it easy doc okay you'll see them Friday I'm sure uh we recognize Teddy who is 12 and Spencer who is nine very good uh for the remarkable efforts in helping the victims of the devastating south southern California wildfires through their musical talents they raised close to $7,000 to support
013those those affected by the fires Teddy is a talented guitarist performing at various locations in lower Manhattan and Huntington while Spencer played crucial role in promoting their cause the dedication and generosity directly benefited organizations such as the Los Angeles Fire Department Habitat for Humanity of greata Los Angeles and the Dream Center These funds provide provided much needed relief to victims of the generary Wildfire which tragically claimed 29 lives and destroyed over 16,000 structures Teddy who has been playing guitar since the age of five is also a student of high school music and arts in saset he performs in two bands happy young kid with school friends in chin diaper okay chin diaper with high school P I want to make sure I got that right okay uh their selfless efforts exemplify the spe of culturing
014Harbor compassion leadership and drive to make a difference I have two quotes here Teddy shared I felt really bad for the fire victims it was horrible that's why I wanted to help out because everybody was losing their homes and everything they had it was very nice of you and Spencer said I love helping people it just makes my heart feel so good very G ring dedication to helping others serves as an inspiration to all of us Teddy and Spencer we are incredibly proud of [Applause] [Music] you so let's get a picture so we have two certificates for you big day for Spencer for you thank you let's get a picture guys [Applause] get Dr bar you want get in the middle for your picture come on get in the middle two big [Applause] smile okay
015we have a second recognition right coling Harbor has uh the College Board has recognized coling Harbor for a commitment to promoting female students in the computer science principles program we are proud to be only of one of 847 institutions globally to receive this distinction from our efforts of improving gender represent representation in the steam Fields a special congratulations goes to our very own Melissa mcccc Miss MCC where are you who if you were here this weekend was part of Mama Mia as the Director of the show is our dedicated computer science teacher for exceptional contributions to this achievement Melissa has inspired countless students throughout her passion for Education and Research preparing them for a bright future in computer science and Beyond thank you Melissa for your unwavering commitment excellence and Innovation to education thank you
016[Applause] okay very exciting very very busy um so as president of the board here are my remarks to the public so um I know we see a lot of the same faces at these meetings and I want to thank um those of you who are regulars for coming out I actually don't know how many people are here because of the snow but um we've been I've been using this portion of the meeting this president's report to update you on matters regarding New York State regionalization Attorney General's office matters um at our last meeting a Community member asked how much has been set bent on our suit um against regionalization and um I just wanted to report out on that uh here so um the Cold Spring Harbor portion the total cost um um including the
017coldman harbor portion of the article 78 which was $ 6,351 43 and then there were some additional costs of $518 $875 those were both in January um a community engagement expense where we um that was our Zoom meeting we fronted the cost for a zoom meeting right you and I and Nick held we held a we held a zoom meeting for um the community uh that was $840 I think we had over 200 people participate yes we had um another prep session with the attorney $315 and an optout letter that was $175 so all in um it's 9,744 just to be completely transparent about what we are spending to um fight regionalization here in New York uh there are 21 school districts have joined the suit and we will continue to keep you informed as
018we have more developments I also want to take a moment to mention that at the last board meeting one of my fellow board members pointed out um that some people up here ran on transparency many of us also ran on changing the way this meeting works and how we communicate with you and how quickly you get your answers things have improved but we still have a lot of work to do and you will see in tonight's meeting and in future meetings that this board pushes back uh New York state board training tells you that as board members you look stronger when there's consensus and I think there's one thing this board can agree on which is to disagree with that um we want you to see us publicly agree and disagree we have different opinions
019we want to ask C questions and we want you to have high expectations of us and if You' have input for us uh we say this all the time but please please come to meetings speak up or um ask questions send emails really we we want to hear from you we welcome it um and uh just before I wrap up because we have a lot to to get you tonight we just uh felt that it was important to give an extra word of thanks to our teachers for all their hard work and everything they do for our children we were really glad to see in news day that they were recognized as the highest paid teachers on Long Island and the third highest in the state so with that said we have a long agenda
020and we look forward to hearing from our leadership about budget proposals I expect we'll have a lot of questions so I'll turn the meeting over now to our superintendent for his remarks thank you thank you very much Alex this past month has been ex has been exciting and busy one here in csing Harbor we had a flurry of activities across our schools showcasing incredible Talent dedication Spirit of a staff students and Community a junior high winter sports season kicked off where Elementary and secondary staff participate in valuable training sessions on January 21 in February 7th the junior high and the West High students each enjoyed their own dance while the Junior High School Musical production of mam Mia was resounding success this past weekend in addition we had a special um recognition of Milan lustig
021our semi-finalist in regeneron science Talent search at the coling harbor Labs last Monday there was a guidance meeting where students gained insights in the college essay writing process from representatives from jio and Penn State last Wednesday was an annual senior rehearsal dinner where 110 seniors from the community joined senior citizens joined for a dinner engaging with our high school students and enjoyed a mat night performance of mamame Mia especially thanks you to a grant from our Cold Spring Harbor Education Foundation to assist the Cold Spring Harbor Goose Hill students and supporting them in a well-balanced well-rounded education by balancing academic rigor with the invaluable benefits of an unstructured play guso Primary students took part in playday a special event celebrating the vital role of play in children's social and cognitive development light Harbor School uh
022recently hosted a Scholastic Book Fair which was a tremendous success in addition students across the school celebrated World read alloud day enjoying special guest readers who brought stories to life in their classrooms one of the highlights of the month was our annual Steam and Humanities night where over 700 students in community members participated in engaging in Hands-On activities taught by a Junior Senior High School staff students elementary teachers and more this event is a favorite among our elementary students It's a Wonderful opportunity for younger students to explore new subjects meet friends from across uh the school district and experience exciting excitement at the Junior Senior High School environment I want to thank Dr fton for taking over the event this year you did a wonderful job thank [Applause] you let's continue to celebrate and support
023the outstanding achievements of our students teachers and community members thank you please take care of yourself if you can take care of someone in need thank you thank you okay thank you all right so it's that time of year tonight we kick off budget development season we have budget presentations tonight from our buildings and Athletics and we'll start with a budget overview from Miss Costa good it's B already got [Music] okay welcome everyone Board of Education as as uh Miss willan said today we kick off our first budget development um meeting of the season and our season starts tonight and it culminates in the budget vote in May um later later this this spring so a balanced budget we usually talk and we start the budget development process talking about what a balanced budget is
024a balanced budget is both our revenues and our revenues support our expenditures at Cold Spring Harbor and all school districts our revenues are made up of three components the tax levy it's governed by tax cap legislation the formula our tax levy currently makes up about 87% of our of our revenues our state aid which makes up about 5% of our budget and this is the governor's we will talk tonight about the governor's state aid proposal which culminates in the legislator adopting the budget later this year it's due by April 1st and we'll talk about that in a little more detail and our last source of revenues is other revenues that we have um fees and miscellaneous Revenue as well as reserves and fund balance and all of those three Revenue sources support our budget which
025we normally talk about the district's budget our District's budget is about $82 million will be finalized at the end of this process and this is actually what you're voting on when you go to the polls on May 20th you're actually voting on the authorization of the school's budget but it needs to be supported equally by the revenues that we have we're going to speak in detail about each of these components so we're going to start at tax levy as we said the tax levy is governed by legislation this actually is the tax cap calculations some people refer to it or it's gotten a common term of the 2% tax cap that is not true it's actually a complex eight step formula and it actually has exclusions that that layer on top of those eight steps
026our initial preliminary tax cap calculation comes in at a maximum allowable Levy at 2.23% increase over the prior year that's a levy of 72 m262 th000 and uh that's about a one $1,577 th000 increase over the prior year this is the at this point this is the maximum allowable Levy that we could go out to the public that needs a simple majority vote of our public on on May 20th and actually this is just the preliminary calculation we're still working through some of the numbers and the estimates it's due to be filed in the controller's office on March 1st and can be filed after that if things change after March 1st but um this is what we are working with as of today 2.23% maximum allowable Levy and this is actually the 18 steps of
027the tax cap formula in case someone's interested there's actually a link in the bottom to the New York State controller's website here's a summary of all of those eight steps and as we as I mentioned already it has gotten the common term of um you know the 2% tax levy which is not true as you can see from this slide this is the one component that's actually given in its name the 2% tax levy it's one of many components of the formula and it's actually capped at 2% or the growth of inflation and that's where it's gotten its common name so this is that one component the 2% cap and it's actually tied to the inflation growth rate this is put out by the controller's office there's five years of data on this page and
028you'll actually notice um we have a fiscal year that ends June 30th that's why we I highlighted this column so this is that's our column of information and the growth of inflation is 2.9 5% this past year and we're capped at a 2% allowable Levy factor and on this one page that has five years of data four out of the five years the inflation Factor has exceeded um the allowable Levy growth factor of 2% and another fact just for us to keep in mind is this is the 14th year of tax cap legislation and while you see five years on this page and four of those five years inflation has outpaced the growth factor over the 14-year life of this legislation eight out of the 14 years the inflation Factor has exceeded the maximum allowable
0292% growth factor and districts have to you know it's a challenge for us as inflation continues to grow and this is a historical slide for us just so we see over the 14 years actually this is the past 13 years and we're working on the 14th year right now you'll see this is just data points of where our budget and our tax levy have come in the column on the far right hand side is where the um the adopted levies have been for the district over the last 13 years and here you could also see where our budget amounts were budget increases what the levy amounts were what the levy allowable was and what the adopted Levy was so this is 13 years of data that coincides with the legislation for tax cap and we're
030working on that last year right now so we just spoke about um the tax levy now we're now going to move into the second Revenue source that supports our budget it's state aid at this time last year you may remember that Governor hokel came forward with her proposal and um the sky was falling a little bit she proposed cuts to half the districts in New York state and that was um unfortunate because we had to have a lot of conversations hang on one second I'm having a little trouble here so she um that is not true now actually Governor hoko came out on January 21st with her budget proposal and in her budget proposal she proposed a minimum 2% increase in Foundation aid for districts across the state many districts are receiving more but if
031you're in that bucket where you um either have declined in enrollment or you wouldn't see an increase in your foundation Aid you're getting a 2% minimum that is where we are we are in the 2% um increase bucket that's a $440,000 increase for the district and Foundation Aid the rest of our state aid is really made up of expense driven AIDS expense driven AIDS are really you have to spend the money to get the money and then further some of our expense based AIDS like the hardware technology software library and textbook AIDS those AIDS are also pupil based you have to spend the money to get it and it's also based on the pupils you have so as your pupils are declining in your District you're going to receive less money in those categories so
032overall our additional Governor's proposal state aid is up to $75,000 from last year or a 1.7% increase over the prior school year including all the aid categories so we spoke about the tax levy we spoke about state aid and the last Revenue source is our other Revenue sources in the district our other Revenue sources are made up of we have miscellaneous Revenue it's made up of Interest earnings we invest our money we earn we earn money on that money and um that is one of the one of our miscellaneous Revenue sources we also char for services we have tuition we have um driver's education programs we have um Lost Property and and other recoveries Bose Bose's pays us back some money every year those are in our charges for services but I just wanted to
033know to the board that interest rates are declining and that is why our interest earnings are declining in this school year alone we are projected to earn $700,000 Less in interest earnings than we did the prior year and it's just for declining rates so another source of Revenue and funding sources for the district is our reserves the district currently has the reserves that you see up on the on the screen we have a workers compensation reserve and unemployment Reserve we have two retirement system reserve one for our um employees retirement system members and one for our teachers retirement sister me members and then we have an employee benefit acred liability Reserve that Reserve can be used to pay out compensated absences for staffs that exit the district that retire or exit and those are the
034five reserves that the district has and we can only use those for the spec specific purposes for what they were put aside and our L LA last source of funding that supports our budget is our appropriated fund balance so each year our district uses Surplus that we have earned in the prior year for the ensuing Year's budget and um that is a source of funding and revenue that supports our budget annually so we've now looked at the three Revenue sources on the right hand side here and now we're going to take our first glance at the school district budget this year so first glance so this is our first glance of the School District budget $82 m319 th000 it's a 2.01% increase over the prior year and those are the five categories that we usually
035present the budget in administration program is also our instruction program Transportation community services and then we have benefits Debt Service and transfers those are our five categories of the budget we're going to take this slide and we're going to just move it forward and talk about the information on here just a little bit a little bit more same same slide so how do we review the budget through the next couple of months so on the right hand side you'll see the dates of presentations where you're going to hear the details that are in these five categories so our administrative budget in on at our next meeting on March 11th buildings and grounds will do a presentation on their budget that will happen next month we'll also talk about the other administrative codes that are in
036that category of our budget and then we have the program section the largest section of our budget also called the instructional section of our budget and that is almost a $42 million budget item and you'll see on the right hand side we have five present presentations scheduled tonight and all five of the presenters that will speak tonight their budgets are part of this $42 million program item so you're going to hear from Goose Hill Westside Harbor the Junior Senior High School and Athletics and then next month you'll hear from curriculum and instruction our pupil Personnel Services and our technology budgets and they'll also round out next month we'll talk about transportation and then that last that last category benefits Debt Service and transfers and that's how we look at all the items in the budget
037in detail and we put them all together so as our so we're going to move forward same slide again this is just a little information for the board the largest component of our budget is our program our instructional program it's um 41 million I'm not reading the exact number 900 $983,000 is the proposal at this early stage and that is a $1.5 million increase over last year but it's want the board to note that in that $1.5 million there are instructional additions that are part of that number so the budget is rolling out in version one there are three additional instructional additions we want to bring to you attention it's an expansion of the ICT program at all four buildings it comes to $68,000 it's a continued class size reduction effort that the board has
038started and those those efforts continue into Lloyd Harbor and Westside additional instructional staff at Lloyd Harbor for fifth grade and second grade for West for Westside and that's a $271,000 um addition and and the students at the high school just finished requesting their classes for next year and there was an increase in students wanting to go to occupational education programs and bosis and that was an increase in about $75,000 and we built that into the budget so that $955,000 of in instructional additions are part of the $1.5 million that you see in the instructional uh program line wanted to just bring that to your attention so now we've looked at the three Revenue components and how they support the budget and what does a balanced budget look like at this early stage so at this
039early stage it's version one we will make it through a number of versions before we adopt a budget in April but at this point in time would like the board to see just what a balanced budget looks like so these are all the components we spoke about in the prior slides it's our tax levy it's our state aid based on the governor's proposal it's other funding sources and our fund balance and then the the total expenditures so this is what a balanced budget would look like today it will change as um decisions are made over the next couple of months but this is the levy at the maximum allowable Levy the board sets the levy and they will make that decision as we move through the process the governor's state aid proposal will change I've
040never seen it the same in all the years I've been doing this from the governors to the legislator's final state aid packet so we hope to see that on April 1st they're required legislatively to pass a budget by April 1st but they did not last year so um we we'll hope that they do this year and this would be our recommendation for other funding sources and fund balance use and this balances the budget out the revenues are an increase of 2.01% and our expenditures are an increase of 2.01% so the budget is a um the budget is a a tool one year how we run our educational program in in a district and how we support our operations but it's also important and we started last year when of looking at our long rrange Financial
041Outlook the governor proposed um a serious cut to state aid last year which forced us to start taking a look at our long range Financial Outlook and what that would do that did not go through last year um and she did not propose anything like that this year she proposed a minimum 2% Foundation Aid increase but it's still a good business practice to look at our long- range Financial Outlook so we are looking at where we stand um where we stand and what the future looks like so this is a glance of our long range Financial Outlook The Columns in grp GRE are the years that have passed those are actual data those are um audited data those numbers tie right back to our financial statements so in 2023 the district ended the year with
042a $4.8 million surplus in 2024 the district ended the year with an $8.2 million deficit and I you see that I noted there that it was CVA because that is the year we settled the CVA claims for the district and then you see the column in yellow that is our current school year that we're in we're about Midway through the year but we do begin right now starting anticipating where we're going to come in at the end of the year so for the 2425 school year we estimate at this early stage um a surplus of $3.5 million and we're going to look at the 25 year and then the four out years together because we're going to concentrate now on the Surplus or deficit line and where we are is we see the district with
043a surplus for anticipated this year and the four out years and that's a healthy situation that's where you want to be as a district you want to be in a healthy situation like that um but we also look at this long-range financial plan and we just take note of what's happening in the district these are assumptive datas and anything could change like if the governor came forward with a proposal it would change our assumption for state aid for the out years so that's why we continue to look at this as assumptions and things change but what we know today and what our assumptions are today just for the board to note our Revenue growth that's in the yellow column and the four purple columns you'll see that our Revenue growth is not keeping off our
044percentage growth with our expenditure growth and that's why you see the surpluses what we're happy to see healthy surpluses you see them declining so it's just something that the board to be aware of and as we look at um our healthy Financial Outlook it's just for us to notice um the growth in each of those items are are different so now we go so where are we so we looked at the budget we looked at a first draft of the budget we looked at our longrange financial Outlook and now we're looking at things that aren't in the budget things that the the superintendent and the administration are asking the Board of Education to consider so these are additional budgetary considerations they are not currently built into the budget so some of those all of those
045considerations are the following um asking the board to consider a committee on special education ch CH a math coach districtwide math coach Lloyd Harbor an ICT contingency position there is one grade level at ICT Dr schimp will talk about it in more detail next month that if there are other students that enter um into the ICT model in that grade we would need a contingency position we need more resources there um there is a consideration on the table for you for high school reduction in class sizes math seven and eight class sizes additional P additional purchasing resources and also what's not into the built into the budget which is important for us to tell the board is retirees breakage we you'll see tonight the board is actually approving the retirements of a number of teachers
046and I think they approved some at the last meeting also so there's breakage every time we have a retiree leave the district who's on the higher end of the pay scale and we replace them with a new teacher starting their career out for the district we're anticipating at this point in time with the retirements we know a 260 $6,000 breakage that is not built into the budget right now that would be a reduction in our budget as opposed to an addition in our budget in addition to that we did this last year and I think we'll continue to do this is we begin to look at this year's budget 2425 we look at items that people are asking for in 25 26 and we say can the budget support doing them now you know was
047there not a lot of snow did we have do do we realize savings that maybe we could adjust the 25 26 requests and purchased them in 2425 so we have identified $153,000 at this early stage of the budget process that we think that we could purchase now that you'll hear from budget you know you'll hear from each of the buildings and the directors that are in their budgets that we're actually acknowledging that we might be able to do them now and here they are on the next slide you'll hear from Athletics tonight and um a bunch of items are in the athletic presentation Mr banino is asking for new bleachers a sound system on the lower Turf two scoreboards at the baseball field in the new gym four aeds and Lacrosse goals we believe we
048can do all of those purchases in 2425 school year and remove them from his budget and we have Westside you'll see Dr Barnes is going to ask tonight for Coral risers $88,000 we believe we can do them in this year and Facilities they'll present next month they're um they have a request in for a high school floor scrub scrubber machine and we think can do that that this year that's $18,000 and Lloyd Harbor is in the Final Phase of their Library renovation and that's the Final Phase is $30,000 of additional shelving and and Furniture we believe we can do that this year that adds up to $153,500 and we go back to this slide and the total budgetary considerations that we're asking of the for the board to consider is $333,700 we move forward one
049of the five categories when we looked at the budget before is the final category to which has benefits Debt Service and transfers one of the transfers in that category is the transfer to Capital last year we spent some time talking about the transfer to Capital and how stabilizing that amount in the budget will help stabilize the tax cap calculation it will not stabilize the tax cap calculation in every aspect but of all of the factors that influence the tax cap calculation this has an impact Direct on the tax cap calculation so we spoke about a consistent $350,000 in the budget in this line item for um projects improvements in the district um and that impacts our calculation as we move forward so last year we we we approved $350,000 next year we're asking the board
050to consider $350,000 of this Capital work these are the projects that have been identified as a need um there are three hot water heater replacement needs two at the Junior Senior High School and one at Lloyd Harbor there's districtwide exterior security lighting needs we're in the beginning stage of deciding um what that would look like for the district and then if um money allows interior alterations at the junior high Junior Senior High and Goose Hill and the projects are kind of indicated in the right hand side over here um the way uh transfer to Capital works is after if it's approved then you start planning out the projects they go up to the state and they're later bid so having exact prices on all these projects is not something that we would you know that
051we have exactly at this time so we build broad descriptions so that we can do um as much as the work as as we can with the $350,000 so what are the next steps in the budget development process so next meeting in March will'll revisit the budgetary considerations we're talking about tonight we'll also continue continue budget presentations we're scheduled for another it's like six or seven presentations in March and then after the March meeting we come back in the April meeting in the April meeting we adopt the budget and the tax levy we balance the whole budget and adopt the levy and and the budget and then after that it's pruner dates we have we conduct a budget hearing on May 13th we're required to do that and then we hold the vote for our
052budget and our uh trustee election on May 20th um over in the the F house we say the pack but it's the field house so yes we hold it in the field house any questions the 350,000 um transfer to Capital that would otherwise become excess or you wouldn't put it in the budget Mr wman you just wouldn't put it in the budget your budget would be $350,000 less okay back to that plus could you explain to me how that works is that a cumulative number or each year has its own Surplus so why why does each year have a surplus if it's a budget it you have a a surplus baked in the numbers so a surplus so a long a surplus or deficit is actual operational res results and a budget is the the
053structure with which you start the year off and You Begin so for example we I'm going to go back to a slide right here to balance our budget in the column on the lefthand side we use fund balance of reserves in the current year we're sitting in we use 3.5 millionar of fund balance and reserves if and when um we are not showing a surplus we are basically spending our fund balance and our reserves forever that number would decline and you would be using the one-time monies of your fund balance and your reserves to support your budget and they call that an operate you know you're either in an operational Surplus or deficit so right now to balance our budget every year we use fund balance and reserves so to answer your question Mr talente
054if you literally took your budget down to nothing okay you would you there's a couple of things that would happen one you wouldn't have any money to handle contingencies in the future if something happened and the second would be if you had an operational deficit you need a source as to where you're going to find that money and it would have to be in the money you've saved in the past you can't use reserves and you can only use fund balance so so we build our budget as the tool to operate the year with the goal of not really using it all using it all because we need for emergencies and unforeseen it's we we run I say we run about a 90 to9 $5 million operation here 82 million is the District Operations and
055then we have the federal fund the um Debt Service fund we have the capital funds we run about 9095 million in operations here so this becomes the structure with we handle the budget and this is the actual results that they happen at the end of any year can I ask a question and is this budget that you have proposed for this year based on the 2% tax cap at the max yes but you would last year we didn't do that we did one was it. you went to the max last year here's the max it's up there we did 162 yeah here you are you here's the history hang on sorry we're a little too fast so last year the maximum allowable which is the second column to the right is 1.62 and you went
056to 1.62 but Christine that was because we took the 300 my mic not working yeah it was impacted by the security my mic working thanks I want this on recording that's because we took the $350,000 transfer to Capital out of the budget which changed our formula and reduced the tax cap right no you didn't take the 350 out of the budget you left it in the budget the prior year in 2324 you did you decided to not move forward with the security booths so that was 23 24 we really never wanted to move forward with the security booths I don't think but it was in the budget so what is what needs to change so if we don't do that transfer to Capital what's our Max your maximum allowable tax the tax cap calculation will
057not change it'll be 1. so we can just no you go you can come in at any number you want the board this number but so it changed last year because we didn't use that money from the previous year correct that is correct okay but cuz we had the option to use that and then keep the tax cap at two it was 2% I think is that right it was two something I don't remember yeah yeah it was yeah Alex if you turn around this the exclusion box that's in the center of this page that was the Box the one that boxed off that says exclusions that was the box that was impacted when the decision was made to not go forward with the with the security booth okay so does that hold true for
058this year then so no this is the this is the this calculation will not change but we can come in under that we don't have absolutely absolutely it's the board's decision what the maximum allowable tax Lev is this is the maximum you could go to and only need a simple majority vote you could come in at be dramatic zero I mean anything from zero to 2.2 3% you only need a simple majority vote of your so and you can run a couple projections for us with those as options because I think that would what we do when we go through so yes if that's what you want we can run whatever those projections are that's what I'd like to see so on I'm sorry go ahead where um when we talk about the Surplus that's
059sort of budgeted but it's not really budgeted is my understanding because it's it's put into each category so where would you find the $3 million of sort of budgeted Surplus if you were looking if I was looking to remove it everyone no no if if I'm looking at the budget there's a lot of lines for salaries benefits Etc where would you find the amounts that add up to the Surplus that's being budgeted there are some planned unknowns and like health insurance is an area that we don't know if people are going to change from Individual to family coverage we make some contingencies people get married they all their family so you make some contingencies so we see surpluses in um that area pretty much every line in the budget if you ran an appropriation status
060report for the end of the year you're going to see buildings every line item supplies equipment contractual costs that come in slightly under budget but you also see those that come in over budget when you do budget transfers and you only see budg of transfers that come in at $10,000 and above that's our board policy any transfers needed for 10,000 and below below are operational we have a process internally where we approve those and that happens daily and regularly as part of the process question looking at sorry looking at that Surplus deficit line that we're just talking about it looks like it's declining could you tell us what's contributing to that decline sure so when I spoke about the slide ear if you look the revenue section is on the you know you see the
061category revenues and expenditure on the left hand side underneath those categories there's percentages you see it says 3.59 in 2023 and it runs all the way to 1.93 in 2029 that's the rate of gr the rate of um change in our revenues each of those years either actuals current year or projected if you compare that to down below the expenditures you see the rate of growth of our expenditures so we'll talk about we'll talk about 26 um we see a 2.11% estimated increase in our growth in revenues you compare that to 2.82% growth in expenditures anticipated that is going to that's going to contribute directly to a decline in our Surplus for each year so every year that your expenditures grow faster than your revenues you are generating with doing nothing differently less of a
062surplus in all of those out years can I go ahead yeah so Bill asked the question I was going to ask I there's no line item that generates a surplus it's all throughout the budget there's that built-in cushion is that customary for districts to do every District's building in these surpluses they are building a budget as a one-year tool to run their operations those that are not you hear those are the ones that you read about in Newsday they're meeting to close buildings in West Babylon they're meeting to do things that are very difficult because they have line items that have nowhere to go and then we have a a contract out right now um are those increases factored in the compensation figures in this budget or or not there are assumptions made we build
063the budget and there are assumptions made when we build a long-range financial plan yes can I ask about enrollment what is our enrollment is it going down it's G yes it's gone down 20% over the last 20% and we're still keeping class sizes that's I see that's costing us you know was 200 over the last couple years the board has made that you know I guess a priority to reduce it is a priority I want to just on tape that we want to keep it that way I mean I shouldn't you should talk into your microphone speak for yourself but but I'd like that to be um like a top priority I was hoping the community to come out with that that's already if you see here Christin put that in Kate you see over
064here it's on the right hand side this is noting on this slide that's all automatically built into the budget because we we have heard you as a board built in right already in yeah it's already in and you'll see when Lloyd Harbor and West speak today each of them have a enrollment slide you'll see which grade it's related to you see the number of kids in that grade you you'll be able to see it very clearly when they give their presentations later so when you say class size reduction that's what we chose not by the 20% decline enrollment that's what the board chose the board wanted classes less than I you know if it was 20 all of our classes I think with this addition to the budget are under 20 kids in last of
065two element5 I wasn't sure if that was because of the decline I think 23 was the number you know what I'm saying now okay we can put a note on here that says class side reduction classes less than 20 like we can put it clearer if you would like it clear ever as a board say less than 20 so let's not put that we never changed the policy technically yeah but I just wasn't sure if that was due to the 20% decline or if that was our doing so okay now it's clarified yeah this is two this would be two new teachers in grade five and grade two So Christine in addition to showing us maybe a few variations of the tax cap maybe you could also then just highlight where all the overages are
066in the budget for us cuz you must know where they are right I don't I don't necessarily know where they all are because if like let's use the high school as an example if they don't spend all their supplies know yeah got it okay we can show you in a prior year where money ended at the end of the year helpful that would be helpful I think yeah so I noticed some of the expenditures push forward um into this year is that cuz we had the Sur plus there and we could draw down on that was that how that works I'm not understanding the question there's um you had a like a um bunch of items you said we can do in 2425 was oh right here yeah is that because we have the Surplus
067and we're just calling on that to pay for those so for example there are there are um two codes in the budget that are under the direction of administration one is an equipment code and one is an unforeseen like contractual code and that equipment code is if something major happened in the district you know a major system went down we have some money at our discretion if about this time of the year nothing major has happened we start to look for this or I start I start to look for this because we're not going to spend the discretionary equipment money that's not being asked for by the buildings and the directors and we start looking at ways that we can use that money effectively for what the district needs cuz we were talking about alert
068us too maybe this year event but I don't see it on the the list we're doing that already we're that's already moving forward it's not these are requests Mark in 2526 that we would oh you're pulling forward right we made the decision we made the decision before this yes I understand thank you I just I have a question regarding um the weather and people who are employees um of the district who live further away than just here in Cold Spring Harbor would it make sense to to and I everyone weigh in I don't want to make a unilateral decision here but to perhaps have the board read the presentations that follow this and then ask questions at the next board meeting just because it's already 930 and I can see that this will go quite
069some time and then there's other items on the agenda is is everyone comfortable with that yeah we can I okay with that yeah I don't as as much as we'd love to hear the presentations I do worry about people getting home from here so it's it's getting late okay sure is that okay okay we have a we have a lot of this show goes on for a while and a bunch of meetings so okay maybe we'll do that meeting earlier doing all the presentations at once no I I'm saying we'll read their presentation so they don't have to do them again if that's okay and then if we just have questions for them we can rather than reading through every slide cuz that takes quite a bit of fine a bit of time I know
070a lot of work went into preparing the presentation so I don't want to take away from that also is that annoying would you want to do your presentations smiling you're good you're good you guys thumbs up thumbs down get in the car okay okay thanks I just checking okay all right okay so thank you I I just I I heard it's little slippy out there already okay yeah all right okay so thank you so thank you Christine thank you Christine okay that was really helpful thank you um so I think we are now at committee reports did any committees meet um yes would you like to do it or I'll start okay the uh the health and the health and safety committee met um last Thursday we talked about uh the alerta system we talked
071about the alerta system I think that uh that we're trying to get state aid back from bosies but it's a thing you wear around your neck it charges it's charge is good for like six months there's a thing on it and it dial it will immediately dial um 911 or it immediately goes to it says like call the Cavalry it's time um so that would be great uh we talked about fencing at different properties specifically uh Westside we talked about and um there was I guess Homeland Security came and did an audit and you know they also said around the back of the high school is probably could use some fencing um so we're still I guess this the Anthony is still working on that we talked about uh cameras uh License Plate Reader at
072the end of the driveways um I don't know know any more about cameras than that uh some aeds I know um you know get some training in aeds uh put them in more locations and then we also talk that possibly it might be a good idea to have all of the staff trained in CPR AED training um maybe on an alternating basis so that you know it's a two-year it's a two-year certification so when one expires you know so every so at no at one given time everybody won't be out um we talked about the traffic light um that should be coming soon hopefully uh we talked about active shooter drill um Colts Spring Harbor is on a waiting list to have an active shooter drill at our facility um you can come and watch
073is what I was told um they are going to start testing lead in the water at the facil at the buildings um and the parts per billion has gone down previously it was 10 what 15 parts per billion was acceptable of 15 parts of lead per billion was acceptable and now it's gone down to five five so that'll be that'll be fun um and then also they are going to you're you're our scientist what I don't want to be there that day I also don't want to be there the day um they're going to increase the monitoring for our oil tanks I guess it was on an annual basis Anthony weekly okay also don't want to be there for that um and we have an automated system with probes in the tanks and so it'll
074just be somebody you know transcribing the data and submitting it uh anything else well just on the fencing um we made it clear we want to see the plan before we move forward to see if it's we don't want security theater we want to make sure it's going to accomplish the goal we're set out so we're not going to spend the money unless it makes sense um and and um it's good news Alerus is moving forward we might get half uh half the cost picked up by Bose make thechase Bose and that will reduce the price by half which would be terrific and the cameras are going to be on the field um and Capt lion plate capture which is which is good it's retrospective but we can determine um if an event happened what
075vehicles uh entered the campus um traffic lights what three to six months I I got a report back on here um possibly the end mid to end of April finished that's he says holdups and Equipment due to tars any unforeseen issues but it could be to end of April sounds like April break to me so wonderful that would be great that would be get to be the first one to drive if she would like to and uh yeah we're many of the parts are in ready so that's we're going to add signage around the uh Circle uh the Horseshoe at the Junior Senior High School no standing that's right and also I mean standing only no standing only EXC me no no uh cuz uh we we want to try to keep that open but
076we we can't if people continue to park there correct and then on security the um the guard the headcount issue is dissipating and we have um either 35 or 36 right we up to 36 possibly and we have line of sight on additional members which would get us to where we want and uh yeah the new director of security is on board he's been here a month he's um he's really I think quite terrific and we're lucky to have him he's fully invested in this uh Institution and he's really thinking outside the box um making uh contact outside the district um for example those active shooter drills when he volunteered our premises they they do those overnight and um it's local law enforcement they're using our facility they're also learning our facility when they're practicing
077in it so you know he's he's really done a terrific job he's only been here a month and um we're very lucky to have found him and brought him on so that's all I have very one of the things I don't remember you mentioned I was looking at the traffic light information to be adding a an additional security guard with a golf cart circling the fields um so um he or she will have it be actively seen we're looking at the the uniforms that they wear that it's clearly that this is a security officer so they can easily identifiable so all things I guess we could bring that up now then there's a request for three uh golf cart rentals that's on the AGA Mike two two of them athletic one was the addition for
078um security okay yeah I saw the contract before so one is for okay I didn't know so um yeah my qu I should wait maybe for the point where this comes up but um my question on those is not whether we need them but they seem really expensive for lease the three Monon lease M Mike do you want yeah sorry to make you walk all up not a problem so this was the first year we've ever rented golf carts um we have owned our golf carts but they were bought by by the Seahawks booster club they obviously have run out of their life expectancy and this current fall we rented two golf carts for The Fall season so we just for the spring I put in for two further rentals because they're needed following the
079same process additional security guard one was asked for so that's why you see the three moving forward um I've only ever worked with Northshore golf cart so that's the only reason why that's the agreement or the contract I was asking to be signed we absolutely can look into purchasing our own I do feel that purchasing them will be very expensive to get we're getting the very basic and then they take them away they're also warrantied so if they break they get fixed by the company or replaced without payment when we own them we are responsible to fix said in that contract that it was included like Repairs Service all of that too yeah so this was the first year we've ever done this um and we've never purchased them before I absolutely can look and
080see if there's other golf car rental places around and bring back different cost but that's really how it came about it seemed like a luxury SUV release not a golf cart relase Fair maybe there's technology in them that makes them the two that we had in Fall one is for the athletic trainer yeah uh so it has a for kids to sit on he drives around the other one has a back for equipment Transportation due to the U actual facility getting stuff to the upper Turf to the all the grass fields baseball softball fields um that is it the only reason why we use them it's not for us to drive around there was one for 3,000 there was one for this is for three months by the way 3,26 2100 corre so it's like
081six it's like8 8, three for three months and you were happy with renting them this year it seems expensive so it felt like I could get an Audi Q7 for that so the answer is yes the company was be very responsive um any issue they were always there the keys were like they really they came on site they transported they took the ones that we had away um it is the only place that I've ever worked with but we've never rented before so when I did it this year in the fall I was just putting it through for the spring moving into next year's budget we could absolutely look at um all options and make the best decision that's not a problem mik I spoke about it was the repair component if it's down we
082have to send out we're down a week maybe two weeks without unit this is the next day we have something on site I want to make one more point about so the biggest thing with these golf carts is they you know re charge the batteries so like if we had a situation that we don't know about where power went out in the sheds where we charged them we could wake up the next day and it could be B they would come right then one phone call otherwise I have Joe and melari and everyone else working on them it was really a hassle over the last like several years but they were very old that's why we went this route were the old ones a battery charge too they were okay thank you you're welcome where
083were we so Mark were you still reporting on okay are there reports I guess policy policy policy policy uh so we met at the end of January um we dealt with uh four main things mainly um if you remember at the last meeting uh we had the second read and final approval of policy 2160 which is our code of conduct policy and there's a provision in there in paragraph e that was new and it dealt with um dis annual disclosure of conflicts of interest so the policy committee has worked up a form to implement uh or to recommend that we Implement through Joe um to comply with that policy uh 20 and it would be a subset of people who have uh influence over purchasing Etc who would have to complete this every year um
084we're going to circulate that to the board for its view after um after the attorneys finish with it uh the second item um we dealt with a policy that's actually on the agenda tonight for a first read on student V voter student voter registration um and basically we updated language regarding how the district uh as a policy will uh provide voter registration applications to students uh we also have U on tonight policy 5500 relating to Student Records so we finalized um we made some conforming changes like for example we clarified what uh personally identifiable information consists of um we clarified that volunteers are considered school officials for for that policy's purpose uh most importantly we updated the the data items that can be included in the directory and so um I know there were items
085that people wanted to be included and so the policy conforms that and that's up for first read tonight as well oh thank that was it was it okay sure uh no well go ahead we well we did uh we did prioritize talk about prioritizing all the other policies so they keep coming in every month and so it's sort of a never ending L just when we think we knock something off five more come on yeah that's all all right sorry did I uh I think um just to note uh the policy 5500 the ptg are going to be very happy that they'll be able to provide you know grade level information um all that stuff you know so the directory should go a lot smoother much easier you're welcome got it done okay thank you
086all right so now we're going to move on to audience to visitors um Cold Spring Harbor Board of Education and administration welcome your attendance at Board of Education meeting meetings audience to the public affords residents an opportunity to address the board of education on both agenda and non-agenda items each resident is loud to speak for 3 minutes this is not a forum to discuss student or staff specific issues please contact the district separately on these matters question talking about the policies okay so just come up to the mic and introduce yourself um Cecilia Gilroy I've got uh two at Lloyd Harbor Colin and Francine and one in the junior high Katherine Gilroy um so first I was so excited to see the policy on voter registration I just think you know the fact that we're
087emphasizing um Civics right now and making sure that students know that their voice being heard in government is is great so so happy for that um information for our kids is obviously super um important that we're safeguarding all of that data so I just had a couple of questions around those changes that that I saw in the PO policy and maybe specifically um the paragraph around like volunteers you mentioned the volunteers now expanding the scope of who would have access to some of these personal identifiable information um and in this digital age and just you know really I would prefer to air on the side of restricting more access so just wanted to hear a little bit more about why we were expanding access for volunteers and and how we would kind of govern and
088train people it's actually maybe more that we made sure there would be training for volunteers to understand what is personal and what is not and what that can't share that out so that's what we add we beef that up that the building principes and volunteers come in that they make sure they understand you're going to see stuff being in classroom names addressed so on and so forth that that is indeed personal information you can't share that out so that really revolved around that change of adding training to the to the policy okay I thought the formal policy said that they were restricted from seeing that and this was allowing like they're going to see stuff in the room like somebody's birthday Lun Duty during lunch duty you're going to see names and even someone's ID
089number may come up we're just making sure that that you understand you cannot share that information out okay so we're not creating a new class of people who can access private information that's not the intention we're telling people that they can't they can't do something we're only making sure of that okay um and then could we just talk a little bit more around the purpose and the intention of expanding the definition of the things that are included in the directory it looks like we used to just include name address and enrollment status which seems sufficient but we've expanded did that to now include what participation in school activities weight and height for athletics there's a whole bunch of different new things I'm just curious where where that came from so it it started as ptgs
090requiring you know stuff for the student directories and it kind of expands it into you know um like a wrestling meet uh if a if news day calls and they want to know about you know a wrestler his weight they always say you know so we have to be able to give out that information their weight um I mean obviously we're not going to give out the weight of like me but you know but it it would have to be appropriate and we could always say no but you know we also have to you know we can't restrict it to the point where we can't give information you know like weight was specific TOS height weight was specific to to sports um things like that so it was you know it was mostly you know
091if um if the booster club is trying to you know celebrate someone or you know help me out help me out said but the parents can opt to not parents could always opt out if they don't want to participate yes there's always even like even on the football team it says your height and weight in the brochure or in the pamphlet so the height weight was always associated with Athletics that was it okay so we were just thinking of all the cases that it might happen yeah um but of course you know when the ptg like they they have to foil for these things you know we could always say no the ptg isn't going to ask for height and weight you know but the booster club might if they're putting together a program you
092know for homecoming yep I'm just thinking about all the things that we're going to have to do to safeguard this information right and like the club activity is like I don't want people to be discouraged by participating in the vast array of clubs that we have especially in the junior high because they might end up on a list somewhere that someone can refer to later um and I'm just being conscious of like the digital footprint that we're creating for our kids and if there's a way to just restrict this further and really have it be Mission critical item items that we're Gathering and collecting and monitoring that was just my first reaction to some of these listed in the yearbook the clubs are listed in the yearbook with their names with their names and a
093photograph yeah I think the intent was to try to restrict these things and call them out as we needed to um it wasn't like let's give everybody you know let's give them anything they want like we were kind of thinking you know we started out really small we're like well what about the booster club what about yearbook and it's really limiting it to clubs and activities that are directly associated with col sping Harbor ptgs in your life because they do so many great things and we want to make sure parents know that these things are going on so that's where if you want to call an expansion is allowing to have certain access an email contact of the parent not the students's email content not the students's ID number none of that to say hey
094this is a following thing that's going on can you participate so is anything that would be the betterment of the school district meaning the students really thank you okay I think we're um last thing I would just advocate for um expanding that opt out period from 14 days to 30 days and obviously letting all the students know that this is going on it's a great opportunity learning to safeguard your personal information and this is what's out there wait can we just discuss the out out how does it work that's always the option it's in the school calendar when they opt out yeah so they have a certain amount of days I didn't even so if you don't reply like sometimes the ptg will say like if you don't give us your address you're not going
095to be in so this is they there's a form they fill out they I have to say no one filled it out to opt out of sharing their information in the school calendar they scan and it's a Google form they fill out and that's how we go about it but you know I mean parents always have the option to you know they can always write to a ptg and say remove me from this list correctly or somebody contacts us say don't if you did that we wouldn't share your contact information if anybody asked for it yeah just and just to be clear there's nothing really new here right and the information is isn't out there just for people to grab like people have to foil for the actual information like you need it's not just
096out there for anybody to take we could definitely say no yeah of exactly what you want yeah exactly you say no good question thank you yeah anyone else but if you think of other things that we should be including definitely let us know okay um so we're now going to move on to approval of minutes uh January 14th were present may I have a first Heather second Bill any questions all in favor thank you oh you have a question sorry no I said I oh oh I okay they were like I had a question okay um we will now oh this is a tough one today there's so many people I know okay so we're going to move to personel recommendations of the superintendent do you want to I'm going to take a first and
097a second and then do you want to make any remarks or anything okay let's do a first okay a first here for this Heather a second bill um we have some very long-standing people here we have hundreds of years of yes of coltsman har first we have favor Jen who I've worked with so closely our officers were next to each other for so many years where we spent a lot of time uh we actually didn't use the phone we just yell from each other from our offices and we're both we're both we were both loud teachers when I taught kids said Miss amount of sterile when I went to the bathroom I didn't miss any of the lesson that's how loud it was and Jen and I were both like that so sometimes we had
098to close the door which was wonderful to work with Mr ol bill and I started together 28 years too we started in the same class we've been out to dinner um I'm gonna get I will tell you this when bill came to drop off the letter he just started to cry oh uh because I he brought it to me and we've been such close friends he's he is truly a gem it would be very difficult to find someone to come even close to who Mr Bill oloff is um this is going to be one of the most difficult things for him to do he is great uh Mr hardy again when I taught in the building a a fabulous physics teacher uh so many great things we shared so many uh students together he was
099a senior teacher I was a senior teacher teacher of senior students uh just great years he brings physics alive he truly does anyone who takes his class um is is amazed uh uh JT is doing some observation in his class and he said to me wow either he's really great or I remembered all my physics back in high school and it was more like he's really great he said it's been like 20 years ago so he said he's just amazing he you you scored very well on the test you said right you did Susanna Susanna is here I mean she's a first grade teacher who gets here like at 6:30 in the morning I mean we'd often get talk with each other in the morning she lives in the emwood bump into each other in
100bagle Chalet uh she is truly amazing she want me this little lyard over the summer that's so nice she is no one is ever upset when they see GC as a students teacher she is truly amazing Maria sagora John she beat you in pictures most certainly uh she she uh loves kids beyond belief she is everywhere sometimes it seems like just three of her because just the time and effort she puts in with kids uh she is truly an amazing teach uh Miss watt a great math teacher uh almost 30 years in education here um teaches it's some of the hardest things I have to tell you the the toughest spot is the first year that you teach accelerative math to students because your your smart students go from math being really easy to truly
101being challenged and she's done that for so many years uh and she's done with a smile and she does a great job at it uh Miss Conan um she's been a secretary clerical I think for 25 years in CT spring haror uh Debb's moving on with her life uh doing so many great things she is going to be very difficult she was on the other side of my office Jen was on side de was on the other side so I lost both of them what does that say about you and I moved too [Laughter] so uh and um Miss Thomas the teacher a she's truly a wonderful person so but she's actually coming back she's going to be a Le a sub clerical person oh Nico school nurse at the high school NSE at the
102high school junior senior high school I know she's so sweet she is sweet I know it's such a nice list so sorry to put you on the spot no that was easy I wonderful thing to say about everyone yeah great all right so um all in favor what if we say no I know I tried it with I tried it with masimo it doesn't work I said that to Susanna if I don't come pick up your letter does that mean you have to say yeah all right so we're going to now move on to congratulations to everyone we're now going to move on to um business recommendations did I miss anything oh appointments oh sorry appointments uh so um I did them already I did them as a slate yeah yeah yeah we did them
103as a slate thank you Christine I'm not losing my mind okay we now move on to business recommendations we will take donations budget transfers and additional business matters on pages 9 through 11 as a slate I think you've already recognized the Educational Foundation for the did at the last board meeting no I don't think we did no this is another Grant a new one oh this is a new one I thought you did it in your opening remarks no no oh okay great oh excellent right this came through with Mr gorer who's here as a new uh music uh chairperson uh uh adding to our new lab he moved our lab from all the way in back of the music because Miss MCC moved into the new science Wing so he moved into the the
104fish tank down by the math science area uh outfitted with with computers and the like and this is just some additional equipment about $3,400 excuse me $5,400 worth of equipment just for the students to continue digitally recording um U podcasting and the like so truly nice thank you Jim for doing this and thank you to the Ed Foundation very nice so nice Okay thank you um so may I have a first are we um also doing additional business matters this is Pages nine so we'll do a first in a second and then there's questions oh thank you okay okay you got it so first um I'm calling you Heather Lisa second Heather questions questions okay so of course on page 10 9 10 11 um bathrooms change orders do I ask I mean what what's
105going on here these are negative we're getting money back this is a significant amount of money coming back and I actually did not sign the paperwork because I wanted everyone to ask questions yeah so why are we getting money back I'm all a remarkable amount of money Christine that's coming backing back so a negative change order at the end of a close out of a project is part of the closeout process so if allowances were not used that were built into the um that were built into the contractor's um budget we'll say the allowances they come back in the form of a negative change order at the end of the process so if a contract was 100,000 and there was an and there was allowance built in for 10,000 it literally gets um a negative
106change order for that $10,000 and the contract is $90,000 with the state of New York after that okay so we've been calling these $53,000 bathrooms what is the cost now with the rebate well not all the contractors are the reate this is all there's only three out of the four contractors that um have been closed out by The Architects so until Palace electric is closed out we wouldn't be able to come up with um well what what is it now with these great um rebates what are we up to at least what are we down to because we were told by Mr gillo that the going rate he said within 10% is $1,800 a square foot and we have I mean these are material rebates I'd like to know um how this happened and what
107other projects are we looking at because I this makes no sense it's very can you walk me through this as our business officer sure what happened so what happens is they build a budget that has an allowance in it and the allowance just so you know they $5,000 each trade two of the trades took a $55,000 full allowance which I was going to ask you about because I never got an explanation why they took why why do you say 5,000 because on two of the the two of the trades took the $5,000 allowance two didn't I don't know what that is yeah they that is we did this oh you weren't there I don't know what that is so I mean part of this is more than just bathrooms yeah this is the bathrooms three
108sets of bathrooms kitchen and cafeteria how much are the the $253,000 bathroom's portion of this then I'm still trying to get the number cuz I've I've seen our $1,100 light and it's unimpressive in each bathroom we have an $1,100 light which I'm still trying to figure out how it cost $1,100 so the total contract for High-Tech which is one of the oh sorry that's go sale the Westside change orders you're looking at the original contract for High-Tech was $290,000 $290,500 the original contract for Seaford was 61,800 and the original contract for J&H was $24,300 okay so there's no way to follow that how much of that is allocated to the two bathrooms I'm first starting with two bathrooms before we go beyond other nonsense how much of the two bathrooms that cost us $1800 a
109square foot was rebated can you tell me that I can't tell you that because it's one contract amount for each vendor can we get the amount from the vendors so I I I'm also I was hesitant to sign anything to accept the change order at this point I'd like I'd like the money back but I also would like more information so and just you know as we sign first and then remove pull things but I didn't want to do anything on this me if I'm wrong wasn't part of the problem was that last year this the change order was never signed done anyway yeah that's correct that's correct yeah we really want to get the allocated amount to the bathrooms and so can we table this Christine and get more information maybe because this seems
110rushed and um it doesn't it's a significant amount of money coming back so we'd like to know exactly where it is the total rebate is that is it say 579 + 25 + 15 what I know it's getting bad outside so let's let's continue to ask questions um of Christine following the meeting and for the next meeting we'll have more answers so so we'll get the the deduction for each of the jobs of the contract yes thank you okay so we're going to get specifics on where that money is coming back from from each vendor so we understand to pull those so yeah can we out can I take a motion to take out 9 10 11 12 to 12 change orders 9 10 11 and 12 so may I have a first bill second
111Heather all in favor thank you and all right so now we've already taken a motion to take everything as a slate so can I move forward with all in favor yes as the rest of the Slate is everyone comfortable with the rest of the Slate yes yes yes all in favor thank you okay we now move to special education reports we will take contracts and CS CPS approvals on page 11 as a slate uh may have a first Lisa second Bruce any questions all in favor thank you okay we move to other matters other matters include approval of the legal notice of the 2025 2026 budget hearing and the annual district election overnight field trips for Robotics and the appointment of a hearing officer for Section 75 charge we will take the matters on pages
11212 through 15 as a slate may I have a first Mark May I have a second Heather any questions I do so on these robotic field trips does the district pick up their cost of travel I'm just wondering is that what it means or what are we approving yeah so it is required for all robotics competitions by first robotics to there be assistant there this is to have the assistant be on site oh it's not the cost of travel and housing or lodging that will come we don't know what that will be yet okay but we pay that we do but we don't pay model un or anything like that we pay for the the teacher to go that's it but yeah not the lodging not the travel but we do it for robotics oh
113this is for the Shao I'm sorry I understand [Music] buter on the microphone me sorry first there's the the guy with the salt now there's the paper on the microphone no the the students fund for robotics they fund raise correct me if I'm wrong but I remember helping with the fundraising for them to for the travel so they do yeah the students pay for their own lodging and okay $3 million overage perhaps you want to just like we got some busing added in perhaps you want to talk about defraying the cost of some other trips moving forward it's it's a worthwhile conversation for a future for the next meeting I mean the Washington DC trip was 90000 yeah it's crazy it's crazy Mone I think worth a worth worthwhile conversation so um all in favor
114thank you okay we are now going to move to the first reading of the following policies on page 15 um we are going to vote to wave a full reading of these policies may I have a first bill second Lisa any questions any more comments all in favor thank you um we will now continue with our second audience to visitors hi hi are you coming are you coming up wait come up to the microphone please I know no but then the people at home can't hear you okay Qui question earlier Christine Costa mentioned enrollment is going down 20% compared to what 10 years ago over 10 years over 10 years thank you um thank you all right this agenda includes Financial reports on page 15 and these reports are for informational purposes no vote is
115necessary if needed Miss Costa will answer any questions from the Board of Education and public please feel free to call her in her office this is the discussion section of our agenda I open the floor to any other discussion items from board members of the board of education so oh yeah I have one too go ahead go ahead mine will be quick um I just we got an email about a foil request that wasn't answered and it seemed like it was it was fairly straightforward um I'm just concerned about community members getting answers in in timely a timely manner so um I don't know if that's something we need to discuss more as a board we probably I I don't know how much of a individual foil request we can discuss in a public session
116but I did want to go on record that I found disappointing that again it seems that foil requests are seem to be delayed when the information doesn't seem to be difficult to provide and legally we should be providing information to people I if you don't want to speak about a specific foil request I think I know which foil request you're speaking about that information came to us last week from the um Architects and that information is in paper format um and in consult with our attorneys they advised us to send an extension because they have to review every piece of paper and do redaction and we just received it last week and they haven't had time to do that redaction and um and how long was the request out on the architect for the information
117as soon as we received the request foil all how I don't know when weed the like a couple weeks something like that so it took them a couple weeks to get the information so we're not getting it quick enough from the vendor then to respond to people in a timely manner that's helpful to know that's what my question is we received it last week and then we call the attorneys we want to get answers to people right if we can and the information's in a paper only format and some of the documents are um this thick and this High yeah and couldn't be yeah so they're in a very tenuous uh okay thank you I you can't say the nature of the request I don't know can we I I don't know that it's if
118it's a private email that came to the board I don't think we're really supposed to yeah I I would um I believe I know what you're speaking of I would Afraid from discussing it in public okay thank you I I just wanted to be clear that we do take this seriously and that if people are requesting information it's being delayed like that's helpful information for us too as we look into whether or not to keep contracts with people too if they can't get us information in a timely manner that's another good piece of data for us it actually comes in the paper form we can't get the email drawings and things like that okay okay okay thank you Alex I have one quick thing yeah Joe I've had a number of Junior parents whose children
119are turning 17 asking can they get a parking spot um anyway I don't everyone seems to claim that the the number of Juniors who are turning 17 who can drive isn't a big number so I don't know if it's a big ask but I figured I'd bring it out if you get this approved does my kid have to drive your kids to school if I could add uh if I could add it's a policy that I don't believe has been regular vigorously enforced and so it's a little unfair for the kids that follow the rules to so it's a good question okay I'll at least take a look to see that's what I heard too so that's know why I figured it up I would definitely at least check Ines are add it to the
120list that's right thank you Joe thank you thank you just to quickly add on it's my understanding that there's some people who've proposed that maybe the upper Turf lot if parking was an issue that maybe that could be like a junior stepping stone and they could walk down the hill or something right now would be apprehensive with the snow on there you have to walk across the snowy field yes yeah okay no driving snow days snow days okay where your sow boots where your s days Joey drives okay so I'll look at the num and many spot okay everyone's favorite part of the meeting oh sorry go ahead oh yeah I was gonna we missed the first discussion too I just wanted to it's an oversight but it's all right we had a discussion earlier
121on the agenda either I missed it or um but anyway I do have some items I know people want to get home so you tell me um I'll just hit him quickly I mean I let's just try to get this off the um the the to-do list because we can't go back and forth and email and whatnot I I think it's unclear and many people don't know that Mr mono receives emails I know we add it language when people send an this went dead when people send emails to the Boe Mr monastero also receives them I don't know I know we just recently added language but I really think we should have two email addresses Boe and Boe and super and call it a day just put two email addresses for people to choose from
122and it's it's not apparent that he is being included and if I know people can individually but let's just I if the board doesn't disagree let's just get that off the to you know the list I think one of the things that came up in discussion is just the management of the email inbox because the Boe email goes to the board and to the superintendent and he is able to in his capacity as a full-time employee of the school district manage the inbox um efficiently and get it off to the questions off to the right people who work here whereas otherwise it is the board president who manages every single email so that was part of the it just more efficient for people's answers you know it it could end up taking a little bit
123more time and then it would also involve the extra steps of the board president then asking the superintendent if the per right person to reply was so and so like it would end up being three steps for people to get an answer um mark what was your thinking it's very rare reach out to the board they don't want to Joe to see that communication they want to reach out to the board and or Mr mono excuse me people specifically said that to you meaning because had one email but and that one person typed in everyone but I guarantee you a lot of people would never know I mean look you can leave it that way I don't think it's Good Housekeeping um but he's the CEO of the board isn't he yes so I don't
124how do you separate the two bodies um very easily we have super Executives and exclude him sometimes we that's different I I agree so if someone's reaching out to the board and they have a complaint or they they have something regarding Mr monastero he they don't necessar and they now we have language in there recently but it's I don't understand why we can't just have two for me they could but they don't I think I don't know it's isn't there a technology way to do this like delay it for three hours then F add Joe to it or forward it to him and it would give us a chance to call and say or you can just have if you want to email the board Boe CA or board and super boom and done I
125don't understand why it's so complicated but that's just a suggestion you don't have to go with it the other thing I know we're going to move along I mean I hope we can reach resolution on the the email thing though um the allowances I brought up the I brought up an email I'm I'm what's the um enrollment so far with kids selecting Italian as an elective do we have any four so you know the description of the course and again I know snowing out but it says Italian language and culture and then the first sentence embark on a cultural and linguistic Journey we were going to offer an additional language I thought um we're talking about Italy's Rich art history Cuisine traditions we want the kids to be conversent in a new language um this
126is not AP an AP track so the culture component not there we call other languages Spanish 1A why not Italian 1A French 1A it it it's I this doesn't I don't I'm afraid this title might turn people people off from enrolling we want to offer a third language so you believe that the title is dissuading students from signing up because it sounds so heavily about not just learning the language you're going to talk about the cuisine of Italy great I mean you know really we're talking I thought the idea was a third language component not talking about Italy's Rich Cuisine AR You Know Rich history of art Traditions I don't know why that's in I and maybe I don't know how it it morphed into that I thought um The Proposal was to add a
127third language we did um it was a joint decision we talked about the title the description the description also speaks about the students gaining linguistic abilities in Italian um and those skills um the decision was made to separate that course from all of the others and the other thing that I shared with you an email is that all of our world languages courses in embed a cultural component within the course that's not only a requirement that's good when you're for teaching a new language to anyone they have to understand things in context so that's I just went to the grocery store and bought Nutella and strawberries for crepes in French four so yeah they still they do food in those classes no I get it but you you said I know times limit you said
128cuz for the AP they need to have cultural but just keep in course could still open up options for students there's no stopping a student from challenging the AP exam for example upon taking the selective will they have that with with 40% of the class is spent on culture food and why don't we teach them conversational Italian or whatever language we picked I'm not saying because it's Italian I'm just disappointed that we we're adding a third language and we're adding a third language sort of it's almost like a fles class well research has shown that when you teach a new language along with the cultural piece of it it enhances students ability to speak that language they help it helps them to understand how to respond in in real Lifetime right at some point yes
129but in the beginning you need to building anyway with time's limited I think four people when um is a pretty bad start and I think the course sounds like a uh the description how many do you need to run it that's a decision we see how many resources we have they like okay it's a case by case basis I didn't know if you had like and and we're still going through students course selections yeah we do definitely still have more time the other topics I mean I guess we'll just wait till next time although it's it's frustrating um I I learned too that we have hold harmless didn't kick in yet so these those Mastery scores we saw they count towards their grade point average right the recent data that was shared yeah that was
130based on the scores counting either 12% or 20% I didn't realize that until after the meeting so those scores you know were not where I assume we would like them to be right and and the grades count it already the grades count counted yes yeah depending on that that's concerning again not won't spend the time on it but um we did talk about that being an area of improvement the Mastery rate um the other ones I'll just wait till next meeting because but I I I don't know what the rest of the board thinks um I thought we were adding more of a language I would I would have never proposed the idea if I knew it was going to be uh so watered down it's they're not going to learn much they're going to
131learn about I mean art pasta really we could discuss further but you're making it seem like adding a cultural component is watering down the curriculum in fact it's enhancing the curriculum but we can certainly have a further conversation about that but why doesn't it say Spanish and culture with Spanish 1A why doesn't it say French and culture all of our courses embed a cultural component you're correct that they're not included in the title right we also wanted this one to stand out compared to the other courses so there was no confusion that students could take Italian to satisfy their requirement so that was another reason for having that one stand out with a separate title but all of the courses all of our world languages courses have a cultural component I'm aware of that yep
132in the book or the resource would be with the same publisher we would use for Spanish and French so whatever content they have there would be similar to the Spanish and French content it's not only a requirement that we do it it's good practice and as I said for those who do choose to take the Italian maybe they would challenge the AP exam maybe they're going to pursue something further with Italian we don't we're not sure what they're going to do with it so we at least want to set them up for what the expectations would be for any other one of our World languages courses and the idea was that this was like the trial year to launch it right but I agree it would be nice if it had like a solid launch
133so let's I it would be I just had one really quick but does that mean the language component is the same it's just we're adding the cultural component or are they learning less Language by adding the cultural it's so I spoke to miss Wilkins just to get an understanding because Mr italiante wanted a breakdown of what percent she said across the board and and it varies slightly from course to course but it's about 60% to 40% of language to culture in all the classes roughly all the languages it's very it's it's challenging to quantify that's a lot switched the name to uh Spanish and culture and uh well the AP exam is actually called a Spanish Spanish 1A and SP and French 1A cuz this is 1A this is Italian right but just so everyone
134knows the AP exam is called I'm going to give Spanish as an example AP Spanish language and culture that is the name of the AP exam all of our courses leading up to that exam are helping to prepare students for that level okay thank you we have one more board member with another question um with regard to course schedules I think we should look at possibly not printing them um they're beautiful and they're bound so lovely I know my daughter received it after we had already had our um meeting so I think it might be great if we went digital for all of them because I can't imagine how digital for everything I can't wait to not have this anymore this got delivered at my house and I literally like a terrible reaction but have
135it digital keep it digital okay it's all of a digital okay so thank you it is late it is snowing just for the record Mark the first discussion wasn't in my script script so we'll put it back in it was not purposeful we love a robust discussion all right so um right yes we do robust discussions all right so thank you may I have a motion to adjourn Heather a second Kate any questions all in favor