001okay hi everyone the the board has returned from executive session and there were no other actions taken may I have a motion to open the meeting Bill may I have a second Lisa all in favor all right let's rise for the Pledge of Allegiance under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right so um tonight we are recognizing Milan lustig uh he's received the distinguished honor of being named a regeneron science Talent search semifinalist it's amazing we congratulate you on this recognition and wish you the best of luck as you continue through the process congratulations we're so proud of you I have a you know what J since he was a freshman in high school um coming into the ptg meetings doing uh robotics demonstrations and just every year you just get more
002and more impressive and this is this was a no-brainer of course you were going to win it so congratulations we're all going to be working for him one day I tell him all the time [Applause] so for all right so every meeting we hear from students from each of our buildings and um about everything going on in their locations and tonight we're pleased to welcome representatives from the junior high school come on up junior high students sorry technology could be slow sometimes hold on I know why it's coming up to see for e for for for okay com you got start you're starting you're starting you're starting here go here go here hello my name is feta I'm Emma and um I'm Andrew here are some highlights of what the junior high has been doing
003over the past four months 131 new seventh graders entered the junior senior high school hallways on September 3rd 2024 we kicked off the the year with the remembrance bll honoring those who fought during World War II thank you to all of our teachers who taught us how World War II influenced the world around this time junior high students also took part in team building activities seventh graders found themsel learning how to work together at the Brookeville Nature Park and a week later eighth graders came together to overcome challenges at comset state park by late September both 7th and eighth graders were running for positions on the student council the result the results were president Sarah pacy 8th grade vice president Lyla Newman 7th grade vice president Sebastian Barry secretary laurano treasurer Andrew leopard Representatives Talia
004AR arado and Olivia pinkowski Emma ler and vieta young one of the student council's first tasks was creating a B Banner for homecoming they did an amazing job the seventh graders also had the opportunity to learn about the dangers of social media when officer Levy from the suffi County Police Department came in and spoke with us we appreciate the time and effort taken to protect us during November the Junior High student council raised ran a fundraiser in collaboration with White Post Farms offering the members of culturing Harbor community everything from delicious breads to perfect holiday pies once winter hit the junior high was in full swing celebrating the holidays in cold weather the student council ran our annual candy cane gram Drive selling over 200 candy canes with little messages to the recipient which were
005then distributed before the December break these sweet treats were the perfect way to enter into the December break another way that Junior High celebrated was by performing for the loved ones during the winter concert we want to thank Mr gini Mr s Angelo Mr hucker and Mr for their hard work and dedication to the music program right before the break the junior high students with the help of Mrs Yul Smith had a toy funders here to provide new gifts to children to Cohen's Children's Hospital thank you to all the students who had who and teachers who participated in this toy drive and a special thanks to Miss J Smith who coordinated this event thank you for your time and have a good night [Applause] thank you so much junior high students that was great thank
006you does anyone have any questions for our junior high students no okay thank you very much wonderful job all right so um as the president I'm going to give you my president's report I just need to find it here on my phone um all right so good evening again everyone I'd like to give you um a little update on where we are with regionalization I'm actually going to read you a uh press release that went out from 21 school districts including Cold Spring Harbor this week just have to make the font bigger okay um so this is from uh January 9th 2025 21 school districts eight New York state legislators two municipalities a local teachers union a non-for-profit with 1900 members a mayor and three individuals have commenced litigation to anull the New York State
007Department or New York State EDS uh education Department's final regionalization rule which went effective on Christmas Eve by the rule New York nysed has mandated that the regionalization of school districts across the state usurping the statutorily prescribed local control of elected school boards to the unelected commissioner the rule will not only transform the public school system but will impact the fabric of local communities to to suppress public outcry nysed has misrepresented that rule that the rule is optional but the plain text of the final rule states school districts and supervisory districts shall begin the implementation of approved regionalization plans no later than the start of the 2627 school year this is a mandate to avoid litigation the petitioners asked nyed to withdraw the rule or modify the mandatory text to be consistent with Ned's public
008representations that the rule is optional nyed refused stating it is not interested in any settlement of the issue the position demonstrates that NYS refuses to relinquish its Newfound power the Mandate controls the petitioners were left with no choice but to sue to anull Andor modify the rule so that's where we are now um additionally we've received further communication from the Attorney General's office on our registration policy we are um going to be considering that and we'll be putting that up for vote at our next meeting so that will be in February and um unfortunately Mr mono is not able to attend the meeting tonight I have um Dr Brody here running the meeting with me and um we're going to look forward to an extra special report from Mr mono next month so tonight we
009have three updates and presentations the first is on District comparisons of grades 3 through 8 New York State Testing and region results we will also have information on the 2025 2026 school calendar and we will finish with a upk update so miss latud are you kicking us off all right thank you sorry I'm just trying to get myself organized here I apologize okay can you hear me all right so follow following uh Mr Milan lustig being named the semifinalist in regen one of the semi-finalists in regener regeneron we have uh many other things to celebrate so we're going to start with this Slide the purpose of tonight's presentation is just to bring to light how our data in Cold Spring Harbor compares to that of other school districts so this slide provides an excerpt of
010data from news day on students overall performance on the New York state grade 3 through Ela and math assessments by District reporting that state test scores are down this year for ELA and slightly down for mathematics across the state despite this downward Trend CSH ranked in the top three out of 126 Long Island districts for ELA and in the top six of 118 Long Island districts for mathematics when you put it all together for ELA and math Cold Spring Harbor is in the top three overall for grades 3 through eight New York State assessments behind quag and Manhasset and ahead of saset Northshore and Jericho that's for the 2024 results you should know that quag which is ranked number one is a single School District serving grades K through six with a total enrollment of
01175 students since quad's assessment data only includes grades 3 through six it may not be directly comparable to to that of other districts serving grades 3 through 8 as we take a closer look at this data the 202 2024 data revealed that Cold Spring Harbor had one of the highest Ela proficiency rates on Long Island ranking third behind quag and Manhasset that's the blue area that you see circled there Colt Spring Harbor had one of the highest participation rates for ELA on Long Island ranking third behind herck and quag and that's the yellow area right here additionally outside of quag Cold Spring Harbor had the lowest percentage of students scoring a level one for those of you who don't know level one means that you're not meeting grade level standards and we had the lowest
012um outside of quag lowest percentage when comparing the ELA re M results to the previous school year so you'll see on this side this is basically the slide that we just looked at 23 24 the ranking of Cold Spring Harbor improved in 2024 rising from sixth in rank to third the participation rate also increased while the overall proficiency rate remained consistent unlike most other districts who decreased in their proficiency rates you can see the arrows on the side which show uh which districts went up which districts went down you'll see down is the the red arrow green going up and the yellow means they stayed approximately the same we will also examine the results of our comparative districts by grade level to identify both areas of strength and those requiring Improvement but first let's look
013at the Mastery rates okay so everything you've seen up to this point this was data from news day the next slide one to break this down by Mastery so this data was not available on Newsday this is where I would go for data on other school districts data. nd.gov this slide shows the Mastery rates for ELA across our comparative districts say we're looking at the blue areas Mastery is a level four on the assessment so this is where we're looking although these rates were not reported in Newsday we were able to retrieve this data from the New York State data website as I shared please note it's really important that everybody understands this is the same cohort of districts from the previous slide but not necessarily the top 10 across Long Island districts for Mastery
014in order to get that we would need to do this analysis on every single School District ac across Long Island within this group by the way in case you don't know uh Mastery is uh level four on the New York State assessment within this group of districts Cold Spring Harbor was one of the few alongside quag and Manhasset to show an increase in the percentage of students achieving Mastery in ela so as you look at the side here you will see this is what Newsday was reporting on that a lot of districts are going down they were speaking about proficiency you can also see that Trend in the Mastery Although our placement in for Mastery in ela has shifted upwards in comparison to the other Long Island School districts CTS ring Harbor remains committed to
015continuous Improvement and what I mean by that is I I show you on the side here you have the 2223 same school districts and then and where we are in 23 24 recent literacy initiatives have focused on small group and individualized instruction to address students specific needs fostering a culture of academic growth for all students we believe that the addition of a literacy coach has been instrumental in supporting our staff throughout this work and we are grateful for the board's continued supports went too fast so this slide is still Ela but now broken down by grade level so taking a deeper dive so overall as I shared we were third uh in terms of the ELA how did we rate in terms of our grade levels you'll notice at the bottom you'll see out where
016we stand with respect to those districts compared to 23 24 at the top you will notice our performance from the prior school year uh which is at the bottom as we compare to the top there was an increase in proficiency rates for Cold Spring Harbor along with improved rankings among this cohort of districts in grades three 4 7 and 8 again that's credible and something that we we are celebrating as mentioned in October there was a decline in proficiency rates for grades five and six which you can still see that was discussed in October which may be attributed to these students taking are you okay okay which may be attributed to these students taking computer-based tests for the first time we know that there are a lot of other variables but I want to be
017clear that that uh those were the two grades taking CBT for the first time six with the exception of Jericho in grade five achieving an increase of about three percentage points from the prior year for longer right it's not that everyone started correct this year it was just that we happened to a lot of yes a lot of other school districts have had the CBT in place for several years it was new for us so I don't I'm not saying that's the only Factor it could have been a factor uh by grade I mean uh yeah Mastery by grade uh I I don't this was a lot of data to compile I could certainly add on something similar to this with Mastery but I don't have this specific chart broken down by Mastery okay but
018I I could get it for you okay moving on to math this is now back to the Newsday data you could see the top 10 in the leand corner we were were within the top 10 this slide shows our proficiency rates for mathematics now alongside those of our comparative districts as shared in Newsday where Cold Spring Harbor ranked sixth across all Long Island schools as a reminder our sixth grade math data was only based on the results of one of our elementary schools in turn the math data including participation rate for Cold Spring Harbor may be skewed outside of quag Cold Spring Harbor had the lowest percent of students scoring a level one so again you'll notice similar to the other slide we have our proficiency rate proficiency means that we're scoring at least a
019level three and that's why you see the level three to four at the top the total percent tested this is our participation rate and then the percentage of students with a level one it's also worth noting that our proficiency rate is within 1/10th of Jericho 2/10 of East Williston and 7/10 of saset in other words they're very close and you'll see that here on the chart this shows again the slide that you just saw for 2324 and how does that compare to where we were last year with these same districts regarding math proficiency rates colds Harbor has a slightly lower ranking when compared to other Long Island School Districts from the prior school year this is for mathematics and our proficiency rate is up from the prior school year you will notice by looking at
020the arrows to the far right that proficiency is up for all top 10 Long Island districts for mathematics with the exception of Jericho which remain flat the next slide is again this was inw workings of pulling out the individual data from the New York State education department website this slide shows the Mastery rates for mathematics across our comparative districts and those would be the blue areas now Mastery again level four although these rates were not reported in Newsday again I I explain where these were achieved from please note that this is the same cohort of districts from the previous slide but not necessarily the top 10 across Long Island schools for percent Mastery within this cohort of districts quag and Cold Spring Harbor achieved the greatest percent increase in Mastery rate with nearly a 20%
021increase for Cold Spring Harbor so you can see here in 2223 here's where we were at for Mastery 37.0% and we are at 44.1 and that represents a 20% increase there's a difference between talking about percentage points versus percent increase okay similar to the other slide for ELA the math assessments are here broken down by grade level now so we can see how did we compare with these districts from one year to the next an increase in proficiency rates for Cold Spring Harbor along with improved rankings among this cohort of districts was observed in grades 3 7 and 8 again there were incredible gains in grade eight which represents a 30% increase in proficiency from the prior year so I'm talking about um all the way over here for grade eight in the prior year
022we had a 73% proficiency rate and here we are now at the top within this particular cohort of districts um not the same for the other area we can see we're at the the top in math 7 and we have some some room for improvement here as mentioned in October there was a decline in proficiency rates for grades four five and six however as we all talked about in October it's really important that we look at our cohort data in other words we're following our kids from one grade to the next for grade 4 the 2024 results reflect an increase in achievement for this cohort of students compared to the previous school year their proficiency rate as third graders was around 83% compared to approximately 91% in [Applause] 2024 results are great I I was
023noticing though also that like last year's sixth and seventh grade are this year's seventh and eighth grade right so that's they over they performed really nicely also um and then those are the dips that you're talking about right like correct the fifth yep but then they went up just looking at it that way yeah so similar dips yeah similar dips um again these are for five and six not that they're the only ones but for five and six uh yes there were dips from the prior year again we don't have um all of the data for six as you know and this was the first time our students were taking the exam on the computer right yeah no that's and it's good to see grades holding at such a high level too right yeah that's
024great all right before we move on to region exams did anybody have any questions on grade three through eight truly incredible achievements I mean none none of this happens due to one thing this is everybody working together uh truly incredible efforts by our students supported by their families our teachers uh a lot to be proud of here okay moving on to Regent exam data I know this is really tiny um I don't know if you all have it on your phones in front of you or you have the presentation so I'm sorry it's I tried to make it as large as I could so now we get into the comparative data for our Regents exams and we will begin with the comparisons of proficiency meaning a score of 65 or high as we examine this
025data more closely it's important to consider the total number of students tested for each exam particularly when small sample sizes could skew the results for example only 14 students took the physics region in Cold Spring Harbor with 12 of the 14 achieving proficiency keep in mind that our AP Physics students do not take the Rance exam if just one more student achieved proficiency the percentage would have increased to 93% so we just want you to be aware you know as we look at physics for example there is a a chance for the data to be skewed due to that sample size while it's valuable to compare Cold Spring Harbor with other high- performing districts we must be mindful of the other factors that can influence the results such as differences in diff District structures varying
026levels of particip a in athletics and diverse emphases on academics we are a Class B school for example due to our size but we compete against larger schools due to our ability for the past three school years Cold Spring Harbor has received School of Distinction distinction honors for having all of our programs recognize as scholar athlete teams we've also had our boys lacrosse team state champions 22 23 24 girls lacrosse 2024 state champions girls soccer 2024 Class B Long Island Champions and girls tennis 2023 2022 State finalists in comparison to this cohort of districts Colt Spring Harbor has more teams 21 programs across 75 teams than these districts with the exception of saset why is this important it demonstrates that we have a high percentage of students participating in athletics while keeping a close watch
027on their academic studies we are proud of and fully support our students dedication to becoming well-rounded individuals our goal is to Foster an environment where each student can Thrive develop diverse skills and contribut contribute positively to their Community nonetheless we remain committed to continuous Improvement and working toward the board goal of increasing our rankings regarding Regents and AP exams targeted topic specific review sessions have been implemented over the past 3 years in addition to ongoing review sessions held in class and during teachers extra help periods time is also allocated during department meetings and superintendent conference days for teachers to analyze data identify Trends and adjust instruction accordingly in terms of this particular data uh wanted to have you note that the June 2022 region exam in US history was cancelled uh by NY which is
028why you're going to see that data missing in the subsequent charts all right so what are we seeing from from this data our 2024 proficiency rates for Regents exams alongside those of our comparative districts are approximately within three points of the top performing comparative district with the exception of US History geometry earth science and physics and you can see that on the chart whereas we are the leading I'm sorry we are leading all comparative districts in Algebra 1 for the June 20 24 Administration bear with me a second a little sticky a historic iCal look back for Cold Spring Harbor over the past several years shows that our Region's proficiency rate in physics continues to improve okay so we can see physics I'm on the wrong side excuse me I was looking at that I
029said that doesn't make any sense sorry about that here's physics that I was talking about uh continuing to improve for proficiency that's the 65 or higher now as we look this is for 22 this is our own data now 22 23 and 24 just to look at it without having numbers I I know it our eyes start to glaze over sometimes we're looking at a lot of numbers so I think it's helpful to just look at the bars right now if anybody wants to look at the numbers by the way I do have a link down there and you could happily bring it all up so this gives us an indication for the last three years remember 2021 uh was the year after covid where we didn't have the exams and of course 2020 was
030covid so these are the in terms of a five-year look back this is what we have we can see as I stated before we can see where we're improving so it looks like there's been a slight dip in our proficiency rates across some region exams for the 2024 Administration compared to the prior school year uh but their comparisons to 2022 reflect Improvement and Cold Spring Harbor remains steady on the higher side for Algebra 1 global history and Ela and you can see that on this chart as they are the the highest and they are maintaining consistency moving on to here we go Mastery our Mastery rates for region exams continue to be an area for improvement although gains in Mastery continue to be observed in living environment earth science Algebra 1 and US history so
031as we keep saying there there is always room for improvement and and this would be the area we need to improve upon I would say this would be our highest priority area would be the Mastery on the regions exams as we continue to strive towards improved rankings one of the board goals it is important to note that proficiency and Mastery rates on regions exams in English Math and Science along with those of AP exams contribute to the US News best high schools rankings proficiency has a weight of 1.0 while Mastery has a weight of 1.5 with respect to the US News and World Reports best high schools rankings so that's important for everyone to know right so how are those how our rankings comprised they take our AP scores they take our regions data and
032a few other factors and and that's how they're coming up with our rankings any questions so far so it's on the next page I was going to ask directional how are these scores from prior years it's on the next page okay oh from our prior years yeah so we can see here on this slide um speaking about our our Mastery rates this is now breaking down for us without all the numbers how are we doing with respect to ma Mastery when we compare it to ourselves um so as we go through we can see for living environment we have a nice Trend Happening Here increasing continuing from 2022 uh we have Earth science same again slight increase from the prior Year from 2024 Heather question was do it seems like generally speaking the proficiency rats
033are more consistent with the comparative school districts aside from a couple of spots when we're looking at Mastery it looks like a big difference across the board what are we attributing that to and what's your recommendation to to to address that yeah so I have I'm going to get there um in terms of what are we attributing it to it it really depends uh let me just if I could just finish this train of thought of how we're doing and then I will get back to um to your question so um earth science steady increase so to your point Heather we see chemistry so we're just focusing on what are what are the areas that need that um that Focus chemistry is down from the prior year but still up from 2022 but it's still
034an area the Mastery chart with the breakdown of each class and I was looking at that comparing it to the proficiency chart and noticing that we're just a just on the proficiency chart we're like right there just a couple of points you know away from some of the comparative districts but there AG huge Gulf when we're looking at the Mastery so why are we more successful of proficiency and not as successful at the Mastery like what is and why and what can we do stop like fix well there's never unfortunately there's never going to be one answer I would say that in in terms of Mastery rigor is going to have something to do with that right and so not to say the teachers aren't offering a rigorous curriculum but taking a close look about
035how the assessments align to what the expectations are on the exam so I have a list of improvements ways to improve uh to go through so strategies for improvement include and do it doesn't have to be limited to this list analyzing past performance which we keep doing right so we've been offering time to staff and department leaders to analyze the data teachers are able to see the their classes data individually as well as how they compare to the region teachers also have the ability to see which standards for example their students may not be doing as well on so that when they they move forward they're able to specifically address those areas that's going to change from year to year may not be the same standards providing tailored review sessions so you should notice that
036we have these quarterly review sessions in place so quarters one two and three look a little different than quarter 4 but all of them require the topic that is going to be discussed so the teachers are using their assessment data to think about what what do our students need more support in and so all of these review sessions that are happening well for those that are happening throughout each quarter are tailored review sessions to specific topics based on the data I would also suggest uh simulating test conditions testing conditions what does that mean so do our students have the stamina we know that you know it's it's an immediate gratification Society right so it's hard for people to sit still for a long time right they're going to be taking an exam that's that's two
037to three hours in duration so that was another reason why the review sessions in quarter 4 have a two hour they can be two hours in duration or they can be an hour and a half part of that time could be used to help build stamina where students are practicing some questions on the spot and then right away getting feedback from those questions so simulating test conditions is important I think that students need to feel what it's like to sit there for two to three hours taking these assessments and I would also say that doing that at home that's not something that just has to take place in the classroom or during a review session uh students should be T practicing these exams um as we know New York State education department has a whole
038web page devoted to all of the past exam exams uh it's very easy for students to bring up prior exams to see how long they're taking on questions and timing themselves and making sure they could sit there for the two to three hours so that that's an important piece as well uh regularly administr administering formative assessments quizzes practice exams really important to gauge student understanding throughout the year uh teachers are working that they're they're giving quizzes through throughout the way um to assess students uh progress um something that I I just mentioned but I'll reiterate using online resources and platforms that offer Regents exam practice videos and interactive tools Con Academy for example can be an excellent Tool uh for additional practice that would be if if I'm going to recommend any it's going to
039be KH Academy I would say is a reputable place to go ensuring that c our curriculum is closely aligned with the Regent exam specifications there have been uh changes to some of our Regents exams if you remember the notice that went out last year was our first administration of the algebra 1 exam which is why it was earlier in June compared to all of the other assessments so you know we just keep making sure as things change that we are prepared for those changes there's curriculum line curriculum writing that goes along with all of those changes and the department leaders and teachers have been on top of those things uh Jen sorry that wasn't the first time they took Algebra 1 region last year no the first time taking the new standards oh the new
040standards okay thank you I was going to say that's not right so there is a timeline for many of our regions exams are changing changing in some way shape or form we've been hearing a lot about common core versus NextGen learning standards we've been hearing about these NextGen for the past what 10 years or so I it's just with covid it slowed things down so the upcoming Regents exams are going to be based on the next gen learning standard I have a question it was a point you brought up earlier about physics so using phys physics as an example here and we're such a small school district students who take the higher level physics don't take the regions is that right students in AP Physics right okay so they're not taking it so and then
041so in other school districts is Regents physics considered a higher level class or is that also just the physics that other kids would take at that point is it higher level compared to like is there like a basic physics too do you know we also have a physics non- Regent we do have a physics non- region also and do they at Jericho have physics non like my question is are we disproportionately having higher level we a small group of kids right like how our varsity teams pull up kids from eighth grade sometimes our are all of our higher performing science students in the AP Physics making it harder for us to have as many kids do Mastery just there's less kids I I would argue is that what you were saying I couldn't say for
042certain okay uh but I would argue yes that that if we had our AP Physics students taking that exam which as we know in terms of region requirements for graduation and advanced uh region diplomas I'm sure students aren't doing that because it's it's not really a need for them they can satisfy all of that without taking a physics region and just in a bigger school there's more kids taking all of these classes there are more kids and some school districts I don't have that list for you right now and I could certainly investigate if you would like but some schools may require that their AP Physics students also take the re can we find that out I I could look into sorry that would be really interesting I actually think so to know if just
043just specifically for not all the subjects but like let's look at physics right because I I am not a physics person but I from what I've seen of physics it seems like it's a really good program here so perhaps if at Jericho and saset their AP kids are taking the physics region where maybe we're not looking apples that's why I brought up that point before we have very few we have 14 students who are taking the exam and it's it's tough and that's why I want us to take all of this with a grain of salt right like it's important to see where we stand but we have this issue of a small sample size now being compared to other school districts okay yeah is that the same with all the classes or is that
044just physics I included I know it's tiny but I included the total number tested for all of the schools I would say in this cohort of districts we would be closely aligned with East Williston in terms of the the total number tested so that's why I included that information on this slide I meant like with the AP like is there is everyone taking the Ala regions or people taking AP English and not taking the exam I everyone's taking Ela it's just physics that that's applied to or are there other ones that that TR in our school district it's only the AP Physics kids yeah so we have students in other AP courses for example AP US History they're also taking that Regent so you still have to take reg for US History correct okay and
045and that's not it's not required it's just our students are doing it because it's helping them to get an advanced region diploma that's another low one right yeah yeah so US history is yeah so you I I think I heard you say Alex that it was another the US History right yes so US history is and I think I skipped over one of my notes I did have a note about us history that is based on the new that's the new framework Okay so but you were going to say something else I'm just going to get my notes on that effici yeah yeah yeah know I know I know so for US history and government uh so yes that is an area of um another area where we we need Improvement um that the teachers
046have been working on with their students the new exam US history and government places a greater focus on students ability to analyze historical documents sources and data rather than simply recalling factual information and I know Mr damusy has uh brought this up as well in reviewing our regions data for example the enduring issues essay requires students to identify a long-standing issue or challenge in US history and demonstrate how it has persisted over time they need to analyze how this issue has affected different groups individual and the country as a whole and to explain how it has been addressed or not in different historical periods so it's a just no it's a a different exam than it had been in past years not that we can't be doing well in it we certainly can be doing
047better in it um but just so you know it's a new framework the new framework that they're being assessed on I'm sorry if I missed this so are there some uh of these categories where our AP student students are also taking the regent exams so AP US get my number where it's 36.7 yes okay so I mean sample size I know we have a small sample size in physics but the the data um are useless if there are AP students taking if it's apples and oranges way it's not the size of the sample as much as if they're being co-mingled cuz then we're having AP students compared to our non-ap students I understand that that's why I kind of gave a disclaimer so I'm saying though like we really can't it's not your fault but
048this data can't be used really to do any sort of analysis if we don't know what's co-mingled but where we have our AP students taking the region we can certainly use that score that everything else it's just that's the only one so yeah I know I missed that I was sorry I was I admit it but uh not going to lie so uh it's the only category that then AP or our AP students are taking every category here I think AP chm they don't take the Regents so AP chm for example we they're also taking the chemistry regions not if they took the chemistry regions though you may not as same year correct nonap chemistry the same year wa you may not like I you may take something that's what I'm trying to figure out
049but if you take AP Chemistry chances are you took regular chemistry because AP Chemistry is really hard um and so you would take the Regent with chemistry but you only take the chem Regent one time so you wouldn't take it with chem with regular chem and then AP cem okay got it right so it might not be with this data in other words um so is this really analyzable then or it so all we're doing today is we're seeing how we compare to our other high- performing districts I completely agree with you and that's why we do this however we we know that we have a lot of other factors I will also share I mentioned structures so in other districts these other high- performing districts Jericho Manhasset East Williston Northshore many of them have
050individual department leaders we have a different structure here not to say that it's not working I'm just letting you know that there are different structures in place for all of these schools so we're we're seeing where we stand but we have different structures we also have a different percentage of students participating in athletics that I shared before we have a very high participation rate of our students in athletics what does that mean for us that mean and extracurricular activities that means they're involved with something after school and not getting home until 7 8 9:00 at night and still working on their school work you know to to do well on their in their courses on their assessments so I look at it as I I'm so proud of our kids and our teachers I get
051very emotional about it I'm really proud of them because to accomplish what we're accomplishing with giving our students a balanced program here is truly off the charts yes we always have room for growth and I would say Mastery is the one that stands out but we've been focusing on literacy our literacy numbers are going up we've been focusing on IPS our AP results are are the highest than they've been in and as far as we could look back so this is another area where we just need some TLC the teachers are on board they they're doing great they're they know what they have to do but we are I we're very lucky here that we believe in exposure for our students exposure we let them you want to take an AP course come on in
052you're happy with getting your 70s in a challenging course good for you because that's going to mean great things for you in college so this is great that we're looking at it but for me personally this is not the end this is good to see where we stand but I agree there's too many what are they doing there what are we doing here at the end of the day we know what we're we're trying to accomplish here and our kids are doing great with everything that they're doing in this District so we should all this is a proud proud moment for all of us so and you you detailed an act plan I too just quickly back Mark to your data points I think one of the good things is Jen you've been so good
053through the years of doing these really really very detailed data presentations which I think have really helped to we keep talking about like turning these dials right and we're seeing it go up so the next thing is the Mastery right the proficiency is up the Mastery will go up I mean this is I I think this is outstanding thank you yeah you detailed an action plan on on how to raise scores um one thing you didn't mention which I think has some support amongst the faculty is hold harmless um so where does that play in do these other schools do you know count as part of the grade point average so I I don't know if anyone has changed recently but I do have a list um all I know at this time is uh
054that region exam scores count in uh saset East Williston and Great Neck I'm not sure if they Chang their percentage I know that schools who are continuing to count the exams they were typically held at 20% um have decided to lower but still count it uh hold harmless I know that Jericho for a fact is hold harmless and our district is now hold harmless I that's the only de I know Mr dansky and I are working on getting a more comprehensive list but I will tell you that each from year to year it's been changing some are saying we're going to go hold hold harmless and then they change their mind so we're working on getting you an updated list but I know you have more to say about it do you think it would
055help or hinder hold harmless these scores you always give me these trick questions I'm trying to learn it's not a trick question what's your professional opinion I have no education background well I would say I would say that I want to go back to the reason why we came to that decision to begin with right and I think that the the concern by families what was GPA because I will tell you and Mona mentioned this during one of her presentations last year gpas are still important to colleges I would say that they're up there with the the the level of which students are challenging themselves are they taking these challenging courses or are they taking it easy during their their senior year for their junior senior year for example so I think what what parents
056and families expressed is that our G they felt like their gpas were almost being held hostage because it could cause for example a student to go from a B+ to a b and then they would argue my child is competing for a spot in college with all of these other schools who may not be counting the regions in their grade and therefore their grade may be higher as a result of that so some deemed it as being unfair so the rigor on a region exams higher than the rigor on a Cold Spring Harbor exam or a Cold Spring Harbor final so you're telling me a state test say higher rigor than a Cold Spring heart I didn't say that so we should want the kid I didn't say that and I'm not saying that okay
057I'll leave it at that um however what to answer your question I think that for students if something counts may they work a little bit harder towards it sure the other argument to that is it appears on the child's transcript right and so many of our students here are aspiring to achieve what's called an advanced Regent diploma so for that reason and those were the arguments you know for switching to hold harmless um but to your point mark I think it Go could go either I could support either way but I will say would Stu some students try a little bit harder if they knew it was counting as 20 12% of their grade possibly I can't say that for certain there are some school dist districts out there where their grades are encountered and
058students are doing the same if not better so it's hard to say number one exactly Jericho's number one they're hold harmless yeah yeah and I I know when kids got into college I know no one studied after that they just mailed it in so I'm just I know Jen has three presentations tonight right is it three Jen the next one is really very I'll even sit up my chair it from there yeah okay I'm getting cut off no you're not getting cut off but we're getting off topic and that's my responsibility part of the discussion actually we've had this discussion over and over again okay but go ahead Mark I'm done any other questions not for me thank you Jen okay thank you everyone than you J I like a new template was different I
059liked following the arrows but he noticed yeah know look it was visually very appealing thank you actually I'm going to bring this with me because speed things along oh I'm not I think there's is there a discussion I think between my other [Laughter] presentations are we doing calendar thanks thanks thanks do you want to do up or do you want to do calendar let's do calendar is next on let's do calendar right why not we'll stay in order who is leading the calendar discussion yes please I think it's on it's just on okay just on just get in there in charge okay okay so we're going to discuss we have two draft calendar vote for next year if you look at draft one draft one has two superintendent conference days on August 27th and 28th
060School the first day of school for students would be September 2nd Tuesday September 2nd this calendar includes a vacation day on April 2nd which is would be the first day of the April break and as well as the Friday the 22nd of May which is the Friday before Memorial Day so that's the first proposed calendar um those are just the major portions of it um the second proposed calendar the superintendent's conference days would be September 2nd and 3rd Tuesday Wednesday students first day of school would be Thursday September 4th that would then eliminate the vacation day on April 2nd which then the kickoff to that break would be Friday uh April 3rd and then we also would not have the Friday before Memorial Day so we would just have Memorial Day uh May 25th I
061would also add that draft number one which is the August start date that also gives us two contingency days in the event of inclement weather whereas the second calendar would not we would have to lose days from someplace else should there be inclement weather in that scenario so where would you where would we normally take the days in calendar 2 if there was like a snowstorm um that would come it it really depends um normally we wait until April break so depending on where it would probably be Friday the 10th would be the first day to go would that be put in the calendar at that point that that would be a if we went with draft two would it be put in the calendar that the April 10th could be a continu generally it
062would say should there be inclement weather and we we necessitate a day it would be taken from this and then this we usually only go like you know you pray we're only going in for two and hope that there's none um so in that respect calendar one just does afford us more wiggle room in terms of Mother Nature sorry I know you're you're the relief pitcher today okay do you know have we normally I know this year in probably last year we've had the extra two days have have we ever had a year recently where we didn't have the extra days oh SE and you come back I'm sorry I all have to in September starting no you mean in general not having snow where I have extra days to take away we usually build
063them in from my like recollection in school year it is general practice to build them in just in case because otherwise then you start taking away and then people get upset because they have a vacation plan then that's not how it rolls out I just right they don't come to school cuz it's in the middle of a vacation right right exactly just something I wanted to bring up because I know it keeps coming up in recent years that last day of school the 26th that's the Region's raing day so that's something that we don't have any control of right that's set by the state because that day keeps on getting pushed it seems back further and further and people want to start sometimes sleep away camp and you know that's like the number one complaint
064we hear about school going too late is that sleep waking up starts before school end do anything about right because that's set by the state exactly so basically this the state sets the Region's calendar and the last region exam usually it's physics actually ironically is that morning and then that's why they do poorly that is a little bit of it yes that is kind of a little bit true um should make it first so yeah we we have absolutely no control over that and then the and but how does that affect the elementary school kids the region State you know that's the question that parents ask if it's a regent date then why does it apply to elementary kids that's that's like the push back question so well the other thing too is that we're
065making a calendar to make sure that we have enough days to meet the requirements so yeah I mean even though the Regence does kind of drive the bus the bus still has to drive 181 days so right and a lot of schools outside of new New York start earlier which is also one of the reasons why when you look at AP APS right they've had like a month of more school at a lot of schools right we've had for in New York right okay yeah [Applause] um all right well we need to adopt this tonight so does anyone have any other questions about it this is just the presentation though the the adoptions later in the agenda is that right yeah okay and um which which superintendent conference days did the teachers prefer the one
066having superintendent conference days in September or having them in August I believe that they enjoy the August the September they but they don't want it not having it at all isn't an option wait are we are we allowed to do that no are we allowed to take a comment from the um I would I would say stick to the public okay okay okay okay we're not we're not voting currently so okay okay okay so okay so we will then discuss both options again later in the agenda okay thank you okay um now the upk pr presentation so cute I'm just going to give a very brief update but I couldn't help myself by putting some pictures together of our upk students so so before we get into the update for our 2526 School Year how's
067it going in 202 2425 so these pictures give a glimpse into a day of upk and you can see there's some exploration happening you see the uh the homemade binoculars in the upper right hand corner we have students writing their their letters in the bottom right hand corner a little outside activity in the bottom middle section there what did we find here and they're all looking at at what it is that she found um some science experiments um the in in our classes students have classroom jobs and that is the chart that you see there in yellow towards the bottom uh the students have their faces associated with what job they have in the classroom we have students reading you could see the one student in the upper leftand corner pointing to the words as
068she's reading them and we have uh on the bottom left a student who is watering the plant they they find acorns outside in the fall they were collecting acorns they plant things I mean this is just a a wonderful glimpse into what's happening and if you could just indulge me for 46 seconds there is a yeah if it works this is just one of their Recaps do they do this every week uh so this is from Westside so Goose Hill does the pictures and Westside does a brief little video with all the pictures every week incredible so we just wanted you to see just get a little glimpse into what they're doing and we're we're so excited I know Dr Barnes if he's still around here is truly over the moon having upk in his
069building and has said quote unquote that it has elevated his building so um in terms of what's Happening how are we we're already preparing for 2526 believe it or not so everyone was very excited we had the upk Lottery application that was opened from November 22nd through of December there were 77 interested families in our upk program for the 2526 school year last year we had 69 interested families and just while we're on that note um many people have been asking about the waiting list uh we had 33 people on the waiting list last year and we nearly were able to get through um the the waiting list with the exception of three to four people um not sure if that's similar situation would happen uh but currently we are confident to say we can
070open up two classes here for the 2526 school year and based on the number of sections that become finalized we have to see if a third section is possible or not so right now it is at two sections so uh for the 77 families uh there will be a number of them on the waiting list a virtual parent meeting was held on December 3rd so we wanted to make sure that before the deadline of the application that parents had the opportunity to ask questions so I hosted a virtual meeting on December 3rd um following that meeting prior to the holiday break we had families receive their child's random number for the upk lottery it's not that we're picking out names every family is given a random number and then the numbers are randomly chosen through
071if you can imagine a a bingo Ball Contraption that's what we're using for the the lottery uh the lottery was held on January 7th so it was we got back from the break and that Tuesday we held the lottery All Families were invited to attend the lottery the lottery was also recorded but not posted because during the lottery not only is there a random drawing but I am announcing the student's name eventually who is pulled out and so if anyone contested the the lottery the recording is available if anyone would like to come in and see the recording and they were not able to attend uh the remaining 41 children after the 36 were added to the waiting list in order of their drawn numbers so at this time none of the families who secured
072an open seat have voiced their declination of a seat not to say it's not going to happen but at this time we have not heard of any declinations families were notified on January 8th about their child so that night I posted the the random numbers on our website for those who were very anxious to find out um and then all families received emails uh the following day um specifically with the name of their child appearing in the email just they they said wait is this an accident or is this really my child so we just wanted to reduce any angst by families um as we said locations for upk have yet to be determined uh being that class sections for 2526 have not been finalized and then information about registration will be forthcoming it's planned
073to take place in February and March although we do have some parents who just email me every day to say can we fill out that ride they're really anxious to get themselves secured um so starting in February they can register so uh that is where we are with our upk update did anybody have any questions or discussion and while we're thinking about that I have another side of just pictures for you to stare [Music] at thank you thanks Jen PK is tough thank you and Jen you've done so much to get it off the ground and I just love those pictures will you send them to us all the time but add us to the list I want them they're great this is really wonderful and it's nice to see it thriving in its first
074year thank you thank you so much all right so now we move on to committee reports have any committees met since our last meeting I don't believe so actually oh yes sorry Heather the um professional development committee met just recently on January 9th um we um reviewed the district's professional development plan and identifi some areas that needed updates there was collaboration in small groups taking a deeper look into the schedules for this year's superintendent conference days determining if any improvements were in order and there was a review of the outcome of Staff surveys relative to each of the activities and workshops considering Which experiences were the most effective in meeting the professional development goals and engaging staff um after the small groups met there was a share out about recommendations um it was discussed again
075um how we could potentially increase survey participation um and some options of what we could do to do that so we could hear from more teachers um and some other um discussions were regarding liting the number of offerings to ensure staff can attend other workshops of interest um incorporating further responsive classroom at Lloyd Harbor and Westside integrating different groups of Staff within the same workshops um for example workshop on behavior management Tech techniques something frequently requested by staff could be relevant to all so those were some of the things that were discussed thank you all right so um we are now going to continue with our first audience to visitors the Cold Spring Harbor Board of Education and administration welcome your attendance at Board of Ed meetings audience to the public oh did my mic
076go out hi that's okay um I'm tired of hearing me speak too audience the public affords residents an opportunity to address the board of education on both agenda and non-agenda items each resident is allowed to speak for 3 minutes this is not the Forum to discuss student or staff specific issues please contact the district separately on these matters come on up hello everyone good evening um one question that I just had introduce yourself sorry Scott Koffman um at 12 Eric Court um just one question I had more more a question or if you can send information on it I'm just curious how much are we actually spending school budget currently on the litigation around regionalization and if so like how much how much of our budget is actually being allocated towards attorney fees and things
077along those lines and also just curious how much of the superintendent and staff time is being spent um focused on regionalization again more just request for information than com sure uh I think we could answer a significant amount of that I cool most of the superintendent and staff time is not being spent on this I would say is that a fair statement to say I think Joe probably spends some time some time on it yeah we would have been spending a lot of a lot more time had we had opted in to the planning process it was oh wait if I could just finish answering the question though but because we're in a cohort with 21 schools we're sharing the cost of the attorney Christine I can't remember the original cost was a few thousand
078doar it's not five perhaps and um an occasional maybe $250 $500 here at that right it's it's not a very large number we could certainly provide that number it's a that would be a good thing probably to provide and then to Kate's point it would be a ton of staff and the superintendent's time if we went along with this and um then to give up our control over our district so that's that's where we are with that if that makes sense but I I would say I I actually probably received the bulk of the communications as um the president there's a president group who um organized most of this along with the attorney so that is I spend a lot of time on it cool thank you I was just I was mostly curious about
079the cost it sounds like it's not Material so I appreciate it yes of course it was a great question thank you for bringing that up anyone else all right um we will now move on to the approval of minutes so we are going to do the December 10th minutes bill was absent may I have a first Lisa second Heather um any questions all in favor thank you okay we are now going to move on to let me just get myself situated here you know what the audience may not be aware of this but there's one chair in this group of chairs that sinks throughout the portion of the evening and it's like a joke who gets the chair but it's me tonight I keep sinking so I'm just going to readjust and then we'll it's
080going to be fun it's like a little game okay um I'm back all right um so it's like lucky chair so um Personnel res Personnel recommendations of the superintendent on pages 1 through 5 as a slate so may I have a first Heather second Bruce are there any questions anything we need to highlight here no all right um all in favor thank thank you um we now oh oh so go ahead would like to go back andlight the fact that Mr colion a longtime well respected well loved teacher of science at the juu senior high school will be retiring and in this slate we are accepting his resignation so I think that it's really important to recognize that he has decided to end his tenure at Cold Spring Harbor and ride off into the sunset
081and enjoy his retirement and I think we should really thank him for his service to the community and to our kids for the past close to 30 years right so thank youum thank you for [Applause] that um okay so we are going to now move on to um business recommendations we will take um donations budget transfers claims Auditors report and additional business matters on pages 5 through 8 as a slate may I have a first you we have to do it after the second okay yes that's okay do you want to make the first motion so you can get closer to your question okay first yes thank you second Heather okay what is your question it's the discussion a little Clarity on this one the budget transfer um 83,000 director facilities director of school safety
082is that our new is that the new H I was gonna actually say we should probably also welcome our new director of school safety shall we do that as well our new director of school safety Mr Richard Smith at the back of the room joins [Applause] us thank you thank you for letting me in this evening and um and Christine you explained this sure this transfer Kate is taking care of of moving Anthony out of the three in functional areas that he was reported in um custodial maintenance and security moving him only into custodial maintenance that's one half of the transfer the other half is U moving the money so that rich Smith's money is in a salary code so that we can pay him as an employee of the district covert was paid as
083a consulting firm which is not an employee of the district so it's doing both items in that thank you that's a good question um um any other questions wait we're going to page what eight did we I have one is it to page eight because if so I have another question yes okay I just want to ask a question about oh wait is it on here I think it is I'm sorry I just want to make sure I'm on yes the Fantastic tours and the the transportation to Philly I mean there's a lot you know of anxiety around these bus companies now are these companies that we' used that is there is there anything that can be shared on that absolutely so we only use um the bus company that was involved in can you
084just make sure that you're saying can I just yeah thank you sorry I think you might be referring slightly to the Farmingdale um tragedy we'll call it that bus company no longer exists they're no longer on the table so the bus companies that we use immediately we worked with our attorneys we only use bus companies that meet our requirements for liability and other needs that we have they're inspections their buses their drivers all of the things that we've determined are necessary to go on a coach trip and then every contract is reviewed in detail by our attorneys to make sure that all of those items are memorialized and taken care of so the district is protected so every contract we don't use boiler plates every single time we go somewhere they look at it from
085the beginning to the end of the process okay I guess that's the most we can do right yes okay any other questions go ahead sorry this is on the the traffic control device um on page seven item four number one um is there is there anything in the contract that could cause us to pay more I know the I forget what the cost is now but in the 300,000 but is there are there any provisions in the contract that would cause run over I'm not looking at the contract right now Bill okay but my memory serves me as this and I can I can if it's different than what I say here I can let you know tomorrow but I believe that James pun and I there is wording that exactly says not to exceed
086this amount okay thank you so I you know I will take another look at it when we're not here but I believe that is in the final agreement while we're on the topic of the traffic light could you give us any time frame or do we have any idea of when it will be functional sure so after working with the Town of Huntington um after you sign this agreement this agreement is now going to go to the town and they have to execute it themselves the uh supervisor of Town of Huntington is ready to sign it because they already passed a resolution giving him authority to do that once they sign it they're going to go forward to hink is the is the vendor who is going to do this work um they've given us
087a time frame of three to 6 months the reason why there is such a range is because they know they can do the work but the production of the arm that is the traffic control device could take up to a couple of months if it if there isn't one waiting and we need something special for it to be manufactured so they've given us an estimate of 3 to 6 months for the traffic signal to be completed and operational as will there be maybe any discussion about the time of day they'll be doing the construction as we get closer we'll be of course meeting with them for project meetings as to you know how they're going to do this when they're going to do the work obviously we prefer the least Interruption of services to students
088in the building and we of course will have those conversations great thank you one more question sure um do either we or the Town of Huntington notify the our neighbors on seaward Court I think it's seaward but the road that runs parallel to the driveway has does anybody let them know that this is happen we'll make sure we do that when we get a start date when we think you know it's starting because we'll we'll kick off with them we'll we'll make sure that the surrounding neighbors know what the tentative schedule is like it's an interesting one because we've never I I mean personally I've never worked with a town on a project so you know um we'll stay in close contact with them so we make sure we know what's going on okay thank
089you okay so all in favor thank you okay we move to special education reports we will take all contracts csse CPS approvals on page eight as a slate may I have a first Heather may I have a second Lisa any questions all in favor thank you all right um so we are now going to move on to other matters which include the approval of the school calendar um and uh all other matters as a slate what uh just quickly before we go just a point on the calendar uh Mr banino Athletics start 2 weeks before school starts correct so it' be the 18th August it's August 18th so that's not reflected on the all high school sports okay excellent that's new that all all high school sports will start two weeks before school as opposed
090to one week before school except for football scho okay good to know thank you thank you and football will start earlier yeah okay I just want to venture back to the question you asked before about what do the teachers prefer yeah um I would just venture to say that if you pulled all of the teachers some of them would prefer to come back two days in August and have off an extra day in April and the day and then some of the teachers would prefer to not come back to school until after Labor Day I think as a general like unions in general prefer after Labor Day just as kind of like their stance but I think personal preference you probably would get like a mix of answers just Jen did you want as was
091shared before the teach some teachers also prefer to have their students earlier in the week on a Tuesday as opposed to a Thursday and a Friday and also I was going to ask this a question before we approve the calendar does this calendar does doesn't seem to have a lot of variation some years we have one or two or three or four options are we hopeful that this calendar follows some of the surrounding school districts because that's also helpful to teachers I think we're out of order it's my fault because I should have taken a first in a second before we open to questions I just wanted to make one clarification about date so let's I recommend that you if you're voting on draft one and you get a you know if you get a
092majority then you wouldn't you don't have to discuss draft two but you would put one the two drafts up for the vote and if it passes the board vote then you don't have to discuss draft okay you can have questions regarding draft one and if it passes then if not go to draft so sh should I take a motion then do I take need to take a motion to split them though into two or just take a motion on draft one I I think you can take a motion on draft one and we can add a resolution for draft two if it doesn't if it doesn't Su let's go with that all right may I have a first on draft one Bill second Heather any additional questions so hether my question was does draft one
093follow most or of the surrounding school districts to our knowledge yeah we did sit down with calendars from other places and look to make sure that we were aligned no that's helpful thank you yeah I I just want to repeat the comment I had before I'm somewhat worried about not having the flex days in version two so I just would ask you to think about that when we think about version one you have a first and a second okay so all in favor of version one okay okay thank you so now we don't need to vote on version two right thank you and then the rest of the items we need to take as a slate because we broke that out right so on number two which is uh disposal of obsolete equipment and number
094three um stipulation settlement so um may have a first Heather second Lisa any questions all in favor thank you okay [Music] um we are now going to move to a second reading and adoption of policies 2160 um board member School District officer and employee code of ethics and number 2382 recording and broadcasting of board meetings um we are going to vote to wave a full reading of these policies May and adopt may I have a first Kate may have a second Bill any questions comments Lisa yes there was a typo in policy 2160 uh in this is um code of e this is board member School District officer and employee code of ethics second read and adoption in Section 8 it currently reads involvement with charitable organizations School District Personnel may be involved as a
095volunteer officer or employee in a charitable organization which has a relationship with the district if School District Personnel of the charitable or charitable organization the school district personnel must disclose such relationship in writing to the district dot dot dot um I think that was just a find and replace error it should read involvement with the charitable organization School District Personnel may be involved as a volunteer officer or employee in a charitable organization which has a relationship with the district if School District Personnel is a board member officer or employee of the charitable organization the school district personnel must disclose such relationship in writing to the district so basically it's explaining if you are if a board member happens or a school district Personnel happens to be on a board of a charitable organization that does
096work with the district they need to disclose that to the district but the way it was previously written it it it didn't make sense so now thank you all right um all in favor thank you okay we're going to now um move on to our second audience to visitors I'm not going to read the statement again but if anyone would like to come up and speak this is your opportunity okay uh this agenda includes Financial reports on page nine and these reports are for informational Purp only no vote is necessary if needed Miss Costa will answer any questions from the Board of Education and public feel free to call her in her office all right this is the discussion section of our agenda um the floor is open for any other discussion items for members
097of the board does anyone have a discussion item I I actually I have one question and it's sports related so can I ask this here so this is my question it came up the other day in a conversation students in Cold Spring Harbor so many of them play sports which is great team sports does New York State also require them to take PE is there a reason why you're not it's just because it's a New York state requirement that you have to even if you play a sport yes everyone's saying yes okay that's something I probably could have Googled but you're right here so I figured I'd ask you all right there you go all right that was my question that was so easy um all right anyone else no okay motion to adjourn may
098I have a first bill second Heather all right all in favor thank you