CorpusRecord 140023

Cold Spring Harbor Board of Education Meeting- BOE Meeting, December 10, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / CSH Board Meetings
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,491 words · about 81 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay um before we get started I'd like to give a motion to adj executive session may have a first thank you Lisa may have a second thank you Bruce all in favor thank you all right the board has returned from executive session uh there were no actions taken may I have a motion to open the public me Lisa thank you second he all in favor thank you please rise for theed indivisible andice for all thank you so tonight we continue the tradition of having student holiday performances at our December board meeting this year we're fortunate to have performances from the Colt Spring Harbor strings on emble brass Ensemble and chamber singers thank you for the students directors and to Mr Jim Granary for [Applause] organizing hi everyone my name is Andrew hawler I am the

002director of the C har grass Ensemble we have two tunes for you today we start with Holly Jolly Christmas [Music] r [Music] happen [Applause] one two three a [Applause] hello everybody my name is amenda I am the orchestra director here at the high school I would like to introduce our sh and they will be playing Happy h [Music] [Applause] the [Music] h [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] [Music] [Applause] good evening everybody thank you all for uh being here this evening and for listening to our fabulous musicians uh um we are now going to sing a few tunes for you uh we have our chamber singers here tonight as well as several members of our high school choir uh we're going to ask that you all take

003yourself back for a moment imagine we are in uh dzian London walking down snowy Cobblestone Lane as you hear the carollers coming up the lane with their cloaks and their top hats and bonnets uh we're going to start with uh a piece by pul in the ble Mid Winter [Music] the [Music] I am I If I Were A wise I would do [Music] my my heart [Applause] [Music] how may we do for to is foror for [Music] we mighty [Music] for [Music] we got more quick tunes for you uh I was in I was told about a tradition that had happened in the past so anybody who has a set of keys and wants to join me on the bells is more than welcome to do so anybody who knows the lyrics of the next

004couple of tunes more than welcome to join us we're going to sing de [Music] la la la la to be [Music] la la Jo heart Jo [Music] sing [Music] [Applause] together and one more to send you off we're going to end with We wish you a Merry Christmas and for those of you who may have seen uh Christmas with the cranks we're going to be channeling that really excited Christmas caroler energy this evening uh we wish you Merry Christmas also has lyrics about demanding pudding so you going to hear us demand for pudding and by the end hopefully we've gotten it so here we go singing We wish you Merry Christmas we wish you a Merry Christmas we wish you merry Christmas we wish you a Merry Christmas and happy New Year tid [Music] to

005tid [Music] Christmas tids to you you are [Music] Christ Christmas wish you Merry Christmas wish you Merry Christmas we wish you a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year [Applause] you [Applause] thank you that was wonderful what a treat to have those performances it was pointed out to me earlier that I'm dressed like a Bart Bella but I will not s for you tonight if you love pit perfect you get the reference okay um I'm going to foro my president's report this evening because we have point in the agenda I'm going to turn it over now to our superintendent really have good evening members of the Board of Education staff and community members welcome to the December 10th we're gonna Mr grer you're here sorry we're going to present the student recognitions to three of

006our students for the selection to the 2024 nma All State performs and sounds thank you congratulations to all of you see them back there okay we need Catherine too would you would you all come down would you come on down please and Catherine if she's in the house too I think she was just performing she's coming she's coming come on Catherine yeah you good evening everyone um it's my distinct honor to recognize three exceptional student musicians from our high school who have achieved an incredible milestone in their musical Journeys this year two of our students Zoe ablon and Amelia saladino were selected as alternates for the prestigious nisma All State mixed chorus and Katherine zagler was chosen as an alternate for All State Orchestra the All State Festival is one of the highest honors a

007Young musician in New York state can achieve the selection process is rigorous and competitive involving thousands of students who audition each year to be chosen as an alternate is a testament to their except exeptional Talent commitment and Artistry these students have not only dedicated countless hours to refining their craft but have also demonstrated the resilience discipline and passion that music education instills in young people they represent the Excellence of our music program and embody the values we strive to nurture in all our students on behalf of the music department and the entire Cold Spring Harbor community I extend my heartfelt congratulations to these outstanding musicians Zoe Amelia and Catherine you have made us incredibly proud and we look forward to all that you will continue to achieve please join me in celebrating their remarkable accomplishments

008[Applause] made [Applause] I'll start over again good evening members of the Board of Education staff and community members welcome to the December 10th meeting of the Board of Education First I want to send my heartfelt thanks to the string Ensemble gra emble chamber singers who perform early this evening their performances showcased an incredible talent and dedication of our students in the Arts it is always the privileged to witness the result of the hard work and the guidance of their teachers this time of the year serves as a reminder of how fortunate we are here in kman Harbor surrounded by such wonderful students families and community members over the past month our students demonstrated the spirit of giving by collecting non-p parisal food donations to support those in need many of these donations were distributed to

009The Helping Hands rest Commission of Huntington Station and to the parish Outreach food pantry of St Patrick's Church in Huntington their efforts make a difference in the lives of others and I'm proud of their commitment to our local community since our last meeting we also celebrated two National Honor Society ceremonies the national Arts Honor Society showcased their tremendous achievements including the spectacular artwork we inducted 59 students into the Honor Society recognizing their Excellence academics leadership service and character the event was highlighted with a CSH Alum from 2009 pan who is an artist and illustrator now living in California additionally we held a national World honor language Society in Dr ceremony by led by a World Language Department chairperson Kristen Wilkins and her team this ceremony honored 83 students for their achievements in French and Spanish

010the events Kino speaker Alex L Castro from the class of 2017 congratulations to all Andes on this prestigious accomplishment December is always an exciting and busy month filled with opportunities to celebrate our students dedication and work last week on December four the junior high concert took place here in the pack wering the audience with outstanding musical performances later this week on DEC 12th the Lloyd Harvard school will host his fifth and sixth grade concert here in the PAC 7 p.m. Westside School will host their fifth grade and sixth grade concert on December 17th also here in the pack at 7 p.m. and finally we conclude our WI concert series with their senior high concert in art exhibition from December 19th again here at 700 p.m. in the pack these events are always a wonderful opportunity

011for families and community members to experience the excellent talents of our students also want to take a moment today to thank Mr berer and his staff as well as Zoe Amil and Katherine for the outstanding contributions your hard work and dedication truly appreciated and congratulations on your thisal performances jobs well done next week car will hold will host 41 Long Island school districts for the our annual ADP collegial circles event on December 16th and 7 this event will bring together over 110 teachers from across Long Island to collaborate share insights and learn from one another about teaching advanced placement courses this is a prime example of districts working together to enhance their skills and improve teaching and learning teachers will have the opportunity to exchange strategies explore best practices and bring back valuable tools to

012the home districts each district can then T these ideas to align with their unique needs and priorities empowering Educators to make decisions that best serve their students events like this I like the power of local collaboration and local decision making enforcing educational Excellence as we reflect on this month of giving and gratitude encourage everyone to take care of themselves and if possible take care of someone need thank you and have a wonderful evening so each meeting we hear from students from different buildings about all the wonderful events going on in their locations tonight here are pleased to welcome our students from the Junior Senior High School [Applause] good evening and thank you for having us here I'm an president of the student government and with me today I have Vice secretary and playing basketball right

013now and then I'd also like to introduce the officers of the class of 2028 we have President Ellie hurger vice president Charlie rice Treasurer Sophie kener and secretary leam Mendon we also like to ask you to please move to the front row so you can see our slideshow we put together tonight we decided to surprise you with some of the thousands of pictures from sor camera to take you on a short tour of the highlights from the year so far enjoy as we tell you the story behind back in the summer we had our lacrosse parade celebrating both the boys and girls lacrosse teams for both winning both bringing home a state championship shout out to coach Bon and coach castley at the parade alumni elementary kids parents high school students and teachers all came

014together to cheer on the players also in the summer we had seventh grade orientation where the new kids became accustomed to their new school by gu the older siblings guided them through the halls and also guid them through the first day for the seniors our year started early in the morning with senior Sunrise although a little cloudy the senior class was determined to make the best of it and enjoy the beginning of the end of our journey at Cold Spring haror our fall Sports this year started not only in the fields but also in the classrooms and hallways with their m in school the whole week we were learning about World War II and a game that was never played each grade was taught lessons about World War II and all subjects related to General

015P for example roses were created in in Spanish classes and Miss G taught her students that ice cream was considered a crucial factor in World War II students also had the honor to hear Miss Patton talk about our grandfather as well as other guests who taught us a part of history that should not be forgotten coltsman Harvard players have the opportunity to share this with players from Island Trees we also celebrated Homecoming on the same day as the remembrance B with Spirit Week leading up to this day with days like pajama day and USA tribute day all leading up to the pep rally where we had teams dressing up as characters who Pitch Perfect as well as the back street boys before this week we had P night where we created the class and sports

016banners personally I think senior class banner and field hockey had the best one but these events are just some of the ways our school shows togetherness community and family and then for All Sports girl soccer and girl swimming had historic Seasons both teams made it to State finals creating new records for both har High School field hockey volleyball boys soccer girls tennis cheerleading football and boys ball all the great Seasons as well at almost every Co Harvard game one of our leading singers sing the national anthem hen this year was special for us seniors when teachers and students dressed up to spread school spirit last Friday students at faculty wore blue and gold toate um for fall drama the fall play Hamlet was a great success and coincided with the current AP reading curriculum um

017we had the uh introduction Ceremonies for the music trium Society National Art Honor Society and World Language Society this past week as well as the junior high Winter concert um provided by natural helpers the Spanish club and the K family traditional Spanish food was donated to helping the helping C Foundation 15 student athletes sign their commitment to colleges this year one from wrestling four from boys lacrosse one boys soccer two girls crew six girls lacrosse and one from track all clubs in the junior high and high school are working on their activities at full speed to mention a few animal rescue club had a rescue dog come in for their meeting CSH Sports media Club has been raising this character boards through their graphics and photos on Instagram trip to Philadelphia boots of Love is

018creating cards for children in the hospital the fashion Club is working on various s projects and will be working on a recycling project the baking club will be taking a holiday treat next week International Club is getting organized for their annual event National Honor Society will be hosting the senior dinner before the dress rehearsal of a musical all board members are invited student government is raising money for dinners that will be delivered to the homeless we are also organizing the dod Hall tournament which will occur at the end of win SPS lastly December Spirit weave is coming up from the PEP Club as well as the Ronald McDonald House fundraiser to help families and meeting thank you all for listening [Applause] thank you um students that was wonderful already that was very wonderful thank you

019so much let them know Mrs G we loved it that was amazing Sora thank you for all of those pictures it's so fun to see them so much happen as all thank you so um I'm going to walk on or take a motion to walk on um a resolution um the resolution authorizing the commencement of article 78 regarding regionalization uh may I have a first to walk this on please he may I have a second Kate any question all in favor thank you okay I'm going to now read the resolution um it's a little long okay so um whereas on December 9th and December 10th this is the resolution authorizing the commencement of article 78 regarding regionalization whereas in December 9th and 2024 December 10th 2024 the New York state board board of region considered

020and adopted the final rule adding part 124 and subpart 24-2 to sub chapter e of the regulations of the commissioner of Education relating to the regionalization plans the rule and whereas according to Ned the rule will become effective as of December 24th 2024 and whereas the rule requires school school districts to participate in the regionalization planning process which includes among among other things school districts submitting a strength that needs tool on a form prescribed by the commissioner and convenience with the district superintendent and stakeholders and whereas the rule authorizes school districts to elect not to participate in the development of a regionalization plan if it so elects the superintendent of a school district at consultation with their board shall communicate the district's election in writing to the department Office of Education policy 89 Washington Avenue

021education building room 2m Albany New York 11234 the deadline for submission for such letter shall be January 15th 2025 and every 10 years thereafter and whereas the superintendent has consulted with the Board of Education and the Board of Education wishes to formally opt out of participating in the development of the regionalization plans and whereas the school district's election is not an action as defined in 6ny YC RR 67.2 and therefore no further cra cra right okay CRA review is required now therefore be it resolved that the board of education on behalf of the district hereby elects not to participate in the development of a regionalization plan be it further resolved the Board of Education elects not to submit the strength and need tool to New York State Department of Education or engage in any regionalization

022planning or regionalization implementation be it further resolved that the superintendent is authorized to send a letter setting for the board of education's ele election to opt out at the development of a regionalization plan and reserving all of the school district's rights and remedies be it finally resolved that the superintendent shall send a letter to the New York State education department Office of Education policy 89 Washington Avenue education building room 2m ALB York 11234 or any other address the New York State Education Department designates so that it is received by at that or those addresses on or before January 15th 2025 so may I have a motion to accept this resolution ruce second Kate any questions discussion all in favor thank you okay so now I'm going to take a motion to walk on another resolution

023may I have a motion to walk on a resolution to authorize the superintendent of school to sign a letter of agreement with the Attorney General's office may I have a first Kate may I have a second Heather any questions all in favor okay now I will read this resolution we have hereby resolved that the Board of Education of the Cold Spring Harbor Central School District accepts the terms of the letter agreement dated December 10th 2024 with the office of the New York State Attorney General and be it further resolved that the Board of Education authorizes the superintendent of schools to sign the letter of agreement on the board's behalf so now I need to take a motion to vote for this so is do I have any votes in favor of this resolution and discussion

024anyone is anyone opposed to this resolution all are opposed thank you I'm now read um a statement on behalf of the board by letter dated on July 5th 2024 the New York State Attorney General's office contacted the district regarding the district's policies and procedures governing student enrollment since that initial contact the district through its legal council has engaged in an interactive and open dialogue with the O A to demonstrate its overall compliance with admission regulations and its unwavering commitment to the education of students the students of Cold Spring Harbor revised policy [Music] 5150 reflects the policy committee efforts to adopt changes requested by the O A despite the district's obvious good faith efforts in working with the oag for the past several months the oag is demanding that the Board sign a letter agreement which

025would prohibit the district from making any changes to its enrollment website or registration documents for a period of 2 years without the O A approval in addition it has been ominously communicated to the board that if we do not enter into this agreement the Attorney General's office will seek quote unquote further action while the district always seeks to have a productive relationship with state agencies such as the O A we cannot in good conscience consent to any agreement that would forfeit the board's local control over the district we were elected by the people of this District to govern the district not to turn that responsibility over to the attorney general consequently the board cannot enter into this proposed agreement thank you so um we are now moving into a our discussion portion we're going have

026a discussion from John gillo our school district architect regarding Westside bathrooms I even everybody just wanted to bring you up to date as to where we are um with this last round of bond issue projects as well as the 2122 app prod that took place this summer really quickly go we'll go through each building uh at the Lloyd Harbor Elementary School this Cas of the bond included the Little Theater renovation which included air conditioning and Little Theater as well as the cooling of the cafeteria the equipment is all on site we just by the time we got it school was already underway and it's scheduled to be installed over the Christmas break there was also another work location there which is I think 12 or 13 different work locations for bathrooms single store and multi-

027stall bathrooms um those bids came in higher than anticipated so one of the FL processes would be raid those down on a priority basis and rebid those in the future from the 2122 Capital these were all HVAC related projects which came out of postco uh the work uh Alid Harbor is all complete in a punchless phase there at go Hill there were no bond projects this phase this was just 2122 Capital uh we put the air conditioning in the community room and the speech office that's in the punch list phase and then we also had a third work location administrative offices um we are going to go now rebid that on a room by room basis some of the work was done internally we going have to do some of the work that we originally

028thought we had to address and we can rebid that and like I said this phase of the bond doing no projects this summer The Pack the building that we're in now uh one of the phases of the of the product was to renovate the Performing Art Center here with some general construction work a lot of Acoustics and lighting the budget up there was $825,000 and the original bids came in at about 1.6 uh $1.16 million I had recommended that we reject these bids and we take advantage of Cooperative bids which is another means to uh reach out to to vendors we gave the same scope to different vendors and we wound up coming in with the total Award of 89,000 which is actually $116,000 on the budget a few $100,000 on that phase of the

029project West Side we had two we had Bond projects and we had capital projects uh the four work locations for the bond projects this summer the first was the renovation of the kitchen and the cafeteria that was all the finishes and the air conditioning of the cafeteria the flooring the ceiling the lighting uh and then we took a classroom which was up against the existing kitchen Us St in size and we frined out for the new walk-in refrigerator freezer we opened bids for the kitchen equipment last week the bids came in very very high I'm now working with two different vendors who are also on a Cooperative bid to see if we could bring that kitchen equipment number down lower and I'll get back to Joe within the next day or so at the time

030we also it was three sets of bathrooms uh going work location 2 three and four although we were under budget on the entire package in January I decided let's not be over budget on any school for now so we did the work of work location one which is the kitchen work location three and work location four and we held off on work location 2 later in the spring I had a meeting with the superintendent and I was directed to move forward with work location two bathrooms uh I had said that the only way to do that because the board had already awarded project would be a change order so I reached out to the four contractors who originally bid on the project they were willing to hold their number and then we awarded the change

031order for the for for four trades GC Plumbing mechanical and electrical so the bids that were originally received and opened under a sealed envelope in January were the same bids that they were holding their price on in uh May and then we had some small HVAC work as part of 2122 Capital that work is completed and then final punch days this is the slide we showed back in January these are all of the projects that are remaining as part of the bond referendum to date there's about $1,700,000 left any project that has an as next to it was already submitted to the state ation department and has been approved we would just need a direction from the Board of Education as to which projects they would like to move forward on one I would like

032to just bring to your attention because I know we had some issues with the utility company and increasing fees coming to the buildings but the way the bond was laid out the fuel oil tank that fed two of the oil rooms at the high school was literally located where the addition was going to go so as part of the whole Bond the plan was to pull out that fuel oil tank put in the temporary tank run the new gas to the building and then we could get rid of the oil tank and when we went back out to National Grid and they came back with a much higher gas price number we put that on the back burner but right now we still have just a temporary tank feeding the boiler room so we're really

033uh filling that boiler fuel oil tank up almost every two or three days during the winter so that's something we may want to look at to revisit the gas P so we can get rid of the temporary of the smaller fuel oil tank we then be able to run gas to all the boiler rooms and we can get rid of all the oil throughout the district throughout the building and you be just running on gas but again those are the projects that are still available and the available funds as of June 24th Happ from the business office same thing with 2122 Capital the total recommended award was $766,000 and the budget was 1.1 we have about $368,000 where we can do more hbac related projects that came from that 2122 if you remember you're limited

034to the scope of the work based on what the voters approved so we're really limited on HVAC work from the fund in 2122 so really the next steps would be prioritizing the rest of the bond projects and either redid them and or redesign and submit to the State education department and just to know the 2425 capital reserve which was the air conditioning and the electrical panels the outlets that's currently at the State education department waiting review and there was some HVAC work some Boiler Room work that we were looking to get done at Westside and lyd harbor there were additional funds in the 20 in the 1819 transfer to Capital that we were using we did the drawings for those those projects are also up at the State education department waiting approval and then all

035of this work will take place in the summer of 25 so I know there's been some discussion about how expensive things are so I just wanted to remind everybody because we are a public works entity we are bound by New York State prevailing wage and I took a look at the uh New York State labor department wage rates that are required to be issued and printed in all of our specifications and the fulltime trades for these projects this summer The Carpenters paid $135 an hour plumber is 140 hbac mechanic is 50 an electrician could be anywhere between $60 and $165 an hour and when they go to submit their payment Rec they have to provide certified payroll and if they falsify their payroll it used to be a misdemeanor but now it isy there's also

036insurance requirements that ner gives us to put into the specifications as well as bonds for a bid Bond a performance bond and a laboring material on little hard to read um this was just a breakdown I Jo said was some question about the CH order and the cost this was a breakdown of where the numbers came from the general construction on one of the work locations and again I know it's hard to read but the bid they provided was $54,000 for the labor and the material to complet the work they then added a 10% overhead of $5,400 a profit of $3,000 and a bond and a bond charge of another $1,200 and that came to the 637700 what we also which location is that's what location that's that's the CH one that was be January

037wasn't awarded until May I don't know what what is that that's the two pair of bathrooms at West Side so both bathrooms correct both B yes and you had a signed change order in May for that I gave it I got the approval from the superintendent I wrote the change orders we got them signed by the contractors they were mailed to the district they were signed by the district sent to me and then they were sent to the State education department they were signed by the district in May in whenever they were signed so when I wrote them when I wrote them and submitted them I don't know when they got on through the board agenda well it says here that they were approved in May by the board in your presentation is that accurate

038they were approved by the the superintendent gave be direction to move forward with those okay so it's different than what it says presentation not originally awarded directed to move forward change order at meeting in May yes you wrote that yes I had a meeting with the superintendent and the director facilities in May and I was direct not at the board meeting in May no okay thank you just clarifying thank you so the two bathrooms or 60 you divide that by two and that's approximately the cost of each one correct but if you look at that and then you look below all of the about [Music] $24,000 oh I'm sorry that's just for one trade that's the one trade what what trade is it that's the GC the GC yeah and I'm new I'm the newest

039one so I'm absolutely what does that mean for the GC um that means is that Park East or no so so paries is the construction manager who oversees all the construction but because all of the bids that we live out in January is it's over $1.5 million we have to divide by the Wix law which means we have four Prime trade we have GC who does the brick and the mortar and the tile and the sheet rock and the demo and the esus you'll have a plumbing contractor Prime an hbac Prime which would do ventilation and exhaust and then electrical contractor which would do the lighting and the wiring and the fire that that's helpful so this is for then this 637 is for what was that again General contct yeah but which which um

040Services again the contract no no I mean what are they is this for tile demo all he does all of the demo if you look down low you have two CS 28 hours $35 an hour had one carent doing the backer board that said the primer 32 hours and the metal stud the track they broke it down by subcontractor through the general construction but when you go down the whole thing and you look at that 63,000 $24,000 of it is not even hammer and nails it's bonds it's insurance it's overhead it's punch list it's Clos out conditions so now you're down at 30 right up the top you're down at $38,000 for the two bathrooms 19,000 a bathroom we we have two new doors put in with all new hardware Door and Hardware and install

041is is $4,000 now these days I think we paid $5,000 a door when we get all the doors throughout the district right before and during Co with the uh Salto system and division P so it's it comes out to about in in terms of actual labor it's about 15,000 a bathroom to do the tile sheet lock the demo the removal all right that's what I'm trying to get I I want to break down the four trads and figure out and you're saying these Bond costs etc those are fixed and that's a percentage of the job how does that how bonds the bonds are fixed numbers it's has to be inded a performance bond and a labor and material Bond to cover 100% the cost of the project and then on the insurance side nyser provides

042the insurance documentation that goes into our specb and they have a stipulation if the total cost of the project is over a million dollar n wants a contractor to carry a $10 million policy and if it's under a million $5 million policy and then ni also ask that the contract to provide a separate ocp policy which is kind of another umbrella on top of the umbrella to cover any costs that aren't covered by your general liability policy so if the cost of the the work was less the bond cost would be lower Etc it fluctuates with the cost of the project correct yeah the bond is going to be based on the total cost so in this case J&H had a bond for everything at West Side the kitchen the cafeteria and the three sets

043of bathrooms so was whatever his total cost was this was pro rated for this this bathroom you're saying this figure this is this is his number what the bond increase to go from whatever whatever the number was he went from his original bid was 423,000 it got up to 6 by 63,000 which is the cost of the bathroom the additional bathrooms so to go from 424 to 488 the bonding company charged him 2% increase okay I'm just the reason why I'm asking is I'm trying to break it down so this was the portion you said he did other work this was the portion prated to this these two bathrooms this portion there was a bigger Bond charge but you broke it down pro rated or there's no bond charge on the kitchen per se no

044there's a bond charge on the kitchen so if you look at his original payment W which was 424,000 because when he since his initial breakdown he didn't think we were do moving forward location 2 so his bonds and insurance are based on his original bid that was awarded by the board in January which was 424,000 when you add a change to a project the wording in the general conditions allows a contractor to increase their bond for by 2% if the project wasn't done what are we changing that's you said this is aange change from what well it wasn't awarded originally in January you didn't a would to work it was rejected is that correct we rejected the work at that time the board rejected the board rejected it yes in general yes thank you based

045on my recommendation I did not move forward um how are you paid through this process so it's always been since I've been here in 98 it's based on a percentage of construction cost so my fee is a 5% construction cost which is lower or standard than any any of the other firm job so if the work gets done I get 5% if it doesn't get done then in the language in the contract if we go to get SCD approval and then the board says we're not going to do this project I get paid up to a certain point and and not allowed to build anywhere you know going further we decided not to do that project okay another question so this was two out of six bathrooms right what was the cost of the other

046bathrooms the other bathroom for location three was the same exact price 637 for location four which were bigger bathrooms by like a few inches I think right yeah but the the cost bid in January was the same price the work location forward to the bigger bathrooms was bit at 97,000 and then the kitchen was 262,000 I'm C Brees on per bathroom yeah we paid 63,000 for one bathroom you saying so each work location two three and four with each repair of bathrooms that's how that's how it was bit out so work location two is two bathrooms that were in in back to back classrooms work location three was the same set of bathrooms directly above those two two and work four were bathrooms across the hall I directly off the hall they were a little

047bit bigger those were work location four so three locations six toal so you get 5% of the cost of a project and again I'm new so the district comes to you and says we need to renovate let's just say the two bathrooms the 111 112 do we ask you to design a bathroom in a certain price range or we do we give you you conc so it's it's very different the public side from private side I mean in the public side you kind of do stuff backwards um we so after the bond of 2004 when it was finished we did the bond of 200 2004 2005 we brought back the facilities committee and we met in the mornings probably four times a year superintended uh business official director facilities Mar said time myself and three

048board members and the board at the time established a capital reserve and every year that capital reserve was funded and Mark and I would use the building condition survey to look at the nuts and Bs type projects and then we would be with the building principles to see if there are any programmatic or educational projects that we may want to put into this coming Year's PA a reserve from there I would based on the scope of work that we discussed I would break them out in terms of budget appropriation and I would give you guys a budget if it needed a little sketch we would do a sketch and Mark and I always came back with more money than it was going to be in the capital reserve we went through project by project and

049ultimately the board facilities committee made a recommendation we want to do these six or seven projects in this comy May's capital reserve and it was a million to so we don't give you Direction you're you're kind of figuring this out and then coming to us for a number and saying this is the budget and then you you'll build a cushion in and then we vote on it it's a it's really a give and take I mean if it's we need a roof on this session it needs to meet the building Cod needs to have an R30 need be one in 30 years that's pretty straightforward but when it's like programmatic and educational I want the feedback from the end user I want to art teacher or the science teacher the family consumer science teacher get

050the scope from them as to what their vision is then come to the facilities committee or the ultim you know ultimately the board de and say here's the plan here's what we want to talk about here's what we want to go forward with do you ever show the board renderings of pictures course and then they look at it so the board saw the renderings of these refurbished bathrooms we didn't two person bathroom I mean you know Big Stuff fields and the science wing and the stem wing and the fitness center we did renderings for all of the big stuff I don't think this was a two person it's two single bathro I'm sorry I it's an individual bathro one toilet so you determined based on your knowledge of years of experience um the tiles going

051to cost the brownness the the hours and and when all said and done then you based on that you submit it but there there's no direction in terms of let's make this really nice or make this really sparse like the bathrooms are pretty Bare Bones and um there it comes out to about you know 1,800 a square foot and if that's the going rate then that's the going rate so if we had say an independent architect designed the same specs and and and hire Subs to spec out that with all the bonds and everything else within 10% they're going to come to you know uh $53,000 a bathroom you're very confident yeah I mean when we broke down remember you can't get private sector guys I understand that I'm saying Apples to Apples these numbers

052will hold up you're saying so I mean if we look at location two that's the one we're talking about we received five bids from 5 GCS the low bid was 63 the second one was 65 the next one was 77 and we had two bids of 104,000 and 124,000 that's when you say and we were early we were December January because we live in 9 week Windows people in December and January you would think they're still hungry for work in the summer but 24,000 for two 4x6 bathrooms it's just astronomical but these are the these are the bids we're dealing with we can't go back to the low bidder and change scope we can't negotiate the only thing we can technically negotiate you can say hey can you give us back a couple of dollars

053you know you know come in a little bit lower maybe get it to 60,000 and then I've always seen that if the guy gives you you know a little bit of a credit up front he's going to find something broken down the line is going to try to make the money back for well you talked about here how you went back and and used Cooperative B it's cuz you the first round the bids were too high did did we go back and use Cooperative bids on these bathrooms on these not no any reason why I was told to stop using coopertive BS because why you just say you said here hundred of 300 over 300,000 was it that was in yes that was in January and then I was told after that we really shouldn't

054be using Cooperative bid that's why I bid the kitchen equipment out originally which we had just bid um and I don't think we would have gotten a cheaper price if you have a contractor working in the building literally next door and or above and bl you're not going to get a cheaper price than the guys on site I mean if you want to get Cooperative bids to do the 13 sets of bathrooms at Lloyd we could by all means get a price I mean you could reduce the scope which I don't recommend you could just do tile floor and a sanitary Cove and painted sheetrock walls in the in the bathrooms to save money okay and I I just want to go through some of these invoices as well because some of these invoices have

055line items when I visited these bathrooms I'm just not seeing it so we we I'd like to do that but um I I think we always want to go back and try to find the lowest price right um I don't know we and so you're confident though that these prices would hold up under scrutiny scrutiny meaning if if we had an architect designed the exact same bathrooms and we had Subs come in and do the exact same work these prices are within 10% of Industry Norm they're paying within the plans and they're paying within the specs and they're following all of the protocols and so I mean yeah so if schools have to build bathrooms at $1,800 Square dollar a square foot then that's the going rate I guess that's going and if you're building

056a multi bathroom it's going to be cheaper it's going to be only $180 to $200 a bathroom for a multi down so I asked for the invoices for the upstairs um first the main floor West Side those bathrooms and and the low you know the basement level those bathro essentially the same the prices should be essentially the same correct there was a additional work there might have been more work if we had to run you know do more electric maybe an electric panel was TI to one work location and not the other or shut off vales in one I would have to go back and look item by item and how many biders of the four trades are we getting you said you got five for GC that's a good number typically how many do

057we have for each 5 GC four plumber and only two El and and how often do the same vendors or the subs win the business CU I asked for a list of the diversity of contractors that do work I haven't gotten it yet so what we do is obviously the the first step is once we decide on a project that's going to it's approved by the state and then we go out to bid we send a notice of bid is to the district we select bid dates the district advertises in whatever the board policy are for advertising in newspapers whether it's Newsday or local news or whatever we then put it onto our website where people they used to have to come into the office and we made 30 or 40 sets of plans inspect

058they pick them up there would be a tremendous amount of wasted paper now they download the plans inspect off to the website and they B there and anybody can see them um we have other agencies I know that constru connect some of these other uh construction data papers that then they'll take our plans and put it on their website so I mean we'll get a lot of people from out of state asking about the projects could we put on the screen what we got for, 18800 square foot I'd like to show everyone what these pictures look like I know we have them um in the meantime Joe just so we understand too so we have a complete understanding of the cost so the 63,000 GC that's for the two bathrooms right that's a general contract

059of cost so then when you add the carpentry the plumbing the HVAC electrician what bottom line what did each bathroom cost us to approximate we have six bathrooms what was the what was the cost for each bathroom I think the two bathrooms of location two came in at16 location to so 50 something a bathroom and is that what we're looking at now John I don't know that's the bathro $50,000 bathroom so you know we're not talking remote control Toto Toilets uh we're not talking towel warmers radiant heat we're talking unfinished um heat heat elements or heat boxes um basic tile this is Bare Bones and this is800 this is the best pricing we can get cuz you know it's it's very important we spend our money wisely obviously and I'm just I'm new and I

060maybe I'm naive but this seems awfully basic for 1,800 square foot I can tell you that in some of these small obviously the doors are not in yet we're putting the firearm devices in tonight I know in a neighboring District of yours they use their maintenance Crews to do these single small BS I was going to ask that so we could do it inhouse is that what you're saying Yeah we actually did that when Co spring or Library moved out of goose Hill and we had the big empty space at Goose Hill the district decided to hire I don't know how they worked out with civil service they hired three mechanics and those mechanics their job they were hired to build the two classrooms in that main office area in a little outer area of

061the Cold Spring Library and it took them about three or four times length of it would if you did it as a real project but that's what they decided to do and they did that and at the end of the library they got rid of the three mechanics and they done but some of these smaller projects to your point Northport the person we're talking about has a I have a larger um mechanic group they do a lot of these individual single St bathrooms themselves in house if we did it in house what would it have cost a lot cheaper in your estimation did you ever tell the board guys you're wasting your money do it in house no I mean we tried it before we we got rid of it we didn't do it that

062way anymore I'm confused a little bit because you said earlier I thought that you recommended to the board that we hold off on these bathrooms at the January I've rewatched the January meeting today too and I'm just trying to only because we had every every school was under budget except for west side and the whole project was overall under budget so instead of being over budget on West and under on the other three I said let's just stay under budget on all and we'll deal with the the next set of bathrooms in the future so it wasn't because you thought they were expensive for what we were getting that was everything is expens I I received bids last week just asking yeah I received bids last week on a, 1400t interior minor renovation nothing to

063it it came at $700 aot for, 1400t I the numbers are through the roof I thought as we started to get further away from Co you would start to see numbers come down I'm just not seeing them and the lead time I mean you see we're still we only got the mechanical equipment for Lloyd that was ordered in March we only got it in November and electrical equipment is over a year out it's a 52 to 60 we back log on electrical equip switch gears and Transformers and P it's still crazy out there are the same winning the business again and again or we have a diversity of Subs working in our district there are people that like to deal with schools and there are a lot of contractors that are starting to get away

064because they can't afford the bonding and the insurance requirements on these projects though did the same people do all the bathroom work same general contractors yeah I mean I could pick or choose maybe there's three or four others that could have bid or would have been on this project well you had seven bids in some cases lot 7, the same people keep coming in low no but all right I'm just trying to figure out um so the bids go to you and then you open them and the bids come to the district to us come to the district they have to be there so this bid opening was January 8th they're required to be submitted in a separate seal envelope before 11:00 a.m. on January 8th and then we go into the community room we

065break them up into the different trades we open up all the bids we read them aloud and then it's our job to review the bids along with pares and then the bids get awarded to the lowest responsible bidder so is Park East our representative and looks after our interests correct so we hire them to make sure we're getting good prices you're hiring them to make sure that the plans and specs are followed accordingly they also do a peer review to make sure that what we're bidding or what the contract to bid on is on the plans inspects and there are another set of eyes for the district yes and what is your role once the job begin to design it and then what happen and we're here on a weekly basis at weekly job meetings

066so we're here every week walking the jobs doing weekly job meetings writing job meeting reports completing a punch list dealing with the problems and issues that come up and our job isn't done until the substantial completion form is issued and you know final payments and when you come Park East is at the meetings too you're all working together I guess Anthony's at these meetings correct yeah par is on site par is harder to be on site when a Contractor on site they're on site but par is responsible to be here full time and can we pull up okay so I want to so some of these bathrooms red and white in the same you know they're all recently done how come some are done red and white and some are done just absolutely Bare Bones

067there a little too small to just to get that red White Band so we just left them all white but we could add a red red and blue we don't want to edit I'm just saying um you know they kids bathrooms too I mean no fun tile or anything but I'm not even going to get in that I don't I'm not looking at the ad cost I I think for 1,800 a square foot we can have fun tile for kids um we can make it uh cuz they're going to be with these bathrooms for the next what 15 years and um they look would you say they're unimpressive there single small classroom B okay the only difference between them and the ones at go is gos are a little bit bigger but I think at

068Gill we didn't even put tile on the walls we stopped at the sanitary code you can do that at L but I just think the you know the maintenance upkeep would be crazy like let's pull up the electrical bill for this job cuz I I I want to go through that I think we have um I just see okay so you know could we could you go down please and educate me um for example lighting fixtures 2200 I are they like on back order cuz there's no $2200 so the the light fixtures are required with the energy code they have to have um daylight harvesting in them that controled with a CAT 5 cable to turn on and off and dim the lighting requirements now have gone through the roof of some of the new

069in increased uh environmental codes what's the mobilization that's them getting out of bed and driving to West Side really you know they say they the mobilizer they got to bring their work box in they'll have it on site for the through the truck okay General conditions just curious what conditions they're General so General conditions would be their you know the payment for their office staff um any submitt any permits any job clean ups lighting fixture install and then we have Branch wiring labor so that's labor 4700 but then you're charging for install and then you know so what's the difference so when you say I don't do the work and I don't charge the work and I don't put the invoices or the bids together so these are actually question so who's watching our money

070well I don't put the bid in the bid is based off of our plans and specs but you you sir said that we asked for a bathroom and then you design the bathroom and then you tell us you design it with a little cushion you tell us this is what it's going to cost so we can build a budget pass the money for example we wanted a traffic light we got a quote which I believe you you were engine $675,000 the actual cost you definitely built the cushion in because the actual cost is going to be between three and $325,000 so that's too big a cushion because we're voting on 675 we have to vote on accurate numbers and this um this is concerning that you're not able to go through these invoices and tell

071us what exactly this means because you're telling us You're The Keeper of the budget prices right well I mean you have so the branch wiring is the material or the wiring that goes from the lights all the way back to the circuit breaker panel and then you have the labor to run the wiring back at the circuit breaker panel and remember required to have two people on site at $150 an hour and they're required because the rooll union to be paid for full day so if it's $1 $300 you're $2,400 a day for two guys and they're not going to probably work the full day to run BR circuit wiring for two bathrooms fa equipment what's that so that's the fire alarm equipment that they would be having to buy from the company that Services

072your fire alarms they would sell them that and then the fire La equipment installation and then punch list and close out all right let's go to another bill please um any way to turn that sideways what's this bill for I don't recognize this one actually I was looking for the uh AC bill or the plumbing here's here's AC okay where's the AC by the way cuz I just see a little um 4x4 ceiling vent so that's the exhaust fan and then the duck work and then the pend in the ceiling so what was uh 16 hours for what did they do I just see a little like you said a little vent in the ceiling what what took 16 hours so they ran the new they pulled down the old duck work and they pulled

073the new Duck work up to uh exhaust fans and then the grill in the ceiling and that took 16 hours I have you ever had the agback replaced in your house yes I have did it take multiple days for them to remove anything and replace it yes okay that's for a house this is this is a b room correct and uh I I just I just it took one day my house um air balancing 500 what the there what are we balance so they got to balance and make sure the exhaust fan is sitting properly and pulling out the proper CFM we'll specify a CFM we got to make sure that the fan is pulling the proper CFM was that in 16 hours that's in the air balancing yeah so the allowance for five what

074are we allowing for again so an allowance is always built into to a project just in case something comes up during construction that's unforeseen so in this case nothing took place that was unforeseen so we'll be writing a deduct change order of $5,000 back in the district for unused allowances on we get 5,000 back okay next bill we 14, work the GC no that's the plumber for the two work locations and they they were Renovations so Plumbing existed right we pull all of the plumbing out out with old and in with new and again they're required to have two plumbers on site and we didn't use the allowance again no you'll get that back and when you gave us the 53,000 per bathroom roughly does that back out those allowances that's the net the allowance

075comes off the top of that didn't use any allowance on any of the bathrooms when we n these allowances out we'll end up with 53,000 per bathroom or we'll end up with less I think at the end when you get your allowances back it'll be down in the I don't know 20,000 15,000 I got to look at all the okay but that's what I'm asking that 53 goes to what you think maybe 43 probably less than that because none we didn't use any of the allowance in any of the three work locations for bathroom so that's 15,000 right there did you use the allowance on the first four bathrooms that look very similar to this no the only allowances that were used were in the kitchen uh there were two minor requested by the owner

076to use some allowance money um and then all of the rest is coming back as part of D change we can't obviously deduct the allowance at the beginning because we haven't started the work so then when you do your project close out you allow deduct change orders to reduce it before you do your final payments okay so those materials in there you know Home Depot you know no frills and wor $3,250 for toilets um you know there's one toilet what's the other it could that toilet you know it's two toilets two toilets two sinks two floor drains 3250 yeah and they're not Home Depot they're from directly from yeah I know I'm just saying I'm even marking it up for so 242 man hours um profit what what they actually put in the profit they're

077making on the job they're they're for a change they're requ they're allowed 10 5 and two which is 10% 5% profit and 2% for Bond increase that's right in the general conditions can you explain what rounding is because it seems to be on every bill that rounds up to an even number is that I guess what they did they rounded it up to number yeah so I guess the only thing you know I me one last thing please if we could look at the bills for the upstairs I think we have them um CU I want to see if they're roughly the same let's just let's just stop here for what's this bill original contract [Music] 62,000 total contract what does this say so that's our original bill for I don't know yes that was

078must have been their original their original for work location 1 three and four and then we added the 14,500 which is the work location and then that's his total [Music] contract I have no idea what you're saying but you're confident that these numbers are you know completely within the normal scope of unfortunately in the public sector now these are the numbers that we're saying they're through the roof but it sounds like you're recommending that we have an in-house team to start doing more of this work it might be a good idea to do some of the some of the work in half sh I mean we did the renovations to get the robotics live anon's team helped out and did a lot of a lot of the stuff in house I mean districts are doing

079it you know but it's a full you know you have to work with civil service and full-time mechanics but that would be job instead of doing ab andc they would renovate a bathroom or they would put ceilings in a classroom right so these light fixtures for 2200 just I'm not sure I understood that we're getting fixtures or they just cost a lot the fixtures and the lighting controls and the wiring I can send you a cut the the switches are like not even flush they're not even automatic the old black switches that were there probably before the bathrooms are renovated I don't think those are the final ones I think waiting for the permanent ones to come in I know he was there tonight doing some work putting in the firearm devices I think I'll

080check on the other stuff do you have an estimated date on this that I don't and we're still waiting on a lead time on the doors I mean doors are another thing 20 we lead time on doors and hardware and what was the date that work was started I forget not until June what that first Monday June 26 June 28th something like that okay really Qui do you have the bills back there um that you can bring up for the the first floor um because they should be similar I don't know they're the last of each of the PS of the upstair bathrooms that's those are the B we talked about 11 112 should we be doing something differently to um follow the cost and the money um should we be giving you more guidance

081um in terms of I we could we couldn't have told you design a less PE bathroom because that's as Bare Bones as it gets so it's not like we're asking for luxury to be put in but what if you were sitting on the board and There Was An Architect that worked for for you um what would you say to that architect I've always been very careful unless I'm specifically told about overdesigning because it's public money absolutely so you're sitting in my seat and I'm over there what are you asking me I want something that's nice I want the bones to last I want the best roof I want the best Windows I want the best door but there are ways you can do things you don't have to put Italian marble flooring you can do

082it with paint and ceramic but sometimes just to get somebody to come into a small project of this magnitude you're going to see these ridiculously high numbers and like I said what we've done in a couple of other districts we recommend their their maintenance grw do some of these other products they don't have the overhead the bond the insurance all of this stuff goes out the way side they're being paid so the labor is not there you're basically buying material that they're installing on their 8 hour day do Architects ever work by the hour say we came to and said we need you to design two bathrooms what would your fee be for that versus a percent of the project I mean I've seen it a lot on on rfps it it's under $100,000 maybe

083is that under $50,000 is that something we should do is is try to build that service by the hour it's it's very difficult because my process that I do and the amount of things that I do for districts and in this District that I've done for free and never said boo over the years I mean I guess you could but I mean I've never done that way but I usually don't build unless we're doing a capital project but you're designing the project so you actually control the price of that project to a large degree right you you could design it 50,000 or 70,000 as long as it comes in under budget we don't know the difference right yeah and that works good once or twice but you know we we don't know it's a very

084small community there's only 124 school districts how would we know if look every I keep in this presentation I keep saying under budget that seems to be the as long as it's under budget but you're setting the budget right yeah so maybe we should pay projects by the hour and then it's not a percent of the project do Architects work for school districts in that fashion the problem with that is again like I initially said the budget and the approval from the community has to come before the design so you would ask them by the hour we want to spend $200,000 on X but if the community doesn't approve that or they approve more or they approve it's very difficult it's not just hey you know 10 hours and and in 10 hours design me

085something I do so much more back and forth that is over and above the 5% we have a one3 fiveyear construction plan right so we know what we're going to be building over the next year so if we find an architect and say we need bathrooms we need a kitchen we need this and you bit out you know um to design all this what would the fee be flat fee that sounds like a better way to do it right and then we we could build the budget up that way so um I'm just trying to think of ways to do things that's the most cost effective because um I do want to find out if the prevailing rate for like very Bare Bones no for bathroom is 1,800 foot maybe it is it just seems

086like a lot of money can I can I just go back to something you just said um you said it's expensive to get some of the some people you know contractors come in to do these small jobs right so that's kind of confusing to me because one I don't think this really is a small job it went from two to six bathrooms was very glossy so I would you're saying it's a small job so is that do does their prevailing wage differ on depending on the size of the job no the second so then what did you mean by that when you said it's hard to get people in to do such a simp job some people are not even biding and what they'll do is they'll throw a ridiculous High number like if I'm

087going to come and build this little project I'm going to put a high number if I get it great I'll make more money if I don't who cares because I didn't really need it but whether the electrician is 1 hour or 50 hours the owner of the company has the list Jo mono Works 8 hours a day he gets paid $150 an hour for 8 days and 40 hours a week and then he has to sign it and now the labor department just came out this last week they want every and any contractor that's going to do public works for veiling wage projects to register on the New York State labor department website and then within the next few months upload all of certified payroll so anybody in the world can see if XYZ contractors

088paying his employee certified payroll and the actual weate so what is what is that difference can you explain to me what the coar list is through b do you know what that is the what the coar list no I had a question based on something that you said also um I know you said that you would never recommend something that was overpriced or like overdesigned something that we didn't need so my question is in our our new science which is just beautiful um the the glass that turns opaque whose recommendation was that so that goes back to 2017 2018 that's I'm asking CU yeah I mean they went to everybody went to Sham and everybody wanted Shaman they wanted the Rival either Shaman or and they have that at Shaman that wall has that and

089that was the recommendation to spend that money and then what about the wet lab too the design of that that was the intent at the time was to get the wet lab the marine biology the coral reef lab we put in all fiberglass stff work to receive it we put an all PVC piping to do it all Joe and I have been dealing with with issues now on how we get labor to put in the fish tanks what do you mean you're having problems with labor well it's it's a problem we have the equipment that we need and I know eron has picked out the equipment and Joe and I have had countless conversations about this we know the filters the pumps the tanks the racks to we could we have a bid ready to

090go to buy the equipment but the installation and we checked with the attorney and they said this too has to be paid prevailing wage and I'm sure there's not a fish store company in the world that pays prevailing wage to install a fish tank don't we pay the prevailing rates not the fish store well no they have to pay his employees so they bill us don't they they do but I don't know if they would now want to be because no I mean you're owner of a fish St you come in you bring a fish tank you have a a truck full of Parts you fild the fish tank you do what you got to do and you go on your way have you ever built a w lamp before design room design yeah because

091our students have not had a wet web they signed up for a class and this project has taken a ridiculous amount of time is this something every day you're checking on to see you know I I I know how I work I know how the people I work with work I've never seen things move this slowly sometimes like what took so long with this wetland so we have again not again the Avenue start from the beginning what it took so long the Aven well I'll tell you where it took so long is we designed the wet lab science chair left new sign share came in halfway through the project there was Rumblings that it wasn't going to be a wetland anymore and we were going to do who told you that previous administration so then

092it was brought back up to the Forefront and again we do not have the means unless the attorney can help me with this one to have Labor done in the school to install the components of the lab we you said You' done other web Labs right so how did you deal with the problem then you work with scho the district just what the equipment and whether they're in-house staff or they person that like I know in South can we do that could what can we do that I don't know if if you're did you ask ER does not these students need to have a functioning wet lab it I feel badly for them and I'm on a board that's supposed to get them their wet lab and and I ask questions and are you working

093on this every day Joe and I talked three hours ago about this and when's the last time you talked before that um three times a week what Liv and what what do you accomplish we really don't accomplish anything thank you for adting that okay I have one more John one question I have one more question about spending recommendations and this this goes back a couple years but I was on the board at the time when you um had recommended the gas service installation and we did not did not approve that can you remind me what the cost was of that so origin we got numbers from PSC and and the two I remember is the high school and Lloyd originally we were told that it wouldn't cost us anything to bring high pressure gas to

094Lloyd Harbor yeah and it's it was going to be $5,000 that were going to eat the cost right we got SD approval we went back to to National Grid and they came with a letter and said it's going to cost $1.4 million that's right at the high school I think they told us it was going to be 400,000 to come from lawren up to the building we gotd approval we went back in that grid and they wanted it was 1.1 or 1.2 something like that something something in the neighborhood of about $3 million for both projects or a little south of that maybe so and did New York state in 2023 when we were having this conversation did they change the law about new buildings having gas in New York state and is our governor

095moving towards not allowing gas in buildings they're pushing for electric not gas right not allowing gas right so I'm wondering why when you I I'm just trying to clarify because you said you would you try to only recommend to us that we spend money in a way that makes sense for the district so and at the beginning of this presentation you brought up the gas again knowing that it's just south of $3 million just to bring the line in and knowing that we had the I know we had the conversation right that New York state is moving away from allowing gas in state buildings right and new buildings so I'm just wondering just as you're recommending to us how to spend money I'm I'm recommend what the explanation is for that well I'm I'm not

096recommending one I think it is you would never burn enough gas at lyd or west side to justify bringing gas to those buildings I was recommending the high school because the high school would use 247 365 you have five boil this says it's you have it in your recommendation under District y projects not just under the high school those are just that's how it was originally listed on the bond okay okay thank you for clarifying I think roof generators and and and gas um I was just trying to it was a really really big number I feel like it was $5 million all in to bring the generator and the gas is that correct to this just to this building maybe is that right no it was 5 million for everything and then we originally

097said forget Floyd forget Westside put the generator in Goose because it's admin and we were always back and forth because there's gas on that street already right where at Goose on goose yes yeah waiting for new in fact it's right outside there's a gas line right outside the school Harbor yeah we're just waiting for a new regulator to come in and get that generator up and running oh and there is a gas line already Gill has been running strict on gas since 07 okay and Lloyd Harbor has G Lloyd Harbor has no gu Lloyd Harbor and West right now are only oil but the other problem that we have is that when the bond was sold we didn't call for these to furnish and install a new 10,000 gallon fuel oil tank was the anticipation

098because you thought you were going to dump the tanks and put gas in correct so now we would have to have the attorneys like we decided we don't want to go gas but we want to put a real fuel oil tank in we would have to see if the attorneys if that if we could do that under the bond or we have to go back to the community and ask for a shifting of fund to put in a new fuel loil tent okay and what do you think that would cost uh about 375,000 for a 10,000 thank you Mr gorilla um I'm just trying to sum up with lessons learn at least for now so we should hire an inhouse crew to do jobs like these bathrooms you're saying it would be much cheaper how

099many people should we hire it depends I think when we would when we did the library in Goose Hill I think they hired three mechanics and C Spring Harbor how many people should we hire that's what I'm saying when you did it in for go Hill I think you hired three one could do plumbing and mechanical I think they had one that was just a carpenter and one could do carpentry you say hire you mean we hire directly you guys hired them I don't know how work for civil services this was back in 2009 so we had employees that used to do this work that no longer you did but you hired them for a one project so we can do that we can hire people off the street check with the attorney in terms

100of civil service can you do a one done orlo in your in your bu well maybe some have some more full-time maintenance people right on the school grounds cuz you know I just keep thinking about six bathrooms were all 300 Grand so if we had let's just be hire two full-time maintenance workers just you know at I don't know 100,000 each I I don't know what 150,000 anyway you could get to that 300,000 probably for a year and have two guys do a lot more than six basss yeah so I to me I keep circling back in my head that this is not working so we're going to have to try something else smaller projects I agree okay the wet labs when are we going to have a wet lab Joe did you talk to

101the uh you we going to reach out to that guy this morning ER didn't send me the name we reach out to she get you can we get receipts for things like the toilets and the lights and everything so we can see that that's everything that is those are those are not receipts though those are the invoices that we p on oh so we have a so like I've asked for invoices and it's taken a week to get them do we have them on on site here or do they have to get them from you no they go on site proove them so the process is the construction manager reviews the P once they approve them they send them to us resign them take a certified pay roll send it to Christine's office and then

102once she has all the paperwork in hand then she'll issue the check based on that's what's called the g703 that's a continuation sheet and then she would pay based on that bar east is our construction managers so the bills go to them they review them and then they pass them to Christine and andil copy to them well then they come to me for final signature and then they go to the business office so you sign off before they go to Christine cor on the bills and then if we had our own construction manager in house do you think that would be beneficial versus an outside that would be Anthony anon's our construction no he's he's a director of facilities and usually what districts do is they hire separate construction manager because now the director facilities

103is doing their day-to-day operation and it's hard to do the day-to-day operation and the onsite watching construction going on while everything else that they're doing in the summer so we PID quite a bit of fees to Parky so we can have an in-house construction manager no I'm just tring I would assume so if we hire by the hour an architect have an in-house construction manager you know this looks like a more more attention we don't have a 7 8 Monon wet lab um you know I'm just I'm asking you to put yourself in my seat and then me standing there give me the business tell me hey this is what I want from you or this is what I need from you I want you to play me for give me give me your your

104cuz you know better than me this this field you know better about architecture construction cost I want you to pretend you're me and what questions would you ask me standing there well I I know with some of the the statements that you're making I don't think Civil Service would allow you to hire a construction manager separate from the director of facilities um maintenance mechanics yes but there would be probably full-time employees but these are more questions for the attorney not for but our director of facilities could manage the construction I don't want to speak for Anthony to do day-to-day plus there's I can tell you I can tell you right now that does that happen in other school districts no I don't know no one director facilities that is working and doing their job have

105construction manager they do yes so you just no they have an independent construction man using like Park East or something e they don't have an inhouse correct okay they have an inhouse director facilities and then the construction manager reports to direct but again could you please just role play for me you're sitting here I'm standing there I'm a you're a board member what questions would you ask you about bathrooms about how to do things better educate me I mean we're Bound by so many things that aren't nuts and Bs we're Bound by bonds we're Bound by Insurance we're Bound by prevailing not bound you're you're me I no no I know you're me what questions I want to hear the actual questions that you would ask if you were a board member of of a

106person standing in your position I would ask then if the architect before you submit plans to the State education department sit again with the director facilities and other facilities committee meeting and get a sign off and then PR they going out to bid review those plans again and get another sign off and have final sign off before we move forward and what's the what would you accomplish doing a better pricing more over not better better pricing but better assurances that we've had the end user take a look at the plans and specs that would be a good thing we also want before pictures can we start making that a practice that we we take before pictures of jobs cuz honestly when we got those pictures I thought I had a question if there were before

107or after pictures um and so you said um we want receipts for like the cost of lights and toilets we can get that cuz that those aren't receipts that's that's on there I mean I don't know what that's between the contract um they don't exist I'm sure they're going to have receipts I I again that's between the contractors and you know that's not for me to say here's a receipt and then you say oh I can buy a cheaper cuz I've just and I've taken enough time I just find it so hard to believe that those bath from were 1,800 a square foot and if they are the system really broken because we're we're spending too much where we could spend it on you know uh education uh salaries benefits and and wet Labs you

108know that nicer WLS if we ever get one I can you promise me you will focus more on that please I've been I can promise you again but I have been focusing and what I told Joe today is I will come out if we can get the fish tank guy I will come to the site I will do the drawings myself and we'll bid them out with the labor and it's going to be hundred plus th000 for fish tanks and you've done wet Labs before and we're trying to figure out how to get it done I'm confused to be honest with you well again all of the other end users have had people that could do the fish tanks and building on themselves so I'm just just thank you so oh Heather a question okay

109sorry my voice are they coming under budget or over budget that part of the so I think I think we said I think the price that eron was getting was roughly about $65,000 that was for all of the equipment in the overall price of that piece we had a contingency we didn't break it down by fish tanks because we had no idea how many fish tanks you were going to do if it was going to be built in over years but there's money in the bond to pay for that it's just the the avenue to get the labor to install them is the hiccup but there is money in the bond to cover that course it doesn't have to go outside of the bond thank you okay thank you very much you're welcome thank you

110everyone thank you John okay so this is my point of clarification um Mr mon can you tell tell us when the board when the change orders appeared on the board agenda in August and uh actually Mr taliente asked for detail on what the change orders were he was told by the assistant superintendent of finance that they were for what they were for boilers right so not for the bathrooms so um just so everyone's aware thank you okay um we are now going to continue with the rest of our agenda um committee report so um the policy committee met we've addressed that a little bit already this evening we're going to have a report now from policy try my voice is done um policy committee met this past Friday um we have two policies tonight for

111first reading the first one is 2160 board member schol district officer and ethics um we updated the policy the purpose which is to avoid all conflicts of interest of persons while they are employed um by the district or when they owe duty to the district so that would be a board member so that is what that policy that we're updating touches on um second policy that's on for first read that we worked on Friday is a new policy and that pertains to the recording of these board meetings we have three policies on for a second read one's voting procedures that's 21 20.2 that updates um is really concerning early mail ballot and then 82101 that's for the use of surveillance ceras on school properties this is a policy we're adding pertaining to our use of

112surveillance cameras for purposes of student discipline and safeguarding our property and Facilities um Alex in her statement referen this last policy that's on for second read That's 5150 R um in that policy the policy committee is recommending changes that are intended to modernize the admissions policy and specifically addresses documentation requirements to demonstrate residency in the district for example the policy list ways a parent caregiver can prove residency and clarifies that various documents may be used for proof instead of must be used for proof Additionally the policy provides a link to the New York State education department website that lists a students under New York state law finally the policy clarifies that students will be admitted next school day or as soon as practicable after for a that's all I have okay um we moved on

113to committee reports we are on committee reports yes I had a couple items in discussion discussion is a different area than committee reports were you on a committee that met we usually have an open discussion yeah that discussion is oh we're still in we moved to committee report but you want to go back to discussion Yeah couple items that's why okay so did we finish with policy yes policy have let's let's do the tech committee and we'll go back to discuss then thank you okay just really quickly the tech committee met on November 14th um we it was mostly it was run by D fton she's been doing a lot of great work since she started um we she spoke mostly about the roll out of parents Square all the different things that you can

114do with parents Square um how you can you know eventually you know we we're going to keep seeing updates uh the other day there was up to start getting uh attendance through uh through parents Square um hopefully Sports will start to be on that you so I think the end game is that you can be able to sort it and set it to what you want you know you can see the specific things that you want um to be alerted about uh Dr Fon also talked about she's reviewing some of the program purchases that we have um some of the subscriptions see what's being used kind of get rid of the things that haven't been used in a while um we don't need to redo the tech plan as that's good until the 2526 school

115year um and we are still we're finishing up the E switch project and um yeah and we're still always uh looking into Ai and how we're going to deal with that thank you very much any other committees no all right let's return then to discussion go ahead thank you so much so last meeting um we agreed to poll the students and residents about a third language and I was wondering if we had any further update on that referring to the survey right what what's the status of the third language So based on the we gave the surve out two separate surveys one to the parents and Guardians and one to the students and the the parents there are 280 responses from parents and Guardians and their first choice of a third language for an elective

116was Italian followed by uh second choice of Chinese Mandarin for the students there were 595 responses and their first choice of a language was Italian that came at about 40% of the the students and the second choice for students was American Sign Language so in taking that into consideration along with everything else that we've been discussing so we talked about how challenging it is to find teachers of third languages um we we are leaning towards the Italian because not only is their interest we do need to have students interested in the run it that's another Factor we need staff to teach the course and so we do have someone on staff who speaks Italian so that that's something that we could possibly staff um if it's one section that will work out if it's more

117than one section then we're looking at hiring um a part-time person so it depends on the number of sections so it was all of those factors taken into consideration to move forward with Italian when are we making this official or is this where do this stand yes we're making this official so we're offering an elective Lo time correct and we were we're holding off we just wanted to report back to the board um we put in the Friday notes as well to make sure that the board was on board with that um so the the program of study is not moving forward to be sent off to print until you were all comfortable with that decision as well we have to vote on that no at the last meeting we said we kind of left

118it blank as whatever we decided afterwards that so it's going to be Italian and then miss just said it be it's Italian and then that's it the board doesn't have to no we already approved moving forward with their recommendation so that's Jen's recommendation thank and then um did we get pricing on the panic button for the lanyards yet we talked about last month we have that is the board going to get that price because we want to buy them or at least know how much they cost that's something we're looking to put in the budget for next year so next year so that we have to wait till next year to purchase can we find out how much they are because we probably could find we're getting back 83 we thought right roughly was that

119we thought about $83,000 83,000 uh all right so that's a not an insignificant amount no that's a bathroom in so hopefully five the uh the perception survey what's the status of that so we we could just move forward uh we're looking at the the the company I like if I want to say what company I like right now uh getting the final quote from them to purchase VI bosies and I think we could have something on the general repard meeting for improve of the company and the traffic light what's the status of that today the Huntington Town board I have to check to see if they prove we expect them to approve the I want to use the correct term the resolution for the town attorney then to draft the uh IMR inter missal agreement

120for us to move forward to do the purchase and installation of the light through them so they had that first step would be today uh if it's not they'll send the contract over to us our attorney will review it and then at our next board meeting we should be able to have it on as a resolution to move forward with uh the Town of Huntington that would be the most cost effective of of doing it between uh going out to bid where there were two who uh put in a bid going through the town requirements contract was less expensive by about $2,000 if all goes well one one of the estimates will be up and running they had estimates anywhere from uh 3 to 6 months they said the most uh time consuming component is

121the metal arms have that idea they're fabricated I guess per each item everything else is more standard we may start quite soon you said then relying on the town so if the town approved what we expected them to today we would uh sign the agreement they would approve the agreement at their meeting and then they move they seem very anxious to get it done to do the work last did you say we needed to have one more meeting to approve it toin next one so at this at the Town board meeting today they had to approve the um resolution for them to draft the agreement between us and to to okay and then if they approve that we need one more meeting to approve that so if we I understand the holidays are coming so

122that slows things down but if we can get a forum together before winter break we could do that and approve it in a meeting oh yes as well rather than wait until mid January and have another month but I know that it probably doesn't make much of a difference but yeah but we' have to wait for the account to give it to I don't think it would be a big deal okay thank you last question was um I could read my scle oh we were looking at putting cameras in um for license plate purposes in on the campuses to capture license plates and um can we get update on that in terms of where that stands and what the pricing looks like did we get the prices for the ceras and again I was looking

123for these to be budgetary items for the next budget think Mo quick on that we could I think these are part of myd for so if you're coming in off lawence Hill Road where what build and what that be Lawrence Hill Ro we can put one that is attached to uh the football field that we have a network about oh that maybe the snack bar or something we could do anywhere from the snack bar or on um the Press so coming down and oh we don't have Network out there so we don't have so for any of the locations you would have in the high school obviously being the biggest challenge because of the distance uh for the building but we do have a network okay thank you I'm sorry I thought of one more

124thing so um we do very nice um uh what do you call those get Tire we uh like orientation for eth grade moving up Etc we do um you know nice presentations they're not recorded So if you miss that night you miss it and those are so important they're filled with terrific information so much information it'd be nice to relist to is there any reason why we don't record those types of meetings um on um even there was one on College they recorded the college night I asked about it because I also was not able to attend and I got the so if you see here we have three cameras that were installed as part of the one work in the pack and that was part of what we going to do going forward to

125record them we're using them today so that was the first one with the work being done to be recorded So in the future we'll record those meetings we'll be recording those meetings right yes we're recording them and we're using that equipment today um we do have to on those meetings those are easy we do have to be careful tonight I'm not so sure all the music will be allowed when we post to YouTube it may be uh copyrighted we may have to block that out okay but we'll see yeah I mean things are proprietary we do here I would assume we don't want um but so we password to protect those for parents or anybody can log on to our website and watch how we counsel parents and we haven't that will be the first

126we we don't have a password protected I mean it's it's really just something I think if we want to do or not I I password can get out easily probably doesn't work I don't think I I wonder to Joe are you been able to do that if other residents wanted to watch the meeting have this meeting the attorney yeah a public oh no a meeting for let's say nth grade parents orientation to high school if that's recorded and posted can that be then password protected or does anyone in the community have the right to watch that no I you could pass okay process would be okay talking about a specific meeting with N grade parents to discuss yeah incoming nth grade or 11th graders it was a college meeting this week right okay that's that's

127acceptable okay that's that's an interes I think they'd be happy parents if they could watch it if they V that night you know so and our faculty puts in so much work they did a good job it's um you know we live on it's great sometimes you want to go back and and look at what you missed too yes I don't know what do people think password protect prot who youting into the meting you're only a 10 grade show would show up would you let them know some people show up without kids they come by themselves sure if a person without school age students just a res in the district yeah I'm not not taking a tenis like that if they have kids in yes yes okay so why don't we right now now keep

128it that we're going to record the meetings and since we're on page one of the agenda and it's 10:27 p.m. let's discuss further whether or not we want to password protect them at another meeting is everyone comfortable with that yes okay thank you all right all right well here we are then we are at lost my place but we're in our first audience to visitors of the evening um Cold Spring Harbor Board of educ and administration welcome your attendance at board meetings attendance to the public affords residents an opportunity to address the board of education on both agenda and non-agenda items each resident is allowed to speak for 3 minutes this is not the Forum to discuss student or staff specific issues please contact the district separately on these matters I just wanted to introduce

129yourself address 1592 thank you I wanted to first of all thank the board because tonight we saw something that we never saw before and the problem of a $54,000 bathroom is minuscule in an $80 million budget but it's it represents a much bigger picture and the fact is this the gentleman that was here and everybody Associated all the contractors everybody nobody is incentivized to reduce costs and that was what the board really I think realized tonight um the work that was done I'm not going to reash we spent hours on the bathroom but honestly do you really think thew was changed the $116,000 I'm willing to bet every dime I have that they connected to the ex thing that work so we need someone like a facilities manager or an overall manager to insect and

130make sure we're getting our money's worth we saw this with a with our $450,000 softball fields that town of Boer Bay paid $100,000 for and we're really getting to this now and I think the lid has been blown off and I really hope moving forward that any project that's done in this district is done on time and on budget but is done re responsibly and I really want to thank truly thank all of you guys everybody for really taking the time and exposing this because it it's disgusting you know a house cost $300 a square foot to build I'm very experienced with prevailing wage and I know what it does to it cost it it increases them but six times you know that's crazy anyway you a lot of time on it I wanted to

131thank you guys because it was very eye opening what came out at the meeting tonight thank you thank you okay we're going to move on to approval of minutes um November 12th uh Bruce was absent uh may have a first Lisa second he any questions all in favor thank you okay we're going to move on to Personnel recommendations I have a walk on for personnel so may I have a motion to walk on um a resolution uh for an element teaching position at scho may I have a first Heather may have a second Bruce any questions discussion all in favor this is just a walking it on thank you I'm going to read the resolution now whereas the district has needed to fill an unexpected vacancy in a teaching position at goil elementary school and

132whereas the district has entered into an agreement with Alexandra pillo for a non probation appointment that will not lead to tenure to be compensated at an annual salary of $ 62,939 may I have a first Lisa second Heather any questions all in favor thank you um all right uh we are going to take uh the other personal recommendations of the superintendent uh other matters leaves resignations Alex I don't think you did minutes approval I did minutes approval already Yes yesk you that's okay we've been here a while um appointments on pages two through 10 as a slate may I have a first P second Bruce any questions all in [Music] favor thank you okay we now move on to business recommendation donations bid Awards budget transfers and the claims Auditors report and additional business matters

133on pages 10 through may I have second Kate um as a part of discussion I'd like to just uh mention the donations um and thank our donors you want to do it Joe sure we have a few donations here first we have the West ptg who donated the Gaga pick the passes now they donating the ground prevent the mud when the kids come out to play Gaga which is like kickball handball combined they really love it at both buildings um then we have at the West I ptg they're doing the uh cafeteria dressing up the entire cafeteria all four walls using 71 visuals there's a in your packet there there is a a rem what it will look like it's going to look great at Goose Hill what happen to GL uh play day this

134is for the Education Foundation again thank you for making that donation uh play is so important they'll be using this on of that day and uh the materials going forward we also have the use as R for drone to be used uh again from the CL car laboratory after of Junior Senior High School those are all that okay thank you thank you all in favor okay um we now move to special education reports we will take all contracts and CSC CPS approvals on pages 14 as a slate may have the first second Lisa any questions all in favor okay we now move to a first reading of polic see 2160 and 2382 on page 14 I I think I'm right on this and that we did skip did we skip the did we go all

135way to 10 I'm try okay sorry thank you I just want to make sure I get it right thank you and we did special education we special educ and so now we're at policy first um so policy 2160 uh board member School District officer and employee code of ethics and oh okay I see uh reporting and broadcasting of board meetings um we're going to vote to weit first read on these policies may I have a first second Lisa any questions comments all in favor thank you okay we're going to move to a second read and Adoption of policy 21202 and 82101 and R uh 21202 is voting procedures 821 0.1 is use of surveillance cameras and school property and 5150 R is school admissions regulation um we're going to wave vote to wave of full

136reading and to adopt may I have a first Bruce second other discussion the second read and adopt ofes was located it's not a change to the wording um what was intended was the last paragraph of the entire policy was intended to be moved up to um the first say first page um I want take I'll say because I don't how printed out to the section evidence of residents in the district so that final paragraph will be just to be underne that subhead evidence of residence in District and they mo on to say prior to enrolling children in school Etc thank you so the paragraph is just out of order it's not it's not a matter of changing the word okay should have been moved up to underneath that so that will be um rectified all

137in favor thank you okay this agenda agenda includes Financial reports on page 11 and these reports are for informational purposes no vote is necessary if needed Miss Costa will answer any questions from the Board of Education and public feel free to call her in her office oh this is a second discussion session section of our agenda would anyone like to discuss anything further at this time no okay we're going to continue with our second audience to visitors I will not reread the statement but if anyone would like to come up from the audience and speak at this time this is the second and final chance okay may I have a motion tojn Ru second Kate all in favor thank you very much everyone [Music] spe ter lit every you too

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.