CorpusRecord 140265

Haldane Board of Education - December 3, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Haldane BOE
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Putnam County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,921 words · about 61 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001um hello everybody um Welcome to our meeting I'm going to call our meeting to order and ask everyone to stand for the pl of difference of opinion oh is a bigger one I pledge alance to the flag of the United States of America to the stands Nation indivisible that flag is always in a um great president Clemens here vice president Valentine trusty mcnell here trusty copper here trusty clemenson here and may we have the recommended action for approving the agenda please be it resolved that upon the recommendation of the interim superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the agenda as written you have a motion please so moved second all those in favor I I any oppos all right um so the next meeting of the board of education is next Tuesday December

0027 sorry two week from now Tuesday December 17th 2024 at 700 p.m. here in the middle school high school library um and the topic will be our annual report from our um director of curriculum which is um uh the basically the workshop topic is curriculum instruct and instruction Report with State assessment so there's a policy where annually we need to have a presentation on the state assessments but Josh has really strove is doing a really good job at thinking about how to really present data to the board and we've had a c Maggie and I with Carl had a couple of conversations with him really working for those U presentations to be as useful as possible to to the board so um I think it will be I think it will be good um the

003only other comment I wanted to make is you know again I want to thank the community again for voting um on November 19th for our Capital referendum um there's really uh now so much for us to do moving forward that's very exciting um the this is on the agenda agenda a little bit later um but the board did have a retreat um on Friday where we really kicked off our superintendent search and we'll talk a little bit more about that um and then the last thing I want to say um at our last meeting we did talk um a little bit when the student who was here who's I guess the brother of Owen powers we did talk a little bit about the cross country race but there's a really nice article in the current

004this week about the success of our boys cross country team and it really raises that you know oww finished I think um uh yeah like uh third in state in our division which is the highest any uh Halliday Runner has ever finished and the boys team finished fourth which is the highest that any um of our cross country teams have finished and so um just like a truly successful season four sport that doesn't get as much attent attention but I thought it was really um I was very glad that I had made the effort to go to the regional race it was great to see the boys run great to see the girls run and great to see those two teams really supporting each other the way that our students always do in sports so

005um I think there's a lot of things going on I've see you have you're gonna talk about some of this so I'm actually gonna hand it over to Mr Alano sure yeah thanks Peggy I I just have two topics I I want to brief the board on and the community so uh you may have heard that the Rockefeller Institute of for government um has completed its analysis of state aid in in the state of New York um the report was issued uh yesterday evening it is very dense very extensive over 300 pages of of reading I don't expect that the board was able to to to do all that reading last night uh but I did start to take a look at at at the report and and some of the findings some of the

006recommendations and I'll I'll try to just summarize them but you know first it it makes a lot of recommendations uh if the state were to implement all of the recommendations the their state budget would go up dramatically so so it's unlikely that they would accept all of these recommendations they probably are going to need to to pick and choose which is complicated but to give you an example um you know one one thing is uh the Rockefeller Institute recommends that all electric buses for all school districts in New York state are funded by the state because school districts are really struggling they're very expensive still the infrastructure the buses themselves are about three times a diesel bus so we are like many others seeking grant money uh to try to implement it but there are

007no guarantees and so that is one recommendation another is giving some flexibility with wealth uh calculations for school districts so typically household income is used property values are used but districts can could in their recommendation could pick whichever is more favorable to the school district now you know that maybe you know seems to be a fair recommendation but again it it it it's an expensive thing to do uh or also they recommend um uh doing a using a different calculation for economically disadvantaged uh students right now we use free and reduced lunch uh and and the Rockefeller Institute points out that that doesn't capture all of the students who were living in poverty and in need so this would you know expand that that budget line uh if implemented uh also in a similar way

008English language Learners right now we use um our survey our intake survey to identify students who who um English is their first language and the funding is the same whether you are a level one English language learner a level two or level three however the supports we give vary if you're a beginner you get more intense support at the at the school level if you're more advanced we start to wean off the support so uh the The Institute recommends base the funding on actual services that are being provided so so look at those levels of services in each individual District I'm not sure exactly how we would do that I think there' be some responsibility on the district to report it but they think that is a a more fair you know way to approach

009it um also they Advocate reestablishing separate special education funding outside of foundation Aid uh that was done in the past they they they think we should revert back to that and also expanding uh funding for student Mental Health Services and of course the data and and and all of the the research supports that as well so those are all great things but the state unlike the federal government as you know has a finite budget the federal government can raise the debt ceiling they can print money they can do things that a state cannot do they must balance their budget so this is going to be quite the challenge on the reverse end they do talk about um phasing out something called save harmless now this doesn't apply to hdan which is good uh but districts

010that that um over the years were not entitled to increases we're given a minimum increase probably around the same as CPI was around 3% it was called save harmless so more affluent districts were getting this for well over 10 years and the Rockefeller Institute recommends phasing that out over a fiveyear period so there wouldn't be a a hit in year one but over five years 50% of those increases would be lost basically um also um fund balances districts with excessively High fund balances would be encouraged to use them before receiving state aid now these are all recommendations the governor you know next steps the governor uh is due to provide a proposal to to both the assembly and the Senate on January 21st usually that's on time it's a draft budget that the governor proposes

011in the assembly and and the Senate we'll take a look at the governor's recommendation and then they make their proposals and it goes back and forth in my judgment and and I I don't know more than anyone else I'm sure over the next month or so all of our school boards Association the superintendent Association I'm sure everyone is going to be discussing this at our meetings um but if the intent is to implement these things in in year one I think it's going to be a challenge because we're expecting the state to let us know our state aid numbers in about two months and this is such a complex issue I just don't see it happening but maybe they will pick some of these recommendations and try to implement them in year one we we

012really just don't know until all that legislative process starts to play out up in Albany so I I think for us what does this mean well we have 2.9 Million this year in in Foundation Aid that's a significant part of our budget and if there you if a a 10% either decrease or increase for us is is significant and you know a 10% decrease for example is is the cost of two teachers so um I think we need to keep a close eye on it right now I'm not seeing anything alarming pertaining to our own uh you know budget uh maybe we would be fortunate and receive you know some some additional uh Foundation Aid I just don't know but we will be certain to keep you informed uh it'll be part of the budget

013discussion which will you know start you know around February or so and and March and April it'll really ramp up and we'll we'll we'll keep a close eye on this but it's an interesting topic and from what I'm seeing organization are applauding the Rockefeller Institute that a lot of these recommendations are are welcomed like like the busing and you know more funding for special ed and mental health like these are things we've been advocating for for a long time the question is you know how will it be delivered and will will there be winners and losers as far as public school districts any questions or any thoughts on it how is it determined if a school is a safe harmless District uh it's based on their wealth Factor okay so you know districts with a

014high level of individual wealth and property wealth uh didn't get any increases above that that minimum it it usually mirrored CPI and Carl am I remembering this correctly so save harmless is basically if you appli the for formula as written these are districts for whom their Foundation Aid would have decreased over time and they're save harmless so so what makes them safe harmless is because is that again the formula would have resulted in decreases in in state 8 but the way that it's been Foundation has been implemented is there's there aren't there aren't decreases the state's been guaranteeing them the same amount at least the same amount or not or not a decrease and at least I felt like at least like $500 a student or something along those lines and yeah the legisl kept

015that but the governor in the last round they tried to do it last year she wanted to get rid of save haras there has been no heads up that that's right so you know so what'll happen is the you know the governor like Carl said you know Governor is going to go she'll present what she wants and then it goes into the and the legislature just goes after it so there'll be a significant amount of push back on any type of cuts so and one one of the biggest challenges in clawing back save harmless you know if a district is going to lose 20 or 30% of their state aid even if it's an affluent District well there's a tax C so you know how do you deal with that you know the answer may

016be well G you know you don't really deserve state aid so raise your your local property taxes but the push back is well gee we can't do that all at once so the Rockefeller Institute you know their recommendation is Phase it out like over a five year period so one per year decrease would be more manageable for those districts which does make sense okay to be continued um throughout the the um Capital project as we were doing tours and meetings and speaking with the public and engaging uh the question came up frequently well you know when when will we get started and and and um there was a lot of you know excitement and and enthusiasm around that that question uh just to kind of frame a little bit for the board and the community

017where we are the Friday before Thanksgiving uh CS Arch came down to meet with the entire administrative team and we right away wanted to talk about next steps so what we accomplished in in that meeting was we will have a a districtwide capital project committee which will be admin administrators as well as two board Representatives that committee will meet monthly and our first date is December 18th we will meet monthly with the architect and the project manager probably for the next three years if there there may be a month or so where you you get off in the summer but um it is best practice to continually meet and just make sure that that everything is is you know on track and and and you're holding you know everyone accountable for what they need to

018be doing um additionally we we're creating six subcommittees and I I did send this to the board but for the community uh one subcommittee will focus on the Student Center that will be built uh on the high school the other uh committee will be focused on the steam Innovation Labs one at the middle school one at the high school uh also the general education classrooms at the high school which right now we think we'll you know certainly be uh relocating the the foreign language classes out of Mabel Merit uh there'll be another subcommittee for the art classroom because that is looks very different of course than than a gened classroom um the fifth committee will be safety Security Site work and parking lots and that for the most part is is like our district Safety

019Committee um and and members but but all of these by the way will have administrators teachers and and people who will actually be teaching and supporting students out of these spaces so they will have input and the last um subcommittee or support offices so the main office the nurse the psychologist social worker speech enl OT all those special services uh that will be a committee and and all of those people will have input they may not be at every committee meeting because you know obviously pulling them away from from working with students is is a challenge but we may bring them in you know two at a time um we also plan to for a lot of these subcommittees to do visits so csarch has done some really good work um you know um similar

020to what we want to accomplish we also know of some districts here that that did not use CS Arch but but have some you know great Renovations that they've done recently so I think the administrators the teachers the support staff going out seeing talking to other other teachers and administrators coming back collaborating with the Architects I think that that will you know produce the best results for for us but that'll be a pretty short process right to get to the final plans right this has to happen over the next like four months yeah yeah so that that it sounds like a lot of time but that's re really not there's an awful lot of planning so they they start with schematic designs then the more detailed our our design development phase that will probably conclude

021around May and then they get into actual the construction designs which are really in-depth designs that eventually will be submitted to State Ed for approval uh hopefully by the end of the summer then if you do the expedited process you could potentially have approval I would say sometime October November and then after that you can go out to bid and potentially so the question is when will we get started construction like shovels in the ground potentially uh late winter early spring you could actually start doing some construction here and then the more heavier uh you know construction like framing out the the the new classrooms in Student Center summer of 2026 happy to take any questions on that that was a lot of information sense to okay and and oh and one last thing CS

022Arch and and Palumbo they uh they have a public relations department Megan worked very closely with them on the videos and and all of the the communication they will continue to offer that service so when it makes sense we could continue to provide the community with updates and they will come to the board and make formal presentations anytime the board uh wants so having the two board Representatives on that District committee I think whenever it makes sense we will plan to have them here at the board meeting making formal presentations as well okay and the two board members will continue to be me and Maggie is that is that or do we well that's up to the board I I leave that up to the board so that's actually something we should talk about sure

023yeah that's that and it's a big commitment think about it is yeah um something you want to talk about now or something you want to add well I'm actually trying to figure out like is there a place where it should go in the agenda but I don't think I don't think there's an issue there's not we're not going to take any action Megan you don't see an issue with us right now um so it would be for those monthly owners meetings that we right right so that's what you say thank you appreciate it pardon thank you good job well certainly for the foreseeable future superintendent would make sense for for continuity sake at least until the new superintendent is in place to consider what future boards might want to do I mean the only thing

024I would think about I mean that does make sense to to me I mean it's one of the reasons why starting a few months ago I requested that Maggie and I start joining these meetings because even though Carl's doing a great job Carl's only going to be here for through this year and I thought it was really important that somebody have a more historic understanding so um I I'm certainly willing to continue to do it I don't know if it's something that you know I think Maggie is or not but I also think if somebody were just dying to to you know like it was so important to them then then I think that's something we could also think about accommodating yeah I'm happy to concede my spot but I I can also because it

025is interesting yeah um but I'm also happy to to stay on it I think realistically there might be times where not necessarily both of you can attend the scheduling is is not going to be easy because there's a lot of you know we've got to talk to our it's not just CS Arch it's some of the other groups that we're working with as well so we're sort of at the mercy of their schedules right well I I I I feel comfortable staying on and I'm happy to stay on but I think and it sounds like Maggie is open to doing it but I think if if one of you all really wanted to you should think about it and reach out to me and let me know great all right okay thank you thanks yes

026you're welcome actually we got the email today from nisba giving a quick overview of the Rockefeller Institute report and I was like I knew Carl would this very wise to say I didn't um do much other than make sure everybody saw the email um okay so um we were going to have a student recognition right now but that student is um playing oops sorry about that is um playing um in a basketball game so we'll do that in another night so we're going to skip that um to very exciting our special presentation which is the uh Elementary School visit summary and detail report so I'm gonna here our first first detail report of the Year okay so we have the pleasure of host listing Maggie and Peggy the same day as the uh the vote

027that's right which was an exciting day so Elementary School was uh was very busy hosting the community hosting the board was was an exciting day um so we had a little pamphlet of just look force that I gave you guys a copy of just so that you had it um I was asked to just highlight some of the work we've been doing over the last well now it's my sixth year so for the last six years um in literacy at the elementary school just to bring everybody up to date um we have new board members new community members new superintendent um and there's just been a lot of changes and a lot of work being done especially in the area of literacy when it comes to our curriculum and instruction so just to highlight some

028of that work is there a clicker am I asking I'll be your clicker perfect so we updated statement have it but um we can go to the next slide so um just highlighting the work that's been done over the last few years so I presented it in two ways it's pretty much the same information but just in two different uh frames so this is the work in how we did it over the course of five years leading up to this school year because I think it's important to think about the timeline and what was going on in the elementary that led to some of the the work and how it was framed within what was going on in the world and um and just everything else so when I started at the elementary there was

029already a pilot of the TC phonics curriculum underway uh that had been implemented under the previous principle um during that school year we shut down Co was um unfortunately a real uh part of that school year which meant that a lot of our instruction shifted to remote all of our instruction that spring shifted to remote when we started that next school year we had officially adopted the TC phonics curriculum shifting from foundations and we had adopted the uh TC units of study in reading and writing those had been used as the framework but hadn't been adopted by the board until that spring but when we implemented in that fall we weren't allowed to hold small group instruction kids weren't allowed to to be within six feet of each other we weren't allowed to pull kids

030together for academic intervention from comp from alternative home rooms so if Mr MCN was in one home room and Miss copper was in another home room but their skills were similar and I was the reading instructor I couldn't pull you together because if you ended up having covid now I would have to send Mr mcnaull home for 10 days um or 15 or however long it might end up being so we weren't allowed to cross contaminate home rooms so it really was a true uh impediment to our assessment of whether our instructional resources were having an impact on our students whether these resources were um were good resources to have chosen um because our our phonics instruction was TC a good resource or not we were masked we couldn't we could show students how to

031make sounds with their mouths because they could could see our mouths we couldn't see their mouths all of that was um truly difficult for our teachers for our students for our families it was a really difficult time to be uh teaching students to read make sounds or any of that and that was the conditions under which we had adopted a new phonics program we then returned the following year and our teachers were really struggling with what they had been seeing in the classroom really wanted to do better for our students not just because of the curriculum change but because they saw how much students were struggling with reading with where everything had been over the spring of 2020 and then the fall and everything with covid and so our teachers were really motivated to say

032TC and all of that aside is there anything we can do to help our kids make up for all of the impact that we've had over the last year and a half um so many of our teachers then started attending professional development locally and regionally and just doing a lot of their own um Research into what could they do to help our students with reading and they then came and were bringing back those resources through our after school professional development to TurnKey practices they were learning about which is now the science of reading um but at the time the that term wasn't what was being used necessarily uh but they were doing professional development on phic awareness pH iCal awareness bringing back strategies such as the heart word strategy which it's just one particular strategy

033for words that don't follow phonic rules when you have a word that doesn't follow the rule that can't be decoded what are ways that you can teach students to learn that word um and how to incorporate uh decodable texts into instruction so those were being brought back and turn keyed by our um by our teachers here at how we started using uh in hardgrave to work with our teachers um I think I'm not sure actually now that I think about it whether it was that year or the following year but miss uh Megan Hargrave did a professional development on science of reading with our teachers in the fall of 2022 um on what science of reading was telling us was the best practices for our students so at that November 22 um superintendent conference day

034all of our teachers got together and learned about that that together we uh Incorporated decodable texts into our instruction that year and started um phasing out the use of leveled literacy texts when we were using them for direct teaching instruction um shifted away from practices such as 3 queing which the research was really saying was uh some of the most detrimental reading strategies when it came to helping kids learn how to read and continued our work on um professional development for our teachers and then last year our biggest Focus um based on science of reading research was on how we assessed students uh and their reading and how using those assessments could direct our instruction for them and Target our instruction on reading so last year um after the board visit you had asked like

035all right so what are we what are you using all this data on how does it tell you what to do with students in that last year's presentation we had followed a particular student and if we saw what their um their NWA looked like how did we then dig into that and what was the hlp telling us and how could we then follow that student through their progress monitoring and determine whether what we were doing worked or didn't work and what would our steps be so that hlp work was what we really focused on last year 19 of our teachers attended the sun newal uh coursework to get their micr credential in Reading um and our reading League uh we partnered with the reading League to get specific uh professional development on additional um science

036of reading strategies and assessment uh which we've continued to this year so that's sort of our timeline of like how we got here um switch and then this is some of that same information so I'm not going to go into as much detail but why we did some of that I wanted to provide some of the context for what those strategies why we picked those strategies as we went through it so the these are linkable and if that you can dig into this and spend as much or as little time as you want as you want to gain your own knowledge of the science of reading but each of the turquoise ones is clickable so one of the um articles that as I was saying like how do I best help my teachers many of

037my teachers are really motivated and they're bringing me along in this process I'll be honest because you know some of you were on the board when I was hired but some of you were not I was a high school science teach teacher you know my literacy instructional strategies have grown as I've worked with really competent reading teachers along the way and spent a lot of time in primary classrooms watching the amazing things they do that then I've brought home and then worked with my kindergarten and like okay now I can help you read because I lost Katie wild teach kindergarteners how to read and then now my fourth grader is a better reader having sat in many uh primary classrooms but and I got my micro credential in Reading too so um but in reading

038this article on like what are the best ways for leaders to help their building uh embrace the science of reading these are some of the action steps that uh Josh Elder and I said like what are the best things we can do to help bring this along so the first thing was like schooling yourself and making sure that yes Mr Elder and I are making sure we're aware of all the best practices and our teachers are so making sure that we're up toate on the professional development analyzing and adjusting our assessments so that's where that hlp and incorporating the Dibbles and making sure that our assessments we weren't just using those things like the nwaa um which isn't aligned with science reading it's a good piece of information and longevity of the nwaa is beneficial

039and its alignment with the State Testing is beneficial for those measures but it's not as beneficial in telling us whether kids can read and whether our strategies are going to help them learn to read and decode Dibbles is to help us learn why can't they read or why can't they decode these words and how do we help them learn to read the NWA will give us information on Hey where's their comprehension and does it give us a good prediction on how they'll do on the state test and how can we help them with that but that's a different measure so making sure that our assessments also have these other measures for helping them learn how to read which is a critically important skill and making sure that we have those assessments um was a really

040important step for us we the next one um analyzing our curriculum and securing good resources so like when we looked at our academic intervention making sure that when we adopted PF that it was a resource that used explicit phonics instruction that was a um um I'm losing my word but it's well uh it's aligned with science of reading practices and it's well rated within you know the what works clearing house within um within well respected um analytical tools PF is a good resource that we're incorporating resources such as the decodable texts so those are a resource that is um analyzed and shown to have good outcomes for students so making sure that we are incorporating those into our instruction youly hgy hardw strategies those are resources that are shown to really help kids make progress

041so making sure that those are incorporated into our classrooms and then making sure that we're looking at our curricular practices so the reading League uh released a curriculum evaluation tool where you could look at your practices and what it does is it says you know are you doing this in your classroom if you are it's not great and we sat back with each of our grade levels and did an honest reflection on which practices were we still using and the teachers would say oh gosh I actually am still using that we need to work on removing that or oh no we've done a really good job we're not using that we're not using the level text we've done a really good job we've replaced those with decodables or we've done a really good job we've

042REM removed all the lessons that refer to 3 queing and we've switched to heart words or we've switched to breaking down words into syllables I think we've done a really good job of removing that but they were really reflective and then they sat with Megan Hargrave and they said hey here's a spot we don't think we've done a great job here of removing this strategy and we're not sure of what to replace it with that's what we need help with so last year that's what we used our um third set of three professional development days we did the reflection with the curricular um evaluation tool independently um in grade level groups at the superintendent conference day and then they met with Megan and said all right we'd like to go through these that we've flagged

043as our most needy areas can you help us replace the practice and help us direct us to how we do that so we did those at grade levels and then sought the resources to replace those practices redesigning schedules isn't something we've spent a lot of well we spent a lot of time redesigning schedules but not when it came to reading um our schedule has some of the practices that they most recommend um we have 90 minutes dedicated to ELA 45 on paper for writing 45 on paper for reading I'll be honest our teachers sometimes incorporate that in like a Project based approach where sometimes it's you know reading and writing are together or reading and science or together um but we do have time that's um chunked in uh a good amount of time our

044K2 have an additional amount of time for phonics and K through five have the Extended Learning Time block we talked a little bit about that at last year's board meeting also but not everybody was here and I know our community watches as well but that's our time where our teachers can pull together students for targeted intervention it's also our time where our reading Specialists and math Specialists can pull students out if they need extra help without them missing their core instructions so it means that they can get pulled out of the classroom without missing their reading their writing their science their social studies it's a time when their teachers are not doing that initial instruction set aside and then if a student doesn't need to get pulled out for any extra instruction they can be

045doing additional work or passion project or um additional pushing kind of projects um and then providing professional additional professional learning so this year uh in November all of our Co K5 teachers did an additional work um with the reading League who came in and specifically worked on phic awareness and how they can assess students on their ability to um to work on um breaking syllables apart and putting them back together blending them together um and then how to intervene if they assess a student and find that their phic awareness skills are not where they should be so everybody K through actually K through six because Miss McCullum also joined uh in on that professional development um and then Megan Hargrave is coming back uh in the spring in more of a coaching model with our

046teachers um rather than grade level um professional development but more coaching with teachers uh this spring um one one so and then with that we are now moving out of so all with all of this the end result is we know that the resource we have adopted which is the te Teachers College units of study and phonics is not adequate we've done a lot of patching and work and are very confident that our teachers have put together curriculum and instruction that is doing good things for our students but it's because they've done a lot of work to pull out practices that are not adequate and put in practices that are good for kids and that's not sustainable long term and it's leading to choppiness because when you do that the kindergarten is replacing with one

047strategy and then the first grade is replacing with a dis different strategy and you don't end up with a Common Thread that goes through the reason we've done that is because pretty much across the state everyone was using the teacher col unit stad and as we look we um we pulled Regional Schools if you say what are you using and what resources are you thinking about everybody's either in a we're in the middle of searching we're looking we're not sure we just started we are triing this everybody's in a space of patching and so in that we don't want to adopt something and Rush when everybody's adjust like a lot of the Publishers are saying oh we're adjusting we're incorporating you don't want to be adopting something that then is also not adequate or in

048a good place so we've spent this time making sure our teachers know what a good resource would have and having all of them receive the micr credential and really do the research and get a good solid understanding and a really good solid Foundation of what it looks like and what they want those practices to look like like right now they're using the uly phonics and doing a fantastic job teaching phonics with that resource so when they go and they look at a phonics resource they're going to say well I know youly does this really well well maybe we want to adopt youly maybe that's the resource we want or maybe something does it better or maybe something has a reading and writing component and those kinds of strategies Al together in a nice cohesive block

049but at least now we know this does it like this and it works really well for kids and we can then look for well we either want that or we want something that Does It Better whereas if we' started that process two years ago either that there wasn't something that existed or we wouldn't have had the the knowledge to find what would have been good for kids um so now we had a risk resource selection committee we came together the week before Thanksgiving or the the full week before Thanksgiving we came up with the critical questions of what we like about the current resources we've had and the current the current patches that we have so with what we're using for grammar because quite honestly the teachers College writing doesn't have grammar we've been teaching

050grammar the whole time using teacher created resources ofar um so what do we want it to have for grammar instruction what do we want it to have for spelling instruction what do we want it to have for handwriting instruction what would we want it to have for phonics instruction what would we want it to have for Content knowledge building um what would we want all of those things to look at what are we looking for and then a list of resources that are rated well on um Ed uh Ed reports what works Clearing House and rated well by uh surrounding districts that have recently gone through a curricular um search for ELA resources or um the reading league has worked with a few districts recently and gone through a process and said well a few

051districts have selected these couple of resources um to then get samples of those and begin that search process so you can the link there has some of the questions we asked has some of the resources we're looking at um and we're going to be getting we're going to be continuing that search over the next few months I would say there's two camps we may end up in we may end up in an Ela resource for which would be for the reading and the writing and when I say reading I mean more the content reading not the how to read reading so like a reading and a writing resource and then a phonic resource or we may end up with a resource that does all three um and there may be some supplementing that we need

052to do I doubt any of those will incorporate the typing piece so we may end up having to use additional resources to support the typing of writing um or we may end up having to have an additional spelling piece some of them don't incorporate that as well so we may end up get to adopt some minor resources or minor tools that uh support those things it'll depend on which ones we find um you never find a curricular resource that does everything perfectly so it'll be evaluating them and finding the one that we think does the most things really well and then finding some tools to support the things that um we think that we can supplement the best you know like if we find something that does a lot of things really well and then

053we think it needs a tool to support spelling that may be an easy thing to backfill with our you know our knowledge we've been doing it on our own here at howan with an alternative um you know teacher created resources separately during these past units so that's sort of where we are with Ela reading and comments so before we move on to the actual building goals I'll pause there first of all it's very triggering to have to be taken through through the like oh my God I was there for every step of it with like I remember this um I just question about at each at each grade level as you're talking about the teacher selected materials in curricular um there's consistency across the grade level so there an agreement as what at first second

054third fourth grade there's consistency from class to class is what is being delivered so and I would say there's there's consistency even across K5 it's just that when you have when you have the TC units of study let's originally right the resource has a map of when and where and even some language that you use so even if we use the same heart words as an example right so if we say all right because we're not going to use three queing as our way so three queing would say oh um I don't know this word I'm just going it's a book is decodable I can't think of one off the 10 top of my head I'm I'm on the spot but book but I can see he's looking at a book so I'm going to

055guess that it's book because I'm using the picture as a clue to read the word book right so queuing is when you use the other things on the page to read the word instead of decoding the word right heart word is when you say like oh I don't yet know the word that o oh says o so it actually is I'm catching up to myself but I don't know I don't yet know that oo says o so for me I have to memorize that so you'd put a heart under it and you'd memorize that right now I don't know that word that rule so I'm just going to memorize that when I see oo it says o for now later I'll learn the phonics rule for why that is right if we all use heart

056words but we don't have a curricular resource that tells us the exact how and when and where we we do it and what words we we use to explain it to kids even if we're using that same strategy we end up with some inconsistencies and slight differences and so it just doesn't have that Common Thread across the five grades in the same way as when we all have like a manual that we refer to that then we end up with some common language and they hear it the same way and they end up with that building of building blocks across of it so we have a lot of common agreements right now and we have a lot of common professional development it's just more scattered than I think we would all like it to be

057and the the grade levels have a lot of consistency because they have a lot of common planning time they actually have all five days of the week right now for common planning time so they get to get together and talk about it and develop a lot of common lessons um but they don't have it between grade levels so that's hit and miss and they share resources but it the language and the exact way that they talk about it just isn't as cohesive as it could be if you had a common resource that could support that development that does that like you know that we have you know been following this but I find this presentation just to be so interesting because it brings all these little different pieces together and it tells this really important

058story about this long-term investment that the district made in literacy instruction and it brings you know Christine's right she's talked about this in different places along the way but it brings it all together in one cohesive story and to me one of the things that I find really spectacular honestly about this presentation is it gives me a kind of sight into the continuous Improvement that Christine has led as a building leader about something that's so important and how so this this continuous Improvement this is sustained investigation and what really goes into like just really high quality teaching and learning I mean I'll be honest I don't think I think it's rare for us to get such a deep dive um on something but I feel like again early literacy is critically important there was a

059narrative or has been a narrative in the community that this was a place where how had room to improve it's it's a it's a narrative that we wanted to address and I think this presentation goes a really long way to to really showing all the work that's been done at how and um and then you you get this like really beautiful insight into just like all these different pieces and all the thing that Christina is managing and all the how hard are the teachers are working and and really sort of where this this this long longer term investment has brought us I mean I think it's really I'm really appreciative of this presentation and I can't I can't complement our teaching staff enough in that yeah it sounds like yeah they were really you said

060leading me along the way yeah number one there are a number of our teaching staff who really are leading it and number two if they w Wen truly invested in ensuring that these practices were in place each day they would our students wouldn't be making the progress because it truly has been a weeding process of taking the lessons out and replacing them and you know I know John's not here but in honor of John who is no longer with us and Michelle needs to say and how do we know it works that's how do we know it works I don't I don't want to steal Josh's Thunder for next presentation but I did ask his permission um so if we skip to one more Slide the standard for what kids should be able to do

061if you have good reading instruction is they 85% of your students with good tier one instruction should be hitting the 35th percentile or above um in their oral reading fluency so this is the fall winter in Spring oral reading fluency for our students for 23 24 the first time we were able to measure it and assess it so fall winter and spring of last year you don't do an oral reading fluency in kindergarten because they aren't there yet you can do it in the spring and we did do it in the spring but we didn't have the measure when we sent the data off so if you look at Spring grade one 93% of our first graders in the spring had an oral reading fluency above 35% 84 91 86 84 in second grade 96

06290 92 in thir grade 86 88 86 85 80 81 so Josh and I met with the reading League who does all this data said wait should we be concerned about the 81 they said no like these numbers bounc right the that all of your numbers are right around that 85% tells us that your tier one instruction is strong you don't want to focus on any one of the numbers too hard this is one year One Moment One time you'd want to look at this over a couple of years before you focused on any one number you are in a really good place with your tier one instruction your next questions and again I don't want to steal Josh's Thunder for next month but but like you know my next questions are things like okay

063so this is our 35% or above how many are right at 35% how many of our students are at 40% how where can we be pushing you know where are our students excelling then what do we do with our students who are in AIS the kids who aren't hitting 35% what can we do with our tier two and three it doesn't mean we don't have questions it doesn't mean we don't have work that can be done there's always work that can be done we want to be we want to be better than good but it means that the patches and the things that we're doing with our students are good we are doing good work with our reading instruction yes we're going to keep doing more and I hope that a good solid reading resource

064is going to get us to an even better place but we are doing the work with our students just two things Christine um I you know I really do appreciate actually the Deep dive so this is actually really valuable um I like to see that the teachers are incredibly uh flexible and adaptable trying to do everything that they can and you and you perceive within the next year few months you're going to see that Common Thread developed so when we adopted our math resource if I can't remember when you joined us but it took us a year and a half to adopt a math resource and we had a little bit of this conversation when the um when Maggie and Peggy came to visit a lot of that was we came when we got that

065committee together our committee was on very different places because some really liked our previous resource they were looking for some different things we had some different opinions on what would be the best kind of resource and it took us a while to get to some consensus about what we wanted and then to really dig into those resources and figure it out I would say one really good thing about where we are right now with reading is everybody has a really solid common goal for what we want so I don't think it's going to take us very long to um to come to consensus around what we want and which of the resources looks good so I think I think by the end of the year we'll be coming to you with this at least for

066phonics reading and writing I think we may have a little bit longer just because there's a little bit more like what kind of content reading do we want kids to have with a writing resource that's doing well what do we want to do with spelling and grammar that might take a little bit longer but at least for phonics and then I think we'll have we'll be developing a really good Common Thread K2 for phonic initial early literacy instruction and I think that would be a really good place to be in for the end of the year and then we can build the core Ela instruction sure and then on this data and you don't want to do too much focusing on it but that grade five would have been uh Co year grade two three

067right so that grade five is our current six that yes so that's that's the same age as my daughter so they would have been they would have yeah they would have been uh they would have gone out in first and been in yeah um so they're very full Co in second yes those are very foundational years so for reading so recognizing that me you're still these are still you know positive yeah exactly and I just and just to tie this back to and 81 is still not oh yeah no no yeah right right because tying this back right to Mt the right so the district's efforts towards multi-tiered systems of support right I mean just you know that's that's really what we're talking about here right that's really this what you know Christina is really

068making this really important point that you know the the the the instruction that we're doing is is really getting a high percentage of the kids you know getting yeah and I don't want to focus on anyone cohort but you know that grade level we have a special class reading cohort we have like so we have other things for a cohort to for the 20% that aren't that D that would just drive your you know your tiered support to to structure that that's all so then your and your team is looking at you know how they and sounds fantastic because it you know they're actively engaging in trying to do as many different things as they can to encourage children to read and you know instead of like and also the idea of like let's not

069adopt you know a curriculum too early right where people are kind of like building the bridge while they're Crossing it so probably a wise decision um hind sight I mean I sort of regret I think that's a little bit what TC phonics was hindsight's 2020 but the initial criticisms for the TC units of study for reading and writing were that there was an explicit phonic phonics instruction so then TC phonics came out a lot of districts quickly adopted TC phonics to fill that Gap well I mean yeah they have they have a product that they they ship out you know I mean they try to hit it but um but great you know you you've invested in the district has invested in the people right that do that actually do the significant amount of work

070so thank you all right I don't we'll see some of the others maybe won't take as long but the official goals are goal One support the bond referendum I think you guys are pretty up to date on that don't think you have a lot of questions and Christine was had a lot of different me so my goal was to support that work did I went to the q&as went to PTA events participated in tours put out information in the newsletters provided information to staff um I'm part of the I'm leading the steam room uh small group selfishly I was a science teacher that's a fun group to lead for me I'm going to be a member of the support staff room but um Dr silk is going to be the lead facilitator of that one

071since she's going to be in the main office so I'll be a participant in that but I'm going to lead facilitating the steam room ah cool conversation so that'll be our next steps and I'm sure all of you will be part of that work at different parts so I'll keep that one brief goal two is continuing our work on the use of data including the holay learner profile and intervention so that includes that work on Dibbles and literacy that we just talked about so I'm not going to go into that as much but an interesting part of that is Shifting it from being the how literacy profile that we have talked about to being the housing learner profile and some of the work we're doing right now is trialing some number sense screeners and the

072acadians math probes with our students they uh in the past one of the things we haven't had as much of are normed math assessments we have the NWA we have the state test data we have classroom Assessments in math but there are fewer um normed math pieces so there's some of the things like students should be able to to able to do within math can do they just count on or can they um do they count up or can they count on meaning can do you have to start at zero and count up 0 One Two Three or can you put three in your head and then count on um can you do doubles can you uh can you you know count by threes can you do those things so there's those sorts of screen

073that you can do with children in the aadience math probes test their number sense to see where some of their gaps within math are in similar ways to where the dibles test their phic awareness so um we're trialing some of those and then seeing how they line up with some of our grade level standards to see how they give us information on students and their math abilities relative to what we're assessing um in different grade levels to see what we might use to um determine whether a student needs additional help in math um and then we would add those so with within like if you look at our old mtss plan it says you know these are entry and exit criteria using nwaa and using the state test data we're looking to add things from

074our HP in math and Ela so that we have a more comprehensive entry and exit criteria doesn't just look at those pieces so grade level assessments and benchmarks would be used um for both math and Ela and then we would update the mtss plan with all of that information so more to come so right now we're trialing them just to see we haven't used them before so we want to make sure you know do they give us information that aligns with what we would see in the classroom and what we get from our kids so that's that you said um that the data help to um identify students who need extra help what about identifying kids who are a little bit more advanced and um meeting their needs so the math probes they dig into

075what their number sense is on grade level I haven't I haven't given the math probes myself so the only way I've heard them used is to see whether their number sense is developing appropriately or not so I'm not sure that these would do that um they might I'd have to look I don't know that they would give us that those particular screeners would give that information um the NWA and the KH Academy do give us that information so we use uh the KH Academy and the maps accelerator So within M within the nwaa it tells us what student should be learning next and the maps accelerator ties into KH Academy which is leveled soent get something right it pushes them on to the next skill um we've had a couple of teachers say that that

076can be frustrating because some of those next skills you need a little bit of instruction like it doesn't just you don't just jump into some of those higher levels of math without a little bit of instruction on how to approach a problem um so when they when they just get it on the computer without some instruction on how to approach it can be a little bit of a a frustrating experience when it's independent work um but they do get uh some time on more challenging problems there and what our teachers have done is when the kids come then they use elt to say okay let's let's take a step back that thing that was frustrating you on Independent work this is how you do it and using elt that way but I don't know that

077that those probes would be the appropriate CL thanks goal three this one might have some questions is planning and preparing for the isan prek and transition of fifth grade so for fifth grade uh Mary an and Julia and I have been collaborating on the schedule um and just looking at how we can move fifth grade to the Middle School the moving the fifth grade to the middle school isn't directly a me project and that that's making the secondary schedule for them to arrive but wherever I can help them I'm helping so we've been looking at the cafeteria you I mean that continues to be the the tricky part of it so we're just looking at different ways we can schedule um middle school and high school for lunch so we're we're trialing a few different

078things and just playing with it we're going to reconvene the master scheduling committee and just uh have them reflect on the changes we made for this year there are some things that I'm sure people like and as always I'm sure there's some things that they don't so if there are any of the things that they didn't are they things that we can fix or not um we'll look at that uh we're also going to be meeting with the fourth grade uh to just think about what we need to do with the fourth graders next year to prepare them to enter the Middle School the following year so as you know our current fifth grade is departmentalized do we want to incorporate any departmentalization into fourth grade do we want to do that the whole year

079would we want to do that just in the spring um you know some discussions around switching classes and transitioning um so we're going to be having those discussions uh in the next few months to think about what we would want that to look like there are while we still have the fifth grade there are some staffing challenges to departmentalizing fourth grade um but we'll look at that and see I think there's probably some benefit to doing some of it but we'll be working with that um um in the fourth grade and then next year obviously we'll need to have two graduation ceremonies two sets of culminating events you know two sets of field trips that sort of thing so that they all have a culminating Elementary experience okay uh so Carl um Katherine and I

080met with the office of early learning we have a request for proposal to meet with to be sent out to Community Partners we were just talking about timing earlier today so whether we send that out just before the holiday holidays but give them a longer amount of time uh to complete it or we just wait and send it out after the holidays but either way it's probably going to be due the end of January beginning of February so the state requires us to reach out to Community Partners even though we're opening a prek here um we have to attempt to work with a community partner for 10% of our slots so our maximum number of slots is 42 so our 10% slot is four or five students so we have to attempt to find four

081or five seats for kids in a community- based organization and the idea of that is that we won't have before or after school care here so attempting to find somewhere that has four or five seats would allow somebody who needs before or after school care to enroll their child in a community based pre school that has before or after school care where they could have upk there and that family would pay for before or after school care but they would receive upk for free through the district we may not find we had didn't have anybody who took us up on upk the last time but we were looking for a full classroom the last time we may find somebody who is willing to offer us a couple of seats we may not but we're at

082least going to make the required attempt if we don't find anybody then we can petition the state for a waiver which means we tried we did a you know we we did a um a true search we made a what's the word RFP yeah well we did a a full faith effort to to uh to make a partnership um so we'll reach out it doesn't have to be within the district so there are um Community Based organizations in Beacon who have partnered with the beacon schools they may be willing to give us four or five seats you know the parents would provide the transportation so um they may be willing to we reach out so that RFP will go out to the Cold Spring um Community Based preschools The Garrison Community Based preschools The Beacon

083Community Based preschools and we'll also put an ad in the newspaper and publish it on the website in case there's anybody regionally that we haven't thought of who's interested and sees it and wants to apply um again if nobody's interested we'll put in for the waiver uh we' started going on school visits to some Regional prek programs just to see what they have and look for ideas for our own program we're selecting curriculum to offer an hour program I'm working on the budget Furniture curriculum resources uh we're going to put out the advertisement to families for registration with the print kindergarten registration so that usually is in the beginning of January so we'll put that in the newspaper and on the website and on Facebook page that says kindergarten registration is opening and so is

084prek registration um in February we'll have the kindergarten family information night we'll also have a prek family information night um that first information night will be about how it will work so upk is a lottery we will have more students eligible for upk than we will have seats we will only have 18 seats so let's say 30 30 families register for pre we will then by random Lottery choose 18 students who will be able to participate we'll choose all 30 in order so we'll have slot one through 30 um and then the remaining families would be on a wait list in order it's a totally blind lottery so we can't look at need we can't look at special education we can't look at anything it's just totally blind no sibling preference no pres no pres

085um later in the year once we know who's been selected for the program then we would do a family orientation of like hey this is what the day looks like meet the teacher here's the classroom come see the program uh we would do student screenings like we do kindergarten screenings and then we'll complete the St State application to say hey please let us have a PK program in the summer which which is weird that's how that works but they told us they don't say no once we complete the application so that's prek what are the do the age the age requirements basically the same they have to be four by December 1st December 1 yeah so for kindergarten they have to be five by December 1st for prek they have to be four by December

0861st so if it's only if it's 10% who can go to another Community Based preschool but there's only 18 seats why why would it be four or five kids funding for up to four oh it's funding based okay so we only have Spa we don't have room or the ability to really have two classrooms here theoretically yeah if another if a community based organization said hey we want to offer you a whole classroom of 18 kids they could they just didn't last time so I don't anticipate that we will get that but hypothetically uh preschool Q says yes we want to offer you 18 slots we could be running a class of 18 here and a class of 18 there and that would be great then we would have plenty of seats but I don't

087I just don't need I'll cross my fingers but what I'm really hoping for is someone to have four or five slots and it could be a couple places somebody could offer us two and someplace else could offer us too okay and that's allowed to it would be more difficult to manage if a place offered us one another place offered us one another place offer us because we're required to work with their teachers and have them come to professional development do for sites at visits do observations and that means that then I'm going to observe for different classrooms for different like that's that's a lot but if we had two and two you know that's something I wouldn't not consider it'd be more to manage but um it'd be possible and if those if those places

088placements were offered up that's also through lottery or right so to say yeah so you would register and you could say I'm registering my child for preschool I'm only interested in helping and then Michelle P off register she said I'm only interested in nest and then um then if I said you could have just nope I can't do it because I need before or after school so for myself when I registered my my daughter did upk at Deacon I couldn't have her do the school based program at the time it was only half day they didn't have transportation I couldn't very well leave howan drive to Beacon pick her up at noon time and then drive her to daycare that wouldn't have worked so I said I can only have her go if she gets

089the spot at the community based organization um which she got um but if she'd gotten a school-based spot I wouldn't have been able to do it so we may have families that are in either of those like we might have a family that's only willing to take a hallan spot we might have a family that's only willing to take up Community Based spot right and does the state offer like an instrument for what that Lottery should be in how like or they just say it has to be totally random I mean there's random yeah yeah name generators there's hat if I could just add just to manage expectations we only can offer partner preschool programs $5,400 per student right it's highly unlikely if I believe many of our local programs have waiting lists and if

090they're charging 12 or 14 15,000 I think that's typically the range it's very unlikely that they're going to pass up on someone who's willing to pay 12,000 to take a student for 5,400 so we must make an good faith effort to partner but it's unlikely that someone will take us up on the offer just just be clear I mean those of us who on the board when I actually don't know how much we talked about in board meetings how much we talked about intended meetings but like pristine already has made valant valant valant efforts for years to try and take advantage of this this upk funding that's been we put the RFP three times before this again looking for 18 slots yeah yeah so maybe this will be different so we'll see yeah and we

091didn't we didn't open it up regionally before which is the only thing that makes me a little more hopeful yeah let see but yeah not for L try you haven't been I think that's oh just just uh for any families that are watching or looking at this later just what they could expect the family information night we have set for February 12th that's just a where they can ask questions about like the lottery the process what that would look like we expect registration to open up in February the lottery would be around March or April um and then weight list notification would be rolling after that you know the anybody who was registered early and right then when they got picked we'd say oh you're on the wait list but if they registered in August

092they could register and they on the late list and we would keep it open that's done thank you thank you thank you great thank you so much of course it's a lot of things I'm sorry good stuff all right um so we're now um at the opportunity for the the the first uh communication from the public the Hing Board of Education desires and Vues input from the entire School Community this first public comment session is reserved for comments on any special presentations or active agenda items for those who wish to address the board we'd ask you to sign in and state your name for the record um although I'll read the whole thing uh we'd ask you to keep your remarks with three minutes or less disparaging remarks and discussion of District person Personnel strongly

093discouraged and while we do not engage in dialogue we want you know that we're listening all right so next we have our information reports that we will be on our my God January 2025 this meeting agenda um and so uh next then is consent agenda minutes this is the minutes for both our uh uh November 19th meeting as well as our exact session um minute so um may I have a motion please some moved second it all those in favor any opposed next we have committee minutes so committees from the Comm from the district and uh the wellness team um actually Carl it looks like the wellness committee is thinking about maybe wanting to change their charge and so I guess we'll just have to see I assume somebody will want to come and talk

094to us about that yes I know this is picking up on the conversations they had last year so really appreciate both committees um moving into consent agenda I just wanted to comment one thing yeah I noted um and one of the uh treasure rep the um budget transfer had 11 well it had 11 it it connects there was $1,000 that was moved to signage and I was like I was going to ask Katherine about it but then when I read minutes from the safety meeting I realized that it was all towards um like emergency responders saying that sometimes when they arrived on campus they did not know where to go and so that is what I'm guessing the money is going toward is better signage for emergency responders or is it just better signage all

095through campus for everybody it's an expansion of those you know a year ago maybe we got those blue signs the blue bigger directional of those fill of the gaps um particularly you know the back entrance of Cedar Street and what you can access from where and the fact that there's you don't access the athletic fields you know I think for as small as we are it's still a kind of confusing campus uh so it's expanding on those signs and then it's also some signage that is um campus rules for lack of a better word what permitted and what's not permitted on campus that's that signed it's interesting because the signs took a really long time to be made but they really recognize and this is something I think Phil did Capital reference yeah yeah it

096was so important it's really important right like what's the main building what's you know like things people just aren't gonna know anyway thanks kind of fit together nicely so I was like oh that's I like that um consent agenda Financial we have a motion please so moved second all those in favor I any opposed consent agenda Personnel have a motion please so move second um I don't think there's anything we need to okay I'm gonna say one thing about this so anyway H it's always so exciting to see our students come back and work in our district and I don't always recognize the name but Abby sto went was in Pet's grade so I was just like it's just so it's so great and it happens a lot you know see back are you talking

097about Abby St yeah she's also always that she's coaching the JB girls yeah yeah no that's really it's it is so you know you notice it when you really recognize the name it's great to see kids come back including [Laughter] talk about no just about the payroll oh good sure I might have it Ju Just A Brief comment um you do have uh on the agenda a recommendation to appoint a payroll clerk first I want to compliment Katherine Platt and and Josh Elder for having an ongoing search as a very difficult position to fill uh they did interviewing for two months straight uh met many people and and a lot of qualified people but we really think Christine Fury is is is a good fit for us she a great resume yes um she has

098experience it's it's at a municipality not particularly a school there's a bit of a learning curve but I think it's also worth mentioning that Katherine Platt really has held this together uh I I met with our Teachers Association earlier this afternoon and pay payroll has been almost Flawless so we do have some support from from aose payroll expert consultant but really during the days Katherine has been managing this in addition to everything else and she's done a fantastic job and and was willing to continue to do it to find the right person and and I really respect that so I just want to publicly thank her and in front of the board recognize that that she's really bridged us and and and done a fantastic job so now we have a a transition plan with

099the incoming payroll clerk Katherine will work with her bosies will continue to work with her for a couple of pay cycles and we think she's going to do really well great thank you for making that note yeah that's fantastic um so all those in favor I any opposed uh so new business moving on to the csse CPS recommendations maybe have a recommended action please it resolved that upon the recommendation of the interim superintend attendant of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the recommendations of the Committees on special education and preschool special education as presented uh may I have a motion please so moved second all those in favor I any opposed so the next item is just a superintendent search update um the board is actually going to go into executive session at the

100end of the meeting to talk more in detail about the timeline and next steps but as we promis the community um last spring when Dr bante um moved on to a new role uh we the board was committed to making it through the capital Bond referendum we made it through the the referendum successfully uh we met in Retreat um the Friday before Thanksgiving um and uh decided to use pnw bosies as our uh search consultant um and so we are already our I'm actually sort of working with a hem behind the scenes right now putting together a timeline um and uh the community can expect to uh learn more about the the timeline and next steps um before we go on winter break and just to give the community a heads up there will be

101lots of opportunities um to be providing um input into what the community and the district is looking for and our next superintendent um come January when one of the things p&w Bose's does for us is lead a number of focus groups as well as puts out a survey um and as we are committed to doing really would like to hear far and wide what people are are hoping uh to see so I don't have the exact times but that's really what's What's um what what is ahead of us um again all with the intention of um uh identifying a candidate some on the spring and then having that person uh join the district um on July 1st of 2021 right look you'll hear more about that um so second opportunity for communication from the public

102um board Reflections I'm sure the Carl might bring it up at the end or you might that this weekend is the production of MC Beth on both Friday and Saturday you can see two ways is two different experiences with two different Lady M and Mr M but if you can make it please do I think it's going to be great and I unfortunately am going to be away but if we're moving into our our winter concerts I mean so many really nice things happen in December so it's a great way to bring that to an end any other board yeah I just wanted to um thank Christine again for um allowing Peggy and I to come in and see some of this science of reading and you know I just for those of us who

103aren't involved you know intricately in education it was really fascinating to see the kids work on Phonics I got to go into three different classrooms two first grade classrooms and a kindergarten classroom and um you know teachers all did things a little differently but it was all all connected and I saw you know two small group um instructions and one first grade costumes where they were using manipulatives to like not necessarily count out the letters but I mean it was fascinating that you know this is how kids are are learning to read with with buttons um and then one of the kindergarten teachers you know was using her arm to tap out the sounds and it's just the kids seemed really engaged maybe it was just a few minutes that we were in there but

104it was really um it's exciting to see you know so thank you yeah yeah I mean one of my favorite things to see is a child who is really learning like really applying what she's learning how to read and decoding and I got to see that and something that I saw and it's really it's um it was it was really clear um how hard everybody um was working and it's always a real F to get to be in the schools um anything else obana all right um so I'm going to make a motion to adjourn into executive session uh to discuss matters leading to the appointment of a particular person I have a second second all those in favor any

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.