CorpusRecord 140266

Haldane Board of Education - December 17, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Haldane BOE
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Putnam County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,103 words · about 79 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay welcome to the December 17th hdan Board of Education Workshop meeting please stand for the pledge of the United States of America and to the repic for stands one nation God indivisible with liy and Justice all vice president Valentine here truste clemenson here truste cupper here trusty mcau here and uh president Clemens is excused for the evening um approval of the agenda I need to make a motion to amend the agenda to add a short executive session to the end of the meeting to discuss um the hiring of a certain individual we have a motion sove second um do I have to have the recommended action for that I will yes be it resolved that upon the recommendation of the interim superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the amended agenda great all

002in favor I I I any oppos great so the next meeting of the howan board of education is a business meeting it'll be held on Tuesday January 7th 2025 at 7.m here in the Middle High School library um yes and I just wanted to uh say welcome it's the December Crush I don't know if anyone else is feeling the crunch of of all the things that are happening um we just came off of was it two weekends ago the um Hing High School production of MC Beth which I heard was Stellar um with the two casts uh basketball season is in full swing I think calan has five teams and then one shared modified team with Garrison um and it is concert season as well so we had the high school and middle school last

003week tomorrow night is the elementary school concert at 7 um and I'm always amazed we talk about this I feel like all the time but I'm always amazed at at what the teachers what our music teachers and our music staff can um pull out of our kids so it's amazing to me so congratulations to that um Mr Alano sure first I just want to wish everyone a joyful holiday happy and healthy New Year to the board and Community um I also had the the privilege of attending MC Beth as well as the middle and high school concerts and and I will say all three were were magnificent I I heard of how dain's Performing Arts reputation for many years while I was serving down in Garrison uh but I never never got the opportunity to

004to actually enjoy a performance firsthand and and let me just uh give a shout out to all the people who who made it possible uh certainly our director Marthur mikos mikakos I believe I have it right Dan mcgard uh who oversees our our music department department chair um Jessica Stein music and band teacher Sam sour music and chorus um and Eric star who I believe was with alane and now has come back to lead the uh jazz band and I will say you know particularly the high school performance I mean it ended with a standing ovation and I've been to many many music concerts and schools over the years and and it's hard to receive a standing ovation but it was genuine uh it was electrifying um you know I think the last song I

005wrote it down was Louis Prima sing sing sing I mean just what a incredible performance so thoroughly enjoyed it congratulations to all the students who who participated and all the people who worked so hard to put that together now just getting onto some education business uh I'm going to ask Michelle to help me um last week Michelle and I attended uh commissioner Betty Rosa um held a town hall meeting in our region she invited many officials she was here with our top officials from State Ed Dana lenberg was there our State Assembly woman Shelley mayor who's a state senator and also the uh head of the education committee uh and many other people from State Ed and then board members and superintendents from throughout this region from probably four or five different counties so it

006was well attended hosted by bosis and there are some really uh important initiatives that that the commissioner joined us to to let us know and Michelle took diligent notes much better than than I did so Michelle would you share some of the happy to share some of the notes I took so the main two topics that were discussed at the Town Hall were regionalization and the new graduation requirements um certainly regionalization got most of the air time uh it's on everybody's mind uh the chancellor wanted to clarify that participation in this process of regionalization is not mandatory we were told what is mandatory or what they are mandating is a conversation about it um do we want to do it do we want to participate or do we will we choose not to um they

007moved the due date for the strengths and needs survey uh to middle of January January 15th and I think Carl is Mr arbano has started working on that um we were highly encouraged to participate uh they sort of framed it as what is your school doing that's creative and Innovative here is what we would do here's what we could do if we had the resources and the pathway um so it's our opportunity to highlight our school to Albany they're Gathering ideas from the field and they couched it um as a chance to kind of ask for things what does our district need to think big in our working with other local schools and kind of make our as what could what do we need to make our aspirations a reality um they were for example

008they talked about would we be interested in our having our high schoolers participate in internships and Healthcare might we be interested in having our high schoolers participate in internships in New York City kind of would we be working with other locals schools and maybe making something like that a reality those were just a couple examples they address concerns about local control um and how there will not be a loss of local control really um focused on this is not a consolidation effort this is not a merging effort it's not about the state looking for ways to reduce Foundation Aid which was a concern expressed by some of the school leaders there um the data from the needs and strength survey will be compiled um submitting it uh commits us to nothing just because we write

009these ideas down and submit it doesn't mean that then we have to follow up and do them it just will allow an overarching look at how the schools can better collaborate um so that's regionalization uh also graduation requirements the new grad requirements were talked about still very much in the early days um Dr Rosa talked about the fact that it was really born from the concept that um application of skills in the real world um may be much more indicative of Readiness to graduate than a test score she said you know teachers talk all the time about you know how they're you know working on Project based learning um integration across subject areas and across grade levels and none of that really matters at the end of the day when it boils down to uh

010passing the region um certainly there's concern there was concern expressed about the standardization you know are will will we have a menu to choose from how will colleges know you know if each school is kind of putting together these different graduation requirements and you know kind of looking at the you know profile of a Learner in a different way how will colleges have a sense of you know what is a student coming out of hellane how does a student compare to students coming out of other schools um Dr Rosa said you know there's already many uh courses that are required for graduation that have local assessments not standardized ones so she said you know it's kind of doing the same thing um and it sounds like they might be considering um kind of sharing rubrics

011but the way that the goals are met and the assessments that are created might be local so again this is like in the early stages um uh in development and the last thing that I thought was interesting that she talked about was this uh teach.org um apparently there's a website uh and I guess different states are taking it on there's uh teach neww york.org which is an online certification process for teachers and um we were told that there's more students enrolled in that than in teacher prep programs at colleges and that it's something so it's really meeting a need there's also a much more diverse population of students enrolled so it's really it's like this um a huge like teacher prep program and she talked about maybe developing some Regional initiatives to establish it as

012a teacher Ed program that students maybe even in middle school and high school can start kind of thinking about if they're interested in going into the field of education and you know kind of how can teach new york.org kind of be you know um incorporated into middle school or High School curriculum um for blossoming teachers so we were um you know and to make kids aware and to encourage them um uh to go into education as a career choice so those are my notes I don't know if you have anything you want to add on to that that was incredibly thorough Michelle Ju I'll just add a couple of things um this uh teach.org program that she referred to um is really a response to listening to to uh leaders throughout the the state and

013and there there are real teacher shortages not just in New York but Nationwide but particularly in New York there are certain subject areas special education uh foreign languages The Sciences mathematics where we're seeing the pools really shrink and and it's harder and harder to find young people who want to pursue this as as a career so in response to that uh they launched this initiative and I I was pleased to hear that you know enrollment is increasing and and it's being able to attract some some young people into the field because that really is very needed with regards to the graduation requirements just to put it in perspective uh looking at the time frame the current and Julia helped me with this if I get it wrong because I know Miss M sniffin has been

014working and and also sharing information with the High School faculty but the current ninth graders cohort of 2024 will be the first that will not need regions exams to graduate although they will take regions exams it's actually 2026 2027 cohort so freshmen in the 26 27 school year won't be required to take region exams towards graduation it doesn't mean yet that they're totally gone because Essa which is Federal Regulation may still require us to have a standardized measure to receive federal funding so they 2627 cohort which would mean incoming freshman that year will not need to take Regent exam towards graduation requirement so they will be under the new credit they will be under the new criteria or you know standard whatever that exactly looks like yet to be determined they're talking a lot about

015um a consumer type mathematics component and an environmental component in addition to the seals which we already have established but it's still great thank you thank you so the board will hear I'm sure many more updates in the months and and years ahead uh also um Michelle uh for clarification Josh Elder is doing the bulk of the regionalization data collection and and I I offered him today help uh but um he he he really is running with this and um again I I think they it was wise for the commissioner and the state to postpone the deadline uh within the lower Hudson uh region the superintendent did have some concern uh our superintendent Group found some language that uh was really not well known but in the state Register there was language that indicated that

016Bose's District superintendents do have the authority to have districts share um that language has since been changed because when when we discovered that language people thought well gee you it was rolled out rather quickly and we were concerned about Foundation Aid uh seems like the governor um is is signaling that she will not pull back on on Foundation 8 at least this this year um and it is an election year um so you know your constituents and and and you know people lobbying uh do do matter they they listen to those voices so the regionalization um I was pleased when I saw the commissioner give reassurances change that language and give reassurances that districts will not be forced to share resources or to partner with other districts now hdan has many many Partnerships and and

017they date back decades you know whether it's Sports mergers our students to uh OED programs at bosis Partnerships with other districts for various things so I think we do a good job of sharing resources our partnership with Garrison the board and I thank you we all visited Garrison and miss sniffin and and Dr cashion and um Tom Cunningham presented on on our high school program and we received a lovely letter from from the the new superintendent there how much they appreciated us us you know sharing all all the great stuff that's happened here so we do I think an awfully good job of sharing um but as Michelle said I see no downside because this evening you don't have to take a formal vote but I would like to pull the four of you I've

018already spoken to Peggy and if you are in agreement unless you're opposed to this we'll move forward uh Josh will enter uh all the data they want to know everything about us our programs courses um you know extracurricular programs athletic programs everything is going to get entered uh student performance data and then sent up to New York State and then in the months ahead they will be looking at opportunities uh with districts in our area so again with assurances that there's going to be no forced collaboration or sharing um I just want to make sure that the board is comfortable with us moving forward and being part of the regionalization a handful of schools are not and their boards have decided not to participate but I would say that's maybe 5% of the schools in

019our area any thoughts or any questions from the board members do you need to know now can we let you know at the next board meeting absolutely we kind of St with it and that is that all right with everybody sure yeah it sounds good any any questions um for Michelle or me okay all right well we'll you know if we get any more information we're happy to share more and we we can make an in the meantime Josh will continue working because there's an awful lot of of work to and and and with the anticipation that we will move forward but we'll we'll revisit this at our first January meeting yeah okay I'll add it to the agenda for that one thank you cther okay thank you that's all I have okay thanks um

020I'm turning it over to is it Deputy to or Mrs jamm Jam who wants to recognize an exceptional High School students best kind of news right so a lot of times I speak more informally but I'm going to actually read the formal document that I wrote this evening for Parker Parker come on up here take off your [Music] coat your parents this is their chance to be really proud of you come stand here I get to be proud of you too so September 20th one of our elementary students misunderstood his family's instructions for getting home after school after being dismissed as a walker he got turned around and he became quite lost and aside very lost had his mom gotten to school later and said where's my child we would have had no idea of

021where to even start looking for him he didn't have cell phone or any way to contact his parents luckily for him Parker was walking in the area many people could have passed this child by not because they're unkind or uncaring but because they're busy or distracted they have electronics and schedules that pull them in many different directions however Parker noticed whether because he has a young sister about this age his exceptional character or his caring Spirit or a combination of all three something made Parker stop and take notice of the child and that something was out of place he wasn't able to help him find his way home because he didn't recognize the address but with quick thinking and problem solving Parker called the elementary school and got in touch with me he explained who

022he had found where he was and that he was concerned that the child was too far from home and needed help he agreed to stay with him until I could get there when I arrived the child was calm and smiling not at all what I expected given the circumstances this told me that Parker had been been reassuring protective and kind while he stayed with the child this act reflects the highest ideals and responsibilities of citizenship including compassion for others commitment to community welfare proactive problem solving and dedication to helping those need Parker's actions serve as an example to his peers and show that he serves as a role model to younger students of our community so there are is AR Toby I was just in charge of keeping them flat these are letters for me

023get two copies one for each of your parents to frame and embarrass you with forever and then take a picture from there but thank you very much I don't know where he would be so thank you for all the work you do uh now we have two more exceptional high school students here to give us um an update the high school our student advisers um William moara and Z delosa hey guys hello everyone we are the President and Vice President of the junior class um student uh student council so we're here just to present on what's been going on in school all right so to start off um I'm going to talk about the science Bowl so we've had four students um Seth Lunen pack Max cupper your son um and Lincoln Way have signed

024up for a science bow that will take place in March of 2025 and this group is led by our earth science teacher Mr posc and this contest teams will answer questions to compete in that competition hopefully hopefully win so now moving on the international Club will be doing a fundraiser um they will be selling candy canes and po SATA bracelets on Wednesday December 18th in the high school Lobby the candy cane sales will benefit do will benefit Doctors Without boing Doctors Without Borders is a non-governmental charity that provides Medical Care mainly to conflict zones and countries affected by endemic diseases and private donors account for 90% of their funding so it is important um the pulera sale will continue on Thursday December 19th paa project is a fair trade nonprofit organization that educates empowers and

025connects Central American artists with students in more than 3,800 us schools by selling colorful hand open bracelets all right so moving on recently we had a visit of Garrison students to H just um eighth graders that weren were deciding on whether to go to here or O'Neal or an alternate High School um that was on November 6 there were 29 students that came and toward the high school tomorrow um we will have eight students um toward the school and they will Shadow freshman uh for half the day just to see what it's like and how to get a feel of like what it's like to be at how um and also um soon January 16th we'll have a Bose Tech tour for the sophomore class so they can they have the um like ability to

026see and explore alternate education options for high school and so they don't have to just um use class that how they now um one thing that the teachers have been doing this week is um secretly participating in their own Spirit Week oh Monday was Lumberjack Chic Tuesday today was blizzard day where blue and white gear tomorrow will be dressed like a student day I'm excited for that one Thursday will be anything but a cup so you can drink out of anything but a cup as Friday will be tacky festive we um so like Mr Albano said we recently had a successful play MC Beth um on December 6th and December 7th that's the Friday and Saturday of two weeks ago um lead roles were played by um freshman through seniors um with Juniors lucky Bell

027and Merck Williams playing the lead role of MC Beth and seniors Sophie couch and Helen hudon playing the lead role of Lady McBeth on their respective nights and then a word of thanks to Martha MOS and Andre Andrea mchu for directing the successful play now for chorus and music we want to congratulate Oliver pekis Andia star for their selection and participation in the New York State School Music Association conference all state Oliver participated in the mixed course and deia received the young composers Award with the performance of her piano piece and participation in composers Workshop shs lastly we want to congratulate numerous students who participated in the area all state Music Festival on November 23rd that's it that's all we got thank you very much for your time question okay questions oh there's always questions

028it's not a freebie you know you don't just get up there and just read off paper um yeah I am curious do you guys read read Shakespeare in English class at at Hing so each year the sophomore class reads MC Beth towards the end of the year um that's English honors read it towards the end of the year and uh region English read it towards the beginning of the year so um sophomore grade and above kind of has a background of what's going on so they have a good background also the teachers before the play went had a little like um catch up on what happened in mcth and like what's going on and just so kids understood the pl because obviously Old English is a little hard to understand but right Juni um freshman

029read Romeo Juliet Rome Julet read and then the juniors in honors yeah all good great thank you any other questions do you happen to know um for the sophomore trip to Bose is that the for the whole 10th grade class or do you have to sign up to go um it's only you you can you have to sign up if you chooseable to everyone sophomore class but yeah you have to sign up to be able to go only if you're interested okay thanks what could you I wanted to ask about the science bow where it's where it's located and if you do anything about it I'm not sure where it's located I know it's taking place in March so there's ways to go till then um still plenty of time to sign up for kids

030I might even take that I'm not sure do it they might need some more students for the team so yeah um I'm not sure where it takes place um but yeah it's just it's kind of like a decathlon for Science and Mathematics um and like a range of like all sciences and Mathematics is it a is it a program that we typically participated in or is it this is relatively new I think this might actually be the first year Seth lenac and Mr posc kind of started like a club that um students can join they have meetings every Tuesday about like practicing for the competion Earth sence yeah it's got wide thanks any other questions good thank you very much coming in thanks for coming in all right um and now we have right um

031this is our required annual presentation it's our Workshop topic for tonight our required annual presentation on state assessment data with our director of curriculum Josh thank you move out of the way relocate here good evening Board of Ed thank you so much for the opportunity um to talk to you tonight about our 20234 New York State assessment results um and um I thought it was very timely to go off trustee covers talks about the new graduation Pathways and the concept around uh all these really great Project based warning experiences that are happening combined with or coupled against um the current measures that are used to assess students in New York state and uh it is good news to hear that they've at least recognized that there seems to be a disparity between the two at

032times and to recognize that uh intelligence takes multiple forms and that there are other Pathways for students to achieve uh and to demonstrate proficiency against these standards other than standardized ways um but that being said I am here to talk about all the standardized ways New York state currently Contin to go through and does this and so you know from a higher perspective I continue to share this here in h when we talk about assessments we are grounded in conversations around how do we assess what we value and this community uh of Learners has come together and articulate um these six heldane Essentials which um since my time here in heldane coming in my fourth year uh represents um our learner profile before learner profiles um about what this Community Values as students graduate and

033go through the helding Central School District um critical thinking problem solving communication growth mindset emotional intelligence and wellness um I would say that the New York State assessments um tackle some of these at times right there there is some validity to that um and I think that there are also aspects of this that we see gaps uh in that but that is our our local decisions of how we go through that um it's another good reminder around curriculum development how uh in New York state we all have common standards to achieve but the methods in which students go about achieving those standards is differentiated based upon the values of the district in which they live in um that's why you go to heldane or you could go to Beacon or you go to Harrison and

034you can see these implemented in very different ways at times u based upon some of the um values that the communities have put forth um as I kind of also get into this idea around data um one of the things that I would like to share with the board uh this is a goal that's been developed over the last couple of years with our administrative team um and it represents kind of a consensus approach for how we want to enter into conversations around using different aspects of data um whether a district level grade level building level or or individual class SI or individual classes and so the goal is the continued development of a systematic approach to integrating data that complements our processes for supporting and grounding conversations evaluating program s promoting inquiry and informing

035decision making at the classroom grade building and District level and so um one of the things that I want to share with you a little bit later tonight is the ways in which our district under goes this process of utilizing data uh to fulfill this um always a work in progress but I think our administrative team has made some really good inroads in the last couple of years around using data to move program forward and inform the decisions that we're making some of it is New York state assessments and some of them are not right so assessment practices essentially come down to you know these three we have these classroom assessments we have um our NWA map data which is a universal screener that we utilize and then there's the New York State uh Ed

036um the New York State education department Board of region examinations um which will be the first part of what we'll talk about but essentially the idea is the triangulation of these three measures to be thinking about progress and how our students are doing how healthy our district is and how aligned and healthy our curriculum are um on a day-to-day basis or a year-to-year basis right oh didn't realize this was this um New York State assessment so the first part that I want to go back to is this this presentation is is in two parts right the first part is the compliance aspect so we are mandated to every board uh as to present how we did on last year's assessments results which is what I'm going to go through with you in the first part

037of this presentation and then the second part of the presentation is what I alluded to which is all the ways in which we feel our administrative team and teachers are actually utilizing data to inform our curricular conversations at multiple levels uh and I have it grounded in a few examples um and this is based upon feedback I've had with certain board members as well as presentation last year was uh not just understanding what the results are but the ways in which we actually utilize those results to kind of inform our program here in h so the New York State 3 through eight assessments are on demand tests um that are designed to measure really two things um students proficiency with the New York State learning standards or progress towards proficiency at a specific grade level

038at a specific point in time right so they're given in the spring of every year um and they're aligned against grade level standards three through eight um we give them an English language arts uh 3 through eight math 3 through eight and science shift is five and eight so last year was the first year that that uh grade five took the exam it was traditionally fourth grade right the tests are administered uh untimed great in two sessions uh the items are aligned with New York State learning standards uh and developed with a sample of New York State teachers um there are a variety of multiple choice and open-ended items on each test um the questions are designed to measure critical thinking problem solving and written language and often require students to describe and defend their

039reasoning so there is alignment to our um helding Essentials in those in that manner uh and some of the questions are released with the test results embedded in those are sample questions that you're trying to test out on kids moving forward um and the results are definitely shared with um uh teachers and parents so one aspect is uh purpose is to measure individual students uh progress towards proficiency and the second measure or rationale is whether districts uh have met required Targets in terms of New York State accountability in the every students of SE act as well that information is compiled um to determine whether or not school districts have done that sorry about that uh an overview so not to be lost in this conversation is that uh over the last I'd say four or

040five years many different uh disciplines or subject areas have undergone new alignment to new standards and they've been red out over a series of time um and you know our teachers here in helan have done a tremendous job of continuously to align their curriculum uh against these new standards to prepare students for the the tests that you're going to see and the results that you're going to see so didn't want to get to lost in this scenario so last year was the first administration of the new Elementary grade five and the intermediate grade 8 science test align to the New York State Next Generation science standards a pretty wealthy overhaul for science uh in terms of terminology um as well as how test questions were administered to students very very different shift in those ways

041computer-based testing was mandated in grades 5 and8 for ELA math and science uh and in June of 2024 was the first administration of the algebra one regions aligned the New York States standard from that moving forward to this June um you will see the first administration of the geometry region um aligned to the New York State Standards uh the first administration of the biology and Earth and space science region exam aligned to New York State Next Generation science stand so let me pause for a second there uh districts were given the option this year to either administer the new assessments or continue to administer the current assessment that's in place and has been in place many districts including helane have chosen to administer the current assessment that has been in place with the idea of

042let's see this test as it comes out and utilize that to further ground curricular work to make sure our students as prepared as possible moving forward in the new Assessments in that way right uh and computer-based testing is going to be expanded to grades four five six and eight and I believe seventh grade is just jumping on board to we decided um based upon how students did last year that we were just going to open that up to seventh grade as well um so third would be the only one that we are not we're intentionally holding off for another year on our little third graders before they're taking the test that way um and then just fast forward uh another year is you can just see that there's a new Ela Regence exam aligned to

043new standards um chemistry and physics and then computer-based testing so the purpose here is just to kind of show by the end of next June kind of represents this end of the alignment era of these new standards that have been rolled out uh since the beginning of last year so to speak right tremendous amount of work by our teachers is what I'm trying to get at in terms of just preparing and and just keeping up with that aspect of it so um that being said I'm going to jump in and show you some of these results and so before I move through through these just some things that you're going to see right our students uh continue to perform uh very solid against obviously New York State results as well as our comparable schools um

044and these results are essentially extremely consistent with the way that our students have continued to um perform over multiple years right uh not any High fluctuations higher low right um and so I think one of the things that we can take from that is a uh a healthy tier one well aligned curriculum for vastly majority of our students right they're they're going through instruction in a given year and when they get to these assessments that are designed to um um align with those standards our students are performing at measures that are very well in terms of being prepared for that right so this one is our elementary school um and Ela you can see in grade three we had 75% 71% and 66% in grade five and I'm not here to kind of read all

045the numbers to you um but you can just kind of see uh how we go through the comparable schools have been the schools we've been using for the last four years or so um based upon demographic size and social economic it's a kind of a number that is utilized to pick those comparable schools right and then if I move into math again still three through five um we see 85 85 and then grade five has its classic notorious slump but every grade five seems to have in terms of testing uh procedures uh or test writing that happens across the region in a lot of ways um I would say last year uh was the first year that we had utilized our Eureka squared math program which was somewhat of a new program we have been

046using Eureka previously and this is kind of through that process we adopted um kind of the new and improved version of that um and so you know one of the takeaways is that uh it seem to have the desired results or continued the practices that we've been having a lot with our teachers in that way right I'm going to now just fast forward briefly this is grades middle school now six through eight going back to ELA right um we see that uh our Ela scores and our uh Middle School 6 through 8 tend to be very high in the 81% uh say for grade six and seven that shows a slight increase over what we've seen and then 77% in grade 8 which continues to um exceed comparable schools obvious vastly exceeds New York State

047not that New York state is a measure that we would necessarily look at but just in context of how these performances rank uh in terms of our state then we have our math six through right um again um sounds redundant but uh you know it's it's it's illustrating many of the same concepts for us that we've seen with other results um and it's it's consistent with how we've been performing in past years this is the science results for grades five and eight and just a slight pause here um our students fared extremely well in the new science uh examinations that were in grade five as well as in grade eight a little bit more on this as I project it in in in the future in the presentation but one of the mass vast differences

048around the new science assessments was the length and complexity of the reading passages the charts in graphs that students a very different type of literacy that students were being exposed to right um and the idea that they were to synthesize from that information constructive responses off of that um not very different from Maybe Ela assessment at times but in terms of the world of science it's a vast different change from how science was previously assessed in New York state which was tend to be very multiple choice based with small responses uh this was a very big shift um which was very vocabulary based and much more reading comprehension based uh and continues to be so moving forward um so this was the first time this had happened um just a a note in our science

0498 um right that's a a place where um there's different offerings so some students take the New York State science 8 exam and then we have which were 40 which were 29 of our students and then 42 of our students took the living environment region examination right so they're not taking the science 8 they're taking a region exam in eth grade I'll get to that a little bit further the reason why you don't have a comparable uh bar is that our comparable schools many of them um uh offer a regen exam for all students so don't provide the option of taking the science a they accelerate their eighth graders either in biology and or um earth science at that point it's a preview to a point we're going to talk about a little bit um

050but uh as you can see they perform very well now we shift down to subgroups um for these exams and the batch goes to three through eight at this point and the reason there just to remind is our n number uh is so small in those areas that it's difficult to have a three through five number because that number for for example with students with disabilities tends to be so small um Realms on the statistical significance of it and so we open that up to three through eight and look at it in that context um and if you've seen these presentations the last few years it's almost these charts are virtually the same right um our students slightly outperform or or outperform our comparable schools there isn't New York State data on this um and

051they stay relatively um consistent uh in their performance over the last few years this is Ela and then slightly the same thing for mathematics right I'm going to move on to region examinations if we don't mind unless there are questions or we wanted to pause for a second my thought was to keep going okay we'll Circle back Circle back then got it um so region examinations uh again measuring student achievement specific courses right um a region or an advanced reg requires to to pass certain examinations and so you can see a list of the exams that we provide in 2024 um exams have multiple choice and open-ended uh students take the exam when they have completed their course of study uh and and we New York State utilize a scaling method to communicate achievement of

052State learning standards right so it's not a direct proportion of what they get it's a scaling method that goes into that um so start with our Middle School who took region exams right so in living environment we had 42 students uh every single one of them passed 100% pass rate and you had an 86% Mastery rate included within that uh and then in Algebra 1 uh very similar 100% passing rate and a 59% Mastery rate which is an 85 higher in the that's for our Middle School shifting to the high schoolish right um so these examinations are scored on a three four five um oh Excuse Me 3 four five yeah uh measure uh five means exceeding um and four is meeting and three is um uh is partially meeting right um and as you

053can see with our scores uh which is you know three or higher um exceeding extremely well so common core Ela we have a 96% passing rate with a 67% Mastery and you can just see those numbers moving forward right so one of the questions that we gain out of looking at this instead of looking at performance uh in ela through like a third grad or fourth grader fifth grade is also to see what happens when it gets to the Common Core one which is a requirement um for all of our students in order to graduate so uh one thing to look at would be by the time we get to that point we're looking at a 96 last year a 96% pass rate with a high degree of Mastery in that against learning standards um

054it kind of supports this idea that you know students learn at different paces and uh these um standards at grade levels are important to track and monitor um but can kids can continue to grow throughout certain years to get to certain points and I would say that having a high percentage rate in the 11th or or the common Cory La has some significance when thinking about our literacy program K12 right as well as our results and other ones um this these examinations are out of uh a level four one two three four instead with three and four being proficiency and four being Mastery uh living environment at a 91% earth science at 90 and chemistry which is a tremendous result of 99% with a 57% uh Mastery rate in chemistry right uh extremely strong numbers

055uh that come out of our high school in terms of their performance on um their standardized scores uh this is going to go to the second part of the presentation around how we utilize that but I didn't know if we wanted to pause and see if there was a question on all that wealth of information provided y probably address my questions but I I'll put it here anyway on the uh on the chemistry uh those are students that are freshman and sophomores or no uh meaning accelerated that they were accelerated in eighth grade and then accelerated Grand in nth grade um so to get to chemistry at that level some are accelerated eth grade right and then some then get double accelerated um when they become ninth um in their pathway I should say just

056nth grade so that number is a mixed cohort meaning it's right whereas the living environment of 20 so that is a mixed cohort as well living environment yeah yeah so it'll represent some of the ninth graders who accelerate in the eth grade right and then yeah uh some of the 10th graders possibly who were taking it in the after taking um in the biology got you and then on the number for uh grades five and8 New York State science 8 um 52% howan proficient that is meet that's meeting the base level of proficiency you said 29 students so roughly half did not make that proficiency accurate but then go into that mixed cohort and living envir environment and then succeed in um not always next year okay they don't always jump going from that into

057a living environment course uh for prerequisites okay because it might be earth science okay thank you yeah I had sort of a small question about um I've heard a couple eliminations about um you mentioned the state tests was it from 3rd to 8th we're going to computerize or fourth not third graders you mention third will be third will be they will be have you noticed um had they been computerized before some of them no uh in terms of giving them they had not been okay I was just wondering if you you know were worried about that or if that has any type of you know noticeable difference in in yeah so I would say yes something that um we have many schools including how they we planned for so the New York State gives simulation

058periods that we um so even prior to this test actually being administered um some elementaries grade levels piloted there were opportunities to just pilot so fourth grade previously to having to do it have been piloting opportunities to do it as trial um New York state has been offering like I said simulation periods they give us a window in which we're able to log into the system and kids are actually able to go on and do some sample questions it's not uh comprehensive by any means uh but we took advantage of that for the last two years and we're doing it again this year it's really allows a check on our systemwide to make sure that we've inputed things correctly um and gets the teachers to better understand the process of what this looks like um

059and there are some tools and features within the examination itself that you do need to make students aware of right I would say a lot of students are very tech-savvy coming out of a you know a covid time where they're very remote learning and there's there's lots of it and so um they're picking it up different um I would say um but it it does look different and so um there is an intentionality around so for example in January we come back that's when the simulation period opens and uh our grade levels are going to participate again in it um it's really helped the teachers really quite frankly um and then a lot of the things that we do with kids are electronic anyways um they might not match it exactly but conceptually it's there

060so uh like any kind of testing there is some test wiseness that goes into it uh that we've planned for and we've been implementing but didn't seem to have much effect on the fifth and eth grade that we had seen in our assessment results or anecdotal information from when they actually took the exam or on a network or bandwidth or anything like that thank you yeah jumping around sorry um so I'd like to just shift again just to talk a little bit about there's that and then the ways in which we actually utilize some data against this goal um to engage in conversations with our teachers around our programs and uh make decisions and promote inquiry um which I really think is where we've made some tremendous gains in the last couple of years um

061and this has really been uh you know a group effort so there's my colleagues are sitting here miss jamond and miss sniffin and uh you know Dr Sil Dr C have all kind of been utilizing this idea around you know how can we use the data to inform some of our conversations that we having um so I'm gonna highlight a couple of areas to just just kind of ground that in some way so um Miss jamond presented two weeks ago around literacy and um and trying to not sound redundant about it she did a tremendous job highlighting all the work that we've done what I would say is um that work is um very much so grounded in this reemergence of the hallan learner profile that uh Miss jamond has kind of resurrected with her

062staff um which was really it's Resurrection stage last year is kind of pulling it together um but then this year is refinement of it in a way that we're actually to use this data um and really make some of those um conversations so the thing I would say about the New York State assessments is um you know I can stand here and say it's healthy the numbers look good um but I'm well aware that you know whether it's 81% that means there's 19% who have not to your point earlier right there's half students who have not met proficiency and those percentage points represent students um and that's where those conversations lie right is what do we do around the students that are not performing CES um complex and there's not a magic fix but it's

063where the efforts need to be uh drilled into and so one of the ways that we've also stepped back around looking at those numbers is that the Hing uh learner profile which I I don't want to get lost in this data chart uh by any means but just a preview of it oh no I I have the access I grant access sorry hit hit hit request and then she'll get the email right away if it's mine it's mine oh but it says it's mine no it's a copy that I made because I had student Nam you have your cell phone what's say you have your cell phone fck I mean how much time we going to was I'm not very teex savy this is going to be a minute Talk Amongst yourselves you gota have

064that like technical difficulty Tech we need some music going that's great yeah right I got it I'm on it 20 seconds Amici you haven't achieved Mastery yet approaching wrong to begin with right you were the one uh so I I don't want to get lost in this in any ways but I think one of the things that was drilled down was we have the New York State results that tell us this uh we have n which is a universal screener which I don't want to lose sight of that provides us a wealth of information it does uh more on that but when it comes down to um exactly where might students in our elementary schools struggle in the idea of literacy we have administered uh a wealth of different assessments for every single student at

065multiple times of the year at a better opportunity to try to better understand where we should Target instruction against specific groups of kids and specific students right so obviously student names are redacted out of this um but you can see you have blue as exceeds meets approaching and below and miss jamm and myself had spent the better part of the Fall sitting with teachers grade level teams looking at this and promoting conversations right discussions what do we notice right what do we think um and it gets into a variety of of conversations that help our grade level teams uh you know collaboratively um plan together around similar groups of students who are struggling as well as informs individual teachers around their individual classrooms around how to Target small group instructions around tier one instruction that

066best meets students needs within their classroom right that's kind of a highlight of showing this and so it takes your New York State data and says Okay um as well as the NWA data but really drills down on a more granular level that we feel are decisions that we could make around how we should be instructing students that we think are most targeted to accelerate their growth in what we feel is probably one of the most primary important things is this students being able to reading decode on grade level by the end of grade three right at a point like that is what you'd be looking for um because that will allow them to really access everything hellan has moving forward right and we know the longer that students go with having uh deficiencies maybe

067in some of these areas just the more bifurcated sometimes programs can be about getting them the help that they actually need um which is a systemic issue um in one way so what we did with that is we partnered with a group called the reading week um more on that a little bit uh in a second but we had all this really great data and we found that um one plug sorry I have to really thank Andrea Saunders out there she compiles all this information and she creates these spreadsheets for every single teacher in the elementary school more on that in a second um and it's tremendous the way that she puts that and she facilitates that work um the reading League had a service that we could provide them this information and they would

068tally the information for us and provide us so miss jamond shared this chart with her with you guys a couple weeks ago but I just wanted to to talk about it this just talks about the oral reading fluencing which is a specific subset of a test that we provide right um which is really just in the accuracy and the fluency that students are able to read um in a particular time Mo against you know how many words they get wrong or incorrect right so um what we've come to understand around this is it tends to be one of the most impactful uh assessments you can provide in terms of the data it will give you in a very short time and how you can make decisions raced around students um literacy uh from their performance

069in it and so um not around aligning of Standards this is straight reading comprehension and decoding and development um we provided it and we found they gave us this information back which you know um our students are consistently performing at very high levels in terms of it so in terms of our mtss tier of Assessments of tier one tier two and tier three um what we've signaled out of this is that many of our students do have these reading capabilities and the plateau doesn't mean that they're plateauing it means they continue to move at grade level expectations throughout the year um so it was just another measurement of an attempting to measure our elementary literacy program um which we didn't walk away say oh this is great um it gives us pause to say okay

070there are aspects of what are going on that are working very very well and it bides more time to be thinking about other things that we'll talk about in a few minutes right if you obviously if these numbers were much much lower it would be indicative of like an acute issue that we we need to get in there extremely fast and fix right um but as uh Miss Jam talked about the other day you know the practices teachers are doing in classroom has changed over the last couple of years the way that they instruct students um best practices aligned to science reading has really elevated as a result of looking at some of these right and then this is what it looks like this year right just to kind of show you the same thing

071uh the grade one don't take too much in there there was a little there's a little error in that one but they gave us this information anyways um but this is our oral reading fluency right in the fall of of where students are so you know our students uh continue to come in with what we believe are are strong skills in that that being said it does represent a portion or population of students that are not meeting these expectations right I don't want to lose sight of that that piece of it right and so really when we talk about the use of data for evaluation inquiry and decision making at the elementary school it hits multiple areas so the first I talk about is classroom instruction so as a district we've um uh been discussing

072with all of our K12 teachers ideas around Universal Design for Learning right which is um a framework for thinking about how you plan instruction uh on the onset of instruction to meet all of your learners in your classroom to remove obstacles at the onset of of instruction which is um similar but a little bit different than differentiation differentiation is during instruction like you've noticed as you've gone through a series of learning that you need to differentiate way this is trying to capitalize on the ideas of Engagement um and understanding that uh as you know your class in front of you there are ways that you can proactively design lessons to really engage students um uh and move them forward uh obviously it's It's Been instrumental in our research based practices around the science of reading

073Jam presented uh last two weeks ago around that practices we've stopped practices we've adopted and practices that we think we need to think about adopting in the future right um and consistent with our work around targeted small group instruction which we've been utilizing our literacy consultant for the last few years um but it really informs that idea of you know group station work and how we're really planning that work and providing students within that classroom what they really need based upon this stuff uh this data to really Target where we think that they need would either need to grow or or to move up professional development It's Kind great conversations with um Miss jam and myself and teachers first is obviously n which is last year um I'll get to that in a second but

074the whole District kind of reup on its NWA um professional development and how to utilize those reports um but we've gone out and contracted with the reading League all of last year to provide um a common experience for all of our teachers to build our knowledge around the science of reading teachers went out and did the the new PS micro which was tremendous but we definitely felt like having all of our teachers in a room and hearing a consistent message and having common language was really important for our work moving forward um and then Megan hardgrave is a literacy consultant we've been using for the last three years and continue to contract with um and she really provides that extra data piece around um how to plan targeted small groups around information right um in

075our mtss services so it has really enhanced the way that we've targeted our tier one two and three services and so when we talk about students who are not achieving proficiency who have been recommended for AIS Services either tier two or tier three um that dat those data points have really uh Been instrumental in allowing our teachers to Target what those tier two and tier three um instruction really looks like they have better information about what that is when they're going in what it has um put down for us which is a need is um mtss tracking program right so we have Excel spreadsheets that we have a teacher do but there is um no there is software out there that will allow us to put all this information in and that makes it much

076more accessible to our K12 teachers moving forward so it'll track students if they've ever taken any AAS service at any point in time what those Services were if they exited if they moved in um it's a refinement of how we want to collect that data moving forward and have a repository uh that we can look at not just for academics but it could be social emotional as well um so that's a need that we're looking for and then obviously it really informs the conversations around curricular resources so uh as M Jam said two weeks ago we are in the process of looking to adopt literary resources which best supports our curriculum and so I think we're at a really good place with that because you have a K5 really K8 faculty that is well informed

077uh and knowledgeable about it um they have exposure in terms of practices and the level in which we're analyzing these programs is really coming through that I like to have that knowledge around what's best for us not to be forget in this conversation is math as well um and we have the KH Academy program K5 now um and what that does is you can take your NWA score so every student after they take NWA is provided what's called a RIT score which is just an achievement level of what they've done at that point in time you can enter that RIT score in and KH Academy will generate um resources and problems that are tiered specifically to those students based upon that score um it targets the areas that they're deficient in or areas they could

078grow in right so that is utilized in small group instruction so students log in what I'm looking at is different than maybe uh trusty mcneel is looking at because our scores are different um and that's just as Target as it gets makes it easier for our teachers to be able to do that um that's been really impactful and we've just completed kind of that K5 process in the Middle School uh they use EXL which is a very very similar thing and then two years ago we identified the uh preventing academic failure reading program that Dr cun really brought in for her tier three students so um by no means is this uh the answers it just represents ways that the the elementary school has utilized this data to make some informed decisions and promote discussions

079around what resources practices development um we would like to move forward with I'm going to move on to the middle school and high school but I'll I'll pause for a second if there are questions around just don't giggle you knew I was going to ask something so here's the deal uh grade one 68.8% on the oal reading fluency jumps up to grade two so to me that sounds like there's a significant amount of growth once there there really are students how many of our students in grade one are not in are are not our kindergarteners because New York kindergarten is not mandated not mandated I don't I don't know the answer how many a small percentage or this year we had seven that were not ours they were not are okay and Miss Jan not

080what was the issue with the grade one there there there was there was some it was a new assessment and I not being someone who administers it I can't fully explain the details we have some questions around that the validity of it anyway correct okay and I would also say the year before we did also see a lower first grade but then they were at that 85% the end of first yeah it seems like what we're doing works really well right so it shows a nice curve so the question is on that grade one if we had prek which are our students then right prek in kindergarten that concept would be you know that oral R flu fluency is that um age appropriate in which those kids are working on that material or less so

081you don't do an oral reading fluency until the spring of kindergarten is the first time you would administer that I wouldn't suggest testing just the we have access to the curriculum right I would hope to see um even this year the end of year kindergarten beginning of first raade next year um a difference with the new phonics in instruction more with more science of reading that's really been infused um if we don't see a change I'm say huh that's weird what I thought we were seeing all of this with our internal classroom assessments so okay because the oral read influency along the way is looking like it's making a lot of room and we'll have those numbers I can certainly share with you we'll have them in January for the mid year I would say

082I think to the point you made having students in a prek gives them gives us one more year of access to them with our curriculum and our things yeah our teachers and kind of like the like our run like the you know exactly okay I had a question about KH Academy math program that is not the the main math that's kind of an supplemental you had mentioned Jam at the last meeting that there was something where that's that's like an extra enrichment and that that it doesn't always it's not perfect yet or something just in terms of for kids when they're yeah so if they're testing um I think the question on that day would be was about is it useful for the kids who are testing above grade level and it isn't always because

083as you get above grade level in math you sometimes need direct instruction and so if you just come across A New Concept like algebra as an advanced early fourth grader that doesn't make sense if you just come to algebra question you need someone oh this is how that works so it doesn't remove the need for instruction but it does make a really good interactive station within the classroom and supplement to the curriculum so moving on to the middle school and the high school um so I say similar between the Middle School and the high school is last year uh we had um onsite professional development for all of our staff around how to you our uh not how to use a refresher on the NWA assessments part of that was um preco it was planned

084to have done and then Co had taken place so it was a little bit Rocky and then we had something like 15 new staff members you know through throughout that time and so not even everybody understood it so it was a good time to just pause and we had NWA come on in and provide professional development for our staff to ground them in the information right what the reports are how to use the reports and various things so we've done that for both of our um well for all of our our our our teachers K12 um and where you see the payoff is in the for both this fall at the superintendent's conference day under the leadership so miss sniffin at the high school and Dr silky at the uh middle mid School facilitated with

085their grade level departments or grade level teams these NWA results and grade level teams got together looked at the information and used this uh information to Target instruction small group instruction curricular development um it gets a lot into some of that information and the adoption of different curricular resources so uh that was something that we were purposeful about last year and then purposeful about this year making sure we provide teachers the time particularly at the superintendent's conference day to pause and take a look at that information against the results I have when we get back from uh the break in January will be the second administration of the NWA and then when those results come out we'll facilitate a very similar process with our uh teams as well um and that's been tremendous follows it's

086it's similar in that because it's around creating targeted small group instruction around the needs of students um teachers uh that you know some of the reports that are really utilized is uh you know they get this RIT score which provides and there's grouping mechanisms you can group students by a variety of aspects about their RIT scores that allows you to differentiate and create class groups that way or small group instruction um really helps teachers in that process um which has been tremendous um what I'd like to also highlight uh that Miss sniffin has done at the high school and took it a step further uh with her Department to chairs um is a department analysis of regions results right um she facilitated these two things called a gap analysis and P values now I don't

087want to lose you in this one either um but I I do I do want to show you for a second uh what we're talking about here um so this is provided and this is around uh the rious examination in uh geometry right um it's the building Benchmark and again not not to lose but what this report provides us is the specific performance indicator uh that was assessed on that and how our students performed against that specific um performance indicator so red is not good right St standing with that um and it will tell you I can't see it's too far away um but it just says in terms of performance how well our students either you know it just does the work to say a lot of kids got this question wrong right um

088and it continues to go through and show all the ways that our kids got questions correct right and so when you think about it for Department teachers to sit and look at this information it really allows them to just go back and take a look at their curriculums and say what are the areas that we've performed well in and what are areas that we either need to refine or change to make sure that we're not seeing the score again uh I would go back to the idea of promoting inquiry with teachers and uh it's not miss sniffin presentation but I would say that um the conversations that teachers were having around this information is what's really impactful right where they're sitting and looking at these and you're talking and you know in chemistry where was

089a 99% passing rate that you have the teachers are looking at taking a look what they got wrong and refining curriculum around how they can be improved which is what we want right in ways um but it gets at a really high level refinement of what our curricular resources look like at our high school and it's really Testament to the work that mnin is facilitating with her Department chairs and that culture of looking at this information uh as it moves forward is this the one no it's not the one that I want to do in addition to is P value I don't know what P stands for I'm I G get into it right um this is a a report that is also shared that um on this column it talks about the complexity of

090the question right so at the bottom for V po terms is the question was deemed to be less complex and as it gets to the top the question is deemed to be more complex uh these funky numbers here indicate how well our students performed on those areas so to the right is they performed well and to the left are areas in which uh they probably did not perform well in certain questions again an extremely useful tool as teachers are looking at so like there's a you can your eye just gets drawn to a clump okay so you go back you look at the actual you know regionally right this is not New York state but regionally the performance indicators and and what those are and how teachers can use this to refine their curriculum right

091so it's a way of taking granular data on New York State assessment results and using them um for a curricular analysis type idea right again I don't want to get lost we can have that this why I'm not going to get just this uh is Ally in blue and then the bouncing ping pong circles are are is helding so it's it's attempting to kind of show regionally how other schools did in the same comparison right again uh really Spurs good conversations amongst our teachers around curriculum right an example that I want to show you about how this comes together in ways is this conversation in in earlier slides I talked about it was hard to compare our eighth grade results to comparable schools because many schools do an advancement of all students in the eth

092grade into a living environment so we've started this conversation with our teachers around the expansion of living environment uh biology in the eth grade I'm cautious to say not for all but ways that we might be able to be thinking about um having more students take that class right um the Regent exam information we saw shows that our students in living environment in eth grade do extremely well right those who are accelerated and that there is a 52% half of students that are taking science 8 are getting master or higher and this has been something that has been an ongoing performance for our students over a number of years and so the question becomes are we able to advance more students in conversations that it had is um it can reduce the number of sections

093in the high school that we have to offer to provide biology moving forward which has conversations around if you're saving a point two what class could you add on the back end of it to strengthen a science program as it moves forward right um which is a great conversation to have but it really gets into a Readiness analysis because as you have that conversation enter guidance counselor and math department chairs who are saying wait a minute if you're going to start accelerating students earlier in science you have to make sure that their math competency is also there so we're not putting them in higher level science classes and they don't have the computational skills or the mathematical Concepts in order to support their success there right and so that's a great conversation to be having

094as well right with people um we don't have an answer for it yet it's ongoing right uh right so opinions we we have thoughts around what we might want to do um which would be are there courses that we can offer them that is a holding place that still Advance our coursework moving forward um in a way that's a just a a microcosm just an example um of one that uh we've been ongoing having and all of our science teachers have been since the beginning of this year have been working with a science consultant to update their curriculums uh against the Next Generation standards should we be thinking about moving forward on this so there's also a curricular aspect that if you're going to be advancing you want to make sure that students are moving

095through uh in the element the Middle School um that they have the prerequisite knowledge it's very similar to mathematics where you're not you're compacting curriculums right you're not skipping one um you're taking a three-year course and you're trying to get it done really two and a half at at times right so those conversations have been ongoing and it spurred a tremendous amount of work that our science and Caron have been um doing in that in that right to kind of prepare ourselves to make sure that we're we're we're ready should that be the scenario that we' be looking for right um so that's the closure on my end of just kind of full circle of of trying to think about ways uh that we've integrated data to complement our processes for how we ground conversations

096evaluate programs promote inquiry and inform some decision making within our buildings um classrooms and at the district level doing these P value charts all the time what's that are those P value charts conversations happening all the time uh I wouldn't say all the time right um you know look you know there's there's more expansion to be done as we've gotten better we can do these P value charts all the way down to third grade right um and have those conversations as well um they're not um as someone like they're not yet um but we're you know like I said through the work that miss sniffin is doing at the high school it's providing a really strong Road mapap to think about ways that we can have these conversations in the Middle School right and then

097down at the the elementary school you know there's always to be to be clear is how much value you want to put into those conversations at grades three four and five right it goes back to how do we assess what we value and so um there's always that wrestling right I don't want to say it's there could be a saturation Point who determines what that is I don't know um but we want to make sure that there's a healthy balance between what we're doing in some ways I feel well there is an advantage with the um with the comparable districts the regional districts um especially when you look at regions exams because you know regions exams are a moving Target right so for any given teacher you have no idea what's actually going to be

098on the test right um and so you could think very myopically like well that was a throwaway question that's you know that's came out of nowhere but which happens but if if you're looking at your scores and you're seeing regionally that actually you know other schools hit home runs and we had a strikeout that's an issue right it at least informs conversation probably at best right just for the purpose of reflection just to see what is going on so I think that's that's really valuable um you know I don't want to harp on the points too much but just something to to drill down because we know we talked about kind of level one level two level three kind of uh supports right we want to get as you know certain students um but we

099do drill down in this data and there are issues with level two level three supports from what I'm seeing and there's only so much that we can do even we extrapolate out that 38 subgroup where um you know we're still missing some students here uh and when we have a incredibly small cohort of students right um we want to make sure we cast the best net possible um so just some just something you know in the future or to highlight at any given time um or Regina might be able to do it uh as well but like we've talked about this a little bit which one of those supports is really helping helping those kids because some of the you know we're we're doing well right according to comparables but you know we want to

100be able to do as best as we can and we want to be able to uh analyze those supports right we want to make sure that you know we're getting the best bang out of the work that we're putting our teachers to right yeah it great though thank you Josh no no I agree and it's not to to indicate that uh we stop to your point right I think that um trying to figure out uh even with that oral rency fluency was you know these are students at 35 higher but like the ones who are not on that list where are they right and and and where are they on that list cast that net smaller or wider what does that look like inways but absolutely agree and it can absolutely be something in the

101future um to take a look at that's where NWA has like the growth metrics that that are involved in that that at least allow us to see where students start from where they get to and it might not show up on some of these other things like uh New York State assessments but um to know that students are progressing at what rate um is good information to know and you find significant value in the approaches that we have towards the data and testing in general meaning your philosophy me you know we're gonna the state is beginning to move away from the region for the purpose of graduation right for um you know and they can achieve that in other ways but um you know in your mind you know this is this is the direction

102that we are continuing to go in through 2027 yes okay questions oh I have a question and this is I've I've asked this question before about it is often the case that our students with disabilities overlap with those who are economically disadvantaged and I'm just curious about in the indication graphically how you represent both or how you include or exclude or yeah it's it's not a perfect system so the the graphic information is what is uh from the New York State at data site so it comes comes from that but I I do I uh to promote inquiry I have questions around how economically disadvantaged gets tagged right in in many ways and um you know it invokes uh image or a thought pattern around economically disadvantaged and I don't know if it's accurate in

103some way right um that's not just us that's lots of places that it's difficult sometimes to better understand that so the overlap you can see where couple are um you know labeled both probably right um yeah I just don't know how well that economically disadvantaged is a real true indicator of that yeah and my other question about when we talk about comparable schools back to that eth grade question in accelerated biology it seems like we are and for the most part consistent with what we deliver and you know you know do better and a lot of but how why is it that our comparable schools have already accelerated biology and how has it what are some of the reasons why they would have done it already and why yeah I mean in it's not that

104you know hdan has always offered an acceleration in it um to move it to all um is I don't know why other schools I mean it generally comes down one of the reasons you accelerate for anything is to provide better opportunities at the back end of of what you're able to do right so you're you're looking to get rid of excuse me you're looking to uh um go through graduation requirements quicker that allows you more choice at at an end of a program to offer science research or any number of Things Different APS or whatever that might be um that doesn't mean that they're not offering those in other ways I do think though other schools may have different based on size they have different FTE that allow you to capture students who don't do

105well in that course and they're going to have to either retake it or they skip them and they put them in a different science class and that doesn't always work out well either in some ways so um it's a way of accelerating from a curriculum to move through but I still think it riddles the same issues where you're going to still have pockets of demographics kids who don't succeed well and then having to offer opportunities for them right so in essence we're we're offering an opportunity for certain students to succeed in a way that another District isn't by having the two options as opposed to yeah yeah I don't know if it's I think it's just um I don't know if the conversation has been is there an impetus for wanting to do it or

106rationale as to why and that conversation has just started to happen right right and the new I think timing also comes as we think about new changes and graduation Pathways or requirements it could lessen some of it and so if you can I do think there's an opportunity to the more students you can get through to get done with that just creates more opportunities moving forward which I know has been the impetus for the conversations um at the high school how could we expand program in some ways right uh and that might be a place to do that there is difference between the course yes and Tech the test itself yeah so by not you know by not putting every student in eth grade in that class which is effectively an accelerated class right that

107you know it it it allows um you know differentiation for those you know for the cohort exactly overall so you know it is and and and to the point that Josh you know the idea that you you're then you would have to capture those students in in other then High School yeah Sciences yeah which you know you you you you know you still have to be able to make the whole exactly rather than supporting them in eth grade you have to support them yeah if I could add to it just you know maybe an outside you perspective well sort of an outside perspective and now having conversations with the team um I do think it it is something that um the district certainly could move towards um having living environment which will soon be called

108biology for all eighth grade many districts have moved in that direction um I think the idea to your question Sean is if you set an expectation here you may get something here yeah but if the expectation is lower then then you may not have your students meeting their full potential that being said Ezra makes the point it's a high school level course developmentally maybe not every student is ready to take that course in eighth grade and I think you do have to have some safety net options in high school for students who maybe cannot master through all the skills and Concepts yeah I mean what you're describing actually is I think we're in agreement and so far as I don't I'm curious about other schools decision to accelerate when it seems like not all students

109are ready to be accelerated so it seems like having the optionality in our middle school is to our benefit so long as you know obviously there's GNA be a gear shift towards providing the kinds of economic I mean the kinds of of curricular uh intervention early on so they can succeed I was just curious as if it was a largely a financial decision for other middle schools or you know no I I I think philosophically you know setting high expectations but but another thing to look at what what supports are in place right for students who may not be completely ready for for such a rigorous course in eth grade uh looking at how much time how much lab time I I districts have increased lab time so there are many considerations and there's also

110a consideration of alignment which the the you know the team has has talked about aligning your science curriculum six seven and eight to make sure they are prepared in eth grade Josh even points out a lot of math related to science so in my opinion you have real opportunities particularly with new graduation requirements on the horizon to rethink some of this I also agree just make a point Josh said earlier to emphasize that you have a very high performing School District you know when I was considering uh when you were considering me to to um join you I did look at a lot of the student performance data High School consistently High performing recognized Blue Ribbon that that's all based on our performance data also the grades three through eight Ela data I think places

111our student performance in the top 4% of New York State I think there's maybe 730 schools and I want to say you know you're right there with the top schools across New York state so to proceed slowly with all of these decisions I think is wise and Christine and I had some conversations around around Josh around Ela we're doing great work here yeah you know the teachers are you know do you just go with a program um when you when you're having a lot of success these real complex discussions as Josh said though I don't think there if if if we were struggling and the performance was very weak there may be more of an urgency to have to let's try something new but what you're doing is working there's been a lot of investment

112of time and energy over the past two three years as as our administrators have showed you and the last thought I will leave you with is a couple of weeks back 60 Minutes um did a profile of cono so Con Academy now is integrating AI I want to say it's being piloted in maybe 200 schools across the country and basically the concept is that every student has on their performance and the data that it's collecting has like an individual AI tutor that's interesting and that's powerful and that is very near in in the future I think for for all of education so just another thought I'll send the board in your Friday update I'll give you the link if you missed it it was fascinating and you Maggie brought up KH Academy and a little

113scary but I would even think a lot of the programs are going to all be integrating more and more AI in the future and and it's just a powerful a really powerful tool yeah Anderson Cooper didn't ask any hard questions no he's a Vanderbilt that's right I know what he gonna do I think I think this is just a very brief historical perspective question back when like the grades three through eight um State assessments were coming I guess a little bit over a decade ago I I wasn't here I was in the city so it was a little bit different culture but there was a lot of fear around oh my gosh March is GNA come we're gonna have to shut the door and it's just going to be grind grind grind test prep test

114prep chest prep and I just want to kind of my first year on the Schoolboard like what's What's the culture of that like you know I I guess you know with having kids in the district I'm not really seeing that so much but our our good scores a result of you know is there a lot of test prep going on or is there a real sense that it's a much more authentic style of assessment yeah I would say that there's there's always preparing students when there's an assessment right um the high school do computer based whatever it is you want to make sure the kids feel comfortable in the format of what that is to your point no I don't believe it's a shut the doors and we're not all we're going to do for

115the next month is rot rehearsal of these things and constructive responses I think it's more of an indic of you know we say it all the time with our teachers is the standards are our road map for how we design instruction right so if you have these assessments that are in technically aligned to the standards right what you do from September all the way through is really where all that good work goes into and so you know the ways in which they have to respond are modeled and are woven within the curriculum and what is being asked of them from the beginning till it gets there so it's not so much hey we need to stop and go over how you write all of this it's embedded in what you're doing already I do think

116that you know prudently there's you know there's opportunities to say this is what you're going to have to do you have to sit here tape if you have questions I might not be able to help you like there's all of that to get them involved in it but um I kind of know scenarios of what you're talking about and I would say that is not the culture I have seen here since I've been here in any way in any way shape or form and if I could add under a when your children probably were in that age range sh the test scores were tied to teacher and principal performance of and I think one of the the smartest things that the new commissioner and the new Administration has done had we've done away with that

117because we learned that um I think all it the only purpose it served was to create a lot of anxiety with teachers believing that they were going to be judged on student performance and the student performance the way I the way howan is using it and what Josh described and it should be used to inform instruction and inform curricular decisions not to judge individual teachers um and I I think they acknowledged it was a big mistake but it created tremendous anxiety thanks for addressing that so one last thing Josh um so Carl made a good point about suggesting that you know this is something you know putting the living environment uh you know it's possible to squarely put in the Middle School curriculum with Middle School transitioning to a 5'8 does does that present a

118benefit to doing that or it does it not matter I mean I think anytime there's you you you know if you're going to put five on the same schedule and teachers around with the other six seventh and eth there's a benefit of access in terms of collaboration I think that helps um I think it can be I think you we're going to move in that direction you also need to think about it's not just a six seven and eight scenario it's four five issue there's other work you can do in those areas that can help spread that out a bit in order to to make kids you know better prepared to take it in eighth grade so 100% it's a it needs to happen regardless when fifth grade moves up or not right like it

119you still have to do that that kind of work anyways fifth grad's in that tricky spot this year because they're also on the receiving end of having to do assessments and then we're going to be asking them at times to be thinking about preparing kids moving forward can't be too bad yeah just kind of about like a linning curriculum you know I mean if you say if you say guys this is this isn't an accelerated program for some of our middle school students this is this is a Capstone class for our middle school students is it you know that that you know that's the question you provide that for reflection and say whether or not that's valuable or not exactly I don't know I'm asking the question so no I think it is we've even

120looked at some of our at the middle school we have some elective classes that um all students take through so like ecology is one that sixth graders are taking as elective and it's an opportunity to where's where can some of these standards live in that right like you know time right presence with kids so absolutely to be looking at younger grades as well thank you thank you thank you very much appreciate it thank you very much thank you I'm sorry Peggy wasn't here to see it oh I I can imagine she is disappointed but she has either already sent J so thoroughly in her she's either already s j will my phone was just buzzing the whole time that brings us to our first uh communication from the public I don't know if anyone's here

121but if they are the howan Board of Education desires and values input from the entire School Community the first public comment session is reserved for comments on special presentations and active agenda items for those who wish to address the board please sign in and state your name for the record please keep your remarks to 3 minutes or less disparaging remarks and discussion of District Personnel are strongly discouraged although we do not engage in dialogue we are this anybody okay we have our administrator information reports Mrs sniffin among other things talked about the Juniors and seniors that were inducted into the National Honor Society interesting our director facilities gave an update on obtaining grants for electric buses there's a lot of good stuff in there um consent agenda minutes may I have a motion some moved

122second okay um minutes from our last meeting all in favor any opposed okay um committee minutes this is from our most recent policy committee and we're actually going to talk a little bit about some of the work um a little bit later so we can if anyone had any questions um we'll kind of we'll answer those when we get to the uh policies for below um consent agenda Financial may I have a motion move second anything that we want to V here uh no I think we just we're happy to um have a merger with the Garrison for modified girls basketball it made sense allowed us to to have a team for for both schools great which is great all in favor I I anyos okay um consent agenda personel may I have a motion

123so move second anything here no I'll just I'll just mention to the board FMLA um we we made a change from the past where we are going to um just have employee ID numbers just for confidentiality uh most people um are not concerned about that but we we are just presenting it a little differently uh to protect confidentiality all in favor I hi any opposed okay um unfinished business uh superintendent search update um we posted the job the job has been posted right I don't know if it was today or yesterday yes it is posted I think it's not in print yet but the the electronic postings are are live so and I just wanted to thank neither one of them right here but our board president Peggy Clemens and um Megan Shields our district

124clerk um for really helping move along um the the sort of the front end of this process and we were sort of thinking we would post maybe in a couple of weeks but um just wanted to be um to get it out there as soon as possible so they have really been going back and forth with um pnw Bose's to make this happen on the language so um that's been posted um we are working on our timeline and we're actually going to be going to Executive session at the end of the meeting to talk um a little bit more about aligning calendars um I also wanted to thank um Mr Albano who's been answer using his expertise and we've been using his uh experience to answer all kinds of questions that we have um and

125Josh as well Josh Elder our um director of HR um who's just been there to to review things and help us along so um we're trying to no yeah we're trying to sort of speed up that the process that we can so we can um you know take our time where it really matters in terms of hopefully we'll have a good selection take our time so that's the update if there's any questions about that that's great um business um CSC cpsc recommendations be it resolved that upon the recommendation of the interim superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby approves the recommendations of the Committees on special education and preschool special education as presented I have a motion so moved second all in favor I any opposed okay we have a um a new policy

126um and this is just something this is a first reading just something we would Michelle and I and Megan Megan would love to get your guys' feedback um by the next meeting on um a new policy uh that creates space uh for discussion when it comes to naming school facilities um memorializing things on school property and even um uh donations uh that that have donors names on them um which we have down at the at the football field presently so there is no formal process so we thought that uh this would be good uh Megan pulled together um a policy there for you guys to read um and it's pretty basic which is sort of you know sort of the a good way to do it but um because right now it also will create

127a way to log these initiatives um you know because trees with plaques get moved and things over time get forgotten so this will create um sort of a process so if everyone could kind of take a read of that and any thoughts I'd love we can discuss it at the next meeting um and it also allows either us to discuss and vote on it or we can designate the superintendent to sort of have the the last word on it as well so um that is that then the next one is a first reading and adoption unless anyone opposes um this is a required um update to the um non-discrimination uh policy draft changes I believe it's a lot about reporting um reporting these inci um and and updating the language um but it is required

128so this is one that we sort of go ahead and move on unless anyone has any questions on it okay so we have the recommended be it resolved that upon the recommendation of the interim superintendent of schools the Board of Education hereby waves the second reading and adopts the following haldane Central School District policy as attached number 3420 non-discrimination and anti-h harass assment in the district we have a motion so moved second all in favor I I any opposed okay um this brings us to our second communication from the public think we have any any board Reflections I I'm going to start I forgot one thing in the superintendent search I just wanted to to tell everybody who may be watching or anyone here um to be watching the website we are going to announce

129we're going to have some forums um for different groups to come commun can come tell us you know what they want to see in a superintendent um so that will be posted shortly on the website I just want to rate my gratitude to Julia sniffen and as well as Dr C for the presentation you gave her Garrison it was great to be there and to be so well represented so wonderfully so thank you for your time and effort and energy in doing that I will mention uh M best uh that was incredible did a great job uh tech crew did a great job the actors were amazing everything within that play was shockingly impressive so it really um that was a testament to the work and the community um here at H it was amazing

130really was oh you know I just would suggest I know we talked about the regionalization um getting back next meeting I feel like that's a short amount of time with the needs and strength survey being due January 15 and if we have any issues with it and decide not to go forward it kind of doesn't make sense for him to work on it so it's kind of like why don't we decide if we have concerns about going forward with the survey why don't we make a decision soon than January 7th so that Josh knows whether to work on the survey or not that's a nice that's apprciate I think I was at the curriculum council at pnw today uh with all the regional leaders and this topic came up um there is concern though you

131know that if you opt out of it they're still going to move forward with it and you just kind of lost your voice right so I I don't know I mean I appreciate the sentiment um but uh I I I don't think it's something that we prudently would up should for the reason of not doing the work right like I it's not it's okay like I appreciate it um in that manner I don't see any concern with putting it I I would like to see the survey get turned in yeah personally yeah yeah I think that makes sense um I was just suggesting that as a board if we could we have any issues with it or concerns my only question is why do why would districts Carl said there were a handful of districts

132that did not want to go forward and so what are the reasons yeah well in is there a valid reason there there if I may say something about I think one of the things that has frustrated a lot of individuals that I talk to is it's like 40 some pages long and um it's the bureaucracy of the state they are literally asking you to go to the New York State website and pull information on that you have to hand put in they have the information they cannot they cannot extract it they're asking us to do it and go they literally say go to new like oh and put in your region results like we reported this four years ago well it started as a mandate and then became a conversation right so I don't know

133why we're going to talk what people are I got you and and if I I'll just add to that they started I don't want to prolong um the evening here but um I think initially people had concern of losing local control now that's been addressed my my concern you know I have no more concerns but but the districts that did opt out um their superintendent reported that um they're already sharing because we do have a Statewide model of bosies right and their main purpose is to facilitate sharing of services so they view it as well you know in a similar way to why are we giving the state data that the state already has and you know why are we you know duplicating efforts we have a Bose model that has worked for for decades

134and decades so I think it's more on principle that they they're saying gotcha you know and and and the other thing is you know they there was some mentioned that maybe they would Finance if if there were creative ideas that maybe they would try to find some funding to support those ideas that is what the commissioner is telling us people are skeptical though you know they're saying well GE you just did a foundation Aid formula and you're struggling to fund state aid and people are concerned about the federal dollars also so you know is there really going to be money invested in in our ideas are we doing all this work for nothing so that that was that's some of the the sentiment but I I agree with Michelle Michelle and I were there we

135had some conversation I just don't see a downside we we do a lot of great sharing and collaboration but maybe there are ideas that we haven't thought of that will be generated from the process I'll touch base of Peggy and maybe we can I'm sure it's fine I just wanted to because she's not here you know hear her her thoughts on it and we can move forward we'll let you know sure thank before way before the next meeting I guess um any other nothing for me good so um I would like to make a motion to convene into executive session to discuss matters leading to the appointment of a particular person great

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.