001[Music] okay good evening everyone good evening welcome to the February 4th 2025 Mount Veron city school district school board meeting please stand for the pledge I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all please note that truste Donna marabel is joining this evening's meeting via video conference from marott Maris in Washington DC 901 Massachusetts Avenue Washington DC 20001 trusty McDonna present truste marabel present but I can't see the room okay we can try and fix that trusty Mitchell pres trusty Middleton pres trusty and Jenga here trusty white president trusty Kerwin here VP Kelly here president Saunders okay we have our Quorum and our student trustee de Grand Pre here hi okay um superintendent
002do you want to do the recognition are we going to do that good evening everyone I would like to start by recognizing um two Heroes within our district um several board members wanted them to be honored so we'll begin with that recogn recognition I'll go to the podium and anyone else that want to join me please feel free good evening again we had a medical emergency um recently at the Academy this emergency included a student who was unresponsive we had two individuals that was very helpful to the survival of the youth youth who's still in the hospital and um you know we're praying for him the first person we want to recognize is one of our security officers say his name is Joshua Joshua Melendez could you come forward thank you so much for saving
003a life we appreciate your work and it was so courageous of you to realize that the student was in danger and you helped him survive that was my pleas yes here's a certificate did you want to no just um I'm just going to say that first of all not only is it a pleasure to have you in building where my daughter attends so we have already talked in the past but to see the video and watch you jump on the scene the way you did and know exactly what to do commend you and your counterparts our safety offices are extremely valuable and important and you're appreciated so thank you for what you did saved the help save that man's life thank you thank you did you want to say [Applause] anything um it was just
004it was something that it felt right to do so I'm just I'm happy um it was just m I don't know what to say you know I was like um I'm just pleasure you know you did a great job sorry to put you on thank you so much the um other individual was a registered nurse a male registered nurse that I'm told can't be here tonight Gary Gary a uh good to have medical people on the scene we want to thank him as well um he couldn't be here but let's give him a round of [Applause] applause did you want to say anything oh I one last thing um just so that you understand um our safety agents and our buildings work extremely hard they not only keeping our babies safe they're keeping our teachers
005our build administrators safe um and a lot of times you know some people say hey I just came in here yesterday you know who I am why I got to show ID these are the reasons because how this is why them following what they're supposed to do they're following protocol and in certain situations like this we had a gentleman that went above and beyond the call so we have to be thankful for our blessings he knew exactly what to do in the situation the young man faces serious challenge like I said heart attack something else and he was on the scene so we should always remember to respect and appreciate our safety officers and every one of our buildings including this district office here I appreciate you all I'm sure we all do our speak
006for all the trustees I'm sure as well as Dr Smith who doesn't need me to speak for her again thank you so very much um [Applause] did you want so T um tonight I'm going to ask the board uh for consensus to change our meeting structure for tonight uh for presentation because I want um the community to hear because a lot of times when we have public comments a lot of people leave so I want people to hear this presentation if that's okay with the board members is that okay okay all right so tonight we have um tonight we have excuse me so most of the board uh said was okay to switch up let's can we just take a vote is it okay to switch out is it okay two three four okay okay
007so tonight we have I want to introduce uh Tamela Boyd uh and she's gonna talk about she's going to talk about the Mount Vernon Charter review commission so introducing Miss Boyd here okay Dr Dr Smith you have something to say okay you have hell sorry uh Tamil you have someone that's going to present with you as well yes um but at the end of my comments okay all right so um good evening um as uh the board said my name is Tamila Boyd and I'm the chair of the 2024 Charter review commission um thank you for giving me this time tonight to come and talk to you about the commission what we've been doing and how you all can get involved um I've now done several of these presentations and at each one people ask
008me about my background and how I got involved with the commission so I'll share that here um I'm a relatively new resident of Mount Vernon um I purchased here may 2023 I'm a lawyer and I have been for just over 20 years I've spent the bulk of my uh career in government including nearly six years as a general counsel of a New York City agency and I share that only to share that Municipal governance isn't foreign to me so uh when the charter commission formation was announced one of my neighbors who knew my background talk me into applying and so here we are uh today um with me tonight is Matt linger he's a director with the national civic league the national civic league is an organization with over 100 years of experience helping municipalities
009engage in good governance um they are advisers to the commission and you'll hear from him a little later um so tonight I want to talk to you as I said about the charter what we've been doing um what you can do to help and why you should care about any of this and we had slides um if you're controlling the slides could you go to slide two thank you um so uh what is a charter so a charter you can think of as the constitution for the city it's the rule book so essentially it mandates uh it it says how things are done in a city um it outlines the government thank you it outlines how the government works the officials are and what powers they have and it defines how laws are made how
010services are delivered and how residents can participate in the political process um a charter commission is a body appointed to review and suggest changes to the Charter in Mount Vernon those recommendations are placed on the ba on the ballot for public vote if voters approve the recommendations they become the law so a charter change can do a lot of important things a charter change can alter the form of government so the new form is better align with the preferences of its citizens a charter change can restrict or increase options available to government leaders a charter change can alter electoral representation a charter change can clarify ambiguity or confusion caused by current language in the charter um importantly a charter change can redistribute Powers among elected officials appointed officials and governing bodies and it can also
011redistribute power as between City officials and residents um finally a charter change can convert elected positions into appointed positions and the other way around so uh the Mount Vernon Charter review commission is a group of 15 people seven were chosen by the mayor seven were chosen by Council and the 15th was chosen by the first 14 um we also have an eight member Advisory Board importantly The Advisory Board doesn't vote but they provide assistance to us and some much needed expertise in are that the commission members don't cover um so what has the commission been doing we split into four subcommittees each assigned to look at different parts of the charter there was a finance committee there was a governance elction committee a human resources Social Services uh committee and a public servicespublic works committee
012the Committees arrang interviews with relevant City officials we interview the mayor the com controller city council and department heads we also interview officials from other cities to understand their structure operations and issues and this information was used to inform the decisions that the subcommittees were being asked to make um based on what we heard our experiences as residents and our review of the charter the subcommittees were asked to research possible solutions to issues and recommend Charter amendments two subcommittees presented its recommendations and a third is currently considering three additional recommendations which they'll present at our meeting tomorrow so as you can see from this slide some of the initial recommendations that came out of the subcommittees um were changing to a city manager or chief administrative officer form of government uh which the subcommittee argued
013would provide professional City management and remove the politics from basic city services um eliminating the elected comproller in favor of a non-political appointed experienced Finance professional requiring a mandatory referendum which is voter approval um of any tax increase above the 2% state tax cap creating a formal process to ensure that the planning department has input into rezoning and land use decisions and finally having council members elected by Wards rather than at large which the subcommittee believes will make running for Council more attainable and also result in better representation for all segments of the city so these are just a few of the recommendations that commission will vote vote on um the full list is available if you want to see it reach out to me and I can get it to you and we also
014intend to post the list on our website so sorry so to recap um the commission has completed steps one and two on this slide um we are now at step three which is educating the public about the process and topics under consideration now I've been doing my best to get out in front of as many groups like this as possible to talk about the charter it's importance and how folks can make their voices heard um to help with that Outreach process as I said we're working with the NCL and they've helped us draft an opening survey that survey is designed to get some baseline information about how Mount Veron residents feel about their government and how the government's been doing um at the end of this Matt's going to show you the results that we
015have so far so you can see the kind of information they're collecting and the numbers that they're going to Crunch and at the end of that process we will share the outcome of the survey once the survey closes um after that the commission will consider the survey re results and any feedback we've gotten from the public and then very very importantly on March 19th the voting members of the commission will vote on which initiatives to send to the ballot for Mount Vernon residents to vote on I think that it is is vitally important that we hear from as many people in the public as possible to make sure that when commission members vote we're voting with your voices in mind um that's part of the reason that I'm here after that vote the commission will
016hold public hearings and Community conversations to inform the public about the initiatives that survive the vote um and after that public engagement process we'll finalize the proposals we'll draft our report telling the public how we got to where we were and then we'll MIT the proposals for inclusion on the ballot in November 2025 um how can the school board help the school board can provide your insight into how the city's government governance impact schools you can provide recommendations on Charter changes that you might like to see you can encourage your members and parents and anyone in your sphere of uh in your sphere of impact to get involved you can provide space for upcoming public hearings or Community conversations um you can also take the surveys attend the public hearings uh organize Community discussions and
017tell anyone who will listen about this process um and the importance of this process what it can mean to them um and if you know of any groups that want to have this conversation let me know and I will happily go to them um most important in November please vote um and just in closing I just want to talk a little bit about why you should care about any of this um I know that the school district and the city are different legal entities um here um but our Fates are hopelessly intertwined right how the city is run and the financial state of the city has a direct impact on the financial state of the school district and you're living through that right now um you you will continue to experience that as decisions are
018made about things like Pilots for example that maybe do not take into account the impact on the school district also you're not just Schoolboard members and parents you are residents and as I said earlier as the residents you are the ultimate deciders the commission makes recommendations but you all vote and if you don't want it it doesn't happen um so you know I think the charter is great um while the charter is far from a magic pill it is a very good place to start to address the issues that currently plague Mount buron and so now I'm going to turn it over to Matt and he's going to show you tell you a little bit more about the NCL and show you the results of the survey so far thank you guys again for hearing
019me out thank you thank you camla uh thank you so much all of you for letting us uh be part of the your meeting tonight I'm Matt linger I run the center for democracy Innovation at the national civic league the civic league is itself kind of a historic organization it was founded in 1894 by Teddy Roosevelt Le brandise uh Mary mford number of other people at the time and it was founded in order to make democracy work better the democracy at the time was going through a rough patch trust in government was low polarization was high democracy wasn't working as it should and so the civic league was part of a wave of reforms from the 1890s to the 1920s that helped to kind of establish the forms of government government that we use today
020um so clearly we have some trouble now with democracy at every level school systems and and and local governments are on the front lines of that uh and we are trying to kind of help again uh to help kind of modernize you you take take some of those structures that have been around for about 100 years and kind of bring them into the next century and make sure that they're working the ways that we all want them to work one of those levers for change that's actually was part of that original kind of wave of reforms is the city Charter uh and the the league has actually been the holder of the model City Charter since 1902 we updated every so often um and the ninth Edition which came out in 2021 was the first
021to embrace Equity uh and engagement as core principles core um priorities of local government so it's it's it's actually an interesting sort of thing because and most people don't know that the city Charter exists even and even people who work in city government or our our local officials don't really pay it much attention but it's essentially the Constitution for your city it is basically the kind of agreement between the institution and the the people of that Community about how they want to govern together how they want to interact how they want to exchange information all those sorts of good things so you can kind of put all kinds of interesting and helpful things into your city Charter to kind of change the way the governance works so as part of the process one thing we'd
022like to do is have a kind of really easy uh mobile survey that we use that we call a scorecard to get people's input on things um and so uh I'm going to show you a little bit of the the version of this we've done for Mount Vernon that Tamila and her colleagues have been kind of using in different parts of the city over the last few weeks uh there's a link um that was in the email that if you click on that you should be show seeing the the results and if that isn't working I can always share my screen and I I can't actually see you all in the room so you'll have to bear with me um Tamila is is it showing up on the screen for them no no no it
023isn't okay no it's not let me try sharing my screen then okay so so far we've had 135 people uh take this survey and what we're going to let you all going to show the QR code in just a minute so that you all can take it as well uh but so we have 135 people about 2/3 were able to make it through the whole survey which is actually a fairly good rate for surveys um and we asked a number of different different things some general and some more specific things about the charter so we asked a general thing here and the first first question which is you know how in what areas do do you feel local government is performing well um Waste Management among the things the options we gave waste management was
024the top vot getter none of the above actually was was the um the single top thing but that's obviously not a specific category um would you like to be more likely to engage with local government if there were more opportunities for Community input we asked that um and most of the people either said yes or they said yes and more of these opportunities should be established in the charter so there's a fair amount of of kind of at least so far of kind of motivation for change in the charter that would make it easier for people to engage in local decision making uh we asked what barriers by the way you are seeing my screen right I'm not hearing anything so I'm hoping you are that you can hear me okay yes we can hear
025you Matt okay got it okay so now the third question here I'm showing hopefully you can see this uh what barriers do you face if any in participating in local government um most uh people the the top uh kind of vote getter so far has been that meetings have not been advertised early enough uh after that there's a lack of information about how and then some people said meetings don't work don't happen at times that work for me very few people actually said they don't have time to participate which is interesting because that's a common perception uh we also asked him what areas areas do you feel government could improve um and the the number one thing here was transparency decision- making followed by engaging residents earlier on decisionmaking processes and then making it easier
026for residents to engage I'm not there is we also gave people the chance to write in some options here I'm not going to click on that now for for purposes of time but you'll be able to see all these results including the right uh through the link and then we asked some very specific questions about how you might might want to be engaged in decision making in the city so we asked a wide range of things um one do people want more input on budget decisions through processes like participatory budgeting which is something that is a New York City uh in many New York City boards now and Citywide uh do you want regular surveys from local government on key issues uh regular events where you talk with your council member and City staff better
027Council meetings with more dialogue that's a common one in some communities where they've got kind of an oldfashioned format uh for dialogue where P basically people just get two minutes with the microphone to to make their comments uh more control over zoning and other issues at the neighborhood level and an annual process for where a random sample of City residents learn about a big issue and make recommendations to council and that's a term for this a citizen's assembly so the the parti the um approval rates for each of these things are fairly High all of them over 50 the highest single thing looks like the regular events where you can talk to your council member and City staff which is a basic and commendable thing and then what measures would you like to see the
028charter to see in the charter to ensure accountability for governing bodies so people we ask people about regular rep public reporting on decisions and outcomes independent audits of government performance clear consequences for unethical Behavior or misconduct mechanisms for residents to appeal decisions and transparent decision-making processes again the respon the the approval rates of these things are are generally High overall um the mechanisms for for appeal is the the least popular but that's still over 58 58% and independent Audits and clear consequences for un behavior of the two top go-getters then at the bottom as you'll see in that we also asked people some basic demographic questions you know which zip code do you live live in in U Mount Vernon and then we ask people just to to give some description of themselves and that
029basically the way that the thing works is you can say as much or as little as you want about your political views whether you're male or female um you know um your uh your rational ethnic background your age group all those sorts of things we're running a bit high proportionally high in 50 60 70 year old so we're higher on the older end of the scale that's you know a fairly common thing uh but in terms of getting more Equitable participation in the survey getting the 20 plus people under the age of of 40 I think would be a big kind of priority moving forward so those are the those are the um uh the results so far um and in a second we'll I I'll put up the QR code or or you can
030put it up in the room depending on what's what's working here anyone have questions or comments based on what you've seen so far I I have a a question um sure so this was done online correct Tamila yeah so sorry I'm sorry I'm like where's the question coming from um yes the survey is online um it was also blasted out by email I sent it to a bunch of different Community groups it is posted the city posted it online and my expectation is that the city is going to blasted out two email groups uh two email groups this this week um so what he's showing now is the form this form was actually created by the city um and this is what's posted online and that's the QR code if you point your cameras at
031it it should give you the uh little yellow address for the survey and you can go there um and take it so you um I think he mentioned that a lot of seniors um have um but there are some seniors that don't have or don't have access to Internet or websites that are not maybe not know about this would it be okay if they mail out the surveys would that be a possibility I can certainly ask I mean obviously it's not something that we can do in the charter commission but it certainly would not hurt to um ask the city uh if they can do that I and then and when does the survey end I have not put a Clos date on it um because I want to talk to the NCL about the
032sort of the right number of responses to make actually crunching the numbers mean something um we have gotten a pretty good opening response but I wouldn't expect it would end until closer to the time that we have to vote I and I just want to give them a chance to you know crunch some numbers and give us some information about what the results of the survey show um so in my mind that is maybe a week before March 19th at least then okay and I think the uh the plan is Tamila correct me if I'm wrong to to have some face-to-face meetings right where you could be showing some of these results allowing more people to take part in the survey if they haven't already uh allow people who don't have access to the internet
033maybe to come to the meeting uh and and learn more and share some of their views so I think there'll be a range of ways for people to to participate uh yes I I don't know if you heard what Matt said but the plan is like I said I've been going out to these groups we just got this form um but I will be having these with me again I will ask about uh being able to mail them out but I might be able to take some hard copies with me um and hand them out as well um but I am planning to do several more of these before voting um which is why I ask if you know of any group that you know I can go to and talk about this and maybe
034take some of the forms um I would be happy to do that okay any questions by board members okay all right thank you okay thank you and you have my information if you have any questions you think of anything please reach out okay thank you thank you thanks everybody thanks Matt thanks Matt okay thanks Matt thank you all right so um we could go on to public comment so we're going to move on to public comment there is no legal requirement to recognize public comment at meetings of the board of education however the board recognizes the critical importance of community discourse and involvement in the education of Mount Vernon's children and accordingly members of the public are invited to speak at each regularly scheduled board meeting subject to the terms of the board policy please
035state your name and the organization if any you represent a speaker must register in advance by no later than 400 p.m. the day of the meeting by contacting the district cler clerk in person at 165 North Columbus Avenue Mount Vernon New York by phone at 914 66552 35 or by email the board welcomes all respectful comments whether praise or criticism however identifying and criticizing a specific student parent teacher administrator other Mount Vernon education official or employee is strictly prohibited any such complaint must be presented and addressed through the proper administrative channels each speaker is allowed three minutes to speak up to one additional minute may be used for the speaker to summarize and conclude their remarks if appropriate board trustees and or the superintendent or other staff members at direction of the superintendent May immediately
036respond to a speaker's remarks our first Speaker tonight is Stephanie Brown Stephanie Brown okay Kimberly for thank you thank you pleas good evening everybody good evening and young lady state that why these meetings are not broadcast in Spanish because the a majority of the people in the city speak that language and that's what she's requesting she also ask if uh the question that she submitted was not answered yet would you actually provide with a question maybe I can repeat it to them she's going to State it right now hold on okay why the students have to suffer the consequences of the decisions made by the board okay thank that was the question thank you yes sir sure student uh missos to translate I'm gonna you speak English as well so I'm I'm going to speak
037English I don't speak Spanish well yes I do speak English but majority of the community and most of the people that probably are online don't speak English and there's no one to translate for them yeah no I understand it's a good point I understand that point I appreciate that point and I'm sure we'll we'll take efforts you were the young lady who was at the meeting in December is that right who asked and the question was why why are you having to suffer consequences for our actions so first let me just say I apologize for that you didn't get appropriate answer back then I wish I had said something back in December I didn't say anything so I I'm sorry that I that I didn't say anything I will say something now to that I
038will address that now um I know it's hard to go through a change like this but Our intention is not to do it to you personally okay it's not I know it is personal and I know it feels that way personal and it should because it is it affects you but that's not our design our design is not to re particular consequences on you our our design is to improve the overall uh profile of the school district going forward right so we we look over it's more of a utilitarian approach we're looking over the whole the whole thing I would say to you your resolve going through this appearing once twice now a third time that suggests to me that you have a lot of resilience and that you're going to do quite well in
039this transition and I would ask you to help Shepherd some of your classmates who might be struggling uh through this process as well look look out for them if they're struggling because you seem to have the resolve to do it and again apologize for not responding in December and best of luck to you wait no very much I have something I have something also miss AGA we spoke the night of I apologize to you then have you you had any apology publicly from this board no no one so you've gotten no apologies from anyone as of a public so I'm I'm I'm going to piggy back off of my fellow trustee and I'm going to personally offer you a public apology for how you were treated at that town hall meeting you deserve to have
040your question answered and while all of us we not mediating moderating and only one of us here is the Acting Superintendent somebody should answered your a question or at least said we can get back to you talk to you on the side the way at least one of us did at the end of the meeting so again I apologize and we need your voice and voices like yours your teammates classmates they should come bring them with you let them come here and speak their message also in their native language and speak in English as well but come share and show up that's the most important part please continue to do this do not let anything discourage you from that thank you I will miss a agulara I did speak to you after the meeting but
041I was moderating and a town hall was presented by the school district which the superintendent is in charge of and the answers you needed should have come from her cabinet and the superintendent so why couldn't that I talked to you after the meeting so it wasn't just one you didn't talk to me you talk to M okay well you were standing there I addressed both you and your mother and the people around you so you did get an answer and I appreciate you I appreciate you coming out but it's incorrect that no one spoke to you after the meeting because it's true no one did so you weren't standing there I didn't come up to you and say you didn't come up to me you came up to my mom you there was a group
042of people there my family but you didn't come up to me you came up to my mom well good luck in your future Madam chair i' like to address the young lady as well thank you sandre Booker ma Madam chair I'd like to address the young lady as well can you hear me I think we went on to the next one have a that's also speaking to I guess there's a delay in me hearing you or responding so I would like to address the young lady if I may miss Booker just one moment all right go ahead trusty marel uh I too would like to apologize to you uh Miss agair and I would also like to say to you that although none of us wants to see what is happening happen it is an
043unfortunate situation we do apologize if you felt as though your voice was unheard I hope that you feel as though that your voice was heard tonight um since there were three other trustee members that did address you if you have any further questions please I would like to encourage you to continue to reach out if you have questions you are your mom or your family to come out and uh speak to us and if we could speak to you after the meeting um of course we would like to do that as well so we we do have email addresses that are available if you'd like to email us you can also do that and we will um try to respond to you thank you thank you say since we are doing this tonight I want
044to say to you arera listen be the voice that others do need young people and be persistent as you have been to continue to come back where you are right now demand your answers cuz you got to write so keep on keeping on and be the voice be the voice I will don't worry okay okay Shandra Booker my name is Shandra Booker I am can you speak little in in the mic bring it up thank you okay my name is Shandra Booker I am a parent here in the mount Bon City School District I have two children in the district touching on what the young lady um addressed one of the easiest ways to connect with your community is a welcome taking the time to speak to to your community being welcoming welcoming criticism as
045you say when you address your public comment that's not what the community feels here they do not feel welcomed they do not feel that their words are welcome because when they do express what they are feeling what they are going through the snickering the comments behind the microphone like we can hear you whether it's online whether it's in person we hear you and we hear that you don't welcome us you don't welcome the community you don't welcome the comments keeping a district office open when you operated completely fine out of Mount Vernon High School while closing three schools is completely laughable why are we maintaining this building for admin when you have an underutilized campus that you can obviously operate out of because you did it for months while you were renovating this building the
046reason why you're losing your students is because you have yet to address the real issue in Mount Veron City School District and that's the the lack of a substantial C curriculum for these students making sure that they are learning the things that they need to learn so that they can be successful in life making sure that they are served properly having a search and a forum for a new superintendent in a school that you're closing is the biggest slap in the face to the community I took my two children out of their previous school because our Acting Superintendent didn't do her job in her previous position to protect my children and now after them being in this flourishing environment under a wonderful principal under a wonderful set of teachers and admin I'm now being told
047that their school is being closed and that my daughter who has options for Charter because that's where our students went our students were chased to the Charter by this trustee board by admins that go unchecked for years and get to stay in their positions without being properly reprimanded even though they are doing tons of damage to our community we come to you and ask you for simple when's the last time you stepped into your schools when's the last time you walked through your schools when's the last time when it wasn't you being voted into your next seat in office did you speak to your community and find out what is really happening in the schools when did you take the time to speak to your parents to find out what's really happening how the students
048are being served in each one of their schools I Come From Brooklyn we have a very very highly maintained PTA community and our PTA has a forum on the board they are able to speak out our PTA should be able to speak without interrupting public forum to present the good that they're doing in the community please give them a platform thank you Miss B thank you c quaw quaw c quaw thank you um my name is Cynthia crenchaw and I am going to be repeating the same statements over and over again trying to save our Legacy just like the Colombia citizens try to save Columbia day and remove indous Day from the school calendar Cecil H Parker was the first black principal I mean sorry the first black teacher in malver and Dr Clinton Young
049Senior was the first black principal although you mentioned Edward Williams name was mentioned but he stood on the shoulders of Miss Parker Parker school has had such res um Renovations as new bathrooms new lighting the foyer was painted the locker was painted they re they redid the resource room with new floor walls and completed painting we had a basketball court donated by Good Morning America new prek playground fairly new cafeteria and handicap accessible for front and back this board I understand is trying to sell the schools for the dollars for these properties whatever how much that would bring I heard 34.5 million I'm not sure I don't know what it is okay so you're trying to sell our schools if this is unjustified to sell the schools and the community finds out that some of
050these board members are into real estate and will be profited from the sale of our schools they should be seriously jailed seriously jailed I understand the charter schools is trying to increase their enrollment we went through this again I bought petitions to you and gave you petitions I've asked you several times whatever happened to those petitions and do you have the date when they supposed to be coming to the board to talk about increasing their enrollment also there's some negative um things going around about this survey that you guys are doing for a superintendent I understand that this per that these that this group in Maryland that they did not do what the board wanted them to do that this survey that we going to be talking about tomorrow that this group hired the same
051associate superintendent and that we are paying them $52,000 now if you trying to throw us off by putting all these negative things out there about this group that is going to do this survey is not going to work we need a survey we need a positive one we need a Justified superintendent that's all I have to say and we are not going to just sit on our hands and let you do whatever you want to do there will be rallies there will be petitions whatever it takes we need a Justified board this board is not right you're getting rid of three schools from the last meeting all of the trustees was not on board together we had a five to four vote why was these three schools pick it's it was picked because of the
052property that you are trying to sell we are not going going to just sit on our hands we're going to fight you all the way if you make it so be it but we're going to let you know we're going to fight you and what you're doing is not right to our kids or the citizens of Mount verett it's not right and if you sell these schools and we find out that anybody up there is into real estate I hope you are jailed thank you M F Lynn Middleton truste lyet trustee Lynn Middleton good evening Mount Veron Community I am Bishop Dr Lynn M Middleton Schoolboard trustee I'm concerned about Mount Vernon City School District's future I'm concerned that some decisions that have been made are made and are still made and are made by
053those at the helm without full board awareness or consent most of the times as elected representatives it is crucial and critical that all of us are always informed and involved in the major decisions that affect our school Community where priority number one is a concern which is our children and when actions are taken without our Collective knowledge and approval it undermines the full board's Authority and can lead to outcomes that may not align with our supposed ly shed vision and values I pray I pray for those who sit at the helm of where I sit prioritize transparency which has been questionable for a long time as I have had the seat that I sit in and collaboration should not be just some of us elected representatives but all of us as a full board F
054this is Black History Month and if I had to Define by where I'm sitting my biggest question would be why are why are we celebrating what we do without knowing what the real effects of it is so where is the effect of it talking loud saying nothing we should all be here to serve the best interest of our students families and school communities but my colleagues it requires open communication and a Cooperative decisionmaking process I pray that in the days ahead it will be those of us who will work together that will help to restore trust because I'm going tell you I lost it where I sit and ensure that the full board is fully engaged in charting the district's path forward we must focus on the process and principles rather than attacking individuals be
055mindful that everybody going to get a turn me today you today there is an urgent need for transparency and an urgent need for collaboration and a need for board's rightful role in decision making we have to address concerns without escalating tensions by calling right wrong and wrong right amen amen I'm going say it is so and so it can't be do as I say do it can't be I'm going along just to get along what was the purpose of you running for where you're sitting to in a seat right now so all of this really is a springboard to negativism it speaks volumes as a trustee who will not be controlled uh call a department in this building for all the right reasons and I'm told oh she said I can't talk to you it
056speaks volumes when I walk in an office in this building and I might not finish it's okay cuz I can come back and again I'm told she can't talk to you it speaks volumes when employees invite some of us to come as trustees to Food Service meetings and the like and I'm told and we're told oh y'all can't come to the meeting it speaks volumes so as a result again it speaks volumes about how some staff is being treated Even in our district all this is a springboard to negativism employees verse their concerns about how they're afraid to speak about what's wrong that in some instances they are being treated inappropriately by some principal some just some of times without accountability because temporarily they're protected by what's wrong and protect who they know is wrong
057so on December 19th I could not get into a zoom meeting for school closures because the host principal said that orders from her boss said not to let us in my God am I done yes you're done all right cuz I know you're going to tell me to sit down when you thank [Applause] others and that ends public comments Smith so Dr Smith you want you want to do superintendent report you have a you have a superintendent report oh I didn't know that just taking all your time I was going to have okay okay um just another um curve from our regular uh we're going to have hya is the search firm that we the the board has used has selected to do the search for uh the new superintendent and they're here and I
058think Mr McCormick and Karen are here to present Ed McCormick from hya and Karen laen Gil gilan okay may be burning a good evening everyone it's a pleasure to be here and I first let me say thank you for the opportunity to help uh shape the future of the district uh certainly uh finding the next superintendent is the most important task that that boards come upon so I uh uh this is uh my seventh year with uh with hya I've uh last five years I've done about 30 uh uh searches and they're all different uh but they're all important and we managed to find the best person uh for the district uh and all the ones that I've been in we've had a high degree of success a little bit about hya National Organization with
059a national reach but a local touch we have about 130 Associates across the country we have done about 1,600 superintendent Searchers over the last 30 years uh so we have a research tested basic processes and protocols that are we are extremely proud of and has led to a great deal of success there is a uh what we'll do this evening very quickly is uh that uh Karen will take you through the three phases that we will focus on uh this is all for information and then I'll just up end up by updating you where we are in the uh protocol as it relates to the timeline uh we were we're driving towards a June uh July 1st start date but a but really a preferred candidate should be in place by April 15th cuz chances
060are we will uh not bring someone to you who's out of work and they have a exit language in their contracts so we allow about two months for them to exercise that language and be available on the start date that you're seeking so the work starts uh has already started and we will uh complete everything about uh April 15th as I mentioned but at this time I like um well I like Karen take you through those stages and then I'll I'll complete the summary at the end thank you Ed uh just a little bit more about our firm too we are the faces that you'll see in the district however we do have that full-time back office and IT staff that uh support what we do so it's more than just the two of us
061that are working on this search for you and this is the way that we approach it we do have these uh these are steps through it right now we're in u the engaging part it's about 3 to four weeks where it is very important to understand the desires of the organization now notice that's not just one person that's the organization we are while we're here and um what we're hoping for tonight is to make sure that many people will go to the survey we've heard about surveys tonight this is another survey that's very important to get your input we want the input from everybody in all constituencies that helps us understand the desires of the organization because the organization is the entire School Community we're meeting with focus groups who are representatives of some of
062the constituencies but we're even telling those who are coming to the focus groups to also on their own individually go and fill out that Sur survey it's a a brief survey it's in both English and in Spanish that we're looking for the feedback which will help us determine what are the skills the knowledge the dispositions those attributes of a successful superintendent in the Mount Vernon City School District very often leadership is contextual and the needs here are not the same as the needs in the school district next door or the next County over or on the other side of the state the needs here are specific to things that are happening here so what we're doing as the your search Consultants listening to you taking all of that input and then we will come up
063with a leadership profile that'll be the next time that you see us except for tomorrow night and and hold that thought because I want to come back to tomorrow night but uh that next time that you'll see formally is presenting the leadership profile which is taking all of the data from everyone who has put into the survey and all of the focus groups and from the community Forum will'll take that information put it into a profile and we'll also use that then to the sort through the candidates who are interested in the position because there should be a direct match from what you're looking for to what what candidates we're bringing to you and that's into that next phase of recruiting we're bringing in the widest range of candidates who meet the requirements not who
064just a bunch of candidates these are people who meet the requirements and it's the requirements that are specific to Mount Vernon then after that uh we're facilitating that selection process as the board of education does their good work in going through those candidates doing their interviews first round doing a finalist interviews and then we'll be um sending off to a third party to do a very deep background search on um successful candidate then as Mr McCormack was saying it goes into the next phase of um bringing that the transition of the new leader and we'd like to have that done by July 1st that is our Target date so speaking of those dates oh this is just um one more way of showing how all of this information the board's strategic plan the board interviews
065interviews with each individual board member the focus groups the community forums and the stakeholder survey all feeds into that Professional Profile report I guess instead of just talking I should have changed that so you could see it while I was talking all right now this is our timeline we had a plan meeting with the board on January 23rd the focus groups are happening this week and um tomorrow evening we are and it is in this room correct we're having it right here no you're having it at at the next school over next door at home school so next door I won't be here I will be next door and we're inviting everyone from the community to come to that Community forum and provide that input and we'll be asking three very simple questions and taking
066all of that information back again so we do invite you to come and if you can't um please make sure that you fill out the survey the survey runs until February 7th the profile report will be on February 13th then we'll start going through those candidates present the Slate to the board on March 24th with the initial interviews being on March 29th the finalist the next week on April 5th and that takes us to the date that um you heard Mr McCormack saying that we want to go back to the background checks and the target date for the Public Announcement would be April 15th Mr M great uh just a couple nuances as it relates to the search itself everything that you do is anonymous the uh focus groups uh we will not report anything
067by name uh we will report by group for instance I will in the process now of interview in the board members they all of their comments will be uh uh aggregated into one one section uh teachers principals all of the people that we talk to uh we will report all of them information uh by uh by that organization or by that group but there will be no names and uh we don't even take names during the session uh that's so people should feel free to share their true interest and their real feelings with us there is a uh an attempt to have a whether it's the focus group are the are the surveys uh confidentiality is is important that that is a uh will be uh will be the uh Hallmark of all of the
068all of the items that report back to you all of the reports that we make will be to the board in a public forum uh we will not have um uh two separate type reporting one for the board one it will all be uh to the board so whatever we tell the board uh the public will and uh and hear the same thing now if there is a specific uh something personal on an individual we may not do that in a public form if it's protected but the information generally speaking everything the LPR the leadership profile report uh the desired characteristics report uh will will come back to the board the Slater candidates that we bring to the board for the initial review will be 8 to 10 uh candidates uh we will not publicize
069that uh we will uh and U everyone has agreed that this is a confidential search and the reason for that is simply that there are people who would love to come to the district but they're in in a very comfortable position as they are and to have their names bannered about before even consideration by the board is unfair to them to their home districts and certainly to uh uh to your District so when we get down to Personnel pieces and applications those pieces will be done confidentially until the board is ready to announce their preferred candidate which is around April 15th there there is a so uh there is a uh there will be a time uh on the web page there the timeline will be there so you can check us against our progress
070there is a all the information that we provide to the public will be linked into that timeline into that superintendent search section of the website we uh will not um uh we will come back and provide updates to the board uh both in person and by email depending on how the schedule is running and that information will be available again to uh in the in the timeline so the progress reports that we're making uh will uh be available to the public uh as well as the board we have a there is no there is no intention uh to uh to change the information that we receive we make no judgments about it we uh uh we report it as we see it now as we hear it there is a uh so if if you
071have thin skin maybe you want don't want to listen to the report or read a report but the we will not alter the information as reported now we will not report obscene statements and and things that are off the charts but we will the information we report will be as we heard it uh and U and that would be for your review there is no uh there is no intention to to hide anything as we come forward uh in this process it's too important to uh to play Mickey Mouse games with the data and not find the best employee uh best best superintendent for the district so there is a um there we will uh the back end let me make one comment Karen mentioned it was a deep background check as you find the
072preferred candidate we will do a deep deep background check on that candidate at the uh at the will of the board uh there is a u we would do go back seven years on news and social media uh criminal background checks bankruptcies Financial background uh they know more about we probably know more about them than they know about themselves uh there will be a u there will be a a u mortgage payments we see all of those things that relates to payment of credit cards and we don't miss much it's done by a uh third party it doesn't it does not benefit us at all as an organization and they bring the report back I will receive the report if there are no red flags I will um I will report that to the board
073president and then to the board and we will H put the report itself uh store the report uh with the attorney it's uh it's very sensitive information about an individual that you're hiring uh so it should not be bannering around uh the hallways but it'll be available if ever needed at the attorney's office on the Locking key so I uh this process is a tried and true process it is uh we ensure that uh it's confidential uh that the that uh that everyone is vented through the same lens I I don't know anyone here I did know someone here 20 30 years ago but the everybody internal candidates external candidates will be vetted through the same lens uh there is is a u there we will Joe's first cousin twice removed will not be treated
074differently uh than than anyone else so very very very proud of the Integrity the transparency of the process uh the reportability of the process the frequency which we will process the process will run and the information that we will share with you that will always be available on the web page uh for your review and and feel free to of course call us in and ask any questions if something you don't like let's talk about it uh there's no reason we don't we don't hide uh I live about 6 miles up the road so I I can get here pretty quickly there is a so so the important thing if there's something that's a skew that that's out of the protocol for which I've just just slated then let me know tell me about it
075uh you know things happen as a it's not a perfect Society we can't predict the to snowstorms may change some of the dates but but we will not change the Integrity of the information as we go through it Madame chair I apologize for the lengthen of the of the response but I wanted to make sure that everyone understood their overview of the process and the fact that is that it's a true and tri process that it has has transparency and Truth uh with that I'll answer any questions that you may have yes sir so I got a couple um so regarding the the the background Deep dive you said can you please explain at the will of the board what that means I know what it means but I want it to be the people
076need to hear what it means it's not confidential uh trusty Mitchell what it what it simply meant was is that the board has approved the expend for that it was reviewed with the board during our planning session and we have Incorporated that into the process that at the end the preferred candidate will undergo a deep background check right so my understanding from verbiage and the contract there's several different packages involved for us to choose so I thought that really that's what it really meant when you said at the will of the board it's up to us to choose which one of those packages that which would will board at front at the front end that you're approved in the uh uh in the uh plan meeting I think you're talking about the advertising package and
077I want to and I I thank you for reminding me of that as a to-do for the board uh we need to we will have to decide on the final advertising package which was optional and the uh we have already put it on the hya web page which receives based on the posting that you approved uh and our web page receives about 25,000 hits a month so the word is out matter of fact we have two two uh applications in already so the uh so the so I would expect that we will have a a very Bountiful response to the to the request for applications but the uh but that um it will the advertising piece which runs the gamut anywhere from $600 to 6,000 we gave you a model of about $ 3900 as
078I remember which includes uh Ed week uh it includes the uh ASA the National superintendence Organization it includes napsi National Association of black school Educators alas group Latino group and the northeast regional uh package is a a very typical advertising package that the board will eventually should decide on has not been decided and we have not exercised those those options yet no I appreciate that so the the contract your contract you said that the timeline the timeline is going to be posted public facing so that the people can see the timeline as we go along correct that's correct is that going to be on the district site Dr Smith this is a okay will the contract also be public facing because it is public it's not confidential what we're paying them in the stipulations in
079the contract so basically what we received so far H has been posted on the website and whatever we get we post and is a contract also on the district site I haven't seen that I just seen recently mention of a survey the company will we put this the contract on the district site for the if we receive it we will their contract you're requesting it to be posted right yes yeah well we said if we okay no that's fine I haven't received it and I you know I don't have it so when we get it we'll post it when should we have that uh you have it we do we do yes we haven't right I thought we had it already still have to finalize some things so we still have to finalize some things
080but they started working already okay all right so all right that's another conversation honestly um and and the last piece is everything that you share infowise in decision making it will be with the entire board correct it will not just be with key members a few members or this sub committee and that couple people your cousin my cousin no it will not be with the entire entire board uh we have we have U uh the the board president is the key uh key uh uh point point of a contact but we copy everybody that's why on the on the planning uh document you saw all of the board members listed with their uh with their emails and so and I think we even have a the the Consolidated uh what do you call it the
081total the one with total board members that go to all board members that we will use so that there is no intent to uh to uh uh to to to disenfranchise members of the board can I just ask a question I read the letter that President on to sent out to the community on your letterhead on the hya letterhead um was that the way that that should have happened without the rest of the board members but just president Saunders and basically on hya letterhead or should it have gone out to the community um on your letterhead with your name and maybe all the board members or is that something that you you know you gave permission to do typically what I'm just asking the question cuz you know some sometimes there communication process is very
082poor the typically the um the that's an instant shot but the the typically the it uh it it does go out that way I've um uh we put it on the we put the on our letterhead because those the processes that you use and how and what said in the community uh President sers signed it as the Authority for the community so in terms of uh our ability to send information directly to the community is not non-existent so uh that's the link that ties it together any other questions to the board yeah and uh as Karen just mentioned also they recognize Hy is Agent that's working on behalf of the board okay I got one more question um and I just want you to speak to us so I can get clarity because I did
083get the flyer that was circulating which you heard mentioned from the public tonight about how and I'm not worried about what happened in Maryland cuz some things could be written but maybe not all things okay so I don't live in Maryland I live in Mount Vernon I work here I went to school here and I've been born and raised here okay so my concern is this house that I live in this house that I work in and so basically I want to know um that transparency is at a 100% level because we did read though what we did in terms of what happened in Maryland and then what you what you started with nationally never worked with so-called wasted money because you ended up right back where you started from with an interim superintendent and
084if that's the if that's something that would happen then what are we wasting our time for and our money right I'm just saying so because it's circulating okay and it has begun to circulate from Sunday that I could see all right and it's still circulating um I just would that you would bring Clarity and ter and I heard what you just said already but I just don't want to think that we are wasting our time that's all and I I don't know how to answer that question differently than I've answered it it just it wouldn't be uh it would not U it wouldn't be a lot of Integrity if I started to change answers every time question came up but the but let me just give you the the facts 93% of the people that
085we place make it through the first contract about 80% a little over 80% of the people that we place uh the are still in their jobs or have retired from their jobs so the so the sustainabil sustainability and credibility of the system is evident and can be there's a proven track record of that I would not U the so there's 70% 7% that does not make it so there's the things that happen so it's not it's not absolutely perfect uh recruiting is not a science it's an art but we do it fairly well and we have a great we have great numbers to show for that okay thank you any other questions board members just get up okay thank you Ed have a travel thank you very much and uh we shall return thank you
086yeah just very very quickly the website is up we wanted to say thank you to the folks who helped us do that very quickly and the survey link is right there on the website too so please go to it and um let people know who aren't here tonight to do the same thank you thank you thank you Dr Smith good evening Mount Vernon even I wanted Dr Smith I wanted to talk uh briefly um about the concern about immigration and I concerned that several of our students are not attending school because they believe that ice um will show up and take them and um we've received several communication guidance from our attorneys and we've received the New York State guidance on safeguarding the rights of immigrant students um a letter that will be sent out
087and put on the website de Mount Veron City School District over the past couple of weeks there have been significant changes within the government abolishing the Department of Homeland Securities policy limiting where Federal immigration enforcement acts can take take place previously spaces such as school and churches have always been considered protective areas and students still remain protected in these areas every child regardless of their immigration status has the right to a public education Under The Landmark Pryer and do Supreme Court case the State education department the Office of the Attorney General and the office of the Govern Govern of New York distributed a document to school leaders throughout the state sharing guidance on how to safeguard students during this time the district is devoted to following these guidelines in order to protect all students and
088staff to the extent possible by law under New York law all children ages 5 to 21 who have not received a high school diploma are entitled to a free public education in the School District in which they live the mount Vera city school district is dedicated to ensuring all students have equal access to an education no matter their immigration status race or ethnicity the district is committed to keeping our Scholars and staff safe while continuing to Foster an environment that is inclusive to all so that ends the superintendent's report thank you drk you so we're going to go on to uh committee [Music] reports okay budget and finance no I'm sorry trusty Ellie I'm going to start with you uh I have nothing to report this week thank you though thank you um audit committee
089trusty Kerwin so um as far as the audit committee we I don't have any report audit committee has not met yet we will we have a resolution that um that's out where the audit committee um could have met um as a whole a board as a whole we will be discussing that resolution perhaps to change it we will be discussing it with the attorneys from englman and Smith um tonight all right thank you um Finance the budget yes so the budget and finance um committee met on January 27th where we went over the preliminary information regarding the 2526 um budget uh we also discussed the revenue estimates for 25 and 26 budget um in January Governor um Hoku released um the foundation Foundation Aid projections based on that Pro projections Monon city school district is
090set to receive a 2% um increase in the foundation Aid this will equates to uh 1.6 million to our school district so we're happy for that um yes currently the superintendent of business Jose is working on the budget um he is taking in consideration the district reorganization um the first draft as he promised will be um completed the first week of March also at the budget at the time the budget committee met we reviewed the proposed budget including potentially will'll be um raising um school taxes this year that's that's also in discussion we will have to discuss it with the board as well um in addition to the 2526 budget um process we also discussed the final um analyst report that was presented to the board by Capital uh Market advisor and that status of
091the multi-year financial plan um the first draft is of that plan should be completed by March and it will be presented again to the board and shared with the public uh we also discussed the grants you know um the school district over siiz should have a lot of Grants unfortunately we the school district was not successful or have not been successful in obtaining grants thus far I think we only probably brought in about $44,000 back in October if you remember remember the school district took out a tan that's a tax anticipation note of um 15 million which is due to be repaid info by June 15 of this year 2025 the committee also discussed the taxes that's owed to the school district by the city um the business superintendent um will be um asking the
092controller to come to the board one board meeting perhaps and I'm hoping in march to share um a report from the city to um the school district and that's all I have for the budget committee I have a question thank you I have a question actually um so I we're going to have some reports is is the projected savings um since we closed those buildings are we going to see well when will the public see the projected savings based on the closing of those Builders when will that that was one of the things that that one of the several things that stopped me from being able to vote in favor um when will the public be able to see those projected savings so since that vote just went out um the business superintendent I could
093I I mean he could speak or Dr Smith could speak on that um they are working on that that's part of um the report that should be coming out but I I you know turn it over to Jose to answer that so March um after the budget committee reviews the first draft of the budget we can go over in March the projected savings okay I appreciate that um I'll aim for mid-march but I don't want to no I'm not myself you got a lot I get it um question um and this actually kind of so we've been we've been we've been constantly hearing about the downward enrollment impact of why we had to make the decisions that we've made and I think we've been looking at your projection showing us out through I think 2033
094uh correct that that was based on um the long range plan through boses right so what my question is and this is a question that I've been hearing a lot you know outside why are we what do we doing to combat that downward spiral ofr what are we doing to work to increase because the downward spiral didn't happen because the ceilings at Leadership Academy are fallen in they they're happening for different reasons uh the proposal at State Legislature um comment was made and it was very strong it said that Mount Vernon's academic record is not stellar and I don't see any real reason why that is not playing a major factor what what plans do we have and that's not really a question for you um sorry sorry is that part of the budget committee
095it's all about the dollars yeah this is all still about the dollars the question should be ask about enrollment that's not part of the budget committee that I just presented took one word but I'm going to still I'm going to continue my my conversation Dr Smith I will make a request you don't have to answer right now but I just want you to know that I for one am wondering what are we going to do and share with the public that is going to combat this downward enrollment projection that we've been seeing that drove the closing of these three buildings do you have I just want to let you know that I'm interested and there's members of the public that are as well because it looks like we're just like kind of accepting that downward
096enrollment and we're just going to walk off into the sunset and it shouldn't be the case I don't believe anyone is accepting a downward spiral nor do we want students to leave the district basically the comment that was made by the during the legislative meeting talk specifically uh about where we stand I I met with him afterwards Jose um Mr famosa and I met with Shelley Meyer Senator we met with um also um predo as well as we met with Senator Jamal Bailey basically sometimes people need clarification because he spoke in terms of students but um if J um Jamal Bailey predo and Maya was here and they asked about what's happening in our curriculum I would have Jamal Jamal speak about that because they would see the Improvement that's going on so a lot
097of what said is really hairsay while we have a long way to go we we still are improving academically and I'm glad you brought the of academic up even if it's budget because we spend a lot of time on everything except for educating our students and a lot of money it feels like a lot of money that's being spent and that's what that's really the part of it as well that's why it's money that's where the question come from what are we going to do curriculum wise academic wise to stop this continued downward spiral that's showing that's supposed to happen over the next 8 to 10 years that's what I'm saying I'm sorry but we're not the only District that it's is losing enroll it's all over the country it's all over all over people
098are losing um school districts are losing enrollment it's not just Mount Vernon but it's all over no I totally get that no I'm I'm I'm a ruining goal so accept I'm just going to look about maroon and gold right now and I understand definitely you're right 100% but I'm maroon and gold today um so the question I had was we had the revenue we saw the revenue right how it went down across x amount of years Warren you're talking to Dr Smith right uh no so I we you showed us Mr foso showed us that we saw the downward the revenue in the negative over several years right now was that also based on I would imagine cuz it's before your time so I'm not blaming you this is your predecessor that that means that
099the budget was balanced each of those years on projected or expected monies we were supposed to collect the levy or otherwise City Ed or otherwise correct yes part of the revenue based on projections yes right so after the this is my this a professional opinion I'm asking of you your professional opinion once we saw we were having an issue after the first year collecting money that was owed by the city what made us not take into consideration know that factor being what would you imagine do you think it was a sound idea to continue closing the budget and balancing the budget on projected funds that we were supposed to be receiving from the city and the tax L do you think it was a sound idea no that's your opinion I'm not holding you to
100it trust you m you know I can't answer that what I what I will tell you is going forward we have spoken about it into the budget committee we are giving very conservative numbers when it comes to revenue going forward that's good I appreciate that thank you thank you and I'm Malon all the way born raised educated here and have been for Malon students from the day I sat on this board so I don't want to hear that they're only Mal Veron I'm Mal Veron too okay next is the claims committee I do not have anything to report on the claims committee the education committee Dr um Ed education committee Sabina you have anything to report on education uh Dr dor just told me February 10th is our next meeting but um I did want
101to also share that the greenhouse initiative is going forward at the Mount verer High School we're preparing to um add the curriculum for the district am I right Dr doet yes because we have big plans for the district District as far as uh after school and there is a Saturday program so um we're inviting the three high schools uh students to come out on Saturday morning or to sign up for it this Saturday morning it's Saturday at 8 it is presently already um going on so we're hoping to have more students involved because this project is really about the Legacy for students can board members come too presently um yes we'll be we'll be yeah we wanted to have uh the board members come out when things were definitely uh full um yeah fully uh
102activated right now we're just starting it uh there are students who are really showing up okay uh there particularly three of them that are 8:00 in the morning during the winter to show up and do something extracurricular is amazing um and we're hoping it's going to support the curriculum throughout the district all right good good to hear good to hear um next committee is um facilities trusty white facilities good evening everyone evening good evening good evening good evening um I'm out of context right now but um going to go on with this little report um since January 6 to the 27th we have had extensive house inhouse repairs such as fixing broken toilet sinks piping also repairing light sensors running new power lines to at certain schools they have also painted classrooms installed lighting and
103kitchens repairing gym and locker rooms add addressing emergency rooms and and safety concerns with staff railings and emergency lighting at some of the schools um we're in compliance where compliance driven projects included includes water lead testing across all the district buildings I have to say and I'll say it again our staff is really working hard they're saving us a bunch of money okay W they're saving us some money and we appreciate them all together our custodians our um head custodians the custodians the cleaners and everyone that's involved especially um Mike and his committee thank you I want to give a shout out to the electricians and the plumbers oh that's right the electricians and the plumbers sorry we doing amazing work amazing and volunteering and maintenance uh uh supervisor thank you Mr rundi um did
104you said I know we in the in the report you said we had lead testing in the water at one of the buildings can you just confirm I'm sorry at all the buildings how were we did everything come back negative we're all set cuz I don't see the results that's all I just want to I'm making an inquiry so we we can go over the reports in the committee meeting where I can go through the results because there were multiple tests on every drain that wasn't marked not for drinking so it's it's a very extensive uh report sometimes you it's not that straight simple cut dry no but none of the drinking water is no anything that students are still drinking from or able to drink from is clean and anything that came back after
105first draw that didn't meet the standards we close it down we cap it off they come back cuz some times lines need to be flushed and they come back and reinspect for first draw and then they give the sale of approval I appreciate that so and closing in a couple other things um I know we're close to getting that ice machine and refrigerator over Benjamin Turner do we have that timeline are we looking at that happening before the close of February uh yes we do it's slated for delivery let me see February 7th okay and installation will happen same day hopefully okay that's great the the window at Denzel Wasington where are we with that the one it was crashed through so the window is slated for delivery the end of next week and installation
106that's great to hear thank you how soon will we be able to think do will that be in-house installation we be able to do it ourselves we got to get someone it it's part of the package with the company okay that's good to know and um I'm going to just make one s one statement about and it's got to do with facilities so in the gymnasium at the high school with two things first of all the weight room I was there um the we lost Gus Williams recently he's basketball and Mal ver Superstar he's he was a incredible person his jersey H is has been displayed on the Walling gymnasium but the Exhibit cases were and some of them were in the shambles I want to say that as of today those cases have been
107refurbished and they look wonderful and you can go and see Gus Williams jersey in there now it's it looks great in there so I want to shout out our people Mar Stucky thank you for your work um and in the wait room I just brought up something about the floor being broken in there so hopefully we can work on that the last thing I want to say is um uh I you know what I'm going to stop there that's it that's all I need so is that it for facilities yes okay uh trusty Ellie has something to say I had a question about so if there's a worry about lead being in the water does that mean that the water filters are going to be changed more often cuz like at school they have most
108of them have like a green yellow and red light sometimes they don't come on or sometimes they'll be red for months and nothing happens happens or like where the water filter is supposed to be and like where the um markers are supposed to be that's broken so I was wondering if that's going to be changed at all or fixed that's it so the any water that's labeled for drinking or I should say not label for drinking filter or not doesn't have any traces of Le any contaminant so it's safe to drink the filters that's that's a building issue if the filters need to be changed the building custodial department has the filters they need to change them out if they have issues they contact us we'll send out maintenance cuz sometimes there a special tool
109or we need to move supplies so they just have to communicate to us if they need assistance and we'll get right on it is that it okay Ellie yes thank you great thank you um family and Community engagement that's uh Chris and I did you have a report should I just ask Dr doet okay all right uh a R is uh trusty white yes we haven't had an HR meeting yet but our next meeting has been changed from February 6th to February 13th same time 1:00 one zo okay thank you uh so um Chris Ida anything to report the Ida will meet again next week so at our March meeting I'll have a report all right thank you um Insurance nothing to report on insurance uh policy um I the trustees had a um Retreat
110back in the fall I think it was October um and we created some policies and we created some policies that are now um being reviewed by um the in-house Council uh uh Royce Russell so he has them I'll follow up with him when he comes back back okay uh Safety and Security trusty Jenga we haven't met yet M uh special education yeah we okay uh truste marable anything on technology yes uh thank you uh last time I reported that we had utilized one of our insta and um one of our employees to help to coordinate the efforts of our bosies Tech Team um I'm sorry to report that it appears as though that is no longer happening um I'm not sure what um what transpired so I'll I'll wait until I get a report from
111uh someone um we'll let me know what actually happened um as a result of the individual being removed from coordinating those efforts uh we did not have any tech support for our state test coverage um this past um past week um productivity has gone down since that has occurred um I'm also concerned about the security issues that um our technicians um are actually have access to our access to our buildings through the use of keys they also have access to our alarm systems um so I do have some security concerns in regarding technology in addition to that it's my understanding that one of the technicians found themselves in an uncomfortable position and along with that that we've had some equipment that may also have been um has been uh uh I don't know where it
112is it's it's no longer with us we don't know where that equipment is and so uh we have not met with technology so when I meet with technology and I know Mr Ramirez I'm sure he is on it um he will get back to me to find out uh what's actually going on and if we can address it because my bigger concern is that our Consultants should not be directing the efforts of the district that the district directs the efforts of our Consultants our Consultants are um are contracted By Us in order to do the work that we authorize and it is my belief and my fear that uh this Consulting Group which is bosis um that they have um they have feel felt entitled and that they have come in and they feel as
113though they can dictate to our staff what our um efforts are and what our focus should be so um at this point I will get back to you at the next um report but I'm hoping that these issues can be resolved when we get to the next meeting that's all I have thank you trusty Marbel I have a question you're telling me that this was discussed in your committee meeting I'm telling you that during our in our we have not had a committee meeting however what I I do check in to find out where we are and I was informed that the efforts that we implemented on the committee H are no longer happening thank you thank you um Wellness committee uh trustee Mitchell um we didn't meet but in real Wellness is also emotional
114and things like that it's black history month again um I'm hoping that our schools I want to I'd love to see to the board and I'll be honest Mandela never ceases to step stand to the occasion uh with their living uh exhibit Living Museum exhibit I learn a lot even when I go trusty Middleton and I went last year it was an amazing experience as usual so I'm hoping we'll see some really incredible black black history exhibits and uh presentations uh this year please don't hesitate any school administrators I'm sorry school yeah School administrators building building principles that are hearing this now please don't hesitate to uh send out and create some sort of uh invitation for board members to come and uh see the babies show us what they know thank you so I
115am also on the wellness committee with trusty Mitchell myself trusty keran and trusty jener we had meeting with um armar and we were it was our understanding that we can just have a wellness meeting but uh it's our understanding that we um out of compliance and we need to do have um parents and students involved on that committee so um and based on the uh National lunch program the USDA National lunch program we have to engage uh parents and students so I think we need to uh try to recruit some so how are you going to uh recruit the parents is it just an all call how they show their interest they write to the uh clerk how are we going to I think we need to engage the parently aison with that help us
116to recruit parents think that would be the best thing to do right we as the parent aison in the past to please engage with the parents and get maybe one or two probably recruit some people we can't have 50 people in that committee so definitely need to have but we want some folks from the um from the from the community and that's actually for all our committees right can we have we can have uh public members for all our committees I'm just I'm talking about that one in particular I don't think I don't know about all of them we don't have uh legal here to tell us actually actually got Gus here Gus I'm sorry Gus can you answer that later on today can we have public uh public committee members for our committees for
117the district I think that would be part of our procedures and policies our committees so um when we get to that yes I don't think that has been um sused out yet with this board no I was asking is it legal is there any any legal ramifications Gus why legal sounds good thank you all right so that does it for committee reports old business I have old business you have something to say yes I'm sorry buiness there is a um sorry there is a um a company that I help facilitate to bring into the school district eloc environment they has sent out an invitation for um students to register High School 9th grade to 12th grade to for the um cyber security computer course that is been held at Sunni Westchester and that's on 17
118South Fifth Avenue they have a slot of 40 seats and so far only I think about 20 22 students that um applied I just want to encourage any um high school students that's listening to please um contact your principal because the principal received the information and the registration um package for you to apply for um the cyber security um course and it's on Saturdays The Saturdays 9 to 12: p.m. thank you and when does it start it started actually started already it started in January January 11th January to when January to May 17th and they can come anytime now can they still yeah it's still yeah registration is still going on it's it's still open because as I said they have 40 slots um what they are going to do since if mon Veron students
119are not um you know available to go or not interested they are going to the neighboring um cities to invite those students to attend okay but I encourage our students we were first first to approach um so I would like our students to attend and again it's 9th grade to 12th grade have we sent out some sort of form or all the forms the forms went out to the principls I sent it to um Dr Smith and it was disseminated to all the principls for the high school high school students We'll add it to the website add it to the okay great thank you thank you okay so uh old business this is um public comments from January 21st uh board meeting how long this is question how long are you willing to sacrifice our
120children and our city the answer was the decision to close schools and reconfigure schools is to improve the district's financial situation for the betterment of our students question two why is that why is it that no one from the board has visited the schools and worked through it leadership leadership has received mult leadership has received and has done multiple walkthroughs question why are we closing schools that are vibrant and uplifting answer there are many factors that impact the decision to close schools mainly Financial enrollment and infrastructure question why are you closing my school when there are other schools that need more money to fix them the answer is the decision is not just Financial for example it's the location and enrollment five what is it what is it that I and my classmates have to
121deal with the consequences of your mismanagement the decision to close leadership was a recommendation of the building condition survey question was it your as okay I guess this is to me was it your assertation to disrupt the meeting at the NAACP I think that what I do on my personal time is my business um question we we each will each one of you please tell me and the community why you did not answer the honor Academy student from the January 7th meeting she said she wasn't answered the answer is Vice President Kelly spoke to the student and her family that is it for for public comment answers just another reminder as you are aware that the Mal city school district has initiated a search for a new superintendent and has retained the services of Hazard
122young and AA and associat hya a consulting firm that specializes in Assisting School boards with the consideration of candidates for superintendent a key step in this process is to identify the characteristics as we will be seeking in our new super intendent an open Forum will be held Wednesday that's tomorrow February 5th from 6:30 to 8 at mver and honor Academy formerly homeschool and we should greatly appreciate their assistance okay uh this is about the r and tuckaho Joint team from last meeting I understand completely the concerns that were brought to the attention of the board but I have seen firsthand how beneficial It Is by joining keems we I'm a swimmer on the swim team and I managed the boys team and the boys team went from probably less than 10 swimmers to over 15
123in one year the boys team won their first meet last year they won multiple this year just because of these other boys from another school and even then these boys even though these boys have done Club teams they've done swimming for many years they have taught our boys and brought a competitiveness to the team that they want to be better they want to swim against them they want to swim in relays against them so I perfectly understand the concerns about money but I have perfectly seen firsthand how not only it makes students better athletes but you also make connections with other kids outside of the district and you're building a bigger community in Westchester so that would be my only comment okay we're going to move on to our resolutions can I have a motion
124for 7.1 Human Resources 128 certified motion okay I found this on the web for can I questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 7.2 approval of Human Resources resolution 120b classified motion questions concerns discussions I have a question uh um this would be directed to Mr Campell in reference to you just kind explain status I saw prob if someone is speaking could they speak into the microphone I can't hear them I'm sorry okay CU she's just going to ask him right so okay I'm not going to ask him what I'm going say is we cannot discuss individuals publicly in this forum well I'm not discussing him I'm asking what was on the tab and on the tab it said that basically he was going back to probation from
125I guess where he was cuz it just shows the amount salary Etc it's on the tab it's right there I'm sorry we won't be discussing the individual I'm not discussing it I'm just getting ready to ask a question okay your question so my question cuz I don't have to discuss I think I'm intelligent enough to know so my question is this um if somebody 26 years ago already went through probation why would they have to do probation now with an addition with the fiveyear probationary period when they've already done that if they leave a position they go back to where they were then they shouldn't have to do that of course he wants to answer you it's it's been corrected okay okay thank you Mr Campbell Dr Mr Campell all in favor oppose abstain motion
126carries can I have a motion for 7.3 request for a leave of absent second questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 8.1 authorization for the hiring of an instructor for the Ford automative after school program beginning February 10th 2025 to June 9th 2025 motion okay second questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 8 point two authorization to amend the mount Veron City School District Mentor program for new teachers approved that the January 21st 2025 board meeting motion second questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 9.1 approval of pupil Personnel Services memorandum number 14 dated February 4th 2024 2020 yes 2025 supposed to be 20 okay um can I have a sec questions concerns discussions
127all in favor I oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 10 point one authorization to correct resolution Worden for kg and D Architects for the September from the September 3rd 2024 meeting questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 11.1 approval of treasurers report for November 2024 and December 2024 motion second questions concerns discussions I had a question we've never had a presentation by the treasurer is that confidential information that we need to discuss an executive uh session if we wanted to discuss the treasurer's report it could be discussed in the public so that means that the treasurer can do a presentation in front of the board in front of the board yes okay so I'm requesting the treasure due presentation in front of the board um any
128more questions comments okay all in favor oppose abstain motion carries you have a motion for 11.2 approve the internal claims Auditors report for November 2024 and December questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries have have a motion for 11.3 Approved General funds transfers dated February 4th 2025 motion questions concerns discussions all in favor I oppose abstain motion carries I have a motion for 11.4 authorization to appropriate general purpose Grant in Aid and to amend the 2024 2025 budget canas second questions concerns discussions just a quick question is this a result of your efforts when you went up to almany is that where this came from I'm sorry could you repeat that oh was just wondering where this where this came from this general purpose 50,000 from the state no but I mean
129where did it come from that's what I'm wondering like why did the state did someone just say hey we're going to give you 50,000 bucks because we love you or what what was the purpose so they didn't directly state why like if it were because of the the if it was because of what was being stated in the advocacy going on here with the state um the state has discretion to give uh through the treasury got it I just so that's how we receive that's how re they're taking pity on us and they know we're we're so they threw us 50 Grand they did they did yeah in in short next time let's try and get add a couple zeros to that Zer right okay all in favor oppose abstain motion carries can I have
130a motion for 12.1 to enter into executive session for the purpose of discussing pending litigation the financial history of a particular person or Corporation or matters leading to their appointment employment demotion discipline suspension dismissal or removal of a particular person or Corporation and to receive legal advice on a pendant matter have a second please second I have one question um earlier I did ask the question there are several matters that are on the agenda for exact that there's no reason why they're not being discussed in front of the public I don't I didn't get an answer on that uh there were topics that should be public facing I'll pull the email back up hang on a second oh is this oh thank you okay so I also have a question when you finished trusty Mitchell
131say what now I also have a question when you're finished okay so prior your school taxes I don't see why that's something that we should be discussing in confidentiality that's District that's the public that's school taxes um I don't see why we're not discussing that in front of the public um what whatever the uh the school buildings being offline after closure should be something we talk about in front of the public um I can understand we possibly preparing for the audit and Ida uh presentations but for those in Albany February through 24th through 26 I'll leave that out of it but the things the things that I just mentioned prior school taxes uh the um the Ida present and I'm sorry the building School offline school buildings offline why are those not being discussed in
132front of the public why are they being made confidential and and of course prior year school taxes I can I answer the PRI the prior school taxes should be an executive session after we speak you could then decide the board can decide what they want to do with that what's okay I the reason I asked for exact because I cannot state it openly okay got it and the other items one of you mean the Committees for the last 10 years no no the school the school building closures after closures can someone speak into the microphone I cannot hear wanted to know why you wanted to know what committees people were on for the last 10 years not not that one yeah you know if you want to go school buildings after closure remember let me
133read it again the school closure school closures so I want to know why we can't discuss it in front of the public why is it in I wanted to talk to the trustees because as you as you heard one of the um community members said somebody said the buildings are for sale and we need to all be on one Accord as to what we're doing with the buildings that's something that we need to discuss in in private are we going to are we going to close them for a year two years what what are we going to do with them I mean I don't understand why that's not a public compensation it's their buildings really all right so is it the intention that we is it the intention that we discuss it in private and
134then bring it to the public is is that I think that's what we always do that's what we always do oh okay thank you nobody's trying to hide anything so you it will be presented to the public oh it's going to be presented to the public afterwards after you discuss it that that makes sense I just don't it just yeah okay that makes better sense thank you I appreciate it so there's motion on the floor FL I have a question I have a question ahead we can hear you hello I have a question we can hear you go ahead okay um we have a reconvened to public session if all the items on the agenda have already been addressed are we reconvening to public session only if necess no not no I don't think so
135okay thank you all in favor I any oppos abstain okay we are in executive session okay and we won't be returning thank you everyone have a good night good night