CorpusRecord 140426

AMANI CHARTER SCHOOL PUBLIC HEARING FEBRUARY 4 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MOUNT VERNON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Westchester County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
2,068 words · about 12 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] good afternoon good afternoon everyone welcome I'd like to call to order this public hearing for Armani public charter school today is Tuesday February 4th 2025 please stand for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation from the God indivisible liberty and justice thank you this public hearing refers to an application submitted to the New York State Department of Education for Armani Public Charter School the school requests to increase its grade span to include K through grade 4 to its current grade 5 through grade 8 configuration and to make a correspondent increase to its authorized enrollment from 355 students to 554 students by the 2029 2030 school year please come to the podium when your name is called you

002will have up to four minutes to speak our first speaker is Jose famosa thank you um my name is Jose foso I'm the assistant superintendent for business at Mount bernon City School District I'm really here to talk about not necessarily the the pros and cons of charter schools but the the timing and the impact this would specifically have at this time at Mount Veron City School District So currently Mount Vernon City school district has 600 97 children enrolled in over 20 charter schools from Mount Vernon in the surrounding areas charter schools are funded with public money which means fewer resources for traditional public schools at a time when Mount Bernie city school district is facing an extremely challenging combination of declining enrollment and increased student needs the last thing needed in this community is the

003expansion of a charter school in 2014 the district had an enrollment of 8,199 students in grades K through 12 subsequently losses in each of the last nine years have led to an enrollment of slightly above 6,500 students this represents nearly a 20% loss during this time period a comprehensive longrange planning study was completed by bosis that projected additional losses are expected in each of the next 10 years the forecasted 2033 enrollment of 5,168 students represents an additional loss of 20.3% when compared to the current enrollment while enrollment has been declining we have seen a sharp increase in the needs of our students over the last 5 years we have experienced over a 17.5% increase in Special Needs students the cost related to special education has increased over $20 million over this time period as a

004result of declining enrollment and rapidly increasing cost the Board of Education recently approved the closure of three school buildings in Mount Vernon City School District along with this we are also working on a 5-year plan to properly address the challenges being faced the focus should be on maximizing resources to support the Mount Vernon City School District that educates over 6,500 students and not on diverting more resources to Charter Schools as stated previously we already have 697 children from M Veron attending over 20 charter schools in the in the surrounding area thank you thank you Javi zuckman thank you um I'm writing on behalf of ammani Public Charter School to express our strong support for the expansion of ammani to include grades K through 4 beginning on September beginning in September 2025 as we continue to

005serve the mount ver Community we believe that this expansion will further our mission of providing Mount Veron New York students with the academic skills necessary to succeed in competitive middle and high school programs college and the career of their choice the concept of ammani began at a kitchen table Founders Charles and de Stern formed a coalition to bring a high- performing Charter School to Mount Vernon the Sterns along with other public school parents Educators and business people joined forces to develop the school's Charter application in 2010 the New York State education department authorized the Mani Public Charter School as the first Charter School to open in Mount Vernon with free admission open to all children including those with special needs and English language Learners like other Public Schools ammani receives the majority of its funding

006from New York State nearly all ammani Scholars reside in Mount Vernon with students admitted through a random Lottery held each April I've been a part of amman's growth for the last 12 years beginning in 2013 as our first seventh grade ELA teacher then Senior adviser and current school counselor since our first graduation in 201 uh5 in June of 2015 we have graduated over 900 Scholars of those all have gone on to competitive middle and high school programs colleges and the careers of their choice Amman Public Charter School has been committed to offering a rigorous and supportive environment IR for students in grades 5 through 8 and we are proud of the academic and personal growth our students have achieved expanding to include Elementary grades is a natural and exciting Next Step as we work to

007better serve our community's needs by adding kindergarten in first grade in 2025 we will give Young Learners the opportunity to begin their educational Journey with the same focus on excellence and individualized support that has made ammani successful in Middle School the expansion will provide our community with a consistent highquality education for students from kindergarten through Middle School ensuring that children receive a strong academic Foundation that builds upon itself year after year amman's emphasis on small class sizes personalized learning and a supportive inclusive environment will continue to be a core part of the school's Mission as we expand our grade levels we are confident that amman's growth will offer even more Mount Vernon Family amilies the opportunity to choose a school that meets the needs of their children and provides an alternative to Traditional School models

008we are committed to maintaining the highest standards of academic achievement and Community engagement and we are excited to continue our work as an integral part of the Mount Vernon educational landscape thank you for your consideration of our application to expand amanii Public Charter School we look forward to your positive response and the opportunity to continue serving our community's educational needs thank you can I hand this in um I'll will take a copy Max Smith thank you good evening my name is Max Smith I am the board chair for ammani public charter school I stand before you this evening with a proposal to expand our Charter Middle School to become a full-size Elementary School a decision that could benefit not just ammani but the entire District at a time when we Face sign ific challenges uh

009this is has been a difficult time for Mount Vernon obviously we understand three schools are closing student enrollment is down and we are facing serious budget constraints it's clear that our district is going through a period of transition one that requires careful strategic thinking to ensure the best outcomes for our students and the future of our educational system the expansion of ammani can be a part of that solution not an obstacle uh we need ammani in this school district more than ever ammani has a strong track record uh which has already been noted uh with regard to standardized testing with our students consistently outperforming many of their peers uh we also have award-winning performing arts program Championship sports teams and robust after school programs and expanding our school would not only allow us to serve

010more students but to raise the overall educ ational bar for all our children in this District um this today we're not here this is not about a competition this is about collaboration the school and the district should be partners and not adversaries we share the same goal to provide the best education possible for our students by expanding our charter school we can help ensure that more children in this District have access to a highquality education that meets their needs and prepares them for the future the parents of this community have the right to choose the educational environment that is best for their children that right is a fundamental part of what makes a thriving diverse educational system giving parents more options whether through district schools or Charter Schools helps ensure that every child has the

011chance to succeed regardless of their background or circumstance ultimately our goal must be to keep students in this district with the closure of sever several schools we risk further diminishing enrollment across the district and losing the resources needed to support all our students expanding amanii would provide stability and preserve enrollment in this District helping to maintain financial resources and a strong educational Community as a whole I ask you today to consider this proposal not just as an expansion of ammani but a vital step toward ensuring the continued success of all students in our district together as allies we can turn this moment of challenge into an opportunity for growth choice and excellence in education thank you for your time and consideration thank you Char Stern good afternoon um thank you uh to the board and

012to the state Ed Department uh for this opportunity uh to speak at this public hearing um um my remarks I I shared with the clerk earlier today so I will paraphrase um I can say um with the highest degree of confidence that I support the proposed expansion of Amman Public Charter School to the lower grades K through 4 this is a strategic move for Mount Fern and families uh who need a public school choice and this will actualize an option five years earlier than it exists today so I would say to uh my colleague and distinguished friend here Mr famosa who characterized that this was the last thing we need at this time I would say this is is the very first thing Mount Vernon needs more opportunities to attend school right here in Mount

013Vernon I think that this expansion will make amanii an even stronger program uh by way of some quick background in two in 2010 my wife Deborah Stern and I uh founded a money Public Charter School to offer families a public school choice and since that time she has served as the executive director uh while I have remained active in the growth and development of the school I I hold no official position there a couple years ago I was volun told to work on a initiative to uh see how it would be possible to have a capital project because if we expand the school we're going to need a larger building well I can tell you with certainty that the resources to do that uh absolutely exist and we have gone to the trouble of developing

014a fairly elaborate um model where we can stress test the financial implications of uh financing a new facility and I'm confident that Amman will remain a strong viable school for decades into the future um the expanded school will actually be more financially resilient than the one that we have today because the affordability analysis tells us and it's also very logical that the shared services that are distributed over a larger number of students cost less per student so the summary of it all is that the proposed expansion of Amman is sound educationally and financially and I I am delighted to be in full support of this very important Initiative for parents and children in Mount Vernon thank you thank you Sophia parande Deb bro Stern thank you so much adjust the mic okay thank you so

015much I appreciate you okay good afternoon thank you for this opportunity to speak about ammani public charter schools expansion our work is not complete here at ammani Public Charter School in fact we're just beginning to realize our full potential to serve the mount Fon Community I should have started by saying I'm Dr je Stern executive director and founder of ammani Public Charter School sorry for 14 years Amman has demonstrated its commitment to academic excellence and student growth preparing our fifth to eighth grade Scholars with the critical thinking skills needed to succeed in competitive high schools college and careers of their choice our results speak to the effectivess of our model but we know we can do more by spanning to include kindergarten through fourth grade we can begin nurturing this academic Foundation even earlier providing

016a transformative K8 educational experience this expansion isn't about just great adding grades it's about expanding opportunity and access to Quality education for more Mount Veron Families Our approach is always centered on creating an academic and personal environment where students Thrive we focus on developing the whole child through rigorous academics combined with social emotional learning our teachers and staff work tirelessly to build strong relationships with students and families creating a true community of Learners we are well prepared for this growth we have the experienced leadership dedicated teachers and strong Community Partnerships needed to successfully expand our model and I want to thank many members of our board who are here today um in support of our this program our financial stability and teachers and staff that are here too our financial stability and TR back record

017of responsible management ensures we can sustainably grow while maintaining a high quality the high quality education our community expects ramani this expansion represents hope and possibility not just for the additional students will serve but for the entire Mount Vernon Community when we lift our children through education we lift our whole families and neighborhoods as we look to the future we remain grounded in our mission while embracing this opportunity to do more our work continues because every child matters every family deserves choice and every Community benefits When schools Excel that's the whole reason and the only reason that my husband and I got into this work the expansion of a money Public Charter School to include K4 is the next step in fulfilling our promise to this community thank you for your consideration and support as

018we work together to provide more M and families with the educational opportunities they seek and deserve and I'll give you Keith mcco good evening everyone my name is Keith mccole and I'm the president of the mount Veron Federation of teachers I stand before you this evening as I did last year to be against the expansion of aanii charter school there's several reasons for this one is the district's Current financial position that everyone is well aware of we need to make sure that all the resources that the school District currently has and and is offering this the students remain intact we know that that the Board of Ed trustees have authorized the closing of three schools for next September expanding this charter school would be detrimental to the school reorganization Charters continue to drain uh School

019districts of much needed funds and resources that the students desperately need keep the resources in the existing School District that's why the mvft is opposed to this charter school expansion thank you for your time thank you that ends it for our registered registered speakers okay letters can continue letters can continue to be sent to me to my email R James mtvernoncsd.org until Friday February 7th 2025 all letters will be sent to the state next week and we will wait for notice from them did you want to say anything you good okay meeting is adjourned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.