CorpusRecord 140428

Mount Vernon Board of Education Special Meeting January 14, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MOUNT VERNON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Westchester County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,616 words · about 37 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] good evening everyone good evening good evening thank you all for coming out tonight welcome to the Mount ver City School District special board meeting today's Tuesday January 14th please stand for the pledge [Music] I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and Justice trusty McDonna present trusty maraval present trusty Mitchell present trusty Middleton present trusty and jenger here trusty white present trusty Kerwin present FP Kelly here president Saunders here okay we have our Quorum I can't see anything Rita can I have a motion for 2.1 approval of the mount fernon City School District option two school building configuration motion second questions concerns discussions question so we know that this has this is going to be

002a very difficult decision and it's not popular whatever we decide um I think that um there are some still some unreadiness um I would like to just ask the board to consider maybe delaying the vote tonight for um maybe for our next board meeting possibly I think there's still some things that items that we really need to talk about and discuss such as a redistricting plan um the reor chart phase in and phase out or dissolution depending on school closures a technology plan a HR plan a fiscal management plan and I think that we really need to kind of um dial back a little bit and I would like to hear from based on the information that we received over this weekend some of the analysis that um some some of the board trustees may

003have have looked at if we could hear from each trustee what their thoughts are at this point um I know that uh trusty mcdna and I want to say thank you because you did some of the heavy lifting and some of the hard work that I was trying to to manage myself but you did it and made it a lot easier for me um but maybe if we could start with um truste MCD and see where what his thoughts are based on some of the analysis that I know that he has created and maybe if we could go by and ask each trustee at this point what it is their thoughts are so that we can kind of hear and then maybe it would help inform our decision since this is the first time that

004the board is actually meeting at this point to actually discuss this plan um well we were here to vote we've had many uh we've had Town Halls we've had um many meetings to uh discuss this reorg um so we even had many reor committees but um I would I would like it to open up to the other board trustees to uh to uh discuss or to see where they are with this um suggestion okay I want to speak to um I did make it clear today I think when we kind of met for other reasons but um I concur with trusty marble and I made that clear today earlier today that I think we should delay and thank you Chris U for making plain what was a lottery and because of what I did read

005in terms of option two in terms of numbers in terms of um dialogue that um there's still some um questions to it that need to be answered and then these to be more dialogue to get more clarity than we don't have cuz some trustees may have it and other of us don't so I think we all need to come together again and then come back to the floor um with some kind of consensus so um that's where I am with it and um it would be great if we can definitely do that because it is certainly needed and on behalf of this community who's frustrated I'm a little frustrated and basically um there are things that I don't want to do in terms of school I don't want to close any school but if we

006can and we got to close one oh well but um just want to come to some kind of consensus better than we have not and it is important this is crucial this is critical this is our students who are first should be first and so um we know March 1st is coming but um we still got a little bit of time where we can come together so um I sure do concur with what was already said trusty Matana would you have anything to add I I do thank you um I think what I'm going to do if you don't mind it won't take long but I just want to read what I wrote this morning uh I I'll I'll summarize it because it was a little bit long but it'll give I think the community

007um the gist of of my thought process here um I I wrote to the board um good morning considering the requests from the PTA the PTA wrote a very or I should say it's the the group of ptas PTA Council PTA councils uh wrote wrote a letter requesting uh not to stop going ahead with the reorganization we know that that has to occur but asking for a a a delay so that some of the unanswered questions could get answered so I I responded once I read that saying considering this request from the PTA I suggest post postponing tonight's special meeting my understanding is that the final reorg plan is not due to the New York State education department until March 1st which gives us time to hold more Community forums back in November I suggested

008that we hold Public Work sessions I am making that suggestion again now I suggest we hold at least two Public Work sessions that would allow the public to to be present while we discuss this more thoroughly ask questions of each other and the administration also I think it would be a good idea to more formally apply practices from the process known as evidence-based decision-making a common practice in evidence based decision making is to numerically rate variables that are important for a given decision this provides a completely transparent framework by which to communicate decisions I think the district has been doing this to some extent but I think a more systematic approach is called for given the feedback from the community I went on then and listed uh eight domains and 24 variables that I think

009we could rank some of them we have discussed in some detail but not all of them I ended by saying in addition we should rate ourselves right now um with respect to important important considerations uh with regard to making school closures and there were four broad domains I thought we should self assess at this point for example the extent to which we engaged in data analysis we student performance data enrollment Trends Financial Records building conditions thoroughly reviewed most I think the area where we we most struggled was with transparency and communication uh was the rationale behind closure decisions clear clearly explained uh were were was detailed information about transition plans provided um I would say that that we fell short of the mark there so that was that's what I put out this morning in

010response to the PTA this has been a concern of mine since I first found out about this last October and I've tried to express that it's it's a shame that I think we're at this moment in time right now I I would agree with trusty marabel um and Middleton and others that we take a little bit time and and redouble our effort to focus on clear communication this is a decision that obviously schools are going to close and it will hurt when that happens change like this is not easy to do there's no way to do it without people being upset but we should at least satisfy ourselves that we did all we could to make it clear to people in the community thank you okaye [Applause] Mitchell good evening um I too share the

011same sentiment that we have to this was the topic that when it was brought up I it I met it with uh great I felt challenged I was definitely challenged by it having kids in the district right now even though they they are going to be affected because my daughter who does go to uh honor Academy even though it's her last year um you know she has friends in lower grades that are going to be impacted by the suggested closings um I want to also shout out the uh the PTA Council as well for their email which was very eloquently put very effective but very on time it was so on time and I've sat in meetings and I sat in the uh when we had the uh PCA meeting for the high school uh

012and the entire PTA Council was there um you know we've it was just to hear everybody be there we need to see y'all on a regular basis here you know what I'm saying it was good to hear you today but we would love you would love those type of emails where you reach out and tell us what's going on you are the lifeline like the parently aison Y the lifelines between the parents the public and the school um but I'm going to read what I have to say um really quick I'm going try and paraphrase um per the district site under the building reorganization information tab within the reorganization process it is clearly stated and I quote the district formed the reorganization committee and began requesting input from stakeholders seeing transparency and Community engagement as

013a vital and necessary aspect of a successful transition now I'm going stop there because the reality of what we've seen between the committee that was created of board members selected by one board member that didn't include all board members that doesn't speak transparent when we had on when we had a board member make make notice of it that it was he was in disagreement and I agreed with him that that was the definitely not the way to go that was when these subcommittees were formed and then after that the subcommittees had inconsistent meetings no real information was shared consistently everybody left those calls including myself still feeling like there was a piece missing I had only one call as part of the transition over my committee for um transportation but I also understand that our

014cabinet is the is extremely stressed extremely uh bombarded I am the Emil villain here so um when I say that I I apologize for how I've plundered your data packages my fellow board members and Dr Smith I it's not with malice intent but when we're making a decision that's going to unpack this district for the for seeable future you're not this we're not doing this again in 5 years we ain't doing it again in six it's we're going to see this impact for many years to come to have a decision like this be made and to expect us to sit here and just say all and we have not seen what we've asked for we have not seen and the public has not seen what they've asked for we have not presented it in a

015fashion that is acceptable and changable digestible to the public to the stakehold ERS of any and all ages it is not fair to ask us to make a decision like this and have any whole heart intent if we don't have what we have asked for and needed a knee-jerk decision this District needs not one more knee-jerk decision to cause us hundreds of thousands of dollars let's just put it out there's no more kneejerk decisions needed I will not be a part of that gang so if I'm speaking for myself and I know I'm not but I am speaking for myself right now there's no way that you can expect us to do this and say it's transparency when we're truly not giving each other transparency from leadership coming down it all has to change it

016has to be a rroo a reroute and we have to regroup on this entire thing and we have to make the people who are most important part of it we we had meetings where people weren't able to attend because the time of day was horrible we had meetings where public and board members were barred out intentionally due to as from instruction we had had Town Hall meetings where we had a student who spoke up and had a question and was just downright ignored like it was nothing to ignore this young lady when she got up and asked why she has to pay the consequences for the decisions we're making she was ignored that's not transparency and that's not fair that's not right so I'm speaking for my son and I'm speaking for my daughter and

017I'm speaking for everybody that talks to me that I speak to in the street that tells me how they feel that don't get up on that mic and don't necessarily for the district and can't say what they want to say because they're fearful that something's going to happen to them at their job when they report tomorrow that's all I have thank you okay call me trusty Kelly okay so there's a a motion on the floor okay um if if no one else has anything to say I I do on the question so looks like the vote is going to go ahead um I want to just let you know of another request I made in this eventuality um we were given after I put that email out and I the one that I just read

018to you asking to delay the vote um board leadership said that if we do not do this now if we don't take this vote now we will miss the cut off and we'll we'll have to lay off more staff than initially estimated um so so that was basically the ultimatum that we were given and so in response to that I asked that if that's the rationale that we have to go do this tonight or suffer even worse consequences then please make that statement UPF front so the public knows that so that in mind we will take the vote but you should understand that if if if I for example vote Yes right now it's because I've been given the information that says if you don't then you're going to do more damage to the district

019than not which I believe is is maybe specious but that's the information I have so I have a responsibility to do to do the right thing by the district and so you should know that that's that's the position we're in I have an i based on your comment I have a followup I don't comment response what would be um I I didn't even see that email um trusty mcdonal so thank you for that u i I would like to know why we cannot delay this vote well not delay the vote because we can vote tonight and if the vote is no we could what are the implications of us doing it bringing it back on Tuesday at our next board meeting so if I um I I was the one that respond responded to uh

020trusty McDon regarding if um you know there there will be some in my opinion uh with a closing schools I'm assuming that there may be some um um job implications uh I don't know the numbers but um you know we are as we know we are in financial distress so it doesn't make sense if uh if we keep all these buildings open we have buildings that are not at third of capacity so what do we do while I may so do you want to have a meeting to to talk about it right now we more than welcome to have a meeting about it well I mean we have to do something we've had many of meetings right well we're so you guys are making all these suggestions so what so tell me what you want

021to do but as a board we have not actually had an opportunity to flesh this out as a board there have been committee meetings but as a board we have not all met to actually hear what every board member thinks or what their process is because I think that we have we're a Brain Trust and that we have to listen and hear what everybody else thought think of something that I did not think of or may realize something that I did not realize so I think it's important that we hear from our our fellow board trustee members so that we can kind of really process to make a a a decision I'm not I I I know and I know based on the information that we have received and that we have heard that we

022are going to have some closures and I know that it is not easy to hear and I also know that we all there are some schools that have been you know really needed probably needed to be closed a long time ago and and and I know I know that intrinsically I know that but we have a responsibility to our community to number one let them know why we're making the decisions that we're going to have to make and that we justify those decisions based on good rationality not just because we're just Jerry picking them for whatever whatever reason for whatever reason we need to have a solid basis for why we make these decisions and again is one week from today going to going to impact us to the point that we're going to have

023um layoffs that are going to be um that that relevant I mean we're going to have layoffs we already know that and I would like to know perhaps I don't know if this is a question that maybe perhaps we can hear from one of the cabinet members um to what would be the implications of one more week what could we do in one more week that we haven't done thus far we sent out surveys we've had Town Hall meetings um it was we we've been around I've talked to community people I explained to so so I talk to my community members can can I comust McDonald wait wait wait so I think uh trusty white was speaking please don't interrupt her no one else interrupted you guys when you were speaking so M trusty white

024I mean I don't know what more we can do in within one week right now okay trusty CN you were going to say something um yeah so I just wanted to um follow up on what trusty marabel said when she said that the trustees have not met and discussed this decision I beg to defer because from October um the trustees have been meeting at each executive um meetings that we had and we all discussed this thoroughly we I mean we had the cabinet members we have the acting superintendant came in and spoke to us um in in in in extent that we all at one point agreed that we should close the schools we should move forward we heard from Capital Market that um we hired to um carry out the financial to to look

025at the financial of the school district and so we discussed this at length we left here 11:00 almost 12:00 and and for you to say that we did not discuss this in in as a as a the board is incorrect and none unless I'm missing something I think uh you left early that night trusty Middleton I'm I'm going to let um I'm not the only one that knows that we did not have detailed discussions as a board I'm going to let one of my other board trustee members comment no we did not Madam president sorry okay can I just say this let let me just say this we have had our executive sessions after these meetings in these last few meetings we talked about other things beside what we really needed to there were many

026things that we talked about and then there were many things that I heard about that others talked about that all of us as stresses didn't talk about so there were there was even an email that I read today this morning that all of a sudden it went to test scores it went to selling the properties and this was stuff the community did not hear this was stuff that I did not hear but these were questions that were asked and then it was said well we don't know yet and here here here's here's where I differ with things and my question was to our uh in coun our in-house councel is it legal and is it uh uh justifiable that our Acting Superintendent is able to make critical and crucial decisions such as this reconfiguration and

027it's not personal y'all stop taking it personal for me it's not personal okay so so is it is it justifiable to do that and to close schools where other schools that should be on the list is not on the list besides Miss Parker who was the first black teacher that Mr Holmes didn't even want her to teach white kids in the classroom but she got the job okay so so so so so my point is we got a sitting Superintendent at home we got an Acting Superintendent here so is it legal is it justifiable for somebody I don't want to say you have the expertise but maybe not that if you did in the beginning when you started the conversation we just got it in October at the executive meeting okay but if you did

028then in fact with expertise saying hey Yep this is what we need to do let's take it to the board let's take it to all the people we need to our parents our cabinet members our board members our staff members would have all been in included long before now abely and if everybody would have been able to join the bandwagon to even go into the schools that you want to close to see what really is wrong besides what you're telling us and haven't really seen it analytically and systematically on a piece of paper that we've been asking for from bosies then maybe it would just be different so those are the little things that we miss that matter and it is not that we sat in every last last few might I say um executive

029sessions and thoroughly discuss nothing maybe you did but I know L Middleton didn't but you were there okay I was yeah I was there I was there for a whole lot of other things but not a thorough discussion cuz if I was I wouldn't be having this conversation right now I beg to defer well that's you all right so we still have a motion so I don't agree all right so um I think that um answer the question please answer that legal has to answer the question so as far as your question I think I answered it in the email but I answer that was I'll answer it one line not that wasn't an answer and you you'll get approximately probably two lines in reference to this um as an Acting Superintendent the word acting

030is that they're taking the place of the superintendent and has all the powers of the superintendent to do everything and anything that the superintendent will do so to your question answer is yes and the superintendent job and responsibility is to come up with whatever ideas whatever programs whatever implementations that they want I'm sorry go ahead I'm listening to you I want to make sure I hear you um no I'm listening to you okay we'll come up with come up with come up with whatever there is for then and this is the missing piece but I think you're on it right now as far as the board is concerned then the board takes the ideas from there and then start to either vote vet ask for more information before it moves on so the superintendent presents

031the board then as a group decides if the board does not decide all the implementation goes out the window unless it's within the preview of the superintendent to act on their own so now we at the point where whether there's gaps whether it's been vetted to the fullest whether there's other questions the superintendent has presented and now it's up to the board to move forward because ultimately it is the board that makes a decision so that's why we have votes it's very difficult to do that when there are gaps I am just responding to your question and reference to that is up to the board and thank you but there are gaps trusty you were having okay I'm sorry thank you Mr Russell for that reply cuz that was a question of mine as well

032especially knowing that we have a superintendent search underway we got a new superintendent is most likely going to come in in July and this person is going to inherit what we are about to create and that is going to also be a deciding factor for anybody looking to get a new job well I'm also going to have to deal with this and it's going to be something but trusty K when I'm going to reply to you I'm only going to State make Clarity you said said that you know we we um the board agreed to closing the schools yes we agreed to closing three schools but you did not get a unanimous on which buildings there is a known fact that Parker and honor Academy and oh by the way um trusty Middleton uh Dr

033Holmes who didn't hire Miss Parker is the reason the reason why he didn't hire Miss Parker is the reason why it's now called honor Academy is because she was not the only black teacher in this District that he said in writing and New York Times that he was not going to hire black teachers in this District so but back to yeah back what I'm saying um we were we we know that there are buildings honor Academy and Parker buildings are not the buildings with the highest level of repairs for category a which are the life-threatening they're not the highest they're other buildings this conversation and ladies and gentlemen this is what this is what I've been arguing about is this conversation should not have been presented to the board pre-chosen with three Bild build already

034we should have heard a conversation that included at least six or seven buildings that we could have vetted we could have been taken to see the truth the proof we could have seen the Bose reports where Bose said this is what we have found in our analysis not based on what the district told us to say in this letter we would have been much but much better position to make a decision had we been able to vet how much of the bond money that was spent from 2020 on those those buildings and why we can't close certain buildings dependent on how much of that 2020 Bond was spent how much it's costing to repair and then the idea of the rezoning we're not transporting kids to school unless they have they're underneath that umbrella where

035there where we have where State mandated to what are we getting ready to do for all these students who are now going to have their parents we're going to have to give Mr G and everybody a bus to pay the bus take our kids all across town and get to school and that's personal money coming out of private folks pocket and I got to get to work late cuz I got to take my child because the district does not have the ability to bust students that's not new that's old no old knowledge but I will say is these buildings that were chosen are the are are my biggest issue it's not the it's definitely not it's I don't want to see teachers laid off don't never mind we're losing teachers left and right like it's

036going crazy but who wants to lay off more teachers than we already have possibly to face nobody it's not about that it's about the overarching and the fact that there's other buildings and other factors that should have been talked about and we have had time shouldn't have rushed on this the 2020 Vision took I believe at least an entire school year and that had pre-thought before I wasn't on the board then but I've heard I've done research there was pre-thought and blueprint before it was brought to fruition before it could be brought to the public spoke out took back retweaked brought it back said no talk to the people talk to the people talk to the people so this is where my challenges and my issues are not here to be the adversary right okay

037um truste white do you have any more to say no trusty Kelly trusty Jenga I'm not going to not ask you trusty Kerwin I need I just let me speak with the attorney I just have a question you want to speak to him off the off the Record I I still have something to say on the question sure do you need the attorney here no well hopefully it'll be back momentarily possibly I think the court will suffice I just wanted to just a couple of things number one this I I don't think the the the intention is to stop the reorganization from happening th this is going to happen we can't carry 16 schools this is this is a certainty that that it will happen I think for me and for other trustees right now

038if if we can delay this a little bit longer in light of the information we just received remember on Saturday we got a new file which I then took and and this this is why the trustees were thanking me because I took it and I compiled that with other information we had and that yielded some additional questions about enrollment and outstanding bonds for the for the buildings those questions went unanswered no no one answered those questions so those are I think are are fair questions to ask and but if waiting a week if that helps the community come to terms with these decisions then I think that's a respectful thing to do if it's not going to if it's not going to hurt us at all why not do that why not why not allow

039another week for people to get comfortable with what will happen I I I really don't see any problem with that unless as as the uh the board president said if we don't do it tonight there is a uh a significant risk of doing more damage to the district if that's if that's true then then then there really is no choice in the matter the word so um i' I'd like the superintendent to please answer any questions now since this special meeting was called for the um reconfiguration a week ago can we please get the answers but the trustees they have questions can we get the answers now mean well what um they had questions um if there was a a document that was presented is anybody aware of what uh trustee I think they wanted

040the Bose uh report am I right yeah well that's not that's not you guys all got that I sent I sent an Excel spreadsheet to all of the trustees you you received that on Saturday information what additional information do we need I saw I saw your your spreadsheet the long email that accompanied it what additional information all right I'll read a little bit yeah that's fine there are some enrollment variances that I'd like to understand for example the Bose reorg report dated December 3rd 2024 has 2024 enrollment at 697 students but at the Town Hall on December 6 the enrollment was said to be 6578 students and the Bose rear report has 2025 enrollment increasing from 69,000 uh 6 697 students to 6,962 students this contrasts with the Bose 2023 2024 Democrat uh demographic report

041which had uh a much lower 2025 enrollment I said why is this why are these variances I I don't assume anything nefarious I'm just trying to understand what the differences are that's what that is in addition can I mean can we have an answer to that first you can continue Chris I just want to get the answers if anybody's able to answer yes Mr Mr rundi can you answer that question you have any documents in front of you to the so the demographic study is K to 12 also that our enrollment does fluctuate quite a bit throughout the years and so they taking a snapshot in time so it's like trying to pick a stock price it's this price now but it does change but the demographic study was K to 12 there's prek in

042one there's prek not in another one but roundabout those are where the numbers are is it added District in some is it is it charter schools in some I mean is it is it including all students those are in District uh educated students I'm talking mostly about the December 3rd Bose's report which we received in early January uh that that is December 3rd contrasts with what was said at the December 6th meeting which Ed November numbers so why were the variances uh between those it was 69 100 versus 65 or difference of 329 students no I mean I I know what you're talking so if it's that number of students you're going to be one study is showing K to 12 and the other one is showing uh prek which includes cbos too um so

043that's why I could break it down for you though so so your study cuz I have the current we can pull the current enrollment right now too yeah can you put it on the screen oh it wasn't my study we pulled the enrollment for the district and in the in the demographic study it's K to 12 on the front cover of the demographic study it says K to 12 I'm not looking at the demographic study it's the December 3rd study from both if they're showing 6900 it's because they're including prek okay and you're not cuz I'm looking at the information you you guys didn't include prek when you presented to the public on the Pres I would I would have to check but on the presentation now you typically include K to 12 because those

044are the mandatory grade okay all right and prek I just want to clarify prek is Grant funded so when you have changes in the grant that number may or may not stay consistent and we already know that we're supporting $3 million out of the general fund for pre so that number the board is going to have to decide but if we continue on this deficit they're going to have to look at if they're going to continue to fund prek from the general fund yeah the other question had to do with what what we received in January was the outstanding Bond debt for for the different buildings which we asked for so we could we could bake that into our analysis and and looking at the total costs right because the the assumption that we were

045given or the understanding that we were giving is if a building has a lot of outstanding Bond debt it wouldn't make sense to close that building because would affect the ability to get uh a reimburse for that from the state correct that is correct I just want to clarify the definition of of the amount we were looking at amounts that had significant debt like uh $10 million5 $20 million if we're talking between $1 million to2 million that would not be considered significant for for this type of a thing um so we were really looking because we have some buildings that had significant Renovations um it didn't only include the 2020 Bond it also included the energy performance contract that was done so there's other debt that the B that the school has had that is

046still on the books it's not just a 2020 Vision got it right so just looking at that the question then raised there were one of the buildings that that is targeted for closure seemed on a financial basis seemed to make less sense than closing another compal building that was never discussed as a possibility so I think that's what the the question was why why that particular building I think there was a feeling among trustees that um there was sort of a rush to to do these three buildings and I know it's been said it's been said that certain buildings have been on on the Block for potential closure for for a long time um maybe that's true I haven't seen anything in writing I've heard people say that um so so those were some of

047the questions that that I put out there on Saturday which were which were not responded to I think what happens in a case like that is I I usually assume the explanation are simple right it's a different difference in time or that I made a mistake right that's another possibility but when people don't answer the questions when there's silence when already there have been questions about transparency and communication well that that gets my antenna up uh and and and and and it makes makes me worried just you know response to to uh what trusty kman said about meetings in executive session about reorganization I I would be very careful about saying that because there were no organized meetings and if there were we would have been in violation of open meeting laws talking about reorganization

048for the district is not an appropriate topic for executive session part of the reason why we couldn't all get together was because of open meeting laws right the whole the whole problem remember I pointed this out go back to October I I was asked to be part of this reorg I assumed that all trustees were part of it and they weren't then I found out when I mentioned it to a trust and they were like I don't know what you're talking about that stunned me and it and it bothered me and I thought it was wrong so I came up with a potential solution since you had mentioned that the audit committee received permission from the the school district attorney to meet as a whole right to violate open meeting laws and meet as a

049whole I went to the attorney and I said hey why don't we do that for the reorg you know you know what the attorney said right we know the Atty C said no you don't have permission to meet as an audit committee as a whole right and that and I presented that to you because you were under the impression that the attorney had written a letter saying saying that we could do that that turned out to be incorrect that was not correct so that's when I suggested look why don't we do this I will rotate off the RoR committee and let other members rotate on because it's important that we all have access to the same information to to make to make decisions we did have we discussed uh the reor in executive session yes

050however it was not an agenda item that we exclusively spoke about there are many many topics we talked about and if it were I would have said we should hold a work session to do this because the public should be involved in this please don't pretend like I didn't go back to nove go back to November and you will see I laid it out very clearly sure D that's true I'm sorry okay not discuss um the reorganization plan in executive session was I there by myself probably my point is not that we haven't touched on it me no okay all right this is not fruitful if there are questions that need to be answered because questions are on the floor please ask them and we'll look for the answers but this back and forth is

051not going to be productive I'm sorry so um we need to just no I understand yes so truste so so the the question was um to um from Chris to Jose uh regarding some enrollment figures did that answer your question justy McDon I I think it's a start I need to see the information um I want to see so if you're saying your your numbers didn't include prek and theirs did I want to see that um I want to see the breakdown um if it's not in writing then it didn't happen at this point I'll repeat my question if we delay the well not delay but if we vote no tonight if if the majority of the board votes no tonight based on Robert's Rules of Order one any one of us that vote anyone

052that votes no can ask for it to be reintroduced next week my question is again what is the implication of us of if that happens I'm waiting for an answer so I think that um the question is if we should do it if she we make this vote next week I think that may be something that you guys are floating out here well we're already in the middle of a motion so that's so my my question is Trusty MCD had some questions trusty Kelly asked if any questions were out there that they asked they be asked so that when we come back next week if we decide to come back next week we wouldn't be going through the same scenario well we have a regular board meeting next week correct that's correct okay all right

053so but we were trying to do this last week but anyway you know if there's any other questions other than trusty McDonald I have another question any other questions that you guys need to answer get answered from the from the cabinet that we can I need my question answered I think from the acting sup I mean we had a question on about layoffs being further impacted by us not making this decision theight is that true are we going to look at seeing increased layoffs if we don't make this decision tonight not tonight I'm think I mean I'm just going by what was said to us March wait a minute to hear suit right I think there's the procedural right what what is entailed in making this decision there is a timeline to our decision right

054that's correct okay so Dr so your question is whether or not a week would make a difference for us it would that's not your question's question my question is no that's my question right that's that's trusty Mar's question so you can answer her first all right I'll answer you first we we are way behind schedule you keep say we're saying March 1st is the deadline March is a weekend so we we are we can't make a move if we do not make a decision we have a budget that needs to be done there's a lot of work that needs to be done and we need to get started on it will a week make a difference it does but will it mean the question I think you have is in terms of layoff I'm answering

055two questions of one we're we're not at the point of laying people off but but at the same time a week for us is a long time we have six weeks really if that to get get to the state but we have we we need to work on a budget and that's um you might recall that a question in executive session raised the issue um of whether or not we could move forward with uh um option two and closing three schools with the exception of trusty M Mitchell everyone present said yes do you remember that no I didn't this was in executive session yes it was so we discussed it in we discussed it the idea of us moving forward with the with the idea of closing three schools I said I agreed that we

056have to do we have to close schools with what buildings we did not agree on which schools we did agree that we need to close schools but we did not agree on which schools and the information that we received we did not receive the information first of all let me let me clarify a couple of things we were asked last last meeting if we could vote on it which it wasn't even on the agenda to vote on we were asked to vote on it so we were taken by surprise that we were even going to be asked to vote on it to come back into General open session and to vote on something that we didn't even see on board docs previously so that's number one so we asked asked for information and it said

057they said they were going to give us the information on Friday evening it didn't come on Friday evening it did come on Saturday Okay so on Saturday from Saturday until now there are there are have been questions based on the data and the information that we have received and I believe that a decision like this needs to be a unanimous decision by this board and if we have three or four trustees that are still unready based on the information that we have received I think that it is prudent for us to wait a week so that we don't suffer the diet consequences in a 10year p um 10year um uh pathway I just want to piggy back a little bit too off of trusty Mitchell to Campbell wait hold on just one H second the

058the layoff question yes or no if we don't make the decision tonight will it cause additional layoffs if we don't make the decision tonight cuz it was communicated To Us by board leadership that was that was said we need to make a decision by March 1st no that's not what you said it's okay that's not what you said I'm going to say about if you don't got a receipt I can't give you any money let me say that if we don't make a decision by March 1st I really would rather hear from the soup right now you would you're repeating what I said I just want no no no no I want to hear from expain something you're quoting something that I said let me just clarify let me just clarify what I said go

059ahead okay there's the voice go ahead ahead I love you really love you I know I love you you so so I can we let the superintendent answer the question please well with your answer while you coming I know I'm just piing backing off let her answer you can ask the question it's going be pretty much the same go ahead it's okay but let her at least answer one at a time okay thank you trusty Mitchell I guess trusty Mitchell the week will not make a difference in terms of laying off people thank you very much okay okay so in that regard what I wanted to know from our HR person I know he's like oh god there she go yeah I see you but anyway let ask my question um if in fact we

060did vote tonight what is the approximation of layoffs reter staff there would be are you requesting numbers yeah I'm asking for an approximation at at least you should know by now right it doesn't you don't need to be sarcastic you said it not me I'm not sarcastic I'm just asking the question he's not prepared to answer that question tonight I'm just going to shift gears for one half second just I'm going to call out one thing cuz we it was mentioned earlier about open meetings and meetings in general in our own bylaws number 3220 is active bylaw since it was adopted July 2006 and I'll point out one thing in relation to special meeting something that has been conversation again and again we've heard it from members of the public regarding uh public comment during

061special board meetings number nine of uh of bylaw 3220 and I'm going to be quick in the case of a special board meeting with business conducted in public session as opposed to a special board meeting consisting only of an executive session public comment shall be permitted however all public comment at such a special board meeting must pertain exclusively to one or more items on that meeting's scheduled agenda a speaker wishing to make comments of any other nature may do so at the next regularly scheduled board meeting therefore at this and every special board meeting public comment should be allowed as long as it relates to the agenda item and we have been telling people for for years that they're not allowed to have public comment at special board meetings let's follow our own by laws

062let's not just change them let's not amend them let's just follow them because it's fair it's the right thing to do so um we have a motion on the floor we have a motion on the floor all in favor hi hi all oppos oppos oppos oppos opposed abstain motion carries I have a motion to adjourn the meeting motion can a motion to adjourn motion second may we have a poll all in favor I oppos do that mean each one of us has to go four of you so we voted on all of the I four of you sure yeah so out of the nine of you out of nine of you four of you we had sorry so we have um marabel opposed we had um Lynn trusty Middleton oppose we have you oppose and

063then we have uh trusty Mitchell and trusty mcdonal I POS okay okay all right and so that leaves us with five right and so right so we have all we need is five to pass the vote so all Every Other Board member the other five did vote Yes and everybody's fine with that fine as long as R yeah can you rad the uh the everybody except for myself trusty maral trusty Middleton and trusty MCD aside from us everyone else voted yes so that would me I'm not you know what every time people say names around here it gets violent so I'm going to let everybody in here if you want to raise your hand this the resolution can you just tell them what the resolution was for just clarify okay their resolution was for the

064district to move on to to option two please no one leave yet please please please listen up will you can everybody listen up can everybody listen up all right now it was asked that it be pulled we heard the Nays we did not hear the yays so a true polling is those that said no and those that said yes so either we P it or we can have those that said yes to say that they said yes from the beginning from the beginning the motion that was on the table thank in the midst of everything that happened it was resolution to move forward with the closing of three schools and to move on with the reorganization if that got lost so now once again can we have the polling please from the clerk for the

065Y was closed at that time can we have the he's asking for the we have trust recorded we have trusty Saunders trusty Kelly trusty Kerwin trusty white truste and jenger for the nades for the nades we have trusty Middleton trusty Mitchell trusty marabel and trusty McDonna now you can close up thank you motion already Clos all in favor I any oppos okay motion carries

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.