CorpusRecord 140430

Mount Vernon Board of Education Regular Meeting December 17 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / MOUNT VERNON CITY SCHOOL DISTRICT
Date
2024-12-23
Location
Westchester County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,124 words · about 68 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001please stand for the pledge I pledge allegiance to of the United States of America to the for it stands one nation godible andice for please note that trust wand white will be joining us via video conference this evening trusty McDonna pres trusty marabel present trusty Mitchell trusty Middleton present trusty and Jenga here trusty white you're is she on mute trusty white trusty white she's on mute um present trusty Kerwin present trusty Kelly and president Saunders here okay we have a quorum there is no legal requirement to recognize public comment at meetings of the board of education however the board recognizes the critical importance of community discourse and involvement in the the education of Mount Vernon's children and accordingly members of the public are invited to speak at each regularly scheduled board meeting subject to the

002terms of the board policy please state your name address and the organization if any you represent a speaker must register in advance by no later than 400 p.m. the day of the meeting by contacting the district clerk in person at 165 North Columbus Avenue mon Veron New York by phone at 914 665 5235 by email the board welcomes all respectful comments whether praise or criticism however identifying and criticizing a specific student parent teacher administrator other Mount Vernon education official or employee is strictly prohibited any such complaint must be presented and addressed through the proper administrative channels each speaker is allowed three minutes to speak up to one additional minute may be used for the speaker to summarize and conclude their remarks if appropriate board trustees Andor the superintendent or other staff members at the direction

003of the superintendent May immediately respond to a speaker remarks our first Speaker tonight is Miss Ward Miss Ward Erica Rivera Erica Rivera Vanessa Jenkins Vanessa jenin Ariana agala okay you can come up to the podium good evening um Dr Smith and Board of Trustees and all um other guests and and families and members of the community presid it um my name is Ariana agar and I am the parent of two Scholars from Mount Vernon honor Academy formerly known as homeschool and a member of the school's PTA um I requested to speak tonight because my family and other families from honor Academy are greatly concerned surprised and distressed by the news about the possible closures of three schools including honor Academy I am concerned that parents were not advised of this possibility and brought into the

004conversation sooner considering that there was a sense that there could be closures a few years ago as mentioned at the last Town Hall honor Academy has been a part of my family's life for the past nine years we appreciate the connections and supports we have made and received from the teachers administrators and other families I appreciate the open Green Space that the school has its fields which has allowed to the school to host field day and District events the TTA has sponsored events such as outdoor movie Nights Easter egg hunts and the field was a sanctuary to my family and other families during covid not all schools within the district have a field I've met families who have moved to our area or transferred to the school because of the positive reputation that Mount Vernon

005honor Academy has which is a testament to our principal and the teaching staff and support staff some who are alumni of homeschool or attended School in the district as children themselves in the initial email that went out to families about the reorganization and school closures I see that the schools listed to close may be considered marketable property but we urge the district to consider the value they have in our communities to consider what our community or other people thinking of moving to Mount Vernon can get from these schools including honor Academy such as a supportive environment classrooms that are not overcrowded and open Green Space compared to schools in the Bronx and other parts of NYC in the last two Town Halls it has been continually stated when people have complained about the school's closing

006that nothing has been decided yet every proposal includes the closing of three schools so I ask what are the potential options to actually save our schools what needs to be done to keep schools open also many families are concerned about the process being rushed and to the detriment of our school district and families wanting to stay in the district I'm concerned about families including myself my own family finding themselves scrambling to figure out school arrangements for the next year especially if they have children in different grades and I have a student a son in seventh grade and this includes families who travel by public transportation we would like to request more time from the state to evaluate our options with our families and staff involved in the process I would also like to request a

007breakdown of the repairs needed at honor Academy and that information please to be provided at the virtual meeting taking place with the school Community tomorrow evening to help our families better understand what is being considered within the possible closures thank you for your time and have a good evening thank you Brenda Crump Brenda Crump Cynthia crena Cynthia CAW um it was mentioned at the Town Hall home meeting that there was talk about schools closing if there was talk it was in the regular back room meeting and never discussed in front of the public however about five years ago Dr Hamilton Dr Hamilton suggested a proposal to make Parker the hub for all prek and kindergarten on the South Side he picked Parker because it was a solid structure school and accessible for the buses was

008important however it was rejected because the North Side schools did not have a central location for this population of students and the parents was against it the Southside parents didn't want their children bus to various locations but to stay in their own neighborhood people of color has always been bust for various reasons tired of that now you all are looking to close Parker which has a great amount of history as you know Cecil H Parker was the first black teacher to teach in Mount verer in all of Westchester County Good Morning America advertised on channel 7 about a new shiny basketball court that was built at Parker in Mount Veron due to Nesta Felix love of the kids and Parker the following programs are currently located at Parker volleyball bball Community pickle ball and basketball

009Parker has new bathrooms new light fixtures Halls are recently painted fairly new cafeteria new prek playground and more the first Wednesday of June is considered CA H Parker day the district poured money on the North side which has been discussed at board meetings at several times ignore the south side is this a form of discrimination a complete Wing was added to a Norths Side School while ignoring the Southside an example Parker is 87 years old and you predicting 24 million Williams is 92 years old and you were predicting 20 million Pennington is 93 years old older than both schools and you were saying 8 million Pennington is on the North side and look at the amount of money being placed in the schools that is older than Parker my point taken can we see what

010exactly is being done to the schools what's the breakdown you are spending our dollars and we have a right to know 62% of our dollars goes to the school board 25% goes to the city and 133% goes to the county the majority of our tax dollars goes to the district and the district books should be open to the public what kind of work are you putting into these schools there's rumors that you are keeping certain buildings open because of a friendship because of what's going on in Mount Veron friendship goes completely out the window there's been mismanagement of our tax dollars and maybe you should reduce the salary of this Administration by 5% to help in this situation and let us feel that we are all in this together thank [Applause] you thank you syia

011Tyree good evening superintendent that board trustees even when I was at the meeting La at the meeting last week y'all talked about a deficit in the city my questions to you are and I know you're going to answer them next year superintendent it was fine you said there's a decline in our enrollment why is there a decline you have two churches that you are housing I believe so I was told prek and kindergarten you can let me know if that's true or not do we pay for it and if that's the case and the kids schools are declining bring our kids back why are we housing them in two churches when you saying our schools have a declined in enrollment you paid $10,000 to one of your lawyers and you said the reason why you

012gave him the raise was because he found you a lot of money I have yet to hear what money he found for you and where did you spend this money the deficit every time you have a meeting talking about the deficit you talk about what the city owes you each time I'm hearing it it goes from 10 million last week you said it was 24 million y'all are now collecting the taxes so why are we still going up up up saying the city owe us superintendent Smith when I was at that meeting last week I did they used you as an escapegoat every question that was asked all they could say was superintendent superintendent and then one of the board's trustees said that you run the board we know that's a lot of Trustees run

013the board they tell you what to do you need to not let them use you as an escapegoat for all the stuff that's being wrong here and the mismanagement in this District so please stand up for yourself don't let them put all the weight on you when it's them that's telling you what to do thank you Mark Stucky good evening thank you for allowing me to speak this evening two things I would like to speak on real quick you had a new floor put down at denell Washington in the auditorium I'm asking for the board to go look at that floor what brought this up was because Saturday they was doing work there and I was walking my dog she's a lab and I wind up noticing that the company who was doing the floor

014work marble flooring parked their vehicle on the sidewalk in front of the auditorium entrance on Fifth Avenue we don't know how strong that is pertaining to the weight of that vehicle but I asked him can he move the vehicle off the sidewalk because it can in May is a possibility that it can crack the uh the Slate that's down there they move the vehicle away no problem and at the same time before he moved it the rubber base that they was using for that flooring they spilled some on the floor on the ground I asked me to clean it up they did it today I walked through the building this morning just to order to me you might want him saying hey why didn't you go through channels I wanted to see what I wanted

015to see before anything and I noticed on the staircase if you standing on the outside of the facility of the B school on the left side of the staircase that goes into the auditorium on the staircase you have some foot markings with this rubber on it now they need to clean that up it's not a big dig thing there but they need to clean it up with some acetone and whatever they use to get it up so I continue to walk through and check the building check the carpet to make sure there was no damage done to it nobody knew nobody knows what's taking place because we don't have anyone to watch over those who are doing the work in this District but the best thing that about that is they come and take all

016our money and keep it going so I walked the stage floor what was the purpose of changing the flooring on that stage the purpose was because they said the nails was popping up yes it was because a year ago I did the some repair work that of those nails that was popping up on on a Christmas program that was having there and I took care of those issues we spent the district spent good money of the taxpayers money to do that floor with the nails whatever they did is popping up out of the floor so our children can still walk across they do their dancing and get cut once blood is shown you got a lawsuit look at it walk the floors not only that but you have what they if they took Plywood And

017buted it up to join the plywood together it's now sinking in certain spots if this floor was done at kigu Hall or Radio City it would be Flor fless you have the Whipples which is the beams that are underneath all of this that's supposed to be straight they're wind up being shown it's a horrible job have somebody look at it because it doesn't make no sense for the taxpayers to spend the money everybody why up saying Stucky everywhere no God put me in places so I can see what's taking place so I can wind up being the voice for my home okay the next thing wind up being you had a meeting that took place a town hall meeting the other night a week ago it was disrespectful to our leader the mayor of the

018city of Mount Veron cutting her off getting her to get to her point or whatever the case may be if she's the leader and she wants to talk for an hour she gots that right she's our leader of the city of Mount Vernon to disrespect our leader a woman is disrespectful you're fighting against each other of color it doesn't make no sense that's why we can't get along we fight every time we turn around my time is up for something and the whole thing is you don't want to listen to me because I don't hold PhD but I tell you one thing I'm smarter than everybody who sits up here thank you Jeff Monroe [Music] this is the best practice application of this microphone just so you know good evening everyone good evening Community um

019I come back with uh some bittersweet uh feelings because I love being in community with my community um regardless of what we're going through I'm here for it because I'm one with you but I'm also I'm also I think in an in an a moment of opportunity because this crisis that we're all collectively in in offers in my mind an opportunity to retrench to kind of re retread an old Tire if you will um and I'm going to say quickly what I can in the next two and a half minutes because I've said this before I went to the uh The Forum last the town hall Forum last week and I found that I'm probably one of the least informed people in the room because I've just been busy doing a lot of things like

020a lot of people including other services around the Community um but as an organizer and um as a media professional I understood that you have very limited uh minutes in a day to communicate an idea to an audience that's even if it's a fixed audience a workingclass audience that's there in the middle of an evening is not going to be there all night in the hot Auditorium uh able to communicate their actual articulated or or well even their best articulated thoughts in a hot Auditorium um when they could have been informed more appropriately over time um in in a kind of drip fashion if you will so that important aspects key facts can be even in the town hall format can be delivered in a way that was not ever going to work in a

021two or threeh hour uh single night fashion I think that's a statement of the obvious but the less obvious thing is that um I've said before that we should practice the democratic practice of town hall functions not just once a quarter or once a crisis but actual ongoing practice where you invite people physically into a space because we're still human beings we're social animals and you can enable it with zoom and whatever other electronic devices available but people need to be able to be considered valuable enough to bring into physical space with each other I think if you inform people on an ongoing basis and you still can uh and frankly although this sounds like a critique I'm I'm offering it as a solution because I'm willing to help um in fact one of my

022parallel questions for this is why we don't have a television production curriculum and if we do I'd like to know what you're actually doing with that studio and or the other media facilities in the district you can do a lot more than whatever the kind of instinctive propaganda inclinations might be for an official when you have media in front of you but the community needs to be heard you need to actually bring a mic and a camera to the community and ask them what think of ideas when you've thought them out uh you might you might not like what they say uh they might not even say things that are appropriate quote unquote but it's a so-called democracy you have to give it a chance at some point uh this this practice of kind of

023elitist um you know go to your friends go to the churches go to your sers and your frats see what they say go to corporations uh it hasn't worked it's not going to work and um quite frankly I think this country is in a place where common people are finding that their power is uh best invested outside of the system and I'm trying to give you the best and humbly I would say sage advice to give democracy a chance because you don't want people trying extra judicial extra legal matters to take power into their own hands um I'm an organizer and I know what people are capable of when they're angry and desperate um I'm just ad I'm just advising you as a citizen and as as a neighbor and and as a uh a

024coworker if you will I'm willing to help you if you're willing to help us and help yourself thank you thank you thank you John Galo good evening my name is John Gallagher I reside at 165 East devonia Avenue and I represent Property Owners uh CPO is our original organization I've been out of these last couple of meetings board meetings here and I've sat down and listened to uh some of the presentations given by the public I'm here to correct some of the mistakes and misstatements that have been made here one of the ones that was made here recently was that the city budget is $79 million it is not $79 million it's 148 million and it's going to be 152 because our mayor who has her supports come up here and attack this school district

025uh is looking for about a 5% increase I was told tonight by somebody in the controller's office that that budget may be down to 4% so she's uh decreasing it by 1% where your money has been going ladies and gentlemen if you pay taxes and if you pay them through a morgage company or a bank your increases have been to the city not to the school district we've had people come up here talking about one plays a recording about the 0% tax increase but what they fail to add is that yes property taxes make up a big part of the revenue for school district or municipality and whatnot but they also get what is called state aid and federal aid and if you go look at the records for the Mount Vernon School District you

026will see that state aid has gone up significantly over the past few years so therefore when you look at a tax increase you have to say to yourself wait a minute the rate of inflation for the last couple years has been running about 2% and if indeed that state aid has been increased federal aid has been increased we've getting we're getting grant money which now is questional because of the mismanagement and let's throw that in let's talk about the mismanagement that is going on in previous administrations in the school district and probably people on the uh side of the Board of Education here uh there was whistleblowers that came forth to my organization and these people that ran for office that wanted a 0% increase and bear in mind was very important to realize is

027that it's not the school board that passes the budget it's the voters and the voters said yes to 0% increase significantly over the last few years and meaning what we want done is we want audits done and I talked to several people about a lot of homeowners and the people that ran for the board the last couple years years that are in favor of audits would say to me Mr Gallagher why don't we need an audit well go ask yourself why the feds are in the school district right now and they've been here for almost two years their investigation is active which means something is going on and there is reason to be here and I'm not blaming anybody here that's sitting on the board right now whatever this goes back years with his been

028mismanagement so why would people if you got any sense in your in your head say I'm going to give you more money so that you can misspend it no the people that ran for the board that I supported as homeowners groups that are also parents that have children in our school system said to me Mr Gallagher we want to know where our money is being spent so before you throw more money into an organization know where your money is being spent and these board members that were put on that got elected call for Audits and once again that's why the feds are here and they're finding stuff out your concern should be very simply is what are they going to do about it what are they going to do about it this mayor wants to

029run the school district well let me tell you about what this mayor has done with tax increases and whatnot over 30% the last couple of years her new ideas to bring Revenue in are bringing more marijuana shops to Mount Vernon oh we really need that don't we she want she wants to increase your sales tax she also wants to bring pilots and they are a disaster this community they of wrap up very quickly the developers of these Pilots do not pay taxes they pay payment in Le of taxes and it's very minimal but they wind up sending 30 or more kids to our school district which cost us tons of money taxpayers and by the way your assess values have G gone down in the city a result of our mayor in the administration just

030bear that in mind thank you thank you thank you and that ends our public comments for this evening superintendent report my good evening everyone we have two presentations tonight we we will start with Dr Gail White Wallace she will be presenting on the universal pre kindergarten Dr Gail White Wallace this will be followed by Capital [Music] markets come on we got lighten up this room come on y'all you hear the children I know I can I I be what I want to be what I if I work harded it I I go where I want to be I I thank you Oscar all right everyone good evening I had to lighten it up in here a little bit for those those of you who do not know me I am the class of 1997 Mount

031Vernon High School and I'm also the proud director of the prek program the g&t program and in my words all things fabulous here in the district of Mount Vernon first I want to address the board thank you for having me this evening my colleagues on the deis my staff could all the prease staff who are here tonight please stand up y'all better make some noise thank you to my colleagues I see Dr Waterman in the front to uh there's some parents here today that I've had the pleasure of interacting with also our parently aison and the community so today we're going to talk a little bit not about restructuring I want everybody to put that on a back burner we're going to talk about something that's very important to any system that is taking advantage

032of the Milestone tonight we're going to talk about why the ages of 3.5 to 5 are the most important years of any student in this District scientifically physiologically and and emotionally then we're going to talk about how the district over the last 5 years has capitalized on the Milestone next slide Oscar I'm not working I'm not working so for those of you who are unfamiliar with developmental milestones we know that when a child is from birth to 5 years old they have the most cognitive and intellectual growth that they will ever have in their entire lifespan so what does that mean for the m veren city school district that means this is the time to harness our Learners next slide this is the time to create the foundation so that they can be successful at

033steam so they can dance across that floor at Denzel and so that they can Master fixing that car or being a chef out the mount ver and high School CTE program at this time from 3.5 to 5: this is where our students begin to develop educational understanding to give them a foundation it also provides them with the practice they need for fine motor skills in addition self-regulation getting rid and reducing Tantrums understanding how to harness your emotions and most of all social and language skills next slide this is more than instruction this is a moral imperative not only are we as a district instructing students for their physiological psychological and educational and social growth but we are also reinvesting into the city of Mal Veron because what you don't realize is students that are in

034early childhood programs such as prek 3 and prek4 allow parents such as myself to go back to work it allows families to earn and thus pay their taxes and thus continue the cycle of fiduciary responsibility to their city in addition the moral imperative of our Early Childhood Program ensures that the city of Mount Vernon continues to have a strong Legacy the long-term effects are measurable and we'll talk a little bit about that as we go through the presentation next slide now Early Childhood programs there are many but the key for the mount Veron city school district is that it is a quality program on your screen you're going to see about 12 indicators of what a quality program consists of all of our teachers are certified most of them duly certified all of our staff

035and our cbos except for one staff member has a full New York state certification those and community- based organizations are working with me to get their child development credentials from New York State we provide more than 15 hours of highquality professional development we continue to maintain the ratio of 8 students and two teachers we provide meals we provide instruction we provide iPads we provide even the materials to make sure that we remove every barrier for students that includes clothing students that includes school supplies that also includes starting January 21st after Care thank you Dr dogget next slide so how do we know that it's high quality we surveyed our customers last year 80% of the prek parents completed our end of the year survey and the data speaks for itself how do we know it's

036high quality the proof is in the parents the parents gave us 4.84 stars out of five stars overall in our program 95% of the parents believed their children were ready for pre for kindergarten 87% and I need y'all to look at that number 87% believed our family programming was exceptional or good that means out of the 408 students I had enrolled 87% of the parents engaged in one or more after evening or weekend item with their children no other department has that type of parenting engagement last but not least to my staff 97% of the parents who took the survey expressed they were happy and received regular communication about their child's progress next slide so what does high quality mean for the milestone in M Veron we have literacy instruction math instruction and technology that

037are all thematically integrated if anybody understands early childhood education and making sure students meet the mark it must be interdisciplinary from the ELA themes social studies science they are all webbed together to ensure that we are scaffolding for students and providing them with background knowledge next slide literacy instruction is vertically articulated to the K through two Continuum with the implementation of Foundations in all classrooms we also use not only synthetics but we also use Letter People letter of the week site words readers and songs last year we graduated 20% of our students that were reading on kindergarten level already that came in without letter name knowledge in order to reach all of our students we have small group instruction as well as Center practice and watersford online learning next slide and of course trusty Kelly

038is not here now y'all knew this slide was for her the science of reading slide I put where I gotta call her uh so the science of reading is the Hot Topic right now and what we've done in this slide is just shown that we are being very deliberate to correlate the work that we're doing in the classroom to the requirements of the science of reading next slide take a look at my babies oh my Miss D you see yourself up there girl all right so what you're seeing right there are students engaging with readers you see students writing letters and engaging in some literacy small group and whole group instruction next slide our mathematics instruction makes Dr Jag nandon very proud as we provide core instruction but also ensure that we're giving tiered small

039group and manipulative instruction to students next slide there's some small group math aren't those students cute and they're smart and they're working so hard at their counting their onetoone correspondence and by the end of the year we're doing word problems addition and subtraction next slide our program design is one that is unique in the district because of the importance of the Milestone we begin with family involvement monthly worksh shops we visit homes we have counseling support and CPS support we then couple that with social emotional development giving direct lessons and implementing research based Second Step curriculum we have collaborative culminating projects and you guys know I'm the director of all parties and all things fabulous so you know in prek we are partying every month we are celebrating every month and if you stop by

040the classrooms this week you will see our Polar Express where children are building life-size trains to watch The Polar Express movie and engage in a plethora of activities and finally immersive experiences cooking building and of course tons of trips we could not do this without the parents because this Milestone has to be support supported with a very clean and strong f family involvement this is our first Vip Day this year it's called very important person you may not have a quote unquote dad quote unquote mom but you have a person that's important to you and in each school we had a VIP day where parents came to hang out with us and they also articulate with our social workers next slide our social workers and our teachers ensure that students are getting all the social

041and emotional development support that is needed through whole class group counseling and individual counseling what I love the best about our program is how we support and do Behavior modifications at home when needing needed and provide parents with the resources that they may need here are just some pictures of our CH Miss Ellena you see yourself up there girl all right next slide Partnerships so uh Dr Smith is it okay if I address the question about the schools in the churches okay so I'm going to address that next slide so yes we have two programs and two churches that are required by the state so when you receive prek grant money you are required to employ community-based organizations to provide instructions to students those Community Based organization are chosen by RFP which happens every 5

042years on a cycle there are two providers friendship for TTS who service the Lincoln and home students because Lincoln School does not have prek as well as Our Lady of Victory who service Grimes school because Grimes does not have prek Hamilton school which does not have prek and the spillover for Mandela and Columbus because they are always full within one month of registration so we are able to fill all of our classes using the support of our community-based organizations please note that prek requires specialized classrooms so just because there's room does not mean the classrooms are 900 square ft have regulation bathrooms and have egresses outside to exit the building friendship for Tots and Our Lady of Victory are all of the programs that we have in the district here are some pictures from Friendship

043for Tots and some of the activities that they do Our Lady of Victory located on the west side also provides the same instruction we make sure that we provide professional development to those cbos that we do to our teaching staff Partnerships in the community we don't do this alone the Family Services of Westchester provides clinical support in conjunction with us Iona university helps us with social work interns and for our students who are not eating healthy who's the chair of the health and wellness committee up here on the table Warren is that you we do five sessions with feeding Westchester for our students who don't eat well we do cooking classes with them and their families to get them to eat healthy feeding West also helps us feed our students and gives us donations of

044food for those children who need food and groceries at home the pajama program our newest program where yes we sleep train children in prek do you know that pre students are up to 1: in the morning 2 in the morning 3 in the morning on iPads when parents are sleeping 133% of our students do not get enough sleep per night so we are partnering with the pajama program and doing sleep training for those students and those families almost done let's talk about how all of these things have impacted the most important milestone for our students in Mount Veron take a look at your data from last Academic Year look at those numbers look at the end of the year 93% student students letter naming 82% letter sound 70% counting and that's not 1 to 10

045that is 1 to 50 shapes 85% proficiency number discrimination 95% proficiency counting sets of numbers 88% operations which is a kindergarten skill addition and subtraction 79% of enrolled students number naming 80% and story retail and comprehension are 90% by graduation by the third week of June this is our current enrollment 410 students 23 classrooms and we're still registering last but not least why this Milestone is so important I have been working in this District for 22 years I have taught at six schools I've had seven different positions and I am a struck to watch fouryear olds come to us with the following issues no toileting no potty training deficiency in speech and language Behavior challenges excessive Tantrums struggle socializing and playing F motor deficits and low understanding there are children who come to us in

046September who have never seen a book but they know what an iPad is and the data shows take a look at your screening data the blue or students who are at a correct developmental level the yellow the gray and the orange represents all the students who are not meeting their developmental milestones and most of that lies in speech and language cuz they're not talking they're not having conversations and F motor because they swipe they don't write so when they come to us in prek I'm guaranteeing that that Milestone all of those things are developed because we put pens and pencils and crayons and paints in their hand and puzzles in their hands and books in their hands from day one this is our data I want you guys to have this in your head because

047I'm coming back at the end of the year so you see where our students have started as of October 1st 0% letter sounds 50% letter naming we're going to move all those bars up our goal this year is a minimum of 80% in every single area and how are we doing this partnering partnering with the parents during parent teacher conference night we meet with every parent and we create a goals and Improvement form that they must sign we also provide a planned home for every single student we have Saturday Academy for students as well as monthly family workshops and regular meetings our goals are 80% my goal when we started and Miss Saunders do you remember when we had 50 kids in prek we are at 408 we are at 78% of students who are

048in kindergarten being in prek the goal is 95% of the students who come to us in kindergarten to have been sitting in a prek classroom who are ready for kindergarten and our long-term goals are to make sure look at those kids at Parker in our summer program our goal is to have all 90% here our goal is for parents not to have to choose not to come here because we're going to give them before care we're going to give them after care and we are going to add language immersion for our enl students those are our hopes and dreams so I ask you m Vernon what are you going to do with the most important milestone in our students life you're going to enroll them in prek and from there we move forward to Master

049Three which is where our superintendent is taking us thank you all I'm ready for the questions Dr Dr Gail White Wallace thank you once again as always your energy is through the roof and you never fail to deliver overd deliver thank you um if nothing else this presentation just totally cements the absolute necessity The crucial of prek for our children there is no vision of education for any child without the the beginning which is prek um so this was very uh very helpful especially the metrics showing the outcomes and where we started to where we ended at the end of the the last school year um how I'm going to bring a question up on the situation because we know about the reorg that's happening we've talked about it and we know the buildings are

050being closed what is going to be the impact to our prek we have I as far as I know we've been challenged with being able to car to all the students in our district who truly need prek which is why we have friendship for tods and OLV helping but but what are we going to do when we've got three less buildings and the prek how is it going to do we have a plan what do you see so planning can't begin until we have a solid configuration right so once there's a determination of the configuration and Mr formoso has nailed down the numbers I could give you a clear plan I mean do I have a plan y'all know me I got three plans actually five I've got five plans um to really be fiscally

051responsible to not only the district but also to the students so once we have a configuration I'm ready to rock and roll um Jose and I have had uh some preliminary talks but I'm not going to I'm not going to sugarcoat it little people are expensive they're expensive um and the state mandate to ratio is really what makes makes it expensive um and we're going to have to work as a community and a team to make sure that we make sure every child harnesses what happens during this Milestone if you tell me you got a plan three through five I feel a lot better still want to see everything come to fruition thank you I got you question um how many of the 408 well first of all I'd like to just Cong um say

052thank you Dr Gail White Wallace on your presentation I concur with truste Mitchell um how many of the 408 410 students that are in our programs currently actually graduate or move on through our educational system to 12th grade or we do we have any of that data we don't but I do have so it's it's so funny the last time I did the study the attrition rate was about 28% on average per year um attrition and unfortunately that's that's sort of the cycle here in Mount Vernon and I mean that's something we could discuss but it's around 28% attrition and there are a number of reasons when we talk to parents one reason is parents can't afford to live in Mal Veron the rent is high they they just can't afford to live here or

053the conditions that they're living in they they cannot stay in those conditions um in some of the buildings so that's those are two reasons when I talk to parents three of course you have children that go to private school so we're accounting for those students who are going to Independent Schools we also have students that are homeless so we lose some homeless students as they get their permanent housing we lose them also to attrition those are usually our our top five reasons for attrition in the district okay thank you for that information the other question that I have is what how much funding comes from from actual grants or aid from the state or from other sources versus actual District funds so you're looking at approximately last year we were at 4332 million from the

054state and I think 1.68 Jose from general fund around there something like that okay okay and one last question what do you know what the research says about the reduction of prek programs in districts such as Mount Veron so when you look at the New York State website and they you talk about allocations right allocations with your state funding has really been steady and at a plateau for the last eight years so people are really utilizing their state funds fund and minimizing of any program really comes on the general fund side but you you know your places like New York City Peak Skill Asing Yonkers they're still running most of their programs at the regular capacity programs that are reduced most times are prek-3 programs as people really believe that that is teetering in daycare

055versus being a schoolage child so that would be where you would see most reductions in urban areas because you have to you have to contract out for prek-3 because most schools are not prepared in the physical plant for those students thank you so much any other questions any other uh achievement questions longterm anybody have other any other questions you know I got the numbers right here thank you Dr White thank you so much everyone and if I don't see you have a happy and wonderful holiday season you [Applause] too Mr famosa would you like to introduce our next presenters um so tonight we have Capital Market advisers there are are fiscal advisors um coming to present the fiscal analysis uh of the school district we are also engaged with them to do a multi-year financial

056plan as well so tonight they're just going to present a PowerPoint based on the analysis which uh goes back roughly six years for the district okay thanks good we ready very good thank you and good evening everyone I'm I'm Richard tortur I'm the president of capital markets advisors uh with me this evening is my colleague Tom vakis who's a vice president with our firm um CMA is an independent financial advisor we work with um approximately 150 school districts across New York State as well as approximately 200 municipalities counties cities towns Villages fire districts Etc um our primary business is to assist our clients as they enter the capital markets to borrow funds to fund their construction projects their Acquisitions of equipment Etc or to issue debt to fund cash flow needs they issue tax anticipation

057notes in anticipation of real property tax receipts or Revenue anticipation notes in anticipation of state aid what we're here to talk to you tonight about is another part of our business which we call Strategic Consulting uh we have a practice that we've had for about excuse me about eight years where we had advise clients on day-to-day activities with the intention of improving their operations improving their efficiency improving their effectiveness Etc um what we're presenting on tonight is the first step of what will be a multi-step plan to get the district in touch with its Financial condition so the fiscal conditions analysis is the first part of this this multi-step process what we did in this uh process is we reviewed existing audited Financial dat data prepared by your Auditors we looked at economic and demographic

058data provided to us by the state by the county by the federal government and we constructed an overview as to where the district has been over the last five or six years and where it is present and our goal is to just give you awareness of your financial condition before we engage in the Second Step which will be a multi-year financial plan so let me pass the ball to Tom vakis who's going to talk about and present the plan to you thank you and good evening uh as Rich mentioned if we could go to the next slide uh this fiscal conditions analysis is the first of two reports that that we intent to start preparing um showing where the district has been over the last several years and where it currently is as far as

059it's it's uh fiscal condition is concerned um that would lead into a forward-looking multi-year plan um that we hope to to complete in the next several months um working with the district's Administration um looking back and where the district is presently unfortunately shows a pretty Grim financial position um the district has a recent history of running significant operating deficits on an annual basis uh and that's resulted in a significant draw on the district's reserves um um so much so that the the district's unassigned fund balance or a rainy day fund really has dropped to a negative position a significant negative $5 million position um which is concerning and unsustainable on a long-term uh path um and what that's led to um in part is a withdrawal of the district's credit ratings from the two major

060credit rating agencies Moody's investor service and standard and Po's Global ratings um due to a lack of financial information being provided to those rating agencies they've withdrawn the district's credit rating um that can have significant repercussions uh if the district needed to access the capital markets and issue debt for capital projects infrastructure improvements it would have severely limited access to Capital and it would be doing so at significantly increased costs um next slide so this is a brief overview of what the district's operations have looked like over the last six years um as you can see from that middle red row there has been a history of operating deficits and multi-million dollar operating deficits um on an annual basis the the district's revenues have come in under budget um the districts some of the district's

061expenses have also come in under budget but not enough to offset the the lack of of uh sustainable Revenue um and again that led to to a severe draw on the district's reserves next slide so this is a little more detail about the fund balance specifically um and just to to give a brief overview the restriced reserves that you see here those have been um assigned by The District in the board for for specific purposes that they've been reserved for um the assigned fund balance has also been appropriated for specific uh expenditures that they plan to to be to be spent on the unassigned is the the most troubling um that's what you have in reserve to pay for any unanticipated expenditures things that might not have been foreseen um that you want to have

062ample reserve your rainy day fund we would expect a district of Mount Vernon size to have somewhere closer to 20 to $30 million in unassigned fund balance that would be what we consider a healthy Reserve level uh it's about two months of operations um the fact that there's a negative position right now is is concerning and something that needs to be addressed um sooner rather than later next slide this chart here shows the how the district has performed compared to what was originally budgeted um so you'll see the variances in the the revenue line have been consistently negative meaning that the district has brought in less Revenue than what was originally budgeted for um you'll see on the expenditure side there have Al there have been positive variances meaning expenditures have come in under budget

063which is a good thing um However the fact that the total variances have been positive meaning the district's performed better than what was budgeted but there have still been significant operating deficits um is concerning um that means that there was already built into the budget a an expectation that Reserve levels were going to be drawn down on and even if the district performed better than what was budgeted it's still needed to draw down on those reserves so is really relying on the fund balance and the reserves in the bank to pay for operations and again it's just not a sustainable practice and something that needs to be brought uh more in line going forward next slide thank you um and in part of that is a I think was mentioned earlier is a a decline

064in enrollment for the district um over the last 10 years the district has seen about a 20% decline in its enrollment which is significant and over the next 10 years uh a further decline of about 20% is expected and that can impact things like your state aid um those revenues might decrease accordingly as a result of the the declining enrollment um part of that can be attributed to to more children going to Charter Schools um over the last 10 years the Charter School enrollment for district students has more than doubled um so that's part of the the reason for the the declining enrollment but certainly isn't the entire reason um and as a result of all that most of the district's buildings are significantly under capacity uh for as far as how many students are

065being taught there um almost all buildings have less than 50% capacity and a lot of those are probably in the 25 to 35% um capacity uh threshold uh this table here is from The District's long-term uh excuse me building condition study um showing the capital infrastructure improvements that would be deemed needed to keep the buildings in working condition um the priority one and priority 2 columns are items that might be expected to be done done in the next 3 to 5 years the priority three column are more long-term projects uh and priority four are considered Next Generation project so maybe 20 20 years plus um but even just looking at Priority One and priority two it's about $46 million worth of projects there if the district were to take on all of those that would

066increase the debt load by about by almost 50% um and for a situation where the finances are already stressed to be able to accommodate an additional 50% of Debt Service would be uh difficult uh the fiscal stress monitoring system is something that's put out by the Office of the State Controller it's an assessment of a jurisdiction's financial position um and really meant to be used as a a warning sign for for communities um to let them know if they are be either susceptible to to fiscal stress if they're in a stressful position already um so over the last five years the district has been either susceptible or significantly fiscally stressed um as reported by osc um which is something that we wouldn't typically expect from school districts school districts have a significant amount of state

067aid um support um and a lot of resources that can that typically put them in a good financial position however Mount Vernon was the considered the second most fiscally stressed School District in New York based on its 2023 audit um and uh a lot of that had to do with the low levels of of cash of liquidity and the low Reserve levels so it really all keeps coming back to that um situation where the the district's low reserves are putting it at a at a dis disadvantageous position so I mentioned earlier about the withdrawal of the uh major rating agencies um Moody's withdrew the district's rating in 2023 S&P earlier this year and that was due to a lack of receipt of financial information from the district and and again it puts the district that

068in an unfortunate position um as your cost of capital increases due to uh no rating um so here is just a chart showing the different rating categories that those companies have and it's really like a like a credit score for for an individual um it's an assessment an a thirdparty assessment of the district's ability and willingness to pay its debt service um so it can range anywhere from AAA through double A categories single a and then baaa before it gets to sub-investment grade so the district had been a baa to and a triple B plus prior to its ratings being withdrawn which is on the lower end but still an investment grade rating which would give you access to the capital markets to finance capital projects to finance cash flow needs um because those ratings

069have been withdrawn it doesn't eliminate access to those to those markets the district just issued a tax anticipation note not too long ago however it's doing so at significantly increased interest curs and this chart is just a further illustration of that it shows uh the different interest rate scales for different uh rated credits um so we would expect a AAA credit to be to have the lowest interest rates associated with its debt and increasing across doublea single a and then finally baa um so a lack of a credit rating really puts the district even further to the right of this chart um and again just increases the interest that would be Associated on any debt that is needed to be issued so where where does the district go from here um we will be undertaking

070a long-term multi-year financial plan working with the District administration to put together a financial forecast of where we expect the district's finances to what we expect the district's finances to look like over the next 3 to 5 years and what we plan to do is come up with a list of recommendations initiatives we think could be implemented and forecast out what kind of impact those might have on the districts over the next five years um so that would include a couple of different scenarios what the district would look like if it did nothing everything kept kind of rolling along as it is what it would look like if the most attainable initiatives were implemented and what would what it would look like if everything was able to be implemented over the next five years and

071we can forecast that out see what kind of impact each initiative would have um report back to the board to to kind of make an assessment and uh ultimately take action on what would be implemented and this would be a living document that we would look to update periodically once or twice a year at least um so as results begin to come to fruition we can see how the district's picture is changing and what steps need to be taken to either correct course keep on course if things are are improving and what uh the district's options are um periodically so that concludes our presentation we be happy to take any questions from the board I have a question regarding the one of the reasons why we The Moody score and S&P score were removed you

072mentioned it had to do with untimely reporting now this District we've not been we've been without a treasurer for several years were we excused from reporting just because of that or should we still have been doing our due diligence to ensure that it was done is there some excuse like is there something that how does that work there there can be some flexibility given by the rating agencies um some Lee way however ultimately they do need uh up-to-date financial information to maintain their assessments okay and um you also mentioned that there was basically over forecasting for expectations of Revenue in several points in different years what key factors Drive coming up with those forecasted amounts that we could be so far off and none of us sitting in these seats no matter what committee what

073position no one knew none of us could know or none or whatever whatever any whatever how could it possibly have gone how could that have happened of of course I wasn't in the rooms when the the budgets were prepared a loaded question the certainly a big portion of that was was real property taxes not being remitted to the district by the city um there were also significant overestimations in state aid being received um so it may have it could have been just an over Reliance on fund balance um not taking into account actual results from prior years instead maintaining budgeted numbers to forecast forward um that can lead to a continuation of those overestimations can you um speak to what the tax cap is is we took several years we we didn't raise taxes it

074was a zero tax levy um can you explain how the tax cap works and what our school district basically failed to collect on when we needed to and how that tax cap was impacted every year because I have an understanding but I want to hear from somebody who's smarter than me uh so the tax cap is a a state imposed cap on how much the district can increase its property taxes on an annual basis um it's typically 2% or the level of inflation over the past year um so you are allowed to override that but if a super majority of the district voters uh agree to it um but that can but what if you're within that tax cap it only needs a simple majority to be passed um as any District budget would be

075by not increasing property taxes over the years it's a compounding effect because every year that if you had increased say a little bit the property taxes you would have gained that increase on an annual basis and and it would have compounded from there um so it it was just Revenue that that wasn't ultimately collected that may have been able to be and how would you say that impacted our fund balance just we understand the city the city not paying us a portion of a dropping a bucket to the considerable budget for the entire school year you know the 11 million is a drop compared to the entire entire school budget for the year but it's constantly been held up that that's the only reason why we're here and I and I'd like I'd like an

076expert to explain is that really the heaviest part of this is it an even bag what is it really uh from our analysis that was the biggest driver of the underfunded revenues um it's hard for me to say if that was the was that for that for each year for each year okay each of the last or so years right um so it obviously wasn't the only contributing factor but it it did seem to be the most significant you uh thank you thank you for this presentation um my first I've got a couple questions to try and just understand understand this I'm I'm I'm new to the board of July so I'm trying to get a grasp on this um the two things I'm most concerned about are this unassigned fund balance this 4.9 or

077so million dollar that's a deficit in the UN unassigned F fund balance my understanding was that assignments of the fund balance cannot cause a negative unassigned fund balance is is that correct and if that's true how did that how is it possible that that would that would be the case that we would have a negative 4.9 million if it's if it's structurally not something that you can do uh by the rules so the assignments are a little bit separate and apart from the unassigned okay um and it can get a little confusing with with accounting rules of what's been reserved for specific purposes okay um that Limits The District's flexibility and how those funds can be used the unassigned is more so what at this point with the deficit position what the district owes itself

078and needs to pay itself because it either outstanding liabilities or debts that are owed payments that are owed that haven't been made and are and are obligated by the district got it and so that will need to be corrected I I in this next budget correct it needs to be brought back to zero I would think at least certainly as soon as possible right I mean is there is there a timeline on that a state imposed timeline the state controller is going to say Hey listen you can't no we could carry it we could carry that negative balance it it technically yes it just may impact the district's ability to pay its bills got it okay um and the other thing is just the so the overall just sort of understanding the picture here I

079get this piece about overestimating the revenues and that's a combination of maybe thinking more state aid was going to be coming in than actually did uh and anticipating a closer to 100% of the tax revenue coming in when really it was more like 97 96 something like that and that compounding over over years um a over Reliance on the fund balance drawing that down from 2015 until it got to negative declining enrollment due to things like Charter Schools changing demographics uh forces you to then carry more infrastructure than is needed the infrastructure is old and expensive so overall the cost structure is a real expensive cost structure for the district um and then on top of that most recently I've been thinking about these Pilots these the the giveaways from the Industrial Development agency these

08030-year Pilots which generally mean the developers get about a 50% break on average over 30 years we've got a whole bunch of those out there we've got new ones coming online those be those make it tricky to predict the revenue as well so am I on the right track and thinking that all it's an Confluence of these variables have come together and people weren't attending to all these details over over the last decade and all of a sudden Wham we're we're in a real bind is that a fair assessment absolutely I I mean each of these issues on its own may not be uh debilitating to the district but taking as a whole and really take taking a step back and look them at them together unfortunately paints a pretty poor picture I don't know

081if I necessarily have a question or more so a comment but I feel for you for to be the bearer of this news number one but I also thank you for helping us to sound the alarm to our community that we have to understand that based on the data based on the numbers based on the information that we have been hearing over the past couple of months cuz I like um trusty mcdna have just recently um come to the board that although all of these um town halls and all this information that our community unfortunately has been receiving in the last few weeks and months it's unfortunate but I think that we have to come to a realization that unfortunate as it may be that in order for us to continue to educate the children

082in this community that we are going to have to make some really really really tough heartbreaking heart-wrenching decisions and it is unfortunate that we have come to this place but it is real and I just want to commend the staff I want to commend the trustees that have been on this journey and it's unfortunate that no one saw this coming before today some people may have seen it but everyone wasn't on this board all at the same time some people had information some people didn't have information some people were shared information some people were not shared information but now that all of the covers have been removed and it has been unveiled I think that we really need to search in ourselves and say look we know that we don't want to be here we

083don't want to be here I'm born and raised in this town worked in this town taught in this town served in this town and it is hard to hear the information that we heard tonight and that we've been hearing over the past couple of months but I just ask and I appeal to our community to look at what is being recommended and that we and I know that we don't want to lose our schools and we want the communities that we have seen but unfortunately we are going to have to make some tough choices in order to bring some of it back so I just needed to say that any other questions okay thank you thank you appreciate you thank you so much um we're going to move on to I move on to our

084committee reports committee reports um trusty keran audit committee any audit we don't we don't have anything on the audit committee um as far as the budget committee we just heard um from Capital Market so that covers the budget committee report oh I'm sorry uh sorry thank you um I was saying as far as the budget committee um report we just heard from Capital Market so that covers um the budget committee um report thank you thank you I have uh the claims committee I have nothing uh facilities committee is Trusty white um on the line trusty white what happened to trusty white trusty white do you have anything for the facilities committee I'll mute yourself you're muted trusty white always forget to turn that off we did have a HR meeting no facilities excuse me facilities

085do you have anything for facilities we're doing facilities first yes we had a HR meeting no facilities okay oh you ask for facilities just going to no oh no I do want to say that the girls bathrooms locks and Hamilton has been fixed and um I'm waiting for a report about the ice machines and the refrigeration at put my glasses on Benjamin Turner or have they been repaired or are we searching for parts no one can hear me yes that's it yes okay anything that you needed to add trusty Mitchell for that report um you know the uh it's for there the btms refrigerators have to be replaced that's my understanding that was the last communication um 6 months ago uh we're still just waiting for that to happen we did follow up on it

086thank you trusty white for uh bringing that out and yeah yes of course the locks at uh Hamilton on the girls bathroom um there when is our next facilities meeting after after the holidays it will be I'll let you many months after okay we all right so hopefully scheduled yeah y that's good thank you otherwise that have nothing very little um okay family and Community Eng trustee Middleton Dr is good evening um there was a um we didn't have a parent engagement meeting we had a um subcommittee parent involvement day meeting which is a subcommittee of the parent engagement meeting on December 12th um I wasn't able to attend that meeting we had an IA meeting scheduled at the same time but discussed um that meeting was read run by um Dr Gail White Wallace

087and she's the chair of the parent involvement day so during that meeting um she discussed the the format of parent involvement day which is going to be held on Monday February 10th um it was also discussed at at meeting with the options for what parent involvement day will look like whether it be a full day a half day um how the history of parent involvement day will be incorporated in additionally there's going to be a planning team that's going to set up the workshops and there'll be a follow-up meeting um in January to finalize what parent involvement day will look like we have a parent engagement meeting scheduled for this Thursday at six o'clock on December 19th but this may have to be rescheduled due to several conflicts several concerts several events going on that

088night so we may have to reschedule our full parent engagement committee meeting in January thank you Dr dogget Human Resources truste white Meg again yes we did have a HR meeting um this month we talked mainly about the reor and not too much we can say until we get a definite option that we're definitely going to use and how we will be dividing teachers um psychologist and the bulk of the staff how they will be transferred around but it's really nothing much to say I know we have FMLA we had about um five people on FMLA this month and basically that's it okay trusty McDonna Ida okay excuse me thank you trusty uh yeah so the Ida um the Industrial Development agency met on the 13th of December and I'm going to give you a

089brief on that and I think as we hear it's it's more and more important to understand what what's at stake here when when we're looking at these Pilots um the 115 South mquest Pilot I mentioned was approved in fact they had a groundbreaking ceremony today strangely the the mayor who chairs the Ida did not mention it at the meeting that there was a groundbreaking that tells you how proud they are of this project that it was not even mentioned as I told you last time the the minimum Gap in funding that will come to the student come to the district from the students in there is about $4.6 million it's more likely to be more because they underestimated the students in that building they used a multiplier of 0.15 which means 15 kids per 100

090units it's probably going to be quite a bit more than that the the multiplier is probably more like 0. 22 so that's a difference of across 315 units you know uh whatever 20 kids over 30 years that's that adds up to a lot of money um so that's 115 mquest and that's done um the next project is Q West I think I mentioned that that one came before that's 2 128 units these are all below market rate U and by the way the information on 115 mquest is up on the website just be warned it says uh affordable end market rate that's incorrect there are are no market rate apartments in 115 South mquest and the the closest you get are a few units at 90% the average is 60% of the area meean income

091Qs is 228 units that project showed a funding gap of about 2.9 Million um at the meeting the developer offered an additional million dollar to the school district as a lump hunt sum payment UPF front when construction starts they anticipate that to be next June so that means they bump that from a million to 2 million and on the back end in years 16 through 30 they doubled that offer to about 1.1 million um if you bring that to today's dollars it drops to maybe a little bit under a million um so still the funding Gap there is about 1.5 million but that's a lot less than what 115 mcqueston was I think going forward there are at least three more projects almost identical to these they're all um at about 60% Ami this is

092a this is a a I see it now it's a blueprint that these for profit housing developers use they go through the planning process they get linked in with the community they hang around for a couple of years they get all the approvals then they go to the Ida that's where they make their money they make their money there and these projects are all financed by us it's all financed with public debt Deb they put very very little of their own money in and then typically we'll see what happens after they get paid all their money they get all their money paid in the first 15 years so my concern is what do they do after they don't have a profit motive anymore so I think going forward we should probably talk about you know

093um we don't have a vote there but um how to magnify this important topic um this cost our school district literally millions of dollars um there are at least a thousand units already out there and there's a thousand units coming so I think we need to pay very close attention to this and just keep talking about it okay thank you thanks so much trusty McDon um Insurance committee trusty Corwin was there any report for no don't have any report policy the policy committee met last week um we um decided on a policy that uh Royce Russell is going to read the first reading of tonight trusty Russell I mean trusty Russell you don't want that job you can't do it now oh oh because we're in committee meetings I'm sorry well we're gonna have that

094first reading tonight okay okay Safety and Security she stepped away she okay special education there's no meeting technology trusty maravel we'll be meeting in January thank you okay and wellness do we skip security she's not here we had we did have a meeting with security uh with the security team uh Mr rundi uh uh was there with us uh we didn't get to cover much but I think we're we're going to cover more at the next one all right um it's kind of kind of related to security the building condition survey you said was on the district site where um under the build-in condition Serv yeah under the reor under the reor are you back to facilities or you jumped over Wellness you don't have a wellness no well I no no no I'm asking

095I'm asking about the BCS report because it does relate that's I Wasing I caught the dots yes so it's under the reorganization no I spiled it's under the reorganization section of the website if you go to why we need to make a change now you'll find it the building conditions the building so what it is is the entire survey is 176 Pages uh that is a streamlined version identifying what priority 1 two 3 and four is it shows uh each building how much the total cost of each priority it's categorized electrical infrastructure Roofing uh Windows Plumbing so it it really breaks down the cost it in a digestible form to give anyone who wants to see the current state of the buildings thank you I appreciate that so um also Wellness committee met and it

096was a good meeting uh we met with Aram Mark who was our first Food Service Company we discussed moldy pancakes and things like that and raw meat and all these other different things and how they going to move and how they've been moving uh we got some coverage on some new tactics that they're using to make sure that we're State and audit ready and we should always understand it um money comes from the state that covers the food the money comes from the state that covers these refrigerators to be replaced money comes from the state for everything is called cafeteria fund or the C fund the money comes from the state to cover all those things including payment to aramar so aromar is paid from the state as well as money's collected all of it's

097collected through the school district and aramar is paid from so it's imperative that they do their best to treat and service our children at the utmost so the meeting we had was it gave good indicators that that's the direction they're moving they're starting to move um so we're looking forward to uh meeting with them more on a monthly basis we discussed at that meeting we'd like Dr Smith to always to be there it's always good to have her there but we learned about State Readiness for audits to make sure that we're ready in case we're audited on production records and things things like that measures are taken to make sure the um Aram walk employees are trained and supervised properly the way they should be the way they should be um so overall was a

098good meeting and I hope that at the next month's meeting we'll have some sort of uh information more that we can share at uh for my committee report on it thank you Trustin Trustin Jenga did you have anything else to add to fac to the security no okay thank I'm sorry all right so that ends the committee report and followup on Old business um questions from the December 3rd uh regular board meeting there was a question as to what is going on with the district's view on the New York State proposal for regionalization there's nothing on the website the answer is we are in the beginning stage of this discussion districts are not required to participate we will update the community in the future so now we could move on to the resolutions oh I'm

099sorry that's the end that's the end of follow-ups is that really the end of follow-ups there's no other questions that from the prior meetings that were most people make statements they don't ask questions I'm talking about no just for the actual questions not the statements that are we not going to from the last meeting or the one before that we're not do the question that was the only one there was a teacher that came that they answered that question that's what you're refer no I'm not talking about no there were several parents and otherwise who ask questions that I didn't hear any answers today but okay well I I'll we'll talk offline we'll talk offline okay so we're going to the um resolutions okay can I have a motion for 5.1 Human Resources 1177a certified

100motion second questions concerns discussions all in favor I oppose abstain motion carries can I have a motion for five point2 Human Resources 117b classified motion second questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain I don't think Wanda's sound is on oh oh she's on mute Wanda can you turn your unmute yourself thank you I'm sorry okay again all right okay motion carries can I have a motion for 5.3 request for leave of absence motion who was second that was trusty McDon okayy questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose abstain motion carries can I have a motion for 6.1 authorization to hire staff at the Mount Vernon Aquatic Facility June to Spring motion second questions concerns discussions all all in favor oppose oppose abstain motion carries C have a motion for 7.1 approval of pupil Personnel

101Services memorandum number 11 dated December 17 2024 motion second questions concerns discussions all in favor oppos oppose abstain motion carries c a motion for 8.1 approved General funds transfer purchase order increases dated December 177 second questions concerns discussions all in favor oppose oppose that was what happened she oh okay I think she's um got a 30 delay okay abstain okay motion carries C have a motion for 8.2 approve the treasurer's report dated July through October motion questions concerns discussions all in favor I oppose abstain motion carries have a motion for 8.3 approve the internal claims Auditors report dated July through October motion second questions concerns discussions all in favor I oppose abstain motion carries c a motion for 9.1 authorization to enter into a letter of agreement with Hazard has at Associates motion questions concerns

102discussions all in favor I oppose abstain motion carries C have a motion for 9.2 first reading of policy 7300 .60 Amendment to the code of conduct student searches and interrogations can I have a motion motion okay second okay I got Mitchell questions concerns discussions question can we just get a a simple understanding how this amendment addresses the concerns of the public and the parents regarding the pad Downs that were happening sure once I read it we'll go to that okay okay questions concerns discussions all in favor I O oppose abstain you abstaining from the reading yeah okay was it for the it's for the reading yeah yeah we're not going to vote on it tonight we're just reading okay okay and motion carries you can go ahead Mr just uh so we all understand so

103they may be so that we can clear up any misunderstandings what happens is this is the first reading and then after the first reading board members will have a chance to those who are not on the policy committee will have a chance to review this amendment and then either one we can decide to have a second reading or bypass that and then there will be a vote at some later date and that's when you can vote abstain yay or nay to that end today is just uh first reading so for the public those that are out there that may not remember this even though it was highly visible in the community uh this uh Amendment to the code of conduct came from the physical searches that were conducted at steam Academy and there was questions

104as to whether or not that was in line with the code of conduct and there was I guess concern Conns that tabled one students civil rights Fourth Amendment rights versus The District's liability financially if something were uh to happen because we are in charge of the care of kids so based upon that the policy committee which is headed by myself uh truste Middleton uh trusty njenga trusty Kerwin trusty Saunders and trust and uh Dr Kelly I want to say thank you for your input and thank you for being a checks and balances to anything that I drafted that you checked and said well let's think about it differently so now this is time for the reading so 73006 Amendment for code of conduct Starts Now this document was once a one page document now it

105is a three and a half page document I tried to cover uh as much ground as possible um I think policies and code of conducts are documents that should be Revisited based upon circumstances so um it says 73006 Amendment to the code of conduct student searches and interrogations the board of education is committed to ensuring that atmosphere on school property and school functions that is safe and orderly to achieve this kind of environment any School official authorized to impose disciplinary consequences on a student may question a student about an alleged violation of law or district code of conduct students are not entitled to any Miranda type warnings before being questioned by school officials nor are school officials required to contact students parents Guardians before questioning the student however school officials will tell all students why

106they are being questioned we move to physical pat down searches the board board authorizes super authorizes the superintendent of Stu of schools or their designes building principles or their designes assistant principles the school nurse District security officials to conduct searches of students and their belongings before searching a student the authorized School official must inquire about the student's possession of physical evidence which violates the district code of conduct such searches May generally only be performed when the authorized School official has Reasonable Suspicion to believe that the search will yield evidence of a violation of law or the district code of conduct defining Reasonable Suspicion Reasonable Suspicion is defined as follows one metal detector alert or x-ray machine alert metal detector alerts the superintendent of schools or the destine building principles or the dese assistant principles the

107school nurse uh the district security officials that a metallic item is on a student's person two handheld wand alerts a handheld wand alerts the superintendent of schools or their dese building principal or their dese assistant principal the school nurse or District security officials to the presence of a metallic item on the student's person so those are grounds for which if those things were to ring you would go and to another stage and we'll get to that on the next page um reliable informant is another grounds for reasonable suspicion so what is a reliable informant or information reliable information is provided to the super attendant of schools or their desinee building principal or their dese assistant principal the school nurse the district Security office from a reliable informant indicating that a student has a prohibited item

108such as a weapon or drugs possessing consuming selling Distributing or exchanging alcoholic beverages or illegal substances or being under the influence of either illegal substances including but not limited to inhalant Edibles cocaine LSD PCP aetam synthetic canbids heroin steroids vaping lookalike drugs and any substance commonly referred to as designer drugs including illegal narcotics unprescribed medication marijuana Vape devices or alcohol this list is not exhaustive of illicit drugs for personal observation the superintendent of school or their dese building principal or their dese assistant principal the school nurse or the district security officials personally observe the student concealing a weapon metallic or non-metallic or drugs on their person regardless of whether a metal detector x-ray machine handheld wand alerts occurs reliable informance is defined as it may include students volunteers bystanders or individuals with a verified track

109record of providing accurate information information from an informant may also be reliable if corroborated by another source or if a student provides a statement against their own interest and what is a statement against the own interest a student says I have this item on me when question a verified track record is not mandatory to be considered a reliable format that means that you do not have to have a list of students that say they gave information before to believe a student for the first time generally individuals who have previously provided inaccurate information will not be deemed reliable physical search and pat down protocol all searches must be conducted to respect the students dignity and privacy while ensuring the safety of the school Community voluntary disclosure the student can voluntarily retrieve or reveal the items in

110question before conducting a physical search so this is more to your question uh trusty uh Mitchell um so the procedure would be you come through the metal detector or your hand handheld wand if something were to go off if something were to ring the first stage is to say student a do you have something on you that's that's what we call either a self- search or a chance for someone to give an admission against their own interest so the other students could be safe metal detector scan after retrieval or voluntary disclosure of the students must pass through a metal detector and or undergo a scam with a hand handheld wand that means after the student is questioned asked to reveal whatever is in their pocket whatever they may have whatever is ringing they then still

111go through the metal detector or still is wanded and if something Rings again then you proceed to the physical search pat down a physical search if the metal detector or wand signals the presence of an item an unauthorized School official May conduct the pat down so it's after all those matrices or all those scenarios that then the pat toown comes into play guiding principles searches should only be conducted when necessary and is sensitive to the students dignity all search should be conducted in a manner that respects the dignity and privacy of the student while ensuring the safety and the well-being of all individuals within the school environment authorized personnel must adhere to this policy to ensure compliance with legal and ethical standards whenever practical uh searches will be conducted in the privacy of administrative offices

112and students will be present will be present when their possessions are being searched searches will be limited to to the extent necessary to locate the evidence sort protocol for schools or events without metal detectors or handheld wands sometimes you go to event at a school there is no metal detector there is no wand it may be a basketball game it may be a softball game it may be an after school program in the absence of metal detectors on hand wands the following protocol must be followed students self- search the superintendent of schools or the design building principles or the design assistant principal School nurses uh District security officers will instruct the student to perform a self- search empty your pockets empty everything around you uh go in your back pockets take out what's there the

113student must remove all items from their person including Pockets bags or any concealed items step two pat down search Once the self search is completed the superintendent of schools or their design building principles or their design assistant principal school nurse or District security officers or officials will perform a pat down search of the student these procedures apply specifically when metal detectors or handheld wands are unavailable this policy underscores the district's commitment to creating safe environment while safeguarding the rights and well-being of all students so that is the first reading and is always up for discussion in executive session okay can I have a motion for 10.1 to enter into executive session for the purpose of discuss in pendent litigation to Financial history of particular person or Corporation or matters leading to the appointment employment demotion

114discipline suspension dismissal or removal of a particular person or Corporation and to receive legal advice on a pendent matter have a motion please motion second second okay all in favor any oppos motion carries we are in we will not be reach session will not be returning everyone have a nice holiday

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.