001from The Interpreter just give us one we sort that out all right let's try it one more time we call this meeting into order of the business meeting and budget public hearing Tuesday February 4th 202 five Madam clerk roll call please Mr princi here Mr here Mr here Mr head Dr haris Mohamed president MREs here we thank you at this time we that there the motion um put in place to allow M rzy to participate virtually as she's out of town mam I move that we allow M Ry to participate virtually it's been moved by Dr Harris Muhammad and seconded by Miss uh Burke to allow for Miss Rizzy uh to participate virtually mad cler call Mr P yes Mr C yes yes Mr HED yes Mr Dr Harris Mohamed yes m b yes Mr
002jaar yes Mand yes and now we will have our translation services announcement thank you good evening everyone if anyone here needs interpretation from English to Spanish we do have interpreters available in the back of the room for anyone that's watching online we have interpretation available through Zoom as well thank you thank you next item up is Pledge of Allegiance and moment of silence U Mr to the flag of the United States of America and to the rep for it stands one nation now we have 1.04 approv the minutes of the December 2nd January 8th and January 13th have yes ma'am Madam chair thank you I move that we approve the minutes of the December 2nd 2024 meeting January the 8th 2025 meeting and January the 13th 2025 school board meetings second it's been moved by
003Dr Harris Mohamed executed by Miss Burke to approve the minutes for December 1st 2024 for January 8th and January 13th of 2025 school board meetings Madam cler Mr person yes Mr car yes Mr yes Mr yes M yes yes Mr jaar yes M Fernandez yes motion passes thank you before we adopt the agenda it's my understanding that there are a few amendments that are requested Mr person thank you madam chair I would move that we add section 6.04 to receive for Action approve amended calendar a CL session after business and approve the agenda M CH second that it's been motioned by Mr peral and seconded by Mr hedp mad cler I'm sorry there's a question Miss B thank you madam chair close session is in regards to what they were shared prior to I know
004the public the feedback that you that you Shar regarding not having to disclose the nature that you well um Miss B the the uh topics will be read during the motion so that will be very very clear to the public but if you want to know I believe there's a I don't recall everything but the public will hear the exact topic that's incling the post session yeah you're asking me do I want that to take place or should it take place or it's it's up to the U I'm always accustomed to hearing when we say Clos session what in reference to I I have it in front of me when we get to that point but I can speak a personel case yeah so there's a personel case there's a um evaluations yeah yeah I
005just wanted to make sure that no it is and and obviously when the board reads to go into a close the uh the motion contains all the topics so the public will receive that as well thank you very much Dr Harris Mohamed answer my question and his comment thank you wonderful um and so let's revisit so it has been motioned by uh Mr peral and seconded by um Mr PPA to to add 6.04 receed for Action approved amended school calendar for 2026 and um Clos SE session for um section nine and also approve agenda as amended Madam Mr personal yes Mr rard yes Mr yes yes m m rzy are you on mute she Dr mam yes Miss B yes M jaar yes M Fernandez yes motion passes and now we'll move on to one
006of our most exciting sections which is our recognition Mr C thank you madam chair I am thr to introduce our student representative for the month of February Mar Maria bu Maria is a senior at Armstrong High School where she is a member of the yearbook committee and speech team participates in theater and serves on superintendent student advisory Council amar's Awards and recognition include honorable and Scholar Ro as well as being a three-time oratorical contest winner Maria gives back to her community Through service work as a camp counselor for children and as an adult care center in her Spare Time Amaria enjoys Reading Writing drawing singing and going on nature walks upon graduation Amaria plans to attend a four-year College where she will major in business and minor in theater and if I may add I
007got to hear her speak at the MLK oratorical contest and she is phenom please join me in welcoming thank you everyone thank you so good even everyone board members superent ceras and guests thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak tonight and advocate for myself and my tears I appreciate your commitment to listening to student voices and making decisions that directly impact our daily experiences it means a lot to know that you value our perspective I first would like to address school start times in particular those for high school students while I know the Administration has addressed the benefits of later start times for high school students in the past I want to reiterate how helpful it would be to have the start time for high school students begin earlier in the morning ear
008start times equal early dismissal times therefore leaving more time in the afternoon for students to partake in after school responsibilities students who have after school jobs wouldn't have to worry as much about working late coming home late and going straight to bed they would also have more time for studying homework Sports and downtime which are all important things for students to take into consideration when planning their day additionally since becoming a student at Armstrong I've been inspired by the strong sense of community and the genuine care that the staff shows every student whether it's helping us succeed academically offering support when things get tough or simply making us feel seen and valued the teachers and staff go above and beyond their dedication has made a meaningful impact on me and my peers however as much
009as the people inside Armstrong make it a special place I want to share some thoughts about the state of our school building like many other schools in the division Armstrong is showing its age our school is over 50 years old and maintaining such an aging structure comes with real challenges I would like to take a moment to recognize and Express gratitude to the operation and fact fa team who work hard to maintain our buildings their dedication and tireless efforts do not go unnoticed and we truly appreciate all they do to keep our learning spaces functional and safe despite the challenges they face that said despite their hard work there are ongoing issues that affect our learning environment one of the most PR challenges we face is temperature control in many classrooms the heating and the
010air conditioning system don't function properly leaving the rooms either too hot or too cold this can be distracting and uncomfortable making it hard to concentrate and learn there are also issues with the water leaks and some classroom and in certain areas parts of the ceilings are missing occasionally we deal with P concerns as well as these conditions can make it different very difficult for stud as to feel safe focused and motivated I understand that maintaining older buildings require careful planning and significant investment and I know that these are not easy decisions to make however as you consider priorities for School faculty I urge you to keep in mind that the importance of creating learning spaces that are clean safe and conductive the students grow a modernized Armstrong will provide a welcoming well-maintained environment where students
011can Thrive academically socially and emotionally thank you for your time your thoughts consideration and all that you do for to support RPS students your work makes a difference and I'm grateful for the opportunity to speak with you tonight thank you everyone for listening thank you so much Amar we are going to take a picture after we go through the rest of our resolutions and so um if you have any family or Armstrong uh folks here we'll have them come up and do that picture thank you so much for your words this evening I'm almost certain I know who your mom is being in the audience she's very proud of you great job today as we move forward to 2.02 receive resolution to assess um to access to education student pivacy and immigration enforcement at this
012time I will read the resolution whereas it is the right of every child regardless of immigration status to access of free public P 12 education and the Richmond Public Schools welcomes all and supports all students whereas the Richmond Public Schools has a responsibility to ensure that all students who reside within its boundaries regardless of immigration status can safely access a free public K through 12 education whereas Federal immigration law enforcement activities on or around Richmond Public Schools property and transportation routes whether by surveillance interview demand for information arrest detention or any other means harmfully disrupt the learning environment to which all students regardless of immigration status are entitled and significantly interfere with the ability of all students including US citizen students and students who hold other legal grounds for pres presence in the United States
013to access a free public K through 12 education whereas through its policies and practices Richmond Public Schools has made a commitment to a quality education for all students which includes a safe and stable learning environment means of transportation to and from school sites the preservation of classroom hours for educational instruction and the requirement of School attendance whereas parents and students have expressed to Richmond Public Schools fear and confusion about the continued physical and emotional safety of all students and the rights to access a free public K12 education through division schools and programs and whereas educational Personnel are often the primary sources of subject resources and information to assist and support students and student learning which includes their emotional health now therefore be it resolved that the US Immigration and Customs en Enforcement office ice state
014or local law enforcement agencies acting on behalf of ice or agents of officers uh for any federal state or local agency attempting to enforce Federal immigration laws are to follow Richmond Public Schools policy 4-3. three relations with law enforcement authorities attached to and Incorporated in this resolution to ensure Richmond Public Schools meets its duty to provide all students regardless of immigration status access to a free public K through 12 education be it further resolved that the board declares Richmond Public Schools to be a safe zone for its students meaning that Richmond Public Schools is a place for students to learn to to thrive and to seek assistance information and support related to any immigration law enforcement that interferes with their learning experience be it further resolve that Richmond Public Schools shall within 30 days of
015the date of this resolution create a rapid response team to prepare in the event a minor child attending school en Richmond Public Schools is deprived of adult care supervision or Guardian ship outside of school due to a a federal law enforcement action such as detention by ice or cooperating law enforcement agency be it further resolved it continues to be the policy of Richmond Public Schools to be the furthest extent to the furthest extent of the law not to allow any individuals or organization to enter a School site if that visit would disrupt the educational setting given the likelihood of substantial disruption posed by the presence of ice or state or local law enforcement agencies acting for ice any post by the presence of ice or state and local law enforcement agencies acting for ice any
016request by ice or other agencies to visit a School site be presented to the superintendent's office for review as to whether access to the site is permitted by law a j a judicial warrant is required or any other legal considerations apply this riew should be made expeditiously but before any immigration law enforcement agent or officer appears at a school site be it further resolved it is it in its continued commitment to the protection of student privacy Richmond Public Schools shall reward excuse me Richmond Public Schools shall review it record keeping policies and practices to ensure that no data is being collected with respect to students immigration statuses and if any such information is being collected or maintained then it then it to excuse me then to cease any such collection as it is irrelevant to
017the educational Enterprise and potentially discriminatory be it further resolved should ice or other immigration law enforcement agents request any student information the request should be referred to the superintendent's office to ensure compliance with family educational rights and Privacy Act Burpa and section 22.1-cu privacy standards for a Judicial warrant and any other limitation on disclosure this review should be con conducted expeditiously but before any production of information is made be it further resolved Richmond Public School shall post this resolution at every School site and to distribute it to the vision staff students and parents using usual means of communication and that the resolution will be translated into all languages spoken by students at home be a further resolve the superintendent shall report back on compliance with this resolution to the board in its next meeting VI
018further resolve the board directs the superintendent to review division policies and practices regarding bullying and report back to the board at its next meeting and communicate to staff students and parents the importance of maintaining a bullying free environment for all students be it further result the board affirms that Richmond Public Schools Employees have the academic freedom to discuss this resolution during class time provided it is age appropriate and students are to be made aware that Richmond Public Schools counselors are available to discuss the subjects contained in this resolution and be it further removed further resolved after school providers and other vendors and Service Pro providers who contract with the division shall be notified with resolution within 30 days and requir to abide byy it thank you at this time we'll move forward to 2.03 recognition
019of national board certified teachers thank you madam chair whereas national board certification is the most respected professional certification OFA ailable in education and provides numerous benefits to teachers students and schools whereas the national board certified teacher program was designed to develop retain and recognize accom teachers and to generate ongoing Improvement in schools Nationwide whereas Richmond Public Schools is committed to Excellence in the education of all students and recognizes the importance of supporting and rewarding our accomplished teachers whereas RPS commends Lindy Williams of Mar mford Elementary School who received the renewal of her national board certification now therefore be it for claim that Richmond Public Schools hereby recognizes and honors Lindy Williams for completing the maintenance of certification program for national board certified teachers in accordance with the national board for professional Teaching Standards and calls
020upon all schools and community members to join in this recognition congratulations again we will do a picture once we are done with all of our proclamations all right next up receive Proclamation for school crossing guards thank you madam chair crossing guard Appreciation Day February 12th 2025 whereas crossing guards play a vital role in ensuring the safety and well-being of RPS students and families as they travel to and from school each day serving with vigilance patience and kindness andwhereas these dedicated individuals Brave all types of weather to provide safe passage at busy intersections helping to protect our children and Foster a culture of safety in our school communities and whereas their commitment contributes to safer school zones encourages walking and biking to school promotes a sense of security for parents and caregivers now therefore be a
021proclaimed that Richmond Public Schools recognizes and celebrates February 12th 2025 as crossing guard appreciation day and encourages all schools and community members to join in this celebration moving on to 2.05 receive Proclamation for black history mon whereas a 1926 historian Dr Carter G Woodson a native Virginia established what would become Black History Month to celebrate the profound contributions achievements and cultural influence of black Americans throughout history and whereas in 2025 Richmond Public Schools asks every Community member to recognize black history all around us and honor the remarkable Legacy embedded in the fabric of the Richmond Community City rich with stories of resilience leadership Innovation and progress and whereas RPS recognizes the legacy of The Honorable Senator Henry L Marsh the first black mayor of the city of Richmond a dedicated public servant and an unceasing
022advocate for justice and equality who recently passed whereas black history is not confined to the past but is reflected in the profound contributions of black Americans today in every conceivable field including science business politics art literature Athletics and more and whereas RPS is committed to fostering an educational environment that uplifts and celebrates black voices histories and experiences as a vital part of our students education and whereas honoring black history Empower students to see themselves as change makers who can carry this Legacy forward now therefore be a proclaimed that richan public schools recognizes and celebrates February 2025 as Black History Month and encourages all schools and community members to join in this celebration thank you at this time we will receive Proclamation for school counselor week National School counseling week February 3rd through 7th 2025 whereas
023the theme for National School counseling week is helping students threat which highlights the indispensable role school council of play and nurturing students confidence well-being and success inside and outside the classroom and whereas RPS school counselors are essential members of the educational team fostering academic achievement social emotional development and career Readiness for all students and whereas RPS school council has provide critical support to students guiding them through personal challenges helping them build resilience and empowering them to set and achieve achieve meaningful goals and whereas RPS school counselors create safe and supportive environments for students serve as advocates for equity and access ensuring that every student has the tools and resources to reach their full potential now therefore read it Proclaim that Richmond Public Schools hereby recognizes February 3rd through 7 2025 as National School counseling week
024that encourages all schools and community members to join in this celebration and now we'll receive Proclamation for school board clerk Appreciation Week School Board clerk appreciation week February 17th to 21st 2025 also known as and now we'll have Mr FAL to read the resolution whereas Schoolboard clerks are essential to the effective and efficient operation of school boards providing invaluable support to the elected representatives who guide public education and whereas clerks are responsible for preparing agendas recording minutes maintaining official records and facilitating communication between the Richmond City School Board RPS staff students families and Community stakeholders and whereas the dedication and hard work of the RPS board Clerk and Deputy clerk significantly contribute to advancing the mission of Richmond Public Schools and supporting Student Success whereas the RPS board Clerk and Deputy clerk demonstrate exceptional organizational
025skills let me repeat that exceptional organizational skills professionalism and a commitment to service for the RPS Community now therefore be and Proclaim that Richmond Public Schools recognizes and celebrates February 17 to the 21st 2025 as school board clerk appreciation week and encourages all schools and community members to join the celebration yes we would like to say a thank you to both you and is mar here tonight she's not we just wanted to give you a little something to just thank you we cannot um all of the work that you do behind the scenes and for all of us not just um our school board colleagues but the administration as well so this is a welld deserved nonalcoholic ofation for all that you do for Richmond Public Schools thank you very very much thank you we
026forgot the car this is quite awkward but next up we have received Proclamation for school board appreciation thank you madam chair whereas the education of our children is the foundation for a thriving and prosperous community and school boards serve as a critical link between public schools in the community they serve and whereas the dedicated members of the Richmond City School lead with love devoting countless hours to developing policies and advocating for the success of every RPS student and whereas the Richmond City School Board serves as a champion for Equity excellence in Innovation and education and plays a vital role preparing students for Success building strong School communities and whereas Schoolboard appreciation month provides an opportunity to recognize and celebrate the invaluable contributions of these public servants who work tirelessly to uphold the mission and values
027of Richmond Public Schools now therefore we Proclaim that Richmond Public Schools recognizes and celebrates February 2025 at school board appreciation month and encourages all schools and community members to join in this celebration and we richond public schools are delighted we don't have a big old basket of but we have beautiful flowers for each of you a beautiful certificate if one of you could model did you get your ceric yes and thank you you all receive a poster that has every school logo on it and they are very cute so we expect these all in your offices your homes wherever your heart desires so that you can always be public schools close on behalf of the administration on behalf of all of our schools and our staff I do want to personally say thank you uh
028to chair Fernandez Vice chair first of all and all members of the board this is not an easy time to be an elected official and certainly not one with a responsibility for the education of our children and I couldn't be prowder to serve alongside you and so excited about all that we will do together over the coming years thank you thank you so much likewise it has been a pleasure it's been a month but it feels like a year already right we had a lot of things overcome in just but it's been a pleasure to work alongside of you certainly appreciate all of your efforts sacrifice and support it's a pleasure moving on to 2.09 receive Proclamation for kindness speak whereas kindness is a powerful and transformative force that Fosters respect empathy and compassion strengthening
029relationships and building inclusive communities and whereas Virginia kindness week serves as a Statewide opportunity to promote and Inspire acts of kindness within schools families and the Greater Community and whereas fostering a culture of kindness within richan Public Schools encourages positive social interactions supports mental health and strengthens bonds among students staff and families and whereas teaching nurturing and recognizing kindness can help reduce bullying promote inclusivity for all students and increase long-term happiness whereas by promoting kindness and compassion we Empower students to become empathetic leaders thoughtful citizens who contribute positively to their communities now therefore be it proclaimed that Richmond Public Schools hereby recognizes February 9th through 20125 as Virginia kindness week and encourages all schools and communi members to join in this celebration all right now everybody who kind come up and take a picture all
030right we are GNA begin with Amaria and any family members you have here and any Armstrong family members who are here as well let's come on up take never you on this side yes one two three right one two national board all right crossing any Crossing oh no spe all right smile three one two three one two come on down again take two go get your flowers and hold them for the school appreciation I love it just have one concern about these flowers I have a yellow bow and snap peer everybody you got hold than on YouTube watch thank you all for your patience move forward with the next section of the agenda thank you 3.01 receive announcements Mr P thank you madam chair uh I would like to report early ear today I was
031at the RPS career fair uh with some of my colleagues and I would like to report this is the first of its kind in RPS and and thank you at the the past of Madam chair said a few words to the uh the industry that was there so there's quite a bit of Industry there and the students the 12th graders across RPS were invited they were brought in and it was an opportunity to bring students together with industry and ask questions learn more and it was absolutely fascinating able to B it that's great um and and really I'd like to highlight the the level of energy and enthusiasm from the students that were there the words that I did say to the industry there is that we do have in our strategic plan the pillars
032of career pathway development as well as Community involvement from industry and today really was a Nexus of those two things and adding in the Third Leg of that scho was being there to witness it so that we can get the feedback feedback from the students get the feedback from the industry uh absolutely fantastic they are doing a followup April 28th where the students can go back and meet with industry again uh they're instructed to perhaps dress up this time have uh have their resumés on their phones everything was digital connection which was fantastic and they can actually make applications for jobs and I was really blown away but some of the opportunity that presented there so just a shout out all the hard work that Miss thank you madam chair I'm so elated to report
033that shim elementary school as we know continues to be the only International Bor primary year program throughout the Metro Richmond area and on this past Thursday they celebrated their 10th anniversary to include an International Festival hundreds of folk foods that I've never heard of before FL but I ate as much as I possibly could before going to my next meeting and also our children performing every country you can think of continent as continents as well I'm also proud to report that shim's population is very diverse when we have parents there that was were there when I was principal I did not know were from Ukraine China Germany West Africa and it was a good homecoming and I also am so proud that I was there and um our faculty and staff worked hard to get
034that program in place than I retired so thank you so very much but they made me proud I was very full to see the program has continued after 10 years and it's looking fabulous and they are fully accredited not only by state standards but internationally as wellow that's the Steven District everyone thank you so much Dr Harris muhamed thank you madam chair just have one announcement this evening and just wanted to share with everyone that the policy Council has a new executive board and I know we welcome them with open arms very soon we will hear from Mad Madame chair Emilia bird and the phenomenal executive team very soon and they continue to work with our head start Office of richan Public Schools led by Dr Leslie wi so I look forward to us meeting
035them thank you Mr hedp thank you madam chair just a few quick announcements one uh to concur with superintendent Camas about the uh MLK um for contest U that Mr hard and I were also in the presence of of greatness it was a a great honor to MLK and gave gave us a lot of Hope for future Generations um ready to tackle tackle even the most challenging um CH issues a couple of uh the principles in the in the fourth district also had a couple uh announcements they wanted to share that Dr Massa was excited to uh to thank his hugan high school counselors uh miss this uh Harrison M Harris Mr Christmas Mrs Scott M Morales m read and this re for all of their work um this Petri said remember to uh to
036turn in your uh or to update your information um in the division handout that was sent out to the Southampton Community but perhaps that's important for all of us um and then um principal Hawkins at Lucille Brown said they're having International pizza night tomorrow night so you should thank you madam chair the time of okay I'm get back to you on that there was a clarification about the time of any other announcements wonderful at this time we transition into 4.01 public information M you please read the guidelines conduct of speakers speakers sh State their full legal prior to address on this reward speakers will address this as a whole than individual school board members the division superintendent school board attorney cour or any other staff member the school board will listen to comments that will
037not respond during the public information period persons appearing before the board will not be allowed to L campaign from public office two promote private business ventures or three used profanity or buar language the community members comments during the public information session relate to school based issues the chair May refer that individual to Richmond Public Schools administration for one-onone consultation and follow is important that all Comm members who wish to participate in the public information period by the guidelin set for policy the policy result inure the remaining time that has been allowed to the speaker Comm members May Express their views in writing in L of any presentation comments receive and writing in of an presentation will not be during the meeting but shall be posted to the school platform Bo thank you madam cler we
038have 14 pre-register speakers first we have listed miss an Forester um I want to ask I have a comment about the budget and I was wondering if I can read that now or if I should come back up for the second comment period for the budget um it's just I mean it's not I'm not going to be any longer I just think know it was like inappropriate to say hour if I wait I don't see any concerns with that thanks good evening my name is an Biser I'm RPS teacher and the rea president um I wanted to first start by just addressing policy 4 dash 3.3 uh regarding ice ageny school um just as a Richmond I'm just very proud that as a community um we've all been on the same page and working together
039on this um and that protecting our community members is of importance to all of us so from the mayor's office um this board the school administration as well as many union members it's just great to see that we're on the same page um we appreciate the draft policy language I had a few points but they were honestly all covered in the resolution you read so thank you um moving on the Union is very concerned about the presence of asbestos at Red Elementary um I've personally seen reports indicating that aestus was present in broken tiles there and they're in high traffic areas such as the auditorium which doubles as their gyms um since those tiles are broken there's Airborne pieces and that's a huge health risk um it's also my understanding that RPS may be out
040of compliance with AA for the aspectus hazard emergency refund act which requires yearly notification of the staff families and employee organizations on the Asus management plan inspections by licensed professionals and training for custodial staff um I know staff at Red reached out to the administration and Facilities Department about this for I think over a year um there still hasn't been any repair or remedy I know I addressed this in an email with the facilities department and the superintendent last week among other issues and that part was not addressed um and so we just implore you all to please get that remedy soon I mean that's putting staff and students and like you know direct contact with a known Caron um also related to facilities it's my understanding that the roof repairs and Replacements that refunded
041in the CIP budget last year have not begun and so because of that I recently found out that some of those interior rooms at ball Middle School that were covered in visible mold last year um have leaking and stained ceiling tiles again water coming in from the snow melt um and so that's undoubtedly more funding that we're going to have to pay for um I appreciate the facilities was really quick to get out there and have that replaced last weekend um and so I hope that we're just behind schedule um but as we do approach another budget cycle I urge the board to utilize their auditor and ensure that the procurement process and timelines for repairs and construction projects are as efficient with time and funds as they can be um as you all know
042we need tens of millions of dollars to make our facilities safe and we can't afford to waste any of that money um and so regarding the budget um the Rea is against the absorption of healthcare insurance premiums for employees um this is essentially a pay cut um surrounding counties such as henrio do absorb all employee Healthcare increases and rather than just passing them on to the workers um we understand that the budget is tight but I can almost guarantee you um if you let workers in schools tell you where we waste our precious funds they would have plenty of ideas um my guess as teachers would point to unhealthful outside trainings and supplies and curricula that they AR they don't ask for and they don't use um we've also seen audit reports where so-called office
043supplies were really used to buy chicken dinners um or 200 day Pilots where staff at some schools have been fighting extreme temperatures um wasps buzzing around um and just overall lack of support and so to put the burden back on workers when we have seen so many instances of wasteful wasteful spending is unacceptable and insulting um lastly on Friday I sent an email to all of you and the superintend um on behalf of what was then 14 employees in the talent and finance department um we now have 18 letters for you all regarding the toxic work environment and that includes um inappropriate comments that are racist and discriminatory excessive supervision verbal harassment intimidation Outburst coercion of employees who have filed complaints and grievances unjustified writeups positions in the talent office being filled without proper posting
044for other applicants and favoritism in hiring promotions and reclassification attached to my email was a list of letters and statements from employees in those departments I do remind you all that foil laws do not prohibit individual employees from speaking to work experience publicly but instead prohibit school board members from discussing Personnel matters priv um publicly and so I humbly ask you all to hear these women's stories and yes they are all women they are all women of color and many of them have dedicated almost their entire career to RPS and have been here many many years and so um please read those statements that were emailed to you and just hear these fols out thank you thank you next up we have on the list Clinton Roberts with Richmond for all okay he's yielding his
045position to last Jeffrey Miller good even hello good evening my name is Jeff Miller I'm a parent an RPS parent of a fourth grader at Patrick Henry she was in second and third grade at chimazo so I remember that International food thing last year was great um school closures happen we get it uh blizzards ice there's no water these things are understandable however some closures not just this winter but in past are often unnecessary and great more problems than they solve I and other parents would really really really appreciate more intentionality and consideration when you're making decisions on school cancellations it should be a last resort not something done as a knee-jerk reaction or a quick fix it should be the default position of the school board that if regular people are expected to go
046to work then their kids should be able to go to school canceling school is obviously disruptive for kids we all know this the problems that come with that a lot of kids depend on school for meals and and other services um but what I think might sometimes be overlooked is the difficulties caregivers pH when schools are closed I'm fortunate enough that my daughter could come to work with me if she had to in a pinch but there are a lot of folks her friends neighbors uh that don't have that option they can't just Willy nearly take off work wh's um school system and there country unfortunately Child Care is not something you can just dial up and access instantly and affordably it's incredibly difficult and expensive to make last minute adjustments especially for working people
047working people are the lifeblood of this city many of them are parents of RPS kids uh cancellations cause a whole host of ancillary problems some of these parents will have to make the decision to maybe not even uh not be around and just go to work and leave the kid unattended for the day if they have to just to make their hours or get the paycheck um there are situations where you could be using a scalpel instead of an axe if a few schools have issues with temperature or things like that you can close those schools not the whole uh system uh so basically what I with myself and I know a lot of frustrated parents would just like to make sure you understand if we need to get to work if there's no reason
048that we can't get out and get to work there really shouldn't be a reason for the kids to not be able to make it school and have their full school day so that that's all I have thank you very much thank you Andre Bryant Andre Bryant Andre Bryant d branger good evening my name is jod grinder and I'm standing here today with my colleagues in the talent and finance department to share our stories of a hostile work environment especially at the hands of a cheaper talent and her ethical Behavior we have already to share with you an almost 60 page document outlining our personal stories and I have with me the printed copies with more people's stories who have come forward in the past few days I have been an employee of Richmond Public School
049since 1997 and currently an executive office associate for the chief of talent during all my years with RPS I have felt like I was treated with respect and dignity until the start of 23 24 school year in August of that year the chief Talent officer started working with RPS when I had my one-on-one meeting with her she stated that she was self-sufficient and did not need assistance so I continued working supporting the director of compensation and benefits and director of of teacher and leader pathways however I saw on RPS website that the chief Bal had posted an executive office associate position I was informed that part of position whose role was at the same as mine when I asked her about the position I was informed that part of my position will be given to
050the new employee hired by her a younger white woman I was pushed out of my position without justification or due process when thinking about my situation it is hard not to not see the obvious racism and agism I am a black woman who has been doing this type of work in RPS for over 14 years with no issues and was originally told by the chief that she did not need an assistance to only be replaced by a younger white woman a year later when I asked what my new title will be she stated I don't know Talent something that was a punch in the stomach to show how little thought was put into changing my position it feels like it didn't matter to her what my work look life as long as there wasn't a
051more seasoned black woman working as her assistant she has truly messing with my life Al her RPS School model is teach lead and serve a love how about adding high with love and that starts with having a Chu respects her staff thank you lenia Evans my apolog Mis did I get it right no how do you pronounce your name was close thank you we would love this same reminds us that we let love motivate us to be giving caring bear uplifting to others in our community however we cannot say that this has been our experience as RPS office employees a culture within the central office Department often Foster favoritism toxic environment bullying show blatant disregard for employe mental wellbe and work balance in the finance department we have seen our life colleagues get opportunities to
052be reclassified reassigned to different different positions without the role being posted which is against RPS poliy as black women in the department we have never received any opportunity to I have come to the I have already come to the school board meeting to talk about the unfair compensation as a result I felt like I was punished with an automatic denial of my raise the same night and receiving no additional pay and only Dom minuts and respons only more Dom minuts and responsibilities as a department we often feel disregarded and we are under extreme pressure to launch a new system and many of the concerns that we have shared were dismissed by leadership and never addressed decisions made by leadership demonstrate a lack of sensitivity to these issues the veiling attitude seem a one of stubbornness
053pushing forward without regard for the challenges that we Face we have lost valuable time with our families and our health due to these circumstances we have dedicated countless hours to reflect the RPS slogan to we would love only to find that it has been at our own detriment as we don't receive any return we often F feel we often feel use been forgotten like slave on a like a slave on a plantation is this the true cure of RPS thank you thank you sh Maxwell good evening my name is sh Maxwell and I'm the substitute specialist for the talent office for the past three years I have been single-handedly managing the substitute office for the entire District along with smart fine Express with limited assistance this work has always been difficult especially due to staff
054and issues but this the Sheep of talent has continuously made this work almost impossible and has created an extremely hostile work environment there's no way for me to fit my experience with her in 3 minutes but here are some of the things I want to highlight shortly after the chief started her role we had a brief conversation where she marked my accent in an extremely public area with my co-workers present I am a proud afro Latina who is not embarrassed of her accent and who has accomplished a great deal and has worked hard for the benefit of our Scholars and for RPS as a whole no one especially not my supervisor has the right to Market she consistently addresses me in a disrespectful and condescending tone that has been forceful abro and at times with
055an elevated voice she has yelled at me over things as trivial as my own personal Furniture in my office which she refuses to let me move to my new office even though it was purchased with personal funds and for doing my job the chief constantly asked me to perform task tasks outside of my responsibilities and in turn she tells principales that she does not know where is Miss maxu and has told me that if I if they continue to complain she won't be able to secure my job even though this is of her making in one specific situation the chief demanded I do work outside of my RO and on the the day after my sister-in-law I passed away she was like a sister to me I was slated to I was slated to travel
056to attender funeral and the demands of the sheep made it difficult a very difficult situation she made it worst in the she found words during the first meeting with the talent office I know nothing about HR I read a book and I passed the interview the decisions Mrs Clemens made as regards to the substitute office are a reflection of this fact because it had a negative impact on our district I thank you so much for affording me this for thank you Van Shelton Van Shelton Bernice Lewis misson coming I'm sorry who I have the first she has the second latia lley and I'm just assist oh I see I was confirming is Bernice Lewis here okay she was next that's who I called next for the sake of just since you're here I don't want
057to um but just in the future if you can be mindful of please come forward when when asked okay Miss Bernice Lewis are you okay with them moving forward since they're already here yes I am okay okay so we have before us Leticia lamley and Marie Marie Holmes is not on the list if you could sign your name just for clarification say with two persons speaking is that we nor have one person speak but I think are you okay well miss Shelton we just sit there until she's ready to speak okay all right that's did you want to go ahead and proceed good evening Madam chair scho board I come to you this evening um to present a collective statement from the compensation and benefits team in the talent office detailing concerns that the chief
058of of talent Behavior has fostered a toxic and hostile work environment since the arrival of Miss cins has she of talent our workload duties and responsibilities have significantly increase we are performing tasks that were not a part of our original job desription our responsibilities have expanded and we now are accountable for complex tasks and larger projects our skills are being underutilized as we specialize in the roles we were initially hired to do and we are performing tasks outside of those skills we are unfairly targeted with additional duties and responsibilities for and the responsibilities are and our responsible for unattainable deadlines with our current staff we are also overlooked and undervalued in the workplace on March 7 2024 the benefits and comp team submitted a formal request to miss Clemens via email for a desk audit
059addressing the unsustainable workload that is impossible to manage with the current staff we have we emphasize to her that the current workload compounding with the FML coverage requirements made the assigned task practically impossible to manage effectively especially since our colleague Sherry Brown was out on Le the current situ situation presents a significant growth lock to Optimal team performance and morale we have each been assigned four different FTE that prohibit that prohibit effective contributions at the specialist level we are the only staff members in a talent office that have to manage three different email inboxes along with the man of workload that comes along with our daily responsibility 30 seconds we requir this audit due we we requested this audit due to fundamental disconnect of our Chief's understanding of our workflow and the reality of our
060daily task prior to implementing changes she lack a grasp of complexities involved in processing even one single item and the time commitment required to each stage of the task despite our director Alison Davis explicitly convey concerns that the proposed changes are unattainable and implemented regardless with disregard and practical implications on our teams thank you for your time thank you leisk I had the other part oh I see even school board members and Hamas thank you for allowing us to um speak on um the comp and benefits piece once once she received that request she verbally came to Alison dav's office while we were in a meeting on March 11th 2024 and stood in the door and St they would not request a death started for us she also stated that we were going to be
061generalist this did not happen this did not take place and that she would get with Allison to to have us plac on the correct job uh grade for the amount of work that we were processing this also did not happen after the verbal denial once again we were sent once again we sent her another um email on April the 9th 2024 requesting a written response to discuss the death audit and have anwers and we have included this in sufficient response in the meantime we asked for additional staff to help with the magnitude of work that we are struggling to process since that time we submitted this request for additional staff she has not hired any additional staff for our team but has hired three new full-time employees a project manager Labor Relations Specialist and a
062receptionist and upgraded to employees from specialist to manager and manager to director our director has been actively engaged in discussions with the chief ATT regarding the responsibilities and functions of our team after these conversations the director presented the requested written proposal for realignment of our duty for our team on November 7 2024 it is important to note that no other directors in the count office besides ours were not required to present a written proposal for any changes in their teams on November 18 M Clemens asserted that a team doesn't require additional FTE to effectively manage compensation and benefits for over 5,000 employees excuse me passionate 5 employees raises concerns especially considering that other teams within the town office have been granted additional Staffing Resources the disparity in resources allocations prompts questions about workload distribution prioritization
063and potentially undervalued contribution staff team we are being asked to do tasks plus others outside of their official duties with no additional support the chief has created a tar environment where our jobs seem to be very ever expanded with no insight and it has also affected our health physically and mentally I have to enter thank you thank you Sher Brown I called multiple times I didn't see you come for please come for C my name is Bernie I am the human resource associate in tal like so many of my colleagues in the talent Department I have been experiencing unlawful conduct mistreatment and bullying whenever I interact with the chief of talent clins in my personal situation this has been going on since August 2024 through January 2025 and like too many of my colleagues I
064had recently f a grievance in response to her extremely problematic and unethical behavior in the following letter I will go through some of the issues outlin in their gev early in to's time at RPS I asked her if she still wanted everyone to come into the office on she said yes there would be no exceptions made for anyone exceptions to that rule have been made for staff recently hired who are her friends from outside of RPS and for the school foots is sit before me which is a violation of requirements set out by the Department of Homeland Security when I asked about the scheduling the required person on boarding for school board members Maggie told me in extremely nasty tone no you will not I do not want them coming into the office meaning the
065school board members they don't need to come here and I don't want them in here especially in these moments she abuses her power to the point that I'm constantly in feel in subordination if I do the right thing in my job I have watched her break policy and protocol multiple times I want to finish my most recent experience which pushed me to file agre and come out about her behav on Wednesday January 15 2025 mag came to my office around 12:30 and told me she needed me to move my office for the other side of the building because she wanted only the recruiters on this side of the deal during this conversation I also asked her a question about my job responsibilities since there were a lot of changes being made in the department and
066they had not been communicated to me I asked her question only about my job dents and if they were change because of these changes and she responded in a loud and aggressive tone then my duties will not change and I don't have the right to make that decision when I responded stating that I was not trying to make a decision only get clear about my duties she said it sounded like I had a problem with the recruiter and proceeded to call me passive and aggressive because I asked questions later that day I met with Mr C and my representative Divine who was present and told him how the disrespect and bullion had been happening since she started working here and that her behavior could not continue I say time is up can I say one
067more your time is up respect for everyone El speak Cherry Brown the help cut down on confusion for me if if unless your name is called if you could wait your turn to speak unless there's some type of reason for you all standing yes yes okay I'm Sherry Brown and um because of what he's going to read I'm not able to go through the whole thing you'll understand as you hear my story um he's going to read my for on yourf on my beh yes I don't believe that is something that we allowed to do I'm just checking I appreciate everyone back I'm addressing the attorney for clarity thank you so much if he wants to read for okay all right thank you could you please sign your name well thank you do you want
068me to say this is fine thank you good evening uh my name is Jacob Neil H I am a member of the Rea board and I am here to read on behalf of our uh my fellow Rea member m r Brown because of her because her experience was too difficult for her to share herself her statement is as follows the first time I sat down to write this I had a hard time describing what I went through with the chief of town from March to July 2024 I can't fit the whole story in two minutes but I am going to try my best for the past two years my husband has been battling a critical illness and I was fortunate to be covered under the Family and Medical Leave Act F MLA to care for
069him as needed unfortunately during this time my department was going through some challenges with no support from the chief so I continued to juggle my work while caring BR the reason I continued to work even though I was had been approved for FMLA was that I felt a commitment to the employees of RPS my co-workers and my director at the time what I received for my dedication loyalty and commitment was heartbreaking during one of the most difficult times in my life I was called into a meeting with the chief it was told that despite being a previous great employee she felt compelled to suggest that I resign my personal until my personal circumstances improved she accused me of being a liar a thief and an ineffective employee in the days following meeting she continued to
070contact me relentlessly for my resignation even after I took full FMLA and more disturbingly in the days following my husband's death when all of this happened I was 56 years old with medical issues expensive prescriptions and had just suffered one of the hardest losses imaginable when she threaten to take my income and my health insurance benefits away and wrote all those terrible things about me and my work performance she eventually broke me down I know all of this information seems unbelievable I have no reason to lie as a human resources Chief she actually did and said those things to me it was hard for me to tell this story and share it so publicly but when I found out that she continues to be an abusive leader I agreed to help by sharing my experience
071with the hopes of helping others who are still suffering I pray my story helps and I pray that things change thank you Alice and Davis good evening my name is Allison Davis and I am the director of benefits and compensation for vir colge schools on June 10th 2024 my colleague found jene the director of employment in legor relations filed a complaint of pay disparity based on race and sex discrimination against the chief Talent officer though we are not union members we as co-workers and women of color feel compelled to support our colleagues who are bravely sharing their own experiences of discriminatory and unfair treatment by the chief Talent officer as a proud granddaughter and daughter of Rich public school's alumni and staff as an RPS Alum myself and employed for 23 years I am deeply
072saddened to hear my colleagues experiences there are unfortunately more account of negative and unprofessional behavior by the chief Talent officer but many of our colleagues are too afraid to speak up because of the real threat of retaliation we have been enduring the complaint process for 8 months and have notified that the investigation report will be completed soon we respectfully request access to the complete independent investigation report access to all of the versions of the previous investigation report that were shared with the superintendent and an opportunity to discuss the findings with you the school board in a Clos session my department the benefits and compensation department is severely under stra to support almost 5,000 employees we have been set up to fail my team and I are are unable to perform our jobs effectively and efficiently
073with limited resources overlapping demands and lack of administrative support we have been set up to fail it is impossible to allocate the necessary time and attention to each priority and achieve the desired level of customer service our employees deserve we have been set up to fail I've even been directed to issue disciplinary letters to my team for every occurrence of a m timeline or deadline again we have been set up to fail I sincerely hope that you hear what is being shared tonight and quickly address our concerns about the chief Talent officer thank you for your time thank you Sher Brown is listening to Lindy good evening my name is Lind I an office associate for original public schools for the employee and Labor Relations Department during my time in this role I was told
074by the chief Talent office to take on additional responsibilities that extended beyond my primary Ro and supporting the ELR Department specifically I was tasked with managing the off Renovations and coordinating the move to two different floors in addition to those responsibilities I was also responsible for managing purchasing and inventory for the entire town office despite performing my duties beyond my description as an office associate during this time I did not receive any additional compensation I was also told by the chief that I would not be excuse me I would not be considered for any reclassification to reflect my actual workload this situation has led to feelings of frustration as I have been performing duties that will typically fall on under the responsibilities of multiple staff members without any recognition or adjustment to my compensation after
075I learned about a new executive office Associates position being created with the intention of giving it to a non-contracted white employee without a job vacy posting inw process or any consideration for others within the department I felt both ignored and undervalued by the chief Talent office office this felt like a direct contradiction to the standards that were set when I initially part about a potential reclassification to a similar position I tried to address my concern and I was told to just apply for the position when it would be posted I discovered that the position had finally been posted but with new requirements that disqual that disqualified me from applying to the position this was a change from the initial online job description and it seems to be designed to make the role inaccessible to myself
076or other highly qualified Administrative Office Associates and office Associates currently employed in the district given that the requirements were altered months after I had already expressed my concerns and filed agreement the chief officer moved the gold post that specifically exclude me from consideration this feels not only fair but also retaliatory I find it deeply concerning that the goals goal post keeps shifting especially after expressing my dissatisfaction with the initial handling of the situation I want to ensure that my hard work dedication and the responsibilities I've taken on are recognized and then moving forward the process of job and reclassification is handled transp transparently and equitably thank you for your time thank you Clinton Roberts colleagues I'd like to also share that we have pass the 30 minute limit for public comment right chairwoman Fernandez Vice
077chair personal and The Honorable members of the school board my name is Quinton Robbins and I'm the chair of Richmond for all um I first want to commend this board for quickly putting together a policy um to address uh the you know shifting immigration policy on the Federal level uh that's attempting to weaponize um you know ice and the Department of Homeland Security against our friends and neighbors um I also want to extend congratulations to the incoming School Board this is the first time I've spoken sort of in this session of the school board however um I'm already concerned that this elective board is ADV abdicating its authority to the unelected superintendent um for example last week the school board's auditor told the audit committee that the administration asked him to redact sections of an
078honor report the discussion that ensued was about best practices um and I think you've missed the point the administration is directing your employee to do something without your permission um I recently spoke at a school board member from another locality and he remarked um that from the outside it looked like the Richmond School Board has forgotten that superintendence can only do what the school board allows them to do not the other way around not the other way around I feel I fear many members ran with the intent of rolling back the hard one oversight and Staffing Authority um that the last board wrestled from the administration uh and you know given the the the the the horrifying testimony that we've received tonight um I'm begging that you fulfill your oversight Authority if we don't have
079proper checks another crisis in this district is a guarantee um uh last night I also caught that your director of engagement placement and planning mentioned that he consulted with Charter networks on our strategic plan Charters are private schools they don't work they suck money out of neighborhood schools leaving schools with less I looked at your director's LinkedIn and noticed that you used to work for K this is alarming the kit chain and its for-profit subsidiaries are one of the worst perpetrators of C student abuse in the country they punish and push out students that don't perform well on standard test in order to juice their numbers I think the public needs to understand why this Administration is engaging with Charter networks at all and which Charter networks are being consulted and praying Kip wasn't one
080of them uh now on to the budget I love the Joe Biden quote don't tell me what you value show me your budget and I'll tell you what you value this is an austerity budget this is a budget that conservatives would die for and what this budget shows me is that the super intendent doesn't value workers or their rights Dr Harris Muhammad hit the nail on the head last night when she asked if the administration had discussed the wages or benefit proposals with workers unions once again the answer from the administration was no sadly this is not surprising your head of Human Resources said that it wasn't specifically uated in the collective bargaining agreement so it was allowed to be clear this is a violation of the collective bargaining policy and workers rights your chief
081interpretation is trumpian this is how Republicans want to interpret labor law on the national level you ran as Democrats and we as Democrats believe that any changes in wages benefits or working conditions must be bargained for if you accept the administration's interpretation you are helping Republicans erode labor rights period this would be shameful if you change wages benefits or working conditions you must reopen bargaining with the unions they democratically voted to have their Union and you are required to respect them I want to highlight uh the provision titled training incentives and ontime performance awards for bus operators I think Vice chair pel put uh put it perfectly last night when he expressed concern that this would encourage speeding and risky Behavior this is performance pay Mr cameras has a lot of experience designing performance pay
082systems when he worked for DC public schools and he knows this doesn't go well furthermore this has been not not been negotiated with the Union because the administration is stalling on the contract this is a violation of the collective bargaining policy this Administration is attempting to dictate a budget to you again 30 seconds you must assert your Authority and really dig in see what we're spending on ask these teachers who work hard and know what's going on in the schools every day and where we are wasting money I'm asking that you reject the Camas austerity budget this doesn't serve workers and it doesn't serve students if School staff for struggling to make ends me thank you thank you colleagues um because we are well over time for the comment public period are there any objections
083to this moving forward to the budget to mam Madam chair thank you just for clarity if I may am I hearing it correctly we are moving past 5.01 because of time we are absolutely okay I just that's thank you for clarifying the question we would move forward with a public hearing um for the fiscal year 2026 budget are there any objections thank you okay with that being said we will be moving forward now we will recess the school boards a business meeting and convene the public hearing on the fiscal year budget for 2026 comments are limited to those related to budget again comments are limited to those related to budget each speaker will be allotted two minutes for individuals and 3 minutes for organizations please state your name before sharing your comments and be sure
084that the mic is turned on at this time Dr hereis mamed thank you madam chair I just wanted to um ask about a norm if we have a speaker that speaks off of the budget hearing how will the school board proceed we would have to ask for you to disengage if it if it so the question is if a speaker comes up and goes off of the topic of the budget we will ask you to refrain from speaking outside of the theme of thank you m thank you for asking clar question are there any of those that would like to speak at this time good evening good evening I believe what I'm about to say your name my name is Susan hudin um I believe what I'm about to to read does apply to the
085CIP budget um in the respect that our schools very very much need money allotted to them for repair so my name is Susan hudin is I and I stand before you tonight as a 31-year veteran teacher with RPS working all 31 years at Elizabeth red Elementary a 74-year-old school my time with RPS and at Red at one time brought me nothing but pride and joy today it brings me fear and great anxiety last year I stood at this Podium and brought to you concerns about mold in our building and then again after the mold report was published where the validity of that report came into question due to extensive cleanup measures taken just before that study last year I was told by a person in facilities to quote worry about what happens in your office
086basically saying that the condition of the rest of the building is none of my business to that I disagree that being said I am here tonight to plead with you to address a serious and preventable risk to the health and safety of both students and staff at Red the presence of Frable aestus in the building specifically in the floor tiles and mastic in our Auditorium which is a heavily trafficked area I reported my concerns to my building administrator multiple work orders were submitted and when no action was taken within a reasonable time frame I had these materials tested and the results confirm that both the tiles and the mastic contain asbest a known carcinogen a week ago today I reported this the serious nature of the situation at Red to District level Administration and still
087no corrective actions have been taken I would be lying if I said I wasn't concern concerned for my own health along with the health of my colleagues knowing that we are exposed daily to this crumbling toxic material but it is but it is the students who are of even more concern I want to emphasize that young children are especially vulnerable you say time yes oh I'll send rest to you thank you good evening good evening uh my name is Alison Kaplan I'm the school counselor and the re rep for Elizabeth R Elementary School um so I've exchanged and this also in relation to the CIP budget um I've exchanged a great deal of correspondents regarding the subject I'm here to speak on including a public comment that I made to the board in March of
0882024 we're still dealing with this bestus at red and the federal requirements within thees Hazard emergency response act or a her for short are still being violated and disregarded we have exposed pable disruptive asbest in the form of shattered tiles that is in a highly trafficked area within our School auditorium we need the auditorium floor to be replaced and we need it now I know what you're thinking and yes work orders have been in the system since at least November and the aara reports I requested last year positively identifi these tiles and mtic as having asbest our Auditorium serves as a location for PE band and Orchestra afternoon dismissals and assemblies this means that students and staff are exposed to thetive particles daily for extended periods of time $90,000 was allocated to Clark springs for
089a new gym when F students were relocated there and it was replaced simply because the floor on the gym was carpet um our multi purpose bace exposes us to an unknown Carson agent and this should alarm you for the federal requirements in aara staff and fames should be receiving yearly notice about the assestive containing materials in the building this does not happen for the federal requirements the aara custodial staff should be receiving aist awareness training this does not happen heard the federal requirements in Thea copies all of allesist um inspection reports and management plans should be kept on P for viewing of the school this does not happen and per the federal requirements iner professional professionals licensed to aate and work with thep should be taking actions to remediate the problem immediately this is not
090happening um I am asking for all of this to happen in summation and to be clear um it's also unfair to ask employees to absorb 50% of an insurance cost increase while also failing to remedy that they were being exposed to par daily thank you thank you my name is Hannah Clayman I'm an RCF Middle School exceptional education teacher and an Raa member I'm here to talk to you about the budget proposal to increase our health insurance costs uh one of rs's budgetary priorities is to reduce the vacancy rate being competitive with surrounding counties should be a priority for that we should be protecting employees from rising healthcare costs uh to compare henrio Public Schools is giving an annual salary increase of 4.8% plus a 2.37% step increase compared to RPS is 3% and 1.17%
091step increase additionally henrio provides protection from rising health insurance cost by continuing to absorb health insurance increases rather than passing them on to the employees we deserve better than this any increase in health insurance cost is a pay cut this will eat up any salary increase four step increase and the cost of living is only going to get higher please give us a break some of us are barely scraping by with families Child Care health issues food and inflation don't increase our deductions we already have enough please think hard about how you want to save some money because you will lose staff if you pass this thank you thank you good evening I need to sign in yes yes leing members of the school board my name is Brian pton I'm the president of Teamsters
092Local 322 I'm here today to talk about two very alarming matters first is the call for for employees to cover 50% of their insurance that is ridiculous and unacceptable it nullifies the raises that employees have received my question to this this board is are body does this approach a acknowledge and recognize the hard work of the workers who keeps RPS uh functioning why is it that workers are are time and time again called on to make sacrifices and suffer economic losses we need to do we need to do better we should do better anything less is an insult to the workers and it demonstrates how they are viewed by this board I'm going to segue into something else the board is considering Contracting six or seven schools to ABM Industries as I understand it this
093company has quite the reputation they have been accusations of wave stuff approximately 154 records records submitted and a significant financial penalties attached to the company their record clearly demonstrates that any business relationship with ABM would be a risky proposition and further provide unnecessary problem for all key stakeholders so part of making good effective decisions is doing due diligence crunching the numbers this right here is mistake waiting to happen thank you for your time thank you good evening good evening good evening can you hear me it doesn't doesn't sound hot we go my name is Beth alore and good my name is Beth alore I'm a teacher in Richmond Public Schools and I live in the fourth district and I was not planning to speak tonight um but as I listened to my colleagues at Red
094Elementary School I realized I teach in the space that they're describing and it kind of paralyzes my mind to think about that luckily I'm not there every day I'm only there for 1/4 of my assignment but with a very strong family history of cancer I I can't understand the teacher uses the auditorium but he can have his students not walk over the tiles I teach Orchestra the band and Orchestra students have to walk over the section in question to get to their instructional space and I have a legary question this is related to the budget and I'm not being sarcastic how much are we spending defending lawsuits and again I'm not being sarcastic is that in the budget somewhere I'll email tomorrow and ask where can I see that in the budget and I know
095we have an insurance policy but I've been wanting to say this for a while my oldest friend on this planet is the chair of a school board in a very high performing school system in the Northeast and she says the way to protect yourself from liability is to remove the causes that would encourage people or require people to to sue for a remedy you don't Shield yourself from liability by trying to pretend you don't have liability or that you don't know what's going on or that you don't have the expertise the way you Shield yourself from liability personal liability is to fix the things that would make people sue you and I offer this as a friend and a neighbor because these people have been so kind thank you they I cannot believe that they
096hadn't gone to a class action lwuit at this point thank you are there any other comments as relates to the budget all right there comments ahead we will end the public hearing no worries at this time we will reset the public hearing for um the fiscal year 2026 budget reconvene to the school board next up we have board action items 6.01 receive for Action approval for early commandment and Lial bonuses thank you madam chair uh given the hour I will be brief in the presentation we have a host of bonuses but the only ones that we are requesting action on this evening is early commitment bonuses those are bonuses for individuals who agree to come to RPS now for next year uh we have found that doing so can be quite effective um it would
097um commit us to uh $225,000 in next year's budget so we would need to keep that SA or san in our budget discussions um but we did feel that was worth it to ensure that we were able to fill as many spots as quickly as possible um uh through this process would that have to engl Mr drr mam thank you superintendent cameras uh I think in this very competitive market it's important to lock in our our future candidates and future employees as early as possible so I I commend that uh that strategy I know that you're not asking for approval uh for what you what the other siphons and uh strategies that youve laid out but I do feel compelled to comment on all those um I am concerned about the uh I understand the
098the math and science are hard to um uh hard to um staff um but and I know that makes sense when we talk about the quantitative numbers when we talk about how many folks are in the building how teaching these subjects and and and such um but I I wonder what the qualitative effects of this might be that you know there does that devalue what other teachers are doing I'm one of those teachers that doesn't teach math or science and I can tell you that what I do in my classroom is just as important as what someone does in a math or science classroom um and so I would I would be very fearful of uh bifurcating our our faculty U creating animosity between people because of the content that they teach so uh I
099I just am very very concerned about that and I've had a number of my uh constituents ask about how we Define hard to staff as well um and and so that I would also that that maybe is my question uh but the other I just wanted to to share my my concern uh if you choose to you know ask for that in the future thank Mr H thank you madam chair thank you Mr HB I I certainly understand your concern uh the selection of math and scien is based on where we have the highest frequency of VES with no judgment whatsoever about the relative merits or value of different subjects but merely where we have the highest number of vacancies similarly hard to sta schools are def finded empirically by those schools that have the
100highest percentage of vacancies and we traditionally have difficulty faing but again I'm not bringing those forward this evening as they would commit the school system to a significant expense in FY 26 and I that would be putting the cart for the first as we are still engaged in budget conversations back here Mohamed thank you madam chair thank you Mr cameras um for that Clarity I am concern concern that we are dipping into a budget to promise um bonuses a early commitment for new hes when we have not approved the budget for FY 26 so we're already promising monies from a budget that we have yet to approve and I think for me no I know for me that's backward and so I I do appreciate the um growth mindset in terms of trying to recruit
101and fill the vacancy but we've had vacancies all year it is clear go to the website and so I'm going to speak to two schools in my district in particular that have not been supported with full Equity we do not have a definition of what is hard to sta if you speak to building principles and assistant principles if you speak with people in central office they have a different definition that's a concern for me and I know that we're not um the request is not to approve the other pieces to this but I recommend I highly recommend that we do not approve this tonight because we have yet to move into an unpack a budget where there's so many gaps and in my professional opinion and so many concerns with high cost of programs and
102not supporting our staff and so I will be voting not on this not because I don't support bonuses for new recruitment but because we're not doing enough currently to fill the vacancies that we have and I'm a witness to two of my schools as a matter of fact three of them where we lost a math coach because we could not move on the EXP the um the urgency of filling that position and so now one of my elementary schools has a high risk of moving backward because we didn't move quick enough and so again I will be voting know on this tonight thank you Mr Mr per Madam shair Mr C explain to me what would the what would approving this give you what tools does it give you what changes does it allow you
103to make as opposed to waiting for the normal budget proc Mr C thank you madam chair thank you Mr for the question um if we were to wait until our budget is fully adopted uh that will likely occur at the end of May um our biggest time for hiring is from now to May so the early commitment bonuses helps us lock in talented individuals during the peak of the Hing season thank you madam chair mral and M bur thank you madam chair just for clarity does this commit us to any dollars prior to July 1 Mr Hammer no Mr first all M thank you madam chair I believe Mr first go just asked a question that was on my mind as well so I two two questions number one I just want to make sure
104I'm clear for this ask this will come out of our current budget yes Mr thank you madam chair uh M no it would come out of next year's budget these bonuses would not be paid until these individuals became employees when they would start um usually in the July August timeline but you may recall we have done things like this in the past however we used American Rescue plan funding so we were able to um be rather generous since we got a lot of American Rescue plan funding and it was available over the course of many years that is why we're in a little bit of a different situation this year follow M chair and I correct that we do have a do this weekend is that this coming weekend yes sir followup question Madam chair
105so is that okay yeah so your question is in the event that we get whatever teachers to teach whatever openings we currently have they would be given a a bonus for signing as we have done in the past yes ma'am and what percentage what what exactly would that percentage be above what they would not get or what is the amount uh right now they would get nothing if they they were to sign um I'm sorry I I may have misunderstood the question well okay when they you come in SE July or September whenever they sign form a contract to get started what is the amount I know in the past we did 4,000 or 2,000 or whatever the amount was is there a set amount I'm going to ask uh Miss chain to come on
106up and share that information and then my other question is how many persons are we planning to do this for just the ball fig as to what we're working with thank you good evening so we estimate about 30 individuals and the signing bonus would be 7500 I believe Mrs Burke was inquiring as to what is the current signing bonus and would there be any difference I don't believe we currently have sorry I'm sorry I thought you answered that question thank you okay man I'm not clear now I what you were saying but at one time we did give a bonus that's that's the question last hiring season yes ma'am which was for what amount um I do believe it was 45 um yes but as of right now Mrs Burke just to be precise anyone
107who is signing today does [Music] not previous bonuses that we provided were using the art funds which we no longer have access to which is why if someone was signing out they would not receive that they were to be very they were for last year's hiring which uh once we rolled over to the new school year they concluded so now we're going into next hiring season and so we're bringing them back for consideration if I may I think the clarity is surrounding um when they sign we hear that no one gets paid today what is what are the steps from the the if if there's a candidate that we intend to hire what will be the next steps leading up to this bonus process I think that's what the clarity is needed thank you madam
108chair so if I were to sign my commitment letter if this were approved um that would then commit me to come to RPS for the 25 26 six school year um and then uh typically the way the bonus is paid out is typically in two installments um one they would receive in the fall and then one they would receive in the spring uh it includes a clawback provision such that if the individual were to leave I believe the period is within three years we would claw back from their pay the amount of bonus because they're committing to stay for that period of time as well one last yes and then I'm done so is this just to get clarity on this which I'm not there yet I will be is this inclusive of hard to
109staff schools or this is for the positions in which you early who is this for this is for individuals who would commit right now to coming to RPS next fall yes ma'am okay thank you so there is no incentive for har to St schools at this time we have not brought that forward to the board because of the expense related to it um that said I'm more than happy to uh modify the proposal for the early bonus bonus the early commitment bonus to be for individuals who commit to RPS at one of the hardest staff schools if that is uh the desire of the board it Narrows the field a little bit but we could certainly um go that direction as a compromised measure we can I could just feel thank you for sping the
110time to clarify that and I do feel better about what was just stated at the end of the day each be quiet Circle um I was just wondering do we know what the other counties around us are planning to offer in terms of sign in bonuses I don't know if we I know they're also going through the budget so they're probably doing the same things but if enrio is guaranteed to offer $5,000 of assment bonus that's going to impact the new teachers we can attract if we are not prepared to offer something as well thank you thank you madam chair thank you Mr rard um we do not yet know for certain um we were hoping to preempt anybody else I will say that we at RPS typically um need to pay a premium to
111attract uh similarly experienced Educators um given the many real challenges that teachers in RPS face um um as you heard from speakers our buildings are far older and in Far um L good shape which creates all kinds of challenges and so when teachers are making decisions about where to go um uh we typically have to pay more to attract the same C individual I have a few questions FL um comments thank you for the presentation um I think it would have probably been helpful to just go through the presentation um just because there's so many nuances to this piece that's just some feedback um nevertheless um I would aim to uh say that hard to sta schools has to be a priority in this um and I don't know if how we can structure it
112so that that remains top of mind speaking from a district that have um a very high vacancy rate um and the and some of the schools with the highest population en Richmond Public Schools um I think that we have to somehow ensure that we remain attractive and the those areas I I'll stop there I have another thought but wanted see if you could chime in there yes Madam chair um for my earlier comment my uh modified recommendation to the board would be to approve the early commitment bonuses for individuals who commit to hard to staff schools um thank you for that um compromise um I lost my second question one second it will come back important um I'll move on to my third thought um I I love the the concept of bonuses I think
113that it it really helps us to create um this um attraction to Richmond Public Schools I would be remiss to say if I didn't get the feedback that there have been times in the past where bonuses were promised and somehow we're kind of we dropped the ball and ensuring that we follow through with that regard and so as we move forward with this bonus initiative um if we could just sharpen up the the execution uh to ensure that a promise that is made is a promise that is kept Dr Harris yes thank you excuse me thank you madam chair in addition I still have not heard a clear definition of what is hard to STA and let me give this example Martin Luther King Junior middle school has made tremendous uh strives in their instructional
114program and their discipline but they continue to be a hard to sta School however they are penalized because they have moved the needle but they're still hard tode they have six vacancies in that school in math and reading so I can't support something that doesn't have a clear definition to it I support bonuses I support SS I support all those things but it's not Equitable across the division and I'm going to stand on what is Equitable also what is excellent thank you thank you did you want to come thank you madam chair only again to say that we look at the schools with the highest percentage of vacancies based on the available funding if we feel that we could address the top five of those schools those would be the hard to staff so for
115example if a school had 100 positions 10 were vacant they have a vacancy rate of 10% um if that's the highest rate and the next high school has a vacancy rate of 8% and so on we take the top ones figure out how many positions are there how much we can afford and when we designate those schools as the hardest to stop um I did recall my my question but you have me going a different direction um but for the sake of just continuity and time um the sign on bonuses um that we offer to new new hires um Dr Harris muhammd made a comment earlier of having concerns about not being able to anticip at what the budget will be can you just share your perspective let's just say that I think the target
116was 30 um new Associates $7500 per associate we get them teed up we get them ready to go and knock on wood hopefully this does not happen we don't get the in anticipated budget that we asked for how will we circum or offset um what we've promised the the new hires if we don't have the allotment that's being promised thank you madam chair we would have to find an offset somewhere else in our budget if I I recognize that is concerning truly I do um which is why I very intentionally did not bring forward for your consideration the fal SLE of bonuses um but I also know that the cost of not having a fully licensed teacher both financially and of course academically not to mention socially and emotionally and so many other domains is
117very high and our ability to reach our goals is tied very tightly to our having a great teacher in every classro and so that's why this is the only I'm bringing forward to you for consideration that would bind us going forward and my commitment to the board is if you do approve this I will find the necessary non-personnel reductions if we were not to get the funding for this I see a few hands but I want to allow um Mr Jafar I think his hand was raised and Mr Rizzy also would like to ask a question as well in that order thank you m chair okay now I'm trying to wrap my around this and I recogize Mr C uh your willingness your state willingness to revisit that and I heard the phrase hard to
118staff schools and be able to somehow incorporate those into the equation and so I'm wondering as I sit here are we saying now based on the way the plan is presently designed that we will offer people or new staff bonuses and they get to choose where how how does that work thank you madam chair thank you Mr Jafari so we would per my updated recommendation uh Define the set of heart staff schools those with the highest vacancy rates they would then commit to going to one of those schools that is what they would be Comm to okay as a followup Madam chair so then again back to my original question that will come after you revise the current F that is presly on the table not Incorporated my I have modified my recommendation this evening
119so what I am asking approval for this evening is now the early commitment bonuses for our do we have mam chair of course do we have a list what if a hard to St you would dra me here we have two different this for school May yes yes so no we don't have two different lists of schools um and I apologize if the term hard to staff is is confusing um what that is we look at the schools that have the highest percentage of vacancies those are the ones that have found it most difficult to fill their teaching spots those are the ones that we would be asking people to commit to to get the bonus so for example if there again is a school has 100 teacher positions and they've got 20 vacancies then
120they have a 20% vacancy rate um we would be saying look that is one of the hardest staff schools so if you would like to come to RPS and receive this bonus you have to commit to going to that school not some another school that has one vacancy we don't need to worry about that school we want you to focus on I make one last question so do we know historically where hard to stand schools are do they continue to be in the very same places that they always are not always there is some consistency um but they have inflow over time um there are many factors uh that play out we have had schools that have been very challenging to fill uh but because of new programs or new leadership um or uh upgraded
121facility they have become easier to fil some are persistently part um and we try to create incentives for additional folks to come there m thank you madam chair can you all hear me okay yes ma'am thank you thank you um I guess you know when we talk about sign on bonuses it's always difficult you know um as someone who has taught for years um whenever there's a new croper people who come in with bonuses it always made me feel a certain type of way and there's no way to avoid that um I have two questions um first of all do we think or or have we researched whether these bonuses that we're offering makes it whether they make us competitive with the other school districts who are using similar methods recruitment methods yes um thank
122you Mr R um we are not yet exactly sure what our competitors and the counties um and other school divisions are going to do but um we have a sense that it's going to be a tight Market uh this hiring season and so we expect others to be the same um we do know from prior years when we did have the ARP funds um that the bonuses were attractive and did bring in quite a significant number of individuals um it's always hard to know exactly what motivated somebody right uh but it was certainly helpful to us in in past Hing seasons yeah thank you and and then the other part of the question is uh I'm sorry madam chair may I continue of course thank you um you know when we have bonuses of this
123nature and Mr Camas please correct me if I'm wrong what ends up happening is that the har to staff schools um end up with a lot of new teachers and no shade in new teachers I was once one myself but there's so much research that shows that students who um need the most are often in classrooms with the least experienced teachers have you considered any kind of incentives to get experienced teachers to move to some of these schools thank you madam chair and thank you for the question Mr Z yes look I agree um having more experienced folks uh tends to be better for kids um look we also get to choose who we offer the early commitments to and we prioritize people with experience so brand new folks um with obvious exceptions are uh
124not the ones that would be at the top of the our list we're looking for folks with experience five six seven 10 years of experience who would be willing to come to these Harvest St awesome thanks thank you so there were several hands raised but the order that I caught was um Mr hedgepath Mr Faro Miss B and then Mr thanks Madam chair uh Mr Camas the idea of spending money before we have it gives me heart palpitations but I thankful that you are sure that you'll find a spot for uh for reductions to to cover this because I I don't want to handicap your experience um from the beginning I want you to have the tools that you need in your tool box to recruit in a time that is arguably one of the
125the worst for Teacher recruitment uh so I also appreciate the the the clarity on the thank you on the part to staff schools I think you know what you know whatever you decide that is particular if it was just last year if it's an average of the past certain amount of years we can communicate and be very transparent about that metric so we have a universal understanding of what hard to staff means um so that our existing teachers and community members understand that I would feel comfortable with uh the amended uh requests tonight thank you Mr F Madam chair I I support the original proposal and I support the amended proposal as well I really appreciate the ments and questions that my colleagues on this board have made as a Public School parent but as
126a non- educator it's been really helpful for me to hear that again as a non- educator I think the original proposal was really good I worry about trying to play with what seems to be a partially moving Target with the hard to staff schools but again if if that's what brings us to a bigger consensus I'm open to that thank you madam chair thank you Miss B thank you madam chair um I too appreciate the dialog we've had this afternoon because we've gone from and we need to have this conversation because this is something new um what I'm thinking is I would really like to have defined as already mentioned what is how many second okay um what is a hard to staff school because I'm thinking from my experience as a principle I never
127had a fully staff School of certified teachers for 20 almost 20 years so that back to also um unfortunately us that hard to St at school you have other problems or other challenges I should say it may be um another need besides having that teacher there can I I ask for pleas yes ma'am all right thank you so my question is um I do want to see what is a house staff School my other question is for those teachers in the past that did receive a two years ago or whatever are they still with us I'd like to see some data on that and my third item is um what about a bonus for teachers who are currently employed with experience to go to a h staff School you promise me $7500 to be a
128school for two years that's an next vacation think providing I can go back to my old school so what about a teacher in this side of town coming to share her knowledge or his knowledge here and experience does make a difference thank you for the thank you Mrs um I think you have eliminated the fact that hard to staff is a confusing term and so I was conferring with the chair perhaps we should call it high vacency schools which might be a little bit clear and all right well I I'll keep trying um as for your last thought um it is it is certainly an interesting um proposal though it does not increase the total number of teachers at RPS and so we want to try to expand the pool so that we're we're closing
129vacancies that said I would love to talk with this board in the future um about ways to incentivize our most experienced and most expert teachers to teach at our highest poverty schools um that was a a bigger conversation but when I think is worth us having absolutely Mr thank you madam chair just because I know there's been a lot of discussion on what is hard to staff what is a high vacancy I was just curious what we actually thought the price differential would be if we went with the original proposal just early commitment versus early commitment to a hard to staff school like how much money are we actually saving um or we or is it really not that much Mr K thank you madam chair thank you Mr uh essentially either way it's for
13030 spots the only difference would be in The modifi Proposal we'd make sure those 30 spots go to the high vacancy school so the cost yes M Mr P thank you madam chair let me SLE up and get on this horse and beat it to death um High vacancy schools uh I I'm with my colleague um Mr pero on supporting the original uh ask only because a nless definition cuts both ways is there a risk of leaving money on the table if we can't Define what the job is and we are assuming what a hard staff school is if somebody says no I don't want to go to that school are we not filling a position elsewhere because we we've sort of cornered ourselves into requiring it to be something we're not quite sure what
131the definition of Mr thank you madam chair and thank you Mr personal for the question I am not too concerned about that and if we did get to a point where we were we're we're six weeks eight weeks down the road and we've only been able to get out 15 early commitment bonuses to high vacancy schools I would come back to the board and ask for permission to broaden it to the original proposal so that we didn't leave anything on I have a couple of questions I am a proponent of changing the title I do believe that it does cause a bit of confusion when you think of a hard to staff school by definition it could mean someone who has had challenges a school that's had challenges with hiring overall and not necessarily speak
132to the vacancy Fe so I think there should be a distinction um between the two so that is very clear what we're speaking on when we speak about heart to St schools and um you know your proposal wasn't necessarily sex when it comes to um High vacancy schools but it's very clear direct to the point and so I I would be ad meable to that um the only and I am um in favor of the amended version um for uh for hard to staff or vacancy schools my only question is with a high vacancy school um would you mind if I get DCT appreciate your grace you spoke of the percentage based on the need right or the need based upon the percentage in districts such as the ninth where we have a high employee
133rate we have a a preference of teachers but the impact is greater as it relates to the vacancies I just want to be sure that when we're looking at the Dynamics of the schools that we take into account um the amount of vacancies may impact each School differently I hope that makes sense I just wanted to call that out not to say to change anything but something to be um to consider think we're good at this point do we have a motion M CH make a motion I move to approve the amended early commitment bonus as presented by the administration Amendment meaning um our staff schools do I have a second second it has been motioned by Mr Wesley catch and second by Mr faroo to approve the early commitment and referral bonuses as amended
134for hearts and staff schools madam cler there's a question Miss would the um Mr hedback consider changing the um name of this project rather than part staff schools to um schools with vac is subject to that exent because hard the staff schools I don't want to go there yes I go there but this state there vac schools there could be other causes for that so my my my ask is that he would amend the motion to every SP sure thing yes just want to re it I think we're good so it's been did you have a question just ready toot for clarity sake to ensure that we are clear on what we are voting on okay it has been motioned by Mr hesap and seconded by Mr Farooq to approve the early commitment and referral
135bonuses for 2025 and 2026 with the amendment for high vacancy schools M CL Mr P yes Mr car yes Mr yes Mr yes M rzy yes Dr Harris Mohamed no m b yes Mr without standing I'm no M Fernandez yes motion pass thank you and now we'll move on to um 6.02 receive for Action policy 4- 3.3 relations with law enforcement authorities I believe just before Miss wi Dr wi pardon me um presents we'd like to call out that um we have also uploaded the overview um as stated in last night's um board meeting and so just wants to ensure that the public knows where to find that thank you good evening School Board chair Vice chair school board and superintendent cameras tonight come to provide an update to item 6.02 since November our multilingual
136Department out of the office of academics has been strategic in our preparation as to how we can support our multilingual families in the wake of the changes in Immigration policy this plan and related processes have been in collaboration with the mayor's office The Immigrant and Refugee engagement office and our office of Engagement and other Community Partners we have gathered resources for schools and families and created protocols to help our school leaders navigate the changes in Immigration policy in the state and now we will have our um Victoria goz who is our um budsman who will provide a short review of the steps that we have taken and then we will ask for any questions we continue to say RPS is a safe place because we want to make sure that our students are present every
137day because we love them again thank you Mr Camas before sces U speaks I just wanted to note that Miss Blackwell who you all know um has been instrumental to this work unfortunately she has a sick child at home and is unable to be with us this evening but she's certainly as you know is a passionate advocate for all of our students and um has been instrumental to the development of much of our work and I just wanted to make sure that she received that recognition thank you thank you Dr W good evening school board thank you for allowing me to be here tonight um as Dr wian said I'm Victoria goes and I'm the onsman for students and families for richond public schools as uh Dr wigin said before since November 2024 the off
138the department of multilingual Learners excess has convened and began having discussions with other departments within the academic office regarding the upcoming changes that we are now seeing currently in 2025 um since uh January 2025 we have kind of extended those conversations to the office of Engagement as well and we met to develop a response to be shared with the leadership team um we also discussed our communication plans for how to address our response to immigration and law enforcement next slide please thank you um so we have bolstered our Communications in regarding uh our stance on the response to immigration as you all I'm sure saw the video that superintendent Camas shared this past week regarding our our believe that all students are welcome in Richmond Public Schools and all students are protected under the US
139Constitution to attend schools we have conducted training with principls twice now the first training was held on the 24th of January and the second training was on the 31st of January the principal directors were also in attendance during these trainings in addition we've also conducted training with our care and safety Associates our care and safety Associates on the 31st of January as well as support staff on the 31st of January that includes social workers school counselors family Rons and student support Specialists this past Monday we conducted training with our office Associates as well as today we conducted our training with lead teachers next SL thank you appreciate it um the impacts on attendance as of yet we have not seen or um experienced any evidence that our chronic aism rates are are impacted or will
140be impacted save for yesterday which was a nationwide initiative called a day without immigrants um in which Across the Nation students as well as just individuals stayed home uh from work and from school and refrain from shopping to show solidarity with our immigrant population in the United States and as a result schools Across the Nation did experience significant uh drops in attendance but we don't anticipate that to continue the next steps in our plan uh first of all we're encouraging families please update your emergency contacts and you're okay to pick up contacts at the school as well as preparing family preparedness plans we're continuing to collaborate with the Department of culture and climate to ensure that we are providing the adequate supports for our students across the School Division that are impacted by the recent
141immigration policies Across the Nation and also to support our families that are impacted by ice detainment we're collaborating with local immigration activy groups to facil tra trainings and offer legal and emotional supports to our impacted families we're planning to have a training on February 11th with the International Rescue committee or IRC on how to identify trauma in students affected by immigration enforcement and lastly led by the academics office the Department of Family and Community engagement and the department of climate culture and student services will establish Dropout prevention and attendance protocols next slide please thank you thank you Victoria um I do want to highlight um what doc what superintendent camon said we um Dr blackw would have been here tonight with um about her child but her Department which is in the academic department has
142been um very instrumental in making sure that we were prepared and started to prepare very early along with our other departments including engagement so um we would like to take any questions you have questions I'd like to make a comment um thank you for being proactive and not reactive to um the the federal mandates that were brought down it's interesting that we as a as a school board had reached out wanting to do a resolution to re you know to encourage the families only to hear that you all had already started planning on creating a resolution and so it really speaks to our commitment to our Scholars to our staff to our families that we want to keep them safe so thank you um these are unprecedented times but with the commitment that we have
143with our fellow colleagues in the administration I have no doubt that we will ride the w thank you I believe we also have to approve the policy or so at this time we need to vote on the policy as stated and the resolution mam my I move that we approve the policy 43.3 relations with law enforcement authorities as well as the resolution that has been drafted to support it second it's been moved by Dr Harris muhammd and seconded by Miss Berke to adopt the um Power 4- 3.3 relations with law enforcement authorities and the resolution mam CL mral yes yes Mr per yes Mr H yes Mr rzy yes Dr Harris mam yes yes Mr jaari yes M Fernandez yes motion thank you all right at this time we will move forward with the amended
144item 6.04 next up is 6.03 receive for Action head report approval good evening again um this is our monthly Head Start report you see all the documents attached and um our head start at um new um policy council is doing great um next month we have um made sure we have the training that needs to happen for you so we look forward to the training this will be back in March um for um head start training um but we look forward to continuing to grow our program you have any questions [Music] Harris Mohammed thank you madam chair I move that we accept the ha start reports for approval as listed um for your information second it's been moved by Dr Harris muhammd and seconded by Mard to approve at start report mral yes Mr yes
145Mr per yes Mr yes Mr yes mam yes B yes Mr jaar yes M Fernandez yes thank you moving right along now we are at item um 6.04 um receip RPS school year calendar Amendment thank you mam chair I am requesting the uh change of one day to a full instruction Day from a current day off uh the options before the board are February 17th which is off for President's Day the week of spring break which is March 31st through April 4th Easter Monday which is April 21st or Memorial Day which is May 26 I welcome the board's decision Dr Harris Mohammed yes Madam chair thank you Mr K thank you for that I have a couple of questions what is our current number of instructional hours during the day is a 5.5 or the
146six hours can you come up to the desk please 6.5 hours chair follow up so if the state requires 5.5 and we are currently in 6.5 5.5 is roughly 1,47 something hours so 6.5 is going to give us clearly over 2,000 hours do we need to make up the day if we've already exceeded the number of instructional hours mam Mr C yes the short answer is no uh in fact we could uh likely end school at some point in early May given the number of instructional hours that we provide our students however without the addition of one more school day um I do want to be clear that we would fall below 170 days as a result uh chronic absenteeism would be calculated based on uh a denominator 170 meaning if you were absent 17
147days you would be considered chronically absent as opposed to 18 I do want to be very transparent with the board that will have a sign significant negative impact on our chronic absente ISM rates and so I do advise the board certainly it is your decision to add back in one instructional day as um our colleagues have been very smart to do in the PES to ensure that we are above the 170 Dr har thank you Mr C thank you for that our community needs to know that they do not understand that concept that a day makes a difference when it comes to us calculating chronic absentismo and high level discussions of this magnitude that we bring all the information forward to the public so they can understand we have to be um a day a
148day that we have um so determined to be in a growth mindset and transparency and so many people do not know and I will bet you our staff does not understand that concept because it has never been explained to them that chronic absent absen ism is a part of our accreditation and it it makes a difference with one day but we did not explain that in our meeting yesterday and and so and we have never explained that and any um language or communication it just will help them are we going to reach everybody with our Communications no we know that but when people when we have individuals that are calculating the out such as myself um because it's just what I used to do as a building principal and and now it is it is
149clear it has to be clear that is not so much or we have the time we don't have to because we have the time a lotted or in our safe box the kids don't have to come to school however if that denominator it wasn't explained that way but that denominator makes a difference and so I appreciate you unpacking that with the um for hour community and Community Partners so they can understand that even though we have the time that because chronic absentismo years ago before we had the attendance piece 15 minutes or 30 minutes were added to each day and at the end of the year if we did have snow we didn't have to worry about making it up so apparent we cont with that well my question is to to our superintendent is
150number one um what days for Chester also had the same days off and we all pretty much stay consistent or aligned with each other because of where people live and their children and all the rest what days have they utilized and have another question follow from that yes I do not want to give you incorrect information so I would have to check that Mrs B all right then my I know need to make a decision I'm glad 17 keep to know Advance appreciate that and then my other question is snow is predicted for next [Music] week um we actually are preparing a communication that if we are uh forced to not be able to hold School physically we will go to a virtual learning day to preserve the number of instructional days and we will
151be providing communication to our families and staff about that very soon Madam chair I'd like to make a motion uh I motion that we RPS converts Monday April 21st from the holiday to full day for this school year second it has been motion by Mr far and seconded by Mr peral is there a matter of debate Miss ver thank you madam chair keeping aligned with the other religious holidays which we have April um 21st is a holiday as well so if we're going to get in the habit of of um change around for some religions then eventually may have as well and there are many persons on Eastern Monday that do have um I'm not other words I'm not going to go from faith of April 21st because it is a religious holiday for the
152faith of what I have thank you other thoughts I'd also like to chime in and share um I agree with my colleague um Miss Burke I think there's a slippery slope if we start to um make adjustments to let let's be clear this this is an actual policy that's in place that was confirmed yesterday evening it's a it's a policy that that recognizes this as a religious holiday um one that is um honored across um many states not just ours and I think that it's important for us to be sensitive to although it may not be a mass population for consistency state to allow those to observe religious holidays and to stay away from that in any regard for all of the religious holidays that are represent we have you know several like yam kapor
153Dali which I um was had a chance to to experience um a presentation at one of my schools jail friend um last year and many others and I just think we should keep that sacred um not for me personally but just at for a sake of consistency Mr HED thank you madam chair I um I do share U concerns for that date um for other reasons as well the uh often times 3day weekends holidays breaks are rallying points for our our teachers our students our communities to have time off um and I and and I I know that that that time is very valued I also think about uh hard to schedule appointments for doctors dentists things like that where our employees or teachers might have scheduled those out on days that are off um
154and you know are they is that going to be a challenge for them in the future I also think about know travel schedules uh that are made well in advance for the school year so those are some of my my concerns about that and my question for Mr Camas is that it what would preclude us from adding a day at the to the end of the year nothing but the of the public I I do want to note that we would be requiring our staff um to come uh in the first week of June which uh I think we could likewise prove your comments Mr HED but assume that many staff have made plans for that week and so um I do think that would similarly be disruptive unfortunately there are no good options here
155and so it's picking the least that Mard thank you madam chair um I certainly hear the concerns about April 21st um and um shared that I definitely understand that someone who works for a Church Easter is very much a part of my life um I think my only concern is that LE spring break which a lot of Staff have made plans for and I'm concerned about staffing issues which impacts our children um and then I definitely do not want to prolong the school year um the only other concern is of course Memorial Day which is a Federal holiday and to me that that's also important to not impact um so I know we're out of quandre um my one question is of course follows during winter break so I I guess you know we've never
156counted that as a religious holiday so to speak um I know for we pick we flip back and forth between yor and rash every year I believe right won one year W the next or not our policy is actually written to be just for keboard although that is a recommendation that we have received from some pick one or the other as usually one falls on the weekend so I guess my question sorry longwinded um how did we choose which holiday we we watch for each Mr thank you madam chair um we looked at what other jurisdictions around the Commonwealth and in other states had done um consulted uh various Faith leaders as well um to come to the Mr P thank you madam chair uh as superintendent pointed out there is no right answer um
157there's only looking at the data and trying to come up with at least bad answer and as the board we're the last stop and we are the ones who have to make decisions about not good answers there's only one option on here it our stated intention I just heard it a minute ago is to is to prevent chronic absenteeism so attendance is the goal if we were only one of those dates is is not a Federal holiday or otherwise spr break or um what I'm getting to is a a high probability of absenteeism so we were to reinstate Memorial Day a federal holiday weekends we are nearly guaranteeing iism likewise with spring break likewise with going into June the opposite is true of Easter Monday not withstanding religious observance I think we all need to
158cogent of that but it is not a Federal holiday which means there are many parents who work in federal state local governments and indeed commercial sectors that follow federal holiday guidelines those caregivers be at work that day and so there may actually be hidden benefits to to some of those families that would otherwise need to seek Child Care again it's not a comination on religious observance it's trying to make lonate and in this case the numbers to me are pointing to April 21st thank you um I'm not support of the April 21st date um for what has been stated uh before in many households it is respected and valued and um I do believe that um there was a question that was raised to extend the days um is there any thoughts around perhaps um
159that as an alternative um Mr C thank you madam chair unfortunately that does not solve our Chon issue that would be in support of Memorial Day as an alternative ready let can you repeat the motion please the motion on the floor that was motioned by Mr peral and the seconded by oh it was motioned byoo and seconded by Mr FAL um to um amend the calendar for to 2025 getting ahead of myself for April 21st right to convert April 21st 2025 and instructions day there we go Mr bable yes Mr car yes Mr per yes Mr hedge yes Mr rzy M thank you Dr mam no m b no Mr jaar yes M Fernandez now motion passes thank you all right next up is the consent agenda [Music] I I don't have a motion I
160just have a question sure I have requested to pull out Personnel actions out of the Cass agenda we did it one time Madam chair and I'm making another request that we do that that we continue to do that thank you for that that feedback um discuss um there was a discussion that we would like to Mr Camas to share with us as relates to perhaps um keeping the Personnel items um for the second date of the um school board meeting but having a close session to discuss any concerns on the Monday could you clarify I'm sure I just M that up thank you m chair um in our new structure we always have a Clos session on the Monday board meeting at which time if there were any concerns about personel actions the board could
161raise them at that time and at that point we could then determine if it were needed to pull Personnel actions out of the consent agenda on the Tuesday meeting um and that way uh it would address anybody's concerns but the default would be to leave in consent and if there were no questions raised during the Monday close then you can move forward with a in consent Dr Harris mohamd the concern I have about that is the public is scratched out of the discussion of personnel the Personnel actions and I know during public comment of course we do not um mention names however when board members have a concern about the Personnel actions particularly positions schools and things of that um nature I think the public needs to hear that and so just having the discussion
162in closed session is a concern for me because we haven't done that in the past unless it's a particular individual dealing with a particular hire or termination which sometimes have a different process so of course it is the will of the board but um I think this has been a long discussion of mine about Personnel actions being in consent agenda because we're just like voting for everything in the block and we have not had any discussion about the Personnel actions and sometimes information on our Personnel actions item is incorrect or um omitted and so I just think the public needs to be a part or hear a part of that conversation of course without um violating um any of our policies when it comes to individual names Mr Camas thank you madam chair just to
163clarify if there were concerns uh something was omitted something needed to be changed uh in the past you would have had that conversation in closed session and then when the board came out of closed you would have um say approved and amended Personnel actions list um all that I was articulating and that we discussed with board leadership was you could still have that conversation you would just do it on the Monday evening and if there were no such concerns you would just move forward um with Personnel in consent um so for example well yes I'll leave it there is there a motion Dr Harris moham I'm still not clear because I don't see the issue of of of honoring the request I just don't understand and maybe it's me but I I just don't understand
164why that has to be but we can move forward thank you so much Madam Chair for My Clarity um Dr Harris Muhammed could you describe how you would like to see Personnel action items handled moving forward just from my understanding to understand the difference between what is being proposed and what is current I would like to see as I've stated before Personnel actions underboard action items every meeting if it's because we have a new Cadence if it's that Monday or if it's that Tuesday I would like to see it um there when it is under consent agenda it gives many in the public that we are um approving a Personnel action docket without having conversation about that and when we are approving things under consent agenda it is my understanding from training that we are
165just approving it we're not having discussion at least that's how the board in the past has moved and so I don't feel comfortable with that because we're not having sometimes we may not have discussion about that about the Personnel action item but I think it should um I think it should be there but again if you know the board moves in a different direction that's fine I just I'm not clear on what the superintendent has um has proposed maybe I can think about it and come try to understand it but I don't with all my experience and education having it under a consent agenda is not helpy but I'm always open to different of course to different things but right now I'm I'm not comfortable having it remain under consent agenda for the many reasons
166that have stated in the past thank you for allowing me that time no thank you um I do believe that there when the documents are uploaded two weeks in advance we have the ability to view Personnel action items and if there are any concerns we do have the ability to pull it out and discuss so I just want to be clear to the public that we do have the ability just because on the consent agenda does not mean um that we have to just abide by that without any call to order a question uh we do have the ability to pull those items out and um if I understand Mr cis's um feedback correctly that would be done on the Monday night of uh the board meeting in close and um if there are any
167items that we believe need to be pulled out for discussion once we come out to the to vote we will call those personal items out at that time yes mam chair that's correct also I just went back and checked our examples from hreo and Chester Field both of which include personal actions in the consent agenda thank you do we have a motion I'll second that okay we have a motion by Mr P and uh it has been seconded by um Mr hedpack to approve the consent agenda as as present Mr yes Mr car yes Mr brute yes Mr yes m r yes she said yes thank you Dr Harris m m b yes Mr ja yes m f yes moving on to new business before we move forward colleagues I will just share it is
1689:15 Dr Harris mam thank you madam chair I would like to bring forth again I know our new sitting board was not um present for this conversation but in November and December of 2024 I requested or I recommended excuse me let me change the language if I if I may recommended an external audit of the talent office I requested that several times but most recently in November and December and I am um Coming forth with that recommendation again I am also recommending that we move forward with that external audit as soon as possible um uh following the steps that we have done with um previous audits in the past and I just want to stress external audit and we move forward with ex um expediency um oh in addition to that I would also like
169to see in the budget and I looked in the budget and it I made just need the line item the number possibly code of necessary um the funds that were allotted that were approved from the school board previous school board for the Richmond teacher Residency program because those all of those slots were not feel where did those funds go I don't and I may I may be missing it but where are those funds now and where are they allotted to go and um lastly because there has been some discussion about moving to ABM and some of our selective schools I am recommending for us to review the reports if any exist of the ABM firm before we approve or deny contractual Services I would like for it's a recommendation for us to make um just
170to review those Port reports that not only have been mentioned this evening during public comment but before thank you and I can also send that in the email because it was a lot thank you please do thank you I about to call you thank you m chair to look forward to the audit of the talent office as requested in December I by the for board um my question is I need Clarity regarding I'm getting emails from um persons asking about the 10% increase they were to receive and December about December whatever and you never did get it especially office assistance so um can you elaborate upon that please or does be added under new business report Mr thank you madam chair um Mrs B if you have any specifics if you could forward those to
171me I can was that was five hours ago I did follow and I've got some more this evening so to than any other business all right now we are going to move into close session um I Believe Miss Burke you have the motion yes maam I move that the school board of the city of Rich convening close session to discuss and consult with legal council concerning Personnel complaints and author as authorized by code 22- 3711 A8 and A1 to discuss and consider a gance case and Personnel case number 20251 involving the performance and discipline of employees as well as to discuss and consider the performance evaluation of three central office employ employees is authorized by 223 71181 to discuss and consult with legal councel regarding the performance of employees they relate code 2.2 37111 and
172the consultation and legal councel regarding for issues as authorized BYOD 2211 it's been moved by and seconded by Mr H to move into closes stated Mr first yes yes Mr yes Mr H yes m rzy yes M Fernandez yes we are now closed