001like to call this uh meeting of the pburg Schools Board of Education to order I'm GNA ask Mr jur to do roll call but first I'll note that miss mkey is not going to be able to be here tonight because she is sick and she was nice to not spread her germs with us so Mr jur roll call please Mr Bennington here miss lmer here Dr rord here Miss Roland Miller here I invite everyone to stand that we might say the Pledge of Allegiance algi to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right we welcome everyone to the commodor building today while you're here we um want to make sure that everyone is is
002safe uh please note that there are exits on uh both the East and West sides of our cafeteria all around in case of emergency there is an AED right outside these cafeteria doors and if you need to know the address it is 140 East Indiana Avenue at this time I'd like to um present the agenda for approval so moved second Mr Bennington Dr reford roll call please Mr Bennington yes Dr reford yes M ler yes Miss Roland Miller yes all right so um this time we have a several recognitions and so Mr Hustler I'll turn it over to you all right thank you very much and um so uh with us tonight is uh Miss Rebecca cofold who will be um uh sharing a statement about the business business advisory committee which she chairs and
003I'll I'll turn it over to um Miss Coffield for the uh statement and welcome this evening hello thank you and thanks for letting me go first so I can put on my cheer mom uniform and root for us against Anthony Wayne tonight um for those of you who don't know section 33 13.82% our role is to advise Administration and staff on how the programs they're putting into place are making our students prepared to be a part of our Workforce uh we are a volunteer committee and we volunteer to meet quarterly uh with District staff and administration to give advice on what programs are doing and how we feel that's applicable or not to us in the workforce so our statement uh meetings of the business advisory Council heing called the council were held on March
00421st 2024 June 20th 2024 September 19th 2024 and January 16th of 2025 meeting agendas are planned in partnership with uh Randy dror Treasurer Tom hosler superintendent and Brooke price assistant superintendent all of whom attend each meeting also attending each meeting to provide important feedback and ideas with the council are Justin Foltz director of student services and well-being uh and Susan Roland Miller board president lastly the implementation of action steps as they pertain to the business advisory council plan would not be possible without the direct work of Christine Albright coordinator for careers and community service liaison at perisburg schools now in her third year in this role at perisburg schools Miss Albright is pivotal to District programs for the development of student professional skills student Career Education and exploration and student networking and relationship building with
005industry and local community businesses Miss ALB attends all of our meetings as well notable accomplishments as they pertain to the business advisory council plan are the following updates to the perisburg school's business advisory council plan again this is required for annual submission to the Ohio Department of Education this plan outlines action steps responsible parties for the development of professional skills for future career building Partnerships and coordinating job experiences we held College and Career lunch and learn sessions uh during lunch at both the high school and the junior high school where students could learn about specific career paths and degree programs career Affairs provided an opportunity for students to gain insight into the career clusters that interest them students were able to make connections with adults who have jobs in the careers they find interesting and
006also collected information about the education required to be successful in that particular field they were also given the opportunity to make a connection between school programming choices and careers lastly students were given the opportunity to participate in professional skills such as communicating and talking guest classroom speakers shared their work experience to students um on how their studies connect to various career Fields inviting guest speakers into the classroom provide an opportunity to connect students with professionals and help them build their network of resources to Aid students in their career exploration and development to help them find the next step after graduation perisburg high school continues to host career day each spring during career day PHS students are differentiated based on their career Vantage Point freshmen and sophomores explore career paths through breakout sessions facilitated by local
007professionals from various Industries while Juniors participate in job shadowing experiences outside of peris spk high school just a plug for Miss Albright she's still looking for volunteers to serve as both speakers at career day as well as um having Junior Shadow you should any of the public be interested in serving in that capacity mock interview days are also conducted at perisburg high school each Academic Year students from perisburg high school's career prep course participate in career Readiness events where students are paired one-on-one with a business partner who interviews each student as if he or she were being interviewed by an employer for a paid internship or job The Experience allows students to participate in interviewing skills and professional behaviors while at the same time developing a level of comfort in communicating with professionals a mock
008interview also offers the chance to demonstrate the connection between academic Concepts being taught in school and how they are applied in the workplace exploration of potential career paths and obtaining basic work skills is facilitated through High School internships these longer term experiences Focus on exponential learning allowing students to investigate fields of study and career options several students from perisburg high school were connected to informal internship opportunities career day at the perisburg junior high school was run in conjunction with the DECA students from perisburg high school the perisburg junior high school career day allows seventh and eighth grade students to explore career paths and breakout sessions facilitated by local professionals from various Industries the event itself is run as a business project by perisburg high school students thus the perisburg junior high school career day serves
009a dual purpose of providing both real world real world project execution experience for the perisburg high school students operating the event the council continues to lift up the importance of the wide variety of pasts to in demand and high paid careers members represent multiple businesses where 4-year University degrees are not necessarily required and regardless of educational requirements training takes place with the employer as the council seeks to provide feedback to the district and administration on their career initiatives we continue to encourage the District staff students and parents to see the many paths available to students as they become the workforce of our future the council wishes to continue to support perisburg high school students by expanding workplace Readiness initiative options as representatives of the local business community we are committed to ensuring Partnerships that allow
010for new initiatives and opportunities for students recognizing the required budget reductions that will inevitably cause an increased workload load for and or reduction of staff that manage these programs the council remains ready to serve with great interest from the community we have expanded our membership and the business sectors we represent in the face of District budget constraints the council is aware our schools are holding the future of our Workforce for our businesses to succeed we must have schools to succeed we must understand the extreme consequences of not providing this support and we give our firm resolve to stand against the obstacles enacted by those that lack understanding of the mutual Destiny of school and business Community success uh as just one side note from the council itself there is an option for schools to decide
011to join a consortia if you will to fulfill this state requirement that by the way doesn't get any budgetary support from the state um but perisburg has enacted the idea of not doing that specifically enlisting members of the community people who live here people who work here people who expand businesses here it is important to the perisburg school district that we're working with the community to produce children who become Professionals in our community we are ready to help you wherever we may have service thank you thank you thank you I I want to thank Becky for her leadership of this group and for expanding it to include more and more different types of professions that have a voice then and how these careers are um kind of shared with the student and broadening that out
012um I I will confess that I just missed my first meeting in in January um but I'm aware that from the career day that they are specifically looking for people um with Health Care um Healthcare backgrounds trades stem so that's it's a really great day for students to start to be able to really ask questions and get face to face so if if you aren't one of those people and you know somebody that's one of those people um encourage him to reach out to Christine but thank you Becky thank you yeah yeah I'd like to just you know add again and Miss Rand Miller you led this group for for years and and you know I thought you're irreplaceable and I guess I'm I'm backing off on that now seeing the work that Becky has
013done and particularly putting together that impressive list of community Business Leaders that are here in the in the perisburg area is you know that's that's that's quite the list of people to help advise this district and the business needs uh that our students need to need need to get a grasp of as they go through perisburg so congratulations and thank you thank you and uh good luck at the game so we have some State qualifiers to recognize the the perisburg High School dance team and I'd like to invite uh Mr Deus up to in introduce the coach and the players so Mr tus I was hoping they would dance in thank you um it is my honor to introduce the perisburg High School dance team they um qualified and competed at the state competition on
014January 26th so I'm going to introduce uh Coach Sierra Clark and the team and uh coach Clark will tell you all about their accomplishments well oh yeah I I think I I think I know um so as doia said uh the team got to compete at States here at the end of January this is the first time in history that we were able to take four different categories to States um so it was really a big a big accomplishment because I believe there's only three other schools in the state that has taken this many um so I'm really proud and they have also um been able to compete in like the biggest largest categories this year so they went one step up and competed in the largest categories this year they came in fourth um
015in game day in the state fifth in large lyrical eighth in large palm and eighth in large hip hop as well so really big accomplishments here top 10 in all four categories that's awesome so I I was like I do my order a little bit different so I'm not really sure how they do it up there um I think they do an alphabetical but I do it in order of grade um so I'll introduce them um from our seniors uh first up we have lla fiser and then Kate brle you can come over here and say hi these are our two seniors they've been on the team for four years um and then we have our Juniors we have southernland blly pton Lynch Claire Meyers and Isabella Shields they look like they like they're so
016shy uh we have our sophomores uh we have Lily Shields Indian debruin and then Lily oh my bulock here I am thinking I have to look at them and then we have our freshman we have Lisa I'm not even going to try her with her last name because that's not me we have uh Presley McDonald's she is not here with us today we have Morgan yeah I last names are fun um Morgan what is your last name you see I I'm great with last names uh Cameron bugy did I say that nope not even close see see I'm I told you I know their first names that's all um we have Anna celle and Anna Waldo and am I missing anybody else oh and Stella Dawkins who is not here as well but here's our
017team for we have 16 members I want to say I've um I've been at three basketball games and you've performed at every halftime so I don't know how much more extra time you're spending Beyond practices and all of your competitions but I'm really grateful for the way you give back to the community and by the way you're pretty awesome I mean I love the synchronization it's so clear how much much you really worked so hard so congratulations I was hoping they would dance yeah I hoping they come dancing act like they're so shy [Laughter] if they had music maybe and as always we like to thank the parents the grandparents all the people that got them to practice got them to the competitions um their success is um due to your support so thank you
018for being here for all the ways that you make uh this possible for them and how well they represent our schools so thank you it was appropriate that I next we have a next we have a couple of donations that we would like to recognize so I'll bring uh ask Mr ABY to come up and we'll begin with the SS soe group donation our folks from um SS I'm gonna move this up just a little bit ssoe group here um again it's always fun I'm not a dancer just in case you get confused between the dance team and me but um uh it's always fun when I get to be here because that means that we are recognizing some great Partners in our community community and uh tonight we have a special uh group here
019with SS soe group um who recently made a donation along with some matching gifts um uh from another Foundation to provide clever Touches for clever Touches for the e8th grade um science department and I didn't know what a clever touch it was until I um learned more about it but it is a tool that the science teachers use in the classroom to it's an interactive touch screen that allows them to add a lot to their uh teaching and um the students I think get a kick out of it because they can perform experiments and that like shakes and flashes and and everything else so um it was uh brought forward to us by Jen Krueger one of our teachers at the Junior High and um and then we were able to fund four of those
020one for each of the of the um the sections there so uh we have our folks from SS soe here to um thank and I'll let you guys if you guys want to and also if you saw the um news in the blade recently I think you guys also have been doing a lot to support um education and lead I saw the the article this weekend so thanks for not only for what you're doing for perryburg but uh for students across the region so thank you just briefly I'm Vince spfy I'm the CEO at SS and this was brought forward by one of just parents of perisburg student Katie Grant who's responsible for for that so thank you Katie uh as he said we like to support education I was glad to see the business
021advisory Council we think the partnership between business and education is extremely important we're very focused as an engineering firm on science so we were happy to be part of this and we have dozens of perisburg families that work at ssoe so we're happy to support that and appreciate the recognition tonight thank you [Applause] should have brought a demo you know like a video or something thank you a perfect timing to recognize us soe coming after the business advisory Council so I appreciate that connection too makes a difference yeah yeah you know we find that uh anytime we can connect our business community and partners with our students it's uh mutually beneficial for for everybody so um now it's a little cold for ice screen tonight but um we do have the ruers here Rick and
022Dana uh Ruffner who are uh from oder Diner um and they are here to make their annual uh donation to The after prom committee um so we have Stacy gisler who's one of the chairs of after prom so coming up we get to recognize a great business partner but then also um again highlighting the volunteers so um and Stacy and her team who's co-chairing with uh Mary hire who couldn't be here tonight but um for those of you that aren't aware the after prom is a traditional full fully funded uh it's fully funded through donations uh to celebrate prom in in a safe way um her name after the prom and uh Rick and the folks at OD deer have have really been a an annual uh supporter of this and um it's I I
023know it's been something we appreciate I think you've had a lot of fun being part of it and then we'll also make the plug for um anybody else to that wants to um sponsor yeah get involved or sponsor or po eventually be a chair in a year or two is that especially for maybe some of those younger dance families so um again uh we just want to bring up Rick and Stacy and I don't know if um Rick I forget what the total you we had a total last year I'll I'll tell you what is uh we do have a donation this year uh again we're $2,957 this year which brings our grand total over the time that we've been doing this to uh um like $3,585 and uh my wife and I both are
024alums of Perry I'm 81 my wife was 84 so we have a soft spot in our hearts for Paris for schools and we were just sitting out there and I know that um when we first started this which I'll hang that check to you and I'll let you speak but we were just sitting out there it's amazing what it cost to put this event on now and when we first started giving to this event it only cost about $155,000 to put this event on and I'll let you go from there and tell you what it cost now thank you very much though yes so thank you again on behalf of myself and my co-chair Mary H High all of our wonderful volunteers who we have one of them here tonight as well as a class
025of 2025 for your continued support of after Prem um without Community Support as you know we wouldn't be able to put on as Jeff said this safe and fun uh event for all of our seniors and their guests so thank you again um and yes we were talking about our budget I'm like it's about $25,000 now to put on this event so every little bit helps so tell them do they know um so this year our theme is a western theme um we always have uh I should say always this is my third year being involved but we have a lot of Inflatables we have two mechanical blls this year um we have three cartoonists that sketch the kids and or a couple kids at a time and those gals last year worked from the
026time the event started until like we were like okay guys it's time to go so we we upped it to three this year to make sure everybody got their cartoon sketches um there we have food trucks Donuts sandwiches um just a lot going on they do relay races so very excited to be a part of this and again thank you for all of your we excited to be a part of it too great appreciate [Applause] it and I know Rick when we began this we had a a primary funer of the after prom who backed out unexpectedly and um Rick had uh planned on doing doing the antique car show and said you know we could have that be something that could raise funds to to um you know to have the car Crews be
027something where we could collect funds for that so it was really uh very important those early years until we kind of got our footing again and and also I think not only is it a benefit to our students but on Friday nights the downtown and area businesses are busier there's a lot of foot traffic where folks you know come and check out the the great classic cars and then they're hitting many of the businesses so not only is it a partnership that benefits our students which is fantastic but it also is something that gives back to the community every Friday night as long as it doesn't rain or it gets too dry out um you know we have the ability to to do something to help the local businesses as well so it's it's a
028win-win for everybody so thanks for the initiative and I know it's a lot of setup and we don't do anything you take care of it all Rick so we're just very grateful for what you do to make this possible so thank you this time we um we'll take a brief let's say five minutes see if we can get back faster that um for those of you who perhaps were here for some of the recognitions and you wanted to slip out of the meeting this would be a great time to do that so we'll take a f minute break we'll be back at 6:14 get you down e e e um we have one person that is asked to make comments on an agenda item uh I will ask her to uh approach the microphone and
029we'll need you to state your name address and any group affiliation that might be appropriate as always we ask that statements are directed to the board and primarily to me as the presiding officer um just again state for everyone so that we know the board will not respond to public comments the purpose of public comments is to provide input um into agenda items that the board will be acting on later in the meeting um if there are any any um specific expectations that you have that you will receive an answer uh to a question that you have we ask that you send us an email um that that is separate uh each person has a maximum of three minutes to speak and at the end of three minutes and I will ask you to complete
030your sentence and allow us to move on with the meeting so at this time I invite forward um Veronica falter thank you my name is Veronica falter I I live on 1993 Lexington Drive um perisburg schools has much to be proud of in its accomplishments as evidence by tonight's uh presentations and I don't begrudge you that however with the good comes the bad I understand that the blade needed to be involved once again for the school board to take actions against Mr Henline I am referring to Mr John Henline being seen on school grounds during a basketball game my source informed me Mr Henline or excuse me Mr Hustler Miss price and Susan Miller quote got upset because they said they had heard that had not heard um that at all anywhere and then they
031said we told him he could not come on the property and we took his badge he isn't allowed this arrogance of Mr Henline cannot be and should not be tolerated the school administration will be seeking for to pass a levy the safety of our students should be put on the uh should not be put on the back burner um um not until Mr henin's retirement kicks in um and with all intents and purposes he should be fired given his multiple Alle ations and his own ad by his own admission uh the wrong that he has done seeing that he has is found to refuse to comply with the board's request to not be on school grounds I'm asking number one for the uh if the restraining order on Mr Henline is an order number two
032what is the school doing to keep uh parents informed and our our students safe from any uh further Predators as such as him and number three how and who is monitoring the anonymous calls on the hotline regarding Mr handlines uh infractions and any infractions concerning any other uh staff thank you very much for your time thank you we'll move on to uh 6.1 Comm Community engagement turn it over to Mr Hustler all right well thank you um so um wanted to share uh we do have some dates that are available coming up here in the next um five months and these are opportunities for the community to drop in to meet with uh board members that are in attendance as well as some different administrators it's really a blend of activities that allow for um
033to learn a little bit about the district so every other month there'll be a presentation that's kind of topical for that time period uh last month uh we might have cursed ourselves because it was about winter weather conditions and things took a dramatic turn from that day so I don't think we want to do that again but um alternating months are in February we will have uh just a drop in so there isn't a set a so anyone who has questions can drop in these are held off school grounds uh this upcoming event with us will be at uh way library from 6:00 p.m. to 7 p.m. uh and you can see on March 12th we're doing uh like our lunchtime we we'll talk about State Testing we're beginning to enter that period of State
034Testing in the district you know during March and April and and then also looking uh for dropin on the April 23rd date um the Topic in May right around graduation time I know that seems very far away uh but uh celebrating the class of 2025 so we'll have our uh development director who also works closely with alumni and and look at our uh College advising and members of the Board of Education talking about this this remarkable class and then also in June 24th uh a state of the schools looking back at this past school year so that'll wrap up these uh opportunities for uh District dialogue so again another opportunity to to share information but also more importantly for us to be able to to listen and uh these are opportunities you know during the
035day in the evening whenever folks can take the time to to make that happen so um so that's our report for the the the upcoming District dialogues um and then there was the um Community engagement committee uh that met on um Tuesday February 11th 2025 and I know Miss M can't be here so to as one of the members to to share but yeah I think um on top of kind of those open forums we wanted to we're working on creating more structured opportun unities um one would uh be on a Saturday morning the other would be on in an evening we're looking at Tuesday evenings right now with those would be open to everyone in the community we're hoping everyone um considers coming to those and they would be um more structured questions at
036small groups every single person would get to be heard um kind of through the small tables and then reporting out to The Wider group we're looking at having a kind of written way as well for people to get input during those or if they're not able to attend maybe something afterwards we um are trying to work with a facilitator right now so we can't announce dates until we're able to kind of line up having a external you know neutral facilitator for those discussions with those skills so that's what we're working right now kind of what the questions would be as well as um just the setup for those so hopefully um in the next couple weeks we'll have have more to announce on those and try to get them on calendars we know we're we're
037trying to do a fast turnaround in order to get some good feedback as we we'll be looking at our timeline later um specifically about the levy but in General trying to get good feedback about where people are in the community right now so all right anything else on any questions Community engagement ideas of things we haven't thought of yet more to more to come yeah all right we'll move on to um number seven the treasures report and we'll turn over to Mr drewer for his financial presentation thank you little bit longer report tonight than normal got a couple topics I want to cover besides the uh normal financial information but uh let's just give you a rundown where we are through January this is the normal cash balance chart that I show you were at
038our um at our low point of the year we just got a taxx advance today so um again it follows the curve that has pretty much every year and more specifically here is um just this year's data the light green line being revenue and the red line being Red Line being Revenue light the light green line being cash balance and the dark green being our expenditure so just tracking like like we do every year at this point on the EXP on the financial side we are at 1177 true cash days and you know ideally we would stay around 120 but that's just not the way it it works um our revenues are running 99.6% year-over-year and our expenses are 99.5% year-over-year just a couple of things to point out on re on each area so
039right now we we got into January our last income tax payment the withholding portion is looking good we're seeing growth as we expected with the non- withholding is down um we're up year-over-year but we're trending below forecast so I expect my forecast will be adjusted down for in income tax collections for for this year by a couple hundred, probably and it's on the non- withholding side so um on on the oops sorry on the expense side really only one thing to point out that's off trend is you'll notice on the capital outlay being 100% over 100% of total and up significantly year-over-year with our new bus purchase we had um EPA grant that um we end up paying the um Cardinal bus that $400,000 and then it's been returned to us so and and in
040January we paid it it's been put back in the bank so it'll be corrected again next next month but we knew we'd have to kind of front that 400,000 because it was coming from the EPA and we and it went to Cardinal bus so it's actually so two $2 million in buses we paid 1.6 million that's how it'll end up showing on on the books so so really at this point you know we're 58% through the year revenue is on forecast and actually slightly better and um expenses are trending slightly better you know and and some of it is um you know certainly in salaries and benefits we' we've had positions not being filled you know uh custodial positions particular not been filled we've got a couple other positions where folks have left in anticipation
041of next year's um reductions and so we're obviously saving a little bit of those those salaries as we speak any questions on Where We Are year-to date financially okay all right Governor's budget proposal this is almost a CH daily change thing but I think it's worthwhile I think Mr hosler and I both hit on this but we're going to kind of share what we know of as of today and I am going to editorialize here and say the bottom line is Shifting more pressure on local funding the fund Local Schools I mean that's that's that's the fact so right now in the governor's proposal he is f they're proposing to phase in a fair school funding plan that's good we're happy with that but there's no increase in b cost that's not good and we'll
042get to I'll share what that impact is here in a minute and the governor has a focus on reducing spending on empty seats that is getting school districts off the guarantee and last time this really happened was um in 2018 so we we we don't have necessarily history of what happens when you try to get districts off the guarantee so it's early on we got a long way to go but I want to share you where we are today so right now there's uncertainty in how they're going to handle this getting off the guarantee we have some Intel on that but again you know the budget is not necessarily the proposal is not necessarily the details of how you do things we we are kind of trying to read between the lines read the tea
043leaves that's coming out of the bud the the governor's office you know because we have questions what's the pack of toll enrollment most dist many districts who are on the guarantee are on guarantee because of declining enrollment right we're a growing district and so does that impact us are we you know what is going to happen with the the base cost not being updated it's going to force us on the guarantee even though we're a growing district and I'm talking about that more in a second here so it's crazy to think about this you want districts off the guarantee but you're going to force districts on the guarantee and again in the case of administration's last time this happened so I'm right now I'm modeling the Middle Road case I'm going to kind of show
044you what we think the worst case is but hopefully um um more rational Minds will prevail as we move through this so what I'm showing here is what was actually built in the November forecast so there's nothing new here and this is the this was the Assumption there were no increase in base costs and but the funding formula would be full fully implemented and you can see if you look at the top line that means a base cost funding stays essentially flat a little over $88,000 per student but because you're not updating the base cost the state share of that base cost drops from $1,600 per student down to $800 so state is saying your funding is flat I mean the cost to educate a students flat which we know is not true right just
045inflation alone is going to drive up the cost in education a student but they're assuming that the costs are flat and oh by the way you're going to get less you're going to get half of what uh you are today for per student so that was that was built into the forecast in November and the impact here is this over time you're going to see the local share going up and state share going down so it's pushing if you if you want to fund schools at their current level they're not even talking about increasing just at the current level is going to put more pressure on local funding so in the in the forecast you'll see the last three years because of not updating the base costs that forces us onto the guarantee we're a
046formula funded District today and actually as I play with the numbers today would actually be on the guarantee next year by a little bit be we'd have to add in the forecast right now I have us adding about a little over 1% student growth every year to get off the the guarantee in 26 we'd have to more than double that and then more than triple that increase in 27 not to go on the guarantee and by the end of this forecast we we wouldn't have enough room for the students anyway we couldn't add Portables fast enough to get off the guarantee based on enrollment growth so it forces the district on the guarantee which is again in my mind crazy we're growing District we have we have more students in at desks yet we're going
047you know the funding per students is going down so how it be phased in we don't know but how much we're on the guarantee is this last these last row here right now the simulation has us on the guarantee by almost 1.5 million in 27 2.7 million in 28 and 4 million in 29 now we don't expect that all to go away but some portion of it will and right now we're looking at probably next year maybe 50,000 a half a million the following year and a million dollars the next year based on what we've seen so far so it's it's a moving Target and obviously we we need to you know you know get with legislators and it's it's not just us we got to get you know more people people paying attention to
048what's happening with school funding and get the message out there this is unacceptable that you know we're not no fault of our own you're going to move us on to the guarantee and I guess back back up just a second and doing this a little while I think I get it but I question the guarantee in the state of Ohio is designed to keep school districts from getting less money they shrinking kind under the old model and this is and this is this money is based on 2020 this money is based off 202 so it's even five years old right so perisburg school district is looking at now becoming a district that's on the guarantee even though we're growing and also working in the legislature is also working in the legislature is the potential that
049this guarantee funding goes away exactly so there may not be no bottom in state funding that's that's exactly right so it's a defunding from the state the state local partnership has just been blown up now this the governor's proposed budget right we recognize there's going to be a lot of battles between now and June 30th and we'll we'll be there with our story but you know you hear that oh and the general assembly says obviously the public doesn't care because no one we don't hear from anyone except those who want vouchers don't you don't hear from the 90% who don't who are going to public schools so I'm urging everyone to reach out not just you know all our local reps and say look this is this is not this doesn't work but just it's
050a warning so as I build a forecast for May even then it's going to be a level of uncertainty because we won't know what the Vian budget is in probably until the 12th hour on June 30th can you give us well one I think um yes that comment by Senator Huffman that he had only heard from private school parents so they must be the only ones who care is is something we need to work on I I think one of my questions as I try to understand all of this or at least the logic from the state side I know that and and Mr Hustler is going to cover this more in his presentation but that we are right now impacted by our perceived wealth by the state so our increased property values are now
051um causing us to get less money even if base costs doesn't get from the state how does the if we how does the um our increased perceived wealth of our property impact what we're getting from the state and our need to be on the guarantee as well okay well so it goes back to this table here the state share what happens is there's there's a couple steps in the calculation based on the number of students you have and based on average salaries for the state the teachers the the formula says you need x amount of teachers you need x amount of Administrators you need a treasur you need all these positions and they add up to the this amount divided by the number of students that's your 8 thou that's your that's your base cost
052doesn't include other things like special EDS other things but your base cost for basic Services right is built into that then the next thing is what's the split between local and state share and that split is calculated based on the wealth calculation the wealth per pupil in the district and that wealth is 60% property values and then 40% income half that income is your state income reported income and half is the federal so it's 20 so it's 60 property tax 20 State 20 Federal that gets you your wealth calculation and so what's happening here is the state said okay your base costs are flat but guess what just by you know we we're seeing it your property Valu is going up I'm not even talking about an extreme year like we had last year just
053an average year like it went you know we went up a few million this year in value so we're richer right our incomes have gone up we're richer so one side of the equation is going up but the other side's not being adjusted so I think what Randy if I could jump in I think the um there's this kind of um seesaw and the states on one side and local residents are on the other so what what's what Randy described is is right now our income here locally is updated every year the valuations are updated in real time so on the one side of the Seesaw we are getting wealthier in the eyes of the state the state's contribution is based on average teacher salaries average principal salaries and so that's what's driving that that
054base cost funding amount and the reason it's flatlined if I'm not mistaken is because they are saying we're going to continue to use 2020 averages so the average that the money that the state is coming to the table to that seesaw and and trying to to to make this formula work they're using dollars their averages from 2020 so what a teacher was making in 2020 what what it cost to feed a student correct in 2020 are the numbers they using so so what happens is as we're getting wealthier in the eyes of the state the state is actually contributing less and less because they're saying look at and what they are contributing is based on what the funding amounts were in 2020 for those averages so so that's where it's one thing to fully fund
055the formula but I would argue that if you're not going to input the state's contribution so that it reflects real time dollars lining up against our calculation which does reflect real time which by the way benefits the state because they're saying you're getting wealthier locally we have less to contribute because you can go to your local taxpayers for more and then when they are finally sending the check it's based on 2020 averages so that that's a major problem and that is causing us to throw off into the guaranteed world so before the fair funding happened we were on we were a Capp district and the cap District meant that the formul said we should get a lot more money like 33.5 million a year more and now because they're choosing not to fully fund it
056at the level that we need to keep that balance between the state and local um it it's causing us to to come up short and um and messing with our calculations even though we're a growing District yeah and it's very clear if you look at this Slide the current funding you look at our current funding a little over 10.7 million that's at 67% implementation of the fair funding formula next year it' be 83% still actually less but you see it's higher than what the base cost of 220 2020 is so we're actually capped right now we're capped but then in 2027 if they forced us on the we're forced on the guarantee so we're going from cap to the guarantee and it's anyway it's the point is it's something the Board needs to be aware
057of you I'm I'm going to keep running simulations and looking at it at some point in time and I'm going to have to make my guess for the May forecast but at this it's not looking good it's something we're going to have to consider in in terms of the levy ask versus further reductions I think one of the things you said um Mr juror at the finance committee meeting I'm going to paraphrase but the um State's making decisions that assume the local tax can afford to sport schools now more and in the future more than the state can um that that the local taxpayer can pay more for the students while the state can afford it less um but last time I checked I'm not getting a refund on my state taxes so I'm not
058really sure that rationale that they're they're putting out there um it seems to me if we can afford it more they can afford it more too so I'm it's a little it's a little frustrating and we have to figure out a really good way to I think communicate this more to the community you know I um it is complex but there's just some basic unfairness of you know the fair school funding plan might need to become the unfair school funding plan I un the bottom line it's no longer a fair funding plan the formula no longer has relevance you can implement the formula but if you don't increase base costs it's irrelevant right you're back to the days oh I think you can have $6,000 for student and you You know despite it costing 88,000
059or 11,000 or and then you get and then you yeah it's you get $6,000 per student and here's your share and you know if it's 20% or whatever and it's going to drive us down to the minimum and I think that on the other slide that state share I mean the fact that it's going it's going down each year the state is planning on giving us less funding per student each year yeah and that's what I'm I'm not sure that the community realizes what what our state legislators are doing right now with public education they want to fund it less and less well if they're going to put us on the base of 2020 perhaps we should base our taxes on 2020 and go back to those we are we already there we're already at
060our 2020 taxes no I mean I meant that as a personal week District we that be nice you know say oh well if you guys are going to operate on 2020 let's go back to 2020 so anyway with that good news let me move on to something thank you on that one yeah run on so just want to give you the board a quick review on um our fund cash balance that questions come up a couple times and I just want you to kind of walk through all the funds we have and how they how they work at a very high level um we have we have a lot of funds all right and many and and most of them are have purpose or restricted funds and in different Revenue so we have funds that
061you just cannot use for whatever they can only be used for what they were designed for and essentially we have one unrestricted fund that's a general fund of course that's our biggest fund and when I say unrestricted it's still subject to proper purpose but you know the board can use it really for really for anything what's proper in the district so this is a list of all of our funds as of the end of January we had about 42.8 million in cash balances across the funds with the with the general fund being the biggest with 25 million so obviously we we operate out of the general fund um for the most part so let me walk you through briefly not always one by one you're welcome um highlighted in yellow are restricted or special purpose
062funds they receive no tax revenue they're from fundraising or student fees or ticket sales um the biggest one being um Athletics and Athletics obviously funds um the everything for athletics except salaries and transportation that comes out of general fund and and of course what were the boosters help them with but so Athletics you know all their ticket sales self funds paying for the officials field maintenance and all that stuff we have some endowments and scholarships those are um endowment is there kind of toward bottom third and you see down at the bottom special trust those those are donations over the years for scholarships or endowments we are working actively working to get them transferred where feasible to the the foundation they can better manage it um but it takes it's there's some legal requirements to
063do that just I just can't say hey take this money that you know the donor's got to be aware of it or um we're spending them down in some cases there's no new money coming into them we're just spending them down give them scholarships out until they go away and then you got like the Technology Insurance Fund which are student fees and that has grown but what happens with that is that's used to repair student devices and then the technology department uses that to buy disposable items for students for student use so all that money is is it's are based on student fees and goes back to students in one way or another either repairing devices or you know buying mice and keyboards and those kinds of things Bond retirement fund is just what it
064is it can only be used to pay back um our bonds and that we do get tax dollars in there that's the the millage we receive on the two Bond levies that are still active and right now it's at a low balance we it'll we'll it'll build up here and then we make our bond payment interest payments in June and then principal interest payments in December so this is at its low point we always keep a little bit of balance in there in order to if property valuations would drop the try to minimize having to increase millage in order to make it collect enough money to make the bond payment this building fund 04 was a one-time fund we borrowed money to do the lighting project through the district and to do um hbac in
065this building at the high school that money came into that that fund for that purpose only there's a balance there but at the end of this year when that project's completed that it'll be zeroed out no longer so it was a it was a one time purpose fund we have two permanent Improvement funds the tech fund which is a half Mill inside millage and then the permanent Improvement fund that's up for renewal in May and we Mr Hustler has talked about that we don't only use for items have lifespan of five years or more right now the balance we try to maintain in um around a million dollars in the permanent Improvement fund right now you know James is planning for the summer projects so his balance is going to come up and he'll spend
066it down but also allows to keep a little bit of a balance in there for the unexpected on the tech side that's a a pretty high balance at this point but U Mr schaer built that balance up because he knew this year he's had to replace the switch gear across the district and that's about $450,000 he doesn't get enough in each year to do that so he has to save up you know for five or six years down the road and I I have probably not March maybe April I will sharing you the capital spending plans that show 10 years out for each of those and how that cash flow Works termination benefits the board established that several years ago the the general fund makes a makes a transfer every year and that's just to
067handle swings and turn when when Severance essentially when people retire and we're paying out Severance rather than having the up and down in the unexpected in the general fund we have a pool there so on a big year like this year that that balances going to drop and so it doesn't necessarily impact the general fund General fund's predictable that way so think of it as a little Reservoir that can handle ups and downs in and abs and flows of retirements and we're looking at that that's what we look at annually to say at some point in time like you know we don't have expect a retirements or very few maybe we don't we don't make it don't transfer out the general funding that year but that's an analysis we can we do every year to
068look at that it's it's a good place right now this is where I'd like it to be like I said when we have a big year coming up it'll absorb all those retirements and not hurt the general fund and unpredictable manner food service we have a high cash balance there but this is this is a no touch fund it can only be used for food service it's a federal program you cannot spend that money on anything but food service we do look at making sure indirect costs that we can charge the Food Service are are charged but again it's a federal program it's audited every year so you can't for example we can't we'd like to um let's say our cafeteria monitors we can't pay for them out of food service because they're not working
069in the kitchen right so they're very clear distinction of what you can use that money for the commodor fund that's funded through the Levis common Tiff which expires in 2033 that's maintenance of this building and for example the HVAC project that was funded through a bank is being paid for through that fund so we're we've accumulated some money over the years but that's that's the only money we Ed to maintain this building you know a previous board when we got the Levis Tom commas Tiff made that decision to create that fund to maintain this this building so that we're not using general fund maintenance dollars to maintain this facility the biggest one's employee benefit this is our self Insurance Fund this is this is a huge deal um we do have Mr Christie and I
070have an actuary look at it every year to give us recommendations on the appropriate balance here assessing the risk we are self-insured we're our own insurance company so for example we do have for example stop-loss insurance but if we High claim it'ss could be lasered out of it or excluded depending on the circumstances for example we have a cobra claim right now it's excess of a million dollar a year that was excluded from our stop loss so that's coming out of that out of that reserve and in fact in 2024 that calendar year our um expenses exceeded revenues by 1.7 million if we didn't have this Reserve we would had to increase premiums by 20% but because of this Reserve we could do a modest 5% increase and keep things level for the employees and
071the district so and so it miniz the risk of general fund we are and it's audited every year for solvency because you know our actuary does a good job and Advising us you know all he does look at the numbers and the risk and say look you're a good place you're not so good place and we have a well-run um insurance plan but it it can be expensive because we're only sharing the risk across our district right but and Don and I are consistently looking at other options to try to lower those costs but for right now that the self- Insurance Fund is just there to pay claims and other costs and of course the big one is the general fund and we're 117 true cash days which in my mind is not excessive particularly
072you know as over the next you know year we'll continue to draw that cash balance down particularly next year as we you know see the full effect of the levy not being renewed we'll have some reductions but we won't have you know it's not going to cover the entire spread on that any questions on on that no it's very helpful I think there's a lot of misunderstanding about those funds in the community so I think that's very helpful to get an overview of that yeah I think one of the and as as Mr Jer alluded to one of the um easy targets there is that employee benefit fund that Health Insurance Fund is a self-funded um organization in insurance .3 million may feel like a lot of money until you have some catastrophic Health event
073which does happen in these things that gets lasered out of the stop Gap and all of a sudden you know three4 Million worth of claims expense cuts that in half or you have a a significant drug cost for one of one of the employees that is now coming out of that fund and that can be23 million so and we've had that we've had million dollar drug claims fortunately that we've gotten other sources um foundations with the pharmaceutical companies it still cost us $250,000 yeah right so you know I think we do a good job our the the we have a health um Insurance Committee of staff and working with this working with the staff to look to be good better consumers of health care because every time someone goes to the doctor it's it's coming
074out of that fund right so essentially when I go to the doctor you know other than my co-pay that bill is coming out right from per schools are right in that check essentially well yeah I it's encouraging to hear you and Mr Christie you know you look at other types of options fully insured you lose control over that over those those premiums um potentially or um you know going into a Consortium which if you're on the right side of the money that works out if you're not you're paying for claims of other organizations we've got the the gud to do it the um Healthcare Clinic which is a great way again to make our Associates a better consumer of theth healthare cost to try and keep so under with those those ideas in place self-funded
075works well when it works well and it sounds like it's working well here because we we had a rough year and you do they're cyclical yeah exactly the last thing I going to mention is you know we've had our we had our last month had our um post audit conference again we had a clean audit uh the audit is not yet posted on the auditor State site as soon as it is I'm I'm not allowed to make it available until the auditor State makes it available but we got our confirmation back from the auditor State their desk review again the independent auditor found it clean the state udit does their desk review and said everything is good so we're just uh waiting for the that final thank you for that I I had that as
076a is a question if that audit was posted yet Miss Roland Miller and I did participate in that that closing conference and again commendable that and I I was an auditor for years um not having a no rec or you no no recommendation no finding typee audit is is rare so congrats to you and your team Randy could you um just touch on what I was asking you about before we started just for other people who might be concerned with all the things that are going on in the federal level about the EOS what what you know about that right now because I really think this email that I'll forward to you that I don't think you got really does pertain into your field all we know right now is it's business as usual for
077us right we are continuing we have the way the federal grants work they're managed by the state right so when we when we our grant money we apply to the state for the grant money they're taking their allocation for federal government and then they're they're they're paying us we're so we're actually paid through the state we're not paid directly from the federal government so obviously it's concerning what's happening in Washington with those what's happening we get about 1.5 million in federal grants the biggest one being a million doll in um for Ida for special education and then we got smattering of title one and some other grants in there but it's about um 1.5 million that doesn't include food service too which is also with some of the things happening with the FDA grants that
078that could be an issue but right now we're like it's going to be you know there's no communication States going we're just business as usual until it's not and so um and there's so much chaos we don't we don't know how to handle it other than just keep our head down and keep plugging away that's not really an answer but that's that's the way it is it's an answer for right now so I appreciate that thank you and the expectation you you hear different stories but if the Department of Education is really done away according to the um this the um secretary that they're they're really what they're trying to do is push that to the state level so it seems like the plan is to keep funding in place but give more control to
079the States now that's that's that's the part that's the that's the what we that's what was testified to Congress now what actually happens and stuff that's another another story but remember Congress is the one who actually funds it not the executive branch okay other questions we have um uh financials and 7.2 that we'll be looking to approve and before we do that though I'm going to look at the finance committee meeting we met on last Friday Friday so I'll ask Mr Bennington for a report well I think in addition to everything that Mr Dre just kind included in his report one of our one of our key talking points was with the um Levy discussions that we've had and and we've had some discussion in the last two meetings about the timing of of the
080operating Levy we've got a pi levy on on in May May right um potentially a operating Levy in November and there's a whole host of discussions this Board needs to have to get us there so we started to dip our toe in in in the water of how it when and you know how how how do we have these discussions I think in the agenda is is kind of a timing just if if we could pull that up uh just some key dates that are out there to to remind everybody of what's ahead of us you know so the filing deadline for the November 4th election is August 6 working backwards from that resolution and necessity resolution to proceed I wake up almost every day hearing about you know we had three levies recently so
081all of this process should be very familiar to this board here Mr jury will be presenting The Five-Year forecast May on May 31st uh and then as we discussed the state B bium budget should be released on our r or by July 1st 2025 so with those key dates out there the board started to work through a little bit of some Milestones to think about to get us to that filing date of August 6 2 you kind of see how those are laid out there so that those dates aside for the the discussion in the finance committee meeting was more focused at least from my perspective as to what's the information that this Board needs to have to make a good decision again this board's SP and Miss Binky isn't here and I honor her
082her desire to want to have put this on on a spring ballot um this board came down with you know we want to make sure that we're making the best decision possible and to take the most time possible to make that decision so you what i' encourage this board to do out of that finance committee meeting is what what do we need to know you know things that come to my mind are we've got community engagement sessions coming up that hopefully will flush out a little bit of what is the right tenor what's the right amount how long should the next Levy be um we know that we are going through cut right now and the administration is is working through maybe what that what the next round of cuts could look like how does
083that influence a decision with everything that's going on in the buildings and in the community today are there things that we've done because the $6 million wor the cuts that we're doing today don't come back under the current plan you have we learned anything that is you know that that that we should reconsider or that we should try and fund that are kind of non-negotiable so I don't have answers here again what what what what is in my mind about the timing of the next discussions we have to have are what are the questions we have to ask the administration for as we make this decision and time once again isn't isn't on our side and I don't know if that's we need to start these discussions a little bit more in Earnest in the
084March regular meeting April seems a little bit too late so I think you know that that was from my perspective where that conversation was focused in the finance committee meeting Tom can you scroll down to that document a little bit yeah no thank you yeah that's not the latest one apparently yeah but the two key questions here I had I had a bunch more questions on there but apparently I didn't put the latest one up there the and and really be helpful to me like Mr Bennington mentioned if if there's specific data or scenarios that we want to run it doesn't cost anything to me to generate them obvious little little time but anything to help you look at the whatif at some point in time you're going to have to play paint in the
085tail and the doggy and pick one right so and I just want to make sure you have as much information as you can yeah three months ago I would have said 13 and a half 14 million under you know a four or five year I'm not so sure about that now with recent information coming you know what we've talked about with this guarantee and what's coming out of the out of Columbus but again as I've said before the levy that I like is the one at this point that's going to pass too so what information do we need to know that we'll get support from the community I think um you know our next meeting would be the March work session and I know there's a couple things on the agenda for that but maybe
086what we need to do if we could be prepared at the March work session to you know begin to talk through some of these questions and then also um maybe come to an understanding of what these scenarios you know what are the scenarios look like that we want some projections for whether it's you know putting back in $2 million from the reductions or cutting two more million dollars because we expect the state to continue to decrease their support of our students education um you know what what kind of uh structures we might be thinking of you know I keep playing around what does it look like to have a smaller continuing so that we know that we've locked in our students education while having a second one that if there's that increase that we need
087to ask that would say these are you know the student experience Beyond you know Reading Writing arithmetic so if if everyone could be given some thought to that if we could work maybe on that at the work session in March that would also give finance committee and Mr drewer some time to have some conversations as about this because really um with this timeline we need to start yeah by the March regul meeting having some real discussions about what the different options are so this um starting timeline was a big help thank you Mr drawer for providing that um so we do anything those are the high points no um we do have uh Finance report to approve so moved Bon Miss larer second Mr J roll call please benington yes Miss ler yes Dr reford
088yes M Roland Miller yes and we'll allow Mr Bennington to keep talking the student achievement committee update so Miss Roland Miller and I have met with uh Mr Schwarz Miller and Mr sens uh back at the beginning of the month on student achievement one of my challenges with student achievement it was three weeks ago which seems like a lifetime ago so I will just with the with uh consideration of time here too and other presentations we have I'm just going to pull out a few thoughts from the minutes that you have here and we certainly spent a good amount of time talking about the one plan and the data that's coming together to help support you know what our progress needs to be in things specifically like math and Ela and supporting other students of
089needs and that's kind of where the focus really um where the discussion really focused was on how does a at risk student get defined so uh this uh uh Mr Schwarz Miller and Mr sens are working on rubrics kind of stratified by grade level to help put a framework around the various different data points you know grades uh Panorama data um attendance all of that to help them identify you know this is what you know again a framework for this student could be at risk and may need some additional support we had an elementary update they continue to work on the the standards based reporting subgroup and you know specifically kind of the next actions there are focused on figuring out talking about what do what is important for parents when we're talking about Ela
090progress to to focus on to hear about in in the reporting back uh to parents in in in the standards based reporting uh I pull this one out math Camp always fun to talk about math camp and how popular that is and I believe quickly with an announcing math cap 60 kids had signed up already I think as you recall that I believe was the one last year that they had one session it filled up awfully quick so they had to do a second session that also filled up starting to talk about the summer reading Academy and looking uh for Innovative and creative ways with our budget issues to try and bring other partners in for example way public library in order to help support uh a reading Camp going into the summer uh secondary
091uh there's a CT we talk about CTE funds Career Technical education funds uh These funds are thirdparty funds specific for Career Tech uh industrial Tech type of of learning and they're looking at some virtual reality technology I pull that one out because with our budget constraints it is easy to again kind of say well wait we're buying virtual reality technology type of equipment for our students yes from third party funds from from Grants that have been given through the CTE that Canam for C that can only be used for industrial and and Tech not for salaries that's right that's right thank you um uh item C here na results I would encourage you there's a nice document that's included with the minutes to go through that and um I particularly like the dead birds article
092that was awesome I mean a title like that I got to read it but it was I would encourage anybody who's following along with this or gets hyperventilated over results national results State results or anything like that to read especially that dead birds article um not because it's got a really cool and clever title but because the information in it is powerful um and and very thought-provoking I thought it was a really good article thank you m lmer yeah gold star for you you read it I'm hooked on this stuff still the educator and you uh the last thing I'm going to mention here you know the raing practices committee uh continues to met met on January 14th there's a nice write up here in item D1 you know the the that group is focused
093on surveying and getting feedback from its from what they've defined as their stakeholders uh teachers students and parents uh in order to best proceed forward on on standardizing the grading for the district so I think uh otherwise you know there's good materials included with board ducks can um I just want to explain what the one plan is to people that don't know what that is it's a requirement by the state of Ohio um that a school district has to come up with this plan based on a set of data um because some people might not know what that means the one plan um but if you Google it it's right there on the o is it o o DW's website for one plan and what it entails I saw that there was some discussion about
094um gifted Services has there did you guys discuss anything thing about the loss of of our gifted programs in these Cuts so so the discussion was you know that desire to keep great gifted Services going even if it's not a pullout model you know right now yeah right the the traditional gifted kids go into another classroom you know the conversation is starting with how can those because those services are changing right how do those Services get supported with the kids still integrated in the classroom I think there's much more to come on that but that's that's the desire that's the goal we do get some State money for gifted now that's part of being going to be cut too but there is some funding that comes based on a k number of kids who are
095identified so and we generally provide a five times the amount of service that we get funded by the state but we still have some level that we need to provide in that case so there's some money that we do have to spend towards gifted programming if nothing else obviously we have to identify them at this point if we do some in in classroom stuff to spend what little money we'll have that would be would be a good thing we W have to send it back thank you Mr Bennington um next on our uh agenda is to provide an update to the board of what's been going on since our last meeting regarding student safety and staff accountability and um I think there's multiple voices that will we'll all chime in at some point but at
096this point I'll turn it over to Mr Hustler well thank you um we wanted to um brief the board uh following our our January 21st uh board meeting and um we've asked uh uh assistant superintendent uh price and Dr folz who who who have a an important role in some of these activities and and updates to to join us so that they could provide um an overview relative to their areas respectively so um so we we understood and we heard the community last month and and in the previous month as well you know talking about the concerns that they had that that reports had been ignored mishandled in the past and that was something that was troubling for us to hear um and I know uh the board members that are present talked about you
097know the the concern that that that the board collectively had with us so our goal tonight is to to give an update on what's happened since we've last met because this is something that has been very important to us in terms of how do we begin to um you know to act moving forward um you know words are are one thing but actions are are much louder and so we want wanted to share with the board and with the community the things that we said we were going to do and what we've done and as we move forward what you can hold us accountable uh too um so we encourage the feedback and questions and the continued collaboration because we know student safety and staff accountability remain a top priority for us as we go
098through this conversation not only today but also for the days ahead uh so we wanted to talk talk about the significant steps that we've taken uh you know beginning in December and and last month and into this month uh to enhance those student protections to increase transparency which is something we heard a great deal about and and also improve a reporting process so that we can better monitor the things that that are happening in the district and we'll talk at Great Lengths about that um so um so we wanted to to to highlight a couple couple things that that are in the works things that we've already begun to do uh first is is a student's Bill of Rights to be heard outlining clear reporting Pathways and and all of these things here we're going
099to take a little bit of time in the moments ahead to do a little deeper dive but in terms of where we are today this was one of the things that we've worked on and this is that clear reporting Pathways for students um making sure that they understand there's always been Pathways available to students but creating it and presenting it in a way that students understand how to do that is is something that's very important to us as we reflected on what can we do better and I think throughout the conversation you're going to continue to hear that as a theme that that reflection of what we can do better uh we developed specific professional development module for administrators and staff uh we implemented that with our administrators earlier this month we're planning to roll
100this out to staff and we're continuing to talk to to uh uh um some professionals in the area in terms of mandatory reporting and the things that we need to have all of our staff touch Bas on uh ex an expanded reporting mechanism to reinforce the uh report at that was created um in January and also extension 2800 the voicemail where people can report things to us so we'll we'll spend a little bit of time you know talking about what we've heard so far and what's going to be the the future of that program as we go forward the student safety and staff conduct uh policy anti-g groming is something that we have drafted we had a meeting last uh with two board members uh actually last month to or at last week to talk
101about taking things that are in policy now today but but pulling those threads and weaving a policy that explicitly talks about these kinds of behaviors so that we again are very clear on what those expectations are um and and really understanding those expectations and boundaries before staff interaction with students um and and and our in our current staff and then we also you know reflecting wanted to to talk with the sro's the police chief about a formalized uh police department documentation follow-up process because that's something that we in our reflection understood that there's areas that we need to improve and and I know that Mrs price will talk a little bit more about that in her meeting with SRO saying this would be beneficial to them as well and so that's something that we want
102to roll out so so um in addition to this we are implementing a semester a semester uh each semester review process with law enforcement um to to look at and and District leadership to look at that reporting system that we have put in place to make sure that we are looking at um those uh things that we should be in in terms of what best to protect students we also want to identify areas of future Improvement because we know this isn't this is what we're doing today and we're never going to come back to it it's something that we need to continue to look at to study to review and plan and so we're setting up part of that these these semester meetings to have our sro's district leadership the police chief uh representative from
103the board to sit in to say okay what's been happening this semester what what can we notice and I think these are steps that'll be meaningful progress to to also reporting this out um to the public in a way through the board meetings um and and doing a report about what we have found as as we move forward throughout the school year and so that becomes something that um you know is important for us so I wanted to begin with uh establish a a draft of of perisburg school student Bill of Rights and and really this is outlining clear reporting Pathways for students that we have today to voice concerns about safety and to do it in a way that's uh you know confidentiality safely and and confidently so we're committed to ensuring a safe
104and supportive respectful environment so this was really this statement here is really the the framework for which we worked from to create this message to our students and and it and you'll see here that you have things highlighted that you have the right to be treated with dignity and learn to to to learn in a safe environment um if you feel uncomfortable unsafe or witness inappropriate behavior by a staff member another student you have the right to take action and what does that mean and how do you do that again there are policies out there that that kind of point the way but we don't want students to be armed with a flashlight but we want to have a sign pointing the way for them to make sure that they're able to move forward um
105and then as always they they we want to be intentional they've always had the right to do this but we want to be intentional and streamlining and emphasizing the process for students so in that document and again it's in draft form and as we work with the board in in sharing this Distributing it um we will fill it out so that people can see this but um these are the key components that we want to share the right to be in a safe learning environment the right to be heard and taken seriously the right to know how to report take it for granted that students have that knowledge and they don't that's one thing when we looked in the mirror we saw that that wasn't necessarily the case the right to protection against retaliation and
106the right uh to confidentiality and and we'll talk about those things so for students recognize when to report how to report and what happens next having a document that outlines those things clearly for students is very important because it's mysterious it's a huge step for them to step out to to have that voice and we want to be able to give them a document that says here's what you can expect we want to help help them understand what to immediately report so inappropriate touching or inw wanted physical contact jokes gestures advances professional boundaries and this is something that you'll hear in some other areas about well what are those then that includes but not uh Limited to excessive private Communications gifts invitations to meet alone outside of school and you'll hear this theme throughout the
107presentation today about ways that we're highlighting these any situation you feel uncomfortable un unsafe or coerced um we want students to feel comfortable to be able to ask the question and and be comfortable with you know raising their hand and saying I'm not sure about this and and so we want to be there and of course retaliation is always a concern when you're talking about adults that have power in your lives and we want to make sure that they understand that that's there we want to compile ways to to let students know these are ways that you can in fact report so talk to a trusted adult a parent a teacher a counselor coach administrator or other a trusted adult in your life say something reinforcing that that there are people around them that they
108can trust with this information we have a a reporting mechanism a couple different reporting mechanisms that are available the newest one was created but we also know that the voicemail and and email is available to them we also know that it already available is a safeer Ohio uh School tipl line where you can call in and it's Anonymous and um that is something that I know students are very concerned about we have great law enforcement partners that are here that are willing to help and we want to make sure that they can understand that there are ways to do that and of course Child Protective Services here in Wood County um so there are ways that we want to bundle all of these options available to students uh so so this is something that that
109we have we have a a document we've put together I know um at the meeting um last week board members on the ad hoc uh committee worked through this and gave input and feedback with this and also with the policy we'll talk about shortly the the safe students anti-g groming policy they wanted us to to talk to students about this and that was very important so the next step is taking what we have drafted and then sitting down and and fortunately I have a group that I meet with monthly a superintendent advisory committee of students where we meet and talk about different issues um we will want to bring this to them and get their feedback on what is missing from their perspective and they're a great sounding board for us um the next thing
110that we did do in the last month is developed specific professional development modules where we wanted administrators to look at different situations and scenarios so this isn't sitting and getting and reading things but actually getting administrators to look at different situations and then reacting and having conversations in small groups and Reporting back out saying how would we handle this and then we have created a similar um um activity for teachers bus drivers and other staff because how those information flows to those different groups is is very different so I wanted to to this is just one aspect of what we're doing um and we know that um you know there there's other trainings that we're looking to do that is required of Staff as we move forward so on February 4th we we did this
111training with administrators staff development is being coordinated with across the district with other employee groups and then we're working with the district Law Firm to to to do the professional development in terms of mandatory reporting and the responsibilities we have and and some of those things so this is part of the the module that we just had talked about so um we had different situations that we presented uh to the administrators and we have very similar ones that we'll present to bus drivers and teachers that are geared towards their position and we asked them to to read these things and to say how would you handle these how would you document these things because again looking in the mirror there are situations that come up where are we missing something by not documenting them a
112certain way or handling it in in a different way and where are those breakdowns that can happen so so this scenario here is a custodian reported that when cleaning their area of the building 2 hours after school was dismissed they entered a locked classroom the lights were off there was some lights on at the desk there were two students there and and they were all together so as a custodian what is your responsibility to report that as an administrator if you get that report what do you do with it and what are the questions that you would ask um and so that was very important to us to kind of walk through that and to hear those responses and offer advice in terms of what needs to happen this is another scenario where you have
113a bus driver who holds a few students on the bus after everyone is dismissed and maybe those are their favorite students and um they give them candy or small gifts for being good Riders and you're an aid in a classroom or a teacher and you hear students talking about this what do you do about this is it something that you should report if you are reporting it how do you document it in a way that we can look at that behavior not only the moment it happens but also month later or years later um so so this is another scenario where an elementary teacher attends a club soccer game on a Saturday where several of their students are playing on either team the teacher doesn't have a child at the game but mentions an interest
114in the students teams the teacher interacts with families and students um while they're there is this something that raises a concern because one of the things that we're we're conscious of is that there are activities like this which we think we would want our staff to do and participate but this is very different than maybe some of the other scenarios so why this might be something that you celebrate with staff members taking that interest in students and doing it in a way with their families and at this kind of a setting it is very different than this next scenario which is a student shared their favorite teacher really cares about students and shared a story about how the teacher met a classmate at a local coffee shop on a Saturday afternoon the student was struggling
115and they just needed someone to talk to what would you do if you're a teacher and you heard that about one of your colleagues um and and how is this maybe different than the last scenario and how are we documenting this so again another situation in the staff Lounge you hear colleagues talking about a teacher that they allow certain students to hang out the favorites all of those kinds of things um what is our respons responsibility to do that so these are things that we're continuing to look at because we all have a responsibility regardless of what role you play in the district and you hear conversations and information and and so this is that looking in the mirror and what can we do better and what can we do to make sure that we're
116doing what we need to do to to document things and to make sure our staff are thinking about things the first scenario that I shared with being in a classroom all of our lights are on timers and if you're not moving around the lightss automatically shut off so were they having a student council meeting or some type of activity and the lights went off in the room and instead of having to get up and move around they just turned on the desk light and kept working but we won't know until we ask those questions why was the door locked well somebody shut the door and it locks automatically so but we need to ask those questions and we need to trust but verify and so I think that is part of our our learning process
117so um the expanded reporting mechanisms um that report at email in the 2800 extension uh Dr folz is one of the individuals who receives those messages directly um as as does another staff member Don Christie our Human Resources Director and board president so um we wanted um and we appreciate Dr fultz being here this evening and maybe walking us through a little bit about what what's been happening in that realm to date um as he does that um if you go to our district website on our landing page this is what you'll find which is you know what to do and what is it for so I'll just Advance as you uh as you want me to yeah sure so I think you know there we always want to promote our students right to go
118to a trusted adult first but at the same time with a lot of these situations we want to provide something that feels a little bit more comfortable I think to them and even some people who are as we found uh moved on Beyond perisburg High School in their days here to reach out and do this on their own terms whether it be by a phone call or email so yeah this information was posted to the district website as well on the homepage the bottom as well as pushed out through districtwide communication as well so we've tried in several different ways to make it uh as pervasively known as possible uh you know in terms of what to report I think what we're looking for are specific concerns about staff member Behavior Behavior or to resubmit
119previous reports that may not have been fully addressed maybe there wasn't a circling back to uh discuss how things were handled and so it was left a little bit open-ended which you know sometimes will lead people to you know come to their own conclusions and maybe not have the benefit of knowing the action that was taken or you know maybe you know there were things that we could have done differently and better so you know I we welcome those sorts of reports as well so you know it's designed to handle detailed reports related to staff member conduct and and not intended for General feedback or non-specific concerns so we really want to dig in to uh into the weed so to speak on these and really get to the essence of what occurred is and
120going back as far as possible to retrieve and identify information and people involved as as we can so uh some things that we're asking for in these submissions in the detail U names dates descriptions of the incidents as much as possible and if you want to move to the next slide I think there's a little bit more detail so once we receive each of these so voicemail or email uh we assign a unique ID to it the data came in the source whether it was email phone website uh a name if provided and we have received several Anonymous reports as well the nature of the complaint the staff member cited uh or people involved and then there are several people that this could be assigned to uh myself or our executive director of human resources
121or maybe some other party maybe um in some instances uh if there's a conflict of interest we would find someone to be able to serve as investigator for that as well so uh we've used a couple people on staff to help talk with staff members and students who you know maybe have a little bit better rapport with some of these students uh or families in order to provide that level of comfort to get the information we need in order to move forward so uh every the action that's taken including the correspondent sent uh the resolution so we may be sure to assign status levels to this so that way when we have multiple people involved we know where things lie uh the date resolved if applicable and then you know outcome summary as well so
122very detailed a lot of several different people with their hands in this and we're also trying to treat this information as delicately as possible and maintaining people's confidentiality as um as appropriate so so in order in the name of accountability and just transparency you know I wanted to provide a little bit of an overview of some of the things that we have received since everything went in place in mid January so on this is a summary since we opened up the voicemail box as well as that email address we've received 22 reports five reports received are not reporting staff misconduct so uh some of them are General um just sort of maybe displeasure or just a sense of how things are going based on uh things they've observed or things that they've been reading uh
123one report claimed complaints were previously made by administrators against other administrators however no reports had been filed with human resources so there was a number of things that were alleged in the complaint uh but nothing had been followed through down beyond that from that standpoint meaning there was no formal complaint filed you know in order for certain action to be triggered uh by certain members of departments within the district 16 of the reports are previously unreported so prior students um who had not disclosed some of their different experiences that felt compelled to come forward with some of the things that they um that had occurred to them uh while in school uh and the time frame really did range really going back um about 25 years so we had some incidents obviously from 2001 to
124current uh board president met with the team last week or two weeks ago almost to review the status of each report so we have these meetings where we'll take a look at all the different things that are coming in We compare notes and perspectives discuss and uh are very open with each other about you know once we've corresponded where things at are there certain questions or different perspectives that we want to you know hear from based on on just the people in the room and maybe you know the the additional people will help us to look at things in a little different way so that way we can be as thorough and holistic as possible um one report had been submitted in February so everything prior uh to that had been received in that week
125really following everything going live and then uh one individual had submitted four reports that are not specific the first two emails were documented as part of the 22 total that are cited however the last two are not included since they're not really making a specific report but just airing grievances about um things within the district so to speak so just to get a little bit further into this uh reports related to Mr Henline received since January 22nd uh to either the voicemail box or the email uh were 10 uh none of which were previously reported to The District in the time frame of the incidents range from 2001 2018 I did consult with uh someone at the office of professional conduct because we did have have a previous report that was filed with similar allegations
126from Mr Henline and they recommended that we take everything we had been we had received up to a certain point and submit a second report combining all of these new allegations uh reports received regarding Mr Henline that resulted in District reporting to the law was one so and that um was simply do that because of the nature of the allegation made it could involve something criminal coming uh coming forward all right so I think this leads to our semester review with our SRO and would you like to go into that um sure we'll get a little bit um further into this a little bit a little bit Yeah so the presentation with these reviews there's there you're going to see this slide appear um a little bit later as well but but it this this
127slide represents us sitting down each semester review the reports that we get with the sro's um and with the chief and and a member of the board to review what we've received and how we've handled that so again it it allows us to get that feedback from the resource officers on these reports that we're getting and and this review process is something that we don't have now and looking in the mirror and reflecting on what we can do better we understand that this is something that we we want to do we also understand it's important with our SRO to sit down with them and review these things so there is that dialogue to to look at you know pass reports and flag patterns because that is one of the things that you'll see under you
128know kind of underscored here is is how are we tracking different reports to see if there is a pattern or not and taking these threads and things that you hear here and here and that goes back to that activity that we shared with the St staff activities if you're hearing these things how are we taking that thread and making sure that we're looking at it through the right lens not only in that moment but months later weeks later or or longer um so so again and and then we want to continually look at what can we do better to improve the system uh so that's important so may I just add one last thing I just want to say that we appreciate all of the reports that we are getting and you know we are
129learning a lot about some of the things that we want to sh up along the way but I do also want to emphasize that we are you know trying to respond to each with the level of care and compassion um that it deserves regardless of when it might have happened or who was involved and I know in each instance we're Consulting with legal counsel as necessary in addition to law enforcement to make sure that we are um doing what we need to do with everything that comes in so so the next area is the the student safety and staff conduct policy we met last week to have a draft of the policy um the board said we'd like to get um other eyes on this to get feedback um especially with students again the purpose
130is to Foster that safe respectful supportive environment for all students uh grooming is a process of building that inappropriate and exploitive relationship with a student um so there was a lot of conversation at the at the review with the two with the ad hoc Committee in terms of what are those behaviors and and how do we best capture those um this policy applies to all School District employees contractors volunteers and individuals um grooming uh there there's a couple different ways that we're looking at that that definition one are some very broad Strokes where we have providing special treatment or gifts to students non professional communication social media personal messaging platforms um isolating students from their peers and families um that's important encouraging and permitting boundary Crossing behaviors that may escalate and then also we looked
131at the lure code of professional conduct for Ohio Educators where it defines it as grooming a student a minor uh um befriending and establishing an emotional connection a student and or minor and a student's Minor's family to lower the student miners inhibitions for purpose of inappropriate emotional romantic or sexual relationship so it's trying to find those behaviors and patterns of those behaviors that might be present um and and then the professional boundaries uh that that's something that's very important as a professional you never want to put yourself in a position where there could be an an accusation made um and and if you're knowingly putting yourself in those positions that that could be something that needs to be flagged and explored a little more closely uh so those are some of the the the pieces
132of it that we're beginning to shape and when we do the first reading you'll you'll pick those things up um understanding the the key components prohibited misconduct mandatory reporting so when that bus driver or that teacher hears something it's not up to us to determine well that's just the way misso and so is and everybody knows they're harmless our responsibility is to report it's not for us to determine whether or not there's credibility to that it's our responsibility to report and that's part of that training we want to do with all the staff um the training and awareness monitoring and accountability which you're hearing pieces of that this evening and investigation consequences and we want to be able to communicate these expectations to families and certainly students so the last piece of this um I'll
133turn it over to to uh Mrs price um thank you Mr Hustler so we had I had talked with principles um a couple weeks ago and then last week Dr folz and I met with the SRO to really try to gather feedback and look into what can we get better at how can we make sure we are consistently documenting and tracking these types of things and so um I'm not going to kind of read through all of this but basically we're working really closely with the perisburg police division our SRO we have Safety Committee um that meets monthly as well as a parent safety task force we'll be running some of this stuff by them as well um and you know SRO are such a resource to our building and so we're really just ensuring
134we all know what the expectations are of each other so we don't miss anything and so we can recognize patterns of concern a lot earlier um and just have a better way to historically document what those are so Tom if you can scroll ahead so in kind of reflecting and reviewing things um we found several examples where uh police reports are shared verbally um and we'll get into um kind of on a next slide why that is um but essentially until a report is closed uh information can only be shared verbally and there needs to be typically some impact to the operations the school or the Safety and Security of student staff and um families so for example we don't need to know if someone has a you know cell phone violation in their car
135but we do need to know things that may have an impact to school safety and those things can range from of course staff misconduct is what we're kind of um led us to this discussion tonight but also there are custodial situ there are domestic violence situations that may bleed into school events so there are other things too that sometimes impact the safety of of the school and it's threading that needle of what do we need to know and then how do we document it and who needs to be looped in on those things um and so again you know there's some challenges too sometimes things are reported to the police and there's not really anything to investigate there may be no people's names listed or anywhere to start that investigation it may not be criminal
136in nature but there may be something that we still need to do or could still do about it as a school system and where's that line and what do we do with that information so those these Court these semesterly checkins and review of what has been kind of collected over a semester I think will create a good checks and balances to make sure we're being consistent in those approaches so if you scroll ahead um so again ensuring transparency across all buildings we kind of worked um with principles and with our SRO in the perisburg police division to kind of lay out a reporting process um so there's kind of two different funnels there are police reports involving students and then police reports revolving involving adults for police reports involving students there's a little um more
137latitude in what can be shared because obviously if anything poses a threat to the school um certainly the sro's can share details just like I referenced previously if it's an open case we can't get that hard copy until it's closed so it can be discussed verbally and we are Shoring up again these are the cliff notes version but Shoring up the process of making sure that verbal discussion is documented with General notes you've got a summary date and time um the administrator is going to be the person responsible for taking those once that report is closed the SRO will let that administrator know so we will be able to pull that report and then there is a system called caseworks which in a nutshell is essentially a kind of a data track tracking system for
138student threats and safety and so um we have access to that our sro's have access to that um we would have a redacted version that we could put there along with any notes regarding that incident and then we can factor that into if there is a threat assessment summary conclusion that results from that or some type of of safety plan for a student we can Factor those into that and it's a way to track and make sure there's a historical way to look at those things and then for adults again there are a variety of of ways police reports on adults can impact schools but again we want to make sure that we're in the loop for anything that would impact the operations of the school or the safety and well-being of student staff and
139family same thing like I said open case we can discuss verbally same process would happen that District um supervisor or direct administrator would take notes for example you know if a bus driver obvious or if someone's an employee and they're a bus driver and they get a DUI we need to know that because it's a different course of an an ction may need to be taken well it will need to be taken in that regard um so our SRO will work with who those direct supervisors are that may need to know if a police report has been filed on an adult that may impact the district in some way um and then same thing SRO would tell the building administrator once that report's available and then this is the piece that we're kind of working
140through on our end again they're going to take notes document all of those things but also document that outcome so whether there was was an investigation and if so what resulted if there's discipline resulting from that for an employee if there are support plans for an employee that maybe result from a police report or any restrictions to people being on school property what central office administrators need to be involved and so um if you go to the next slide then Mr Hustler so essentially for students um those reports will be kind of uploaded into caseworks and those that information will be incorporated into a student's thread of assessment or safety plan and then for adults um what we are working on is really kind of a shared U building team drive that those building administrators
141would have so that way we're not relying on one person to have maybe a file in a filing cabinet but a way that we would be able to um have a kind of a central place to store information so that we could have an historical look back if someone said you know three years later hey this got brought up did anyone do anything about that we could search by year and um the individual's name that would be impacted with that and really see what was done um and what was what the result of that was and so certainly if any discipline were would result that would go into an employees personnel file as applicable but there may be other things that you know happened between you know let's say two people at a student two
142two adults at a student event who got into an altercation and we may need to be aware that these two people may have an issue with each other right so you know and there may need to be restrictions to school property for some of those things so um we are Shoring that up on our end um really appreciate the perisburg police division's input um we we went over this with them last week they gave some good feedback as well um and certainly value value that um again like mentioned previously then we plan to kind of review this semesterly um with those with the police division and our SRO um just to make sure we are all on the same page and buildings are consistent with how they're handling these things and I think you know
143so what we want to do is we want to establish the expectations and communicate this process with the community and families um we're we're implementing this this documentation this you know the policies this spring the process that that was outlined um by Dr folz and and Mrs price in terms of that that implementation and documenting and Reporting System and then also we want to bring it back to the board of education and and have a a summary report each year with with broad information we we understand that these reports are Anonymous that anybody can make them from anywhere and that that's that's very good in terms of having that Comfort level to do that we also understand that that they are Anonymous and can reported from anywhere and they may not they might be done
144for a specific reason to harm somebody so we want to make sure that we're doing this and going about this in a way that is respectful of the people that report and there are things that we because the nature of what we do and being in the public that that that you report that to us and we'll do the best we can to keep it confidential but at the end of the day that may not be impossible so making sure people understand what that expectation is um certainly with students that is part of that but for adults and others you know there's limitations as to what that can be um and we want to make sure that you know we are keeping our eyes on the right things and having that system to be able
145to look back is is very important to us being able to identify Trends and flag those Trends is very important to us moving forward and and um you know I think we have looked at the and have put things in place that gets us moving down a path that will take us in the right direction um which will beneficial to our students and and certainly to our staff and community so those ideas of that ongoing accountability communicating back to the public having multiple eyes on it looking at how we're communicating with police looking in the mirror we understand that that this not having that hard copy getting that verbal report would what do we do with it whose hands is it in we need to shore you know that up um we want to work
146more efficiently and closely and in that capacity uh looking at new policies and bundling these things like we talked about before are essential in giving kids and families the tools they need to make reports and pointing them in that right direction so they're not looking and saying what is it that I can do but being able to have that neon sign saying this is the path that you can take and and I you know we we welcome and and Dr folz went over all the reports and said that we're very grateful for the people that do that that is a very uncomfortable situation to say years from now you know years ago this happened to me and I'm reporting it today because I want you to know about it that takes a lot of Courage
147even even as an adult looking back at that period and we want to recognize that we want to create a system where people are more comfortable in reporting um the the the statistic that Dr fult shared about the number of previously reported reports that came to the district that we didn't act on was very important to us in doing that review that look in the mirror and as we've processed this there has been one report that said we have this was reported before it was reported by an administrator against other administrators and we don't have a record of that um um and and so we're trying to get additional information um but the information that we have to act act on is only as good as the information that we can receive so taking all
148of these steps from letting students and families know all the different ways that they can provide that feedback in those reports is really important knowing that we're going to do something with those reports is really important and then how do we capture that data and continue to to review it and hold it in a way that we can access it months and and years later is really important so I think this helps us get moving in the right direction and um you know we want to continue to look in that mirror and make sure that we're doing the things that we need to do uh to improve so so I'll open it up to any questions that that any of you may have I'll just add that um just to assure the board I I
149have been tracking each of those kind of kept my own list and then we were able to walk through that back on the 6th uh I I think one of the things that you know we talked about in the policy committee um that we've been talking you know is I've had some individual conversations with each of you and certainly with the administration is is the um the challenge of how to how to change a culture where and I think some of it you know I've reflected a lot you know me toooo movement was 15 years ago and our understanding of what um what was acceptable which shouldn't have been um which maybe we turned a blind eye to before that now I I think our students are more educated about what is appropriate that when
150they say I didn't feel right about this to give them a really clear pathway and that's something that Dr refer and I were talking about at the policy review is how do we make that just as simple as possible for students to know what to do when they don't feel right about a situation um and I I I think what was so hard about so many of those reports were how many people said well I didn't report this because I didn't think of it was a big deal and each of those things was a big deal because they still remembered it 20 25 years later um and all those little deals you know helped make a really big deal understandable so I I think the ways that we're working to educate um students and teachers
151and administrators is huge I do think the work that's been done to um better communicate with the police I think that that was one of the things that we really identified early on that there were some just significant gaps in that communication um I I think the challenge right now that I feel as we look at these policies and as we think about the training is that we we know that mentoring relationships of adults with with students and especially high school students is really important um they're positive and I we're you know how do we continue to ensure that those mentoring relationships oftentimes with teachers um that having someone outside of your parents as a trusted advisor and Mentor in your life that happens with coaches and advisors and and teachers that those healthy relationship
152ships can continue to um you know continue to happen and support students while also talking about um the accountability of of where lines start to get crossed and how um you know we hold one another as adults um responsible when we see those things as well as um kind of empowering students to say to friends hey that wasn't cool I need to go report that because I I know you didn't see this but I did um so I think all the efforts we've taken really just in the last month are a significant step there's still a lot of work to do um but I I am really grateful for the work a lot of energy and time has been invested already and I I think we're heading in the right track yes and um I
153think the big thing too is that we talked about is making sure that we're able to hold this information somewhere centrally um so I did have a question though you talked about um Mrs price I think it was in here you talked about as being the the administrative school like their own building team drive but I'm going to guess there's a and if not I would like to make sure that there is a centrally located yeah I don't know in my head I'm seeing a spreadsheet but I know there's better ways to do that you know but obviously you said by name and date so we would work with our tech department to create that team drive so it's not owned by anyone administrator it's essentially an administrative drive that we would put the the
154administrators on but then we would also be able to access and that and it you can create it in such a way so people can't delete from it um you can only add to it depending on who the owner is so we would kind of centrally set those up through the tech department and then you know if an administrator changes you would remove that administrator add a new one um but you'd have that historical look back of all those documents um so you could search by year in the name of a person to see when something occurred and what was looked into and what was done about it regardless of the person in that position currently oh that I know that's the big one of the many concerns but that was one of the big
155ones is to make sure that we're able to track that so that we have it and it's not just one person having that information um so I know there's a lot of work that went on to here and then can you one of my big questions and we had our ad hoc committee meeting last last last week was the um some people obviously don't want to give their name and what is the truly Anonymous way to report and that would be the safer School line for my understanding is that they report the information to somebody at the state level and then that person contacts the district without giving a name but gives details so that you can investigate is that correct yeah so in essence yeah in essence um and then what happens is multiple
156people get alert when something goes through the tip line and you have to Market resolved with the state so you have to put in the system how it was resolved or they will like you can't really ignore it it keeps um now some of the things that are challenging with that is sometimes we get reports and you know for example on Thanksgiving Autumn rainbow is being a sixth grader being bullied at Fort mags well we immediate look into that we don't have any student by that name in The District and we don't have sixth grade at Fort Megs right so we document that we could not substantiate the threat but that goes into the system so and then of course there are other things that that you know our SRO make house calls our administrators
157are contacting parents after hours I mean we get the alerts at at all times I think one was on CHR like New Year Eve so yeah New Year's Eve I mean it it you get you get them multiple ways so those have to be marked resolved those are already tracked through that system um but sometimes it is challenging if there's nothing to go off of there needs to be at least enough information to figure out where to go with a threat um and so even if there isn't you still have to mark what you did to substantiate that you couldn't move forward with it depending on what the information is just to even with the tools that we have available now I think we've had people submit email on behalf of other people doing so
158anonymously to help protect their identity and you know we've had people leave voicemail messages as well and I mean not leave their number and even the caller ID they can block so I mean some of what's available they can truly do it anonymously that way but in terms of being able to really dig into some of these situations if that something that they want is for us to follow back up and see where we can go with it we need to know you know a certain level of detail especially if that it's a someone who this happened to first person to be able to talk with them at some Point's really vital so right and I think that's part of where our your rights as a student and our student Bill of Rights comes in
159and I'll be very interested to see um because we had requested that it get vetted by some students to see because it makes sense for us but I'm an adult 55 years old you know and I think also it's it's important that we um teach our kids to trust their gut I mean as an adult and as an adult female you you know when something's hky or just we just need we our kids don't have that yet and just getting them to be able to trust that you know if they even think it's a little bit off and I've told my kids that then you know you need to tell somebody you need to tell somebody so thank you I this is a lot and I think it's a great first step additional questions or
160I just in looking at this presentation and some of the discussions that we've had and the agony of this this whole experience um since last May basically when it came to your attention and then Us in June I mean we all inherently knew that there was a process that was 25 years old and culture being as it is it's a fluid thing and that 25-year-old process through this incident happened to show us oh this is how we need to update it this is what can do this is where some of the holes are this is why there's misperceptions this is why we need to do this and and to see all that you have done to bring this to be more user friendly for students for the community for faculty and staff I just I
161just commend everybody who has put a lot of sweat to te into this you've done a marvelous job and I know I know this is still drafty I know it's still coming together but goodness gracious this is this is really quite remarkable I love the student guide book The Bill of Rights that's I mean all of this is just really wonderful and I think this is a I get criticized for always being the poana when something comes when something bad happens but this this is the beauty and and the benefits of what happens when you've got an investigation and what should happen when you have an investigation that something good comes out of it and this is remarkable I I mean it's from what Dr folz was saying it's already working and that's that is
162quite a relief that is quite a relief and over the year I'm sure we'll find out little tweaks and things and to have student reviews and your student advisory councel they'll keep you updated as to what needs to be changed on it or whatever but yeah this is and is is hinky a uh professional that you know is that the right knew it that was awesome I like that so you have to include that in the book somewhere you know if you feel hinky about something you need to report it okay well I thanks thank you Mrs price and and M Dr folz and Mr Hustler for that update um before we move into the superintendent report we are going to take a f minute break e e e we could continue our meeting I'm
163going to turn it over to Mr hosler for his report all right thank you so I have a brief report um just uh a February report so um wanted to congratulate um Perry's High School's uh Tera zman for um being selected for a presidential award in excellence in math and science so we'll have more information there but uh just six Ohio Educators were among the 336 teachers that were receiving this National recognition so it's great to know that um others across the country know what we have known for some time that we have an outstanding educator uh with Miss sechman and um Bessie Cranson who uh re was the Ohio um strings teacher of the year uh she's been working in the district as a strings teacher for nearly 20 years and um has helped
164uh be one of the driving forces in making um our program the Strings program what it is today which is just uh not only across the state but nationally known and um we're very excited that she received this award so Military Appreciation Night at girls basketball game at the Junior High um we wanted to thank uh city council member uh Carrie walstein and uh representative Michelle Grim from uh Northwest Ohio to recognize veterans and active duty members that were in attendance there so being uh a district that you know really prioritizes military families and serving um students that are in military families that's that's very important to us so um Wanted just to say thank you for the seniors uh five seniors uh that were um you know pictured here um you know continuing to
165do great things for us um and um I know they are part of a great tradition uh in gimnastics and no doubt we'll be recognizing them uh with uh state qualifiers but um always great to see um our students um especially a group as accomplished as as they are so um our speech and debate continue to Roll Along winning their F fifth uh tournament this season so I'm very excited to see not only the numbers of students participating but the results that they're getting so that's exciting to see and I know they have some of the State uh events ahead of them so they're certainly in great position for wonderful things to happen so Band on the Run um is scheduled for May 3rd so it is a it's a it's a run a benefit
166the the HPI and Junior High bands and you can sign up uh to participate you don't have to run uh you can walk and if you don't want to walk you can donate so there is uh room for you no matter where we go mock trial team uh presented um at the Wood County courthouse and uh did out outstanding attorney Awards outstanding witness um and then another outstanding attorney so that's great this is a little mind-blowing but we're registering for the class of 2038 um so we'll be you know seeing a parade of families bringing their students in very soon for registration and and uh it's it's pretty exciting to see that 2038 that doesn't seem like uh but but there it is so the French Club will be celebrating their annual uh marra um
167event on May 8th and uh from 11: to 2 in the P from 11: a.m. to 2: p.m. in the Commons there's no charge for the event and um it is a lot of fun and a lot of neat things to benefit from that activity so and as mentioned we have the district dialogue that that we highlighted earlier um and so the bayum budget so I wanted to pause a little bit and and kind of pick up um and and talk through a little bit with what happened and what's happening in the state and uh um treasure duor did a great job of really bringing it home uh to what it means so we we know that we've already begun to talk to legislators about the need to update the inputs that is raising the
168state's average that they're bringing into that equation um and we began to to do that um and and so that will continue to happen so you've heard a little bit about what this means for perisburg schools so the one thing that the the um that drives what Randy had talked about in his presentation is this weighted capacity per pupil and and that's that um went from 3.7 to 6.7 and what that means is perisburg is cons considered wealthier under this funding formula and that means the state is saying perryburg you have the ability to raise those funds locally based on their calculations seen here and and we are not going to provide that additional funding in that time our for every dollar that comes into perisburg right now 19 20 cents of every dollar that
169comes into perisburg comes from the state of Ohio at the end of the bayum budget it'll fall to 11 cents will come from the state of Ohio so that is a dramatic shift to local taxpayers and again the major thing that that's this driving this is those inputs that the state is not wanting to to increase so our state aid is dropped and Randy covered this from from 12.63 million down to 11.2 million it's a 1.3 M $1.4 million loss 11% over two years the largest sing drop is between fiscal year uh 26 and 27 which is uh a negative 7.7% drop in state funding projected so um and how some other districts around us are being treated um again you can see where Springfield um is is probably the largest uh drop in in
170terms of their uh funding but you can see Anthony Wayne is relatively unchanged uh but when you start getting into ATO um Sylvania Rossford Ottawa Hills uh you're you're in Lake you're you're seeing those kind of numbers rack up in terms of the negative impact here locally why why have a huge discrepancy it has to do what's happening within your District so so if if your valuations have increased sharply um then you will see um that that wealth Factor kick in and that's kind of what we're describing and seeing that that reduction if your valuations haven't changed as much you're not going to see as as much there's it could be a matter of enrollment projections that the state's using it could be a matter of um Pipeline and utilities which could help offset certain
171things so there's a lot of other factors that go into it every district is is unique and and how that works um um so it appears public schools have relatively flat funding over the next two years in the banian budget um spending on vouchers is to is going to increase an estimated 8% uh so again it is about you know what the state prioritizes in terms of where do they want to fund we shared this last month um about the the um the speaker uh saying that the third I don't think there is a third third phas in for cup Patterson that's the fair school funding as uh as as to the expectation that those things are going to go in I guess the clear statement I can say is I think those increases in
172spending are un sustainable so what that means is the expectation is that additional spending is going to come down to the residents of school districts but budget priorities as you can see by some of the other things things is certainly very different this is just um the beginning of the process so I don't think you want to overreact and say this is what is going to happen you heard Randy talk about I'm going to have to do the best guess in May because we won't have a definite answer then so you you heard the call and we'll talk a little bit more about it about the legislators need to hear from residents that is critically important that's something that we'll be sending out some information one of our colleagues in chardan Ohio did a really
173nice job of framing things and and we're going to take a page from them to help our residents make sure that that information is being communicated but just a reminder of what has to happen with the budget so the governor introduces his budget and that's what we're talking about now and then this year they alternate years so this year it actually starts in the house so a state legislator will take the governor's budget and just adopt it as a bill because then they can begin to work on it and discuss it and then the house is going to put its stamp on it they will break up the bill into different um committees they'll hear testimony they'll make different um uh changes to it and then they will pass a version out of the house
174then it goes to the Senate the process starts all over with the Senate and they will put their stamp on it so the house will pass a version of the budget Bill the Senate will pass a different version of the budget bill and then what happens is they assign individuals from the house and the Senate to come together in a conference committee they hash out a bill and once it comes out of that committee it will go to the house and to the senate for approval and typically it will be approved in both Chambers and then it gets passed then it goes back to the governor and the governor can sign it and then they also have the ability for line item vetos and there's certain things that they can strike out of the budget
175that the Governor doesn't like or support so this is a lengthy process this is the first lap of a many you know of several laps in the race to come and so hearing what Randy said you know that legislators are saying I'm not hearing much from people we we need to we need to let them know that we're concerned about this because who does it impact it impacts our taxpayers or our students or both um and and so that's what what matters is the inputs that is the most important thing that we can begin to communicate is that you need to update your end of the bargain which is you're going to use current average salaries for all of these positions that goes into the input which will then allow the state to balance out
176with what we're responsible to pay because right now we get updated our responsibility gets updated every year and there's hasn't been since 2020 so so that is very important there there is a a house education committee and a senate education committee so right now all the action is going to be in the house the chair of the house is representative Sarah Fowler Arthur from Ashtabula um and there is her phone number an address and then it's going to go to the Senate where um state senator Andrew brener from Delaware he is the chair of the Senate education committee and then that's his contact information there um so that is where the hearings will take place and they will make adjustments and changes to the bill in their committee and then they will vote it out
177to the main floor so that's how that that piece of education is going to start there and also the finance committee but we're focusing on the education committee on the on the house side um you can see these are the house members members um if people that were newly elected uh haven't submitted their photos yet so that's why there's no photo yet because their sessions just began um but you can kind of see um you know who who is on the committee and uh our two state representatives are not on the committee that are local um and that uh Josh Williams out of Sylvania Township if you look at the um the screen his district is the green it's it's kind of like a butterfly almost kind of a thing or I don't know how
178to describe it but it's to the west of perisburg Sylvania the west of perisburg but then you can see how it goes along the river through perisburg and then cuts out in perryburg Township so there there may be some individuals in perryburg schools that are representative by representative Williams so that's why his name is appearing there and then also representative harz in in perisburg um representa gambari has always been somebody that we've relied on to to help with conveying education you know um messages and um he's not on the committee but it's good that they hear what our concerns are and I know representative gambari has been very supportive of schools representative Williams is a very um openly for choice and um and that's where he aligns with uh and I I'm not talking out
179of school they'll he would tell you that himself our state senators um Teresa Senator Teresa gavon Bowling Green and you can see her um covers most of perisburg schools I am sharing that um Senate President the the most powerful person in the Senate is the president uh uh Senator mcau is out of Napoleon so a familiar you know the r our athletic leave and and you can see his his district is is um you know basically just surrounding Uh Wood County but an important voice that we want to make sure that he's hearing as well as uh Senator gavon so I don't think uh Senator gavron is on the education Committee in the Senate I didn't include their information because it's not in the Senate yet but she is certainly a powerful person in the
180Senate as well so so that kind of concludes the report any questions that you might have happy to answer I I just want to highlight back on your slide 17 that while our funding is decreasing over the next two years um to where we're really looking at about 10% of all of our costs actually being supported by the state and the other 90% falls on us that they're increasing vouchers and just vouchers that's um funding to take your student to private schools and to Charter Schools which again in some is is granted the problem is is that um our funding decreases while their funding increases still with no accountability tied to that no testing no no accountability for the outcomes of that money um so I just want to highlight that again you know I
181will add to that because you know we we talk about that a lot um there's a really uh if you read the Ohio Capital Journal there's always a lot of information about you know all of this and there was a good article it was just yeah just this week so was today yeah yesterday the 17th so it talks about cup Patterson and you know all all of that but it talks about the vouchers and how they increased um vouchers in the data from 2223 uh it says according to League of Women Voters of Ohio research of State data voucher programs have seen enrollment between 22 23 and 23 24 increased by 3700 students while the spending on voucher expansion nearly tripled in the same period so 3,700 additional students where they touted as being we're
182going to give people a choice and they say the bulk of that enrollment increasement to students whose families had already decided and been able to commit their resources to enroll their kid in a private school and you know you know how I feel about vouchers and you know it they don't accept everybody you know and I'll say it again and I I'll keep saying it that that there's no private school that would take my student my Lucas who's Now 23 years old with the special needs that he had he would not and he again creating that divide between the Hales and Have Nots at the expense of our children how to express to our state representatives and people making these decisions what our priorities are um for our students can you everybody that link and
183again with no accountability Public Schools can pretty much they don't have like we're state or public schools have all the testing requirements all the you know State tests all this and all that and you have to take everybody but again all of our money is going to private schools because let's make the Hales have more yes I will send that to you and I'll send it to everybody yeah but if you just read how Capital Journal there's a lot of great information I also wanted to highlight um it is board appreciation uh time so I don't know if this is approp or not but thought you wanted to skip over that for some reason yeah thank you um in all seriousness we're very grateful and uh certainly will convey the message to uh board member
184mkey but uh you know it is more challenging than ever perhaps to serve on the board I can't think of a more important role to play in your community and also probably the most thankless role to play in the community serving on the board and um you know from staff and from students you have a bundle of of thank yous that that are there uh for for you and um you know I know you never get downtime whether you're at a store or you know pumping gas or at church uh inevitably you know somebody wants to talk to you about you know something going on with the schools and so the amount of time that you put in outside of these long meetings and the Committees that you serve on and attending events and being
185visible um it is a sacrifice to your families and uh we're very grateful that you know that you're choosing to spend that time with us and it is very appreciative um in all seriousness and we worry about who wants to step up and and answer the call and make it serving the students as you have such a priority and uh so we're we're grateful for that so so in sincerity thank you so I appreciate appreciate and I haven't looked at these yet but I want to do a shout out to have sent me a a card and and included test the dog that was adorable so thank you yeah this is one of the highlights yeah these are you know last year I received these at our first regular meeting and I probably I mean
186I really enjoyed them I think I'll appreciate them even more this year after having suring that is it is always appreciated the teachers and the students the staff take time out of their day to do this for us and I have kept I've got a box I've kept every one of them that I've ever gotten and yeah there you go I will go through all of these two with a lot of appreciation it's an honor to serve thank you it's time um also superintendent committee reports uh we had operations Miss ler did you want to take that one or okay let me pull this up real quickly me just a second there was a lot yeah there's there's always a lot but um uh in in regards to something that's happening tonight um Courtney our
187transportation director mentioned that the drivers are very excited about the redistricting it's taking a lot off of their plate it's making a lot of things make more sense it's making them and therefore their students more safe and so they they definitely um it it I guess the reason why I'm mentioning it was because I hadn't really thought about it I thought it was a unique perspective um they're trying to get a gasoline tank to be on site to make that that easier um new buses are doing super well um the tank also will help save money because they'll be able to buy gas wholesale yes so save money absolutely um and the excitement that if if we approve the reduction of HPI hours um all the roots will then be on time barring unforeseen circumstances
188um but that was I mean at the beginning of the was it this year or was it last year when we didn't meet that state mandated minimum time for that which was totally absurd um but this cleans all of that up too so just a lot of as I've learned over the years what seems like a simple solution or just a solution to something has just a of dominoes behind it and I thought that that was kind of interesting of course Jason is already going over summer projects um and getting kind of that working on um Denise boy when she starts talking about food service she she's just she's in her happy place um she is such a tour to force in getting so many things going um in that department what she's doing for
189Food Services just amazing and she's getting involved in another Symposium in April in Chicago um and let's see the one that was surprising was that Schaefer didn't really have a lot to say and and so what he did say was in English but that's in the notes and I don't think I need to go over that but I just want to distress those things in particular for you highlight too the um talked a little bit at the meeting about the head custodian at PHS will be um acting on her yeah I think hers is a resignation but I think it's kind of a retirement too um so we want to thank her for her service um and I think one of the things that that Mr juror picked up in his report is that again
190in that those accounts it looks like there's a lot of money but um Bren is going to be ordering computers now to try to get ahead of um any projected tariff hikes um hikes price that's right yes thank you um plus all the summer projects Denise is going to be needing to replace a lot of equipment um in the cafeterias so um there'll be a lot of uh purchases made to um you know kind of replace and upgrade some of the equipment so and put in perspective there our one one device purchase this year is low it's only $400,000 because um Mr schaer keeps some you know inventory on hand for spares and he's he's cutting that to the bare minimum just to get by so um you know technology is wonderful and but there's
191there is a cost I think I'm just going to highlight one other thing um that that we kind of joke that Brent didn't have a lot to say but he noted that he had been spending a lot of time on public records requests um Randy noted that he had spent 20 hours uh the week before um all there there's at least five or six different administrators that have been spending significant amounts of time on a myriad of of public records requests and um I think as we talk to folks out in the community just to encourage them to really Target those to what is needed because it takes a lot of Staff time um administrator staff time to fulfill those so we're grateful for all their work in doing that and there's a legal cost
192associated with those requests from time to time too oh yeah redactions cost that's yeah' be interesting if we could get a roundabout cost of you know how much that is the cost of the district in the last couple years again it's it's people's rights I think it's just a question sometimes of what they're fishing for all right um anything else superintendent report number 10 like to move us on to number 11 these are the items for Action that are not in the consent agenda 11.1 is the recommendation on the elementary boundaries and I'll turn that over to Mr Hustler thanks and I know U Mrs price will um certainly jump in as we go through this um if there's questions and um I know that uh um missel is here as well a transportation director
193so we'll be able to to answer questions if needed but um the redistricting Elementary boundaries we're making the recommendation for for option a um and you know just a reminder that we we um we redistrict every single year every time a new Street gets added with houses on it every time a new um multifamily apartment complex goes in a new plat is added on to an existing subdivision we look to see where there is room for students and then we assign them to to that building and it may not be the building that that is closest or within the boundaries and that has created a challenge since 2015 you can see that we've added um almost 800 students to the district um and and that's significant we we talk about how students come to the
194district and we understand how that works um we were hoping that we would be talking about opening a new Elementary School to alleviate that overcrowding at the elementary buildings and do a redistricting with a new building coming online and we know that that's not possible um we also know that um the operational ly uh failing um being rejected by voters uh resulted in us not having enough funds to operate the schools that we have let alone consider bringing on a new building so we set out to find ways to be more efficient ways to to save dollars and and so um Brooke uh in Courtney um did a great job of of you know taking that on and coming up with multiple options and then narrowing it down to two um this is our current
195um busing system where bus stops are and you can see colors that are mixed in the green and the red uh the teal um yellow all those kind of overlapping and when you zoom in on that you literally have exactly what I described a new Street goes in well those kids are going to have to go to another Elementary School that plat went in those students and and that's what is being represented here where you literally have around the block three different buses from three different schools going into the same location and that's not very efficient so we understand the current issues with that and um and what that means and um we understand that overla the longer routes divided neighborhoods um and then limited walk zones are are all issues that we are currently
196dealing with so we did a pre uh survey and and I and Brooke you can jump in here and and uh talk about what we did before we started the process so the pre- survey essentially asked what the primary concerns were from our families and so I know most of you went to those presentations and you kind of um solve what those questions were so Mr Hoster you kind of can scroll through so disruption of peer networks loss of connection to community or top concerns um you know what will help with the transition certainly different events to acclimate students to a new building um what factors were most important so minimizing disrup ion to the number of students that would be impacted how close the building is to home keep the neighborhoods together those were
197all things ahead of when we kind of deed the plans with what were top concerns from families and so um like I mentioned previously in some of the community presentations we essentially created projected enrollment reports so we took every current K3 student listed where they were living and figured out through transportation software where are the most efficient boundary lines and then looked at what that would do to enrollment numbers and then we plugged in a placeholder of 360 for the incoming kindergarten class and so um you can see there's a sample Mr hoser if you scroll ahead um well we then asked additional questions um following the survey and um if you kind of keep scrolling through here essentially overwhelmingly on all of the questions we asked option A was preferred by families so every
198single one of the questions was in the 90% tile for option a um comparatively to option b um which is you know around 6 7% um for each of the questions listed and these are all in this presentation and so we looked at anticipated growth area so you'll see Frank you know jumps a little bit bigger out of the gate but they're a little more landlocked in terms of the areas that are are going to be coming online for development um looked at trying to create that balanced enrollment between buildings how many students are impacted we did talk about um we do plan to offer applications for interd district transfers for incoming or fourth graders um to remain for their final year in their building so we do plan to communicate with fourth grade families
199regarding that process probably towards the end of April um and then we will look at what those numbers do in terms of what we can approve to make those accommodations for fourth grade um again you know there in or because we're doing this because we there needs to be a cost savings effic and efficiency and balancing out some enrollment sizes for for workload within buildings um letting all the siblings stay is not going to be logistically possible but we do want to work to make accommodations for those students who are in their last year at their Elementary um if the board chooses to move forward we'll be working with Elementary principles they've already been working behind the scenes having conversations about what we want to do collectively for welcome events opportunities to meet um new
200classmates new teachers to our buildings so we'll be working on that as well um and so you know we ask people to share any additional thoughts they have um you keep going um so this is kind of a summary of the main of the main kind of concerns but just stability minimal disruption um a lot of parents did want their children to finish their Elementary years to avoid another year before they transition to HPI um keeping neighborhoods together um you know concerns about splitting some established neighborhood hoods um really work to avoid that and then um again option A overwhelmingly PR preferred for minimizing disruption um option b was criticized for overcrowding to right out of the gate and so option b would essentially Force us likely to get a portable placed at to earlier
201than option A would um you know some people just really don't like either option and would prefer an additional option but again when you look at how to make the boundaries most efficient and balanced out enroll sizes there's only so many ways you can do that and make that work um so it's really marrying both of those ideas together to kind of come with the plans and the plans you can see were pretty similar because of because of that um so we are recommending to the board option a um again that's what this map looks like and you can see comparatively to what Mr hoser showed earlier obviously the boundary lines are are much cleaner with this option and then these are summarized as the main changes this information is again all all available in
202this presentation as well as on our district website we have an actual list of all the apartments neighborhoods and street views um that we have um put on the on the website and we'll we're continuing to like work and finalize and even get Street numbers on that and then we also plan um you know the board approves this option to include walk zones so essentially it would be a road code book that would live on our website where people could look to see exactly what building they would go to based on their address as well as whether they're in a walk Zone um so that's a breakdown showing the enrollment um again this can save around1 $150,000 just in transportation fees keeps buses off the freeway delays Force transfers keeps neighborhoods in the same building
203and then um by doing this and balancing out those grade level sections we essentially can uh reduce We Believe approximately sixth grade level sections again we still have incoming kindergarten to enroll so it's not an exact science but with our project enrollment with our current students that's about $480,000 so anywhere from half a a little over half a million to $630,000 could be saved um by implementing this option and then again this just shows the building capacity the buildings with asterisk have Portables um and so you can add a 100 students essentially to each of those building capacity numbers um and again this is the number of students impact did based on that project enrollment report of current kindergarten through third graders so with option A 31% of the students would be moving to a
204different building option b was slightly higher with 34% so I think that pretty well covers a lot of that general information um and and again I know the board attended those events and and were able to interact with uh people that that did that did attend um we also have the um you know loaded up on the website but but also um um available to to staff uh and families the streets which and who's changing and and that's out there as well so um so that's something that you know we do have available um and this is what it looks like so folks can go out there and take a look so um and and so that's kind of where we are so happy to answer any questions that that you may have at this
205time any questions about the presentation yeah with the um email that we received with that person had having given us a a different version and I've sat here I almost wanted to make a transparency so that I I know there that's really going back a a long way trying to figure out what the difference was between what she was proposing and a I mean I can see it but her her text and her email sounded reasonable but I mean obviously there was something that must have not jived with Courtney's maps and figurings do we do we know what that was um I I think um if I recall and I know you have it printed out there um it began to split uh you know Frank was extended out um so one of the concerns
206that we had is that it it would potentially make Frank an area where there is going to be more growth um in that Corridor down down yes so so that was one of the concerns is that Frank was designed to to have the enrollment it had because it wasn't including areas where there was going to be a lot new growth and um that plan did expand it further into an area where there would be more growth and that is our smallest building so that was one of the things I think that was a concern as we started to pick through that so um and um I do think that there was also you know expansion with Woodland where there was a little more populated area um and it is um you know you you do
207that and then you undo something to B to that that kind of moves the balance a little bit um we looked at lots of options not just two those were the two most viable options that were presented to the board and so um unfortunately when you're trying to carve out what you're interested in doing you're going to be creating someone else who's going to want to carve out and I think people have been we're glad for the feedback that we received and the meetings that happened after the meetings um the emails I mean we're very grateful for that and we understand this is a really hard topic because you're talking about kids moving to a new building and we don't want to lose sight that that is impactful for those students um so we also
208understand that there comes a point there isn't ever going to be a plan other than just staying what we're doing now and not changing that would be embraced by by all and um so if you're undoing this and this there's going to be another family that's going to come with a very thoughtful email like that person sent you with a very thoughtful map and say do this because then I I don't have to change and my neighborhood doesn't have to change and ultimately we need to change we don't have the space the funds to to do and and um you know so that that that's a little you know I'm not doing it justice but the analysis was a little more in depth but that was some of the reasons why well it it it
209goes back to what I said earlier is that you come up with a with a plan like this not only the amount of hours and labor intensity that went into coming up with with that option but you come up with another option you think oh this is so much better but they don't I don't see it either a lot of times the Myriad of dominoes that start falling and going off the table yeah when you're trying to just tweak one little thing and right so that area of growth that would be shifting from to to Frank yeah um to you know the has has you know more space that that can absorb where Frank is already stable with the numbers that they have and you know so when I when I saw that email I
210think when I looked at that because I you know played around with this a little bit too and I I think it didn't take into consideration that what has been included which was one of the goals of this was future growth so I do think that that is a that was one of the goals and I think that that's Incorporated in this option A I think what I'd like to do is um ask we can discuss um this and talk about why we would vote for it or not but I think I first want to make sure that we want to discuss it so if I could have a a motion to adopt the new Elementary boundary plan known as option A is presented if we could have a motion a second then we could
211have more discussion go moved second Dr refer Miss ler um discussion so looking at these and Mr Hustler um you know like like you said it's it's never going to be an ideal time it isn't you're somebody's student or somebody's family is going to be disrupted um looking at these plans I'm you know when you look at the original map we knew they were all over and would I've had a couple people say to me they they didn't realize you're taking one bus from way over here going all the way over to almost 795 you know and that is so inefficient um so I appreciate the time that went into this and and explaining that it was more than two options because you guys spent hours hours on this and again you know I'm I'm
212a former Elementary principal I've been an educator for 30 years it's never going to be an easy time to make any kind of move like this um we were hoping for a new building to make it you know an easier move um the good thing about it is that the kids will back to back together going to HPI and not have to wait till the Junior High um kids are resilient I like the plan that there's going to be things available for our students because that's important you know to to meet again with their friend group you know neighborhoods are we're trying to keep neighborhoods together um and you know just keeping in mind that kids are resilient and they're going to react the way the adultsa so if we go into it with an
213open mind you know you'll and just keep it positive um is it going to change is it going to help with everything no and there are going to be kids that have anxiety and stress and you know and all of that and we're very cognizant of that and I don't want people to think that we're not because I think that's one of the things that bothers me the most is somebody says well you guys didn't think about that or you don't care well obviously we care because we're here this is this is not you know we we ran and and ran for Schoolboard for a reason um we agonize over this type of thing and I know that this was the best two plans that were available um that make the most use of our
214resources and know that we will be able to provide for our students the support that they need and for their families as well so thank you again for putting all this in there and I appreciate all the feedback from the families too and I did quick math and you know I'm not a math person but you said there are 688 return surveys and approximately 00 families or 1600 I just me by 1600 kids so there's probably more than that you know so not knowing how many families you sent out I mean that was a 43% you know good survey returns are 20% so we had a lot returned which was good and I'm I'm glad that there were a lot of voices heard as well yeah I agree I appreciate the process that the administration
215and fellow board members went through to get this community feedback and design this plan and to come up with something that was going to the most efficient and most cost effective and I Echo what has already been said here is that this isn't all about cost to me there is an impact on our students on our children to make this change and this is what is a polarity these are two different kind of forces acting in opposite directions of each other we've got the needs and the emotional care of of of of our students and and wanting some consistency versus losing 17% of our budget and needing to demonstrate to the taxpayers that this Administration this board has looked at everything to bring you know the cost down in order to support that that that
216new reality of the budget um and because of that you know this was or this was not the plan right the plan was to build a new Elementary School on the west side and and and we got those results so you know this was this was not the plan until a few months ago and again kind of looking at all those rocks and saying this can uh rationalize the bus routes can rationalize the level of of of Staff in the buildings can rationalize uh future growth can keep Portables down again not the plan that we want to do still probably not the plan that we really want to do but it's apparent that it's the plan that we that we need to do and again not boiling it all down to Dollars and cents and
217I am encouraged you know one of our one of our elementary principles princip in the in the back there at the table right now and just knowing what a great job our building leadership I have faith our building leadership is going to really help welcome these students and make this transition you know as as easy as as possible and and that may feel empty now but I do have faith that that'll happen so um you know the the plan I respect the process that the district went through that that courtne Brook went through in order to to come up and others went through to come up with the plan that will hopefully work best for our students for our district and candidly for the taxpayers I think one of the things along with everything that's
218been said because I know that um you know this is asking a third of our students almost a third of our students to to learn a new building to learn some new staff um I am comforted by the fact that they will be going possibly with neighbors or friends from their schools uh I do think that this plan meets the the goals that were originally set out when we first talked about this process back in December I think it was um you know not only the busing Effectiveness uh incorporating future growth neighborhoods to the same schools but one of the things that I've really focused on as I've thought about this is really um creating more Equitable experience for every student so I know that there's students that are going to struggle with this but
219I also know that there's going to be students who benefit from this change one is because they might actually get to go to school with their neighborhood kids but two is that we're going to have um the same number of kids generally for the same resources there was only one guidance counselor for Woodland that had you know hund and I I'd have to look back you know 150 kids more than another building but there was still just one guidance counselor there still one music teacher and we had the same resources in each building this makes it a much more Equitable experience um we won't have students that have to be um you know on a stage or in a room that wasn't designed to be a classroom um so I'm I'm I think the way
220that this gives every student in our district um the same experience is really important to me and I still think a lot of them might be jealous when they see all the festivities and things that they get to do over the Summers they're ushered into a new building and maybe the other kids will say well gee I want to go too and then the parents will have a different problem but I I'm I'm really excited about all the all the plans that I've heard to from various principles saying well this is what we're thinking of doing to you know help bring those kids along so I think it's I agree it's it's a hard thing you know a third of your students that's that's a lot but it's a it's it's a I think it's
221a logical and thoughtful and good solution to a severe financial problem and I'm kudos to y'all for every the tortures that you had to go through in order to come up with anything let alone a plan that was so resoundingly acceptable to the people who participated in giving feedback there there was no gray area on that one no other comments I'll um ask Mr durur for a roll call all right Dr reford yes Miss ler yes Mr benington yes Miss Roland Miller yes all right on to 11.2 approval of Hall Prairie intermediate daily schedule for next school year Mr Hustler um I know we spent the work session uh earlier this month going over with Mr best in great detail um the the why and um I know it was a good conversation and um
222felt based on the feedback to bring it forward to the board for further consideration so um that brought us here this evening so so at this time is are there any additional questions for clarification that we have I know we got to ask a lot at the meeting at the work session yeah we we did get to ask a lot and and I know it's just got to be twisting people's brains and not as to why this is a why this even came up as a suggestion why it even why it even works and hopefully this will be a a tempor orary solution until we can get other things worked out I know there's a lot of people that are very unhappy about it but I I don't I honestly don't see another path to
223do it I really don't I think it's it's a painfully good suggestion is what I'm seeing there's again there are a lot of dominoes that fall into place to make other dominoes work and I I think that's a really this is one of the I I think I think this one's a lot harder to decide on than the than the maps for me because it just it's counterintuitive to take school hours away isn't it I mean it just it in some ways that doesn't make any sense but because we've we've given so many extra hours for a students and this allows a streamlining and a massive C cost savings um let's just pray it's it's it's a temporary solution to what we have to do now I think that's important what you brought up um
224Mrs larer that when we look at a reduction obviously like you said counterintuitive but no what does it I can't read that little 17.63 days over the state required instructional hours for this age level so that was all the additional time we were providing is it ideal none of this is ideal um you know I do I do have a concern question we'd like to um obviously think about over the course of this happening at the beginning of next school year is you know um to involve I don't know some community involv somehow you know because the students will be getting home you know obviously a lot earlier the time you know 7:50 to 2:45 you know they're still getting home before your typical work day you know 4:30 5 o'clock so but that extra
22530 minutes um can be concerning there's something that we can you know come up with as a you know community of like how to you know the the kids are students are too old for you know why services after hours or something like that but I don't know if there's like some kind of community involvement that you know they'd be interested in providing something you know for students to go to you know for that extra time if parents AR you know or come up with some kind of I don't know but have some brainstorming for some families you know I don't know if they could all like somehow assist with that you know because that that would be a concern for some families I do know well I'm going to go and make a motion
226to accept this right recommendation Mr Bennington second second Dr refer any additional discussion I'll just refer back to kind of my polarity comment before that this is another example of balancing what you know needs of the students versus kind of the reality of of uh the taxpayers decision so of the community's decision it's not easy no not at all I think I mean personally I was um I continued to question this up until the work session and so I I think as we interact with community members if they still have questions I would definitely Point them toward that work session because that made it make a lot unfortunate sense to me so uh Mr juror roll call please Mr benington yes Dr rer yes Miss lmer yes Miss Roland Miller yes pass this 11.3 um
227we had agreed to this but Mr juror wisely pointed out that we need to suspend policy 0147 0147 stipulates that we are paid for any special meeting and we agreed um that we would do special meetings that were Community engagement meetings called a special meetings because more than two of us wanted to attend that we would not get paid for those and so this is um a motion to suspend board pay for Community engagement events um special I guess I really should say suspend board pay for special meetings that are Community engagement events in 2025 so moved second Mr Bennington roll call please Dr referen yes Mr Bennington yes Miss ler yes Miss Roland Miller yes 11.4 um I saw language about this but I'm just going to keep going with the language we need
228to appoint members for a board policy committee um this is distinct from uh Dr refer and I have been working on policies specifically related to reporting and misconduct but this is going to be the general Neola biannual review of of policy and Dr refer and Mr Bennington have agreed to serve on that um and so I'd like to make that motion to appoint them so moved too myself yes go for it you can do it second Miss lmer I have a choice Mr Bennington sorry oh so I'm confused yeah so Dr referen moved to appoint herself and Mr Bennington to the policy committee okay that's that's legal then was there second Miss lmer was our second okay got it and you'll make roll call now please Dr reford yes Miss larer yes Mr Bennington let
229me think about it yes Miss Rowan Miller yes cuz I'm not on it um Mr Hustler if you'll speak to 11.5 um yes so um in in Ohio there is a a rule um that if you are um a licensed teacher administrator uh that from the end of the school year up until July 10th um you have the ability to pursue and and leave your current contract for another opportunity if it is during the school year um or after July 10th um you have to have um approval of the the district to release you so if if if a district does not want to have somebody leave and break their cont contract then um you can file a report with the with with ODU to you know have them consider with the office of professional
230conduct so um we had a teacher a number of years ago who um was at Woodland Elementary I believe um who ended up uh leaving two days the night of parent teacher conference before school not parent teacher conference but the preview night before school began left for a job in another state uh across the state line um and so we that that created quite a hardship for us um finding a teacher um literally the day before school begins so we filed a complaint with the the office and then the feedback we received was well your board of education accepted it so you're okay well we have to accept the resignations to post the position to find a replacement so what we've what we've come to terms with is that we're acknowledging that this um resignation
231termination of contract after July 10th without consent of the board so that we have the ability to post the position and if we so choose we can file with the Department of Education um professional conduct to have them weigh in on whether or not they will take action on that individual's license or not so that is what is leaving us leading us to to this particular uh recommendation to go outside the consent agenda because the person is leaving in the middle of their contract can I point out too um for the record it's orc 331 19.15 but um also so we cannot force that teacher or an employee to stay correct force them to serve so you have to allow them to resign yes but it's how you word it correct so for people say
232well why are you letting her or them we we did this last year for somebody else I remember so I'd like a motion um is the word acknowledgement the action acknowledgement of Joy roots's resignation termination of contract after July 10th without consent of the Board of Education and acceptance of the sole purpose of backfilling the vacant position so moved second Mr Bennington Dr reford second o call please Mr Bennington yes Dr referen yes Miss larer yes Miss Roland Miller yes and 11.6 we've read that do we any questions about that anything you want to add no just thank you for your consideration and um you know thank you for bringing it Forward I'll I'll move on I'll move on Mr bton making the motion to approve the sick Leaf pool as noted in the agenda
233second Miss lmer second Mr durur roll call Mr Bennington yes Miss larer yes Dr reford yes Miss Roland Miller yes thank you that leads us to 12.1 can consent agenda items 13 through 17 I'll note that there are nine um board minutes just because that's a lot of minutes I'm sure youall read everyone um three from the tax budget hearing organ meeting and special meeting on the 6th of January um we then had special meeting regular meeting in January we had the retreat we had a work session and then two from the special meetings related related to the Elementary boundary presentations um any comments Mr Hustler from Personnel actions um you know this is the time of year where we're beginning to see resignations retirement so um Miss Lions who's a high school Spanish teacher
234at the high school um certainly um a very skilled educator and uh Kristen Lee who's been a guidance counselor and then working in a new capacity helping take off the 504 responsibilities of buildings um are are both um we wish them well as they look towards their retirement um with that um a familiar face uh you know name here in the district Nancy Oster who's the HPI secretary who's um retiring at the end of this year so we wish her well-deserved um congratulations and um and uh you know and again you you mentioned um the uh Michelle Chapman who is the head custodian at the high school which is an incredibly challenging an important job and um you know perisburg High School is one of the largest cities in Wood County so and you're in
235charge of making it work there so she's done a phenomenal job there uh so we're very um you know and and you know we we see that uh um it being you know huge shoes to fill but we wish her well so thank you I'll move on the consent agenda second Mr benington Dr refer roll call please Mr Bennington yes Dr refer yes Miss larer yes Miss Roland Miller yes which takes us to 18.1 board discussion new business if you want to discuss anything you're going to have to buy me dinner I'm just kidding is anything didn't talk about tonight that anyone wants to talk about should be breakfast almost and know breakfast yeah midnight snack yeah can't buy eggs though sorry um and uh there were no additional public comment people that signed up
236so if there is no objection I will adjourn the meeting no objections we are adjourned that's