CorpusRecord 142829

Perrysburg BOE Special Meeting 1-13-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Perrysburg Schools
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Wood County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,453 words · about 70 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001like to call to order this special meeting of the perisburg uh Board of Education Mr juror would you do roll call please Mr Bennington here miss lmer here miss minky here Dr reford here Miss Roland Miller here I invite everyone to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I allegiance to the flag of the unit United St States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all we welcome you to the Commodore building tonight we thank you for attending uh we care about the safety of our students staff and families and guests please note that there are exits on both the east and west side of the cafeteria uh in case of emergency an AED is located just outside the cafeteria door your and

002if in an emergency you needed the address it is 140 East Indiana Avenue next item on our agenda is to adopt the proposed agenda so moved second Mr bankton miss larmer all those in favor can I do voice Vote or do we need to do individual let's just do Voice vote all in favor please say I I I those opposed okay we have an agenda uh the only item on our agenda for today is 3.1 discussion regarding operational Levy options and timing for 2025 um there was a presentation uh now I'm not loading right okay well we'll do that later um I had it and now I don't have it interesting um does everyone else have access to the presentation because suddenly I do not okay I'll keep going there it is um so at

003our last meeting which was also a special meeting we were talking about the permanent Improvement Levy and miss m brought up the idea of having an operational levy on the May ballot and because it was a special meeting that was not an item that could be discussed at that meeting and so we've called this special meeting I've called the special meeting to discuss that and so I guess I would give the floor to miss Mankey to kind of have the chance now to speak to that idea okay um first of all I would like to say that um I think it would be prudent for us to put on both the pi Levy and the operating Levy in May um the Pi Levy announcement um should be made with an accompanying list of planned maintenance

004improvements and their Associated estimated cost to help sell this one is with the operating Levy we are willfully choosing if we willfully choose to miss the first opportunity it only reinforces to the community and risk creating the impression to our voting public that the operating Levy is not as crucial as has been conveyed two establishing the operating committee at our previous effective millage will send a strong message that we are interested in upholding our District's Financial underpinnings three this allows us to have time for much needed dialogue with our community that we have talked about that will be necessary to move forward with any future funding the last three defeats point to our new reality that we can no longer assume passage of any Levy or bond issue we place on the ballot we have

005to understand that the interest rates and rate of inflation over the past several years has significantly impacted our voting public in their financial flexibility the dis the disposable income that was there is greatly diminished or no longer available our ask has to be reasonable that is supportable by the majority of our taxpayers we need to continue to look at trimming overhead and other areas of cost savings um I know we all wish as a board to have our Dream scenario but we are dealing with a functional reality and we just need to lay it out there for our taxpayers and I know we don't enjoy and sometimes we feel like it's a waste of time to put out the minutia but I think it is very important to get our point across and with that

006um yes I do believe that we need to put an operating levy on for May and not wait until November and did you and you insinuated this I think in your comments where you did you mean the 13 and a half million that would go on or yes right thank you um others discussion if there's questions um about some of the information that was provided for background I guess do you have a so do you have a sense if I may of four year fivey year continuing what's what's the structure that you think or that you would propose I would propose four years thank you so back in um December we we had briefly discussed this during the meeting and at that point there had been um some discussion about wanting to wait until November

007and make sure we had more time to listen to the community and more time to consider you know what what cuts not only what cuts we wanted but what cuts um would be permanent versus those that may have such a detrimental effect um things like hiring freezes that will have a detrimental effect on students over time to consider those um and and so at that meeting um there wasn't any move towards putting a you know this quick turnaround to figure this out so I that's why I kind of I'd like to suggest that we talk about is we'd have about two weeks to um structure whatever Levy we'd want to put on the ballot in May are we interested in doing that and then I think to get more into the details um Miss M's

008suggested the 13.5 but we're certainly not um we don't have to do that much and we don't have to do that little I mean that's what we've lost but we've also made cuts um so I don't know I guess I wanted to there's a lot to consider if we want to go with the May ballot then we need to talk a lot tonight if we're not sure that we want to do that and we are going to look instead to November then that's why I thought it might worth talking about that issue what are the limitations what's the possibilities of running a campaign um I know we can get it on the ballot with enough conversation and and special meetings so if I may interject from a timing standpoint to get on the ballot probably

009what would have to do is I'd have to have the resolution of necessity at the regular meeting next Tuesday and then I have to get a fast turnaround and a special meeting to do a resolution to proceed so we have time but it's going to be I'm I'm going have to push it because the county order technically has two weeks now uh Matt will do it more quickly for us than that but just so just so you know wouldn't we be able to do a resolution tonight if we came to consensus uh no I don't have the I don't have the language well so I do not have yeah but I know you have the numbers so that's what I want to get clear in my head because I've heard different things so I figured

010if I'm confused which of course is easy to do but if I'm confused there's probably others that are confused so I'm going to tell you what I understand and then you can you can correct me if I'm wrong so beginning January 1 we were we lost our $1 13.5 million so the solution was to take 7.5 million from our savings to get us through the rest of this school year which takes us to June 30th right June 30th okay I'm doing pretty well all right and then from July 1st to December 31st that's where the $6 million and cuts come from Tom we put up slide 16 well he even knew the slide number okay so this hopefully Sue this illustration your point okay the orange and you see where the orange and blue connect

011that's January this year okay at that point I take it back so um that's January next year so the the orange reflects the rest of this year so and then at the next fiscal year right so that which starts in when July that's the next fiscal year we're the first half that fiscal year is without and again half of that Levy and then if you pass a new Levy it's effective January 1st and the blue line reflects a new Levy the orange continues if no new Levy and of course no additional cuts at this point obviously we'd have to because obviously we're in you know we're we're um bankrupt um so and you know remember if I did in the forecast I put 14 million in and the reason I used 14 million it wasn't

012completely random number obviously it's close to the 132 but I used 14 because that gave me a level of comfort that would get us through fiscal year 209 right well and you can and the question you can ask well well what's a half a million dollars well over that time period it's about 2 million right accumulated accumulated time frame so take take that blue line and drop it down a little bit and so we still could probably squeak through fiscal year 29 but we're squeaking right instead of ending year fiscal year 29 at 13 million we're probably down closer to 10 or 11 which makes me worry about January and February you know payroll right so 14 gave us a little bit and the other thing this is that keeps the six million in cuts

013that we're already making and Tom as we noted up here that also assumed we built in there no new teachers and staff so as we add students now I take it back no too strong a word we put a little bit into the forecast for compliance reasons we have to add intervention specialist or speech pathologist or something because of the numbers but essentially that is if our student growth continues there's no staff built into those years right so that's why the the the the slight decrease in cash balance over time is just slight right if we have new staff that accelerates that so this is kind of 14 million I think is our best case with and this best case spending to get us through 2029 so at 14 million and we're on and I'm

014on the blue line that still means basically no new teachers and staff with the Six Million that we've cut yes wow yeah that's why I chose the 14 right that was kind of I feel you know you can argue okay can we squeak by 13 and A2 probably but that's you know but again that just think about that that's not that's not just a half a million a year it's you know a half million each year so it's accumulates so I'm not suggesting which number I just want you to make sure when you think about these numbers um what a difference it make you know 13 and the and the and I other reason I pick 14 is because essentially that millage is the same as what fell off right because valuations increase we can

015put the same Mill back on so essentially level millage increase but a little bit more a little bit more Revenue okay so then all right I'm understanding that but how is asking for 14 million going to be accepted by our community which just said no to 13 and a half I'm seeing a disconnect there if we're trying to listen to the community who said no we're not giving you the 13 A2 why would we come back and ask for more and make that logical argument I think the the last Levy did ask for the 13.5 million that we had that was set to expire but then we asked as an incremental Levy to go up so it was a combination of those two things okay um as as the note here if we would have

016asked for the 13 and a half million to continue we would have gone to the voters and said we're going to ask to have the levy uh renewed and we're going to make approximately $6 Million worth of cuts if you pass this Levy and so the board back in June talked about those and weighed those options and felt you know let's let's do what we've done before with the incremental Levy and um you know clearly that was not um you know supported so so that's the so this is a different Levy than what was proposed in November so this is just set another way we don't need the incremental piece of it because we have $6 Million worth of cuts that will stay for for a while till we get to 2029 we get to

017yeah or or you know obviously growth you know we just got to understand the impact that growth will have right and the incremental Levy took into account growth this does not and you're basing these assumptions based off of how school funding is working today yeah and I'm I'm assuming essentially no additional help from the state I'm what if I said I'm assuming less help from the state given recent comments thank you comments as early as last week yeah yeah it'll be a challenge to predict where we'll land um in the last two ban budgets I think there was a commitment to continue with the uh Fair school funding and continuing to implement it so when we talk about that what we're what we're talking about is the state um fully phasing it in they've done

018it you know 33% at a time with each banian budget so we're 66% of the way there so this and when the state goes to fully fund it um they're also raising their inputs so it's based in part on the state average teacher salary the state average principal salary all that kind of data gets updated because right now they're operating on data and funding that was two years old so we get updated as you know every single year with property taxes so the state is going to be asked to fully fund the the incremental or I'm sorry fully fund the fair school funding plan which benefits perisburg because we're a growing district and we'll get full funding for all the students that are in the district um instead of partial funding that we received now

019and the state updating its inputs brings in additional revenue from the state so the conversation about this is that well if the state doesn't update their inputs every school district in Ohio is getting their inputs updated every year because valuations are going up in every community and local residents are being asked to pay more when the state is being asked to pay less so um the new um speaker uh speaker Huffman who just took over um the day after their first session this is a quote from him saying that yeah we're not you know we're not going to um you know we're not going to be able to do that so it has created some um it has created some backlash uh this was a follow-up article uh where there's some uh members of the

020GOP which is um president Huffman's or I'm sorry uh speaker Huffman's uh party are saying we don't agree with that um so um so this is something that we're beginning to see um you know the future's a little bit more unclear than it was before based on this new input so so when sorry Mr house I me thank you for that when when does that Clarity come in that clarity come in before March June 30th thank you June 30th yeah I mean I I think I mean correct me if I'm wrong Tom I expect this right to the 12 hour you know midnight on 12:30 you know by by law they have to have an approved budget and I think it's you know it's going to be that kind of battle and just to just

021to re reiterate where where our focus our forecast is on this within the current law the floor is funding at 2020 levels they can fully implement the fair school funding plan but if they don't increase the base cost as Mr Hustler indicated essentially we get wealthier but our costs are in theory the same so we're actually our dollars per student is going to go from $1,600 a student to $800 right and and maybe I can I've I've done a white paper on that calculation I can present to the board at some point in time but our funding the such is going to stay flat because we'll instead of being if you will kind of capped where we are today we'll be be on the guarantee because our our funding will not fall below 2020 levels

022right so our local funding is at 21 levels now and our state funding be 2020 levels and put that in perspective I anticipate this year our total State um this is foundation not does not include State share of local taxes it be about 12 12.7 million in 2029 that being 12.5 million so $200,000 difference that's assuming there's no cut only that they kind of maintain status quo if you will right so if they don't change the 2020 law that's kind of where where we are if that makes sense and that was part of the fiveyear forecast projection so and you presented all of the base cost information so we do have that yeah again I've done an analysis that I'm I'm geared up to share once uh we get into hearings on this to show

023how you know if you don't update fully funding implenting the fair school funding plan important what's more important is increasing the base cost that's a bigger factor for us because again as Mr hosler pointed out we're getting wealthier on paper okay I'm not going to and because our incomes are going up our property values are going up yet they're saying the cost to educate a student is the same as it was two three four years ago which we know is not correct so the the layer of uncertainty there is certainly that um we would need to either make more Cuts if the state doesn't fulfill its promises I'm going to put that one out there um that we would either have to make more Cuts or that as the state has kind of suggested um

024that we would have to go to the local taxpayer for more money at that point so that I that's an uncertainty that um makes me concerned it um and I don't know Miss mcky what your intent was but my concern is is that we could go in May and ask for 13.5 million find out that the state has changed its funding for us and we're going to be in a situation where we have to go back again in November and I don't know if the intent was to ask for a second Levy then um once we're able to listen more learn more um kind of plan out further uh is is the intent that in November we would go back with another Levy at that point I would say if the discussions with the public

025heads in that direction then yes there are conversations that we need to have with the public are going to be telling of what we do in for November and also I mean really along with that what Randy has said what happens by June 30th that's going to tell us what we need to do too I mean this is just this is the reality of being a board member you have mult multiple funding areas that you're jockeying and where it's coming from and and what's being said by the government and by your public um I iess said it's just it's reality of how you take care of things financially in light of the I was so hoping that Huffman wouldn't be speaker um but in light of his comments um and ambiguity that he's thrusting all

026public schools to be in until the we hours of June 30th does it make sense to wait and not put an operational on now in the spring and wait until the fall so that we know what we are definitely working or not working with I mean if we Sorry if we don't if they do that horribleness uh of not updating the base costs which that seems so ludicrous to me that they would do something like that but not Beyond expectation because they still haven't figured out what the deral case means so if they're going to penalize Public Schools even further and not increase That Base cost like they should then that might change what we need to function with and we won't know that until June 30th right Randy I think one of the questions

027though you have to ask yourself is are we willing to risk that if we can get in May back to 13.5 or 14 I I mean personally I would feel better about where we're going if we wait until November and put on an amount that our public is not willing to say yes to then there's further Cuts I don't want to go there I think one and I'm going to go back to something that Miss larer said I I think one of the things that concerns me right now is that um when we say that the public didn't support the levy why was that I think that there's a lot of answers to that and I'm not sure I know fully the answers to that so I I'm not convinced yet that if we put

02813 A5 million on the levy that um that that's going to pass I I don't I don't know yet um and and that's so I I um whether it's 13 and a half whether it's 14 my concern is as we go and we ask again without having done the community engagement pieces Without Really hearing without having a a long range plan you know one of the things we keep hearing is that we need to have a plan this feels to me like half a plan um and and I'm not I'm concerned whether or not the voters will support it and then if we go back in November again with the same thing then it could cause more trouble so that's I I have actually in my head been playing around with the question of is

029it time to split this Levy in two um do we go with a smaller amount in May something like this I'm going to say N9 and a half million which would allow us to not have to make additional Cuts going forward um it would not help us long range but it would get us through and then in November once we have a better picture and can truly do a plan put a second Levy My Hope Is that a smaller Levy would pass um and then if we set those at different years we wouldn't be asking for 177% of our budget again in the future um I think that that's um to have two smaller levies is what I I've been playing around in my mind for the last you know however you know 48 hours

030that we've been thinking about this so I I am concerned that we don't know if the 13 and a half or 14 million will pass and what trust with the community will we lose even further by putting this on the ballot is there any validity to asking for a different kind of Lobby instead of asking for property tax um this go around with is there any benefit to asking for an income tax there's a different collection rate on between the two right well okay first of all I think your timing is going to be tough on an income tax for May second of all we already have a half% um traditional income tax to get the equivalent of $ 135 million that's 3/4 per and you could obviously have an income tax and the property

031tax again I don't know what we have the time to get the Department of taxations numbers to do an income income tax but I don't know you know maybe it can be done but that just put in perspective so you're looking at 3/4 of a percent the equivalent of a135 million that's the last number so that may have changed a little bit an income tax can only be in quarter percent um increments is that right quarter percent um they figur it out an eth but you can only ask in a quarter so and then you know typically communities like ours it's very unusual to have an income tax because the the high relatively High income normally income tax is more favorable in communities of high land value low income Farm Farmland essentially but that's fine

032we have an income tax or I'm I'm I'm happy that we have it but the other half part of it is the income taxes are getting passed today are are earned income taxes which are essentially taxes on paychecks versus a traditional tax which pay taxes your whole 10 you know your whole 1040 tax return now for us to convert that half of percent to earned income you're talking about again going from a half percent to 3/4 percent or so so again those are big lifts I mean there's certain things the board can consider um but it it it we need to we have to do a lot of work and if we recall I think last spring I did I did a chart for it's one of those things there income tax versus property tax

033in this community it's about you know half the people are going to win on either side of that right if you're relatively High income low property value you want property tax right if you're relatively you know low lower income but High property you want the income tax depending on are you you know where your wealth is tied up so it's not an easy it's not an easy but if you're at the media in this in perisburg that is if you're at 135 to 140,000 household income and 325 to 350,000 home value anything there and above you want property tax okay and I I do think comp we've heard from people in the community about income tax but I don't personally I think that's one of those things that I wanted to take to to the

034community um yeah because they aren't they weren't very successful in the last round of Elections if you look at the levies across the state so it's a hard that's a tough yeah the reason why I asked is when you look at where it where our levies have strongly failed has been in our rural areas and I think it's it's horrible what this country does to our farmers and how they are taxed to death and all of that it that just really needs to get fixed there's no excuse for it um and I just wondered if maybe that would help or income tax though in in our farming country income taxes are generally favorable okay because as a farm a business you know everything you you do on that farm essentially is a write-off so generally

035as reportable income or less I'm not I'm generalizing here right right right that's why there it's a benefit in in those where you have lots of land value and right now land values in Ohio are very very high high and I talked to some some farmers and what they're able to lease and sell land for is incredible now their wealth is tied up in that land right so it's not necessarily in cash so it's it's a it's an important question to discuss but if that's the route the board wants to go I think the the Susan's point is that it's going to take a lot of discussion to get us there maybe that would be a fall thing then rather than trying to figure it out in this rush and you were talking about two

036different ones maybe that would be something to look at more closely in the fall as an option and then more something more traditional that we could do of a smaller nature because I like your idea of splitting it into two and that gives kind of it's kind of like a compromise between what lur is asking for that we do something now at with because we know some of what we need now and that like you're suggesting 9 million so the 9 million would definitely help cover some of our future costs for the rest of this calendar year um and then to buy and then by the Fall we'll have plenty of time to see what the state is going to do you're awfully quiet Tom she's waiting to jump in I was I'm listening I'm

037listening slide 13 did so my my question when you talk about Randy you said three4 for income tax three qu of percent last time I had that's the last time I had a calculat about 3/4 of additional to what we already have is what a half is it a half or a quarter it's a half so on top of the half that we already have so this um from the forecast and if you look at 6.01 is kind in the red the ugly red numbers right that's the that's the the year-over year um in this case deficit right so I think we'll end up this year a little bit better than a negative3 million but and but next year even with the $6 million in reductions we're looking at 9 million and we end the

038year cash balance of 13 which makes me nervous but that's doable and then the next year it's almost 13 million so that's the number I'm looking at when you talk about breaking the levy up into smaller pieces certainly a strategy just recognize though you could be in you know needing new funds in 2027 right depending on where where you are and obviously we can run any scenario you you want to play with there but that's that kind of gives you the in my scenario we would have the smaller well an amount on the May and then really have a good wellth thought out plan for the November Levy they would both be this year see and I felt like so and think about what's going to what happen remember because of the calendar year versus

039fiscal year breakdown whatever we pass in 2025 we'll get half of it next school year so we don't we get full collection the following school year so so we end up if we whatever we pass we'd get a little bit you know half here and so it's that it's that next year which ends up being the concern the 2027 year is the year of concern and obviously what we have up there for 28 and 29 can't happen because there we can't run a negative cash balance that's not that's not legal so so I agree with boy it would be great to pass something in May and bring some Financial stability to the district as soon as possible there no doubt that that makes this job a hell of a lot easier like you said this

040job isn't going to be easy you know regardless it's more important to me to get the whatever we do to make sure that that this ask is Right rather than it's quick just so that things get easier there's six Million worth of cuts that we know we have to do this year that the administration needs to work on that we need to approve we know that there's another I might get the number a little bit wrong here n and a half 10$ n million were the cuts that we got to start hearing about what that looks like too it's time and attention on that work there's a opsy contract that needs to be renegotiated this year time and attention on that there's the dayto day you know still kids are in buildings teachers are still

041teaching um there's a pi Levy that we it felt like there was alignment you know we're moving forward with a a resolution of necessity that we're going to need to approve and do that where I start to get concerned as what I'm hearing about is the potential for two to three levies in 2025 and when M I think it was I forget how you worded it I liked it it was you know are we suggesting that we wait and see what the fair fund what the state funding does before we make a decision and my my reaction to that when you said that was well it depends on how easy you think levies are to do it depends on how easy you think campaigns are and there's strategy that we're talking about there's tactics how

042much should it be what type of Levy campaign or what type of Levy should it be but then there's also the logistics of this and when I refer to Logistics it is the what is the campaign committee's ability what how well are are we we the district the C you know there's this we're not The Campaign Committee but what does one two or three campaigns look like in 2025 what's the funding what's the ground game what's the engagement there what's the messaging with everything that has to be done and campaigns they're not easy to do they're not easy to do so that's asking of a lot there so again I just I encourage as board as we think about this and your music was distracting me a little bit I'm so sorry I can't even

043find my phone which is usually pretty unusual it's I'm sitting on it that's why it was so quiet and I also think about what are going be the changes in this community that we're going to experience here over the next 10 11 months we've got people out there that still don't believe that these cuts are real that we're actually going to be doing $6 Million worth of cuts still hearing about that and this isn't know let's bring the pain by any means this is just let's we got a reality we have to deal with here but at the same time we've got another side of the community that's saying well you're not doing enough or there's still more that you can do so when you start to play those two sides it's like one side

044isn't going to necessarily support a levy until we really show the cuts until that you know until we make a level effort to make Cuts because that was my takeaway from the last three elections was it's time to cut and that's what's happening so are we in a position where you bring some Some Cuts and bring some stability but then at the same time come out November you know one reason to do this sooner is some of these folks that that are big on school districts and when as they start to see us talking about redistricting and talking about shorter days and less opportunities for their children we're going to lose some of that support too so there's just a lot that has to come into this decision that really makes me nervous about doing

045something fast as much as I'd like to and I I'm on The Campaign Committee if this if this board says let's do something here in May and let's go then we'll go but I think we only get one shot at this I really do I really think if some if if we go in May Pi Levy doesn't pass Andor some form whatever those amounts off of an operating Levy doesn't pass I don't know what the point of doing anything in November is we will but it gets incrementally even harder then and we've been talking about Community engagement we''ve been talking about getting out in front of all kinds of people to hear what this legitimate ask needs to be that would pass and I think we need to do that work plus you've got three

046board seats up for election this fall too so that's going to add time attention yeah that's going to add a lot of issues for lack I can't think of the word that I want to use but adds a lot of issues to it as well um gosh I'm I'm really in a quandry because I can see the advantage of taking it and making it into two smaller ones um I think there's a lot of validity to taking a breath and getting the community engagement group going and really finding out what if anything the community will support because we haven't put anything on the ballot these last three that was excessive it was what we needed to really continue the excellent work that perisburg does and I fully stand behind those especially the one in the

047spring last year which I thought was one of the most brilliant lovees an ass that I'd ever seen and that actually lost more than the one in the fall and we didn't lose by that much um this last one so I mean that's the poana attitude towards it so I I agree with you Eric on that is that I'm not really solid on what does the community want us to do at this point where do they want us to go I mean we as a board see in our committees the work that y all do and what money is needed to continue that work and get the results the the superior Superior results that we get in our district for what we use and what we have um and the community is saying no so

048what is there yes that I don't know that either I don't know that either really I think one thing I wanted to point out um you know we're we're using May and November um we're we're talking about the you know the the two previous levies and then the most recent so I think it's important that not all um levies are the same so operational levies are are viewed differently than permanent Improvement levies and bond issues so you know our runup is you know two failed Bond issues and an operational Levy so those are all those are different and they're asking for different things I think we have to be careful in not to recognize that a May election is a very different election than November it pulls out a different group of the community to

049vote and and that can have um an impact on whatever the message the community may be sending when you have 5,000 people coming up to vote versus 18,000 so I think that's important to keep in mind that this may is a primary um a gubernatorial um primary perhaps depending on how things shake out so it is a partisan primary locally um you know will there be enough candidates to run to trigger a primary for local candidates so so this may could be a very low turnout um election and and you know and so when we talk about low turnout you know we're we're looking at when when and we we've not had u a lot of experience going off cycle we call it during primaries um so uh this past March was the first time

050that we had done that since 2007 but in in uh March there were a total of 8,000 voters and um and that was a presidential um primary so that in primary speak that is the high Watermark of what we can expect showing up to the poll so we don't have I didn't pull the data from the last primaries um that weren't presidential how many voters but it it will be less than than that number um and so I think that that is something to you know to to reflect on as you think about this as well part thank you that that's great points because I was I thought about that earlier this this could look like I get out the vote Campaign which feels expensive feels like a lot of work that doesn't stop us

051unless you're not funded for it but what you also triggered there was that we just did our last Levy in a presidential campaign right the high water mark for turnout there was turnout my understanding is that the turnout was exactly what we had expected it to be probably exactly what we' hoped to be and we still lost which again points to the import of the ask for me getting the ask right so am I hearing you Eric that you would rather wait for the fall and ask once ra oh look at that smile well yeah yeah the the levy that I want is the one that'll pass and I don't know that I'll be ready to say that we've got the one that'll pass by in two weeks that's what I'm saying I would love

052I would love to get something in May we'd love to be able to bring again like I said stability to the community we could start having better discussions about what these cuts are going to look like we can have better discussions with boosters organizations that are so graciously offering their help we can have those conversations but if it fails those conversations look a lot different for the rest of this calendar year and going forward so I'm not here to make a I'm not here to make a decision tonight I'm here to have a I'm thinking but that's what I'm thinking you know we've talked about this so many times that we're between a rock and hard place no matter what we do either way you know I'm concerned obviously about the possibility of the large

053Cuts proposed or which will more than likely happen uh to Ohio's public school funding I mean he speaker Huffman wasted no time putting that out there um we are pretty much Counting not just we but those affected by Fair funding are counting on that to be followed through as promised um I don't see that happening that's a huge concern um I think we'll know more like you said at the last hour in June my concerns again are too many lovees at too many times too many asks I mean we heard that all the time you ask for too much you don't have a plan well we have a plan States's not helping us with it um you know I think people are starting to understand how school public schools are fun and how this affects

054um our students you know that we were not a guaranteed District you know that are and it's right here you know they they talk on they're going to have to rely more on the community to to fund public schools which slide are you looking at this is it was just that um article from that was in the news it's a 16 it's I mean how many articles are in there or how many you know that hit the news immediately you know you know we can go back to 1991 we talk about all the time all the time about how you know the way Ohio funds schools is UN unconstitutional we started to get there partially with the fair funding and it's going to be yanked away not even at current levels I think it's important

055that we do follow through with what we talked about having conversations with the community um unfortunately the election calendar doesn't help us at all and I I don't feel I don't feel we're ready to put something on a May on top of a permanent Improvement you know because we would have that plus this plus need something else in November and I just think that's too much um as much as it's needed I just don't think the community is ready for that and I just don't want to be rushed and I don't want to feel like we're just putting something out there to get something out there and to get it wrong I mean that's those are my personal opinions coming from your 30 years in education living in the district for 21 seeing the writing

056on the wall you know from the state and you know they don't have public school in there they just don't have what they they don't want Public School funded the way it should be and just make the gaps bigger between the halves and the Have Nots and I'm just not ready to rush something in preparation for tonight I looked back at my notes from our meeting right after um that we had after election day in November and it was we need to we need to listen we need to hear what's going on we need to take our time trying to figure out what our next steps are um I think that language Mr bangton that you raised the right ask um I am not convinced that 13 and a half or 14 is the right

057ask I'm not I don't know what the right ask is yet and um you know I I was looking at that we have not placed a levy on the ballot during a primary that passed since 2000 I realized there haven't been a lot of them but I think we also had a couple failures there that led us to maybe believe that wasn't a good idea um and it is a limited turnout we we've always said we want as many people to be able to have a voice in this as possible so I'll I'll be honest I you know I started playing around with this too Levy thing in case there was um a sense that we wanted to put something I'm not I'm not hearing that from a majority of us yet um where I

058started was we need to get it right um we need to listen we need to look at what the reductions were what the long-term effect of those are going to be what we're going to need in the future what the state is doing and that's not going to come together in the next two weeks for me okay I hadn't really caught that data um that you said on here I'm looking at slide 29 right now and you're right looking at the May elections that's that's not a a favorite election for us and we usually don't do those May elections I mean that's something that you've stressed many times Tom that not to do May elections and and I kind of I definitely agree with Lori that that would be the potential of three asks in

059one year when we know we've heard that people get tired of us asking and so we think it's a good idea to ask three times um that seems a little toned deaf as well um but then again I I look back at what we've done over this past year and I thought all of these were very welld designed very thoughtful and asking for what the district needed for its rapid growth with with your two guidance so um I I really am kind of reeling at this point um not really understanding what the community wants I mean of course everybody wants lower taxes and they want not to have to be be spending so much money for schools that's not always the individual districts prerogative to not ask for money because the state doesn't fund the

060schools correctly so that's not always on us but can there be an agreement between the community and the school districts that are suffering like we are to understand that it takes money to run our schools and to do them well the whole argument that perisburg doesn't have to be as excellent or to be less excellent that just doesn't compute to me I mean these are our kids we need to give them everything that we possibly can every opportunity that we possibly can to excel it's a rough world out there so to keep taking opportunities away from them that doesn't that doesn't make any sense to me um so I think that that all all that rolls back to say is that at this particular moment I am confused what the community wants us to do

061I mean we we've certainly shown the numbers courtesy of Randy explanations c um to what it takes to do and to be perisburg and be a yellow jacket um and now you throw in the the monkey in the wrench with speaker Hoffman I say Hoffman all the time and it's Huffman uh speaker Huffman um and that's really going to send districts reeling it's not just us I hope people understand that this isn't just us it's TPS it's it's ATO down the street it's Bowling Green it's Washington local Anthony Wayne svia Tangi Columbus City yeah slide eight you had asked but just that last to not fully fund the plan could cause the schools to rely heavily on property taxes which will then lead to more levies which will then be shut down due to already

062having high enough property taxes in short Huffman proposed cutting at least 650 million let me repeat that 650 million in public education spending in this year's General assembly's budget that was from January 11th to 2025 Ohio Capital Journal public education public education it'll get well they'll turn around and give a billion of our taxes to the voucher program private school funding correct but I declare 650 million in public education spending which which is what they are constitutionally required to do to do I think miss beny you were trying to hop in um yes what we have done in the past is not working and I know we are looking at we have to move for forward no matter what Ohio decides so let's not look at what we've done before because like I said it's

063not working we we need to break it down we need to do small steps I mean yes we have examples here in the past it's mainly Bond issues that didn't pass um the one operating Levy that didn't pass when you look at it when we asked for more it did pass um us passing up any time I would rather hear our public say no to what I proposed versus is not putting anything out there because if we wait for the legislator to make legislative body bodies I should say to make up their mind and we have to put a higher amount on we think to function we are still passing up a base amount that would be functional versus cutting later on to something that is not functional but my question to you is that

064we asked for the 13 and a half yes it was a an incremental it was an incremental and that's what the public I mean we had people stand up here and say that we also had people stand up here and say that nine years eight years was was too much and we've also had people come and excoriate us one person at a time because people want us to have a plan so we offer a plan and and that got shot down that's why I'm saying I understand the confusion here because we're getting mixed messages we give them a plan we give them a long range plan we show them what the district needs we show them what the state is not doing that it's falling on us to support but they keep voting it down

065regardless of what kind of Levy it is so that's why I'm saying I don't really understand where the disconnect is what do what do they want us to do um because I think we've had three excellent options put out there that shows planning that shows long range planning that shows hey if we do this we'll have less ass we won't be on the ballot three times in one year and that got turned down I mean there's lots of things that we did in response to what we were being told and that got shot down so where Where Do We Go From Here securely and asking can we actually as tough as it was to run a campaign uh the last one underfunded overburdened for the people who are trying to support it can we do

066that with two levies at the same time that sounds like a major ask of the people who work on The Campaign Committee and Eric you would be able to speak to that better I I've not been on the board when we've had two levies at the same time so I don't really I don't even know what that looks like has that ever happened Tom when you had two levies on at the same time um I I think uh I think you'd have to go back to to um let me see I think I have a slide that has that of course you do last time perisburg had two issues on the same ballot was June 3rd 1980 1980 oh my gosh they both passed uh it was operating in pi and that's the history going

067back from you can see the 70s and 8 you know 70 to 1980 there that stretch represents that so I mean and one thing I have on my list to do is is to to reach out to whomever on The Campaign Committee because I'm I'm concerned about our level our the ability to campaign just for the pi Levy which should be Prett straightforward do we still have a committee the great work that that committee has done I don't know the answer to that and that's you know that's outside of this room right these are two separate things but um so yeah I don't even know who the who the names are right now I think one of the things that I'm concerned about in going back right away um you know we've made the $6

068million in reduction uh the the big cry was that we needed to reduce and we've done that now I mean we again put out what we needed in order to maintain exactly what we were doing um and we heard that it was too much and that we needed to cut we've cut I I've heard rightfully so from the parents whose children as students are being directly affected by those reductions but I haven't heard um is was that enough is that was that enough for the Cry of reductions that we needed or are we going to put another are we going to put the 13 and a half out there and they're going to say no no no you still haven't reduced enough I I don't know there's the other n and a half yeah or

069where's the other three million that we needed I I don't know that was a that that's my concern is that we've not had that chance to have that dialogue in the community yet heard so I'd want to believe that we 13 and a half what everyone was paying before would be would pass but we also heard that people I mean you've talked about this a lot miss beny that people have felt that they with inflation that without um in you know equal increases necessarily in some cases and salary that people are feeling really strapped um we were asking for 13.5 million and they said they were strapped I it do we do we need to cut more than the 6 million we've done I don't know that yet and we won't know that until we

070get out into the community more so again I I'd like to believe that 13 and a half would pass but I have no reason to believe that right now you what you say there really resonates with me because we've been for the most part focused on the top side of the um uh the top side the revenue side of this equation not the bottom side you're right I am still hearing Eric there's still opportunities to cut in this District I disagree with that I to me that's a value statement but you know what do you value in education but yeah I'm still hearing that there's still some some meat on the bone to be taken so well I hear you it's a good point Eric you mentioned a couple of times $9 million to do

071the other I think you said the other $9 million is there a a $9 million cut I've missed somewhere that N9 and a half n and a half is that the number that we're kind of because it would be seven and a half of the remaining 13 and A2 plus the 2 million incremental that we at least that's where at least it depends on where where you want the cash balance like I said in we're looking at um in 2027 $13 million deficit just to maintain a cash balance of around 60 days means you got to cut 13 million right right so it's 9 and a half buys you time or eight or 10 but in 2026 we would have received 15.5 million not 13 and half million that's that's what we projected meing with

072the forecast grow andet and and and and recognize that cost are not stagnant you don't cut you're not cutting six million off what we're spending today you're cutting six million off what projected to spend next year right because you know our natural gas um electricity salaries Insurance regardless we don't have to do anything and they're going up I mean it's it's the same thing everyone else experiences right so so when you're so it's a moving Target that's what you got to recognize that you don't cut six million and 6 million flat because you still have growth okay here's a tough question that I think we're going to see from people if we wait past past May to put something on they're going to look at all of us as a board and say you've known

073since November 6th that we had a cut and since that date we've had the opportunity to have conversations and we have not what is going to be our answer to that because we're now at January 13th and we still do not have anything formed for having any conversations with our community well I think my answer to that is that we talked about the importance in our December meeting of community engagement a committee that I appointed you to so how's that going oh since we haven't had a meeting yet well tomorrow so tomorrow morning we'll have our um the first board standing Community engagement meeting um and I I think I I've been functioning because until a week ago we weren't looking at a we we had I thought we had agreed that we weren't looking

074at the May ballot for an operating Levy so while there certainly has been an importance to it there has been a lot of the reduction work that was going on um I would love to be out there right now but it's it's not yet but I that was part of the reason is that while it was important to do it also didn't seem as timely as it did until the last week well I'll probably also add that on if we if it passed on what's what what's the date in May May 6th it's not like the money comes in on May 7th and everything magically comes back still having to reduce this is still a you know a January one the cash would start coming in so again there's time to figure out what the

075right ask is and what the logistics of The Campaign Committee is that so if weit my answer so if we waited until November and it passed in November would that money start coming in in that January so either May or Jan May or January May or financially it's the same however however the point is I think Miss makings M that if you pass it in May you you reduce that anxiety of what's next I would love to again I would love to reduce that that anxiety that would be great and and you have the opportunity then to really like the the boosters and others who want to help it's hard to have them help when we don't know what the nut is right that's that's the benefit of of May I think to the point

076now of course you you got to pass it we are equally exposed to the criticis the criticism if it fails in May why did you not listen to us and put an unthoughtful ask on the ballot again we don't trust you forget about November again we're between a rock and a hard place um going back to what Susan Roland Miller said uh it was my understanding too that we were working on reductions and the only ask we were going to have in May was for p because we I thought as a board we had talked about that we weren't ready to ask for anything else in May because we weren't sure exactly what was going on and we knew that we couldn't put two on a pi and an operating you know it's been what

07710 weeks and three of those weeks were holidays um while it seems a long time ago it's been only 10 weeks um again you know we have I have people telling me all the time what are you going to do I said well what what are your thoughts you know you can't put something on in May and a pi and something again in November you know there's I think people are starting to understand and listen um and go back that we talk about all this at the meetings um you know the community engagement that was a big discussion and I'm glad to hear that we're starting tomorrow um but you know things things can't happen quickly uh it's as quick as it's in 10 weeks I think a lot has happened and we've been focused

078on how to get through and make reductions to you know to at least sacrifice some type of learning outcomes and learning experience that our kids have um that'll look the same next year and I just I I don't see it I don't I don't see that we're going to be able to pass a pi and an operating in May and then come back and without not knowing what happens until June another it could be a huge ask again in November well you just passed for 9 million now you want this why didn't you know that back then you're damned if you're do and you're damned if you don't and I just I just feel that in looking at the numbers that we're not we can't put two on in May what's more important right now

079and what do we what's our best bet to do what we need to do in M we've always been talking about the pi and for me the most important thing we can do right now is take our time to listen to the community to understand um where is our shared understanding about what is what is going to be the perisburg educational experience it's not going to be the same and that's that's okay I mean it you know we'll kids roll with stuff um you know I'm concerned about the staff and the teachers because um a lot of the cuts haven't aren't going to directly affect students but they are going to directly affect the um workload of our staff so there's a lot of things to consider and different people to listen to and that

080okay so it seems like what everybody's saying not everybody it seems like what could be said is out of an abundance of caution and an effort to truly hear what the community wants us to present to our Administration and the rest of the community is to get that data first before we proceed with an operating Levy the permanent Improvement Levy presents its own questions as to do we renew do we renew plus do we renew and add a plus to you know I mean even the operating Levy is no I'm sorry no even the permanent Improvement Levy is still throwing yeah throwing enough monkeys into the wrench or wrenches into the monkeys or however you want to say that that is enough to make your head spin as because a million and a half to

081take care of our buildings right every year I mean it sounds like a lot of money but when you got a boiler that goes out and there goes 500 Grand or more stick to the operating Levy and not the pi L right well no I mean just the fact that we don't have that settled in our minds yet and then to throw in the operating Levy to because we don't really know where that what the community is asking us to do and that's that's a lot of questions on our behalf and responsibility that I don't think we have the data for to responsibly throw something out even though may sound so I wish they wouldn't make us do this so far ahead I that's really hard I mean May seems like a lifetime away right

082now gosh we're talking graduation but how we've got we were forced by the Electoral Cal calendar to make this decision now which is at least a month to a month and a half sooner than what I think we're comfortable in having to do right I would like to my last comment for the night is to you know thank you Miss Roland Miller and Miss Mankey for calling this meeting to give this board at least a chance to talk about this um didn't feel right either just you know we talked about it in December not let it you know kind of letting it go unspoken undiscussed uh right before the deadline okay so Randy where what is what are we looking at here do we have time to Noodle on this for the we'd have to

083make a decision about the operating Levy point we would need something on the Monday agenda Monday I mean Tuesday it's going to be Tuesday it's going to be tight I mean you don't have again the steps are resolution of necessity and I can turn that around in a day with our attorneys to get the language that's you know kind of boiler plate then it goes to the county auditor and and they're quick and they provide the bot the millage and then we put the ballot language together to come back to the board all right that has to happen and then on February 5th by February 5th I'm you know handling hand delivering it to the Board of Elections so you know that's that's the window I mean things can happen pretty quickly um and I

084have heard of cases and I and I frankly I've talked to Matt about this in the past there there's always the opportunity he' come up for a board meeting you pass a resolution of necessity then we take a break and him and I go off in the corner and do the calculation on resolution proceed but I'm not saying that I can't speak for him he may not be comfortable in the circumstance doing something like that so it could be turned around quickly but you only have two we got two two weeks right a little over two weeks if my Math's correct and so the question I'm going to you know try to be the the old guy in the room here is what kind of day are you going to have in a week or

085two that you don't have today to put that together all right that's the you know it's one of those patent principle General patents principles is that you don't make a decision till you have to but when you have to you go with the data you have and you do it and um so the question I have I'm concerned financially you know the anxiety of not having something on May is there but whatever we do it's got to pass well it's May or November so and and you are paid the big dollars to make that decision Tom and I can advise you but I you know I can't I can put the numbers up there and do what I you know what I believe is right from a financial standpoint point but um I don't represent

086the values of this community like you do and I think that's it's question it's a values question at this point looking at the cuts can we make more Cuts yeah but what don't you want right because every cut has a consequence that most people don't recognize right right I mean and it's got a domino effect I had a conversation with a Community member today about that and they go why don't you cut this okay we could do that here's the consequences oh I didn't know that cuz you know every job every position has a purpose there's in in the district and um I think everyone has to recognize that what are what what do we value so when we make a resolution of necessity is that do we also have to have the amount with

087it so that they can figure out that's what I thought the resolution the resolution of necessity we put it yeah you got to put the amount and the term in it and then essentially then then we the county auditor calculates the millage that's that's the that's that's the key there as of right now I don't hear enough support for the idea of putting this on the agenda on Monday but we also have time um if you know as you said we don't have to make we we would have to make a decision uh before Monday to put this on the agenda right now I'm hearing that the majority of us though want to wait until November and we've had a chance to really create a good plan after listening to the community um but that

088can change as well but as of right now I I don't hear enough support to put it on the agenda we can put it on the agenda I'm a definite maybe I mean I got a lot of information tonight about it too I I'd like to kind of you know do one of those balancing acts the the good news the bad news the the Y and nays you know how what does that the pros and cons that's the word I was looking for to actually see and maybe talk to some of y'all over over the weekend or well I'm not going to be very available this weekend but um to just kind of know I mean I I I I really do I see some good points both both directions like Laura and Randy are

089saying the anxiety of of the not knowing and but is that worth the risk of antagonizing the community again because we're throwing something out there um I I honestly I'm kind of spinning on this I really am I'm kind of spinning on it because I really thought that we had three really good propositions that we that we propos to community thoughtful well done proposals that that tanked and I'm like I say especially this spring one really surprised me um so I need to I don't want to make that same mistake a fourth time and that's what causes me pause about all of it I'm not spinning as much as you are on it probably but if um and I don't know why I'm kind of writing this for you you called the meeting but you

090know Randy you're you're a wise man if you had a you may in your back pocket want to have a resolution of necessity for 13 A5 million for four years I'm not saying it goes on the agenda but hearing this larer talk talk we can put it on the agenda yeah it can be a motion we can because tonight we do kill it tonight I mean if we don't give Randy and Tom some direction well do we want to the but that's the question do we do the 13 and a half million do we break it down into smaller bites of the elephant like Susan was suggesting if if you're if that's where you at then we don't do it and I would agree with you there too I'm looking for a path forward here

091and I think what you just you know you were open-minded enough to want to do something but you're now still like what is that right amount that struggle I get it so to me that takes me back to this is a November discussion and and fundamentally if you go less than 13 and a half I mean you're talking about if you do another ask whatever the case is you got to prepared for additional Cuts so the question is that $6 million what the district's going to look like after those reductions are you comfortable you know are we comfortable with what the other consequence would be right so I just I want just think about both cases is that if if I if$ 13.5 million were a slam dunk there'd be no it's a no-brainer and

092but and I don't know that it is but it would be nice and then that would give us at least a couple you know four years of to chew on it and be able to maintain where we are and if the values of the community are such that they don't like you know the reductions in um back um gifted education program and those kind of things then you got then you go back that you got that additional ask down the road so so I'm looking at your cool graph again um so if we were to put think about the 13 A5 million in in May which would mean a slightly Lower Blue Line than what it's what's on there for four years we keep the six million in cuts that we already have instituted so

093it's really not helping restore anything that we've already lost no new teachers other than those that are mandated that gives you some it gives you some planning and some some room to work so that we're not looking at the Orange Line because currently we're on the tra trajectory of the orange line right right now I would say that the patient is on the table and still bleeding okay um given that you know we're we're we're we're not on the blue trajectory here but we're still on the orange because nothing has passed yet um so so you know passing something this next year you know would sustain the patient and and that's kind of the the 13 half million or 14 million does that um and and it keeps us above or at or just below

094that line depending on the variables of of um you know the amount that the board would seek and then all the other variables that go into State funding and those kinds of things which we won't know um so I think you know we can put together some pros and cons based on this conversation and have that be part of the presentation on on Monday you know I'm sorry Tuesday thanks um in terms of you know what we heard today and and revisit the conversation if folks wanted to do that um I guess my question is if we were to discuss this again on Tuesday what additional information is is there any additional information we actually would well well for example um I would like if you are really interested the problem is the the the

095options are infinite right you got 13 and half and 14 million that's kind of a baseline you know stabilizes the patient gives us some time to to fix the underlying disease use that metaphor sorry about that so maybe it's seeing that line as a 13 and a half million and not the I can fix that the other thing is but let's say you want a $9 million Levy I'm just I could I could run the forecast numbers with that and you can I could do the same we can do the same type of projection and just to be clear my assumption of the 9 and A5 million is that that's a starting spot and then an additional Levy would go on in November of the right amount well again that's the whole thing only I'm

096not suggesting 9 A5 million without additional funding N9 and a half and then four later or eight and five whatever those all those things are options right so I think we need some direction to give you what you want to see at least in terms of data not what you want to see in terms of result but what do you and more than happy to prepare whatever you need for Monday Tuesday yeah so so if we have uh I'm sorry I say I think we need to we need to see numbers I mean what's that going to look like if we put something on the ballot of May we're not going to get anything till January anyway regardless right it's not going to happen June 1st if we put something on the ballot in May

097and it passes we still won't get any money until January correct but yeah but we we already have that plan right but that's but that but people need to that has to be very clear too but what what is the cost going to be to a homeowner will we be would you be able to have that information on Monday if we did just just say you know million and then 14 or 13 and a half but then what would it look like in the fall and what are those costs because it's going to be something in May plus the pi plus something in November and there needs to be a total so people can see what that is so that I don't want anyone to say that they didn't know what the ask was well

098like you know that's that's a good question like a pi Levy if we do the straight renewal there's no change right because we had talked about that the last meeting that you were going to have both both we could so we could see what that's going to be for example the the the pi we talking about incremental right so even let's talk about the um n and a half versus 13 and a half versus 14 slight is that 25 right now it's it's somewhere about 9.71 Ms 72 Ms somewhere in there depend on your rounding for the um 13 and a half that's two to 3 hunds of a mill less than if what it was in November okay most people are not going to notice that amount right it's so it's so small to

099go from 13 and 1 12 to 14 and these are ry's numbers and Matt and I have been really really close so I feel comfortable in sharing this you go from 9.72 to 10.08 which is. 34 Ms that's $11.90 per year for 100,000 so about a dollar a month that difference between 132 and 14 is about a dollar a month per $100,000 right but at 9.72 whatever that math is coming I didn't calculate that cuz that's that's essentially replacing what was so like the 9.72 is $340 a year per 100,000 so $300,000 home which we're already seeing people tell us on their tax bills they're seeing $1,000 reduction this year in their tax bill because that's what came off the bond came off no the no and then we have then of course then we

100have the bond issue the last year collection on it and and so that's coming off too and um I'm remember I got the it'll be on the board agenda on Tuesday the amount but um that is $60 a year for 100,000 that's coming off so that's something that kind of worries me too because I'm not negating the fact that we've got quite a disparity between the blue and the Orange Lines here but people are going to be getting their tax bills and seeing this nice reduction in there and they may decide I like that well that's why every everything we do is now a new tax which is what also concerns me I think one thing for the conversation to consider is we've talked about how the benefits of being on in May it gives

101us that stability it gives us that you know the patient is stable and in F future discussions but I also think that the board should consider what happens if the levy fails because the conversation the day after will be now what and I think that needs to be part of the conversation that you're having today as well because then do you go back you know we had 5,000 voters tell us no and now we're we're going to go back in May and no or you know from May with a no vote for 13 a half or 14 million then what do we do in November and so I think you know that that becomes part of it so as a as a team we have begun to work on the question of you know if

102if nothing passes in 2025 what do we have to do um to make sure that we have you know the funds to avoid going below you know that line so we're working on that so we can share with the board and the community in the event that there isn't um a levy passage this year in 2025 here are the things that we'll need to do to continue to operate and avoid hitting that line and that's where you're hearing about the 9 million to $1 13 million of reductions that that work will reflect you know that range so I I think that maybe in the next part of the conversation is if we do go forward with May and it passes great we check the box and we can continue to have dialogue and do the

103things that we've talked about but if that Levy fails then what what does that say about November because if you you run the risk of you know you go back with the same amount well didn't we tell you that answer in May well 5,000 voters voted in may you know now we're going to have 16,000 voters does that does that change um or you know do you go in with a lower amount and then now we're making you know additional reductions and you know based on the results in May um which you know we would have to be prepared for you know a smaller dose of reductions in May if the board went with a lesser amount or all of it because again we have funds that are riding on it so so I think

104that's the other thing is just to be comfortable with if the levy goes down you know what what do we do we have time to talk about that the levy goes down you have you'll be filing by August to be a November ballot so it's not quite as tight as this time frame right but you know on May 7th or whatever that that next day is the conversation hopefully is what's the next challenge if it isn't then we got you got work to do and I think you know you've talked about it here we know what it is to maintain what we have and we all think that's I think we all agree here there's that's a legitimate ask but we don't but you know unfortunately or fortunately or unfortunately it's not up to the

105board you know and the other thing again in and the my concerns you didn't ask but I'm going give them anyway um is is yes I'd like to have it locked in in May so we don't have to worry about that last ditch effort November however we've got the the bandwidth of the levy committee and the ability to raise funds because this is not it's not nothing and and they've struggled to raise funds if I'm not correct yeah Eric yeah we yes they so you've got the levy committee it could be the greatest decision in the world but we don't have a way to support it because we can't fund you know the support obviously and then the the other part of that is um we do have people our athletic boosters our music boosters

106and others who want to help get the Gap but that but that you know going into next year can they really help next year because without that funding secured if that make if that makes sense the gap's still going to be there but we don't know if the Gap is this much or this much so um I can you know getting back to Tuesday you just give board gives a direction what You' like to see in front of you on Tuesday I will be more than happy to work with Mr hosler and and bond counsel if necessary to prepare whatever you would like you would like to see so what's the answer for the agenda on Tuesday I'm hearing to have a draft of the resolution for necessity the 13 for four years okay 13

107and 135 instead of the 14 why 135 instead of the 14 take it back to where it was do you want to see any other analysis that's that's pretty straightforward but there's anything else You' you like to I'd like to see that then in a fiveyear because fouryear puts us on a um like a nothing election I mean it's it's one of the it's not gubinatorial it's not presidential it's just one of those in between put it put you on the same cycle as the P Pi L if you go five years that's what we're doing okay and it wouldn't have to be 13 and a half I'd rather be at a election that people are going to show up up for then you kind of outlined just a couple of looking ahead over the

108next few years of what that could look like um part part of the discussion the board had in June of of 2024 ahead of the decision about the November election was that voter fatigue that you know always coming back so eight years was keeping it on the presidential cycle where the most people could vote um and that's why the board landed at eight years and it gave time to talk about the other issues you know the the facilities the growth and facilities and so forth so if we do the four-year option we took the liberty of just plugging in what that would look like so in 2025 you know that those would be on the ballot and then you would see us talking about reductions in 28 or 29 depending on the amount that the

109board would seek or sooner if the board were to seek significantly less um and then State funding changes significantly right yeah and so you see 2029 it would pop up and and then the next year you would have the pi Levy if we keep that fiveyear and then you can see the five years they land on the same year and then if you were to do six years you could see how that spreads out so um so with four years we're looking at in between in the next six years we'd be looking at one two four elections in six years and then you can kind of see from there um and all of that would be for you know to capture with the exception of this year um it would be the pre the next

110you know three elections would be just to capture what was approved already no no additional funds and if you do the additional funds then you run the risk of where we are today and and risking it all for you know a gain of a couple million dollars a year well does it make sense to look at the option excuse me the options that we've really talked about tonight the 13 and a half the 14 and nine or nine and a half nine and a half nine and a half would it make sense to look at all three of those so that we would have the information that we would need to see what all three look like well you tell me what makes sense but uh 13.5 million versus 14 obviously I was more comfortable

111with 14 that's what I put in the forecast I felt comfortable against to 2029 but at this point I would take 13 and a half if that was if that was the bet that that got us done right we could deal that then the question is if you want to look at those other options you just tell me you know kind of what you'd like because again how you split that you know it's kind of arbitrary at this point I mean you could run some some models and you pick your poison anything less than I make 13 million in a new in a new ask means there's some Cuts coming right if you don't P if you don't pass that second second piece and so that amount that you're going to have to cut potentially

112is that difference between X and 13 and a half over you know through 2029 so it's how much do you want to how much do you want to risk you know it's it's what it comes down to risk and reward you know what do we what what are we comfortable with with with with risking you know for example you know I'm not saying this is the option I'd recommend if if I thought 13 and A5 would pass solidly I'd go why not make 13 and a half continuing the last Pi Levy not last Pi the last incremental Levy the district had it turned into a pi Levy that's continuing it was a $13 million Levy I can't remember what year it went continuing um but it's continuing as a fixed sum Levy and now here's

113here's the history of continuing levies um this was discussed in June so I just brought that slide over yeah so the the 2016 that was an incremental Levy that was made continuing at that level as a fixed some Levy it collects $13 million a year it's been collecting $113 million since 2016 it'll continue to collect that at this point I mean I'm not thought a a wrench in there but I'm just the the the thinking when I was originally thinking about splitting the 9 and a half million because that's just kind of our bread and butter money right now that would have been continuing and then we would put on a fixed sum four or five year in November but again that three campaign so I I do think that there's time to this might

114be a time to lock in some long-term funding that we know is going to be needed I mean I I can't imagine cutting all the way back to that or beyond that at this point I don't think we really would in any way um have the student experience I'm not even sure how we would do that so to me the 9 a. half million as a continuing was part of the scenario to at least lock that in and then talk about what is it that we need what what type of student experience do we want and and what will that cost us for the November ballot yeah 9 million is bread and butter I would say 9 million is bread and margarine I grew up on margarine I'm not not quite it doesn't I mean

115we'd have to make cuts to you know let me model of forecast was 9 and a half in there and then you can see what the Gap is I was trying to come up with a number that was rational that could be a continuing um I I don't I would not go bigger than n and a half million for continuing ask so I'm hearing 13.5 million at four years and these are just going to be possible motions for us to approve well yeah like said I got the now correct me if I'm wrong I got the impression you're directing us to go ahead and get a resolution of necessity for for 13 and a half the question was four years or five years that that is that correct to draft that to draft that c

116certainly for four okay and then the question is do you want any other legislation drafted or do you just want some analysis I want to be very very trying to use our time efficiently the time is tight we can pull a lot of things off pretty fast if we have good Direction what is so 13.5 million at four for the resolution people wanted to see the 14 million and the 9 and a. half million cost but no no resolution drafted I don't okay is that what I heard I don't know what we're hearing anymore well but we have to make a decision on Tuesday's meeting well I mean here's let's again if you said talk about a Tuesday night you want to do something other than what we've drafted you we have a special meeting

117that week and I will you know Bond council is pretty good it's a template turning it around and getting it getting in front of you so as of right now those are the scenarios that we've discussed it doesn't preclude people coming with a new scenario after giving more thought to it on Tuesday but there are the scenarios that we've discussed that we want to talk about again on Tuesday enough scenarios enough scenar why4 versus the five because I'm looking at the five as a compromise between the four and the six blesss um again going after the the argument we've been beaten over the head with about the number of asks when you're looking at slide um the fiveyear looks like a a nicer compromise between what the what a fouryear would throw at us here's

118here's I'm going to throw this at you call Community engagement part we've all heard you don't plan but 8 years is tooo long long four years is right but then you're not going to be able to plan long so you're not going to win either one of those arguments I think you're going to have to figure out do what you got to do because you're getting feed you know right now the feedback is mixed right I mean the vote feedback was one way for the eight years and I think sue you made I think it made perfect rational sense but obviously we did not able to communicate or convince people of that you're going to have to pick your poison I guess is and five years is equivalent to four in in people's minds so

119again fiveyear puts it on a presidential cycle is that do I have my dates right or the four year does 24 28 that would a be a gubinatorial would be the four-year 20 no nothing three years would three three years would put us on a presidential right that's right five years put go so i' I'd be I'd be more inclined to say five y so would I are I was going to say one of the big arguments that I constantly heard is um we get to pick elected officials every four years in some cases every two years going further out even though people complain because they are constantly going back to the polls they feel better about going back to the polls in the long run I mean it's just you know some of our

120elected off your kid who's always arguing with you about eating as peas they're going to constantly argue but they know if they want to get up from the dinner table they're going to have to eat the peas you know same thing with with our funding people are going to argue about it all the time but they know if they want the services for their kid they're going to have to say yes so and the answer is that they gave us was no well so not all of them yeah 2030 if we did a five that's a gubernatorial time right in 2032 is here this might help you right here so Mr jur can you help me if on Tuesday we have a resolution of necessity that states 13 A5 million at four years is it

121very complicated to change that to a fiveyear i I'd have two both of them prepared okay I'd have both resolutions prepared because again the resolution necessity all it does is County auditor calculate the millage and then when once that come comes we can't amend that we cannot amend that Tuesday on Tuesday though if you just had one presented and then we want to amend it because it just sounds like there's so many different scenarios right now that we're considering well I would again what what I would do is have both of them in my pocket okay that way it's the attorney is prepared this sounds um okay so we want 13 and A2 at four years we want 13 and A2 at 5 years does anyone want any other scenarios prepared no fix and again

122fix some Levy Mr some so not your okay split one no okay and I think I think you know ry's point and working with the attorneys it's really important that we get it right because we know our colleagues and you know in the district North of us didn't get the ballot language right and and that kept them off the ballot so so it's important that we are very careful with that so I like my job and I prefer not to be run out of town because of a typo in a resolution dot your eyes and cross your teas any other [Music] discussion and I'd like to move and I without anyone saying otherwise I'd like to adjourn the meeting good thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.