001tax budget hearing I'm calling this uh hearing open for public comment on the 2026 tax budget um see as we've got a big public crowd to ask questions about the tax budget um I'm going to go ahead and make just a couple of comments the board will approve this during the organizational meeting but annually it is required and every count by law every school district should be submitting a tax budget um to their tax Bud budget commission and which can consist of the County Treasurer auditor and prosecuting attorney um every County does it a little bit differently um you know the format as well as whether or not they take a hard look at it but essentially what the tax budget is is our submission to the county saying you need to collect all the
002taxes we have to show that um we have need for that collection and that's where the tax budget commission takes the T this tax budget and then will assess all the taxes for calendar year 25 right is quoting for our taxes this paid this year are from on 24 right because they always a year year behind so what you have in the tax budget here in this first sheet is the general fund and the general fund is the one that's broke down the most most detail because that's obviously where the bulk of our um local tax collection is it shows last year um when the previous fiscal year which is for us year 24 the current fiscal year which is last year is 25 and then the next two are next fiscal year so it's
003fiscal year 24 fiscal year 25 and then projected 25 fiscal year 26 so the first page is just a general fund and Tom if you want to go ahead and scroll to the second page then we get into um the bond retirement fund and this is important even though Again The Tax Commission can lower the collection rates on any of these millages if they deem that we don't need the money now bonds um is it it's a little bit different calculation cuz we you know we can show exactly what our payments are due and they collect enough to make that payment plus a little bit of um a little bit of cushion so if you go go ahead and scroll Tom the pi Levy we have two Pi levies you know the one that's voted
004millage again we talk about that later tonight but this again it says Hey we've got use for that money please collect please collect it and go ahead and scroll the half half M for Tech so all those again we're just showing our need um and our projections on the revenue normally at this time then they would they' also have for us the anticipated tax rates but they're not done yet we'll get them at the regular meeting so any comments on the tax budget and the tax budget is kind of a um bureaucratic device but I pull I use the same numbers in the tax budget that are in the forecast so they they tie they tie together any any other comments okay I I'm going to call this uh hearing to a close so tax
005budget hearing is is is now closed short and sweet he thanks what that thanks I have never seen anyone show up to a tax budget hearing and actually some counties are yeah I wouldn't take it personal no there's no complaint about it though it's it's kind of a it's become very important because like we have at least in one County that tax budget has been cutting school funding on their own saying you don't need the money we're cutting we're cutting the millage and of course that's there's some question they can legally do that or not but um they see it as their as their mandate and and I can I can honestly say it's not um it's been a oneoff it's no longer be a oneoff with this the state of um where the state
006is right now that that's the appetite is to cut off Public Funding when they can look yeah follow following years count too oh that's really hot are we moving into the next meeting no we that at we didn't do iMed okay how are your kitties in their condos the cold weather good the one comes in quite a bit so that's the smart one no no that I don't know what that one was about it's not one of mine so he was a stranger so funny yeah they uh the one he's in quite a bit he hasn't spent the night inside yet but and the other one is a little more timid so yeah because didn't I send you I think it was from not Neiman Marcus e e e all right good evening everybody I'm
007going to call to order the perisburg education organizational meeting on this January 6 2025 if we could start with the Pledge of Allegiance please I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all roll call please M Roland Miller here miss Lar shmer here miss minky here Dr reford here Mr Bennington here our safety briefing perisburg schools welcomes you to the Commodore building and we thank you for attending tonight's Board of Education meeting we care about the safety of our students staff families and guests please note that there are exits on both the East and West sides of the cafeteria in case of of an emergency an AED is located just outside the cafeteria
008doors you are located at 140 East Indiana Avenue thank you for joining us tonight and supporting perisburg schools so the next first item on our uh organizational meeting agenda is an election of the new board president Mr Dreer if you would kind of walk us through the process yes I it I have it written there but just to make sure it's clear um president proam will ask for nominations no seconds are necessary when all the nominations are presented then president protm will ask for a motion in a second to close nomination we'll vote on the closure and then we'll do a roll call vote on the presidential election if we have more than one nominee the vote is for the you not yes or no for for that particular person and so we need you
009need three votes obviously to seat the president that make does that make sense yes and is the president protemp allowed to open the nominations by making a nomination yes certainly okay then uh I'm going to open the nominations by nominating Miss Susan Roland Miller are there any other nominations take a motion to close the nominations so moved Miss lmer second Dr ruer roll call please miss lmer yes Dr reford yes Miss minky yes Miss Roland Miller yes Mr Bennington yes congratulations M Roland Miller we need to vote on President we need oh we have a see you explained it fourth year in a row I screwed it up excited to be done with that I got closer that time I got closer that's why I was trying to spare us the yeah you tried I
010tried you tried is a valant effort Randy thank you Randy right okay now so we need roll call for this is the elect of President yes we have Clos the nominations okay Mr Bennington was yes Miss larer yes Miss minky yes yes Dr reford yes Miss Roland Miller yes okay now now now congratulations Susan congratulations yeah I thought we were going to discuss who was going to moderate I think you're ready to go like peace um we'll move then to the election of a new board vice president and I assume the process is the same and hope you get it right we'll see if we get it right so I um open the floor for nominations I nominate Eric Bennington please okay we have a nomination for Mr Bennington any other nominations a vote to
011close the nominations so moved second I forgot I can second stuff now give it to you gotta get in back in the loop here so this this vote is to close nominations very C Dr referen yes Mr Bennington yes Miss larer yes Miss minky yes Miss Roland Miller yes now the vote to to elect the vice president Dr refer yes Miss minky yes Miss lmer yes Miss Roland Miller yes Mr Bennington yes congratulations Mr thank you all right I want to um thank Mr Bennington um for his leadership the last three years um certainly through some challenging times uh I've really appreciated your leadership your guidance your wisdom and I'm going to preemptively thank you for all the hours that you will spend sharing such things with me over the coming months that sounds ominous
012thank you it's been an honor to serve and in and uh with the people at this table right here so thank you all right we move on to adopt the proposed agenda um I know that there may be some changes to specific items which we can either pull from consents or discuss at the time are there any other changes though to the agenda specifically so a motion to approve the agenda so moved second roll call please roll call please sorry Mr Bennington yes Miss larer yes Miss minky yes Dr reford yes Miss Roland Miller yes we have the agenda our first item 5.1 is the regular board meeting schedule time um dates so if we um I'd like to ask for this to be um made as a motion to adopt this and then if
013there's any amendments to the motion we can consider those so moov second roll call for um putting this motion oh sorry okay so we have a motion um are there any amendments or changes or discussion around this motion I would like to make an amendment um I propose that we make board meetings for 6 PM same reason as last year so we can allow the public to be here in time and also for those of us who work and do not get out in time to make a 5 5:30 meeting I would appreciate a six o'cl meeting so I'm not late and not rushing to get here we have a motion is there a second what with the amendment for the amendment for the amendment I have a motion to amend we have to have
014a second in order to discuss it right correct so I'll second to discuss okay so miss mcky have the m made the motion then okay so we have a motion in a second so discussion to move the meeting from 5:30 to 6 is there another day of the week that you could be here at 5:30 because I noticed at some meetings you're able to be here earlier than six so is it a day of the week problem or is it only a Time problem um it's a Time problem it's not specifically a day of the week okay and the reason why we do 530 is to accommodate students and student recognitions right Tom um the uh it's it's the the board meeting times have changed over the years so Mr Hustler are you on sorry
015uh so the the board meeting times have changed over the years so initially it was I believe at 7 p.m. when I first started on the board or working with the board um and and uh and what the board overtime said you know on Monday nights there's other activities that are going on it's it's a it's a late night they thought that having it at that time was not allowing people to to get home you know they thought people would be more likely to come at an earlier time after work and because once people get home it's hard to get back out for board meeting so then they moved it from 7: to to 5:30 um and that also helps with recognitions and things you know kind of on the way home from work so
016so there hasn't been a a set I mean it's been at 5:30 for a number of years now but it hasn't always been at at 5:30 uh the work sessions have also that that start time has changed over the years as well so so I think it's been 5:30 since I've been on the board it's been it's been a long time yes yeah yeah um and they weren't getting many people to participate at the board meetings uh before at 7 so they changed it to 5:30 hoping that people could it'd be more convenient for people to stop in on the way home from work kind of a thing um so so I don't know if that's really changed but now with YouTube people who want to watch have that ability you can't participate but you
017can certainly observe um well that that was kind of my my thought about it was that for people who want to participate or want to see it what I'm hearing is that they're just going to YouTube anyway so it's one less thing that they have that they have to attend thank you for being here but that being said um but I'm concerned about the students it seems to be a good time for them and if I'm not mistaken it was Gretchen who really got the the ball really rolling on the recognitions and so we've been doing that for many many years and I think that that's important for us to see um the work that our staff and our students are doing that we're trying to encourage and direct so does a half hour make
018a difference in a student's life yes it does a lot um I'm not I'm not really me personally it doesn't make a hill beans a difference I have to find somebody to watch test either way so it doesn't matter but I I am thinking about the students on that one and I love having the student participation other discussion I mean in spirit of compromise does 54 I mean we're talking 15 minutes that's 5:45 think some of that it would help me from coming from my job yes and I think it would also help the parents who get the student here not everybody gets off at 5: not everybody gets off at 4:30 oops ninja way to go dude he going um for the parents who want to be here for their students I I believe
019that six o'clock would be better for them and really with the students coming from practice I think it would be easier for them also to be here at six o'clock and the coaches aren't having to run um practices short because they have members of their team that need to be here for something else whether it's for an academic recognition or if they have students that were on a previous season team I think that would be a good compromise we could do that 540 Well we'd have to change the motion we'd have we could do a friendly we could do a friendly Amendment to the motion if Miss Mony was interested in changing it to 545 she wants a vote on six then we can continue to vote or we can have to vote on this
020amendment and then you could make another amendment I believe I could do for 5:45 but keep in mind this gentleman probably knew that there was a tax meeting at 5:45 yet he walked in here at 5:50 and I'm guessing it's probably because he was at work um so I think giving parents especially a little leeway so they're not rushing to get their children here would be a a good service for us to do so do you want us to vote on the six o'clock or would are you willing to amend your motion to 5:45 how about we vote on both of them okay we do a 545 and at six o'clock and see how it goes okay well the motion on the floor is six yeah the motion on the floor is six do that
021one first call to the question on six o'clock all right uh call the question for six Mr dwer Mr Bennington yes Miss larer I'm GNA say no Miss minky yes Dr referen No Miss Roland Miller I'm going to say no I like the idea of the compromise so that I move for 545 you make an amendment for 545 make an amendment for 545 second Miss larer who who had the second Miss L discussion on 545 get 545 546 call for the question then Mr dwer Mr Bennington yes m lmer yes Miss minky yes Dr referen yes Miss Roland Miller yes okay okay so we're back to our original motion 5.1 with the change of regular meetings at 5:45 on the third Monday of each month and you see the dates there any other amendments or
022changes give a second okay are we just doing we're just doing 5 just doing 5.1 right now so call for the question Mr drewer Miss lmer oh okay so now it's the dates and the time yes sorry Mr Bennington yes Miss minky yes Dr refer yes M Roland Miller yes all right we have board meetings the next two the next um five items are grouped together but I think we really need to look at each one individually I think there may be some changes um so and we have to fill in some blanks as well uh so 5.2 is the board retreat I think everyone had been notified of this previously so hopefully that continues to work with everyone's schedule um 5.3 are the work sessions um I just want to highlight that we have
023scheduled unusually I know that this isn't our normal practice but we have scheduled July and December work sessions uh with the idea that if they're not needed they can be cancelled rather than trying to add them into the schedule later so if we can put all of those work sessions if this passes on our calendars that would be really helpful the July one I'll note is the second Wednesday of the month and not the first Wednesday of the month in order to stay away from the h holiday so that is there um and Ju Just um on a point of um open Sunshine laws if you end up having the work session on July 9th and we have other business that we need to do that day there will be there will need to be
024a new notification right because it's because the work section we got to make sure we have on there what's happening and I just if there we got other business I just want to be careful about that we just that we add that in there so just just a watch out if we get to that point okay oh so this is different than what you originally sent out isn't it okay yeah that's I think mainly the July and December dates being added um the standing committees and other non-board appointed committees um so you'll see that we have um let me back up there was a meeting as you were informed that uh Mr Bennington and myself attended via Zoom with um Mr Hustler Mr drw and um Miss price where we met with Cheryl Ryan from
025osba to talk about committees how are other boards doing committees um and this is kind of where those conversations landed we wanted to really align our committees and the language of our committees around our the board's main responsibilities and our our goals for the coming year and our strategic plan and you'll see that uh we no longer have what really is Communications because that really is a more operational piece but as we've talked about Community engagement has become a really important part of the board's responsibilities that we want to focus on and so that has shifted um both kind of content as well as people uh the finance committee of course continues and the teaching and learning committee has has really been split I want to say but we've renamed that as student achievement as
026that as the main focus uh one of the things that you'll notice that policy is not a uh a standing committee anymore we see that as an ad hoc committee opportunity for when policy changes need to be considered that those will be scheduled and we'll ask you know I'll I'll Point people at that time with your approval um curriculum review which would have been part of teaching and learning that that that would become an ad hoc committee too that's kind of pulled out of that and then other ad hoc committees as our business requires um we do have you'll see the schedule there um and then we have assignments several of the assignments we will address or we have addressed already in other motions but we will be addressing the osba delegate legislative lison and
027student achievement lisons in the next couple you'll see that um Dr reford would be with the pris public schools foundation and then by policy as president I would be on records um what we have not included anymore are those uh committees appointed by the superintendent as those are not board approved and we want to make sure that that's a clear designation that our responsibilities aren't in the operational side and that there are these um main areas that we're responsible for um I think to the person on the outside who was who was counting up on their fingers board responsibilities um when we looked when Dr uh Mr Bennington and I talked about um assignments for this coming year we looked at total assignments across superintendent uh appointed committees with the uh assignments for osba the
028foundation and the records committee as well as the board standing committees so everyone has three or four assignments for the coming year so that's pretty equal it just may not look that way on paper right now um I think that that's kind of the high level piece of that I'm going to keep I'm going to keep running through these and then we'll go back um for those that we need you'll see that the osba legislative lay is on uh that we are suggesting um Miss larer again for that role which is I had no idea how many committees she is on um it's a very large role and I think as we continue to move in our funding issues that this is a really Central role for our board and so I'm grateful for Miss
029lr's willingness to serve in that way we will need a um alternate for that position um osba student achievement lay is on Mr Bennington has agreed to do that again and is being a board repres resentative on the student achievement committee that makes a lot of sense um I'm going to suggest that as the other member of that committee that I probably be the alternate and then um that's so we're looking at 52 through 56 are there any discussion or changes to e any of those five items I'm going to suggest or I'm going to propose that we pull operations out of a superintendent appointed committee and um and we put it in a regular board committee and my reasoning behind this is because of the things that we are doing in there they're not
030necessarily um specifically labeled to um a student or a staff member in terms of what we're talking about um I think it's good for the community to see operations um how we are I would say smartly spending our money and our savings and I think it needs to be um an open public um chance for people to come to a meeting and see what we're doing especially with the levies that we have coming up one of the things that we had talked about when we were we were specifically to that committee was the mechanism to be able to continue to pull the communications the work that that committee and those folks are doing and and I think there is opportunity in the regular board meetings to continue to do what we've been doing and share
031all of that great work and all those those savings that are occurring um to my recollection and I haven't served on that committee uh throughout my entire tenure here but I don't recall any public participation that has ever occurred at that meeting I don't know that that's necessarily what drives a decision but I I agree with you I think it is critically important that those that are going to serve on that committee continue to bring out and talk about the work that is being done in there um because it is good it is it is great work that's being done but I also think moving it to a superintendent committee also kind of gives it some logistical uh some logistical flexibility as far as noticing and and and you know um the type of things
032that can be talked about in that meeting like security building security things like that cyber security some of the other topics that do get covered in that meeting I think for is that an um Amendment then to the item that you want to make yes I'd like to see that as an amendment okay so the like an amendment to move operations from an administrative superintendent and appointed committee to a board standing committee is there a seconding none I would say that that um will move on I I I will comment that one of my main concerns as we talked about committees was um I think operations is an incredibly important area I think it's incredibly well-run but I also know that that 80 2% of our budget is personnel and so if people are really
033concerned about how we're spending our money they need to look Beyond operations so I'm not sure I also really that is an area that is clearly delegated to staff um and we're really there you know the superintending Committees are are us there for information versus our work and I think it's important to keep that as um an administrative superintendent appointed committee other um we need an osba legislative leison and delegate two it's really two different things um we need an alternate for that is there anyone willing to serve in that role don't all jump Mr Bennington is willing to serve as that alternate thank you we will fill that into 5.5 are there other work sessions so we have 53 54 55 and 56 any other discussion or changes to those um were were we
034going to there's there's been some discussion about changing the time for work sessions um so is that something that we can go ahead and approve this as is and maybe bring that up at The Retreat then since we won't have had any um work sessions yet and we can discuss more thoroughly if we want to keep that 7 AM time or go to a different time I mean we can certainly consider that and change it okay um as of right now yeah I think we need to approve as is and not try to coordinate seven schedules right now if we wanted to try to change that yeah I can put that down as a discussion Point At The Retreat on the second all right if there's no other discussion comments what about um U Miss
035miy pointed out the April 18th finance committee That's Good Friday Good Friday are we in school is not in session that day but I don't know what it doesn't make me any difference but is it a do you do we want to change it I'm just I'm just I'm asking the question M minky brought it up I just want to make sure that do we want a different date then for the April meeting or I would say do the 17th because if if staff is off I don't want to ask them to come in for my staff's not off your staff isn't off we don't we don't follow scho the school calendar I think that's then to Mr Bennington Mr Miss 17th is fine with me we got payroll and stuff that like they got
036they schedule their non work days separate differently but you know doesn't what whatever works would it would it be bad to or would it be difficult to do the 17th and not for me no doesn't make any difference I to to to me I'm going to be both of them are work days for me so Mr benington the 17th of April which so Thursday the 17th instead of Friday the 18th I'm a CPA it's two days after tax day so anytime after April 15th is good with me you'll be awake 17th is fine yeah give me a day rest and then we'll get back into Finance all right so we will you file all those extensions and you can just scoop off thanks for that all right so in 5.4 under finance committee we have
037a change to Thursday April 17th of 2025 thanks for picking up on that are there other okay then I'm gonna move to 5.7 where we approve these five items together and if Mr juror is ready we can do a roll call did we get a a motion in a second did I miss that sorry motion to approve all five items so moved second second Miss lmer thank you roll call Mr Bennington yes Miss larer yes Miss minky yes Dr rord yes Miss Roland Miller yes I'll get the Rhythm down I promise all right uh we have consent agenda about your third year you'll get it by my third year and then I'll smooth Nom silk um so consent agenda item seven there are multiple items here I would for the consent agenda I'd like to
038treat this a consent agenda if there's one specific one someone wants to pull out to discuss we can but otherwise I would look for a motion to approve the consent agenda so moved second any discussion anyone want to pull an item uh just a question um who's going to be in charge of 78 Mr drewer I'll what's that who's going to be in charge then of 7.8 have not decided okay and I'll just highlight 7.9 I want to thank Chris Campbell for continuing to serve to answer your question no sorry I'm still in charge of 7.8 I'll have to appoint a a compliance officer who I don't know who that will be at this point but ultimately it's still credit limits are fall on in this role at Le the board is if they approve
039this it falls on this role okay okay just 7.9 um Chris Campbell for the pent career Board of Education um grateful for his service in that all right we have a motion and a second if there's no further discussion I'll call for roll call I missed the I'm sorry was Eric Mr bangton Miss lmer okay all right got it now sorry get it all right Mr Bennington yes Miss larer yes Miss minky yes Dr refer yes Mr Miss Roland Miller yes and we've hit the end of the agenda so I call for the adjournment of this meeting so move which moves us if I can hit the right things immediately into our special meeting so I call to order the special meeting of the perisburg Board of Education okay we need to take a vote
040on the inment well problem is we had a we we have a motion for adjournment the the president can say if there's no objection adjourn the meeting I'm sorry yeah there's no objections to that right no okay yeah no meeting's adjourned the issue is once you get a motion in a second then we have to act on it okay I would hate to have the Roberts rules cor Le come after me you're a nasty Bunch I'm going to call to order the special meeting um roll call Mr juror miss larer here Mr Bennington I'm still here miss minky here Dr reford Miss Roland Miller here we have adopt the proposed agenda again to remind you that we um we limited to the items that were on the agenda for the special meeting um primarily around
041the permanent Improvement Levy you'll see that we also have an executive session um for the purpose of the investigation of charges or complaints against a public employee as well can I have a motion to approve the agenda so move second Miss lmer yeah that didn't come out all the way uh roll call please miss minky yes Miss larer yes Mr Bennington yes Dr refer M Roland Miller yes so item 3.1 discussion of options for the expiring 2019 permanent Improvement Levy and I have just a very short presentation to to tee this up so um just want to kind of it's kind of a repeat but hopefully a reminder what what we have so thought I thought Thomas had it up there did for a second you blinked and you missed it so you know back
042in December the board uh you know asked me to get some language together for Resolutions of necessity and so I want to kind of just walk through a couple things that got get us to this point then what we have to do sorry Randy and there's only eight slots so this is okay all right Tom we go to the next slide all right so just a review the election days is May 6th filing deadline is February 5th um there are two key steps for the for the board resolution of necessity that outlines our ask okay and then it requests the county auditor to calculate the need needed millage resolution of necessity does not obligate the district to do anything at that point essentially it does is allow us to have the exact numbers that would
043be in some ballot language following that then we if the board would pass a resolution to proceed and that defines the ballot language that we submit to the Board of Elections and that resolution also says hey Randy go ahead and file that paperwork so those are the two key steps that have to happen um before um well before February 5th because that's what you actually file on the 5th so both of those steps have to happen both those steps have to happen and cover resolution necessity night gives me time to work with the county auditor to have the numbers for the regular meeting to have the resolution to proceed go ahead Tom so so current our current Pi Levy it's emergency fixed sum Levy with 5year Levy was last renewed in 2019 and Tom correct
044me it's been renewed every 5 years since 1980 or something yes correct it's a qualified Levy which means that it is Homestead and roll back eligible so let me Define that a little bit more gross collection in fiscal year 24 is $1.7 million 1.5 of it come from local property taxes 76,000 from public utility and then this is where the homestead roll back eligible come important 17 75,000 so about 10% came from State share so the taxpayers in this case are getting about not everyone I mean over 65 in particular they qualify there's about a 10% discount so 90% of that is coming from you obviously local sources in the state is putting in in 10% all right so that's important to think about as we talk about how to replace or renew this Levy
045in 23 um last tax year the effective rate millage rate for class one was 1.17 Mills it was voted at 1.9 so those numbers keep in mind so the effective millage has dropped over the five years and it's actually be in this tax year it'll be less less than that I just don't have the official number yet so it probably about 1.1 or a little bit less for the actual effective millage so go ahead Tom so there are three General options with other than not renewing it right that's that is an option you could just let it go go away you can replace a levy and you can renew it with an increase and you can do a straight renewal and I put them in this order as you'll see for for a reason so
046go ahead Tom replacement Levy allows you to turn the clock back we're going to replace this Levy at the original millage at 1.9 Ms right so it's collecting 1.17 the last tax year we could replace it at 1.9 cuz that's was originally passed but it would no longer qualify for Homestead and roll back discounts all right a renewals that increase the renewed portion would still qualify so that that 1.17 or that you know current would still qualify for discount but any increase would not so what I what we did was put language there to increase we know we need more money in the pi Levy but whether or not this is the time to ask for on that's the you know question the board's going to have to deal with but just for point of
047reference a $500,000 increase is about a34 Ms at this point or a little a little bit less okay so you actually have so one of the languages you have is a resolution of necessity with this scenario here so the bulk of it would be still qualifi for discounts but the new portion would not that make sense very clear then go to the last slide Tom and then obviously straight renewal it remains qualifi no um and there's no additional Revenue so that's that's the simplest and um again we don't know what the exact millage will be but it's going to be somewhere less than 1.17 for class one for that's residential Agriculture and I think that kind of summarizes you know I think the the discussions and hopefully narrows it down for what you know board
048wants to do I have I have put two resolutions on the agenda one the straight renewal and a renewal with an increase you can you know you can pass one or the other or pass both of them it doesn't obligate the district anything at this point if you want to entertain an increase if you don't want to entertain an increase that's fine just we'll do the resolution just to just for the renewal so the board has both those options right now in front of them replacement didn't feel like it was worth bringing in front of the board it just a it was just a hill too large too high to climb at this point loss of Homestead and rollback is is and once you replace it there's no going back it's no longer a qualified
049Levy yeah we're not interested in that well if my if my arithmetic was correct um yeah that was that was something that concerned me that it would lose the homestead but if you do the renewal plus it came up to 1.51 which is still less than the replacement but getting some much needed dollars correct for I mean I'm am I doing the arithmetic correct that's approximately right it's not going to be you know we don't know where the effective millage will end up until I give it to the county auditor but you know but we know the 1.17 is probably high right but but that that's that's based on the V last year's valuations depending where we ended up so but you're right Sue that's approximately where would be 1 Point 51 Mills and 3.34
050would not be would not qualify for the discounts so taxpayers would cover that so what what happens today is that the other portion of they see the 1.17 Ms and then the discount is rolled off so it's act the effective mil is actually less but taxpayer really doesn't see it because it's taxed and then they discount it if that makes any sense okay so if I I just want to if no one wants to discuss letting this Pi Levy go away eternally and no one wants to discuss replacement okay that's then we have renewal with increase versus renewal um I think renewal seems a a little more straightforward so let's continue on with the discussion about renewal with increase any you know clarifying questions or let's at least start talking about if so what I
051hear is is that we don't really have to decide between these two tonight if we do decide then we only have to submit one so let's find out where we are in terms of are we ready to make this decision do we want to wait until January and at least getting the ball rolling on both or do we have strong feelings one way or the other so more discussion about the renewal with increase I think I would because we don't have to go with it if you get the information I think it would be uh beneficial to see um both scenarios for the um you know for the giving it to the auditor or whoever you give it to about the taxes you to see what that actual is going to cost either way if
052that's something that we can do so we can you know have more information about which one um would be you know obvious you know would be more beneficial uh just to have that I think just to so we can compare I mean that's my personal thoughts yeah I agree with that I'm not ready to make a decision tonight for the sake of discussion just so that this table and and the community knows where I'm at I mean I'm I'm probably leaning much heavier towards a straight renewal for several reasons there's a campaign that that needs to happen there's messaging that needs to occur and I'm of the mindset that the simpler the better but that being said I hear what Miss larer says about the much needed you know additional funds of $500,000 I find
053that you know I accept that too we all know that um so I don't want to rule out a renewal with increase tonight if I don't have to so I'd also be in favor of moving forward with both resolutions of necessity uh with continued discussion tonight and at the uh at the regular board meeting in in January so by that January meeting though we would have to make a decision that night because it's due the 5th unless we want to get together unless we want to do it again I guess we have the we do have the retreat too that we could take an action there but I'd rather not I'd rather not be doing that know we could make votes during Retreat if there on the agenda we could but again I don't think
054that that would be wise I would say that we should go for both um just to look at the amounts and let the public look at it um I also think that definitely before the next meeting I think we need to get together and I think we need to talk about an operating Levy also I think that needs to go on the May ballot I know that's difficult and a lot of and generally I know we don't like to go with two on at the same time but I think waiting is a mistake on our part um could you explain that well I'd probably caution this is a special meeting with a specific agenda I am also I am open to another special meeting if we want to talk about timing of an operating Levy
055but that tonight is not the night for that okay yeah before us we just have the two resolutions to approve right now so I'm hearing pretty much everyone that we want to move both resolutions that the next step Mr J so do we need to do them individually um I think we can combine them okay so I'd like a motion to approve four .1 and 4.2 resolutions so moved second Mr Bennington Miss ler any other discussion we call Mr drewer Mr Bennington yes Miss ler yes Miss minky yes Dr reford yes Miss Roland Miller yes and if there's anything else if you think you need for those discussions after we get the numbers from auditor let me know and you know put some other things together and um in terms of you know what it's
056being used for for example I think one of the questions I have right now is how much say over the last three years we've spent out of operating funds for things that could have come from permanent improvements so how much are we spending out of our now limited operating funds for permanent Improvement costs I can I can figure out what that is but the this is really the first year since I've been here that we've spent significant money out of general fund that would have come out of we normally would have been P Pi we've had some stuff mainly repairs this past summer and and that's why some of our expenses on supplies and purchase services are up um these are like critical things that happen that must you I don't remember the specifics either
057but I mean weird things and you know of course the other thing is just like for example um the boiler the the lease purch least purchase on the boilers the high school it'd be nice to do that out of Pi it's doing partially out of Pi but it's also out of general fund because there's n enough money the pi to do that right this building's project got the Commodore fund that can support it but for the rest of the district it's got to come up between pi and operating I think it's important too to um just for context for people that are tuning in um there are three different types of levies that school districts can put before voters so one is an operational Levy an operational Levy are um they raise funds that can
058be used to operate the district to pay staff to you know initiate programs buy the fuel all the kinds of things to keep the lights on and people in the classrooms um a permanent Improvement Levy is different a permanent Improvement Levy is the second of three different types of options and what that means is that we raise funds um specifically for what the state of Ohio considers to be permanent things and that is that is those are things that last longer than 5 years so think about parking lots roofs boilers some of the things that were mentioned um you know in terms of Maintenance um Hardware we can't spend those dollars from permanent Improvement levies on people so the funds that are raised for this are specifically for those you know repairs and maintaining buildings
059that were built in the 1950s or in this case a building in 1931 and then the the third type of Levy are Bond issues and bond issues again are dollars that can only be used for Capital so improvements Renovations uh new buildings those funds also cannot be used for um programming or people so as we talk about the permanent Improvement Levy um it's important to know that this isn't going towards you know people we're not allowed to do that so this is going towards maintaining our buildings um and what Randy was talking about is as our buildings are aging the amount of money that we generating from the pi isn't enough to cover those expenses so we start to dip into the general fund which is used to keep the lights on to pay staff
060so um if the levy were to fail then we would be looking at you know where does that $1.7 million come from that we're using now to do the windows and roofs and Tuck pointing and all the kinds of things that happen uh so there while this isn't about people per se if the money isn't available to the district it becomes about people because now those funds aren't available and we're still going to have roofs that need to be repaired and um those kinds of things so just to give a little bit of context in terms of the different kinds of levies and what this is for I'd also point out that one of the things that we don't use it for but in many places Pi L is used purchased textbooks as we've gotten
061away from hard cover textbooks you know that that burden for subscriptions and you know curriculum's coming out of general fund that would that would in historically been used Pi money for because textbooks normally have more than a fiveyear life but you know those days are are are gone that's interesting 1980 you know I guess definitely when we first approved this yeah and really put that together yeah all right we have a motion to approve the two resolutions any other discussion Mr J a roll call please I thought we already voted did we vote Yes oh really you yeah and why were we still talking about because you went out of order and opened up more conversation about it I wasn't going to correct you brought something I was going to tell you that later all
062right it's time for executive session so you can say that it looks like a good time to go into execu so we're going to be moving into executive session for the purpose of Investigation of charges or complaints against a Public Employee I do not um there will be no motions or business following that meeting and um we will adjourn the meeting after that executive session right thank you we're into executive session uh no you need a motion I need a motion to do that yeah so Move Motion thank you second you'll get it it's a learning experience roll call please miss minky yes Dr rord yes Mr Bennington yes Miss Miss lmer yes Miss Roland Miller yes now we're going to move into executive session she says there's no absolutely no confidence whatsoever