CorpusRecord 142831

Perrysburg BOE Board Meeting 12-16-2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Perrysburg Schools
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Wood County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
19,475 words · about 109 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay good evening everybody I'm going to call to order this perisburg board of education uh regular board meeting on Monday December 16th 2024 Mr Drew your roll call please Miss Roland Miller here miss larer here miss minky Dr rufford here Mr Bennington here we'll start with the pledge of alance please stand I pledge allegiance to the flag flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all we have a full house tonight welcome everybody uh as is our custom we're going to start with safety briefing given how many people are here today as I do this safety briefing you know I'm also mindful of the events that happened in Madison Wisconson today and thoughts and prayers are Never Enough

002um but that is certainly on my mind this evening so that perisburg schools welcomes you to the comor building and we thank you for attending tonight's sportive Education meeting we care about the safety of our students staff families and guests please note that there are exits on both the East and West sides of the cafeteria in case of of an emergency an AED is located loated just outside the cafeteria doors you are located at 140 East Indiana Avenue thank you for joining us tonight and supporting perisburg schools before I move into the proposed agenda I just wanted to address the crowd on on one thing I know that probably several of you are here for the public comment section so the public comments will be governed through a signup list that that is at the

003front table there if you plan to speak tonight please sign up once we start the public comments there is not an opportunity to sign up after we begin so with that can I have a motion to adopt the proposed agenda so moved Miss larer second Miss Roland Miller roll call Miss larer yes M Roland Miller yes Dr rord yes Mr Bennington yes the proposed agenda is adopted all right next uh what's always fun to do in our December board meeting is our recognitions for false Sports so Mr Hustler yep thank you um and welcome everybody I appreciate you being here this evening and at this time I'd like to introduce uh Mr Aaron cookson uh perisburg High School principal who will introduce our high school state qualifiers I should say a portion of those because

004I think there's some coming next month so we get them all on this agenda so good problem good evening members of the board and Mr Jor Mr Hustler uh it's my pleasure to introduce our coaches for our state qualifiers this year I do want to congratulate all the coaches and all the uh student athletes and attendance this evening uh you all give great pride to our high school and we truly appreciate all that you do so I'm going to start with our boys Cross Country Coach uh which is coached by Keith maderas [Applause] thanks Mr cookman cookson thank you board of education for all your support and especially Mr hosler we love seeing him at all the Cross Country meets uh we had one young man qualified to the state championship this year Anthony Clark

005uh this was Anthony's thirdd trip to Columbus so he's qualified his sophomore Junior and Senior year uh Anthony was he has been academic all Ohio he's been all Ohio uh this year he was the nlll champion the district Champion the regional champion and um Anthony is also our new School record holder here at perisburg 15 minutes and 16 seconds for 5 kilometers that's that's moving right along and on top of all that Anthony is not only just a a good runner but he's also a good captain and a great kid uh I don't want to embarrass him but he's also quite a student he's a National Merit scholar so congrats to [Applause] Anthony you me and Rachel Mr cookson's already he's got his sneakers on well again Anthony congratulations on a on a great season

006and a job well done and and one more time let's give a round of applause d this time I'd like to introduce our girls Cross Country Coach uh once again the girls had a fabulous season and they are coached by Mr John Manheim thank you I I would also like to thank the board and Mr hosler for the opportunity to recognize these athletes what I'll do first is recognize a group of girls I'll say a few words about them once they're all up um but before I do that I want to bring up our our coaches my assistant coaches are coach Ed Osborne coach Steve sliva and Coach Karen dolliver we uh we have one of the largest cross country teams in the state we had 66 girls this year and it would not be

007possible to manage 66 girls without the help of these individuals several of which are just volunteer coaches that that show up every single day so we appreciate their help and support I'll introduce the athletes freshman Lexi Schultz sophomore Carly frier she is a basketball player so she is in Ann Arbor tonight and could not be here sophomore Alyssa Hinman sophomore Ailyn Rodriguez Junior Kalin beckan junior brayy beckan senior Ava Beeks senior l and Senior Natalie Sanders so this group of girls uh behind me was very accomplished this season they were the nll Champs District Champs Regional Champs and they finished sixth in the division one state meet so a super super high finish and something that we're very proud of I want to have the three seniors if they could step out for me these

008young ladies these young ladies in their four-year career were a part of two state championship teams a fourth place team and a sixth place team and and I'd like to think we could put that up against any any sport from any school from any state that's get that's getting a little crazy there but um unbelievable they're all going to do big things at the at the next level um Natalie and Ava were three time all first team State athletes and for the rest of their life they'll be able to to tell people they were two time state champions many of the girls behind them will be able to do the same thing as you can see we still have a lot of Youth here I'm not talking about the coaches cuz there's some age there

009um the youth here we we still have a lot and we uh we plan to do big things moving forward so once again thanks to the board thanks Mr Hustler for all of your support all right thank you thank you [Applause] and finally we have uh our girls cross I'm sorry our girls tennis coach here is uh here this evening as well Kelly Carter I believe she has two um student athletes that she would like to introduce so um Miss Carter thank you m thank you Mr cookson thank you to the board Mr hosler for recognizing our students um I'd like to have all of our coaches up here as well Caren brazelle and Pat Pat J Marco we didn't make any Cuts this year we haven't really in the last I was assistant coach

010for four years because we want to instill love of tennis we all love tennis us and so we had 47 girls and without these guys that would have been we had a great season we felt like we got a lot of play time for all the girls our JV was huge but they got a ton of play time because of thankfully we had a good amount of coaches we had a great group of girls wonderful girls we had a great season we truly enjoyed coaching them our team as a whole we were 15 and four was our record we came in second in the NL and second in districts to the same team both times we're second in the district in in the postseason the tennis goes into individual as well as a team part

011but in the individual postseason tournament we had six of our players um we dominated sectionals six of our players in the finals of sectionals in singles we had it first and second and in doubles we had first and second wow and all those girls went on to play districts and then the two girls that we're recognizing tonight Penelope GM Marco and Maddie Watkins Penelope is a junior and she has been our first singles player for three years in a row very impressive Maddie is a junior and she played her freshman and sophomore year she played first doubles and she was nlll champ two years in a row at doubles this year she transitioned to singles was our second singles player and the two of them teamed up for the Post season tournament and they were

012sectional Champions District runnerup they went on to state to finish in the top eight these they're both um they were both first team nlll First Team all district and all all Ohio and as Juniors these girls were captains of our team did a tremendous job they're huge role models on and off the court we couldn't be more proud of the way they represent us on and off the court they're great Sports they win or lose with dignity and Tennis is an emotional law it can be a three-hour match it can be a lot of ups and downs and they handle themselves with such Grace and dignity always we're so proud of them [Applause] lot of smiles up there well let's congratulate these athletes one more time on a on a great season okay I think

013next we have Mr buer coming up for the junior high all right good evening and once again I like to thank the board Mr Hustler for all of your support of our Junior High uh community that we have it's U it's my pleasure to introduce um our cross country coaches here tonight so um we're really proud of our cross country programs um you know both our boys and girls you you you saw the high school Success just a little bit ago and and you know after talking to coach maderas and and and Coach Manheim over the years um we talk a lot about the continuity between the Junior High programs and the high school programs and the two coaches I'm going to introduce have a lot to do with that they've built great programs here

014at the junior high not only with the successes they've had in terms of the kids running um the Juni Junior High CrossCountry state championships is a relatively new event over the last eight years or so and our teams are consistently top in the state so when we when we take our teams down to Columbus there is a Statewide expectation that the perisburg teams are going to do extreme extremely well there um but what's even more impressive to me that the coaches have built is this culture of of success this culture of teamwork this culture of bonding and they get the kids to want to continue to come out at the high school level so they do a great job uh the first coach I'd like to introduce is our head boys coach which is M

015Mr Matt Ferguson uh thanks to the board again for recognizing our Junior High Athletics it means a lot uh to our athletes and coaches uh so we had a great uh boys cross country team this past season the three athletes we get to recognize tonight are truly the best of the best on our team um not only do they have to race against 60 of their peers within our team to make it to some of our top uh Varsity scoring positions but then to be recognized tonight here they have to place in the top 30 at the ohaa postseason race and those individuals for the Junior High boys this year are Nolan Shaila come on up Nolan uh Michael Butterfield and then both just a quick word about each of them Nolan is just a

016seventh grader he ran um 1129 to finish 21st overall at the state and so we look forward to seeing him back as an eighth grader next year improving on that and then our two eighth graders Michael and Bowen uh they set the tone this whole season for us um both in practice in every race Michael uh finished 23rd at the postseason race and then ended up in the season uh his PR 11-11 to be top sixth overall in PJs alltime cross country history and then Bowen Willer um was 13th at State um and his PR this season was 1112 and he's seventh overall in our top 10 here at uh pghs so a great season for these guys congratulations again boen Michael and William all right next I would like to introduce our head girls

017coach which is Mr Mr sha Murray I just want to Echo what everyone else has said you know thank you to the board thank you Mr Hustler for letting us recognize the athletes today um I want to kind of bring up my assistant coach uh coach Michelle Dalton uh everything that I talk about today uh couldn't be possible without her help um so just real quick before I recognize the the three athletes um that finished in the top uh 30 I just want to kind of acknowledge the fact that we had so there's 57 girls on the team this year and honestly none of our success could be possible without all of them it it really takes everybody on the team to make us as successful as we are um kind of the way the

018season works at the junior high so our like state meet is at the end of October which is 3 weeks after our league championship so it's essentially 3 weeks it extends the season by another three weeks and we kind of tell the the athletes you know if if they don't want to continue their season after NLS they don't have to and we had the vast majority of the girls continue to come after nlls some of them couldn't even race in the state meet but they still came to practice every day for three weeks just to kind of continue to be a part of the team and kind of continue kind of being involved in that so I I think that's really awesome I just wanted to recognize them um all right so at our State

019me there were 20 teams in our race uh we finished third which is I'm pretty happy with pretty impressed with uh in our race there were 220 Runners uh in our individual runners in our race and we had three perisburg girls that finished in the top 30 um the three girls that finished in the top 30 this year were Marissa cop um Joselyn Downey and Julia Matel um Marissa is sick so she couldn't be here tonight but I do want to kind of point out that so this is Marissa's second year she finished in the top 20 so she finished in the top or sorry top 30 both as a seventh grader and as an eighth grader um Joselyn Downey so she finished uh she ran a 12 minutes 55 seconds which uh was her

020first time running under 13 minutes which is something we celebrate on the team and she is the only seventh grader we had who finished in the top 30 this year and then Julia Mozel uh she ran a 1259 at this race and I just kind of was looking back and wanted to kind of recognize the fact that that's almost 2 minutes faster than she ran last year at the same race so that's a pretty impressive accomplishment so fantastic achievement again congratulations on behalf of the board uh one more time how about a round of applause for these athletes so again on behalf of the board I want to congratulate all the athletes coaches assistant coaches uh that work so hard to have such a fantastic season to make perryburg what it is I I I

021see some familiar names on this list having uh set up here for a while so some of you may have heard this before but it is still heartfelt you know this board certainly also recognizes the um the contributions of parents Guardians grandparents all of you folks that get your athletes to the practices on time that uh cheer for them when uh things are going great that probably pick them up when things aren't going so well so again you're also a very important part of their success and the board also thanks you and recognizes you so I believe that's it for the board recognition portion of the agenda for this month so we are going to next take a 5minute break so that those athletes students that need to move on to something else on this

022rainy cold evening can do so um we will the next we will move into public comment public comment is on agenda items only I will say given the special meeting that we just had it's going to kind of be a wide definition of what is an agenda item because afterwards the board will be continuing the discussion of cuts and potential Le so we'll take a 5 minute break I'll gavl us back in and we'll be ready for public comment if you do plan on speaking and if you'd like to come up and talk to me real quick so we can kind of talk about how it's going to work I'd be happy to do that so we are on break sounds good y e e e all right I'm going to bring us back in

023session as we move to item five public comment so for those that are speaking that that didn't come up the public comment will be limited to three M three minutes an individual I will recognize uh when I recognize the speaker please come to the podium please keep your please keep your comments directed to the board not to the uh not to the audience uh the board will not be responding tonight this is not a uh a town hall type of situation but myself or Mr Hustler or somebody else from the board May respond to depending on the uh on the uh comments and the subjects if you have anything to provide the board I don't think you do please hand it to the back with only three minutes it kind of gets a little bit

024confusing messy when you try and hand stuff uh to the board members up here or expect us to look at it while you're talking we're going to be looking at that and not paying attention to you but if you hand something to people in the back we will look at it uh later on so it appears everybody we've got uh first order of business uh the by policy we are limited to 15 minutes per public comment session so I would like a motion based off how many people we have to talk to allow everybody that wants to speak tonight I'd like to uh I'd like a motion for an extra 15 minutes for a total of 30 for public comment so move Miss mkey second uh Dr ruer roll call please let me catch up

025you got it sorry Miss minky yes Dr reford yes M lmer yes Miss Susan Roland Miller yes Mr Bennington yes okay we have extended public comment the 30 minutes and first the board recognizes uh Travis Latimore please come to the podium um please State kind of your affiliation with the uh with the school district uh we'll do at this time with the students who showed up to support us please join me at the podium wow so good evening board members and Mr hosler my name is Travis Latimore and I am here representing the perisburg High School athletic boosters with the rest of our executive board and concerned students our mission is to support the athletic programs and activities of the perisburg High School athletic department through fundraising and volunteer efforts this Mission aligns seamlessly with

026the district's mission to ensure all students achieve their greatest potential Athletics play a critical role in that mission helping 895 student athletes grow academically socially and physically while fostering lifelong skills and opportunities tonight we address the proposed cuts to freshman and jvb sports as well as Pride Club activities due to the recent operational Levy failure while we understand the financial challenges these Cuts would have long-term detrimental consequences for our students our schools and our community we're here to express our concern and offer proactive Solutions first the athletic boosters are ready and willing to bridge the financial gap to ensure freshman and jvb sports as well as Pride Club activities can continue as planned for the 2526 school year this step avoids an immediate disruption to current and future student athletes who rely on these programs

027for development and opportunities and continues the tradition of award-winning school spirit activities provided by proud club for all students second we are committed to launching a community campaign to Rally support for another Levy our goal is to ensure the district regains long-term Financial stability preserving programs that align with our shared mission of maximizing student potential we believe that both Solutions are necessary to avoid negative impacts we believe that cutting Sports and clubs has implications far beyond immediate cost uh savings without freshman and Junior High Sports families may choose private schools or other districts a loss of students weakens not only our athletic programs but also our academic reputation and District funding fewer sports teams means less Community engagement fewer tickets sold fewer concessions purchased and less sponsorship opportunities our athletic programs provide critical Pathways for

028students to pursue sports behind High School Beyond High School including scholarships these opportunities would be diminished cutting school spirit activities tied to inter Scholastic Athletics threatens one of our proudest Traditions the Swarm this award-winning student section Fosters Pride both belonging and unity not just for our athletes but for the entire School Community these impacts are not just numbers they represent real students real families and real Futures many of those impacted stand here with me tonight even one year of cuts sets us back in closing we have always prided ourselves on providing opportunities for every student to grow academically socially and athletically cutting Sports and pride Club activities undermines this commitment and negatively affects all of the student athletes their supporting classmates their families and the overall Community we're not here to criticize but to collaborate

029even one year of cuts sets us back so the boosters are ready to bridge that financial gap today and support efforts for a new Levy tomorrow we urge you to work with us to find solutions that preserve these opportunities for our students and together we can protect something that makes Paris special ensuring that all students achieve their greatest potential thank you for your time tonight thank you Mr [Applause] lore the board recognizes Jennifer Kelly hello my name is Jennifer Kelly and I'm here as a representative for the high school performing arts boosters I'm a parent of a ninth and 11th grade student who participate in not only Athletics music programming but also numerous clubs my children have had the great opportunity of attending perisburg schools for their entire educational careers and I cannot say enough

030about the positive impact this district has had on their academic and personal growth as a community we find ourselves at an impass the recent failure of the school levy is a dilemma that affects all of us parents students Educators and the broader Community this outcome not only raises immediate concerns about funding but also poses critical questions about how we maintain the standard of Excellence that perisburg schools are known for the effects of this decision are not abstract they are tangible and very personal we are talking about larger class sizes fewer resources reduced extracurricular opportunities and the loss of valuable teachers administrators and staff who have dedicated themselves to our children's successes these Cuts will fundamentally alter the experience of students like mine who have benefited so greatly from the opportunities that this District provides we

031understand that cuts are inevitable when funding falls short but cutting what makes this District unique and appealing our teachers our programs and our student opportunities is not a long-term solution we ask that the board Administration take this opportunity to reflect on how things have been handled to find ways to rebuild trust and to focus on Creative community-driven Solutions from speaking with fellow community members it is clear there were a variety of reasons for the Levy's failure some expressed concerns about Rising taxes While others mentioned a lack of understanding about how funds would be used or uncertainty about the district's long-term financial plan these concerns while valid cannot overshadow the urgent need to address the funding Gap and Safeguard the quality of our schools as parents and community members we want to know what specific lessons

032has the leadership learned from these repeated lovey failures what changes are being made in your approach to rebuilding TR with the community and communicating the district's needs more effectively how is the board and administration ensuring that you are preserving the quality of our schools while making responsible financial decisions what are you doing to ensure our schools are financially sustainable while continuing to deliver the highquality educations that our students deserve what steps will you take to ensure the future levies succeed what will you do differently to engage the voters and address their concerns most importantly how will you lead us in a way that prioritizes students and respects the community's voice we appreciate the tough decisions need to be made but those decisions should prioritize maintaining the Excellence that perisburg schools are known for that requires

033creative problem solving a willingness to adapt and most importantly transparency with the community tonight I urge the board to take proactive steps towards rebuilding trust and collaboration with our community this might involve hosting open forums to directly address voter concerns utilizing surveys to gather information from community members providing clearer communication about how funds are allocated or even revisiting and revising the levy proposal to better reflect Community priorities we all want the same thing a strong vibrant school system that prepares our children for Success let's not allow this setback to divide us but rather use it as an opportunity to come together learn from this experience and move forward with a shared vision for the future thank you for your time I'm confident that if we work together as a community we can find a path

034forward that benefits not just our children but our entire Community thank you thank you Miss [Applause] Kelly the board recognizes Alex boret members of the board good evening my name is Alex Barrett I live at 2161 Woods Hole Road and I have a first grader who attends Frank elementary as some of you probably know I am also the founder and administrator of the largest perisburg Facebook group with over 21 ,000 members I know that many on this board and probably this room have strong opinions on that group and its influence over school levy issues I have much to say about that much longer than three minutes and I am sure many on this board do as well but perhaps it's a discussion for another day as I mentioned I have a daughter in perisburg schools

035and my son will be there next year too my wife is a teacher and we have a support perisburg School sign in our yard for every school levy I care deeply about the quality of our schools but I am very frustrated at the option that was chosen to be on the November ballot the expiring Levy represented 177% of the district's budget instead of playing it safe and attempting to secure those much-needed expiring funds in an unknown economic climate the board chose the most expensive option with the least likely chance of Passage it was the equivalent of doubling down on a 12 and praying a face card wasn't going to show but on November 5th that is exactly what happened there are many in the community who did not want a single dollar cut from this

036District but who felt stuck between two unattractive options the choices were either to vote for extremely painful Cuts or to vote for eight years of large increases there was no middle ground I'll ask the board to entertain a hypothetical for a minute let's say the levy had actually passed in 8 years when that Levy would expire what exactly would be the board's plan at that time the board would have to ask for a nearly $28 million levy on year one just to sustain their current funding an even larger percentage of their operating expenses than the failed Levy was today to put that into perspective in 2025 the district will lose less than half of that amount in absolute dollar figures if you believe the cuts that are being discussed this evening are painful I cannot

037imagine what those cuts would do to our district continuing to put increasingly large incremental levies on the ballot sets up the district for catastrophic consequences if and when one does not pass perisburg supports Levy renewals for our district at a comfortable margin and will do so again if the option is available I implore the board to take the easy money seek a renewal of the 13.5 million that the district was already collecting and ask for any additional funds via a separate Levy even if it is on the same ballot we must stem the bleeding in our district our teachers our students students and our community deserve it thank [Applause] you the board recognizes Miss Nikki Clark hi board um I'm Nikki Clark I have an eighth grader over at the Junior High um I'm also

038the president of the parents group at the Junior High um so uh kind of following with some of what the others have said um us as parents you know we've been really good stewards for this District we're carefully learning the info as it's shared with us you know we're learning funding we're learning levies we're learning budgeting all the things um on on how you know you guys are coming to these decisions um and then on top of that we've gone out and we've learned it and we've we've learned to teach it right we've had to teach it to our friends to our neighbors to people who you know maybe didn't understand this before or maybe you know found some sort of you know fan fiction online to figure out what they were doing um we

039did that right we watched our board our board decide uh you know unfortunately the most costly option for a renewal and while that was on the heels of a failed Bond uh we had hope but we also had a healthy fear of what could happen right um we remained steadfast pushing that this was important it was the only way um after everything was shared regarding the need the first thing that came out was the questions what's going to happen if it fails your last one failed what's going to happen um that list came a month later and and a lot of us you know probably in this room took a collective gasp at Holy Smokes I'm going to feel that my kids's going to feel that perisburg is going to look different it's going to

040feel different um and and yet we had to hold that hold that shoe up and go it's not going to drop it's not going to drop we have to just focus this this Lev is going to pass we're going to put all our energy into makeing it pass so that's what we're going to do and and I have no doubt that most people in this room walked out of here you know as positive as we could pushing pushing pushing um obviously we know how that land uh so at theend at the fall of that Levy a lot of us braced ourselves and went okay how do we fix this and as you can see by the groups that are here today by the ones that have reached out you know we've we've spent a lot

041of time and energy trying to figure out okay if if half the community says you know what it's our taxes I can't afford this I want to stay here but I just can't I don't have kids in the school anymore okay so you have these groups trying to figure out how to fund this outside of taxpayer dollars um there are school districts in Chicago for example that have programs that are sponsored by outside companies um to keep some of these clubs and things moving um and to have them secured and guaranteed for years to come that that is something that I'm hopeful our district can look at and say you know what um maybe we don't have to put it all in the backs of the taxpayers maybe we have the opportunity to set these

042things up further into the future and with a little bit more security right so inflation doesn't matter as much because we've got this tied in over here and the funds that come in from our taxpayers can more hit our entire base um you know another big thing and we touched on this earlier was the inconsistency even across our board members and our our parents here and the message that's seen in public we have to clean up and and we have to do what we say we're going to do we I've come to many of these Schoolboard meetings I watch every single one of them I'm really trying to stay involved but it hurts when we're at a board meeting and we hear well we need more businesses if we have more businesses harburg then the

043taxes will go down and and people won't have to pay as much and everybody will be happy but then when we go to these zoning meetings we have those same parents board members whoever saying well yeah but you can't put that one here you can't have that one over there you can't have this we have to be consistent we have a board meeting where we talk about how the vouchers are are hurting our Public School System but then we are actively supporting a house representative in Columbus who pushes for vouchers that's not consistent that drives this dissonance that our residents are talking about all over Alex's Facebook post uh page area so we have to work on that we have to do what we say we're going to do um so you know Mark yes

044three minutes can you yep so I'm just asking please please let us let us help help us you know the information you know what it took to cut these things so you can help us with that by providing that information and let us let us set our kids up a little bit better a little bit more permanently maybe thank you thank you next the board recognizes meline [Applause] Jones hello my name is meline Jones I am a senior at our high school and I am an active member in our the department on and off stage of the 1,700 students at PHS there are approximately 1,100 of us in the Arts Theater choir choir orchestra band and visual arts today I'd like to share my story I have grown up doing theater and I've have seen

045and felt the impact theater has had on the people who are in the production and watching theater gives people the skills to be more confident in themselves understand others be creative make friends learn lessons communicate better work as a team and problem solve these skills are essential to a community at least a successful community that I want to live in according to ready to innovate a new study published by the conference board they provide that us employers rate creativity and Innovation among the top five skills that will increase in importance over the next 5 years and rank it among the top challenges facing CEOs 97% of employers and 99% of school superintendents say creativity is increasingly important in the US workplaces 72% of employers say creativity is one of the primary concerns when they're hiring

046and 85% of these employers can't find the creative applicants they seek employers might be finding themselves in the same place unfortunately due to the levy Cuts data from the College Board shows that students who take who take four years of Arts and Music classes while in high school score 98 points higher on the SATs than students who only took one half year or less as I'm sure we are all aware perisburg schools are very proud of the academic achievement of their students and their vigorous grading system where a 91 is a B+ the SAT is the only required test that we do at the high school for students and as I'm sure you all can guess the scores are very high at our school those 1,100 students in the Arts at PHS mentioned earlier represent

047around 65% of our student body and that means it wouldn't be surprising then to see a notable decline in perisburg SAT scores SAT scores impact College admission and scholarship opportunities I a member of our high school's theater leadership team which I've been on since 2023 I have learned to be better at planning creating advertising hosting events speaking to a crowd and giving back to my peers and Community yesterday in fact we had a Holiday Helper event which we organized where we supported four children for the holidays we were able to fundraise through winter 1X casting through by having each person bring in $2 to go towards getting the children their presents if you've seen WEA you know they are student directed and that students take on the whole production team the winner 1X are also

048an opportunity for people who have never done theater before and want to try it out or they've had trouble getting into the player musical students are learning such valuable skills and getting to experience a new side of theater that they may have never gotten to before taking away the winter onea is going to have a tremendous impact in our on our theater department and US students theater is a place where at the end of the day you can come together to do something you're all passion about and make new friends friends are so important research by Dr shirle Bryce Heath of Stanford University shows that young people who are actively engaged in the Arts learning and arts production improve their self-esteem and confidence assume leadership roles and improve their school's overall performance what's interesting is

049Dr Heath wasn't studying the Arts rather studying after school programs her data revealed a remarkable outlier of Effectiveness which turned out to be the Arts cuts to the school's Arts will negatively impact the present and future of our students their careers and our community please make sure our community and government officials understand the implications and please prioritize the budget to preserve student development especially in the Arts thank [Applause] you thank you Miss Jones next the board recognizes James AER Miller I'm James Austin Miller um live in Wexford Drive perisburg my background is is a CPA and also a state auditor having audited for the state of Ohio 13 years to little Public Schools three times and many other schools in the district so I think I know something maybe I don't but anyhow I put

050together a cash projection as given uh the board meeting and based on that on the project cast projection I took in the reduction of the $6 million and took the expenditures at the 25-year level the same with that the school will have a $112 million cash Reserve in 2026 sufficient a sufficient Reserve to run the school so that means everything is fine of that 12% represents the expenditures of $80 million going further there is an implied contract legally I don't know how legal it is here that you're going to educate the students by doing a rift you're breaking that contract going on there was mention of the levies the two levies 2019 and 2024 were risk levies they should never have been one Levy there should have been two levies an incremental Levy and an

051increase in Levy the same way in 24 there should have been an incre a current Levy and an increase in Levy that's risky Management on the part of the management of the school district so that's all I have to say I'm the financial guy so that's it thank you Mr aill final speaker for tonight is the board recognizes Jeremy block good evening my name is Jeremy BL I have three students that uh attend perisburg uh schools um I come here as a parent who was disappointed that the levy failed um but I also want to state that I understand why people are opposed to it so I kind of ride that line I wanted it to pass because despite how much money I felt it was I thought it was what was best for our

052kids um I want to start with two observations and I want to do this to preface my question at the end so my first observation is I work in the private sector but in the private sector when a bunch of people show up to a meeting that don't normally show up typically means I'm not doing my job well right or I'm doing something wrong so it's clear to me that something's wrong here right I don't come to a lot of these I really was hoping not to ever have to come to one of these but here I am second observation as a manager when things aren't going well and you have problems My Philosophy has always been it starts with me what am I doing wrong the problem starts with me so I only bring

053this up so you guys have a sense of humility going into this I hope that you guys also feel you have a sense of responsibility this Levy situation um my question or my ask is and and I've I'm concerned about a lot of the cuts but a lot of people are more qualified to speak to that than me the one I want to speak to is the rezoning of the elementary schools districts um I know not a lot of has come out on it just yet I hope more information comes out my ask is before a decision is made I hope that you reach out to the community specifically me I would love to be involved I speak for my whole neighborhood who could potentially be red redistricted uh so I hope that you reach

054out to us offer Solutions if it's truly a financial concern which I don't believe it is but if it is I think we could have a discussion and find ways to uh get past that because I think our students are the ones who are failing um and are losing here um and so we need to work harder to make sure it doesn't get to the students it stops here that's all thank you thank you Mr BL so I will again on behalf of the board thank all of the speakers tonight for for the feedback for the comments the Board needs to hear this feedback we've been getting a lot of emails as well if somebody is sitting in here and and and you know and as spurred of thought please send that email to us

055this is not going to be the last time we do public comment we'll be talking again in a regular meeting in January and there will be opportunity for public comment there but againe appreciate the thought and the comments and the passion and the tone with which those were delivered so thank you we're going to take a two-minute break in case anybody wants to sneak out now before the board goes into its discussion but we'll reconvene pretty quickly so we are uh in recess again e e e all right I'm going to bring us back into session here so next item is the board discussion follow up on the Thursday special meeting on on the comments that we just heard as appropriate uh related to to these materials in this work we have in front of

056us you know from my perspective just to kick off the discussion there's a lot a lot of discussion a lot of feedback to hear to assimilate to consider I'm not going to be one that's proposing or I suggest we're not proposing any action at this meeting tonight what I am proposing is that we discuss any other additional comments questions and direction that we want the administ ation to look into for us on some of these topics that we have in front of us and these topics are based off of discussions I've had with Tom and Randy and and and some of you that have been engaged in the process to talk about what is at least I'll call it the most time-sensitive of issues to discuss so we're going to start with these I know

057that in the materials is last Thursday's presentation as well for reference so going down the list kind with that context we'll start with you discussions about the facility use and in light of that discussion last Thursday um we've got the facilities that are generally open up to the open to the community we've got pressures on our custodial staff we've got you know pressures on uh other staff opening closing cleaning those buildings so with that I'm going to open it up to the board to start there we can take this in any order you want I'm trying to put a a little bit of structure around this so I'll keep going then I'll buy you some more time so I don't think so my position this is not a matter of if this is a matter

058of when um and how to do it so this is not something that that I think you know certainly on December whatever the date is today 16th that the board can say we're we're we're close closing the we're closing the buildings to outside organizations on one one I I that that doesn't work so what I'm interested in is what is you know what how do we have these conversations with the impacted groups to turn around and say okay is it March is it June is it next school year so I'm kind of interested in the in the when having the administration talk about the when as well as the you know how is that going to look how is that going to work okay well it seems to me that it is one area that

059doesn't affect our students directly it seems like an area where we could at least as I understand it we could at least temporarily close our building to outside groups except I I would I would go the full monty I'd say morning noon and night to the outside groups um um if that can save a teacher a program a sport theater if something like that would help do that I would I would rather you know to all my friends who are members of BNI I apologize but you know something's got to give and I would rather give there than taking away some of our programs that as oh dear I'd have to look at it again I think it was uh Miss Kelly that said that um our our schools are distinguishable in the offerings that

060we have and the things that we provide for our students and the extra mile that we go and that that was painful for me to hear because it's that extra mile that has to go if that if something as simple as simple nothing in this business is simple but is something as simple as that closing this off to outside groups so that our over taxed custodial staff and operations staff doesn't have to deal with that I think I think that makes a lot of sense I mean we've got to have a custodian here tonight to put all these all these years away to redo these tables um if BNI I was coming in the next morning which they they're not but if there's a group that's coming in here the next morning then they've got

061to be here until whenever we leave to change everything over that's that's a lot to ask when they've got other buildings that they have to clean that to me it seems like a simple thing to help us stretch this six million so that it it's not affecting our students so I'm I'm full in favor of not just 6:30 and Beyond but the whole time I think what I heard most clearly on Thursday night that is leading to this topic was um Mr Bloomer and Mr Ma's concerns that we are of the six positions we were are cutting in the custodial staff that five are now already vacant that that that that shift isn't going to wait until next fall that that shift has already happened even before we H January um so knowing that um

062as much as students are being impacted by these reductions we also know that staff is having to absorb all of the work of the staff that we cutting I want to be cognizant of the custodian needs at this time I am I also though want to be able to honor if we can agreements that we already have for building use um you know people have planned based on our agreement that they could use our facilities so I realize things have changed but I I don't want to I'm not sure I'm supportive of a full blanket decision that would just cut everyone off without looking at each individual um circumstance I appreciate that we can I'm not sure exactly if the reasoning of the 4:30 to 6:30 is still allowing but I assume that that's because

063we feel like we can still handle it at that time and I like that because it supports a lot of the student groups that may be meeting in our building afterwards I'm guessing things like Girl Scouts and Boy Scouts and some of the other um student organizations that do meet here or in our buildings after um I'd like to you know consider not maybe the immediate decision is not to accept any more applications for building use at this time um that would be one thing that I think would be fair um I think also in talking with Mr Bloomer and Mr mapus that um with not having the substitutes with not having the extra staff to kind of spread out that I do think we need to look at Sundays not no one including school

064activities being in our buildings on Sunday so that the custodial staff can actually have off and I think we need to look at our holidays to ask um custodians when everyone else is off to come in on the 26th the 27th for instance this month again when we're already asking them to pick up the work of at least one person in their building being um cut I I think we need to look at those decisions and honestly if it impacts things like practice I would also argue that students need some time off too um so they're the things that I um I I do want to make move to respond because we already are in this situation of over taxing our custodians we charge I'm sorry we don't take comments from the um Doge exteral

065we do not generally so going along with what you were saying um I would like to we talked about this Sunday than and having it um you know closed off but then if we do have and this was going along with the question um find out what the cost is the actual cost it is for the custodial for the electricity for all of that and and if somebody wants to use that facility if that's the road that we go if it's an outside facility that they pay for the use of the building I know other school districts do that um it might be cost prohibitive for some people once they figure out exactly especially if it's a sun and it's a holiday and how much that's going to cost I would like to look possibly

066at that too um as a possibility you know for some of our um groups have been using our buildings for a long time well that was something that Mr Bloomer was worried about because of the reduction of staff and the fact that they're going to be drastically overwork they're already refusing these extra um extra jobs that normally they would have jumped on but like Susan said you know you need you need needs some downtime um I like your idea of not accepting any more applications I was basically looking at this when I hear the 6 million Cuts I'm thinking the start of next school year because the money that we're using from our savings is getting us through this year so I'm when I'm saying no more school school use I am thinking about when

067this the $6 million cut starts and I use that in quotes um because as as um Mr Bloomer already pointed out there he and other groups are already feeling the reductions and not rehires or you know in retirements not filling excuse me filling positions sorry about my voice um I'm going to go into my sexy grvy voice before the end of the night I'm sure um so yeah I I I should have clarified and I and I didn't so it was a good catch right well any other any other comments thoughts a few on this um I am not opposed to looking at the um basically other groups looking at the share of cost of custodian um there might be a minimum that we have to have and there might be also a Max um

068this is a department that we I feel it's like the largest cut that we've made with within one Department um and I do question whether or not we've cut too much because of the conversations that we have had especially setting in operations that they're already over taxed and we haven't even gotten into winter and all the issues that come with winter um I think this is a great conversation to sit down and have with the community members who are involved in these groups and also asking them to step up and help with some of the responsibilities if they do want to use a building and what it's going to take for them to do addressing you know issues when they come up with them giving them warnings training chain of command um and I I

069agree with Susan that I think taking Sundays and holidays out and making sure that our staff does have some time off and is is not dreading their job is very important important so Mr Hower next actions you know in kind of working through that the the key Community groups that are in there and thinking through a proposal as to you know the when and the how and and how much sure um you know we could begin to to kind of craft based on the feedback what that would look like you know as a district I think we've been a very strong partner with the Community groups um I think a lot of people don't realize that you know when when we talk about you know Junior jackets or bidy wrestling or some of those kind

070of perisburg musical theater that's here um you know and sometimes we have to close the door to the board meetings because the different activities that are happening just in this building um those groups are are you know the participants it's a great thing that they're doing and we work really hard with them to keep the cost down and so for those groups we charge them generally when we incur an expense when it comes to Staffing so if they're going to be here on a Saturday in the commodor building for example then we're going to charge them for that person because we don't have someone here um probably a decade ago to help out with this at the Junior High in high school we shifted a custodian's hours to go from Tuesday to Saturday so that

071there would be a custodian on a regular shift on Saturday so all those groups using those buildings on Saturdays didn't incur any overtime time and you heard uh Mr Bloomer and and uh Mr mapus talk about how that position is a hard one to maintain and and with the loss that we have they haven't filled that so we're beginning to you know you know what we can continue to do um you know is still try to work with them those outside groups but what how we've done it in the past and we're very fortunate that we've been able to do those kinds of things for these groups because who ends up paying are those participants the families the kids the um and so moving forward you know it's it's what I heard the board kind

072of saying is it's not sustainable the way we're doing it today so what is that balance and I think that's a term that we're going to try to use a lot this evening is what is that balance between what we can support um you know financially um and we heard the conversation on Thursday night where it's not only the Manpower of going down you know from to to clean up after the groups but it's the bathrooms and the things the paper the soap all the kinds of things that go into it um and and um you know managing that a little differently is it will be our kind of marching orders is to try to find that balance um and and uh we'll be prepared to come back with the board with some some thoughts

073and some concrete times I think we look at each building I think we look at the activities that are there and what I heard the board say was um you know we want to do the best we can to honor what we have um already committed to um but you know but also try to thread that needle and find that balance with our staff and what we can you know sustain this year in in the current form so so we'll get to work on that and and bring that back to the board next month so move on to Elementary boundaries again context of that as as the Administration was digging deeper into where we can continue to save money it was becoming apparent that there are certainly some some opportunities for efficiencies that come along

074with with taking a look at how neighborhoods are um neighborhoods are mapped to the elementary schools for me you know this was a new this is this is a new thought this is not something we were talking about in October it's a natural outcry of saying the natural natural result of saying you know what else can we do what else can we do let's continue to dig let's continue to turn over different rocks this to me though right now H and I know the administration is starting to work on it but haven't seen kind of the total impact from a dollar standpoint haven't seen a the impact of the neighborhoods that are being mapped as one of the speakers said tonight we haven't done any of the community engagement work that I agree with that

075I think is necessary for this board to have a real thoughtful um discussion about whether not this is something that should be pursued but at this point too I think we need to pursue it to answer those type of questions so there you go I just bought you all time to think and and make your comments I'll open it up to you guys well everyone's thinking um Mr Hustler could you explain a little bit more um both for our benefit but also I've received some questions about this and I think there's a significant misunderstanding about how we are currently making decisions about where students go and why our bus routes look nutty um can you can you talk a little bit about how that is being done right now and therefore what if we um

076rebounded the elementaries what wouldn't be happening in the future um sure um so we you know um so we have four elementary schools and um you know the you know Frank and to Elementary both built in the 1950s were the first you know elementary schools and um you know that that were outside this complex right here and so they're built a half a mile apart and when they were built perisburg was just literally the boundaries the roads the boundaries and um and and so that worked well as the community you know expanded beyond the boundaries uh the next Elementary was Woodland uh and Then followed by um Fort Megs in the early 19 you know in the mid 1990s early 1990s so um so that boundary when it when when Fort Megs went online were

077pretty much what you would expect with what a neighborhood uh school and and what Elementary braries look like like so this area all goes to that elementary and that area goes to that Elementary as the community began to expand Beyond you know in the 1990s and into the 2000s um a lot of the growth began to shift more towards the lvis commons the perisburg HPI High School area um so that is where the growth is is happening so what's happened over time is we have been redistricting um and and so what I mean by that is when a neighborhood is in the fort Megs area for example um Fort Megs is full uh we brought in uh trailers Fort Megs became full again so the next plat in that neighborhood so the houses in the

078back of the neighborhood when those get finished they're not going to Fort Megs they're driving past Fort Megs and going to the building where we have room and sometimes they might pass to other elementary schools um so that is a form of redistricting so we're redistricting you know without having to do it for the entire Community but neighborhoods and and now we're even getting into some situations where if a house sells that is in one area if we have a bus from another school that has room that that family moving into that home that was at that Elementary now may be attending that other one because that's where we are in terms of enrollment so the on the screen here you begin to see these are actual bus routes r with stops and you can

079see where they're literally on top of each other or you know buses are crisscrossing um and then if you kind of highlight that you know kind of blow it up a little bit you literally will see you know three different elementaries at a corner are the same street and so we understand that re reconfiguring the elementary boundaries is a huge deal for families for staff for the community and we have been doing it this way because we we knew that at some point we're going to be needing to build a new elementary school and when we do that that makes perfect sense to do the big redistricting one time and then and then you know set the balances right across the the four or five elementaries depending on you know the issue that was approved

080by the voters so the November last year plan was to expand our buildings keep the four building footprint for elementaries um that uh to and uh Frank being so close together really hurts us in many respects and um and and you know clearly that didn't happen um so there is no plans in the future to to build a new Elementary I mean that process has not begun the reason why the you know if you go back and watch the board discussions as you know one of the reasons why the 8-year window was desired is it would give the board and the schools time to engage the community during that eight period and say okay we have stable funding for the next eight years let's have the conversation about where do where do we what do

081we do with our our elementary schools and growth and all those kinds of things so now we don't have the stable funding in addition to having you know that that conversation lined up so um as we began to you know ask staff to find dollars there was a huge uh area of opportunity in terms of you know transportation and not only does it do that but it would allow us to possibly redraw the boundaries to not only save the routing information which we shared I believe last time that it a minimum of $100,000 a year but also if we reconfigure the boundaries to align with some of the intersections where we have crossing guards and having that be the boundary that could reduce those costs um and it also balances and you heard that on

082on Thursday night it balances the buildings a little bit better so that you know we don't have six sections of one grade in one building and three sections in another building because that isn't uh necessarily an efficient way um to to operate those buildings uh so so all of those things kind of lined up and said well let's have the conversation with the board um when you're opening up a new building you have kind of a longer Runway to begin to have those conversations with the community um to to do those things which you know clearly are important on Thursday we talked about if we were to do this um we would begin to gather that information um begin to look at you know those hard costs to see if it's worth that Pursuit and

083then begin to engage the community here we said we would generate some options uh roll those out go to each Elementary building in the evening engage with parents show them the different options collect feedback um and then bring that back to the board and say here's what we heard you know here's what we adjusted and if the board were to choose to do that this is what it could look like um you know it's it's a it's when you're building a new building and and you re redoing the boundaries um again you've got time why that building is being built when you're doing it to reduce costs it's it's a different situation entirely um the other piece of it is right now we have scheduled you know to add um trailers to certain classrooms as

084we continue to grow um to buildings for additional classrooms by rebalancing we can kick that out a little further so that is you know another savings as well so so bringing it here is not um you know we understand the you know Mr BL spoke and talked about you know we we have have questions and we understand that this is a a huge conversation with the community um but we're bringing it here because we understand that there there's potential savings not only today but in the future um and and it's worth the discussion um so um how how again we have back in the old days you had pins and maps and redistricting with routing was was a very comp you know very timec consuming today um there's some different software Suites that you can

085enter things and just to get kind of a glimpse and and we shared that with um you know so this is our current enrollment um and then this was this this is not this is taking everything we have not even rolling up the students which would influence so you know you roll when you do this for real you would roll up the students who are moving into the buildings who are moving out you know and and design your bus routes but this could show exactly you know with with a very quick without setting any guidelines just what it would look like so this is more or less for visual purposes um you can see Frank and Toth how that is a challenge having those two buildings close together when growth is occurring and elsewhere we'd

086also um you know be attentive to the fact that whatever we do we want to set it up in a way that when the community gives the green light to build a new Elementary in the future that they can take whatever is designed and and easily adapt that to to um fit a new Elementary if they wanted to keep you know a footprint of four or add a fifth Elementary um so so that's kind of you know how that conversation began on October 88th um we did not this wasn't part of the conversation um but as we've begun to dug dig into you know our operations our cost all those kinds of things um when we've challenged staff it it's come back well if you're asking the question here is something to to consider so

087and that's what led us to this place I'd like to continue to move down the path of looking into it I still think there's a as I said earlier a lot of uh things to consider before we go there but when I hear the trailers alone million dollars low side at least raises my curiosity to want to continue that discussion right um you know and right now there's legislation pending you know in in this uh lame duck session that could impact Transportation um you know so we're watching that very closely that could have a further impact because right now the staff has done a tremendous job of getting getting enough drivers for us and and we're we're in an enviable position um the reductions here would further reduce their hours which might make them vulnerable

088to go elsewhere where there might be more hours so when we talk about the savings I just want to be clear that it's savings on the back of you know what we're paying staff um to change routes to to have fewer routes um so um but then has its own implications on hiring and keeping staff right and and possibly with the changes that might be coming um you know with some legislation you know and and you don't want to react until it happens but that they could make you know those those drivers we have will be put to use going outside the district um not serving our students so that that's something we're watching closely so can you refresh us on what that legislation is because I believe it's lame duck as they're looking to

089pass it by the end of the week um so um what it what it um there there's some bills that are there and things have been added to the to the bills and this piece of legislation um we have students that live in perisburg who attend other um private and Charter Schools outside of perisburg this law that was passed in the 1960s in Ohio says that public school districts are responsible to bus students within a 30m radius of their home so 30 mi from you know perisburg there are over 70 Charter and private schools depending on where you live in perisburg so we have the right to deem some of those in Practical so if you have one student attending a charter or private school in downtown Toledo and it is within that 30 minutes

090for us to take a a bus pay a driver to transport that one student is very expensive for the district because we have to pay that every District does so what we can do now is deem that to be um impractical it's not practical to take one student with one bus and a bus driver to do that the legislation says any student who is a non- perisburg res a non- perisburg uh student who is on an IEP um so think about a student that might be receiving speech services attending a charter private school that perisburg schools would have to provide transportation and not deem those students impractical so that would be potentially an additional don't quote on the numbers um approximately 50 students that that you know we would have to provide busing for going

091outside perisburg schools um that we could not deem impractical and there's other legislation that talks about that we have to have them delivered within a certain time window of their bell schedule regardless of our bell schedule so we're watching that carefully um we've been speaking with our state legislators had a conversation with representative gambari who's very responsive to hearing about these things and uh you know so we're keeping our fingers crossed so so we're watching that thank you um I would like to say that I understand especially as a parent how important structure is and especially to kids schedules and their day I think I don't see where this is out of the question in the future because we are in a growing district and there's going to be changes occurring constantly and also we

092have aging buildings and with the current rules and standards with ofcc which is the Ohio facilities commiss uh construction commission There are rules that weren't there back when these buildings were built in terms of how much land you have to have if you build a new building so going forward there's going to be a point where if we take down a building there's not going to be a building going back there in the same spot looking at that we need to understand especially as parents our reaction to our children is going to have an impact on them so please be positive about this going forward with them and let them know that this is part of life you need to learn how to roll with the punch and maybe you're going to be meeting some

093kid at another school that you're going to end up being best buddies with and we're all in the same Community they might also be in Girl Scouts together or Boy Scouts together even though they live on the other side of of the community you might still be seeing your friend from one thing or another this does have a very large impact on the cost of fuel the number of bus routes so that's the cost for salaries with drivers and support staff that might need to go on these buses um over the past I think I can easily say 15 years um we've had a within Northwest Ohio we've had a shortage of bus drivers if you talk to any District you'll find that this is one of their number one concerns and especially with the

094legislation that's going on everybody's concerned about it um um I also see with the development in our area the traffic impact safety impact um The Balancing of classes and grade levels at our schools and not having to do trailers you look at the cost of trailers and it's just it's outrageous and these are something that's only temporary trailers do not last very long I think I think it's safe to say trailer life is like 15 20 years Max expected life's 10 okay so expected life's 10 um and if you want to throw in some other stuff just for the fun of it think of the environmental impact also so I know the with the redistricting we haven't done it in was 10 years ago it'll be 10 years ago April I believe I don't I

095don't think we've done it since I've been here so I think the previous superintendent we had talked about it because I know that we had pretty much we were about three years into our um neighborhood and there was big talk about it because I know working in my day job um we redistricted in that in 2011 and it was very um thoughtful it was a lot of work it was a lot of like what you know Laura said you know kids are resilient um and it it has to happen sometime it can't just kept being pushed out pushed out not that it's going to happen right now but it is something that we do need to look at um and obviously we would not do it with without input from the community y I think

096we were redistricted when when my son was entering second grade so that would have been I don't know that math is a little Beyond me right now but was5 um so 204 I think 2004 and yeah he he met new kids and and then he saw them all at the junior high again well we avoided having to redistrict when we opened Prairie because what we did is we pulled fifth grade out of every Elementary which created space space um and then we were able to you know continue with the boundaries we have knowing at some point in the future we would need another Elementary and we were really just trying to tread water until we did that one time you know um so so there was a redistricting of sorts it just created space in

097each of the elementaries but now we're you know at capacity again without that grade level being there so well and again you have more um time and and more ability to communicate in even a better case when you're opening up a new building versus the situation we're in now yeah I think the the cost savings I mean I think there was been several calls to try to look under rocks and come up with some Creative Solutions and again there's a there's an impact but I think the amount of money that could be potentially saved here is certainly worth pursuing yeah so let's lock down the the the the hard costs and then also probably a community engagement plan would be the two things I think the board's interested in hearing right I know Dublin City

098Schools is uh just went through it or finalizing it for the beginning of next school year um after our meeting on Thursday it popped up in the news so obviously you know something's listening but duin City schools and they had a whole plan and you know what I mean I saw that yeah I mean nobody wants it to happen but um it was very thoughtful and how they did it I thought that was interesting it might be something to look at okay going to move into the HPI schedule the reduced Day thoughts there somebody else can go first on this one I think this is one of those where I trust and I've spoken with a couple administrators that this really has been looked at that the schedule's been turned inside out upside down and

099um with the changes in the electives with the way that they have structured the schools that the best thing for the students right now actually would be to to pursue this um I think there's been you know some conversation about other options but it sounds like most of those have been considered um it it is interesting to me that they have far more days over the state requirements than any other building so terms of hours and therefore days so that would bring them in alignment with the other buildings as well and so at a time also again when we're asking staff to absorb more and more it makes sense to bring them an alignment with others and also take some of that off the staff as well if we go forward with this I'd like

100to see the staff and Administration use this in a positive way with um teacher in service curriculum development all that other fun lovely stuff that we have to do you're asking how how reducing the day would impact those so it do it does create I think what you're asking is it does create a day that we will have staff contracted so without the students there doesn't mean the staff go home so what we can do is begin to line up those those professional development learning opportunities that today for example we're pulling teachers out of school to to get that training with our language arts training that's happening districtwide if we can line up some of those kinds of activities on those days that could result in further cost savings when it would come to um

101you know hiring subs and and lining those things up so we would Circle those dates on the calendar to try to maximize that um so that isn't leaving and and doing that we've cut a lot of those budgets anyway um but there's still some training that you know we need to do we have to do and this might create that natural time and break to do that so um so that that's how that day could be used with staff um with what we have to do okay Tom have you heard any feedback from either Mr Scott or um or Mr Scott Mr best um or the or the staff I mean how do they feel about doing that um you know I know I know Mr best is here I know that um you know

102they've um talked about it at the Thursday meeting and and um there are functions that begin to to have to happen um and you kind of got a taste of that with the principal kind of explaining how their schedule works so when you eliminate on the screen these exploratory electives so each of those electives that are there imagine 30 students that are in that room and then if you eliminate those then what where do those students go and so that that is what if you recall that's kind of what he talked about that um you know the loss of those sections is creating an environment where we don't have room to we don't have a place to send students so shortening the school day eliminates that what to do with 900 students at the end

103of the day um and and I'm I'm kind of doing a um Mile High description but on Thursday he went into a little more depth on that so if you recall and if I recall they talked about Transportation too and how it would stop the what do they call three tier routes so the high school you know it' give a little bit bit more leeway so people were home earlier or less routes and less back and forth with cost savings for transportation right the um the start of the day is is pretty easy uh for transportation you can very easily say okay we're going to pick up this grade at this time drop them off and then the starting time of the next day the next building is at this time and you can set

104those up very carefully challenge we have is on the afternoon because each level has a different duration for their day so the elementary day is the shortest day um the high school is the longest day so when you're doing those tiers um it's not as neat as it is at the front end where you can set a 30 minute or 45 minute gap between the bells to start the day because that way you can guarantee the buses are arriving on time on the flip side each of those school days are longer than than the others so it's not as neat so what ends up happening by changing this it creates a little bit of cushion where we're not pressed for that bus to to have to drop off and get back out there because that

105day is longer for them at HPI and the elementary day is shorter so that creates that and that's what he was explaining why transportation said this would help us out because it creates that breathing room where they're not drop and go and get on that next next TI um but the loss of instructional time is we have these things here because they're great for kids and kids get to explore they get to unplug and and it's part of that stem experience as Scott mentioned so um it it it there's an impact with this and and he alluded to that so I I mean I agree with Miss Roland Miller too I know I mean hearing the thought process that's gone into that that feels like one I mean I don't have any more to add

106to this discussion uh student instructional days probably along those same lines too another one that you know we are above the the state required minimum and hours that need to be taught and and with the budget constraints ahead of us this is one that just generally when we go to work on the uh 20206 academic calendar year makes sense to me it it's interesting um you know this this allows one additional day in a quarter and we could bring that to the board to modify the school calendar you know beginning in January or February so that that is something we could plug in you know moving forward um as a superintendent in Michigan um during that um you know in the early 2000s the automotive industry was struggling and um the legislature there changed it

107from days to to ours which Ohio followed suit um and school districts that were struggling struggling financially and in Michigan school districts could not go to local voters for additional funding came directly from the state so when the tax um levels fell in Michigan there was no money coming in and school districts couldn't go to their communities and ask so you had school districts that began to drop significantly the student number days um you know where it used to be like 180 um and there were districts that went to 4 day weeks or you know four instructional days had staff in on Fridays and um dropped to 160 to 165 instructional days um we had some people that emailed and said have you thought about going to 4day days and and um that's not something

108that you know I think would be good academically um here also would affect a lot of Working Families so um you know so I know that that question has come up and people who live in other states have seen that happen and has driven that question but that's not you know that's not where we're heading at this time um you know in the future this this is an area where you know $44,000 of savings per day and again that's on the backs of AIDS and bus drivers and folks that come to school when students are there and when students aren't there they're not working so just that's where that those dollars come from so keep that in mind so for those not in a school setting can you clarify um the difference between we used

109to have the what like when we went from Calamity days snow days to hours and that this state requires a certain amount right and so that's why you see such a big difference because of the uh hours that kids are in attendance sure so a number of years ago we had uh a minimum of 180 school days and and we would have and don't quote me on this but let's say 83 instructional days so we were over a few instructional days and um the state changed this to hours and they set hours based on um you know the grade level bands so as you pointed out fifth and sixth grade is set on the sixth grade which is 678 hour requirement which is more than the fifth grade elementary so that's why they're so far

110over um you know in some cases um but at any rate when because our school day days were longer than the typical school day when they converted even though we were at 183 days um our hours were much longer and that's what you're seeing calculated you know out here so now we have to keep track of hours um and and then we converted it here to our school days so so if you you know um the old days if you got you know less than you know if you had more if you used all five snow days you had to make it up so so that fist snow day was really a big deal when you got there now it's instructional hours and you can see that we're we're well over and um you know

111uh the only time we would worry is half day kindergarten if we made this adjustment um you know they would be at you know we could only have four four hours or four day 4.64 um you know um days for those so if we had five snow days they would be having to make up time at the half day kindergarten level but with the switch to full day kindergarten um we only have one roughly one section of half day kindergarten across the district thank you so more to come on that as we fill in the calendar for the next academic year takes us to the 2025 Levy consideration again another conversation that there will be several more of these in the I'm going to say the coming weeks potentially because this one is certainly time

112time sensitive um two opportunities to put a levy on in 2025 one being May one being November and if we want to do something in May you know we've got a lot of discussions that we need to have between now and first week of February when that ballot language has to be submitted to the board of election um again I guess I'll say I'll say it again to me this is for 2025 not a matter of if in my mind it's a matter of when and how much um I do reflect back on you know the decision that the board made back in November and you do this long enough and you hear the community says just tell us what you want tell us what you need um what we were all trying to avoid

113was the $6 million were the cuts that we have right now so there was certainly the thought that a straightup renewal we'd still be having the last two meetings we've had talking about $6 million wor the cuts and that's where we are today but also you know and now it is and now it is recognizing you know what we've heard there is a need to stop the bleeding in my opinion what is that amount that we need to stop the bleeding and more importantly as importantly what is the amount that will pass because what does keep me up at night now is is you know in addition to these 6 million worth of cuts is the 13 a half or so I'll Randy will tweak my numbers here as we go but it's the next

114round of cuts it's the next round of cuts at the administration is probably going to start talking about here early 2025 we probably wouldn't even even we probably may not have taken a lot of action on the Six Million we're talking about and we'll start talking very quickly about What the deeper next round looks like and the best way to avoid that is one way to avoid that is a levy I say the best way there's no best way here but you know so I think it is you know it is the work of the the biggest concerns of the three conversations we've got to have the what are the big thoughts on the $6 Million worth of cuts in that direction back there what is the what is the 13 and a half or

115so million dollars were the cuts that are coming and then what do we do about the levy and that because of the time sensitivity of that one you know we as a board need to talk about how we're going to talk about that know if that's more special meetings if people want to put their you know put their cards on the table right now if we need to ask the administration to go back and kind of color in the numbers a little bit more we did just approve a five-year budget that had a levy assumption in there is that is that the right number is that the number we want to do is that the number we think we can pass so um but I do believe and and I'm o I'm open right now

116I'm you know knowing that time isn't my friend I'm open to what that right answer is I'm open from the community I got a lot of that I got some of that feedback tonight as to where we need to go and I appreciate that I'm listening to that you know want to hear more of that because at the end of the day for me it is what will pass what will pass so you know and adding to what we talked about when we put the levy on and pardon my saying but you're damned if you do and you're damned if you don't because it was people telling us that Levy burnout and putting something on the ballot every two years to get what we needed why aren't new new construction new homes being taxed and

117that's what the incremental takes into consideration um school funding and finance is a beast of its own it no matter how much you see it no matter how many classes you take on it no matter how many things you see there's there's always something new it's not just like your household budget um you look at what the funds are were we talking about the house floor or whatever moving it back to 2021 um Levy or state financing bringing us back to 2021 levels at the State uh the way the state funding formula is and you'll hear me say this day in and day out almost 30 years ago it was ruled unconstitutional the way schools were funded and nothing has changed at the state level in 30 years so wealthier districts are considered or are

118made to rely on local money um and then you look in the again look in the news and what was it the private or the public school money going to private school vouchers how much money went that year this year you know out of public school funds so there's a lot out there um to grasp and to understand so I I honestly I don't I don't even know what the right answer is at this point you have people on this side telling you this people on this side telling you this and you're not voting for this unless it looks like that I don't know how we come to a consensus in the community you know obviously part of it has to do with with the city um you know I think they relegated too many

119rezoned too many uh commercial and farm to residential and now they're seeing what that what that is happening um we are not Rossford talking to a friend who lives in Rossford you know we don't have Amazon we don't have um it's a First Solar you know we don't even have I don't even know if we'd be able to recoup that and you had the information you put in there I think I saw something somewhere about what'll what'll happen if there is that Top Golf that comes um into the area it's still not I mean it's not going to be the you know the the golden coin that's going to solve everybody's everybody's issues what what commercial development does is shifts the burden from the residential it doesn't necessarily change the funding for the district it

120just shifts the burden so a top golf obviously would generate some new Revenue because we're at the 20 mil floor but it it but it would the other levies it would shift the burden a little bit to them now we're $ 1.4 billion doll in valuation you know so a top golf is three and A5 million in valuation it doesn't it doesn't move the needle right it all adds up we want it we we want those you know you know I want commercial development from my perspective in order to help reduce the burden off the homeowners you know we're 80% funded by residential Roser is about 5050 and and Amazon doesn't vote right so don't bring kids so we like sh we like Shifting the burden so that's a good thing so we we appreciate

121it but you got to keep that in perspective I mean our new construction does it help certainly there's a reason why our incremental Levy finished at 9.75 Ms 6 Ms below what was expected when it was put on the ballot because of growth right you know and even if you look at today you know I put in the forecast the $14 million Levy that's probably equal to or less than the cost of the 13 half million Levy right cuz valuations already gone up so the millage is going to be about the same so you know obviously don't know what that is until we actually run the numbers but you're not talking about huge shifts right and and it's just it's circular I mean it's state level it's the city it's the district it's it just

122keeps going you know you look at um the land over at Five Point uh by St John you know that was commercial and they rezoned it to residential and that's still being built and it's going to affect us down the road if I'm correct I believe Brook brought something up about what those units are that aren't even built yet and here and here's a brutal facts and you guys familiar with it our school funding in Ohio is what it is right and and the great organizations realize that and we're going tojust we're going into a budget battle in the spring I know I'm gearing up I've already got testimony worked up and had conversations with already because you're exactly right that what's going to happen in the spring this is looking at my crystal ball

123is the legislator is going to say we don't have enough money to fund the formula so they're not going to update the base cost now that's not Woe Is Us we're not going to lose any funding but we're not going to gain any funding right we're going to go on to the guarantee and we'll be we'll stay at 2020 State funding even though how many students have we added since fiscal year 20 330 350 more than that right so our state funding is going to be we're not going to lose State funding we're just going to go farther and farther than guaranteed like every other District so we're going to go from formula funded if they don't update the base cost part of it because what happens is that they update the wealth side of

124it but they don't update the cost side of it so it's it's an imbalance so that's the that's the fact now I can tell you our professional associations are willing to battle we need you to help and we can criticize a little bit you know of um representative gambari but he fought for the formula now we know that formula cost us vouchers right we weren't going to get the formula without vouchers that was just a reality in the last general assembly and it's still that way because most people 90% of kids go to public schools but parent and families aren't voting in their self-interest and it's it's a top agenda for the Senate President to continue to privatize so I think you know so the crystal ball is a little cloudy um and what we

125do know is what is you know seated before us on the table and and that is you know we have some some deadlines that you know and we have a permanent Improvement Levy that is also set to expire um and we've renewed that roughly renew or replace every 5 years since 1980 so that has to become part of the conversation too um that can't be used for operations it can't be used for people it can be used for roofs and boilers and windows but not people so the board you know has a couple of you know um decision points ahead um you know the first decision point is do we go on the ballot yes or no um and if the answer is yes then that decision Point becomes well then what do we go

126on the ballot with what is the amount and this chart kind of shows kind of into two different paths it shows the Assumption made with the 5year forecast um you know $14 million um and you know 13 a half went away so this is $14 million so that basically covers that the $6 million of reductions that we're talking about would stay in place so when we talk about that incremental Levy um you know a renewal isn't just you know a renewal is is a redu reduction and it's no growth moving forward so this 14 you know million dollar um that was part of the fiveyear forecast assumption shows what that cash balance would be and then you see highlighted the two months true day cash so what that means is that when you hit that

127amount that is two months worth of operation saved the district has two paydays a year roughly and you see those Peaks each year here and then it's in between those Peaks that we need to have a certain cash balance to avoid borrowing money to pay for the light bills or or to make payroll so the question is you know what what is that sweet spot in terms of what is it that the community do we think that the community would approve and if it's below that 14 million then we're talking about further reductions why we're asking the voters to approve a levy um unless we fall below that that you know two months true day cash and then we're we're you know we're operating paycheck to paycheck to kind of compare it to a home

128situation where we might run out of money one month um depending on that so if it's zero do we run out of cash and you see that um and the amount of reductions would be um I mean you know I we we'll talk about that so but if it's 14 million the 6 million Cuts stay certainly the board could reconfigure what those look like but we would need $6 million to stay out of the budget that we have now identified to be reduced and if it's between Z and 14 we have to cut that difference if I'm I'm taking a little bit of Liberty with ry's 5-year forecast but just for the purpose of explaining so if it's you know we think we can pass a $7 million Levy then we need to fill that

129balance with fur further reductions um and you know unlike this year where the levy failed January through the end of the school year we're using our cash balance to avoid having to make midyear reductions if a levy fails next year we don't have that luxury any longer and we would have to begin to um make midyear reductions um which mid year meaning January 1 2020 which which right yeah because the tax year if you pass a levy in one year it doesn't go on the books until the following year um and then if it fails in in 20 you know 2025 um you know then we'd put it on in 2026 but we wouldn't begin to collect until 2027 so we we would have no new cash on the horizon or asking a question for

130new cash so it's it's very you know so so that those are the kinds of decision points I think the board is you know having to contemplate and and you know what does that look like because if um you know so so I've said enough but just to kind of give you that parameter of zero 14 and 14 means we're not bringing anything back um and and then in between there um that means that there's a a level of reductions and again all this means no new growth no additional staff we've averaged about 10 teachers a year in The Last 5 Years um that that does not you know it it is just you know what we have now so would that change if it were an incremental Levy instead of just a flat flat

131rate there would be growth in the levy so the incremental Levy and how that's worked and you know somebody mentioned Dublin um I think the last District to pass at incremental Levy was Worthington another Suburban Columbus that's growing um what an incremental Levy does is it asks uh voters to or taxpayers to increase the amount that they're paying incrementally each year so that the district is is getting a bump each year um so so unlike a traditional Levy where you know you know both levies at the end of four years let's say may end up at let's say 10 ms um in a traditional Levy you pass 10 ms you collect 10 mills each of those four years with a um an incremental Levy you might say we're going to start the first year at

132four Ms because that's what we need the next year inflation additional staff we're going to need six Ms eight Ms and then it ends at 10 ms so when you do it that way you look at the difference and there's less millage being paid because you're getting it as you need it versus a traditional Levy which you set that up front now you you I'm oversimplifying this to give you that visual um but but that's you know why it's attractive here because each time we've gone up as Randy pointed out there's more people that are moving here values increase what people pay for that bump is less than what was on the ballot and that was less than six Ms difference between what voters approved and what we actually needed um I think it's important

133to point out you know think about even if we were not growing but we are growing even if we are not growing let's say we're round round up we got a $80 million general fund budget what's inflation a tax it's two to 3% two and right so there's 1.6 to $2.4 million if we did absolutely nothing you know just for inflation now we don't do nothing right we're looking at ways to to trim the impact of that whether it's you know energy contracts you know looking at other cost reduction things so we do hedge some of it but the fact is even without growth we're seeing you know when you're when you're you're seeing those kind of increments so your choice as Mr huster pointed out is traditional Levy you get a bunch more money

134up front and then you pay that cash balance down over the life of the levy then you go back up it's like a hockey stick and that's traditional funding is done in in Ohio you you get more than you need in the first couple years in order to have money at the end right so the Jo the beauty of the incremental is that we don't do that but on the other hand obviously we got feedback that people don't like that either but uh yeah the first incremental Levy went on the ballot in 2004 um it was set to expire it went back on in 2008 um we it was we passed it another incremental Levy in 2012 uh another incremental levy pass that so during that time there was that bump that was is taking

135place each year when we got to um7 um so we we opened up HPI and we had built up our cash balance operated and we said we would go to the voters um and we ended up having to go to voters in 2019 so between um you know 2016 2017 you know 2019 that's where you know we got back on the incremental Levy in 2019 5 years and and it's confusing and and I think the board has to you know consider you know what what are people willing to sit down and take the time to understand because the incremental Levy and exp discussing how it works is is complicated and Randy I know you feeled at a number of calls about people felt like the numbers that they were working out in their minds or

136being told included the taxes they were already paying this expired Levy and they were saying that they were going to have to pay another dose of that and that wasn't accurate um so people were confused by the incremental Levy so I think as the board talks about the different Levy options I think we have to keep that in mind that you know when you're talking about traditional Levy it's a lot more straightforward this is what you're going to pay for the next how many ever years incremental Levy has worked well in the district going back to 2004 voters have approved it you know in in 8 and 12 and 16 um when well in 16 it became a um continuing Levy but you know people people understood it and and in it on the campaign

137Trail educating folks it became challenging to explain and then with the retiring Levy people were automatically saying that that was going to be added on to whatever they're already paying and that confused taxpayers too and we fed those calls range didn't we so I think Mr Bennington your comments that um it used to be that the community would say what he need and we put a levy the board would put a levy on and it was supported um I think that distinction is really important because I do think what we put on the ballot and I don't think this is fully understood because I know I keep getting comments that we we just asked asked for what we needed to continue the student experience as it was so we asked for what we needed just

138to do that and to cover the growth um it seems to me at this time as we talked about last month that I I need I'm feeling the need to pause before we jump into another operational Levy um and to go to the community as we started hearing tonight as many of us have been hearing individually um what what is the what does the community want out of the student experience in education um I I I I don't know that right now as we talked about last month we want to put a community engagement plan so I think there is a I want to distinguish the two that there is a community engagement plan specifically designed to take to the community the rebounding of the elementary schools um but what we started talking about last

139month was was um a community engagement plan where we would go to the community in general about um what is education in perryburg going to look like and what can we afford to do uh because we can't we can't afford to do what we used to do anymore um my hope would be that we could find some way to do more than the 14 million in order to bring back some of the Six Million in Cuts but that's something that I would have to hear from the community that they were willing to support um before I would be willing to do that that 14 million concerns me because it is just the minimum um and what we heard tonight is the people don't at least that we're in this room don't want just the minimum

140but they also the community at least the majority of the community said that that we don't want exactly what's being offered now so there is a we've been working um Mr h CER and Mr Bennington and I and I'll be um Miss man and I are going to be meeting this week about forming a work group to really create a a robust Community engagement plan that will create open Town Hall meetings that will offer some opportunity for an exchange and dialogue um you know look specifically at at certain groups within the district to go and sit down and and talk with and get their input so I'll just me right now knowing that by January 5th um I think it was January 5th we would have to have an understanding of what that operational Levy

141was going to be I am not prepared to do that because I don't I don't think the community is saying anymore tell us what you need and we need to find out what the community needs what they want right now um I do think the pi Levy is um something that I think that the community has always supported it's something if we continue it at the same rate that it is I would hope that the um Community would understand the importance of that for us maintaining our facilities or at least getting us most of the way towards maintaining our facilities we know it's not enough to cover all the buildings anymore but it really goes a long way in um helping cover our maintenance expenses so I would support the idea of putting on the

142May ballot the pi l ly because I think that is something that there's kind of a shared understanding and support for but at this time I I would be very concerned about jumping into another operating Levy I I will say one of the challenges we're going to have and it's going to be a fact and you know it's the board's decision but we we'll need to have a plan probably after May for the state two plans one let we're going to have to we'll be in fiscal um if not fiscal caution we'll be in fiscal precaution they've decided they' the auditor of state and the um and the Department of Education are stepping up looking at that and they're and they're being much more aggressive about oversight now precaution doesn't put us in oversight but

143it does require the plan and you know if you don't have an adequate plan then that's when they start you know ratchet it up so just it's just something we're going to have to do anyway the point is we're going to there going have to built in parallel so that it's not they're independent decisions but they have you know they have a um correlated impact on each other so and I I realized that what I just said is risky because it puts as as Mr hosler put it pointed out it means that in November we've put all our eggs in one basket because if it doesn't pass in November but that's why I also think it's crucial that we hear more from the community about what that should look like has my to no my

144my my head's more or less where your head's at the the pi Levy sooner rather than later to hopefully get that one get that conversation um um done and and so that we can focus on the levy I probably open up probably in my mind I'm still open to the thought of doing something in May but it's a small that's a small opening I'm not I I'm more thinking the November time frame as well just because campaigns take time money ground game there's a whole lot of other things that need to be lined up as well um this is not you know if we were sitting here I've looked at the results I've looked at the results by Precinct and this isn't another District that only lost by four votes this this this this Levy

145failed this Levy failed you know handedly so you know the concept of designing an incremental Levy as much as I support them and as much as I think they they they they work physically for a for a growing District like perisburg clearly didn't work for the voters so I'm probably taking that one off the table in my head and I'm my numbers more cards on the table is in the 14 million four maybe five year and let future let a future campaign figure out the incremental side of that that's where I'm at today I can be talked out of it so these were all property taxes have is there any validity in talking about it uh an increase in the income tax I'm not EXA we I don't think I've ever really talked about that

146since I've been on the board is there when we looked at the incremental we talked about income tax to replace that 13.5 million was about 3/4 of a percent so our income tax would go from a half% to one and a quarter that's and that's and that keeps the 13 and half that doesn't include the increment now obviously you get some inflationary growth with income tax but uh I think we felt like if you looked at the mean income in perisburg and mean home values most not all right most Property Owners if they're the any if they're the mean or higher income property tax is cheaper but but the board can certainly look at that right that's that's that is certainly an option the other option was we have that half% income tax it's a

147it's a traditional tax so it's essentially a tax on your you know your your 410 if you did a earned income tax so those on um not who have non you know earned non um wage earnings it would benefit them but then we'd have to increase that the 34 of a percent that half% of to go three qu so there's a lot of moving Parts in there and you can't because you can't have two income taxes you can only have you only have one so I mean it's worth discussing but uh is there something is crazy of an idea of having a little bit increase of a income tax and a little and an increase in property tax so that it's not all all on property tax or all on income tax you're certainly can

148do those combos right the other thing you got to remember about income income tax is it takes 18 months to get full collection right so if you pass a property tax in November we get full collection that next calendar year an income tax takes a year and a half by the time you get withholdings and all that stuff so it's not it's it's not that you shouldn't look at it I'm not I'm not saying that I'm just saying if we want to have this conversation we can we can run whatever numbers you want the Ohio Department of Taxation will run I because because obviously our valuations change they give me a table of equivalent income tax to our millage right so and so you can kind of pull that of course as you know um

149you got to go with a quarter percent right that's the lowest you can go right so how do we advance this discussion I think we need to definitely look at some work sessions with the board um and I agree with Susan with Community forums moving forward is the only way that we're going to be able to move the conversation and the vote forward um you know failure is not an option it's going to be baby steps to do this it's going to do be some um deep Dives and some hard truth um we need to make sure that we have a long-term plan in place and that doesn't mean a long-term plan that we're taking to the voters this means an overall long-term plan with our levies and our bond issues and the growth of

150the district and which way we're going to go with it um it's it really boils down to what we do for the future and it can't just be talk we got to leave behind basically the events of the past the criticize just learn from the history of what has happened and um we need to quit admiring the issue and get to work on it um we know that no matter what we do this district is going to keep changing and evolving and we have to make sure that we have a plan going forward that can change and evolve with our community and I think going along with that too um I I appreciate all of those words because I think I just I think when I hear in the community you know you don't need

151all of that when I went to school it was this this and this true it was that that and that when I went to school I don't I don't want to admit it was 30 plus years ago when I graduated because in my head I'm still 21 but things change our students need changes and and it's how how do we meld those two camps and I think going about having conversations with the community understanding the why and how we get there is is important because I think what you know we did all of this I hear all of this well we need to be more transparent and there needs to be lovey forms and there needs to be time for asking questions well we've done that you know how do we get people to attend

152you know we haven't seen this many people at a board meeting since I think the last time we had all the state qualifiers and this is what we need to but we need to see this all the time I mean we went through the summer in the spring with one person here if and this is the kind of Engagement that we need from the community all the time not at the last second I don't you know because I mean this this is painful this is gut-wrenching you know I'm I'm an educator I'm a mom of a band kid my oldest is still in a performing art hearts at 26 years old it has it has done wonders for him I get it I understand the mom of a child with special needs I get it

153that's why we moved here that's why we moved here that's why we're all here we're not here to this none of this is easy I haven't slept I've been stressed out because we're making decisions about kids this is about kids this isn't about anybody else but it's about students and what do we do for students both of my children are graduated we're not leaving anytime soon I haven't sold my house we're staying for the duration and somebody paid for my kids somebody paid for my parents somebody paid for me along the line and we have to get back to that as a community and I think going back to you know the different interest groups and getting people in here but we need to see it all the time all the time we need to

154have that um you know at our meetings and in our whatever we're doing as a community related to schools and I hope to see that again soon so you're thinking I did have somebody uh mentioned to me the other day and I don't find a lot of humor in this but did say have you ever thought about posting your board meetings to YouTube um I said we we'll we'll consider that so I I raise that just because that does kind of ring the bell that there is a need to figure out how we are engaging our community and getting the word out broadly so that's the that's the joke they are they're on they're on YouTube so that was sorry I'm sorry without ask is super forum for anybody who's not involved in this and

155and I say this with the utmost respect right it's super hard to feel like you can be involved when it's if you come to the meeting you can talk first minutes and then we'll see you later and then and not to engage with the because this is not because technically people don't understand a Schoolboard meeting is a meeting of Schoolboard members held in public like we're supposed to look like right and but that's it and we're supposed to be looking at each other nobody's suppos to be talking to each other else why the community engagement plan that that this is still important we need advocates for public education we want people to be well educated but we also need to create um opportunities where we can dialogue and because again I we can hear some

156wonderful things but we can't build on that conversation here um we want to keep building on that conversation get the kettle corn out right we're working on it we're working so I'm going to say a community engagement piece Miss Rand Miller miss mkey you know with without putting the cart before the horse it's probably getting some some traction on that to help inform a levy decision yeah I I I can get on board with that other than I think I still think the pi Levy and May should be strongly considered by this board so would we do that at the same rate which is woefully under what operation needs with the additional buildings and their ages or at this point yes we ask for the same amount here's the deal you know and we're still

157under a tight time frame we're going to have to have a couple meetings in January because I have to have two resolutions in order to get to February 5th so it say an immediate action if we can have those resolutions resolution of necessity and a resolution to proceed just like any other Levy Y and I need to um have the county auditor run so what we have to do is set well we just do a rep um a renewal then he's just going to he was going to set that at and it's going to probably drop below one about 1 mil is it 1.9 at 1. down we're down about 1 mil for the per Improvement Levy yeah on the on the screen you can kind of track this this is the levy history um

158everything in red are are Levy failures and um you know when when you look at the pi I mean at one time it was 2.2 Ms and it's Fallen now um you know to to less than one so um you see 1.9 Ms in 2020 uh 1.9 Ms 1.9 um and then you know it it is you know in 1994 was 2.2 Ms and that was a renewal from 1990 so you know four years later and that failed so that renewal failed and then they came back with the one point you can see kind of track it uh came back with um you know the 1.9 so interesting to see that you know that history so um I don't have that history so you're saying that it was renewed at 1.9 Mills not at the

159dollar amount those should be different dollar amounts I would think yeah so so that's that is the the requested amount was 1.9 Ms so that's what it's been um okay anyway we need the point is we have to have that conversation if it's if it's just a straight replace replacement it's not going to be 1.9 Ms Right probably one one mil maybe one point 1.1 right now yeah replacement and renewal are two different termin some people use those words interchangeably and Randy will spot me on this but when it's a a renewal you're renewing it at the rate you're collecting and it would reflect a lower millage rate for the voters you're talking dollars right dollars the district is bringing in is the renewal it would be well it would be a renewal would be

160the same amount in the millage would be less yes now replacement levies are going back to what the voters approved but House Bill 920 reduces that amount so you're going back to what the voters approved so that would that would be a slight increase so what we've tried to do is just do the replacement and keep the dollar amount the same ignoring the millage rate just keep the dollar amount the same the a replacement is um going back to what was originally approved which then you capture that difference between 2.2 Ms and 1.9 m you would you would capture that difference and what we're saying is we would want just to capture the the funding that that is there and the millage rate would fall I just need to have 9 95 to 2007 there

161were 13 levies in perisburg and seven of them failed um so you can kind of see that you know it's it's tough sledding so I just need to so you know probably if if the board's Direction is to re replace excuse me renew the levy I'm going to have to have legislation ready before the regular meeting probably should have first piece of reg um legislation for the organizational meeting I would agree I I I think that's the direction so I'll the um resolution of necessity and then that that will trigger as a county auditor to calculate the millage and then we have the resolution of proceed at the regular meeting luckily for all of us we have a full like 3 four weeks to think about that so but times of the essence so let's

162move bottom line is I got to start the drafting process now understood all right I'm going to open it up for any other additional reaction to the plan anything else that anybody wants to put out there I know that board members have been engaged with Mr hasser I've had conversations with most of you um this is not the last conversation oh May sorry Mr Bennington there is another po I could have we could craft legislation for a couple resolutions of necessity right and then have a county auditor calculate what that millage is at that point and then you can the board could pick one or something renewal do a renewal and a replacement language yeah that' be valuable yeah all right with that I'm going to close the board discussion for this meeting thank you

163for the for the discussion again thank you for those that spoke tonight for the feedback that helped inform some of the discussion and more discussion to come on those points and others it's a it's a big plan we've got lots to talk about we're going to uh continue to move through Randy are you good for the treasures report yeah I'm going to move real quickly here obviously um but you know there is a fiduciary responsibility for the board to stay up to date on what's going on so I'm I'm going to quick just click through my presentation real quick um here's our cash balance summary you know our trend is like normal I want to point out you know I love to see the cash balance there just recognize come January that trend line loses

164$6.5 million okay so it looks good today but you're going to see that that fir we don't get that first payment it's going to be $6.5 million less so that's when we're going to see the impact of the the levy failure um let's go to here um I'm just going to skip ahead all the stuff let me just back up so um just right now just to kind of get quick on state aid our state aid was recalculated in October at our second payment we're still trending behind for you know there's been no in impact of no base cost index cost update took down our funding but ad kind adk kindergarten gave us more students so it raised the funding so it's about a break even like we predicted and it's going to continue continue

165that way um our costs you know we're on trend on salaries and benefits purchase service and supplies are coming back in to where we expect now um again this is one of those areas that I can tell you that we pay attention to Counting paper clips is not going to get us out of this but we're going to count paper clips anyway and uh keep keep working on that but a lot of that's driven by maintenance stuff actually you know the pi Levy it doesn't just impact Pi what they can't afford out of Pi we pay for out a general fund and this is one of the areas that shows up so just we're on trend on revenue and expenses are on trender getting back there so and we're seeing some salary um um reductions

166you know on the backs of custodial we've already talked about primarily we've not filled positions and and we've talked about those strategically if we have an opening do we need to fill it if we can even if we can even do that so um Tom can you reload me yep what did you do just boot last thing I want to talk about there's a piece of legislation in the consent agenda I want to spend some time on that's our our bus purchase and this is may seem kind of crazy we're talking about cutting 6 million and we're and we're buying 16 propane buses but um we're going to take out of the fleet 16 diesel buses that are 20 25 years old in fact we had one crap out it's a technical term by the

167way last week my cold is catching up with me it was not good it was not really not repairable and it's one of the buses that would be going away so there's a resolution so when you have buses that can can get historical plates that's not always a good look is what you're saying yeah exactly exactly so there there's on resolution to approve lease we have the money I could write a check for these buses today but because of our cash situation felt it was better off preserving our cast and let use someone else's money the total purchase price the 16 propane buses little over $2 million we're our total lease is about 1.7 and and the lease includes I went ahead and put cameras and GPS into the lease they have more than 5year

168life expectancy and plus it preserves cash out the per Improvement Levy that's why we're doing so it's you know it's you're adding just a little bit expense there of that 2 mil 400,000 of it's going from the EPA for buying the propane buses so that's you know that was kind of the incentive to do that and there's still some money we're waiting with some additional reimbursements for the state for clean energy so we'll get a little bit more back but here's the here's the thing 16 buses propane buses compared to diesel are going to say us save us anywhere from $5 to $10,000 a year easily bus for bus right and so we we paid we just finished paying for the last 12 buses that we bought we're going to add 16 buses there for

169a little bit more money than we paid for the the 12 but the savings is going to cover that distance difference easily so yeah we're putting money out and we're doing it over five years but um and to put in perspective our lease is about four and a half percent I'm still making 5% on our investment so it's not going to stay that way but the point is we're going to protect our cash reserves um and do this so that's that's on the the agenda so any questions on that I want you're going to vote on that part of the do I have any consent I don't if I had any consent no I did not have it's separate I pulled it out the consent you're going to vote on it separately yep and the

170last thing real quick we talked about tax abatements the city's getting serious our structure for tax abatements in the city is to keep the schools whole which is good for us but it's it's shortsighted some other ways and um so the city is invited us into a conversations about looking at the ordinances on tax abatements I'm going to have an initial meeting 23rd December yes I'm working the 23rd um and but then at some point in time we'll figure out which board we draw in a couple board members to have that conversations but at this point um not bragging I think think because of I'm more equipped most of the folks on the the um Housing Council because I've I've worked with abatements a lot more than most people have and so it's it's a

171delicate situation it's again it's one of those things on put Shifting the burden from under residential or commercial we need to we need to be involved in that conversation right now our our ordinances do not support commercial development that's just a fact so and this last thing is our financial audit is complete um it's well it's undergoing quality control review right now we have another clean audit and we've not had a post conference in a while but we will have one in January in which you were all invited if you wish to come and listen to the auditor talked about our our audit so congrats congrats on the clean audit I do plan on being at that meeting to hear uh what they have to say but uh let's let credit to you and your

172team Randy for well you know it's I talked about before it's it's gone so far beyond the fiscal office now I mean they auditing college credit plus they you know they're auditing you know food service and some things that go you know the fraud training all of that is included in that so it's and it's going to get um even more fiveyear forecasts are now on the auditor States Target of looking at and um not that I I don't see a problem with ours because we have you know I can back up every number I put on it but let's put it this way not all districts do the same level of due diligence on their forecast all right thank you so item 7.2 is the approval of the November 2024 Financial presentation can I

173have a motion please so move Miss mkey second Miss lmer roll call Miss minking yes Miss larer yes Miss Roland Miller yes Dr refer yes Mr Bennington yes uh November 2024 Financial presentation is approved item eight board committee and discussion there are minutes for most of these meetings here we will start with the operations committee miss m or Miss larer since it is already 8 o' I'll just give a couple highlights on there um as Randy was talking about the main one that I was concerned about was where the busing was going and the cost savings on that just to follow up a little bit on that there are some future cost savings possibly with the federal program um with propane and then also we will be looking into there is a handicap segment also

174of the Grant and um we have two older uh buses with those that type of equipment that we need to make sure that we have available for our students um and we also have because of the number of propane buses we have Rous Motors is interested in doing a study on our existing buses and the study that they're looking at doing usually that's something that will cost us but because of the amount that we have they are it sounds like willing to come forward and and do this without cost to us which is great for us okay thank You So Randy am I understanding that the um grant that James applied for for the for the buses um did that go through I wrote down 4,000 I don't know if that's well there there's there's

175a number of different things there's some State money that that's kind of debed up based on there's a pot there and how many buses were bought purchased they'll divide it up so we don't know exactly it could be 5,000 8,000 4,000 from the state but the other thing he talked about and M maky pointed out is that the that bus program from the state from the state from the feds through the EPA is out there again he went ahead and put an application in for in order to get handicap buses now it doesn't commit us to do it right but if he doesn't apply you don't have the opportunity so probably in the summer like we did this year if we get the award then the board will have to decide you know and and

176we're having more need for handicap buses okay Miss Roland Miller curriculum committee tnl um you'll see the minutes agenda from our meeting on the 3 um a couple good links there a lot of our time was spent with um Jason hubard learning more uh about the curriculum mapping and where they are with that and why um the impact that that's having in the classroom um there's a great kind of piece there under 3c1 why Curriculum maps are essential which I commend to you but that was how we spent the majority of our time and then finally we there was a policy committee meeting I believe uh we've got a first reading of some policy changes don't print it out 205 Pages um nine out of the 41 policy changes are related to technology pieces definitions

177um expanding the understanding of you know cellular what a cellular device is um about 10 out of 41 are related to the board and so what's happened is the there's not a lot of new information there but it's restructuring the existing policies to um try to make them a little bit user friendly around meetings and agendas um so you can take a look at those 11 of the policies were uh related to updating regulations uh on the uniform Grant guidance in the education department General administrative regulations um UG and Edgar I don't know if you're actually supposed to say ug or not but it sounds kind of funny um fiscal policies um from mainly Senate Bill 168 are in there too so it's it's quite the collection um there's about six or seven different house

178bills and Senate bills that are reflected in the changes um I would highlight to you um not only the board ones just to review those in particular but we've also um in 7510 that the language about the use of our premises facilities that um the language is going to be changed to that the community may be allowed to use the facilities um as resources permit so that carries from some of our conversation tonight but if you have any um questions or addition changes before we see this again in January just um let Rachel Zer know copy us and to clarify can you um tell us like how how do we get these changes for policy like I know I mean they come from they come from Neola so service that takes all of the changes

179at the state level and recraft so you'll see the that they've um a couple of the policies are are completely new some of them are um Replacements and some of them you'll just see are lined out but um since it's pretty complicated and everchanging there's already a couple of them that will have some updates to correct the unin unintended consequences which are not useful thank you Mr Hustler has something to add that's more cogent than maybe what I no I was no I think that was great I think when you look at the policy changes um you know there's a kind of a code obviously there's there's green which is the new um you know you can see what's crossed out so that's highlighted what changes um and so this is just a sample policy

180of property inventory and um you can see that there are different options available um it may be the duty of the superintendent business manager treasure so there's discussions about who's responsible for that particular area and in um in Ohio there's two primary groups that do policy updates Neola is probably the largest um so when you Google other school districts in Ohio their policies look identical um and that's uh because you know they they have attorneys and people that focus on what has to happen but you can see how you know what what's going away it's very transparent what is coming on and being recommended and then what are the different options and and and that's true of every policy that's here so it's and you will see that there's a couple of the policies that

181are generated internally there are policies so you'll see that noted in the notes at the beginning of the very large packet that you should not pack print out right I just wanted to clarify because you know obviously we didn't create 200 and some pages of policy and it was no but and they come from noola but the what doesn't come from niola is at the very beginning you see here um the proposed changes and it's kind of a summary of what that is about so that is something that is done internally that um um Mrs ziker does do and and so it's nice to have that and then you actually see the language so um we're very fortunate to have a process that you know really does take it seriously um I had anticipated a

182204 page document so I was reading it Sunday night and oh this is oh dear I'm not going to make it by Monday you know and I it traveling across Indiana there wasn't else a lot you know the other the other thing with that section you'll see here at the bottom is that you know those policies are then handed over to the the policy changes updates are handed to the administrator or people who are responsible for it so then you get to see who's reviewed each of those policies um so it's not just one person sitting in a vacuum saying we're gonna you know but actually like what do we do um how does this work um so so that that helps uh make that process uh um even more relevant to what we're doing

183here operationally and it's not clear obviously Neola looks at it from a legalistic standpoint and then we can customize it for ourselves and and we do but they they give us the broad to be compliant but in the end the key is that whatever's in the policy that's what we do I noticed that a couple of times but all I could think of was how long was this meeting my goodness yeah thank you for that explanation to others so that they because it's a it's a it's a big thing with 200 and some pages so thank you okay no other committees met uh moves us to the consent agenda the consent agenda is going to cover items 10 through 14 have a motion to accept the consent agenda so moved second Dr refer Miss Roland

184Miller roll call please Dr reford yes Miss Roland Miller yes Miss larer yes Miss minky yes Mr Bennington yes takes us to item 15 other items to vote on outside of the consent agenda we'll do them individually um we have a staff resignation as documented as as said here in the agenda can I have a motion to accept item 15.1 so moved second Miss Roland Miller and Dr refer roll call Miss Roland Miller yes Dr rord yes Miss minky yes Miss lmer yes Mr Bennington yes item 151 passes item 15.2 the bus lease purchase agreed ment that Mr Jer went over during his financial report uh motion please so moved Miss Roland Miller second Miss uh lmer roll call M Roland Miller yes Miss lmer yes Miss minky yes Dr rord Mr Bennington yes bus

185purchase uh agreement or bus lease agreement passes item 153 so my term as president expires on December 31 so we need to appoint a president pro term between now and the organizational meeting um FY that organizational meeting is also right in here scheduled for January 6 so we can confirm that that date works for everyone as well that date was January 6 January 6 consistent with last year it's that first Monday of the month but before we get there can I have a uh first I need some nominations Mr Bennington I nominate Mr Bennington second we don't I don't know what we do but I was goingon to nominate him too okay I'm holding open for any more nominations holding open for any more nominations Clos call for nominations are closed so let's talk how

186does that January 6 date work what time uh good question six o'clock I would say for that organizational meeting because we need a tax hearing that day as well we'll do the tax budget hearing at 5:45 and then we can go an organizational meeting at 6:00 consistent with how we did it last year yeah and then probably plan on a speaking as president protemp in 2025 a work session after the organizational meeting as well we can always cancel that one but we'll roll through three meetings so on the same day six like right after one after another on the on the six so bring snacks yeah I think it's important we'll work on the notice but if we we phrase it that way you don't have to put a time so you do F they'll

187just just kind to keep going keep going okay all right so any other discussion on that any other nominations okay can I have a motion please so move M lmer second Dr refer and Mr Bennington you can vote for yourself I vote against myself yes you can miss larer accept yes Dr refer yes Miss Roland Miller yes Miss minky yes Mr Bennington abstain um that passes so last item so we had no other signups for public comment we will again be holding public comment in January at the regular meeting so with that if there's no other items for the good of the group I'm going to call us adjourned thank you we are adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.