CorpusRecord 142832

Perrysburg BOE Special Board Meeting 12-12-2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Perrysburg Schools
Date
2024-12-13
Location
Wood County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
26,541 words · about 148 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I just know green green data yeah is that on start to getting emails today yeah F here we go 6 o00 okay good evening everybody I'm going to call to order this special board meeting of the perisburg board of education on Thursday December 12th 2024 Mr Drew your roll call please Miss Roland Miller here miss lmer here Dr reford here miss minky Mr Bennington here start with standing with the pledge for for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all and as we have some guests tonight I will uh do a safety briefing perisburg schools welcomes you to the Commodore building and we thank you for attending tonight's

002Board of Education meeting we care about the safety of our students staff families and guests please note that there are exits on both the East and West sides of the cafeteria in case of an emergency an AED is located just outside the cafeteria doors you are located at 140 East Indiana Avenue thank you for joining us tonight and supporting perisburg schools so we have a proposed agenda in front of us tonight for this special meeting you can see even from how the tables are set up we're going to be doing this a little bit differently than how we've done regular meetings I did also want to point out because some people have asked and we do have some guests here tonight tonight uh as is the case with with special meetings is there is not

003an agenda item for public participation I look at this meeting as kind of part one of a two-part meeting that second part being at our regular meeting Monday where there will two opportunities for public participation in that meeting so look forward to this discussion tonight as much as one can look forward to a discussion like this uh and then engaging with and hearing feedback uh both in the next regular meeting as well as future meetings also going to ask for an executive session uh towards the end of the me uh towards the end of the meeting so with that context can I have a motion to adopt the proposed agenda so moved Miss lmer second M Roland Miller roll call M larer yes M Roland Miller yes Dr reford yes Miss mkey yes Mr Bennington

004yes the agenda is adopted so this board at its last meeting and as as you know we have we know that the Administration has been working on uh a the budget reduction plan in light of the outcome of the November Levy campaign so with that I'm going to turn it over to Mr hosler and Mr Junior to hear about the work that the administrative team has been doing all right well thank you um appreciate all of you being here uh this evening and uh certainly thanks to the uh administrators that we'll be hearing from uh as well this evening um we we wanted to um to to have this meeting to to kind of update um and share information with the Board of Education about uh the plans that we're making to to address the

005funding Gap that we have uh with the levy loss that will begin on January 1 of this year um we know that uh this this uh sharing of information is is really a dialogue in terms of picking up the conversation from where it began on October 8th so October 8th we had a special board meeting uh we began to talk about in the event that the levy were to fail here is a plan um blueprints we referred to them um in in terms of what we would need to do to address the the loss of$ 13.5 million 177% of our budget so we kind of outlined in in that meeting this blueprint and when you think about a blueprint um you know if if you're comparing it to like a home blue blueprint you have

006a a a a drawing that shows that this uh you know blueprint will be for a two bed or a two-story home two-car garage it will have four bedrooms and and a kitchen and those kinds of things but it is just a drawing and then this evening um what we're hoping to do is to begin to talk about the plans that we are beginning to to to make the steps that we're beginning to take to construct you know what that blueprint says we have to do and again what we have to do is address a 13.5 million loss for the district and so we'll we'll spend a little bit of time talking about that most importantly the feature and this is something that we have not done before but most importantly the feature this evening

007is when we get to the portion of the plan the blueprint we will hear from the people that are charged with you know helping create that blueprint and also having to to live in that part of the house so we're going to hear from the administrators as they uh talk through what this means especially through the lens of the impact on students um so so we'll have some guest speakers so we have some Empty Chairs here that we'll soon be asking administrators to come go over those and it gives the board a chance and an opportunity to have a conversation uh to learn more to ask questions to have that followup you know with the folks that are that are intimately involved with those aspects of of our operations um there there are um as

008Mr Bennington said there's a regular board meeting scheduled for this Monday uh individuals will have a chance to watch this to to talk about it to observe to give board members feedback so um there will be opportunities for for public participation um at that meeting and I know the board is is planning on future engagement with the community as well so so again this is just an update in terms of uh from October 8th to where we are today now that we know we have a direction from the community in terms of the funding level now it's up to us to to right siiz our operations to fit that funding level and so that's what you'll hear you know this evening so um there will be no votes that will take place today uh this

009isn't a list of employees or anything like that it is just taking that October 8th plan and beginning to to fill in that drawing um so the the there are some steps that we're considering that we're going to share with the board as we've gotten into this we've asked the the the staff to turn over every stone in terms of where we can find um savings and we want to redirect those savings into the classroom as much as we can and so you you'll hear some things that were uncovered as we're beginning to work that weren't part of the October 8th conversation but I think our relevant for the board to hear about those conversations and perhaps in the near future give us direction as to how we want to proceed with that um so

010so tonight's about um sharing information it's about uh getting an update and and getting that information uh so it's a different kind of board meeting uh and it's one that uh I think is important to help gain an understanding as we go forward so we want to begin with um um some financial implications and um I've got three slides here um student athlete um a musician and a teacher and I I want to picture um I want you to picture that Runner you know crossing the or the runners crossing the finish line and you see that Runner and you think that you know that is a pretty special moment and when you think about reductions and things that are happening it's like okay we just want to focus on that Runner Crossing that finish line

011and and you know what does it take just for that Runner to cross the finish line or in the next slide it'll be the musician who's playing that Solo or the teacher who's delivering that lesson and and you think that's it that's all you see as a resident or Community member is that moment in time but what this represents here is all the the things that it takes to get that Runner to that finish line to get that musician to the stage where they're playing that solo um or the teacher to to have that lesson um and and so here for example with the student athlete you know you have that student athlete who's crossing the finish line but we know there are coaches behind that student athlete who helped train and condition that that

012the team who looks after the team who does all of those things to get them to that race um there's physically a bus driver that drove them to that meet in that location um there was a custodian back at the school who opened up the locker room so they could grab their materials to get on the bus or greet them when they're coming off the bus um there is a a secretary um in transportation who got an order for a bus to be at this location at this time and scheduled it with the driver there's another secretary that's relaying that information to the transportation secretary saying this is what we need here's the schedule this is where we're going and then you have the athletic director who sends a note to the Treasures Office saying

013we need to pay the officials we need an entry fee and they handle that and then you have a principal who's in charge of the athletic program who's making sure all the students are are eligible you have some ticket takers that we have to schedule you have athletic director who signs a contract with the schools to attend that who secures workers for that event um and and it kind of goes on and on so when we talk about the positions that we're going to talk about they all play a hand in getting that student athlete to that finish line to that moment and what we're beginning to do is we're starting to poke holes in that structure that supports that student athlete uh with the student musician the same kinds of things that are here

014there's beginning to to poke some holes into what gets them to that performance and to perform at that level and and of course the the teacher the center of what we do in our mission um again it is all the things that go into delivering that moment when they're teaching that lesson um and and nailing it in the classroom like this is what we do but the department heads the Deans the curriculum the technology all those things have to come together and click so tonight when you hear about a reduction in technology and and the reduction of of tech workers reduction in custodian no department heads know that all of them have a hand in getting to that critical moment um they're all important they all play an important role in making perisburg what it

015is and making our staff and our students perform at a very high level so the idea that you know these positions can kind of slip away understand understand that we see just the the tip the peak but there's so much that goes underneath that that makes that moment happen so as we start to go through this we want to make sure that we're kind of you know laying that Foundation of how all these things are connected and when you start to pull people out of that lineup something's going to be a little bit off and people will compensate and and do what they can to fill that but it won't be exactly the same because it can't um so so on uh beginning on January 1 of 2025 we will no longer collect um 13,415

016n52 um so the the 2019 5-year incremental Levy is uh set to expire and it was not um a levy that was replacing that was not passed um homeowners will will see a reduction in their taxes um for each $100,000 a home value um $28 roughly $28 per month um and and so that is what will happen on you know beginning on January 1 you know we're not out of the woods and I think it's important to to really hear this for a moment we are not out of the woods the plan that we talked about on October 8th takes funds one-time funds from our our our cash balance and those funds enable us from January 1 when we sto collecting that you know through the rest of this year to finish up this year

017without having to do midterm uh or midyear reductions the $6 million of cuts that we're going to talk about get us through the beginning of next year but if we aren't successful in passing a levy uh next next year if we the board chooses to put a levy of significant lesser amount there will be more reductions that will have to take place and we'll spend a little bit of time um going through how that works and and why that is so we're really not out of of the woods so a failure next year means that we wouldn't have the ability mid year to to um to get through that year because we've already pulled the amount that we can't afford to out of the the the cash balance so so we have folks that are

018talking about you know well if we raise funds and we want to save this program or that program um you know we we'd like to do that now it's really challenging and we've responded to those folks who who've said that we love the passion we love the enthusiasm we want you to be part of that solution but understand if if we're a patient and and we're on the gurnie and we're we're bleeding out we have to save the patient first and when we save the patient we can repair the hand and those activities are essential just like your hand is but if the patient dies there's no use for a hand and that's that's what we're facing in terms of not being out of the woods so we understand that we need to get direction

019from the board in in the weeks ahead as to what that path is forward and tonight is a is a first step in having that conversation um so the reduction plan again we we kind of talked about that and we'll talk about the cash balance and and I know Randy did a great job on on November 18th when he did his fiveyear forecast in terms of projecting out what the district needs from his conversation um we are beginning on on um January of 2025 we're basically reverting to the funding level that we had in in 2021 so 2020 2021 school year is where we're heading back in terms of the revenue level that we have today since 2021 we've added 330 more students we've added 33 and a half half teachers since 2021 and of

020course since 2021 we know the costs of good and services have increased we are not immune to inflation and and that's very real to schools when we talk about the cost of a gallon of milk increasing um we understand that because we buy milk for about 3,800 kids who bought lunch today so we understand that um in his report Mr Junior talked about 84% of our our general fund is instruction operations Transportation student support um 84% of our budget is people when you go to the high school or you go to Fort Megs or Woodland right now the building's empty there's very few few supplies there there isn't an inventory there our business model and all schools business model is an empty building um and we pay people to to go in front of those

021classrooms and teach those students we pay other people to go out and pick those students up and bring them to school and take them home and then we pay others to help out around that function so we don't have large machines and equipment that we're investing in we don't have rail cars we don't have an inventory of metal or products that's our model is people um so so that's essential um going back back to 2021 the amount of negotiated agreements the percentage increase uh compared to the Consumer Price Index in terms of how inflation um we've we've settled contracts well below what the cost of living has been I think the board's been very responsible in how it has treated its employees and the taxpayers um and and so that's important when we talk about

022the the going back to October 8th when we did a summary of all those positions we saw that this was the summary um three administrators 26 teachers three exempt 24 classified par professionals three um contracted employees to and when you think about going back to funding levels of 2021 we've added 330 more students we've added 33 and a half teachers since 2021 our our plan is reducing 26 teachers so you can begin to see when you look at the plan what we've added in that time in that window um we're really having to right siiz our budget back to what it was in 2021 and deal with the reality that we have 330 more students than we did then um and that's what this plan has to do and what it has to accomplish moving

023forward um understanding I think cash balance there's spend some some some things about the cash balance and and I've had people and even some staff members say well we have a cash balance we we don't need to make any reductions So Randy and I will kind of walk through what that is but when you think about your home um and and how that how you operate your home and what people recommend in schools and and even you applying some of those principles to your home you know you want um in your check savings account enough money to have a couple months where you could pay your bills and and survive if for some emergency if something were to happen in school districts we follow that same kind of principle um so you know in the

024fiveyear forecast you know Randy talked about you know trying to achieve 120 days of true cash that's that's four months we'll talk a little bit about you know trying to maintain two months cash balance um and and so when you talk about that balance it's designed to provide an adequate cash balance um to to pay our bills and and we'll talk about the timing of that and how that actually works here in a moment but we also have some other restricted funds so for example food service has a cash balance those funds are restricted and we can only spend those funds on cafeteria and food service so we can't pull pull funds out of that and apply it in other areas permanent Improvement funds are restricted we can't pull permanent Improvement dollars from that Levy

025and apply it to um paying people or or or programs um and then finally we're self-insured and the money that we have in our Insurance Fund um pulling that money out and spending it that would mean that we would have to be at some point taking money out of the general fund that is used for educational purposes to pay medical bills so we keep that fund separated and we restrict those funds just for the purpose of you know you know being available for the medical uh insurance so that's something that we continue to do this um was shown on October 8th and and it shows that $13 million shortfall the one-time cash balance that covers our operations starting on January 1 and through the end of the year school year and then uh $6 million

026in reductions to kick off the school year that's how we're doing that um and and um you know the there will be a growing gap of funding uh when we um you know as as costs continue to rise so I think this is an important chart and and this is what Randy showed in his in his um fiveyear forecast and we've kind of displayed it in a different way so so that people can understand so school districts have this cash balance and I like to think of it you see these in in fiscal year 2425 you see two distinct Peaks there's one that is roughly in July and August and then there's another smaller peak in in March February March in that window so that is our payday that's the day when we get our

027our state aid payment local tax collections all come into the district so in your home that is your payday so in perryburg staff gets paid on the 5th in the 20th of every month so if you were to take a snapshot picture of a staff member's um you know bank account at 12:01 a.m. on the 5ifth of any given month it would look like that tall Peak and if you said to that staff member you're flush with cash you should go to Hawaii with all the money that you have they would begin to say something like well that's that money isn't there that money is going to be spent in the weeks ahead over you know automobile you know payment or loans or all the you know mortgage insurance groceries heat electricity all those things

028and that's how it works with schools so you see that what happens after that Peak is we start to pay our bills until the next payment so so that's how that works so so folks who are focusing in and saying they have more than enough cash um they don't need to make any reductions is ignoring what happens in the days and weeks and months in our case what happens after we get that pay you can see here that what what happens is it begins to dip now in that column you have established two months true day's cash so that's the line that we don't want to go below and if we go below that that two months true day cash when we hit those valleys before the next pay we would have to begin to

029possibly borrow money to to make payroll to pay the bills so so you can see that that dip that up so next year you can see what begins to happen two two things I want to point out one that Peak isn't as high as it was before because we're stop we're not collecting on that Levy the valley goes much deeper and then you look at that estab U establish a two Monon two days cash that line in the next year moves up a little bit because the cost of doing business from year over to year even with the reductions that we're proposing goes up so we become dangerously close to being in a position where we might not have enough cash to to pay the bills to do the things that we do without having

030to borrow or do those kinds of things and then you see a Divergence right there in the blue that follows Randy's 5year forecast so that that shows us that based on his 5year forecast which we said at that meeting this is not a recommendation it's not saying that's what the board will do but to keep above that line $14 million would be necessary that 14 million would be new funds to the district that 14 million replaces the 13.5 million that went away and keeps those $6 million of cuts in place so those aren't coming back with that $14 million and you can see with that we we we almost touched that that two two months worth of cash the second line that is shown there is if nothing happens so you see that Peak fall

031and then we go Below in in May and June of next school year so when we talk about doing midyear reductions it's because we are beginning to fall below that line that we're comfortable with in terms of being able to operate operate then we get our state aid payments again not quite as high and then we begin to pay our bills to pay staff to do the things and then we run out of money so if it C if it takes $14 million for us to stay above that that two-month cash balance line it would take about $14 million of additional cuts to stay above that line without any new funding so when I say that the patient is on the table and it's bleeding this is the Trail of blood that we're beginning to

032to watch this is the this is the decision that this board will have to make in terms of which path do we take more importantly this is the decision that the community will have to take in terms of what does it want for its School District but the the $6 million cut that that that remains intact and additional Cuts may be coming and that's where I I spoke earlier about you know we need to save the patient before we get to discussing the hand all the activities and things that we're talking about that people are concerned about as well as we are and you'll hear that from the principles those are important things but the core of what we do the heartbeat of what we do will be forever changed and and it's not a

033threat it's it's not us trying to to portray things it this is this is why we asked for the funds that we asked for last time in in November to to keep above that line to continue to grow we understand that that's not available to us we'll come up with a plan to do the very best we can and you're going to hear what that plan is from those folks but I I think it's important to get that visual of how the next two years uh are going to be playing out out in the implications of those and the impact it we'll have on our students that we serve um so so we'll we'll kind of get into that so the October 8th reduction plan we're beginning to to you know reduce costs today um

034we're we're want to provide an update in terms of what we're doing um Don Christie are our Human Resources Director is is working on seniority list and lure job classifications all the things we need to do to to create um a reduction and force reduction and force list and we'll be talking about that and bringing that to the board when the time comes for the board to vote on that so that we can issue those reductions um and and of course you know the timeline for the reductions will follow how Revised Code and establish protocols and and bumping and all those kinds of things that we do so um Staffing reductions are planned for next year here unfilled positions that we're experiencing now that are slated to be cut we're taking a hard look at

035not filling those and and you know custodians for example you'll hear this evening how we've already begun to do that and we're feeling the pinch of what that what that means to our operations and what we do so we want to hold meetings with staff continuing the dialogue which we have those are underway keeping them informed and I know that the board wants to schedule Community engage M sessions and keep the public informed and I know the board will hear about that Monday some ideas about putting together a plan and the board is leading that initiative and directing us to to make that possible um so looking back at the Levy in Ohio we had 142 School levies on November 5th 50% of them failed 71 levies failed um a lot of perisburg like school

036districts were part of that uh Avon Lake um you know is in a process where they're looking at uh a combo uh bond issue and Levy and and you know this is from one of the Cleveland papers Marysville which is the suburb of Columbus failed their second Levy um Finley our our um colleagues just to the South experiencing some tremendous uh you know reductions uh like us um Westerville uh Bowling Green this is something that is being played out in districts that that look and feel a lot like perisburg um so we want to begin with the update on the actual reduction plan so at this time we'll begin with the junior high and and high school and so we have some representatives of those buildings to come and take a seat and and we'll

037begin to to go over um that information so give him a minute to transition up here take out yeah so we have with us uh Mr cookson principal perisburg high school thank you Mr cookson I know you're missing some Student Activities this evening yeah as as uh our other guest Mr uh Scott buer principal at the junior high who is supposed to be reading at a band concert so the Night Before Christmas up I'm not mistaken so thank you for being here and Mr Chuck jaob I'm sure there's athletic event taking place somewhere in the district as we speak so um gentlemen thank you for taking the time and um so we'll begin with um this was from October 8th the list of position that uh Staffing positions from the high school and Junior High

038that'll be uh reduced so maybe we'll start with there and sure okay um I just want to thank you for the opportunity to speak this evening um something that obviously is Weighing on all of this in the building um but as Mr Hustler mentioned that uh we're going to try to make the best out of the situation that we currently have so I want to touch base on a few of the um positions here uh at PHS that um will be uh non-existent next year uh starting with our academic uh piece uh speaking about World Language uh speaking about um our music program uh as well uh because those are the two main um Contin areas that will be will be affected most next year in terms of uh academics with our world language uh

039with the reduction of an ASL teacher and Spanish teacher as well as um one period of Chinese that'll obviously increase classroom sizes uh in those areas as well as um you know not being able to give the students as much um you know one-on-one attention as they currently receive um and I know uh the music programs as well uh will be um not able to offer for all the the programs the the great programs that they currently um offer our our our students and our community um as well I know that's something that that we'll we'll work through and we'll work with the teachers uh to be able to do the best that we can uh but in order to pull off a lot of the programs that they do and performances that they do

040it takes it takes um u a lot of people it's a heavy lift because of the quality that they they put out there uh every every single uh um program that they put they put out um also our I want to touch on our student Support Services um and our de of students they have a big role uh at the high school um we do have uh students who need additional support um you know with drug and alcohol prevention um as well as mental health um and with the um elimination of some of those student support services and our dean of students um that will be a that will be a gap that we'll obviously work hard to to fill um but um they do so much on a daily basis um that that will

041be a challenge uh to best support our students but also families as well uh at the high school um I guess in in in in a nutshell for for this slide uh for the high school um there will be you know less electives offered as well not only in World Language in music but also uh across the board um through all content areas which lessens the ability for us to meet the passions and interests of our students um also uh the larger class sizes which I already mentioned uh and and finally just that you know the less support for our students and for our families uh who really do need uh do need that support um I guess would you would you like to speak on that that like erens I just want to thank

042you for the opportunity to speak a little bit and um going through the the junior high uh situation here you know I'll start with our our three music teachers I just want to make sure um to clarify as you'll see the band The Orchestra and the vocal music as as 0 five and right there so it's a half position each so I think it's important to know that our current setup at the Junior High um is we have you know two band teachers who co- te in the morning uh four sections of a band class two choir teachers with three sections and then two Orchestra teachers for two and then in the afternoon those three go to HPI to provide music services at HPI um by eliminating the the half position we're eliminating that code

043teaching piece of it which has a a huge effect on the students that we can serve being able to do the the the Cod teaching model that we have in the music allows us to take students with really limited music background and we can use the two teachers to sectionalize the the students specific to to um the individual needs and the experiences of the kids and also break it apart with the instrument base have a section of of students solely work on violin or cello or whatever it might be with that it also allows us the opportunity to have um certain specialized classes you with it you know for example uh with our Orchestra program you know we have two level Orchestra classes like a grade seven Orchestra Class A grade eight Orchestra class but

044we also have a Ensemble class that's a mixture of both seventh and eighth grade students um that's a tri out based and then in the band World um once again we have like sections of like seventh grade band e8th grade band but we also have two sections of what we call a 78 band which is a smaller design class um that's really intentional for students who are just starting out in the instrument to provide that extra attention um you with that and then with the changes you know with the music program those specialty classes would not happen anymore um then we would also have to take a look at that individual attention in the musics um you know with bringing in students who have who are just beginning to learn an instrument um you know

045they're not going to get that the the direct teaching that they have which is going to lead to like what we think Could Happen lead to frustration and and and students not wanting to continue with the instrument because they're not getting that individualized attention that they've had before um you know like Aaron had said in terms of you know the Junior High music program is an incredible program you know and through the Oma process and community events and the concerts and having the two directors in there uh helps and goes a long way to be able to construct all those different things that need to happen um so all of those different components that we do in addition in the music program with with the Omas um with community events with the honors the sectionals

046that we do um we do some uh collaborations with BGSU that becomes very difficult than handle with only one music person you know in each in each POS each position with that um you know you'll see up there um two gifted ELA teachers and so right now the model for the junior high is we have a A Gifted seventh grade teacher and a gifted eighth grade teacher for ELA and and students have to qualify for the gifted Services through some stain benchmarking indicators um you know with that and they both of those teachers currently teach four sections of a gifted Ela you know class um so what happens is obviously not having those positions which were not required to serve um for those gifted Ela those brings those gifted students back into our general seventh

047grade ELA and our general eighth grade ELA class so it's going to be up to the teachers to stretch those students students uh in the gened class which we have full confidence that they're able to um you know with that so our gifted students may not get the uh individual attention and that that stretching of the curriculum that they're currently getting with that as well um but there's a ripple down effect to that as well um the the current setup at the junior high which is um it worked out really well for us is in ela like our our typical grade seven Ela teacher and a grade 8 Ela teacher uh would each teach four sections of that grade level class and then their fifth section would be a lab class um where it's designated

048to work with their students that they have that need the most support and we do a a data review process on a quarterly basis to look at our student data on what kids need those individual supports and then obviously we call home taught the families and um it's a fluid situation where we can put those students in that lab class to get those supports um taking the ELA gifted out of that and then also with the the larger class enrollments coming to us in grade six and five from H hbii we're no longer going to be able to have those lab classes with reasonable class sizes um so the gifted Ela piece not only is affecting our gifted students it's also affecting our students that we need to provide a lot of support with in

049the in the ELA curriculum you know with that so it is a a true Ripple down effect with that um and if we don't make that adjustment you know we'll be kind of looking at almost 30 kids per classroom in an Ela classroom um which you you simply can't manage very well with with those numbers um Scott if I could stop you um you know before you go on you mentioned our the band and you mentioned class size for ELA just what is an approximate you know when we talk about two teachers with the band program how many kids are in band so I think people understand absolutely that piece yeah absolutely so the the general band classes we have like a grade seven and a grade eight band um have between 40 and 45

050students in it with the two teachers uh that's 78 band that's designed for uh students just learning an instrument or maybe some students who have some complex needs to be in there that's right around 18 to 20 and those would be the classes that we don't know if we' be able to offer anymore um you know because of having those Dynamics with that thanks sorry yeah yeah yeah absolutely um so you see the trickle down effect with with the ELA piece of it and then also with the band piece of it as well too and um you know obviously the assistant principal position um is is a critical position you know with uh the way we currently have set up um I'd like to think that administrative team is a very Hands-On team with students

051um you know part of the the things that makes the junior high really special is uh we have a a class schedule that has collaboration time built into it with both our department-based uh tbts and also a teaming TBT so the teaming tbts um is your math science socialized English intervention specialist um have a full period three days a week so we can talk about student issues um you know do tier one tier 2 tier three interventions uh support and our our assistant principls and myself and our counselors attend those meetings on a regular basis to help with the process and organizing to provide those supports for the students and same way when we do our department which is like your entire e8th grade ELA or entire 7th grade we're in those meetings as well

052too um and I can go on and on about the the the roles of the assistant principal but it definitely will change the Dynamics um of the building and what we're able to do in terms of being Hands-On with teachers and students and be able to provide those supports it's it's going to be a reallocation of workload um administratively and then in the student services office with it as well um so we'll kind of you know um maybe begin just to talk about so these uh from October 8th we began to talk about the the activities so these slides represent the activities that will be um eliminated next year um so there were the High School Junior High um and then we have the the building leadership teams um the curricular resources um 10 Department

053chairs um and then here are um the programs that are going to be offered and then the ones that aren't in terms of uh activities and clubs that you can see what are what's being struck out won't be back so there are um opportunities for kids to still participate um and you can see kind of when it gets to um you know band and and Athletics extracurriculars you can see the things that are being reduced and things that are you know still in play um you know so that's kind of a total look and um you know so and then this is the reductions for the High School athletics um and then for junior high again following the same format with the High School uh you can see the different activities that are being uh

054planned and so I'll kind of pause there um and and maybe uh CH talk a little bit about from the high school perspective and then maybe um wrap up with just the reductions of the different clubs and what that means from your perspectives and good evening um appreciate the opportunity to provide some clarification if you have questions um you know for somebody who has devoted 30 years to school-based Athletics it was definitely a disheartening task but it's one that had had to be done from our department and looking from from a global view of you know what can we cut and not and and have the least amount of impact totally on our Scholastic Athletic program we we these assistants the way they're listed in the supplementals want to make sure you understand that the

055whether you're a JV coach of varis and a freshman it's called assistant coach in our supplemental so when you see these assistant coaches these are freshman programs um so basically baseball assistant that's your ninth grade baseball coach um and then when you get to soccer those are those are the those are jvb programs so that's our freshman level for the most part for soccer uh and then all the weight room supervisors um that that are there for all athletes to to be supervised um so um this will impact probably 140 kids that we have playing freshman sports but it's also not going to just impact the Freshman so what will happen here is that you'll have a JV team in which really the 10th and 11th graders will be impacted because there there's going to

056be cuts and so you know your top six freshman and your top six um 10th and 11th graders make the JV and then you know those so the student athletes it's not just a freshman incoming freshman they'll have opportunities now there are other sports you know that that just have JB or Varsity um and and to the junior high to speak on their behalf why why there are no cuts to the sports because down at that level if you eliminated you know they only have two fall Sports One winter two winter sports one Spring sport so they'd have zero opportunities where at the high school school there's you know cutting the Freshman there's still opportunity for the student athletes um so um but this would you know impact approximately nine coaches and and some supervisors

057Supervision in the weight room and and about approximately 150 kids will be impacted from rosters and then just to wrap up with the clubs and activities that are nonathletic yeah and blt's department heads yeah so I'll speak a little bit to The BLT The BLT you know the building leadership serves as department heads at the Junior High um it's a group of teachers um that we meet on a regular basis it it' be like the like almost like like our Advisory board administratively at the Junior High um and you know we we've really tried to emphasize a shared leadership culture in in at the junior high with empowering our teachers and empowering our our leaders in our building um and building their capacity and our building leadership team has really been the critical piece of

058that um as as the voice um not only with our administrative team our student services team but then with their tbts as well too so a lot of our decision- making our data review process um the big picture thinking goes through our BLT and their insights and their advice and their experiences more than anything um are absolutely essential uh to the operation and the growth of our building um directly towards our our teacher growth and our student growth as well too um so the the elimination of the BLT and and they have odd in our building odd jobs that they're responsible for as a department head as like such as like Department budgets you know curricular supplies things like that um that those roles and responsibilities are going to be absorbed elsewhere um you're with

059it so that will be a tremendous loss for us um but once again it's more of like a culture thing of that shared leadership and the cap that that's going to be affected but we're going to try to keep that intact the best that we can um from a from a club standpoint that from the junior high perspective you know Chuck had kind of talked about the Athletics you know with with the junior high you know the first thing that you know I I tell all the sixth graders when they come to us in May from each in the middle is how to be successful in the junior high is to get involved the very first thing I tell our seventh graders at our first day of school with the web orientation day is get

060involved the first thing I tell our eighth graders at our class meeting their first day of school is get involved and so and you we really want to have an environment where where students have a sense of belonging and they feel connected to their school and I think we're we're really aware and in tune that for a lot of kids it's it's an extracurricular that that brings them that connection to the school you know with it so it is is through and and have to decide what what goes and and and what doesn't um you know from our perspective we were looking at experiences you know is there you know certain things that we have you know similar experiences available already that the that the students that were part of that piece of it can

061jump into something that that we already have or something that's already available you know with it um you know just looking at some of the the cuts that we have you know extracurricular wise um that it's going to make a big difference on our student um participation numbers um you know winter running running club was one of those we have 8 85 students a part of that our math counts who goes to Columbus and competes on an annual basis has about 25 students our mock trial program um has been very successful about 25 students and they compete at a state level in in Columbus with their with what they do there um you know our power of the pen is another organization uh that competes at a district and state level often going to the

062University of Tiff tiffen Lord's college and ashy University and competes there they got about 25 kids that do that um and so it definitely is going to be an an effect you know for the kids who find that sense of belonging and uh like I said we're hopeful that with the options that are remaining that those those kids find a sense of joy and that in that belonging with another opportunity that we have I'm very similar to what Scott said I'll start with our our department heads our department chairs um we use them pretty much interchangeably with their building leadership team they do serve as a liaison between the administrative team and their departments and obviously filtering down to the students uh and they're an integral part of U the way we do business at

063the high school um I put a lot of trust to them as a as as the building principal uh to um to you know carry out the the the Mission Vision of our High School uh and to you know filter that down to their their department members uh and they do have a lot of uh a lot of uh odd jobs you would say they order materials for the year for the Departments um they're the head of the the curriculum uh in their departments uh they run their department meetings um they provide you know up-to-date content topics uh and just do a lot of odds and ends uh that go unseen uh so that'll be a really big a really big loss with the 10 Department chairs um going away so I just I thank

064them uh every every day um that they do what they do so it that'll be a big loss um our supplementals uh on on the one slide Mr hosler if you can go back to our main supplemental um I'm I'm going to talk more about the district approved uh clubs and activities you heard from Mr Jacob regarding our sports but um we have uh currently 66 uh ways in which students can get involved and connect with perisburg high school and at least one adult uh in the high school which research says is really one of the most important things for Student Success at the high school level uh we have 66 currently uh 25 of which receive a stien or a supplemental and 41 which do not so teachers are working um you know without

065pay for those so I commend those those teachers for taking time away from their families and their lives to you know to spend it with our students uh so a lot of those um most of the uh the clubs activities that received the stien this year well not next year we did pres preserve some uh for um reasons of um being able to reach the most students as possible like our our student council and also to provide students with that High School experience High School a positive High School experience which I think is so important um to to meet the meets uh meet the needs of the whole child so for example our student council we will still have a student council next year to run things like homecoming and prom and some of the

066things that they do um and that's just a large group so we can have a lot of student involvement there and also uh National organizations like National Honor Society which is very important for for students too as they go off to college uh we're going to preserve that so we took a real long hard look at at this list and obviously all of these um clubs and activities are vital very important uh for that Student Connection piece um but you we had to make we had to make difficult decisions uh so um My Hope Is that our students obvious obviously still can find their find their uh their their Niche at the high school uh through the things that we we can preserve this won't have as many many options um and I think I

067think that is it okay you go to kind of uh piggy back off of M what Mr cookson said the things you see on these slides these are the things that come with the paid supplemental contract so what he was clarifying was that there are other District sponsor clubs and activities without a paid contract that could potentially still occur if there is a staff member that would still want to lead that District sponsor club or activity so just wanted to clarify where you might see some imbalance of some activities you know versus Sports there are other District sponsored activities that could still be available to students that don't come with that paid supplemental contract and then Additionally you know you look at these things these are tough decisions this is what makes perisburg per perisburg

068it's hard um but when you total up all of those supplemental contracts you're talking $400,000 that's six teachers so you know those are the decisions that we have to make all right thank you gentlemen and uh you have questions board members just because I'm receiving questions about what's being cut and not and I don't know how to interpret forensics people want to know if speech and debate debate mock trial I'm can you just clarify that one for me yeah um forensics SL speech and debate synonymous yeah will be one that is is cut so what what concerns you all the most in these reductions I mean there's going to be I mean we're going to I mean from from our situation with Athletics you know there's going to be some in unintended outcomes of transfers

069right I mean kids are going to pursue other options possibly um when you look at our success we've had at the varsity level when you take away your farm system there's a reason why we're very competitive we've got great coaches and and and good student athletes that are learning our systems and you pull that away that's one less tier that leads to our success and it will impact our Northern Lakes League I mean we we'll have it will mess the scheduling up it will impact other members of our league not having those teams I think for me I think I kind of touched on the the whole student support is and the Ripple down effects uh is is what keeps me up at night um you know every night thinking about you know we we

070have a incredible staff an incredible structure at the junior high we've got great kids uh largely because we've been able to support those kids in such great ways over my eight years of of being an administrator in the building um and knowing that you know that sense of belonging with the clubs and the extracurricular some of those things aren't there a lot of them are which we're very thankful for um but some Ripple down effects and I kind of talked about it with the gifted Ela you know positions you know that doesn't just affect our gifted Ela population to it also affects our you know our our our intervention you know students who need that extra help or just need that pre-teaching before a lesson in that lab or you know going in with that

071lab teacher and building their confidence to feel good to participate in class that next day because they have that time that extra time with that um so we we still provide intervention it's just going to have to look different and it's going to create some um some really good conversations about how to provide that within the classroom um but I you know between that and some other things you'll learn about a little bit later tonight with student services and things like that um our our our students support is is definitely um my biggest concern um you know we're very Hands-On I would like to say like I said the junior high with our administrative and student services teams um you know being in and not only working with our students but also working in brainstorming

072and problem solving with our our staff and and trying to connect with families and bring them in and um you know and talk about you know it's you know trying to you know to hold idea of delayed gratification education if we put the work in with kids in the junior high it's going to lead to success at the high school level and their Futures we may not necessarily see it at the junior high but we know the work is is working based on results that the kids are getting coming out of the high school um and that's largely because of of of the support that we've been able to offer on an individual basis or or small group basis not only in a classroom piece of it but with those other intangibles check-ins and and

073all these different things that um that are are that that's going to be affected in a lot of different ways so like I said that's what that's what keeps me up at night so can I I just wanted to double check Mrs price real quick you on just regarding the supplementals unlike slide 39 are the are those I know the ones that aren't a paid supplemental have been eliminated but those are all paid on these slides that aren't crossed out on all of the slides right correct all right thank you I just wanted to make sure thank you I guess uh from from my vantage point uh it's definitely U similar to what Scott's U worries were uh our students needs social emotional needs our students um um I guess uh peer influences uh and

074other things that they're just experiencing right now are increasing and they have been increasing um and without the um the supports that are currently in place it's going to be that much more difficult to meet the needs of our students and also their families because we do service a lot of families uh as well uh and help them through difficult times and um I think we do a really good job of that with a lot of hardworking people that put a ton of time effort energy and love into what they do um and you know our students are definitely going to be uh they'll feel it our families will feel it as well because those people just won't be around so I really feel for them obviously we'll figure out the best way we can

075support those students and those families still uh but it's going to be that much more difficult um especially in a timely manner and then just the the connectedness to school um you know students are more and more in isolation uh and you know I hear all the time uh hey Mr cookson I I come to school because of football or the chess club or you know the musicals I hear that all the time and it's it's a big big Poll for kids uh and with uh less choice and more limitations on what they can choose to get connected with at the high school which hopefully we we still have some things that they'll they'll they'll enjoy and want to be involved with and you know make connections with those adults um you know that'll be

076uh that'll be something too that we'll definitely take getting used to and you know trying our best to provide those um connections for them thank you something um before you J and go I when I when I went through this presentation I actually got through all all the slides Tom um I want to preface what I'm going to say that I am not second guessing you and I am not I don't want to make that impression I'm just throwing out stuff to see where it sticks um because I'm I got two emails today about the band program I think that's going to be probably the biggest scream that we're going to hear because we have such an outstanding music program beginning at HPI on up um so I'm sitting there thinking what what can we

077do you see the half here in the half there and you wonder what's going on um this I I talked to Eric about it and and it really is kind of a wackadoodle idea I saw that you were getting rid of a Spanish teacher but oddly not a French teacher so is there any possibility in in all of the language classes that I taken over the years of making language and I'm thinking French and Spanish because I'm not that familiar with Chinese um couldn't those be online classes you can learn those classes online I've done Rosetta Stone I've done Pim psler I can never say that right doesn't say much for my language skills um but if those two if if those two classes for those those two years were either done with the guidance

078of a teacher to make sure that they're meing meeting State benchmarks but did it online wouldn't that open up some classrooms for you wouldn't that open up some time for teachers wouldn't that allow maybe some reduction in cost that maybe we could get one of those halves back um in our band programs or whatever um then for year three and four we need that teacher to because most of those programs are not meant to be at the three and four level you get into a lot of reading you get into a lot of culture you do all that kind of stuff um and again I don't I don't know where to what to say as far as Chinese is concerned but if I were looking at going after the language programs I would probably keep

079Spanish and Chinese because those are the languages of the world right now over French though that was my personal favorite but sign language you cannot do that online I know BGSU tries it I know a lot of students who did that and they they said it was horrible it was a terrible way to learn sign language but sign language with the um with OD W's I almost said ODU with OD DW's focus on Workforce that's a language that these kids when they graduate especially if they can do the full four years or even three years of it gives them a viable job opportunity right out of high school and and I thought gee whiz um I want and I'm I'm probably sure that y'all thought of all this but it was something that popped through

080my mind that um if I was cutting something that's probably how I would do it or to use Owens for CCP classes they've got a great sign language program over there or uh I don't know what they do for anything else with that but I would actually drop the eth I didn't see that on there in um Mr buer in the junior high are you keeping the eighth grade language classes yeah that's that's correct okay see if I would almost get rid of that and try to keep our music programs over keeping I know that gives the kids a fifth year but one one of the complications is um it's it it to to be honest is is a seat thing so we we have 430 eighth grade students and seven a seven period day

081and so it we we're actually in a position now where we we need actually more electives for eighth grade students to be able to take and so if you if you took away our eth grade language classes you know with it it would even you know M make that need even even greater you know you with it um you know I think one of the things that are it's unique about our eighth graders is you know and I and I would say I would argue that maybe your first year of language is the one that you actually need a dynamic teacher in there to get them bought into it and get them enthusiastic about the content you know with it because I think with language a foreign language as an eighth grader if it's online

082you know we've seen that the kids don't engage very well and are meaningful with their online instruction you know I think we saw that in Co a lot we we we we we battle the computers a little bit right now too um you know I and and the and the teachers that we have right now teaching language in e8th grade are really engaging they get the kids bought into it they sink into it and then that takes them up to Aaron's level at the high school and they're they're committed and I think that's a big piece of it is to be committed to that moving forward um you know and I think there's there's there's no no better way to be committed to something unless there's that connection with that person there teaching and that's

083just that's a testament to the teachers that we have in that in that place that they they leave our building loving that language and most of them continue to go on to to the high school level so I I would I would actually uh fear that if we if we got rid of our language programs uh that they may not pursue it or if we would do an online version of it that it would be a oneandone and there actually probably wouldn't would wouldn't progress to the high school level that would that would be my fear with it well I can definitely I can definitely understand that it's it's certainly not optimal none of this is optimal none of this is Perry's birg and like I say I was doing my level best to try

084and think out of the box and if I've learned anything over the years is that every time I come up with an idea this guy tells me about all the dominoes that go into what I thought thought was a great idea um so okay no it it makes sense I just felt like I had to had to ask I'm sure I knew that y'all thought about it but I just I just hate to see problems with our music program when they're just nationally recognized and that just seems de side of criminal to have to do that can I clarify the the foreign language did I hear like the ASL you're not getting rid of Spanish You're just reducing a teacher so you'll still have a Spanish program at the high school right you'll still have

085an ASL program at the high school but we all know that ASL is so so hard to find a teacher for that very difficult I know perisburg has struggled yeah for several years as have I yeah um right so we're not eliminating to clarify for everybody in the community they're still going to be Spanish correct still going to be ASL correct um it's just you don't have you're reducing the number of teachers in the program correct exactly Miss lmer you'll be happy to hear that we do currently partner with Owens for CCP um and we also do we're partnering with Ohio school for the de for ASL um through online instruction yeah for our a level one some of our level one students and it's going really really well so um that's pretty cool yeah

086yes we are preserving ASL as much as possible um because we know that's important and it's it is Grant funded by the state of Ohio because they know the need for interpreters but also for ASL instructors so and you said Grant funded yeah yeah yeah even better yeah this questions for Mr cookson um with the reduction of foreign language and freshman Sports um is this going to become a issue down the road for our high school students especially with graduation requirements um with the World Language um they'll still be able to choose you know from the four that we still offer from Chinese ASL um French or Spanish so uh the reduction I don't think will affect honors diploma or the ability to meet graduation requirements uh the class sizes will get a little bit

087larger obviously but um no that shouldn't affect graduation require IR ments or honors diploma because they still have those opportunities for both um and then the Freshman Sports And in regards to um pretty much in regards to the gym waiver oh um it will limit them somewhat um they will still have the opportunity The Freshman like Mr jakc alluded to still have the opportunity to participate in in sports and if they don't um potentially make the the sport of their choice maybe there's another option for them to be able to uh to take part in um or they can get the waiver and other areas outside of uh Sports as well if they're you know involved in other uh activities um I assume you're referring to the the the two years of of of a

088of sports before their senior year or a band or other opportunities as well so um I think it could potentially limit it somewhat but I those opportunities are still there for them will there still be the summer option for PE or is that no longer an option we are yes we're we're still working on uh summer health PE and summer school in general um for for this upcoming summer so you could still take the PE during the summer which is what my did before they allowed merching band yep that's the plan y so then I'm I'm gonna be the I'm gonna go along with um Mrs larer and I'm going to be the 12th voice and I'm sure this is not going to be a popular um statement but looking at this I just I

089feel there's a disp disproportionate reduction in the Fine Arts versus the athletic programs um SL you want just all of them if you're looking at the junior high well I mean if you're looking at the junior high and you're looking at I mean I get it I I coached I was a varsity athlete I understand Athletics um you know also everybody knows I work for TOA public schools and I know there's a couple people in the community in the in the audience here that you know we we've had to other school districts have had to eliminate big cuts you know in into Athletics so just looking at this you know I I just don't I want to make sure that it's pretty even across the board and when I look at this I mean I

090don't know numbers and that it just to me it just feels like there's more cuts to the Fine Arts programs um and then their larger numbers of participation in Fine Arts than there are for some of these athletic programs and I don't know if that's just me or um you know the need for seventh and eighth grade sports like I said don't don't shoot the messenger I'm putting it out there because this is the these are the these are the people who've come to me that said why seventh and eighth grade Sports I mean I I get it but if you're looking at what benefits the bigger and the larger amount of students are we looking at everything across the board and I'm asking a decision right now yeah I think I think we we've

091tried to to find that balance I I can speak a little bit to it from a junior high perspective if you look at it so like I said before like we we took a look at like comparable experiences for for example you'll see um a stip in that was eliminated the activity coordinator for winter running club you know there's 85 students in the in the winter running club um but we also offer comparable experiences with cross country and track that are still on the table there uh you see the from a music standpoint you'll see the um you assistant directors in band Orchestra in in choir you know with it so we're we're still having so those those stiens are put in place to do our concerts so we're still having the concerts those are

092all still in in play you know with it and that's something that we've talked to our Music Folk about as well too um it just might look different in terms of the the length of it or the amount of the concerts that are happening all the the way through um with that so all those different experiences are still scheduled to to be in play with that um it might tail entail um some more creative work on our administrative team to supervise kids while one grade levels perform sining and the other one isn't because a lot of times that that was the Dynamics of it you have one one director directing or conducting the music while the other one is doing the supervision from the other grade level so then there's that piece of it that

093we work out administratively with that um but those experiences hold will still hold true you know at the Junior High um if you look at different things like um the math counts and then the um Power of the pen and the mock trial um that were eliminated there uh the rationale with those particular uh things um were those were um activities that we we not affiliated with with a league or an official organization with that also had um pretty uh significant expenditures outside with registration fees or travel costs um so Mack trial like I said before Mack trial um and math counts competes to Columbus and these are expenses that are paid out of building level funds you know with it and the same with the power of the doing some registration fees to different

094events um all around Northwest Ohio um that kind of go into that but um if you know from an art standpoint you know you know the the director positions from all three musics are still intact like I said the the concerts are still going to to go on like I said it might look a little different super supervise wise um you know all the way through there um you know but then you know if you look you know we the musical all those stip in supplementals the show choir um all those the stem the Quiz Bow uh student council it'll stay in intact there yearbook um I think one of our goals would be like um to see similar you know commonalities at power of the pen there's a lot of commonalities with yearbook so

095it's a similar experience um so that was the rationale with thinking um if you look at our athletic programs in terms of numbers um just kind of going through so we have like for basketball we have one coach for seventh grade boys basketball right we have one coach for 8th grade boys basketball and so forth um you know cross country we have two coaches for both boys and girls um and we have about 75 Boys on a cross country team about 70 girls on a cross country team with with two like quite frankly are probably underst staffed you know in terms of supervision with that right um you know with the football piece of it you know seventh grade and eighth grade you both have around 50 you know players on on both grade levels

096you know you know with it um and then and track I mean there's 25% of our school does track I mean there's 250 kids you know out there with with the track piece of it um you did see a couple uh reduction in forces in athletics with wrestling and in cheerleading um those two positions were relatively new added um you know but they don't have the student participation numbers that the other ones I just mentioned that did um that you could do appropriate supervision with what we had had with that um you know with with those two teams so hopefully that that clarifies a little bit for you with the thought process at least at the junior high perspective you know with it like I said we want to try to keep intact um as

097many experiences as we could um and keep affiliations and things like that in in play for us thank you um that was like I said I wouldn't be doing my due diligence as a board member people had asked you did and I'm I thank you for putting that out there because I've been asked several times when people have seen this and I said you know I I would do my duty and ask and I appreciate that clarification along with the numbers Mr DWI a roundabout number on how much summer gym cost the district no idea no idea what what cost the district summer PE summer PE summer PE no idea no idea yeah there is a fee charged to students we are we are look summer program in general we in fact we got a

098meeting scheduled on Friday just to talk about all that so we we don't generally break it down by by class but we're looking at you know Staffing and costs and those kind of things but there is a fee though charged for health and PE yes there I paid students and families are charged for that quite a pretty penny if I recall and I'll just add in um back in October and I'm not going to remember the figures and I didn't bring this with me but I had I had questions about the especially the supplementals and how those were reduced um and I ran the spreadsheets on the supplementals and what was cut in the athletic department um exceeded what was cut in the supplementals now that doesn't get into teaching staff but they were it

099was more equal than I expected when I ran the numbers all right thank you gentlemen I appreciate it so we'll move to technology maintenance and transportation so we'll follow a similar format that we that we used with uh our uh junior high and high school um uh teams um so we have uh Jason Bloomer who is our director of uh maintenance um and and then we have uh James mapus who is our executive director of operations so he's responsible for transportation food service and um maintenance and ground so he oversees those so um so the the positions that fall into those areas that you'll see um at the high school two custodians at the junior high one custodian um and uh at the board office we have a district or in the district a district

100custodian a grounds person and then technology uh tier one technology tier 2 and Male carrier um so maybe just kind of walk us through about those positions and the impact and um you taught me a new word trash and dash so Mr Bloomer thank you for that it's not great but I'm sure that might come up in your ation yeah um thanks for having us here tonight to uh go over some of this so some of the cuts that we have uh obviously we have two at the high school one will be a day shift one will be a night shift uh position uh at the junior high we will have a night position at HPI we will have a night position and then we have a district custodian that we were able to use

101uh between and what that is is they travel between Fort Megs and in Woodland um one of the things that we did is we looked at the size of the building the number of students uh activities things like that so they they actually get were receiving 20 hours uh at each building to help uh with cleanup and things like that to uh help the custodians just because of the size of the buildings and then we actually had a what we called as a district sub it was a full-time position um that that would be eliminated as well uh then is in I think the last slide was one grounds person that was being eliminated Mr Bloomer just help us um our custodial staff numbers per square footage we were below the Benchmark to begin with

102is that correct correct so the the the average that you want to be around um and I have it here is somewhere in the roughly the 19,000 to 24,000 average um we're already now going to be above that um which is a little concerning for us and I think if we go to the slides uh further down and and we get into the activities of things that we have in our buildings um and we're at going back to 2122 we have around 20 or 7500 events in our buildings the following year of 2223 we went up to 8,500 last year we were at 9500 and currently right now as of of last week we're at almost 7,000 events in our building uh so so thinking about that when when we get into uh basketball games

103and all the events going on and Community use of of what it takes for our custodians to keep up with with that it's it's challenging for them um and I have been working with uh the junior high the high school HPI with the principles to sit down and and try and fight through this because unfortunately with our reductions they have already hit us uh we James and I sat down with Mike Holyfield our our opsy rep uh because we had some uh retirements we had resignations which you can see on the board now so we've already lost five of the six positions that are being eliminated so our cuts are hitting us now um and we're just trying to keep up with everything and I think the challenge part now is everybody's still pretty much

104functioning at 100% and we've lost 15% of our staff already and we're still trying to make everything happen so kudos to them I know they're struggling through it and and we're trying to help them any way we can to get through this uh so one of the big things we're looking at now is is how do we function with all the events in our buildings I mean we're on Pace to have over 10,000 events just just this this year so that's one of the things that we're trying to kind of group together I I meet with our head custodians on a regular basis um and and how that affects us yeah that's just so far this year um and that was as of I believe yeah December 6th so there's 7,000 outside events or inside

105events as far as as you know what's going on in our our buildings and I think there's a pie chart um that follows that that kind of gives us a breakdown of what um I don't know if you have that did you have that on there the the the question about substitutes too I know we're changing the process in terms of securing a sub when someone calls off and then just how is the subpool while I kind of advanced to that slide so yeah so what we have is with our Red Rover which is our absenteeism uh with our subl list so if somebody puts in for a sick day or vacation day we have our sub list that can pick those up that's another thing that's going to be eliminated is our subs um

106with the cost of what we looked at of of what it cost for us to have those subs it was it was either cut the subs or keep a full-time position and and we felt we wanted to keep a full-time position to keep somebody employed uh so with looking at that our subpool is about five six people um we actually tried to get a couple more um filled and this was before the Lev unfortunately um they weren't able to do that um so we're we're sitting at about five or six people and it's up to them when they want to fill that position similar to um I believe our our our teaching Subs that you know if they want to pick up a day they can and um one of our subs that's actually here

107tonight um he's uh I want to say he's in early 80s that is still working and and I appreciate Jim filling in and he still fills in quite a bit um and does a great job for us so um it it's hard it's hard for them of what we have to do uh to keep up with all of our building activities so so the chart that is here um uh Jason and James did a great job of pulling data so every time there is a an after school event weekend event um they're able to go into our system and kind of extract it and and say okay here are the activities and you can see that in and tonight's a great example I had somebody say boy I saw all the cars in the parking

108lot and I thought the room would be packed well the building is packed because we have Junior jackets practicing across the hall um we have perisburg musical theater that that is down down the other end of the building and that is playing out in every one of our buildings and for for years we have made a commitment and I appreciate the board allowing us to do this to be good partners to the community so so not only are we talking about opportunities that we're providing our own students but we've opened up our buildings none of these groups are being charge for their activities this evening um so that kids can participate um we have a custodian here we have a custodian other buildings they're able to kind of keep an eye on things check the

109bathrooms you know after it's additional work for them but but that's something that we've been able to do and and what's happening now with the reduction of custodians the lack of Subs the inability to have those uh Subs at a meaningful way 34% of the activities that are happening in the district are Community groups that are not school district sponsored events and so that creates a real challenge a real challenge as you're hearing um from Jason about how do we do that 4% of that 34% are charged because again we we like the fact that there are kids across the hall participating in these activities um and and so but we are now at a point with the the the funding level that we have to to hire staff to do these things it is

110challenging to to maintain yeah and one of the things that we used to have um when I got here is we had a custodian at the Junior High in the high school that worked Tuesday through Saturday and one of the things for the Saturday that we had was to help out with athletic events or Community use things like that so they weren't being charged unfortunately now with the reductions that we're having we've already switched the junior high I believe it was last year that it went to a Monday through Friday just because we couldn't keep up I mean we're losing that one person on Monday night of of cleaning our building so we had to switch that and then we just recently switched with all the with all the reductions of the custodians the high

111school so now that that position that was Tuesday through Saturday is now Monday through Friday just so we can keep up with cleaning build cleaning the classrooms um keeping them safe keeping them uh disinfected things like that for the staff and and for the students and and that's our number one thing is for their safety and and for their well-being and and that's what we're trying to do and so it's it's just hard when you look at this and and you think about you know close to 10,000 events that that are happening in our buildings and 3,500 of them are Community use so that's just you know something that we we have to take a look at yeah thank you for highlighting that concern right there about the community use and the impact on what

112your guys uh what your folks need to get done on a daily basis also as in the side I was here late talking with Mr hosler and ran into gy who is here still doing his duty and he is a great guy to talk to but I you I do have a question here though so you had mention you know the right the primary mission for your folks is to keep the classroom experience clean and safe and with these Cuts with with with losing custodians what are your concerns about the experience and what's going to have to happen within the classroom I think as far as the classrooms I mean the hard part is is losing our subs so we we sit there and we focus on just the reductions that we lost of of

113one custodian at night at the high school but we have to take in they they take vacation time they you know they have to call in six so that one person now turns into maybe two or three so we have to focus on what we what we have to do and and our biggest thing is to make sure that the classrooms are are taken care of um and like I said we've been working with Mr cookson um meeting with him of different things we can do um as far as the teachers of what they can do to help us um you know make sure that we make that that experience for them for the students when they come in that their desk are clean that the floors are clean um so it's it's it's just

114a challenge for them and and we're doing everything which I think we can I think the biggest thing is is that we have to look at you know with our events in the building um especially the high school where I know last night they had a basketball game um the girls were playing tonight the boys are playing uh typically we would we would go down after the games we clean the gym get the bleachers all put away for class the next day well now we're at the point now with already having reductions that the bleachers are staying out we we just don't have the time to go clean you know after we clean those bleachers to put them all back away then the next day to get them all back out so you know working

115with uh you know Athletics and and we've met with Mr ja and different things and he spoke with the coaches of of things are just going to have to change of how we operate thank you I just want to say too one of the things that we've noticed this year that we've never had before is where we've kind of had to insert oursel and volent told someone like hey there's a Sunday event someone has to pick it up and um it's hard when they look at you and they're like we're just tired of picking it up like we're just burned out and we get it you know it's hard on their bodies they're cleaning all week they picked up extra rooms they're trying to get those rooms clean they're trying to get events cleaned up

116and then now there's a Sunday event and they're like I I don't want to work it and excuse me that has been a challenge as well um we've been getting pushed back on that in my eight years here I've never gotten pushed back on that um but we always get it figured out and they do it but you know obviously it's one of the things that we are hearing from them so one one of the things that as we're talking about this so you you've heard about just the ability to cover the ground you know when when groups are here um the ability to have subs and vacation days and things like that and be able to fill those and just absorbing that extra work um we're losing Subs um we're losing staff and so

117um you know there's a sustainability question that has come up from our staff saying you know how how can we sustain what we're doing and I think that is a a legitimate question and and you know here you know we began to to try to find that balance um between um doing what we can for our our staff um but also doing what we can for the community the fact that we have that many events um and and again if we have somebody here that can unlock the door for them we don't charge them so we've been great Partners to the community but what we're hearing from our staff is this isn't sustainable so what is the right balance and I think that's something that we'd like to bring back to the board is we

118need to strike that balance um pulling the rug out and saying know community events I think is not the right balance but continuing to to ask our staff to do what what has been described um and having our buildings with those events rolling until 9:30 um I I don't think that that's the right balance either um so we're working hard to come up with something that we can share with the board to say you know unfortunately we're going to have to sit down with these groups and say um you know this is what we can do for you um and and share that with you but I think it's important to hear the reason and the why behind that so the cuts are impactful in in a lot of different ways yeah and one of

119the things that we looked at is is and I know we talk about inflation and things like that but the 2021 22 school year we spent $103,000 in custodial supplies in the 2324 and I know there was an increase in outside events or events in our building but we were up to 158,000 in custodial Supply so and I know some of that is inflation but the more events we have the more cleaning we have to do so the more cost it is on us so um just something else to think about um when we look at this so Mr mapus do you have or Mr Bloomer whoever can answer this do you like what's the average number of hours are custodial staff is working I mean you're right we can't keep up at that pace

120nobody can but if you if you don't have subs and somebody's on a vacation then we don't have a b to clean the building I mean what what is our average hours I mean we're still I mean they're still working their 40 hours but the the overtime for events and things like that um it goes on a a seniority basis so not every person has to take an event so if if there's five of us in in order and and I'm at the top of the list and say hey we got a basketball game on Saturday I can say no I can't work that then it goes to the next person so some of the I work here and there and some of the other ones are picking up more overtime and in working those

121long hours and and that's where we're hearing it like I can't keep doing this right what happens when nobody wants to pick up an event then we have to go so overtime yeah we can't force it the one thing we can do is is open it up to other District custodians um so even though they may be you know we have 10 nighttime custodians at the high school you know if there's a Saturday event say let's just say nobody picks it up we can put it out to to the other custodians at the other schools if anybody wants to pick it up the hard part is is you know we have building codes access you know where's everything at set of keys um all that stuff so then it it it just gets harder and

122harder to to make that happen um but like Mr Maus said one way or another we we make it happen um and and it's just it's it's taxing on them at this point thank you I think that um one of the things that that you heard and Jason thanks for the information and James you know citing the amount of supplies that we spent from 2021 to where we are today because we charged our staff with turning over every Rock to find where there could be savings and there's only so much we can cut with paper and supplies and those kinds of things and so we've asked um you know Transportation the same kind of question you know turn over every Rock what can we do to to um to find those dollars that we can

123redirect to to the classroom or other areas or or to hit that Target um so so one of the things that came back and it wasn't shared on October 8th uh but as they began to do their work and and work on um you know finding those dollars there was a tremendous uh opportunity for for Savings in in terms of routing when it comes to our elementary and looking at our current config configuration so we we we wanted to share with you about a discussion about uh new Elementary boundaries because that is an area where I think there can be an opportunity for some additional cost savings that might help you know put some more money into some of those other areas that that Lori and Sue that you talked about so so um I

124know Brooke has been instrumental and and James um so turn it over to them as we get into this conversation yes um again we've been tasked with looking at where else can we be more efficient what else can we do um you know the reality is we've lost operational funding you know we've heard a lot from the community long-term plan you know that 8-year Levy was the long-term plan to hopefully be able to you know sustain our operations as well as um you know hopefully then within that time period hopefully be able to ask for a new Elementary building you know unfortunately that also did not pass so we don't see that on the horizon anytime soon and the reality is is the way that we're growing there is an imbalance in enrollment between our

125elementaries and where the boundaries are boundaries are currently drawn it's not an efficient it's not an efficient model right now um and what's been happening is we've actually been essentially quietly redistricting as new subdivisions have come online and so typically you know we'll get word a new sub a subdivision is being developed it's approved for 46 Lots we know within that neighborhood maybe it's slotted to you know being in the fort M Zone that whole neighborhood will not fit in Fort M school so we already having to divide neighborhoods or look at class sizes class sections for new students that enroll and force transfer them to a spot where there's space so that's already happening and the reality is we're continuing to grow that that's not stopping regardless of of not having that funding stream

126so why now again you know we're looking at where's students are enrolled and we're trying to achieve that balance between schools redistricting would also of course just increase efficiency of bus routes and walk zones and again evening out that enrollment between buildings and we'll get to a slide to show you the differences and some of the things that that causes um but also redistricting could also delay the need for another trailer it can push that out a little bit longer and so if we can push out you know half a million to a million dollars of costs further out that certainly will help um um again evening out the number of sections within a building there's operational pieces to this that aren't necessarily realized on the surface so for example part of this reduction plan

127at the elementary level is we're reducing Library we're reducing an encore section so we're going down to four you know gy PE art stem well a couple of our buildings have six sections of a grade level in the past we've been able to divide up five sections into four specials dividing six sections into four specials is going to be problematic and right now where we have those imbalances in enrollment that's what happens and so um Additionally you know each building still only has one Dean one health aid you know a a limited a limited amount of staff and so op from an operational standpoint just a workload standpoint what can we sustain um so piece to the Staffing levels with r districting as well of of course like the space issue so if the district

128decides is is something or the board decides is is something we should consider and pursue um you know what is look to January early February really fine-tune some some details of what that would look like and what it would do to to enrollment size um reduction of routes all those types of things the cost um basically essentially like the benefit and the cost comparing those two things and we would present those options um to the community we would hold meetings at elementary buildings and then a general meeting to gather that feedback um and we would collect data we do some surveys and then the idea would be that we could present at the February board meeting options to the board based on the feedback collected and have a recommended top option for consideration um we

129would like to have these plans in place by March um March is typically when we kindergarten registration is February but March is typically where we place students and so of course we would want to not notify families of those changes that would be coming as well so you can see the differences in enrollment now you know Woodland has 179 or 180 more students than to and you can see those building capacities um the buildings with the asterisks already have trailers but really you know we want to look to how can we maybe even out enrollment closer to around a 500 average per building versus that imbalance that gives us a little more breathing room and it also delays the force transferring that will have to happen so if we don't do anything what's going to

130happen is Fort Meg and Woodland will be well over capacity a new student will move into that area we're going to have to force transfer them to the building with room and that's not going to be efficient um in any way shape or form and is is going to be problematic as we continue to grow so this kind of of this is our current routes and you can see the overlapping and the inefficiency that's happening with the way we've currently been growing and again I want to kind of go back to reiterate the original plan was to be able to secure funding for a new Elementary build that elementary and redistrict one time at that time so that was the that was the long-term plan that's obviously not happening now which is why we're bringing

131this as a consideration to the board um so you can see there's a lot of overlap and here's some closer up pictures of just you know you have four buses essentially going into you know one down one street to pick up students because that's what's having to happen now um issues with our current routes is expensive because we are having to send buses into several buses into the same neighborhood because of some of the spacing issues there's a lot of overlap um a lot long longer routes you know there are student that drive by three elementaries to get to their own Elementary um currently with the way that the boundaries are we're also having to divide as I mentioned before having to divide neighborhoods so right now there are are already divided neighborhoods due to

132the growth um and again that imbalance of enrollment um we're also limited in our walk zones with the way the boundaries are drawn and so this could give us the ability to rethink some of that as well so this is just a sample this is a sample with um the software that we have within Transportation um where it we can plug in information and it can redraw boundaries based on efficiency so this is just a sample and you can see the difference of how all the colors are kind of grouped together obviously meaning it would be more efficient that way versus the previous slide where you saw a lot of overlap um and so again this is a sample one of the the things that we will have to do it's it's that balance of

133efficiency with routes but also so density and you have to consider enrollment side size um for where all the students are living and what what buildings they would go to um but this Consolidated routing Tom if you want to scroll ahead there we could possibly reduce um about five routes just based on preliminary data um you know again increased walk zones requiring less busing as well may even be able to eliminate some potential crossing guard locations cuz right now we have to post them at some pretty busy streets we may be able to change that um approximate annual savings by just the five route reduction would be an estimated 100,000 per year and that's just the the route and again it would reduce the volume of buses on the freeway the way that we would

134look at redrawing the boundaries and again it delays that forced transfer of new students which is super inefficient to do when you're routing and it would be we would be able then to keep kids in the same neighborhoods going to the same building building instead of having this divided neighborhood situation um that we have now so considerations moving forward um one of the things we have to consider is the anticipated growth and where those areas will be assigned and we have a slide that kind of shows you what's coming online here in the near future we also have to consider just Equity um we we need to look at socioeconomic status and make sure we're taking that into account when We R drawing our boundary lines um particularly concerning like Title One funding we also

135want to look at the number of students impacted so with that we're we're putting together we will drill down to every student on that street that might have a change so we really know how many students are impacted along with that though I will kind of caution the board um I really think if if this is something we do pursue we are going to need to consider pausing in District transfers because we will have have a lot of people that of course want to remain in their current building and I think that's going to be a real Challenge and may defeat the purpose of redistricting with that so I just think that needs to be kind of out there I know it's an unpopular um you know popular thing to say but I think that

136needs to be a something we're going to have to really wrestle with um I know that will be hard for some families but again I think I think it won't work if we if we approve you know District transfers if we make this change um you know unfortunately unlike redistricting when we have a new school this is really being driven by a lack of funds we need to do something different that that $ 13.5 million is a reality and um this is a way to one alleviate some of the financial strain but also give us space for a longer amount of time because we won't we won't have a new building coming anytime soon um we'd also need to look at possibly some policy changes around walk zones as well so these are areas already

137approved for developing in the community that are still under development so you can see there are several here um and this is where they're currently slotted to attend but um you know we just got an email I think last Monday you know 46 homes was it comry Point um 46 additional Lots in the 19 forget which one um but you know we we're continually kind of have a spreadsheet and keeping track of the number of lots approved and so this is kind of a sample of what is is still currently under development now that we would want to take into consideration when we're looking at redrawing District boundaries or potentially redrawing District district boundaries so um again we didn't talk about this in October um you know the goal was to secure operational funding and

138be able to hopefully pursue an elementary building which which is needed we are still growing um but this is our reality and so this needs we think we should bring it to the board for at least a consideration and if the board chooses to to want to potentially pursue that we would gather information put those details together share it at each Elementary as well as with the board and kind of go from there yeah I just want to add to uh one of the things too with bus routes that we have to keep in mind is right now a lot of those bus routes are three- tier bus routes and so some of the buses have a hard time getting into the high school I know that's one of the things Aaron has to deal

139with every day is some of the buses coming in late because of those three tier because we're trying to push in elementary and some of those other things because we don't have necessarily always the driver or the buses to do those things um so this would also help with that the other thing that it would help with as well is some of our bus drivers are getting four and a quarter uh you know or more hours when you start staying in the same area when you're pulling out of the school and you start dropping off within two three minutes that bus route's going to go a lot quicker than when you drive for 20 minutes and then start dropping kids off so you start reducing time of of bus routes as well um all the

140bus drivers are minimum of four hours so typically we see between four and four and a quarter for our 4 Hour driver routes our 4H hour routes sometimes they do go to a quarter but some of our elementary routes really push into especially the Woodland routes and some of the Frank routes now that are are expanding out we do see where some of those routes are you know 5 and 1 half hours and so those would be reduced as well so not only would we lose those five five bus routes but other bus routes also would be Consolidated as well can you explain the three tier busing first sure people understand we have buses that do a um in the AM they do three segments and in the PM they do three segments so we'll

141have a bus that goes out and does an HPI or Junior High route and then they'll go pick up high school kids and then they go grab an elementary route um so that's what their morning looks like and then in the afternoon they're doing is they're going to either Hall prair Junior High as their first route and then they will go to it depends on where the route uh ends they could go to an elementary first and run them home real quick and then go to the high school or they could go to the high school and then go pick up elementary kids are we discussing tonight the um building usage and the rebounding of the elementary or is that this is information so so this is information I mean certainly the board can can

142discuss the the reaction you're hearing it for the first time um and um you know so however you'd like to proceed with that discussion and yeah I was just sitting here thinking that as well because I I've certainly heard kind of a ask for a for a direction on this particular instance this issue but I do think looking at the amount understanding the amount of M materials we have to cover still I think it's important to hear that information ask clarifying questions tonight to come back Monday to be prepared for a little more robust discussion I think some of the things that I'm already thinking that I know we'll want to discuss are the two you just mentioned right there so that that'd be my suggestion okay and I'm getting the High s so we're

143going to take a uh keep it a tight 10 minute break here we will rejourn at 8:05 that 805 no M gble [Music] e e e was my okay um thank you for that break it is uh 8:07 and uh we will keep moving through Board office and District that believe Mr Mr Hustler is next um so next um we will we will um touch base on um the board office and uh and so these are um certain positions that are districtwide and connected to this um this uh this building and and also districtwide so turn it over to Mr Christie and uh I know Mr Schwarz Miller is is up next can can uh can can jump in if needed but when you look at the board office in those District positions as you

144can see we put that because most of those positions operate out of this office or out of this building but even though some of them are most of the times out in the buildings they're they're headquartered here and then then they're out off of there so um and you can take a look at that with that Development Office secretary that being out of Jeff aby's office uh with that position being reduced um we also have a districtwide mail carrier um that basically goes between all the different buildings throughout the day delivering uh and providing that service uh we will have to look and see how we can do that differently uh with even if I'm going out to the high school for a meeting delivering and getting things delivered in that way as well but

145and there's also the financial the money aspect of IT person also moves all the money from the buildings to the bank and and also they're responsible for delivering the books to HPI so our relationship with whey library that is the person that brings the books back and forth so so so it's not just a male carrier right they have a we have a safe in the van because they pick up all the deposits from the buildings and take them to to the bank um which obviously will no longer happen happen so how will that happen then well it before we had The Courier position the building secretaries did it we'll have to revert back to that where the secretaries are making deliveries to the bank for any deposits that come into the buildings y okay

146so then Tom are you saying that we're not going to do the the way library book delivery or book thing I don't I don't know what it's called what I'm saying is that that person's responsible for that and and right now we we don't know yet how we are going to replicate that or you know because it's a little more involved in having a secretary go to the bank transporting the books back and forth is a different proposition so that that will be a challenge they'll have to work through and I don't know what the answer is yet yeah it's there there's some other there's going to be some challenges there I mean simple things cuz sometimes we're in session the banks aren't that money can't sit in the legally cannot sit in the buildings

147they'll have to come back to the central office and we'll lock it up in my safe so there'll be some there are some other challenges it's you know that we'll have to work through okay about so I was going to talk next on that central office receptionist position it it's played a critical role you know anytime somebody is coming in here to the central office they buzz in and then that person is there to to bring them in you know give them their ID you know notify whatever area that they're going to to have that meeting and then typically we would walk down to that office to get that person to come to our office off of that so uh they they also do a lot with the uh Stinger passes and processing those for

148all of the our senior citizens who are using those and picking those up and just do a lot of General duties it comes under the HR office umbrella but that person not only does things for the HR office they do things for many departments even our teaching and learning Department even the Treasures Office uh so it's kind of a person that's in multiple areas and impacts uh quite a few areas Within the central office operation and so looking how we're going to readjust and do that differently uh where people would be able to come in buzz into and get into the VES area and then we would be having to go down and meet that person there and so somebody if I have somebody that's coming in I need to be out there to to

149meet that person there would be a call system that they would be able to to do B basically pressing a button pressing a button was you'd say Brooke off of there and uh being able to get that attention to be able to do that um so you know we we currently have that person also right now it handles all of our what we call our Red Rover our absence management system for our all of our teachers we centralized that in one location and previously it was out to all the buildings and the building secretaries were responsible for that it's very helpful to have that centralized because in the mornings she gets here very early to be able to help fill positions that may be have not been picked up yet and so she's getting those

150out to other subs and I think it's really one of the main reasons why our substitute teacher fill rate is very very high in comparison to other school districts because of that role of that person being able to do that so again that will be pushed back to the buildings as well to handle that that proc that process with that too uh so there's a lot of pieces to that position that will just be you know pushed out to different areas and to different people as well I remember ARA being so concerned about security and that was one of the things for that position how will security for yall be affected by the the loss of that yeah they will not be able to get out of that vestibule area until somebody has going down

151to get them yeah they're they're tra in a sense they're trapped there because they those doors you won't be able to open those from the inside in that vesal area okay okay yeah all right well that's good yeah the development office secretary I know that was something that the board you know heard presentations about you know adding that support in development so it's the one one of the main departments here that that works hard to bring in funding for the district um and as you increase you know Jeff uh ABY made a presentation of the board uh a lot of the research and data that that we have um a lot of the research and and thing data that we have um shows that when when you have more staff in that realm the possibility

152to to raise more money is is what happens um so and just to give you some things um with that position going away but we went from 1722 donors in 2019 uh last year we had 3,132 donors so that office is getting more doning ations more donors that are cycling through so that support goes towards that so that was part one of that fruition you know having additional staff means additional touches the other piece of it was it allowed um our our uh development you know director to go out and spend more time on the road um engaging with prospects um larger donors so in that respect um in 2020 2021 we had 23 donor owners who made $1,000 or more gift to the district and um in 20 uh 24 you know this last

15323 24 we had 40 donors that made over ,000 uh gift um to the district and foundation so um you know so that that loss um you know is certainly going to put uh limitations as to how you know who does that work now so we have a development director who is spending more time time engaging with donors is going to spend more time having to to to do you know some of those kind of clerical things because there'll be nobody there to do that so that isn't you know another impact with that and um in the assistant treasur position with you know all the transactions that I just mentioned in the development office they'll certainly have increased in ry's Department as well yeah and assistant treasure is going to create some not having to

154create some issues in terms of um segregation of Duties because for example I just can't those duties can't I can't take those duties some of them because of segregation of duties there going to have to be spread out over other people and there and it's going to be just a responsiveness issue and some things we're not going to be be able to as quickly respond on some things but uh um you know it it's going to be a CH a challenge everywhere and uh my my main concern is still being able to be stay compliant you know for example the credit card program I can by law cannot be the compliance officer so it has to be someone it can be subordinate to me but it can't be me and so we'll have to figure

155some things out like that um so we we do have a hiring um a hiring freeze for next school year so I think that's um important for us to um you know to keep in mind that that with the incremental Levy we had um an increase each year in the amount of funds that we were collecting uh so that we could keep up with growth you saw the previous slide about all the developments that are underway um and and so we were very fortunate to have that incremental Levy that gave us the funds at the moment that we needed it uh in terms of Staff uh so without that we don't have any additional Revenue coming into the district so I need to add there too if you recall when the bond issue failed we

156we we were adding about a million dollars in new staff a year and that was built into the forecast well then we go okay we're going to have to add Portables so we reduce that forecast about $500,000 a year for new staff now for next year that number is zero now we have some money built in the future years but you know $225 $250,000 cuz we're still going to grow and we still got class size issues and we still have special education compliance that we're going to have to keep up with sorry to interrupt Tom yeah and that and that's it so we're very limited in terms of what what we can do moving forward Tom can I add to that as well and that Tom mentioned earlier too that when a position becomes open

157either through retirement or somebody else leaving the district that we are going to review every one of those positions and say do we need to fill it and then I'm having conversations uh with all those building with the building administrators saying okay what's the enrollment do you what can we do can we you know not fill that and and get the feedback from them and then go from there off of that so you know we also have to realize that we we are having some retirements that that are coming through with the strs lowering it down to 33 years we've had a couple come through we still have some that are we're waiting to see if we're going to get additional ones um but we again have to look at that whole picture and if

158that position has to be filled or or not off of there so I I still am in a constant state of recruitment uh because we never know from year to year whether some elementary teachers or this teacher may leave or their husband gets transferred or what life happens that causes positions to come open as well so we we always have to be ready you know for those situations too so and then with the salary freezes there for administrators and our Exempted staff you know right now I we're seeing that competitive wage piece right before eyes Jason what he's experienced with Rossford uh losing some of his staff that can make $2 an hour more going to Rossford as a custodian uh so we're we're seeing that you know that competitive part because we are we're

159very competitive with when I work go to other conferences with HR directors from Northwest Ohio I mean we all are checking each other to see you know who's who's you know getting who who's paying what and um you know everybody's always looking for that edge just as you are in coaching of you know to get that that team to be the best they can be and who can recruit for you as well so so those are those are those issues that'll be brought before us um there there's uh two unions two unions uh that represent the majority of Staff here in the district that are employed uh there is a group of employees that are not represented by the union um the administrators and Exempted staff so we we have a a salary wage wage

160uh freeze for administrators Exempted staff um and and so that'll be taking effect um you know at the next beginning next year so um and Mr Christie there's a couple of things uh committees that showed up up that people had questions about in terms of you know why do you have to why are those still there right the first there is the local professional development committee which is called the lpdc uh the state of Ohio and higher viice code requires a district to have an lpdc uh in the district and the purpose of that is to main thing is lure and making sure the staff are keeping up with the requirements they need to do to renew their license and they over over that 5-year time frame of making sure that they are on Pace

161to do that and so Paula Stout and in my office how the HR office handles all those she is reaching out to staff that committee we meet once a month to review requests to review uh what people are doing and making sure that they are getting those things approved but we're required by law to have that um and so that that's why that has to be there the second part is also so uh and it comes really out of Brent's office the teaching and learning the resident educator mentors uh we're required Again by law to provide our new teachers resident educator mentors and that has to be within their first two years and so that's why those have to be there as well um the professional development chair is part of our teacher contract and

162there's a uh sum of money that's dedicated uh for professional development for our staff and so that person manages that committee and they review when those professional development requests come in and make decisions on whether that applies to what we call their individual professional development plan A lot of them call it their iy dip uh off of that to they have to when they're doing professional development needs to be related to the goals that are in their plan and so that person chairs that committee uh to be able to use those dollars and again that needs to be has to be there for that Mr Christy can you explain to the community and you know so what resident educator is I mean I Educators know but what do commun community members who you want to

163do that I mean I can explain it but that can that can we can kind of transition the BR area as well so um the resident educated program used to be a four-year uh program for those new to our profession um after four years they could apply apply for a a an official license not a they call it a trial license provisional and so it was reduced to two years a few years back um and um we uh we have done a a pretty good job here in perryburg supporting our our new staff members through the process um and so I I'll actually talk about Resident educator a little bit on slide 74 um just uh to give you heads up um my message was more fluid a couple hours ago uh being slide 70

164found me making a lot of notes or crossing things out uh to avoid some redundancy so I apologize in advance um our teaching and learning this is Brent Schwarz Miller our director of uh teaching and learning so sorry so just yeah so thanks Brent so our Department's Mission uh is really root rooted in ensuring Equitable and high quality instruction for all students um that entails wanting all of our students to meet grade level expectations um exceed their personal best and prepare for future aspirations navigating that requires addressing a host of complexities and challenges um each is unique as the 6,200 students and staff members that we serve um and so with that in mind I just wanted to to sort of lead with that and share that we identify curricular review as a sort of

165a foundational practice for us for our instructional work um through this process we're developing common curricular maps to Ure consistency and Equity uh the map serve as pacing guides but also a shared vision for Success uh they enable us to uphold the same standards for every student regardless of teacher um this work extends Beyond curriculum at our latest tnl board committee meeting I shared a document why Curriculum maps are so essential um they're foundational in that they impact every other initiative that we do whether it's multi-tiered systems of support closing gaps uh for our uh identified in our one plan um assessment development grading practices inclusive practice is uh supporting co- teing um data informed decisions resource allocation teacher evaluations all are impacted by curricular review I share that because um teacher on special assignments

166listed and I I want to start by sharing what our current teachers on special assignment are doing um and sort of the impact of not filling that position so as you know last year uh the state um came out with a wonderful um mandate regarding in English language arts curriculum um we have two teachers dedicated to supporting that implementation currently um the implementation of Foundations in grades K through three and the implementation of Whitten wisdom in k6 and this impacts approximately 120 or so teachers this lift uh in implementation is immense it would have been immense in a smaller District it's immense in a district our size um I compare it to turning a ship um we do so cautiously and realistically um and without the support of these individuals um instruction would vary greatly

167and uh it would just be undesirable for our students overall the other thing I'd add with these two individuals is they also provide training in science of reading and reading intervention strategies without them we would have to pay out of District people or trainers to come to us and so they do provide for us um some cost-saving measures just because they're able to do the trainings we need we have two additional um teachers on special assignment doing curricular review they currently working with 12 different curricular review groups um four of those groups are in stage three which is implementation which is where we want it to be uh this works finds them working with 70 teachers on those revieww teams but also that would impact about 120 so teachers in those curricular areas as well

168um these individuals are also highly involved in schooly support data analysis instructional code coaching and support in specific specific areas like stem and the Fine Arts um one of the things that was sort of highlighted during our covid experience were a couple jumped out one were the gaps uh in achievement between our our um highest Learners and our our most needy and struggling Learners and the gaps widened over that period when I say widened I mean uh our our Performance Based on our all student average versus our for example our students with disability it widened our performance and the other thing that was most not able is just the variance of instruction um so the variance from teacher to teacher in specific grade levels and our need to make sure that we are in line

169with what we value and what we want in terms of uh our instruction at each grade level each subject area so um when we set out to to look at curricular review and and make sure that we have a curriculum that that is agreed on and consistent we looked at about 29 different curricular areas across 360 or so teachers um so the decision to to not fill the teacher on special assignment delays some work in some curricular areas that we haven't been able to tackle as of yet um we certainly understand the decision and will continue to work um and and continue the progress in the areas that are al already in the curricular review process and support the areas that are now not yet made that that jump uh we have made considerable ground

170in that in those 29 originally identified areas we have 22 of those areas in the curricular review process um and so that is uh just tremendous for us um so that that sort of addresses that teacher on special assignment slide um in terms of gifted I I know uh Mr buer touched on this um this decision truly reflects attention um of what we're requireed to do and what we aspire to do um as was shared um we're mandated to identify gifted students pull out instruction with gifted licensed teachers is not a requirement um transitioning to differentiate instruction within the gened classrooms um is a necessary Financial adjustment for us um I want to say the tension felt is partially in recognition and appreciation for the hard work given by our current gifted teachers we're certainly

171grateful and do not want to miss the opportunity or understate the fact that we're so grateful for their hard work um what I will say is the shift um can be supported in in the fact that there are districts across the St across the state um producing high achievement whether it's pull out or uh whether it's differentiated in the gened classroom um with our curcular review process and targeted support we're committed to ensuring to support that move into the gened classroom and help teachers adjust to the rigor and challenge with more students in their classrooms um so those are the gifted slides there's two and then the the last slide uh highlights some broader reductions um some of these responsibilities remain and now fallen existing Personnel uh duties like data analysis new teacher support the

172resident educator program um Tech integration and specialized training will just require our department to be creative um find Creative Solutions and um just collaborate additionally within our our department and try to handle it um the other thing that that I wanted to recognize and um the burden of of a lot of the changes outlined tonight um some of that burden is placed on our building leaders um um as instructional leaders in the buildings our principles are tasked with f fostering teacher growth and Student Success many of the responsibilities that were you he are being reallocated uh become more managerial uh tasks and um one of our department goals is to try to remain focused on providing Clarity and support and resources to try to help lift some of that burden um so our our building

173leaders can concentrate on being instructional leaders so all right any questions from from teaching and learning all right thank you thank you so next we'll have our elementary principles and um Mr best uh HPI principal done good evening and thank you for allowing us to be here to speak with you tonight um Mrs Mrs Mrs Bryant principal at Frank elementary sorry so no um like Mr Schwartz Miller was speaking about um we will be losing all of our gifted teachers um as Elementary principles when we were making this decision we were looking at what is mandated by the state and what is not mandated by the state um and although we do value what our gifted teachers offer our gifted students um gifted services are not mandated by the state um gifted teachers are able

174to provide students a faster Pace with the curriculum and a deeper more complex content um and the students will feel the loss of not having those Services um those students will be pushed back into the gened classrooms for those S um for their content and this will impact not only our gifted students but also the other students in the classroom because the teachers that would have um the gifted students receiving services in a different classroom would have Learners with diverse needs um you know in a smaller band now with the gifted students in the classroom they'll have a much bigger band of diverse Learners um which reduces the individualized attention and support that each student is able to receive on our list um which none of these cuts are ideal but we are responding to

175the community's vote and the need to make these hard decisions um we have classroom teachers on the list two and one intervention specialist you've heard the redistricting rebounding proposal earlier doing that will equal out some of the buildings which um is one of the reasons that we would be able to do this um we looked at enrollment numbers class sizes it's inevitable that class sizes will be impacted when we're trying to take away $ 13.5 million from the budget um so while it's it's heavy to offer up as a cut these are the decisions that um we're being asked to make thank you Miss Molina principal at Toth Elementary Dr salowitz principal at Woodland Elementary there you go Gotta first all right so I want to talk a little bit about the assistant Librarians uh

176and kind of the impact that'll be on each of the buildings uh it's really a place where reading comes alive it's a place where uh kids can kind of discover their love of reading for reading sake a place where great literature can be discovered hobbies and interests can be discovered uh and research skills honed uh and it's just a place that really supplements all the other learning that's happening in the building uh it would be a great loss for us I think also from a logistic standpoint um you know Woodland has two grade levels that has six sections uh losing the assistant librarian will bring us down to four Encore and I know uh Mrs price has mentioned this it will push our oncore classes to about 36 to 38 students in certain grade levels

177um just by pulling that out so it'll be six student uh six uh classrooms divided into four classes um and so that right now I mean we've been able to really minimize the amount of uh splitting that's been done and really kind of limit um the amount of students in each class um but the possibility next year will be that 36 to 38 range um Michael just mentioned Encore and just to share that that those are our specials so art music stem um Library PE um we also have custodian on our list Mr Bloomer has already spoken about that we feel the cuts already at the elementary level uh Jason feels that we feel the cuts uh through conversations it's um it's just a reality that we have to live now with the cuts and

178what that looks like at the student and the teacher level is um you know putting trash out in the hallways to make it easier for the custodians of course we always ask our students to clean up after each other which they do a great job at um but that certainly felt within our our buildings our aging buildings before before you shift over to HPI can you just clarify for me because I'm not well-versed in elementary schools anymore the because they're called assistant Librarians but you're saying that Library will no longer be an encore option can you clarify the three and how the assistant piece fits into that okay so I'm I'm going to some of it history I think that predates me uh I believe that they are assistant Librarians assisting the main librarian at

179the junior high school um and so I think that's in classification and in terms of three of them uh based upon enrollment growth over the last few years uh a few years ago we had two and they were they were shared so ours was at Woodland was shared at to with to and Frank and Fort Megs based upon the number of sections in growth over the last few years uh Woodland and Frank or I'm sorry Woodland and Fort mags have their own and now to and Frank Sher um assistant Librarians though still are operating their own library in in the school on on an everyday basis though it doesn't mean that there's a librarian still in your building because the the assistant is gone they are assisting the one at the junior high school library

180will not be offer at element thank you Scott Bast I'm the principal at Hall Prairie you guys are so cute boy girl boy girl just fits right in with your with your um level there so thank you for giving us an opportunity to speak with you tonight um I'm going to start with our building secretary position um as you know our secretaries are The Gatekeepers they're the ones that set to tone they're the ones that greet our our parents and the students each morning um I know I personally rely on on our secretaries to do a lot of things um everything from you know calling somebody down to the office to setting up a meeting um we're going to reduce our secretarial staff from 3 to two um to put this in perspective uh we

181currently have 930 students um Woodland the the next highest or the highest Elementary has 580 so we're going to have two people doing the same job uh for 450 extra families that you know in our building so it's really going to slow down our response time and um it's really going to have a big impact on how we operate next year in the office um you know Jason's talk about the custodian uh positions uh just to give you an example there uh two weeks ago we had the Toledo Symphony uh U Symphony orchester in our building the same time we had Junior jackets we had several hundred people in the building until about 9:30 and uh our custodial crew couldn't clean half the building until they left which gave them about an hour hour and

182a half to to finish up so you know the the the custodians have a big impact on on our our daily operations um I'm going to skip real quick to the the steady hall monitors uh we currently have two full-time monitors and two part-time monitors we currently have the two big uh classes so we have the bubble coming up through the school the loss of those uh positions will increase every math Ela science and social studies class by four to six students every single class with the elimination of those positions um you know with the gifted Ela positions you know Scott talked a little bit about that um you know up at the Junior High in the elementary uh folks um at our building um that will impact about 200 students next year the loss

183of those two positions um that will be going back into our gened classes every single one of our sixth grade ELA classes will be at 30 that will be the average um you know it also impacts you know how we instruct um just like you know the elementary buildings we you know we're working through a new curriculum and the differentiation piece is going to be huge um the intervention specialist positions uh one of those positions is our Behavior specialist position that works with some of our our neediest and most diverse uh Learners uh the other position um is one of our uh Team positions we currently have one is per team and losing that one extra person is going to really consolidate or condense where our students with special needs are placed so there's going

184to be a higher concentration on at least um seven of the teams and then um you know our lunchroom monitor um right now we have three monitors um we have um for example in in sixth grade we have about 240 kids eating lunch at one time um so that will go down to two um so that that's going to be a big stretch as well um what's not on our list um up there um you know Tom mentioned the The Courier the male Courier um that picks up our our books from only Library that's going to be a big adjustment um you know we've been working with Scott and and Aaron with uh the music folks so that we can continue to offer that at our building so that that really is going to impact

185um our school day so these are some of the activities and and clubs that are involved so we'll we'll kind of just talk through those a little bit all right at um the elementary we offer um student council and safe Patrol Those are some leadership opportunities that we give to our Upper Elementary kiddos um we have a yearbook that is um you know captures the year for memories uh for those kiddos um we do some showcasing of an art show um and of course our students enjoy taking their field trips and then each building um has some different clubs that they offer uh running club Game Club um what are some of the other clubs I can't even think stum Club um so those are after school activities that students um in a variety of

186different grade levels can sign up to participate um and just find something that fits you know what their interests are you want to talk about your clubs so I think one of the things that has made Hall Prairie unique since we opened is the ability to put our kids in leadership positions uh one Club I want to highlight uh Turtle protectors back in January 2019 um right before Co hit we had a group of students present to the school board a club they wanted to create and use our 3D printers um over the years that club has uh been maintained by our students um in fact I bought three little trinkets yesterday to help save the turtles but um some other things up there you can see um band Orchestra and vocal music even though

187we'll continue to offer those uh classes uh we won't be able to hold concerts or performances um we have our art show winter art show tonight um which is a great um experience for our kids we won't have those art shows anymore as well can I clarify one thing and just to clar verify like with when we talked about the junior high and high school reductions in those clubs and activities all of the things on this list have a paid supplemental contract so each building kind of has the ability to create different activities based on the like you know there's five supplemental contracts at an elementary level to create some of those clubs HPI has a number of those but the things you see on this list they're after school hours so a teacher is

188compensated to run those clubs and supervise those clubs and activities um but that's why they're on that reduction list because those all factor into to the overall amount of money that we need to reduce also on the Elementary on the elementary slide um I think a couple more speaking about activities you'll see that all of our Student Activities and supplementals are cut that's drastic but that's the reality of where we're at um these the Student Activities The indirect student student supports they enrich classroom learning they extend um they are vital for that enrichment but when we're talking about $1 13.5 million in cuts um we have to look at the enrichment part and and cut those first so while they're all being cut this allows us to preserve Core Curriculum instruction um State mandates so

189I just wanted to speak to the fact that of why all of the elementary positions are are cut so on on this slide you can see that we are eliminating our uh BLT our building leadership team the other buildings have talked about that um just like the other levels you know we rely on that group to um provide a lot of extra leadership um I know I rely on that group to help provide some insight and get different viewpoints so having that shared leadership opportunity gone is really going to impact the quality of our uh programming um you could see all of our activity coordinators um all our supplementals are gone and just like um Jessica shared you know those all they're incredibly important and give our our students the opportunity to grow and and

190show leadership um we just can't move forward when we talk about the 13.5 million that we have to cut could you explain the the band Orchestra and vocal uh at the bottom there is is crossed off is that just mean is that a reflection of in other words we're not doing the performances or does that have to do with the instruction so that that those are the supplementals for the after our performances okay you you want to go one more slide um or yep I was just showing that that was the performances but yeah what I made it I was making an assumption I wanted to be sure y because I'm getting emails so um one of the things that has really made Hall Prairie unique are some of the exploratory elect uh options that

191we've had over the years um it's been a big part of our steam uh program and our identity um you can see the list there at the bottom those are all the non-performing arts classes that we will be eliminating we suspending next year um a lot of those classes are are you know a a kid who might not Thrive let's say in in E you know Ela or or math they go to these classes and that's their relief for the day that's where they shine um and and again that's a large part of our identity um if you look uh at the third bullet uh Point um without those classes you know we we can shorten the school day and help out with the busing still maintain our our uh common planning time uh originally

192when we um you know Scott Aaron and I met with you know Brooke and and Don and and Brent and a couple other folks you know we were talking about a hall Prairie schedule that ended at 2:10 in all honesty if you end that at 2 p.m um you could create further savings um $9 $10,000 because we have we're required to have IEP meetings ETR meetings 504 meetings and just shorten in the day in extra 10 minutes or 45 total it we don't have to get subs to conduct those meetings we can have uh those meetings during the day with without getting that additional support um you know talked with Courtney um about the shorten school day um I I don't know the specifics her world but it seemed to really help you know because

193it freed up our 17 drivers basically to get to the elementaries in the high school before their route started which has been problematic um for a while so yeah so to clarify we eliminate all of those last bullets construction 101 create exploratory there's 's nowhere for those kids to go right so you have 45 minutes of nothing for them unless you reduce the day I mean what would they do so right now we have a each grade level has what we call an exploratory Block it's 45 minutes so that's on the teacher side that's how they get their second common planning period on the kids side they get to go to these classes that's also when we offer band choir and strings so um hopefully I'm answering your question um you're correct we don't have

194a place for them to go so then what I mean they go home right that's what I mean so you'd have to shorten your day can't give 45 minutes of nobody overseeing them yeah essentially thank you all right yeah I don't have any questions just you know just that reaction like all of this you know like Junior High and and high school there are some passs limited the here it's all taken away I mean I get it it has to be but this is this is you know so sobering isn't even the right word thank you yeah I to be honest Hall Prairie won't look like Hall Prairie it'll look like every other school and this is only $6 Million worth of reductions I can't even then comprehend what another $7.5 Million worth of reduction

195have the same thought right but then that's GNA jeopardize your stem designation as well will it yeah yeah thankfully we um we did it last year so we we have our stem designation for another four years now we're still able to offer some stem is part of our um the elementary is called Encore those special classes but it it's nowhere near what we have now and Sue one correction it's not 7 and a half million I mean if we have new money potentially 7 and a half million but you're looking at 9 to 14 million with cost increases well just because you we're talking about 20 million over two school years right it's not 13 and a half it's 133 and a half million in one year yeah that that's where I was going was

196if if we weren't borrowing from the piggy bank then um well not borrowing but taking from the piggy bank so you set a couple of things that really uh and I I I bet you Lori went through it too that hit that is hitting me hard as as a teacher as well as this bringing our gifted students back into to the general classroom and the differentiated why can't I say that word differentiated education that these teachers are now going to have to be planning for and it reminds me of a mom who has to make either dinner for this student or this student this this kid now because they've got to go to this practice and dinner for for husband because he's coming home but he's going somewhere and all these different meals that they're

197going to have to make and it's so so similar to that type of a thing um and it's it is such a burden on our teachers that want to do everything for all of their students and and then you really took my breath away when you said 30 students on average or at the least in an Ela classroom I was just going to say that OMG so is in something like a class like that which is just an enor enormous amount of work after school hours can parents or volunteers help out with that at all so one thing to point out in sixth grade next year every academic class will average 30 everyone not just Ela every single math Ela science social studies class okay question still stands is there any place for parent volunteers

198to help that burden be honest I I don't know that answer um I I I don't know the answer yeah and that's one of that's one of my biggest concerns it's like our our staff is already working at full capacity and cannot add one more thing to their plate unless you've been in a classroom trying to teach 32 K it's like hurting cats so now you have 32 kids you're trying to to do the best you can for with a variety of ability I I don't even have I I just I I'm just I don't have the words exactly not the professional words to come out of my mouth yeah it's just I hold it I mean I was a I was a seventh grade teacher teaching Ela I had 28 kids 29 kids it's

199we cannot and what I'm afraid of is knowing our staff that they're going to want to do it all and they're going to keep taking it on and taking it on and taking it on because that's what they need to that's what they want to do because teachers are helpers and we and they're going to burn out and and health they can't do it we can't and we cannot ask them to do it and they're going to feel like they have to do it and are and they're going to be guilted into it and this is going to affect across the board and I know this is probably not the time but I mean just when you talked about reducing a secretary I mean the response time our parents expect is like that they're not

200going to have it you're not going to be able parents are teachers are not going to be able to respond quickly to parent Communications they're not going to be getting that one-on-one personalized information about their kids I mean people do not understand how this ripple effect is going to happen across it it it's not just oh well we're not going to have ninth grade football you're it's it's just unbelievable this is just it's got wring on the happy not all right well thank you all than you so thank you thank you now this is the one that upsets me the most right do I get an introduction do I have to introduce myself Mr Hustler Dr F you Dr Andrea gler and Dr gler with pupil services and student services after that as he muts

201it right yeah uh well first I thought it'd be worth saying that I know pupil Services is a little bit of a mystery I think to people within the community so uh I like to say within a school district pupil Services is really the Catalyst to ensure that we're living up to the idea that all means all and uh our programming is complex and often very much intertwined with the law so things can be laborious and uh takes a lot to work through what could seemingly be an individual case so uh that being said we're working with students with all different kinds of exceptionalities so some of our most vulnerable and needy students so whether we're working with students who are economically disadvantaged students with autism students with physical disabilities students with ADHD students with

202mental health concerns um it runs the gamut and we are here to advocate for them on their behalf and make sure that we're in compliance with the law and doing the things that we need to do so uh there's numerous programs that we oversee and I think the first that we wanted to discuss and I'll pass it over to Dr gler is our special education program thank you thank you guys I know you've been here a long time so we appreciate you giving time to our department as well starting with special education a lot of you probably know this but in the world of special education were required to be compliant with the individuals with disabilities Education Act and what that says is that every student in public education is entitled to a free appropriate

203public education so I'm going to date myself I've been working in the special ed World in perisburg now in one capacity or another for over 20 years and we have always gone above and beyond we've operated from a best practices model we've really provided individualized research-based instruction and and intervention tailored to maximize each student's potential we've been a destination district for our gened students but even more so for our students with disabilities I don't think a week goes by that I don't get an email from a family that says hey move into the area can you give me a call and tell me about your special education programs we've heard great things um so you know we've been Innovative we've been Trailblazers and I think when I think about shifting some of that that's a

204really hard I think shift for me personally to wrap my mind around cuz I've we've been a district that other districts call and say tell us what you guys are doing or how do you do this we've been a model prog you know for programs for services we've created a ton of programs for students with disabilities and when you think about special education in perisburg you think about exceptional not appropriate so we'll be shifting with a lot of the cuts that I'm going to talk about to more of a compliance-based model and what that means because we're required to meet the needs of students with disabilities we one 100% will continue to provide the services outlined in students IEPs but we'll be meeting those minimum requirements you know legally procedurally the going above and beyond

205um I can't remember who said it if it was you Dr rer about response time to parents our intervention Specialists are extremely responsive to parents they almost serve as you know service coordinators for them in a lot of ways so I'm going to kind of summarize some of the positions in the special ed side of our department that are getting cut because I think they're all linked so there'll be an intervention specialist at the high school two at Hall Prairie and one at the elementary level along with that three pair professional positions we are in the same boat as Jason Bloomer where we've had some resignations that we are not filling right now and I think I don't know who said the buildings are feeling it and Jason's hearing it the buildings are feeling it

206and we're hearing it being down a couple pair of professionals um on top of that we'll be losing our academic assessors so we have a couple part-time staff who completes testing for us for required evaluations that allows our intervention Specialists and our school psychologists to be more Hands-On with students so that piece won't be there so ultimately I think some of the biggest impacts are that case loads will go up for intervention Specialists will be closer to those State Maximum levels where they're um allowed to be we've tried to keep them under a little bit to truly provide that best practices model and give some wiggle room so that'll result in I think a lot of impacts in different buildings at the high school level will'll likely not be able to offer the same courses

207as coau courses that we have in the past we'll have fewer sections of course our es uh Mr best mentioned clustering students we will no longer be able to have that distribution that's very natural for the population in the building across every team because we're going to have to Cluster students on teams so that intervention Specialists can provide services I also think we're going to see an impact on meaningful inclusion right now because our intervention Specialists are able to give that very individualized personalized attention to students they uh above and beyond IEP minutes spend a lot of time in general education classrooms supporting students Consulting with teachers modifying assignments assessment instruction and with more students on their case loades are not going to be able to do that our school psychologists are involved a lot

208as our intervention specialists in our mtss processes in the building so I think everyone here is probably well aware that early intervention is key there's tons of re search behind it without having them as accessible to provide intervention for students we're not going to catch all the students before they get to a point we have to look at whether or not they have a disability and needed special education services so that's a lot um and like I said I kind of wrapped a lot of things together there but I think it all goes hand in hand I know one of our slides talks about some of the non-staff cuts one piece of it is red ring the number of extended days for our school psychologists so that goes along with the same concept less time

209for them means less time for students one thing people often don't realize is in the special ed world the clock does not stop ticking over breaks so when our staff are out for the summer and we have a parent call and say I'm concerned my student has a disability and I'm requesting an evaluation our school PES need to be able to come in and work and respond to that request within 30 days just like we would when school is in session so those are some of the things even from a compliance perspective that we're going to just have to keep a really close eye on knowing that we have more limited time and let I think the last thing I want to say sorry like Brent I think I've tried to streamline a little looking

210at the clock but I've talked a lot with those of you on our board committee for people services our administrators in our district there's a an extremely high turnover rate in special education and the turnover rate of special Educators is like 46% higher than that of General Educators so I think some unintended impacts too that I worry about and we'll try my best to stay ahead of is trying to make sure that staff are not getting burned out and what are what are they giving up to take on some more things because I also think that having to constantly fill positions and rehire and retrain not only is it very labor intensive on the administrator's end whether it be building principles me Justin our assistant directors but research also shows that that impacts students and

211families it impacts student Rapport it impacts engagement it impacts outcomes for students and the relationship with families as well so I think there's a lot of hidden trickle down effects that are hard to make tangible I'm going to give one more example and then I'll let Justin have the microphone but I think every building principal talked about the loss of the building leadership team members and that's something that impacts my department too because I pull the special ed building leadership team member from every building every other month and work with them and hear about what's going on in the buildings are their concerns with parents concerns with kids do we have gaps in our Continuum of services um are we aligned are we doing things the same way at Woodland and at to and at

212Frank so again that's something that I think with that going away creates a bigger Gap in our special ed programming across the district as well all right uh there's the positions I'm going to talk about now I think uh as the district has grown and be you know and is wonderfully diverse it needs continue to escalate at the building level to a point where this board at one point in time was able to justify the creation of these positions in order to service the needs of these students on the Aggregate and so with that you know the 504 coordinator is a good example of that where um Section 504 is a part of The Rehabilitation Act of 1973 three which basically um guarantees or entitles students to be able to have equal access to you

213know educational programming where federal assistance is provided so uh to Dr geser's point you know we have been doing some things over the last few years and constructed a lot of streamlined processes to make things more efficient for our buildings and also to ensure that we are living up to the spirit of the law so as an example prior to this position you know this responsibility was delegated to different people throughout all seven buildings all with different flavors and understandings of what the intention of the law was and enacting plans for students for lots of different reasons so uh prior to the last I think four years we were adding 50 to 60 plans currently we're at 173 but we were getting to a point where we had over 225 plans going up 40% in

214one year we were a little bit all over the place so we reigned things in and we were able to uh help educate our staff create some guidelines and procedures and it helped to centralize something like that to um take some of the burden off of our building level administrators and counselors so you know that being said you know the immediate impact that's felt it's going to be about 1,400 hours worth of work that is going to trickle down back to the buildings to some level and so every everybody in this room my colleagues in the back especially has a full plate so it's not about what this the loss of that 1,400 hours means here at the district offic sits with their full plates with these legal mandates that we have to meet what

215is going to have to come off of their plate that either is an amenity or something that is very value adding that we're just not going to be able to do anymore so I think time will tell what the exact impact of a position like that being eliminated will be but I think um it's going to have an impact on counselors administrators School psychologists and intervention Specialists who we already know uh we're having a hard time retaining uh the assistant director of student services and well-being uh in addition to being a very talented and creative person uh that has some really great strengths that we've been able to build this position around to really have a Keen Eye on some very uh marginalized uh students an example I can give you and this is really

216tangible is our homeless students believe it or not we have 25 students who identified it as homeless within perisburg that number is up 75% in two years and I would ask why do you think that is it's not because we've seen that kind of increase it's because we have people paying attention and who have gotten really good at educating our staff I'm want to look for screening them through to us and being able to go through about a 10 to 20 hour process to get the student the resources that they're entitled to so that way they can worry about learning and not some of the other obstacles and challenges that they have we have 56 students who are Foster placed or Court placed they have rights and entitlements that we need to look into and

217have someone oversee those are complicated cases those take a lot of time to look into so when you're doing the numbers in your head you think 56 out of 5800 well that's not a very big number but when you don't have someone who is paying attention to it or it's added on to the plates of you know other principles and administrators it's hard to make that a priority so things slip through the cracks uh our immigrant migrant and elll population have really benefited from a lot more direct oversight and it's not to slight anybody who has ever in this District looked over those programs but we've seen an increase in our elll population as an example from I think uh going back8 years ago was 36 to now 145 uh just this August alone we

218went from a nearly 100 to 145 in that's unprecedented growth is English language Learners thank you and so you know our assistant director has taken the lead to help provide structure to help advocate for new positions come up with creative ways to to work with the county to bring in additional help at a lesser expense to the district uh really to Triple the size of our team in the last 3 years so you know attendance intervention you know there's a number of mandates around ATT uh attendance right where we have students who are classified as habitually truant you know they need to have attendance intervention teams there needs to be plans in place and uh PE the person in this position is responsible for uh compliance in those areas working with the buildings to even

219do home visits work with the courts are we going to file truancy charges what is the next step do the child need to go to Diversion again these are individual cases that require someone to be involved at some level so the social worker so I would add this as well to our assistant director is that uh the creation and oversight of the social work department that we've created over the last few years uh is a major responsibility and really we've developed a first class program and our individuals have actually been to national conferences and been keynote speakers to talk about how we've developed some of these things and I'll point out that 14% of our students are now classified as economically disadvantaged so to put a number on that that's 812 students that's like half

220the high school if we pulled all those kids into there or you know maybe not as big as HPI anymore but uh maybe a few years ago that would have been the case so we're not talking about a few kids that live in one particular neighborhood we're talking 800 children that uh their families fall below the federal poverty guidelines and uh have needs that maybe would be going unaddressed uh otherwise or at least would not be getting the sort of attention that we're able to provide now and I I brought an example so this yellow document is something called the no uh no wrong door help wherever you turn this is put out by Wood County because I know there's probably people that Wonder well why don't we turn to the county for some of

221these resources and what I can say is um I think we're probably in this position is because we have in the past and that our needs probably surpass what the you know we're the largest city within Wood County and maybe in the past if we had a family that had a need such as utility ass instance we might hand them this and say Hey you can call uh Great Lakes cap or the job and family services on that number and they'll be able to help you out well our team doesn't do that our team actually will call someone that they know there help the family complete the application ensure that it's done correctly and get them what they need and sometimes even quicker or know different resources and workarounds like it takes knowledge and expertise

222to understand how to work through this list instead of just plop it down in front of them and say Here's the help you need which without those people around this is what our staff at the buildings like our counselors have to resort to because they are don't have the time with 350 to 400 to 450 and in some Elementary 600 students on their case load to be able to do that except in extreme circumstances where you know their health or safety might be at risk uh lastly I want to talk a little bit about the student and family engagement liaison so when we start looking at you know some of the data that we get from families and students regarding sense of belonging and connection and we really pull that apart and look at some

223of the different underrepresented groups in the district um we've made a lot of inroads whether it's through our elll programming our English language learner programming or even some of the things that we've done uh in other pockets of the district but you know student family engagement Le on is reaching out to new families to do onboarding with them sending email to check and see how their enrollment process went is there anything that they need and we get requests from is there another McDonald's that's closer to my house to hey I I missed you know Supply pickup or we need this what can you help me they that person becomes a little bit of a coner uh another example of what is done with that position is mentorship and so this individual carries about 50 to

22460 students on their case load throughout the district where no one else in the building is having success reaching these students and you know we call this individual in to work with the family CU maybe the family has a conflict with the building because they're frustrated because uh no one's able to help their child and serves as a little bit of a mediating force in helping to menend fences and provide a not only a trusted adult but a positive uh conduit for the family so I think this is kind of an interesting statistic I'll share it so I looked today to see some of our behavioral uh referrals that have been written throughout the year and just see how many there are throughout the district uh in so far around 1,500 Behavior referrals have been

225written for students K through 12 so K through 12 6,000 kids so I don't know if that's high or low or anything like that at this point but that being said 85% of those are written for boys 85% and so I think if you've had boys in your home growing up and you've taught boys you kind of know okay but there's a need there right so to kind of satisfy that you know the student and family engagement Lea done and myself we work to see okay we need a program that works with boys specifically to you know work to develop their needs and so over the course of the last year you know two years we've put a program together specifically for boys in grades 5 through 12 where we've taken a couple hundred boys

226through different small group intervention to address their specific needs and that's what we do within this department it's about identifying needs being creative problem solvers and being able to figure out how do we deliver on this to help these students that otherwise wouldn't be helped so without the capacity to do you know with about the people to execute these things they just can't be done and so it's programs like that that you know we put in place too for Equity purposes because we have some great programs for girls and we have a little bit of a gap when we don't have similar opportunities for boys and that can be a little bit problematic so you know the student family engagement liaison also engages families with whose students have attendance issues as well so it's great

227to have these tools in the toolbx um and the same time um some of them aren't mandated right and so they're not required but you know being a district that is here to ensure you know every student's greatest potential is met you know that's what our charge is and that's what we try to do with what we had so um I think I'm good andless there's any questions or the next slide I think we have some other program related things that we wanted to touch on so I guess I'll continue for a bit one of the things on here that I wanted to point out was the elimination of the preferred provider program I don't that probably doesn't mean a lot to many people so this was also born out of some frustration with local

228resources and supporting the mental health needs of our students and there's plenty of options available I think some some of the relationships that we may have had in the past just weren't working for any different reasons and within the mental health space there is incredible turnover and so we were finding that we were losing school-based counselors in the middle of the year who were carrying case loads of up to 50 kids and so we finally just said we got to try something different and so we have resource lists that will pass the families who want to seek out help for their children in the mental health space and you know it's long but it's vetted and often times what they'll find is there's way and right now you can't get your child in for several

229months unless you're lucky and you find a upand cominging practice that is just looking to accumulate new clients well we went out inv vetted and talked to several different area counseling practices and said we want to partner with you and we want to take some of our funding and we want to ensure that our families are able to get the help they need for their children and so in doing that we have uh contracts with these uh practices that say if we send them a referral they're going to see the child that's referred within five business days so we've given our families a fast to get their children mental health supports if and when they need it and other nice thing too is that they know when we call and we've taken our their kids

230through screening um screenings in the building as needed for certain things that they're getting reliable information they know exactly what to expect there's great dialogue and collaboration probably the best that I've even experienced in these kind of relationships sh not only in my experience here but also uh in my in previous districts so you know that is another thing that's more of a I'll call it a luxury I think um because we have existed in the past where it's like here's your Referral List we can try to get you in touch with the right person but you may have to wait and so what does that have impact does that have in a classroom I mean if a child isn't right emotionally their learning is going to suffer and maybe even the learning of the

231kids around them as well so is there anything from here you wanted to add on so okay I just want to point out that um you know there's lots of good information on the internet but it's about six to eight weeks from call to an appointment and if you know anybody or you've been around anybody who needs that support two days is too much yeah it's very scary situations this is a very serious situation and um and going along with what you're saying uh Dr folz when you talk about um the mentoring for our students I mean how does that affect their academic achievement I mean if they weren't getting it what happens I can tell you that at the high school level and I'm sure we have some of our high school administrators who

232that can attest to this that we're we're getting kids across the finish line that otherwise probably wouldn't get there and you know yeah certainly attendance and getting them to come to school I mean even with our student support student service support specialist that we have through the county himself and the student and family engagement liais on probably have built connections and mentorships with nearly a 100 students between the two of them his room is always full he's got great rapport with some of the toughest students to work with and that's exactly why he's there and again um was it something that we have to do no but is it a need yes and so with the resources we had that was an option that we chose to exercise so um certainly if you can if

233those children feel that love and belonging it's a need being satisfied well now we can work with them on what are you thinking about for yourself next how do we help you achieve you know at a level that's going to get you there how do we connect you with you know someone beyond graduation so you have meaningful employment like those conversations take place but first we have to get them to trust us and find the person that they can trust so that's the key I think Lori and I have had a lot of benefit of being on your committee and these two particular positions that you're talking about when I saw them on the list back in October I just I said that can't that just we can't you just can't when you sit there

234and you don't help the students that need it the problems that come from that down the road just escalate like you said you know somebody who who needs and and I didn't realize the bullet number two until I read the slides last night and since I know someone who needed that desperately and because we had that program Not only was that marriage saved but that student was saved in so far as the student did not totally destroy the classroom because they got in on this and got the help like Lori said when they needed it and whoever came up with that idea I thought was just beyond being a Trailblazer I had to use it at least once tonight right um but these are three things that with with what you all have done God

235bless you because I know this was tortuous to do this whole presentation and everything but if there is any way to salvage those two people in that program for the students who so desperately need it because we've seen the results of that we've seen how desperate you know that so many people out in the community think that like Ray Pullman used to say it's not the chalk and chalkboard classroom anymore our students aren't like what we were in school the pressures everything that they go through and I blame social media and since my son's not here I blame video games too um I I cannot see a perisburg school district out without those three everything else I can sit there and Cry tears over and kiit cans and and bang walls but those three I

236think are just it's it's neglect it's student neglect I don't know how else to put it I just I think I'm sorry to interrupt I was just going to say I think the only way I could try to put logic behind it is I think if you roll back to the last time we were head operating funds at this level and you look at the positions that were existed none of these did right and so I think the harder thing to understand is that all this was attempted to being done by one individual prior to that and so there were things not being done obviously to this level but that's the commitment that was being made and I think a lot of these positions were created with you know grant funding that was one time

237that we you know due to that have had to made the hard decision that it just not sustainable with what where we're at now financially and so looking back it's we're ref functioning without them before of course are we better off with them yes but under the circumstances I this is just what felt like it had to be done understand that but don't we also have a lot more students now I was just going to say that we've had what 330 plus since the 2021 and and students have changed people have changed um over the course of the last four years oh yeah and while we may not have needed it and we have used it with Grant funds it's needed I would say that probably needed it but we to do it but now

238we've shined a really bright light on how much mhm you know and I and going back to the people Services too and I'm GNA try to do this without getting emotional um I'm very open about our story of Lucas from ages three to now and I truly believe that if it wasn't the school district he wouldn't be where he is today and yes you do go above and beyond and it's very upsetting that people don't understand that and what we do is the school district for our students is is more it's it's what's needed and I appreciate what the district has done for our students not just mine and so this is this has got wrenching yeah the fact that I mean when you brought up the homeless students I mean that was surprising in

239and of itself but then when you said why just because we've had the people there to have to look close eyes on it you can't do that when when you're trying to put 30 hours worth of work into an 8 hour day you can't do correct yeah perryburg is an excellent district for several reasons for for a whole bunch of reasons and during my time as a board member right it's human nature we you don't hear about all of that on the street you don't get those emails saying that you look at the data you look at the results you look at the state report card you see the graduation rates all those things and you say yes you know that's where as a board member you know you're the district's doing great work amongst

240other things but I tell you the one area where I do get compliments consistently during my eight years on this board has been on the work that this group has done right here the work that pupil Services has done those are the emails those are when I'm having conversations with parents say that work is exceptional and we're going to be shifting we're going to be shifting from Excellence to compliance and it's going to it's going to look a lot different now that's yeah thank you I appreciate that and I one piece that has crossed my mind as we've been working through a lot of this is because we've had really great intervention programs for behavior and mental health you know we're talking about impacts on students we are very likely to see a rise in

241special education numbers because of that when students aren't getting the intervention they need they're not going to close gaps it's going to impact outcomes and I think we're going to end up seeing more students identified with disabilities as opposed to getting intervention and closing gaps obviously I don't have a crystal ball but I think that when we really talk about how different things impact students we have to look at the long-term impacts as well one of the things Andrea and I have really worked hard on the last couple years is how do we retain our intervention specialist uh because the level of burnout for intervention Specialists is she said it is much much higher than any other teacher out there and you know when I am out recruiting and bringing people into interview uh we

242we would talk about those things that we were doing to support our intervention Specialists I am really worried moving forward of what's going to happen with our current intervention specialist and then the shortage of Educators out there that are being going into being an intervention specialist is very very small and talking to other HR directors around the state of Ohio the hardest positions to fill are intervention Specialists and so uh that that's a huge concern uh coming from from our office um and I always felt when I was interviewing because I interview pretty much almost everybody teacher who kind of walks through the door at times and have that touch that first touch uh with many of them and it's it's such an easy sell when when you are talking about per Berg and uh

243that's change that's going to change uh for us in there you know it's like you're you you're recruiting somebody to go play for Ohio State that was easy you know they just need to win a little bit more so and that talking about the turnover you know we experienced that we experienced that in the high school um in the three years Gus is there I think he had three teachers and and students it it takes it takes a while for them to get back into the routine and for people to understand them and and students and that's it does it for a general ad too but especially students um with an intervention specialist that that relationship and understanding the kid and it's just this is just so like I said many times gut-wrenching yeah the

244last thing I'd like to say is that I appreciate you guys sharing some of the questions that you get from people and you know once some of these Cuts were announced you know we're not immune from receiving those questions too and I think the one I have the hardest time with is you know people asking thought we were supposed to be about all students and the best exclamation I can give is what I did earlier you know but I think you know there is a doubt now that are we are we really attempting to be you know for you know does all really mean all anymore and I guess the The Challenge from this point on is to prove that yes we are just in a little different way thank you yep so a couple

245other things and we'll move quickly um some other uh reductions that that we're um contemplating is reducing the number of uh reducing the number of student days um by four uh so each day is is approximately $44,000 uh so by eliminating a day per quarter um you know that that could result in some savings um we're also eliminating the tiered substitute pay system you know we've heard uh don talk about you know that that our sub fill list has has increased and we've had kind of a tier system for Subs as an incentive and so that's something that um you know again um something that we do we had the funds to do it it it benefited the classroom in a lot of ways and and not available and and we know we're hoping that

246there's some more retirements but um back going back to the four instructional days the schools uh in Ohio um used to have a number of school days it's switched to hours it's tiered by the the grade level bands uh so here is um the number of of uh days so we converted the hours into days um the number of school days that we are over the state minimum so for 10th to 12th grade uh we're currently over 19.8 days of you know we go longer than that minimum and you can see across a board that we're well over half day kindergarten which we have a just a small number of students that are in half day uh we're only over 8.65 days so if we have two two two um fog delay days and we

247cancel school four times they would be having to make up hours so that's the significance of that so with the less than four days of instruction you can see um that is um you know we're still well over with the exception of the half day which were we'd be below five days uh we also factored in um with the shorten day at at HPI um you can see the difference in terms of what that time means overall um but but that that difference takes us from 28 extra day with no change to schedule to 13.63 uh so that's something we're doing we've increasing that was something on the original blueprint um in um uh back in in October where we're doubling the the participation fees for uh those activities you heard that the the person

248who is kind of uh in charge of the Stinger Pass Program is is her position is being cut so how do we continue to offer that when the person who does that is not there uh Stinger passes is a nice benefit uh we also know that um this past fall uh Stinger passes were used 797 times just this fall alone and you know that's gate Revenue uh in that's not being collected so I think that's something that you know we can continue to to talk through as we look at different kinds of Alternatives um you know so so I think for us that leads us to the kind of the future Levy discussions and um you know we we talked about what happened and but uh we have a levy that is set to expire

249at the end of next year that's a permanent Improvement Levy so as we begin to talk about 2025 uh there is a levy uh on the book since 1980 every five years it's been uh replaced or renewed it brings in approximately $1.5 million it can only be applied towards um things that are permanent so root think roofs purchasing buses uh fixing and repairing those kinds of things so so the board will have to decide do we let that expire uh again with our aging buildings 1.5 million doesn't go very far but we're certainly thankful that we have it uh so so you know do we renew that and then when do we the board uh wants that to go on the ballot so it's May or November are the two windows for elections that that

250the board can choose so that's something that we need to think about um as we get into the discussion about levies we also in fiscal year 25 we're retiring the debt Mills uh so we did talk about this during the operational Levy uh because um with the operational Levy the first year we weren't going to raise taxes on the eight-year Levy the second year uh when when it would go into effect uh the we were retiring these these debt Mills from the high school and it was actually greater than what the projected first year um or or second year collection would have been but anyway that is coming off the books as well um we've had some conversations there's been a a golf uh Top Golf kind of uh uh company that's interested in coming

251to perisburg and we've had some people say well go top golf is coming your $ 13.5 million problem is going to go away so we wanted to just highlight and and Randy did a great job of pulling some stuff together but um in Columbus there there is an actual Top Golf these are right from the the Cy's um Franklin County not Franklin County I think it's in Delaware actually yeah p their uh their their taxes and the property value uh is 9.9 million all the taxes they pay for a year which includes schools and also all the other taxes is 264,000 per year um so in perisburg Randy did the exercise Randy I don't know if you want to just walk yeah so question is you got a top golf here or something similar similar

252valuation similar total taxes but here's the thing what new revenue for us would be what's there that's new Revenue they could still pay $260,000 or $300,000 in taxes but that's not new Revenue we'll get you know what you see there about $70,000 in new Revenue now the rest of that would go to reducing the effective millage for everyone else and that's the house bill 920 can't collect any additional so it's actually on my um to-do list when you get through some of this other stuff at a board meeting to walk you through how this works I can do it Levy by Levy to show you that the only reason we get more we would get more additional money because we're at the 20 mil floor if we weren't the 20 mil floor we would get

253the $15,000 inside millage and and a little bit on the pi and that's it yeah so so yeah so let me be clear we're grateful that there is commercial Development coming in we're grateful that this is not not $9 million worth of new homes or apartments y so we're grateful that that is coming in our point and so 75,000 is 75,000 that's great but the idea the concept that this one development is going to solve all the schools problem that's the exercise here so we're grateful it's coming we're grateful that I understand um outside of the where it's located we're always happy that somewhere in the district there's commercial property being added the key is the key is the commercial property reduce the burden on the residential homeowner that's really the strength of commercial development

254obviously you get some additional Revenue but for us where we are it's just it's roster situation is because they're 50% commercial that yes this gives you the perspective of how much commercial development is necessary to make up 13 and a half need 193 top golfs to come to perisburg where gos yeah because you got got to realize we're 1.4 almost 1.4 billion in in taxable valuation top golf's 3.5 million right in taxable valuation so it's it's just the Susan's numbers we want it we need commercial development but on its own it doesn't solve it's not going to solve the problem today not in a residential neighborhood you know today um the fiveyear forecast just kind of going back you know Randy calculated the $14 million that would be basically replacing the 13.5 million that went

255away the $6 million would stay in place so for those that are saying well the district you know the board why didn't you just ask for the 13.5 million and and capture that to do that we would have had to have made the $6 Million worth of cuts still be doing this meeting right here right and then going to the voters and asking for that um so I the board spent months talking about that so um so I wanted just to highlight that as the board considers future elections and and what to do you know it's just the you know the electorate the mood across the state um is is challenging right now with with levies and and uh again we we highlighted some of those um in perisburg here locally um you know from

256from 2008 to to 2020 was the longest stretch in in perisburg history um you know since going back to the the the 20s or 30s that we've had success

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.