CorpusRecord 14323

1-28-2025 School Board Workshop

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Appoquinimink School District
Date
2025-01-29
Location
New Castle County, DE
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,088 words · about 51 min
Collected
2026-06-04

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening everybody and welcome to the January 28th 2025 uh app quinic School Board Workshop tonight we're going to be talking about uh the superintendent evaluation this is discussion we're not taking any votes because this is just a workshop uh and so with that why don't we all stand and say the Pledge of Allegiance the pledge of aliance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all okay with that I know Michelle this started last year under your presidency do you want to take the lead here in Walking us through our latest draft sure so as um Mr foron said this is just a discussion around the superintendent evaluation um I do want to point

002out Mr Abrams is joining us via Zoom hi Norm um we're in an effort to create this tool we've tried to do our best to incorporate the voices of all five board members so there's been different revisions um we had arrived at some standards and goals that we discussed at another board workshop and then when we went to put um measurements on those it was brought up that some board members would like to see some additional standards and goals so tonight um I can walk through the presentation about the standards and goals that are the same or I can address the one that has been changed to present to the board I do want to remind everyone that we cannot talk about um the measurements during this board Workshop we can only talk about the

003standards and goals um because it's a Personnel matter so proposal for this evening will be to go over the changes of the standards and then we would need to go into executive session to talk about the measurements um we because of Delo or public meeting laws we can't go into that executive session this evening so that executive session would be noted need to be not noticed to the public and before our February board meeting we would go into executive session to review the measurements and the rubrics and then during the February board meeting we would be able to have a vote on the tool so are there any questions about that so far no nope hearing none um would you like me to review the standards that did not change or only talk about the

004standard that did change the standard that did change okay so in taking the feedback of the board members who wanted um some additional measurements created went ahead and took a look at what we had and tried again to balance the voice of five people and the input of five individuals and I'm proposing that we make an addition to standard four so all of our standards had two goals associated with them and as we reviewed them they had goals and evidence this addition would be a goal three under the professional responsibilities standard and the measurements or the evidence would be what would come up with for measurements for the core functions of finances hiring and employment School discipline School transportation Building Maintenance and community relations um that those rubrics um and the way to measure those

005items will me to be discussed in executive session um I should add that some of those might be difficult to track and kind of come to consensus on how those are exactly measured but that was what was asked from the input um I would like Dr Moss do you have anything to add about the measurements that you could share publicly well not necessarily at this time I think have some conversation about them and then okay points come out at that time okay might be a way to do it does anybody have questions or feelings on adding this goal as under standard four so my reaction continues to be as I have said all along that you know I know we kind of initially came up with like five standards and they were supposed to align

006with the five goals of the Strategic plan but I have always said and always felt that if you're going to evaluate superintendent the things the core functions are what matters most and because doesn't matter matter if we're advancing on some of these strategic goals if our finances are in shambles they're not but if they were I mean that would be a real problem if we're having problem Staffing um classrooms to the point where other districts in this state at least one other District uh was having such problems that uh they were changing their school schedule that would be a problem you know School discipline would be a problem um so for my money that's the those core functions should be I'm going to say at least half the weight of the evaluation I'm not sure

007if by making it just part of standard four it really demonstrates the importance of those things I can be persuaded otherwise or we can just keep that in mind as you know if as we uh eventually do an evaluation I can appreciate that's your feelings but I Al I mean being tasked with creating this and trying to Value the voice of everyone are there other feelings on it I mean I know other people had other input into other goals that they might feel equitably are as important I mean I guess I'm not really following your train of the um whater like so you're you're pointing out these ones that are under standard 4 with emphasis okay like finish the thought for me I guess I'm not really understanding like why the emphasis from your perspective

008in comparison to everything else it almost feels like it minimizes the importance of the other standards and so I just want to make sure that I'm understanding your perspective before I comment well I'm sorry did someone speak with me I just if I'm I don't have the um I'm I'm trying to locate the paper so if if I could just interject here also I know that the amount of work that was going in we grabbed the um from the Strategic plan goal one goal you know goal two goal three goal you know the goals and then structured it this way and and as I expressed to you originally wasn't is that I was under the impression that that there was going to be a quote unquote um back door or a some mechanism in place

009that you would also be able to evaluate um Dr Burrows not only do we do that on a daily basis but um we we passed the referendum you know we were running at 65 open positions we got more money into that you know and of course that was all of us coming together to see the need but you know he was the one of the driving forces behind that to stick with the 36 Cents to stick with the bigger referendum to to help address that need so under the previous mechanism I was trying to figure out how we were going to evaluate him on that and then the other things um you know moving forward is and which then I was under the impression that we're going to have that open dialogue box where you

010could add things at the end you know put in you know like that separate section where you could freelance or free type what you know what you felt were his strengths his weaknesses that weren't addressed in the original uh five layers that was laid out and then if we went that way you know what was the mechanism to say okay as far as um and again I'm trying to find him in front of me but just say you know in goal one he got a it's in your email from Casey from Friday it's an attachment to your email right and I just when I logged in I've gotten bombarded with all the other things I I'm bringing up now but so like if you graded him a four on you know grade one or three

011however you come to the to pick the score that you know the five of us come to to say okay this is how we've evaluated him and then Circle back around to oh what how did we do in the budget finances do we give him credit because we came in under budget do we or do we go over budget and did we go over budget because Norm you can't talk about the measurements oh okay I'm sorry so that's that's what I so my guess my concern is is that of this how do they do these get a separate goal or do these just become another measure measurement in another box I guess that's what I'm trying but first let me say that there still is plans to include a text box at the end and

012I think that's an important inclusion for some of the things you pointed out but also because I feel like once your score is created you might want to provide feedback on why you scored a section a certain way so there will be a text box at the end but then does the text box so if I wanted to say in in the finance section if there's nothing in part one through five that addresses finance and we come in under budget I would gr him that we've achieved all our goals he might again don't forget this is a Personnel issue okay okay I just want to offer just a point of clarity because it it's been a while so just how we got to the five standards so we as a board we looked at different

013tools um or Michelle looked at different tools and then we brought some tools to you and then we had um we narrowed it down to one tool and the tool that we narrowed it down to had these five standards so that's how we got to the five standards um that we currently have and then we tried to within the goals of those standards we try to use the Strategic plan to get to that point um with the excuse me with our our tool okay I think at this point I guess we just move forward and do it for the first year to see how it and you know we work it all in I think it's okay thank you oh and also we were looking at I apologize we were looking at putting a text

014box at the end of each standard so there would be an opportunity if you thought there was something that wasn't captured under that standard where you could give a narrative there as well okay thank you Dr Barrow so if if we can just go back if I can just double back to you Mr foreston on your emphasis on the standard four that Mrs wall just read professional responsibilities finances hiring School discipline and you made some comments but I'm I guess I'm not clear on again the emphasis on this in comparison to the others like what is your underlying message I need to align right so ultimately when you do an employee evaluation at its most I'll say gut-wrenching decision you make is do you continue to have this person as an employee or do you

015not are they not performing and therefore you decide it's time to move on I'm not going to decide to move on under a lot of these goals because I don't think they're really legitimate I shouldn't say legitimate I don't think they're appropriate reasons to decide to hire or F or to continue employment or fire somebody for example standard one goal two administer an annual stakeholder survey and use data to strategically improve if we don't if we go a year or two without doing a survey I'm not going to get bent out of shape and say well Matt you didn't do this sorry we're letting you go even though it is one of our goals here on your thing I'm going to make a decision to I'll say retain the employee or fire the employee because

016our finances are in shambles because we're over budget and we're running short of money and we have to cut programs or I'm going to make a higher fire decision because we're so short of teachers that it's really impacting classrooms or that school discipline gets out of control and we don't have a plan to address it in a meaningful way um you know standard for goal too grow and strengthen Community relationships um you know I'm not I don't know that I'm going to hire or fire somebody because we didn't grow and strengthen our community relationships last year but I will do it if we ran a deficit and so that's my point a lot of this stuff is feel-good stuff it's aspirational with you want to make sure you're pursuing our strategic plan but if we're

017going to actually make the decision to to not retain somebody it's got to be for what I consider to be a pretty significant reason and these items here to me strike are the significant reasons that I would base a decision not to retain somebody on but some of this other stuff I mean I even question as I continue to question some of the legality of it um but some of it is just it's you know Foster a supportive learning environment for our staff and students I mean again are our finances there do we have the teachers right now we're short how what are we short now 30 teaching positions something like that 30 yeah I mean it's down significantly from last year so you know we're making progress there's a teacher shortage but and we

018haven't had to um make adjustment to school schedules because we're down teachers like they did in in another District in this state that would be a red lag and a problem but and that's why I put the real emphasis on this because I'm not going to want to not retain somebody if they don't do the annual survey or some of the other things here um and that's your opinion though there's five of us I know but I'm expressing my opinion to Sheba asked me and now you know why yeah yeah no I I appreciate that I yeah that's helpful um just so I can understand why you decided to draw emphasis there I I can appreciate that perspective um I disagree but I appreciate it I mean I do think there's value in everything that

019you highlighted under the experience under standard 4 but I also think that there's value in the other areas and I don't think it's as far as separating someone um I would agree with you I don't you know using standard one um stakeholder surveys I would would agree that I wouldn't be interested in separating someone for that reason but I do think that there are key components in leadership superintendent leadership that there's a level of account accountability that should occur on all levels Beyond finances and teacher shortages and things of that sort it's the whole it's it's it's a little bit more from my perspective it's a little bit more holistic and I would agree that I would not entertain a conversation of separating someone over not administering a survey I think that's a bit much

020but I would also argue that at the time of an evaluation is not a Time necessarily that you're is not a tool that you're necessarily using to separate someone for as long as I've been managing people I have never brought someone into my office at the time of a survey I mean at the time of a an evaluation and separated them so I would just you know highlight that I think we all have been in positions of management to where this is more of a communication tool and then when having this conversation nothing in here should be a surprise right so if someone was being separated they would know well before you're bringing an evaluation in front of them so I do think that uh from Mrs Wall's perspective uh there's value and what we

021all have put forward in this but I understand your emphasis on that understand I'm not saying appreciate that yeah no I appreciate what you're saying I'm not saying we ignore the rest of it at all I'm just saying if I was wait different things wait I mean they shouldn't all wait equally and and the survey is a perfect example it's good to do you should be doing it if you're good leader but I'm much more concerned about the core things you're supposed to be doing and so I just and yeah I agree you know you're not going to necessarily call somebody in the office for the first time and say this is your employee review by the way you're flunking and you're out I mean I am a real softy in that regard and um

022you know I want to give you want to give people Second Chances and third chances and then if they continue not to perform despite everything you've asked them to do well then you might have to make a difficult decision but it's the rubric it's the things you're being evaluated on that tell you what's important and if we suggest that everything on this list is weighted absolutely equally that's something I think that's the then is the percentage the allocation or weight as as you but I think that's also something we need to talk about in executive session yeah the value of each and how how those metrics are measured because I think there's some things that fall under this new goal that will be hard to measure and so if these are very important to you

023then I would challenge or if there's a goal that's very important to anyone I challenge you review the proposed measurement of it or the waiting of it and you talked to Dr Moss in advance of our executive session for some feedback on how that relates to the individual standard the goal and the tool overall because then we can have have some healthy discussion about the waiting and the measurements when we're in executive session but we're the goal tonight is to make sure that we're good going forward with the standards and the goals so we can have that real conversation about measurement well I think for consistency we have to have the same scale we can have varying weight like percentage obviously all adding up to 100 to use um Mr forest's example like maybe four

024is 40% or something along those lines or 45 5% but I think the manner in which we assess performance needs to be the same so like for example if you're going to use a Liker scale you know disagree highly disagree somewhat disagree or you know something along those lines I think that's the piece that we that's the next piece I think that we have to agree upon the percentages I think would come less well in my opinion they would come less because I would need to better understand how I'm assessing performance in that metric and then subsequently how much is it worth right so go ahead no I think that's a really good point and it speaks to kind of fast forwarding and thinking about the process of what you're actually going to go through

025with the evaluation right like is everybody filling it out filling out the lyord scale putting the text box in but then what like do you come together do you have conversations about what you put in the free text box um what is the the end result coming out of that are you taking everybody's scores is it auto tab is it GNA like Auto tabulate or like I don't um or you gonna know depends what system we use I guess so we would probably have to look at that later but and just to kind of take a second and and go back to some of the stuff I can see exactly what you were doing when you proposed all of these a couple of them like the community relations uh I do think is important it's

026and it's embedded in standard four goal two so there might be an opportunity as well with the hiring employment that was focused on in standard three goal to so there's opportunities with the two of those to possibly look at shifting some of the language in there if you wanted to do that um some of the other ones as was as uh Miss wall mentioned can be a little bit tricky to measure and I know I'm the metrics guy and we're not here to talk about metrics but finances hiring uh Transportation it really is dependent on what we have available to us and what we're looking to do with it so like we that would be the next level and what indicates a measure of success in those areas yeah and I think we would have

027that conversation but I do think as you kind of implied as well is it's important I think to go through these and get to a point where we decide if we're moving forward with the additions so that we can have that conversation in executive session related to metrics and I could come with metric options um related to that so yeah I think that's ideal I mean because respectfully this is I I think it's been going on a little too long and so I don't want to continue to belabor it so you need us to walk away tonight with agreement with what's here in front of us is the goal yeah I mean and respectfully I'd like to say we I think that we've came to points where we were at consensus and then there were

028additions made so if we're really I'd rather stay and get to consensus rather than gather at another point in time and feel like we're starting over agreed could I make if I don't think we ever had a full consensus but we don't need to re repow that ground if if we're going with uh standard forward as presented um could I make just a maybe suggestion that we collapse some of the other goals in this maybe we make this the only goal and then have the only goal in this particular standard and then have these measurements that we agree upon underneath that if everyone's okay with that I don't to throw more into the mix but I just think with three goals goals that are in standard four I I mean I think we can collapse

029go because one of the measurements in this is um commun relations well that's goal two and then um and then the engagement piece which is also kind of community relations like if we could just say understand for professional responsibility administrative skills and competencies and then have evidence and measurements underneath that but I do think we have to have a conversation around the data that's I know we can't really go that deep here but it's important because if there's not data available to support or we can't come to a consensus as to how we're deciding success in relation to finances um it can make it a little bit tricky so it just and a I'm not opposed to your plan it's just then how do you assign EV you need to assign evidence to each one

030and then do you want it tied back to this I mean as a group everything has been tied back to the Strategic plan so then are we making all those measurements tied back to the Strategic plan or is that goal going to completely standard excuse me going to completely deviate from the way the rest of the standards are that that's why I drafted it the way I proposed it in other words I understand that when this was first being put together we have five overarching goals in our strategic plan so he came up with five standards in the evaluation but that's what I said I think consistently all along there was nothing in those five standards that really addressed is he just able to do the job it's one thing to advance the ball on

031your strategic plan but it's another thing to make sure the school buildings are always open it's another thing to make sure the buses are running on time that we've got the classroom staffed that you know we're not running a deficit that our spending is under check and none of those things that I in my thinking were really satisfactorily addressed in just the standards I mean even on community relations we've got standard four goal two growing strength and Community relationships and there's also the one about the stakeholder survey those were tied more to the Strategic plan um and I just think again I mean is your superintendent able to do the things you want a superintendent to be able to do on a regular basis um to me that's whether it's 40% 45% whatever percentage is

032I mean it's like you know when when you have your first day of class in college the teacher hands out the syllabus and then he hands out how he's going to figure out the grades and your first now they get it emailed in advance but B pardon I said now they get it emailed in advance but go ahead okay I'm dating myself we used to get it on stone tablets yes but um you know I mean you you get that information up front and that's what we'll do with our superintendent when we're done here's how we're going to evaluate you and it'll have everything he needs to know um we're just not quite there yet but we're I think we're getting close I think to your answer your question I think um so under community

033relations under the evidence piece I could keep the parent Community engagement opportunities at the school and District level which is the measurement under uh goal two and I could also keep the increase the percentage of participants on the annual state C older survey which would be under that as well so I could still keep that we could still rework that into that okay they align with the Strategic plan that aspect of it Mr the question um is there a reason we can't just move all these core functions under each one of the goals where they belong so maybe goal One Core function four function um coing and then we'll put finances under wherever finances is is mentioned I just don't understand the reason for this separate portion why well because it's one why can't we

034div it up into one of these goals evidence for function right right because to my way of thinking and so I apologize um if I it's one thing to have goals in your strategic plan I want all my kids to get better grades next year and then better grades the year after that then better grades the year after that I want you know I want our percentage of students achieving competency in math to go from you know 50% to 60% in four or five years an important goal and that really probably should be our number one goal but it doesn't really capture whether our superintendent himself is good at the things you know as the chief administrative officer of the district um is he good at the things that we need him to be good

035at and so you have goals and aspirations and that's what our strategic plan is that's the direction we want to head and and we have ways that we can measure are we pursuing those goals effectively but I mean there's no point in even trying to get to those goals if you don't have an administrator who's already really good at his job and knows what he's doing and knows how to lead the organization and that's what I would and so to me that's a separate question and a separate measurement then and are we making progress towards a more diverse teacher body or if we're uh but these are not things that you have said during the entire process in which other people have been providing feedback uh I think I have and maybe I didn't explain

036myself or maybe I wasn't listened to I've always said I thought that just tracking the Strategic plan was a mistake I've said that from day one and I've always said that I want to know our superintendent is doing these things as well and I don't think there's any harm in putting that in the evaluation even if it's coming up at the last second even if I walked in today or next Tuesday or our next meeting if somebody walks in and says hey you know here's something else we ought to add to the evaluation if it's a good idea we ought to accept it don't disagree with that I just think that there are times when I feel like there's been progress being installed on this and I'm questioning if this is another tactic installing this

037it's not a tactic installing the reason I finally put pen to paper was because I needed to put pen to paper and explain myself in writing what is the proposal then for going forward Mr to are you gon to comment can I ask you a question yes so and again I now found what I was originally looking for so if we again I and and maybe I'm wrong I was under the at least thinking this whole way through is that everything would go down on paper and then it would be handed off to make sure everything was measurable so we didn't put something in here that that that couldn't be achieved couldn't be tracked or couldn't be tallied so I don't I don't want to say anything that's going to you know get us into

038to the gray area of doing that um Richard you make good points on what you're asking to be in there but then I I also caught Dr burrow some of that stuff can be grabbed in a separate way so so I guess coming back to what you have put pen to paper to um I have heard you say those things as we've been discussing it but does does it need to be in the Box the way you presented it or can each one one of those things be like the community relations I mean is it acceptable to be pulled in to the other areas and graded in that area or would you like it to be as you and your your words pen to paper in this section in this manner and then if that

039is the case is everything else on this page a way to track it and measure it to say yes we've set the goal of X we made it or we didn't make it is is everything else on this page achievable that way if my question makes sense I'm not sure who you're asking that question to Norm well I guess it's kind of to you it's kind of both to you and to um to Dr burough and and yes I I I do agree that that some of these things in here are important you know the finances they are important and and I'll Circle back around is is I again it's and I might be speaking for the five I don't think anybody's trying to stall anything I think we want it to be right it's

040the first time we're doing it we've had a lot other obligations along the way through the referendums that have pushed us back and and now it's come back to Circle to this so I think it's a matter of getting it done we have a meeting in February so between tonight and our next meeting is everything that's on the actual page listed here you know for any anybody else for you know speak you know speak now or for never speak again is everything that it's sitting on paper tonight is it achievable can we grade it can we measure it can we quantify it out to say yes the goal was made the goal wasn't made and then from here moving forward um between as you being the president and Miss Graham being vice president along with

041HR say to Matt Dr burrow is there anything on here you know yes or no provid a reason yes or no and and you know with Miss wall saying because she's done a majority of this work to move forward for us as the group to to get it to paper that we can actually move forward with it I mean I think that's the other part where we're at is is we could keep adding stuff for the next six months and never get across the line you know can we get what everybody's feeling tonight if there's anything anybody else wants in here say it or don't say it and then let's over the next week or two get those things hammered out that we can actually move forward with it maybe I'm just too far you

042know along to say that we're almost there and maybe there's another step that I'm missing that we need to do as a group so I think where we are is do we keep goal three and standard four where it is or do we are we okay with collapsing um making it the goal in standard 4 and then we work on the evidence piece with Richard to see to make sure that we're understanding the evidence aspect of it and so when we come if we can agree to that then when we come to the February meeting we can have measurements and look at the measurement pieces of each of these goals and then we need to decide after we get that the measurement piece I thought we had decided on how we were going to measure

043previously but um I think we are in a good spot with how we're going to measure this and now we just have to get into the weighting aspect of it like is there going to be a a standard that's going to weigh more than another standard and so forth so those are the action steps tonight what we really need tode is I think the hold up or the Crux of this I think we agree on the other five or the other four standards we need to come to agreement on standard four and then we're able to move forward into the next phase and on uh at our February executive session then at least from my point of view Dr burs and and Mr forston and Miss Graham and everybody there I defer to you guys

044what I'm looking at looks fun to me if if it's measurable and achievable and it works for everybody go forward I'm I'm okay with it is if every you know we are 105 if it all works for us then move forward with it if somebody has a problem with something then let's not because of the work put in then let's not do it and circle back around in a year from now to to make changes when we get there and that is still the plan right we're going to roll this out for one year see how we you know what we selected Works doesn't work and then make changes then I mean if this isn't a settin stone document it can be changed down the road adding things and taking things away correct yep yes

045I still have a question about why we can include these into the goals the standards as they are why can't we move the core functions into the five gold five standard I I think that's what I was asking Mr why do we need that section that's want which ones do you want to move there so we can do go one then cor for uh function p in whatever one that needs to go underneath goal one and then goal two include those like I still don't understand why we need that section when it can be placed under the appropriate section that was already created so Mr you're I'm sorry I just wanted to clarify the question really quick so um you under standard for professional responsibilities with the with the black um bar the uh core

046functions finances hiring employment School discipline School transportation Building Maintenance community relations you're proposing that we take those six and bake them into the green areas that were already established right okay I just want to make sure I understood where would you propose that you put them so just what I'm suggesting suggesting and that's why we put it here under professional responsibilities because really these evidence pieces are all under professional responsibilities they don't really fit under I mean I guess you could well let me take that back I guess you could put like hiring employment under people systems and operations like that could like shift into there but community relations um can go under facilities teaching and learning I guess you could well it's still like I I see professional responsibilities under hiring finances School discipline

047School transportation Building Maintenance is all kind of under professional responsibilities um that I have that's why we that's why we kind of stuck at here if I could jump in considering we're like specifically looking at these I do have to throw in like when it comes to data that I have available I don't really have have data related to school transportation available so you'd have to have some serious conversations related to that also finances I don't know that I'm necessarily qualified to come up with metrics related to finances um but I can support in that uh Building Maintenance I don't personally have data for the district building maintenance available to me um so we would just need to expand on some of these a little if we're agreeing that we want to include them I

048think we'd need a little more clarity on what Direction you were looking to or what specific thing you were looking to assess I feel like that's where it's important where the in my opinion where the text box comes in because all the things that you keep saying are very important to you it what I would expect you to write in your evaluation of Matt so that's where that text box comes in in explaining where you see his him succeeding and where he needs Improvement or where he might need Improvement right but it's all about notice too right let's say we took this out the core responsibilities out to me they're the most important thing if I'm going to evaluate Matt on and the things I think are most important aren't even in the evaluation thing

049that's a problem right I mean how can you you know if I was an employee any employee and I got called in for an evaluation and the evaluator started saying I want you know you're not doing this you're not doing this you're not doing this and I'm looking at what I was given in terms of the evaluation form and none of that stuff is in the form I'm GNA say wait a minute where was that in the form is it in his job description well he is the superintendent of the school so I mean I mean I'm just saying in that example then the the argument will back you into a job description right so whether it's not whether it's on your evaluation or not is moot it's what's in your job description so but

050we're creating a tool that we're saying to our superintendent here you I'm just using your example and if I was that employee in that example or that leader in that example I wouldn't even entertain your dialogue around what's in my evaluation I would say well here it is in your job description right because that's but again why have a tool because I'm telling you superintendent I'm telling you associate up for partnership I'm telling you whom ever teacher who who wants a raise um yeah we had this evaluation for but you weren't doing stuff in your job description so we're gonna you know it's the it's the tool that tells me what I should be focusing on and telling me what's important so that's why I think it's got to be in there so point taken

051but if I can go back to your point Dr Moss uh I guess I'm now I have a question I guess I'm questioning then the validity like how are you going to validate you just said you don't have data or you said you you don't think that you're qualified to come up with a metric around finances point taken School transportation and building maintenance you said you don't have metrics so then we have three of the six who now I I now have a question mark next to so what are we even doing then and then to take it back to miss wit's point so if we take those we can have dialogue around those three and then the remaining three is there an opportunity to bake them in elsewhere so if you don't have data

052around these let's just stick with we have data on finances we get a finance report every month but how does excuse well can I just clarify my question so Building Maintenance what's your idea behind Building Maintenance what do you want us to evaluate under the title building maintenance well you talked about a ler scale which is always kind of a fuzzy thing anyway but I mean are our buildings in a state of disrepair that were constantly you know there are leaks in all the roofs and there are leaks in all the windows and the heating is going out in three buildings are we not engaged in down to mat responsibility if annually we take things to the state and they deny us that's not Matt's job that's the state's job so I can't evaluate that

053on a leaky roof that we've asked the state three times to pay for but on things that we need to go but should we even have the Leaky Roof to begin with are there things we can do with our small cap to make those functioning I mean if it's an example of something that should never be an issue in my mind but if it became an issue it would be an issue because parents would be screaming bloody murder and we would be screaming bloody murder to the state and we'd expect our superintendent to be camped in Dober to make sure the problems got addressed I mean do you want them camped in over or do you want them doing all these other things well so these are the core fun this is why I put

054this in core functions if you have buildings that where the HVAC isn't working that's a problem if kids are having to wear their winter coats in class to stay warm that's a problem and if it happens on an isolated incident we're not going to worry about it but if we have a pattern of building maintenance issues that's a problem and I don't want to overstep but as I was looking at these specifically my initial thought was I see a lot of these items here we you guys vote on them as a board right like finances you go through hiring uh discipline will come up from time to time Building Maintenance so just something that I noticed we'd have to be really specific if you're trying to attach these specifically to things Matt can use to

055evaluate to grow as a leader I would just encourage you to be a little more specific with these because I see overlap between the board's responsibilities and um some of the comments you're making around these and I don't mean to overstep because I hear the point you're making specifically about the one about there being a lot of the Strategic plan in the items that we have in here uh and wanting to have something that really encompasses the job that you think he does related to this and I get that but that would be something that I just think that we should have a discussion around specifically so could I ask you a hypothetical question then so in in if let's say there's a million dollars in the maintenance department and we have five blown water

056heaters in five different schools but in the maintenance plan they're supposed to service the water heaters every three months but we skipped doing that maintenance because we ended up I don't know just just power washing the buildings instead of doing maintenance because we allocated you know the I think where you're going with the the maintenance is that is are we doing our regular maintenance and and we're not then something breaks once fine but if it's something that's continually going on then that also disrupts the flow of a school so I I understand at least I think I understand where how they're trying to allocate this one if I'm if I'm understanding Mr forst's uh or at least that's why it's there I just stick sticking with Building Maintenance and the examples that have been provided

057I think that respectfully is one of the like most mundane things that I would I I don't even want to talk about like like I can't see myself sitting in at evaluation time saying Matt let's talk about the Leaky Roof from six months ago right I'm not even sure that I would even remember like I'm looking at the six topics I I can certainly get behind hiring an employment School discipline finances I still need to hear your rationale around school transportation and I think community relations Is I think self-evident um just in the actions that we see you know that new uh state of the district I think meeting that you're doing and all those other things so that's pretty straightforward I do think that community relations bullet could be baked in elsewhere um I

058guess I'm just still struggling because we don't have metrics around three of the six so I'm not sure it's fair to say we don't have metrics around three to the six our data we don't have metrics okay our our data person is not our Chief Financial Officer I think ER I'm talking about building maintenance and school transportation finances definitely get okay first you said three now we're down to two School transportation we can talk to the head of transportation and and you know we have school buses now we got them because we were having real problems with with buses and getting kids to school on time and so we had to do what we had to do um I I'll say problem solved but if that problem became chronic again and our superintendent didn't seem

059to be doing anything about it or didn't seem to be focused on it that would be something that I think that blurs the line too between match job in the board I mean I don't want to bring up too much but for a long time Matt was talking about transportation problems and there was someone on the board who is adamant about not buying buses which could have been a way the school district could have started to address the problem earlier than we did so is that Matt or is that the board when it comes to Transportation well I think at least in the initial term it's Matt is he proposing Solutions we can ignore his Solutions or tell him we disagree and then we're going to measure him on it negatively by a decision we

060then made if we're not getting kids in classrooms in schools that are functioning then a lot of the other stuff in here improving community relations increasing the diversity of our staff it doesn't matter yous are getting we aren't doing that right but he's he's the leader of the district and again if my if the goal of this tool is to say to our superintendent here are the things that we want you focused on like a laser to make sure this is always happening you're right I mean Building Maintenance should never really be an issue we have to worry about until it's an issue we have to worry about and if it comes up and we start to get a lot of complaints then that's a problem it never should I agree with you it never

061should be an issue although we do have minor issues here and there but um but I think it's part of the core function kids need to be in schools where the HVAC Works where the windows aren't leaking where they're not drafty or the toilets flush all that sort of stuff and if we're having problems keeping our buildings maintained then to me that's that's education 101 that we're not accomplishing the same with Transportation the same with school discipline the same with teachers in the classrooms right we're not having to rearrange schedules or go to some sort of every other day schedule because we don't have enough full-time teachers uh and the same with finances right we need to stay ahead of finances we can't be running problems we can't be having problems with finances they're having

062problems with finances in some other districts so you know if we're not doing these things and not doing them well then some of these other standards some of our strategic plan doesn't matter we're not going to get to our strategic plan unless we're doing these things I disagree I disagree so I have a question about this and since this is brand new to us creating this and any other things that come before the board we vote and things go forward if it's more votes for than against so if we don't come to a consensus on the tool as a matter of the board agenda may I just make a presentation of the tool and then we can vote on it and then go back to Executive session in March for measurements okay and then Mr

063foron should he disagree or any other member of the board make a presentation of a tool and we vote is that but I was under the impression that before we got that far that everything on this page would be given in a substant manner to make sure that it was measurable it was achievable and it was to be so everything on the I guess what I'm trying to say is everything that's on the paper minus anything that Mr foron presented the the new block that's there tonight is everything on that page measurable achievable in any kind of metric should or does that have to go to the next level for them to say well no we can't measure that or no we can't achieve that those propos those proposed measurements were already sent to you

064to review for everything other than Mr forest's changes so why wouldn't your text box be sufficient in that area so if you wanna if you want to so let's just continue to stick with um um Building Maintenance and school transportation we all agree that um someone could get us Finance information so we're align that right so let's let's drop down to your other two why wouldn't your free text box address that like because Building Maintenance to your exact point wouldn't or shouldn't be a consistent issue so then why would it become an a cons a consistent measure on his tool why wouldn't you just address it in your free text box when and if it comes up because as I said earlier the tool is the signal to Matt or to whoever our super intendent

065is as to what is important right and the way this is drafted now and I disagree with other parts of it I think some of it's illegal the way it's written right here we asked you to come back with language in which and I have and you've ignored it no you have for standard three where this evidence now and I'm just reading what's out there for the public I presume says a measurable increase in the percentage of teachers and administrators who represent the diverse population we actually asked you to come back with that and you came back with this instead of that you didn't come back with what I said what I said at the meeting I said at the meeting I said it at the meeting rather than that the only thing I think

066we can fairly ask for legally ask for is that we increase the places where we cast our net and we cast a wider net so that in theory we'll get more a larger and more diverse pool but we absolutely cannot well this judge our super on whether because I was presenting I was going off in a different area we had a discussion about this you guys either ignored it or didn't pick it up didn't we had a discussion that night and follow was you were providing language that I have not seen it was not sent to me I didn't send language I made I I stated it I stated it uh orally verbally you to send the language so we could include it all right I'll send it to you tomorrow I mean it's not

067that much of it's not that change thought it was obvious for my comments the reason I went to this was because I all along of us I have said all along and consistently that I don't think this tool captures the things that you want in a in a superintendent it doesn't emphasize to him that he has to do his base job well it's a it's all really nice stuff and it's nice aspirational goals but whether or not our teach our our uh employes become more diverse as a body doesn't tell us whether our finances are working doesn't tell us whether we're having student discipline problems doesn't address any of what I think the core issues are that we want our superintendent to be doing well and I have said that from day one at every

068meeting I have said that so I'm a little I'm not trying to draw this out and I'm very disappointed that you're accusing me I'm very disappointed that you're accusing me of trying to throw tax in the road to slow this down that's not what I'm trying to do I'm trying to make this better we can make it better but then tell me how you want it written all right well I provide it I I will provide you further written comments right now we're like come I just did so on evidence for goal two rather than Implement targeted recruitment which which standard are you on standard three goal two evidence right now this is a metric are we supposed to be talking about this in the you can't talk about a metric you can talk about

069how it's written here goals and evidence okay so the evidence should be a measurable increase in the areas where we are recruiting so that a larger pool of applicants is at play but I don't think we can the evidence can't be a measurable increase in the percentage of teachers and administrators who represent the diverse population so say again what your opinion is one of five people of how it should reach but also trying to be legal so we have to have this reviewed by Council if if we can't get it changed right so I think this is illegal the way it's written and we've asked you to come up with why that is because I said at the meeting one of our meetings you can't say to our superintendent or to anybody we want you

070to hire increase hiring and by the way we're going to reward you and your goal here is if you hire more diverse applicants that's how you're going to be measured because at that point you're discriminating against people on the basis of race sexual orientation sex whatever but we can't discriminate and yet this tells me if I'm the employee that I'm going to get rewarded and that it's a good thing and it I get a favorable Job review if I have more minorities however they're categorized that's illegal you can't hire somebody because they're a minority now the way you can get I think more minorities and a more diverse population is to cast a wider net and to go to places that perhaps we haven't gone to in the past that might have more diverse populations

071and encourage them to apply that's all fine but you can't measure somebody's job based on whether there are now a greater percentage of Hispanics or a greater percentage of African-Americans or a greater percentage of um you know Catholics um that's illegal because you can't say to somebody I'm going to give you a reward I'm going to say you're doing a good job if you actually hire those people and get them in the percentage because now you're saying to that person hire people based on their race hire people based on their religion hire people based on their national origin and if that's the direction that we give that's illegal and I said that a couple months ago at an earlier Workshop maybe it was a year ago four and five of the Strategic plan I don't

072have it in front of me it in front of me but believe it talks about diversifying our hiring pool diversifying our hiring pool meaning the the I don't have it in front of me well to Richard's point at this at this time it seems like the tool that we've all worked on um just needs to be edited some more so that it can be the standard tool so that we can go ahead and evaluate and create metric I don't feel comfortable um going to the meeting in February with no like with no it's still very vague for me this part I think we need more details I think the tool needs that maybe be edited again for all three of the goals and standards um so that it can be not perfect but it can

073be the tool that we want to move with going forward but right now it just seems very very very vague and I don't feel comfortable evaluating Dr burls on what we currently have and what we're supposed to be looking at in February personally I don't want to rush this because it's February is coming up yes Dr Graham's Point we've been at this for a minute but since it is the first time a tool is being reviewed I think that we just need to take the time that it calls for to get it done correctly so um I don't want to be rushed tonight to come up with a decision to do it right now personally well we're not yeah we're not and we're not by the way I agree wholeheartedly but we're not um we're

074not voting or whatever we're a consensus I don't know what we're walking away with tonight but I personally um would like to further uh edit the I will I will do a better job and get something with more detail and more meat on the bones I can appreciate that then I would ask that everyone does that but I also then we're back to the five diverse opinions and input from all five people again so I'm I am fine with not rushing it I am all for doing it right but from being the the point person at least thus far to try to have to gather information from five people who often times feel like they're over here and over here and then bring something to you guys that's here and then hear I wasn't represented

075or I wasn't represented you a great job though is a challenge Michelle don't you should not feel bad and you also there's other people who have been working on it too and I can appreciate that you guys aren't where we want to be but if we're starting all over from square one then I need a better way to gather the feedback of five diverse opinions because it's important to me as a member of a board that you're a fifth a fifth a fifth and a fifth so not that I want to negate what's important to you but I'm sure there are very different things that are important to you so how do you gather this and to tashiba and to Norm and to myself how do you gather those and recognize the important contribution that

076we're all to be making as a board when I feel like a lot of these things that we're measuring mad on are our responsibility as the board yeah and I don't think it's I don't don't misunderstand me it's not I do think this is being belabored don't get me wrong I don't want to rush through it but I also am not in favor of starting again like we have a good foundation I will admit H you know okay Mr Fon brought forward his additional core functions I can't necessarily get behind School transportation or Building Maintenance but I hear you I can get behind finances hiring and employment School discipline and community relations um so obviously we're not talking about metrics tonight we're not talking about percentages I would hope if could we take like maybe

07710 15 minutes to at least try to agree on the content like that's the goal of tonight for us to agree on the content and then um well and we don't it doesn't have to be the February executive session if we need more time it can be March executive session we just can't talk about measurements and I don't want to want to feel rushed on it but I want to make sure that all voices are heard yeah but also it's never going to be perfect right so we need to get something in our hands that we're at least we have at least a 90% confidence in and move forward I think we said we were going to roll this out in June did we said we were gonna use this in June why is that

078sticking in my head did we not say that well yeah the starts of school year yeah I thought that's what we said like June right so soich can I can I something just one second nor I we just we have gone through each goal and standard one by one and everyone has said yes before yeah but I thought I heard you say start again well I know I'm just I'm just reminding everyone that at some point whether you were hesitant or not we read through them publicly we talked about them and I think I said something like I'm sure we can go to a video but you know ready to move on to the next one and we moved on so at some point there was consensus around the existing tool Melle I think you're

079Mr foron one second m Michelle first of all let let me step backwards to to be this you know the person the driving force to make this happen with the five of us I believe personally you've done an outstanding job just let's start there second I do believe the five of us we do have consensus on the tool the mechanism and how we've gotten to tonight I think the only uncertain Clarity is the last piece that's been brought in here under section three so I guess my question I guess for us is and I think we all agree we're here to this point tonight so to go backwards no gosh no I hope we don't have to do that because the work that has been done on your part and everybody else in district office

080to get here tonight we're here all right so then what are you know the amb ambiguities that need to be addressed let's hit them and and make sure we can get there I I think this is from where we were at to where we're at tonight it's it's pen to paper it's really good and and I'll just back up the other thing on the language I from what I remember the night that that was brought up the language was proposed and to be changed and I thought it was changed so I'll I'll apolog to say that as I've read it moving forward from the night that you know Mr foron said I think we need to change a language to this I'm not a lawyer and I'm not an expert I actually thought the language

081was changed to what he had suggested so I I I do know that was out there but please let's not go backwards the work that's been done by everybody to tonight it I would hate to have for us to lose that I think you've done a great job as everybody at district office has so please let's keep what we have Tinker with what's been brought out tonight and and see if we can make it work because it sounds like we're all there and you are right balancing one of five for everybody is not an easy task and I think everybody's going to think their points are the most important but at the end of the day the five of us still have to evaluate the superintendent and we all still have to work together to

082get those five mechanisms and if if Mr foron feels we need to add these three for him I'm fine with that if you want to add to you know if you want to emphasize on something I'm fine with all that I mean we've all been elected by the community to do this job I think the five of us can agree that that's hopefully the best way forward thank you so let me just say first Michelle don't take anything I say as criticism of you personally or the job you've done I mean you were given and you took on a Herculean task in trying to put this together and obviously we're five different people with five different sets of thoughts and it was never going to be the case that you were going to come out

083with something that would would we would all just fall in love with immediately and we do have different thoughts and I think that's in part of I don't want to say the issue but we have we do have different thoughts we're all trying to make this as good as it can be and so I don't want you to think in any way that I'm being critical of you or or the work you've done I think you've done a a good job putting it all together I actually do think it's fairly close closer than people seem to think uh maybe that's me now but I'm just being an optimist and and now that I've weighed in with some language that can be cleaned up and revised um this you oh go ahead this is just a

084workshop we've kind of handicapped ourselves a little little bit and I disagree with if you got that opinion from Mike Stafford I think we could call an executive session right now if we wanted but that's not what our Council advised us so fine um but part of the discussion of what gets set forth as evidence and goals I think depends a little bit on what the metrics are going to be or how we're going to evaluate it you can't have one discussion really without the other because it all flows together and so let me suggest that at our February meeting perh and you know I I hate to say this but um maybe we come together a little bit earlier for our executive session and have an extended executive session to discuss the metrics and

085try to put it all together uh in in a more comprehensive draft and prior to that meeting I will get to each of you my thoughts on what those metrics should be I'll get them to you it's today next Tuesday no next oh yeah we meet in two weeks right yeah so give me till next Wednesday just because um I've got to go to Pittsburgh this weekend so um but I'll get you my proposals on what how the those metrics should be structured I'll get you the revised language I know I I said what the language should be at the one meeting on standard three goal two but I obviously didn't submit anything in writing to you and if if I was supposed to do that I apologize but I'll also give you revised language

086I'll give it to all of you for that as well and then when we're in executive session we can discuss the metrics because I really think that that will I hope indicate to you in particular to she but what I'm really thinking about on some of those core functions yeah exactly because I was just going to ask you like what would you be looking for UND discipline so I look forward to that communication just so I can I will I will get to you all by next Wednesday and if there's another way that you think there can be mve to other parts do you want to send that in writing so that can be I'll work on something okay tsha did you have any other feedback on these no I I I look forward to

087um the suggestions from Miss Dua and then um Mr forest's explanation of some of these just so I can kind of just understand the thought process thank you Dr not to put you specifically Finance is that something you can speak to Mr about a measur I can do that no sounds good do we feel like this is a good stopping point or are there other items that we want suggested I think I think we've decided what we're going to do next but again I want to to to who how Steve how many viewers do we have right now five to the six of you out in our TV audience I want to again say thank you to miss wall for all the hard work that she has put in um you know it's a lot

088easier to uh to make criticisms than it is to initially be the creative Force and and we've all gone through this at various things on other projects and this is something we're creating essentially from Whole cloth we had some examples that I don't think necessarily were all that good starting points and and I think when we're done if we do it right we're going to have a model that we're going to charge other districts to copy least that's my hope I will say to anyone taking it on the big biggest challenge is to making sure you are counting the voice of everyone but also there's the the issue of it being a Personnel matter so there's not any other employee in our district in which we're like this is exactly how you're being evaluated and

089this is how we're doing it so you know to Dr Bros thanks for hanging with us as we try to figure it out as well all right unless anybody other else has anything I'm G to adjourn the meeting Norm are you okay I'm good thank you all right well thanks for zooming in norm and and with that we're adjourned Steve I

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.