CorpusRecord 143345

BERKSHIRE BOARD OF EDUCATION SPECIAL MEETING 1 22 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Berkshire YT
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Geauga County, OH
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,273 words · about 41 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001[Music] you e e for it was better on TV anyway honestly it was good how could you be so does Texas and you openbor we I mean we live out in the country so we have issues all the time and spectrum is coming down our road you know we we uh we were having that issue so we bought um starlink well we didn't start and we had like really no luck and our yard is pretty open got up on the top of the roof yeah I put I put ours up on the up on the top of the roof and it's been great has it been that's what everybody said even T&T guy told us get Starling so we did and then Danny we left it on the ground so I could get it there

002were some things we could get but Dan yeah I put it up on the roof and I could with the app you can kind of walk around and see where where you get the best so and I bought that I have another like roof uh Mount if you guys want it well we're going to tryck just they came the other day but it doesn't drill into the roof it's got weights on it and it sits on top of the roof yeah so I have one and you can have it because I don't need it let's see how spectrums I tried to give it the hiscock because I knew he was G he already bought one yeah yeah well everybody talked about how good it was and probably Danny has like this much patience sometimes and

003so probably had and what I did is I got yourself yeah and then I bought a second receiver and put it in so I have one like right where it comes into the house and then one in the kitchen and it spreads the signal farther so and I'm thinking about maybe getting even another one because it'll just make it that much faster use it for your TV too MH we use it for everything what what's your it's like $120 a month mhm yeah the satellite was like $500 the the roof mount was I don't like to bring the meeting to order if we could stand for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice

004for all Beth roll call [Music] please here miss mcav can you use your microphone please sorry about that Mr Burman still here Mr Manfredi yes uh Mrs Miller just texted and she's walking in uh Mrs here and Mr wassworth here I need a first and a second for approval of the agenda so moved second any discussion Beth will call please Mr Burman yes Mr manfredy yes Mrs Stone yes and Mr wwor yes okay um you know I'd like to hold public comment till after we do our presentation typically we do it before but uh tonight we'll do it after so um instead of uh having public comment before it'll be after so uh we are to new business and that is the discuss of future tax levies tax implications additional Revenue sources of the district

005so John and Beth take it away all right thank you um I uh Mrs mcaffrey and I um worked on this uh presentation for you we just wanted to give a financial overview and a path forward we will reference challenges achievements and Solutions in this presentation and um to start we're going to go we're going to go back to 2017 and what our journey has been since 2017 we picked 2017 because that was the year that uh I got here and when I got here Mrs mcaffrey and I sat down and she asked me what my vision for instruction for the district was so that she could match the finances for the district with our vision for instruction so we could try to put the best instructional program together and make sure that uh we

006could afford that instructional program and uh we built that at the time largely around um bringing in some additional revenues through open enrollment because open enrollment was um uh was funded in such a way that if you could get extra students that you would um you would see a benefit from it so if you look at this chart you'll be able to see that um in 2017 we were actually losing more than we were gaining in terms of open enrollment we had um we were losing $468,000 a year because more kids were leaving us than were coming so at that time we we started to make some strategic improvements to attract and retain students we we were we kind of revived the prime committee we started to uh increase the Hands-On learning aspect of what

007we were doing we started to do more direct uh advertising to families both in District and that were open and rolled out um and then in 2018 you can see we were still losing more than we were gaining but we were kind of making some ground in 2019 then we started actually gaining more than we were losing we were we were gaining some momentum at that point our bond issue had passed we knew that we were going to be building the new facility there was a lot of excitement and then in 2020 we started seeing significant increases and in 2021 we were at about $660,000 more that we were bringing in um then we were losing because of open enrollment and so our business model was working well I think we would have uh we

008would have been great at the time however then in 2022 the state introduced a new funding formula and that funding formula essentially eliminated the um open enrollment uh incentive so um they didn't take the money away that we had gained through open enrollment but they capped it at that so we were not going to get any more additional funding due to open enrollment which meant um that every additional open enrollment we we took we were it was just going to kind of um lessen the impact of that funding um at the same time that that open enrollment formula was changed uh vouchers started to take effect and in the beginning uh vouchers weren't affecting us as much in 2022 we were only losing about five uh vouchers and then last year or I'm sorry in

0092023 six and then that jumped up to 69 last year um and and the effect of the the the thing that the vouchers we've never been afraid of competition in The District in fact we we enjoy competition we believe in ocracy we think that uh we should compete the problem is that the vouchers only benefit if you choose to go to a private a charter or a non-public school families that were choosing to come to us from another public or even a private we weren't seeing that same benefit so we're not getting that amount of funding that people that go for the voucher are getting so they're getting at the high school level about $88,500 a student for the voucher whereas ours is just being calculated in like a regular enrollment we're not getting that

010extra bump so that that hurt us in in terms of um we no longer see that benefit so you know if you if if you think of this in in terms of the analogy of a game so say you know here we are at Great Lakes Chief Stadium we're getting ready to have this awesome contest we're gonna go out to uh to our field and we're going to play this game it's going to be the you know Burkshire against whatever School wants to uh battle Us in terms of fighting over vouchers but the problem is the way the rules are applied we're just draw this big blue line down the middle because the privates parochial and Charters they only have to play on a 50 yard field because there's little to no regulations there's no

011oversight there's you know no standardized testing requirement all those things but you know Berkshire and or all public schools were forced to compete on a 100 yard field because we do have all that oversight all the all those regulations so the the problem is you know we're set we're put in this position to compete but we have to play on the 100 yard field they get to play on a 50 yard field and then everyone wants to compare our score at the end of the game to act like that was some kind of a a meaningful competition and even so we're still competing fairly well even with that in mind so just ju when when people say you know this is a choice they're honoring parent choice when that choice becomes private but if that

012choice is another public then it then it's meaningless because we don't get the same effect that the privates get so we're going to talk about some of our key financial challenges the biggest of all was the state decided to you know blow up our our business model when the took the Open Enrollment incentive away so right off the bat you know the Open Enrollment incentive is taken away that incentive is not taken away from anyone who wants to accept a voucher on top of that we'll take a little piece away from us because we had the a loss of utility revenue there's there's nearly a million dollars in delinquent public utility that hasn't been collected and and that's public utility that should have come to us that we were counting on that we didn't get

013because it wasn't it wasn't ever collected and I don't think we've ever been given a really good explanation as to why it's not being collected there you know we take another little chunk away from the district because even though the privates proales and Charters get this voucher now we still have to provide services to the privates proales and Charters we have to provide their transportation and we have to provide auxiliary services to them if they need a School site we have to send a school psych to you know to to service kids there um they get a portion of our federal funding so even though they're they're getting that full voucher that we're not getting we still have to provide those services so that's another little chunk taken we'll take another little chunk away because

014of the preschool mandates and if if there's a special ed preschooler we're completely responsible for the um the education or the cost to educate those those children but there's there's no State funding that ACC companies preschool um we'll take another little chunk away from the district because you've got court Place students and every year we have um two to four students who one quick example we had a student who was on probation uh violated their probation and the courts plac them out of state in a residential treatment and the district is we don't have any choice in where that is and we don't have any choice in in in how much that costs but we have to pay for the educational portion of that because we are the residential public school so those are those

015are costs that it's really hard to plan for um because I we have no control over that we take another little chunk uh away from the district because we have curricular mandates from the state you know that the state decides okay everyone must teach the science of reading so you know whether you had this curri curriculum or not now you got to pay you know 300 I think we pay I think we spent $350,000 on the science reading curriculum that we implemented not to mention the training and the time and the other things that that go along with that and then we'll take another chunk away because of the overregulation and the amount of reporting compliance issues audits lure excessive standardized testing all of which leads to Resource drain for the district and increased stress

016so essentially what what we're doing here is with what we have left of the badger here we're using that those resources to provide the highest quality educational program that we can provide and I think not a lot of people in the public understand all the little different pieces that are taken away before we can start to to provide the program that we want to provide but what I will say is we have demonstrated strong stewardship of the taxpayer dollars the biggest thing I can point out right away is that we worked with the USDA to build this new school we are the only school in the state of Ohio that has ever done that and what that did is it it allowed us to fund the school through the USDA instead of going out and

017uh getting on the bond market and and getting legal counsil involved and I know that we talked about this a lot during during the um during the bond issue campaign but that saved our taxpayers uh just over $4 million over the life of the loan so in addition to that because we financed with the USDA that gave us the capability to then refinance which we wouldn't have been able to do had we gone the traditional Bond route so these are things that we're thinking of that not a lot of other people are are thinking of in fact no other schools have ever done so in 2022 before we had even moved into this building we refinanced that Levy so our voters passed 3.6 Mills to build this building and then we refinanced and that dropped

018their millage rate to 3.49 and the next year it dropped to 2.6 and now it's collecting at 2.5 so demonstrated fiscal responsibility that how many other school districts can say we built a new building and before we even moved in we started showing efficiencies that saved money to the taxpayers now maybe we didn't do a really good job of of you know informing everybody what we were doing but we were being fiscally responsible and prudent with the funds that we were given another example is if we look at ending cash balances for all these are all the districts in giaga County this is Berkshire right here we have never had a high ending cash balance because we've always spent what we needed to spend and we've never tried to hoard money or save we we've

019we've kept it the same and you can see we're kind of the same here we Beth does a really good job at at trying to anticipate What expenses we're going to have and what revenues we have and we stay the same we're not going up and down trying to do you know the different things that that that a lot of other that you see happen in a lot of other places so there's some demonstrated stewardship of taxpayer dollars we're doing everything we can to give the best educ ational program we can at the lowest price and speaking of best educational program I I want to talk about some successes that we should celebrate because we have seen increased student services here um to deal with students mental health issues things like that we've had increased

020Hands-On learning opportunities increased Career Education opportunities there are some pictures of our diesel tech program we also have the medical assisting program we have our Badger lab vocational PR program where we've got students working in 32 different businesses within the county um all at the same time showing increasing test score as well so you know do we have the best test scores uh in the in the county no but they are consistently increasing as we're also increasing all these other services and adding to a deep program of studies at at our high school so offering our kids um the Hands-On um Career Education that they need while improving and increasing test scores every year we've gone from a three star to a three and a half star to this year we were a fourstar district

021on the state report card um and uh you've seen that we've had increasing numbers of AP Scholars we've had college credit plus On The Rise so so we're not just focusing on one area we're growing all areas and offering all kinds of things to student and that's demonstration that the um the model that we have in place is working so we really want to hold on to that model do everything we can to keep it and continue to increase that that um achievement on the state report card while also increasing the number of uh Workforce Development programs that we have and and I that doesn't even speak to our newest one that we've started with with Preston which is going to provide even more opportunities for for our students here in the future so that

022brings us to where we are now this this was our you know our our Badger that we talked about with all those different little chips taken off of us but we we recently lost another little piece of the badger um with the rejection of the permanent Improvement Levy which will put more um strain on our general fund um because of the lack of that Revenue we could we could offset some some things that now will have to be paid for out of the general fund there are also Al Rising costs and then frankly we're not sure what um external factors are going to influence school funding you know if you if you've been keeping up with the recent studies we've got um some of our state legislators uh saying that they feel like the uh

023funding formula which the effects of which didn't don't benefit us greatly I think they benefit some other districts um a little better but now they're saying that that may be unsustainable um as well so just another another um kind of pickle we've put oursel in so if we look at our current five-year forecast we're looking at um the this this red box shows the amount we're spending versus the amount we're bringing in and you can see these are negative numbers so we're deficit spending um which is not uncommon for school districts and that's when when you start to see that then you start to look for Grants or other things to offset those things which we do frequently but the alarming number is now without that permanent Improvement Levy we can't offset some of those

024costs of the general funds so you see in years four and five we're looking at fund balances so you can't we can't have a we can't have a fund b a general fund uh negative balance because then we can't operate so so things will have to happen either we'll have to find some additional revenues or we'll have to completely gut the um the model which has shown great success for us which is something we want to try to avoid if at all possible when we start planning for the future we'll talk to you about some Revenue generating ideas or things that we that we have in the works that we're already doing one is the the new building that we that we're building out back for preschool uh and and some people might think well

025if you're in if you're in a you know Financial strain um how can you afford to build a new building well last a few months ago when we were making this decision I we showed that the cost for no action was going to be over a million dollars because without that building we're not going to be able to serve these different student populations that we have to serve we have to outplay them in other programs which is going to cost us over a million dollars to build that new facility for the first 10 years is going to be $981,000 and then after that $691,000 so so building the new facility and being able to educate those students here in house without sending them out was going to save money and then in addition to that

026if we fully utilize that that facility we could bring in some additional revenues upward of $771,000 a year if we can fill all the spots so so that building is an investment in our future um and will help us um in the future another thing we've done is we've done a lot of grant writing we brought on a grant writer this year who and that's another thing people would say well what why did you hire a person to write grants if you're in financial trouble that person has brought in triple their salary in Grants already we're not and we're just about halfway through the school year and and in the past Beth and I were doing as many grants as we could while we were trying to do the other things we have to do

027but we weren't able to focus on that and so that focus on on those grants really helps to kind of Target those areas where we need to make up for some funding um so we're getting state federal and private grants um and then we get other donations in as well um but we're able to to to funnel that through one person who can make sure that we're you know we're focusing those efforts where they need to be focused so as we as we plan for the future here the the only other ways to bring in Revenue aside from what we just talked about with the the new building and and the grants are local property tax levies I mean our the options that are available to us are operating funds uh an operating Levy which

028is funding day-to-day operations like salaries utility supplies permanent Improvement Levy which is restricted to Capital Improvements uh emergency levies which is a fixed dollar amount of over a set period of time another type of Levy is an income tax levy it could be either earned income tax or traditional income uh we currently do have a 1% earned income tax levy which is beneficial to retirees and seniors because it's only tax on earned income and retirement doesn't count in that um and and the other the other benefit to an income tax levy is everyone participates and it's based on your your income level so it's not like only Property Owners um are paying for the schools everyone's paying you know a little bit the other option is an inside millage transfer which occurs when a taxing

029Authority such as a school board reallocates inside millage uh for one purpose such as operating expenses to another such as a permanent Improvement or debt services so those are options that we have available to us uh for additional Revenue um the options as as we see it when Beth I sat down to see what we would need if we were to run an operating Levy we would probably need to ask for about a 4.9 mil operating Levy to get us out of this uh fund deficit that we're looking at in five years if we were to ask for an additional income tax it would be in the neighborhood of a half perent additional earned income tax which would generate a little bit less than the amount of 4.9 Mills would would generate in a levy

030um if we were to ask for a permanent Improvement Levy it would be about 2.5 Ms and that wouldn't completely get us out of this debt but it would allow us to shift uh enough expenses from the general fund to the permanent Improvement fund that we could really attack that deficit and and operate you know as we have been and then if we were to do an inside millage transfer that would also be about two and a half Mills from the general to to the permanent Improvement fund um so the the uh what does this mean for the taxpayer a 4.9 mil operating Levy in this District would equate to $171 15 cents per $100,000 of market value a half percent earned income tax would be about $250 per $50,000 of earned income a 2

031and A5 mil permanent Improvement Levy would be about $87.50 per $100,000 of market value and the inside Mill is transfer at 2.5 would be the same about $87.50 for $100,000 of market value now as Beth and I talk it seems like options three and four are really the only realistic options that that um you know we think would would be po possible or potential so we went ahead and and and decided to show kind of what we could do with a new 2.5 mil Levy or inside Mill and so there are there are certain things that we could pay for so anything with a life of five years or more like we we're still paying on the Athletic Facility the stadium behind us and we're paying interest on that so that could come out of

032that the lease for the new building for for prek could come out of that we have an ofcc transfer that we're required to make um every year which is supposed to go to um potential big um um maintenance we need down the road uh we could pull maker space equipment Career Tech equipment Chromebooks buses all out of that um uh permanent Improvement fund it would be really no different than we had operated in the past when we had the permanent Improvement uh Levy that's why we were always able to to kind of make that work so we have to be able to collaborate for a sustainable future here I'll go back to this was our five forecast we talked about the deficit spending and the being in in a negative fund balance if we pass

033a 2.5 mil uh permanent Improvement Levy or if we transferred 2.5 of our inside Mills into a Perman Improvement into the permanent Improvement fund our new fiveyear forecast would look like this you'll see we're still deficit spending which we could Target but if you notice year four we are no longer in a fund balance and year five that fund balance is divided by four basically so we could really Target with grants these deficit spending years and everything we can do to to knock this down has exponential impact on the future so we feel like uh with that 2.5 Mills we could really get out of this issue be able to continue to run the model that we're running and provide the benefits that we're providing because what really what we're doing is we're trying to

034provide the best we can for our youngest students for our middle students and for our oldest students and um so that that's that's what we're collaborating for that's the investment that we're trying to protect to make sure that we can keep doing great things for all these kids in our system with that I'll turn it over to the board for any questions that you you may have for us John can you go back to the balance sheet for a second does that one include uh funds from the preschool no fun funds from the preschool well some it includes some some funds from the preschool but not a fully realized fund from the preschool so yeah so anything we can anything additional we can bring in from the preschool and from Grants would knock that number

035down Goa how many mills was the uh Pi Levy that got voted down collecting for us it was a 2 and a half mil Levy initially it was collecting at under one mil so Point uh Beth yes correct don't would have collected at this year but just under one mil just under one what is the average cost for a preschool student I know there's several different layers y um preschool will vary depending on the severity of of the disability so if if it's a non-disabled preschooler we don't we really don't pay for that that's a tuition based so parents pay tuition for that but um if we had to if we had to place a preschooler um it could be between 44 and $140,000 depending on the severity of the the special need and how

036do we I mean it doesn't seem like there would be a way to really plan or budget for that it's kind of the year before you can kind of get an idea but yeah we we Tred so that that crept up on us a couple of years ago because we didn't have very many and then all of a sudden there was an explosion um so we you do the best you can like looking at the year before or a couple of years before to see if there are any Trends uh we have a decent handle on it now but it's still you know it every year it seems like we get a couple of either movein or you know PE people find us and you know that so we just do the best we can

037to to be it's hard to plan for basically the state contributes nothing to that correct the the state will contribute a little bit to the special needs preschoolers but not they they don't they don't fund it much at all how does that impact going into the future like these kids that starting here in preschool how does that impact us when they're in second grade and fifth grade and yeah the the longer the longer we can have them the better because they can so when we when we get them in preschool then we then we are in control of kind of what they're learning so that when they roll into kindergarten they're they're coming in kind of on a Level Playing Field with other kindergarteners coming in what about financially because those kids would still need

038special services as go through yeah if they're our district resident they're going to get special services but but we've we can we can we control that a little bit easier in K12 because we have a bigger uh K12 staff already and we have those programs we've been bringing our our U special needs programs inhouse more and more because the more we can do here it's it's um it's it's more it's more efficient uh we can run the programs uh more efficiently than if we um if we send those out to outside program so we we like to keep our kids here as much as we can and then once you have so many like once we were at the point where we had eight or more it just made more sense to to have our

039staff run the program because at that point you're you're sending out more than you're bringing in and you're sending them so would you say um from 2017 when you got here till today we send very few special needs kids outside the district unless they need really um really really special services is that an accurate statement yeah we're it's it's a very severe case or a court placement that put them out of the district now we we do our best to not outplay students when we don't have to so we built this since you've been here to be able to have our kids stay home and the other thing about not transporting them away is that they're actually getting education right away instead of being in a van or in a bus being moved from here

040to there um the second part of that is our tech programs and the more vocational that we're doing by offering those programs our kids are in a van or bus less or not at all and they're getting more substantial training or learning because we keep them at home yeah it's easier for them to take the the High School courses as well because right right now our diesel program is at the old Board office um next year it'll be at the OD do facility across from Preston so that's not very far away they're able to get there and back and and able to take more classes um when we when we get when the students go to Auburn it's a 45 minute bus ride or you know 35 minute car car ride so you're basically an

041hour plus that that's an hour plus in the car that they couldn't take advantage of a class here because of the travel time so if we wanted to put another I mean we have to do something so if we went with the route of trying for the third time to get the pi ly passed how soon can we get that on the ballot legally and what kind of impact does the timing of that have on our Outlook yeah at this point I think November is the soonest we can get it on on the ballot be Beth you correct me if I'm wrong that's correct um and so what that that uncertainty um so there's the uncertainty of is it going to pass and then there's if it passes in November Beth when did it when

042would it start collecting if it pass in November so if it passed in November we would collect in 26 if it didn't pass we would and we kept trying we wouldn't see anything till 27 so there there's there's risk that you know if it if it did pass that would be great we would have to make some Some Cuts but they would be cuts that we could manage because we would collect again in 26 but if it didn't pass I we it would put us in a position where we don't have a whole lot of choice but to start making you know significant cuts and we we do our best to to save the classroom from any of that but at at a certain point when you have to make up 4 million it's going

043to touch that you know eventually then on the other side when if the inside millage was used how how quickly do we get that or how did does that come about so so if you voted to have inside millage shifted that would also take a place in 26 but it would be a a guaranteed thing I I think the scariest thing about our forecaster right now too is with the legislature talking about um potentially not funding the formula you know that's another unknown that you know we just don't know how to how to forecast for that how to predict for that um you know you have new legislators coming in and they're saying that the this formula that they stuck us with is not sustainable um so so what does that mean we don't know

044you know is just like with the public utility tax we were counting on almost a million dollars uh from the Orwell tremble Pipeline and it just went away it's and and now it's you know the valuations went away and now we have this almost a million dollar delinquency that you know we've asked repeatedly what's going on and um we're not getting answers from the county so that's very frustrating because a million dollars could do a lot for this this forecast um but the last the last um that we were told and this is all the schools in Jaga County are affected by this um don't count on that money so you know when you have that in your forecast and you're collecting five years out and suddenly it drops off that's a big change you

045know and so we scramble and try and make it up someplace else what is our how do we compare to other schools in the county as far as staff administrator teacher ratio um I'm not 100% sure about the county I know Statewide that typically you know building level Administration is about one to every 200 students so if you look at the high school we have 435 students we have two building administrators so we're right around the average at the middle school we have about 435 students and we have two administrators and at the elementary school we have about 5 15 I think students and we have one building level administrator so we're a little bit lower at the elementary we're a little we're about average at the middle and high school and to your point

046what we're doing is working I mean that's that would be a very sad thing about and the and the thing about the administrators I mean I know everybody jumps right away to you know get rid of those building administrators but they provide a direct line of support to the classroom teacher because if you don't have an assistant principal to to uh handle some of the issues that teachers face in classrooms then there left to dealt with those issues in the classroom while they're also trying to to teach so in terms of you know who's on the chopping block first yes you know probably District level administrators then you know building level in terms of assistant principal um before we would ever get to the classroom but just realize that the loss of those also puts

047a strain on the classroom teacher because they have less support especially when we have Rockstar administrator administrators like we do who are just doing amazing things for the district and getting outstanding results and forming good bonds with the kids it just that would be that's just I think the proofs in the pudding that the the model that we have is producing results on on all of our metrics it's not and and we we really thought Hands-On you know learning that that that you know helped kids through Workforce Development and that's really where the state wants schools to go and we're doing and we're showing massive improvements there but we're also showing those incremental improvements on the report card and the other things so it's a model that's working it's and and we get calls from

048other districts to ask how we're doing it what we're doing um and that's why I think it's a model that we want to protect if we can protect it um and you know if we can't protect that model then eventually something's going to give either the Workforce Development or the report card or or heaven forbid you know the program in general but when you when you have a a proven working model you want to do everything you can to continue to support that model when you look at having five principles and assistant principles total for 1,400 children you have 280 children per administrator and and you can't say that our ele our elementary doesn't get help from our middle school because they do because we're in this same building Am I Wrong by saying that

049these principles and assisted principles are co-mingling and working with each other yeah yeah they're helping each other with um with lunch duties and um you know and yeah they they're they're working together uh like a they work together frequently and we we have weekly administrative team meetings where they all talk about what what their needs are and they all kind of jump in and help each other where it's needed so and that's why we built the model of having one building and so they can help each other and it isn't um the assistant and high school principal only take care of 9 through 12 because I know that not to be the case they're they're working with Mandy or they're working with Heather to help and um I mean we've seen that happen so for

050the public our administrators all work together and and that really goes for anybody um that we have on our team they're co-mingling and working with every group because that's why we wanted one building so that we didn't have to have duplicates of anything because the way we used to have it with ledgemont Burton elementary and then the old building I mean we had to have separate people because they were in separate buildings we don't have that anymore accurate is that an accurate statement yes thank you I want to say something too that you don't realize as a public the expenses and all the things that have to come out of a school's budget because I was a teacher for 30 years and I didn't realize all of and I used to come to board meetings

051and all that other kind of stuff as a community member as a teacher but so much stuff comes out that we don't even realize what comes out of the budget that we think is just for education because everything and now you look at you know when John put all those pieces together and now that the State's starting to take money through the voucher system to out of that big fund there's less and less for us to have and we as a community then have to go to these levies that nobody wants just to support our schools the way we want to and it's it's really quite complicated and so hard but we all as board members want the best for your children and our children and that's where decisions become so hard to make sometimes

052I think I think our problem is everybody who is watching this presentation or joining us online or care to ask questions about this are the ones that support us and the progress we've made with this school and its system and and most of them 99% of them love what we doing the problem is there's a large majority of people out there that don't take the time or don't care to take the time to learn about what we're doing and see the progress we're making they only see dollars and cents so I think really comes down to the question we it's obviously uh something that we have to change and whether that comes from a levy or an inside millage that's really our choice right that we we need to get funds and I think those

053I agree with you in your presentation those are the only two options that we have is either having voters vote on it or transfer inside millage so I think the million-dollar question is do we can we put all of our effort in to pass a levy or do we think that's going to fail no matter what if if we can't pass a renewal Pi Levy that was collecting at less than half of what we were what we are now going to propose even though I think the economy is turning and it's going to be a little easier uh out there do we have what it takes with information and data and energy and time and campaigning and reach enough people to turn the tide to have a levy go through I think that's really what

054it's going to come down to yeah I think it's it's really easy for people to make the claim that you know the school wastes money or but we we are the most regulated uh entity that that I mean everything we do is audited and you don't win auditor of the state awards every year by wasting money or not being fiscally responsible and that that's the only thing I would point back to people who really don't know what how we do things but just assume um or assume that they know how you know how revenues are are given or how things you know there we wouldn't every year that Beth has been the treasur she's been in the top 1% and and essentially this District then because of Beth's work has been in the top 1%

055of all districts in the state in terms of fiscal responsibility so if we're mismanaging things then 99% of the State of Ohio's public school districts are really mismanaging things yeah this to the the public this is not an easy decision for any of us and we can't kick this can down the road um bad things will happen as we have seen in the past but so um again like what Dan said I think we have to weigh the option of you know are we to put that effort into that and try to pass that or do we do an inside millage transfer because we cannot depend on the county to collect a million dollars that we're due and we can't depend on the state to have a fair funding model for the schools and our

056community is very important and I think the vast majority of the people in our community would agree that you know the school is the Hub of the community and and your real estate value depends on how well the schools do um so to to the general public this this is not a you know an easy easy decision for us to to make the state and we're talking specifically um Matt Huffman put out a video where they want to cut $650 million of funding to public education now in in quick numbers the state has about 620 Public Schools but it's not uh based upon the size of those schools you know their range in size that would affect us approximately a half a million dollars right away they make another cut then you're going to cut

057what yeah obviously if you're cutting 650 million out they're going to be taking from every single District it's the only way they can make that kind of cut and he is adamant saying that he wants to do it we have to protect our investment and our kids and our and our district we have to protect it because the people in Columbus are not going to protect us they they've made that clear that the voucher program is staying and we didn't even comment on this but the 69 vouchers that are paid out our our kids that were already in in other schools they weren't in our school and left they already were in those schools now it's just that the money followed them to those schools I don't knock that program I'm not opposed to the

058program I'm just not happy that they're going to cut 650 out of the budget they're going to hurt us that and that's hurting our kids if they would simply make the if they would simply make that Equitable and say then open enrollment should count as a voucher because that's a choice if they if they made that same commitment to the public school then now that wouldn't be great that would be that would be good for Burkshire because we're winning the Open Enrollment right war that might not be good for some other districts who are losing open enrollment but if you re if you want real competition have us play on an equal siiz playing field exactly and our goal is to educate the children that walk through the doors we don't look at their address

059we don't ask them who their parents are Our obligation is to educate those children and I'm a firm believer that no matter where these kids come from there are kids when they walk through that door and I want them here if they want to be here so so what our next steps Beth well I don't know if uh if you put off public comment John if you want to jump that to now or this is the time if we're going to do it unless or we can continue to talk obviously even after public comments but um I delayed for those of you weren't here uh public participation usually happens at the beginning of the meeting I chose to do it after we had our presentation so if there's anyone that has any comments questions Now's

060the Time to ask you come up to the microphone address the board and all we ask is that uh you know you're addressing us and asking the question if you have any questions or comments okay now back to your question yeah what's the what what are next steps [Music] what procedure so if you decide to put the the pi Levy back on you we would have uh two motions to pass and then it would go on um would file it with Board elections it would go on the November uh ballot if you decided to shift mil Village um from general fund to the permanent Improvement fund um we would need to advertise twice and there's some timing on the advertisement so I think we would have to advertise like this if you wanted to do

061it in February uh we would advertise this Friday and then the following Thursday and then you're required by law to have a public hearing uh you're required by law to notify the county auditor and then um so we would probably have to push our board meeting back an hour do a hearing on the 10th which would be our next board meeting and then once the public hearing was over you'd go into a regular session and then have it be part of regular business are we making a motion tonight do we need to make a motion tonight that what are were're headed I I need marching orders as to uh how to proceed so um either way I think you need to either make a motion um for me to prepare resolutions uh either for either

062issue for for next board meeting can we um have the public session and talk about the inside millage transfer and then still have enough time if uh if after that we vote on and it doesn't pass they'll have enough time to put the pi levy on for the fall so discuss the the inside mil transer and then yes you would have enough time to do that so are you saying if you had a public hearing and then you said okay we're gonna yes you would okay so you're saying we're not going to make a motion tonight she's saying we need to tell her to you you have to give Beth marching orders way or the other um and I think Brian I think your question was can we start you down the road of the

063inside millage transfer and then if after the hearing we decide we don't want to do that do we still have time to make the resolution for the um permanent Improvement Levy was that your question correct yeah that and so yes we there is time for that so you so I guess the board probably a motion is the best way to do it because then you're going to have a vote on uh you're not voting on what you're doing you're just voting on what you're asking Beth to do next so really we're voting if we want a public hearing or not is what it comes down to correct right to discuss yeah the we're voting on if we want a public hear okay I have a question here too that why can we do this inside

064melage what kind of things tell us that this is acceptable what kind of laws or statements or so the in inside millage transfer is is allowable by law it's part of the Ohio Revised Code um and it it does affect the 20 mil floor and the 20 mil floor is part of the Ohio Constitution so the Ohio Constitution says that a school district is constitutionally required to collect 20 Mills to support a free appropriate public education it just so happens in our district we haven't passed any operating levies in so long that we are at the 20 mil floor so essentially if we transfer the two and a half Mills from the general fund and the permanent Improvement fund it drops us below the 20 mil floor so taxes would increase to raise us to

065the 20 mil floor so just so we're clear if you vote to do a millage transfer it will increase taxes well all four of the choices all four of the choices will increase taxes we need to get money from somewhere so uh have other schools in our area gone that route in the last there are other schools in the county that have transferred inside millage but they were not at the 20 mil floor like we are so you can transfer inside millage if you're not at the 20 mil floor it doesn't affect taxpayers yeah but if you're at the 20 mil floor floor than it then it does affect taxpayers okay so no no one else has been at the 20 Mo floor when they've done it in this County other places in the state

066have but not in the county okay any other questions or comments so when we have this public hearing will we then be voting that night or will we have time to digest the public comments so you're the hearing cannot be part of a regular board meeting so I think we would uh push back the regular board meeting till at least 7 okay um and then hear from the public and then I I would have motions probably ready for all the different options uh and then you you know you would pass whatever going forward it's not required to have the vote that same day I mean you could say I want to wait till March I mean it it it all depends on how fast you know how quickly you want to proceed it's just a

067huge you know it's a huge decision that none of us want to be in this position I mean it's just an absolute shame that you know the levy failed twice when it had been in place since 1989 and we were going along great and it's just a Beyond disappointing outcome that being said you know this is a very big decision on how we recoup that money and so I guess we can decide that night you know if we feel ready to take action or if we want to postpone it a few weeks for clarity of Beth I I want to ask the question and I and I know I've asked it before but I want to publicly said if there was a change in the way the state funded the schools and I mean I'm

068not saying they're going to fund it in the positive way and and things go away but if that did in fact happen we are not obligated to collect that money even if it passes we can push it back and not collect it am I correct oh correct yeah okay so I mean I want to make that clear that we're talking about making this District solid like we always have if you go back through all the board members that ever sat here this District was always Frugal and always was funded I don't care how far back you go we can name names back 30 40 years that was how this District operated we still operate that way today I mean you I could talk about Beth receiving the the highest award in the state for being

069the best Treasurer in the northeast Ohio voted on by by our peers so we know we're we're a Frugal well operated District that's how we operate but we have to fund it so our kids get the education they deserve and we're not in the red that's it so Beth do you want a you want us to vote tonight so that you could put a resolution together yes so if you would like to hold a public hearing prior to our board meeting on February 10th I just wrote up a quick uh motion motion to authorize the treasurer to take the necessary steps to hold a public hearing to potentially shift inside millage on February 10th 2025 at 6: pm and for clarity purposes when we're voting affirmative or not we are not voting that we're passing

070it we're voting so that you can gather the information do the advertisements and the advertisement and the information is that correct correct okay any other comments or questions by the board Beth read that one more time please a motion to authorize the treasur to take the necessary steps to hold a public hearing to potentially shift inside Mill on February 10th 2025 at 6: p.m. at 14155 clear and Troy Road the auditorium I'm going to make the motion I'll second JJ Brian any comments roll call Beth please Mrs Stone yes Mrs Miller yes m Mr Manfredi yes Mr wesworth yes and Mr Burman yes okay do we have any other topics we'd like to cover all right then I'm going to ask for a motion to adjourn so move Brian I'll second Jody Mr Wadsworth yes

071Mr Burman yes Mr Manfredi yes Mrs Miller yes Mrs Stone yes thank you for those of you who came out and endured this cold brutal weather thank you for coming out tonight

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.