001that in an effective and efficient fashion. A maximum of 30 minutes of public participation as it pertains to school related topics will be permitted at each meeting. Each person wishing to address the board will approach the podium and state his or her name and address. If several people wish to speak, each person will be allotted three minutes until the total time of 30 minutes is used. During that period, no person may speak twice until all who desire to speak have had the opportunity to do so. The period of public participation may be extended by a vote of the majority of the board. I think we have someone that's calling to speak. Is she here yet? Let's move on. Then we will move on to the superintendent report. Dr. Claire's. Good evening everybody. Want to wish
002everybody a successful end of the second quarter. Want to uh extend everybody happy holidays, happy new year. Hope you get some time with friends and family. Um, at this time I want to introduce Mr. Larson and he's going to be presenting our Hurricane Leadership Academy students. Hi. Uh, want to say thank you to the board uh, and everybody else in attendance for allowing an opportunity or giving an opportunity to our students to present this evening. Uh starting last year, the hurricane empowerment project was an idea to create uh and to provide our students uh that we feel show leadership potential with potential with the supports needed to make the school a better place. Uh students that were identified for the inaugural group last year showed leadership on the field or on the court, in the
003classroom or on the stage. These students were some of the best and brightest Brooklyn has to offer and that is saying quite a bit. The Hurricane Empowerment Project is in its second year with a brand new cohort of young people who are learning about themselves as leaders and how they too can uh have an impact on the environment around them. This year, we have asked the graduates from last year's cohort to serve as members of the student advisory council. We met once prior to the start of the school year and now meet quarterly to review ways we can make the Brooklyn High School experience better for all of our students. This group has started multiple clubs, developed plans for community engagement activities, and represented our school as student ambassadors on the first day of school,
004as well as at the welcome back rally, and as well when we invited first ring principles to the district on November 21st. In our last meeting, I asked four amazing young people to stand before you and discuss the impact that the hurricane empowerment project has had on them. Each one was assigned a specific competency under the portrait of a hurricane through which to view the school. Starting us off will be Belma Veljek who will discuss her experiences and its impact on the competency cultural acceptance and citizenship. When prompted, Belma was asked to consider the following questions in her response. How has going through the hurricane empowerment project had an impact on you as a student at Brooklyn High School? And how have you used this to better the school climate? Going through the empowerment group
005has had a significant impact on me as a student at Brooklyn High School. It has helped me practice respect and cont contribute positively to both the school and wider community by participating in various activities and discussion discussions. I've become more culturally culturally empathetic and compassionate, understanding the importance of diverse viewpoints and the value of each individual's background. I have been involved in organizing events that promote acceptance and inclusivity ensuring that everyone feels welcomed and valued. This has helped foster a positive school climate where students feel supported and encouraged to express themselves. This empowerment group has also allowed me to share ideas and learn from other pe other people's perspectives and idea ideas. This exchange of knowledge has encouraged my peers to appreciate and respect different cultures leading to a more harmonious and collaborative school environment.
006Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Next will be Danny Fam who will talk to us about the competency, creativity, and innovation. When prompted, Danny was asked to consider the following questions in his response. How will you use what you have learned through the hurricane empowerment project to guide your future? And what do you see as the greatest benefit for you following high school? So I want to start off by saying um so about this whole thing is that I think what's what it's important for is to inspire students like me and the other people here just talk to take action and but not necessarily give us a reason cuz I think like we all like have our reasons why we want to do things what our causes are right and this wasn't for to give
007us a reason but rather inspire us to take action. See, I'm one of those people who like I I won't do something unless I know it's 100% right. I will keep asking. I I'll be shy. I I'm I just need 100% confidence. But what this thing has walked me through is that um sometimes you just have to get out there. There won't be arrow signs pointing you to the right direction. you just have to go look, venture out, go forward and and that's how a lot of things get done in the world. You challenge ideas and you you just go ahead and forward it. And one one of my personal experiences is definitely um cold emailing for jobs cuz it is it is hard out there. Just it is rough. But um just finding as
008many emails as I could, just being bold, saying, "Hey, this is what I want. If they respond to me, lovely. If they don't, I take take it with stride and continue forward." And this speaks to me as I'm going forward because as someone who wants to go into medicine, it is so competitive and it's just one of those things that you have to be bold, you have to take initiative and um that's that's what I want to take from it. And speaking on a broader term like um a lot like again a lot of changes happen because people um you know go off go on the road less traveled. They they look for things that need to be changed but don't necessarily have pe a lot of people speaking on it. So um so yeah
009this is just to say take those opportunities and venture out when you can. Thank you. Next will be Florence Soo who will review the hurricane empowerment project's impact on the competency connection to community. When prompted he was asked to answer the following questions. How has being a part of the hurricane empowerment project strengthened your bond with Brooklyn High School? And how has it taught you the importance of giving back to your community? Having been a part of the hurricane empowerment projects, I feel like my sense of pride, service, and connection to the community has flourished. I have pride in Brooklyn community because I've seen how the school's teachers and students work together within the building. For a lot of our teachers and students, they try to better better themselves and work harder every day and
010they work eagerly with groups like the Hook and Empowerment Project to improve everything they can. I have a feeling of service in our community as well because we have worked hard on getting different clubs and groups established at our school and will hopefully be able to serve a greater community too. For example, our school scholar club has branch out from this project as a way to serve the uh school better in available extracurriculars which is an important thing in all schools. Finally, I feel like the connection to the Brooklyn community I feel connection to the Brooklyn community. I participated in events like promoting garden club at the fall festival this year leading me to feel more connected to people who graciously support us in many ways. Our community works to help fund raise and volunteer
011to help us in many ways possible to let us learn and thrive. Now, taking all of this and understanding the significance of this empowerment project and its goals, I'm hopeful that it will set new traditions in our school for future students to follow. Our school has traditions of course, but all mean things like the football team and marching band. New traditions for students will set the tone of our school as one that is active in community and always works to better themselves, which is the ultimate goal of the project that I am proud of and many students as well. Good job. Thank you. Lastly, we'll be Isabella Lig who will review the competency of critical thinking and problem solving. When prompted, Bella was asked to consider the following questions in her response. What has being
012a part of the hurricane empowerment project taught you about the importance of being a leader and how will you use this to better your impact on the world? Good evening everyone. The hurricane empowerment committee, it's taught me that leadership isn't just about titles or authority. It's about like inspiring people and it's shown me like what it means to lead and how lead and how impactful leadership can be. Um under Mr. Burton's member mentorship. Um, a group of students eager to grow like the ones back here learned how to lead effectively both in the present and for our futures in college and beyond. Our meetings weren't just about discussions. They were opportunities to experience leadership firsthand. We tackled complex real world questions, engaged in critical thinking, and applied practical solutions to challenges. One of the best
013leadership experiences during this project was creating and leading our own initiative. Like Floren mentioned, he created a garden club. My group decided to come up with an idea that would help um the community access more resources. Through this, we brainstorm several possibilities and we did a school base supply drive. Um at our community bike rodeo, we came up with um an idea to collect school supplies for underserved people of our community. And Mr. Burton emphasized the importance of weighing the pros and cons of each option, teaching us how to think critically about how each choice would impact our project success, which led us to this idea. Once we launched the supply drive, challenges did arise. We needed to figure out how to coordinate with the event organizers to ensure we had enough volunteers and to
014spread the word effectively. However, the skills we gained from the hurricane empowerment project helped us navigate these hurdles. We learned that leadership means seeing the challenges not as roadblocks, but as opportunities for growth. Ultimately, our project succeeded in collecting muchneeded school supplies for students in need. More importantly, it taught us that when you approach a problem with critical thinking, evidence-based decisions, and willingness to adapt, you can create meaningful change. Thanks to the Hurricane Empowerment Project and Mr. Burton's guidance, I now understand that leadership is about finding innovative solutions, making thoughtful choices, and determination during difficult times of projects. Thank you. Thank you. All right. I want to take a moment to thank our students who spoke this evening. Appreciate the time that they spent both in crafting their response as well as the time that
015has this has taken away from all of the activities that they're involved in. I want to celebrate them. You see Miss Beljack here is dressed up in her cheerleading uniform. Uh she's one of our uh cheerleaders here at the school. And then Danny, Bella, and Floren all represented us uh at the uh concert this weekend. So, these are students who are actively involved on a regular basis and uh they truly are some of the best and brightest that we have to offer here at Brooklyn High School. Um, in here I said uh if we could please give a round of applause for these amazing students. I wouldn't mind doing that again if you wouldn't mind. And I want to thank the board for providing us with this opportunity for allowing us to celebrate some of
016the best and brightest that we have to offer here at Brooklyn High School. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you everybody. One of the one of the things that I think that we realized last year is that obviously math, science, social studies, practical arts are the the content and the curriculum is is so important. But it but one of the things that I think that we really we we discussed as a a staff last year is how important leadership and communication is uh moving forward. And so we want we want part of this program and and we're hoping we we're continuing to provide this training and this these opportunities for all of our kids, but how important that that these life skills are are essential for for success for them, right? And you know,
017they they live in a very different world than than when I grew up. And you know, I didn't get my first cell phone till I was 26. Yes, I'm old. So, um, but this is this is th that's native for them. So, again, we want to make sure that they have the opportunity and then they have the skill set, uh, moving into whatever their next journey is outside of Brooklyn to to be prepared. And they are really, they truly are an amazing group of seniors. uh they they some of them come down every uh Friday or every other Friday and play games with our elementary kids um in the morning just to you know welcome them and some of our second graders work our seniors and checkers and some other things like that. So, it's
018it's really kind of fun to watch watch connecting with our with our high school kids and our younger kids and and this group particular on the first day of school. They wore their shirts and then they greeted um our our kids as they walked in the door. And I will tell you, it was like paparazzi. They were they it was the it was the funniest thing to watch how excited our our elementary kids were that they were there welcoming that. So, so not only are they are they just great kids, they're just great role models. So, want to thank you for being here. Appreciate it. This crawl, I do have a statement I'd like to read before before we move forward. Um, want to thank We have parents here, staff here, students, community members, elected
019officials. Um, moving on to an important topic of the board's uh consideration of a potential policy change regarding open enrollment for the 2526 school year. Um, you know, I think it's I think it's very important to reaffirm and and communicate some important points as we as we move forward. And I wanted the board and and really the community to hear my perspective on things. I know um I know ultimately that this is a a board decision and the board will be considering this uh in a little bit here. Um but but truly I want I want you to hear my perspective of things and truly my my interest is is solely of Brooklyn, our students, our families um and what's best and our staff and what's best for them. Um, from a from a matter
020of fact and and some some some data, the the board and the leadership team have been discussing the prospect of open enrollment going back since the spring of 2024, including public board meetings in April, May, October, along with community presentation on October 10th, where I presented current enrollment data trends and and potential um impact of of of enrollment in the district. On December 3rd, the board of the board of education considered the first reading of this policy change. Over the past nine months, I've shared enrollment data, guidance, and suggested procedures for the board to consider. I believe the board is considering this decision with the best interests of the Brooklyn school, students, families, and community in mind. Since 2014, the district has seen enrollment decline by almost 300 students, resulting in a reduction of staffing
021and programming since then. Particular in 2020 when I came back, uh we saw a significant um impact from COVID and not to blame everything on COVID, but we have not rebounded from a student enrollment since 2020. We've we've remained about the same. Today we stand at one point in the district boasted an enrollment of over 1,400 students. Today we stand at an estimated enrollment of approximately 1,150 students. Since returning as your superintendent in 2020, we have seen a substantial increase in the number of students that actually open enroll of the district. Students that live in the district, city limits that actually choose to open enroll outside of the district. that includes public, private, Cleveland municipal school district, um, and charter and community online schools. The data is telling. Right now, we have almost 200 resident
022students in Brooklyn currently that currently attend schools outside of the district through publicly funded private private school vouchers, open enrollment to public, online, community, and charter schools. Over the past year, we have seen in Brooklyn alone, we have seen an in a 56% increase in families taking advantage of private school voucher program because of the recently the recent changes in publicly funded voucher program. And and I want to be clear, this is not a a testimony against parental choice. I fully I fully support a parents choice on where they want to send their schools. I believe as a superintendent, we offer an amazing product here in the district. However, parents always have that right to send their children. Me as a father, I lived in one district. I chose to send my children to another
023school district. That's a parent's right. And I 150% support that. The reason I say this is I want to I just want to mention the absolute impact that this voucher program is having on Brooklyn and other public school districts throughout Ohio. The real the reality is simple and I fully understand the questions surrounding this policy change potential policy change. Here's what I anticipate the impact will be on the school district. For every new open enroll student, the district will receive state funding supporting res resources that directly benefit all students in our schools. That funding is approximately the same same current funding level that Brooklyn receives for students to attend here around $2,000. If a if a a a parent takes advantage of the of the voucher program, they have the ability to up to depending
024on grade level and their family income level, up to about $8,000 of publicly funded dollars will go to that family through the voucher program that comes off our bottom line. Um that does not the the voucher program does not come off of our bottom line. If anybody enrolls from a a district charter community or or online school that comes out of our bottom line. The state has made has arranged where the the voucher program is separately funded from school from public schools. So we don't see the the impact in terms of of money lost to the district. We see that impact in number of students enrolled in the district. Good. Appreciate it. If the board considers this policy, I truly don't anticipate more than 75 students across all grade levels to to be to apply
025for this program. And even though this equates to a handful of students per grade, K through 12, it keeps students in our seats, staff doing their jobs due to fear of jobs and the ability to keep provide top-notch programs and opportunities for all of our students. One of the one of the big considerations that that I've had conversations with with staff and and I think this is an important mention. Um, we are very fortunate to have to have smaller class sizes in our district and and part of the consideration of this program is is I do not want enrollment numbers to increase so much that that it begins to impact our staff instruction. It begins to balloon our staff sizes that begin to impact student learning and staff instruction. In the end, to ensure this,
026the application process will take place this spring for a limited time based upon grade level capacity and application specific requirements. I I and we've talked about this before. The this policy is is and can be re reviewed annually and I have recommended to the board of education to annually meet me to review the impact of this policy on the school district. I think it's important if the board considers this change to continually seek data on the impact of class sizes, behavior, attendance, achievement, and finances. I think those are all considerations. I want to be real clear because today's been a a bitty a pretty busy day from a communication standpoint and but but it's been a good day. This is not about athletics. This is not about athletics. This is not about bringing kids in
027this district to displace our current Brooklyn students. This is not about money. Even though we we will receive some finances from open enroll students, we're not going to receive enough money to make a a dramatic impact on our finances. Mr. Sher and I have talked about this. It It's not a It's not a big impact. This is about remaining viable as a school district. I want to say that one more time. This is about remaining viable as a school district. for the students and families we serve in this district. I recognize this is an emotional topic, but it's an important decision. I will support whatever the and and I say this, I will support whatever the board decides. I only want the best for our district, our students, our families, and our staff and our
028community. My sole purpose in this role is to support all of those people, including our board of education and our students and our staff and regardless of any other factor. Change is difficult. I do not want to I do not see this as a negative. In fact, I see this as an opportunity to make our district a place where all want to attend. We have amazing students, families, and staff. I am dedicated to ensuring that all students, both current and new, receive an exceptional educational experience. And I am confident that this change will be an opportunity to enrich our school community for years to come. That being said, I am one voice in in in the cog of decisions and and I wanted to make sure that I said this to you, said this to
029our audience, said this to our community. Whatever the board decides, I will support 150%. I'm happy to answer any questions that anybody has. Parents, community members, please reach out via email and we can set up a time to meet in person, talk via email or talk over the phone. Wish everybody a happy holidays. That's my report. Thank you. Are you okay with answering some questions now so that we can not this time? Okay. Um you you the you have the next um topic too. Oh yes. Thank you. I want to just announce uh we're required um to announce our um um district hearing for a district calendar. We we have a tenative uh calendar finalized for the 25 school year. We have to open it up to the community in terms of uh any input
030they have regarding the dates. Um, I will post that online and our organizational agenda and then on on January 7th, we will have a um comments for the public regarding that district calendar. Once those comments are are um heard, if there's any, then I would ask the board to consider adoption of that calendar so we can notify our families and staff. Thank you, Miss Craw. And I was going to dismiss the kids, but they're already out. They were out. Um we will move on to the treasur's report with um Mr. Sheerart. Okay. Um good evening. Like to report that um so far to this point um to the end of November, we've actually received about $8 million for our levy income, which is about 46% for the year. Um foundation from the state, we've received
031about 1.1 million, which is 38% from the uh for the year. um investment income was [Music] $75,4951 for the month of November. Um unfortunately because of the Fed dropping the rates um we have seen a decrease in our investment income for the month of November. Um if you recall last month it was about 86,000. So that is that is coming down at this point. Um, year to date, the investment income is $440,239. Um, let's see. Um, to date, we are personnel and benefits are running about 40%. Which is actually a little bit lower than what we uh what we were expecting to uh to hit and operations are running at 30.7% for the year. Um so total revenue we've we have received about 49% for uh through November and total expenses we have spent about
03238.4% for the month. Um next month I will be bringing the tax budget to you for approval at the organizational meeting on January 7th. And I also um also have anformational presentation that I'd like to do um in regards to um levy types and levy information. Okay. So I wanted to go over some basic terminology for levies. Um, first to start off is the your house values. When your house is put up for sale or when it uh is appraised by the county, that's called the appraised or market value. Um, the next is the assessed or the taxable value. That is 35% of what the appraised value is and that's that's what the tax is based on that value. Um, you have the full and voted tax rates. So that is what the the levies
033go on the ballot for. That is what they the uh the millillage that they're approved for or the dollar amount. Um the effective tax rate is the rate that is reduced because of um as values increase there's a reduction factor that's applied and that brings the the effective millage I'm sorry the the voted millage down to the effective millage. um roll backs and credits. Uh some some people are are able to get what's called a homestead and a roll back credit through their real estate taxes through the county and the state. Um with the roll backs, the state um the taxpayer gets the credit and then the state reimbures the district for the loss of that money. and that um that it helps the taxpayer because they're not paying that portion of the tax. The
034state is actually picking that up. Um I believe there's a house bill that's out that they are out there that they are talking about voting to take the roll back credits away. So that 2 and 12% that the state is picking up and paying for the taxpayer may be removed and the taxpayer will have to pay that piece. Uh but that's that has not been uh hasn't been approved yet. Um then the millage is a term that's used for the the tax rate and one mill is equal to is basically a dollar divided by a th000. So, if you have a $100,000 house, the that would be the market value. The assessed value would be 35% of that or 35,000. Then one mil would be you could actually the easiest way to do is drop
035off the three zeros for the 35,000 and just take 35 and multiply it by the mill. So, one mill would equal $35 for that taxpayer. Let's see. Uh there's types of the types of levies that are out there. There's additional, which is a new levy that brings in new money to the district. Um there's what's called a replacement levy. That's those are not very um they're not used very often. And what that does, it takes a current levy with the effective millage, the reduced millage. If it's put on the ballot and it's voted in, then it actually replaces the prior and it bumps that millillage back up to what it was originally voted at. So if it was a six mill levy and it was approved then over the years as the valuation reduces the
036millillage if you do a replacement it will actually take that old one off with the lower millage and replace it with the the original millage from when it was passed years ago. They're not they're really not done that often because it it um it increases taxes because it takes it back up. Um then renewals, those are um continue continuations of current levies. So um there it doesn't increase taxes. It's based on the same effective rate at that it currently is at. Um there are types of levies. There's an inside which is an unvoted levy and that um well I'll go over that in a second. Sorry. Uh then we have fixed sum levies and then fixed rate levies. So the inside millillage is a levy that is it's considered unvoted. It was passed by the
037state. So it is it is law and it is based on 10 mills. Brooklyn um Brooklyn's inside millage is 4.6 mills and it's actually that 10 mills is split out by like it could be the county. The city may get some of that 10 mills. Um the library may get like 0.5 of it. So it's 10 mills for all of the taxing districts within the city. So Brook again Brooklyn's Brooklyn schools gets 4.6 mills. Um that can only be adjusted by the budget commission or courts and as value changes um the uh the revenue changes equal to the percentage. So if the value goes up 10% the inside millage goes up 10% as well. If it's re if the um valuation goes down by 10% then the millillage also goes down by 10 or I'm
038sorry the revenue goes down by 10%. Um the rate is constant. The revenue and the values are what's variable. Uh we have fixed sum levies. These levies are voted to generate a specific amount of money. Um they're limited to bond and emergency levies only. uh the rates are set each year by the the uh budget commission. So they have to calculate the valuation in the district. Then they calculate based on how much money that that uh levy is going to bring in to set the new rate based on those uh on those. And then the district only specifically receives that dollar amount. it's the um the value and the rates are the variable for for those levies. Then we have fixed rate levies. Those are the uh really the most popular. Um that's current those
039are considered current expense and those are based on a rate. So if you were to pass a levy for say five mills, it doesn't look at the dollar amount that it's bringing in. it's based on that millillage. Um but then over time as the valuation increases the reduction factor for this also kicks in and reduces how much um how much the millage is sorry it changes the effective millage as well. So in this one the value and the rates are variable rather than the dollar amount. So just a summary of it, the uh the inside is considered unvoted and it's shared um among the political subdivisions like the city, the county, the library. Um it moves in the direction proportional to the value change. So if the valuation goes up 10%. The uh the levy
040brings in 10%. More. Um then there's fixed rate levies which are voted. Those are the bonded emergencies. That's the um a rate is set to produce a specific amount. So it always brings in the same dollar amount. Um those values increase as rates decrease. So it's it's an inverted um inverse um relationship. So as one goes up, the other comes down. Um fixed rate levies again are uh specifically rate vote approved by the voters. The rate is adjusted for the rep reappraisal changes and as the value increases due to the reappraisal the rate is reduced resulting in no no tax impact and then the value increases due to well new construction. So here's some um some examples of the different types of levies and how they are how they're affected with um in this case
041it's increases. So in the first column you can see the inside that's the inside millage. So if a house is is valued at 100,000 and the effective tax rate is 10 the uh 10 mills it would bring in $1,000 in revenue. So if the the new after the appraisal it goes up 10% the new value is 110,000 it still applies that same 10 mills and it would bring in $1,100 in taxes. In the second column it is a fixed sum which is the fixed dollar amount. So if it was eight mills it would bring in $8 $800. If it went up 10%, it would be based on 110,000 valuation. You can see the millage actually drops to 7.27. However, it still brings in the same $800. And then the fixed rate levies. Um, in this
042case, it's 100,000 and it's the effective rate is 50 mills uh with a $10,000 increase. the new effective rate actually drops down to 45 mills because it was a 10% increase. So, it's 10% decrease on the millage and that brings in $4,950. So, you could see it went from 5,000 on the for the revenue from 5,000 down to 4950. So the dis in this case the district would actually actually lose $50 even though it in it increased the 1100 on the inside millillage for a a um a net of $50 a $50 uh increase. And basically it's the same for a decrease in value. So if you uh if if the uh county comes out and reappraises your property and it goes down then you basically have um the same thing where on the inside
043millillage it would um start at a,000 and then it would go down by the the 10%. So it would drop to 90,000 it would only bring in $900 in in uh tax rather than a th000. than the fixed sum levy. It again this this is based on the dollar amount. So the tax revenue would be $800 but the millillage would jump up to 8.88 to bring in the same dollar amount of $800 because of the the uh the reduction in the value. And then the fixed rate levy um operates basically the same way. So if it went up or I'm sorry if it decreased the valuation decreased by 10,000 it's down to 90,000 now the effective rate would actually go up the 10% which would bring in less tax money because um of the reduced
044value on the uh the valuation. So the district would only receive 4950 instead of the 5,000. So in in the total you can see we're up on the top based on$100 $100,000 valuation the district would have received $6,800 in in taxes due to the decrease in values it now receives 6 $6,650 instead. Uh why are we constantly seeing additional levies? Um, one of the reasons is the the um the reappraisal happens every six years. Um, with a reappraisal, the county auditor actually hires appraisers to go doortodoor to look at each each house and they assign a value based on what their appraisal is. That's what the the uh county reports for taxing purposes. Um, the midpoint, which is every 3 years, is called a trienal update. And what they do with that is the county
045auditor looks at comparable house sales to everybody's houses and then they assign that value based on what the market value is at that point and then that's what they apply the uh the um the millillage to to figure out what your uh what your tax cost is. Um most levies are supported um supporting government operations. they do not allow for revenue growth. Um that's that's what the reduction factors uh between the the um devoted millillage and the affected mill is and that's due to House Bill 920. That was passed in 1976. And the reason that was passed is because prior to that time when house values went up the millillage wasn't changed. So um government entities were receiving additional inflationary monies for that. So House Bill 920 was passed to um kind of curtail that.
046So people were um government entities were not receiving basically windfalls because of inflationary um costs. Um there's an exception to the fixed rate levy rule and what that is is the 20 mil floor. So because of because of House Bill 920 and the reduction factors that are used for the effective millage as the millillage drops down, the state put into place um a couple years after 1976 where they have a 20 what's called a 20 mil floor. So part of that is the current expense levies um let's see current expense and um inside millillage. So those are those are all added all the effective millages are added together and if they're above the 20 mil floor then that's okay. But when valuations cause the effective millage to come down, once it drops below the 20,
047it's called a 20 mil floor, then the county by law has to increase it to 20 mills. And the reason why is because like you said the um the state put into law that the counties that districts cannot fall below 20 mills because they they assume 20 mills is the minimum requirement in order to operate. Again, this the 20 mil floor excludes the emergencies um incremental substitute bonds and permanent improvements. So, those are outside of the 20 mil floor. Um during reappraisal, the increased values um can cause the effective rate to decrease below the floor. Um let's see, the floor adjustment um it's annual. It's not um it's not cumulative. And the reason for that is because every year the values if the values go up, you'll get farther away from the 20 mil floor.
048If the values go down, then you'll get closer to the 20 mil floor. So that's why it's not cumulative. It's always every year it's calculated by the county. Uh this is just some um school district um 20 mil floor statistics. Um, every increase in valuation causes more districts to fall below the 20 mil floor. Um, right now 73% of the 611 districts in the state of Ohio are below the 20 mil floor. 15% of the school districts are within 5% of the floor. So um one of the things that we've talked about at one of the uh one of the uh professional development meetings that I've gone to was that they they are kind of assuming that within probably the next 10 years almost 85% of districts will be at the 20 mil floor because
049of the way the valuations are going. Um, the district has a a renewal levy. Um, well, there's a levy that needs to be renewed, I should say. Um, it's a six mill current expense levy. Um, it was renewed back in 2019 for 5 years, so it will be running out um in 2025. Um, it raises $1.9 million for the district. And the levy has the ability to um to go on in May and November. And the um the board would have to do a resolution in order to move forward to put that on the ballot at one of those uh one of those two dates. And that is my report. Yeah, I know those kids are sad. Yeah, I'm surprised everybody stole it. Can you imagine a room of 20 you [Music] guys know that
050there's I've been on the board 15 or so probably interviewed 20 treasures and there's one question we always ask and one board member always asks them like explain to me in common sense the word millillage what's the definition to all the treasurers and none of them get it You know, it's it's I thought I did. You probably know when I'm 20, you know, but uh that word village is a trick, you know. So, it's just funny. They aren't parents. Um we will move on to um comments from board members and board committee reports. And I'm going to start off um tonight um first um my committee reports. The Domestic Relations Commission met on December 4th to sign Christmas cards for the senior care facilities in Brooklyn. Councilman Barowski handd delivered them uh that week. Uh
051city council had their last meeting of 2024 on December 9th and will reconvene on January 6th for their organizational meeting. Uh Brooklyn Cares donated or collected donations for over 85 families this year and the food pantry has been abundant and assisting families in need. Um I wanted to take a quick moment to speak on the open enrollment policy that that is on second reading tonight and up for approval. um the residents voted us into these positions um to make the hard decisions in the best interest of the district and you know we don't make these decisions lightly. Uh this current board has been in discussions regarding open enrollment for about 8 months now and to be transparent I was on the fence because I did not fully understand what open enroll enrollment entailed how it
052could help a school district and why it would be beneficial for our district. Um, it's not about recruiting athletes or even scholars. It's about educating children and providing opportunities while also financially benefiting our district. Long story short, vouchers are hurting our schools and taking your tax dollars to other districts. So, why not open our district to those looking for a quality education and in turn getting our tax dollars back and increasing our state funding? The alternatives, cutting programs or staff are not desirable. And just to be clear, we are not opening our doors on the first day of school and just letting students in all willy-nilly. There is a application process, a cap on each grade level and expectations to be followed by incoming each incoming student. Uh after some very thoughtful discussions, this board
053agreed that open enrollment would be in the best interest of this district. These discussions were open to the public with the data well presented by Dr. ClariS. We also provided two opportunities in October at open house to hear about our future forward plans for the district which was reported and currently on uh available for viewing online. I am very excited for this next step and as a board member I am dedicated to providing and maintaining a quality education to our young minds. Um, other than that, I want to wish our families a merry Christmas and a happy new year. And please take some time to remember those that can't be home with this with their families this holiday season. And we will move on to Miss Rack. Good evening everyone. Um, thank you for being
054in attendance today. I love it when the community members come to our our board meetings. Um, it's it's good for everybody to hear what's going on. Um I first want to say um I don't have any recent committee reports. Um we most of ours meet quarterly and I gave my report for November. Um other than being on our core group um for our um our bond um issue and renovations, there's a lot of exciting new things that are happening in our district and I'm honored to be a part of it. Um I'm very excited that um we're going to be soon be starting with our um doing our renovations with our preschool and our family resource center. Um as I know of other communities that that have um similar um programming and buildings um that
055house our our preschool students. Um, I think it's a just a great opportunity for them to be in one spot and I think it's a great opportunity to have a family resource um center available to our residents. Um, I did attend a meeting last week where we talked about our renovations uh for our um gymnasium as well as our athletic field, our complex. um a lot of good things um you know happening a lot of renovation one which I feel that our our students our staff and our community will be very proud of once we once it's completed um let's see here I want to thank um a Brooklyn Leadership Academy uh Mr. Larson, thank you for um bringing the students uh here. Um I've gotten to know uh all four of them um through
056uh different presentations that they they have made or watching them on the field or um you know at a at a um musical performance. Um but Bella and Belma touched my heart because I coached both of them and they have always been leaders um on and off the field. So, it was great to see them in a different role today, but in a very similar role that they've had with me. Uh, let's see. Um, I just want to thank the the I guess the residents of this community. Um, it's been one year uh since I've been elected to uh sit on the board. I have learned a lot. Uh, one way for community members to get involved is to run for board um positions. Um, and you know, I feel that I've learned a lot
057more about the responsibilities of board members. I've learned about finances of our school. And although there's a lot, okay, like when you present, like I'm finally getting it and I feel like I can answer questions. Um, that only took a year. Well, again, that's a lot. That's a lot. Um, but just the differences between board issues, levies, and grants. Um, and you know, again, I kind of want to reiterate what Kelly said. Um, you know, I feel that the community has has trusted us to take on these positions. And um there are um there are things that come up where we have to have uh discussions and and long discussions about uh where we see our school district, where we want to see our school district. And I think that the board that we have
058now um they take every consideration into um into effect before we make a decision. I do want to wish everybody a safe and happy holiday season. Um and uh we're looking forward to you know coming back in the 2025 and seeing a lot of good things happen for our community. Thank you. Thank you u Mr. Hazard. Thank you Mr. President. Appreciate it. Um first I want to thank uh Mr. Cypriyani, Mr. Sullivan and Mr. Keller. The concerts on Saturday were amazing. Um I had to I would say unfortunately but fortunately attended three different ones. Uh 2:30 uh 12:30, 2:30 and 4:30. Um it was just it was great to see all the kids the band the seventh and eighth grade band we were blown away like like my mom was cheer everybody was chair it
059was such a cool uh uh song playlist that they did. So I was very pumped about that. I want to thank everybody uh that attended the Christmas tree lighting ceremony. Uh I think we had over 120 130 people there um to to get the the tree lighting. It's still on. Uh so if you want to visit uh the pro we had a couple issues. They've been fixed. Uh, so if you guys want to head up there and take a look at it, they'll be on till January 2nd. Um, and take a look at the Christmas tree lighting at Memorial Park. Uh, I want to thank uh, Belma, Bella, Danny, and Floring uh, that came up to talk. U, they did greet my kids on the first day of school. They they still talk about it.
060I think it was great to see the older kids walk them through. So, thank you, Mr. Lson, and everybody involved with that academy. It's great. um the presentation Allison brought up with the with the library transition. Thank you to the city for voting that to transfer that s uh property back to the schools. Um just to see the the the plans that we have in place for the family resource center and and the preschool. Uh I've talked to a couple of preschool teachers. They're excited. It's just going to be a really really cool uh building for them to be a part of uh in a new home for us eventually. Um and then I I do want to bring up the uh the open enrollment. So mo most of you know I have four children
061in the district and and you know obviously there's parental choice like Dr. Clers had brought up. You know we can take our our kids to other schools you know parochial schools private schools but I believe in this school district. I've graduated from the school district. I know what the staff, the teachers, the admin, their their heart is in it. As much as they they want to see our kids succeed and to bring other kids to a product that's so good, that's so passionate about learning. I'm excited to bring other kids involved in that. Whether they're from Parma, Cleveland, Lindale, the acres, wherever they're they're they're surrounding us. It's just an opportunity for them to get a good product. Every day my children come home and they tell me something they learned or something that was
062exciting for them every single day. And I'm not saying there's other schools that don't do that, but there's something special about Brooklyn. And I'm so open to have people know how special this school district is. Jason has three kids in this school district. We have a vested interest in having a school that that promotes the education for the future. And I'm gonna be the first one to vote no on something I don't believe in. I'm not going to do it just to just to, you know, be with the tide. I'm 100% for open enrollment. I'm I'm 100% behind the staff and the admin and I I want the community to know that we did not take this lightly. We've been talking about this since April. Mrs. Crawl brought Miss Crawl brought this up that we've
063had open discussions. Dr. Claire's had a two community meetings that was open to the public. It's been out there. I'm sorry that some people feel like they were blindsided by it, but you weren't. And um we're happy with the decision we're about to make. Thank you. Thank you, M. Crawl. Thank you, uh Mr. Hubble. Thank you, Mr. Crawl. Um first, I just want to thank everybody that helped uh any family in need with the Brooklyn Cares uh holiday gifting program. It's an amazing thing that this school does and it helps so many people. Uh, and it's, you know, it's one of the reasons I'm proud of this district. Another reason I'm proud of this district are those kids that just presented to us. Uh, Belma, Danny, Floren, and Isabella. I mean, this just speaks on
064the things that this school can accomplish and what the kids that we have here can do and the staff that helps guide them in in that direction. Um, I feel like we sit here every month and get blown away by more and more kids. Um, and uh, I mean, it's amazing. Um, we have begun a Brooklyn alumni association. Um, I just want to say that if you have graduated from Brooklyn, if you are an alumni, uh, our president, Ben Maholik, uh, created a Facebook Alumni Association. Please, please join it. Uh, be a part of it. Uh, the plan is to do some really good things. uh scholarships, uh anything we can to help the community. So, please, if you are an alumni, you want to help out, join the Brooklyn Alumni Association on Facebook, find
065out how you can help, uh more. Um just a quick shout out to someone I had coached, uh Brooklyn alumni, Jenna Young. Uh she went to Penn State for high jump. She broke her ankle last year and missed the whole season. Uh well, she is back. Uh they had their first indoor meet. She won the bronze medal. Nice. Uh so she's back. She's ready to get at it. So just a little shout out to another good thing our alumni can uh can accomplish. And just very quickly to piggyback off my fellow board members and Dr. Saris. Um yes, this open enrollment is something we have talked about for for for a long time now. Uh and like uh Mr. has only said, "I have three kids. I will be graduating from this district. I graduated
066from here. My wife graduated from here. My parents graduated from here. Uh, this school means the world to me. And I would not be considering this if I thought it was a bad idea. Um, I think we need to give kids a chance to get the education that Brooklyn can offer. Um my son himself is in a class of 60 kids. It's almost nobody. Um so we have room, we have the staff and uh you know therefore it is something that after long considerations and thoughts I support. And uh I just say anybody that hasn't checked any of Dr. ClariS's uh videos and reports or even the speech he gave just a little bit ago. Um there's a lot of good things behind this and a lot of good reasons why. Um and I hope
067you guys can see it. I can close my report. Thank you, Mr. Neil. Thank you. First, before I forget, merry Christmas and happy new year to everyone as well. That too. Brooklyn Leadership Academy. Wonderful. They did a great job. I'm sure the whole group done a wonderful job. all of them. Um, first things first, I am on the Polaris committee. We did have a new superintendent that we voted on December 10th, Diane Sander. She has experience from Lraine County, uh, Lraine City Schools. She's been in Polaris for 11 or 12 years now. Um, she's moved up the ladder. Wonderful person, new energy, and I see just meeting all the superintendents, I believe. Yeah. And I think it's going to be up and coming. She's uh she's a high energy person. I think a lot of
068great things will be coming out of Polaris as well too. Uh as far as their construction, the new building, they had to do some little adjustment to the footing to meet with the other um building that they have. I don't know if you guys are aware, they were building a they're building a 22,000 foot edition for um electronics, robotics, and automation. So that's pretty exciting for the future of uh Polaris kids, Brooklyn kids, and the LPN program is up and running. And then uh sophomore to junior's class for Brooklyn. As far as percent of kids that have applied, we have the highest percentage of kids at Brooklyn that that applied at uh at Polaris. 71% of them. 57 kids have applied. So, it's a wonderful opportunity. If you ever have a chance to tour that
069place, it's you wouldn't want to go anywhere else. Every opportunity is there. Um, as far as the open enrollment goes, I've been on the board, like I said, 15, 16, 17 years. We had this conversation a while back. I am open it been open to it for 10 years now. I am not opposed to it. Kids are kids. you know, you're going to have good kids and bad kids no matter where they come from. I don't think that's the problem. It's how you deal with them. What I do want to know, and I'll just say this, is 70% of the school, public schools in the state of Ohio open enroll. You can go look on the website, just Google that. It's a fact. 30 There's 26 districts in Kaga County. There's only one or two
070that do do it. Cleveland and someone else, and I could be wrong. I can't remember who it is. Not I know Kenston did it but I'm not sure where they're at. It's really it's more prevalent in late Marine but 70% of the schools open enroll just so you know that's the way the that's the way of the world. So, I think we're going to be okay. Again, we lose. My biggest concern is always leave. When we open the doors August 1st, the 195 people that leave, that's a million dollars. Probably, Rob, would you say in that ballpark? Probably close to It's probably close to a million dollars. That's what leaves the door once we open the door with those 195,000 or 195 people. That's the way I look at it. So, it's a math problem.
071We just got to figure out how we want to solve it. Um, that's the end of my report. Thank you. Um, we will move on to approval of minutes and financial statements and our reader tonight is Mr. N. Resolved that the minutes of the board of education meeting be adopted and all action taken by the board. Board of Education said meeting is hereby reaffirmed and approved. May I have a motion, please? May I have a second? Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Res, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Miss Rafter, yes. Miss Crawl, yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approves financial statements of receipts and expenditures for the month of November 2024, including all purchase orders paid and then now statements for the
072month for the month as submitted as noted. May I have a motion to move? May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Yes, Mr. Treserini. Yes, Mr. Hubble. Yes, Miss Rack. Yes, Miss Craw. Yes. Resolved that the Public City School District Board of Education hereby approves the second reading and adoption for the following board policies. PO265, protection of individual beliefs. PO 5111 eligibility resident non-resident students. PO 5113 interdistant open enrollment. PO 52000 attendance. PO 5780 student parents students/parents rights PO 6320 purchasing and building and bidding PO 6460 vendor relations PO7540.03 student technology acceptance use and in safety PO7540.04 04 staff technology acceptable use and safety PO 830 8310 public records and PO 9160 public attendance at school events. May I have a motion? May I have
073a second? Second. Questions, comments? M just want to Mr. Hazarian again I apologize Mr. if I came off roughly before, but I wanted to to I know I've heard from from a community member, a couple community members today, and I just wanted to give the board board an opportunity. And I know you've heard from community members or you've heard from staff, do you have any specific and and since we're we're live streaming this, does the board have any specific questions regarding the policy tenative procedures knowing that we're still we're still looking to finalize what those look like. um we have them 90% um you know confirmed but that's going to be a conversation between myself leadership team regarding anything with regard to open enrollment like questions policies procedures application timeline like please like I think
074it's an important piece to if you want to ask to provide that opportunity yeah so if you can just uh go over the criteria yeah so so and and again ple please please um know that these are the these are potential change. We're still working through finalizing them. Um we we are looking at so so open enrollment um is can be considered two ways. Um adjacent open enrollment which means open enrollment to districts that neighbor our school district which would be Cleveland and Parma or fully open enrollment for any district in in the area. Um, from a procedure standpoint, this is kind of what we're looking at. We're looking at a limited uh time frame from an application standpoint. Uh, that would occur from March 1st through April 15th once we once we get all
075of the applications, then I have the ability as superintendent to extend that deadline for for another month up until May 15th. But a after May 15th, we would not consider any open enroll students. So, it's a very So, it's a limited springtime. The reason that we want to do that is because number one, we want to make sure that any students that apply and are accepted have a have a chance to transition. Well, like I I think we we lose sight of of this that we're dealing with kids and and I and I love what all of you said like I want them to experience what what we have in this district. However, transitioning to a new school is not easy for anybody, including kids. And so, that's why we're looking at a limited window.
076Um, for for if the board considers, let's just say the the the applica the policy for the following school year, any newly admitted students for next year still have to reapply. When students apply next year or or this spring potentially, we we consider we consider different crit criteria or priorities. And I'm going to read these off what I have and so please first priority parent guardian grandparent has full-time employment in the Brooklyn City Schools. We current we don't we currently do f full-time um employee. We do not extend that to grandparents, but that becomes that first priority. Second priority any current open enroll students. That would obviously be for the following year. Third pri priority siblings of current open enroll students. Fourth students former district of residents was Brooklyn City Schools. Fifth parent guardians are
077alumni of the Brooklyn City Schools. And then the sixth priority first come first serve. So what we would do is we would we would gather those those applications, sort them by that priority, and then begin to begin to work through those applications. Part of the application process is all is all um hard copies, meaning we're not going to accept applications for open enrollment via our final forms. The purpose of that is to to make sure that we have all of the data on the student that we need prior to prior to the application. So, if you've left out a um you know, a 504, if you've left out an IEP, if you left out a utility bill, whatever it may be, far as far as our requirements, that application does not become final until we
078we check off all of that paperwork and we we consider it processed and then it goes into the fold of that application process. Um, students can be rejected or denied application for for three reasons. Um, for four reasons, excuse me. Um, any type of significant suspension or expulsion, a a student that's on an IEP that we do not have the ability to serve. And I'm going to rely on Mrs. Jones during this process because she works with residency. She does residency out of her office. she will be an integral part of of that application process. But if we don't have programming that the student has on their IEP, then we can't admit them. And then the the the last piece um is is grade capacity. And and I and I think this is really important.
079It goes back to the the class size piece. And I I'll use I'll use preschool and fourth grade as as the example because they are already closed should the board approve this policy in a few minutes. Those grade levels are already closed for 25 to 26 school year. Meaning we will not accept applications for preschool or fourth grade. Preschool number one we're already at enrollment capacity where where we're looking at how do we serve the current students we have there. Also, there are specific ratios from the state of Ohio that Mrs. Jones is mandated to follow and we really can't mess with those. That's very specific. Fourth grade. The reason we wouldn't accept um open enrolled applications in fourth grade is because um right now we have three teachers in that grade level. They're already
080at 21 22 students per per class. Well, internally we have a we we have kind of a designated limit that we want to set on classes and fourth grade is already there or approaching because remember if a student moves into the district they they have they have every right and and we will accept them as an enrolled student. So what I don't want to happen is accept open enrollment for for fourth grade specifically and then we have four, five, six students enroll in the summer and those class those class sizes get too high. So from that capacity we we really want to make sure that we're we're continue to look at our class size. We continue to work with look at um the instruction of our staff because I you know that is my promise
081to to our administrative team, our staff, um our parents and our community. We need to maintain the class sizes that that make Brooklyn special. If you are a a open enroll you are approved for open enrollment, um you you are you you will have to transport your student to to Brooklyn. And so transportation for any newly accepted open enroll student is is at that parents um the parents have to do it. The one piece for for renewals that I think is important renewing applications. So let's say we go through the 2526 school year and um students admitted and and they have to reapply. Well, they reapply. One of the conditions that we can consider for for acceptance as a open enroll student that following year is attendance, right? We don't we we don't want to
082we don't want to create issues where where it's impacting number one impacting the students attendance, right? Because that's the important they got to be here in school, but also want to make sure it doesn't impact our attendance. So, um, see if I've covered everything here, other questions. So, after Miss Crawl, so go back to the very first thing that you said. Um, we currently have there are, uh, our policy as it is right now. We currently have um staff members who uh we have students correct enrolled. Yes, we do. So that then when you say you extend it so it's it's parents, guardians and now grandparents. That's currently the way we have the administrative guideline written. Again, this is tenative. This is tenant. I guess we want to give we want to give employees that
083opportunity if they're if they're grandparents and they want their their student their their grandchildren to come here. We want to extend that opportunity. I I I will say um the students, our staff member students are are they do not live in Brooklyn. And and just like our Brooklyn kids, they're amazing kids. And and I loved what what what each of you said is it's about educating students and adding to the value of our school district. and um any one of them are Brooklyn students who live in the city look at them as Brook right look at them no different because of where they live and I think that's kind of an important piece for me you you uh there was a lot of times that you had publicly with the community had engagement with board
084meetings and community openings when did you when did you and how did you notify the staff um I notified so the after the first board meeting on December 3rd Um, I notified the staff on Friday, December 6th. Um, what I what I what I said to them, um, kind of summary is pretty much what we've said here, why we're doing it, what we believe the impact will be. However, I opened open it up to our staff in terms of that they had any conversation or want to have any conversations with me about um about any concerns. And I've also given an opportunity this week to meet with me kind of in a in a big group session. Uh to be honest with you, Miss Hazwin, you know, we there have been some concerns because I
085think you're going to get any you're going to get those small concerns with with any type of change. Um but overall, I have not heard um a tremendous amount of um negative energy behind this potential change. That doesn't mean that people aren't concerned because they're they're concerned with change, but I haven't heard too much from I haven't heard personally. I've heard personally from I think two staff members and those were kind of sidestep conversations and you got to remember we get to vote on this every year. We do and I'll be honest with you I I because I I think it it it is an emotional topic which that's not a criticism. I think because it's a change I would um I would be in the position where I would annually as we go through
086this process um review the data and so if the board approves the process approves that change tonight like I will I will be speaking at a either board work session or or one of these meetings in May kind of updating the board with how it's gone what we've seen some of the n the numbers surrounding this application process. I think I I and I kind of reiterated when I addressed the board before, but policy change and I think everybody should know is it, you know, it's it could be, you know, very good thing um for us and uh and again policies can be changed or, you know, regardless. So, I think that's good to know. I think the board has every right and every expectation from me and my office to to provide data on
087how it's going, right? Because I like we're not doing this, use your word, willy-nilly, doing this. Um, this is important and and if it's if it's working, I want to tell you if it's working. If it's not working, I'm going to make the recommendation that we go back. And and I think we're not going to we're not going to know unless we go forth. Mr. Ho, I have any questions? I think you covered. Mr. Neil, you have any questions? The advertising of it, how are we going to put Yeah. So, it's going to be it's going to be very simple. What I what I plan to do either tomorrow or Thursday. Yeah. If you if the board changes the policy, what I plan to do either tomorrow or Thursday in uh my my holiday message
088to families, I'm gonna embed I'm going to embed the change in policy in that message. Um after once we work with the administrative team, uh secretarial staff in terms of what this all looks like, how is it going to it's going to be simply posted on our website. Um we're not advertising, we're not it's not social, we're not doing any of those things. We're just going to simply make it available to to our on our district website regarding uh application procedures. I will also post on the website as we go through the process of of which grade levels are already closed for capacity. So from the beginning, preschool and and fourth grade will be closed to capacity due to current current enrollment numbers. We also have staff that have had open enrollment in their schools
089in the past. Correct. Including yourself. Including me. So, I've I've Yeah, Miss Deise. I've worked in I've worked in two school school districts. Um, one in Erie County where it was kind of the that was the way of the world. I mean, everybody was open and rolled. I you know, when I worked in Sandusky, I remember we had a girl open and roll all the way from Norwalk. That was about a 35minut drive for the young lady. Um, and then when I worked in uh Kaga Heights, um, it wasn't necessarily open enrollment, but but it was there was more of a quasi tuition based piece, but but we had over 30% of our students um, in Kyoga Heights at the time were outside the villages. So in the villages, you had Ka Heights, Valley View,
090and Brooklyn Heights all funneled into the school district. about 30 to 35% of our students funneled into the district from outside of those three villages. Um it it's it's always it's always been positive in my experience. Um nothing's perfect. Nothing ever is. Um but it was it was generally and and I think you know Ka Heights has had it for probably close to 30 or 40 years. So, anybody else? And again, I will encourage anybody who's listening, anybody who's here that if you have any questions or concerns, please email me and I'll be more than happy to answer those questions. Thank you, Mr. Sherart. Will you call the role, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Roseri, yes. Mr. Huddle, yes. Mr. Rafter, yes. Miss Crawford, yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education
091hereby commends students listed in the attachment of the academic co-curricular achievement athletic honors and band honors. May I have a motion, please? May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments? I'm going to take the time here and read a letter that we all received, I believe, and I there's a other athletic accomplishments on here, but I think this is just a little special letter I'd like to read inside of uh the band honors. Congratulations senior trombone player player Floren So who was here earlier today as he was recently selected to participate in the 2025 Ohio State University band honors band. This will mark Florence second year as a member of the elite ensemble the longest running honors band program in the state. Four Brooklyn students were also selected as alternates. Alternates including Aaron Sharp, trumpet,
092Isabelle Lah, clarinet and Danny Fan both both were here. Tuba Jaden Schultz baritone saxophone. Over 900 individuals student nominations were submitted by a band by band directors from nine states for this year's event. 270 mi musicians representing over 150 high schools were selected for these 300 hunter bands. This year's event will be held Friday, January 31st through February 2nd with a Sunday concert performance in Wigel Auditorium on the OSU campus. That's a heck of accomplishment to those people there. That's awesome. That's great. Congratulations. There's a lot of academic or athletic on here, so I didn't want to go through all the dot the eye. I don't know. That's a good question. It's a second year. It's a second year. He met second year guy. Awesome. Florida keeps me on my toes. Seriously, he does. I'm
093sure he does. And he should. That's right. Mr. Sheer, would you call roll, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Roni, yes. Mr. Hubble. Yes. Miss Ra. Yes, Miss Craw. Yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education in coordinance with the Ohio Revised Code 30 3327.02 and the procedure set forth in Ohio environment of education. The board after having considered multiple factors authorized deter determined the impracticality of transportation for students eligible for transportation under RC 3327.01 as submitted by the school per school per the attachment list on file at the board office. May I have a motion? May I have a second? Second, questions, comments? Yeah, the just a reminder, this these are uh students that live in the city that that attend school districts um school outside of the district and state law
094requires us to offer transportation transportation payment to those students. So, this is that ongoing list we've talked about. At the end of the year, we will verify enrollment of these students at these school districts and the district submits a payment to those families for transportation. Mr. Sheerhart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Yes. Mr. Ron, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Mr. Ra, yes. Miss Crawford, yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby enters into an agreement with PSI affiliates, Inc., PSI Associates, Inc. for title 2A, we'll go with support services for the 2425 per year attached per the ye per the catch contract agreement on file treasur's office. May I have a motion, please? May I have a second? Questions, comments? What is is this? This is uh this is this
095is St. Thomas Moore using their non-public funds and so we're the fiduciary agent. So, we have to approve approve that as a as a board. But this is all this is all through um them and it's no impact on our children. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Sherart. Will you call the role please? Mr. Yes. Mr. Ros. Yes. Mr. Hubble. Yes. Mr. Rick. Yes. M. Yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education authorize superintendent to manage an agreement with Lake Tax Solutions for providing e rate support services for two networking projects for attachment agreement on final treasures office. May I have a motion? May I have a second? Questions, comments? Mr. Sheart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Ne, yes. Mr. Rosen, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Miss Ra, yes. Miss Crawl, yes. Resolved
096that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approves the attachment agreement of with CMSD for excess cost of children with disabilities pursuant to section 3313.981 OC 3323.14 OC and rule 3301-48-2-f for educ educational purposes for the 24 2024 2025 school year per attachment. We have a motion. May I have a second? Questions, comments? Mr. Sherhart, will you call a roll, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Rose, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Mr. Raptor, yes. Miss Crawford, yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approve the renewal HVAC maintenance agreement with Gardener effect gardener effective January 1, 2025 through December 31st, 2025. Attachment of files agreement and filing central office. May I have a motion, please? So move. May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments? Mr. Sheer, will you call the
097role, please? Mr. Ne, yes. Mr. Rosone, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Mr. Efford, yes. Miss Crawl, yes. Resolve that the Brook City School District Board of Education hereby approves the following res classified resignation as noted. May I have a motion, please? May I have a second? Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, we call a role, please. Mr. Yes. Mr. Rosen, yes. Mr. H. Yes. M. Yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approves unpaid leave for the following classified employees as noted. We have a motion, please. May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments. Mr. Sheerart, we call the role, please. Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Rose, yes. Mr. Hell, yes. M. Ra. Yes. M. Crawl. Yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approves the additional hours effective 162 16205
098for the following classified personnel for the remainder of the 2425 school year as noted in this resolution as noted. They have a motion. They have a second. Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Ram, yes. Mr. Rosen, yes. Mr. Rubble, yes. Miss Rick, yes. Miss Crawl, yes. Resolve that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approves employment of the following classified personnel 2024 2025 school year as noted. As noted. May I have a motion? I have a second. Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, will you hold the role, please? Mr. Ne, yes. Mr. Reser, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Mr. Raptor, yes. Miss Crawf, yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approve the following persons for the 2020 24-2 school year supplemental assignments with provision that the
099individual complies with all board of education and/or high school Ohio high school association rules and regulations and the state department of education regulations pertaining to the proper certification lens or the first aid training and fulfills the requirements of the job description attached to their supplemental contract contingent upon the successful completion of the background check and credentiing boys basketball Jim Bourbon boys basketball volunteer. May I have a motion? May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Rosen, yes. Mr. Hel, yes. Miss Ram, yes. Miss, yes. Resolve that the Brook City School District Board of Education hereby approves the following certified resignation as noted. May I have a motion, please? May I have a second? Questions, comments? This will be um effective end of the
100year. We'll post it in the spring. Mr. Sheerart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Rosen, yes. Mr. H. Yes. Mr. Rford, yes. Miss Crawl, yes. Resolve that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education hereby approve the following persons 2425 supplemental assignment with the provision that individuals comply with all the rules regulated state department of education regulations pertinent to pertinent to proper certification. and fulfills the requirements of the job description attached to the supplemental contracts contingent upon the successful completion of background check and credit whatever credit uh Jim may I have a motion so moved May I have a second second questions comments Mr. Sheerart will you call the role please Mr. Ne yes Mr. Run yes Mr. Hu yes Mr. Director. Yes. Miss crawl. Yes. Resolve that the Brook City
101School District Board of Education hereby approve the following individual 2425 school year supplemental assignments with the provision of such individuals comply with all rules regulations. State Department of Education regulations pertinent to proper certification fulfills the requirements of the supplemental contracts as noted. As noted may have a motion, please. May I have a second? Questions, comments? Mr. Sheerart, will you call the RO please? Mr. Ne, yes. Mr. Reser, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Mr. director. Yes. Miss crawl. Yes. Resolve that the Brooklyn City Brook resolve that the Brooklyn Board of Education approve a resolution declaring it's necessary to renew an existing 6.1 mill tax levy for the purpose of current expenses requesting the K County fiscal officer to make certain certain certifications pursuant to section 57053 and 570521 of the revised codes. As noted, resolution on file
102in treasur's office. May I have a motion? May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments. Mr. Chair, um can we discuss a little bit on the the impact of the mill dropping uh under the 20 mil for? Yes. Can you talk about that a little bit? Yeah. Um as I talked about in the presentation the um the district due to the valuation increase the effective millillage will drop below the 20 mil floor. So what will happen is the county based on state law will pump that back up to the 20 mil minimum. Um it's it it's actually going to drop about about 1 mil. So the um the reason behind this is it it the renewal it won't make that much of a difference um as far as the class one residential um it will
103basically stay the same. The class two without the rule the district will lose about $740,000 and the class two is commercial and um and industrial. So, in putting this back on the ballot, it will allow the district once passed to continue to receive the $740,000 on the class 2, the commercial and industrial. Um, both both the class one and the class two are based on the 20 mil floor. The class 2 will still be at 25 ms, a little bit over 25 ms. So because that's not under the 20 mills, that money we would still be collecting and and um and would still come to the district. That's why the re it's important to do the uh the re and put back on the ballot again. So what you're saying is pass or fail with
104this levy, the residential tax owners are going to be paying that same tax to get to the 20 mil floor. Yes. it back up pass we would get the money from businesses fail we would lose the money from businesses yes so we would we would end up losing if if just say we didn't put the remark on the ballot we would lose the 740 on the class two but either way this levy would ultimately have no effect on homeowners on on the residential piece right because that that is falling below the 20 mills already so that would bump back up anyway ways. So, it's important not to lose it. And and if we if we lose the 740, we have two chances to pass the rate of May and in November. So, if if that
105didn't pass, that would drop off in January of 26. We would lose that money. That 740,000 would be gone forever. Um, with that loss, more than likely within the next couple years, we would have to go for a new money at 100%. It would Yes. It would end up being an island. And this is based on the adjustment of the valuation of the properties in the city of Brooklyn, correct? Yes. Because of that, that's what it is. Yes. um like like I was talking about because these are fixed sum levies as valuation goes up the effective millage comes down which is what what actually drove it down um we were we've lost with this valuation increase we've lost almost 5 mill which is why I wasn't expecting us to drop below um until I got
106the valuations from the county and the uh the new villages and that's how I found out that um we're driving below the 20 and like you said earlier we aren't the only district in the state of Ohio. Yes. Correct. That is correct. I've spoken to two I've spoken to two other treasurers that I know and they're in the same boat. Yeah. Yeah. There's um unfortunately because of the valuations that were so high all the way I mean nationally um the districts in the state are all getting hit with this. It's it's not just Brooklyn, it's everywhere. Um there are pockets in Cleveland that were receiving a I believe it was a 35 to 50% increase. So it's um I believe in Brooklyn it was roughly about 17%. Valuation increase. Good. And there's nothing it's not
107anything that the district did or can do. Um it's all based on state law. There's there's nothing we can do about it. The valuations are based on what the county auditor has come up with based on what their appraisers have actually gone doortodoor and none. Um, you know, it's it's just it's there. There's nothing can do. I mean, if there was something I could do, I would certainly do that. Pass the levy. That would start there. Yeah, let's start there. I know that you had there was an issue in the beginning with the valuations originally not being correct and they had to adjust that. Yeah. Way back um it was in September or October, the county released how much the district was going to receive and what they did they included the nonreducible millages. So
108they included emergency millies and bonds. So, and some of the the audience may have seen the plane the county auditor released it to the plane dealer and the plane dealer said that all the districts were going to receive basically a windfall. Um, they were saying that Brooklyn was going to receive 2.2 million. After we started confronting the county auditor about that, it came out where we actually were only getting 293,000 because once you remove all the additional levies that should not have been included, that's when it came down to the actual amount they were receiving. And did you double check with the county this time to make sure? Absolutely. Absolutely. I I probably have a treasure co just to verify it. Thank you. Any other questions? Mr. Sheerart, will you call the role, please? Mr.
109Neil, yes. Mr. Oh, sorry. Mr. Raer, yes. Mr. Hz, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Miss Brown, yes. Resolved that the Brooklyn Board of Education approves the real estate transfer of the Brooklyn bank Brooklyn branch Kyog County Coyote County Public Library County Public Library located at 4480 Ridge Road, Brooklyn, Ohio 44144 from the city of Brooklyn to the Brooklyn Board of Education resolution on filing the treasurer's office as noted. May I have a motion? So move. May I have a second? Questions, comments? Just want to say thank you to the council, city council, mayor, uh the city in general just for making this a very easy process for us. So, we're we're very excited for for the next steps, but uh kudos to them uh for making that process. And and again, I want to say too,
110like nothing really to do with the the resolution here, but the the city council um also also made it very favorable for for the district during the renovation process. they they they waved our their the building fees and permit fees which saved a tremendous amount of money towards towards this project. So, um I know other school districts are not as lucky as we are and so um we weren't lucky. Well, we're lucky now. We're lucky now, but thank you to to our council for for doing that. It again it How did Mr. Mosley vote? I think it was 7. I'm not going to like as far as I'm concerned, it was 7. And so, um, like I said that we we are their partners in in education in the community. We appreciate them. So, say
111that. Thank you to the city. Mr. Sherart, will you call the role, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Hz, yes. Mr. H. Yes. M. Rat. Yes. Miss, yes. Discussion. So, we're going to have a discussion. So, this is just discussion. Yeah. I just I just wanted to make sure we we we don't have to you don't have to discuss and you can go right to nominations, but I wanted to give the board the opportunity to discuss this if they chose to do so. This is a three this is so this is a three-year appointment and we are up for our every every so often the six associate districts get a second seat. Brooklyn is up for their second seat I believe in 2028. Correct. I think that so so this will be a three-year appointment. Does
112anybody have any discussion or I will take nominations for the office? Yeah, I'll nominate Rocky here. Second that. Any other nominations? Nominations are closed. Resolve that the Brooklyn City School District Board of Education in accordance with RC 3311.19 hereby appoints Mr. Rocky Neil serve on the Polaris Career Center Board of Education for a three-year term beginning January 1, 2025 and ending December 31st, 2028. May I have a motion, please? So moved. May I have a second? Second. Questions, comments? Congratulations. Mr. Sherart, will you call a RO, please? Mr. Yes. Mr. Rafter, yes. Mr. Ne, abstain. Mr. problem. Yes. This problem. Only if we get treats. Yes. In the box. Do I get enough votes to make a comment? I do. All right. You should have seen the dinner we had last week. We weren't invited
113to retract the new board members. No, thank you guys. I appreciate it. And then u like I said, we'll do meetings there as often as we can with the new superintendent. She's going to start coming to meetings as well. she wants to be, you know, out in the spotlight as well, too. So, I think at one point too, I tal I talked to Mrs. Andrew, we had a great meeting and at one point she had mentioned um and I think we talked about this, Rocky had her at some point her coming out, presenting to the board. And so I I as she gets settled, I'll reach out to her to see if see if she's interested in doing that and then I can I can gauge the board as terms of what you guys are
114looking for in terms of a Polaris presentation. Thank you. Thank you again. Thank you. Um motion to appoint a president pro prom to preside over the 2025 Brooklyn board of education organizational meeting. I have a nomination. This is just a formality and just kuran. I'll second. Okay. Um may I have a motion, please? So moved. M second. Second. Questions, comments. Mr. Sheerart, will you call the RO, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Hubble, yes. Mr. Raft, yes. Mr. Reser, abstain. And Miss C? Yes. Thank you. Resolve that Brook City School District Board of Education in accordance to OC 3313.26 gratefully accepts the following donation. donation of 100 bags of hygiene products for the Brooklyn City Schools food pantry and an estimate cost of $500 from Jim Wadawick and family. May I have a motion, please? So
115move. Have a second. Second. Questions, comments. Thank you, Jim. Thank you, Jim. Thank you, Mr. Sherart. Will you call the role, please? Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Ros, yes. Mr. H. Yes. Miss R. Yes. Miss Crawford? Yes. Is there any other business? Sorry, I didn't say it earlier. Merry Christmas. have a blessed wonderful holiday season and prosperous 2025. So, and then our next um board meeting is our organizational meeting Tuesday, January 7, 2024 in the treasures office conference room. I'm Oh my goodness. Party fall. Oh, it's I was just reading it. Uh treasures office conference room 9200 B off road, Brooklyn, Ohio at 6:00 p.m. May I have a motion to adjourn? May I have a second? Second. Uh, Mr. Sheer, we call the role, please. Uh, Mr. Neil, yes. Mr. Rosar, yes. Mr. Yes. M.
116And yes. M. Yes. Thank you. Merry Christmas, everyone.