CorpusRecord 144743

February 5, 2025 Special Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Gresham-Barlow School District
Date
2025-02-06
Location
Multnomah County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,893 words · about 39 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right ready yes all right good evening welcome to the Wednesday February 5th 2025 special board work session of the gesan B Board of Education um roll call in attendance Chris howt Holly regelman Blake Peterson David litic Sean farens and online joining us is Myra Gomez um there is one change to the agenda we do not have uh item C the Personnel executive session that will be removed from the agenda with the adoption of the uh of the agenda so if there's a motion to approve the agenda as amended with removal of item C I will in motion move to the approve the agenda with removal of item C there a second all second okay it's been moved by David seconded by Shan to approve the agenda as presented with removal of item C the

002executive session under Personnel um any discussion about the agenda heing none those in favor I I any opposed all right thank you our first item of business is we're going to get our audit results and it looks like we have our people online uh weather was a little bit bad today so glad you could join us online this evening and um we'll just go ahead uh introduce yourselves and then I don't know if we want to introduce who else is in the room um Dennis do you want to let everybody know who else is here in support of you um for the business office we have thank you and and we have Margaret Bri they have challenging names and so those are the business uh office staff along with myself that are here in support

003of the audit okay all right so with that I will turn it over to I believe our Auditors is there anything we starting with Dennis or are we starting with their presentation we will start with their presentation okay all right you anything I'd just like to introduce our Auditors okay ladies and gentlemen of the board my name is Margaret briout I'm the director of accounting I would like to introduce you to our Auditors from KDP this is Arya bettinger she's an audit partner and Maria Macy who is an audit manager they are the people we worked with during the audit and they'll be presenting to you the okay thank you thanks Margaret yes so hi everybody my name is Arya bettinger um I'm here in Medford so I do appreciate us being able to present

004this remotely um we have about a foot of snow here which is very unusual for us and uh everything is really shut down um I'm here with Maria Macy like Margaret said she is the manager on the audit so she is going to start by presenting the audit and then after that I will um share the required Communications with governance and then we're happy to answer any question questions you might have hi um I'm Maria as Arya said I'm the manager on the audit and I have been a manager with KDP for about well I haven't been a manager for nine years but I've been with KDP for nine years um and to start I figured I would share my screen and we can go through a couple of our audit letters and just some

005general key points throughout the audit we would like to communicate with you you um I think I had to send a request to share and if that works I did s like to allow you to share so you should be able to know perfect oh my gosh do you see my um PDF of the AUD yes we do all right perfect um so to start us off I actually find that it's a little bit easier to go to the back of the audit and we're going to start with the schedule of the findings and question costs um this very generally goes through basically all of our different letters that uh we have in the the audit and um our different opinions so I'll start here um in the first one I would like to know

006at the top of this page it says the type of report we issued was with gap was unmodified um unmodified opinion means a clean opinion and that is the highest level of assurance that we can provide within our audit um if the details of this are found on page A1 of our independent auditor report and I'll just go over a few key points in here with you all um in our opinion these financial statements referred to are in all material respects um unmodified is what that says like I said that's a clean opinion and it is the highest level of assurance we can offer um as far I also want to touch on the responsibilities of management and for us as the Auditors um Management's responsible for the preparation and fair presentation of the financial

007statements in according with um generally accepted accounting principles and for the design implementation and maintenance of internal control relevant to that um our job as the Auditors is our objective is to obtain reasonable Assurance about whether the the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement and that's whether due to fraud or error and to issue a report that includes our opinions um reasonable Assurance is a high level of assurance but it's not absolute that being said as I mentioned before uh the district got a unmodified opinion in a clean opinion um we do have an emphasis of matter here um we discussed that in note 16 uh we restate beginning net position for governmental activities um due to the correction of some errors the details of this in note 16 are on

008page 46 um and ARA later will go into the details of all of these with you and you'll be able to ask questions um but for now I'll kind of go through a brief overview if we go back to the schedule of finding in question costs um we do have another letter and this is our government auditing standards letter within this letter um there was a couple findings and I will go through a few of what that means and what we're talking about there so in planning and Performing our audit um we considered the district's internal control over financial reporting as a basis for Designing our procedures um this kind of goes into risk assessment right what we're looking at what where risk might be um but it's not for the purpose of an expressing

009an opinion on the effectiveness um accordingly we do not express an opinion on the effectiveness of the district's internal control you'll see I have a few more paragraphs highlighted here and I wanted to talk a little bit more about what those are um to start a material weakness is a deficiency or a combination of deficiencies in internal control that it's reasonably possible that a material misstatement could not be prevented um we have some more details on in the back of the audit um regarding that uh and a significant deficiency is a deficiency or combination of them an internal control that is less severe yet important enough uh to Merit attention from the board um we've also gone through those in more detail in the back of the audit and Arya will describe those for you

010as well once we go through our communication letter um back to this regarding Federal Awards so um the school district much like many school districts received over 750,000 in federal awards for the year uh this requires the District to undergo what called a single audit where we look at the different Federal programs um and look at the controls related to that regarding for the single audit this year um what was selected for testing was the Esser or education stabilization fund al8 again our opinion was unmodified so that was clean and the highest level of assurance that we can provide and in our opinion the district complied in all material respects to the types of compliance requirements that we looked at related to these programs um again to touch on Management's responsibility and our own Management's

011responsible for the compliance with the requirements referred to above in the design implement ation and maintenance of effective internal control um our objective is to once again that word reasonable is to obtain reasonable Assurance about whether material non-compliance were occurred and whether due to fraud or ever error and express an opinion on the district's compliance based on our audit um one more related to to compliance um in the state of Oregon we're also required to look at um different Provisions in the Oregon revised statutes as specified in the organ administrative rules um which we do look at and we look for any non-compliance with which that could have a direct or material effect on the ter determination of the financial statement amounts however providing an opinion on compliance with those Provisions was not the objective

012of our audit and we do not express an opinion um in connection with our testing related to organ state regulations nothing came to our attention that caused us to believe the district was not in substantial compliance with certain Provisions laws regulations contracts and grants except as noted in note one and that is also noted on page 16 of the audit um there is a sentence in there and the budget paragraph that can also explain that a little more and that's kind of a very general brief overview of our different opinion letters that we go through um and the different items that we looked at throughout the audit thanks Maria um I was going to go ahead and uh share some of our Communications with governance unless anybody wanted to jump in with any questions right

013now but it might be some of them might be answered with the next Communications but I wanted to give people a minute if they had any questions so there were some questions um chair C thank you for letting me address you properly there were some questions that came in from other board members I'm happy to raise those now I don't believe I saw them so if you have them go ahead and then I have a question I know I looked through all this where where was this document sent to us because I'm not finding where it was was it not because I printed some pages out I've got quite a few and I just don't remember what I saw and where I saw it this one's on the agenda but the letter is on the

014work session yeah it's at the very end of very the it's on that one okay because I kept trying to find it but the letter is on the work session and I got that so okay that's what I was trying to find because I sorry I cannot see your screen at all I might have to pop over here and watch Sarah's have to log out so that I could see the letter right now because when I'm logged in it doesn't give me the option to view the agenda so I logged out and went to the public site and then you can see it if okay all right thank you thank you okay go ahead go ahead Mark thank you I'll address the questions in the order that they came to me the first was regarding

015the bond related deficiency findings did our reporting practices change or does this reflect a difference of opinion between Polly Rogers that's our former Auditors and KDP represented here by Maria and Arya and my response is both ANS our recording practices changed in 2324 as part of the audit process in response to the audit Auditors use a tool called materiality it is their discretion to determine materiality based on their risk assessment of their clients Holly Rogers did not consider the difference between how we were doing things and how we now have St changed to do things to be material therefore they did not suggest it as a adjustment and that is why you hadn't heard of this before today KDP provides a high quality service and their risk assessment as a result is different than poly

016Rogers so you know 10,000 foot 5,000 foot there's an analogy when you lower your materiality threshold when you decide that suddenly things that cost less are more important than the previous auditor may have thought they were you're going to scoop up you know it's like a sver rate going to scoop up more stuff so to answer this question yes our reporting practic has changed as a result of the audit the difference poly Rogers didn't necessarily had a different opinion they had a different risk assessment and a different materiality threshold this change that was made during this audit aligns us with generally accepted accounting principles or what you'll hear referred to is Gap if you hear that that's what that means and all tables have been adjusted to ensure that for the remainder of the debt

017service related to the bond we will be in compliance with again this matter therefore has been addressed second question do the findings of the audit change our net position in a material way if so For Better or Worse compared to our assumptions entering bargaining excellent question I'm so glad you asked in government we do things two different ways so what I happen to know based on reading your bios is that some of you are small business owners and I'm I'm willing to bet that you have books that you keep in your business and then come tax time you do an acrel to cash conversion with your tax accountant to help you decide which deductions to take and so if you look at your tax return and you look at your books they don't match there's

018an adjust that happens and it's as a result of what's called accounting bases in government we have further still a third set of accounting bases called modified acal why does this matter net position is a full acral number it's like could be compared to the numbers you see in your books that your bookkeeper produces for you and your business ending fund balance is a modified appr number which is modified a tool is the language we speak it's how the board reports that are presented to monthly are prepared it's how we usually do business and then once a year we go full of pool for the purposes of this so did the net position changed yes it did as Maria highlighted in note 16 there's talks about how where exactly it change and net position is

019not the number we use when we are trying to decide what we can afford in negotiations for that we use ending fund balance I can um I've replied to superintendent cook with exact page numbers on where you can find net position as opposed to ending fund balance and then you can true that up with this is the one we use for negotiations this the one we used when we're talking to the bank yes they're different yes that's weird it has to do with accounting bases did that I could I ask did would there have been any so this would only have affected the full approval not to modified Ru and so our anying fund balance would not have changed some of our adjustments ments affected modified approval most affected full approval going into the audit

020we had a projected ending fund balance modified appr number of 16 about 16.3 million coming out of the audit we had 19.3 gr some positive yes yes okay and I want to add some of that's related to accounting adjustments and some of that's just related to closing entries but we went into negotiations using the budget ending fund balance of about 16.3 million where we actually landed and I can say this through confidence now that the audit is finish is 19.3 that's a point in time right that's that's as of that's like chucking the oil on June 30 okay yep and it's audited and that's so we can say with certainty you know Mar correct me if I'm wrong it does help us with the beginning of now for budet absolutely ending becomes beginning it's our

021stake in the ground when we're setting up the tent in the new year um this was an excellent question if you're interested if you're like what did she just say and you want to do some at home reading in the notes to the financials on page 12 of the actor which will be published on our website and has been shared with you you can see a discussion of the difference between modified and full of rural accounting it's a bit technically heavy but I think it can serve as helpful odd request actually a great request in my opinion um was to present three different examples of budget of letters that have KDP has issued for other districts I have shared these with Sarah and superint Sarah Avery and superintendent cook the three examples that I chose

022were Ashlin School District this is a school district that switched to KDP from poly Rogers in fiscal year 2223 these are their reports as of 2324 as director regelman Cor identified Communications with the governing body are not public record however the audited the act for is public record so while I wasn't able to get you their communication for the governing body every other communication will be included in that packet the second district I chose is clth Falls County School District this is the the the client that I think more most closely is comparable to Gran Barlo in the KDP portfolio that they presented US during the process this is a district that has worked with KDP for years and is now over the course of years working through the process of cleaning up some very

023similar issues you will find that again no communication with governance but a lot of good A lot of the of the other letters I know there's a lot the third that I offer as an example is Roseberg this was this is an example of client that's worked with KDP for so long that they're like died okay and so here's an example of where we're headed like I said all of these have been given to Avery and um John and I think it's a great question benchmarking or what what I suspect is benchmarking is a great way to kind of go are we an outlier or not in this matter um so that concludes the first set of questions the second set came in as number one at the bottom of page 43 kudos to you

024who read this document sometimes I think no one ever does and so at the bottom of page 43 blah it's listed that the amount spent for the student based Health Center was 3, 31566 the funding we received was about 3 million in Grants can you tell me which fund the additional 315 666 came out of energy funds related to Senate Bill 1149 so funds were because all all these Essen with funds used for that not one penny of general f yes nothing from fund it was energy funds which is I don't want to say unended but it's it's easier to use for different things and there were some surprise things required by the city of digging a trench under the street to connect different light things and other things it wasn't part of the original

025bid that caught us going over the trees going down last the Trees of significant trees of significance every time that was your B's name wasn't it yes yes thank you um Maria and Aran in the city agression we have something about trees of significance and it can put a real wrench in construction but they're beautiful trees number two um and I'm gonna let I'm gonna kick this one to Dennis but I'll read it first also on this page the ray remodel Ray is one of our high school programs came in at $371,500 the board approved spending of $320,000 can you tell me the process the district follows when the cost comes in over the amount approved does it ever come back to the board for additional approval take it away Mr C generally the process

026is unless it becomes a 50% increase significant number with special circumstances It generally would not go back to the board in this case the cost of the HVAC units H vac units that were installed and uh the duct work came back significantly higher than participated and to offset that again the energy money was used to take care of that so it was a another unexpected thing part of it some of the stuff was so backlog in being produced it it took time and it took more money to get it in in the time needed to get and take this with the grain of salt just as another example and like I said please take the gra of salt I believe we used energy for some of the churchfield lighting as well to cover that in

027too so it's a great program that Terry has been a steart to did [Music] you number three of this set of question was on page 46 there is an amount of $992,500 listed as Enterprise zones can you tell me more about this is this an evaded amount that we pay in taxes for our buildings or something else it has nothing to do with the Enterprise Zone CH oh excuse me it has nothing to do with the en Enterprise zone changes that were recently discussed with the city of russan is that correct excellent question government accounting standard board statement 77 about like you read that ler like this um stuff I I'm just a real weirdo so b77 talks about hey if we're going to Abate taxes for whether it's an Enterprise Zone a religious institution

028um ourselves in the case of the county not taxing themselves for County property right we should talk about that in the financials because the taxpayers need to understand that when they make that decision there's a dollar attached to it so that's what we're disclosing here we disclose material abatements these are the abatements that needed to be disclosed for the fiscal year 2324 July 1:23 to 6:30 24 my understanding of what is being discussed with the city of Bram has to do with future impact so I cannot speak to much of anything with regard to what's being discussed with City aggression but if it if abatements were to be put in place related to Enterprise zones for City aggression or anyone else it would eventually show up here depending on when it happened if it happens

029from July 1 24 to 6:30 25 yeah we're going to have a dollar not related to that um if it doesn't then it won't but you you hit really perfectly on something that I think that accounts spend a lot of time and energy trying to help readers with with financial statements understand which is all decisions ultimately have lost and we're just trying to measure how much and so yes while it isn't here now because it hasn't happened yet if it were to happen that is where you would see the financial IND of that that is one place where you would see the financial Indi of that you would see specifically the amount ofed that is related to Russian Barlow's tax l so that's that's what we would have received in a year in local tax

030revenue if those properties were not evad is that a way to see it exist yes if existing existing Enterprise fund so I believe for example that some of the buildings just across the M tracks from Cal that I don't know if it's an Enterprise Zone abatement but it's some kind of abatement I go on walks I look at it I go there's a t abatement ver vertical housing thank you it's a vertical housing abatement okay so we look at that and we go ah look at that vertical housing abatement you guys don't see it that way you see something else but um but now um yeah exactly so but see how it all relates is like yes you aate but then you get the kids and so the kids bringing you know I'm not going

031toine on this what's going to happen now so gby 77 discloses just that abatement part it doesn't disclose if additional students come in what's the change to the state school fund that's a separate thing this is just when the County abates taxes a portion of what the county collects is related agressions Levy whether it's our operating Levy or our bond Levy what didn't we collect yes and we don't we don't have an operating I may have us incorrect term we don't have one but thank you okay because there are people who would like us to have one and we do not okay we have I I'm jennice help me out what is this correct term for the levy that we have for just that every district has to be I'll get back to you on

032that you are correct we do not have what I sometimes call a local optional ly right we have what I'll call a vanilla Levy and then we have a bot Levy okay um but no local option Levy okay thank you that is the end of the questions I've received thus far referring to our tax levy there and maybe that's it yeah tax levy and we have a bond there you go at this point local optionaly we haven't ventured into that world but yes we do every year here our tax dve there's here's water is L by two counties and then same thing with the could I ask a question uh related to that ending fund balance3 million difference is any portion of that Esser funding that will be SP after that moment but we won't

033get that like that's that is just general form okay that's it could have been buil up by moving things toer but grants there's no strictly General it's yeah this is wonderful super helpful and informative it's uh I think hitting the you know the new chapter that we're all knowing we're walking into us the susceptibility of a board misrepresenting the district's position and making a bad decision because that is just right and so trying to make sure that 193 is real and so that number is going to stick in my brain and if it shouldn't be real for some reason forget it it's sticking in other brain yes maybe this is not the right time to ask but and I think it maybe is covered by those letters but how typical is it to come in

034the first year for clients to have similar findings is this something that's out of the ordinary is this kind of standard practice great question Arian Maria um yeah that is a great question and I guess I would say it really is it's there's a range you know there's always going to be a range and so there are times when we we get into a new client and yeah there are there are findings it might you know we tend to um we tend to audit a little bit deeper than maybe some audit firms do um and you know especially when you have a set of fresh eyes that can just that can open things up as well um so it's it's a range I I can't really give you um any kind of solid answer but

035I think that the time when your most going to have findings or issues generally are at the beginning of a relationship because because also when you've establish that relationship then you know if there are questions like we're very open to answering questions throughout the year you know it just becomes more of a more of a relationship so there's more there's just less room for these things to continue things happen it always happens you know um but I would say the first year would be the highest risk for findings well and I think um Margaret might have said something or I read it in in one of the other documents that there were some things that they changed in how they wanted school districts to report certain aspects and so some of that then changed with

036maybe where the money used to be sitting in this bucket now it's over in this bucket or it's reported in a different way so is that also a real layman's term understanding the government Accounting Standards Board accountants are unique and that we're constantly pulling the rug out from under ourselves the government account Standards Board Issues new pronouncements at a rate of you know in the last five years maybe two to three per year that is two to three times per year that we reassess everything and change how we do things or don't if the amount of changes of material um you know other changes you were familiar with was gasby 68 when we added Pur remember what that did to that position turned everyone upside down it's a it's a gasby pronouncement okay um so

037yes your assessment is correct the some of this is not just School District but governments government okay and kind of just a little tag onto that that I might come and ask for your uh knowledge on um the legislature is trying to do some legislation that would mandate training for board members to understand the basics of what we're looking at so that we are looking at it consistently so we ask the right questions so we understand the answers that we get so they're trying to create a a financial literacy for board members and I'd like for them to stay in their Lane and help us so I will look for some help on that said you're not gonna submit opinion I will opinion trying to say in my yeah yeah no I'm just talking about

038the legislature it's staying in their L yeah excuse me director howt yeah it's okay if there's any way I can help with that please hesitate to and I wanted to say when we looked at changing from po Rogers to another said you reached out KP and others to put in a propos we knew some of these things were going to change we knew you know we would take a deeper dive particular early in the first year we knew that was going to happen we anticipated thought that could would be findings that had been at a different threshold with a prior a so this isn't a PO surprise at least to the business department and I hope we change we we try to communicate that to but um we we're not totally caught off well for

039me personally I can't speak for my fellow board members but I would appreciate the desire to go deeper as opposed to Le deeper you know it's it just that's what we were looking we we thought we could find an audit firm that would do a deeper guide that would look at things with a Keener eye and to be honest that we probably have a long where complacency can come into play you know Paul Rogers you our procedures we knew what they wanted you know it did it become just a here you go do it it could have been I don't want to disparage that but we knew this was going to get us in a much more stronger position in our audit dealing with things that other you districts have had to adjust to and

040we we we wanted that we wanted a strong AIT me any Valu and that first year is always tough blowing things on both sides we thought we knew what we were getting into DP would say the same that um as things got going it they they the deeper dive they were doing just kind of drug things out so I know I want to make sure that the board understands that this this is was intentional you know to to get to this and I'm just going to double check Myra I know you're listening I didn't know if you had any questions or comments if you either want to type anything and send it to us or if you want to come on and ask any questions no I don't have any questions um I appreciate the

041explanation and I support the idea of giving Schoolboard members a deeper training on finances like it was mentioned earlier okay all right thank you anytime you want to hear about gby pronouncements I'm on it I'm on it with that I wonder if there's any more questions and if not would transition back to our Auditors any other additional questions I think so did you have something okay no all right so back to that all right thank you okay I am going to now attempt to share my screen and go through um these letters I am not as familiar with zoom oh here we go is that working yes it is um okay um so I will try to spend enough time but I realize we're kind of getting there on time so I might also try

042and move through a little bit um yes this is the letter that the board received from you but that is not public record is that correct um correct I mean really everything is available we're in a public meeting right now so if you are not wanting us to have this out yet then I would take that off of sharing your screen I that wasn't my intention of asking it was to help you place in time amongst the many many letters you've received what we were looking at chair's point is well taken yeah so is this public right now it is because we're in a public meeting right now it is this is not this this document is not public record this we're in a public meeting I can stop sharing my screen and we can

043just discuss that be great thank you and this this meeting you know you can because we have provided you with all of these communications um documents you're welcome to guide how you'd like this portion to go I don't want to um make any presumptions so I can I can review this kind of high level and if you have further questions we can go into it um so this that you did receive two letters the first letter is related to our it's called our communication to those charged with governance it's about five pages IT addresses some of the standard um Communications that are underlying the audit processes the audit numbers they might not be evident within the audit itself but explains um it explains some of those those details so that you as a board can

044discharge your oversight responsibility and we comply with our Professional Standards um first we talk about some significant accounting practices including policies estimates and disclosures um for the year ending June 30th 2024 there were no significant accounting policy changes except as noted in that restatement um that was related to the um acced interest and the amortization of the bond premium um there are significant estimates within all financials it's an inherit part of a financial statement and we call out the ones that have the the biggest impact and those are related to um accumulated depreciation and related expense for fixed assets there are two estimates related to other post-employment health benefits two estimates related to pension liabilities and also estimates related to property taxes receivables as your Auditors we um review Management's underlying assumptions for those estimates

045we look at um Census Data perhaps that was provided to the actuary for things like the pension and opep estimates we we look at those and we determine that they were reasonable in this context as a whole um we also call out some Financial dis statement disclosures which we consider a significant I mean they are all significant but we call out a few of them um we also in this letter um discuss some of the audit adjustments that were proposed and corrected by management there was uh proposed audit adjustment that was not considered material that management um opted to not post um not in their side and we did not have a problem with that we just like to call that out to the board and um our opinion was not modified there was a

046separate letter that is referred to here related to um some internal control findings that was the material weakness and significant deficiencies that Maria spoke about um and that is in the um also within the back of the audit itself but then we we have that separate communication to you that Jesus public record okay um there are some other matters that we had identified within this communication that we did not um think Rose even to the level of control deficiency we they're just matters that we wanted the board to be aware of for your oversight responsibilities if you have any questions about them feel free to reach out um otherwise we just discussed that um our independence we all we all we are independent of the district we have responsibilities the district has responsibilities to be

047able to maintain that Independence and we like to make that very clear um and overall this this audit yes it was it was very intensive it was very long I would say though that working with Margaret and Pete has been great we really appreciate how collaborative they've been how great they've been to work with and we just really wanted to recognize that um and share that with the board I do not know if you want me to go into the internal control letter or not that is up to you I'm not sure well so there's a statement out there that will approve about the staff remediation right and so I I don't know how the rest of the board feels I think I just have one question related to that remediation plan because is our

048current level of Staffing sufficient to meet all of those requirements are you anticipa in the shift go speak to what we talked about today do that thank you superintendent don't want to go into the the depth of Finance piece what we're talking about Margaret I want to bring to this I'm a CPA I'm a certified public accountant I used to do what Maria and Arya do I have maintained throughout this entire audit process that while it has been painful difficult confusing long days all the things exhausting exhaus me that I am both professionally satisfied and completely confident that this was the right decision for Gran Mar SCH District considering the future we see in that doesn't come without a cost not unlike tax abays where you pay that cost is up to you part of

049the reason that this audit took as long as it did and cost as much as it did is that we have chosen to take shortcuts that were considered IM material in the name of efficiency and operating with a less than ideal Staffing Group in finance department the decisions that were name that resulted in some of these things were done because as I'm sure you all do in your professional lives at the end of the day something has to give to get it all done and so we worked with our Auditors at the time and made a calculated decision and say we're going to do this the freaking dirty way not the super duper button up gassy fundamentalist way which is the way I want to do it every time but at the end of the

050day there isn't enough always to do that so here's what I want to say you can un ring this Bell I'm not suggesting we do this I don't want but if we were to go out and get a new auditor next year the first thing they would do was look at these reports and go test these things we there is no poly going back to poly retive right nor would I want to so yes it is going to be a heavy lift not just to get us to a place we've done a lot of work to correct these things already right so like on the timeline like we've been here we we've been heading up we're going to have to perform up here for a while and then we're going to come back down and

051reach a new stasis but it is never going to be the level bit once I am working and part the reason I'm book smiled at me and smile is that we were discussing this earlier today I'm working with superintendent CL Dennis clay my team superintendent not elect to see how getting the district's financial needs met that's within what is otherwise a not a picture where we add spending and the way we get an audit to Cost Less is doing this maintenance throughout the year and the way we do that is we hire people who have the skills knowledge and experience to do it and the finance department we forly don't to get direct but I can't give you the specifics because there are entities that would be impacted by The Proposal that they gave to

052that we have to spoken to just today but Market offered a pretty cost neutral option that we need to look at to add Staffing to address the audit as we move forward in the future given how we're working through the spring budgeting process right now it's on the list of what do we need to do how is this something we can or should do so know that it's been proposed that was today to answer your question directly so then I have another just sort of a statement that goes in with this um and and never never never um well that's the way we've always done it no that is not my statement here um however previously there was more and we do have a little bit more time because we had our we had an

053item that was canceled off of our agenda so um previously there were a couple of other checkin points with the board through the process this go around there was the initial conversation that I think I was the only one that had from the board and I don't think that there was any other individual we're previous iously we would have individual conversation with kind of asking questions about not the indepth kind of stuff we're not the accountants but do you have any questions about what you've seen um is there anything that you're unsure about what would you like us to look at and and that didn't happen this time so um you know whether it does it in person or a document or uh just a reminder for the board that to ask those questions early

054on um so to get to up up to speed Arya and Maria the way that poly Rogers does things is they send out a email board fraud questionnaire every year and they expect every day I believe what you're describing as the in-person fraud question uh both a little bit of both yeah and beyond that I'll let Arya and Maria address this question okay I mean that's really great feedback um I I think we can certainly incorporate that into future years it sounds like that would be um really helpful and desired by the board and so I we will we will make a note of that and keep the board reach out to the board more throughout the process yeah just with the real firm that the board isn't directing the audit but just so that

055we are aware um in case someone El us asks us a question we know to refer it back to Margaret or Pete yeah and and you know feel free fre to reach out to us as well if you feel like you're not getting what you need or want from us you know I there's you know we we work for you we want you to feel like we're providing the service you want us to provide um so at any time you're welcome to reach out to us as well one solution that Margaret and I have talked about I think others have as well is some boards have a committee that is the audit committee so a couple of board members would have that opportunity for a couple of touch points through the process and that might

056be the solution that we've talked about something similar to that also incorporating a couple of budget committee members who've wanted to be involved in a different way and sort of a finance committee without that committee making decisions about the finance they're they're told from the the budget committee but they are not representing the budget committee they're just another set of eyes on it um so we we've had Inc um informal conversation about that and um haven't been able to move that forward so Margaret shaking her head she's ready to start it tomorrow I committee all right all of this is just along with the sensitivity of looking forward um we have the sensitivity of looking left and right some of our brothers and sisters in public education have slipped up in ways we don't want

057to slip up correct so to the degree that this audit confirms that we're not slipping up is helpful um I understand hedging the responsibilities uh completely in auditing but I um I guess the deficiencies you've identified would not intersect your knowledge with any of those deficiencies that would have caused the issues that we've seen throughout the state of Oregon um is kind of my generalized question I think I I know what you're more or less referring to and um you know I'm not sure I mean I I guess you know when I when we look at these these findings or deficiencies we had you know we kind of stepped back and I would say some of them are related to really what I would call accounting gyration you know when you talk about something like

058a Creed interest and like um effective uh am like sorry Amor amortizing the premium using the effective interest method I mean these are these are just accounting things you know more or less um some of the other adjustments were really related to you know mostly about timing of Revenue and timing of expense and getting things in the right period you know we didn't we didn't have any concerns around cash we didn't have any um con concerns like that there was just it was really when it comes down to Gap you know like generally accepted accounting principles that's that's where our findings were focused um so I I know the district is already I think maybe maybe even um addressed all of these I think at this point I'm not sure maybe not quite all of

059them there's probably maybe still the some some that may need some tweaking but um nothing here that caused us concerns as your Auditors if that makes sense we that makes sense yeah okay appreciate that thank you so Margaret was gonna just on the things that we've fixed already are there just said I was planning to deliver that during the corrective action plan however I would be happy to deliver it you which would you prefer so is it here or out there is it is it just my plan was out there okay let's do it let's do it out there all right so you have to repeat to put your parts at ease maybe um I will say that arya's assessment is correct if we have 50% of these were addressed with the adjusting entries and

060updated schedules that came in order to finish this off 50% of these are water under the bridge they are set up so that the remainder life of the debt service will be not only paid correctly which it always was but reported in alignment with generally ex that's Cas so 50% done if it's not done there's a plan in place to get it done hence the conversation Mr BR this and I can go into more detail as something that I um would be helpful to speak on my assessment of our neighbors their struggles and where the audit consent should I sa that yeah would save that if you don't have specifics I think we stick with us y okay so um any more from Margaret Pete you've been real quiet so you must agree with everything

061that Margaret has said write that down that down you know Pete this this board has more experience than they do with me or Dennis can you share your assessment and public the audit one uh I guess I'll speak in in Broad Strokes I very much agree with things that have been said so far um I agree that that the level of rigor that the um decreased materiality and therefore increased scrutiny uh in all areas of the audit um puts the district in a firmer position going forward with knowing exactly where we're at uh and and allowing our decision makers the best information Prov make the most effective decisions uh which I think is the name of the game uh it was unfortunate that we were late uh and that that did have uh a cost

062I do not expect that to happen in future years based on the relationship that we built and the the things that are either already done or in progress to be done based on what superintendent Co Market are talking about I had just one other and I think probably it's part of what's out there the letter that the board received um about the audit the analysis um I don't know what it's called but it um it's on the letter head for superintendent Hugh with the date of a 2025 date however I realized that the time period was during his time as superintendent so is that why it stays as that right and is that mentioned in here anywhere that I didn't see it but it's just because he at the time was in charge he was

063the May so these are the audited financial statements for the fiscal year and of June 30 2024 right okay it just weird because it had January 30 2025 with James especially because then in other areas John's signing things I can see why that he's not all right and as we were clear earlier the less my signature is used the happier I am all right so there any other questions by the board any other questions from the board so this is going to be an item out here when we get into our business meeting what I'll be doing when we get into our business meeting is refie reviewing the formal corrective action plan that I have prepared this is required by the secretary of state of Oregon I have prepared it you will have a chance

064to decide whether you accept it my plan for the business meeting is to review this at a very high level and distinguish if it has been addressed and if it hasn't what the plans are to address it so when we have so this is the one that's um has the Oregon uh the Secretary of State that's right okay so I would ask then that um we spell Holly's name correctly on this okay all right I rather liked it I thought maybe we had a new board member then I went back and looked at my own name and I thought is that I did suggest M ran that maybe she should change her name that it just means Holly and I read it you know that's all that means H and I read so excited to

065get the accent over director Gomez's last it wasn't there in the prior year and that's meaningful yeah and then I I'm sorry Hol actually gets confused very often there's not a lot of names that begin with h thank you for your I appreciate my name being spelled correctly we do too my pleasure yes all right so any other questions um I don't see any so any other questions or comments from our Auditors this evening um no thank you for you know giving us the opportunity to be your Auditors feel free to reach out if you do have questions um we are available throughout the year not just during the audit which you know was was quite a bit of the year this time it won't always be but but yeah feel free to reach out

066to us if questions do come up okay then I think uh you are are welcome to it's a public meeting you could stay but you are also welcome to leave if you like Myra you get to stay we will see thank you so much thank you thank you all right back to the agenda all right perfect so as mentioned earlier um we do not have an executive session regarding Personnel um on uh discussion items future board agenda topics um Tracy we've cleaned up a lot of those are most of those either in process they're going to be scheduled in they're being worked on I don't think we had any that were outstanding so um couple of them are at the retreat at the end of the month the DLI update that Myra requested will be

067April when we have our plans will okay further along for secondary okay all right um just looking to see because I didn't have any other notes um yeah I don't think we have I think have anything else um so announcements um we will uh adjourn this meeting have a little bit of time and then our regular board business meeting on February 5th 2025 in council chambers Public Safety and schools building will start at 7 o'clock and I believe there'll be no other business in the work session we are adjourned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.