001good evening welcome to the Russ bra Board of Education Wednesday December 18th regular board work session we will call the order roll call attendance Chris Howard chair Kathy kley Vice chair absent is BL Peterson absent is David litic attendance is hly Reglan Dr Myra Gomez Dr Shan pars and uh joining us remotely we have uh superintendent James PE and I can't see without my glasses we got Don Hugh John Cook jpr so is there a motion to approve the meeting agenda as presented um make sure everybody knows that whenever it was you first saw it what was added was the gbea tenative agreement uh was added on December 18th so is there a motion to approve the agenda the agenda present second moved by Myra seconded by Kathy to approve the amended agenda uh any
002discussion about it see none all those in favor I right any post right we have an agenda so first item that we have up here is the gbea tenative agreement added so let me put my glass on soon so good evening superintendent Hugh for one more day for one more hour um Dr Freeman and Dr Clinger and Mr cook is fling so there there's all right so who's presenting this tonight Dr I'll be presenting proudly uh good evening chair Howard and members howt and members of the board um I get to deliver the good news that the Gres Barlo school district and the gush and Barlo Education Association have reached a tenative agreement for the July 1st 2024 through June 30th 2027 the tenative agreement was reached on November 18th 2024 the East County bargaining
003Council or the ecbc which reviews contract proposals to sure that they match the Norms established in other member districts voted to support the ratification of the tentative agreement and on December 17th which was just last night members of the gbaa also voted to ratify the agreement and I would just personally like to thank Eric nart who I I think is watching tonight and the members of his team um for coming to the table very open honest and collaborative um as well as the members of the gbsd uh bargaining team who were very responsive and collaborative as well chair Howard I'd like to thank you personally as well for being an excellent member of the bargaining team always having the right things to say at the right time and a great perspective and superintendent Hugh thank
004you so much for being a great leader of this District during the negotiations and um doing what's right for kids and for our staff at all times so at this point I would like to ask the board to uh vote to approve um the tenative agreement so are there any um clarifying questions before we move to a u a motion to approve it so any clarifying for Angela or any of the other team up there I did hear something about late start after winter break and spring break is that so that's like say the Monday it would be a late start day for students teachers would arrive at their normal time or something like that yeah so it would mimic the same schedule that we currently have for Wednesdays um but it would fall on
005in the agreement they received two additional late start dates which would mimic those schedules the first one is the first day after winter break this year it happens to fall on a Monday other years it may fall on a different day but this year it's a Monday um and you would also have a late start on that Wednesday as well so for January 6th and January 8th both would be late starts this year um so given that our students go on break like in two days what's the communication plan for families good question um we have once this is approved or decided on by you all tonight we have communication ready to go out um tomorrow morning to families um the general overall communication it'll be posted on the website there'll be reminders going out
006from each school um to families um with the specific schedules for those schools as well as reminders going out I think three days before the 6 two days before the 6th there'll be phone um phone calls that'll go out we anticipated that this might happen so we have a communication plan in place well I Le to hear thanks okay all right welcome is an action item and there is a sample Motion in there would like to make that move okay go ahead move to approve I move to approve the tenative agreement between the Gres and Barlo school district and the Gres and Barlo Education Association for July 1 2024 through June 30 2027 and I will second um so any other discussion about that all right so all those in favor okay any opposed no
007we're here so we have a tenative agreement that now is an agree agement thank you so much this is going to make a lot of people very happy makes very happy and thank you again Angela your leadership in this as well as Dr Clinger and the entire team um it made this process work for everyone and I'm I'm very pleased to sit on the team and um this is a a great agreement that we have looking forward to contining to work with every so thank you so much have a great meeting thank you so I think U most the people are going to be logging off at this point our next agenda item is superintendent search leadership profile report from hya so I believe superintendent Hugh unless you have any other words of wisdom no
008he's gone we're out okay and who's loing on the side this part doesn't matter this is so okay so um and we will have some cupcakes and treats and things at our January meeting so that will be part of the celebration for the Congress got C days so next up on our agenda is superintendent search leadership profile report um haard young teen Associates was hired by the board to assist in the recruitment selection process for a new superintendent they conducted a leadership Profile assessment Gathering input from Individual interviews and focus group settings and the surveys interview and focus group meetings were structured to and we are going to hear some of the output from that on the leadership profile report so good evening gentlemen good evening good evening can you hear us okay yes y
009great well uh I'll go ahead and get things started well first of all congratulations on your new uh licensed teacher um contract that is a lot of hard work having done that for many years so congratulations to you the board and also the team that got that completed that's that's very good news I want to start by just introducing a little bit about what this report is all about and who it's for um the first thing I would say is that this report is for you the board of directors and it can be used simply as a really nice filter for your hiring uh we heard from 200 voices including your own about uh the challenges of the district the strengths of the district and also the characteristics that you wanted to see and this
010this should be a a real good guiding document um for you as you think about uh the um the Slate of candidates that we bring forward it also is a great document for the candidates themselves after the board decides on the Slate of candidates we will be sending this out uh to those candidates to say here is the report uh that was published about our interactions uh while we were in the district and it gives them a good perspective on what's going on in the district it also allows them to uh really think about um and evaluate their own skill set in relationship to what the the gram Barlo School Board might be looking for it's also good for the public the public will be uh reviewing this um it should be posted on your
011website as early as tomorrow um so that everyone can see everything that was gathered um and in complete transparency what was said in all the different focus groups and in the interviews it also will allow and this is kind of unique and unusual to Gres and Barlo um you have a new board of education configuration that will be coming in May um and actually um as soon as January um this will allow the new board of education also to get um grounded pretty quickly on what the the communication coming from the community said about the challenges and the strengths and the characteristics of the new superintendent as well um this is a incredibly valuable document uh for the new superintendent that you actually hire um it gives them the opportunity to see uh you know
012what was said in the community and it provides them an opportunity uh to work with the board of education on maybe some of the things that surfaced within the report and it might also be used um as a springboard for goal setting and strategic planning with the new superintendent um you have 200 voices who've shared their um perspectives on the school district and there may be bits and pieces in there that the board want to tackle with the new superintendent to say um are there uh are there items within this report that we might want to pursue as a within the Strategic plan or within goal setting so with that what's in the report itself well first of all um You probably all had a chance to read it um as as it was in
013your portal uh it provides you a a brief description of the school district and an executive summary um input from about 200 voices from varied stakeholder groups uh it by stakeholder group um you will see the strengths uh that they perceive uh that the district has and it also uh provides the challenges by stakeholder group and then each uh stakeholder group also provided us with characteristics that they wanted to see um within uh with if when you hired the new superintendent um then towards the end and we'll talk about this on page 20 it'll really give you an overview of really what are those highest level characteristics that we heard from all the different stakeholder groups and that's on page 20 and we'll talk about that in just a moment also um within this and
014Mike will talk a little bit about this uh in a few minutes is the a hya stakeholder survey results that we had uh 400 and some uh participants provide feedback to the district as well and Michael walk through those results and then at the very end of the report you'll see um all of the raw data that we collected so what I'm going to do is and this is just really for public consumption is just provide you with a brief overview of um one or two strengths from each stakeholder group and then also a challenge and then I'll walk you through uh the the most relevant um characteristics of the new superintendent so if you take a look at the highlights of the board of education for example the strengths this board of education um
015kind of collectively uh told me that this is a very stable School District um financially and at the core of this school district is a community that supports the public school system and another strength is that you have low turnover in your employees your leadership your teachers and your classified employees collectively the talked to me about um a challenge being internal communication and the speed of misinformation on social media this is not uh just a gresi and Barlo problem this is a problem in every school district that we talk with it is very difficult for internal communication to be factual and to to uh work at the speed of social media and what's out there so just know that that challenge is not unique to gesan Barlo when I spoke to district and school administrators
016um they really spoke um about the strength of the district and school leadership principles assistant principles and the caring and competent teachers and also the programs that have been established over the last few years as an example Career Tech Ed and also the the dual immersion program the challenges that the administrators brought up were um again not unique to Gres and Barlo but really um they need the resources to support the diverse populations and the marginalized students I think that leadership and administration and even the teachers they know what to do um it's just that supporting such diverse populations takes additional resources when we talk to the licensed teachers and classified staff um they are really fond of and believe that the grow your own teacher program um is an Incredible strength along with um
017the ability of the affinity group uh to continue to meet um and just to talk about the challenges of of the bipo uh you um Community um and they they believe that that opportunity to meet is a real strength of the school district and a challenge um they also brought up communication they had a little different spin on it it was more about proactive communication and issues surrounding um Equity as well um they feel that that um they're doing the right work around Equity but that will always continue to be a challenge of of making sure the community understands exactly what Equity means within the school district setting when I spoke to the equity committee um their strength uh generally was really around recognizing and celebrating staff and student successes they think the district is
018a very good job of that and they believe a huge challenge that needs to be tackled is absenteeism and just the disregulated student behavior um that we really has seen escalate uh since uh Co the co years when we spoke to the parent and community members they uh really spoke about um the alternative programs like a Springwater Trail the ray Academy CTE programs the Dual language immersion they believe the district is really striving uh to be resourceful using their resources to create alternative type programs that kids want to belong to a challenge for the parents and community members was really around communication um uh there's lots of conversation in the community and you're well aware of this around school safety and also student and social emotional and behavioral challenges as well just that disregulated behavior
019that we're that we're seeing Across the Nation and so then what did the high school kids say again the high school kids they love the CTE programs uh they love their counselors at the high schools um they believe that they're being prepared well for um College um they believe they receive um lots of support and one of the things the high school kids actually called out was the newcomers program and the support that the school district gives and tries to provide for the newcomers uh to the community which is great what do they believe are the challenges um they too talked about communication timely and ACC communication um and I think that really St stems from some Safety and Security issues of the school that have recently surfaced um and then they to called out
020um they wished that there was more resources for students who were struggling students who needed more support and really um talking about how do we help those kids that are that have been marginalized so that's kind of at a glance um really really high level lot more detail in the report about each subgroups each stakeholder groups kind of strengths and weaknesses and then if you'll turn to page 20 if you actually have this report in front of you on page 20 of the report this is just a um a way that I put together what I believe were all of the characteristics um that I heard from every single uh uh group in a really easy to view format but I'd like to just pair that down to four key characteristics that I heard and
021I think Mike heard in every single group that we spoke to including interviews with the Board of Education and District leadership the first one would be communication it came out in every single group um really around communication being timely and accurate and clear and transparent um and part of that is in competition with social media um which we all know is impossible um but just know that compet uh communication came up time and time again uh the other characteristics that came up were the one around relationships and that is they'd really like to see the new superintendent be involved be visible they want a compassionate leader someone who's cultur competent and responsive to the the need the diverse needs of the school district so relationships um was talked about in almost every single group student
022centered they want someone who cares and is concerned and is kind to students they need someone that's involved with students and without exception um everybody wants an instructional leader they want someone who knows the teaching and learning cycle they want this superintendent to be data informed and data driven they want this superintendent to focus on student learning and closing the opportunity gaps for marginalized students and everyone is well aware that there's a lot more to the superintendency than just being an instructional leader uh but they absolutely um without exception every group said we need someone who knows student learning and so um that's uh my part at a glance um I'm happy to answer any questions but we also uh might want hear from Mike first just about what uh the information that we gleaned
023from the hya uh stakeholder survey Mike I don't think he's here we lose Mike I'm promoting him again really Qui back in okay well we're bringing them in um I I try to find a place for kind of those four big ones that you were saying but I might have missed it is it written in the report like the four key characteristics I really those four key characteristics that I just laid out for you I really pulled out of that grid on page 20 I kind of looked at it went looked back at all my notes and I'm like what are the four top ones that are uh so I didn't really list them in the report but they're communication relationships student centered and instructional leader and in almost every group some way shape or
024form those terms surfaced uh as the most important characteristics for the new superintendent I mean there were lots of words used and you'll see a lot of those but I would say those are the four four most common thank you you bet Mike sorry we lost you was just getting to the end of uh kind of the the big report and uh are you ready to talk about um the stakeholder report I am but I just want to can you hear me okay yeah so I'm in a hotel right now my internet connection is terrible I keep going in and out okay so um it pauses for like 10 seconds and it comes back so it's really kind of weird so just so you know that you might lose me but I'm GNA try to
025go quickly here okay um I'm on page 23 of the report so when you look at the survey the state of the district and you can see the different subgroups uh the vision and values teaching and learning community engagement and management and there's a series of questions that go into each of those different categories and it's kind of lumped into the different groups and so the interesting um piece about your report is if you look at the the dots you kind of want those dots close together um so everyone's on the same page but you the administrators in your District uh seem to think that the district is running better than what some of the other stakeholders think and so that's something that the new superintendent is going to want to look into um just
026to kind of look at that so Norm normally the administrators or the certified staff or licensed staff are a little bit further to the right than some of those other subgroups and normally the parents students Community um don't quite think as highly of the district as the um the administrators or the licensed staff so that's kind of a norm but you want to see those dots a little bit closer together when you get down to the um profile summary you can see the dots subgroups are much closer together so everyone is more in tune to the same page when it comes down to that um leadership profile and then profile data so excuse me there were I think 12 or 13 different questions that each um the classified staff Community licensed staff and parents you
027can kind of see what their top four um leadership profile details were and you got a couple that are very close and uh again it just gives you an idea of what what they're thinking I really like the um on the next page I like how you can go to each of those questions then and you can see the percentage of each group of what they think what you want to look for here is you want to look is there any discrepancy amongst those percentages um when it comes down to the different um groups or the different uh themes that they have and so when you look at the overall the uh quality of the education across the district again you'll note that the administrators are at 64% and then the license staff was at
02819% so there's a big difference and and how they came up with those percentages they either scored or four or five so they they either strongly agreed or agreed uh with those attributes so again if you just kind of go through and look at the different questions look at those percentage and then on the next page it's the same thing it's just with that Pro profile that leadership profile analysis uh looking at those percentages which ones are close together which ones are further apart and typically the leader profile the groups are closer together than the state of the district the state of the district in almost every single Sur the district so um overall this information should be very helpful for the new superintendent and help you get to that that next level of of
029achievement across your District so any questions on the survey I'm just I'm paranoid I'm gonna lose you any questions on on the survey yeah Mike you've cut out a couple of times I think we got the gist of it um but now might be an opportunity for the board to ask any questions that um where you popped out so um the board will open it up to you to ask any questions that you might have about the process about the data that we collected the report or the survey Mike I have a question on page 26 the leadership profile analysis this is one area where you cut out a little bit you said the groups are usually closer together here and what was the rest yeah so when when you compare the state of the
030district the groups are usually further apart but then when you get to that leadership profile analysis the groups are normally closer together and so that's what they really want from that new superintendent compared to what how the district is going with is is the other one okay um the other question is um the the communication clearly is an issue across the board and it sounds like both what is being communicated and how timely is part of the um you know where the Administration has a higher safety instance and you know teachers or students have a lower one could some of that separation be because of the lack of communication that the lower ranking groups aren't aware of some of the things that the administrators are I'd say absolutely yes um and remember communication is tricky
031in every school district across this nation and that is um most communities and and many parents and many community members they're they're not looking at much of the communication until they think they need something then then they go search for it so it may be that the communication is there but they didn't get it when they thought they should have gotten it even though it was available so so um this is really perception data um you know I and I think that District uh office administrators and uh School administrators are very aware of the communication coming out of central office because that's that's a very primary job is to they make sure what's going on that they're communicating out to their community so um I would say that uh the perception is that we don't
032have enough communication but then how do you fix that is a huge challenge because you you can ramp up many different ways of communication and it may or may not change that outcome of of people thinking that um the communication just isn't there but it may well be well and the other uh concern I guess is is it just communicating better or are some people perceiving like absent the lack of communication they would not feel as safe they it just isn't as safe not that that's a good that's probably not a good example but just to pick one there's going to be a real need I guess to to discern is it just communication or is there a real Divergent in that expectation so this is a great point if I was a superintendent coming
033into Gres and Barlo and I saw the communication um in almost every focus group and interview um was um brought up um it would be a place to really dive deep like okay what's really going on here um is it how we communicate is it when we communicate is it I mean districts don't communicate when they don't have all the facts so so is is it because they're trying to the community expects you to beat social media um I think that if was a new superintendent I would delve into all of that to figure out so what is what is the issue um and how can we help solve it and and bring bring some people together to to help solve this so that's the power of this particular report is to kind of identify
034with that Gap and then explore it more deeply thank you so this may be a question for as we are looking through the applications or whatever but thinking about the interview process will you guys help develop interview questions that kind of Sean we're gonna we're gonna that's all this yeah okay yeah we have we have a plan for you an executive session that we will share I I guess the only the only thing I maybe to touch on is in reading through it um our participation wasn't as robust as we would have liked but um and just to acknowledge that but that you feel like you got the a true um read on the district and from each group that you had enough participation from each group is that a true statement I would say
035that participation was extremely low um we had uh several sessions where no one showed up however those groups that did show up um and the information that we gleaned and the input that they provided was outstanding um when we had people there um that's what I would say so so the quality of input was very good um I would have loved to see double um the number of participants um it just uh you know for us in gathering that kind of data I think it's better it provides a better perspective but I don't think that anything in the report would necessarily uh change that significantly um I think that uh we got a pretty clear picture from those who did did show up Mike what would you say yeah you spot on and oh Mike
036froze again um because it's easier for people to to do the survey from home or from their from their workspace versus coming to a face tof face uh focus group yeah well and it also um I think speaks to the communication part you know so this would be something really uh Hands-On and tangible to evaluate the process and see where the holes were in a communication you know delivery model um so I think we were supposed to do a separated survey for students by high school and that would give us an idea of like what is Gres high school students think or bar were we able to to get enough data to kind of have that or I will but if I break out break up here you're gonna have to kind of finish my
037my Pro okay so so if you go into to your portal you've got there are eight surveys actually there's U looks like we lost mic again so the bottom line on the high school surveys is we had very very poor participation at Gresham High School and uh Ray Academy we had zero and then um at a Springwater Trail we had um just like seven um we did have a pretty significant number of kids I think it was over like 119 I think it's in the report that took it at um San Barlo high school so really the comparing and contrasting um of these different High School perceptions is really uh not accurate at all we were very disappointed um in being unable to get kids to take it we were hopeful that the kids would
038take um the survey in like an advisory or a study hall or first period or whatever um and it looks like the only school that really pulled it off um and even even s Barlo it's a relatively low number um given what we've seen in other um relatively large Comprehensive High Schools so the high school data is really um I mean it is what it is you have all of the student uh comments um that were available uh the comments that are given are good um it's good input good feedback it's just not enough for us to kind of make compare and cont compare and cont TR amongst the schools I will tell you one thing that um that Mike found out when he and maybe Mike you could speak to this unless you break
039up again is is what the kids at Sam Barlo um High School uh felt about kind of the tension that is between the two comprehensive high schools and they don't like it um they spoke very in a very articulate way that um that they care very much about their their their friends um close friends at Gresham High School and they don't like if that the community um in some ways negatively Compares uh the two schools for a variety of reasons and sometimes s Barlo comes out on the back end of that uh in a negative way and sometimes gram does um and the kids at both high schools that we interviewed they don't like that perception of the community that somehow one school is better than the other school or that one school does something
040better than the other school um that is really um I would almost say that they feel hurt by that which was I think very perceptive of them yeah I think they want come together um you know as one so that would be something again and we can certainly talk to that new superintendent about you know about that as well yeah so I I wanted to just kind of um while we're still talking a little bit about high schools and things and um certainly there was an incident that was occurring at the time that was high in people's mind but I would like as we move forward and as you're talking with candidates and helping us do that um spring waterer Trail High School is not an alternative high school it is a small comprehensive high
041school that kids apply to attend so making sure that that's very clear and then also Ray Academy is a more Alternative Learning environment that also pulls in students that are not just from brush and Barlo but they may be from other schools within W County that have had difficulty finishing their school and so they have then can come and apply to be so it's just a little bit of a difference there Spring Water Trail is just a small comprehensive and so making sure that uh it is not an alternative school in any way shap I I will say this about the high school kids focus groups we had um really good participation at all four uh high schools um I actually had the opportunity to speak with all 40 or 50 um of the kids
042at Ray um and maybe that kind of deterred them from actually filling out the survey I don't know um but we did have really good thoughtful and reflective feedback from all of the high school kids um at each one of the programs so um the focus groups went well for high school kids I just uh regardless of you know the participation at certain levels I just think the value because I I did go read a lot of the um comments the actual responses to the questions and it is insightful and so whatever information we have I think it's going to be valuable going forward um especially especially for the ultimate new superintendent I just want to say I really appreciate the time and effort I think it's just really invaluable there's a lot in there
043to to talk about for sure all right next any other questions about this [Music] so what's next go to the executive session is that all there is on more that they were actually going to present for this anything else you guys on the report that's all just that it should be it should be posted tomorrow um at your earliest convenience on the district website under the superintendent search section thank you thanks all right so are they um we'll see you in executive session we have a separate link right yeah right okay you still need to announce all right we'll be moving into executive session to consider employment of a public officer under 92660 PR2 pra grlo School District Board of Directors will now meet in ex executive session for the purpose of discussing the considero
044public officer executive sessions are closed to the public representatives of the news media and designated staff will be allowed to attend all other members of the audience are asked to leave the room representatives of the news media are specifically directed not to report on any of the deliberations during the executive session except to State the general subject of the session as previously announced no decision may be made in executive session and do we have any media that have request okay all right okay we're back in all right welcome we are back into regular session um we only have a little bit more left to go in the meeting for the December 18th BR bar Board of Education work session um we have future board agenda topics and we've been going through the um content that
045people have been putting into the spreadsheet and putting those out onto uh meetings where it fits in either where it fits in with other content I don't have that up here right now so I will get that out to you guys um Tracy and Kathy and I worked on that to make sure that we had things scheduled out or that they were checked off because we've already discussed them and I don't know if we have anything else that's going to be put on the entering things into the spreadsheet seems to be working um for folks where they entered in give us a little bit of information I know I need to contact Blake about one of the ones that he had in there because I need to get some more information about what he was
046looking for so otherwise that seems to be working and then we can put it out during times when we know we're already going to be discussing that particular area um we also have tonight here so we didn't quite make it at the J at the meeting I think it's January at the December meeting but this is your last because we doing we have a couple of things for you I know because the way the meeting went today so on behalf of Board of Education and the superintendent you get a golden that is a and then we also have um not sure what this is this and then also it's actually not a master teacher it's a that you too can not even finish your pH to honor your service to the board Kathy kethley they
047spelled it right Fran Barlo School District Board of Directors 20121 2024 thank you for your three years of very dedicated service good luck on the city council yeah when is this show I don't know if you're gonna that 7th at 6 January 7th at 6m yeah that do we get to bring like noise makers and it's a public meeting so to yeah I'm surprised your daughter's fast didn't come to make sure you voted for [Laughter] the what time yeah um okay and that works out well of course because we W be using the same chamber oh all right so we are down to um closing items December 2st 2024 through January 5th 2025 is winter break there will be no board meetings and as we just approved in sorry in the um bargaining agreement the
048first Monday back after winter break will be a late arrival and that notice will be going out to families via lots of notification and then we will have our regular board business meeting at 7: p.m. in the council chambers Public Safety and schools building on January 8th 2025 we will be seeing you all maybe in and out but have a pleasant holiday time a happy New Year and we will see you January 8th 20 thank you we are you