CorpusRecord 144749

November 20, 2024 Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Gresham-Barlow School District
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Multnomah County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,155 words · about 118 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

00124 regular board work session uh currently at center for advanced learning conference room we have an attendance tonight Chris how chair kathyy Vice chair Lake Peters David litic director Dr Myra Gomez director Dr Shan far's director James Hugh superintendent and excuse this evening is Holly wman we have a forum and so with that if there's a motion to approve the meeting agenda I hope to approve the agenda presented second then move by Myra second and by David to approve the meeting agenda as presented is there any discussion seeing none all those in favor I any opposed thank you first up is policy review first reading and I believe this has Mr Cook's name on it looks like it's been a while on these so we have a number that are pretty straightforward tonight the first

002one is AC non-discrimination uh the committee recommends because there weren't many changes recommends accepting the second bracketed sentence in the fourth we go down there it's highlighted for you to look at otherwise it isn't a substantial change that's it the second if you want me to if there's any questions I can take now or I can move um don't you just move who is discrimination who is our district it be me this position so title n s rights and there's a list of no wonder hav been enforced thank you for okay so does that where does that show up then John does that show up on the website it does information and the whole list of who's there and then if you do have a complaint uh it'll take you to that anyway so it's

003all LED together okay all right so no other changes on that one no other changes on that one so I can go to CBG um there are a lot of there are a number of cosmetic changes there that nothing's really subed for you to consider some capitalization things other things clean up righted mean yes yes we have to do it at least once a year you could do more frequently can we take out at least once a year no no the bracket is you have to do at least once a year by law but you could do you could do twice a year no I wouldn't want to do times here I thought it was maybe the other way where we have some wiggle room like in a off year or something and we'll get

004to that administrat coming too so that is how most administrators all right so anything else on that one John no evaluation of administrator we can move to that because the the committee has recommended deleting the last sentence bracketed sentence of formal evaluation will be conducted regularly at least once a year because that was restrictive and what I've described the committee is we are on a 2-year um plan like you just alluded to Sean and in the second year there's a summit of evaluation but each year you're observed discussed and you meet twice a year at least youru admin are on probation for three years that's an the first three years and then it okay and remind me again John the yellow highlight is that just the information from osba come out when we okay that's

005new I don't remember them doing that before questions on that policy then we will move forward to First dat this was an entertaining policy to discuss yeah first aid uh there are there's a lot of language here that's required by lot and the statute so it's there um we have elected to um well this this policy evba is recommending deletion the policy I'm about to get to incorporates this into the new policy so I'll move forward to that and it's incorporated into where is that yeah thank you it is incorporated into a couple different policies what we have done tonight two that I should qualify is there were a number of First Aid student health C related policies that have come this year we decided to package those together this time and try to get

006it to you all at once even though some of them are not necessarily required uh that way we're all looking at all of them at once and try to do the cross the crossload between policies so student health services is a pretty straightforward policy as well um it's what these are the elements of a plan that you need to have and we do have those elements in the plan uh it's that's not new language but at the bottom is new language um if you look at number 12 we're recommending a deletion that's been Incorporated in another spot the designed designated employees was taken from that paragraph right there was taken from policy that's being recommended for deletion and put into this we the committee thought it would be valuable to keep and then the rest

007of this is um recommended by osba and the committee didn't seem to have they didn't have concerns with that one0 students when I when I checked with HR to see I asked that question directly it didn't seem too cumbersome uh when you combine new employees as well as employees who are on whatever safety response Teem you have it's a pretty simple standard to me if anything we probably over that in most cases that's 20 to in our yeah if you imagine even coaches who have to renew almost every year every other year and you count them in you're good to go is there a annual or maybe every other year opportunity for staff members to get trained for free by the district there is if they want most people take advantage of the ones who

008are on safety teams or coaches we still pay for that once it's renewed and yes there are annual opportunities it's either through the ESD or our own verses that's if they're identified to be one of the responders not just for their own that's true keeping their skill level high it's I've been selected to be one of the people needed for us to meet this requirement and respond an emergency and typically who are if you're in a the second Elementary for example you're going to have some of the office like your principle necessary is going to remain certifi so those are some of the examples people that are more flexible andal as well I remember that we were invited if we wanted to get trained this for knowledge we could I believe that's still the case

009but I have not asked question other questions on that the other thing with this policy is it did take an AR that got kind of they're kind of doing that now taking some ARs and pushing them into the main policy so I think that's why this one is kind of a delete this add this it's the polic the basics what you have to do the AR is the stuff that may change more frequently it's the operational part of implementing the policy so the AR is there usually as direction for staff or folks what to do and then if it's not working they can tweak it without having to come back through a whole review process so that's what an AR is thanks still your number no that's good that's fine next policy is ebaa like

010it says on the Highlight there it's a proposed policy from osba I think the policy is fine uh it's how you would respond to infection control if a kid has bloody nose and they're bleeding in a room how is that handled and custodians are the one the best TR to handle that so they know what to do they have the chemicals they have the equipment they would handle that this just outlines how be done moving forward from there safety threats this generated a good amount of discussion within the committee um partially my fault uh we what this says is if you look at number four and it's proposed but this is statute I recommend that we what page are you on I am on it's ebca and it is 15 15 15 okay I just

011want to make sure it's in the same place all right so this is new law that requires districts to report about safety threads um most of it just makes sense there was um a number five in here that said that you had to um report what was done to resolve the issue within 24 hours we've had two this year that took longer than 24 hours so I had some concerns about I'm not going to be policy I'm not going to be law just because we weren't able to resolve the police weren't able to resolve those things so I met with osba and said and gave those examples and said this is a little too restrictive for us not that it's going we can meet it most of the time and Spencer suggested the highlighted language

012second paragraph from the bottom it says if action takes more than 24 hours it would be impossible to provide a communication uh it would be impossible to provide a communication on how the situation was resolved within 24 hours of the initiation and then it gives us some leeway in how we communicate different things at different that langage questions on that and that would be the last of the policies for the board to consider this evening come to us at the next next December okay think for communicating enough now my Tex where it says many Communications right let me get back um so next up make on right here we go um we had uh information before and now we're having a first reading on the city of GFF and Enterprise Zone support and this has

013superintendent Hugh on here thank you chair how uh at the October 16 work session uh board engag in a conversation with CC mels on with the MD Fitzgerald from The Economic Development Department from the city of BR um around Enterprise Z and question that board M work and um at that point in time we the board to take some action on 15% um I think after a very robust conversation decided that didn't have enough information get back to another work session for further conversation um so that's what we're doing we have included some information from both 6 from City um on some additional information and then this afternoon I forwarded you um email additional information uh that Vice chair had had asked for some clarification and I was able to get some information clarified um

014but wanted uh to um Engage The Board in conversation as far decision points I will say for the record that Cal School District has moved the Enterprise Zone at 15% um with the 1% that the city is going to take fees tonight Stacey Michael District they have and they're looking to also 1% um outside of that you might want to engage in a conversation and if there's anything that answer for you or additional questions that you both have um I will you share point James why 15 and we have the option to go this highest 30 um I think it's because the 15% allows for um um incentive for um businesses that would like to um participate in an Enterprise own function or process within a doesn't have to be but we had discussed last

015time that for us um as a school district whatever local Revenue that we collect um the state school fund is that you know equalizes so we collect less money local tax the state school fund actually fill in that Gap so we're not necessarily getting less money if you collect more more money here in the city from ta then it means that more local Revenue has been collected we get less money from State know around what's the you know relationship between the 15% versus the 30 um I do know that uh in the communication that I forwarded to you Stacy Michael had asked USDA and then their recommendation for municipalities and school districts the 15% verus High I think was the question we get 15% this we get 15% that's from this side then we're paying

0161% was 15% yeah so that also was discussed and I think I shared some information from Stacy where the actual 1% that the city would take off the top to administrative fees it means that we would get 1% less but what they would do is then the state would equalize that so we're not going to get any less the district will get the money um taxes those administrative CS are taken off the top then we would get equalized from the state so I think those were some of the questions that you folks had um I know it was a pretty robust conversation the last time um but um that's my understanding um of where we're at and we're asking for this to be first reading if you're not ready to make decision tonight we can

017certainly move it to the next um meeting but I think the last time they talked they really do need a decision by roughly February because that's when there's an opportunity for um mic chip to renew their expansion so question you send an email pretty thorough and the total I just want to make sure is it truly 35,000 or is that like one of those budget items where it's like 35 million you know like yeah so that's a great question because you know ER kind of got from her colleagues at the city what 2023 because we're trying to see okay what would that actually look like remember that Enterprise zones this is for new or expanding so you really can't give you specifics she just used some 23 data so I don't know how relevant that

018is it was just a number that they kind of gave as far as the amount of money but that's actually you know at least in the grand schem I things not necessarily but again um these folks wanted more specific information around what are we talking about are we talking millions are we talking hundreds or thousands of dollars I think that the city did a good job of gathering that information well yeah because if it truly is 35,000 you know you've seen those budgets where it's says 35,000 35 million or something like that truly is 35,000 that's changes my perspective if my worry 350,000 3.5 million something like ginormous impact if there was a def or something like that 35,000 in the grand sche of is my concern that I pointed out to all of you

019was that I didn't know how this might affect um Department if we had to um you know collect the money but you know the reality is we do have folks allocated who they do receivable and accounts payable so we do have staff that could you know push out invoices just don't know how many that's going to be I don't believe we would have to H somebody know until we enter into the agreement and that's where think the IGA if we choose to move forward with this um it's going to be you know flexible where we're going to need to be able to negotiate within the year if things change um but right now I'm cautiously optimistic based on what I heard from the city and what I've talk to Stacy about is that it is

020going to be more work for the district how much I just don't know at this point in time no I understand that and if the IG if the if my understanding is correct that 1% would get basically reimbursed for lack of a better J by the state so we're we're held harmless on that you know 1% of 35,000 350 you know which isn't much and so you take it off your plate I think for me seeing a number like this which is based on data of course it's going to have a new data next year but this helps give you a perspective which which is why I asked the question and um it does put it in perspective we know that it could you know go up by 10% next year we don't know that

021but this P the the clarifications that were helpful for me and I wonder if it was changed all in the resolution or the IG that we have because in the resolution itself says the district or the sponsor of the Enterprise Zone would do such and such like mail out the invoices that is not described in the IGA so if that is the expectation that they are because the next question was if we have to will it be absorbed into a position and again I really appreciate you don't know so we almost have to go through this process to see um but that was the other thing about we've been told that we will be made whole we've been with a nothing in the contract but in an MSD letter mesd letter says the 1% that

022they take off the top will be reimbursed great news that's not in the IG either and not necessarily that it should be but it's it's uh there was something in the IG that said the records will be made available or will be available if we choose to well at least me I would like to be specific on this first first year I want to look at it how much time was used did you have to hire a position were we made whole were we not made so that we can evaluate you know whether or not this is really working for us and if it if it isn't I mean it's got to be a pretty big ding in order for us to take this back but this was really helpful information for me and what

023I can tell you about the IPA it is a draft and you as the board then you would direct your superintendent to ensure that those aspects of the IG are in place make sure that you have updated information so if you would like in a year presentation to say what was the impact of the agreement we can certainly include that but you know there's not spe right now in the IG just because it's a draft so I appreciate the conversation and certainly our team will make sure that it before we agree anything with the city that we have included some opportunity to gather that data as and I think not for this time but it seems like this is every 10 years is that what I understood right it's it's years five five oh every

024five years so every so because it it involves the other school districts just like when we have those legislative meetings all of us in M County have the opportunity to move into it it would be good to discuss things like this too that are local but affect all of us so that we all because I'm still wondering like why 15 over 30 we can potentially get more money for our district why and and is it because and you said that it's because we're trying to make it attractive for businesses well if it's a partnership then you know we're not getting more right that's and that's what that's what Sean clarified right but for like all of us to understand that um like all the other dist all the other board members too like for all

025of us to talk about like yeah what are the benefits to this are there any benefits like what you're asking about um FTE is it how are you guys handling it who's doing it for you that kind of stuff right so we can all be on the same page and also i' probably save um this person time too instead of going to all four districts or five districts to do the same presentation just do it to all of us once and we all ask the questions together and we can all discuss it together okay okay um so this is a first reading we don't have a sample resolution I would feel more comfor on the IG um going through our legal to make sure that some of the questions that have been brought up are

026addressed in particular um as far as the board resolution or where it goes that it's a fiveyear plan I haven't I don't know where that is now there's been so many pieces of paper but um if it's five years then where's that at it's in the resolution where in the resolution it's inter that's actually that's where I'm I'm looking at the resolution and I don't see it okay but it's not in this board resolutions it is not so so it sounds like we need just a little bit more tweaking on it um a little bit more just verification on some of it Myra's uh thought is a good one that we need to make sure that we're coordinating this a little bit better with the other District so that we're not all attacking it in

027a different way we should have a consistent response to it so that they're not having to recreate something every single time they want to do this um and then an annual report of how is it doing they're promising us as an Enterprise Zone to provide jobs I'd really like to know what jobs they're providing and what they're doing that benefits our community well I have to say that um that was part of what the information that we wanted not specifically the jobs but uh I I didn't feel like the information provided to us last time was really a good in terms of I mean like you brought up all the benefits but you brought it up the city didn't and so I think there could have been a much better um educational piece for the

028board about what it was but Chris to that point um Erica from the city said we said well what are the numbers do you know what they are and they said they they aren't required by law in the Enterprise Zone to actually report what the the jobs are that are either gained or lost correct so if we want and I still would love that I mean from an educational white paper anytime this comes before the board the city should provide in an Enterprise Zone the benefit to the school district of participating even if it's uh anecdotal and they can't list specific numbers personally but I didn't ask all these questions till today my bad um so I wasn't going to ask that one because that would have been way too much information to gather but

029I was incredibly impressed with what you were able to gather and clearly it helps to get put it in so as as we now have a little bit more information we've had the presentation some more stuff that's in part of this this um my suggestion is it comes back to the December 4th meeting yeah for Action that's and I will uh ask when this happens be hopefully some of us around to remember but uh it would be nice to see what the actual what are what is collect each year you know right now it was it would have been is it close to that is it closer to something but I think that's a good point that we should clarify in that resolution and or the AA is it just a note to Administration City

030and uh District that we want an annual report not just it's available if we so choose to gather it but we want a report annually so that we can monitor how much is going in how much is going out is that something you want to include I think that's my myp be that's the IG us leveraging political weight to say we made and then that way superintendent so can you add that in there the igga will probably be approved after you make the resolution because we have to run it by attorneys attorneys and so I just wanted to be clear that may not I'm very clear on the expectation that you want within IG do we need to put that in the resolution in order for it to go in the IG or no no

031because that's operations yeah make sure that Mr cook and the team as the information that we will reflect in the IG before it gets our list of things that we get an annual update and the only other clarification for me is that in your response um from Erica at the city it says we will invoice for it and that is not in the IG either it is not clear in the IG that's an expectation we will be C we will be clear so we see the same resolution uh it'll need to be cleaned up a little bit to include perhaps the years and and we'll figure out what goes in the resolution versus what is negotiated with the IG that's but it sounds like we want to at least see some information a resolution should

032have a somewhere somehow that we're doing this for a set amount of time because it says in here we can do it for three to five years but it sounds like somewhere they're telling us they'd like to have it for five years and make sure we have it documented Sean so that in five years yeah people are like what are we doing with this why are we doing this again so okay what's up oh yeah it is bottom the park somebody cut past so and it's a draft and so it's yeah an idea to just hearing over my school board this does enter us into Economic Development sphere and I just wonder if there might be even years develop other political leaders specifically talk more Regional issues we do so many things like with other

033school board members there's value there tightening our bonds a little bit with these County leaders and we haven't had one for a couple of years so coincidentally um I had a good chat with um some of the MoMA County board members at the WBA convention and we put into place some conversation about getting one of those scheduled and so it would include board members it would include local elected so it would it include um our state representatives our Senators the folks that are involved it would include I don't know if we talked about the city specifically but we've done those a couple of times it's just been a few years since we've done one so yes well because you're working on that I would say absolutely include the city particularly because this we are now

034Partners I just don't remember before but I just say throw it in if you haven't because I think that's important and I would also suggest sty she know that she represents and East School Districts and she's the government support state local issues as well so you should start seeing a little bit more Stacy this spring when we start long legislative session but I will make sure I tou Bas with and share that request we'll move it we'll move it forward with a little bit more informtion this yeah and then make sure that we put into place that followup part that's with the other districts because it doesn't make sense to have everybody out there doing it and Stacy going out doing five different presentations doesn't make much sense okay um next up are our information

035items and we have a couple of things so I don't know if you guys it's in order we have it as the fall academic data review transformative social emotional learning seal update and the disciplinary handbook roll out and I know we have guests this evening I'm not sure who's presenting which okay you raise your hand you're presenting on something so we're going to go ahead and go with the academic data there we go and introduce yourself just to make sure that everybody in the room and on watching um good evening I'm Heidi Lasher I'm the director of Elementary curriculum and instruction I'll be sharing Elementary beginning of your data with you today these um our assessments that uh more formal assessments that we conduct in elementary school it's aligned with your four goals of achievement

036data so before you go too far I just have a quick question we have in our board packet for Middle School yes so we don't gotcha gotcha gotcha okay I just want to make sure that don't do that one okay sorry did that okay so before we get started looking at data I thought it would be helpful for us to review the simple view of reading make the data make more sense so the simple view of reading you see we have decoding which is word recognition and your fonic andic awareness and that along with language comprehension which is your background knowledge vocabulary grammar syntax um equals your reading comprehension so we use assessments of dibles which I'll explain more upcoming to measure word recognition and I ready to measure language comprehension I ready to measure

037reading comprehension we use a lot of other Assessments in elementary school classroom formative assessments and lesson data these are on formal assessment that use the Dibbles is the dynamic indicators of early literacy skills and what they measure the there are six sub tests that measure skills that are involved in reading reading works the decoding portion so it measures bonic awareness bonics and decoding and fluencing awareness is hearing the sounds and words decoding this phonics and fluency is the rate in which you can read a word or so first we're going to look at students who measured in dible needing intensive support they needed intensive support with word reading so when you're looking at um data for students needing intensive support you're looking for decreasing numbers over time data over time so we' be looking for

038decreasing numbers because we're looking for Less students who are needing that level support of so here's our data from series of years and what you're going to want to look at is you can go across rows to look at students data to look at a grade level and see how our system is moving and you can look at a diagonal follow the color chart to see how a Cort it's not an intact Cort so there are different students who move in and out of these cohorts to see how students are progressing in a and this is like I said students who measure that they needed intensive forcing numbers 1920 is the last time we measured pre pandemic the measurement that we used was dibles but it was called dibles Next and we now use dibble's

039eth Edition it's a little bit more challenging so keep that in mind too um when students are in about second grade the level the rate that they need to read to the ACT bit faster and there's some additional measures in D State addition so so if the number had not decreased as you hoped it would I mean I know it's still up from 1920 um it's part of that is because of the difficulty well it's just something to take into consideration they aren't the exact same measure's increase so given these numbers what couple of our T key takeaways here are that with a couple exceptions numbers are decreasing across grade levels and cohort and that with the exception of fifth grade we are below pre-pandemic measures in students who measured us needing intensive support any

040idea about why for fifth grade why for fifth grade yeah so if you look at the impact of and then coming back from pandemic the impact their education over time is one of our most imped GRS in country right now we Al started um our uh decoding skills curriculum last year for third fourth and fifth grade and for uh the primary grades we started the year before that as far as intense focus on that this is measuring students who are at or above course so we're looking for increasing numbers here so these are students who measured in this fall beginning of the year indicating that they are at the once again we can look across the rows to see how a grade level is doing so it's more of a systems view of this and

041if you look at diag you're going to see students in a relative homework so we're looking for increasing numbers and oh sorry no I want to see the note numbers across cohorts and grade levels and we have two grade levels that are starting the year above pre pandemic um so my question kind of relates there's a huge job second group and how is that is there an attribution why we see that I mean I have my presuppositions but so in every year seems to be the biggest jump year to year from year to year and that because of the focus third grade literacy is there something changing in a classroom that would amplify those gains um yeah it's changed quite a bit from second grade to third grade the measure is measuring a little bit

042leans a little bit more towards feny and comprehension there is one comprehension measure in there um end so they gain and thenat is that thought the other thing that historically has happened is second grade and fourth grade have been kind of stuck Point historically with our reading data it tends to be a point where we either kind of stall or lag a little bit I know Heidi has some more data we'll talk specifically about those grads um but there's something that happens with those assessments at that time along with our reading but also with our language development assessments as well so there's some developmental things and some kind of expectation things that start to come into play there as well is that that's an education wide Trend t not just a thing yeah so on

043I'm just trying to remember back because dibles is a word I knew and I never actually had Acron to it I just thought was so first grade that testing part of it is that a teacher evaluating a student watching scene as opposed to when we get to fourth and fifth grade are the students doing it electronically or are they still being tested and reviewed by a teacher most of the assessment is 101 there's one sub test where students um read and they fill in blanks okay more and that's more would be like a fourth or fifth grade third grade okay fourth grade but the subtest so just like the sub tests do change over over time even through the course of a year depending on the grade so okay this is a look at second

044grade and you can see it's the previous year's composite score and this year's composite score for all of our students our emerging M school learners and students with IEPs so what we can see here is that we have a growth measure in all groups growth is measured in all groups but our emls measure the largest amount and this is um a celebration for us is often that sometimes we see more of a disc um disproportionality happen so the three between spread students make too this is another one of those years Trac is talking about fourth grade and you see the points of the groups and again our energy multilingual Learners what time of the year did they take the test they take the test three times a year and this is our beginning of the

045year okay we just Agate our dual language programs emerg are are they driving that road or is the bottom didn't so this these are students and there a lot of data in here so I'm going to uh point us to a couple spots um and then I know you're going to learn more di program from on in the future but so if you can see right here our district um students who are at or above four is 48% at fifth grade and for DLI in at least one language 50% of the students are and then when you move over here you see that in DLI the white column 32% in fourth grade and 31% in fifth grade of our emerging multilingual Learners are Arab for in at least one language know districtwide for emerging multilingual

046Learners we have 25% at fourth grade and 18% at fifth grade which takeway here is when both languages are considered de begin to close the gap for emerging with multi owners that make sense to you follow [Music] that so right here if you look at or let's look at fifth grade 31% of our students are at or above in at least one language districtwide the 18% of our students are out of above cour oh got it and when you're become um a language that reading a language those SK transer to your Lear so one of the things that's really exciting for us with this slide is as you look at those first three or four years of DLI if you unpack that data our DLI students are not meeting the the standard um in either

047language at the same rate as our English only students are and you expect that with DLI research you also expect that at fourth and fifth grade and as you go into middle school that's when you really start to see DLI students take up take off and outperform other groups of students and that's what we're starting to see in fourth and fifth grade so our data is nicely falling Al line in line with what we'd expect from a DLI program even though we started it during a Pand that's the other piece of this first help me understand why that so the the because students are learning in just banish they are not passing the assessment in English or Spanish right as you get to fourth grade their skills are becoming stronger in one of the two

048languages that's the part where it's in at least one language so our DLI students are assessed in both English and Spanish and in at least one of those language they are meeting that standard that grade level standard you start assessing them in both languages in second grade they start their English or decoding instruction in second grade and the reason that's so important research shows that if you can gain literacy skills in one language y you're much more likely to gain literacy skills in any language you learn right and so we're seeing that Gap stting to and most students do it by third grade but theoretically and historically by fifth grade they're fully bilingual but a lot of students do it by so now we're moving on to I already already Diagnostic and what this is

049an Adaptive measure that students take at their fbook and we use this to support our instructional decisions but also um we use this as a data a formal data point what students are doing and I ready is uh we use this more to measure the comprehension part of the simple view of reading whereas di we just talked about is to we use that to measure word decoding dibles is more sensitive to the word decoding and then I ready is more sensitive measure for the um comprehension literature literature and information t Okay so this is a view of our fall fall data and it is you can see the the um scale bottom near or above grade level is green lighter green is really on grade level on grade below is yellow and so on so

050forth this is measuring end ofe grade level standards students now to where the standards that they would be at at the end of the school year what we're working on for comprehension is our next steps with um language comprehension is we have 93 teachers across the district throughout the school year up to the spring are participating in learning walks centered on an analytical reading and writing routine to um work on language comprehension skills so the 2425 data is projected for year end 2025 no this is where they measure right now end of your grade level standards so the 2425 is measuring the end of the last two sh and measuring right now students are compared to end of your grade level yes so oftentimes they haven't been taught yet yes that also 22 23 that

051end of year that was beginning of Year let measuring comparing beginning of your each year um it looks like maybe I'm seeing it wrong but I'm trying to do the C thing seems like there's more kids going into the and de bre from to from first to third first so the Deep Bread's not possible before third grade because second grade is two levels below there you go so I mean but uh 29 + 22 is 53% 51% so like third graders in 23 24 19% 29% in yes I and if you go back so you have 51% are in the red whether it's cheap or not third grade second grade was 41% first grade it was 14% as a curious Trend and it doesn't seem like there's that much of an incre I mean there

052is an increase in degree there's not that much of increase in um one of the things that I'll share with you bounce ahead just a little bit to show um here the the red arrow on the left shows the um the sequence of interviewing and starts with bological awareness frequency bonics vocabulary and comprehension we've put a lot of effort in the last two years on word recognition and word decoding and not that we haven't done professional development and language comprehension but this year we are really inly focusing on learning lots for like mentioned those 93 teachers who are going through classrooms and learning um an analytical reading and writing routine that is partnered with our ELD Department to make sure that we have exled it more meeting um strategies that the needs of all Learners

053within that routine so that is that is the area of focus for us you are that should our teachers going to be um serving teachers in other schools or just teachers in their own School they just observing teachers from school and teachers in their own I think the other thing to remember with I ready is one of the things that we look at probably more than this data is mid year and end of year and look at the growth and it does help us identify what typical growth would be for a student as they're making progress through the year or um what stretch thank you stretch growth and so those are the pieces that become really important with an assessment like this where right now we're testing them on things they haven't been instructed on

054yet which is different than dibles where it's more Dynamic for what's happening like at that point in the year and where kids should be so that's just an important thing to remember when we're looking at I ready data and one thing you can see about looking at these domains here um with that focus on Phonics you can see more of the in increase across Bonet all across for now um thing I was going to share with you is this show shows um National um measurements as well so the middle the middle column is the year to date where student house students perform nationally year to date national average you can kind of see how we compare jimy is a growth [Music] okay yeah absolutely and one slide that I did Skip was comparison by the

055dis difference the disproportionality I mentioned how um we're working across departments to make sure that every professional development that we provide make sure that strategies are included that support our emerging M than langual Learners and we're also working across distri on co- planning with classroom teachers and EML Specialists and special education teachers what if yes and no sorry yes means yes you um are an emerging m a learner and no means you're not according to and this is the why behind us really focusing all of our efforts around EML right really thinking about uh students that aren't performing not supporting the same way as we are't other students it's part of the why behind us starting D and thinking about how do we support students differently that are learning um in two Lang and it's

056a focus for um our Target SCH Improvement as well and the strategies particular scaffolding strategies that work for merg and bilingual students work for monolingual students definitely was positive it was great growth when will we see that um transposed to here that's what we're that's what we're looking for bro for that it is it's connected right I mean you would assume that as you press and continue that it will show up here so I'm saying that we're on the right track we things in place we've had you know positive outcomes in an area that ultimately will manifest in another area as long as we stay on course right you have to have the skills that are measured by Dibbles developed first to then be moving into the skills that are more measured by that already

057so it is they do assess different things to be able to read the the um assessment and answer the questions the skill that you're getting that's measured in dibles you're better able to read the the test that you're being assessed on what do you call what um more the word recognition Bic awareness okay and is that I'm just trying to pie together is that some the governor and od's push toward more direct instruction those foundational reading skills that are about how do I break down a word and learn to read it yeah it went to Cycles like depending on when you were trained to be a teacher you learned to teach phonetics and then they told us not to and then we're being told to but like districtwide in every classroom phonics instruction is happening

058with Fidelity across every classroom in in our school district 8 through three and third through fifth grade they just started their Journey last year they received their training and started last year and pay through to they um this is their second year of full implementation and I'm sorry hav po it so in a traditional like in your in your textbook your phonetic focus is K through two then three is when they start reading for comprehension we do all of it in all gr levels and the word study is more advanced in third through fifth grade but K through two it's it's more basic that me more complicated Works to pronounce read yeah and working on um different vocabulary they all but all gr levels also work on the language comprehension portion of the reading as

059well have 30 minutes in word decoding and then the rest comprehension okay so now we're moving in the math and this is the I ready diagnostic that same diagnostic we talked about but this is for math so measures math in the different domains listed there numbers and operations algebra and algebra thinking measurement data and geometry and it does measure students according to the end of your grade level standards so this is a look at fall to fall for math I'm still seeing the same TR is that a byproduct of the assessment maybe or is that the true major of their you mean they incre because doesn't so I know first I read pretty and so you know it doesn't look like we're making a lot of games as a matter of fact it makes looks

060like we're losing ground each year is it that we are truly losing ground in our or is it that the test is maybe not the best their I think and this is the beginning of your assessment so we're looking for and yeah um I ready is a test that kids have to read so there are there are questions to read on a computer and so if you're so one of the reasons we start with reading instruction is because reading instruction impacts all the other subject areas and so just thinking about speculating a bit about what you're asking Sean it might be about the level of reading that's also associated with these tests that actually math is potentially a piece of because I I also know star 360 was you it has that read question in

061so I wonder and if you can get kids to do that and some of those things yeah SN time we have a long way to go in that you would expect a cohort from third to Fourth to 5ifth to start higher in the red because we're the amount of skills that they wouldn't know and hadn't had previously in fourth and fifth grade increase right so this is just the beginning of the year but that is expected in in I ready because here you're also measuring standards that they need to know by the end of the stret Lear saying this is acceptable but I am saying you would expect to have a higher percentage in the Deep bread As you move into more complex math yeah just going to yes because you're adding fraction you're adding

062like get and there's a for Day promotion and great advancement is automatic that I doesn't matter deep in the dark red you are is that social emotional reasons certainly not it's more res Reas you hold students back that lik almost and each student grows at a different rate when it comes to academic skills so some one boy might just be plateauing for a couple of years then suddenly them back solve that my was just struggling went is the district's position generally that's not we'll walk the parents through the research there have been times when we've said yeah that's okay it's not an absolute that you two or three in my career though I mean so there are when you walk parents through the research then you find out how we can support that and get

063those ideas that tends to be the most effective this part of a broad conversation I guess I just I I believe I I believe you and I think the the difficulty from parents view is like you got a child who struggling they they can't get on IEP because they're showing any if they're showing any growth no IEP and then you watch them flounder at home trying to catch up with their peers and they're they're dropping relative but as long as they're making just straight line gains they were yesterday there's no IEP and I think that's what I'm conru and and my question would be what's the um level of support that the child that's now in the Upper Grade Student that's up Upper Grade that is not prepared to do that does the teacher then

064have to teach at that student's level or is the student just expected to catch up or stay up as best they can it's a combination of a lot of that what can be done in class to help a kid act um what can we do to help parents at home support students is there a reason to reevaluate we spend uh you're also asking some pretty complex because we can spend a few hour love to do some pretty complex things on laws that have changed over the last 40 years for good reason of what we've learned about child development and then why are we stilling schools we are because of what we now know there's a huge conversation about this naturally what should we be doing differently because we've learned so much about that's not really

065where we are now having have conversation that's really where you guys are at and your question right in point the other thing that's happening really a lot right now is the ability for kids to access using technology now having things read to them that we didn't have 20 and 30 years ago how they can dictate and have access and avoid that skill problem of I got to write this down and this stresses me out the tools that we have available now that we're not using as well because we just haven't embraced them as much yet could give kids a greater access and increase learning and help them keep up a lot better so it's a really Broad conversation lots of questions that you're asking are very good but it's also the foundation of mtss yes

066like when we start to talk about an mtss system that looks at how kids are performing and looks at a whole kid like what's the how does attendance play into this how does behavior supports play into this if when we're looking at a whole student and thinking about how do we support students that's what MTS I'm looking at Michelle because we all know she does MTS but um that's how we've looking then systemically what do individual students need how do we support them what really is the challenge is the challenge really about math or is the challenge because they're not coming to school so what we need to do is figure out how to support the family and getting the kid to school it is not about attendant and it is about academics and what's

067going on there that we can start to figure out to then determine is it an IEP is it not is it you know what's the opportunity of the kids missing to help them make the growth that we need them May to build on that because I was thinking just that um when next time that we see this data like and maybe having some examples of what the tears of support look like under each level these are interventions that we here just so we can put the two together yeah and what teachers um get from this assessment as well and from ongoing um students engage in I ready you know that on their pH book every day what they learn is what are just right cors students need to work on that matches the classroom instruction

068so there's there's additional small group instruction that takes for students who aren't there yet um I ready assessment uh like skill assessment is that a is that perfectly aligned with state standard so like if we were interested in exploring what is 3 standard they're Aline I think it'd be really cool if you have a teacher who's do a good job with that like implementing the ntss supports with their literacy instruction or instruction to have them come and share what they're doing in their classroom not that I don't like hearing from you B that's my remind that we are newly adopting I right now so there's a lot of professional development and math lab um opportunities and lesson St that are happening across our schools right now yeah I was just going to say that just

069to read the chart too from 2324 to 24 25 that's the same cohort of kids from fourth grade to fifth grade and so that same cohort of kids tested only 8% were in the green and then in fifth grade that same group of kids there now 11% and um the red zone is roughly the well it's a little bit higher by about one percentage point but you'll see the yellow has shrunk and so what that means is that they are making there is a gap but it's the Gap at the red is roughly the same and the green grew by 3% so I think that that's also telling about like it's not just within grade bands but it's that cohort of kids that you're working with over a period of time which is another way

070to look at theow and this is a look at our English in as well I get it just reinforces our work on crosscutting strategies to support our n and we'll continue to monitor grow crossfitting strategies are strategies that you um become familiar with and EXP kind of expertise so that we can help teachers across grade levelings and across School consistency for kids right so if third grade teachers are using similar strategies to fourth grade to fifth grade kids connect how they did something across grades well I don't know if hey or new Tracy have mentioned to to remind our board that when we have targeted schools it comes with additional funding for to provide that P for eming federal funding it's one of title three is one of the federal funds in future presentations I

071think BL asking how Aline is it to the state test it would be interesting to see like uh end of your data compared to the state test you know how many pass the state test versus how many you know green with this and I would venture to guess there probably more kids passing the state test than are [Music] GRE to see the Gap this is the beginning of your data but be interesting just to see that data and see how how well does it because I know nationally yes course maybe it correlates it doesn't really correlate okay so this is um a comparison over years in each domain see the increases are for beginning of year beginning of year to beginning of year and then this was that same um similar slide that we found

072read for map compared to national Norms in National year to date does some of that have to do with the number of days that students are in class doesn't Oregon have one of the shortest years if we're comparing National to I'm all for year me too I am too I I did it while we were in this District manyo year round year round scho I taught year round and I yeah I was a student in year round and I loved it and that is the last slide that I have for you so thank you the data with me apprciate it but wait there's more Kathy were you gonna say that well I I want to just uh reflect on the data that we got and how easy it was to read and reflect I think

073the level of conversation reflects how easy it is and I I'm sure it had nothing to do with what we've been asking for but if it did it's exactly what I was looking for and I appreciate seeing that um areas where we haven't improved yet because that's where we get from done so jumping from elementary to middle school and before we jump in I just want to say the conversation around growth is going to be the same conversation we have with st with them this is the first year we've offered star and so we don't have the same opportunity to look at growth over time and so this is more Baseline presentation in terms of here's where we are and some of the things we're doing in relation to some of the known challenges we

074have around ourl students and also our special ed students um so you'll see some of that as we go through but recognize this is just a baseline um and I'm excited to come back in the winter time to talk about growth specifically as we work with st and they've emphasized over and over over as we've done some trainings getting teachers and administrators up to speed like I said time and time again here how you read the data but wait till you get your second data we just start looking at what grow looks like and the impact that the instructions having on student learning so recognized with this one um as opposed to I ready with growth over time this is really taking a look at our kind of our Benchmark uh before we jump into

075our data point number two that happens in January so with that star what we're using at the middle school grade 6 through eight uh this is aligned to the achievement goals that board has set so once again looking at data specifically uh two piece to this one the first one is what is star uh why did we change and move away from high ready we had been using High ready for a number of years at the middle school level we shift it over to Star and then we'll take a look at what did our Baseline assessment tell us so let's start with what is star and why do we choose it first so with that star is an online assessment similar to I ready it's research based it offers Assessments in both language arts and

076math um it can be used both as a screening tool and also as a progress monitoring tool so one of the elements star the our teachers on attractive um you can not that this is best practice but you could have a student literally take the star assessment every day the test bank is large enough that the student won't receive duplicate questions um so if you wanted to you could test a student every single day of the school year because the test Bank allows that um we don't use it that way but it's a robust um number of questions and it's a robust framework around assessing students as far as the design is concerned helping Educators it's really around thinking about how do we identify student needs within the classroom um how do we use how

077do we use the set to drive instruction and our teachers are still in the process of learning that um how do we have to set realistic goals around growth so back that focus on growth over time that grow mindset um and then taking look at how to attract progress through the year both on an individual level and then also as a classroom thinking about that growth mindset to go through so that's what starts about in a nutshell there we go what does it measured uh on the language art side of things basic vocabulary basic comprehension literacy is about plot character analysis theme development those sorts of things being able to identify author intent uh so analyzing structures of passages and even getting into analyzing arguments are the things that the language art site covers math

078is more traditional numbers and operations algebraic reasoning geometry measurement stat um start Mees on the math we ran a pilot this last year our teachers are looking for a diagnostic to replace I ready uh one of the challenges that our teachers found with I ready is that there's no time limit so some students were taking three four five days to complete the I assessment the Middle School level some students Relish in the fact that it took that many days to complete the assessment um so our teachers are looking for something that would take less time out of the classroom um but still provide valid and reliable data um the star assessment is much shorter takes about 40 minutes to complete so so just that in and of itself is a savings of a couple of

079class periods for many many students it is aligned to State Standards um and I'll show you Sean in just a few minutes uh the correlation graph that we have math is a much stronger correlation than reading but you'll see that just a moment it's available in Spanish which is important to us knowing that our di program is going into sixth grade this next year um and we also wanted to make sure that we had teachers do some beta testing course this last spring both general education special education teachers all across the board um I'm not sure that we piloted it in EML classes but we did have EML books looking at this specifically as far as tool is concerned once again the focus in the empasis on growth is one of the things that our

080teachers were drawn to as far as specific before you go into the data I love this why and that was kind of I ready is would we ever consider because of y with the star switching to Star because of all of these great things versus an I ready to the elementary the I is Led our curriculum so it um it's not just diagnostic teachers use that for in and it's a lineol so they can get a report from already that helps them understand where they need to support student both both assessments are aligned to the state standard so they can still see the standards are being are meeting yes and they measure in different ways so with star specifically the way star measures so even though they talk about standards a student does not get

081a question on every standard in math every standard in language arts what it does is it's a computer adaptive test and it starts asking questions and a student gets the question right it ask different questions more difficult and so it tries to just triangulate what a student knows and table do based on just a 40 minute snapshot so to speak so in terms of which one is more robust um I think I already has more questions which would tend to make me think it's a more robust assessment but the correlations that star is able to do because they have so many students that have been run through the star diagnostic is they're actually pretty accurate with that 40 minute snapshot in terms of kind of connecting dos backwards to what students know on our but

082recognizing the assessment is a little different terms of the way that it's structured um and it's guessing it's it's approximating um what students should be able to do in regards to math so that's an important piece recognize as well star in my understanding was developed to be a predictive IT background so to speak and so you'll see when we get to the data um a lot of the data sections is around predicted state test scores so even though the students have tested in the fall with star has done is run a whole bunch of stats on students in Oregon and it a based on where students tend to be who score like this here's what we predict they'll score in the spring time and the predictions are actually fairly close the accuracies well you'll see

083the probation in just a moment so how did our students do um the first thing I want you to see here as far as participation is concerned um we're a little lower in participation than we were with I ready when we offered that and part of it was just our teachers getting up to speed on learning the new tool the new Diagnostic and those sorts of things also want to point out that students have to change to take the Diagnostic in Spanish or in English um and about 1% of our students opted to take Spanish this time around um as far as the language of practice so um either one is validated whether they take it in Spanish or English students have a chance to do that those are the only two languages that star

084offers they don't offer other languages I would want to take it in both and take the high score what better I yes um so Sean this was your question so along the bottom of the graph is the students score from spring osas math test and on the uh y AIS is their math percenti ring from stop and so what you see is if a student scored low or towards the left on their osas spring score they were fairly low percentile rank on their star assessment this fall on the opposite end of the spectrum that they scored well this last spring what we notice is they actually tended to score fairly well on the star assessment in the fall so there's a pretty strong correlation between how they did on osas and spring and how they

085did on Star and and the correlation provides a nice I doing research I'd be very happy with that is a little less clear um and this is where my mind goes to I'm curious is the issue the assessment either on the Osa side of things Star side of things because when you take a look at students that scored poorly on osas so the numbers are off to the left side of the lower axis You' got kids scoring from the 0 percentile to 100 percentile even though they scor poorly on the OAS is the issue the osas assessment is the issue star do they take the test seriously not sure but with that you can still see there is a slight correlation um because as students um are scoring higher in terms of the percentile they

086are scoring higher as far as the OS is concerned so there's a little bit of a correlation but it's nowhere [Music] near if they didn't take one or the other there there's no data yeah you in the way coration you wouldn't have a data plot point if you didn't take both that's what I want to see that's pretty nice further you are yes yeah whereas this one all of this right here see all of this right here in this kind of quadrant I'm really curious about because what I want to see is I want to see a nice line that's linear going low to high so this is a lot of noise that I don't know what's going on and I'd like to know are those two separate test oh good question um yeah so

087the state reading test or the state language arts has has both a language art section which incorporates both writing and reading and it also has a reading component that's pulled out as far as process is concerned but you can see that the graphs look very similar whether I'm looking at either just the reading subscore or looking at the whole language arts that incorporates reading and writing together there's not much of a difference in terms of that correlation thank you so let's start with the star reading first this is comparing by and large to the state Benchmark what that means is star gives us the ability to compare students either to a state Benchmark so are they meeting a certain standard or it gives us the ability to compare to a National Standard which simply ask

088the question how are people doing relative to What city's ask to so it's not standards based on the national level it's just asking on average how are people doing um and so you'll see that in just a moment the data that we're look at though is that state Benchmark like how are we doing relative to what the state standards are in that particular gr so with this I wanted to just do a quick compar comparison of star to IR know that they're measuring similar outcomes and what I want to see here the IR scores from middle school in the fall of 2022 are on the left and the star scores from the fall of 2024 um and to me I don't want to make a big deal about hey there's less green that's good as

089opposed to I ready they're two different assessments so I don't want to make too much of a comparison what I do see is that I see more students that aren't meeting grade level in both I ready and star and I see a much smaller group of students at the very top who are at or above grade and so what that tells me in terms of a diagnostic result is these are measuring similar sorts of things even though the the greens and the blues and the reds are the same size I wouldn't expect them to be as different students for coming off the pandemic in 2022 um so there are differences in the measure and that's something that's important to account um but they're measuring similar things this one was interesting to me because the graph

090on the right stay exactly the same it didn't change the gra oh excellent from s so um the graph on the left is actually asking the question how do our students compare to everybody else who's taken the star assessment across the US um so we look at the state benchmarks we can see there's plenty of growth for our students in order to meet State benchmarks but what the graph on the left tells me is that a lot of our students regardless of the state that they're living in um are below grade level standards or St differently that that large pink um on the left that's about 50% of our students are at or above the national average which means if you put all of our students in a line half of them are at that

091Center Mark or above which means half of them are at that Center Mark or below we're basically average as far as the nation is concerned as far as our reading results go um which says if we just compare ourselves to who's standing next to us that's great but whoever standing next to us whether Oregon Washington the you name it the arena scores that are down across the nation so that's why I want to stick with State benchmarks because that's going to let us know how we're doing relative to the the line we want so um questions on those I'm going to fly through these fairly quickly um because this is just taking a look at breaking down how did our students do by grade level and then also by ethnicity Race by EML and by

092special education status and one of the things with this one particularly grade six seven or eight the thing that jumped out to me is it's fairly consistent in terms of the needs of our students regardless of grade level so the Box on the side level four that kind of pink box those are students that are above grade level the blue box is level three students are at grade level level two and level one are students that are below or well below grade level um the other piece that I think is encouraging with this for those students in that purple box about 25% of our students um was just some additional support taking place inside of a classroom setting what star predicts is that those students will be able to make it to State benchmark scores

093or state passing State Benchmark by the time spring rolls around um the other thing to know is that a predicted score isn't Destiny right and start emphasizes that over and over again so this is based on how the students score in the fall this is actually predicting what they think our scores will be in the springtime so um that's an important thing to remember it's not looking at their score right now saying where they were based on typical growth and those sorts of things here where we predict they would be um is that is that a comparison that you you expect to use this what start would be in this actually we would when spring rolls around for sure so taking a look at had here right that's something I'm very curious about like how

094accurate is star and I'm also curious for those students that are in that kind of purp Zone who are close or what star predicts is close to being a benchmark I'm curious how we're doing it in terms of helping those students actually gain the skills they need and grow perhaps even a faster rate than what typical growth would be once again that emphasis with starsone grow how we help students grow and meet the out of the other graphs um this is by ethnicity this is mirroring what our state data test from ESS we have an achievement gap between students that are white and our B students which makes me think about how is our system serving the students and how can we change that outcome the other interesting piece as I working with some of

095our principles with this data ex said it's really interesting that regardless of the ethnic group or racial group that the students are part that purple box remains about 25% regardless students are and that was an intriguing aha or finding which is similar to where we were right here when you take a look at sped versus nonsp it's a little small but yes means they are in sped that's on the left no means they're not in sped and the Gap that we're seeing predicted outcomes in the spring based on Fall results is exactly what we seen in the past Ness data and the same thing is true with our EML students as well one of the things that's interesting with this one so EML no is on the far left yes those are students that are

096currently in an EML class receiving Services monitored are students that are exited from receiving services on a daily basis but we still Monitor and check and see if they're growing um as far as the state is concerned what's interesting to me with this is our data for students that are no longer getting daily services in EML and for those that are post monitor your data is very similar to those that are no that have not been in an email program which tells you that they learning is robust um and so we have work to do as far as our email students are concerned that's that large green column there that says yes and that's also the reason that we're targeting School Improvement and so some of the things that we're doing specifically around um reading

097with emls as so Blake you talked about phonics routines Even in our sixth grade this is our second year doing some phonics routines in our language arts classes at sixth grade level because what we found with our Dibbles data on fifth grade our students read there isn't any issue with that but what we have found is that they're reading really really slow so it takes them a long time to process words so as they're reading if you gave them a passage they could tell you what every word was in the passage but it takes them so long to get through a sentence by the time they get to the end of the sentence they forgot start of the sentence said and so what we're doing with the phonics is trying to help that reading become

098more automatic with our students knowing that that's going to be a skill that will help them regardless of contant area also we've been partnering with our email Department this year and we have email coaches that were hired with our Target Improvement dollars and they're working with all of our content area teams at the middle school level um doing co- teing strategies um meeting with small groups and even having the ELD teacher join the cohorts talking about how we can embed strategies for email students into the General Ed content um so students whether they're in an email classroom in the general classroom marting supports just like Myra talked about we know that the supports that are good for emails our students all the way across it's going to be interesting to see what those bars look

099like when DLI rolls up to 100% um also site specifically we also have some coaching support um at Clear Creek trying to build teacher capacity around esol that's for speakers of other languages and then also Dex marcardi has their newcomers group for students that are brand new to the US and so working with them specifically ways to support their learning them accl to the US system you'll see this slide when it comes up again after math it will look very similar because the email coaches are working across language arts science social studies math Etc question Sean look you're about to just in case um for math you'll see that the story is very similar with I guess the aster we have more work to do in that by and large um you can see again

100I ready is on left stars on the right comparing 2022 to 2024 this one is much more similar in terms of the widths of our colors that you can see here which again tells me that I ready and star are measuring sorts of outcomes uh the number of students that are well below grade level in math um is significantly more for the reading is about 45% um whereas for our math it's about 65% so a significant difference in terms of that outcome uh once again looking looking at our state Benchmark that's there on the right to the National Benchmark um whereas in Reading you're about average in math or below the national average only about 40% of our students are at or above the national average kind of large pink it says 37% um so

101what that tells me is with reading we're on average with our peers across the US with math we are not um take any indication about issue students below National their National peers or is it that's a good question I don't looked at the National Data or the Statewide data for Oregon um I can easily pull it up and next time to see if Oregon is is below historically our math for on o are lower than readings for yes traditionally so um by by about 20% signicant I mean if we were all other districts in Oregon OD should be on fire this because obviously we're different and that's well this is partly the reason why at the middle school level we've adopted middle school math because doing math in the same is giv us the do

102that we see here um and so taking the recommendations of the National Council teachers of mathematics bringing and will discourse bring dialog doing more deep understanding of mathematical Concepts less kind of root drill sorts of things but helping students understand the connections between Concepts and math is the direction that we're going and so one of the things I'm curious about is to what extent will that also have an impact on our students ability to demonstrate math these are going to be fairly similar we've seen before the only difference is the green bar is going to be higher um again predicted scores are fairly consistent across trade levels in this case uh that purple bar we reading was about 25% we're just right there slightly below grade level uh for math about 20% so once again

103that green bar in terms of what star predicts well below grade level is a greater number of students um same sort of pattern that you see in Reading is is similar here again the green bars are simply taller same Gap we're talking special ed um and that same pattern holds true with our EML students where our postm monitored and our monitored students um are having outcomes or predicted out that are very similar to our students that are no longer or that never were in email so once again we have work to do support our email students as far as the system is concerned so as far as the data goes this isn't I think an assessment of our students necessarily to the ex is an assessment system serving our kids in ways we can improve

104that working uh like I said you've seen the slide before we're doing the same sorts of things with math that we're doing small groups our email coaches are working with all of our middle schools for coaching support to Ed strategies into classes that are consistent and then with that the other pieces that we're doing B Star is new for us we spent some time already in September and October doing an initial dive into what is the data how do we access it what does it mean um in January we spending some time on the growth measure component of star um and unpacking how to use a growth measure to impact our instruction and then finally in March doing some more work with star around small group instructional practices and how you can use the data

105to inform those pieces the other piece that we're doing um with our coaches we've got a professional um we meet on a monthly basis and our professional learning is around how do we embed strategies that Target both our EML and our special ed students into all of our coaching professional living opportunities um that we offer to our teachers so as an example uh we had a buing opportunity in October where we have middle school and high school together um and our email coaches um had us embed sentence structures and sentence frames into all of our professional learning and model what does it look like to have sentence structures and sentence frames in math or in sence in social studies um and sentence frames are one of those strategies where you give students part of a

106sentence so instead of giving them the entire sentence you give them e apart and they kind of fill in the blanks so to speak um and so our coaches are able to model that with their email coaches AC content areas I've gone through pretty quickly uh because I was trying to be conscious at the time any question is when when would we get another I think the board retreat end of February we will do um midyear assessments mid January we should be ready to go for the retreat how are parents access the or start assessments for next students so um that's one of the questions we've asked star star actually has um individual student reports that we can print up and send home uh because it's so new our teachers are still in the process

107of trying to figure out how do you access them who want print them can we send them on electronically so the answer is yes but our teachers are still trying to figure out how do we do that in addition and all soci conferences so yes it is on the horizon fors with those similar to I ready it talks about here's some of your strengths that your student demonstrated here's some things that you may want to work with your student at home or some ideas that you might find helpful in working your child right all right um I realized we have two more um presentations I'm GNA say a 10 minute bre I to stand up e e e morning we're back welcome g board of education November 20th work session next up is uh presentation

108transformative social emotional learning car again hi [Music] that was still oh look at that I hello good evening um so I am going to be sharing a little bit about transformative social emotional learning um and these are kind of our three big objectives understand od's requirements for transformative seal um understand our plan and next steps and then I don't know that we'll have time but I'll give you a little tool in the slide deck in case you want to go practice at home um so first things are that I wanted to highlight where this fits into the board conditions so really social emotional learning and we'll talk a little bit more about this is another way to say Workforce ready skills soft skills skills necessary for being a successful adult out in the world those

109are all different ways um of talking about social emotional learning and they address safety they also address belonging um I added achievement down there because once we start looking at the standards you will start to see the language that is in your board conditions spreaded throughout social emotional learning um so our framework in our district is um to focus on building capacity or organs not ours is to focus on building capacity for strengthening Equity Focus School cultures support student student well-being uh it's going to come up here intentional focus on social and emotional elements of learning and teaching so when Heidi and Tim were here we were talking about teaching and learning and I think I don't somebody said is this is this just social emotional um learning right like why is there a Gap

110and I think part of it is that when kids have a sense of belonging when they are connected to school when they're connected to the content and have a sense of agency you start to see them demonstrate these other um academic skills and growth and so it's not a precursor for learning but it is definitely something that supports engagement in content um um it's a transformative approach in that it teaches the whole child versus just a set of skills Builds on their strengths perspectives and contributions guides the interactions and relationships between students and adults and we're going to talk a little bit about adults and equip students with skills needed for college career and life and I kind of touched on that so this is the difference between social emotional learning and transformative at the

111so historically social emotional learning some of us have taught it there's skills taught in single class or grade a counselor comes in and says this is how you're nice to your friends right um what we're talking about is how are they integrated into all context so it's not just a 11 but that teachers and students have a better understanding of how to be like work with one another how to acknowledge what's going on and work through that that um emotions are really thought of as like this is your issue you're angry this is the thing I have to manage with the individual student versus why are you angry what's the what's the context in which you're angry um and then how do we understand the environment as it impacts your behavior versus your personal self-management

112not it's not that you're not helping students develop personal self-management but the adults and the kids themselves start to understand how the environment that they're sitting in how they're feeling is impacting that behavior um it also focuses on emotion as an individual Choice versus related to how students are experiencing their interactions with peers and then students as recipients of learning as in they're just sitting there getting taught versus students engaging with their own sense of agency belonging and connection and those are many of the same core characteristics that are precursors to um professional learning skills to professional skills for us to be adults we have to have a sense of agency even if depending on what our jobs are to be adults we have to know that we you know we belong in that Workforce

113or often times we don't stay for us to have that sense of um connection then we are more we tend to perform better in workplaces so they're very strongly connected this is the picture that the state has put together to describe five different characteristics of the framework which is they um talk about the conditions for Learning and thriving and you'll notice that yellow maps to the yellow over here there are the guiding principles which are kind of considered their Roots um and there are five guiding principles trauma informed strength spased Community responsive culturally responsive and grounded in Neuroscience which is really interesting stuff when it comes back to things like I ready or start um St uh then we have the standards which I'll talk about in a moment right here that's all of this

114outcomes adult seal is a huge part of this youve all heard many times in board meetings about adults feeling like they're not being supported like kids are disregulated like doesn't feel like an emotionally safe place for adults this doesn't address all of that so I wouldn't want it to pretend oversell it but having adults have a place to have the sense of well-being and connectedness with other adults within the school Community to feel a sense of belonging themselves supports them and being able to support kids um and then the student transformative SEO so that's the state framework this is our timeline which was last spring we pulled together a planning team of about 60 folks they spent four times about half day each unpacking the standards and really mapping out what we wanted to do

115in terms of implementation each one of those folks went back to their schools and they engaged in a series of conversations with students about social emot like how they feel in the schools and we developed a common vision and Mission part of the plan then is to implement this year adult transformative seal professional development so we already launched um one of those in August right now our schools are working with staff and staff meetings on the second of the series and then um we are also concurrently going through a curriculum adoption with our um with our health adoption so that because a lot of the standards are the same and so we are develop we're adopting a curriculum that will be rolled out next year okay 12 and it will probably be by grade band

116it's not necessarily the same curriculum day 12 and then um we will review the plan and adjust we will have ongoing professional development while we implement the curriculum and we will go from there be in health glasses then or is this outside of Health like in an advisory so in elmentary it will be there's a block of time um twice a week I wish IID were here I'd have to look at the elementary schedule but during their soft start in circle time um in Elementary in middle and high school it's middle is advisory and some complimentary work in health where the standards already overlap and that that's why we're meeting with health teachers to find out where the standards already overlap and and then in um at high school similarly but because they only have

117to have one full credit of Health throughout their four years it's a slightly different it'll probably be much more integrated they may not it's more like they'll pull lessons within their other content areas and that high school it becomes much more about supporting the adults and integrating it into content but we also have advisory um as a component of that so the cellpd for teachers is that how to support students with sell or is it spell for them it's for them but it's so it's for them so we're gonna have therapy well I mean I mean every but that'd be great it's really also just about one of the things we've heard from a lot of adults in the planning was that we they keep hearing you need to self-regulate adults kept hearing you need

118to self-manage and they're like we don't have the tools to do that you're telling me to do something that I've never been T I didn't go to be a science teacher to learn that I need help with that but also how do they regulate themselves exactly that's what I'm saying that they were saying that they felt like they were being told to regulate themselves oh I got that they were being asked to regulate kids no they are being told to regulate themselves and they did they needed support with that or they're being told to manage kids they hadn't been given the proper support and either way you need it both in order for you what we know from neurosciences that if you can't I mean in anybody who's gotten frustrated with their own child knows

119that if you can't regulate yourself the whole thing escalates um right I mean I can say that from the personal experience and so I think that that um the more adults can have self-awareness the better they are and then the better our kids are okay um okay so in the plan we created a in um a two pager one is in Spanish and the other is in English we wrote um our mission and vision it was a very um broad representation of Staff we had classifi we had custodial we had folks from Tech we had classroom teachers and counselors and administrators and and we had a lot of representation from our DLI programs um and what we did was create uh went through a process of creating some mission and vision and we decided to

120start it in Spanish because often times things especially in the emotional realm don't translate from English to Spanish so we decided to go from Spanish to English and see if how that would work so we actually wrote a lot of this in Spanish first and then we translated it into English um especially the mission and vision and so the mission we said is let's transform our systems and practices through social emotional learning to uplift all voices and create more inclusive schools and then all members of the community gbsd community will experience a c culturally relevant Equity centered climate that celebrates the diversity of all individuals and fosters connection and well-being so then you can kind of see what it's a this is a similar representation to what I showed you on the earlier slide so

121let me get to the standards so these are the standards for seal there are five of them um and in front of you you have both the well you I just showed you the plan it's also in the slide deck and then these are the five standards so self-awareness and identity self-management and agency social awareness and belonging relationship skills and collaborative problem solving and responsible decision- making and curiosity I just want you to take like 20 seconds 30 seconds and in your own work context what of these skills and if you've ever supervised somebody or hired somebody or started something what of these skills would you like to see adults have not in schools but in the workforce oh which ones do you feel like like for you personally um which ones do you feel

122like and you could take a minute like wow I wish you don't have to say this but gosh I wish that when I were in school we would have been taught this or maybe I wouldn't have been you know suspended so many times or I wish my kid knew blah blah blah so I'm trying to really have you personalize it think about putting yourself either in your work context or your personal life into these standards and see if you can find yourself and then I'm going to show you a quick video hopefully it works mad when my brother hits me I don't like when I'm mad my brain can get a headache and it can start hurting your blood keeps pumping because you're like really mad and you start to get sweaty because you're getting

123really really mad then when you start getting really mad you turn R when your body can't really control yourself your body just get out of control it's kind of like if you had a jar and then the jar would be your brain and then you put glit in the jar and that would be if you shook up the jar in the glitter went everywhere how your mind BS like spinning around and then you don't to think and you sometimes punch stuff and people when you don't really mean it when I get angry I feel it in my heart I really don't like when I care but the tries to keep it down I like feel like I want to you know get really angry and yes I just like sometimes find a place can Bea

124I need to come down I take breath I bre [Music] my Sometimes I close my eyes or just like it's coming down it's like not like moving it's like slowing down and then stuck the heart fls slow and then it goes into your brain it's like all Sparkles the [Music] bottom my brain look slows down and then like I feel more calm and then like to speak that person oh so I get really mad you can go to the next thank you so before we read those I just what standard or standards when you think back to it did you notice and did you have any ahas about the connection of teaching and learning in SEO um so what we heard when we made the plan is that what students told us is they want

125staff and teachers to like being here and we want them to get to know us they also told us that they're tired and anxious um I just heard something from a friend at a university today talking about even though academically they're doing strong sometimes they're also really struggling and the professor was like so what's the point of they're doing well but they're not doing well we want to feel excited less worried and like we belong want to be a part of informing seal these were just some of the voices that we heard um last spring and that we're continuing to talk to um one of the other things and this kind of gets to your point Myra is that teacher and staff emotional well-being is highly correlated with student performance so many studies suggest that

126when teachers and Staff feel connected to one another supported for their own health and wellness and are able to have flexibility when possible they tend to feel better and students tend to have better academic and social outcome so in on the next slide there are a lot of activities that we've done with our own staff um to support seal um and then we will be repeating some of these activities I'm not going to go through but each one of those links is a link to a YouTube video think it should be in the slide deck on the um hopefully the links were link and um those links are opportunities for you to kind of and what we've done is have our staff and administrators be able to go on those links and then do a

127series of questions so that they can practice right along with the students um one of the questions that we ask and it's also in the slide deck is think about yourself as a child how would you have demonstrated the skill that you see when you watch that video how did you learn this skill as you got older you haven't learned it what are the barriers do you have this skill as an adult what support might you need to develop the skill for your selfishness and so those are all questions that we asked our administrators this summer and we asked our administrators to take back with their SEAL Teams in the schools to ask their staff and the goal of that is so that everyone develops a stronger understanding of how it might actually look in

128the classroom with kids we will continue to practice these things is not one and done like all of us are Works in progress and as we adopt The Curriculum by grade band we will be working with our adults again and how do look in their classrooms whether they're integrating it into their curriculum or whether it is being taught as more explicit lessons in something like advisory so this is our overall plan um I shared with you the mission and vision right now we're working with adult by focusing a lot of the questions we had was on escalation and deescalation and co-regulation so that video I showed you was very much focused on all of us understanding what's happening with brain neuroscience and then how do we address that and also kind of tapping into that

129empathy muscle modeling and naming T Cel throughout our meetings and our professional development and then um there's also a staff Wellness committee um that has a grant to offer many grants in buildings every building has a wellness coordinator um and then we have student transformative seal which is the curriculum adoption engaging with the students and helping with some of the adult professional development and um also making sure that students are a part of informing which curriculum we adopt by great and that is the end of my presentation um it is something that we are working on in multiple Proms and so it's not nearly as clear as like this is this is your map block you know this is your science Block it's definitely more of a shift in not what we're doing but how

130we do it how is um how is it being received by staff and I'm um I'm particularly asking about secondary right we we've been hearing a lot about how they feel unsafe and how kids get rewarded when they're sent to the office they're just sent right back with no consequences and you know everything that we've been hear for the so how um what specific PD are teachers receiving and then how are they being open to it great what does it look like right now in schol so there part of this was part of a PD in August I heard I wasn't at all of them because what one of the other things we want students and staff are in the schools to be talking about it more open ly I heard that it went pretty

131well people are in theory excited about the idea I do what the and um like Gram High School didn't do their fall one yet so I don't know if that's coming like in December is something I have to check in with I have a check in with all the admin this coming week and then right after winter or right after Thanksgiving break um to find out kind of how it's going I would say it varies by school um it's been really good to have the breath of Staff involved because one of the biggest cautions and concerns was that it would sound too um patronizing right to staff you you just need to take better care of yourself right and so that that tone is not the intention of this it's really to try to into

132the the discomfort honestly As Leaders of listening deeply listening to how our staff are feeling and then working with them to build their skills so that they can support our kids and kind of acknowledging you know maybe we have been you know we have we can't dismiss that right so I do think the staff that have been involved in this conversation I am hearing them appreciate the authenticity of the way we're sharing this um it's not something that you can check a box it is not a technical tool and I think if we tried the state when they passed it a lot of districts adopted a curriculum and just rolled it out very technical teach that um we made we took a completely different approach which was we weren't just going to roll out a

133tool to teachers to teach kids we really wanted just slow it down enough so that we had staff deeply involved and I I felt strongly that the that there has to that this has to feel like an authentic engagement and not and and an Adaptive process not something we're just doing to people kids or staff because then staff then it's not helpful for kids and it's required right so it's really easy for it to be a checkbox and it's too important for us to let it be a check box so um with that in terms of the purpose for it um you know why the OD rolled it out is what would you say in a 30 second what was their purpose what were they hoping to gain by fostering greater student connection and belonging

134we will see better academic outcomes and higher engagement okay so that's the academic and hire engagement does it correlate at all to mtss and when kids are feeling better they will move out of that tier and into something yeah right I mean we know there's a ton that it is a tier one it is fundamentally thank you for bringing in mtss it is fundamentally a tier one system level way to address student engagement and barming that brings down for everybody univers but as that it will be interesting let me see I had two points as it is rolled out to tier one kids it has to it's going to be rolled out universally so it has to affect tier two and tier three well all kids get tier one right including tier two and tier

135three right it'll just be interesting to see kids may not need additional support at tier two because we yeah you you would hope that it um impacts that positively and I would ask that I mean I won't be here to see it roll out but I would be interested in seeing the correlation of that particularly because you're doing it differently than a lot of other districts yeah I mean I'm hopeful that by having our adults feel really supported then and like they are equipped and they have the academic tools right to teach reading that the combination will support student learning the the other question is with the PD and all the other things we have our teachers doing how much time and effort is this particular piece taking and is it taking how much is

136it taking away from academics yeah that's a great question so to the extent that that's our professional development we've really we have four that we're planning and giving working with schools to integrate them during their regular PD not at the district level but really at the school level and sort of integrate it into their other content that they have planned so that we're also modeling like one of the elements was um name um F in the context of your math professional development so math is one of those we have high failure rates right well how might how we teach not just what we teach really make a difference in terms of our math scores and so talking about with teachers I have this group of kids who hates math let's dig into that a little

137bit is it what you're teaching or is it how you're teaching not as a criticism but let's figure out why they're hating it and what can we do to support to support that element of it and see where it goes it's not it's not a science right I mean it's a science and it's an art which is what teaching is too but it's trying to really equip our Educators with more tools to meet the kids who we have now in our buildings and the only other um comment I guess is how many teachers will check the box with PD and not Eng it and then how do you as Administration uh keep your finger on the pulse of those teachers because your your best Avenue of getting them all on board is to show that

138it makes significant difference and I do think that's where our coaches and our um our teachers on special assignment who are in the classroom with them and who are actually really pivotal and helping this our like all of our staff who are engaged in this me doing that I I mean I'm just a right but what matters is the people in the buildings feeling like whatever you said it's it's a tier one npss intervention I would say it's not an intervention but a tier one yeah something that supports because I mean you're you're you know you're where the rubber meets but having been through the last my concern will be that people are coming with significant and then we roll This yeah so value how it's I'm glad we didn't just roll I just could

139see how it would could be perceived just kind of disingenuous nobody's I also think I it's not diving in individual students but I I would say um you know the video was um sweet and valuable for I don't know what that number is say I would have said 95% of people and having been through the Journey that my family has been on at least over the last eight years um I know that every kiddo that I had my home wanted those skills but couldn't chemically or because the hand they were dealt by logically decisions outside of themselves and I I am curious how teaching like this interfaces with something of an [Music] epidemic substance related and you know impulse control related you know measures that are really driving kids from tier one to tier two

140who have in tier one I know I'm just trying to bring it more to your acknowledging that we are s we are adding this ingredient into an already PL the stew and that while we want at some point to take it over so that we have 90% maybe back maybe we'll never get there but it without that acknowledgement of what we're trying to accomplish and that it may fall not short but not where we like it to be or it needs to be massaged into you'll you'll gain more credibility with the effort Yeah by acknowledging that and trying to you know I don't know what that means in terms of implementation but something and maybe that's the input from the people on the street doing it well and I do think just to kind of

141I mean to your point like that that nothing is a Panacea for everything right including equipping staff and kids with more seal skills that doesn't it doesn't it doesn't address kids who are neurologically or chemically impacted outside of their control what it does do is those kids who are maybe triggered by that behavior who maybe haven't had opportunities to practice that or are experiencing other senses of othering in their school community and their only tool in their toolbx is to react out of anger or frustration or to shut down I mean sometimes it's not a big reaction it's a shut down reaction the more we can help those kids to feel that sense of connection and belonging it allows our staff to have more bandwidth to focus on the kids who do need more intensive

142right because if if if 20 if 30 or 40% of your students are struggling that's really tough but if 5% are struggling you have more bandwidth to focus on that five because the rest of them are have been given more of the to that they need so that would be that that's the goal that's the goal with mtss but it's yeah if you had to um because when you talk about 30 or 40 you know the the if you have fewer kids that need that 5% you can focus more on the 5% where is the percentage of this Focus comp the academics and I say it's all interwoven and it's how you do the academic part but that's always the question is how much attention do we need to do to get them ready to

143learn but then how much time do we have love to teach true academics it's a it's about how you respond to the academics I don't understand this m just try again that's one way or oh wow I'm sorry you don't understand that's another way same question from the kid different response from adult you get different response from kid you're still talking about that Math's a really good example when you think about how you can have some just small language shifts that can make a big difference something that just sticks out to me because it's something I've done and now I feel terrible about right sometimes as teachers we realize and learn something new and it's like gosh why did I do that so many years so I've always thought of myself as a math person

144I'm a math person I'm good at math I'm better at math than John I'm a math person that's right but that also sends the message that there are people that are not math people and so by talking about being a math person because of something that comes naturally to me that means that there's other people that may not feel that way or if they're struggling with math think well I'm just not a math person so I'm not you know they kind of limit themselves in terms of how they pursue you know some of those things that are struggling or challenging for them so that's an example for me of how we start to think really intentionally about how we shift some of our language so that we don't have that emotional shutdown for kids when

145they are struggl because struggle is good productive struggle is where you learn but if you shut down in that moment because you're not a math person and Tracy is those are things that we can imp and and that is an example of like agency right the student has a sense of agency and then the whole Behavior thing is not become as big of an issue because they have a sense of agency in their learning so I'm I'm on the questions to consider and it's very interesting to think about it and one of the things is we're doing it in school doing it with our staff we're doing it with our students and then had a little bit to Blakes com in the students homeline or where they started their where their impact is if they're

146returning to that if that's still there it are we doing anything that also helps the parents as well because I'm looking at some of these things and I didn't learn this you know I learned a lot of coping skills but I didn't necessarily learn this kind of stuff and so how do you break that chain I guess and and and how do you do that in a way that's respectful which the language that you're using is that you're not saying you're wrong but there's a different way of doing it or or showing the example of we did this and it helped your child no but it's it's um you know if we only keep it to the school then the student has far more impact and and far more things that are happening to them

147outside of school how are we helping the student to impact that which means bringing the families yeah maybe that's your no I know I think that's a really good question I mean and I do think actually a little plug on December 11th kind of point before all of this we're also leading work to educate parents about substance use and I do think you know like some some when you're in education you're planting seeds you're not fixing problem in that moment right and so some of it is where where do we collectively spend our time that we have to support parents and it is a full system job you're hear from Don you know and student engagement and family engagement is a huge part of that work too um and it never ends and you know

148they're multiple facets to it so yeah good good point and more to come and just I don't think anybody saying this but this is when ser it was and so we had in the classroom and I don't remember Community blowback you know maybe there was and I I don't think retrospectively anybody here is thinking really did we really judge you know I don't know hope we wouldn't because is dangerous we said and I think the same way we're super rent to say things about use use we're really reent to say anything about in utero use we're really to say anything about screen time the effects of child's development really say anything about the importance of strong structurers and sleep habits that not all all environments that we subject our children to are e and I

149I would just just because you're high level professional Educators please don't ever let language enter that says that's judgmental to inform families what is healthy for their children you know that I'm a huge so this is [Music] any other questions a lot of reflection question I appreciate this work very needed and hopefully and I also agree that you can't make it technical can't because it has to be hard work hopefully te do yeah and we have to work hard to to build the trust with our teachers so that they do feel like this is authentic right and it is isn't thou shal this is truly like we're here to we're all we chose this career for a reason how do we support you in staying in this yeah and then it's good for them too

150I mean I mentioned at the last for me like it's okay just say hey today we're not going to talk about let's talk about something's going on let's talk about what's going on just have a circle like because we're never going to get through all these standards anyway we're not I never have the 10 years never covered all the and they hav I over but I want to get to know my kids I wonder what going [Laughter] on relation thank you so I'm sure we're and happy to share are we okay so we're moving on to our next and last Jackson all right so we just thought it would be great to have you all here you asked for this you know what what's going on with the disciplinary hbg how is it rolling out

151um we're going to do this in three parts the first um if not on the screen but the first is um How We Roll this out to stack and what we've done so far and kind of our plan for the rest of the year the second piece is how we plan to roll this out to families um and what we've already done but how we intend to go deeper and then how we are going to share it with with students and students of different ages so this I'm just going to keep talking do you oh do you have it on just tell us what to go to good so this aligns um with the with your all uh conditions in several ways I wanted to check all of them um but I checked safety pretty

152obviously and belonging I just did a long conversation at East Gresham this week that was a facilitated conversation with high school students and middle school students coming in to Mentor our fifth graders at East fresh and we talked about what their definitions and examples of safety what their definitions of belonging were then one kid said it really beautifully he's like you cannot belong without feeling safe and you cannot feel safe without truly belong and so those two intersections for this work um deep and came out of a fifth grader's mouth and can I move this okay thank you um so this is what we've done with staff some of this is going to be review for all of you I'm just going to keep talking and then Michelle and John feel free to um in

153August we shared the disciplinary handbook with all of our staff and it was published on our website um there was a lot of work that happened with Michelle's team that she works with you want to talk a little bit about that so um in August um we always p together the PBIS teams from every school it's required administrators are there and so um where this new handbook interfaces with um PBIS is really when it comes to what do we do when we start to see behaviors what this what's the structural pieces and it really gets into a lot of the technical in terms of you know there's some newer definitions um we have forms that we use to document that there's in workflow where when it gets reported to the office what happens you know

154all those those things and there's um a different menu of responses for um you know used to be that there was you know two levels and now there's like five so it's a little bit broader so there were some changes that staff needed to know as we implemented this and so through the PBIS teams um we developed a nice flow chart that would help people see the difference between well what's a level one level two and level three and you know at the building level if I'm on the playground and I see this sort of behavior what's my response and we did a lot of that in depth because we're trying to bring people into calibration so that whether or not this is a minor incident or a major incident isn't based on who watched

155it happen because that's not where you're getting the good evidence based so that's what the PBIS teams um we gave them some tools and some activities to be able to take back to their staff and really um share you know hear some of the philosophy here some of the changes and as we move forward you'll begin to see these so that was the pre-work done to help the St kind of get ready for that and this is not a oneandone thing this is we already have next activities planned and some other that that'll happen in August and then there was time during inservice week where the teams you know had time to in front of their full staff to do and they were able to take that work that's presented by their PBIS team their

156positive behavioral and intervention support teams to look at more in depth handbook really kind of looking at the proess for developing the handbook which we went over with all of you last spring and then really getting into rights and responsibilities of our families our students um and the levels of response and I'm just going to spend a little time reviewing because I it was a long time ago just a reminder that this handbook was not developed by any one group in gam 27 members across the district in a lot of different roles and definitely from different groups from both our teachers union our classified Union and our administrative folks got together and developed this work we worked with North uh no Ed Northwest you're right no um Ed Northwest um came in somebody who works

157with with that organization who's developed you know uh safety and disciplinary handbooks across the region came in and facilitated this work and we looked at what has changed in terms of our disciplinary policy and legislation we also looked at research and we developed our handbook um in August we spent a lot of time looking at the rights and responsibilities it feels like the a really great way to start getting into in St into this work um we asked teams to look at things that were already happening at their school in terms of Rights and responsibilities and then four responsibilities that were listed and figure out what the rights are leaded to so every single right that was listed for students had to be held as a responsibility by either students families or staff every right

158that was listed for a staff member had to be held by families or students and also other staff members and so it was this really holistic view of how those um are held and connected um and then starting to look at what responsibilities are already an expectation of buildings and maybe which ones aren't and that's kind of what Michelle was talking about really aligning um we had a really old handbook if you all remember with things in there that were illegal and some of our buildings we not using them and so there was all this unaligned practice that was happening across our buildings and so really trying to look at rights and responsibilities is a way to get into what needs to happen to have us all do the same stuff um and then we

159got into looking at levels of disciplinary response and that is level one are behaviors that are dealt with in the class if I'm in a classroom with Sean tell him he's a dummy right then the teacher can address me and talk about F that I've done to sha and Sean can talk to me and the teacher can deal with that if I continue to do it that might escalate up but if I was in a classroom and I punched Mya in the face that would immediately not be something that was dealt with in the classroom solely it would be an office and perhaps work working with the teacher in the classroom right so these levels of response and then we have level five which are things that are dictated by law child brings a gun

160into a school it's no longer any of control what happens after that is how we support that student is but there is legislation that tells us what needs to happen so those are the Continuum levels um and just to give you an example this is level one one of the things that I really love about this um disciplinary handbook is that each level not only has interventions and permissible sanctions but it also has this piece of prevention strategies things we can do to try and stop it again or things we can try and use to have it happening at all in the first place right so and gave examples of a level one students using you know being too physical with each other in non harmful ways in first grade it happens um minute on

161the minute you know students pushing each other or playing with each other's hair that's unwanted or taking somebody's book and shoving it into them right those are the kind of things that happen all of the times and there's a list of prevention strategies we might need to call home for a family we might need to have a conference we might need to teach or coach social emotional learning skills things don't change SE seat change they're not rocket science most of the time when there's 32 kindergarten um so where are we going that's what we did in August and then mid year schols are going to be going deeper into looking at levels of response and really looking at those prevention strategies and what is and can be done in schools um strategies and then in

162the spring we're going to be looking at our Matrix which is what happens when one of the things I love about our disciplinary handbook is that it gives a lot of um decision making to pools and so it all depends it asks our disciplinary handbook asks that we consider a lot of things when we're making decisions one of those things that I already AR done um if I like this and I like know you it's really different right um it also asks that we look at level of the student if we have a student who doesn't understand consequence and and um cause and effect for example we might have a really different response to that student it doesn't mean that the student didn't didn't cause harm but it means our response means to be different

163in terms of what we expect how we retach um that student so that's what's happening mid year and in the spring I just gave you a whole bunch of information and I'm going to give you a little more but I'm curious if you have questions do it's in the weeds um do we use reset detention in the elementary levels as a as an intervention or is it all upon I think that I would say it it varies and there's a lot of conversation about that because we want kids to be physical we want them to be active and sometimes what that looks like is um you know when you come out for recess we're going to first have a conversation and talk through what happened yesterday so that we can make sure so you do

164some some teaching during that and so then sometimes it's like okay we do this work okay now you have the last couple minutes of um and so it's um it is a strategy that is permissible in the handbook and particularly at elementary level you're really looking at the kidos because there are some kiddos it's like that do don't even try that because then it's going to make the rest of their day super super hard so that's where there's some flexibility and responses but it really needs to focus on instruction we also have structured recess which is controlling where students can be at recess like if they're causing harm at recess and that's real sometimes but it can be a smaller group that's working with somebody and that we can re teach and do that and

165I just saw that in play at two of our last structured recess happening they're still getting exercise but they can't be on the play structure jumping like or whatever they issue with sth have been really creative at trying to find a way to balance setting limits and providing instruction and keeping Kids Safe you know and for every single kid how that combination comes together um there's a a section I think it's page n considerations for determining level of disciplinary response and it's uh it says uh to whom and how in what degree harm was done including how individuals will be involved in any intervention and I just wondered can um use this term but it's true the victim of whatever the situation can they decline that are they given that opportunity um and to your

166point about the students that don't have the ability toess consequences um what's the conversation about the you know balancing um the kids that want to feel safer continue to learn in their classroom environment with that students need to be walked through the consequences I mean how do you you know meet one but still maintain this the classroom environment so feel free to jump in folks but this is my response to that it I don't think it changes us keeping those students safe so if a student is in one of our classes who doesn't understand cause and effect right for whatever reason um we're still going to have the same consequence in ter or the same response in terms of keeping the kids that are being harmed by that student student safe what we do with

167that student would differ well and so that's that's a great Point um I think my question was more the disrupt ability of the teaching environment so you know one student is in the altercation you know two students involved one student doesn't understand the consequences but to the rest of the classroom who's not even involved but could be you know they don't get to keep learning because there's this situation that has to be dealt with so how do you balance those needs do it look like what I would say is I what every every situation is different it looks different based on age levels what that looks like in seventh or eighth grade might look different than in a kindergarten classroom and there's a certain amount um and classroom teachers are are just Masters at this

168at times where it's like um Something's Happened in the classroom and we need to talk about what happened to have some like let's let's come back together one of our friends is struggling what can we do to support our friend and get back back on track learning um and so there's separate things happening because if there is an altercation between two kiddos you you've got that response that you're managing and you're figuring out how to you know minimize the disruption to the learning and so all of that is balanced and it's based on how intense was the disruption was it something that required other staff to come and help you know the student that's really struggling is it something that the teacher can start to bring it down have kids separate okay you know it

169all just depends on that intensity level and that's where those judgments come in um but it's always balancing that and I think for every teacher it's always let's get back to learning and sometimes you do need to talk about it um and you know and process it because you know and I think that's an opportunity to really bring in some of those seal skills where sometimes people have big emotions and they have big feelings and how do we you know help support folks through that but keep things moving forward too so it's a dance it is a dance and that that's the whole point about the balance and I think that in the conversation I mean it's different with us but whenever we talk about that to always include your acknowledgement of needing to balance

170both not just you know that it is f of course you want to talk about it but at some point there has to be an evaluation of if a student is three times a week causing a situation that has to be talked about I mean that's just instructional L that that is the balance too and that's where your tiered systems of support come in because if you've got a kid of that we've had a major disruption three times during the week we're starting to pull a staffing together to figure out what's happening for this student you're looking at the rot C and you're like what do we need to get in place so that we can bring the intensity on for both this student and make sure we keep learning environment moving with mental disruption

171my only other point I don't want to belabor this but it's the um consistency across the district I mean every school is so different and uh the principal's different teachers are different families are different in some regards and I understand that it's got to be individual but I I would be interested later to see at the end of an evaluation year um what was the consistency among schools because from I mean you're going to hear that from parents well wait my friends are here and this happened and then over here this happened and they were the same thing and yet this you know so that's going to be a concern and I didn't see in all the individuality I didn't see how that you know is read through the handbook so that's just a reflection

172yeah I mean the Matrix in the back is absolutely asking us to look at and we clearly defined I think we spend a lot of time on definitions of different um in like what what um and so it's G to it will be interesting to see I don't I'm not sure I mean this year is um the first year the living document we haven't spent comp so I believe that that more toward January February and I think also um a little bit kind of Cy to what you were alluding to as well previously because the handbook was so outdated that schools were creating their own way of managing their own and with at least this having it be a consistent uh yeah and updated and so it does it's it's first year roll out no

173always compared school you know those conversations you're not going to get rid of that but this so I'm going to keep going and then hold on to your oh no we're going to keep asking it I want I want to talk about the family and Community piece and then I'm gonna have questions at the end as well um is that okay okay I'm talk right [Laughter] um I just want to talk about families and community and students because it's a huge piece um that I want to make sure our families understand this document so we published the disciplinary handbook on our website how many families go on and look at our website very few we've started to use it um in conversations with families and students as things come up right um in October we

174met with our district Equity committee to talk about how should we review this with with families and how should we roll it out to families and they had a lot of suggestions these are just a few I'm not going to read them all but I really love some of the suggestions sending it out to everybody in parents sare and having it in different languages we're currently having it um translated into Russian and Spanish um that will be done by John I didn't tell you I got an update um that'll be done in the next couple of weeks um having students and families sign the rights and responsibilities um and making videos in different languages was a really big um one um a summary and really making it acessible to our families who do not read

175and our families who cannot be was another thing that came up um question and answer and then just kind of summarizing um our summary of uh the district Equity committee for students was really to have it go out through 612 advisory to make posters and videos and then to rewrite our rights and responsibilities for students who are younger so for example our very first right for students I love kids they just call you on St um the very first right for students is learn in a safe way welcoming and supportive environment that values diversity as an asset to everybody's learning and and the the kids who are on the dec the students who are on the DC are like I don't even know what that means you think a first and second graders going to

176even understand what that means and so they have started to rewrite the this the responsibilities rights and responsibilities and we're going to make posters that are in K5 friendly language um with with images so I love that idea um there's a SK em so then we took those um that feedback to gbaa and Osa and we asked where is Staff right now in terms of understanding and using the handbook and then we gave them the feedback from the district equity Committee in terms of the recommendations and ask their feedback this was a collectively developed work and we don't want to now just put it in the hands of Administrators who make all the decisions about it do you have anything to add about that we got that feedback last week Michelle and I in the

177meeting it was our first meeting of the year that we have a district level commit that looks at abroad data and we asked them those questions we asked them feed so I'll be surveying question seems to be abent call sanctions I'm just wondering is that is that is there Reas I mean like is there a reason why you didn't use the word just wondering if there's professional language this that there is profal Lang you can take if you want are you John I we all decided that permissible sanctions involved learning and correcting Behavior but that there was an opportunity for learning consequences seem more like we're giving out the consequence without shift and so sanctions SP more to the committee that it was around actions we were taking to stop the behavior and Sh behavior

178when you look at the Matrix the consequences are and we're actually up in incidence a bit this year by so behaviors are being reported being addressed and things are happening so the kids wouldn't focus on learning the kids can improve from a kid perspective it's like they yeah I can spe and in PBIS you know it's like when we you know when we put a sanction in place I mean there's consequence there's a boundary being set this is not okay and then let's teach you a new skill or something to help you shift the behavior so it's you've got to have both of those so that students can understand where's the line and what do I need to do different and and that you know you finished um so one of the things that the

179association says they just need a lot more time to learn about and become more across schools and across even even within schools um and so I took that feedback to the dec last week and staff sat and said how can we think outside the box we have very little time with sta in terms of professional development it seems really easy to just spend more time but we also have to look at IR read and we also have to look at instruction and we also have to look at teas done and we ALS you know there's just so much that takes up that time and so I'm going to share that feedback with you all next time because we we didn't get as far as we wanted to get with the dec this this time but

180there were beautiful out box suggestions about how to integrate this into other things we're already doing um so the roll out for family and student is that we're going to develop resources that will be shared with families um and we're going to develop those resources in November and December and then really early next year one of the things I really love that you all talked about in terms of t- cell is um Blake you said it it's it's not bad to offer training for for families about two blank blank blaming what one of the things we heard in our safety Summit really clear from families is that they want they're like can you please help us can you help us figure out how to deal with drugs and alcohol with our kids how we can

181hold kids accountable for screen usage how we can set boundaries for a lot of different things and so we are going to work um and I know this is coming up but work on recommendations from our safety Summit and the recommendations that the district Equity Comm committee around how to roll out our handbook really aligned really beautifully and so we are going to be doing some family nights around both both those things um and then we're going to be Distributing the summaries and starting to make videos um and the posters that the students have made in February and March think that question questions just have a comment I appreciate that teachers are gonna Focus strategies it was a nice it was a nice read I I did go through and read it just and it

182had a flow to it that the previous one was all over the place you couldn't really tell it was contradictory in some of and it was I don't know when they make the movie about it but it I was to to your point all you there's always that human adults deal with behavior who kids are are all be here but this is the first time we Bas training on to be able to get more no if you have your question you one out of the the dec recommendations the whole signing thing you know I don't know what the solution is there but I think that's very reflective of what I heard just how do we enhance accountability and and share of our challenges that and what was really interesting is that the students on our

183district Equity committee were the ones who been in the deepest about holding fames account um they were deep they were like wait a minute this isn't this isn't just teachers role why are teachers completely responsible for student Behavior we need to hold families accountable we need to make sure they know what they need to do at home so that whenever students come I mean that was from students and we were like trying to roll it back students were like no no no here's here's an irony for you I like the accountability we need to do and I like the idea of signing the reason we went away from having a student right and responsibility we got we had so few people it was constant teacher going after people so if we can find an electronic

184system if we can do that I agree with that and so I students just they were they were intense on the no on the sorry on the association response I don't run the when this was first rolled out Sean asked a question about does this get after some of the challenges that you've seen and they said with the appropriate resources now that we're working our way through bargaining it was not identified here some level of enhancement as a priority or some level outside of what what you know of the resources that are currently available is that it's a good observation because that really didn't come up like what did come up is there are individual times when they individual students say may need more resources and we target that it was really a passing comment

185it wasn't a deep it was much more about see they shifted from this pretty quickly into Building Safety commitments yeah yeah they did um and they had interest in seeing Majors versus miners because there's been an uptick we're actually documenting more minor behavior so you would expect to see an uptick so we're getting that disaggregated uh for that's coming and they wanted me to tweak the graphs a little bit about total things it really wasn't substantive stuff and some of it was really around just spending more time and because there's so much to learn in August um and because of the structural changes with the forms changing Synergy had to be realigned this is being implemented and so the questions are starting to surface and so you'll see like in a a Monday news from

186a school hey want to clarify when this happens this happens you know the principles are doing so there's just as you use it you find those oh this is different I I haven't had this one before now I'm a teacher you know so there's all that learning that's happening and that's where the ongoing conversations calibration activities to keep the conversation going this is going to be a a continual role in continuing to get more and more aligned as people spend more time with it it just takes takes time and as things come up and what's nice is we're feeling a lot better about the data we're giving and they did ask for by consensus to increase the LLY meanss they also there no way to to go through what they thought so we increase the

187time in those means we go into the evening we'll see what we get out of that because there may be more questions observation I have uh is other than the the one school there's a lot of talk and everything else last last year was it was month after month report after report teachers really not happy with the student behaviors and disciplines and everything and other than that one school I anything this SPO when you look at when you look at to deep in here last did about seven times to the year consistently keeping track and this year I've been doing it monthly and continue do it monthly I have the gra here here it is um by school are elementaries are pretty commenor and the numbers grade levels different you know some there are some

188great levels we have those bubbles that happen the elementary like that's lowest is DCd in high school the school that we've been talking about the most has I I didn't break it out by grade or high school last year Broken Out by total grade level in the district so I don't have compar but it's low uh and when it comes to referrals or excuse me tardies Etc down about four five here the first two months of H relationship and so there and part of it yes so there are differences whether that's attributed to the or not or different efforts can I have one thought um one of the things and I think we saw this happen in the past and it's kind of a think of sort of as a human thing the more that

189there's something concrete that we can see and there's a structure and it's predictable tends to bring down adult anxiety about things I mean things we just sort of know but how that shows up post pandemic reopening schools huge turnovers in staff lots of people who didn't know what the old systems were and so now here we are there's been so much just predictability profession I mean even showing up like in our literacy you know Clarity what we're supposed to teach at K12 there's been so much of that work of the last few years that sometimes it's bringing just the the intensity down I mean it's still November and you know people are tired but there's just overall sometimes that stuff kind of helps just bring down the the temperature we also see difference so far

190and I don't want the trend and staff yeah well and and my only point about it not being you know completely related to this yet is because grown up has so my two comments um for to be taken however you want to uh first of all this is you know an exceptional starting point because it does brings you know a a newness to it and a collaboration in all of your uh levels and everything the um I appreciate the de DEC saying we want to change it enough to where it feels like we're changing course a little bit you don't want to keep everything the same and have people expect that you're you're going to keep doing everything the same way that you have been and I think that there's some value particularly with your

191um your audience of families and community members that see and and regardless of how much teaching and training you do they're going to see some of the stuff that is completely unrelated as a lack of consequences so I only say find that balance between we're changing to whatever the thing the new ter is and just like you said and there are still consequences so I just I just throw that out there for consideration to find that balance and just to be clear that had nothing to do with the DC that I thought you said they said they came up with it so that it said no it was the committee that developed it so it was teachers the dec is made up of families and students right so I just want to be yeah well

192some kind of balance and so's the other just consideration this is new and everybody's learning it and it's uh not collaborating but it's getting calibrated yes calibra and the people that are actually having to really do the nitty-gritty and some of the times it's teachers but a lot is that your PBIS in each school that person really has to get into this I hope that you're open at your year end to say is there something that didn't work not just calibrating with get into it figure it out there could be some things in here that just are and the only people that are going to know that are the ones that are trying to have consequences and accountability and they have to find out where it fits here and they have to you know it

193just might need some changes and for this to be that living breathing always getting better document I can I just add one thing keep trying like yeah I know Tracy sorry because and I think it pulls a lot of these different pieces together like you were asking about our association and we have some like how do we build accountability how do we have some calibration one of the things that did come out of bargaining last spring in our classroom discipline article was around and I just looked it back up is about a student conduct committee at each school so each School assuming that we're going to ratify a contract that you all are going to approve it now we te something this week that's an important piece of all of this too because there's a

194lot so then that's a building level conversation with licensed and classified staff reviewing data talking about Trends what's happening what's working what's not and that that committee hasn't existed so that's going to be a new layer that I think is going to be really important in all of the things that you've just talked about in terms of pulling all those things together supporting especially from the point of those committees gets more of this and awareness out to the broader Community which is really important because that feels transparent like wow they're really they're they're wanting people to be aware of it one of the things about the QR code and I know we're not supposed to require anything but it feels like if anybody wants to participate in something like a sport or drama or choir

195or go on a field trip or do anything have you done your you knowed your farm I don't know just out there I think the students on the committee would agree with you okay good we ask all of our questions thank you thank you thank you all right we are to the end of our meeting um I was just going over this yes no yes that's where I'm right at um yes um and I real I thought I put something in here this afternoon and it's not it doesn't pop up here it pops up on our planning spreadsheet and it is there oh okay okay because I was like did I forget to hit go um what's your question's in light of ta agreement yeah and some of the uh Financial hardships that have hit

196Regional districts I I would really like to see almost a financial forecast including the bargain language what that looks like over a 10e horizon so we can kind of know what's hitting and I don't know if that works in theine years today from State and based on that economic forecast we do project in two weeks the governor will be putting forward her first iteration of what the state's fund would look like so this is the the starting place so certainly something that we could um work on providing whether it's before the holidays or after the new year when there's a new superintendent in place but I think that is an appropriate conversation for us to to discuss but as far as the T articles um I think we would need to have a conversation with

197you any way about what that actually means for the district and going give you some general implications on fund what we have as far as you know other commitments because we have other bargaining groups that we have to make sure that we are up to date with with classified with our you know license and C with our administ 10 was a totally arbitrary number I don't the other ination that Press today is the pur yeah side stuff and just how that all weaves in make nervous we started meeting uh 10 days ago Tracy myself and the finance team and HR you were not you w this either right uh and we're meeting again without you next week uh because I do want a clear picture so I'll have a better understanding in January where I

198think we are there'll still be some unknowns like the legislature Will Made aside but I and we'll have some speculation related to assumptions bargaining with class and the administrator things as well when we vote on that contract we expect January they have to get first doesn't go to somewhere December so the earliest is going to be either January board meeting or February which again somebody's not here they would like to go we talked to them on Monday night uh Tuesday night was their their Regional modification so they weren't just one day later get so December is our next regional meeting and then they have to do some small committee work and they're optimistic that January will be reasonable yes so it was it was a good Mee was a good good Mee so just would

199you want link to put that request on the board planner yes yes yes so just thing that we're money won't work we have enough good Jo so on the uh spreadsheet we have gone through over the last couple of of times that we've gotten together with with the leadership playing the agendas and tried to either identify where some of these things could go some of them were going into Retreat uh meetings some of them were going into just regular meetings um Myra you had had one about uh basic basically scheduling time student time high school scheduling and some of that is being addressed in contract negotiations new language about committee so it is at least still having some visibility um some other things that have come up have been addressed and you said mine that

200I put in is somewhere in the system now Blake's going to put one in and I think uh the only other one let me see where that one is um yep no that one's got January as well so yeah so we we went through and either checked to see which ones were either done you know finished we'd already done something with them or they needed to have more work so that's available there um and there's something else I was thinking about reading sh read it oh so we up to announcements now any other any other things Blake you're going to go ahead and put your thing on there the longterm forecast I think is how so it doesn't look like it's tied into the upcoming budget but you're looking for a longer term as much

201as okay um so we are end at the end of the meeting the announcements coming up next is December 4th the special work session at 6 PM you all should have gotten an email about that and that was added to the um um meeting day that day December 4th is I'll show the regular board business meeting at 7 o'clock in the council chambers Public Safety and schools building and that will be the last meeting of superintendent Hugh so it uh it will be a very interesting prepared yeah meeting and I think with that there being no other business before the board we are aured thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.