CorpusRecord 144978

January 27th, 2025 School Board Work Session

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / North Marion School District #15
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Marion County, OR
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,794 words · about 83 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001supposed be walking in any minute okay by the time I get through here you'll be ready okay we'll call this meeting to order at 6:01 um Kelsey here Merl here Jenny here Heidi here Glenn will not be in attendance chair here and Robert should be here in just a minute or so um we'll go ahead and move on to the flag salute I pled Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for ready for Robert we'll go have a big agenda okay I just have an update on our financial situation um we have been talking to our department ments and buildings about their budgets this year and next year asking questions getting answers and going through

002everything we have staff and enrollment information gathered we're working on class sizes they're being looked at this year and rolling them up to next year uh we've created our seniority list for the licensed and classified because that is the process we'll follow if we have to do layoffs and and we'll also follow the collective bargaining uh contracts because they both have different information in that we will follow those um we'll be speaking with the unions this week we have a meeting scheduled uh Wednesday Thursday Wednesday Thursday with L um and we have started to get some resignations and retirements in and um one or two that we didn't expect so that's a positive thing U for the rest of our employees um we have a list of possible areas of reductions that we'll be reviewing

003with the unions when we talk to them we have gathered information our still gathering information on clubs and Athletics and the participation numbers and the amount of um students we served with each of those number of events and that type of information um we have a meeting scheduled for FTE review with a few of us on Wednesday and then um we will meet with the principles on February 4th hopefully to L the Lin for that and get that information out um we want to have everything complete and we will have everything complete by March 10th for the board that is our day we will presenting be presenting contracts for next year the LIC any question for me that okay yeah Heidi do you have any questions no thank you Elie Merl I was unable to

004hear but that's not here sorry March 10th you said present contracts yes um and what was early on you said something was positive and that sounds like good news what was that we've gotten a couple resignations or retirements from people um that we hadn't expected them to come from so that just helps with whatever layoffs or Cuts we might sure yes Jenny uh I have a dumb question when you said that we're looking at club and athletic participant numbers what are some of the clubs like is that like music club or drama club that kind of ffaa awesome meta okay we have a lot of clubs so yeah I just wasn't sure yeah thanks no problem um Dr Robert Rodriguez joined at [Laughter] Robert and um you just had a brief overview of Finance okay

005moving on I'm good I will save my questions to thank you thanks Lind okay work session all right well I'd like to take a minute to uh thank and welcome some guests that we have today where um and so uh Ashley if you'd like to come up here I don't know Austin if you're joining you're welcome to come up to the to the seat here um and so uh I've mentioned the board previously about concerns around um the future of our our football program with declining numbers and not having a a a a feeder program especially at that Middle School level and so in the fall I reached out to uh to NM and both both being new here just kind of wanting to understand the organization what they serve um all the different sports

006that they serve and so we had I what I felt was a great conversation and I thought it was a great way to not only have a conversation about about what what we might do about football but to hear about their work cuz they work to serve the kids in our community they are our younger feeder program they they serve our future huskies and so um I've asked Ashley and Austin to come here tonight and share a little bit about their work with NM so that we all kind of have a basic understanding of the sports program they provide for our younger huskies and then will transition into a presentation on Middle School football you know past and present and potentially future so with that turn it over to you guys thank you um so

007I'm Ashley Murray I am part of the executive board for n i service secretary is Austin he's the current vice president um I just want to start out by saying thank you for having us here tonight um I've been with n for thick fish years and I know n has been around for I think we're going on 50 under various names and all of that and I don't know of any other time we've been invited to a board meeting to kind of collaborate and get on the same page with the district that we support so thank you for having us here um because like you kind of already said stole some of my words we all have we all have the same goal and that's to help develop our youth into responsible capable confident adults

008you guys do it through the academic world and we're trying to help it through the Sports World um so we're excited to make sure everybody understands what it is that we do for the district um so who we are that's our vision statement that's the official one so it's teeny tiny and wordy um our bylaws and vision mission vision statement is available on our website if you guys want to read through that but basically it boils down to helping kids grow and Thrive through fun safe and supportive Sports programs um most of our programs are wck Level we focus on that over a tournament fall or anything like that um because we are about the community at large and the community at large can play and participate at the recck level in Greater quantity um

009so the sports that we currently offer we as again he uh we try to be a theater program for the high school so when looking at adding things to what n offers we look to what does the high school offer and where is the future of that program if it to start at n my does it have a future through graduation um so we stick to those Sports um flag football had its first official year last year thanks to Austin who is the VP football coordinator we all wear multiple hats um so he was able to get two teams um for first through fourth so first and second and a third and fourth grade and looking to expand that next year um soccer we continue to have 3K through 6 because then the Middle School

010takes over at seventh grade um and volleyball we just had a pilot program this year um I'll talk about that a little bit later but so volleyball full season is coming this fall and then winter we have basketball for both boys and girls um cheerleading 3K through 8 um that is co-ed as well and then tball softball baseball um so the core sports wrestling I just put that because we do have wrestling program at for North Maran but it is not run through n some people get very confused by that it's one of I think it's the only youth Athletics that has not run through NM um and that is just because they've always had their own handle on it and they run it spectacularly themselves um so I want to speak a little bit

011to our participation numbers um unfortunately one uh Co really shot a lot of things down um and then we kind of had another thing happen we switched registration programs um right at Co so I don't have a longevity of numbers but I gave you what I we have for the last two years that we could track um our participation is really great um it's on track historically with what we think registration has been um I don't have hard data to back up that statement um but as you can see if you look at the one on the right we're project Ed to have astronomical participation this year um that was I took the average of the last years of data for baseball and plugged that in and once I did because those registra baseball and

012softball those registrations are currently open so we don't have hard numbers there um but we have we serve a lot of Youth for the community and for how small we are we have a lot of participation um on for that one um and then I broke it down first sport you guys could kind of see predominantly soccer is our largest participation um and then cheer is slowly inching its way up there as the second largest um participation number on that one and then it's it's really tiny up there but it's pretty evenly split between the other sports as far as participation um some big things that have happened in the last year um We R the football at the Youth Level like talked about um and so we're trying to see where that future goes

013because we all we see a gap um we have those fourth graders this year that are already looking to move up to a fifth to sixth grade team and right now there's no program for that Austin's working on it but then even from there we already have parents going well then what they skip middle school and then what um so we're working on that plan and just getting the the love for the game instilled in them young so then even if there is a gap they still want to come in in high school and have some experience and it's safer for everybody um that pilot program for volleyball we did a short a three-week season is what we called it it was basically um practices two days a week for three weeks and then they

014did a big end of the year like against parents finale um by time it got up and organized we couldn't get into any leagues and we just we've never done it so we wanted to gauge interest um it was open to only fifth and sixth grade I think to two grades and there were um 25 kids which is pretty good for um just two grades so that is going to look to be more of a full program in the fall um we have coordinators working on that right now um end of season surveys we have been working very hard for as a whole organization to figure out how can we get better parent input can we how can we get the information so that we we don't all just hear the complaints at the end

015we get the input beforehand in the planning stages um so end of season surveys got implemented a year and a half ago and what those are are a mostly confidential I have access to the contact information as the board member I'm the only one who knows everything else it's removed and then it is sent out to the coordinators and the board anonymously so people have that level of comfort on um their feedback and it's a combination of like generic an uh questions on how the season went how the sportsmanship was the coaches um how they did and then some fill in the blank where they can really give their true honest opinion and we have had some really good feedback there and used it to shape a lot of our Seasons this year um so

016I think that's really good uh we brought back Blazers night uh which for basketball it's just like a fun thing for us for all the kids to do they we go as a group and attend a Blazers game um so we're going to be looking for more of those um and then big things we're looking at expanding that program um seeing how NM can help get that Middle School Gap Bridge um we you know we have to collaborate and work together um I personally am trying to move the six through eth winter cheerleading into the middle school as well um that has a large participation number and a low open head cost um and just getting that out of NM since most NM Sports cut off at that sixth grade um and it would just

017align it with all the other sports that we do um and then getting adjustable basketball hoops in the Middle School gym we're like we're probably 89% of the way there um with uh that funding everything has been approved on our end we just haven't bridged that Gap to shoot it back to you guys at the school board to make the purchase and get those installed um we want to do that because right now um half of our basketball program has has one gym to practice in um at the correct height for basketball um up through fourth grade they play on an 8ot hoop and gym 3 is the only gym on our facility that really that can have an8 foot hoop the primary school gym does but that's just different for gym floor and all

018that so we're looking to get adjustable Hoops in the Middle School to open up another possibility for those younger kids um um we are working on collaborating sorry guys you're good collaborating with the high school coaching staff um we've had a couple of them give us full program outlines as far as um the head coach um like coach Matt he gave us a full um at each grade level what those kids what they should be working on and what he wants to see by the time they get to Middle School be able to do for basketball he even gave us links to drills and all of that and our coaches are loving it so we're trying to get that from all head coaches but you know head coaches already have enough on their plate it's

019bottom of the prior list we give out scholarships um we have yet to turn down a scholarship applicant um we fund raise and we work really really hard with all of our costs to be able to have every kid play that wants to play um and then doing more fundraisers for facilities and equipment like those basketball hoops all of that um we could always use better stuff and then coaches training is something that's really hard because we are it's fully volunteer and it's whatever parent pretty much wants to coach their kid that year um so we want to have a level of coaches training so we have that Baseline of what kids are learning at each age and it's not just up to that parent volunteer as much and that'll just Elevate all you Sports

020was a lot any questions that's really good we will move around there uh Heidi oh hi thanks um no I don't have any questions thank you very much for the presentation Elsey um you said the baseball and softball goes through e8th grade for or yes um because they're through jbo um it goes through eth grade uh softball is hit or miss it depends on um participation numbers last year they tried a 14 UAM um um and but there were enough regist so we didn't have one registration is open again this year and we'll just kind of see how that goes and is there still B respon off all through the middle school no it's just yeah that's why we absorbed that and that oh wow okay are you guys getting good parent transation it's first

021coaching and volunteer yeah yeah that's a that's that's that's one of the harder aspects of being on the board and and being a part of all this is volunteers do you think it's the parents are are too busy in their lives or they just maybe don't have feel they might have the skills for that I think it might be a combination of both I know what do you think actually I think it's both um we hear a lot oh I have a full-time job or I have multiple kids and I bite my tongue and have to not say me too um I think it a lot of the jobs are big um because we have fewer volunteers we've all taken on a lot of jobs so then it's daunting for someone to want to come

022and take on one of those giant roles um we've been working really hard uh in our newsletters and um talking to parents about just taking on small rules like just help this coordinator order your order the uniforms and trying to chunk it down that way to get more parents and once they see it's not that hard just getting them in the doors is kind of hard yeah what about the high school and Middle School coaches do they have assistance that could help out it' be nice to develop the kids from that level and they're also you know they're also learning some key words and plays and some of the basic skills that's a really that's a really good thought love that it I worked I can only speak really to the football yeah um it

023took two years of like planning and and getting enough Community interest to actually field a couple teams this year which was great to have uh but I worked with Mike viel um I've heard that he's no longer the football coach of the high school but um anyway I was working with him and he put on a camp and we helped advertise it got a great turnout for that camp which I think really helped our uh program whereas he didn't necessarily coach or or have like a a day-to-day yeah interaction with the program he definitely helped get it off ground um so my kids go to Wilsonville but um good that I live here and what I found the school is that the kids from the high school they would coach and referee and you got

024them involved and they also got some credit in school and and the kids really love that they look up because then when they go see them play on the field they like wow there's this kid down there then at the game they get to go down there during halftime and you create this atmosphere where they want to be part of that program and they know that they have to work for it to get there so I think you know getting the kids involved so the high school level would be super cool that's yeah that's a great idea I really like that yeah when I first started uh cheer this is it sixth year um we had um the high schoolers would cut they were volunteer coaches and they loved it um and they got volunteer

025hours if they wanted them most of them didn't really care about the actual hours but they got to put on their scholarship applications and it worked really really well yeah the hard part is that it's their season too and finding these the dedicated really good responsible high school athletes are probably doing all of the other things and it's hard to get them to be able to re Sports usually weekends right that's most of the games and stuff and all of our practices are during the week yeah um and then yes a lot of them games are on Saturdays so yeah Games should technically work out schedule wise but yeah that's good that thanks that's a good idea Marl um your volley program that you're beginning was that projected to be free through 6th as well

026eventually yes um we are starting uh third and fourth and fifth and sixth grade um this next year and kind of developing and seeing where the interest is most volleyball programs don't start until third grade um I at Club level and stuff I believe that most of them start at third grade um so it would be a matter of if there's Club other leagues to get into it the younger levels Jenny no no questions thank you so much I appreciate you coming and presenting to the board this gives us a lot to think about um I forgot to ask if you want to chime in anywhere no sorry no you okay okay so well I guess that segue would be just that U you know as we transition into to Lindsay's Pres presentation and talking

027about Middle School football I think it this and I appreciate Ashley's comment about being the first time that way has been here because I think that absence of having a group that's that's active and participate participating in our community you know there's just a lot people will just speculate on what's really happening out there and so I think that having you know uh a group like n come in and just give a basic overview gives everybody a basic understanding of what's Happening in the community as in this case as it pertains to Athletics so um hopefully we get to do more of this kind of partnership with people that are are active and participating in the community so thank you both for the for taking time in your presentation yeah and I would just like

028to say hopefully that we'll have a yearly collaboration where I'd want you to come back and give additional information so that as we're making projections and plans and strategies for the future that we keep our Round Table work group going yeah so thank you for coming to our work session I appreciate it thank you guys for having us thank you that come on the Lindsay did participate in the meeting that we had in the fall with NM and then she got uh tasked with uh coming to uh tonight to give a presentation and I really like the work that she's done here on this though take it away okay so we're going to talk Middle School football um so you can go down yeah so this is just an overview of what we serve right

029now um so we have four Sports in the fall cross country volleyball girl soccer boy soccer um our winter season is split into two so boys basketball goes first for eight weeks and then girls basketball and wrestling goes um second for eight weeks um and so our girls basketball and wrestling those are average numbers um I think right now we are up to 30 7 girls basketball players and 41 wrestlers um and then track and field art average is about 100 and 15 um so our students pay between $35 to $50 per sport it depends on if they qualify for being reduced lunch um we have a current athletic budget of $10,000 per year um and that budget would need to increase with every new sport that we add um for different costs like uniforms

030and refs and transportation all that things so the next slide this is just our rationale for what why prioritizing Middle School football is important um a lot of it is the same as all of our Athletics just you know getting kids active in school um giving them stuff to do being a student athlete but also supporting our high school program and the success that they would have benefiting from our seventh and eighth graders being able to participate in tackle football which is something they don't have the option to right now in our district um and it shows as they move up to high school so a brief history and I know some this might be not 100% accurate there's a lot of people with a lot of different information out there so from what I

031could gauge um it was either 2011 or 2012 was our last season um we had most of the time one seventh grade team and one eighth grade team with about 20 kids each on each team um and the games were played at the middle and at the high school which is going to have to be a little bit different we'll talk about that okay so here's our Logistics the first part of it um this is the money piece of it so um we reached out to um the same rep that does all of the high school football equipment uniforms things like that um the equipment that we do have is outdated so we can't use it anymore it's not certified um so it'll be about $115,000 just for the equipment the uniforms the helmets all

032of that stuff um and that was for 30 players so if we have more than that then that would increase um but that would give us a good place to start helmets will have to be reconditioned every year and then replaced every 10 years the quote we got was to buy our helmet so we didn't have to deal with renting them every year um and the youth helmets are cheaper than the high school helmets to buy they're a little bit smaller um so then we would need coaches uh two to four depending on how many teams we have and how many players come out um and so that's just what their stripen would be per person um looking at the rough or talking to different schools in our um in our little Middle School league

033which is different than our high school league and we'll talk about that um ref costs are 150 per game and then um for the season we pay $100 $180 in Advent fees and $180 in commissioner Fe we also will only were only provided two refs um and we would have to provide our own two refs that were in housee that we committed to be at every game and we'd have six home games and they would have to go through the same training is all of the Salem officials um but they would be hours and hours only um transportation that's kind of normal um helmet refurbishing or reconditioning every year and then um just here and there equipment repair just if you know uniforms get ripped things get messy in football um and then game supervision

034so that's kind of a breakdown of the cost the next slide um so the facilities we need um we could practice on the Middle School field we cannot play teames on the Middle School field they have to be played on the high school field so we'd have to work with the high school team um and then we'd also have to troubleshoot a little bit just because we have two boy soccer teams and a girl soccer team so right now our boy soccer teams split the big soccer field out back and then the girls practice on the football field and so that would kind of have to be rearranged so we could have football on there too um so our league um all of the schools in our Middle School league have football out side of

035Silverton Silverton still goes through challon Valley but the rest of the schools do have football um there are times where Valor and French Perry canbin a team and there are times where the mcville schools canb a team um and then sometimes they have a team each or they have a seventh and an eighth grade in each um and then State and Cascade and sweet Homer currently in our high school league those are the three that we compete against that they see in high school as well except for our high school football team plays down to the 3A level so they don't play with them for football and then um we had our seventh and eth or sixth and seventh graders do a quick little survey just an interest have you ever played tackle football before

036would you be interested if we um if we offered that would that be something you interested in we had a surprisingly large turnout um take the experience playing tackle football for what it is um I didn't specify Oran recess all the things and it is also middle schooler so the chances of them just clicking through is always a possibility but um I presented On Athletics to all of our sixth graders in their Middle School uh Academy class and um that question was brought up a lot is would we ever have football what would that look like um because we do have kids that play in cany or play in Woodburn right now that we know and that's it heart and sweet you want to add anything Heidi hi yes thanks hi Lindsay um what is

037the possibility of grants that might be out there that's a good question that's going to be something that we're going to have to look into um yeah we're just kind of starting with what is it even going to take or what does that look like and then we can move on from there so we can start researching things like that right right and that's assuming that you have a startup cost and then of course you know because some of those items you won't have to purchase every year and then just the ongoing costs yeah yeah okay thank you Kelsey Robert um do do you think that there's a parental like the kids say yes but what about the parents um I think parents would be more open to it than we would think um from

038what I've experienced over the last couple of years is parents with their kids here after school they want them involved in things they want them participating um tackle football we have a lot of families that like football so yeah um I don't know if those if then we said it's at the same time as soccer I didn't ask that question on the survey so that would be kind of the next place to look is would if they had to make a choice what would that look like but what about the uniforms and does the high school do they have to be upgrading pretty soon where some of those could be used into yeah Mark and I have talked quite a bit that there's a chance that there's some uniforms that we could wear it's just

039the sizing can be off a little bit some of our kids are really small so cinching those down and getting sock but there is that opportunity get place to save cost so we would for sure need equipment um helmets and pads no matter what so what about has anybody has in the school district have they ever done anything where they do like a fundraiser like an auction that is that not since I've been here Middle School we tend to not do fundraisers as much because our cost is really really low yeah um but I think and it competes with some of the high school graduating classes that are fundraising they're used to be a North Korean auction many moons ago yeah um again volunteers were a situation where they didn't have enough volunteers to take

040over that process and then on top of it co so it's kind of wiped out a lot of that pce it can generate a lot of income I mean I'm just talking about West and Wilson they generate a one auction 120 to $140,000 a year yeah that's but it'd be amazing if we could do something like that here I mean even just 10 well Robert let us know if you want to sign up for that Merl I had that same question about the U those interested whether the parents were promoting that and would would see that they they did participate it's quite a difference in numbers the other thing I observe is that football is a lot more expensive to equip and and conduct the the play of than any of the others but I

041wondered if you considered dropping one to add another but I don't think that helps much cost wise no yeah all most of our sports are pretty self-sufficient at this point the only thing that's really expensive for us is ref cost um but we we're really fortunate that our High School coaches hand us down a lot of uniforms so our uniform costs aren't very high um we don't have a lot of coaches but yeah football is an expensive sport but if we want a successful high school program this is kind of the place that we need to start um because they just can't safely start in ninth grade and be able to compete especially if we don't have a JB team um you're just putting them in can't put a freshman up against a senior that's

042been playing for four years I I can I can see that and and I thought too there there is a liability Factor so you want good equipment you yes yeah and there's a lot of regulations we have to follow like helmets have to be um we have some helmets that could maybe last one year but no company will refurbish them for one year because it's just a waste of money okay um so they have to be replaced every 10 years and they have to be reconditioned at the end of every season the pths last a lot longer which is really nice but but you have to buy it initially that's all Jenny yeah I was just wondering like this is a great plan I'm really excited to hear that this would be something that the

043middle school is interested in in are is there plans to do it for this coming like 2025 fall or 2026 fall we would like to start it next fall but if we need more time to raise the money than we can when we get the money we can start it and we have it but um I just need to know our leags at game schedules in April for fall Sports so that's kind of the time that we would need to jump in and say yes this is something we're going to commit to doing and know is it one team or is it two teams what is up like yeah and so we would probably be really relying on community fundraising for this so the one team versus two team thing so are some of the

044schools that were in the presentation do they have seven the seventh and eighth grade combined teams is that typical it it hit and miss most of them have a seventh grade team and an eighth grade team or they'll combine like uh Balor and French Prairie always field two teams but sometimes they combine their schools and sometimes their numbers are big enough that they can do a seventh and eth at one and a seventh and eighth at the other um but and mcmv does the same thing nobody else is really in that situation where they can combined with another town or another Middle School in that area um but they're all they all have seven eightth grade rooms okay so that wouldn't prevent us from being able to participate if I've already I was at an

045athletic jure meeting last Thursday and it was thrown out there that this is something that we're talking about and they're willing to be accommodating however they can because they just want their kids to have more opportunities to participate and play too especially if it's like with us there's three schools in our league that potentially if our school could ever get back to playing up at 4 a level they'd be playing against and so that's something that's intriguing for the kids to know that they're playing with them in seventh grade 8ighth grade and then they get to see them again in high school right and I'm just gonna back go back just a minute so Ashley and Austin you guys said flag for fifth and sixth potential this fall so yeah yeah we started the program

046we just wanted to get started with something um it was a lower uh cost to start up with flag get uh Community input you know does this community have a desire to have a youth football program um it took a couple years to build enough kids so I think for this year uh we'll stick with the flag okay through six grade okay so flag Fifth and six and then the middle school would field that seventh eth yeah so that there would be a long term okay so could we do so could go Ahad could could we people go reach out to all the different businesses within our community and seek fundraising and we have 15 businesses that gave ,000 so I'll let Dan I think that that's you know I think one of the reasons

047for having both n here I mean a community you know when you're a 4A size District or smaller this is not just a school issue it's not just an NM or side this is It's a community issue with both the district and those people that want to see these opportunities for their kids and so that's really why I wanted this done publicly with both NM and for Lindsay to present because especially if we just got done hearing Linda talk about seniority lists and reductions and things like that you know talking about $115,000 or $330,000 is not something that the school district but what what would our role be in working with the community that may want to really push this through to see what could we do for Middle School athletics so this is really

048just trying to create Community awareness we have a date by April which some decisions have to be made so we've got a few months to try to figure some things out to see what we can do so that's really trying to bring a lot of community awareness to this opportunity need and what stand what get what's in the way of it happening so all right thank you Lindsay you're welcome can I ask a question Heidi go ahead Heidi um do we still have the boosters at the high school level is that are they still active they are active I I did meet with them um prior to winter break I have not followed up with them I they you know from my understanding they've had a little change in leadership and so but that would

049be an organization to be having conversations about to to see uh what they might be able to do yeah or should or should at least be a part of the conversation for sure yeah thanks and uh I just wanted to say that um I think that you know in the past we've had some uh successful baseball uh not baseball sorry football teams and and I think that football does play an important role in a community um and having it start at you know at the younger grades is so important because when they get to that High School level they are better conditioned they understand the rules it is they are safer because because of because they are in shape and they are ready to go do you know what I mean and um I just

050think it's it's a great thing it's it's a shame once again that we don't have um an auction like we had for so many years uh that was such a great program that did so much for our community the money that was raised um yeah okay thank you than thank you Lindsay yeah thank you yep right so this is ironically titled superintendent gold report but Dez is going to give most of the presentation here so uh uh but she does does an amazing job of explaining data what it means and what we can uh learn from it and so again these are based on uh the goals that I presented to you in the fall that you uh adopted and so um we're here to talk about um that and D's big way yeah and

051when you when Dan first talked about how he was going to talk through the goals um we said during the intro we were going to talk about third grade reading and the eighth grade um math and then then on track your graduation so those are the three um main data points we're going to hit on you look through the whole slide deck all the past data is on there as well so the first thing we want to do is give you an update on third grade reading and where we're at this is just a reminder where our goal is is to get up to 40% um passing uh which is aligned with the state average so what we have to share with you today on the next slide is um this is our current information

052from the Intermediate School um so we give a test that is called hmh growth it's aligned to our hmh um materials that we purchased for ELA uh they give it three times a year beginning of the year middle of the year end of the year and what we're looking for is CL on that so that we're indicating where kids are going to be in terms of the state tests right now this year we're really learning to see how well aligned this data is with our state testing results last year we did not see good alignment um if you Dave I remember at the end of the year um scores for the hmh growth was so excited was like we should see astronomical results on the state test and then we did not see those results

053and we're trying to discover like what is the disconnect is it about the data itself and what's being assessed on these assessments or is it about kids and their experience on the state test like that they haven't been exposed to the state test are the questions different are we hitting the right standards even um like what is being covered on the state test versus what is being covered in the textbooks so um we're really uh taking a different lens on this data this year to make sure that we don't put all of our eggs in this basket and recognize that we need to look at multiple data sources to understand how our kids are doing but what this does show us is where are kids at in terms of their risk level and being off

054track in terms of grade level standards and as you can see just on a snapshot that red and orange area at the beginning there is too big is bigger than we would want to see in terms of our three third grade reading scores the good news is on the next slide this is our mid year and you can see growth right so that red and orange just in the plainness of terms is shrink we have more kids at above grade level and our um Mid like on level or approaching grade level is growing which is fantastic and on the next slide we have a more direct comparison I took all the data so that you could see a side by side beginning to middle and what's great is the way the slope goes up and

055down is exactly what we want to see we have more kids in the red bars growing in those areas that are on level or approaching on level or above level and we see those blue bars um Too Tall and shrinking with the red bars at the below level or far below level and so we're making good progress we we see that we're having some good results with the program the key will now be we're going to do some comparison and our third grade is actually going to also be giving the state interim assessment which is aligned directly to the state tests so that we get kids exposure to that test because for some of them it's the first time they've had to do like a really long extended sitting in front of a test first

056time they've had to maybe do like longer writing on a test and so we want to make sure that they have those experiences the more exciting data for me though is actually not our third grade data but what's happening in our Primary School um and this is just a snapshot of uh from David about how we think through the hmh reading the big picture it gives us um like I said he's really focused this year after we kind of relied on that test too much last year he's been really focused on understanding what the test is actually giving us and what information it's telling us and how are we using additional pieces of data diagnostic data for example to understand where kids need to be um better supported so for the primary school though on

057the next slide this is um what we're seeing with those reading do um uh scores and this is our second grade scores and again they look a lot like the third grade score it's kind of disconcerning um this is our second versus first grade and what you'll notice is our second graders right now pretty high levels of urgent intervention um they give what is called the star reading assessment it's a new assessment to this year it's very well aligned to the state standards and pretty widely used across our state um but but what we're seeing is some really big growth or some better numbers from our first grade team and we've been digging into like what is that difference and I part of it the difference in the bars is that the first grade class

058is much smaller than the second grade class just like if everyone's like what are you talking about Des that does not add up these are raw numbers like literal numbers of kids not percentages of kids so you'll notice like we only have eight kids who are in need of urgent intervention versus 43 kids at the um uh second grade level and that a above Benchmark a lot more first graders already at above Benchmark um or at Benchmark the on watch um is is uh also about even but we noticed their their intervention levels are so much smaller at the first grade and so the question is like well why what's happening with that first grade class and what we as we dug into a but what we're seeing is some really phenomenal things happening in

059kindergarten and then the first grade team is working with the kindergarten team and carrying those through with first grade and so one of the things we talked about when we first adopted which is my first year here when we adopted Ela I remember Chris you having like when will we see the results and like for me it's like okay now we're starting to see that push we've seen some really good curriculum being enacted those second graders had it the least amount of time now we have kids that are really this is the only way they've learned and our teachers are becoming better trained in it and we're starting to see shifts in our numbers and it's really exciting the more of those students that go to third grade on track the easier it's going to

060be for those third grade spores to go up when we have that high number of kids in third grade who are significantly off track we're spending a lot of our energy trying to just get them to grade level let alone past the state test and so we're seeing the shifts going in the right direction when more of our energy can be put towards doing the Core Curriculum well versus intervention on top of that is kind of like um going to the doctor where they're like we can treat your high blood pressure and your type two diabetes and all these things but the better thing would be just like not get those in the first place and just be healthy and that's easier to maintain than necessarily treating everything when it it's off track and so

061we're trying to do the same thing for our kids like how do we get them to be healthy readers before they hit third grade so that our interventions aren't as great um and this one this is a little harder to read on the next slide but it's um our first the first test because they also do it fall winter and spring and so you can see with the kindergarten fall to winter again um the above scores it's red it makes me really happy in that kindergarten the number of kids 40 46 I think per of kids are above grade level in kindergarten right now which is phenomenal um versus just like 16% in that urgent need it's a complete flip for us and we're seeing that same thing in those first grade scores so this

062is this year like in real time the second grades are still we're like pushing them through that system and trying to get them caught back up but those first graders will be second graders next year it's a completely different world so we're really excited to see how this will start trickling into our third grade scores it won't necessarily mean that we're going to meet our goal this year but that we're on track to start seeing some really good results which is really exciting I will add to just as a side note one of the things I'm really excited about specifically at the primary school is they've done a lot of research and working with the star um assessment develop development um and recognizing what are the skills that kids need and really being able to

063pinpoint if a kid has this score here are the three skills that they need and getting um using the early literacy model of high dosage tutoring and really intensive intervention early fast so that those kids can close those gaps faster and so what we're seeing is this really solid understanding from the schools of what skills kids need so that we can close those gaps it's harder the older they get the reading it just I hear this a lot when we're talking about students and their reading um difficulties we just hear kids can't read well there's a lot of things that that could mean is it that they don't know what a letter is is it that they don't know how to sound out a word is it that they don't know how to decode is

064it they don't know how to blend is it that they can read the word but they don't know what it means like what does it mean but when they're in kindergarten usually when we say kids can't read it's like they don't know where their letters are yet we can fix that you know so that that kind of really prescriptive here are the skills they need and this is the order those skills build and once they graduate from this this is how they move on to the next skill is really helping us make those progress um that we're looking for so really exciting okay with eighth grade math again here um is our our goal that we're looking for um we're looking to get at that 27 % mark which is State average so that kind

065of tells you a lot about the math and the state of math in the state of Oregon um for the middle school on the next slide we use what is called Fast bridge for the middle school it is also a Renaissance product like um star and this is our current level we have about 6% of students who this is for eth grade or this is actually a blend of sixth through e8th grade um about 6% of students who are above uh the GR level 41% are at grade level we have about 15% who are in need of some intervention and 38% of students who are in urgent need of intervention for their math um and much like um like I was saying with the the reading scores one of the things that um the middle

066school is working on and I'm working with them on is understanding what this means when this the test that we give says okay they're they're green then what skills does that mean they have or when it says they need intervention what what did they miss what questions do they miss and what does that tell us about where they need support so that we can start um working with our teachers to make sure the appropriate interventions are put into place so we're doing a little bit of diving into that data the other thing you're going to notice on this just as a a piece of information that 85th percentile and above Stacey can correct me if I'm wrong but um fast Bridge is a nationally normed test so when it says 85th percentile it means that

067the student is scored in the 85th percentile of the nation so the national nor yeah it's the national Norms so um that that's also a good indicator of just like you know how what you have to score to kind of be in comparison to other middle schools okay and then finally we have our ontime graduation and right now our goal is 90% graduation rate and right now as of today or as of a couple days ago on the next slide we have our current graduation rates right now we have 71% of kids who are on track they're going to graduate we're good to go they've met their requirements um and we have about 133% that are on the margin which means they are currently and deian can correct me if I'm interpreting this wrong but

068usually it means that they are currently taking a class that if they do not pass it they're going to then be off track and need some sort of intervention whether is summer school or something else um it might be there's a couple of classes that they're taking that they must pass it is possible if they pass the things that are in front of them they're going to graduate but it is that piece of are they going to take that opportunity and make sure but 71% plus the 13% would get us a o our current graduation rate CU um if you'll remember we're at about 81% so that would put us over 84% which is fantastic um we do have about 88.1% of kids that we know will not graduate they are credit deficient enough that

069we can not do enough first aid to get them across the Finish Line this year and they'll either need to stay for a fifth year or possibly do summer school to be able to finish up on time um or not on time but but still earn their diploma we have about 7.1% of kids who are earning a GED which is fantastic um and then we have seven students who will continue on in our transition program those are students who are experiencing disabilities and stay on with us for additional additional postgraduate years so so we have the potential of meeting our our 90% goal especially if we get those kids that are on the margin and then I'm trying to remember how GED factors in as a fifth year um and so we might not quite

070make it but we are making good progress and growing that rate which is fantastic and then we won't share all the rest of it but this slide below has all the previous data so all right well thank you Dez so let's go ahead go ahead and let do questions here and then I'll transition the next one uh I don't have anything right now no yeah this um the on time graduation numbers is this all of the high school or is this seniors or this is just seniors just senior okay just seniors yeah you good Robert um you own the 23 24 8th grade math by demographic what um when it says 27% is our goal is what what are we comparing to is this like to just is it a passing grade or that's our

071goal on passing the state assessment because that's what goes on our state report card and 24% passing is what the state averages currently oh so to pass that exam then then yes the goal is to pass that exam yeah so when it says all students poverty elll sped Hispanic Latino white are the is that all on the same scale yes yes so the sped and the white and the poverty are all taking the same test yes so speds are doing pretty good yeah they're they're scoring on average with our our same test yep yep you good yes ml it does seem like math is a weak well disappointing to see but I'm sure there's work that we can do to help that I had a little trouble with I reading this until I understood that

072boy and I said where are the G LS several slides later I woke up to beginning of year that went through like when I first started and I would talk to people and they say boy Moy eio and I was like what are you talking about beginning of middle of the year end of the year sometimes the wheels just I'm I was right there with you thank you um Kelsey asked my question about the will not graduate is there a further breakdown of that like you're so far that you you're missing four credits or is it like a minimum of credits are missing and you can't make it up over a summer school so you can't make it up over a summer school you're that deficient right and with summer school it depends like we

073have a couple different options that we've done with summer school a lot of times it's the class you just took you just need to finish up the opportunities um and they can take how how many credits do they have the potential of earning if they go summer school depending on it's only one to two week session for four days each week and so it's up to their drive to get it done if they get it done before or at the end of June then they get their diploma this year okay if they don't and they come back in the fall in August they won't get this year's diploma okay but we could get the specific numbers like of that percentage like how many are missing four credits how many missing five I don't have that

074right here um are we seeing that some seniors realize that they're in this category and they're like oh no yes okay I'm more worried about the ones that are real close yeah because those are the those are the ones where we are successful to push them through um so that's where our focus is our advisors want to know who they are so they can help push yeah and so it's a really strong conversation we Happ is there maybe a push for the will not graduate to turn them all over to a GED OPP we've been doing that or right now we have 15 kids in the GED program um and that's our limit so when one gets their their GED then p f another one okay okay but there's only certain sessions that we can

075get them in at a certain time okay thank thank you and I will add just from my experience GED is one of those tricky things um because there are some kids it is a like it's a miracle it's one of those things where it's like maybe the motivation to be at school wasn't there but the academic um background was there and they can take those tests and are done and it's what they needed to get started with their life but there are other students especially students who maybe have had a ton of chronic absenteeism and just haven't engaged in School GED has always been meant to be the equivalent of four years of high school in a test and if you haven't engaged in high school for four years you're going to struggle on that

076GED and so they go thinking it's a simple solution and then they get really overwhelmed by it pretty quickly and then we're worried about a Dropout so really being careful about like who do we offer GED to versus is it a blanket solution for everybody because sometimes it is and sometimes it's a marginal like they'll get a few wins and it will be enough to keep them going and sometimes it's like the student's going to struggle in GED too and then really lose motivation yeah okay and we do have two of those GED kids right now are fifth year okay so we're trying to get them Su of yeah yeah all right thank you yeah I love data excent so I think uh I think this last little conversation uh reflects how hard people are

077working uh I think everybody is working uh incredibly hard to have everybody graduate on time and be successful I think Dez's presentation with all the data is you know I guess the question that I would ask myself we should you know how data literate are we to understand what this information is is telling us to make informed decisions in the classroom you know so when the example of the intermediate score or in Intermediate School anticipating really increased results in the state assessment and it doesn't happen then there's a disconnect between what we thought this data was telling us and what it really told us so um and so one of the things in transitioning the conversation into the to the youth truth conversation is um as we build a new strategic plan where's the intersection

078between the goals that we want to establish that are academic and the experiences that we have our kids are telling us and our staff and families are telling us through perception data which I think we can find connections between people's experiences and the outcomes that we're having academically so uh are we able to put up the is this what you want uh no so should be the next one on the agenda memo yeah yep okay all right so so just to remind board members that in in my email that I sent you on Friday is that uh I'm going to go around the room and ask you what is one thing that you would like to know more about so after this presentation after you see this I you each have to tell me one

079thing that you're curious about or would like to know more about boy I saw some Panic faces she get to pass yeah so it's easy this is easy all right so we're going to go and we're going to start with celebrations so next slide so um we saw increased scores in almost every area of the youth Tru survey which as I'm going around to schools and talking about you know I would have I would have predicted that because when you increase participation rates you remove the outliers the outliers get reduced in their impact on scores and so um and when you prioritize something as being really important you I think you get a true representation of how people feel so but it's also very noteworthy to celebrate that we saw increased scores um so this

080meant improved perceptions from families and staff on uh so one area school safety you saw across the board a lot of uh increases in that area and I want to highlight that word perception you know the data we're looking at doesn't doesn't say things are absolutely these aren't like truth statements these are people's perception but as we know perception is reality for people and so this is just telling us how they perceive our schools um we saw increased student uh positive perceptions of culture and belonging which put us in the 50 to 74th percentile I think that's actually Nationwide not just National yeah so um so and we will point out some of those areas and uh staff feelings around engagement and culture have increased significantly so uh we're going to talk about percent positive

081okay so this is really hard to see um in the one I sent to you the colors are going to be a little more prominent but if you if you went down the kind of the The non-colored Columns there in the middle you're going to see you know percent changes you know across the board um and then when you look at those percentages you have to kind of they're telling you one thing but you also have to pay attention to so if we took just student the overall student engagement across um our Intermediate Middle and High School um had a positive response of of 80% okay now that's that may sound great but Nationwide that's in that's less than theth you're less than the 50 percentile so loss to celebrate but also areas room for

082improvement and then you'll find because the sort of the opposite happens where culture has uh a 21% positive response but we're in the we're above the 50th percentile Nationwide and again this is this is Heidi can I just ask a quick question it'll help me to understand better I don't can you help me to understand better the colors as opposed to the percentage because 80% sounds High to me so are you saying that even that we're still one of the lowest even though it's 80% we're still in the lowest in the nation that is correct so what people are usually like 90 or or 100 well I think one thing about youth truth is that you and I'm going to try to show you some examples here in a little bit of how deep you

083can dive into this to what generates that that 80 that 80% positive response and so I think it's worth celebrating or honoring that you know hey that's not bad but but we know we could do better but what if if that's the area that we're curious about then we got to dig into what's causing that score what what's causing those scores which we're going to get to so um Dan can I yeah so just so I'm clear engagement our percent um for student is 80% positive response positive response 80% of the scores were a three or four four or four or five yeah four or five and then the bottom at the very bottom of the page and I don't know if you see this Heidi it tells us compared to the National Data correct

084where we're at yeah right I see the color the color bars down there the Legend um so in our previous uh survey it was 87% then because it says minus 7 is that how you read that that would be correct yes okay I more question and then I'll I'm sorry to keep interrupting no it's okay this is important to know what you're what you're I mean as we go through this that we have an understanding of it so go ahead yeah I didn't take this test so you had you you had you had a choice of like what one through five or something is a is a like you know yes like a strongly agree strongly disagree kind of thing in between or something like that yes okay I understand thank you yeah so it

085was a one to five rating scale and then we'll we'll show you some of the questions that people that that kids students uh or students staff and families responded to to those yeah so the next one is average rating which just looks at the same just it tells you tells you kind of where did what number in terms of one being uh I think one is strongly disagree two is disagree three is neutral four four is strong is agree and and five is strongly agree and it kind of depends on the great on the age level as well um so again that just kind of looks at the same data in a different way so moving on looking for patterns so we found some you know so we're looking for alignment so if we looked

086at safety and you can see here's the question here here's question that was asked and the response rate so for an elementary school do you feel safe at school so that those kids are getting a yes or no okay and then the middle school or high school is getting I feel safe during school and that's where they're giving the rating the first one was a rating also um it was how much do you agree with the following statements thank you see I got how you P the S yeah so and then the the family is my child's learning environment is safe and again a rating there so that one question has its own percentile rank so what we were just looking at before was all the questions that may have led to a score in

087safety and so then how do you want to drill down to go which areas within safety if we pick that one that we'd want to tune into all right so for example so here are all the safety questions for the high school so you can see high school students had a lot of questions that they answered about safety and the reason there aren't high and low scores so on the families and staff the green indicates the highest scoring question that they answered and the red is the lowest scoring question there are no high lows on students because it was the first year they've done these questions and so they did not rank them from youth truth but next year we have a high low score as well so this starts giving you some ideas of

088so you know if we want to pick things to focus on to understand why this is people's perception this starts giving us some ideas of what we might look into to better understand people's perception so because you could see a connection there on that one where you have family saying scoring low that my child is safe from bullying during school and staff are saying students are that one also was a low score students are safe from bullying at my school so we would want to we would probably want to dig into that if both staff and families are reporting that why is that so when I asked you earlier about your curiosity question so that that's the kind of question that we're we're trying to when we look at this what do we want to

089know more about so then we move on to safety at the middle school oops just going let that hang out there for a little bit and we can go on the safety questions at the intermediate so so I'm G to brought another thing that I saw so if we go back two slides to the high school so notice that the highest one for High School staff is I feel safe from harm during school that was the highest rated one okay go to the middle school that's the lowest one the Intermediate School lowest one so what what is Staff perception that's leading to that type of response so just something I just a pattern that I I noticed so all right we'll move on to the next one finding alignment around respect so on this uh

090particular question you could say does your teacher treat you with respect and for middle and high school adults at my school treat student with respect we had 86% report positive for the staff the question was staff treats students with respect pretty decent alignment there and these specific alignment questions are also ones that youth truth specifically pulled out and said here are places where all your stakeholder groups are kind of answering in the same way and show a pattern of strength for your distr or a pattern of weakness for your history go on to the next one with relationships you know we didn't get one estaff response on this one there were questions that were okay I don't know or maybe it wasn't in alignment all right so if we go into relationship so here this

091is specifically to the high school and you can see where students um so in high school um the highest rated question relationships was how many of your teachers connect what you're learning in class with your life outside of school that was the highest rated one from students at the high school and then on staff you can see staff reported high that I feel comfortable approaching other staff members if I need help solving a problem that was the highest graded one from staff on relationships and the lowest was I feel comfortable speaking honestly to families about their child's progress so we're g to talk about that one in just a minute actually next slide we'll go to the middle school so um so it' be interesting to ask students if you look at the Middle School

092one how many of your teachers are not just satisfied if you pass they care if you're really learning so that was scored lowest uh from our middle school students but if you look at the families and staff one on that same area fam said scored low that they feel comfortable approaching teachers about their child's progress and staff reported I feel com scored lowly scored low I feel comfortable speaking honestly to families about their child's progress so clearly we have we can look and say why do we have this issue about speaking honestly about our child's progress why do parents struggle to come to conference I'm just come to conferences and have an honest conversation what what is that so why is that perception there all right and on to the intermediate wrapping up so you

093can see like in each of these areas on and I just gave you a couple of them you know with uh I gave you examples of all the questions and relationships I gave you examples of all the questions and safety you know there's culture there is profession professional development I mean all of these areas have multiple questions to dig into um and so what I've started doing is last week I was at the middle school and kind of giving them a similar type of of presentation and then they give me feedback on what questions I should be asking parents based on what they what they viewed and so I'll doing the same thing tomorrow morning at the middle school um I'll be at the primary school on Thursday a primary school did not participate in

094the official youth truth we gave them kind of our own homegrown one so we do not have the data to present on that and then uh next week I'll be with the Intermediate School um so with that uh I'll go around and what is something you would like you're curious about or would like to know more about we'll start with you Robert [Laughter] I do think it's interesting because we have talked a little bit about this about bullying and but it's really it's your perception of what bullying could be I mean one girl could be having a bad day and she her friend said her hair was terrible and the other one could actually be getting bullied and you know being thrown in the locker and hey I've been I've done it I've got I've

095been thrown the locker it was a good experience I deserved it but dude uh so I'm I'm I'd be asking more curious to find out like what where is that Benchmark for Bor such a big variable Marl well if I understood you rightly we need to understand that that's someone's perception they probably didn't study this for a week before they took it and so we just need to consider it in that light it it helps me to know what the highlights meant which I didn't know when I looked at it earlier but question do the ones that are not highlighted mean that they fell somewhere in between yes you've given us the high and low yeah and I'll point out to this because it was part of our discussion is like sometimes even that low

096one might have a a 3.8 uh score on it or or even higher but it was the lowest of the the questions that were asked so there were other one every other one still or higher than that one even though it might have a decent score well it might not be all that low or mean that that's really a problem like you mentioned this bullying question which comes out low consistently uh and a communication question comes out low consistently both family and and sta but it may not mean that altoe if you looked at the numbers right that we should study it a little sure it's still at least significant that of all the questions it received a lower score um it tells us something especially if the trend was to be more positive and

097then this one suddenly was a bit lower but you're right we want to go a little deeper and make sure we're we're you know looking Apples to Apples it it would help to know if those are just you know a tenth difference and that's all exactly or more yeah okay um yeah I would Echo Robert's comments on the The Bullying that's that's interesting I think it is based on perception but knowing that the staff also rated that pretty low like that's concerning like and it's hard for me not to switch into like solution mode of like okay let's have a chat let's see what some solutions are to this are we are we seeing and not reporting or you know that kind of thing I'm going to try and just stick with the data um

098I know that's so hard for me um so the bullying but then I'm sorry I'm picking more than one is that okay you're fine I have three okay I have three too and then families not wanting to have honest conversations with their teachers and teachers not wanting to have honest conversations with parents like I really want to see that communication and connection improve and I don't know if that's a relationship issue or you know our teachers a afraid of giving negative feedback um or is it parents are just blocking you know what teachers have to say I don't know but my initial um Deep dive when I first went through this was trying to understand on the third page under instructional methods we had an 11% drop with students and we're still in the zero

099to 24 percentile I'm I'm interested to know more about that that would be a good one to dig in especially one thing to to piggy back on that we had you know at the middle and intermediate school we had 100% participations so this isn't you know so you can't write this off as being well we didn't get the participation that we wanted so so while you know somebody may have not have been thinking as you know about the the the question being asked when you have 100% of your students reporting something you can't ignore that and you've got to figure out so what what are the questions that were driving that score down I'm sorry go ahead no you're fine um I had buling high school middle school Intermediate School uh relational connection pieces um

100the EQ between why each person is struggling and I noticed that at the high school middle school Intermediate School level and just to prove Jenny took my note on instructional I wrote this dayso instructional methods because like I'm with you I'm like why did it go down 11% and quite frankly why is it in the 50s I mean those are two strong pieces of information that I would like to know more about um I wrote the relationship um the communication with uh families approaching teachers and staff approaching parents and why why that is yeah um kind of like the other said um and I've I've had personal experience too just with um not hearing and from teachers and having to reach out to them and then getting um feedback and I and we had one

101teacher that was really great and it's just so helpful as a parent in my perspective or opinion anyway just to hear how my kids are doing and just getting those regular updates and stuff but I don't know some maybe it's our job to reach out to them too but I don't know why um people would be afraid or you know what I mean like whatever it said the strugle what did it say I feel comfortable approaching teachers about my child's progress yeah what what the uncomfortableness is I don't know so yeah and then what you know I I also kind of go into fix it mode a little bit too you know I'm sitting there thinking so so what if conferences we had established a protocol where where we ask parents to ask your teacher

102one tough question during conferences or what if the teachers had a protocol to say I'm you know I'm going to give two positive comments in an area that your child can improve upon because the only way you actually get better at of uh getting through what may or may not be comfortable is just to practice being uncomfortable that's the only way you get better at not being uncomfortable is uh You' got to practice being uncomfortable um and so and be and so so the only way you do that I mean if you just ask people to try harder um it it doesn't work so Heidi go ahead yeah Dan that tactic is working and I can testify to that because you've been challenging us as a board since you came on giving us giving us

103assignments just like uh this is a good example um no that's it's really good um well again with the communication piece and you my the questions have been asked and you've kind of answered uh I guess my question is you know when we get feedback like that that looks like it's pretty consistent pretty clear um across several of the school buildings how do you as a leader um you know approach solving that I mean it doesn't really fall into any one category so you know how do you take something like that on and you kind of answered that well no I mean it's it's like eating an elephant you do it one bite at a time and so one of the um so one thing that I'm doing is I'm meeting with each of the

104principles this week and um asking them to look at their staff survey data and see and pick three question areas that were like the lowest from staff feedback and say which of these which of these three can I help improve in the staff perception of really of them and their leadership and so how can I get better at that so trying to have staff or have principles model that um that I can look at this data that doesn't make me feel good and try to do some you know what could I do in these areas to improve so uh um so that's one thing is to have leaders modeled that I can look at tough data and do something about it uh the other thing and this is a great segue is that on Thursday

105I'm going to be at the middle school Community Forum night and I'm going to be presenting the Middle School data with them and so this is our little practice run of our strategic Plan Building is also looking at the academic data but then asking so to The Bullying question so you know we'll probably have a time to ask about you know a question around why do you believe bullying is a problem at the middle school or what could the Middle School do to solve the perceived bullying issue that you report you know something along those lines to to get it is it simply that well my kid says kids are mean at school or is it or what's the severity of the bullying issue so being able to so you have to take this information

106and then ask deeper questions about what led that to be the perception so I think to the point Dan just made one of the things we're working on with principles is that level of digging into the data because often the thing we we just had a meeting with principles a few weeks ago and it's like the problem named is the problem solved and often we name the wrong problem because we just got a surface level understanding of what the issue was and we didn't ask deeper questions so is it that we don't have a clear understanding of what bullying is is it that no truly bullying is rampant and there aren't clear systems for it is it what right um and so so many of these and it's interesting just because I've been playing in

107it a lot how often you will see a question and it will be like teachers do this and will rate really low and the next question is the same question but in the inverse and it will suddenly rate very high and it's like but this is the same question just phras slightly differently and one you gave them outstanding marks and one you didn't so it's like even understanding like is this a question to pursue if it's pretty much contradicting itself so I wanted to add two just really quick since two of you brought up the academic um instructional methods academic challenges what it's called at the high school the questions um because once again the data makes it seem like it's instructional methods where we would be they're giving feedback on like what instruction specifically

108looks like but the question is like do my classes make me think does my teacher help me um do my classes apply to the real world um let's see in order to get a good grade I have to work hard my teachers explain things a way I can understand the work I do makes me think they give me assignments that help me better understand so that's kind of what instruction looks like which I find fascinating because it's actually more of a philosophical like are you just sitting getting or are you actually engaging the kids it's about engagement versus we tried this new pedagogical instructional technique did it work it's really like is are the classes making you think so just so you I wanted to give a little context to that one because I thought

109it would really interesting when I read those and that was middle school and high school um the primary or the Intermediate School got questions about it too they were simplified um they weren't as long like the high school has a ton of the questions and the middle school has a few less and then the Intermediate School is more like my teacher helps me my teacher explains things in a way I understand my teacher I can ask my teacher for help things like that and then on the district summary one they just call it instructional methods on the individual School ones they're sorted out a little bit more differently yeah I mean we could spend a a ton of time on this so like we didn't even get into the culture category I can tell you

110that there is data that I'll share with the high school tomorrow that talks about around culture around having high expectations and and it scoring low lower again overall seeing some some improvement from last year to this year but again we didn't have great participation last year but basically there's probably some agreement that our expectations aren't High Enough from multiple groups so that would be an area to dig into too so put my name on that one all right did I Heidi did you get all your qu did you did I did you have any more I did but I'm good for now thank you okay thanks ID all right because we got more on this agenda yeah we can stay here move back up for so are we moving to policy we superintendent advisory work

111group okay uh I I want to dive into all that data I to drill down click all the butt I want to click all the buttons so I because uh because we have policies to work through um so I just want and I wanted this just out the public view is that um the there is a uh new state law or expectation around um every District having an equity committee and so uh I'm not calling ours an equity committee because I think I like more words than less because then people have a better understanding of what we're talking about um and so uh ours is called a superintendent advisory work Group which means they're going to advise me and they're going to do work as a group uh for Equitable experiences and outcomes so we're

112talking about and someone tried to do an acronym don't acronym it because then people will get more confused so if you're in a small group and you want to call it the work group that's fine but I'm calling it this um so that we can have a disc we can have a group that advises me uh so that I can bring their feedback to you around what are the equitable experience and outcomes that our our students and families are are will share with us and so um you can look through the attachment that's on there we're going to release the application and we are talking about groups of people that have not always been served well or whose um subgroups that have not performed well or haven't been represented so and um so Irma has

113done quite a bit of work putting the application together we'll release that tomorrow um if you know people that you think should be part of that work group um please encourage them to apply we have an electronic and a paper version not to put you on the spot herma is there anything else you'd like to share about that um no we have um we have had um uh meetings with well I've had meetings with counselors and also with uh principles so that they are aware that again we're looking for um the voices of our um students because students are part of this uh this uh group as well but that are not the ones who are always um at the table so again representing some voices that we've not necessarily heard before so if you

114think of anyone that um would be you know wanting to be part of this um group um just let them know about the application and um we're hoping that we have a lot of interest I I'll just chime in that this all um is mandated through Senate Bill 732 y yes and that you do have to vote to approve the the the group so I believe that's in the law yes that you um I'll bring you the names and then you approve them what um how many people are part of this group and what does the group [Music] uh do they have monthly meetings or like so we are looking at having what we say about six to eight so it would be at least one quarter and then so possibly more than that um

115so at least four so really four to six it might be that something comes up with that group that they really want to bring um to Dan and so as things come up there may be more but atast meetings a year and and how many people and about 10 for our district size it would be approximately 10 we didn't set like that has to be a certain number it just kind of depends on the number of applicants uh but I think anytime you get a committee more than 10 then you're really going to struggle to kind of get a focus and uh recommendations and we are asking people to make a two-year commitment so four to six meetings per year that's on the application question yes yeah is is the two-year commitment uh or term

116mandated in the bill no it's not um and so uh we just saw that in other districts that we were looking at to try to have some consistency so there might be some a stronger commitment so was just what we saw some other districts doing yeah I wondered if we would if you would consider half of them as an initial one year and then after that is two years and so you always hopefully have something to carry over don't time that is a good suggestion can I I add to that so um on the student piece that is something that um cabinet talked about because it might be that there's a senior on the committee but yet they may graduate which may bring in have another spot open for another student to commend so they

117there might be attrition just regularly depending on on um people's commitments moving in out of the district it does have to be um community members um that are living in the district students that are in arst well because we're short on time is there any other questions all right moving on you good yes all right so we are uh back with board policies so we posted uh on the agenda uh osa's updates from November and a few policies that came in December and you uh submitted questions concerns and I hope that you like the document that uh Diane helped put together here with just how we sorted the questions out I think this is I think we just kind of get keep getting better at this process so um I'm just why don't why don't

118we open that and just that might help at least me up that's just where each policy is know what you need to open scroll down to the bottom is the link that was in very bottom the PDF keep going no I'm good I think this might help guide us so that we we can't expedite if we don't have uh if there are no questions so uh you can see the the question that was asked around uh on policy gcaa around tspc um there any additional questions or discussion on that no thank sorry sorry yep okay and then um GC I love all these letters GCB DF the Paid Family Medical Leave Insurance Diane that was one that we're we're keeping the October 14th 2024 adopted policy yes yes okay um so I know there was

119questions around uh policy IIA instructional materials and so there are some questions in there um so I answered those and so I think the big question was you know the boards were uh the Board review is removed except in the matter of reconsideration of cor materials so and if you if you were to if we were to open IIA which is the policy that you adopt it it outlines who's responsible for the selection of materials now core instructional materials is the curriculum that you approve when we're going through a curriculum adoption and so that is that is the area where uh you know if there was a I'll just for lack of a better word a complaint about uh some core materials that process could get adjudicated all the way through the board and the

120reason why I I opted to remove the board from ARS 2 and three um or excuse me three and four three and four is because the board is not involved in the selection piece of that process but these AR r s um ARS three and four um actually two three and four all have very outlined reconsideration uh steps that would be followed whose's part of those decisions um and so and then I would say that really if someone were to appeal a decision of one of of these committees that decided on a reconsideration as superintendent I would be I would not be very inclined to overrule a committee's decision because that's made up of teachers that's made up of community members my job would be simply to was the process followed because why would we

121have an AR that establishes a committee in a process if the superintendent could just overturn that so that would be or or if we put the board in there is that this is a group of people that were called together to review something that somebody wanted materials reconsidered and we have this outline process that could just get overturned because the superintendent or somebody else felt differently I think that these processes are very well outlined in these ARs and so um so that's that's sort of just kind of more of a philosophical piece about that um But ultimately why I selected that the ARs three and four would end with the superintendent is because the board was not involved in the selection of the materials to begin with do we have access to that yeah so

122it's the last uh link on the agenda I believe down under before oh now I'm lost oh it's it's part of it yeah it's in the agenda and if you just clicked on it's like the very last link my machine's not working [Music] to right there oh okay got thank you so on this it's only for reconsideration of instruction materials that would have been like denied before or reviewed and and denied before kind of thing like I'm trying to think of like a a real life I think may be more um someone disagrees with what was adopted like we want to reconsider why this was adopted in the first place okay so help me understand say before we adopted the English language curriculum we had like all that Rogue um supplemental curriculum that was being

123used not in every classroom it was like a hodge podge so how would that look if we wanted to reconsider some of that so there's a couple things one is I was talking with Dan today one of the processes we're looking to get instated is a more formal process for getting supplemental material approved so when I want to introduce something what is the process documented that we go through that hasn't existed before now that's first part so even when there is a um a objection to those materials often it was like oh you're using what I didn't even know you were using that because that wasn't something that went through this process right so we're trying to change that aspect what we have to consider the piece that gets sticky is that there are the

124supplemental materials like I want to have this novel I want to do a class set let's buy this novel everyone's going to read this novel and then there are the materials that teachers use when they're just prepping their lessons and oh this YouTube video would really illustrate this point or here's a quick article that I found that was published today if we try to go through a formal process to adopt all of those that's all I'll be doing forever and ever and ever we have a CB system so some of that goes to then professional responsibility how are we making sure we're training teachers how we're using um policies like controversial topics Etc to make sure teachers are making good choices but when it's something more formal like you want to use this short story

125in this unit or you want to use this novel in this unit um what is the formal process or I want to use this computer program we started um piloting the process last year when Cheryl wanted to introduce a program called reading Horizons which was a reading supplemental support program and so we kind of used like the steps of like okay how are we going to adopt it how what would be the process it's not formal it's not a curriculum um or a set of materials but it is supplemental um and so these type of things would be like when someone objects to those materials what is the process and when it's a rogue objection because we weren't aware of it through a formal process that's one set of things because that's really a a

126principal issue to deal with the feature almost like disciplinary right not that might be too strong but potentially right you are not following materials as outlined in our Curriculum maps when we've gone through a formal process like we've all read this novel and then there is a a community complaint we don't like that novel then the AR clearly outlines here's how we would review that to go through it um so for example and just walk me through like how this would look so for example we have like a fourth grade teacher that uses YouTube that has something that's controversial and potentially sexually explicit how would a parent be able to appeal that through the process and how as a board could we um give guidance to those who come and bring forth information that we

127hear their concerns so so there's like our job as a board to represent our voters and our community but are also maintain the swim Lane of operations but how would that look in between there if the board didn't have the final say so on the policy itself IIA it says this policy is not intended to cover classroom activities complaints regarding classroom activities regarding unrelated to materials can be filed using other established District complaint procedures so I think the use of you know the maybe more random use of videos you know an instructional maybe it could even be a way we group kids to do this activity I want you to all do this activity and it goes Ary or kids are made to feel less than because of you know that would be more of

128an instructional a classroom activity not a material so that line is exactly at I probably couldn't draw a specific line but the example I heard you gave I would say that's a classroom activity versus a material that we're that we're using broadly across a grade level or across a um a particular course okay perfect I'm fine I'm fine okay um anybody else have any other questions s on that one before we move on so the next one is ikf graduation requirements and I think we our team may still have a little bit more to work on this one uh regarding to make sure that are we're maintaining our credits at 25 because I think I saw some footnotes in the policy that we have to if we're going to be above the state we have

129to outline what that is so I think we have some work to do there and Cheryl did you have something to add on this one as well yeah with the notification that we have to do starting grade five for students um with IEPs it says standard modified and then it's missing extended diploma in two places so we need to just take a look at that so well I will let you know on if we bring some if the language changes on ikf I will let you when we go for adoption on February 10th I will let you know what that is all right so then kfb graduation exercises comment that was one where I raised the question we were um regarding cultural heritage and it just seemed like leaving it open to a variet quora

130cultural symbols just I don't know if we want to do that but puts us on the defensive rather than the Native American when is is his mandated so you do that but it was an honest question and there was an answer given here are you satisfied with that answer provided to your question the board unanimously agreed to include this it says so I I guess I I wasn't part of that but it must have been before my time well I think the the language is intentionally broad of other items of cultural significance so I think you know you know I've not attended a graduation here but given the number of Latino students that we have I would anticipate that we would see you know some representation of their culture and and Dean's nodding in agreement

131so I think depending on where you live um in the makeup of your student body you're going to see some different things so and I do think that the the language is really clear that districts can prohibit items that cause that may cause a substantial disruption so and that's where I thought it puts us a little more more on the defensive side because you have to come against it but maybe that just has to be in our day I I guess I'll resign to it but but I did raise the question I personally I personally don't have a problem I sat on the board during that time as did hi Heidi feel free to chime in on anything um I think we did agree that the other items of cultural significance had a great deal

132to do with our demographic of our um student body population and making sure that everyone there felt like they could participate how they wanted to within strict guidelines as laid out in the student handbook so I mean it's not like a free-for-all there is like really really strict requirements around what can be worn and I wasn't aware of that yeah so even though it says that in policy I know graduation requirements and in the student handbook and some other things there's like clear criteria that have to be met in order for you to be able to wear that if that helps any I think it does and it makes a difference to me as the rest of you are all on board all right so ikj any other questions we know how I feel about

133optional policies but if I was the only one that had questions about it I'm not the hell I'm going to die on I I assume this is one of like upcoming policies regarding AI right yeah I mean is this like the soft [Music] one thing that they're really saying in general and I've gone to a lot of different um kosa and National kind of looks at AI is they're really careful not to get too tight actually because AI changes so fast that as soon as you get too tight you have to create a new policy so it's like what they're really saying across the board is get some um guard rails in place and then really use more handbooks and I've been working with GRE really closely to create one to really help us um

134mostly support how students are using AI um so that they can do it safely we're not potentially in a privacy data breach kind of situation with it so this is just giving us a a guard rails a guard rail to address AI in the future not that we have any rules against or for no yet and that will come down to yes are working on that we're we're trying to again keep it broad um and then create clear processes for requesting the different tools and who gets access and how they're used but um I will say I have a son who's a freshman in college and each one of his uh professors started the new school year going AI is real here's what we're going to do with it and um he's being encouraged on

135almost every assignment to use AI in one way or another it's taking over everything and it is a tool to be used responsibly I mean in yeah to use responsibly get to college and be lost so yes agreed okay thanks moving on all right so we are at jca any additional comment on that the questions that were or the question that was asked is that answer and suggestion and answer enough for you um can I ask for some explanation on um the question that was asked the suggestion about choosing will not because I I don't really see the policy up in front of me so I'm not exactly sure what we're talking about there so the see if I can pull it up here and if you click on that link this is the admission

136of Resident students so the the recommended the recommended language is uh the district May based on District criteria provide an alternative program of instruction to a student who has become a resident student and who is under expulsion from another district for a weapons policy violation so I think and so there was a question that this should be the district will not provide alternative programs um um down just a little it oh yeah n so I think the more flexibility that we can have I mean we have uh on occasion upheld uh expulsions when students have have been expelled from other schools and and become our residents but I think that there may be uh reasons to uh have a student uh attend an an alternative program if we feel like we can meet their needs

137and we understand the situation behind that so I think that anytime that we can have some flexibility and in those decisions that we ought to do that and it was previously the policy I was told was was May and this calls out specifically a weapons policy violation I would I would suggest keeping it with may just because a weapon's policy violation it doesn't always mean a gun it can mean a pocketknife sometimes it can mean um a number of things and I think you have to leave this is an instance sometimes where it should be caseby casee determination once the whole um all the information around a situation is known and I would trust the administration to make a decision on on that that would keep people safe but also be fair and if it

138was an alternative type of program it could be you know doing online work after school hours you know in kind of a very supervised setting so it's not like we're just allowing student to come right you know into the school without guard rails what what does being a resident student by definition mean that means they live that one off campus or on campus well that means they moved into our res so they are they are ours they've moved into the north Maran School District but if they bring an expulsion with them we can up help uphold that expulsion depending on the re especially for a weapons violation we can uphold that expulsion or at least the terms of it well that was my thinking I agree with yeah I was Heidi okay Benny yeah all

139right so uh JH CD AR medications I'll just point out that ARS don't need to be um approved by the board okay no comments on that one for whoever ask a question around medications all right let's move on all right JH FF I'm not sure who asked this comment but is the is the answer provided sufficient for your comment I see what saying in statute col and that was that was my question my concern that you're looking at a student one who is not a minor and one who is and that's why I made the comment about violation of law that there are certain laws that enter in then and may cover that situation it just seemed like a compromising situation to me yeah would I be correct in stating this has a lot to

140do around our students who could have bed services that qualify for up to age 21 well I think what the policy is really uh the student to student piece is that um that you know if we hire a student to work for it doesn't really matter what age they are if they are in a working capacity employed by the district they cannot be having also a relationship with a fellow student so that's what that's yeah so if this if you know if we hire a student you know and working in a capacity they can't also have a relationship with a classmate if we're we're paying them to be are in that case an employee of the district so that's what I that's how I read this policy and maybe I was misreading it I read

141it to deal with student to a student why one was older which rarely happens but it does and that that's what it was speaking to but I'm struggling to find it here it's we must have the g g letters on here first and because we do have students who are 18 and 19 can serve students up to 20 right student to student would apply do you have any other questions around that RL are you and then General policy questions those were just questions that got submitted great during this process Diane can they make a motion in the this meeting for first adoption I mean first reading not adoption first reading do we yes we can do a motion it' be kind of like if we did it all these like in a consent in but

142so you need it read out um well you don't need to list each policy you could just say that for the November and the December as presented the ones that are adopted or read first review for first reading so before uh we get through the end do I hear a motion to um do first reading on the November and December policies that are brought forward as presented I'll make a motion that except the November and December policies at the first reading as presented second is that good yeah is that what you need yes okay okay so hearing a first and a second we'll go to a vote all those in favor say I I I I all those opposed we have one Nay by Merl motion carries I don't see anything else on the work

143session but I'll go check with First okay we'll adjourn at 8:10 p.m. thank you thank you thank [Music] you I got some weird I would have pref if there I think we get oh we do yeah

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.