001all right let's get started um as you know the board is supposed to meet every other week so this is thanks for coming out of vacation to uh deal with this issue all right this meeting for the Board of Education Fe February 11 2025 is called to order all items be considered this evening are posted on the PPS website on the board and meetings tab this meeting is being streamed live on PPS TV services website and on Channel 28 and will be replayed through the next two weeks please check the district website for replay TI welcome and thanks for being here tonight's uh special meeting uh before we get started few housekeeping reminders we ask everyone attending uh this meeting tonight members of the public staff and board members treat each other with respect if
002you wish to display signs please hold those below chin level uh for safety reasons keep the walkway aisles clear be mindful of each other um and yeah also uh let's see currently the the board right now has a bet on whether we can finish this meeting and 30 minutes are under so I will try to read this as fast as I can to make it fair um the purpose of tonight's meeting is to provide some guidance to the superintendent in order to improve and provide cost reduction options for the high school modernization projects that are on the 2025 General Obligations Bond it is our responsibility to identify for staff in our community some guard rails and if you will for cost reduction and trade-offs I'm going to turn this over to director Ben Edwards to
003introduce this framework for delivering modernize high schools with cost reductions with a goal to adopt the framework tonight director brim Edwards thank you chair Wong um so I'm bringing tonight uh to the board a resolution with a framework for consideration which would direct the superintendent to pursue and deliver cost reductions in the three high schools targeted for rebuilding and modernization as background the board and staff built the outlines of the next Capital bond for the May 2025 election um at that time board members and the superintendent ask about the elevated costs in the high schools in November the district contracted with the Cornerstone Management Group to evaluate our costs for the for the next three high schools um and to compare them to the previous um PPS high school modernizations and also with Beaverton High
004School which is currently being built in addition to effectively utilizing tax dollars a reason for us to be looking at Cost reductions um in our high schools was so that um PPS could potentially take those cost savings and add them to the Investments already in the May bond for improvements and critical repairs in our aging elementary and middle schools January 7th was the day was the date set for the board vote um on the bond referral to the May ballot which we did um at that time board and staff did not yet have the cost evaluation report but the board did vote to refer the measure knowing that receiving the report at the end of January would still give us time to direct cost reductions in the high school modernizations the board recently receiv received
005the uh PPS High School cost comparison report completed by Cornerstone and received additional information from the office of school modernization regarding the projected costs last week the board had a I think it was last week wasn't it okay time flies last week the board had a meeting to discuss the Cornerstone report and cost reduction strategies and talk about our priorities U both for what should be in the in the buildings and potentially what could be um reduced or eliminated following that meeting directors Holland split and I met to create a draft set of requirements for the modernizations and a framework for cost reductions suggestions from the board and superintendent were incorporated into the framework so I hope all everybody sees their uh contributions um and thoughts and priorities in that in the framework modernization cost
006reductions are called for in two general areas general contractor cost reductions and modernization cost reductions in terms of the general contractor cost reduction the board directs the superintendant to provide potential near-term cost reduction options and Associated trade-offs regarding cost items such as preon pre-construction Services General conditions contractor fee and More in addition in the midterm the board directs the superintendent to to provide recommendations related to Future Contracting method utilization and efficiencies related to PPS project management the second area of um reductions were related to the modernizations the board establishes requirements for the modernization and directs the superintendent to use the guidelines to provide potential cost reduction options Associated tradeoffs regarding hard construction costs including reduced building square footage lower cost Building Systems and materials it's important to note while the guidelines and the framework call
007for cost reductions in all three of the high school project it also establishes that the schools will be built to meet ppss comprehensive high school education specification area program minimum requirements for number and sizes of spaces and to be similar in in terms of classroom and spaces that the previously modernized high schools have had in addition all three high schools will have a foundational level of athletic facilities and physical activity spaces the buildings will be all electric and shall conform to PPS equity and Contracting Provisions the requirements call for reduced square footage in all three high schools setting a requirement of about 25 295,000 square feet which is similar in size to the rebuilt Lincoln and Franklin High Schools staff also should provide additional cost reductions including the reduction or elimination of spaces over and
008above the Ed specs and certifications other than lead gold certification Child Care Centers and school-based health clinics may be optional depending on demonstrated need or provider availability the framework also calls for the high school design advisory groups at each school to reconvene as soon as possible assuming the board adopts this uh framework and with that I'd like to ask I'd like to thank um Dr Holland and um split for um helping craft this uh framework can um offer if you'd like to add anything or um say a few words about it please feel free to do so thank you U mostly I want to thank director brim Edwards in turn for getting us organized to have a conversation without having a quorum so that we could um develop something and move it forward at this
009meeting tonight um I mostly just want to say um on behalf of um the families in the idab wells cluster um think that having the community be able to work on the reductions I think is really key and having a voice in that process but I think also it's just as key to show like you started out with the um the care that we have for taxpayer dollars as a board and to demonstrate that and make sure that we are meeting not just the needs of the high schools but other needs um in our um middle school and elementary schools as possible within the bond amount and so I just just want to say thank you for kind of taking those values that we all shared and additionally the values we have around climate inequity
010and putting those in so that we kind of can all be on the same page but move forward with um something a little bit more structured so thank you very much for your leadership director holl did all right did I like that he's the one that bet that we would finish under 30 minutes um do I have a motion in a second to adopt resolution 7051 resolution to adopt framework to build high quality high schools in a cost effective manner second I've have director brim Edwards moves and pending and arm wrestle competition I think director Hollands uh second it uh is there any board discussion um not a whole lot of discussion I have one minor I don't know if I need to make an amendment to do that um one minor uh wording I
011would love put in there under the uh is that that first paragraph one two fourth under the general contractor cost reductions in the framework in the framework yeah I just want to under say superintendent to provide recommendations related to Future Contracting methods I just want to add in superintendent provide recommendation related to current and future Contracting methods because we're talking about contracts right now that was it just to clarify the Contracting methods for existing contracts no I'll here intendent to provide recommendations related to and I want to say current and future Contracting methods that's I want to add in current right the contract for existing contracts the Contracting methods in the past I'm just want to make sure we capture what you're trying to accomplish so the methods may change but you're not going to
012change the method for an existing contract you said something about existing contracts director Hall so I just want to make sure we get there AR contracts yet that you concern about yeah no cont it's just the methods it's just the methods okay I understand I think if there's General consensus on the board you can deem that to be amended we can take a formal vote if you like but everybody okay with it wrong with me I'm good okay I'm sorry can you where's the word change I'm just curious recomendations for related to current and future so I'm just going to read that sentence all the way through so everyone's clear I was looking so the sentence will now if if we agree will now read in addition in the midterm the board directs a superintendent
013to provide recommendations related to current and future Contracting methods method utilization and efficiencies related to the office of school monetization project management correct any discussion there I was going to ask Dr Armstrong if you have any opinions on that I am fine with that change seems like we have General consensus so we can yes yeah so as amended do I even have to say that um is there any more Bo discussion thank you if nobody else has anything I don't have a board discussion but I have a couple things I want to just say but I w't let other people if they have things they want to say go ahead I just I just wanted to say I really appreciate the work that Gary and Juliet and chrisy did and I saw that you didn't
014you asked for um input from the rest of the board and you used it and I just really appreciate it everybody yes thank you for just quick comment um just want to appreciate the work that was gone has gone into this not you know all the work that has led up to this including relooking at all our Contracting so I just want to reiterate really clearly this whole process is a is a long-term process it's not doesn't just finish today it is something that we continue it is the job of the board to oversee the spending of public money and this is our commitment right this is our commitment that we will continue this work to make sure sure that our money is being spent well sorry public money is being spent well um it
015is a difficult job um at the same time we are also want to make sure that the the Cleveland Wells Community understand that we are we are committed to giving them something like a Lincoln or Frank Franklin or maybe even you know with some custom options for their their population um and they're we're committed to giving them an equivalent school and just want to make that clear this is we're tackling two things at once here making sure our public dollars go as far as possible as well as making sure our wells and Cleveland Community get beautiful state-of-the-art schools that's all I have to say thank you and I think I would add to that that not only are they getting beautiful state of the art schools but that we are not looking to minimize their
016the Ed specs we're not looking to take away their theater rooms we're not looking to take away their Arts rooms we're not looking to take away any of the things that are important to the to the students and the communities of those schools and those and those communities I'm I'm hoping I'm hoping that tonight what this does is this sends a a loud message a resounding message across the district and across the the city that this school board values every school every student every community and we're not in any way shape form or fashion looking to take anything away from our students and and our communities and I just want to say it out loud so that it's stated for the record that and it's Jefferson idb Wells and Cleveland you are going to get
017state-of-the-arts Schools they're going to be magnificent and it is going to be great so I just I just need that out there so that people can stop saying y'all are trying to take my Arts I don't do the Ator but I want all the people that do do it to have it you know what I mean so like let's just have it that's kind of hard to believe you should call my management call my management team let's just say he he doesn't need a class in theater Dr M members sure um there was a couple things and I want to thank staff because um when we got the cost reduction report um um there was a lot of information in it that we've been waiting for for some time and we had a lot of
018questions I had a lot of questions um and I really appreciate the very thorough responses um you all provided because I um it definitely informed um the drafting of the framework um and there's two things I want to just call out because um there's been this Nar there's a little bit of a narrative like how come ours is so much more you know expensive and we are going to be reducing costs and I think there's just a couple things that's important to note that came out of the answers to the questions first of all the the comparison with Beaverton their school is being built for 1500 students versus 1700 students Beaverton is on 47 Acres versus Cleveland which is on eight acres and actually two four acre postals um in Beaverton they didn't include the
019kitchen a kitchen cost because one already ex existed that's another 18 million um they don't have a teen par teen parent child Center they don't have a health care center um they still are putting fossil fuel um infrastructure in and um Bas the escalation isn't um quite synced up so just want to note that when people are like look at what Beaverton did is like there are some very substantial differences between the projects the other um item I want to just call out along that same lines is that in the answers to the questions that we got it also notes that there's this um sort of com there's a comparison of Lincoln and Beaverton um and trying to look at what the es if you did escalation for Lincoln how it would compare to Beaverton
020and I'm just noting that um it's the one of the answers to the question when I asked about that was that the the answer is there's a large error in the Cornerstone report which they had have admitted um in terms of the escalation and that um they used a 5% escalation when it should the market average was 8% um which results in a 40 $45 million air in the report which is quite material um so I just want to note that when we're talking about the cost of things and the comparison so it's hard to do an apples apples um and we should note um I think our teams have been good Ste words of um our tax dollars um to date and that um it's a straight out comparison is not always Fair um
021I do have um just this is just for the record um Dan I'm wondering if you could speak to with the reduction in the square footage and some the other direction that's been provided do you have a an approximate uh per project cost like a range potentially of the cost reductions that we might achieve uh yeah good evening uh Dan young chief oping officer good to see everyone um when we look in totality of uh we look through the framework uh which is super helpful it gives excellent guidance to staff of how to proceed forward um shooting from the hip don't hold it to us but but we Cally thinking about 20 to4 million of savings per project and so that's kind of where we think we are we're happy to say that we we
022we've had that discussion but uh once we get into the work of course know more and and there'd be some additional potential cost in the contractor side of things as well we were looking at that in total again it's a big range the projects are going to be different um but we'll know more soon great and so that could be if those are realized or even above that that can go or even above that we're not to stop there yeah we count on you to do that um that that can then be put into the added to the Investments that we're making already in this Bond 190 million into the Elementary Middle School infrastructure correct okay um and then just my last question um do you have what you need in order for the projects
023teams to continue their work and for the designed advisory groups to to reconvene yes this again this framework is very helpful um you know immediate next steps are going to be uh re-engaging the full design teams uh who've been on pause uh and also putting together really updated engagement and communication plans the design advisory groups are a piece of that but but they're of course not the only piece and so there are a number of other stakeholders and stakeholder groups uh and other opportunities for engagement so we'll be putting updating basically our plans based upon where we are now great that's all the questions I have and I'm super excited for the work to get restarted um and to get the work underway we are too thank you thank you any other board discussion sen
024representative here do you have any well I first want to thank my colleagues and staff for the amazing work they've been doing on this Bond and this package we was that was shared today I think I met with uh the student representatives to The Climate crisis response committee and things they shared with me was a strong support for a bond that supports sustainability efforts and Performing Arts one of the concerns they shared with me they felt like a lot of students weren't really involved in the process of the bond so I think whether that's during the campaign or during our period of kind of developing the bond if we could include student voice more that would be really helpful absolutely that was great input we appreciate it thank you and I'm sure the campaign will
025really welcome uh student student voice voice uh and activism yes when asking for money please practice puppy um all right uh Miss Bradshaw is there any public comment no all right the board will now vote on uh 7051 resolution to adopt a framework to high to build high quality high schools in a cost-efficient manner all in favor please indicate by saying yes yes yes yes uh all oppos please indicate by saying no student representative canavi please indicate your vote Yes any extensions resolution 7051 is approved by a vote of 7 to Zer with student representative canav unofficially voting yes thank you everyone for being here tonight this meeting is adjourned Gary won the bet shoot I'm glad we shake right